To Pimp A Butterfly
Kendrick LamarGood but too dense to take in over 1/2 listens. Will come back to it
Good but too dense to take in over 1/2 listens. Will come back to it
Like most of the albums on here this album has obvious merit. It sounds great and the production and song writing were top notch. I tried to find a foothold in so that I could enjoy is with my heart rather than my head, but didn't manage it.
The first album in this project that I own on vinyl. Radiohead are my Beatles and this is one of their best. They do what other bands can't which is evolve, stay ahead of their fanbases and maintain an incredible level of quality. This album has some of the best Radiohead tracks ever, but I can pick anything out as the album is so good. I'm giving this 5 stars but it's also made me wish I'd not given previous 5 stars out as this is a cut above.
Ok, not my cup of tea, but message in a bottle is a classic
A classic
Good but too dense to take in over 1/2 listens. Will come back to it
Not for me. The vocal became grating, the lyrics are that of a horny teenager and the 80's Casio keyboard music doesn't really hold value. If you were a horny teenager in 1981 then I'm sure this was 'your music' but I don't think it has stood the test if time.
If this doesn't make you even a little joyful then you need to see a doctor.
If you can sperate the art from the artist and forget about the walking turd of human that Kanye has become, then this is a banger across the board. A step up from the more mainstream college trilogy, but not so up its own arse like later stuff. I've stopped listening to him in the last decade but this deserves its place on the list.
Sounded nice, but didn't grab me.
Crazy 60s psych which was fun, but I won't be going back to
Didn't like this one. I can only assume it's popularity is based on being a early version of better female fronted grunge/alt from the early 90's. Better listen to early Hole or even 4 non blondes.
This album reminds me of my sister. I flower out from under her bedroom door for a good chunk of the 90's. In my head, it's always been 'her' music so I never really listened to it. On reflection I can see the appeal, sunny tracks that speak of its time and place. I'll probably listen to this more now, mostly to remind myself of her, but also because it's a good album
Neither liked it or disliked it. Seemed to be a perfectly reasonable crooner but it's not something that interested me.
Fairly middle of the road Americana. Didn't finish the album
Didn't care for it. I can't article why, but it didn't grab me on any level.
Beautiful songs that set the standard. My only issue is the tone of her voice at higher ranges doesn't sound good to me.
There are lots of positives here. She has the look, the ambition of sound and image, I liked the diversity of musical styles and her voice is good. But the album felt about 50% too long and sounded like someone still trying to break through the external facade to reveal her true self. I think there is a classic album in her future, but this wasnt it.
Really enjoyed this. I'd heard the name but never dived in. I'm delighted I started at the start and it will allow me to work though everything in order. This sounded to me like a mix of the clash and gang of four. Short sharp scuzzy and very good. A new fan.
When I get was 13, an older boy made a fortune taping his copies of Nirvana albums and selling them for a pound to the younger kids. In Utero on one side and Nevermind on the other. I listened until the tape wore through. I'm not able to accurately judge this as it's wound through my teenage years like raisins in a Danish pastry.
The first album in this project that I own on vinyl. Radiohead are my Beatles and this is one of their best. They do what other bands can't which is evolve, stay ahead of their fanbases and maintain an incredible level of quality. This album has some of the best Radiohead tracks ever, but I can pick anything out as the album is so good. I'm giving this 5 stars but it's also made me wish I'd not given previous 5 stars out as this is a cut above.
There are obviously some bangers in this and I discovered a couple of album tracks I'd not heard that were good, but it's just too damn long. There is an incredible single album about an hour long in here, it just needs some significant editing.
It's a very good album and I think man in the mirror is one of the best pop songs ever written. A relisten does reveal a surprising amount of filler though.
A beautiful and seminal album. The sparse industrial rhythm perfectly match the dark lyrics that evoke the industrial north. A relisten highlights the fact that the vocal and the guitar are duetting throughout.
Perfectly fine funk/soul with not much to complain about but it's nothing I'd turn to again
If I ever feel the need for xylophone jazz then I'll remember this. But that's never going to happen and this was the first album I have up on.
When this came up, I thought: not my usual jam, but why the fuck not, so put it on at high volume and went for a walk. Turns out the 'why not' is fairly evident after about 3 tracks. I can imagine this sounded raw and energetic when it came out but it now just sounds a bit mediocre. Not angry, not poppy, very dated and weirdly bland.
I enjoyed this and will come back to it.
I enjoyed it. The long form funk was a change and it allowed the whole thing to wash over me.
Love Bowie. Have listened to this before and am aware of the massive foreshadowing that makes it. But I didn't gave the space to properly digest this.
I enjoyed this. Her voice is one of the best. More importantly I think the music and production, whilst obviously from the 80's didn't sound embarrassingly so. (Cough cough soft cell).
Didn't know this album. Turns out it perfectly serviceable 90's wrap. No complaints.
I didn't really get on board with this. Id never heard of it and when it started I thought it may be some good punk/postpunk. But it turned out to be weirdly insipid and quite poppy.
Nothing more than fine. Grating voice and ok 80s pop.
Working class hero is an absolute banger and an new iteration of 'masters of war'. The rest of the album contains some beautiful and incredibly personal lyrics, but it has cemented myself as a McCartney fan over a lennonite.
I enjoyed that.
Did not like this. It felt very one note and bland.
I'm only 50 albums in, I was born in England in the early 80's and I'm already sick of all these 80's British bands. This was fine, bit it doesn't warrant making this list.
I don't live in a cave so am aware of Taylor Swift, but hadn't listened to any albums of hers. I found this to be perfectly decent pop music with a nice bland message and seemed well produced and packaged. I've no idea why she is as lauded as she is, but it wasn't bad.
Now this is what I'm here for. I'd not heard of this but loved it. It managed to sound both lowfi and incredibly well produced, simple and complex, with brilliant variety across genre. There were clear pop songs, punk, country, spoken word, jazz and much more. Plus the jackass theme popped up in the middle which made me think I was having a stroke temporarily.
It's a great album. His ear for a tune and a lyric are top tier. There is a arguement for the album to lose about 1/3 and I do prefer some of the versions included in the live at Carnegie hall, but I enjoyed every second of this.
Mad, mad and not for me today. Maybe another day it may stick, but I got to the barking and rolled my eyes
Some obvious classic tracks but found the rest of the album inconsistent.
I didn't like this. It sounded like lowest common denominator music for simpletons. But further into the album it started to remind me of people I did enjoy, there were brief flashes of Elvis, a Jonny Cash baseline or a Ryan Adams b-side. Country music can be complex, interesting and innovative and this was none of those things.
Nice, dense and interesting. Will revisit.
There isn't anything I can say that hasn't already been said about Mr Hendrix. As a man who can't play guitar, it's amazing that he is so far above his peers that even an idiot can see he is the GOAT. Plus some absolute bangers on this album.
If Grima Wormtongue was given the job of DJing the Uruk-Hai Christmas Party I think would be perfect. It has the innate anger of a pack of Orcs but adds enough wimsy and jauntyness to appeal to murdering half-men celebrating a nice time of the year. I'm sure the Orcs would give this album five stars. However for all the same reasons this gets a 2 from me.
These guys are from my county and I followed them coming up. It was exciting to see a local band make it big and I had this album and saw them live. I'm surprised to see this on the list as it never struck me as a classic. A relisten a decade later shows this for what it is: an ok album, with a fairly marmite singer. This isn't bringing any warm fuzzy feelings back and it won't send me back through their catalog, but its nice.
Brilliant album. It hits so many different heights. The rhythm is brilliant and uplifting, the composition is lush, the production is clean and the lyrics paint a picture of Thatchers Britain in the 80's. I cannot find a single reason not to give this 5 stars.
I can't find any merit in this. I know people rave over Frank Ocean and I've tried his albums before, but on a concentrated listen I didn't find anything that engaged me. Bland and boring.
I was surprised to see this on the list. I would be absolutely the right demographic for this album being English and of the correct age, but the first album by Mike Skinner is so far above this in terms of quality and importance that its much better inclusion. What Mike Skinner does well is he writes really good music of his time and his lyrics accurately describe my life. His singing/wrapping isn't for everyone and if you compare it to US rappers then it's not going to impress anyone. This album has a scattering of good tracks but he very quickly found the edges of his talent. If you enjoyed this or wanted to hear a better version, go find 'origional pirate material'
This is magical. Her voice, her energy, the musicality, the joy all combine to form something timeless. It struck me that this is 30 years old and still sounds contemporary. If the world was more Bjork it would be a better place and this represents her youth and excitement.
It's a bit unfair to drop this on us on Xmas day. I had a brilliant day and this was on loop so of course it gets 5 stars. Merry Christmas everyone!
It was boxing day and I couldn't find a moment that seemed appropriate to put this on with the in laws around. I'm sorry. I'll come back to it I promise.
It was nice and floaty with occasional bursts of tune to engage the ears. But I found them too far apart to hold my attention and this drifted by without leaving much of an impression. Much preferred Moon Safari.
I've not listened to this in 20 years so it was nic to revisit it. The singles stood out and I enjoyed the fun concept but I wouldn't be coming back for a relisten soon.
I'd never heard the name, but when the album started I immediately recognised the voice. It's surprising how many tracks I could sing along to. Good 70's fun.
I didn't find much in this beyond middle of the road early indie.
The is one was pretty straight forwards. I didn't find it first time around but some nice and mainstream girl indie punk was more than welcome.
It's not the best Radiohead album so I was considering giving it a 4 but I listened through again and it's a masterpiece still.
I enjoyed this. It was a more complex than I'd expected from my knowledge of the Byrds. The country sounds and rhythms were appealing and it held up well.
I didn't hate this but it didn't really interest me. I've found I'm quite averse to the 60/70 style of female folk vocal which is grating and lacking in depth. This hit that 'not so sweet' spot and I found it difficult. I'm sure the songs were well crafted and if you like her voice it could be a great record, but not for me.
This morning as good fun and a pleasurable listen. But I don't listen to enough reggae to look past his previous band so it wont get much repeat play
So many if these albums are masterpieces and 24 hours isn't enough to form a coherent opinion of them. This is a classic example where I managed 1.5 listens through and liked what I heard by it didn't manage to get a sense of the stories and the magnitude of the thing. I'll try to revisit.
This brought the rave scene to the main stream in the UK in the early 90's. I remember it being labeled as dangerous and drug fuelled. Which made it more intriguing as a young person. I remember the hits, but a full listen through unveils a surprisingly diverse and musically accomplished album. There is a bigger debt to the Pet shop boys than I expected and all in all the hour skipped along well.
This was fine. Take on me is part of the furniture culturally, but I think it may be a bit overrated musically as it gets a lot of it's credit from the video and the MTV generation. The rest of the album is serviceable pop.
I'm aware that this is a classic and a listen through showed beautiful melody and lyrics. But I had to find it on YouTube and the ads really disrupted my flow.
There is a huge amount to respect and love the Boss for. He writes a banging pop song, he is a man above reproach, he speaks for people who don't have a voice and he works harder than anyone else. But I'm not a blue collar worker in the rust belt and listening through to the album it is still fairly middle of the road pop/rock which is good, but it's not life changing.
This was a delight. Sinatra is such an icon and is so woven into the cultural history that his music comes with a set of pre-conceived notions. I knew the classics and had an image based on the rat pack, stories of mafia connections, womanizing and generally being old school cool with a large slice of misogyny thrown in. However this album really caught me off guard. It's romantic and vulnerable and subtle. The story telling in the lyrics, the lush orchestration and the emotion in his voice blew me away. Plus I read the wiki entry and discovered this was one of the first concept albums and he pioneered this type of album. I'll be listening again and I'll be looking at his discography for more gems rather than the playlist/best of that may have got an occasional play previously.
I'll start with a declaration. I'm not objective about this album. I'm English, was 13 years old when this came out, saw them at v96 at 14 and had my kind blown, own all Pulp albums, listen to Jarvis on the radio and just finished his book. Let's say this is my music. In an attempt to be objective, the music is brilliant pop, the lyrics should win the Pulitzer and I listened to this and danced around a shopping centre. The hits are unparalleled and the album tracks are equally good, there is no filler. If I'm being subjective, this is a core memory for me and fills my old man heart with the joy and vigour of my younger self. If I was in a coma, then play this and I'll wake up.
This is a beautiful album from start to finish. The falsetto voice against the guitar sound is a stunning combination. The songs are filled with emotion and jaw dropping heart. I could listen to Last Goodbye on a loop for a year and still feel my heart swell.
I didn't find this offensive, but I listened to this twice through yesterday and when it comes to review it I can't remember a single thing about it apart from the sound bed that's is used in a sports podcast I like. I remember finding it perfectly pleasant but nothing memorable.
It's lovely to have a change of pace and move away from the western centric anglophone stuff that dominates this list. I only know him from a duet with Neneh cherry in the 90's and it's the interesting to dive deeper. The north African rhythms and instrumentation are lovely, obviously I've no idea what he was singing about but it ticked by quite nicely.
This isn't my usual stuff but I didn't find it offensive. Some fun stuff and a surprising amount of variety. But I'm never going to go back to it.
I was excited when this came up and I've enjoyed 90's hip hop. A couple of listen throughs later and I'm not blown away. It was good but not great, there wasnt much light and shade and it all blended into one.
Yeah fine. I didn't like it loathe this. The definition of a 3 star
I'd never heard of this so came in blind. I found it to be some pleasant country/ folk. The songs were well crafted and I enjoyed her voice. Whilst I can enjoy the skill, it didn't light any fires.
These kind of albums are one of the real benefits of this exercise. I should be a massive fan of his but I'd never found a foothold. He is always listed alongside Dylan and Cave who I'm massive fans of. I listened through to this 3 X with headphones to concentrate. The lyrics are basically prose. The musicality is very gentle and restrained. I'm taking a while to warm up to his growl but I think I'll get there. I hope this is the introduction I need to become a fan.
I did a marathon in 2019. When I decided to do it, I was excited by the prospect. I was used to a usual run time but this was way above the usual. The first 10 ticked along in a bubble of enthusiasm. As the time passed I found it difficult to differentiate one mile from another. After about 30% it became a slog and I just kept my head down and chugged through. My brain only really woke up when the end was in site. In retrospect, I'm glad I did it. I'll never do it again. It was too long.
The man is a pig and a cancer on society. Having said that he is part of the fabric on Ireland and the album is smooth and mellow. I'm a fan of separating the art from the artist but fuck van Morrison.
Like most of the albums on here this album has obvious merit. It sounds great and the production and song writing were top notch. I tried to find a foothold in so that I could enjoy is with my heart rather than my head, but didn't manage it.
Perfectly pleasant jazz prog nonsense. Certainly nothing I'd ever listen to before or again, but certainly didn't hate it.
It avoids one star because the first three tracks are pop classics. But that is an awful album. They knew it as well as they just dumped the three singles as the start and then left the rest of the album to be filled by an AI with the instruction to generate insipid, inconsistent, dated r n b. I shudder at the thought of this.
Loved it. The precursor to a lot of what I listen to now. I love the loops and the crunchiness.
Lovely stuff. Dreamy, French pop with loads of detail in the background. Beautiful synths and base lines, actual hooks and lots to focus in on. But zoom out and let the beauty wash over you.
My second MBV album in my first 90. Still can't get on board. Mumbly vocals, willful lack of cohesion and only reason it gets 2 stars is the passable shoegaze at the end.
I'm a fan of Mr Brown but i dont think this captured him at his best. I'm sure he was spectacular live but it doesn't come across in this
I'm all over the place with this one. I was brought up in a Rolling Stones household so this was on in the background all the time. When I got a record player this was one of the first albums I bought as I thought it was a mandatory thing. When the album came up I realized that a) I still had the record and b) I'd not played it in a decade. So I take a couple of passes on vinyl and one on my headphones and all I can say is, I'm underwhelmed. A lot of these tracks are obviously very good pop/rock/blues tunes. The guitars and rhythm are excellent and I can see why this became a seminal album in its time. But I don't think Jagger is a great singer. And also, as music availability has expanded it seems ludicrous to listen to this, admittedly good, imitation pop version when the original blues records are easily available. Go straight to the source and get it before it gets watered down.
I really enjoyed this. It seems to full to the brim with heart and soul. I like his voice, the music was great and I'll be digging into the back catalogue.
Another classic band that needs no introduction. I'd not listened to an album by them before, but was happy to sing along to the hits. The rest of the album was fine but my ambivalence is more due to this not really being my thing than any failings on their part. A solid 3.
As a child of britpop I was amazed I'd not heard this. Seems like it came just before and paved the way for a lot of music that I love. Knowing that context means I'm inclined to be more generous, but putting it against its followers shows it to be a weaker album.
My second talking heads album and I'm now turning to them without the aid of the list. The energy, the rhythms and the eloquence are all my bag.
I've had a few country albums so far and all I've learnt is that I don't like country. This didn't have anything to change my mind.
I felt this was truer to the origins of the blues but lacked some of the poppier hooks of the the rolling stones for example. Perfectly reasonable and 3 stars
I didn't know Janis Joplin could sing like that! I had her in my head as a folkie. Like the vibe and the wurlitzers. However, if I ever wanted to listen to this again, I'd just put on Aretha Franklin.
I've had a lot of this genre recently and I am generally quite ambivalent towards it. On a couple of listens I can see the blend of blues, country, pop and a bit of psych is unique and it's well done of a little under cooked. But I won't be going back.
I'd never listened to this album all the way through before and I regret that now. What an album. The scope of it is just epic. It does incredibly well painting pictures in your mind using space and quiet as well as lots of layered noise. It's a bit like jazz in that the real skill is in the spaces they leave. This is the first album that gets a five having never listened to it before. Outstanding.
Well this was ubiquitous throughout my 20's on radio and everywhere else. I had the cd and if you aren't tempted to bounce around at Mr Brightside then I suggest you donate your ears to someone who would make better use of them. A relisten reminds me of how many singles they pumped from this album and the general lack of filler throughout. It's not going to change the world but it's undeniably a strong album of pop/rock.
Easy 5 stars. This may be top ten ever. If you rate music by how much it makes makes you feel then this is god tier.
Obvious quality but surprisingly not as aggressive as I'd hoped.
I hadn't heard this so came to it fresh. I thought it was fine, but it's not my bag. It reminded me of The Strangers that my mum used to play to me as a kid
Whilst I can see the obvious musicianship that radiates from every pore of this, i'e prefer the originals and I'm not a massive metallics fan anyway.
This was wild. Hair metal, with extra slap bass and some properly weird lyrics. I didn't hate it but man the 80's sucked.
In my head I had The Grateful dead as a bit weirder than this. The first half was good quality MOR radio friendly pop rock. The second half started to add a bit of colour, but nothing that made this warrant any excitement.
I like music. I recognise and value experimentation. I know all genres aren't going to float my boat and that's fine. But holy shit this is unlistenable.
This process showed me a love of Talking Heads, but I don't think this album was their best on first impression. Seemed a bit less varied than others and that lead to some boredom. Maybe repeat plays with uncover it's depth so I'll be back
Let's put to one side the all encompassing soulless, beigeness that Coldplay have become and look at this album on its merits. This debut was genuinely exciting when it landed. There are some killer pop tracks in this and the album doesn't seem like filler. They know how to write a really good melody for vocal and guitar and I enjoyed this a lot more than I thought I would.
Polly Jean is a icon and should be taught in schools. Her energy, intelligence, voice and message are important. I don't think there are many better opening 6 track runs in an album. I put my headphones on and walked my baby to sleep and was bouncing along. I'd love to give this 5 stars, but the discordant strings on plants and rags weren't great and the drop in quality for the last 3 tracks make this a 4.4. Ive know this album for 30 years and it it was 5 stars I'd have listened to it more, so I'm rounding down.
A stone cold classic and the perfect entry into this list. This album is hugely of it's time and that is a good thing. It washed away the so called "landfill indie" that proceeded it in the UK. It's birth at the start of file sharing and new ways to disseminate and consume music felt new and genuinely exciting. I moved to Sheffield in 2000 and was firmly ensconced in the music scene when these guys exploded. I didn't get to see them at the Boardwalk, but to have 18 year old boys playing music that spoke of our time and place makes it something personal to me. If you ignore the personal and cultural history and look at the music they generated it would still warrant it's place because the quality of the album speaks for itself. The consistency from track one to the closer is incredible. The lyrics are witty and warm with an excellent injection of snarl. The guitars and driving rhythm section elevate this further. Add a liberal sprinkling of pop hooks and sing along choruses and it demonstrates what the best music can be: the alchemy of putting quality ingredients together to produce something more than the sum of its parts that speaks to people and brings joy. Put this on loud and sing every word and you'll be a better person afterwards.
This is my second Fela Kuti album on the list and I've enjoyed both. This live one has a more raw and exciting feel to it and that lifted the whole thing. It's still not my go to, but I'm glad I listened to this.
I like getting introduced to new things and whilst I didnt find this offensive, it didn't hold much interest for me. A low 3
Morrissey is the human equivalent of the stain in your underpants when you have picked up a stomach complaint.
It's stupid, misogynistic, devoid of depth and loud and I love every second of it. I'm about 120 albums in and I've had rock classics like Sabbath and others and they've left me cold. This does not. Admittedly I had this on cd when I was 13 and so I put it on loud and sang every lyric at the top of my voice. Great, foot stomping, lyric shouting, head banging nonsense.
I really enjoyed this but my baby isn't sleeping so that's all you are getting.
So, this comes a day after Appetite for Destruction for me, its an interesting comparison. I highlighted the misogyny in the other one and it feels important to do the same here. As a 41 year old white dude from Ireland, I've never had to assess the correct order for cash app and my pussy, but the message about getting paid isn't one I feel I'd share with my kids. Moving on from the message, it comes down to how this makes me feel. Did the lyrics resonate with me? No, can I imagine they do for other people? Sure. Did the music engage with me? No, I'm not R'n'B expert but I could name 5 better albums quickly. Did I like the idea of mixing spoken word and song? Yeah, why not.
When he is good he is very good. On a par with Hendrix for guitar playing. Has written some of the best pop music in the history of the world and is a manic purple sex pixie to boot. There is a certain amount of filler though so only 4 stars but the singles are what all music should be judged against.
It's weird how snoop has gone from misogynistic gangsta to wholesome dad, but this album was the high point of 90's small dick gangsta rap. Having said that, the beats are heavy, the flow is smooth and there are some absolute bangers here.
I enjoy Brian's later ambient output and I can see the beginnings of the Talking Heads style sound here, but it feels like this isn't a fully formed sound yet. I didn't dislike it and can see the merit in places, but it's an easy three for me.
I'm a Dylan fan. Blame Max Broadys dad who played him in his car when I was about 13 and I was hooked. Blood on the Tracks is up there as one of his best. I cannot add to the cannon about his song writing ability and I know his voice isn't for everyone. But these tracks just soar.
I really want enjoyed that. Lots of brilliant riffs and low fi crunchiness
This process has unveiled a love of post punk that I didn't know I had. Really enjoyed the spectrum of pinky noise through to some genuinely catchy tunes.
Even when I don't like something, I can usually see why it's on the list but this has left me stumped. It's such a sea of blandness and beige. There are passable tunes here and I don't dislike her voice, but it's not good, interesting, new, progressive or engaging.
I enjoyed this. It was wild and weird and I felt like I was at some sort of medieval fair.
Another good addition to the list. I'm not a fan of whatever this is classed as and when the growling started I braved myself for a slog. But there was a surprising amount of tune in these and it seemed very well done. It reminded me of some of the American punk that I listened to in the late 90s when I was a teenager, but with more darkness and depth.
Johnny Cash is a force of nature. I'm part of the generation who rediscovered him via Rick Rubin's albums with him. I'm not a country fan but this bridges the gap due to the quality of the songs, the driving rhythm, his voice and the sheer magnificence of the man. This album has a really cinematic feel and it's certainly adds to the album and dovetails with the reputation of the man.
I'm going to be a heretic here, but I thought this was good but nothing that stood out from a lot of the list. There are some well known classics here and I can't deny the energy and songwriting skill on show. But I didn't see what elevates it to great, I found his voice annoys me and the drop off from singles to album filler was steep.
Lots and lots of fun. Great rhythm and beat. The audio tapestry style just makes it very interesting. There is some variable consistency across the album but when it's good it's very good.
As with previous Neil young stuff, the fact I have to listen with adverts on YouTube is hugely distracting and ruins the flow of the album. However, this one may the start of me liking his stuff. It's the second one I've had and I enjoyed the mood in this one more than others.
I read the reviews and they made my heart sink. Not another wall of shoegaze industrial noise please. I've already given MBV 2 stars. However on a listen this was a much more palatable listen. The balance between scuzz and genuinely tuneful guitars was surprising and it fitted into a spectrum of music that I co in let enjoy, albeit at the darker end.
I like the doors and Jim Morrison but this doesn't strike me as their best work.
I should know about this as I was 18 and in the UK when this came out, I loved music around this area but I've never heard of this. I have no idea how this made the list, it's fine for a genre that I do enjoy but it's not good. It made me want to listen to propellerheads, chemical Brothers and massive attack, not listen again.
Maybe I'm just jaded from being on a run of 3 star albums but this annoyed me. I was aware of their hit in the 90s and there are some decent pop tunes in here and their playing is undoubtedly good, but I ended up annoyed It just seemed so commercialised and annodyne. What happened post post-punk to go a full 360 and turn it into frat rock? It's still a 3 but for once I'm surprised with my reaction.
I thought this was really inconsistent. The upbeat tracks worked really well, but the ballad were very bad. I feel this may be over rated as an album due to Madonna's profile.
A great album that I enjoyed. The singles were well known but the reason this gets 4 stars is the album tracks were also excellent.
This process has given me a new found live of the white stripes and this is another banger
I think this is a great example of a album that merits its inclusion in this list but isn't massively for me. I remember Brown Sugar from the first time around, but the rest of the album seems quite competent lyrically and the groove is good.
The guy's got a Pulitzer prize. And this is in the conversation about being one of his best. And it has subterranean homesick blues, Maggie's farm and Mr tambourine man on. There isn't an easier 5 stars in the world
I was raised on Abba gold and can sing along to most of the hits. I wouldn't choose to listen to it now l, but it's undeniably excellent pop music. Now this process gives me a chance to delve into their difficult break up album and see what it brings and on the whole it seems of a good standard. There is undeniable song writing mastery at work, coupled with heart breaking lyrics and beautiful singing. The darker synth sounds are interesting and it's a worthwhile addition to the list. However, I don't tend to return to their accessible stuff and this would be below that for me.
I didn't come across this first time round as it was 5 years to early but Sonic Youth was a name I knew. On first listen I found it weirdly bland, but I felt there was enough there to come back to it. I managed to get another 2 runs through and it slowly unveiled itself. The initial angry skuzz gives way to some quality songwriting and a surprising amount of space and panorama in the music. I really warmed to it and may return to see what else comes out over time.
With the exception of Sunny Afternoon found this suprisingly bland. For one of the supposed best songwriters ever, I thought it was quite dated and very lightweight.
Does Bob get an instant 5? Probably, but let's listen. It was the first day of spring here, the sun came out and I was out and about in my car a lot with my sunglasses on. I say this because this music couldnt have fitted the scenario better. It's like sunshine in audible form. This album was quality all the way through and Bob is more than an icon. Yes, Bob gets 5 stars
Urgh, this was fairly repellant. On the plus side I can see how this could be considered building on the stones in terms of guitar sound. But this is so puerile and vacuous. Walk this way is much better with RUN DMC and the other supposed stand out track wasn't great.
Yesterday I had Aerosmiths third album and didn't enjoy it, 2 stars. I opened today hoping for a palate cleanser and was given Aerosmiths 4 album. I barely made it through a single listen of this as I was already sick of their stones derivative, screechy, puerile nonsense. Today they get one star just because I'm sick of their shit.
Another artist who sits above reproach. I was raised on Ziggy Stardust and have loved the music ever since. This final chapter in his discography is a worthy finale and it is a marks of the man's inability to do anything undramatically that he died straight after it's release. On revisiting the album, it is dense and textured with lots of modernity about it despite his age. The voice holds well and it sounds great. If it was to be rated at the top of his discography it could benefit from a couple of slightly more accessible or poppy songs but that wouldnt be the point now would it. RIP David
Probably my least listened-to solo MJ album and I regret it now. An absolute banger of disco funk and soul. Sometimes on his other albums, the familiarity with the hits means you don't hear the music, just the anthem and with the obvious exceptions here I found myself able to really appreciate what is going on. The quality of the song writing is god tier, but it's his voice and the alchemy of Quincy Joneses production that raise this another notch.
I love PJ but she progressed too quickly for me and some of her stuff gets a bit more experimental than my tastes. Still enjoyed the listen tho.
God this was bad. For a band known for their singing i found their tone incredibly bad and some of the songs were laughable.
This was great. I'm not American so country music isn't as pervasive, but I'd still heard if Willie. I've already had some country on this list that I hated so wasn't sure going in but my fears were soon calmed. There is a real warmth to this that I can't quantify, it was a delight to listen to. The story telling was great, the voice was very comforting and the music was surprisingly diverse.
I'm staying with my sister, explained the generator and asked to put this on the speakers as we'd be out all day. The whole family voted to turn it off about halfway
A seminal hip hop album. Lost a star due to terrible skits and sex noises.
I weirdly enjoyed this. Big, sprawling ridiculous stadium rock has it's place in the world and Rush seems to do this well.
I can see how this is described as the pinnacle of swing/big band. It seemed like they had thrown everything this music stood for into one album. The quality is obvious to see and it deserves it's place here. It's an interesting stepping stone on the progression of music and I'm glad I'm listened but it's not going to feature in regular rotation.
This should not be enjoyable as it includes most of the tropes of this kind of music that I dislike, but I have to admit I enjoyed it. It bounced around from Americana to classic rock radio to slightly harder and did it well.
It has merit and I managed 2 runs through, but I couldn't say much stood out for me.
This was surprisingly great. I came in with zero expectations and was blown away. The songwriting, guitar parts, the old school blues were all lovely and the diversity kept me engaged throughout. This should be better known
I've discovered a love of 80's post punk and this sit well in there, all be it at the harder end of the spectrum.
This is a banger and right up my street. I love dnb and seeing one of the founding albums of the genre here fills my heart with joy. I played it in the car and my 7 year old loved it as well so thumbs up all round.
If the value in music is how deeply it burrows it's melody into your brain then this is priceless. I spent 3 months on Cuba and this music reminds me of sunshine, rum and people who seemed not to have a care in the world. It put a smile on my face and a spring in my step.
I enjoy Nina Simone and when this came up I felt good about the day. However 2 runs through and I didn't end up as wildly excited as I expected. The slower stuff didn't seem to suit here voice and I found the album dragged a touch. I really enjoyed some of the jazzier piano stuff and some tracks were of her usual high standard.
My heart sank at another MBV album, but either I'm softening to them or this one is better. A bit more melody, some nicer vocals and this passed the time. Still took much industrial background scuzz for me but a step up.
There is a lot of Neil young on this list. I've started to warm to his acoustic stuff but this was the first with crazy horse. I'm still a bit meh about him to be honest. This was still full of the Americana songwriting chops you'd expect, but his voice is still thin and the band are fine.
I think as delighted to get this one. This is obviously a classic and some fit be tracks are proper American songbook standard. A full listen through was delightful, but revealed a couple of lower level album tracks and some weird orchestration so it's not perfect but it's damn good.
This was kinda fun. I liked the guitar licks and there were a couple with a very strong groove. But this isn't an improvement on the pixies and I found it overly long.
Is this the best or worst album title on the list? I can't decide. Not my bag, but I would up enjoying it as it went. Some poppy blues and as much as the pint sized scot is a bit of a prick, he has some.pipes on him. A good three stars, but better than expected.
This was fun. If I had to listen to old rock I'd pick this over the sabbaths and deep purple and stuff. I moved to Ireland nearly a decade ago and Phil Lynott is a god here and I can see why. He is the Irish Hendrix. Plus the rhythm section slaps as well. The live album seems to do a good job of capturing their energy. My only complaint is that it didn't offer much variety and I found over an hour if this way too much. But if you are a fan then I'm sure you'd stuck this straight in your veins.
I was a fan of this first time around, had the CD and saw Arcade Fire in Paris circa 2011. I hadn't listened to the full album for maybe a decade so was excited to come back to it. Keep the car running is an absolute masterpiece, but the rest of it didn't stand out much. I used to think this was so deep and articulate, but now it struck me as "im15andthisisdeep". I'm off to listen to Funeral which I have more hope for.
This was a surprisingly good 80's pop record. Bands like Spandau ballet and Duran Duran seem to have held their place in the music consciousness better, but I was supposed how many of these tracks were familiar It's still 80s pop for which I have little love but this was on the better end of the spectrum and deserves more recognition
I'm really starting to enjoy Elvis Costello. My second album and I've started dipping into their catalogue when we I have time. This one was great, I love how it was recorded loud to give it real energy.
There is a couple of very good songs here, but the rest is very grating. It appears they got more experimental and I barely managed 1 total run though.
Another icon and another easy one. I was brought up on Bowie and whilst this doesn't get the full marks, it was a joyous listen.
A classic three. Nothing that offended me, but nothing that engaged me. Serviceable 70's prog/pop nonsense.
This is beautiful. I've been through the American recordings series with Rick Rubin and I think this represents the high water mark. They have managed to tease out the parts of the puzzle that make cash unique and build exclusively with these attributes. His growl, the drive of his guitar, his man in black American outlaw/Messiah complex. This album is like a minimalist painting from a painter in his later years who has learnt that less is more. A masterpiece and something everyone should hear.
I was surprised by the recognition of the opening track as I went in blind. A good pop song and rest of the album seemed fun but dated. A 3.5 if there was half marks.
Lovely nostalgic feminist pop punk. Great tunes and good consistency across the album. It's a good sign when I'm humming the tunes later in the evening.
This is on the lower end of average for me. I didn't dislike it but I found little of merit and after one listen I was glad to move on. This kind of slacker rock I think is done better elsewhere and the lack of tunes or good vocals means it's slipped past me without anything to hold onto.
Is it even possible to objectively review the Beatles? These guys are so woven into the fabric of music and culture that they stand alone as titans. I was raised in a Stones household and not a Beatles household and I consider it the biggest failure of my parents. This isn't one of the big albums so I hadn't listened through for a long time. God it's good. It's not got the depth of later stuff, but it's still amazing pop music that stands the rest of time. If this was their only album on the list I'd give it 5 stars but I need to leave space for their others.
I'm glad we get something non UK/us, but this sounded very average to me. There are so many brilliant albums here that be comparison this seemed very boring and bland. Not offensive, just a bit meh.
Love, love, love this. I had it on CD first time around and I'd forgotten how good it is. The funky, proggy, jazzy guitars are amazing, the rhythm section slaps and it just seems all round like fun.
God damn it! I like cheesy American 70's stadium rock now. This and Rush (I know they are Canadian but you know what I mean) have been great fun. I'm off to buy a denim jacket with the sleeves cut off, a trucker cap and air guitar like a muthafucka.
Urgh. I can be a wankery indie hipster at the best of times but this was too much for me. There were brief flashes of something resembling a tune, but every time something interesting happened they seemed to shoot themselves in the foot straight away. Neither vocalist is as good as they think they are and it was a difficult listen.
I very much enjoyed this. It passed me by originally and I regret that now. It is lovely floaty indie pop and the french add a certain je ne sais quoi
When you start this project, your mind inevitably wanders to what you may add to the list. If it wasn't already here, this would be a strong contender for me. Richard Hawley is magic. He takes the raw ingredients of old school rockabilly, country and rnb and filters it through a more modern lense. He has a beautiful voice, lyrics that make a grown man feel and lush orchestration. An easy 5 stars for a defining album.
Love this. I've been a fan of the Yeah Yeah Yeahs for a long time, have seen them live and the acoustic version of Hysteric was played at my wedding. Across their albums I've always found there are some significant high points but there can be a bit of inconsistency which is why it's a 4 but it's still brilliant and Karen O is a force of nature.
Unlike a lot of other reviewers, I can see the value of this album on the list. Simply red were massive in the late 80's in the UK. Their brand of middle of the road, white man soul was very popular and no one can deny Mick Hucknell has a good voice. My parents had the later album stars and I remember it well. A relisten doesn't generate many more positives though. It's not a patch on more genuine soul music, and the 80's wraps itself around this like herpes.
So so bland. I can't really even remember listening to this.
As a teenager I went on a long road trip from the North of England to the French Alps by bus. I had a new discman and 2 CDs. They were Dookie by Gree Day and this. I must have listened to each album 5 times each and they are both burned into my soul. This isn't clever, its not the best punk rock and it's not pushing the boundaries of anything. But it was and still is a shit-ton of fun and perfect for a confused, energetic and angry teenage boy. I sang along to every word, I made my kids listen to it and coughed over the swear words and we call bounced around like fireworks in a tin can.
I enjoyed Gnarls Barkley era Cee-Lo so went into this with an open mind. After about 30 minutes I found myself wanting to turn it off. The voice is undoubtedly a strong soul voice but it grates after a while, the rapping is terrible and there ar no memorable songs and nothing that marks it out as an album worthy of this list. On completion I was left with a sense of anger that this had made the list as it was below mediocre on every level.