Reviews (page 9 of 15)
Carry On, Almost Cut My Hair, Woodstock, Deja Vu, I really like and have listened to those on a compilation album a long time ago. I love their harmony of voices. I never cared for the slide guitar on Teach Your Children. Overall a really great album with just a few misses for me, 4 star.
When it comes to CSN (and sometimes Y), the vocal harmonies are the draw. This album doesn't disappoint on that front. The classic rock radio hits are almost all here. The deep-cut highlights are "Helpless", "Déjà vu", and "Country Girl". I'm not a big fan of Neil Young's voice, so I would have preferred Helpless and Country Girl had different lead singers, but even still, they're great songs. 4 stars
Good album. Their collective harmonies work well with the music. Very laid back and soothing. Peaceful. 3.5/5 Probably will listen again
This is a very different album, but I think I kind of feel similarly to how I did about The Who's "Who's Next" album. It has one of my favorite songs of all time ("Our House" in this case), and is generally strong overall, but falls just a little short of a perfect rating for me. This is the follow-up to Crosby, Stills, & Nash, which came out the year before (and was album #192 on here for me), this time adding Neil Young to the mix. The harmonies are as clean as always, but they still manage to rock a bit at times too. "Teach Your Children" is another great track on here, but they lose a half point because it's also on their previous album (kind of weird to recycle a song so quickly). I actually read up on "Our House" a bit here, and I didn't realize that Graham Nash wrote it while living with Joni Mitchell. It's such a simple song, but one that just perfectly captures the small moments of living with someone you love. Anyway, this was generally great. You kind of know what you get from these guys, but this is almost definitely some of their best work, whether individual or as a group. Favorite song: Our House Other: Carry On, Teach Your Children, Almost Cut My Hair, Helpless, Woodstock, 4 + 20, Country Girl 1/12/25
Easy 4/5 for this super group of talented musicians.
I liked it! I think of singer songwriter, Americana when listening to this. I like the guitar, both electric and acoustic, as well as the keyboards in Carry On. Vocal harmonies are smooth with digestible melodies for easy listening. I may not seek it out but I would happily listen to again.
Cool cover. Great album. Didn’t realize I knew so many songs. A very fine album for fine folks.
Still sick but this album is good. Obviously know and love those hits - Helpless and Our House - but especially hearing the later this time really had me tearing up
The Neil Young songs are peak
today i was in the car with my friend Mani and we both got so excited cuz we saw a licence plate that was labeled CSNY XXX and it made me sad that ill never own the CSNY 420 licence plate ... anyways its always been weird to me that neil decided that the best use of his time in the early 70s was to form a super group with these three guys who were already making records together ... i love crosby, and think N & S are totally good musicians but yeah there is super super killer tracks on here and Ohio is just an all time neil track ... ultimately Teach Your Children is my fav one ... its beautiful :)
So much talent on one album. Loved nearly every track.
Добротная классика!
Opinion may be biased because wasn’t feeling 70s music at the time.
I'm a fan of this sound, so I really enjoyed this album!
Great! I grew up to my dad playing CSN on the guitar
a classic!! our house, helpless, teach your children are my favs from this one
A staple. Our House is my favorite from the group. If you have not watched the Laurel Canyon series, the parts about Graham Nash, Joni Mitchell, and their relationship really put this whole era of music in a new light.
Some day, if you find yourself with a newborn baby who you spend hours lulling to sleep, you choose "Our House" to sing to them. This song became my go-to lullaby every night for ~6 years and still hits for me. "Life used to be so hard, now everything is easy cause of you" became a reverse psychology mantra that helped me get through the rough infant years. Rewind by many years to a my teenaged youth, and I had Helpless on repeat, to process the incomprehensible angst I suddenly felt. These songs are timeless and gorgeous and poignant. Deja Vu is my 2nd favorite to So Far (mainly because of Helplessly Hoping) but it's a classic.
Teachers your children well and make them listen to this album
I remember I bought this album for the cover - so cool - and then grew into the songs afterwards. But Neil Young makes it, really, cos in retrospect, without his reedy voice shining through, they’re just a nice country rock band. ‘Helpless’ is timeless but I found ‘Country Girl’ meant the most to me, 46 years on from that first listen. Listening laced with nostalgia from my youth.
Really pleasant album, great music and harmonies
Very good
Pretty decent, though why does Neil Young have to sing on this, I STILL don’t like his voice.
The Office forever ruined 'Teach Your Children' for me. Good thing there's always 'Our House' and the rest of this terrific record.
Adding Neil Young to this trio is just showing off.
i liked it a lot. easy to listen to.
Love anything Neil touches.
Meh, some good stuff here, but I'm not much of a Country fan and the slide guitars got me down.
I love their sound. But a bit repetitive
3.5
I've never listened to this album, but I knew a few of the songs (Helpless). Each of the CSNY dudes has their own thing going on here, the tracks alternate between leads but they all work and flow together. Beautiful harmonies and nice guitar work are the name of the game.
Not a fan of the country stuff, but the bluesy stuff is not too bad
Kinda biased here cos my da loves this album so I grew up listening to it Better than most of their other output I reckon.
it was cool
I didn't like this album. It was very 'soft'
Not my favorite but I love the harmonies and Helpless is my favorite CSNY song
Can't believe how many classics are on this album!
Very nice collection of songs - I do tend to skip the most country-ish songs, though. But the rest are wonderful songs by great legends
Woodstock/Our House the Best. Liked the album conceptually more conceptually than in actuality.
Great guitar and great voices but not really my style, i did enjoy it anyways :)
Nice, looking forward to hearing After the Gold Rush
Every track with Neil Young is amazing
this was probably the introduction to folk rock music in my life. My dad used to play this on his turntable when I was a kid and I hated it then, but man do I ever love it today. The harmonies alone are fantastic. It really doesnt even seem like its that long, either. There's plenty there, but I was enjoying it so much that before I knew it, it was done. These guys really made something great.
Great harmonies, great songwriting, just a great album overall. Folk music zenith
Relatively dull '70s Hippie folk rock that doesn't move the needle for me, except for the song "Almost Cut My Hair". This is the first time I have heard this song (and most of the songs on this album), and it absolutely blew me away. This David Crosby led song really changes the entire outlook on this album for me, and brings it up a peg. Really disappointed in the Neil Young led tracks as I figured they would be the most interesting to me Best Song: Almost Cut My Hair Rating: 6.0/10 3 Stars
Just an astounding well composed album with a very silly and pedantic band name.
1- cool harmonies. i love the chord prog. feels like the color brown. ooh, beat switch up. nice. 2- oh, I heard this song in a commercial once. its cute I guess. its not terrible, but not outstanding. 3- this gives off..like, fleetwood mac x late 70s/early 80s rock vibes. 4- this feels so sad 😭 feels like a sad "sweet home alabama". it'd be good for singing as a cover. 5- this gave me dorney park vibes for some reason. it sounds like if thunderhawk had a song. its not bad. 6-the start sounds cool. its like queen x the beatles. the part after the beat switch up feels like cool water. 7- aw, I've heard this before! i didn't know it was by this group. its sweet. reminds me of maggie. 8- ooh, I really like this one. it feels like a dusty attic with sunshine filtering through. 9- I love the instruments in this one. its great. 10-eh. not bad. 6/10
Son typique que je connais de CSN&Y. Je ne sais pas tellement quoi dire de plus : un bon album bien fait mais rien qui m'a jeté par terre. 7/10
Legendary songs, legendary album 🔥
This album is so good. If you didn't know better you'd think it was a greatest hits album.
It's ok, just like that. Zdecydowanie za dużo na tej liście jest niemal bliźniaczych albumów.
It was nice. I didn't hear dog from the cover though. Could be 4.
Excellent
Graham Nash always said that rock and roll can change the world. This is one of my favorite albums of all time. Growing up hearing these harmonies in my house, on an old console TV stereo. There have never been four voices come together and mesh as one like CSNY. I needed this album to remember that no matter how hard life can become, you can always feel strength and hope through song. RIP David and Merry Christmas.
Couple of fantastic songs blended with pretentious whiny crap on this one. Never got why Teach Your Children was such a hit, Woodstock is a much more pleasant listen.
Ya en la previa a navidad, toca en el reto esta banda histórica, que creo sólo ubicaba de nombre. Con armonías vocales afiladísimas, es un folk-rock tranquilo, propio de esos años hippies. Las canciones tienen la épica de esa época, con una juventud atravesada por una fuerte idea de transformación social y cultural a gran escala. Gran disco, entre relajado y colgado. Volvemos el jueves y de ahí pausamos hasta febrero, gente. Gracias por otro hermoso año de recomendaciones musicales.
i liked some of the songs but overall i found the album pretty boring
Simply a classic ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Better than I expected. ‘Helpless’ and ‘Woodstock’ are great songs, “Teach your children” a classic. It’s interesting how the Neil songs are instantly recognizable as his and on the others, where tight harmonies rule, he’s nowhere to be found. Curious a supergroup as there ever was. 3.5
Just so good. Absolute peak ensemble folk rock. Beautiful harmonies and just such a luscious, pastoral, autumn-like tone throughout. An album made for a cozy, chilly day in. This might be the best supergroup album of all time. Even though the word behind-the-scenes was that the egos could barely be contained, the conflict led to one cohesive sounding gem. This is a must listen and belongs on the list. 4.7/5
One of the first things that caught my attention about this album was the cover. It’s unusual to see Dallas Taylor and Greg Reeves receiving second billing, a gesture that, while unexpected, speaks to the collaborative spirit of the record. It feels rare for non-frontline members to get this kind of recognition, especially on such a high-profile release. As for the music, it’s excellent—a soothing blend of folk-rock that feels both timeless and comforting. Each track brings something unique, yet the album flows seamlessly as a cohesive whole. It’s exactly the kind of music I’d reach for on a quiet evening or when I want to unwind. I decided not to pick a standout track this time. It feels almost unfair, given the collaborative nature of the project, to highlight one song and risk sidelining the contributions of the others. Score: 4/5
Very top of the game here, and a stunning collection of beautiful songs and misfit men. God Bless CSNY!
It was stale, and they also recorded the album with way too low of a volume. One, or two decent songs isn't enough for a higher rating. Favorite Song: "Deja Vu".
when young is added to an already good group it gets better
It's weird. When I first heard this album, what, three or four years ago, I really loved it. Jus', goodness, the harmonies. I'd heard tell of them, and they lived up to every expectation; they were beautiful. I can't even remember anything about it other than that — which, hey, that alone was enough to get me excited to hear this again. So, yeah, it's three or four years later now. Fittingly, I was expecting to have a sense of déjà vu in regards to my reaction. And yet... I don't know. I'll say that, absolutely, this is a great album. These four men are great writers and composers. They play great, and their singing, especially their harmonizing, can be incredible. (And, yes, I don't have a problem with Young's. It's different, but it's fine.) I do believe it deserves the acclaim and accolades it gets. However — and maybe it was because the way I was trying to listen to it (on my back with my eyes closed) didn't really work as well as it did the last time I tried it — I wasn't exactly as wowed by it as I was before? I can't really put my finger on it, or what could've changed since I first heard it... Or if it just caught me on a bad day, who can say? Whatever the case, I kind of found it a little bit tricky to really engage with the album like I wanted to. The best I can figure is that, well, I've heard a lot of new music in the interim. I've especially heard a lot this year, thanks to this Randomizer. With my expanded palette, maybe this album just doesn't sound as special to me as it used to? There were certainly a lot of spots where, despite my praise for their harmonies — and I do still believe it, despite what I'm about to say — I ended up thinking, "These just sound like 70's harmonies. Put on another random record from the decade, I'm sure I'll hear something else like it." I didn't think that often enough to find it a problem, but I think it's still relevant to how I engaged I ended up being. And I'll tell you, I really didn't expect there to be as many rockers as there are. Even if there's only two, it sure goes against my perception that this group only does varities of acoustic folk. Like, goodness, this arrangement of "Woodstock"? And what do you mean this arrangement was originally meant for Jimi Hendrix? And that they actually pull it off? Crazy, man. And here I thought they were just "Carry On" ("Suite: Judy Blue Eyes" without Young). Big points for rocking, I suppose. But on whole... I wanna say, if I thought I would've had the time to write this review tomorrow, I absolutely would have. It's entirely likely that tomorrow I would've been in a better state of mind to focus on and actually talk about this album. And certainly, I'll tell you, if I was asked to rate and review this album all that time ago, I would've given this a 5 straight. However, I can only talk about what I got out of this album today, and today... Eh, it's still a 4. I don't believe it really deserves to go any lower. But, yeah, I'unno. I'm probably gonna look back on this review and regret writing it the way I did, but, hey, that's just how it breaks down sometimes. At least Weird Al's pastiche "Mission Statement" remains one of my top three originals from him. Great stuff if you haven't heard it before, goodness.
Hell of a way to introduce a supergroup, at least. Solid 5 Stars.
I’m at a 4.5 that I’ll bump up to a 5. I don’t have that much to wax poetic about, honestly – this is just really good music, that finds itself right between the crossroads of late 60s folk/Americana & 70s dad rock, and somehow finds a really nice blend of the two that evokes the best of both, with a pretty strong variety of subjects & soundscapes to keep it all a pretty breezy, enjoyable and coherent 37 minutes. A few songs are a little stale at points (namely “Helpless” choosing to reprise most of the track), but it never lingers long enough to cause any issues with the album itself. I guess the main reason I’m at a 4.5 is just because Neil Young’s solo (or at least, what feels like solo) tracks on this album feel really detached from Crosby, Stills & Nash – they’re not bad at all, and they’re a great showcase of his own talent, but they make the album feel just a little disconnected. There’s also a few tracks that feel a little too open lyrically, in a way that leaves them slightly too broad for my tastes. Still though, what’s here is too good to not bump up to a 5; the guitar riffs are on point, the vocal harmonies sound spectacular, and if nothing else, the feelings this album evokes from its instrumentals just have a timeless vibe. I really liked it, and I have zero shame in bumping it up to a 5. Pretty strong pick for my first CSNY album.
liked some songs on this one and reminds me a bit of steely dan.
Some good titles, a bit heavy on the Country side. I still don't like Young's voice.
If vinyl followed the same rules of the automotive industry NHTSA suggestions, I shoulda put on a new set of tread awhile ago... But vinyl I feel, seasons well, little fizzles and crackles, and all. You got country, you got a little blues, you got guitar heroics, and vocal harmony as it's own instrument. I feel it's nearly impossible to refrain from belting out, "We arrreeeeee Starrrrrrdusttt..."
Rating: 7/10 Very good overall, a lot of catchy melodies.
Some all time classics on here Carry on and Joni Mitchell’s Woodstock are stand outs. 4.25/5
I enjoyed parts of this a lot, our house is such a good song. In parts found myself getting bored.
3.5 I mean if they wanted to give the credit where its due, it should be Young & Crosby Stills Nash
I get it, but a bit to much
# Playlist Track - Our House # Notes - A bit slow and repetitive. - I can't dig the harmonies in every single song. Just not my thing. - I HATED the chorus on "Country Girl".
Wel ok 6/10
Woodstock!!1!1!
Pretty good
70’s
Good 70’s rock
Pinnacle of country
Great harmonies from the boys. I really enjoyed this. 4 stars
Really didn't enjoy.
This was pretty good. I already knew one song off of this album and I was surprised to hear other ones that I liked. Wasn’t expecting the different sounding music.
Carry On 3.3 Teach Your Children 3 Almost Cut My Hair 4.3 Helpless 4 Woodstock 3.8 déjà vu 3.4 Our House 3.6 4 + 20 3 Country Girl 3.5 Everybody I Stills Love You 3.6 Score: 3.55
Personal Top 10 album
A classic that holds up well. Most underrated song on the album is clearly Almost Cut My Hair. But if I'm nitpicking, I would definitely have picked 4-Way Street over the studio album.
They really ceded this one to Young and it worked! Nothing really stands out to me but the whole thing is an excellent listen.
Great songs contributed by all four. Too bad they couldn’t stay together (consistently) over a longer period. I think Carry On is very under appreciated. Helpless is another highlight for me, but the whole thing is great.
Awesome album which feels like a playlist given all the different singers. Each member of this supergroup contributes great songs to this album. I wish it were longer and that CSNY were able to make more music together during this time. My favorites are "Almost Cut My Hair", which is exciting each time I hear it and "Helpless", which contains one of Neil Young's strongest melodies in my opinion. Plus the Jerry solo on "Teach Your Children" is always fun!
Quite liked some of the songs, but the style just doesn't really hold up for me as much as some of their contemporaries
Undisputed classic. Teach your children about it
A very member berries 4 but any iteration of Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young reminds me of childhood. Holds up
Another album that I listened to a lot as a kid. Everything still holds up to me except the song Almost Cut My Hair which now feels like a song by the sports guy
No nostalgic connection for me, CSN(Y) occupies a sort of background folk rock that comes on adjacent album radios but I would never specifically identify nor seek out. That made it a perfect candidate for a deeper dive and Wikipedia research to understand what I might not be appreciating. It good.
Doesn’t get much better than this classic.
A perfect album. I almost exclusively listened to this album one summer in Ithaca and every time a song plays- it makes me smile.
Best ever
Low effort review as I'm busy today, CSN are generally good, I still prefer Crosby on his lonesome but there's joy here. I know none of these songs but basically everything here is very good. Feel sure would reward repeat listening.
Starts weak (especially the insufferable "Teach Your Children"), but gets better as it goes along. I can't imagine listening to this album again, let alone being a member of the band and having to perform these songs for 45+ years. I know CSNY were all the rage in the Woodstock era, but I guess you had to be there.
this pissed me off
Simply a solid folk rock album that is elevated by Neil Young’s fantastic guitar. Helpless is always a welcomed listen but really the opening 5 tracks are all excellent, the whole group is demonstrating they got harmonies down as well. It’s funny, I always thought Our House was a Beatles or Beatles adjacent track but I was wrong, still don’t really care for it all that much but the sentiment is nice I suppose. 4 stars
Had no expectations for this but loved it! Amazing voices, didn't expect to recognise a few too
Meh. Decent, bit experimental. Good folk vibes. 'Our House' is obviously a killer song, same as 'Helpless'.
A few recognizable hippie tracks on this one
Really solid. Great length. Some great tunes. Not quite 5 but somewhere in the 4s.
4.7 - This was just lovely and some absolute bangers. I almost cut my hair has always been a fave.
This is a good 'un. Carry On, obviously. But the rest of the track list is very solid, with different tracks highlighting different members songwriting and vocal chops. Fave Tracks: Carry On, Almost Cut My Hair, Helpless, Our House, Country Girl 4.5/5
No es mi tipo de música, pero tiene unos puntos muy altos, "Country Girl", "Almost cut my hair" y "Our House", "Deja Vu" está bastante buena también. Tal vez deba escucharlo más.
Great.
Not very memorable again.
Didn’t know what to expect going into this album, but I see why it’s a classic. A superpower of rock/folk music geniuses collaborating on a punchy 30-ish minute album. Great lyrics, great beats. Perfect for a Saturday morning or a sunny summer day. Definitely going to be throwing this on again at some point.
Quite liked it.
Some great songs on here
01) Carry On - 7,5 02) Teach Your Children - 6,5 03) Almost Cut My Hair - 8,0 04) Helpless - 7,5 05) Woodstock - 7,0 06) Déjà Vu - 7,0 07) Our House - 7,5 08) 4 + 20 - 8,0 09) Country Girl - 7,0 10) Everybody I Love You - 7,0 TOTAL: 7,30 (73/100) Current ranking: 212/382
Great album
Second half slaps
Classics
The best harmonies ever
The soundtrack of my family vacations
soft folk rock, brilliantly written and played. i feel like i've often repeating myself at this rate but there's just something about this period of rock music that is incredibly unheard in the mainstream nowadays. collaborating with neil young only makes it shine more. songs of love, peace, and personal reflection are featured throughout here. the meaningful lyrics paired with one-of-a-kind harmonies... it's just fantastic.
Hep yeah. Was actually just thinking the other day about how good a song Woodstock is
Love their vibe. Would definitely listen again!
Not bad
Good album from a good band! Got a good bunch of songs in 'Carry On', 'Almost Cut My Hair', and particularly 'Our House' which we played at our wedding and holds sentimental value to me. Their vocal harmonies are definitely what makes them stand out as a group, and also coincidentally most present on the tracks that are the best, like 'Our House' for example where it almost makes the entire song. I've read a lot about how this group had troubles getting along, especially with mr. Young who was only part of the group for quite a short while. It's funny how his most noticeable appearance here is on 'Helpless', where it almost feels like he's singing solo. Overall, solid album for sure, but lacks some "better songs" to really punch through. Weak 4 for me.
Last time we had a "Crosby, Stills & Nash" album I thought it was going to be a 4 or 5 star for sure, but I ended up a bit disappointed. This album however really delivered. Of the bat you get a chill songs with harmonies in "Carry on". A few tracks later a surprisingly heavy blues song "Almost cut my hair", the latter part of the song made me think of heavy rock and was probably my favourite part of my whole album. "Our House" was probably the only song I'd heard before and it is a good song although a bit odd. I still don't know why it works but it really does. With its runtime shy of 40 min it is the perfect length for an album for me. Clear 4 stars.
Another easy 5
The times when it shines are amazing. Those harmonies man. But then there’s songs like Almost Cut My Hair, a truly terrible song about being an annoying hippy. Standing up for something? What? Oh something completely immaterial. Shut the fuck up. And then after that Neil Young shits all over it with Helpless. One of the problems with a super group like this is some members SHOULDN’T be given equal footing or in this case writing credit. Stick to your lane. It makes the whole project inconsistent. Blegh
The song Woodstock is the song of the generation. Brilliant writing by Joni and CSNY made it come alive
Just a bunch of high people making some decent music. Overall was ok, but I cannot stand "Our House". It's just the epitome of a boring song.
CSN and Neil young separated for a reason, better off as separate entities.
Straight away, the bridge in Carry On features a tempo change and an eerie organ melody before the guitar solo, super neat. I like Almost Cut My Hair as well, midpaced and groovy with great guitars. The moody title track has another quick-to-slow moment and nice bass parts too. Our House is the biggest hit, it's poignant with its vocal harmonies and I like it quite a bit. The organ returns on Country Girl to great effect. I thought I might find this too folksy, but there's a grandeur to it and enough diversity in the songwriting to keep me engaged.
"Déjà Vu" is the second studio album by Crosby, Stills and Nash and the first with Neil Young. The album was self-produced by the band members and most of the songs were recorded in individual sessions by those band members. The time frame for the members was dark with a death and break-ups with girlfriends. Critically, it had mixed reviews but, commercially, it was a huge success hitting #1 in the US and #5 in the UK and has been the biggest selling album in each member's career. In 2023, the album was selected by the Library of Congress into the National Recording Registry for its artistic significance. Acoustic guitar thumping opens "Carry On." Stephen Stills at the helm and lead vocals. A song broken into two parts. Those familiar harmonies. Part I finishes with the lyrics "Love is coming to us all." Stills gets the wah-wah guitar going in Part II and chases a girl. The second song switches to a Graham Nash song in "Teach Your Children." This has more a country feel with Jerry Garcia on steel pedal guitar. Nash wrote this after seeing a photo of a kid playing with a gun and questions the societal messages that parents are sending their children. Neil Young's vocals come to the forefront in "Helpless." It's slower with a background acoustic guitar and piano. The harmonies really take this song home. Young was inspired, so to say, by having polio as a kid and suffering permanent damage on his left side. One of my favorite Neil Young songs. Joni Mitchell wrote "Woodstock" without ever being there and the band captures the spirit. More harmonies and nice electric guitar. "They got to get back to the garden" A great Young lead guitar solo outro. The album needed a nice, happy song and Graham Nash delivers in "Our House." Simple vocals. The catchy "La-la-la-la" chorus. An ode to counter-culture domestic bliss living. Neil Young combines two Buffalo Springfield songs in the three-part ballad "Country Girl." A melancholy vibe. Some more harmony highlights and actually each band member takes turn on vocals. I have no idea what this song is about; there's a waitress, country girl and celebrity mentioned. There's no doubt denying the high level of very good to great songs on this album. Neil Young seemed to play a major part in the ones I liked. The harmonies and vocals are mostly at the forefront with the instruments in the background. This album is similar to their debut, in that besides the harmonies, this seems like four solo albums. The mood definitely has a darker edge though. Most of these songs have had lots of airplay on classic rock radio in the US and most these songs deserve it. This album sounded really good to me today and will do so for most people too.
It's alright. Feels real flavourless and lacks soul. The only song that really struck me was Helpless, where I finally now understand why people hate Neil Young's singing. Fuck me that song was dreadful. Country Girl was pretty good though, as 'epic' as you'd ever describe a folk rock song. Really not much to say here. Plain ass album. A real meat and potatoes, straight up and down, beef Wellington, "Don't trust the Argies!", dick in the vagina, cheddar cheese, and chicken tikka masala record.
Seeing both the genres tagged for this as well as this lists current run of 'supergroups'. I was dreading that the albums name was going to be an omen for what's to come. I was pleased to find that while there is definitely a consistent throughline in the songs on this album, and you could absolutely manually look through certain songs on the tracklist and find them samey. The way they were presented in their correct order kept me satisfied. Though I can't really say it was something that was particularly entertaining. A lot of songs that were just pretty good. Highlights: Our House, 4+20, Country Girl
What a pleasant, harmonic listen. A bundle of fantastic tracks and a steal at only 36 minutes. Misters Crobsy, Stills and Nash sure can lay it down. Neil Young's voice is like in a live recording of Bob Dylan where he starts blowing a gale into that fucking harmonica and it feels like you've suddenly met the same fate as Lev Trotsky. I genuinely forgot he was involved in this project until "Helpless", where to my displeasure his whiny fucking voice shot straight through my ears. I greatly enjoyed every track on this album where Neil Young was not the lead vocalist.
...I'm stupefied by how uninterested I am by the album 5/10 Fav tracks- our house Least fav - idk man
It is genuinely impressive that the writing credits for this album are so evenly spread between the four members of the supergroup and that the musical style maintains consistency so well. You can clearly tell who is writing what song, and it's not that any of the writers here are better than the others (although I have a soft spot for Crosby), but that their musical styles are different. Even though they all shine on their own, when these guys come together their harmonies are phenomenal. Not just in the sense that their voices work well together, musically these guys blend into something that is more than the sum of its parts. This album gets better and better with each listen and I can't say there are any weak tracks. Highlights: Almost Cut My Hair, Deja Vu, Our House, 4+20, Country Girl
джентльмены собрались и навалили на троечку
As good as it gets for CSNY
Such a great album. Great harmonies. Brings back great memories
Very good
Country rock. It was alright, nothing really stood out to me personally.
OK country album
Classic folk rock.
“Kind” rock, maybe like Creedence Clearwater
AMAZING album. Just great. Almost cut my hair especially is such a banger.
Old classic Glad to got reminded of this album today Some very good tunes
3.25
Classic.
Splendid harmony singing, stellar song writing. This album is a timeless classic.
Everyone should have listened to this album at least 20 times in their lifetime.
Pretty cool
Before I received this album as one to listen to it is always on my own personal favorite album of all time list. It ia a fantastic album from one of the greatest groups of all time.
Nah
Damn.
One of my favorite albums of all time. First time listen was on vinyl during covid zooted alone in my room. Almost Cut My Hair is a spiritual song for me
Can’t go wrong with CSNY. Solid album.
Carry On Teach Your Children Almost Cut My Hair Helpless Woodstock Our House 4 + 20
Some really incredible songs, but there were moments where it felt a little boring.
This is close to peak folk rock... I love this.
Overall: 9/10 This is my first time listening to a full album featuring any of the members of this band and that's honestly kind of embarrassing. I'm glad to start closing this horrific gap in my music listening. In terms of this album, it's a country/folk/rock album that I absolutely adore. The harmonies are shockingly gorgeous and I love that Neil gets to shine the most on this album because he has the most unique voice of the four members. I've seen some people don't enjoy Neil's voice and I'm not sure why I do but he's one of the few whiney singers that isn't grating to the ears. The instrumentation is also diverse enough to keep the album interesting throughout. Can't wait to hear so many more albums from all of these guys. Fav Song: Woodstock Least Fav Song: 4 + 20
Deja Vu…I think I’ve heard this before. Harmony is where it’s at by some of the best.
Country müziğe doydum yeto. Hiç beğenmedim.
Carry on, deja vu
If I were a middle-aged man with long hair blasting this album in my convertible on a highway as the wind licks my receding hairline, I would love it. But I am me and this is not for me. Turns out the only tracks I liked are the ones written by Neil Young. I think they really stand out.
Familiar songs.
Great album, so easy to listen to.
Didn’t love as much as I thought I would
Masterpiece!
I got tired of it as the album went on. I do like some songs, but it all blends together
Tough one for me to rate. Objectively, this might deserve a 5, but I guess the point of the exercise is to give our opinions. While the vocal harmonizing is nice on some songs but overdone on the album in my opinion. Kind of makes the whole thing sound dated to me. I wish they had given more songs to individual singers. Otherwise, it’s a very enjoyable listen and the talent of these guys really shines through.
Buen disco, me gusta mucho la polaridad de las diferentes voces y los coros en cada tema. Por ahí hay algunos temas de relleno.
Fav songs: Deja Vu - absolutely beautiful piece of music. Mind blowingly good stuff.
Opening song bangs (Carry On). Unsurprisingly, the Neil Young parts are the best. The rest is replacement level 60s folk rock.
It's groovy and folksy. I like it
This is a great album that could fit just about anywhere from the 50s through the 80s in about 4 different genres and be a work of art. There are folk, psychedelic, country, and rock elements at play, but they all meld together wonderfully. I was skeptical about this record, but I'm a definite fan now. Notable Tracks: - Teach Your Children - Almost Cut My Hair - "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" vibes - Woodstock - Our House - Country Girl - awesome harmonica riffs near the end 7.5/10
Pleasant enough, but nothing that really stands out as essential
Wait this is actually sick?! Carry On (the beat change is actually nuts) Teach Your Children Helpless (this one is weird in that there are parts I don't like but the harmonies are GROGEOUS) Woodstock Deja Vu !!!!!!!!!! The beginning of this song is just ridiculous and im really upset is slows down. Our House 4 + 20 (jesus this song is sad but gorgeous I almost don't want to add it because of how sad it make me feel ggs) Country Girl Everybody I Love You This album was ridiculous, genuinely enjoyed this front to back. This album embodies everything I enjoy about Creedence Clearwater and I was smiling ear to ear (except for that 1 sad song) GGs boys EXACTLY the type of thing I wanted from this challenge
I actually really liked this
Second half was really good, first half didn't really get me
I feel like I've heard this before.
Never listened to this album, but I knew the first five songs so far. On track 7(our house) and I know this whole record so far. This blows my mind. No wonder CSNY has always been talked about so highly. This is an albums worth of hits. First track I didn’t know was “4+20”. Great song. Now I’m on “country girl”. This one I don’t know either, and the first song where I’m not “wow”. So country girl starts slow and builds to a great song. Great album
Woodstock to the heart, but got love for all Lie and die in the fire, where I learned to ball Our House is the place where I lay my dome On the streets of the San Francisco where my Country Girl roam
Some great songs some mediocre and some just did nothing for me
music for sipping coffee on the porch as the seasons change
Ok
I've heard this album multiple times. Classic rock-and-roll album. Like a lot of CSN&Y (especially with the Y) it's a Frankenstein that shifts pretty dramatically depending on the songwriter. The Graham Nash contributions (Teach Your Children, Our House) don't age that well. They are well written songs but seem pretty cheesy 50 years on. Crosby's contributions are just okay. Young's Helpless is great, but Country Girl is forgettable. Carry On (Stills) still soars and the CSNY version is the best of Joni Mitchell's Woodstock. Comes up just short of 5 stars for me.
Enjoyable but rather hit and miss.
My parents subjected me to CSN&Y too much when I was a kid and I hated it. I realize that technically this is decent songwriting and musicianship, but I just can't. Especially Teach Your Children. Oh lord. No.
Interesting contrasts between the different singers. Impressive when I recognize 6 out of the 10 songs as well-played "hits". The ones that weren't hits were still good. There's a good harmonization, and despite being late 60's this album still feels timeless.
cool
I liked the folky rock vibe
Didn't mind it without loving it. Couple of decent tunes mind.
I hate this album. It's super lame. I mean the whole sound of it is just so cheesy and dated. The musicianship is solid but this genre just does nothing for me. The vocals are mostly lauded but I find them to be so stereotypical for this genre and time period. Not every song needs everyone in the band to sing all at the same time. The saving grace was Neil Young's contributions and the songs where his vocals are (mostly) solo are the best. But even then, the chorus rolls around and we have a sing-along again. CS&N were so much worse without him, so this album has that going for it I guess. There are some excellent guitar parts (mostly thanks to Neil Young) but that's not really enough to keep it from just being uninteresting. I feel like all the boomers that love this album love it purely for nostalgic reasons, and that's valid (for them) I guess - I'm sure there are plenty of records I like just for the nostalgia. But listening to this record 54 years later, it doesn't have anything that would make me ever want to put it on again. 2.25/5 rounding down.
It's pretty remarkable that four guys with such distinctive creative voices were able to function at all, much less as seamlessly as they did in various configurations for much of their career. There's an argument to be made that this album has the best songs Young ("Country Girl"), Nash ("Our House"), Crosby ("Deja Vu") and Joni Mitchell ("Woodstock") ever wrote. Stills is no slouch here either, but he has some pretty incredible songs elsewhere in his oeuvre.
Well written, well sequenced; all their strengths distilled into their most potent. These 4 were combustible combination, but held it together for a great album. One of my favorites.
Like it 3/5
Unfamiliar. Fave song: Our House. Hmm would rate it 2. Other highlights almost cut my hair (I liked the guitar), Last minute of Deju Vu. 4+20 (mellow, nice story). Can see how some people would like this but honestly as a whole not my vibe. I was happy when the last song came on.
Albumi #83, 19.10.2024 Folk rock -ryhmän kakkosalbumi on varsin mukava kokonaisuus. Erityismaininnat kappaleille "Carry On" sekä Stephen Stillsin soolokappaleelle "4 + 20".
Supremely bland. 3/10
Really like this, so many classics. The different songwriter concept has so much benefit to the bands that know how to implement it correctly.
Really enjoyed this, reminded me of a Fleetwood Mac album in some ways so it makes for easy listening. Probably will listen again :)
This was a top 10 in high school. Still love it but doesn’t quite hit the same.
Does exactly what you would expect with our house a shiny piece of pop rock
I'm slightly surprised I've never heard this album before today. Certainly heard many of these songs and I have to say this is already the best CSN(Y) I've heard. But I still find their singing irritating and for that reason have a hard time getting into it.
It's kind of curious that this collection has the first and second album by Crosby Stills & Nash, and nothing else, mainly because these two albums seem somewhat interchangeable. When I started playing this album, in fact, I actually wondered if somehow I'd gotten the same album I'd listened to before, but then realized it was just that there were another bunch of radio hits on this album too (as well as a thankfully much smaller number of largely forgettable harmony-driven tracks). I *do* like it that Neil Young's influence can be heard and felt on this album, as there's definitely more instrumentation to many of the songs (compared to their Young-less debut album). And the radio hits remain both familiar and fun to listen to once again; especially "Teach your children" and "Carry on", but also "Our house" and to some degree "Woodstock". I also enjoyed "Almost cut my hair" as a surprisingly not-CSN-sounding song, and Young's "Helpless" sounds almost better on this album than his own releases. Overall, though, there's not much cohesion to the album, a product it seems of the way each band member recorded and composed on their own.
Quite nice. Not my favorite of theirs (looking at you "almost cut my hair") but still good
Loved it!
This is a truly excellent album. Our House is, obviously, a classic. 4+20 is great too. Well-honed, each song changing things up just a little to keep you on your toes. Atmospheric - would be good with eyes closed and headphones in.
3,5*
Truly wonderful--it's clear why all of these guys are so famous, although kinda hard to believe this was the best selling album any of them ever made.
So all four of these musicians are considered songwriting geniuses and between the four of them, this is all they could come up with? It's not horrible and there are a couple of adequate radio-friendly tracks on here, especially on the second half of the album. But really, I fail to understand the genius of any of the four members individually and have rated them around 3 stars pretty consistently throughout this 1001 album project. Maybe you had to grow up in the 70's to truly appreciate them - but even if I'm simply 30+ years too young for this, there are so much more exciting albums that were released prior to this one. Par for the course, 3 stars for radio filler music between the actually exciting hits that can be found elsewhere.
Almost cut my hair!
know this album well
Ugh, difficult -- it's not bad and there's obviously historical value to it but on the other hand, it's just another badly recorded, garbage sounding, blues dad rock album from the seventies.
It was alright, didn’t blow me away but was decent enough. Not sure I’d listen to it again in a hurry though.
Classic album but I never loved these guys. Always bored me. Listening to this probed to be no different. Bo-ring.
I RECOGNIZED SOME SONGS ON THIS ONE! would i listen to it again?? mehhhhh probably not. am i glad i listened to it?? i think so? overall, i liked it - i love a guitar solo. makes me wanna pick up my own guitar and go absolutely hog wild. daily dad update when i told him i listened to this album - "A classic."
Good vibes, could see myself listening to this album with my Mom (she probably already has the CD)!
There are a few songs I really love (Woodstock, Our House) a few classics that are ok and a bunch of really bland songs that bore me. It’s got it all! I think I just wasn’t mellowed out enough when I was listening to it. I can appreciate that this would sound best around a campfire with some good weed.
It's interestingly folky. I guess
Meh
So so good.
Ridiculously good — every song.
Lots of hits, excellent tight harmonies, and a more eclectic mix of songs than what I would have expected.
Still pretty good
Classic folk-rock album of the hippie generation. Not everything aged great
Dull
In a nutshell: existential folk rock. It's a lament of the free life, of hippiedom. Probably the best harmonies you'll hear on an early 1970s album. This should be your first port of call for learning about David Crosby, Stephen Stills, Graham Nash and Neil Young. Start here, then branch out. Overall: 7/10
Peak CSN&Y which is good enough for me.
This is a great sounding album and the title track is timeless. There's a warmth and complexity to CSNY that is missing from a lot of music. Helpless is so clearly Young doing what he does best. Not everything on this one is equally good but you can see why these four were a huge influence, especially Young who is clearly the standout.
This album feels like the production/mixing level is a grand canyon apart from a lot of other albums on this list especially modern overcompressed stuff. Even if a song or two didn't hit me right away I was listening because the mixing is so good. I think Helpless is my favorite track. This album makes me want to understand why it sounds so good. Even if you don't like the music it should make you wonder why so many albums even on this list don't sound this good.
Deja Vu - Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young (1970) Hippie country A obra conta com duas coisas que não contam com a minha simpatia, que é a sonoridade country com uma temática hippie nas músicas, mas mesmo assim as músicas são legais, e o álbum bem curto e direto, então é uma audição tranquila. P.s. o Neil Young é canadense. Melhores músicas: N/A Piores músicas: N/A 2.5/5
This is really really good - a rare ‘supergroup’ album where the artists really get each other and bring out the best in each other. Maybe not necessarily any of their strongest records (particularly for Young who has so many classics under his belt) but the songwriting, pacing and harmonies here all just work so well
Peak hillbilly/stoner/hippy jams plus a song from the office.
A really nice album! Very chill, loved the vibes 4 ⭐️
It felt like a very odd inbetween more 60s chill pop and the first beginnings of rock. A pleasant listen!
Very chill and an enjoyable listen
Did not leave a lasting impression. Pretty, but nothing special for my ears.
meh
Great album! Really liked the chill vibes of each song.
They definitely have their signature sound. Solid album, more of the same as their other stuff I've heard. Sounds good but the harmonies get a bit tiring after a while.
Legal
Här blir man bjuden på det mesta. Mjuk akustisk folk, twangig country och elektrical rock music. Kanske lätt blir så pass spretigt när ett band består av fyra artister som alla skriver sina egna låtar. Mina åsikter om låtarna korresponderar därför ganska väl med mina åsikter om respektive genre. Men, alla låtar håller en väldigt hög nivå. Ibland lite slätstruket. Gillar inte stämsången som tyvärr var så populär vid den här tiden. Utan den hade 'Teach Your Children' kunnat vara så mycket bättre. Proggiga 'Almost Cut My Hair' och mystiska 'Déjà Vu' sticker ut mest. Båda pennade av David Crosby, som jag då kanske borde utforska mer. 'Our House' såklart också fantastisk. Neil Youngs 'Country Girl' maffig. Bästa låt: Almost Cut My Hair
Favourites: Woodstock, Deja Vu, Our House, Country Girl
Not bad, but the album wasn't really my style. A bit too slow for my liking.
I’m always leery of albums of “musical suites” from bands with multiple but often disparate songwriters. When done well, they can be great (thinking of you, White Album!). The ebbs and flows of mixing different creative snippets together can indeed produce exquisite masterpieces. But just as often it can deteriorate into a mashup of creative ideas that never gel really. It’s that tension that I like when it works; various ideas coming together to create something transcendent and impossible without such collaboration. Unfortunately… just as often there’s less collaboration and more throwing a bunch of separate creative snippets together in a hodgepodge, while the creative members can barely tolerate speaking to each other much less creating inspiring music together. Thankfully, despite ALL the vitriol and infighting going on amongst CSN&Y during the 800+ hours (WTF?! 😱) of recorded material for this album, often with bandmates recording separately because they pretty much hated each other at this point, we get a masterpiece from them. For me, the album started off OK with “Carry On”, but it hits its stride regarding sequencing from “Helpless through to “Our House”. There’s so much to love, from the songwriting, the harmonies (the harmonies! 🥰), to the musicianship. Actually, I think I prefer their cover of Joni Mitchell’s “Woodstock” to her original, which is saying something. So why not a “perfect” five? Well, while I appreciate the end of the album, especially Neil’s “Country Girl/Whiskey Boot Hill”, it loses a little steam for me. Just a little 😜. I do think I prefer this album over their previous, by just a touch
There's some explosive elements of creativity that these guys tapped into which make these songs uniquely powerful. For a team of 4 to be so lit up and capable of synchronicity like these songs show is above typical human abilities. I'd give 5 stars but only 4 because the charge doesn't fully hit in every song
Both ups and downs. Helpless is a classic.
great album! funny listening to our house now that i know it was written about joni mitchell
Didn’t get all the way through it but have listened to it many times before - awesome album, huge diversity in music but all great performances
Some of the greatest harmonies ever put on record
What a familiar sound, even though I had not really listened to a lot of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young so far. Has this 70s feel (obviously) which I absolutely adore. The vocals in some songs were a highlight for me - layered vocals are a soft spot of mine. Some songs reminded me of super early Queen a bit, Queen I and Queen II, two of my favourite albums of all time. Others gave Simon and Garfunkel vibes, while some others had this distinctive Beatles sound. Overall, I knew since the very first song that this album was going to be a solid 5/5. Marvellous.
good album, pretty relaxing
I get the sense these guys would play well together particularly live. Greta musicianship, but the whole album seems rather complacent about their status as a 'counterculture band'.
3.5
A classic but a little softer than what I typically want to listen to
A classic - surely everyone loves CSN&Y
At a time when rock bands seemed to name themselves like law firms, CSN added a new partner in Neil Young. His arrival brought another dimension to the band’s already stellar songwriting and live performances, though it came with Young's famed unpredictability and headstrong attitude. Having already watched Young dismantle Buffalo Springfield, Stephen Stills should have known better—but Young’s musical chops clearly outweighed the risks. Given the towering egos, volatile relationships, and an infamously scattered recording process, it’s a miracle Déjà Vu was recorded at all—and even more remarkable how accomplished it sounds. The album flows seamlessly, with songwriting and singing duties shared almost equally (Stills x3, Crosby x2, Nash x2, Young x2, plus one cover). Stills brought technical precision and rock sensibilities, Crosby offered dreamy, freeform experimentation, Nash delivered polished, melodic pop, and Young added raw emotion and introspective grit. Together, they pushed each other to raise their game, allowing every member’s strengths to shine. Déjà Vu contains some of Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young's most accomplished and memorable songs as a band and as individuals—no small feat, given the stellar careers each of them had. Did/Do I own this release? No, but I should Does this release belong on the list? Yes Would this release make my personal list? Yes Will I be listening to it again? Yes
I'm about one tenth of the way through this list, and the sheer volume of folk and folk tinged albums is almost embarrassing. Other forms of music exist! That being said, the track "Helpless" by Neil Young is good. It's no wonder Young has managed a career spanning decades while the others remain relics.
One of my favorite albums of all time. I love the harmonies, I love the songwriting, I love the songs on here.
Classic album, great songs and vocals
Album #1 Was expecting this to be more acoustic but there was a lot of electric guitar. Was a bit more accessible for me than other folk type stuff I’ve tried to listen to before but generally very well written songs and good musically too. Good first album to get as it wasn’t too long and very easy to enjoy.
Really enjoyed this, would be great on vinyl.
Liked this a surprising amount
I actually like this, even though not my favorite genre or era. There's tones of blues, country, and classic 70's rock (which, if we're honest is just blues and country mixed with weed and hippie hair).
Always love Neil Young. Helpless is great along with many other tracks on this album.
OUR HOUSE, IS A VERY VERY VERY FINE HOUSE🗣️🗣️🗣️
Pleasant
Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young hit just right every now and then. This was every now and then.
Solid folk rock, some proto jam stuff going on. All in a tight sub 40 minute package. Ideal.
4.6 One of the best folk rock albums of the 70s. Love how their voices harmonize together.
Pleasant folk music, with lovely harmonies. The Nash songs were the best and kind of overpowered the rest. Stand-out: Teach Your Children
Until today I hadn't listened to a whole CSNY album but somehow knew what it would sound like and well, it did! There's nothing offensive about it, folk/country/soft rock with vocal harmonies and late 60s hippie vibes. By track 4 or 5 you'll understand why the album is titled as it is... by track 8 it could have been track 2 again and I'd have been none the wiser.
This was painful.
All I can say is this album is a master class in "Harmonies!!!" So good. If your into harmonies an musicianship, this your bag. Enjoy and say thank you.
It’s been over a month since my last Neil Young related album; I was getting worried. This has been my favorite so far — only 36 minutes long! Four stars for the run time, five stars for David Crosby’s hat, two star for the ones who aren’t Crosby and Young, minus 19 stars for that song about teaching children well.
There are parts of this that are incredible, but it's all weighed down in this hippie-era slop of pretension and ego. Still, it's undeniable that there are some incredible songs on here.
A fantastic moment in time. Every song is a piece of art.
Naming the “band” after each individual member belies how well these guys harmonize. Very few, if any, did it better.
Exactly what we should get from a supergroup: brilliant lyrics, harmony, and playing.
Going with 4*, but I don't see myself going back to listen to it, oddly. Still, undeniably good stuff.
Unexpectedly and surprisingly enjoyable.
Decent songs and good harmonies as you'd expect. It was however, an extremely slow and depressing sound for me.
This was one of those albums that I thought I would know a few songs from going in, and it turned out I knew basically every song on the album. It turns out I unknowingly grew up on this album, as my family plays songs from it constantly. It’s just a delight to listen through. The harmonies are immediately identifiable and unique to this band. The overall sound is folky, but still has a rock edge to it at times (especially the guitar parts). Just a great record
Classic album. Every song is good and most are better. Even Our House, which I've always felt was too saccharine, was a major hit. It speaks to the variety on this album. It points the way from 60's folk rock to more complex and edgier (thanks to Neil) rock of the 70's. Several songs like the title track are really interesting with the changes they manage in a 4 minute song like mini movements. The variety of the album could make it seem a bit disjointed to some; the Young tracks particularly stick out. Despite the love focused themes of most of the songs, you can still hear the countercultural metaphors imbedded. Its a fantastic, enjoyable, mostly timeless album.
11 stars out of 5. One of the greats.
Not my cup of tea 1
Well put together but didn't really stand out to me.
Great Album.
This is a grower not a show'er. Love the guitar and harmony work on Carry on. Good tunes - Carry on, almost cut my hair, helpless, deju vu, our house, 4+20, country girl and everybody i love you. This is a good listen. I wouldnt class it up there with my greatest of all time but its a really good album. I think a 4.5 would be ideal. This has been better than most 4's ive given.
For a CSNY album, this is banger after banger. Terrible cover, though. Sheesh. Unless it's modeled after a famous photo, in which case - well done!
You can feel the hippie dream curdling into self-indulgence in real time on this patchouli-powered behemoth. It's still a fine time capsule. 'Carry On' is right up there, the harmonies ate sensational; 'Helpless' points towards After the Goldrush; 'Almost Cut My Hair' to this day sounds cracking. On the downside, of all the versions of 'Woodstock' I've heard, this rather peppy version might be the worst. And, whilst 'Our House' is strong in melody, the sentiment verges on slushy. Also, "two cats in the yard" feels like a slightly peculiar lyric, for some reason. Nonetheless, I liked this very much.
All sounds the same
There's a bit of filler, but the sheer amount of great tracks this record has more than makes up for that. Fantastic song-writing and superstar talent make this an excellent album.
A total classic. Young Neil’s Helpless. Our House and Deja Vu are all astounding. There’s a song about a little thing that’d just happened the year before called Woodstock. The harmonies, as always, are impeccable. If an epic like Judy Blue Eyes had been on this, it’d be even more of a monument than it is. That said CSN seem very separate from Y on this. It’s like two bands stuffed onto one album. A friend left this record at my house like a decade ago and never came back for it. Considering I’ve only spun it once since then, I feel that shows my level of connection to it. As I said, a total classic, but its not quite my vibe, so three stars due to personal taste. Neil would go on to greater things, and CSN have better showings as well. Sixth album reviewed here.
I didn’t find anything bad on this but it also came across as pretty forgettable. Two songs I loved but everything else was just there. 2.5/5
Too many memorable songs not to be 5 stars or A- for me.