Reviews (page 3 of 15)
Wow this really is a HUGE album. I feel that it is high quality
I’m a sucker for Neil Young
Almost cut my hair, super glad I didn't
It falls off in the back half
Great harmonies and a few great songs. Surprisingly prog-rocky for such a hippie band. You can kinda feel the 4 different huge egos pulling in different directions, but they're all pretty good at music. Subtracting a star out of pure anti-hippie bias.
Feels like eating a meal with not nearly enough dipping sauce and by the end you are slightly dissatisfied
This is the second album in a row (from the same year) that I used to listen to all of the time and absolutely loved. I gave Bridge Over Troubled Water five stars as I once again found it to be as great as I once did. I didn't doubt I'd feel the same way about Deja Vu. And I absolutely did. In fact, the songs that used to be my favorites were again and the ones I thought were a step below excellent still were. I loved CSN, but with the addition of Young it gave them just a bit more of an edge that I thought made them even better. Standouts continued to be Carry On, Helpless, Woodstock, and Deja Vu. And the rest were awesome too.
Real watershed moment for sad dads
I literally exclaimed ‘Christ’ out loud when yet another CSNY and adjacent album popped up but this one is pretty damn good. Som lovely tunes here and they do harmonise well. The weak link for me is Neil Young and that voice. Why does he sound like Kermit the frog?
3.5 stars Not a big fan of C,S&N when they're doing harmonies like the first two tracks. It just doesn't do it for me, too grandpa. Poor choice of track listing to set up the rest of the album. But I do already own this album because of the original versions of Neil Young tracks on it ; Helpless and Country Girl. Also their version of Joni Mitchells"Woodstock" worth the price of admission (she was married to Nash at one stage and had a song or two about him or other relationships). 1 "Carry on": Like I said, not for me 2"Teach Your Children Well"; ditto. Probably wasn't cliche in it's time but it is now. 3"Almost Cut my Hair"; people not put off by the first 2 tracks may have learnt about this one for the first time. Let your freak flag fly. 4/5 4 "Helpless"; 5/5 5 "Woodstock"; 3/5 6 "Deja Vu"; Not my Jam, but you can tell it was a hard song to record, props for that. 3/5 7 "Our House"; Cute song that's been personally ruined by commercial use. 8 "4+20": nice folk song (if you're into that - and I am) 4/5 9 "Country Girl"; 3/5 10 "Everybody I Love You"; Should have started with this track and buried the existing first 2 tracks somewhere else because if you like the last track you'll like the whole album, and vice versa. It's just OK to me as a finisher. 3.5 stars just because of the Neil Young tracks, plus Almost Cut My Hair, Woodstock and 4+20 earn at least that too. But I'm not a fan of the first 2 tracks so it's hard to really highly rate and love the album. My love of Neil Young and wanting to find his older stuff, with this band, and my love of Joni Mitchell and her history came first. So my interest in this album came later, just for interests sake and to complete the circle.
Good old music
Just ok. Slightly annoying vocal harmonies.
Skal sikkert være bra, men litt kjedelig. Men det er noe bra her og der.
Sounds nice. Very easy to listen to voices.
So amazing!!!
Much better than Crosby, Stills & Nash. I'm reinstituting the old system for ratings: 5 = all time F2B with individual moments of brilliance 4 = F2B 3 = Individual moments of brilliance and mostly coherent album 2 = solid. 1 = not an interesting album
Overall just a really nice listen, our house is such a banger
album #95 the harmonies in this album really do bring my joy. i don't necessarily view CSN as a supergroup, but rather a band that should have been together from the start. really lovely album from start to finish. neil young still annoys me though LOL. ꩜ average track rating: 3.2/5 ꩜ favourite track(s): carry on, almost cut my hair ꩜ least favourite track(s): teach your children ꩜ album rating: ★★★⯪☆ ꩜ number of albums left to review: 994 ꩜ number of albums from the list that i agree with being on the list: 46 (+1 Deja Vu) ꩜ albums from the list that I would consider on my list: 21 (+1 Deja Vu) ꩜ albums from the list I won't include on my list: 74
Got really good at the end but weak start
I know that I have listened to this album before. However, I don't remember any of it. You could say that I'm experiencing Deja Vu as I listen to it again.
Fantastic! Flowed really well and was thoroughly enjoyable. 5/5
Great tunes. Melodies for days. Hippie dippy and beautiful. Almost Cut My Hair is a favorite.
The difference between the best (Helpless) and worst (Almost Cut My Hair) track is massive, but as a whole, this album is pretty great.
When David Crosby, Stephen Stills, and Graham Nash decided to form a supergroup, they named it after their last names so that if one member left the band, the band would no longer exist. It all seemed logical. Only the musicians didn't consider that another member might join the group, which would require a new name. As you can see on the cover, two more session members are listed there — a drummer and a bassist — but adding them to the band name would have been too much. While I found the debut album by Crosby, Stills & Nash quite boring, this album is a bit better: traditional acoustic folk is diluted with an electric blues sound. You'd think Neil Young had something to do with it, but no, he's the one whining, true to his work of the same era. The album is considered an immortal classic in the US, but I again found nothing special in it.
deja vu? more like pee-yew
first time listening to 70’s music. it’s pretty chill. skipless album. dunno if i’m ever gonna revisit again tho.
Amazing album by CSNY! So many iconic tracks and collaborations on this album. I’m a massive deadhead so knowing that Jerry Garcia played the pedal steel on Teach Your Children is and added touch on this album. The harmonies, arrangements and pacing of the album came together really well. A timeless album.
No, I didn't like this album either. Maybe it's just my mood right now, but after the first few tracks, I didn't feel like listening to the rest of the album. 2/5
yaaay nice album
Surprisingly good
Déjà Vu doesn't have my favorite Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young song (Ohio), but it's still a great album in its own right.
That sweet spot between hippy dippy 1960s and hard burnout early 1970s folk rock.
Great-sounding album with a lot of great songs
8/10 Its very 60's vibes instead of 70's lol
It reminds me of Yes on some parts, making the experience really nice for roughly half of the album. The other half... Didn't really stick much to me.
What do I have to do to get leas Crosby and Stills- hell at least I got Young. Neil’s dirtiness is the entire key and none of these guy should have made music without him- except maybe Nash.
Powerhouse of an album for sure! I have always enjoyed CSNY, but I typically enjoy CSN without Y more (I've never been a Neil Young guy- I don't enjoy his style of singing). I found the same rang true for this album- the more Young heavy songs weren't my favorite, but I still found myself liking them. The real power the group has is when they all come together with vocal harmonies and skilled instrumentation (Carry On, Woodstock). Overall- great album and quintessential sound of the late hippie movement. I'd personally give it a 4.5, but I think the talent and songwriting boosts it to a 5.
Sympa
lots of great classic songs here. A must listen album. A prototype of the "in-band fighting and tension makes the songs better" genre.
The greatest moments of one of the most iconic supergroups in music history. It really does shine and showcase each of their strengths individually. 10/10 [KEEP]
Décevant, 1 tune sur 2 de bonne
Almost cut my hair…. Frl. Juste ca que jai a dire
Vrm nice on dirait bcp the doors c’est cool
7+ / 10
Love this album. Need to listen to the whole set of CSN&Y albums. Gives more folksy hall and oats folk + some jazziness that is so enjoyable to listen to. Maybe not revolutionary, but an album I could listen to again and again.
Fun and nostalgic, reminds me of the kind of music I listen to with my Dad in the car
Folky, country twanged rock with those classic vocal harmonies. It starts so slow. The recording also seems to push the vocals to the top of the mix, meaning I can barely hear some of the instruments. Nothing really sticks with me until the second half. Luckily from Woodstock onwards the album becomes a bit more experimental, with the proggy [deja-vu] being the standout. The Beatles-esque [our house] appears to be the real hit for many. It's every flavour of cosy and twee - not to my personal taste but I can respect the feelings. [4+20] is dark, folky ditty. It thankfully has one vocalist which makes it one of the best tracks in my book. [Country girl] returns to those proggy sensibilities - but for me the vocals are too busy and detract from some pleasing rhythm and melody. Final track [Everybody I love you!] Returns to the earlier album tendancies of vocals first and everything else is in the back. This is difficult for me to rate because I don't mind the bands sound. I struggle with the grating harmonies and their prominence in the mix. It's between a 2 and 3. I'm not seeking to put it on but probably listen to some songs again.
Rock/country clássico bem semelhante a Creedence, bem legal e nostálgico.
I hadn't realized how many of the CSNY songs I know are on the same album. I like the trio without Neil Young, but they rock when they're with him. Woodstock, for instance, has an energy that I don't find in any of the CSN songs. I like that I can tell the four voices apart, but that they still blend well.
Very wide ranging, somewhat too much? Individually the songs are amazing, but there doesn't feel like a solid connection between them.
63/100
Great album
Smooth and easy to listen to folk music/folk rock(?). Skilled artists with really good voices. Perfect relaxing music to have on while reading a book or just hanging out in the summer.
great
Such a great album. Great sharing of songwriting voices, everyone at the peak of their powers. Such a classic era, Almost Cut My Hair is incredible
My very first impression, a lifetime ago, was simply: "This sounds like YES."Granted, in those days, taping songs off FM radio was my main source of music discovery, and as a mere junior high schooler, my perspective was limited. Yet, if you were to ask for my impression today, I would say: "It sounds like Happy End."But enough of those whimsical comparisons.Listening with matured ears today, the psychedelic flourishes and raw rock elements are no longer the main draw.While the distinct individuality of all four members is undeniably brilliant—with each carving out remarkable paths later in their careers—it is the songwriting of Graham Nash and Joni Mitchell that captivates me most.Whether driven by their intimacy at the time remains a mystery, but the sheer quality of their catchy, pop-infused melodies is unparalleled.Even the title track, "Déjà Vu," carries a psychedelic edge that genuinely echoes the progressive rock of YES.It leaves no doubt as to why this album is universally hailed as a masterpiece.And Neil Young’s vocals possess an indescribable, haunting melancholy that is utterly irresistible.
It's a lovely album. Some songs I've always loved, especially our house. But definitely found new favorites: country girl, almost cut my hair.
It's not my favorite CSNY, but it IS CSNY. A very good album.
Småsnork
While this is not my usual music style, I really liked this album. For me, it certainly has some Led Zeppelin vibes, especially on "Almost Cut My Hair", one of the tracks that really stood out to me. All in all a very interesting album with amazing sound!
BUENISIMOOOOOO
4/7
ok
pleasant folk
It sounds like they put some kind of damper on everything. The sound got old quickly. Our house and 4 + 20 are great songs
This isn’t something I’d normally want to listen to but it has its moments. Neil Young is, well, Neil Young and I’m always happy to listen to him even though I prefer him solo. “Our House” is a lovely song about domesticity and is probably the highlight of the album for me.
Standouts Carry On Helpless Woodstock Our House
There's not a bad track on this album, and I don't even like folk that much. The harmonies are perfect, and the songwriting is pretty close to perfect.
A 5. Every track is amazing. The vocals are on point and the instrumentation (bass and drums, in particular) are outstanding.
вайбово, одну песню засейвил. (про кошек)
This is a great album, with historical hindsight it catches the transformation from pastoral hippy dream of the 60s into the grimer 70s. I really like this album, But I never really have it as a go to, I just like CSN without Y, I like Young doing his own thing more. Think it just adds an edge that only really works on this album, but on this album it does work. 5 Star
I really enjoyed this. Similar to Big Star this is right in my sweet spot for nostaligic good times American rock of 70's. Similar to Big Star there is a nice mix of styles and some lovely harmonies. Who woulda funk it another 5 for Neil.
Déjà Vu This has been the sound of the hot weather this week, especially having been out and about in the car, the sunny Californian patina to the harmonies feeling quite magical against the golden brown of the fields and hedgerows. Along with the Everly Brothers and the Beatles, CSNY are some of my favourite harmony singers, and they sound fantastic on here, backed up by some excellent guitar and some superb songs. Although I love the 2nd side, particularly Everybody I Love You, Neil’s Country Girl suite, 4+20 and Our House, the first side is utterly fantastic. The two songs welded together for Carry On make for a superb opener, especially the bass, and the hippy-country of Teach Your Children has such a lovely charm to it. Almost Cut My Hair is the uber-Crosby-Hippie anthem, and is again great. Their version of Woodstock finished the side brilliantly, but the apogee of side 1 and the whole record is Helpless, a truly beautiful song, played, sung and harmonised superbly. The 2nd side doesn’t quite match the first, but as I say it’s still excellent, all adding up to an easy 5. 💇💇💇💇💇 Playlist submission: Helpless
These are in effect a collection of solo tracks written and mixed by each individual, with different levels of input from the rest. Stills' 'Carry On' is the perfect opener as it puts the band to the forefront - with harmonies you couldn't fit a razor blade betwixt, and bassline adding constant movement. Crosby's psychedelic bent with 'Almost Cut My Hair' is dreamy country psychedlia. Young's songs are characteristically solemn and floating efforts, in 'Country Girl' (excellent Beatlesque outro) and 'Helpless'. Then you get Nash turning up with his English whimsy, thankfully not psychedelic or throwaway, but sincere. 'Our House' (whilst indelibly linked in my mind to the Halifax building society adverts in the 90s), is a perfect encapsulation of nostalgia, seeing wonder in domestic life. About the only track here that feels average is 'Woodstock' l, which feels stilted vs the Matthews Southern Comfort version. The album, ironically, feels the consummate band performance, effortlessly mixing the various styles with each member near a songwriting peak. I feel it just musters its way to the top.
Tiene sus momentos. Me dió un poco de repelús ver a Neil Young, viejo choborra
A lovely album that made its mark on the history of music, especially with the hippie movement :))
Ok Vocals!! These songs are produced in such a beautiful, meticulous way. Love love love the harmonies. I listened to the Deluxe Version, I had so much fun with the demos. “Our House” demo in particular made me so happy, I showed it to my partner right away because it reminded me of him. I feel like I haven’t listened to this music since I was a little kid. Made me feel very cozy and nostalgic <3
De Ja Vu indeed. I know going in it’s getting a 3. Why? Because I can’t bring myself go lower despite a longing to give it a 1 out of spite. It’s musically competent, 1/2 the songs on it are instantly recognizable mega hits, its influence is long reaching and undeniable. This album featured prominently in my dad’s album collection. And because of its inclusion on best of lists and what not I have made myself listen to it again and again. Before this exercise I was unclear about certain issues regarding my relationship with music, and particularly the music surrounding me as a child. But something has become clearer over the last weeks. The false earnestness of the 60’s “folk” movement makes me ill. Damn. As much as I hate aspects of this, our house being a case in point, the rhythm and variations within songs is really impressive. Arghh. I’m giving it a 4. 4 Boolean: True, true, yeah, yeah, let’s all love one another
goes hard
Simple, compelling, one-of-a-kind folk rock. This supergroup is taken for granted over 50 years after its creation, but this was a big deal! Amazing time capsule of the hippie movement at its peak. The blend of their voices together is otherworldly.
Great album.
A fan of Neil Young but less familiar with the other three. A decent collection of tracks with the first track and Young's contributions the highlights. Excellent but not essential.
At the heart of it, I just find the ways that Crosby, Stills & Nash (& Young) are very much individual singer-songwriters of a similar ilk and sound but not exactly the same and so they’re trying to corral each other together ends up makes the music absolutely sing. The vocal harmonies are gorgeous, the layering of the instrumentation steps that up further, and them each taking turns at writing songs means you get this really nice variety of theme and tone from song to song (plus their cover of Woodstock is also really good too). I’m already really high on it but I think it could still be a grower as I come back round to it more, honestly.
Didn't liked it
Woodstock is honestly my favorite song on this album; I like its hard guitar compared to the rest of the album. That’s not to say the rest of the album isn’t worth a listen, 4+20 is also really good.
Kinda embodies why i like the idea of this 1001 albums thing because I actually had no idea who Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young were other than knowing Neil Young by name alone. Great rock/folk record with a lot of highlights for me, enjoyed it pretty thoroughly
Okay me likey all songs in this, proper country folk typa music i like
Supergroups almost always end up being less than the sum of their parts, but I do feel this record is an exception. The musicians all mesh really well together and produce an album with some incredible performances and memorable tunes.
I don't love all of their songs. But the ones that hit for me, I REALLY love. This album has enough of the latter to rate 5 stars. Even their lesser songs are better than a lot of the crap that counted as folk rock of the time.
Really interesting to hear Neil Young as a part of a group. I had only been familiar with his solo work. This album is really fun and history of the group was really fascinating. I was surprised by how much of the album I actively enjoyed, particularly the songs that I had not heard before. "Almost Cut My Hair" jumps out as an all time great song. Crosby's vocals are so good and he's supported by the bands backing.
Enjoyed every song. Teach Your Children had a fantastic country music intro. 5/5
Young var fed, resten var ligegyldigt.
Der er få gode tracks, men rigtig meget der slet ikke fungere for mig.
For their second album, Crosby, Stills and Nash expanded their line-up to incorporate Neil Young, transforming into CSN&Y. The inclusion of Young adds a necessary grit that prevents the album from becoming overly sweet. However, his arrival upset the established dynamic of the first record, where Stephen Stills had essentially been the musical director. This new creative relationship ultimately did not work smoothly between Stills and Young, resulting with Young effectively treating his contributions as solo records due to Stills perfectionist nature, and presenting almost completed mixes to Crosby, Stills and Nash simply for them to add their vocal harmonies. Yet, despite the fractured nature of the recording process, the final production sounds remarkably cohesive, and the trademark vocal harmonies remain masterful throughout. Side one is a flawless, perfect collection of songs, whereas side two represents a slightly more varied listening experience, where the individual solo styles of the members become more pronounced. This leaves Déjà Vu being a fine album that highlights the immense talent of its four members but the record just misses out on top marks. Four stars. Side One 1. Carry On A great opening track that sets the bar remarkably high. (5/5) 2. Teach Your Children A beautifully crafted, country-tinged number. (5/5) 3. Almost Cut My Hair I realise not everyone may rate this as highly as me but the absolute standout feature of this track is the live interplay of the guitar work between Stills and Young - it is quite stunning. (5/5) 4. Helpless My personal favourite on the album, though I much prefer Neil Young's solo live versions of the track, most notably his performance on Live at Massey Hall 1971. (5/5) 5. Woodstock A heavy, driving transformation of Joni Mitchell's original that perfectly rounds out an immaculate side of music. (5/5) Side Two 1. Déjà Vu Crosby's jazz-inflected title track is intriguing but slightly breaks the momentum. (3/5) 2. Our House Nash's pristine, highly memorable slice of domestic pop. (4/5) 3. 4 + 20 A stark and beautiful track from Stills. (4/5) 4. Country Girl (including Whiskey Boot Hill / Down, Down, Down / Country Girl) A grand, sweeping three-part suite from Young that brilliantly utilizes the group's massive vocal layers. (4/5) 5. Everybody I Love You A high-energy, guitar-driven rocker that brings the album to a lively finish. (4/5) Total - 44 Average - 4.4 358/1001 191/358 albums reviewed were new to me.
Forty years ago, this LP was often on my turntable, but I hadn't listened to it for a decade. A couple of listens, and my opinion hasn't really changed - excellent harmonies, some brilliant songs ... but some tracks just don't hit it for me. "Helpless" the worst offender, tho' I know that many love it.
The change in the middle of Carry On took me by surprise. Only song I already knew was Our House which honestly I’d always assumed was a beatles song. This album is so seventies. It takes you on a journey.
Strong 7 - lovely harmonies, Young adds a lot of texture to the album with his guitar skillz
I had a similar experience with "Bridge Over Troubled Water". As a child of the '70's, several of these songs have always existed, are such a part of the soundscape of my childhood. It's hard to understand that actually they're on an album. I love the sound and the feel of this.
I actually don’t love their harmonies. Too aggressive at times. The Young tracks are the standouts along with Teach Your Children and Our House. For every great track there is a total bummer for me
Only really enjoyed the Neil tracks, the others were forgettable.
Meh it’s overrated. Neil Young is the best.
Another 70s rock album. I barely get anything else from this list. Luckily, it was significantly more enjoyable than the others. Cool melodies, nice singin, stellar songwriting.
Deja vu indeed
Folk rock.
Just always like this one. Young and Crosby's compositions stand out.
hippie national anthem
very solid folk rock but man i cannot take woodstock or hippies seriously for some reason
4.5
Nothing much to say. Good folk rock. (7/10) Favorite tracks: “Carry On”, “Almost Cut My Hair”, “Woodstock”
Not really my thing. Very mellow.
Good
Some classics here. Enjoyable bops
L’équivalent de Steele dan en country/folk C’est quand même doux et joli, je préfère la fin de l’album je crois 7/10 du coup
Love this, really made my afternoon
honestly its pretty good even though i dont like this type of music, impressive
Our House really jumps out of this album. It was otherwise fine, a nice desk listen
It’s got some highlights (mainly “Our House”), but most of this album is pretty boring. Take off “Our House” and it’s probably a 2.
Found this one to be a lotta funn
Those harmonies sure do hit. Although this is a group project, Neil sure stands out as the A student.
Superb
4/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/crosby-stills-nash-and-young/deja-vu/ Nice! Not every song as catchy as the other, but the variety in singing voices is very enjoyable and there are some absolute bangers on this.
Grande Álbum!
Falls down a bit on the second half, but other than that, good dad rock album.
sehr chill, gute spliffer musik. 3.61 sterne
Brilliant album...
Easily their best. Harmony at its best. All time songs. Easy 5
Helpless et My House sont deux morceaux fabuleux, mais bon je me retrouve à simplement attendre le prochain moment ou je vais enfin entendre Young chanter à nouveau. Le problème quand un des membre mog violement les autres c'est que du coup la barre est trop haute j'imagine...
Passive rock and country blend, not really to my liking. Recording standards have improved so much that this feels very poorly presented without having to crank the volume. There's clearly some guitar noodling here for some folk to enjoy, track 3 for example feels like something that would have been great live with some weed. Could do with more exciting drumming though, very stable and unadventurous.
This was ok, but I really only liked when Graham Nash or Neil Young sang. I know and love the song Our House. I also knew Teach Your Children. I’m not a fan of Stephen Stills or David Crosby’s voice.
Коридоры пустых советских больниц. Хотел подобрать хотя бы оригинальное описание для того, что прослушал. Я очень старался вникнуть или может специально понять значимость данного альбома. Все напрасно: по моему мнению этот альбом мало чем отличается от сотен других идентичных очень похож по звучанию на его предшественника - bridge over trouble river. Их некорректно сравнивать, но там может зацепить вокал и этакая тягучесть альбома. Здесь - лично для меня очень пресный альбом. Поэтому оценка будет 3/10.
Our house is a classic , the rest of the album I am not sure on tbh
okay maybe this is a banger
holy freaking peak genuinely such a banger
I need to listen to this again to enjoy more. I love Neil young generally but I wasn’t gripped by half this album, and really enjoyed the other half, I guess depending on who wrote/sang the songs. Loved the production though. Those 70s drums and tight production is the best. This album has so much notoriety it’s definitely worth another listen.
det er helt ok. kanskje litt kjedelig. country girl var nice
My rating 3.6. Lovely album
Some heaters in here Will I listen to again: 100%
꽤 괜찮은 노래였다. 특별히 좋은 노래는 없었지만 전체적인 곡의 분위기가 좋았던 것 같다. It was a pretty good song. There were no particularly good songs, but I think the overall atmosphere of the song was good.
Country/soft folk rock. There's really not much more to say... Deja Vu has a more proggy feel to it, which I like. Ooh, I know Our House and like it too It ends up a bit eclectic, but I suppose an album with so many songwriters will do that Best track - Helpless, Deja Vu, Our House 3 stars
Ah men här är jag, riktift bra! Ändå lite blandad vibb på denna!
So many memories in this album. Road trips with my folks and hanging with my cousins
This album surprised me and I ended up liking it more than I thought I would.
Crazy that Neil young was able to weasel his way into this album. Great album other than that though lol
It's some core boomer rock, and it's okay. It's also like 1/4 a Neil Young album, so that sucks. Idk, this run of the mill dad rock doesn't really do it for me
Excellent folk rock that is utterly ruined by a single, terrible, Neil Young solo track.
The first album was all dreamy harmonies and beautiful tunes. Then along comes Neil Young and puts some grit and grunge in. You know lots of these tunes already. It can get a bit summer of love and love is the answer, but that grit does its job. And Helpless really is one of the best songs ever written.
good.
I liked this much more than expected. I've always found "Teach Your Children" to be unbearably cheesy so I didn't have high hopes for this album. Turns out they make significantly better music than that.
Pretty good, a nice collection of songs
Back-to-back Our Houses. Freaky.
Ooh this one has some good songs that remind me of childhood, teach your children and helpless are excellent as well as our house. 4.5/5
4 masters of their craft coming together. This had to be legendary and well, it is. It's very sharp and punchy for a record in this style, the production is super well done. A great fall album.
So, some of the lyrics on this album sound a little ridiculous and very hippie-centric nowadays (I'm looking at you, "Almost Cut My Hair"). But that said, this is a lovely album with great 3 part harmonies, and some occasional vocals and skronk from Neil. It's a very listenable time capsule from its time and place.
4 Liked it, not every song worked for me but most did
Filled with gems! The Joni Mitchell penned high point, Woodstock, partners with the achingly sweet Our House. Teach Your Children, Carry On, Helpless, Almost Cut My Hair.....all simply wonderful.
This is a great contrast to the Allman Brothers album. I’m not into “folk-rock” any more than I’m into blues rock, but holy shit if this isn’t just an assembly of all time great songwriters.
Classic songs, lovely harmonies, peaceful and folky. A great album.
Interesting but sounds like every band from the 70s Some greats and mids
It's honestly quite surprising that four huge egos came together to put together a great album.
Quite a lovely album. Amazing guitars.
Fine not for me
Good but not great. Still enjoyed it though.
I went in knowing the album well and assuming a 5 but listening with critical ears, it's a little over the top on the hippy front lyrically. Ton of classics though, the vocal performance is ridiculous, and there's some really good instrumental jams there too. 4.5 rounded up.
I was much more familiar with solo Neil than CSNY, but this is just the peak of this genre of music. Beautiful harmonies, great songs, great guitar work (acoustic and electric) and at least 3 of their most well known songs. Gotta be a 5 star.
I just had the best time listening to this
I purchased this album when I was 15 with my bday money. I wore it out and purchased it again. Then bought it again in CD format. I was fascinated and enthralled with both the musicality and harmonizing vocals. It made me a Neil Young fan. I became fascinated with the pedal steel guitar. Our House was my American Dream which I was gratefully rewarded with.
This thing was fire. Great vibes. I have nothing bad to say. Definitely a 4/5.
Crazy instrumentals, I added 4 songs to my favourites. At the start I thought that this album will be pain, but it is actually fun and I enjoyed it
A little snapshot in time of music in this era.
Interesting genre, I don't think I've heard anything like this yet Carry on- Definitely feels like a campfire song or upbeat, not enough to feel like a car-ride song though. I don't hate the bridge I like woodstock and would definitely add it to a folk playlist
Beautiful vocal harmonies in a collection of great folk songs, with just enough teeth to not be cloying. What is not to love? Neil Young's contributions do kinda overshadow the others, but this is still an excellent folk rock record
Beautiful! I'm always impressed.
favs almost cut my hair our house rating 1/5
It was okay, not really my thing
id give it 3,5 but i cant ;(
More rocky, less folky than I was expecting. Doesn’t quite hit the heights of the prior CS&N album or Young’s very best
almost cut my hair is the most amazing song i’ve heard in my life I LOVE this album
Crosby stills Nash and Young did not invent the four-part Harmony They just did it correctly. Every band who is attempted to do four part harmony ever since has to compare themselves to CSNY. And no, folk music isn't for everyone, but this music is consumable by almost everyone. It's approachable and completely belongs on this list because it's iconic.
Comforting and familiar. Interesting to hear CSN morph into CSNY, as Neil Young steps to the forefront in the later tracks.
Ah zut ! Je pensais avoir fini les albums avec Stills, mais j'ignorais qu'il avait aussi joué en quartet avec Crosby, Nash et Young. Quartet ennuyeux comme la pluie, trop country/folk et pas assez rock, comme toutes les autres productions de ces personnages. =>2/5 J'espère cette fois avoir réellement fini les Stills, mais il me reste toujours 4 (!) Young à subir ...
I liked some of the songs, I dont listen to this genre very much but some of the songs sounded similar to david bowie songs
Quite a mix. I really liked some songs. Less so many others. I only just realised at the end that the Young is Neil Young.
Took years to 'get' Neil Young, but I now love his stuff.
My parents were hippie-light, so CSN&Y were in constant rotation in our household. This album is perfect. Excellent vocal blends. Tight 2-4 minute songs. Excellent guitar work and writing. It perfectly encapsulates the Summer of Love with the threat of Vietnam on the outskirts. It's a really solid record from first track to last. The only weak track happens to be its longest -- Neil Young's attempt at an opus call Country Girl drags a little too long while the rest of the record is so tight.
I like the more raw moments like when the shuffly beat comes in on Carry On and the guitar licks of Woodstock. Great hearing Neil Young. Our House is really sweet, albeit always reminds me of the show Life Goes On, which then makes me a lil' sad. Not really my thing but it's good. I wouldn't put it on again but wouldn't mind if someone else did.
Fuck yeah. I find this to be far superior to their first album… waaay less meandering filler. No real low points and the highs (helpless and our house specifically) are just absolute 10/10s
The only songs worth a salt that Neil Young recorded are on this album, and if you ever questioned Joni Mitchell's songwriting chops Woodstock will correct your bad opinion. Man alive what an album. Straight gas until the last couple songs and even those are excellent.
The peaks are sky high, but the rest of the album is more fine than good. (3.5)
Standout album in the 70's folk/rock genre. There are a few legendary songs, but the album isn't something that I want to listen to repeatedly. Pitchfork: n/a Rolling Stone: Top 500 Albums #220 Best Songs Carry On Teach Your Children Our House
It’s pretty great I gotta admit. As much as I may groan, sigh, cringe or otherwise at a few of these tunes, that’s about sthg else if I’m honest. The album can’t be held responsible for thirty-eleven-teen Vietnam movies high jacking these quintessential 60s classics. That Neil solo too. Can always pick out his style & I’m here for it. This is an easy 4.
Will revisit closer
Yeah I didn't listen to this. I'll probably recommend it to a friend
This was okay, but doesn't stand out to me. I like some songs but don’t know if I’ll come back to it. TOP Songs: Helpless, 4+20, Woodstock
I don't get the hype: 80% of the album is OK but pretty boring. Not even the incidental presenc of Neil Young (that I typically appreciate) can make it better. Besides contributing a few guitar parts, he authors one good song (Helpless) and a pretty useless one. The only other genuinely interesting piece is Crosby's Almost Cut My Hair.
It was ok. Maybe I'll give it another go sometime in the future.
Nothing notable but pretty chill
Some of these songs are so beautiful. This album is a wonderful mix of blues, rock and roll, pop and folk. I need to listen to more CSNY.
This was the perfect album for the first really hot day of summer - didn't realise how many bangers came from this record and made me remember how much I love a mix of vocal tone 🤩
Not every song grabbed me, but really liked this overall. Not too long and nice to have variety! Havent heard Our House is years and years so that was a welcome surprise, also liked Country Girl
Not a bad album, but its just not my cup of tea. Some songs felt a bit slow to me but the songs I did enjoy had a lot of vocal depth and great-sounding melodies and instrument isolation. 4/10, Favorite Song: Country Girl
I enjoyed parts of this, especially Carry On and Woodstock and some of the production. But ultimately not for me.
TAK TAK
Very solid album from CSNY
Nice, short and to the point, but a smidge too country to really give it any better than a 3
This is a nice listen.
The harmonies on this are exquisite.
Love this album so much. Honestly essential stuff, with a great variety of styles
A very good surprise. I was expecting the worst since I like neither country music nor Neil Young, but this album is more on the blues and psychedelic side, and it totally works. Except for a couple of country and folk-oriented tracks that bored me (like "Teach Your Children"), most of the songs are solid blues-rock offerings with a trippy psych twist. The musicians are competent, and even Neil Young's voice is far more tolerable than usual. He should totally have stayed with that bunch instead of churning out dozens upon dozens of extremely average solo country albums. Not necessarily something I'd come back to, but I'm glad I gave it a try. 6/10
Not as "folk" as I remembered.
Beautiful harmonies, solid songwriting, cool and clean folk vibe. But it’s almost too soft, comfortable and padded to really hit me emotionally. I definitely respect it, but I don’t think I’ll come back to it very often.
Yeah… I want to hate. I do. I strongly dislike Neil Young. I feel like I am supposed to like this the way I am supposed to like the Beatles. It bugs me. But… yeah, I have to admit it’s good. I would never listen to it if I weren’t compelled. The presence of Teach Your Children makes that a certainty. But I have to give the album a 4, none the less. Boolean: yes, I admit it was good to hear this yet AGAIN before I die.
I was so ready to be a hater, but this slapped. Still prefer Michael Scott’s version of ‘Teach Your Children’ though.
I dont know, a lot of the songs sound and feel the same to me. Our House and Country Girl were my stand outs though. 5.6/10.
hostia el estéreo, mucha guitarra, almost cut my hair queee, la acústica de 4 + 20 ufffff
Classic rock :)
Absolutely flawless. Incredibly important album. Everyone know Our House. Carry On is a crazy opener. Teach Your Children, Almost Cut My Hair, and Helpless keep it going. Woodstock is one of my favorite all-time songs. Country Girl has me falling in love with a girl I've never know. And Everybody I Love You is a great way to close it out.
Excellent harmonies. Every track is great to my ears. Love the Laurel Canyon sound.
Turns out I know all these songs even though I didn't know the album. Really good harmonies. Couple hidden gems in there that I didn't expect to like. Helpless, by Neil Young.
Exeptional!
Não gostei não
There are some undeniable classics on here. All the musicians are great, but I still don't really enjoy Young's voice all the time.
When I was in college about 15 years ago, my roommate got a record player. He and I were both fans of classic rock so we went to the second hand record store and browsed through what they had. We bought every Beatles, Led Zeppelin, and Pink Floyd album we could along with some Journey and Eagles albums. Along with those we bought Deja Vu by Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young, and man was that a great choice. I wore this record out listening to it over and over while studying. It was the perfect mix of smooth and relaxing along with just enough energy to keep me going. I can still hear the hiss of the worn out needle as "Carry On" fades in, even if that detail is only in my mind. What I'm saying here is that my 5 star rating may be dripping in nostalgia, but I absolutely love this album.
Light to decent 5
Some good folk rock, with a touch of country influence. Sometimes it may fall into background music, but the music is well crafted and the layered harmonies are gorgeous. 'Carry On' starts off the record and it is a stomping folk rocker before turns all psychedelic when it gets to the bridge. I was there was more surprises like that on here. 'Our House' is the only song I knew before diving into this and it makes me feel rather emotional, even if it is just about the simple satisfaction of having a place to call your own with the person you love. Sometimes songs don't have to be complex musically or lyrically to stir some emotion out of me. Having only been acquainted with Neil Young before pressing play, this album has made me interested in hearing from the rest of this supergroup.
So far, I am really enjoying this album. The songs are really good, even if the voices are sometimes grating. Overall, this is giving a 3 or a 4, not something life changing but still an enjoyable listen
A solid effort by CSN and sometimes Y.
This album is practically a greatest hits. I always forget what an incredible guitarist Stephen Stills is on acoustic, especially. For many years, I thought Crosby was the high harmony, but it's actually Nash. Crosby was the harmony expert doing all the difficult middle parts. Love this record. Was the perfect salve right at the moment I listened.
Of it's time production-wise but an incredibly easy listen.
They’re great together. One of the bands where my ideal situation would be a greatest hits album but yeah, I’m into it
A product of its time. Sounds similar to CreedanceCR, The Beatles etc. Not a massive fan of the vocals in my personal tastes, but I am very fond of the drums and especially the guitar in this album. Instrumentally, it’s great.
muito bom véi
Listening right now, on the first song of the album, I like this style of music and the vocals are very nice and harmonic and reminds me of the Beatles with a bit more of a kick. So far I will be adding some of these songs to my playlist if the album maintains this sound. The second song I assume is starting now and I really enjoy the intro to it. The guitar is good and the synth or whatever instrument it is sounds cool and makes the song sound cool. I enjoy the talkbox or similar pedal on the guitar solo. Third song is playing and I'm still liking the vocals and how they all harmonize and sound really soft and cool. I think this is enough note but I love this. 5 stars
Incredible album overall - so many great songs. Carry On possibly their best song and no bad songs on the album. Was interesting to listen to which songs they pieced together and which they all performed together. Fantastic album 5
Moer like tis please
I had somehow heard like zero of these songs before, and I kind of understand why. They are not my jam. I have to give it a three on artistic merit, but I wouldn't listen to it again.
Always is nice to hear an album of these stars.
Fantástico
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s Déjà Vu is a standout country-rock masterpiece that thrives on the individual strength of its tracks despite a lack of thematic consistency. While "Carry On" is a classic, the mix is incredibly jarring on headphones due to the dated "hard-panning," which shoves the guitar aggressively into one ear and creates a lopsided, exhausting listening experience. Beyond that technical hurdle, the album balances grit and grace, moving from the dark, visceral loneliness of "4+20" to the oddly soothing imagery of "Helpless" and the domestic gratitude of "Our House." While "Almost Cut My Hair" strikes a more eccentric note, the record finds its peak in the title track’s Pink Floyd-esque tempo shifts and the timeless resonance of "Woodstock." Ending on the high note of "Everybody I Love You," the album earns a 5/5 for its ability to transform disparate moods—from country-tinged social commentary to grand, theatric climaxes—into one of the genre's most essential listening experiences.
3.5
very enjoyable boomer classic
This record was very good. I wasn't expecting what was given here, but I am pleasantly surprised. Favourite Track(s): Almost Cut My Hair, Deja Vu, Our House Least Favourite Track(s): Carry On
The beautiful harmonies and warm folk-rock sound often feel nostalgic, but there is also an underlying sense of uncertainty and emotional weariness running through the record. Almost Cut My Hair and Helpless stood out to me the most. In particular, “letting my freak flag fly” felt deeply relatable to me as someone who has grown older without ever fully fitting into society.
Love this album! CSNY's best. Highlights: "Helpless" and "Our House"
Fairly good vibe. I liked Our House that was a good one.
Liked Woodstock and our house, nothing special though
I was not expecting to like it as much as I did! I enjoyed the cross section between classic rock, folk, and country and thought the intersection of them were fused artfully. I thought the vocal harmonies throughout the album were tasteful and contributed positively to their overall sound. Additionally, the light guitar licks between verses/choruses were effective in adding interest, without taking away from the focus of the song. Personally, my favorite tracks were Almost Cut My Hair and Deja Vu. Would absolutely listen again!
I already love the vibe from the moment the first song starts. It’s so chill! The kind of music to just kick back to.
3.7
I actually know and really like Teach Your Children and Our House, I didn't know this was the group that did those songs! It definitely captures the general feel of the 70's, that's for sure. Good background music for work, maybe not an album I personally would choose to actively listen to.
A lot of great tracks on this one. Carry On, Teach Your Children, Woodstock, and Our House are all classics and Neil Young's Helpless was new to me but very good. What really makes this a supergroup is seeing how each member contributes so much to the songwriting. There were a couple that didn't hit as much for me, but this is a very fine album.
"our house" fave song out of the album and "carry on." Makes me remember of my grandparents blasting music like this in speakers at 2 pm. "4+20" is a vibe too damn. Reminds me of the movie Sinners highkey. Anyways 3.7/5
No pass out sign on the Door set me thinking Are waitresses paying the Price of their winking While stars sit at bars and Decide what they're drinking They drop by to die 'cause It's faster than sinking Too late to keep the change Too late to pay No time to stay the same Too late to keep the change Too late to pay No time to stay the same Too young to leave Find out that now was the Answer to answers That you gave later She did the things that we Both did before now But who forgave her? If I could stand to see her crying I would tell her not to care When she learns of all your lyin' Will she join you there? COUNTRY GIIIIRRRLLLL I THINK YOU'RE PRETTY, GOT TO MAKE YOU UNDERSTAAAANNNNDDDD, HAVE NO LOVERS IN THE CITYYYYYY, LET ME BEEEEEEE YOUR COUNTRY MAAAANNNNN
This one brings back memories of seeing CSN&Y live twice in 1975 and a highlight was an extended version of "Carry on." Distinctive guitars play with "Almost cut my hair" with Stephen and Neil. Also, another memory form that time was a high school friend who was a piano savant. He listened to "Our house" twice then sat down to his piano and played it from start to finish. The two weakest songs were from Neil Young compared the rest of the album.
Wait this may be one of my favorites. Also of course major props for there being a dog in the album cover which brought me into a deep dive of the creation of the album cover which was so cool to read about. I love humans and I love music. The electric guitar on Deja Vu may have changed my life. I actually had a spiritual experience after this album deep diving into these guys and genre. Unbelievable that i’m having my 70’s rock awakening this late tbh.
recien termino de escucharlo, es el primero. la verdad sorprendido, hay dos canciones que me quedaron enganchadas, un solido 8/10.
A classic album. Sounds from my childhood, and stuff that my father would blast out loud. I didn't realize how iconic this was. Now, I get it. I would listen to it again.
Pretty boring. It's folk rock but like not in an interesting way.
It was pretty good nothing outstanding.
This album is great. Nearly a five. Came up just short.
A solid folk rock album that leans more towards rock. Both the instrumentals and vocals were decent to good. I will say that this album's cover of "Woodstock" is definitely worse than Joni Mitchell's version.
This is so boring.
This is some real hippie ass shit.
No lo acabé de escuchar, se me hizo tan aburrido, neta q pedo con los gringos y su obsesión por el country
I was familiar with a lot of this record and enjoyed the vibe of the whole thing . A couple of beautiful standouts.
Probably their best album yet I can objectively say it very awesome but the country twist is not personal preference. The blues aspect thou is mindblowing and gives it another level of technical and improvisation vibe. A very good album
Наконец-то кантриговно
Who would of thought that adding Neil Young to the roster would make it better? Crazy idea...
Well this is some boomer rock right here. But it's also a stone cold classic, basically a greatest hits collection. Having Young on board for this it is the icing on the cake with his contributions "Helpless" and "Country Girl." Yes, the hippie manifesto "Almost Cut My Hair" is pretty cringe but "Teach Your Children," "Woodstock," "Our House"...pretty damn good.
Defining folk rock album. Unsurprisingly I found myself most drawn to the songs that Neil Young wrote and sang lead on, but there's not a bad song on this. Also really enjoyed the Joni Mitchell-penned Woodstock
A best album ever....
Two cats in the yard
Ouvido em 28/04/2026.
My brother loves this, classic
I enjoyed.
Didn’t expect to like this so much but it was pretty damn sick. I’m proper loving the albums around 1970 and the summer of love. Everything about this album is great but the Crosby tracks are something else. 8 / 10 Best track/s: Almost Cut My Hair, Our House, Deja Vu
A pleasant listen with a surprise hit I didn't realise was theirs
I was pleasantly surprised that I liked this one. Some tunes I recognised that were either covers or the original.
Listenable hippy rock. Sounded better on the second listen, so 3.5 stars from me.
I really enjoyed this album, lots of creative songwriting
This is really good. I don't know what I can say about these beautiful harmonies and interesting arrangements that hasn't been said before about these guys, but this is a great and enjoyable listen. It was a little more rockin' overall than I was expecting! I knew "Our House" by name coming into this, but a few of the other songs were mainstays growing up with my parents' record collection that I couldn't really place until now. Really good, will absolutely listen again and would most likely buy the record were I to come upon it in the wild.
it's growing on me. some good songs i'm glad to have heard. faves: helpless, woodstock, déjà vu, our house, country girl
I have a core memory of listening to "Woodstock" for the first time on a boat off the shore of Hawaii just before going parasailing. Love that song.
A fine album. Didnt find myself over the moon but it was a fun listen.
Classic album by this supergroup Beautiful harmonies. Brilliant songwriting and playing. Still sounds great today.
This was good but it was kind of what I expected. Great harmonies though
Tästä kokoonpanosta vain Neil Young on itselleni erityisen tuttu, mutta kyllä muutkin jäsenet suoriutuvat hyvin. Deja Vu on tasavahva albumi, joka edustaa aikansa folk rockia sieltä paremmasta päästä.
Good solid classics on this album, nothing I feel particularly passionate about.
Really good! Has a cool old feel but feels like it was ahead of its time. Good listening music for just about any occasion I reckon. 4.25/5
I actually like that 70s parallel moving harmony stuff when I'm in the right mood. Works on Teach Your Children really well and turns out quite sweet. Some of these are a little dull, I actually think Helpless drags way too hard despite being lyrically evocative. That one's pretty boring while songs like Deja Vu have a decent amount of harmonic intrigue and keep me interested. I think it's somewhat of mixed bag all said, sometimes it's fairly dense musically and lyrically and other times it's dry and passable. I think the good outweighs the average just enough that I'd call this a 3.
Déjà Vu has lovely harmonies, emotional songs, and relaxing atmosphere, making it enjoyable and memorable, although some tracks feel less interesting, causing the album to lose energy occasionally before returning with stronger melodies and performances that show why many listeners still appreciate it so much today overall.
This is great, really enjoyed this album. Great for late night listening.
Muy tranquilo, me encantó para momentos específicos
Notables - Carry On - Helpless
Always liked Our House. The remainder are pleasant enough.
Not completely my genre, but this is a really good album, I confess I have the singles, "Teach Your Children" and "Our House". This is between a 4 and a 3, but it's not 100% my thing, so....
really enjoy this album
This record sounds great - really excellent country-fried rock, fun good-time music...for people my dad's age. to my ears it sounds dated, even for its time, compared to other contemporary works that have found more purchase and influence in music in the intervening years. this sounds deliberately of its time. it is really good, it's just stuck in 1970. it doesn't help that i've been hearing songs from this album forever - on the radio, on my dad's stereo, store muzak systems, passing cars, movie soundtracks. personally i am biased towards the pieces with stronger neil young influence, i find his later solo work more compelling than the others.
I don't like speaking in superalatives when speaking about the Laurel Canyon sound and movement. But, CSN+Y might have been it. Well woven blend of blues, country and western and folk songs into artful renditions with so much character and feeling. The 4 part harmonies are so damn good and I for certain love the voicing of the acoustic arrangements. And obviously nod to the top of the line production elements for 1970. Easiest 4 star of my life. I will always come back to this and have been an enjoyer. I think the only thing preventing a 5 star rating is that it falls below some of my favorite 5 star albums of this era and this genre.
Wildly different quality from track to track, some of them are just more talented than the other 3.5*
I get chills when I hear "Helpless." If only every squeakquel had a Neil Young.