Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme by Simon & Garfunkel

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme

Simon & Garfunkel

3.61
Rating
30539
Votes
1
2%
2
10%
3
32%
4
38%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 12 of 15)

In the late 70’s, Simon & Garfunkel’s Greatest Hits was one of 2 albums that almost everybody owned (along with Eagles’ Greatest Hits). Including me. The downside of the hits album is that I never really felt the need to dig into the deep cuts. This corrects that, at least some. 4 songs from this album carry over to the aforementioned hits album, although 3 of them show up there as live versions. Regardless, all 4 are outstanding. This album is pretty fast paced, with 12 songs in about 28 minutes, an average length of 2:30 per song (and only one song over 3 minutes). Pretty typical for a pop record from 1966. But these songs aren’t fluff. These are Paul Simon songs, one of the great singer/songwriters of the era. And he packs a lot of meaning into these small servings. There’s only 2 songs that I don’t think are very good to great. “Simple Desulrory Philippic” is a homage to / satire of Bob Dylan. It’s too cute by 1/2, and doesn’t really fit the rest of the album. And “7 O’Clock News / Silent Night” is a little too heavy-handed for my tastes, with the Christmas carol overlaid by a newscaster reporting the ills of society. Wikipedia says the it ‘rather bluntly makes an ironic commentary on various social ills by juxtaposing them with tenderly expressed Christmas sentiments”. Neither song sucks, nor offends. But they do detract from the whole. So where to rate? Do the 10 gems offset the 2 that are “meh”? I will either pick up this whole album, or just the 4-5 best songs that I don’t already own. Oh, how I wish for 1/2 stars, this would be a clear 4.5/5. After consideration, and comparing to the hits album, and 1870’s Bridge Over Troubled Water, I’m settling with a round down to 4. 4/5

I dont know… I felt nothing extra about this one. I can hear the influence these guys had all over the folk- singer songwriter genre but still I dont think I’m gonna revisit.

Kann man gut hören, sehr melodisch. Aber ohne Groove

Great pick for the cold, grey day we had in Denver yesterday.

Some of the songs here are the softest folk rock ever put to wax, to the point of feeling like the notes float along on a cloud. But it’s impossible to discount the technical ability and the beauty of the recording process on display.

Good harms, needs more bops.

wouldn’t usually listen to this type of music but my god was it good

Classic songs. 4/5

S & G provoke two things in me: A resistance to like and a kind of Seinfeld is Unfunny reaction. The first is easily overcome by the duo's craft; The second would be a fair read if it weren't for my love of Bridge Over Troubled Water. On this early effort, I was happy to pick out the Dylan imitation, the invocation of poets. Perhaps records need more of the baroque, less jumping between short slack themes.

A nice album with classic songs.

This is alt girl/boy music, but 60/70s pilled. It isn't terrible. But I am not the biggest fan of it. Feeling a light to decent 3/5

Particularly love A Poem on the Underground Wall and The Dangling Conversation. The imagery in both is so beautiful! The jazzy double bass sound in The 59th Street Bridge Song is so cool and can’t get over the brilliant piss-take that is A Simple Desultory Philippic! Already familiar with Scarborough Fair and Homeward Bound. Overall just beautiful little album. Really short as well! It all just works.

First disappointment, likely connects with some listeners, but not this one. Was glad each song was 3 min or less

This is the point where Simon & Garfunkel start to work for me, but it's still a little too soft and a little too uneven. There are a few real gems here though.

Surprised I liked it as much as I did.

Were good late listening vibes

It's fine.

Found a few songs a bit silly (beyond the intentionally silly ones) but I deeply respect this as a showcase of Simon and Garfunkel's abilities as arrangers.

Short and sweet :) really wish they'd let us rarte stuff with half stars because this is a perfect 3.5 album tbh. Few dud tracks but the highs (Patterns, Homeward Bound) are near the S&G peak

I feel like its probably an important album for the time period and it's solid. "A Poem on the Underground Wall" is my favorite.

"homeward bound" is a good "the road" song: "Tonight I'll sing my songs again I'll play the game and pretend But all my words come back to me In shades of mediocrity Like emptiness in harmony I need someone to comfort me" ^^^legit goes hard as fuck "a simple desultory philippic" is pretty dope. almost like a less funny weird al doing a dylan parody. even name drops dylan (and dylan thomas). at the end of the song he even just says "FOLK ROCK". i appreciate how short this is. 28 minutes! and i enjoyed it more than i thought i would. really nice production value for the era.

This might have gotten a 5 on a different day but I had Fleetwood Macs Rumors yesterday which isn't fair to any band. This is a great peak at a great duo. Their harmonies are excellent and there are a lot of nice moments here. The one star ding is because it feels incomplete. A lot of the songs are rather short and feel like they had more legs to them. Homeward Bound is the highlight but it's only 2.5 minutes. Weirdly it reminds me of tik tok artists now a days.

I like Simon & Garfunkel, but this album contains a lot of the Level-B hits of theirs and it seems to feed to the pretentiousness that Paul Simon's music can often steer into. Not a bad album, but this is a lot of acoustic and mellow songs that can steer towards boring folk rock. The songs are good but Paul Simon has definitely done better. But the pretentiousness on some of the songs is borderline unbearable. The last song is the news over "Silent Night," which is a move that "South Park" would not parody because it feels too on-the-nose. Track #9 is a parody of Bob Dylan's songwriting, but Simon parodies pop culture references that Dylan would use, then falls into that same trap on the last track. I had to look up if this was a parody or the call was coming from inside the house. "Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall" is S&G's version of Coldplay's "Every Teardrop is a Waterfall," meaning they are two songs titles which an AI would write if forced to listen to 10,000 hours of either group. I would have left it with two S&G albums in this book.

Simon and Garfunkel were a musical match made in heaven so their vocals would be an easy 5. Not all of the material here has aged well so the songs are a pretty mixed bag ranging from 1 to 5. I don't know if this was more a thing of the past but it has a pretty scant play time at less than 30 minutes. This one ran pretty hot and cold for me but that pretty much sums up what S&G are to me. Their greatest hits were great but once you got much deeper than that I lose interest pretty quickly. Outside of the hits there's not much else here that grabs my attention.

A classic. Some of the lesser-played tracks I had not heard before and was pleasantly surprised.

I love listening to Simon & Garfunkel so this was an absolute pleas

Only two songs really stood out for me. Last song on the album surprised me and was intense.

I'm not crazy about Bridge Over Troubled Water, so wasn't sure what to expect from this one--but I actually really like this one! Really good listen, and I like that it's less than half an hour long.

It wasn’t my style. It also felt much longer than 30 minutes and was very cheesy at points. Not a favorite.

Scarborough Fair is of course incredible, and Homeward Bound is a great track as well. Otherwise it’s a pretty bland offering from a duo who have more consistently strong projects

吉他民謠 輕鬆田園風 但會變成牛仔 重複一樣的旋律有點煩

Groovy 60’s Folk pop with a sprinkle of rock. Simon wrote some great songs

love love love simon and garfunkel

まあまあ

it was ok. pretty boring

Very pretty songs, impressive songwriting. Somehow more political than I expected.

I'm not a fan of folksy music, but I quite enjoyed the 59th street bridge song (feelin' groovy). That is the only song from this album I will be listening to again. I thought the insertion of the wall pounding and the nightly news on the last two tracks were interesting but not pleasant, but that's art, I guess?

This is a nice little album right here. Simon and Garfunkel are definitely one of the most legendary duos in all of music, and after listening to this album, I can kinda see why. This is another short album, but it doesn't feel like it went by too quickly. The songs are fairly simple, but they're good. There are some interesting things to look at here. The closing track seems pretty fitting for right now given that it's basically Christmas time and the world is still in the never ending chaos that is the 2020s. Speaking of now, this album has aged pretty well. The writing is, again, a bit basic, but still well thought out. The mood is a bit somber, but not too somber, with some lighthearted moments thrown in there. I don't have much to say. It's a solid folk rock album, and that's kind of it. High 3/5.

AJ: Homeward Bound is wonderful. Paul Simon is amazing. The vocal harmonies are amazing.

Gentle, poetic...

I could go the rest of my life without hearing Simon and Garfunkel again and be just fine.

I am firmly in the ‘Paul Simon is a songwriting genius’ and the ‘Simon and Garfunkel’s harmonies are without equal’ camps.

I love it. Sometimes overwrought lyrics, but something in my high school literary magazine soul — especially "The Dangling Conversation." "Scarborough Fair"taking an old folk song as its base and making it a protest theme works better than "Silent Night / 7 o'clock news" where it feels a little "I know authors who use subtext and they're all cowards!" -Garth Merenghi. Melodies are great. Can definitely see myself returning to this.

I understand the appeal, not my kind of music.

An uneven album, even embarrassing in places. But man, the good stuff is SO good. I find it nearly impossible not to sing along to classic S&G.

One of the greatest

Great harmonies, somewhat a product of it's time, lot of twee lyrics. Filled with classics but it's not something I'll ever look to put on.

Finally this one! The first 4 western spices I got introduced to! They really sound like bringing songs from Decameron to life. Dreamy, classic, disciplined.

Peaceful. That's the only word capable enough to describe the album

Beautiful album, Paul Simons lyrics with Garfunkel's harmonies is a throwback to a bygone era.

Simon & Garfunkel are one of those legendary groups that you undoubtedly hear about at some point during your life. I am somewhat struggling to see why this album made this list though. Aside from the spectacular Homeward Bound, much of this album seems very... plain? I can't put my finger on the right word, but for such a seemingly influential sound, this album fails to really hit any of the marks for me. Struggling to find a reason to give this anything more than a 3, maybe even closer to a just a meh 2.5 Highlight: Homeward Bound Lowlight: 7 O'clock News / Silent Night

Saccharine 60’s folk. You see some glimpses of the Paul Simon that will emerge. 59th Street Bridge kills me.

Has a sufjan vibe.

Not really my thing, but I can appreciate why people like it. Homeward Bound is a nice song and I like the juxtaposition of the newscast over Silent Night. It makes a pretty powerful statement.

The harmony is great. 4

An excellent sound, the mashup between folk/country music and the celtic type-of-singing it feels really amazing. You see it on the album cover with that kind of calligraphy that reminds me of when I studied texts from Ancient England in English classes.

It's good, but not totally for me Will I listen to again: 5%

Paul Simon is a bona fide musical genius. Garfunkel was a nice voice, but an otherwise unnecessary appendage.

Lush harmonies. Sophisticated lyrics. More Simon than Garfunkel. ‘Nuff said.

I went into this expecting to like it more than I did. I've liked many of Simon & Garfunkel's songs, but this album just contained too much experimental filler. I'm sure some will say the lyric writing is genius. Outside of a small handful of songs, I found it far too pretentious.

I might be gay now

I enjoy them but this one is too slow for me. I really dislike the title track.

First song is beautiful. Harmonies throughout the album are A+. Classic Simon & Garfunkel/60s.

Classic. Simon and Gartfunkel have written a great anti-war album. 29 min for 12 song is very low for today standards. Great production. Great lyrics. Guitar works is legendary.

A few gorgeous songs. Shoutout to Emily! Most of the album is okay but nothing specialy.

very nice

I like S&G but I don't think this is their best. The song selection feels a little disjointed, which doesn't make for a good album, and even some of the vocal arrangements aren't as tight as you'd expect. Best Songs: Scarborough Fair, Flowers Never Bend in the Rainfall Listen Again: Probably Not

Ah the perfect blend of folk and rock. Simon and Garfunkel are so much better as a duo. Top Tracks: 1) Homeward Bound 2) Scarborough Fair/Canticle 3) Patterns 4) Flowers Never Bend With The Rainfall 5) The Dangling Conversation 6) A Poem On The Underground Wall 7) Silent Night / Seven O’ Clock News

Always heard of Simon & Garfunkel but never actually really listened - American folk rock duo. First song is Scarborough Fair, surely this wasn’t by them? Yeah it’s a traditional English ballad, often sung using Dorian mode and refrains resembling “parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme” (name of the album). Nice vibes so far, relaxed & easy with nice guitar/tones. 4/5 - was erring between 3 and 4 but I enjoyed it’s relaxed nature and a few of the songs were quite enjoyable. The last song reminds me of a few that we get these days where it’s a song interlaced with news bulletins or similar (Muse and Dimension have some).

Relaxing and iconic

Not really my vine but overall good music

Haunting duets, fun poppy songs, and soothing solos. It is a wonderful album that is only marred by the relationship that Simon and Garfunkel had

A good album that starts strong with the title track and goes on from there, bold move cotton lets see how it plays out, some nice further songs in homeward bound and I enjoyed the Bob Dylan dis-track laying down some salt.

Homeward Bound, 59th Street Bridge Song, and Simple Desultory Philippic are highlights on this one, but there is a LOT of cringe scattered throughout. Their albums would get so much better from here on out.

I know a lot more songs in this than I thought. It's a good mellow, acoustic album. Not a go out and but, but one you won't turn off when it's played. It's a quick listen.

Lets have a dangling conversation about this subtly cool album.

Nice album. Gentle songs great voices

Mielenkiintoisia kontrapunkti harmonioita ja leppoisaa folkkia. Scarborough Fair / Canticle paras.

Some classics, but mostly songs I wouldn't listen to again.

Apart from Scarborough Fair and Silent Night wasn't all too bothered

what more can you say? solid album by the masters of harmony

Good and soothing

Didn't even have to listen to this to know it was getting 5 stars. Simon and Garfunkel are one of my favourites and I've been listening to them for years.

no me gusta

Nice eclectic album. Some bangers. Some not so bangers. A great album for the right sort of mood. Want to listen to it on vinyl

Love Simon and Garfunkel - this album is a classic, but not one of my favourites of theirs. My two favourite songs are "Scarborough fair" and "homeward bound". This is a bit airy-fairy for my liking

I knew the title song to this album, or at least the song which contains the words in the title of the album. It was never one of my favorites to be frank, though I tend to like the genre. I also know "Homeward Bound," and it's one of my favorite songs to sing when I'm... wait for it... homeward bound. The rest of the album's pretty good too. I guess you could say it's making me "feel groovy"

At their best, Simon & Garfunkel create incredible songs with infectious melodies and the most beautiful harmonies. At their worst, they are stuffy and boring. This album has both.

weinig variaties tussen de liedjes, met een paar die wel better waren ( ik genoot meer van de liedjes waar er iets meer instumentatie was). Algemeen ideaal voor achtergrond muziek, weinig storend maar ook heel goed aan. ( en ik luister te weinig naar de teksten om te weten of het lyrisch perfect was)

Kinda vibes, def good for a relaxing evening

Favorites include “Scarborough Fair”, “Homeward Bound”, and “The Dangling Conversation.” Underestimated how much I might enjoy this album.

Flashback to the Sweeny Sisters on SNL harmonizing on "Feeling groovy..." It can get a little too earnest and cringey ("you read your Emily Dickinson, and I read my ROBERT FROST." Like, dude, shut up.) but that is balanced out by bangers like Homeward Bound and 59th Street Bridge. For Emily and Poem on the Underground Wall are two of their prettiest ballads. Also, 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night is a regular on all my slit-your-wrist Christmas playlists.

Pretty nice and short catchy songs it felt like I was dreaming all the way whilst listening to it. 8/10

A very nice, fun album! Great folksy album from S&G, exactly what you expect. Short and sweet. Highlight for me is “Scarborough Fair”, which sounded like something I’d listen to for Music of Western Civilization back in college. 4/5.

This should be docked marks for the awful cover but aside from this, Paul Simon is one of the very very few absolute greats. The shortlist of outstanding songwriters that there is no doubt about. What an incredible set of songs.

Predictably nice. All the other songs from the greatest hits that aren't on BOTW. Hello lamppost.

What a beautiful, legendary album that I will spend almost no time listening to going forward. This style of music just isn't my go-to in any leisurely setting, but this is still an obvious great one. My relationship with Bob Dylan has really evolved heavily lately, as I've gone from "still not getting him" to "loving the song that parodies him the most because it still does remind me of him." Favorite track: A Simple Desultory Philippic

A few classics but largely boring. Wasn’t expecting the mean Bob Dylan parody. I’ll give it 3 because 2.5 isn’t an option.

8/10 Fave: Scarborough fair

A classic.

Obviously several well known singles on this album. I was struck by the cultural references, but in a very different form, of both A Simple Desultory Philippic (what a Dylan imitation) and 7oclock News. A very good folk album, showing the diversity of folk rock.

Top 5 best duos in music history

I've never really understood the way they sing their vocals on songs. I gotta be careful driving when they're playing since I could fall asleep

Loved this album, great folk sound

A bit of a classic album. I think at least for me, I remember it to be better than it was.

Standout Songs: Patterns A Simple Desultory Phillipic The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine

Not as twee as I expected. Pleasant, melodic, catchy, dated.

Love this song, reminds me of my childhood

Yeah they sing well together, but its kinda dated.. Is this what folk music was like in the 60s? I understand it was impactful at the time, but it doesn't hit the same nearly 60 years later. Most of these songs are forgettable... Silent Night is yawn. Best Track: Scarborough Fair / Canticle

Heerlijk album. Wat een bangers. Ging vooral erg goed op 'A simple desultory Philippic' wat een perfecte Bob Dylan imitatie is, compleet inclusief mondharmonica.

Twijfel tussen 3 en 4, maar omdat ik net te weinig ken doen ik 3

It feels like they're right behind me whispering into my ears. Rating 3.4.

I'm not a big fan of the old timey folk sound of Scarborough Fair to open the album, but the rest is really good. I especially like how they follow that opener with the very 60s rock inspired Patterns. Homeward Bound and the Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine are favorites and I also like the Dylan mocking A Simple Desultory Philippic.

Expected just some folky stuff but this delivered so much more

Good. Well-executed. Not wowed, maybe everyone has already taken their cue from Simon and Garfunkel so it didn't sound groundbreaking to me.

Not my vibe.

meh, too folky

Simon & Garfunkel are poets, pure and simple. The perfect album to put on if you’re in the mood to chill out and think about the world. Fav songs: Homeward Bound & The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feeling Groovy)

Some great songs. Very quick album. 4/5

quite a few familiar songs, but pretty sleepy.

Title track is lovely. Album is very very 1966 sounding. I'm surprised I've never heard Flowers Never Bend With The Rainfall before.

Gostei, bem calmo

Not bad, but not my vibe. There's better S&G albums imo. Maybe if I gave it a few more listens it'd've stuck, but yeah... Just felt whatever on it.

I already have listened to much of simon and garfunkel.The whole album is very delicate, beautiful and dreamlike, with divine harmonies in the vocals. My tracks i love in include scarborough fair ( just divine), homeward bound (amazing lyrics and driving rhythmn), flowers never bend (great variation between more intense thickly layered moments and delicate ones). My favourite track from this album is poems on the underground; both the introduction and the outro are hauntingly beautiful, and the lyrics of the songs are so poetic it is divine. The intro of for Emily wherever I may find her, to me, is very reminiscient of sound of silence. However, a simple desultory philippic is quite odd, and doesn't seem to fith with the feel of the rest of the album, and the harmonica is awful. Strangely, I think that the juxdeposition in the mix of silent night and the 7o'clock news is extremly striking. I believe this song is trying to show the disregard society shows towards growing issues, perhaps because then simply can't handle the though of all these problems. So, people just sit cosily at home, trying to forget.

the album was a mellow and soft listening experience. never heard the album before, very good.

3.7/5 Fav pesme - Scarborough Fair, Homeward Bound, Floweres Never Bend with Rainfall, For Emily Whenever I May Find Her

Simon. And Garfunkel. I rest my case.

There's not much here apart from the obvious. Patterns is WEIRD. The Dylan pastiche was just odd. Warblers.

Really enjoyed this one. Good lyrics, nice melodies. Short and sweet

Much better than I was expecting from the duo. Would listen again.

Bit bland for my tastes

I like Simon and Garfunkel, but this isn't my favourite album. Though it still has some great songs on it it's a bit too folky. I prefer bridge under troubled water.

Here is when things get fun for me! You would have to be living completely under a rock to know the names Simon & Garfunkel. They are some of the early hitmakers so getting an introduction into their discography was imperative especially for an album I never knew existed until this listen... So what did I think of it? Honestly I really was surprised on how I much I liked it. They are more than their popular music, they are storytellers. There were elements of melancholic introspection sprinkled throughout the joyous instrumentation. Peeked my interest for what else is to come from them on this list! 4 stars.

I understand the appeal of Simon and Garfunkel, and the songwriting in particular on this record was great, but it did feel a bit one note and overly simplistic. Still a pleasant sounding record regardless.

The opener of this album does a good job of sounding both theatrical and satanic. And annoying, too. This continues into track two, where I ceased listening to this shite

Beautiful album from start to finish and the lead single songs are absolute diamonds. Love homeward bound.

Very good, if not really my style

It was better than I thought it was going to be, which isn’t saying much. Ultimately, this level of folk music isn’t appealing to me and as such, was a tough listen

Not a folk fan but that's class

It was good, but I wanted better

Lures you in with the folksy Simon and Garfunkel sounds that have become a stereotype before hitting you over the head with the electric Bob Dylan-esque A Simple Desultory Philippic crammed with pop culture references of the day. Holy shit what a depressing note to end the album on. Fantastic album

2/5. There is some beautiful imagery and poetic writing but it doesn't always translate well into song. Not many I would repeat listen but none of it was bad. Maybe reading the lyric sheet would prove more enjoyable. Short enough to not be tiresome but that's not always a good thing. Definitely a path where Paul Simon was a poet.

Great songs pretty much from start to finish, beautifully produced and despite feeling like it represents a specific time the best songs are also timeless.

Soundtrack to my life if I were a Hobbit.

B- Scarborough Fair / Canticle 3 Patterns 3 Cloudy 4 Homeward Bound 3 The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine 3 The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy) 3 The Dangling Conversation 4 Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall 3 A Simple Desultory Philippic (Or How I Was Robert McNamara'd Into Submission) 3 For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her 3 A Poem On the Underground Wall 3 7 O'Clock News / Silent Night 1 I'm not a huge Simon & Garfunkel fan, so I was surprised to give this more than a 2. Although, that ending song was painfully corny. What does MLK Jr's death have to do with a Christmas song?

Just not really my thing. Still good.

It's been way too long since I wrapped myself in this album of my youth. Growing up in the midst of the Vietnam War, civil rights unrest and changing music bringing light to the issues. Thoughtful and beautiful collaboration.

Good album, very slow and hippie styled

Dit is rete saai zeg... ik vergat sterren uit te delen omdat ik in slaap was gevallen.

Ik heb echt een zwak voor dit duo. Prachtige samenzang en heerlijke jaren 60 feel.

Homward Bound is erg mooi, en de rest is ook best goed te hebben. Al is het over het gegheel genomen wel erg braafjes.

Oef. Dit was echt buitengewoon truttig, dat nummer over die kruiden met stip, maar tegelijkertijd was het ook wel weer aan te horen. Ik rond het af naar boven.

Heavenly voices, undoubtedly. Lush harmonies and beautifully performed and recorded instrumentation. I've heard many of these, so I knew what to expect. There's a medieval choral music element to a lot of the vocal arrangements that is a bit off-putting if you aren't into that sound, which I'm not. Paul Simon also always seems like there's a winking attitude to his music I can never get past. Not smug or sarcastic, but too cutesy-clever. Cloying. It's fine, but not my thing. Much like the previous album, it's a mercifully short listen. So that's good.

Simply beautiful listening A stunning album.

This album is wonderful, I enjoyed it a lot. It’s just pure folk rock and is consistently solid. It has 12 songs and is only 28 minutes long, so it went fast and was over so quickly. I finished feeling like I wanted more, but maybe that’s ok sometimes. Homeward Bound is probably the most well known song and it’s great, but there’s a lot more here too. Any song that sincerely tells me it’s “feeling groovy” works for me, and I loved the vibes on 59th Street Bridge Song. For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her sounded like a Bon Iver song before its time. And I was familiar from the Phoebe Bridgers cover/update already, but I also love 7 O’clock News / Silent Night. I think it’s a brilliant song and somehow works outside of a Christmas album. Great album and I know this won’t be the last Simon and Garfunkel to look forward to. Favorite song: 7 O’clock News / Silent Night Other: Cloudy, Homeward Bound, The 59th Street Bridge Song, The Dangling Conversation, For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her

i would enjoy the beginning of the songs but by the end it sounded kinda repetitive and boring its an alright album though

What a beautiful eclectic album! I love Simon and Garfunkel but had never listened to this one in full. They were definitely experimenting with their sound here and it's cool to hear all the directions they went in.

I really liked it. Scarborough fair was quirky but fun. Homeward Bound was my favorite song on the album, though I had never heard it before. Was not a fan of the Silent Night/7 o'clock News song, but overall I enjoyed the album. 4/5

Little milquetoast-y. One song I hadn't heard before was good.

I quite liked that one. Listened to it doing housework and found it very soothing.

RANKING Patterns Scarborough Fair 7 O'clock News/Silent Night A Simple Desultory Philippic Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall A Poem on the Underground Wall For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her The Dangling Conversation Cloudy The 59th Street Bridge Song Homeward Bound The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine

Good vibes - easy listening. I looked at the song list and did not recognize a single one by name. But there were some gems in there I had definitely heard before. Punchy short album. Can see why they got such a following in their day.

Surprisingly enjoyable

I tend to think of this album as amongst the saccharine sweet folk albums of the 60s, but it's so much better than that. Yes, the sweetness is there, but so is Paul Simon's quirky and original songwriting. I can see how this must have really wowed listeners at the time. It is a step above the Mamas and the Papas or the Byrds in mind. Absolutely worthy of its place on the list and worth listening to more frequently. 5/5

i really love simon and garfunkel and i love a lot of the songs from this album so i was excited to listen to the full thing. my favorite songs are “Scarborough Fair / Canticle,” “Homeward Bound,” “The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy),” “The Dangling Conversation,” “Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall,” “For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her,” and “A Poem on the Underground Wall.”

Great album by one of my favorite groups.

Great record, loved every track.

This is a cool album. I really did dig this.

There are great songs with great melodies and there are just nothing songs.

Made me approve Paul simon in Africa much more

Really enjoyed this album. Lots of good songs. Nice and short too

Like the Emily Dickinson poems they allude to, a bit too light and airy for my taste.

Short and sweet

This album really doesn't do a lot for me. It just feels like two guys trying to continue forward in this flowery, boring folk-pop music while Dylan has already released "Highway 61 Revisited" a year before and "Blonde on Blonde" three months earlier. I know it's not fair necessarily to compare this album to those two, since they're not trying to do the same thing but it feels relevant that those albums still feel vital and timeless to me, while this one feels like it's going through the motions. They aren't on the forefront of anything. I think Paul Simon is a good songwriter but I just don't find the folk music on this album very engaging. Even the hits like 'Homeward Bound' and 'The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)' just feel dated and cheesy to me now. Even the track 'A Simple Desultory Philippic', which I included as a standout feels like a lazy exercise in trying to write a Dylanesque song. Standout Tracks: Scarborough Fair/Canticle, The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall, A Simple Desultory Philippic (or How I Was Robert McNamara'd into Submission), A Poem on the Underground Wall

calming and something new, sounds like some indie music i listen to

im sorry garfunkel is such a funny name

A gorgeous poetic tapestry. For all their discord offstage, Paul and Art conjure something special on record few other duos ever have.

I particularly liked Homeward Bound. While the rest of the album was also nice, I wouldn't listen to it again.

Album opens with folksy Scarborough Fair, which references the album title. Has some deep medieval hymn vibes going with the harmonization, harpsichord, and twinkling bells. Apparently this is a traditional English song. Great harmonization, but I guess that's sort of what these guys are known for. Patterns is a pretty sparse one made up largely of a repeating bass line and bongo pattering. I'm into the composition though I sort of wish they played out the climax a bit more at the conclusion. Homeward Bound is a classic jam. I enjoy the way it plays with tempo bouncing between reflective sections and the swinging chorus. The 58th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy) is another familiar one that exudes tranquility. A Simple Desultory Philippic sounds almost like they are trying to parody Bob Dylan. I would say they do it quite effectively and the result is one of the more fun songs on the album. For Emily turns things 180 degrees into a hymnal reminiscent of Scarborough Fair. Album closes with an interesting overlay of the 7 O'clock news on Silent Night. It is a moving choice to take about the purest Christmas song and overlay news headlines from the time that range from war to civil rights and obituaries. The 60s were a wild time and I have no doubt that the lyrics within this album speak more in response to that than I noticed. I enjoyed this album a lot more than I expected from the outset. Folk isn't typically my thing, and I kind of had Simon & Garfunkel pegged as some sweet oldies that my grandma used to listen to, but the melodies here are undeniable with a few great songs. I'm a 3.5 here and will nudge to 4 because I could see myself coming back if the wind is just right.

Short and sweet. Delightful folk rock by none other than Paul Simon. Cant be sad listening to this album until the 7 O Clock News.

Nothing spectacular but a very nice listening album the whole way through. Perfect length of less than 30 minutes in my opinion. Could have told me that was a Beatles album and I'd believe you. I was not expecting Silent Night to close it out mixed with a very depressing news story.

Scarborough Fair is a beautiful song. I just don't think I'm a huge folk person. Good thing I had a lot of coffee this morning because listening to this and Nico is making me sleepy! The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy) sounds like Babe Rainbow. Weird that Silent Night is on this, but I do like the news section over it.

Folk rock classic, simply not exciting.

Beautiful as always

Short and savoury.

Making a positive of not wanting to be at Widnes Station.

big shout out to DJ GEOFF SPEED holt tight, the HOWFF FOLK CLUB massive stay locked on, WIDNES crew

The opening track is absolutely masterful. While the rest of the album is fine, it struggles to match it. The Dangling Conversation and 7 O'Clock News are songs to save as well.

A very pleasant and pretty lightweight album. Great melodies, not much variety, a little pretentious in the lyrics. Length is good. Best song: Scarborough Fair

More pleasant music from Simon and Garfunkel that also sounds very similar to both of their solo albums (mainly Paul simons). This album was like a piece of bubblegum where it’s short and sweet but gets old after like 5 minutes (in this case 28). I liked homeward bound the most and the dumb silent night cover the least.

hmmmmmm interesting? i wouldnt listen to much more tho....!

‘Scarborough Fair’ is a really strong start; an almost beguiling sound, and the use of minor chords appeals. Slower / samey songs after this but picking up with ‘The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine’ and ‘The 59th Street Bridge Song’ differentiate. The specificity of the lyrics and simile reminds me of Taylor Swift, I can see that she could have been inspired by this album (e.g. ‘Dangling Conversation’). ‘A Simple Desultory Philippic’ really caught my attention, tongue in cheek -sounds like Bob Dylan? But still loved the blues sound ‘For Emily, whenever I may find her’ was beautiful. ‘7 o’clock news / Silent Night’ was perfect (not sonically but strong / risky? message) and great closer. I really enjoyed this and will definitely listen again, and explore more of S&G’s back catalogue. Do not listen to a lot of older albums - 29 minutes is a nice listening experience but I prefer to be more immersed in a longer album, especially as I am often doing something else when I am listening to them. Personally, enjoy the themes of green - plus 1966 being my mother’s birth date, Rosemary being my grandmother’s name, and Scarborough being where my Dad grew up. 4*

28 minutes and still a tour of classical choir, intimate folk, Dylan-satire folk rock, and a news broadcaster overlaid with a Christmas carol. There really is not a single miss on this one, and the vocal harmonies are to die for - Simon's guitar playing likewise.

In today’s edition of how to make a man cry in 30 minutes or less…

A bot background muzak style.

Folk bliss! The boys have some of the best harmonies you’ll ever hear. Not their best album but I still love it. Added to playlist: Patterns

Amazing harmonies, beautiful lyrics. These guys make really good stuff. Folky and relaxing.

Son los unicos que pueden hacer este tipo de musica

It's a vibe

Scarborough Fair / Canticle Homeward Bound The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feeling Groovy) 7 O'Clock News / Silent Night

A couple of things that stood out for me. Definitely I can only take Simon & Garfunkel in small doses. I don't think I could listen to this to frequently. Very interesting backstories on some of the songwriting credits. I'd read about the connection to the Martin Carthy arrangement of Scarborough Fair and grief ofer not attributing to 'Traditional'. I hadn't known of issues with Cloudy though. One song really surprised me for how Bob Dylan like it sounded. I may be wrong, but recordings of some of the songs felt different than I remembered. Maybe different mixes/recordings, or maybe in my mind.

Had some great songs, however the further down the album you get, the more it starts to sound the same.

Listened 8-17-23, added to Notion database of albums.

Not really for me but there was one or two good songs

Baladas de S&G. Un 4.

Beautiful soul touching music. Loved it so much

Scarborough Fair/Canticle is Alfa. Homeward Bound is Alfa. Love the harmonies.

it all sounds the same and its ok i guess. gets really annoying toward the end. Music 2.75/5, Length: 6/5, Message and Artist: 1/5 Scarborough fair

Amazing length and good vocals

Just wooowiii

Really great songs, not my usual stuff, but beautiful writing and composition.

It’s a timeless sound and their version of Scarborough fair is amongst the most gorgeous things ever recorded. Homeward Bound hints at the songwriting greatness that was to follow. The rest of this album doesn’t consistently hit that level but there’s certainly nothing wrong with any of this

The sound of my youth. Thanks, Mom!

çok çok güzel bir albüm

A masterwork of folk pop. A couple of weak tracks that are more than forgiven due to the track the album gets it title from and the very haunting 7 O'clock news

That opener is a classic! I said it on the prior albums but I'm not a huge S&G fan and I don't think this album does anything to change that for me. I did like Homeward Bound.

My quirky guys! The legendary "Scarborough Fair," my first exposure to S&G, and definitely one of their best. What kind of guys just decide to make an ancient song like that? A number of great songs on here, just reiterating how fantastic Paul Simon is as a songwriter (not to completely minimize Art Garfunkel, but the one thing I remember reading on Wikipedia is that he didn't like "Dangling Conversation" because he thought it was too pretentions). Especially dug the Dylan homage on "Simple Desultory Philippic" - what the hell do these words even mean? Also loved the closer, which I had first heard in the form of Phoebe Bridgers' remake. Didn't realize it was a Simon and Garfunkel track, but I can't say I'm surprised. Very bold for 1966. Great album! Favorite tracks: Scarborough Fair, Flowers Never Bend, 59th Street Bridge Song, Simple Desultory Philippic, 7 oClock News. Album art: This one's been embedded in my brain for more than a decade. Not sure if I'd call it iconic, but I personally love it. The boys look very mysterious here, and it appears they are sitting in a field of flowers, but the background has been replaced with blackness. Also why are the tracks in the wrong order? 4/5

AHHHHHHH I LOVE THIS ALBUM AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Hard to give this five stars only because I listened to Bridge Over Troubled Water immediately after, an album that absolutely clears. Objectively five stars tho Favorite tracks: Homeward Bound, Silent Night

Folk classic. Several good and two great songs here

They should have went back to the spice rack for some more flavour for this one. Pretty bland.

not a lyric is wasted. the imagery and emotion are expertly crafted with beautiful melodies that never go overstay their welcome. the longest song here is 3:09, yet these songs take you on a journey that seem to last a lifetime. wow. the peaks and valleys of this album keep it interesting too. the silent night cover with the news overlayed…that’s hilarious. such a clever album. TWELVE SONGS yet it’s only 28 minutes?! that’s how it’s done folks.

Haunting, great playing. Political.

Can’t help but think this didn’t age too well

I've gotten a few S&G albums and have loved every single one of them! They are very talented singers and songwriters! I love their music and style!

Lots of good tunes here.

Simon and Garfunkel RARELY miss, and this is no exception. Phenomenal album, the only thing wrong with it is that it’s not longer.

well paced, relaxing, overall great album

2/5 Best: Scarborough Fair / Canticle Worst: A Poem On the Underground Wall

THOUGHTS -Art Garfunkel: His name describes his looks. -Obviously "Scarborough Fair" is a banger. -The songs sound like if wandering minstrels dropped acid. -"Patterns" sounds like "Kaw-Liga" if you squeezed out the racism. -I'm enjoying this in a sort of "cozy on the couch in a blanket drinking spiced tea" kind of way, but I couldn't imagine going to a Simon and Garfunkel concert; it would be like taking a Xanax and patiently waiting for it to kick in while somebody I just met explains their favorite poetry to me. -"7 O'clock News / Silent Night" is ... really great(?). Simple, poignant. It came out 60 years ago and that makes it feel more subversive. Also did not expect the Christmas song / Richard Speck name check juxtaposition. -These songs are short. Was this whole album like half an hour long? *checks Wikipedia* Yep. I hope they didn't charge full price. -"The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine": second place to "Yellow Submarine" in the "Songs About Colorful Inventions That Came Out in 1966" -I shouldn't like "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)" but I do. You can't listen to it and stay angry. -"A Poem on the Underground Wall" is another banger.

I'd happened to spend some time listening to S&G stuff, this included, earlier in the year so the album was pretty familiar to me. I enjoy this sort of thing - there's enough variation and enough of interest on it to keep me listening and make me want to go back and listen again as well. Solid 4 stars

some legendary songs + misc other folksy protest lyrics and a diss track that still holds up. loses some steam on the 2nd half. 3.75/5

Not my fav, last song was good tho

Fine album that's fine but not as good as the 2 albums that follow. Doesn't feel that cohesive.

I'd only heard "Scarborough Fair" so had low expectations going in. First listen was pleasantly surprised. Second listen bored again. Its just fine.

Scarborough Fair/Canticle is quite dreamy. My faves from this are Cloudy and A Simple Desultory Philippic

Really enjoyed this - I think I was only really familiar with "Scarborough Fair/Canticle" going into it, and it's such a great track - so delightfully mellow! Really liked the Dylan pisstake "A Simple Desultory Philippic" too. Kinda annoyed with the people reviewing this saying "7 O'Clock News/Silent Night" is a cliche 🤨 -pretty sure this kind of sound collage was pretty damn fresh in 1966, so if it seems a cliche now it's because it spawned so many imitations! Oh, plus there's an awesome Phoebe Bridgers cover of it that's well worth checking out... in December, maybe. Fave tracks - as well as the ones already mentioned, I really dug "Patterns" and "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)"

The harmonies stand out the most, its an extremally melodic and calming folk album. I can tell apart the songs easily, and most are great, some songs fall flat if its due to boredom or it just does not sound good, but that is only a miniscule part of the album. Favorites: Scarborough Fair / Patterns / Cloudy / The Dangling Conversation / For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her / A Poem on the Underground Wall / 7 O'clock News I liked most of the album, and the rest was good / alright, there is some filler, but overall it was good. 100% relisten.

I very much enjoyed listening to this album, but I think I just don't like Scarborough Fair. I don't think I've ever liked it and it's always put me off Simon and Garfunkel, I can't put my finger on it, it's just kind of a creepy song i don't enjoy. Homeward Bound however, is fantastic. Other Highlights include For Emily and the 59th Street Bridge Song. I would have to go with a low 4 for the album, its short and to the point, the songs are short and sweet. Really enjoyable

Almost a 5.

Good songwriting, great harmonies.

It was certainly a nice listen. Some of songs started to sound a bit similar by the end, but oh well. I don't know if I prefer Bridge Over Troubled Water to this, but I probably do. A lighter four, but still a four. My favourite song was Homeward Bound.

I'm not a folk fan - far from it. This album, however, is great. The songs are good, the arrangements are sublime, the singing is superb. It helps that I heard it quite often when I grew up. Rediscovering it now through the list was a nice surprise. 4/5

Decent 7

Very calm and soothing vocals with quiet though present instrumentals.

Let me put it this way... The first song alone is enough to give this album 5/5.

Heerlijk, luistert lekker weg op een ontspannen dag, maar prikkelt ook voldoende.

Literally short n' sweet, some interesting and hooks & lyrics/concepts. BT - Scarborough Fair - Homeward Bound - Flowers Never Bend With the Rainfall - For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her - A Poem on the Underground Wall

Maybe I was in the wrong mood for this album today, but I didn't care for it.

I never thought I'd like this band as much as I do, but it's something I'll admit after listening thanks to this challenge. I love the harmonies & the lyrics. It's solid stuff.

A relaxing Friday listen. 7/10

Très «mystique» et éthéré mais tout en étant chaleureux et intime. Bonne vibe

3 words to describe folk music. It's exactly what youd expect, although there's the odd 60s rock flair that pops into some of the tracks. Enjoyable, although I'm rarely in the mood for this kind of sound.

I mean, this is an album named after some herbs, performed by someone called Garfunkel, with a track called "Feelin' Groovy," so it would be pretty easy to dismiss it as the height of 1960s cheesiness. But there's a lot more going on here; the album is permeated with a haunting aurora that lingers long after you've finished.

Fine album, but kind of boring.

I just listened to this album the other day. From the perspective of the variety of styles this might be the best album of that iconic duo, especially with the highly politicised last track. An absolute classic!

This is a great album, but not quite as great as Bookends. There's a few real classics ("Scarborough Fair" and "Homeward Bound" in particular are fantastic), a few enjoyable but MOR songs, and a couple of goofy duds. However the singing and playing is fantastic throughout all of them. Overall I'd say it's a 7 or 8/10.

Such a calming album, such a great duo. Will need to listen to more of there music in the future. Favorite songs: Scarborough Fair / Canticle, Homeward Bound and 7 O'clock News / Silent Night

Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme is the third album by American folk rock duo Simon & Garfunkel. The folk rock album is considered the duo's breakthrough and one of their best works. It is certified triple platinum in the US and was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1999. I enjoyed the relaxing vibes on this album. It was an intelligent, creative, and beautiful piece that reflected the social issues of the mid-60's while being a cornerstone of folk rock for decades to come. Everyone should give this album a listen at least once.

For the second time this week, I own this on vinyl! I just like being able to say that. But as it usually goes, when I own it on vinyl it is going to get a very high rating. And in this case it will get a 5. It maybe isn't this iconic duo's best album, but they didn't ever put out a bad one. This is still a fantastic album and this is like the third time I've listened to it this year and certainly won't be the last time. "Scarborough Fair/Canticle", "Homeward Bound", and "The Dangling Conversation" are three of the best songs from the duo and catapult this album right to a 5 star album. I also love any album that insults both Robert McNamara and Bob Dylan in the same song, two people I hate for very different reasons, but I love to see them both put down. The abstract ending of "7 O'Clock News/Silent Night" is just such a wonderful way to end an album so deeply ingrained but oft overlooked in the counter cultural movement of the mid 1960s. All in all a very very good album that I love listening to.

I really enjoyed Bookends, but I think this is just a *little* too twee for me. Great production regardless! 3.5

Short sweet and not my stuff

This was ok, nothing special in my mind. I guess the one thing this had going for it was that it was short.

Simon and Garfunkel, didn't think I'd enjoy them so much!

A time capsule for the 60's. This album was a treat.

I love there gentle voices damnit. They take you to another place.... "The 60s" I think it's what is called. Where love and kindness are what we're all after. Flowers never bend was new to me and it's an instant favorite. That song captures my view on life and death, albeit a simplified one. These songs are so short and fleeting. I wonder why they chose to never draw it out? They believe in their message and no need to belabor it, I guess. So good.

Not terrible, but not really for me. There’s a Christmas song?? 6.5/10

This album felt like it belonged in a like, fantasy RPG tavern with two guys with lutes playing these songs. It's pretty good

This doesn't quite have the folksy blend that I like best from Simon (& Garfunkel), but still a worthy outing. Must be a hoot and a half listening to this on shuffle and the Bob Dylan diss track ends up playing back to back with "7 O'clock News / Silent Night"

I actually didn’t think I would do this but a 3rd 5/5 to Simon and Garfunkel!

Just not for me

Sorry but I loved it

Tolerable, one or two bop moments

Ensimmäinen soittokierros meni vahingossa ohi kun kestoa alle 30min koko levyllä. Ihan kivaa rallattelua mutta samuttaa janon liianin hyvin.

Kaunis ja harmoninen, mutta tylsä. Pitäis varmaan useemman kerran kuunnella?

Very pleasant

Highlights: A Poem on the Underground Wall, 7 O'clock News / Silent Night 4,5/5

Eleganckie chłopaki

well, it is not bad and have interesting tracks, bur Bridge Over Troubled Water is better for me.

Lovely 60's folk

Enjoyably chill

I've been a lifetime Simon & Garfunkel fan. This album however had taken a back seat in my life for some reason. I forgot how good this was. I mean... Homeward Bound, Feelin' Groovy, and A Simple Desultory Philippic are legendary to me. I am sorry I've dismissed this album for so long.

fan va mysigt det är asså folksy som fan

Simon and Garfunkel have always struck me as a product of their time and ahead of their time simultaneously. No matter what time they’re from, of this album all I have to say is WOW. I came into the album with high expectations and they were excessively exceeded. Although I knew Simon and Garfunkel could be political I was impressed with the finesse with which they express their opinions. The album could not have been any better. 10/10

A an amazing folk album, Scarborough fair is a banger

Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: Not really, just a bit too slow for my taste Favourite song: didn’t have one

Two days ago I mentioned this record in a review and now here I am reviewing it. You may not want to admit it, but the album generator is sentient and the less time we spend debating it, the more time we have to figure out how to stop it from enacting its wrath. So… Simon and Garfunkel, huh? These guys seem pretty cool, right? Look at them sitting in a darkened room, wearing a frilly shirt behind a floral arrangement. Who am I kidding? These nerds are pretentious as fuck. Don’t believe me? Listen to Silent Night/7 O’clock News. Ooh…they paired a Christmas Carol with a snippet of depressing news about the Vietnam war and serial killers. I’ll forgive you for not seeing the irony. After all, it is *very* subtle. I suspect that Simon and Garfunkel were one of those bands people listened to because they though it gave them the appearance of being smart, like Radiohead. Maybe it’s because he looks like Eraserhead, but I think Art Garfunkel is the cooler of the two. Paul Simon just seems like a “try-hard” and inauthentic (an idea which I plan on exploring in greater detail when “Graceland” gets assigned to me. Spoiler Alert: it’s not getting a high rating). “Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme” is an alright record, but it’s schlocky and a lot of it feels like it should be played in a funeral parlor: overwrought and dramatic. When it picks up the pace, it’s too smart for its own good. One of the “rock” tracks is called “A Simple Desultory Philippic (Or How I Was Robert McNamara'd Into Submission)”. In case you don’t have a PhD in Literature, that roughly translates to “a simple tirade lacking in consistency”, which, coincidentally, is probably what you’re thinking to yourself as you read this review.

Solid but not my type of music