Reviews (page 6 of 14)
I have heard of Neil Young but never sat down and listened before. It was pretty great! I do think the songs had all the same vibe and wasn’t particularly blown away by one, so I rated 4. I would listen again.
Proto-grunge protest music with thought provoking lyrics. Neil Young is a legend for a reason.
Moja opinia o Neilu Youngu nigdy nie podniesie się z tych pierwszych absolutnie okropnych doświadczeń z jego muzyką. Liczba jego albumów obecnych na tej liście (9) to jest dla mnie coś kompletnie niezrozumiałego. Jeśli w przypadku Davida Bowiego ubolewam nad tym, że to ja nie rozumiem jego fenomenu, tak tutaj ubolewam nad tym, że najwidoczniej to Young jest fenomenem, bo jego śpiew to dla mnie nieporozumienie. Czasami miewa ciekawe aranżacje, a potem otwiera gębę i czar pryska. Nie łapię tego, ani trochę. Zresztą nie znam nikogo, kto by kiedykolwiek powiedział "Jestem fanem Neila Younga" albo kto by go puścił przy ludziach. Nie wiem, może to tylko jakiś dziwny amerykański wymysł, który z jakiegoś powodu zrobił karierę w tamtych rejonach. Jedyne, z czego mogę się cieszyć to, że już 6 z tych albumów mam za sobą.
One really great song. Not overly Neil Young singing like a muppet. Decent.
Neil at his peak.
3.5/5
Day 12: Best tracks: Powderfinger, My My Hey Hey, Thrasher, Pocahontas WOW. What an album, and exquisitely produced. 9/10 for sure. Possibly a no-skip 10/10 - I'll need more time to determine. Does it belong on the list? 100% Yes.
Rust was actually the nickname Neil Young has for Len Houmous. He was of course referencing one of Len’s famous acid trips when he made this album. 4.3 7/9 Welfare Mothers
Another all-time Neil classic, packed full of great songs, delivered as live for a real raw punch.
Another solid record by Young. I just am never in love with his stuff even though I reconfigure the greatness of the lyrics and music. Don’t know why that is. 3.5/5
The best!
this album makes me feel like i lost my horse
inget gott tecken när man är trött på ett album halvvägs igenom andra låten. sen när det väl kommer nåt nytt känns det fel, låtarna var inte dåliga (inte superbra heller), men albumet var det
Texterna är magnifika, bra ös också på andra halvan! Första mer intressant dock. Bra sväng men inte min sorts sväng :')
This is the pinnacle of Crazy Horse in the studio, followed by Live Rust, their true apex, though they did still kick ads live to the bitter end. I love every song, but Pocahontas and Powderfinger and both of the Hey Hey My Mys and ffs everything here is peak Neil in every way
I think I might officially have Neil Young fatigue from this list. I have one more album from him, but I'm over it at this point. I really loved him in the beginning, and to be fair he does have some fantastic albums, but the last couple I got I haven't been super impressed with. This one was okay. I loved "My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)," "Thrasher," "Powderfinger," and "Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)" but some of the other songs were a mess. I guess "Pocahontas" is beloved by his fans, but it didn't work for me. And what the fuck was "Welfare Mothers"!? Not only did it ruin the flow of the album, but the lyrics were ridiculous. There's a Dana Carvey special from the 90s where he parodies Neil Young songs, and this album really felt like that parody in many spots. Earlier in his career I think he was really on the mark lyrically, but the later I get into his discography, the less impressed I am. He really does sound like a parody of himself at times. There are still some gems, but they are less profound and less frequent. I'd give this album a 3.5 if I could, but I think I have to round up because, while I found many faults with this album, the good songs here are so strong that it carries the album.
One of my all-time favorites
Hard to go wrong here.
8.5 / 10
4/5
It was ok. Of course the hit is a classic. Also liked the Llama one, Pocahontas, and Welfare Moms a distant third.
Dont care for neil young
Beautiful music, but also makes me want to fall asleep on a rainy day. That's not necessarily a bad thing, if you are in that mood. Neil Young is very focused on lyrics. Also not a bad thing. However, it means you won't get much in the instrumental department. If you're into instruments it could be disappointing. The songs that he tries to go upbeat are the worst songs. Stick to the slow stuff, Neal.
Neil Young with Crazy Horse just hits different.
I was annoyed that it was an acoustic live album at first, but it honestly started to grow on me and by the end I was looking at the past 40 mins like it flew by.
Decent folk
Neil Young doing punk rock? An even bigger surprise is that it's actually pretty good. Now I've seen everything. Best songs: ¨Hey Hey, My My,¨ ¨Sedan Delivery¨
Yes, i like it
pretty good album, some songs are VERY strong, some are not so much. but i have my favourites, and some of the tracks are definitely entering my rotation. 7.5/10 favourite tracks: my my, hey hey (out of the blue), welfare mothers, sedan delivery, hey hey, my my (into the black)
I loved the progression from more folk sound on A-side to hard rock sound onto the B-side. Def a good exploration of sounds for the time and I can see how this falls into the prototype grunge type genre.
The first part was really boring with all the harmonica but My My, Hey Hey is always good. The 2nd half of the album picked up quite a bit to raise my raiting to a 3
I don’t really care for this either. I’m not very familiar with either artists.
4* but only just. I found the acoustic side weak (with the exception of hey hey my my) and it was rescued by Powderfinger et al.
An empty sandwich. The two slices of bread being the excellent 'My My Hey Hey' and 'Hey Hey My My'. But the rest is very forgetable. Songs about going to the dentist and a particularly dodgy song about hitting on single mums on benefits aren't that great. Especially as, even then, he sounded like a whiney 80 year old. 3 (-1 Harmonica tax)
Pretty good album - and good songwriting. I liked the continuity between the opener and closer I think it didn’t really speak to me perhaps as much as other Neil Young albums
Not bad but wasn’t crazy about it
Neil Young is always authentic, original and a great songwriter. Love this album.
Rv/g
Solid, enjoyable, great guitar.
Elsker åpningssporet og lukkingssporet; det er Neil i After the Gold Rush-kaliber. Det som kommer imellom bryr jeg meg ikke så mye om. Noen låter er bedre enn andre (Pocahontas, Sedan Delivery), men ikke noe av det høres ut som Hey Hey, dessverre. Er Welfare Mothers en KISS-låt med tekst skrevet av Mothers of Invention? Når jeg tenker meg om, høres det også ut som noe Mothers of Invention kunne ha laget. Er linjen mellom Mothers of Invention og KISS noe noen har forsket på? Kan jeg få stipend...?
«My my, hey hey, rock and roll is here to stay.» Vil Neil Young egentlig ligge med Pocahontas? Og har han tenkt å invitere Marlon Brando med på det? Han synger mye om å bo i tipi og ri på lamaer, «Ride My Llama» høres jo nesten ut som parodi. Tekstene er tidvis ganske cringe, og det preger egentlig mye av det Young har gjort etter denne plata også. At store deler av grunnarbeidet er gjort live, redder mye. Det låter rått, både den akustiske og den elektriske siden, på hver sin måte. Naturligvis best illustrert gjennom de to versjonene av «My My, Hey Hey». Jeg tenker på Dylans go electric-periode, da han kombinerte akustisk og elektrisk, hvor The Band (da The Hawks) kom inn i del to. Selv om Dylans akustiske sett har en nerve og intensitet, så sitter jeg ofte bare og venter på at The Band skal slå seg på, fordi jeg vet at det er så innmari mye bedre. Det samme skjer på Rust Never Sleeps. Men hos Young sin akustiske del føles det som han står og tripper og venter på at Crazy Horse skal entre scenen. Den delen mangler retningen og intensiteten Dylan hadde alene, og tekstene blir mer utsatt uten støyveggen bak. Da merker man lettere hvor klønete noen av linjene faktisk er. Når Crazy Horse først smeller til, er det derimot helt magisk. Det føles som rocken får nytt liv og jeg glemmer nesten all ventingen. Kanskje det er all vrengen som overdøver de kleine tekstene, og takk og pris for det.
Jeg mener å ha lest at Neil Young er den artisten i denne lista med aller flest album. 7/8 eller noe slikt. Dette er det andre albumet vi får og jeg er redd for at når vi er ferdig om noen år så er det Neil Young som fyller våre best likte album i oppsummeringen. For det blir en lett femmer her og. Gleder meg til mer!
Neil old
Classic
"I want to sleep with Pocahontas" she was like 16, Neil
Neil Young, for me a neglected saint of the old folk pantheon. I can tell from My My, Hey Hey that I need to slow down and listen to this one. I sense great depths. I see a young man surveying a landscape of bloodsoaked Americana, singing songs of mourning, and of foreboding, of wheat before the thrasher, a gunship on the shore, the encroach of modernity. I know from his political comments, almost 50 years later, that he remained an empathetic American and ineluctable prophet of doom. The ship still looms, blood still runs. He must be tired.
It erased my review I wrote as I listened but the basics I remember are: His affinity/obsession/idk with Indians is weird. Welfare Mothers sounds good but the lyrics are not it. Sedan Delivery may be my favorite. I know Neil Young was in like 57 bands so his style sounds so much like those other bands but he has a lasting sound. There are contemporary bands I listen to that definitely are influenced by him. I enjoy his overall sound. I think the guitar parts are cool. I like his voice.
Neil Young doing Neil Young things. Solid. The man is a damn folk rock n roll shaman. I love the different sounds he makes with Crazy Horse.
Don’t mind the opener but the rest is bland. Just not a Neil Young kinda guy!
I thought the first five tracks had a more folksy sound to the songs where the last four tracks were more hardcore rock and roll with electric guitar riffs. Before listening to this album, I was ambivalent about Neil Young's work; however, I did like "Pocahontas" a lot.
From the first track, I was rapidly losing patience with this album, and I was completely over it by "Pocahontas," so after that I gave maybe a minute or two to each song in hope of something better before skipping to the next, so my highlight/lowlight callouts will verge on meaningless; it was all bad to me. On songs like "Powderfinger" where I was in danger of enjoying the music, it was never long before Neil Young's reedy, whining voice was back to torment me with some cringe and insipid lyrics. Best: "Powderfinger" (for the guitar) Worst: "Pocahontas" (the last full song I listened to)
Lowlight: thrasher, ride my llama, welfare mothers Highlights: everything else Neil Young was someone I never listened to much until my mid 30s, so was happy to hear something I hadn’t heard from him yet. I loved this album and its messages of trying to reclaim yourself and violence that’s just imbedded in American culture. Splitting it between acoustic and electric is probably just a hold out from the record flipping days of one side being acoustic and the other electric. My my hey hey, is a song I have heard and I liked the wise but not tired message of trying to maintain your fire and if not, better to burn out then fade. Thrasher is just a bit too long and ramble and as much as I like Neil young, space music is not his forte and ride my llama is proof Pochhonfas was interesting in the sense that he’s of two spaces in time, being a Native American time during American expansion and talking to Marlon Brando. Sail away is a bit more fun, which is a nice break between all of the heaviness. Powderfinger blasts in with the guitar and the unfortunate story of a young boy being forced to war. Welfare mothers honestly, got kinda boring and reparative Sedan delivery was fast and hard and rocking that you need before the last proto grunge track of hey hey my my. It’s not my favorite Neil young album(Harvest, everybody knows, and on the beach juggle for the top spot) but this was a great continuation of his work and showed that despair being like a decade on the music business he could still make meaningful, striking, melodic and loud bangers 4/5
Not too bad
peak dad rock
meh
Pas le meilleur de Neil Young mais la première toune slap
enjoyed this, but a live album is a weird way to experience these songs
A perfect album for me, both sides I have time for. A few cheesy lyrics you always get but this is one of my favourites. Heaps of repeatability. SPUN
Fantastic, busy right now or would write more but I get why Kurt was so inspired. Top tier
Neil's records are all the hell over the place, with total garbage and apex pinnacles. This one is decidedly the latter. Rust Never Sleeps and neither does Neil, raging, imagining, howling against the grisly transience of all good things. 'Thrasher' kept me afloat for a month of my least favourite job ever when I was 19 or 20. Used to debate the meaning of 'Powderfinger' for hours. Love how he borrowed Dylan's structure acoustic/electric but reversed. Brilliant record.
Good background listening. Nothing too splashy. Glad I gave it a rip.
The 17 year old was intrigued enough about “Thrasher” to ask who the singer was. That was one of my favorites on the album too. Overall, a little uneven.
need to listen again
Solid album
Some songs as sharp as steel. Some weak as rust.
Listenable.
Relaxing yeehaw Nice vocals and instrumentals A pleasant listening experience
It’s fine
9.3
A bit mid of an album. Makes me sleepy, wanna get high or needin’ a nap, real bad.
rđa nikad ne spava za razliku od mene dok ovo slušam. na(ne)sreću me budi jangov meket
So good. Powderfinger sounds like proto-MJ Lenderman
Favourite songs: My My Hey Hey, Thrasher, Sail Away, Powderfinger, Hey Hey My My Least favourite songs: Ride My Llama, Welfare Mothers Rating 7.5/10
Really like Neil Young
Neil Young...he just keeps on Neil Younging...and that is a good thing. Hard to find nits in the Youngster. 4/5
if only i have become rust. then i can stay up and exchange information with people on the other side of the earth all night long. i have very bad postures and i'm so ugly. that is ok because so are you. do you want to burn out or fade away? you ask, i keep silent because i am afraid. i don't want to walk out of the blue because i have always been descending into the black. sex pistols broke up. johnny rotten was reborn as john lydon. john lydon formed PiL. the king is dead. long live the king. 4/5
Great album for today. My first Neil Young album was Harvest when I was 13 years old ( because I had a crush on a boy who sang Heart of Gold)…. Yesterday we went to my nephew’s home. He and his wife have 2 young sons. The ambient low soundtrack they played was Neil Young songs.
The first half was incredible. Powderfinger is also fantastic. Didn't rate the second half as much but that's a mood thing for me. A strong 4.
Very mellow music. Solid
Musically it’s a bit generic biddle but I like his voice and it’s very Karl Dilkington ‘song with a story’ lyric
This sounds more like a late career post-grunge renaissance than from the actual real life 70's. Really good
Love this album, precursor for other hard rock. My my hey hey
I love Neil Young and even I'm feeling, "Enough with the Neil young already"
This is such a classic Neil Young and Crazy Horse album. It features two trademark NY ballads in “Pocahontas” and “Powderfinger” that benefit from strong lyrics that leave themselves open to interpretation about their meaning. It has an inscrutably weird song in “Welfare Mothers.” It features excellent guitar crunch and ramshackle Crazy Horse stomp throughout. Then there are the leadoff and closing versions of “Hey Hey, My My,” one accoustic and wistful, sounding like something off of Harvest, the other noisy and fierce, with a beat like a stamping press. Young was simultaneously taking stock of a decade he loomed large over but felt confined by, and pointing toward the future, with tossed-off lyrical references to Johnny Rotten, ominous white boats coming up the river, and the famous line “It’s better to burn out than to fade away.” Reflective, restless, tender and angry, it’s an incredible capstone to a decade of personal and political upheaval, even if it marked the end of a run in which he could scarcely put a foot wrong.
There's a tic I have when I'm listening to music, it only comes out right before a song gets so bad I have to skip it, I get this feeling, then ask aloud "what the fuck is this?" then skip to the next song. I bring this up because "Ride my llama" ... what the fuck is this?
Docking a point for the offensive Welfare mothers song and all the native American woo woo themes.
nice
Shoutout to the college magician and the guy who hated him. 2/5
The godfather of grunge. Great album.
boring obnoxious snobbery. i forgot about this album while still listening to it. 1.5/5
- (quote discovered and taken from someone else's review:) "You go to a supermarket, and you see a faggot behind the fuckin’ cash register; you don’t want him to handle your potatoes.” - Neil Young. Yeah, you can F off Neil Young. - I'd never heard this album, but it feels nostalgic. - Solid melodies and lyrics. - Definitely feels more live than produced - I'd prefer more studio than live. - Dislike Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery.
Good album haven't listen in a long time
Wonderful album! I really felt it ended on a high with the last couple of songs! I'd give it a 4.5 if possible.
Man I hate his voice
I like how it switches from sad to sadder
è live!?!?!!?!?!
This one’s easy! 5:5. I always mistake this for an early career ‘greatest hits’ album, it’s got so many standards on it. And his live versions are perfect! I learned to play guitar with these songs and (to paraphrase) ‘once they’re your songs, you’ll never give them back’. Neil young just provided me with a thanksgiving parenting affirmation when one of my kids told me that he and his roommate were dressing up in Halloween with the roommate being Neil Young and my son as “a crazy horse”!
This is one of my all timers Neil and crazy Horse were on fire and at their peak. After reading your review Mike I might have to rethink my Halloween costume (French mad if you were wondering).
# Album Name: Rust Never Sleeps # Artist: Neil Young # Rating: 5/5 # Comments: Absolute banger. Every single track. Loved this record. # Top Tunes: All of it # Would I listen to it again? Yes
I LOVED the opening track. BUT, beyond that, there were maybe one or two tracks throughout that held my attention before I started to lose it. Neil is a great lyricist, but I feel like his compositions seemed a bit vanilla. I gravitate toward a little more musical interest, and this album just didn't have enough to sustain me throughout. I can appreciate the concept of the blue vs black, start vs ending, but I feel like the execution was just left wanting.
Очень хороший альбом, вокал не выделяется, отличный инструментал кроме губной гормошки на которой то ли играть не научились то ли не поняои как она звучит со всем остальным, есть еще несколько косяков но альбом очень хорош 4.4
Good album with some classic song. I’m not the biggest fan of Young’s vocals but he’s a legend.
pretty good actually although i dont always love NY
Gostei para caralho, muito bom.
Good
Excited for this one out of the gate. I love Neil Young and his annoying voice. My My Hey Hey versions opening and closing...chef's kiss. Didn't love all the tracks but will listen again. Given how prolific Neil was, these aren't his best tracks, but I love the feeling of this album. Better to burn than to rust! Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): My My, Hey Hey ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Loved it. Saved some tracks
A second Neil Young album in a week? You're killing me, Smalls. Or his voice is. Or the boredom. Please stop. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): N/A ⭐⭐: Didn't like it, didn't hate it. Saved no tracks.
Цей альбомчик один з небагатьох, що раніше слухав у Янга. Подобаються електронні номери, до акустичних якось серце не лежить.
У Ніла Янга величезна дискографія і з деякими альбомами в мене є конект, а з деякими нема. Ось тут я щось якось послухав, дуже фоново пройшло.
Excellent examples of NY from acoustic to hard rock. An important listen.
Soft folk/country rock. Quite nice really. Lyrical themes of American indigenous peoples. 2nd half is much more rock styled. Prefer the 1st half. Best track - Pocahontas 3 stars, but had potential
Pas mauvais, mais j'ai l'impression de me perdre dans la similarité des tonalités de la voix et des instruments. Pas mauvais en background et j'apprécie la durée concise. 3.5 round down.
La première chanson est magique, après sa dégringole un peu. Y’a mieux et y’a pire
awesome except for the song where he is totally out of tune with his vocal
He’s so good
Classic Neil stuff. I’ve heard most (if not all) of these tunes before. Great stuff. Hey Hey bookends fucking killer.
Here's what I'll say about this album. He sounds very good as a live performer. It's just that I don't like his music.
Niel Young isn't fun or interesting.
This was better than the last Neil Young album. This is like rock and country mixing. His voice still frustrates me, but it seemed to fit better here. Liked Songs: "My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)" , "Thrasher" , "Pocahontas" , "Sail Away" , "Welfare Mothers" , "Sedan Delivery" , "Hey Hey, My My (Into The Black)"
Good variety for a short album 3
Not my usual cup of tea. Its got that old school Beatles kind of feeling that I like. Though it gets a bit boring at times, it's still a pleasant listening experience. I liket it, and even added a song from there to my playlist - therefore it gets a 3/5🎉
When I first heard My My Hey Hey in 8th grade, I knew I had heard it before even though it just came out. It was floating in the ether with the rest of this perfect record. A must hear and I think if you only hear on Neil Young record, you are missing out, but this is the one.
Neil Young sabe lo que se hace. Me ha encantado la apertura y cierre con la misma canción pero distinto color. Abre en acústico y cierra a tope.
Love Neil Young although this album is a mixed bag with some great songs and a few average ones. Still a great listen overall.
not my usual kind of music, not a bad album though.
I quite enjoyed this! I had only heard a few Neil Young songs, but I knew of his reputation. The Godfater of Grunge, and the guy who got dissed in Sweet Home Alabama. Suffice to say, I prefer Neil to Lynyrd Skynyrd. A couple of the songs on this album were a bit samey, but I enjoyed the rest. There was even a kinda punky song on here, which was a bit of a surprise. I also really liked the guitar work. Neil Young's voice is lovely too!
Very relaxing. Beautiful voice on him.
Some beauty here. Some tragic in love with/shocked by the story he's a part of that I found kind of annoying as I encountered it yesterday, but is also an amazing situator into the moment it was created I guess. Weird echos and shadows that feel seen in it. I was a bit reactive to this yesterday, but it's still a bit on the trite side for me.
Realised I don't know that much about Neil Young. Really got in to this, caught me off- guard for sure. Hells yeah, get that fuzz.
Reinforces my comment on previous album. Exceptional guitarist, great song writer, barely mediocre vocalist. I understand vocals are very much down to personal taste so this is just an opinion. Despite the above observations I did enjoy
Not stellar
Nice variety of Neil in one place, good listen, good length before the sound wears me down
Have always liked Neil Young. Voice is not classically the best but the rawness of the melody makes it work well.
From the acoustic opening track "My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)", to the closing Punk Rock track "Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)", this is great album. Also includes "Thrasher", "Pocahontas", "Powderfinger", and "Welfare Mothers".
If Neil Young actually had a Crazy Horse this would be a 5 Star for sure.
It's got a pretty chill vibe, and I could've stood to hear more about his time with Pocahantas. But I don't know if it has a lot of replayability for me.
Slaps
Raw grunge, a great look into Crazy Horse and Neil Young. Some real classics on here. -Thrasher -Powderfinger
Sorprendentemente me ha gustado. Tengo que profundizar más en la música de Neil Young
Pleasantly surprised at this one. Not a Neil Young fan, but enjoyed this album.
I haven’t had an album below a 4 in so long please give me something awful to enjoy
The least annoying Neil Young album I've listened to. Still, not my bag at all.
This feels like the missing link for me. It's a solid step between the thought out lyric/vocal combo of folk oriented beginnings of rock, and the freedom of amplified electric technology. I'm impressed with what I've heard, and I'm still feeling like I need more listens to digest this properly. My rating may fluctuate with time. My mental image of Neil Young was a variety of Hollywood Neils before today. There's a lot more respect now. 3.6/5
Instrumentation is pretty good, but I can't get into the vocals
Fine! Neil Young is such a classic. Not something I’d reach for but listenable.
I’ve always enjoyed Neil’s songwriting, though I’ve never listened to a full album before and I’m not sure a live album counts. I enjoyed this, and I'm aware he’s got other albums on this list so I look forward to listening when they come up.
My My
I preferred the acoustic first half, but still lots to love in the back half. Great listen.
The songs themselves are fine—moody campfire ballads and scruffy garage-rock. But Neil’s delivery just doesn’t land for me... I'm an anti-Youngite. I found myself wishing for cover versions instead, because the melodies and lyrics are undeniably good, yet his voice and ragged style make the experience feel more like endurance than enjoyment.
Aboslute Classic. Don't know if I have actualy listened in its entiriety
Somehow avoided this because of it being a live album. Honestly could t even tell, and what great album it is! Great tracks from beginning to end
Oh dear, not another neil young album havent we suffered enough
Started out with my favorite Neil Young song and everything else was ok. His work with Crazy Horse is def his best.
A decent album, better than I expected. This album was a lot more popular in the 70s/80s but for some reason it’s fallen in the ranks in recent years. Is Harvest better than this? I’m not 100% certain it is.
Was already familiar with Young's work. Knew three of these songs already. Clean, well-executed album with lots of lyric creativity on Young's part. What's really fun is listening to the B-side... you can hear grungy guitar licks that seem 15 years ahead of their time. Young and Crazy Horse were always inspirations.
o álbum é muito bonito, gostei de muitas canções, eu sei que é um clássico, mas foi a primeira vez que ouvi Neil young, gostei bastante, mas não se tornou um álbum que vou escutar todos os dias.
I love Neil Young's music but I steered clear of this album until now because I don't usually like live albums and I thought this would be filled with screaming fans. What a mistake! This is fantastic!
Нил Янг никогда не разочаровывает. Отличный альбом, начинающийся с хита, вначале блюзовый и мелодичный, к концу становится бодрым и роковым. Классный, кайфовый, американский альбом, приближающий своим звучанием к земле и природе. Rock'n'Roll will never die.
Neil, es Neil y eso es suficiente
Really good, he has a very nice voice
sympa
Enjoyed listening to this. Really like the contrasting first side acoustic with more heavier flip side. My my, heh heh, perfectedly encapsulates the chasing of the guard after punk. For me, this album does not come near the quality of other classic NY albums. But there is a time and place for everything, and this captures the moment nicely
It's not my favorite Neil Young, but any Neil Young is pretty great.
Just good-ass American music.
Good, very listenable album.
247/1089 - A little less annoying than the Gold Rush one.
Great album. Proto-grunge is a cool name for a genre and can hear the early influences here.
neil.
как же драйвово!!!
Young is a genius at his art and this is a phenomenal record that fuses country and rock seamlessly. Even the songs that don't really resonate with me surely impress me. A great record top-to-bottom.
Better than the first Neil Young album I heard from this list, but the cool parts aren't consistent
Fantastic album front to back. I love when Neil gets a little heavier than normal, I’m so this is one of my favorite albums of his. Not to say that the folk songs on here aren't also fantastically written and played. Favorites- Powderfinger, Sedan Delivery and Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) 10/10
A live album that actually rules. Neil is a legend and this is fantastic. A true classic.
Cool album. I enjoy the acoustic and electric halves of it. Is it supposed to be live? I can’t totally tell.
This is my 3rd or 4th Neil Young album so I knew what I was getting coming into this. That being said, surprised by how heavy the second half was. 7/10
gods this is boring. dad rock at its rock bottom
2.2
Boring
Was going to be a 1, but the last few songs saved it. I'm sick of acoustic guitar!
So very much not my thing.
Would've been 4 stars but near the end I could only hear Adam sandlers singing voice and it took me out of it.
Welfare mom's?
Good songs good. Welfare mothers was the nader.
Hey hey
- Oké, zeker niet slecht. - 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM
This influenced so much
One of the best albums by one of the best to ever do it. Both the acoustic and the hard rock parts are fantastic — every time I hear the start of Powderfinger I'm instantly transported, one of the most vivid songs ever written.
Great start and finish...the middle not so much. Also Pocahontas was terrible.
This album perfectly showcases the two sides of Neil Young. On the acoustic side, the title track and Pocahontas stand out. The electric side is the heart of the album. The standouts are the electric version of the title track, Powderfinger and Welfare Mothers. I can hear where grunge came from because the guitars throughout the electric side are muddy and dirty, just how I like them.
Seems Neil was passed his peak here
Lovely stuff! Saw a lot of this live, which was tasty. Simpsons: Yes
Solid album.
I didn’t love this but it wasnt awful. Weird one
3 - good album
Beautiful clarity; not for me.
Interesting songs, with “My My, Hey Hey” being the best and most familiar. Some of the recordings started with live cuts, and I sometimes found the sound/audience noise to be a distraction.
I slept through it :) 2 star
Good live music, not a huge Neil young fan, but I can appreciate the talent. 3.3
Decent enough - didn’t really grab me
20.58, hima, sennheiser, qobuz aika turhaa ränkytystä ja monkumista. lämpenin kyllä loppua kohden, vika biisi säröllä oli rokkenroll
blast from the past for me
Really enjoyed it, never heard of the album specifically but knew the first song. Very cohesive, gave my The Who vibes at times. Listened at work so didn't have my full attention... But definitely worth another listen through. Can I come back and edit these reviews later? Testing...
pretty meh vocalistically, didnt really pay much attention to the poetry of it but I caught glimpses of a poetic tendency (lame ass way of not describing precisely what I heard but capturing some vague feeling of it) starting with the pocahontas song. liked the distorted guitar of the first and last song and how they were kind of light and dark versions of each other. that was pretty cool. my my hey hey, hey hey my my. rust never sleeps is a cool title. its always creeping up on you, ready to take over unfeelingly.
Good
Neil has never completely clicked with me, but this is a great record. The last half is better than the first half, and the distortion on the closing track is great.
Not a drive to work jam
I had no idea “It’s better to burn out than to fade away” came from this album. That alone gave it a certain weight going in. I also didn’t realize how fully Neil Young leaned into that off-key, straining wail post-Harvest, and wow, does he commit. 😅 It’s a bit all over the show, but I appreciated the raw edges and the clear roots of grunge planted throughout. A bit messy but undeniably influential.
My My Hey Hey and vice versa, along with Thrasher, Pocahontas, Sail Away and Powderfinger are great. But I tend to lose focus on the other tracks, making this a 4 star instead of a 5.
Starts off very strong. Based off my limited knowledge of him, this feels like the quintessential Neil Young album. Might grow on me.
not the neil i would reach for
It's fine. I'm sure fans of Neil Young love it. Gave it a 4 last time but for some reason this time didn't grab me as much.
I understand the why and wherefore, but not my favorite Neil Young Album
idk man dude is kinda whiny
One of Neil Young's best, right? What more can be said?
Might just be in my top 10. NY really is one of if not the best. Maybe I’m a soft touch on the ratings. Dishing out 5s for fun. 5/5 Best Song: Powderfinger/Hey Hey
Its an easy 5, its so good. Maybe one of his best albums, you can sill here the influence of this album today. Fair to say no grunge without this album?
Enjoyed the mix up of styles but not a big fan
Killer opener and closer, tracks in the middle are a mixed bag (leaning positive) - unfortunately I just don't like the structure of this and I can't see it higher than a 3, though it is absolutely the best Neil Young this challenge has offered (not that that is a big win!)
Meh
Låt, på låt ikoniska.
The first album this site ever served me was 1990’s Ragged Glory, and it was nearly unlistenable. This album, however, was pretty dang good! Much closer to the Neil Young I enjoy, and a ton of really fun songs on the record. Best Track: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)
Solid lyrical country music. The beginning of the album is measured, played on a couple of chords and creates the atmosphere that you are sitting in a half-empty pub or taking a minibus to another city. The second half of the album is already with more cheerful motives, apparently so that the listener doesn't get bored completely. I can't recommend it, it didn't catch on, but it wasn't bad either.
Nice stuff. Loved songwriting. Didn't liked structure. Probably would work better if acoustic and electric songs followed each other, not divided by sides. Fav song: Pacahontas.
Powderfinger
I didn't know who Neil Young was until I started hearing the music. I liked this album a lot. Rock and blues, the guitars, the harmonica. It made me feel so good and somehow also melancholic. My favorite one has to be Thrasher. For me it is 4.5/5 mini0n, 04/09/2025
A bit slow for my liking, but he is a Canadian classic.
A solid summer backyard album. I'm not the biggest fan of listening to live recordings, but the live tracks blended in well with the studio recordings.
Solid listen. Not anything groundbreaking
Ik viel al vrij snel in slaap
Well chill, maar niet het beste werk van de man denk ik.
Relaxed album, zonder echte uitblinkers. De live recordings zijn zo opgenomen dat je geen last hebt van het publiek en hij speelt goed.
It was pretty decent. Not something I’d search back out though
Back to "new to me" albums today, or at least "I've been meaning to spin that one" albums. I'm familiar with Neil Young, obviously (both through CSNY and Harvest), but I haven't investigated any of the later stuff, and certainly not anything from the Crazy Horse years. Favorites: Powderfinger, Thrasher, Sedan Delivery. A "sorta live" album - side A is much more acoustic and folk-ish than side B, interesting way to structure the album. Love the bookend tracks in both styles.
Bookended by one of the greatest songs of all time, can't go wrong. The rest isn't jazz is great folk moving toward out there jam rock. Big fan.
This was the first Neil Young album I bought, as I was getting into his music and this was his latest release. I listened to this and “Live Rust” almost non-stop for a while, and then went backward and got more of his records. Some of the songs on here haven’t aged as gracefully as others, but this mix of acoustic and electric perfectly encapsulated both sides of his output. “Powderfinger” is my favorite NY song, so that alone lifts this to top tier for me. And I love enough of the others (especially MMHH and HHMM) to make this an absolute must listen.
Classic Neil Young sticking it to the disco era.
Dürfte ein sehr gutes "Autobahn"-Album sein. Gute Riffs und nie langweilig
My My Hey Hey ist gut, ansonsten maximal durchschnittlich. Mag Neil Young teilweise sehr, teilweise ertrage ich seine Stimme nicht.
Unser erstes Neil Young Album, werden wohl noch einige Folgen. Fand Teile echt gut. Das erste Lied ist wunderschön. Der zweite Teil war weniger gut.
Another one of my favorites
Better than Ragged Glory, but Neil Young still baffles. He is not a good singer, though sometimes almost characterful. He can be nearly poetic – “the aimless blade of science” – before collapsing into bathos – “slashed the pearly gates” – or plain cliché - "There's more to the picture that meets the eye." Thrasher is almost Everybody’s Talkin’. The album and songs sound thrown together, the lyrics hardly crafted, but Young has clearly been thinking long and hard about some of the themes. Still, “better to burn out than to fade away” is hardly an insight, and Young does not seem convinced himself: the acoustic version fades away, the electric one burns out. Which is it? The first sounds like a demo awaiting a decent band, the second like a rehearsal waiting for the band to get out of its own way. Neither is the finished article. Why bother? 2 This is survivable. With Neil’s lyrics - which are always turgid and childlike in some degree, never elegant, never truly poetic - everything he does runs somewhere around a fine line between passable and boring. He gets away with it here through the novelty of presenting an album in two halves - a soft, sweet acoustic half and a fuzzy rock band half. If all was done in one style then the album would be intolerable. Christ that drumming is bad though. And the singing not great, the guitar playing pretty bad and the sweet West Coast backing vocals always misplaced. Who thought the handclaps on Welfare Mothers was a good idea? Or anything on Welfare Mothers? Shite. 2/5
Still struggling to understand how people can like Neil Young. They rave on and on about his influence and you go listen and it's just a guy who sucks. First 2 songs were fine then it just goes straight down to the toilet
I love Neil Young
Zuhause, Heidenheim, Deutschland. Sehr fein.
Far too chill for a rock album as far as I'm concerned.
Not bad
The mix of live tracks and studio ones is a bit confusing, but the album overall showcases solid guitar work with Neil Young's signature vocal style. Overall pretty solid, though not world changing.
This is a pleasant and delightful listen.
not a perfect record (sail away is forgettable and welfare mothers regrettable) but it's one of my favourite neil albums
neil young is pretty good
Some interesting lyrics but parts didn’t age well. I enjoy the overall sound of the album but Neil Young’s voice is annoying.
Or you could just make a punk album, that would be a sick genre switch
Powerful live performances. I actually wish it was a longer set.
Thoughts before listening: Neil live album. I both love it and also think it's a little rough around the edges. Of course that's pretty much par for the course with a Neil Young show so it's appropriate. Review: You know what, I think I'm thinking of one of the later Neil live albums. This one is great. First half is acoustic and then he cranks it up for the second half with full on electric Crazy Horse. I was actually prefer the acoustic songs here although it's hard to argue with full on hard rock Neil. This is 5-stars.
I have absolutely no idea what about this works so well for me, but anything other than a 5 star rating feels wrong.
Nice album of the godfather of grunge who shows why he is called like that. If you don't like his voice you will give this a 1 start, otherwise you cannot deny his capability of writing great songs.
Pretty lukewarm on this one. It's a soft 3.
You can never go wrong with a classic. But was I in the mood?
I like the first half of the album with just Niel more than the last half. The last part is interesting but with the clear comparison to the first part I find that the fist part connects more with me Standouts My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue) Pocahontas 4/5
Enjoyed this quite a bit
Think I like the acoustic side more than the electric. But it’s all good. Classic Neil. Closer to a 3.5 or 3.75
99/1001. The story of Johnny Rotten: well i just ended up hating P.I.L's Metal Box in the last review. But I don't know about Neil Young, some people claim he's the profet and without him there wouldn't be any grunge and whatnot. For me this is not music to mildly hurt some for. So the same amount of stars as mr. Rotten.
Was a good album, but overall didn't enjoy all of the songs.
Neil Young finally got me tonight. Especially loved the repeating intro and outro tracks. The outro is pleasantly heavy.
Not my favorite Neil Young album. I think Harvest is a much better album.
This was actually quite the surprise and very enjoyable, despite my fears when I took note of this being a mixture of studio and live tracks. The end result is a well-assembled package which sailed by pleasantly in my ears. The stripped back, gentle acoustics combined with infrequent, reflective bursts of harmonica really do provide for some heartstring-tugging moments throughout, with the album coming out of its cave and taking on more optimistic, hard rock tones as it advances. Wikipedia describes Rust Never Sleeps as "proto-grunge", but I'm not sure I'm getting much of that from it (thankfully) - rather, it feels like a precursor to the exploits of bands such as Built to Spill, Dinosaur Jr, Pavement, Sebadoh et al. The opening track has a veil of darkness shrouded over it in a way quite unlike anything else on the album, probably taking the cake as my highlight. I was also pleasantly surprised by Neil Young as a vocalist - for whatever reason, I was expecting some gravelly, two-pack-a-day smoker groaning, but he has a smoother vocal style much more aligned with vocalists of the 90-00s alt/indie persuasion. Would I put this on again? If the circumstances called for something of this ilk, then yeah, I'd probably reach for it.
La segunda parte del disco tiene una fuerza impresionante. Parece que estés escuchando dos discos de dos artistas distintos. 8/10
I don't think I clicked with this one as much. While the songwriting and instrumentals are fine throughout, nothing on here really wowed me outside of "Powderfinger". I'll at least give the album that it gets much better when it gets more electric on the b-side, but other than that, this one didn't land.
It was cute. Nothing really notable but it was a pleasant listen
Not my favorite Neil album but still a good one. A bit jammy for my tatses
Hey Hey, My My, this album will never die. Yeah this album is pretty damn good. I’d heard Live Rust before, and it was also really good, and also longer than this one. Neil Young really does do some of his best work live. Not only on this album does his music excel, but his lyrics are superb on this album. Songs like Hey Hey, My My(Into The Black) or it’s mirror on the first side of the record, or even songs like Thrasher have really vivid lyrics. The songs are also very musically interesting, with Neil’s harmonica taking center stage in many songs. Crazy Horse also serves as a great backing band, with all of the members supporting Neil in their own ways. The album also has an interesting thesis, “It’s better to burn out ‘cause rust never sleeps”. That’s a sentiment that I’m not sure if I agree with, but it makes for a very interesting theme for the album. Overall, this is a great live album, and a great album in general, now, I’ve got to be headed out, hopefully, into the blue of another good album.
Takie figo fago
нормалек.
I'm not sure why we have to listen to this before we die. It's a tight 38 minutes and it's felt long and underwhelming. Neil Young, CSN will drop in popularity as the Boomers kick it. I don't see their appeal. There is so much more interesting music from their contemporaries. It might be my deep dislike of NY's flat, frilly vocals. He's no Thom Yorke or Jeff Buckley.
There's a drum kit on the cover, and the first time you actually notice the drums is over half way in. False advertising.
Just a rock and it's some solid rock
I’ve always wanted to like Neil Young. I’ve got a lot of respect for him but I’ve never really liked listening to his albums past one spin and the wondering why I gave it another try only to try again years later. I also can't help but thinking of that old Dana Carvey bit where he goes "this is every Neil Young song you've ever heard" and then proceeds to do a spot on imitation of every Neil Young song you've ever heard. I was going to give this a 4 based on the respect I have for him but I just can't get into this album until the last 3 songs.
Nice melodies and good background music, but nothing crazy.
Sound album 😌
Not my favourite but a decent album. Might need a closer listen.
3,5 Я очікувала від цього виконавця кантрі, але насправді, єдине, що поєднало цей альбом з Бобом Діланом - губна гармонія. Чи то мені потрапило в настрій, чи це приклад того, що просте - хороше. Думаю, що якби Ніл Янг все-таки приїхав у Київ, то враження від концерту були б приємні і ностальгійні.
5*
Really cool! Very heavy guitar stuff from Neil Young. My My is a classic, obviously, but I hadn't heard the ret of this record before. Surprisingly fun!
Pas mal aber lowkey klingt jedes Lied gleich 6/10?
Top 10 live record - combines every style of playing and performance that Neil has at his command.
This album highlights what I love best about Neil Young - his ability to excel at crooning like a lonesome cowboy at one moment and then turning around and knocking you back with an absolutely blaring, fuzzy, electric chord the next. Solid from beginning to end - I would have liked a bit more mixing of acoustic and electric, but as an intentional two sides of a band, I get it. Truly one of the greats from one of the greats.
Probably my favorite Neil Young album and that's really saying something. From front to back, this is a stellar example of every style of his and I love how it goes from stark acoustic songs to full-on raucous live guitar onslaught. Lyrically, these songs explore the danger of celebrity ("Hey Hey, My My") and the perils of colonialism ("Pocahontas") and violence ("Powderfinger"). And I love how he goes fully punk on "Sedan Delivery." Just a great album
Probably my favorite live album, i spin this pretty much every month at least once. Showcases the two sides of Neil with some excellent acoustic songwriting on the first side; I love the poetry of Thrasher and the wistfulness of Pocahontas especially. Then flip it over and you've got some incredible proto-grunge, Powderfinger is my favorite Neil Young song from a lyrical and musical standpoint, that chorus riff is just awesome, and it tells such a vivid, great story in so few words. And concluding the show with Hey Hey, My My, raucously inverting the intro in a way that matches the song's message perfectly. Old Neil decided to rust instead of burn out and I'm glad he did, saw his show last month and he's still got it
This is my third Neil Young album, and I just didn't connect at all with the other two. I don't know if it's the live-sounding production, the more rock vibe on side 2, or just the brilliant opening, and closing track, but I really enjoyed this one - it's exactly what I wanted the others to be.
not really my taste, but i know my dad really likes neil young.
I have never listened to Neil Young, this album surprised me. Sorry for the backwards comparisons, but I am from a younger generation. Songs like "Thrasher" remind me of The Mountain Goats, and as crazy as this feels to say, and it is not something I was expecting at the tail-end of this album, "Sedan Delivery" sounds like an early prototype of Pixies. Very Francis Black-esque vocals, and while the instrumentation isn't as "strange" as a Pixies song might be, the tempo changes are there. Really neat album considering the the time period.
either something to cry over or to have a slow dance with either way love it
pretty good if you dont care about the lyrics
I’m not listening to anymore Neil Young. I heard there are like 13 of his albums on here. I tried with one record, hated it. I’ve hated his music all my life, and I’ve actually heard a fair amount of it cause I have a buddy that owns like all 113 records he’s put out. There literally is not single piece I’ve ever heard of his that I’ve enjoyed. Don’t need to hear this record to know it’s a big fat goose egg from me. Fuck you, Neil Young. 0.5/5 He gets a half a point for not writing Destiny’s Child’s Survivor.
Singer's voice sounds like Placebo. Lots of acoustic guitar, not a fan. Powderfinger kinda slaps. Second half of the album is actually rock songs, so much better than the first.
Good
Hey hey, my my is too good
I'm a Neil Young fan, but this live album just falls flat for me. 3/5 #151
I can't believe two albums from this combo made it on this list. This one is better than the other, at least.
Not for me