Reviews (page 4 of 14)
8.5/10 I really like how punchy the guitar riffs sound and the bass just sounds great, but I realized after a while that I really don't like the vocals for the most part. I get what they were going for but they're just not for me. Favorite tracks are Starship Trooper and Perpetual Change.
Threshold must be low for albums in the 70s. 10 minute long songs who can be bothered??
They all look so delighted on the front cover, if you walked into the room and saw that, fear would set in pretty quickly. This was so much more enjoyable than "Close To The Edge" which sucked. I can't believe their output in those early years (Yes Album 1971, Fragile 1971, and Close to the Edge 1972). Radio staples from when I was a kid (though it was released before I ever thought about listening to music) include "Yours Is No Disgrace" (9 mins long!), "Starship Trooper" (9 mins long) and "I've Seen All Good People (7 mins long). "Starship Trooper" is one of the greatest nearly 10 min songs on the radio. It has several chapters but it all works and blends nicely. It's the essence of prog rock. "I've Seen All Good People" (42M listens) is the flagship song - it's still catchy & gets a lot of airplay even today. I found the last two songs to be mundane and wandering. The listener counts are solid from top to bottom, this is a popular release with a number of instantly recognizable songs. This deserves a spot in the Top 1001 and I'm not a prog guy, but I can understand where many people might not agree. 3 stars from me.
Apologies for leaning into the joke too hard but this album is a big YES for me
For a prog it was quite inoffensive to my ears. Except The Clap, that one sucks big time.
What a splendid album to start the day with! And it's my birthday too! First of a run of three perfect Yes albums, my favourite era from my favourite band. First one for Steve Howe, who gave us all The Clap with this one (just read that back.... I think it's OK!). Last one for Tony Kaye until his return for 90125. Much of this album became standard live Yes material for the rest of their career (and still is). Chris Squire's thundering Rickenbacker stamps its signature tone all over these classic tracks. I just think it's a perfect album. This won't be a surprise to anyone who follows my social media meanderings.
Very self indulgent 9 minute rock epics... But I enjoyed it!
Good vibe but not really my type.
The Yes album is a classic Euro Rock album. Honestly I didn't recognize anything on that album but I enjoyed it all.
was expecting this to be a lot less unique than it actually was. this one's folksy and not quite fully-formed into prog rock like Fragile or Close To The Edge. i'd say that the proggy elements on here are the ones i find a bit annoying and unserious, though. deserves to be one of the 1001? eh you can cut this one
When to listen: On a boat? On roller skates? Moving in some way for sure. I really enjoy this album, I loved all the bridges and random interludes. Obviously very talents singers and musicians. Twas very much my jam.
First Listen; 3.5; I got two Yes albums (almost) back to back, and I feel like this one is a little more meandering and less punchy thoughout, but I still enjoyed it. Again, was not expecting to enjoy prog rock as much as I did, not sure what that says about me. Similar to Fragile, I enjoyed the bass, the energetic moments, and quirky detours. I don't love the organs and keys, at least not in the doses offered here. Favorite Track: Yours is No Disgrace
This album is like going to the mens room in a dive bar to have a piss. There’s a lot of atmosphere going on, and you’ve got a bit of a shine on. You smile as you relieve yourself at the urinal, cos you know you’re drunk and you’re having a good time.
Was a good album. Some good twists and turns and great musicianship
Enjoyed, might go back to it, not sure. One of the synth melodies reminded me of an Abba song
lot better than yesterday that’s for sure. wasn’t expecting only 6 songs but they’re all that long
I mostly know Yes as a band that influenced bands I like (most notably Rush)... and I hear it.
It was alright and some classics were on there. Probably won't listen to it again.
Tiresome. The songs drag on longer than they need to. Exhausting.
Enjoyed this quite a bit
This was pretty boring. Stand-outs - Starship Trooper: a. Life Seeker, b. Disillusion, c. Würm
Why did it give me this so soon after Fragile? 😭 Another absolute classic from the lads. Yours Is No Disgrace and Starship Trooper easily make it a 5 and the other songs only add to the experience
Yes? Yes, please. For the first time in a while something that does not suck. 3..875 rounded up to 4.
I liked this more than some albums I’ve given three stars to. I don’t know that I would actively seek it out. It doesn’t quite tip into four star territory for me.
I did have a prog rock phase earlier in my life, and I came out of it with a conclusion that there are two types of prog bands - the ones that hit heavier, sound harder, that I truly enjoy (like King Crimson, Jethro Tull...), and the ones that, to me, sounds floppier, cheesier and more like some musicianship wankery than music that feels actually compelling (to me). Yes falls into the latter type to me, and while I do respect the mastery, musicianship and creativity, I just cannot enjoy the music fully.
The Yes Album es una obra maestra de la riqueza sonora y la interacción humana. Lo que hace que este disco destaque es la fluidez entre sus integrantes; en piezas como "Perpetual Change", la interacción entre el piano y los requintos se percibe como una conversación entre amigos, natural y lúdica, lejos de la frialdad matemática. La llegada de Steve Howe aporta momentos brillantes como "The Clap", donde el virtuosismo de las guitarras resulta sumamente divertido. El contenido lírico y tonal es igualmente poderoso. "Yours Is No Disgrace" logra abordar temas profundos con una tonalidad y mensaje luminoso, mientras que la emblemática "Starship Trooper" se mantiene como una pieza hechizante e inspiradora que invita a una verdadera expansión mental. Por su parte, "I've Seen All Good People" ofrece una dualidad esperanzadora pero agridulce, lo que la hace sentir más real y humana dentro de la grandiosidad del rock progresivo. Es un álbum donde la genialidad técnica se pone al servicio de la emoción y la trascendencia.
Solid and enjoyable.
O álbum possui uma musicalidade requintada, uma escala épica, e composições extremamente progressivas. Não há aqui resquício sequer de simpatia Pop. O resultado é uma escuta interessante, que prende sua atenção e faz você notar os mínimos detalhes de cada faixa. Pra resumir, Yes é uma banda de nerd, e esse álbum é um álbum de nerd, simples assim. Me agrada o destaque que o baixo recebe nessas canções. Certamente foi o que mais chamou minha atenção. Linhas pulsantes que dirigem as canções. E claro, o resto da banda segue o mesmo padrão, todos se destacam em diferentes momentos. Acredito que este seja um disco que requer várias rodadas até ser totalmente absorvido. Dito isso, meu ranking é prejudicado por ser feito após uma única escuta. 4/5
Solid album. I prefer Fragile and 90125, but this is still solid.
Not for me
It’s Yes!
sit on porch, humid day, cigarette, 7-8pm
Enjoyed it
This was alright - I'm not particular to prog-rock stuff, but this album had it's moments that I enjoyed. I'd give this a 3.5, but I don't feel good giving it a 4.
OK, but it's unlikely that I'll ever wanna listen to this again. ★★★
Not unenjoyable. Lots of guitar. Very 70s rock. I really only loved Your Move. The rest was a lot of guitar and a lot of it blurred together.
only 1 good song that is okayish. first two are just instrumentals but they're pretty nice.
It’s honestly a masterclass in progressive rock. The musicianship is on another level—especially the bass and guitar interplay—and the songs flow more like evolving suites than typical structures. They really showcase how complex ideas can still feel powerful and musical. Not the most accessible album at first, but if you give it time, it’s very rewarding. It's a must-listen if you’re into rich arrangements and deep musical exploration.
Había algo en los 70 (👃)
Maybe i like prog rock?
Turns out that the best way to separate your new-agey, vaguely irritating progressive rock group from a dozen other new-agey, vaguely irritating progressive rock groups is the liberal addition of mind-shattering, face-melting bass. Please don’t play this album loud if your house has a weak foundation. Best track: “Starship Trooper”
Yes
Completely acceptable prog-ish rock. I liked some bass and guitar parts, but the constant harmonizing of the voices got old pretty quick. I admit I did a little peek ahead and saw that Yes has 3 albums in the book. Will they deserve the 3 album placements? Who knows. Going middle of the road for now, this album is subject to either stay the same or go down in rating in the future depending on how the other Yes material sounds.
This is such the style of music I like, I could see myself putting this on at anytime
With music like this, wear all the capes you want
A good album, I liked Perpetual Change the most.
I really love the guitar playing, it's a bit odd to me but I love their sound and it's fun to listen to, sounds like nothing like I've ever heard really :) it's interesting. It's beautiful and i love how there's lots of different instruments and their music sounds more dimensional i guess.? Like im in the room with them 😭😭 ok i love the different styles in the songs it's awesome:p Basically not something I would normally listen to but it's solid 3,5 *_*
estuvo bueno eh, repetiria 3.5/5
131. ok
Скажите да да да
nah
solide 3. eigentlich ganz gut, aber es fehlt was - die emotionen, die es nicht auslöst
Not my kinda taste, few listenable songs, album have 4 discs and the same songs is mental though
I’ve discovered the older I get the less fond I am of indulgence. And there’s a lot of that here. Time signature changes, ultra technical playing, obtuse lyrics but…. There’s an also moments like the end of starship trooper where they find a groove and stick to it, some may find that indulgent but I found those moments exciting. The harmonies are also machine tooled but really flesh the vocals out. Not for everyone but enough for me
Yes
I like prog and even I find this to be generic sounding and meandering. It's supremely inoffensive and also unmemorable.
In theory, I'm a fan of prog. Really though, I'm more of a prog snob - I'm picky about the prog I like. All the things I like about prog are here: lengthy epic songs with unusual lyrics, instrumentation, and time signatures. But Yes seems to specialize in songs that change key almost every measure which makes it hard to latch onto a great riff or melody, anything you can groove to or sing along with. Starship Troopers from this release is the best example of this. It's the same problem I have with jam bands like The Grateful Dead - too much noodling and not enough melody. It seems like these kinds of bands intend to rely on more of a overall feeling better experienced as background music, or alternatively as art to be marveled at instead of enjoyed. I dig the guitar and bass work, and the close harmonies are great too, but aside from All Good People, I'd have preferred more to enjoy instead of just appreciate.
Yes.
Yaaaaaassssss
It was a lot better than "Owner of a lonely heart". If you like 70s Prog it will probably be for you. Good musicality, none of the melodies stuck, but with prog usually you need more than one listen.
I already liked Yes, this was a good album
Eh kinda mid Fragile is the better album.
OK . I kind of remember this sound ... elements of Genesis instrumentals at times . Not sure I'd listen again though . Almost a 3 , top end of 2
This was a bit of a slog from start to finish!
A few moments of likeable stuff, some decent guitar work, and honestly not as horrible as I thought it would be. Going to go 3. Suspect they have far worse records in their canon.
Prog nonsense
Really dislike the lyrics/imagery of Prog - Yes. Genesis, Rush. ELP..all will be culled in my upcoming Progrom.
Hmm, yes, Yes. Let’s just say that the bonus tracks were the highlight. Sadly they don’t count.
8/10 (4/5 stars) a. Yours Is No Disgrace - 8.8/10 b. The Clap - 7.3/10 c. Starship Trooper: a. Life Seeker, b. Disillusion, c. Würm - 8.6/10 d. I’ve Seen All Good People: a. Your Move, b. All Good People - 8.3/10 e. A Venture - 7.6/10 f. Perpetual Change - 9/10 g. Your Move (Single Version) - 8.5/10 h. Starship Trooper: Life Seeker (Single Version) - 8.6/10 i. Clap (Studio Version) - 8.7/10
It was ok. I don’t really like super long songs but I enjoyed the experimental side to this.
These damn prog rockers and their long ass music
Zone out a fair bit. It's meh
As one of the greatest prog rock groups out there, Yes created lots of many wonderful albums. This third album was there first success in the ears of broader audiences. It's of course very good with all tracks bringing something to the table that would define prog. Yes can do the epic, the quiet, the romantic, the obscure. The only question one might ask: Shouldn't there be other albums by this great band on this list? Basically everything between the first two albums and "Tormato" is amazing.
This album is all over the place and I don't mind it anywhere near as much as I thought I would. Started off sounding like an 80s TV theme, obviously had the obligatory gypsy jazz track, some riffs, harmonies and good ol' blues rock. At least it's quite fun at points. Hats off to the pre dated Nirvana riff at the end of Starship Trooper.
It’s like The Who had a baby with The Partridge Family.
No.
(50/100)
Very good very good
vibey
> the Beatles
Yes is still a no for me but I liked this album more than I was expecting.
Me gusta como juegan con los instrumentos pero no me atrapó del todo. Aún así, es buen album
Cool prog rock
Going into this album I knew nothing about Yes other than they existed, and were something-something 70s related. I did not have high hopes. But! I dug it.
Fine but nothing special
I had a lot of fun with this! Yes is a cool weird group, and this was a cool weird album
This album rules a the only reason I’m giving it a 3 instead of a 4 is because I know how good Yes can be and this is just scratching the surface. But the bass performance on this album is ridiculous and this is genuinely beautiful rock music. I love prog so much. I’ve changed my mind fuck it this is my project and if I want to give an album a 4 I’m gonna give it a 4 damnit. Long live prog long live Yes. Favorite track: Yours Is No Disgrace
YES
Not my favourite
- Best song: Perpetual Change. Love the stereo panning towards the end.
I love All Good People.
Me gustó mucho debí decir. Ideal para escuchar mientras laburas y queres algo medio arriba pero no tsnto
All good people is a classic…hadn’t listened to them as Prog Rock kings but now hear all the intricate breaks and movements! Great debut effort
Давно їх не слухав) Ранній Yes прикольний.
Was alright. Nothing really stands out, I am sure they will on here again with a better album. Mostly harmless.
Second Yes album. I honestly don't remember anything about my previous outing with their music, which I suppose is understandable given that I listened to it 150 albums ago. I'm expecting another prog rock album, likely with a spacy atmosphere. Here goes. This album was a little directionless and scatterbrained, but it caught me at the right time. I've had somewhat of an affinity for prog rock over the past couple of months. Granted, I haven't listened to any prog rock in that time frame, but the reverence is there all the same. I think it's the only genre of music which can be called timeless in the truest sense of that word. Sure, it reeks of the airbrushed, polished visions of the future that were common in advertising and media at the time, but I think the music is largely distinct in its futuristic vision. The spacey ambience of the guitars are pretty good, though it's the unique chord progressions which really set this album apart. The plucky interplay between the pianos and bass guitar make for some solid moments. The synths are generally pretty good too, adding a nice, soft texture to the tracks - I just wish there were more of them. The organs don't do much for me, though they do pair nicely with the aforementioned synths. The acoustic guitar is the only instrument that I can confidently say doesn't belong here, especially on the track where it prominently features. There's also the question of track length, which I largely didn't feel was earned. Many of the songs start to feel empty after a while. While I did have some gripes with this album, I thought it was a decent listen overall. Book time. Peaked at No. 7 on the UK chart, but that's about the only thing of note in this entry - the rest is just about the recording process. Wikipedia says this album was their breakthrough release and was warmly received by critics. The UK and Netherlands particularly liked this album, whereas the album performed more modestly in the US and Canada. I was expecting a little more from this album, but I'm favourable to it being in here. I cosign this inclusion
Fun jams, yea, jammy
This one's good, and it is consistent with Yes's other work, but it's not quite as strong. Favorite track(s): "Starship Trooper," even if it isn't anything like the book or the movie that came out later.
Amazing album. I love yes
Very cool!
Yes might be one of my favorite groups of all time, so seeing them pop up was a delight
I don’t really like prog rock but I do like this … I’ve seen all good people is outweighing the proggyness of the first half
Me gusto bastante, hay hartas canciones que me llamaron mucho la atención. Mi papa le encanta el rock y mucho led zepellin, y la verdad a mi me gusta bastante sus canciones y pude sentir en este album una sensación igual a la que siento con la musica de led zepellin. Bastante bueno para poner en la mañana y animarse hacer las cosas jajjskd.
0/6 bekannt 6/10 Beste Songs: yours is no disgrace, starship trooper, I’ve seen all good people
Yes, all good people should give this album a 5. Stanky bass, so many diverse sounds.
Honestly I was expecting a punk 90s rock band from this one because of the cover and when I played the first song I was like am I listening to the Beatles then I saw it was from 1971 and the whole album I was like oh yea this is absolutely great
Cool
Can hear closer ties to their influences than later albums.
Good rock band from the 70’s-80’s. Good sound, good music, good songs.
Muy guapo
Bands like this do because they can, not because they should.
An example of where the long song doesn't feel like a chore. Good fun.
Some of the instrumental sections dragged on a bit but overall an enjoyable listen with some good tunes.
Meh. This deluxe edition is an album with over 4h, so I went and listened to the short version. One or two good songs, the rest are just too repetitive or just sound like intros...
That's some fine Prog rock ya got there
Very old but yes, I can say it works.
classic YES 4/5
Like a lot of prog, it can sometimes be hard to defend Yes against claims of being self-indulgent and overstaying their welcome, but this one has a bounce and energy that’s missing from their later stuff.
its simply great and creative , and that's what i like. 4/5
It was fine. Nothing fabulous to be excited about for me
Very cool guitar work, and I enjoyed the vocals. It was good, and a style I don't mind.
Giving this a big ol yes
I had to listen to this album 3 times because I kept forgetting I was listening to it. By the third time I was kinda liking it. I should be ashamed at how unfairly I've rated similar albums on this list. I'm not though.
Yes seems a little enthusiastic, I’d say “sure :)”
A little disjointed, but otherwise, zero complaints.
Is The Yes Album Yes's best album? Until recently, I would have probably said "No way!" In high school, when I was in my prog rock phase, I was adamant that Fragile and Close to the Edge were the peak of Yes, and I don't remember any particularly strong feelings about The Yes Album. But everything changed a few weeks back when I got Fragile on this site. I was surprised and disappointed to find it no longer appealed to me. I found it overindulgent, cacophonous at times, and strangely paced, with only a few songs really holding up. When I got The Yes Album today, I was bracing myself for disappointment, though I took comfort in the fact that it's never been an album I really loved. And then, as I listened to it, and remembered song after song, singing along, enjoying the shifts and changes, I found that I was truly enjoying The Yes Album. It was like walking into Narnia—but like, if I'd already been to Narnia, and had forgotten how awesome Narnia was. So many great moments throughout the album. "I've Seen All Good People" may be my favorite Yes song of all time, and relistening after so many years only affirmed that. The unfortunately mistitled "The Clap" is another highlight, a real showcase of Steve Howe's abilities. I remember spending hours trying to tackle it at 50% speed when I was 17. "A Venture" is another excellent entry. I don't know. I kind of love all of it. I think sometimes fans of prog rock are way too afraid to enjoy music. They need to feel clever. So they gravitate toward the more esoteric, the more virtuosic, the more unenjoyable works. This is why Fragile and Close to the Edge are often considered their greatest albums. But I've always been partial to 90125, often derided by the proggiest of progheads. And today, I am ready to make a declaration: Is The Yes Album Yes's best album? Yes!
Grandiose prog rock structured to be long-form, but it doesn't get super noodle-y. Little chicken pickin here and there, that's nice. I think it was good, I'd say solid 3.
The Yes Album is a record that announces its ambitions immediately and delivers on them technically without ever quite delivering on them emotionally. The musicianship is exceptional across the board — Chris Squire’s bass sits in the mix like a lead instrument, aggressive and melodic simultaneously, and the overdriven Hammond moments hint at something genuinely exciting underneath the architecture. Steve Howe’s guitar work is precise and inventive. These are serious players doing serious work. And yet the songs feel sterile. The technical command is never in question, but command alone doesn’t create warmth, and warmth is what’s missing here. The playing is impressive in the way that a perfectly engineered room is impressive — you can admire the craft without wanting to spend time in it. It’s the same ceiling that ELP’s Tarkus ran into: virtuosity in service of something that never quite pulls you inside it. The acoustic live track — “The Clap,” which is an unfortunate name under any circumstances — arrives mid-record like a completely different band briefly wandered in. It’s adventurous in theory and mostly just an interruption in practice. This is prog before it fully disappeared into its own indulgence, which should make it more accessible. Somehow it still feels like too much. A respectful three — impressive, occasionally interesting, and emotionally distant in all the ways that matter most.
5/5
Really good album, I enjoyed it quite a bit.
Love love love this album. I could listen to Squire's bass tone and mastery all day long. Unlike some prog rock bands who are all over the place in terms of the musical themes and genres they embrace, Yes is of a more singular focus. This leads them to greater heights, soaring over all the other pretenders stuck on the ground below.
Highlights: Yours is No Disgrace, Starship Trooper, I’ve Seen All Good People, A Venture and Perpetual Change. I have listed 5 of the 6 tracks on this album as highlights. For that reason I have to give this 5 Stars.
Aun que nunca me llamo demasiado la atención el progresivo, creo que escucharlo por primera vez me ha gustado, que tales guitarras, que largas algunas canciones, pero un disco que se deja escuchar, la pieza de cierre me parecio genial
I like when the vocals sound like The Byrds but the organ guy needs to chill. Yes makes me think that I was wrong about prog rock. They keep the jamming to a reasonable ratio of actual musical content and each song can stand on its own.
These songs have no business hitting that hard. I was expecting some unbearable self-indulgent prog fest, but even the length and the guitar noodling is not bothering me.
Four long prog-rock songs? Yes.
favs: the clap i’ve seen all good people: a. your move, b. all good people rating 1.6/5
very 70s. kind of Rush-ish before Rush existed. seen all good people of course but good stuff other than that one too
Track 1: Good opening song, annoying vocalist Track 2: nice acoustic song Track 3: meh Track 4: boring song. About chess or something Track 5: goofy. Old timey sound Track 6: cheesy intro Don't like singer's voice.
Too loosey goosey for me.
Thoughts before listening: I have always though that Yes fell on the cheesy side of prog rock, and for the most part that is probably true. However, I do really like the album with Roundabout on it, and I know that this is their debut meaning its perhaps before their excessive tendencies took over. I believe this will be a first listen. Review: So this isn't the actual debut album from Yes. but it does seem to be the one where they finally settled on their sound. One thing I do like about this band is that while they could rock as hard as all of the prog rock bands, they also aren't afraid of a folky acoustic song. Thats the secret to "I've Seen All Good People." which is a very catchy folky rock song that was a huge hit for the band. All in all this is basically what I expected from this album. I like it well enough although its not necessarily blowing me away. I'll give this 3-stars.
Listening to this after Van Halen, and 70's rock is so much better than the 80's. Steve Howe is truly spectacular. The songs are long but they don't bore, similar to Television's Marquee Moon in that aspect.
to instrumental sto track 1 allou καλο instrumental γενικα φαρμα βαιμπς αλλα το βαρεθηκα πολυ μονο το ιντρο μαρεσε αλλα νταξ γενικα δεν ειναι το ειδος μου ειδικα ετσι οπως τραγουδανε αυτη καντα φολκ
A+
This is one of my favorite Yes albums. It's damn near a greatest hits album really.
Yes!
Pretty classic album. I'm still not a huge Yes guy, but this album is musically impressive.
Liked The Clap the best, it was a fun lil diddy. Overall, enjoyed more than expected.
3/20/26 - listened while driving. I do not like Prog Rock or Jam Bands. That said, I actually enjoyed this. It was not nearly as self-indulgent as I expected and went by fairly quickly. Top Song - I've Seen All Good People
A classic. Top twenty all time prog album
Да) Хорошее звучание, богатый и плотный инструментал Не понял состав этого альбома, там треки повторяются Хорошая энергия и как сити гриль можно слушать Я добавил себе Буду переслушивать 3.8
holy basslines, but the rest's kinda mid
Masterpiece. ❤️
Genesis vibes 7/10
Surprisingly little Wakeman keyboard noodling. Surpisingly lots of acoustic and folk rock. It's fine, but nothing special
A classic!
Impressive work by rock group Yes. I only knew them for Roundabout before this album, so I expected something similar to that. It's safe to say that my premonition was correct.
Incredible dynamics. Yes is in the embryonic stage of its sonic experimentation. Howe and Squire shine. The vocals carry a trademark of the group that complements the instrumental. Great classic.
Yes, they have talent. Does that talent translate to something I want to listen to? No.
Not my cup of tea !!!
Great album, once again not my style. The music is great, the vocals and singing really turn me off of listening to this by choice
16/03/25 a banda verde do consentimento yours is no disgrace é interessantíssima, mas eu sou suspeito pq gosto dessas coisas viajonas e experimentais (vulgo rock progressivo) (não que não seja mega bem feito tbm) a voz dos caras tbm é foda pink floyd se fosse feliz e leve e esse violão sunshine and rainbows em the clap life seeker foi louco demais, prog rock para a vida violão festinha country em disillusion esse solo em wurm não tem nada a ver com nada, mas o fato de ele estar ali e contribuir para uma experiência mega viajona já é muito foda as harmonias de voz desses manos são do caralho tbm your move tá me fazendo ascender all good people blues vibes, esse final épico a venture não é viajão que nem as outras, mas é um arroz e feijão do rock sensacional a sonoridade do álbum é muito bem definida, os elementos são os mesmos mas não fica repetitivo - perpetual change me provou isso muito bem esse solo chefão de videogame vibes no meio da música, cinema entendo quem acha chato, eu tbm acho rush chato por exemplo mas pra mim prog rock é um dos gêneros que funciona de forma mais subjetiva (que dá para ser chata obviamente) não esperava, mas; 10/10 - foi uma ótima surpresa
Not my kind of thing and there were parts I disliked, but at least they still sounded like a rock band and I've Seen All Good People was just about good enough to scrape it up to a 3
Yeah! Sure! Sounds good!
Love finding a track I know but didn't know was on the album of the day
yeah it whips
this on the other hand is so directly up my alley it is insane.
I like plenty of prog and I get that, in some senses, it's the ultimate genre mashup. But I still feel there need to be guard rails of some sort: coherent themes, hooks or signatures. Yes disagree, and just throw a lot of random noodling into these songs at their whim. The result isn't bad, in fact technically the musicianship is pretty impressive: it's just rather incoherent and confusing.
Very dreamy, very noodly, very ‘70s.
A bit all over the place, but I guess that's the point.
Zzzzzzzz
Yes rules!
Bon, sans atteindre des sommets
Good album
Better than I thought it was going to be. Still overindulgent, but that's Yes for you.
The band may be Yes but for me it’s a No ❤️ this is objectively bad
3.8
Really enjoyed this one. Just a lot of fun to listen to, the riffs are all super catchy and the guitar playing is insane. Will definitely revisit
A lovely listen. Somewhere between Steely Dan and Albert Hammond but, for me, a bit more fun and accessible than either of those. A lovely mix of textures and sounds thanks to acoustic guitar and brilliant vocals. Never listened to Yes before but definitely will listen some more.
O pior álbum até aqui.
Album OK 3/5
This is just a really good album, from start to finish.
Un álbum con canciones muy interesantes y buenas. He sentido una conexión con algunas de estas canciones, pero incluso las que no me han gustado tanto me han parecido de una composición impecable
Yes this is prog rock, No I didn't need to listen to this before I die.
thats ok
Prog rock pioneers.
Mi ricorda la mia amica con cui nn si poteva mai ascoltare canzoni meno di 9 minuti eddaiiiiii
not my cut of tea
Not my favourite Yes album, but I love Yes
Spinetta para gente que no es tan existencialista. La última canción podría salir tranquilamente en el soundtrack de Bob Esponja.
This one is fine. Not really my jam but I didn't mind it. 3 stars.
Enjoyable Yes album. Some songs are way too long. Two versions of 'I've Seen All the Good People Your Move' is excessive. Too much filler.
Decent album, bit short but overall enjoyed it
i really liked this album
YES! YES! YES!
Not my fave of theirs, but it is Yes
Berm bad dumberm Dermbumbum bum beededldeeeedledeeedlee twililililibawowowand dlteeedldletrssz beteawwwwawawa wawaassowo wowww See? Anyone can prog.
A powerful rock record, a more straightforward effort from these masters of prog, resplendent with riffs and iconic vocal harmonies and imagination. Undeniably great rock music.
It's fine. A lot more dull and less adventurous than I was expecting. I like Prog - in principle. I love Floyd,and I love prog Metal, but all those other 70s Prog bands I know little of. So.. a bit naff. Nothing memorable, no great memories, not even any ridiculous musicianship. But it's fine. Nothing bad. Nothing annoying.
This rollicks along at a reasonable pace and keeps the smugness to a minimum. Not that I will ever choose to listen to it again.
Huge fan. Likely one of the strongest debut albums ever.
meeeeh
Good, but blended together too much
Æ tror det hørtes ut omtrent som forventa, så det gjorde ikke nokka særlig inntrykk fra eller til, nei.
Found it pleasant enough to listen to. And there were head bobbing moments. But not strong enough to really get me into it.
I love YES, but I'm not convinced this album belongs on the list. Fragile and Tales from Topographic Oceans are each spectacular; everyone should not only hear them, but try to listen to them before they die. The Yes Album hints at the greatness to come. There are moments of transcendence here. But, honestly, it sounds like rehearsal sessions for the monster productions that follow.
Enjoyed it more than I expected. Took another reviewer’s advice and listened with headphones.
un album solido y completo, me gusta la guitarra de the clap, la letra de starship trooper. me gusta que sean canciones largas, es algo que hoy en día se está perdiendo. noté la referencia a lennon en i’ve seen all good people
I love a long song but over 6 minutes for 4 out of a 9 song album... kinda crazy
Pretty much what I expected too drawn out and jammy for my taste
Yes.
Perfect for JJBA.
Banger
They're very good at their instruments but I don't like the sounds they're making
Liked this one more than fragile to be honest. Short but sweet. Favorite was probably the opener yours is no disgrace. Lot of nonsense yet still kind of hit me.
'The Yes Album' was when everything clicked for English progressive rock band Yes. After two records that showed their potential without really setting the world on fire, 'The Yes Album' utilized longer compositions, jazz piano, acoustic music and dashes of funk to deepen their prog sound. 'Yours Is No Disgrace' opens the record with a grandiose funk bass riff from Chris Squire and some inventive electric organ work from Tony Kaye, serving as a noteworthy precursor to the iconic 'Roundabout' that would appear on their next record, although Kaye would be replaced by Rick Wakeman before then. 'The Clap' showcases Steve Howe's immense skill on the acoustic guitar, before 'Starship Trooper' and 'I've Seen All Good People' forge the tight centre of the record, following the lead of 'Yours Is No Disgrace' with impressive bass/organ interplay, inventive guitar riffs, the rock-solid drumming of Bill Bruford (who would later join King Crimson) and the delightful vocals of Jon Anderson who, along with Rush's Geddy Lee, would pioneer that hard-rocking prog frontman persona. As the album closes with 'A Venture' and 'Perpetual Change', it is apparent that 'The Yes Album' was the first time Yes put together a consistently good record, and they'd only follow it up later that year with the even more impressive 'Fragile'. Yes are one of the greats of the prog rock genre, and 'The Yes Album', alongside 'Fragile' and Pink Floyd's 'Meddle', ensured 1971 was very important year in the growth of the genre. Best songs: Yours Is No Disgrace, Starship Trooper, I've Seen All Good People
Inoffensive and unobtrusive prog rock. An album you'd thrown on when you want background music that listeners can tune in and out of with ease. Like me at work, forgetting I was listening while the album was actively playing over my headphones. When I remembered, I mostly enjoyed the sound before my attention slipped away again. That being said I don't like the plink-plonky mixing of the album, it's a bit abrasive. I'd listen to The Clap and Starship Trooper again.
Yes has some classics, but none of them are on this album in my opinion.
Interesting listen. 3
OH YEAH! THIS IS WHAT I WANTED!
So good! Granted that this isn't my true music style but this is album is so nostalgic of my childhood and of my classic rock loving Father. Very fun.
A more progressive album from Yes after the first 2 and this probably defined their sound for the ones that follow. From the opening growl of Yours Is No Disgraces to the ringing notes of Perpetual Change this is in the Yes top 5.
Not as good as close to the edge imo.
najs! svidja mi se pogotovo pesma the clap jer je drugacija od ostalih, neki akusticni momenat. zanimljive dugacke pesme, veoma sedamdesete!
Apesar das músicas serem bastante longa, gosto do instrumental ter bastante destaque
One of the best prog albums of all time. Still sounds great 50 years on.
Very 70s prog rock. Definitely some masterful musicianship.
6/10 Accomplished and clever, but hard to love. All a bit too cover for its own good, it is still interesting and a fine listen.
anu iyo simgerebi ro momewona da davagulebdi mara isetebi araa ro shuffleshi shemxvdes da gemrielad shevirgo
I appreciate the band’s distinctive close harmonies. And Jon Anderson’s vocals, too. Aside from “I’ve Seen All Good People,” I don’t really relate to the songs, though.
All very ‘clever’ but I don’t enjoy this type of music at all.
I've listened to this a number of times, but not for many years. It sounds a little dated now, showing it's late 60s/early 70s style. I never rated this album as highly as other Yes albums, but there are still good tracks - Yours is no disgrace and I've seen all good people.
Thought it was going to be metal, kinda groovy. Nice instrumental in 1st song. Like more than 1st album recommended. sounds like "roundabout" the jojo song. very mishmashy. very hippie. Kinda sound like the grateful dead. Overall pretty good. Id just listen to the grateful dead or the beetles tho. Would only listen to it again if it came up. Pretty short all things considered. 6/10
Very good album
There is some great bass on this album. I put on the good headphones, which allowed for the stereo to really come through. I braced myself for SIX songs on a ~42ish minute album. I reminded myself I started this for a reason. The reason? To discover new music and to rediscover things I hadn't listened to for a long time, fully knowing that there would be albums on the list that I cannot, nay, WILL not abide. This is one of them. Are there some great Yes songs? Sure. Of course there are. There's a reason that they have endured and people love them 54 years after this, their third studio album. Am I one of those people? NO I AM NOT. Again, Prog rock. I already went on my diatribe about prog rock so I'm not going to drag you through that again, but literally no one needs an 11 minute song that has three sections and features (checks notes) "cosmic imagery, spiritual searching, and New Age philosophy. Inspired by Robert Heinlein's novel of the same name, the song centers on a 'guardian angel' figure and the individual's journey to find inner divinity and truth." Or maybe you do. I'm not going to judge if you love it but I tapped out about 6 minutes into that song because even with the good headphones, it was a LOT. I've Seen All Good People also has three parts and clocks in at 7 minutes. I am thankful that the radio generally cuts this to 3-4 minutes. And you know what? I enjoy those 3-4 minutes. It's an immediately recognizable song - and the mandolin at the very beginning is lovely. Plus, there are some pan-esque flutes. Oh no! What if Zamfir is on this list? I will absolutely drop dead. Also, I looked for a gif of Zamfir and his Magical Pan Flute, and this is what popped up (amongst some other things that are NSFW). Standout: Owner of a Lonely Heart Yes, I KNOW it's not on this album, but so what. It's their best song, IMO
battleships confide in me // tell me where you are
Very long album and songs are super 70s + similar
veel vage nummers, een paar leuke
No
pretty entertaining
One of my favorite prog rock albums we’ve had. Not a genre I typically enjoy but I thought the guitar was good and it wasn’t exhaustingly long. Light 4.
A great progressive rock album. The harmonies on Yours is no Disgrace and All Good People really stand out. The musicianship is top notch, especially Steve Howe's guitar and Chris Squire's bass.
Great musicianship on display here. Obviously this was tightly constructed and lots of work went into this. It’s not the most fun thing for me to listen to but Yes did a good job.
Muy denso, buenos sonidos en algunas partes pero se hace eterno, la verdad no pude terminar de escuchar todas las canciones, no es mi tipo de álbum
I’ve already listened to this album! I like it! 3 ⭐️
First time listening to this album. Fun! Type of prog that makes you forget you're listening to prog, I'd say it's more rock-y 3/5
great
Absolute music
zu lang, zu instrumental
Stereotypical 70’s.
The usual story is that punk rock came about in reaction to bands like Yes (maybe even specifically because of them in some tellings), though in my personal musical history, I came to them after having being steeped in punk and the myriad styles that in turn spawned from it, and just assumed the common wisdom that they sucked. After hearing a number of people I respected musically talking about how much they liked Yes, I thought I'd give them a chance and at least come by my dislike honestly. It took a couple of minutes of Close To The Edge to realize that the punks were all wrong and that Yes ruled. So I got it all backwards, and I can understand why people might not like this, but I like it. Yeah, there's a lot of pompous virtuosity here, baroque arrangements, but for the most part it works because it's all creating this fantastic and imaginative sound world, all rooted in older SF and fantasy book covers, maybe, but I'm of the age where that stuff gives me nice warm feelings.
more pretentious claptrap
I love
god bless dette er så sykt ikke for meg.
Not a massive fan of prog rock, but Starship Troopers and Yours is No Disgrace have some decent parts. OK overall, but wouldn’t listen to it again.
When I was young Yes we're my favourite group, for a time. For pure nostalgia alone I loved this album and it does contain some great tracks.
Mostly really enjoyed it, but “Clap” doesn’t really fit with the rest of the album, not sure why it was included.
Something new, nice discovery
Most of the songs were entirely too long. I did enjoy the upbeat quality of "The Clap" and who can go wrong with a banjo? There is just something about the banjo that always lifts my spirits. I liked, "A Venture" also.
Expansive, overworked arrangements built from ringing guitars, busy bass runs, swirling organ lines, constant tempo shifts, and high, insistent vocals make this Progressive Rock album an overly talkative guide who refuses to skip any detail, which basically just annoys and fatigues me.
Yes, regardless of how hard I try to like them, is usually a no for me.
This was a nice album! The vocals were pleasant, and this was a smooth listen. I'll have to give it another try, since I was a bit distracted while I was going through it, but I still feel it earns a 4.
Favorite Song: Yours Is No Disgrace
Boring
Loved the instruments. Loved
Only one more of these to get through. The No Album. Worse than Fragile.
I respect prog rock but I usually don't love it. This was decent.
I really dislike music where the sole purpose is to showcase the musicians’ skills, with no catchy parts. Yes is one of those bands. It was a struggle to get through in one sitting. I even tried to listen to it again, just in case I’d been missing something. I found it even worse, so I quit halfway through.
Feels a bit like the shaped of prog to come. You can hear what came before and the beginnings of things that bands like Rush would run off with a few years later. The band also emerges as something better than the noodly prog that preceded it. It feels like the band really starts here.
I enjoyed this album. A little less progressive than other things I’ve heard from them, and a little more rock-forward
Banger! Yesterday I was feeling tired and it was the perfect album for that. As soon as I thought it was getting boring, something wacky and interesting happened.
Prog rock (and Yes especially) gets a lot of shit for being pompous and pretentious, but you can't deny the talent on display here. I don't think being able to play your instrument really well should be frowned upon and instead should be celebrated. Anyway, Yes rules.
It must be an incredible feeling to approach an instrument completely unfettered by anything save your own imagination. While this consummate ability may cause you to shit out a goofy, Django Reinhardt-style ditty like The Clap (and then name the composition after a venereal disease), it certainly leads to other gems here. Free of some of the excess that can mark the more didactic offerings of the genre and Yes’s own discography. There are some great rock jams, Starship Troopers pt2, and some, for lack of a better word, poppier tunes, All Good People. On the whole though it doesn’t beg me to relisten to it.
The proggiest prog that ever did prog. I mean, it's not bad, but my first choice for a prog fix is not usually Yes. I can understand why some like it, but for me this is solid average.
Bra gitarr Skön vibe Lite tråkig, händer inte mycket Favoritlåt: Yours is no disgrace
Ahead of its time for sure
feels like I'm flying in a spaceship. decent album.. and I get the transition, but not something I would throw on anytime
First Listen. Was never into Yes - just too proggy for me as a kid. However since then I've ended up loving Supertramp and Pink Floyd so lets see! Some serious guitar playing to open. Mercifully light on the organ so far. Is like the guitarist has to prove they know every trick in the book (and has every pedal)....almost jazz like the way musicians are spiralling off. Washing over me quite nicely - can see why people love this. Will be listening again.
3.5
Some classic prog rock.
You can hear the improvement from their two earlier albums, but relistening to this, you can still they aren't quite there yet. It's a nice flowing album but I don't care for a number of swathes on it all that much. The opener and I've seen all good people are the highlights for me, especially the bass playing on the latter. It's still Yes and it is still a great listen, but it's not quite their peak.
Goed album, i like yes. Niet mijn favoriet van hun maar wel erg sterk
as mid as their other album. this one doesn't have roundabout on it so it gets a lower score.
originally gave a 5 but listening to the songs individually doesn't give the same vibe. the album is like a whole experience but it probably works better all together fav song: Yours Is No Disgrace
Not my thing, not a fan of that classic rock sound.
Love this album, grew up listening to it quite a lot on bus rides home from high school. Some of Yes's finest guitar playing from Howe. Starship Troopers and Perpetual Change are some of my favorite songs ever. Everything else is still a banger. Yes!
in hindsight this is somewhat of a transitional album, their first album with howe and their last album before wakeman. but looking at the context of the release, and the brazen confidence of the album title, its hard to not see it as an intentional magnum opus, and this recklessly sincere cosmic ambition is so illustrative of why yes is likely my favorite classic prog band. this is also the album where they full lock in their hyper-melodic instincts, imbuing their technicolor instrumental chops and anderson's increasingly inscrutable (but still strangely emotionally affecting) lyrics with such a lush and muscley capital m Musicality that can go toe to toe with even their more "accessible" periods. of their prog albums this is likely the most approachable...catchy songs blown up to massive-feeling scale, hippie sweetness and hard rock heaviness, discipline and indulgence in nearly equal measure. honestly one of the big problems with the whole 1001 is a severe deficiency in prog...guess we needed to make room for more britpop records!!!
Not really my cup of tea, but I still had a pretty good time with this album. There’s something boundary‑pushing about it that I like, and it’s not over the top — quite restrained and controlled
What a jawdroppingly amazing album this is. Every time I put it on, it blows me away. The diversity, from acoustic country-ish or Iberian guitar pieces over the big slabs of prog rock to almost jazzy tracks, beggars belief. As does the complete control heard on every note out of every instrument. Staggering. Yes, please!
First song was way too long, 10 minutes of straight noodling. Album in general was not distinct, every song felt like an extension of each other, except for A Venture, fav song off the album. Felt stagnant some moments, melodies change every other second and just feel excessive at times, that may be some peoples thing but not me, not a fan of the aimless feel. Overall groovy, but mid.
good!
Prog rock is one of those genres that is usually really hit or miss for me. This, surprisingly, was right down the middle. I didn't think that it was fantastic. I didn't think that it was always interesting. However, there are some great moments in here. An awesome riff here or there or a nice harmony was enough to get this album a mediocre rating from me. I think it has great elements throughout, but I wish those moments were more frequent and celebrated.
4 bueno
Well, this is just a bit too much out there for my taste. I don't mind a bit of progressive rock, but I couldn't find enough to be happy about on this album. There isn't anything bad really, but it is just a bit too estranging. 3/5
Did not expect to like this as much as I did but very technically good
Yes, it’s pretty good. Light prog rock with a lot of musicality. However by the end I hardly remember any of it.
Classic prob rock! I really like some of these songs and they have some very interesting harmonies.
Meh
Classic prog vibes
My college roommate was OBSESSED with Yes, to the point that he covered his room in Roger Dean's artwork. At the time, my only frame of reference was their left-field '80s hit, "Owner of a Lonely Heart" (and maybe "Roundabout"). Prog isn't my thing, but this is surprisingly palatable. I don't mind it—which counts as high praise from me. I even listened to the expanded edition tracks! The musicianship is pretty great across the board, and I saved "The Clap" to my playlist of instrumentals.