Reviews (page 10 of 15)
I found Crosby, Stills, Nash, & Young's *Deja Vu* to be more enjoyable than I expected. While most songs landed around a middle-of-the-road 3 rating for me, there were a few standout tracks that I would rate a 4 or 4.5.
An iconic album for all time
A bit mellow but there are some classics on there
Incredible! More than half of the album could be considered a greatest hits for them.
Corny, Stale, Naff, and Yawn
Always been sort of indifferent to them but this was good
Déjà Vu by Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young is a stunning album that beautifully showcases their signature harmonies. The album exudes warmth and tenderness, creating a deeply immersive listening experience. Each track is infused with a rich, melodic quality that highlights the intricate vocal arrangements of the band. The lyrics explore themes of love, introspection, and social change, adding emotional depth to the music. The seamless blend of folk and rock elements offers a timeless quality that resonates throughout. Overall, Déjà Vu is a powerful testament to the band's ability to craft emotionally resonant and sonically rich music. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 8 STAND OUT TRACK - Helpless
Folk rock was in its heyday and this album was one of the best of the era.
Excellent album start to finish
This one was a pretty good magic trick... "Guys, your first record was wildly successful and featured the most incrdible vocal harmonies of the whole hippy era. What are you going to do next? We are going to add Neil Young's voice to the mix, and not even thay is going to be enough to screw this formula up." ...and it wasnt, the harmonies were still good and Young upgraded some of the songwriting.
Nice one.
很棒
What a load of shit
Wow! This dog is cute. While listening I was looking for a word to describe this album and heard "cosy". I'll go with it, it's cosy. I don't want to sing along or dance to it, I just want to listen The average commentator for it is ~70yo, if you're interested. I feel old for not hating it
meh. 3rd song is decent and had it in one of my playlists already but rest is a snoozer
Solid album with some good songs. Not a huge fan, but definitely worth listening.
I enjoyed this album so much. There is something in the melodies - it is a mix of joy, relaxation, and emotion. I love the instruments used. It was a good time!
So so
Just one of the best. You have to be a fan of the style and harmonization but it's so good if you are. Deserving of 5 stars. 9/10 (4.5/5)
Only a single memorable hook on the whole album. Seems like they’re too preoccupied with the harmonies to actually write interesting melody.
Chill 70’s vibes
did not find it super engaging, but there are some highlights for sure. Our House is so beautiful, can't believe those people calling it cheesy and shallow! I think a 3.5 overall
Excellent. Listened three times in a row Update. And it’s growing on me. Listened 4 more times
One of my favorite vinyl in my collection
Pretty great album for sure. Strong combinations of folk, rock, blues, and even a bit of psychedelic music too. Instrumentation was lively and the vocal chemistry between each member was extremely strong too with several strong harmonies. Not sure if I’m really rushing back to the album as a whole at this point in time though. There’s not really a flaw I could name but idk it’s just not resonating a to with me atm. Time will tell on that front. Still great though.
First time listening to a CSN(+Y) album. So far I've given a 5 to Crosby, a 3 to Stills, and a 2 to Young+Crazy Horse, whose upper-register singing voice is like nails on a chalkboard to me. Nash remains an enigma, but I get the feeling he's a little too twee and whimsical for my liking, like McCartney's bad days. This album has done nothing to change my beliefs, although I think given enough time I can build a compilation I enjoy. S: Almost Cut My Hair A: Country Girl B: Deja Vu, 4+20 C: Carry On, Woodstock, Everybody I Love You D: Helpless, Our House F: Teach Your Children
I’m never quite sure what to do with albums like this, because yes, I get it was era-defining and incredibly popular, but I’ve always felt disconnected from the Hippie movement, especially when it’s done as earnestly as is from CS&N. I’m not counting Young, because I totally get his appeal. I enjoyed a fair few of the songs, especially Neil Young’s, but there’s always this aspect, this idealism, that I can’t get past. I think it’s best summed up by Our House, which I think is fine as a tune, but as a message, it’s completely antithetical to anything I’ve ever known. The world has so thoroughly changed since 1970 that the idea of being in the future, looking back, and being able to say ‘well it was hard, but we’re doing OK now’ is something I’m certain I’ll never be able to do. I don’t begrudge the album that. But it’s still a barrier to enjoyment that I can’t overlook
These little groups are normally lovely. These guys were just winey af. Bet they were a nightmare to record with
Shockingly good. First album I had on my first MP3 player, have not come back for a full relisten in a while, and it’s better than I remember.
Fantastic album that still reveals the optimistic side of the 60s and hope for a better future, before the cynicism of the 70s set in. Intelligent lyrics, harmony, and some nice electric flourishes throughout. The biggest problem on the album is the jarring movement from the opening song, Carry On, to the second track, which is full on country. In fact, the album does have a little bit of unevenness that way, but the highs are so high. It’s still rounds up to a five star rating.
Side one is perfect. Unskippable. Side two is only great in comparison. I get why some people would find it dated but I think this is the strongest CS&N were with Young only getting better.
I can’t believe how many classics are on this album. The addition of Neil young gave CSN the edge they needed (for my taste). Just When they are at their most hippie (teach your children) they follow it up w a soulful rocker like almost cut my hair. Woodstock and helpless are my favorites, but this has more classics per album than almost any other american album of this genre
Very laid back album of great backing music, and not so great singing.
That was okay...
The vocal harmonies are first rate, there’s a fantastic blend of borderline country, blues and acoustic psychedelia that really hit the right notes for me. The vocal harmonies are first rate, there’s a fantastic blend of borderline country, blues and acoustic psychedelia that really hit the right notes for me. Worth listening to again and again.
Old garage band music from back in the day when rock and roll was still fresh. The soul and R &B covers were certainly not as good as the originals (don’t try to one up Little Richard), but it was pretty enjoyable.
This was a pleasant surprise. Solid tunes here
Nice. solid album
Great album! Nearly a perfect encapsulation of that era and sound. 4.5/5
Would probably have rated higher if I hadn't had like 5 Neil young albums recently!
An enjoyable album but not one that I would listen to again in a hurry.
Not my style but chill
Beard guys rule
36mins, but felt like 136
cracker music 2/10
Pretty tight. Would have got a five if it had had Ohio like I thought it did. I like stills guitar work, and neils, the harmonies are crystalline, and a pretty common observation but neils are the best songs. Like the garcia pedal steel on teach your children. Dig the CSN songs too but to a lesser degree. very much products of their time, while neil manages to make even Kent state timeless around the same time frame.
One of the only albums I've immediately hit replay on.
Tää on aika selkee peruspilari folkin ja folkkirokin osalta. Solid! 4/5
Varsin hyvää hippifolkia.
Favorite Track: Woodstock
Wow, what a great Album with so many different tracks…9/10
Ein herausragendes Album, das die Essenz der 70er Jahre perfekt einfängt. Mit einer Mischung aus solidem Rock, Hippie-Vibes und Country-Einflüssen bietet das Album eine unverfälschte und schnörkellose Musikalität, die sowohl nostalgisch als auch zeitlos wirkt. Die Band zeigt auf diesem Album ihre Fähigkeit, harmonische Melodien und tiefgründige Texte zu kombinieren. Besonders hervorzuheben sind die Tracks “Our House”, “Country Girl”, “4 + 20” und “Almost Cut My Hair”. Diese Lieder spiegeln die Vielfalt und das Talent der Band wider und sind ein Beweis für ihre musikalische Vielseitigkeit. “Our House” ist ein warmherziger und eingängiger Song, der das Gefühl von Zuhause und Geborgenheit vermittelt. “Country Girl” beeindruckt durch seine komplexe Struktur und emotionale Tiefe. “4 + 20” ist ein introspektiver und ruhiger Track, der durch seine Einfachheit besticht. “Almost Cut My Hair” hingegen ist ein kraftvoller und rebellischer Song, der die Freiheit und das Lebensgefühl der 70er Jahre perfekt einfängt. Insgesamt ist Déjà Vu ein konzeptionell starkes Album, das durch seine klare und authentische Musikalität besticht
Has some lovely classic tracks. A great sunny day album
On est en 1970. Les sixties sont officiellement terminées, la gueule de bois post-Woodstock commence à bien taper sur les tempes et le "Peace and Love" se fait de plus en plus discret face à la guerre du Vietnam qui n'en finit pas. C'est dans ce contexte un peu vaseux que débarque le deuxième album de la clique Crosby, Stills & Nash, augmentée pour l'occasion d'un quatrième larron, et pas des moindres : le Canadien grimaçant, Neil Young. Le concept même de "supergroupe" a de quoi faire frémir. C'est souvent la pire fausse bonne idée de l'histoire du rock. Tu prends des mecs qui sont déjà des demi-dieux dans leurs formations respectives, tu les fous dans la même pièce et tu attends que la magie opère. En général, ce qui opère, c'est surtout un concours de celui qui aura la plus grosse et une bouillie musicale où personne ne veut laisser un peu de place à l'autre. Et pourtant... Cet album est un miracle accouché dans la douleur, la drogue et les larmes. Pour le mettre en boîte, il aura fallu, selon la légende, plus de 800 heures de studio. Huit. Cents. Heures. De quoi enregistrer toute la discographie de Guided By Voices, faces B comprises. Il faut imaginer le tableau : David Crosby est en plein deuil, sa copine venant de se tuer en voiture, et il noie son chagrin dans des quantités industrielles d'héroïne. Les autres ne sont pas en reste, la coke et l'alcool animent joyeusement les sessions, les engueulades fusent, et Neil Young, fidèle à sa réputation d'électron libre, n'est là que la moitié du temps. Au milieu de ce merdier, le pauvre Graham Nash joue les Casques Bleus de l'ONU, essayant de maintenir une cohésion qui n'existe déjà plus. Ce contexte, c'est la clé pour comprendre l'album. "Déjà Vu" n'est pas l'oeuvre d'un groupe soudé. C'est une compilation de luxe, une playlist de quatre génies qui se tolèrent à peine mais qui, chacun dans son coin, est au sommet de son art. C'est ce qui fait à la fois sa force et sa faiblesse. La force, c'est l'incroyable diversité et la qualité hallucinante des compositions. Chaque membre tire le drap à soi, et on a le droit à tout : Graham Nash nous livre des ballades pop parfaites, solaires et imparables comme "Our House" ou l'hymne au barbecue "Teach Your Children", avec son pedal-steel qui te donne envie de mâcher un brin de paille en regardant le soleil se coucher sur le Grand Canyon, même si t'habites à dans un trou paumé à l'autre bout de la planète. Stephen Stills, le rockeur de la bande, ouvre le bal avec le monumental "Carry On", une suite en plusieurs mouvements qui est une démonstration de force, un morceau épique qui justifie à lui seul le concept de supergroupe. David Crosby, le hippie tourmenté, nous offre des titres plus sombres, plus paranoïaques, comme "Almost Cut My Hair", véritable cri du coeur d'une génération qui sent le vent tourner, ou le sublime et vaporeux ""Déjà Vu"". Et puis il y a Neil Young. Le Loner ne fait pas du CSN, il fait du Neil Young. "Helpless" est une complainte magnifique, fragile, avec cette voix nasillarde qui te transperce l'âme, une chanson qui semble flotter au-dessus du reste de l'album, comme si son auteur était déjà ailleurs. Le jeu est d'une précision chirurgicale, les harmonies vocales sont à tomber par terre, ça suinte le talent par tous les pores. Chaque note est à sa place, chaque arrangement est pensé, poli, magnifié. On sent les 800 heures de labeur. C'est luxuriant, c'est riche, c'est le son de Laurel Canyon porté à son paroxysme. Un son qui a défini le rock californien pour la décennie à venir. Alors pourquoi seulement 4/5 ? Parce que justement, ce n'est pas un groupe. C'est une collection de chefs-d'oeuvre individuels. L'album manque de liant, de cette alchimie unique qui fait qu'un tout est supérieur à la somme de ses parties. On passe du coq à l'âne, de la ballade la plus tendre au rock le plus brut, sans véritable transition. C'est un glorieux bordel, un patchwork magnifique mais qui trahit les fissures béantes au sein du quatuor. On écoute quatre albums solo condensés en un seul. C'est ce qui l'empêche, à mon humble avis, de s'asseoir à la table des plus grands monolithes de l'histoire. Mais qu'on ne s'y trompe pas. "Déjà Vu" est un album essentiel. Un disque qui capture l'instant précis où le rêve hippie s'est cogné au mur de la réalité. C'est un disque de transition, schizophrène, qui porte en lui à la fois l'insouciance des sixties finissantes et l'amertume des seventies naissantes. Un album qu'il faut écouter et réécouter, pour en saisir toutes les nuances, toutes les tensions, toute la beauté chaotique. Il a beau être le fruit d'egos en collision, le résultat est d'une splendeur qui force le respect. Un gros 4/5, donc. Pour les chansons immortelles, pour les harmonies divines et pour le simple fait d'avoir réussi à transformer une poudrière en disque de platine.
Standouts: Teach Your Children, Woodstock, Our House, 4 + 20, Country Girl Lyrics/Vocals: 4/5 (I don't like Neil Young's voice) Instrumental: 4/5- Very relaxed folk Vibes: 4/5- A chill album with lyrics that echo the late 60s-early 70s Overall: 4/5
To quote my father (a serious CSNY fan) “they just don’t make music like this any more.” This is a rare moment in which I agree with him. This album is perfect.
3.9
This was a short but good album, cozy, good feelings, until they hit me with the song 4+20, that made me go back and listen to it again, after that some of the songs had a feeling of melancholy. liked all the songs, would listen to it again.
Very surprised. Not much to folk music, but this was pretty decent
Classic, but I think I should have been alive at the time to really enjoy it.
Really good album. Some fantastic songs.
So good
Great album
Not bad, nothing stood out.
7/10
What a closer for the 60’s! With sounds reminiscent of the likes of the Beatles, Rolling Stones, and even some Jimi Hendrix, this album works wonders at taking the best of the decade and adding its own creative touch. The rock elements aren’t too hard on the ear and the folk brings a simple yet elegant feel that permeates through the record. Songs like Woodstock and Our House will have you bobbing your head while Helpless and Country girl give a very introspective touch. Also, it can’t go without mentioning the beautiful harmonies on many of these tracks. No matter the person behind it, each song has terrific harmonies that accompany its tune. There is such a nostalgic feeling here that brings me from classic rock tunes to solemn, acoustic melodies. The title track does not hit super hard for me and the lyrics can be quite sappy or cliche at times, but this is definitely an album I’d return to.
Nice album with great musicians.
This album is five stars, their rendition of Joni’s Woodstock is so fun!
Another of those albums that is supposed to be important, but I couldn't get into it. Varied too much. Country Girl is particularly egregious. Second listen at Johnny's behest: -Carry On - pretty good -Teach your Children - classic, one of the best on the album -Almost Cut My Hair - I can see this growing on me -Helpless - I can go either way on Young - his vocals were both delicate and beseeching on this one -Woodstock - not bad, good guitar throughout -Deja Vu - just when I thought it wasn't going anywhere, it ended. I feel like this is a song that I don't like now, but it could grow to be a favorite. -Our House - listening to the lyrics, I now love the song -4+20 - not much going on -Country Girl - what is this mess??! (Maybe this could grow on me? It came together at the end with the harmonica) -Everybody I Love You - awful and indulgent So: verdict is changed, due to Johnny's praises!
Dang, I forgot how bad almost cut my hair is and how amazing Helpless is. Neil young was 25 on this album 🤣 amazing
Top to bottom, a great album.
Wonderful album from front to back. Not a dud in the bunch. Harmonies are amazing. Rockers are good and the ballads are just as good.
Best album of all time period
Really enjoyed this.
They are definitely more than the sum of their parts. Great songwriting, excellent production, and masterful harmonizing.
Excellent album.
Really don't like Neil Young's voice
Classic easy listening!
Classic...in the best sense of the word.
not bad, can come back later nice melodies, harmony
Had some good ones, teach your children, our house, maybe other gems if I listen more
Seriously? Another Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young album? Or is that another Crosby, Stills and Nash album? I don't really care. I get how they were very influential and obviously a bit of a supergroup. But... They're not really that different to warrant having more than one entry here.
5 star folk rock Favorite track: Carry on other picks: Dejavu, Woodstock, Country Girl, Almost cut my hair
Guys were just hanging out and harmonizing back in the day. This album was fine, it's Crosby, Stills, Nash, & Young who I've listened to before (though not just one album straight through), so there weren't any big surprises. My favorite song was "Woodstock" which was the only one on the album not written by one of CSNY lol
Notey Marimba!
The transition between the 60’s and 70’s distilled into 36 minutes of well-crafted music. Clear to see why this was so massive at the time, drawing on anti-establishment sentiment and political dissatisfaction at a time when the old was starting to fragment and a new beginning was being formed. Will listen to again. Didn’t realise this was the source of ‘our house’ - whodathunkit.
Absolutely love this album. For me this is definitely the best ‘super-group’ album ever. I don’t really recall why/where I first listened, but I remember being immediately blown away by the harmonies. And there can’t be many bands to match that aspect. But generally it’s just 4 song writers at their peak, and every song is a winner (Woodstock and Country Girl absolute highlights, albeit Our House is possibly a bit saccharine for me). Yeah it can feel a bit uncoordinated, as the Neil Young led numbers do seem a bit at odds to the others. But the CSN harmonies applied to Young’s songs really lift them and vice versa there’s some ripping Young guitar work/solos on some of the CSN led ones. But I think that’s the benefit, the addition of Young to CSN breaks up a harmony led folk rock that struggles to carry an album on its own (or at least not to score it a 5). So even though it’s actually quite a dark album, it just always lifts me whenever I listen to it. Perfect for a summers day drive (well, for me it is).
Well well well, oh to be in Laurel Canyon in 69. I am a big fan of CSN and Y and what a carry on. Some of it sounds a little twee but the highs outweigh any of that. I would listen to Neil Young all day long if I could and Crosby is a true nutter. Put it on sunny day and zone out....
This album unfortunately doesn’t appeal to me as much as I feel like it should. I love Neil Young and respect the hell out of him, but Déjà Vu sort of pales to CSN’s 1969 debut without Young. I think the live 4 Way Street with Young is the best that the group has, but that also features a lot of Young’s solo stuff performed live. It really surprises me that Déjà Vu is the best-selling album of any of the members’ careers, but I suppose I can be glad for that because it furthered Young’s career in particular and allowed him to record and release some of his best music later in the 70s and beyond.
Steady
A classic. Gotta give them their credit. Vocally top notch and songwriting on this is great. Not my first go to sound wise but some songs I can see myself going back to
EXTREMELY good album. Sounds immaculate. Not much to say. Their voices, blended, sound pulled from the beginning of time, as if they’ve always been there. Intoxicating harmonies and group lock. Incredible songs. Neil Young is so precious, you just want to give him a big hug. One of the greatest! 5/5
Lovely and inspired. Young's compositions especially stand out, but Nash's "Teach Your Children" has always been dearest to me. The Laurel-Canyon-folk songs hold up better than the rock-forward ones. Highlights: Teach Your Children, Helpless, Woodstock, Our House, 4 + 20
It was pretty interesting by song 5 they had a slower song that picked up and they also had a lot of guitar solos
very good, liked it a lot.
Fucking solid album!! Teach Your Children, Helpless, Woodstock.... So many good songs! I love what Neil Young brought to Crosby, Stills & Nash. That distinct guitar work and that voice.... Phenomenal! Favourite songs: Woodstock, Helpless, Teach Your Children, Almost Cut My Hair, Everybody I Love You Least favourite songs: Deja Vu 4/5
-FUCK YEA ELECTRIC GUITAR IN EARLY 70S FOLK ROCK -The vocal harmonies and stuff are really cool, and it has a bit more of an energetic feel to it while also having some nice slow songs -Favorites are Carry On, Woodstock, and 4 + 20
It's perfectly okay. I think I had really high expectations for this album, and they didn't match them.
7/10 Yeah, warm nostalgia and some very good music. 6-20-2024
Couple great songs on here (Our House, Almost Cut My Hair) but on the whole a bit meandering for me.
Great album. I like the Neil Young songs the best
So men having long hair was " letting your freak flag fly" in 1970? LOL. If they only knew. .
Yes
Because of Our House, I'm bumping this album to 3 stars. That song deserves a star of it's own.
Dudes all so good you gotta name em all right?
It's called Deja Vu because it sounds like every other country/folk/rock/blues mashup album released at around the same time. OK in places.
Core formative music memories here.
Nice wholesome folk. Our house is a very very very fine song.
This was good background music. I enjoy a good supergroup. I think what I like most is there’s a different sound/singer in every song, so it never feels stale or repetitive.
I feel bad giving this a 3/5, but whatever. It's fine. I think CSNY are a bit overrated. Neil Young is great. David Crosby is good. The harmonies are great. But overall, I'm non-plussed.
- Our House is a Bean classic - other than that this is meh
- really solid Americana - love the vocals
it was nice !
💙💙💙
Amazing how good Neil sounds when not taking lead vocal. I enjoy the harmonies on the album. Some real classics on this one.
It sounded like your Grandpa’s music that he had on a record player. It was simple and was catchy throughout
Quite enjoyed this album. Loved the harmonies and the musical skills displayed. The guitar sounded great loved the little electric riffs in a lot of the songs. I also liked how the acoustic was used thought it was great not just the stereotypical use of it as a rhythm instrument.
not a Neil Young fan & not a fan of folk rock either, but this was better than I expected. enjoyed the harmonies, different guitar sounds, and most of the lyrics.
Love Mary Neil Young - it is a classic standard. Has its share of hits and awesome harmonies.
Classic incredible need it on vinyl
Way better than I would have expected. A good mix of genres and some great harmonies and guitar work
This is basically a greatest hits album by four songwriters who were at the top of their game when working together...which they rarely did because they were four songwriters who were at the top of their game and didn't need anyone else. "Almost Cut My Hair" is an absolute jam and gets stuck in my way too often. I'm not a fan of the solo music by any of these artists, outside of Neil Young, but this is a masterpiece. It's not the boring folk rock the first CSN album was and this is a must-listen. On other CSNY albums it seemed like some songs were written just so they could harmonize, but that's not the case on this one. Great album and highly recommend giving it a listen.
easy listening, but nothing that is going to blow me away. a nice little dip into the country music sound, but short enough that it doesn't linger for too long.
Hell yeHa
Really good on first listen, definitely coming back to this one
Every song kinda sounds the same
4+ Melkein mestariteos, mutta muutama keskinkertainen raita joukossa.
Always loved this album. A handful of great songs, and just a lovely feel to the whole thing.
CSN is already a songwriting harmony factory, but throwing Y in the mix, however brief, is pure folk legend and magic.
Decent. Mostly too slow for me. I liked the guitar beginning of Woodstock.
Oh crap, my saved review didn't save. Pooh. This was one of the soundtracks to a place and time and my life and I wore out the record. I loved it then and still love it, but I don't listen to it anymore as my tastes have changed. 5 stars!
Harmony echoes, Timeless voices weave through dreams— Deja Vu reborn.
This is nice! 4/5
A classic and a favorite
LOVE this album. College days.
Almost a four, it's very close. I really liked the more rocking songs as opposed to the folkier ones. The guitar work in those songs is brilliant and I'll be returning to those tracks I'm sure. Fav songs: - Carry On - Teach Your Children - Almost Cut My Hair - Everybody I Love You
Fabulous turn of the decade folk-rock
When this was first released I was never interested in the album or in all honesty gave it a listen. I was aware of one or two or the single releases but nothing more. As the time of release was at the height of some of the best Prog Rock albums ever to be released my musical interest and buying power was firmly elsewhere. I liked the single Woodstock and as it was the theme tune to something that was great (and so thankful and privileged that i lived through that time) I would nod my head in acceptance that CSN&Y were a big part of the Woodstock generation. But at that time I was more interested in King Crimson, Yes and Genesis and in any case I much preferred the Joni Mitchell version of Woodstock. And so it remained that CSN&Y remained at the edge of my musical consciousness. Skip forward 50 years and something happened that I struggle to put my finger on. Maybe it was a documentary about Laurel Canyon or one about David Crosby in his later years or an interview I heard by chance on BBC Radio 5 with Graham Nash. Could even be that my next day neighbour was always waxing on lyrical about them but something made me explore the music of CSN&Y more and I became hooked. I love the first album better than this but there is only a cig paper width between both. It is an absolute pleasure to listen from start to finish and maybe its because I am catching up on the lost years CSN&Y were not in my life, I cannot now imagine life without regularly listening. Never bought the original album but now proud owner of the CD and one of 20,000 lucky souls owning the Deja Vu Alternates album released a few years ago on Record Store Day. A record which sits proudly at the front of my collection. If you’d told me this 50 years ago.. A firm 5/5. 5/5 31/5/24
Wow. The first album in over 200 that goes straight to 5 star and am ordering on vinyl having not been familiar with it before. This stands out to me because it manages to offer variety that never loses it's quality. Some albums are very good but have one note, this seemed like a rainbow where the 4 members of the supergroup all contribute something different but equally brilliant. Almost cut my hair has one of the best guitar sounds I've ever heard, our house is beautiful as is teach your children. An absolute classic.
Classic sound
отличный рок для своих лет, но не явно не пробивается из своего времени. звук очень насыщенный, полный, объемный. гитары!
A great acoustic and vocal album, as expected! Not bad, but not my favorite CSNY outing.
Personal biases not aside, this album is great. I love folk rock. 'Almost Cut my hair' 'Woodstock' 'Our house' and 'Country girl' are my favorite tracks. I could listen to it more times and give a more thorough dissection but I don't feel I need to. I'm comfortable giving it 5 stars as is.
The vocals are obviously the stars of this album, and the three and four part harmonies are great. Some of them sound like a chorus pedal, some sound like an a cappella group, but they’re all great. The instrumental work, it’s a backdrop for the singing in all the songs except Carry On, imo. This album is extremely full of hippie-isms, which is fine because it was peak hippie time, but I laughed through Woodstock because all I could think of was that episode of South Park where they’re all stuck on the front of a festival. It’s a great song but I’d never listened to the lyrics that closely before; it’s super festie. I kinda got bored by the end as the songs all start to be a bit more slow and folky after “Our House”. Overall it’s good, but I’ll stick to the singles.
First two tracks slap then they were bragging about not getting their hair cut and I turned it off.
i did just cut my hair!!! exactly what i expected, but very well done. lot of young's voice. but well done. 2.75
Primo! This is my music.
The album is OK, except for when Neil Young sings (e.g. Helpless). I don't think I realized "Our House" was from CSNY.
I liked this better than the individual albums by various members we've heard so far. I think the collaboration makes for a more varied album that isn't quite as one note.
The familiar singles are a little trite feeling, but that's literally because of how much they've been used in movies, TV and other media (Our House, Teach Your Children). The harmonies are otherwise lovely (and not used on every goddamn song - looking at you Beach Boys), and the unfamiliar, non-harmony leaning songs (Almost Cut My Hair) are pretty good. Boomers aren't all bad. But for Neil Young.
Not my vibe.
A lovely taste of the 70s. Wonderful harmonies and great instrumental. 9/10 Would I listen again? Absolutely
Entspannte Musik aus den 70er 4/5
Thought this was going to be boring but it was rather pleasant!
Always forget how good CSNY were, so much talent packed into one group. Teach Your Children and Our House are classics of the flower child era, as is Woodstock. The songs in between are so good. The Stephen Stills opener Carry On, Young’s slow and sweet Helpless, Crosby’s defiant Almost Cut My Hair. The climactic Country Girl rounds it all out. Beautiful and powerful album.
It’s ok. Slow, vibing music
A crackerjack album! I accidentally listened to a 4 CD re-release and dug every moment of it. I felt like Our House and Woodstock were the weakest, I think because I just prefer other artist's take on them, but having never listened to this album, nor heard most of the tracks, the genre range and writing quality (and recording quality) kind of blew me away.
Meh. Not bad, but not their best work overall.
I was initially underwhelmed when I got unduly excited by the opening track which the rest of the album never quite matched or even came close to. Listened casually a couple of times thereafter and one final closer inspection and found myself in love with it. Carry On + Teach Your Children + Helpless (Look Down From The Bridge by Mazzy Star much??) + Woodstock + Our House (though the chorus and the la-la-las are a bit too childish even for that song) are all good-to-great-to-fantanstic. Tapers off just a bit in the second half but even there most of the songs are growing on me.
I don’t know if I love this or find it extremely strange. Maybe a little bit of both? It’s not cohesive, that’s for sure, and I think that’s what’s throwing me off. Main thing I learned is that I really, really like Stills as a guitarist, and I adore Young as a guitarist. Both of them have such a unique style (it makes sense that they were in a band together in another life) that just sounds unlike literally anything I’ve ever heard. Stills’ playing is a lot cleaner, but I think Young’s sloppiness is actually what I enjoy. Above all else, that makes this is good listen, because the guitar work is kind of cool to hear, as long as you’re into that sort of thing. I’ll also say, I think they’re all good songwriters. Now, I have a least favorite [Nash] and a favorite [Stills], but I’m not against any of them. I think all four have highlights and lowlights here. For me, all the lowlights are the folky, somber, acoustic tracks that seem to fill out half this record. Songs like “Teach Your Children” and “4+20” just do nothing for me. I am a bit stuck on “Our House,” as it’s got that post-Beatles domestic romanticism of romance that’s just cute and hard to resist, but then I think about it and it makes me roll me eyes, too. The other thing I don’t love are the psychedelic tracks. I don’t hate them, surprisingly, because they’re not so left-field that they ruin a song and/or drag it down, as psychedelic stylings tend to do, but they are…jarring? They just come out of nowhere. I think when they’re grounded by Young’s eccentric playing, they work a *lot* better, but on “Carry On” or “Deja Vu,” they feel unbounded and too loose for my taste. I’d also say, even though I’m still new to Young’s discography, his songs here feel, well, like lesser Neil Young songs – like, nothing standout, but nothing bad, and sometimes he does just have a knack for something gorgeous and true, like the last third of “Country Girl,” where he nearly brings me to goddamn tears. For me, though, Deja Vu lives and dies on the strength of its pure rock cuts. “Everybody I Love You” is a great closer, “Almost Cut My Hair” has all the gravity I think CSN&Y think the rest of album has and actually makes me sympathetic for aging hippies, and then of course “Woodstock” rips. I do like other songs on this album, but I don’t love them, or I only love pieces of them before they stray into territory I disagree with. These songs, however, are incredible standouts, through and through. While the rest of the album sounds every much like Music for Retiring Hippies™️, these 3 tracks sound legitimately timeless, vital, essential. And like, what do you do with that? How do I rate an album where I adore 3/10 songs, but then like anywhere from 30% - 50% of 4 other songs but would fast forward past the parts I don’t like on them? My general rule of thumb is if I like over half the songs on an album but less than 90%, it’s a 4/5, but like….what about half-of-a-song? (My other rule is if I would buy it on vinyl, and somehow, I already did, I’d just never played it, and I realize it came from an old yard sale dig I did when I was in my teens, and somehow I’ve kept all those albums because it was a good dig and my crates are still mostly organized by “order of purchase.”) I think when all’s said and done, once I’m more versed in all their solo work and prior bands’ output, I may need to revisit this to make a better determination, but as it stands, I can’t say I’m looking forward to that revisit. It’s just too piecemeal for me, down to parts of the song, and no album I actually enjoy would elicit that much nit-picking from me.
Enjoyed the two listens. These four together are a powerhouse. Woodstock was my favorite song, but I want to give the album more listens at a later date. 4/5!
Solid. More psychedelic than I thought.
Very good. Heard before - great harmonies.
songs were alright but like not memorable
Sorry guys, I am a zoomer. This is how I imagine peak folk to sound.
Not my usual thing but I appreciated it as an artifact
It's been decades since I've listened to this album in full. It was fundamental in my appreciation of folk and still holds weight for my today.
The songwriting here is just stellar. Each of these artists writing and performing together makes for some of the best folk rock ever. The mixing and performances are all great and bring a lot of heart to each song. My favorites were Woodstock, Almost Cut My Hair, and Our House
Simply a very well crafted album. Excellent songwriting, good instrumental performances especially the guitars, and solid vocals and harmonies. This seems to bridge that gap between the folk rock of the 60’s and what would become the rock scene in the 70’s. I wonder if any of these guys ever did anything else?
four lead singers on songs is special
A good easy listening album
Somebody has a Neil Young fetish
Ehh album. Not too much to my taste but gotta give credit to the guitar work and the vocal harmonies.
A good album I liked Helpless and Carry On.
Loved it, will return often to this one
Crosby Stills and Nash have always felt like a 'you had to be there at the time' kind of band. Neil Young's Helpless is fantastic though.
I don't really like the big hits from this one (Teach Your Children and Our House). The rest of the album is alright. The songs where Neil Young takes the lead are my favorites, which isn't a surprise since I like his solo work.
these guys are always a good listen. i know teach your children from somewhere but i can’t place where and it will bother me for the next couple days
Here’s the thing: all four of these guys are accomplished musicians and songwriters. But maybe, the four of them together is a bit much and the end result suffers for it. This album is everything I dislike about 70s music: cheesy vocal harmonies, easy listening tunes, and country western affectations. It is only saved from one star by a couple of moments in “Almost Cut My Hair” and “Country Girl.”
I found Crosby, Stills, Nash, & Young's *Deja Vu* to be more enjoyable than I expected. While most songs landed around a middle-of-the-road 3 rating for me, there were a few standout tracks that I would rate a 4 or 4.5.
Fractured with some silly lyrics in places, but I've always enjoyed this one and it was good to revisit. Until today, I'm not sure I've ever paid much attention to the latter portion of the album which turns out to be pretty rewarding. Also, Jerry Garcia played some beautiful lap steel. This group should really have been named: Crosby, Stills, Nash, Mitchell, Garcia, & a lot of Young.
Sweet.
Teach your children Woodstock Déjà Vu Our House Had some good tracks but nothing to be blown away by
I feel like I made in error in attempting to honestly review these albums. I mean - what are you supposed to say about Deja Vu? Yeah. It’s pretty good.
3 *
Carry on is mind blowing.
I have a bias here because "Our House" is the song my wife and I danced to at our wedding, but it's still a very good album!
Love, love, love the harmonies. Not every song is fantastic, but this is my kind of hippie dippy bologna. 4/5
This is kind of a strange album, in that it sounds like three or four separate albums mashed together. There’s a little bit for everyone: the classic harmonies of CSN, the counterculture anthems of “Cut My Hair” and “Woodstock”, the incisive songwriting from Neil Young, even a cameo by Jerry Garcia on the steel guitar. I personally love the harmonies of Graham Nash in songs like “Teach Your Children” and “Our House”. “Country Girl” and “Carry On” were pleasant surprises as well. Very enjoyable album overall.
What an album.. every song is awesome..a masterpiece by csny
It’s fine, lots of acoustic guitars, lots of folky voices. It’s chill, easy to listen to, I can see why people would enjoy it, but I’m not especially moved by anything on the album.
This band confuses me. Did they some of the same music both under their CSNY name and CSN and Neil Young separately when they split? Which was first? Do I even care? The answer is not really. The music is good though. Helpless is a definite Neil Young stand out. Teach the Children is great. Almost Cut my Hair, Woodstock and Carry On have way harder rock vibes than I usually associate with these names. The harmonies are beautiful, the music is well made. Not close to my favorite album or musicians but undeniably good music to listen to.
Alright
Ordinarily I probably would give this a lower rating, but I listened to it in the most perfect setting, and it enhanced the experience by so much. I listened to the majority of this album while on the train, and having this album as the soundtrack to the city turn into suburbs turn into fields turn into forest was magical. I have found my new favourite commuting album.
This is one of those albums which is so familiar that it's easy to become rather blasé about it's qualities, and whilst it does contain a couple of clunkers, the highlights do outweigh weaker numbers like 'Our House' and closing track, 'Everybody I love you'. The album starts with the storming ''Carry on', which apparently was almost an afterthought. Hard to believe that, apart from Dallas Taylor on drums, Stephen Stills is responsible for all of the instrumentation! Other highlights include a pair of Neil Young classics, 'Helpless' and 'Country girl' and Still's beautifully picked '4&20'. David Crosby contributes the excellent 'Almost cut my hair', though I prefer both the extended version with the false star and the beautiful acoustic demo version, both of which can be found on various boxsets. His title track is another highlight, though his trade-mark scat singing is not to everyone's taste. As for Graham Nash, hi 'Teach your children is nice, with some lovely pedal steel guitar, courtesy of Jerry Garcia. In my opinion, however, the band's version of Joni Mitchell's 'Woodstock' is disappointing and not a patch on the original. Nevertheless, a great album which is well worth seeking out.
Record sounds great overall. There are some good songs, thru Woodstock mainly. Overall feel is really piecemeal. It doesn’t feel like there was an overall connection, just 4 songwriters tossing out songs. I’m surprised at the lack of cohesion - Workingmans Dead and American Beauty from the same time/area hold together more. Still the vocals sound great!
Not a fan, I know people love these guys but I just can’t get behind it. Our house is probably the only song I listened to all the way through. Sometimes they sound like the hippy beach boys at times
Probably a record that needs several listens and concentrating on the lyrics. As a background record it was fine, but didn't really do anything for me.
# 225 : They've done a pretty decent job. I think Its OK, I could listen to it, but For a super group it didn't sound like the best of any of their offerings and was kind of ordinary for all the hype.
Horny for harmony
Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young are Dad Rock: 201
Dang, these 4 men are all over this list. But I can’t complain! This was a wonderful listen and I appreciate the different sounds each member brings to the group.
3.5
Decent folky album
It's better than I thought, but it's not great. There are some songs that I actually like, but then there are some that sound like country and country just plain sucks.
I really enjoyed this so much. It's a definite step up from the (still very good) CSN album from the year before. Young just brings so much soul and emotion through his voice, and a hint of more of a rock sensibility. It creeps into the five star category for never really having a lull or a dip in its entire run.
alot worse than the sum of its parts, a sad thing to be I dig the frantic scratchy kind of guitar solos Young/Stills did in this group. There's some other cool sounds. mostly they get buried. Even when I was younger and hadn't soured so much on hippie bullshit, this album is a part of the Neil Young discography I only listened to once through and didn't feel like revisiting. Helpless of course is an all timer, the rest of the songs are weak. "it's never too late to give up on your dreams" in song form, without any of the humour. Neil Young sings a lot about the lost potential of the hippie years in his later albums and though he did get involved in bunch of either cool or understandably misguided stuff I can't help but cringe. Neil, you & your buds weren't gonna change the world, you got comfortable and quit before you started. music: hated. (⌐■_■)
A 2 without Neil. Just can’t muster much enthusiasm for sappy hippie-folk, ya know?
- the return of the law firm band names .. - our house <3
Another album that has the classic 70s sound.
I feel that this album represents rock transitioning from blues and folk. I didn't enjoy it much but it could be worth another listen
Mellow, chill, got a few nice grooves & tunes. Felt like inoffensive background music.
One of the best albums ever. When the "worst" song is an A- Neil Young song, you know it's something that will be discussed for decades.
Excellent jaunt back to my childhood. It was nice to hear these songs again after all these years.
Something for everyone. Harmony city. Loved the smooth guitar and comforting lyrics especially the songs I remember from my childhood. 👍
Really solid album. Lots of creative music styles from the era and great vocal harmonies. Can't believe I've never listened to this before.
Yeah hard to go wrong this album. Neil's joining took this band even higher especially with Helpless as one of his contributions. Plus you have Jerry Garcia playing pedal steel guitar on Teach! Really captured the sound of that era.
Exceptional album that showcases how great this mix of artists is/was. Songwriting, harmonies, guitar and music: it’s one of those rare moments captured on an album that is something special.
This record was played a lot when I was in high school. Not sure why. The harmonies are great. Seems like everyone was at the top of their game. I'd put this on again.
It’s hard to beat this album in the singer/songwriter category, especially since you have 4 singer/songwriters working (kinda) together. Great songs with great harmonies. And don’t sleep on the guitars in this album, they’re really good, too. Great pick
It’s a total classic!
Very pleasant, if a little bloodless. Neil Young is probably the most interesting (occasional) member of csn&y, and his songs on this album stood out a mile. All in all, I really liked it, but didn't quite love it.
I kind of wanted to hate this, given how overrepresented these guys are in this book, but after two listens, it's undeniably great. The only criticisms I have is that it doesn't really have a cohesive feel to it, and some of the songs are a little cold (or too perfect) sounding. The former makes total sense, given there were 4 brilliant songwriters competing for space, and apparently not getting on very well with eachother. I do prefer this album over their first though - the addition of Neil Young is a significant one. There's some lovely guitar playing on here, and a few truly great songs, especially Helpless, Woodstock, and Our House. I actually had no idea that the latter was CSNY, so that was a nice surprise. Really enjoyed 4+20 and Country Girl too. I don't think their version of Woodstock is better than the original, but really enjoyed their take on it. Don't like the last song at all, and found Teach Your Children a bit bland. Overall, this album feels like CSNY trying to put a cap on the hippie era and move on in 4 different directions. 8/10
A classic in my eyes. It got everything that was relevant in the 60s and transferred it to the 70s.
Great album overall. Beautiful melodies m, harmonies, and lyrics
Potentially over rating this album slightly based on experience since my dad was a big fan. They never had the fanfare of Pink Floyd or other tops groups but were doing a lot of similar things.
Lovely, vocal harmonies and some folk hits, but overall didn’t really do it for me
5.5/10
I like this album. An amalgam of the members; all different and distinct voices. Our House will always bee a favorite.
I had to re-write my thoughts on this, because I initially found a lot of it incredibly boring. However about half way through I thought it picked up a lot more and I was way more on-board with it. I went back and re-listened a bunch of times and actually it grew on me much more and I was able to appreciate it. There are some lovely songs in here as it turns out. 3.5 rounded down.
This is one of the few CSNY albums that I have a copy of, it's really great. Lots of great folk-rock/pop-rock/country style music throughout this album. Interesting instrumental decisions and great lyrics. Songs like 'Teach Your Children,' 'Woodstock,' and 'Our House' are classics. 4/5.
I do sorta like these guys more together than their solo work. I like the vocal harmonies, it makes the voices more than the sum of their parts, where in isolation I find some of their voices grating. Not terribly interesting songs on this album, but they do sound beautiful.
Pretty good album. Never understood the addition of Neil young to the group but it was cool. A little weird the way the album ends on kind of an abrupt song.
Good rock and roll.
Really enjoyed this, lyrically and musically.
Lovely Album, just great listening!
good entry, not something I'm likely to listen to again but not objectionable.
Superb, Our House is a classic
Calm and steady. I knew Our House before.
I’ve listened to this a few times and want to love it but only a few songs ever do it for me. Still solid just not killer. Rating: 3.5
Great album. Great vibe. Love this era
Our house, is a very very fine house
Iconic
Really loved this. Listened whilst walking the dog. Some brilliant singles, but more, just a beautiful album.
3.5/5 - Some nice songs
Classic album with many good songs by a true supergroup that came together organically…not contrived by some record company deal. Beautiful.
Definitely a true classic album by one of the great vocal groups. Notable songs abound including "Woodstock", "Teach Your Children", "Our House" and "Helpless". It was nice to hear this album start to finish...
Classic for a reason
Superb easygoing listening..
A life-long favourite. Great harmonies, guitar work etc. Makes me sad, though, to see David Crosby on the screen while listening
Well, I've dropped this album and picked it up several times and while it's nice, it's not resonating to me. Some beauty here but it's somehow cluttered with how the sound is. It's rather folksy. A bit of a shrill tenor - not a smooth base,l - music experience. The strings and vocals are a clear combo. Quite the signature. It's got firm harmony's, but that doesn't mean I like it. I can see tracks to like, it's just not gelling for me. I can't really think of a place or time to enjoy this. It's just a bit of a void album to me. It just sinks within me without a trace. 2 stars. Maybe three ... Nah, let's go 2.
Pretty inoffensive. At least it wasn't very long. I am not a fan of any single one of these artists, and with them together I guess it wasn't bad. But I didn't really enjoy it either.
muy lindo y tmb para dedicar unita jsjjsjs
first few tracks were good, and rest of the album was okay.
Highest selling album for all 4 - that's really impressive considering Young's catalog. And understandable - it's a great set of songs that hit the music culture at the perfect time, introducing a unique new sound totally unlike the Beatles et. al.
Мне нравится Янг и его кусочки. В целом окей. Лучшая песня - Helpless.
Great album, 3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
Fantastic album, a few familiar songs. Really enjoyed this one.
Folk rock. An album filled to the brim with masterpieces that have truly stood the test of time. Folk rock is such a fickle genre, sometimes it doesn't age well. Deja Vu is one of those albums that was so masterfully put together that it will never grow old. It's full of, naturally, amazing guitar work and beautiful vocals and harmonies. I do wish the bass had a bit more presence but it serves its purpose. The album had great mixing and production, just an overall masterclass in songwriting. More can definitely be said but after only one listen it's hard to go into great detail. I typically get tired through folk rock albums, for some reason they don't always keep me engaged. But Deja Vu was a different breed, not once was I tired of what I was hearing. Will have to revisit and listen to other releases. 4.5/5
Thoughts before listening: One of the original 70s supergroups with C, S, N, and Y all having spent time in popular 60s rock bands as well as releasing their own solo music. CSNY mixes these guys' rock chops with more singer songwriter folk songs all sung with some of the best vocal harmonies of all time. I own this album and know it will be an enjoyable listen. Review: Yeah this is good stuff. When Neil Young joined up with C, S, and N he added his ragged guitar style to their folky harmonies to great results. The first CSN album has some great tracks, but also gets diluted a bit with some folkiness that comes off as too sickly sweet for its own good. Neil Young helps to keep this album on track with all 10 songs being strong. My favorites on this album are "Carry On", "Almost Cut My Hair", "Helpless", "Woodstock", and "Our House". 4-stars.
Meh
One of the best albums of the era, favorite in my house growing up
still to listen
One of my all time favorites. This was the soundtrack to my high school days. Still own the vinyl from back then.
Pretty good vibes but no stand outs
A Micaella daily mix classic
Really enjoyed this
Slightly disappointed in this, thought I might have a fiver on my hands, given what I’ve listened to from Neil Young in particular. But there was just something lacking to give it top marks. Still a lovely album though, and Our House is a banger! Simpsons: Yes
Only song I knew already was Almost Cut My Hair. Rest of the album was really good, could listen to it more. Would need more listens for the top score. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If Synergy is The interaction of two or more agents or forces so that their combined effect is greater than the sum of their individual effects Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young is the antonym of that. Individually they’re great but when they come together they’re just good. Our House being the exception. It wasn’t bad by any means but you just expect so much more when 4 powerhouses come together like this. It just made me want to listen to some of Neil Youngs solo work.
Surprisingly good, and better than the other CSN album for sure.
Sencillamente uno de los mejores discos de la historia de Norteamérica. La combinación de los talentos de Crosby, Stills, Nash y Young es sorprendente, y se refleja en armonías complejas, guitarras pesadas y melodías suaves e hipnotizantes que construyen un LP de poco más de 35 minutos que es sumamente difícil de olvidar. Mi pista favorita del álbum, "Our House" de Nash, es romántica, cotidiana y sublime. Recomendable y esencial para entender la evolución de la identidad americana del alt country.
This one was super enjoyable, very easy listening and I like their voices. Makes me wanna lay on the beach at sunset with my lover
Beautiful harmonies between the singers, acoustic instrumentation, and an atmosphere from the 60s. This is a great one
Sounded kind of like the Beatles but not really. Some good songs but overall I was feeling ok about the album.
felt very standard for an album on this list, was pretty good but not super duper exciting or anything. 7.5/10
I could listen to this all day long! Nice melodies and feels very grounded. 8.5/10
5/10 - There were some nice songs. I liked the old-timey feel but also they were not the most interesting all the way through. Helpless was good though.
great album, enjoyed every song I think. Quite a few that I knew already and really like
maybe my favorite album on the list thus far
A stone cold classic. I'm very familiar with all of the top tracks from this one, and none of the deep cuts really broke though. That's ultimately not a bad thing, as about half of the album is already in our collective psyche. It's great.
Really liked this album.
Agradable.
I know most of these songs well. All so good, even the ones I hadn't heard before. Hard to believe that so many hits were on one album. So folksy, rocking, just great to listen to. Five stars.
Harmonies are amazing. Great songs on this one, almost all are hits.
Quality! Funny to catch NY's Harvest and then two albums later catch this. Love the grooves on this one, especially that lead cut.
Easy listening and very enjoyable.
I very much enjoyed this album! Teach Your Children was my favorite song.
Perfect inflection point between 60’s folk/rock and what was to come in the early 70’s for rock. Everybody was for a moment in that band totally together and making a near perfect album.
this has great mix of folk, rock, folk rock (duh) and hard rock. its has the beautiful and polished helpless and the dirty bluesy almost cut my hair. all that makes to a excellent album. my newest discovery, neil young, makes a little appearance on some songs here, bursting out his rapid vicious pentatonic guitar licks and singing like an angel dressed as a farmer.
An absolute delight. Certainly a bonus to have it pop up on a Sunday!
Dat wordt weer smullen, nog eens een Neil Young productie. Een aantal nummers zijn mij meer dan bekend, maar ook een groot deel nog niet. Ik ben benieuwd. De opening Carry On is sterk, de vocalen van de groep klinken als engeltjes samen, uitstekende synergie. De plotselinge switch naar een wat psychedelische bluesriff verrast me altijd. Teach your children is een klein beetje corny, maar wel relaxt. Almost Cut My Hair is een klassiekertje, de CSNY die je verwacht op deze plaat. De Folk Rock spat er vanaf bij Helpless, maar Woodstock laat zien dat CSNY ook een ruigere kant heeft. Deja Vu kende ik nog niet. Maar het laat ook geen enorme indruk achter. Het gezellige Our House is mijn favoriet. Zelf als dakloze zou je deze vibe kunnen voelen. Ik heb dit nummer ontzettend vaak aangezet en brengt me een beetje terug naar de kindertijd. Mijn ouders hadden dit album op cd, en werd geregeld gedraaid in de auto op vakantie. De instrumenten en stemmen zit langzamerhand in mijn DNA. Country Girl en Everybody I Love You zijn goed, maar niet geweldig. Het zijn vast nummers die op je kunnen groeien, maar dat is bij CSNY zo vaak het geval. Het basisniveau is gewoon hoog, maar bij deze nummers overstijgen ze zichzelf niet. Ik waardeer het werk van CSNY enorm, maar het is lastig om deze plaat hoger te raten dan Harvest. Het is wel een dikke voldoende met best wat highlights. Rating: 8/10 Highlights: Carry On, Almost Cut My Hair, Woodstock, Our House
Dit is één van de eerste albums die mij introduceerde in 'oude mensenmuziek', nadat ik mezelf met een hoop geweld had losgerukt van de Hardstyle-scene, de geest van het verleden. Als een belangrijke pionier die de zaadjes van muziek uit dit tijdperk in mijn hersenen plantte, ben ik ''Deja Vu'' eeuwig dankbaar. Maar toch moet ik zeggen dat dit een plaat is die niet echt heel goed is meegegroeid met m'n steeds avontuurlijkere muzieksmaak, en is hij veel vaker voorbijgestreefd door tijdsgenoten dan een paar van die andere pioniers en mede-West Coasters als ''Harvest'', ''Cosmo's Factory'' en ''Surrealistic Pillow''. De eerste helft van het album tikt het niveau aan van een Buffalo Springfield, The Byrds of het eerste solo werk van Neil Young, maar het tweede kantje laat te wensen over. Het is allemaal wat tam; minder gitaarwerk dan op een Buffalo-album, minder variatie dan op een Byrds-album, en gewoon te weinig Neil Young. De samenzang is natuurlijk gelikt, maar redt sommige tracks ook net niet. De opener laat direct de intenties van de band zien, op een album waar de groepsdynamiek centraal staat. Een supergroup-anthem, met een aanstekelijke - en zelfs - funky groove waarmee de song zich onderscheidt van de rest. Daarna door naar 'Teach Your Children' wat meer classic CSNY is, een fraaie folksong met gelikte harmonieën die het lied echt naar een hoger niveau tillen. De zachtaardige souplesse wordt daarna onderbroken door 'Almost Cut My Hair', de signature song van David Crosby, en in mijn ogen het beste werk op dit album. De samenzang wordt vervangen door het samenspel van epische gitaren, en de tekst beschrijft de waan van de dag in de door politiek gepolariseerde jaren 60 in de USA als geen ander. Op 'Helpless' horen we eindelijk de magie van Neil Young, waar het album wel iets meer van kon gebruiken. Het is een geroemde song van zijn pen, en terecht. Hij is zeker 'up there' met z'n beste werk. Een sterk kwartet pakt de luisteraar helemaal in, maar de koek is daarna helaas wel op. Nouja, bijna dan. 'Our House' is natuurlijk een iconisch anthem van de wilde hippies die na een rumoerig decennium eindelijk de huiselijke rust hadden gevonden. Geinig riedeltje, niet meer dan dat. '4+20' kende ik eigenlijk niet zo goed, en viel me positief op. Stephen Stills' beste werk op het album. Maar al met al zijn de meeste hoogtepuntjes niet hoog genoeg om de luisteraar echt helemaal te verzadigen, al kwam ik al een eind met de sublieme 'Almost Cut My Hair' en 'Helpless'. Het is een beetje gezapig, mist hier en daar óf een beetje een bite, óf een beetje Neil Young. 6,5/10 Highlights: Almost Cut My Hair Helpless 4+20
De 4 stemmen van Crosby, Stills, Nash en Young zijn samen onovertroffen. De harmonieën zijn fenomenaal en zorgen voor kippenvel, ook na tientallen luistersessies. Ik snap dat CSN een band zijn begonnen toen ze ontdekten dat hun stemmen goed bij elkaar klonken. Young hieraan toevoegen bleek natuurlijk een meesterzet. Jammer dat Neil enfant terrible Young niet langer dan twee jaar in een band kan zitten waarvan hij zelf niet de baas is. Hoogtepunten van de plaat zijn Almost Cut My Hair waar de harmonieën van Carry On en Teach Your Children even plaatsmaken voor de rebellie van David Crosby (rest in peace). De overgang is daardoor perfect. Our House is een prachtige ode aan de huiselijke romantiek van Nash en Joni Mitchell. En ook al is het eigenlijk wat te zoet, het blijft één van de mooiste nummers van de plaat. Met Helpless voegt Neil één van zijn beste songs toe aan Deja Vu. Dat nummer had zo op Harvest gepast, dat 2 jaar later verscheen. After the Gold Rush verscheen in hetzelfde jaar als Deja Vu, de beste man was in topvorm. De totale lengte van de plaat is eigenlijk te kort. Zeker omdat Woodstock niet op Spotify staat. Dat is jammer. Maar ik ben al jaren van fan van deze plaat, en na vandaag is dat niet minder geworden. 9,5/10 Highlights Almost Cut My Hair Our House Helpless
Good mix of southern rock, 60s pop and a little twang og c&w. Great harmonies! Mostly okay songs, none bad but none truly great either. Helpless is basically Knockin’ on heaven’s door with different lyrics.
Best song - Teach Your Children
Great
One of the best. I wore it out back in the day. Would still play it and love it!
Too bland for me.
#171. It's pretty good. I like it overall, but at the same time it's not really anything special. 3/5: decent Song added to playlist: Our House I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link