Reviews (page 7 of 14)
I didn't really like the last Neil Young I got (Tonight's the Night) but really dig this one for some reason. The ear works in mysterious ways.
One of Young’s best - which is saying a lot, considering the quality of his work. A favourite of mine for years, especially the opening and closing tracks, ‘Pocahontas’ and the outstanding ‘Sedan Delivery’. Solid and essential.
So, only one Neil Young album gets a perfect five. But this is very good: turn on Neil Young, watch Inherent Vice, read Vineland, mourn the 60s
This was my second Neil Young album so far, and this one was so much better than Tonight's the Night. I could actually see listening to this one again if the right mood struck.
No me aburre pero no lo pondría por elección propia
Lo escuche por la mitad y si bien tiene un tinte diferente a otras cosas que escuche, no me termino de convencer. Tambien con una onda yankee campirana con la cual no me identifico, musicalmente esta bastante bien
Ufffff que embole hermano
Much like Dylan’s Bringing It All Back Home, Rust Never Sleeps has both an acoustic and an electric side - and it’s all the better for it. The latter even proved formative for the sound of grunge that would blossom in the ’90s. Partly tracked live and later overdubbed, these recordings sound raw and yet fantastic. Plus, the collection features some of Neil Young’s absolute finest songs (Thrasher, Pocahontas, Powderfinger, Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)). Man, does he shred on the B-side with his Les Paul. I’m not particularly crazy about Ride My Llama, Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery, as they pale in comparison to the other towering songs on the album. But that’s really just nitpicking. Neil Young reportedly included “rust” in the title of the previous tour as a metaphor to avoid artistic stagnation - however, if you’ve got these songs sitting around, one does wonder what exactly he thought he was rusting into.
One of my top 10 favourite artists. So prolific, so political, so non conformist, sometimes raw and gutsy, sometimes sweet and romantic. Love it.
I did not want to like this but I saved 3 songs haha! That is the album rating system, and I'm sticking to it.
This album starts out really strong with My, My, Hey, Hey (Out of the Blue), then confused me with a weird blend of Rock, Country and Folk and in the end ruins all the rapport that it built with My, My, Hey, Hey (Into the Black). At least gotta respect the album's flexibility. 2.5/5
Having now finally listened to all 9 albums featuring Neil Young in this challenge, I remain deepy confused about what I think of him. I've rated his albums between 5 stars and 2 stars. The prospect of getting a live album by him definitely filled me with some slight dread. Most of his album struck me as among his more boring material, if I'm being honest. Ok, I get that there was some controversy around the central concept: "It's better to burn out than fade away". Multiple other artists weighed in and Kurt Cobain quoted it in his suicide note. So yeah, that's pretty heavy. But what else do we get aside from one extreme lyric. Most of the songs were fairly forgettable. But... I absolutely love both parts of the album's bookends, "Hey Hey, My My". Both songs work incredibly well on their own and compliment one another perfectly. Neil Young was said to have had a big influence on grunge music, but I never heard anything other than an aging folk singer trying to cash in a teenage trend. But there's definitely a real grunge intensity to that closing track. But once again, I just don't know how to rate it. On the power of that great two part song, I'm tempted to go up to 4 stars, knowing that I might one day come to appreciate the rest of the album. But if I'm being honest, two great songs among some filler is only 3 stars. Apologies to Neil Young fans, but he's just got a very mixed track record for me. When he's great, he's great, but I don't love it all the same.
Meh. I kinda like Neil Young when he does country-rock, but this album is just 90 % country. Worse, it’s (very) slow country. I really can’t relate, sorry. There’s only so much harmonica and soft guitar I can take in a day, and I reached my limit about halfway through the album. This must be a North-American thing. Something about pick-up trucks and long boring drives. I tried to find reasons to give it a 2*, but there’s really nothing that stands out, it just sounds like every country album ever. Neil Young has done much better albums, why include this one ? Do we really need half his discography on this list ?
🗯 Starts on the porch, ends in the garage — both sides glorious. I’ve seen this around heaps, but was never excited by Young so didn’t bother. Joke’s on me! Side A is acoustic and intimate, Neil in storyteller mode with the kind of songs that feel timeless. Side B? He straps in with Crazy Horse and basically sketches the blueprint for grunge a decade early. ‘Powderfinger’ is a scorcher and one of his finest ever — and the namesake for the Aussie band — while ‘My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)’ drops that immortal line: “It’s better to burn out than to fade away.” Here’s the kicker — most of it was recorded live on tour, but with the crowd noise stripped out, making it feel like a studio album with an untamed edge. I enjoyed this way more than I expected — raw, fearless, and bloody excellent from start to finish. Proof that Neil could be delicate and devastating in the same breath. This album fucking slaps!!
I’m really not a fan of his voice, in fact it reminds me of Kermit but worse. This album strangely grew on me over a few listens though. A surprising 4 stars
An all-time great album with songs that will be played forever.
This is a fairly easy going album, it gently rises and peaks towards the end. It’s good but not great.
A fair chunk of what would become the defining music of the 20th century’s last quarter exists between My My, Hey Hey and its antipodal point, Hey Hey, My My. And, as it happens, so too does what will in all likelihood be my favourite album of this year, the last of the 21st century’s first quarter. First things first, that line. “It’s better to burn out than fade away” was so excruciatingly prescient a lament that it took someone as gifted in running a feeling to its absolute limits as Kurt Cobain to really claim it. Tragically, but that’s Kurt Cobain for you. In its original context, you feel Neil feeling suddenly, perhaps for the first time, less than young. And there’s ample evidence of that perspective shift happening across the record – the biographical ramblings of “Thresher” (symbolism fans: a machine for harvesting); the humble aspirations of “Ride My Llama”; the tragedy of a life cut short for nought in “Powderfinger”; even the resourceful horniness of “Welfare Mothers” and Bukowski-baiting “Sedan Delivery” feel like they’re coming from a place of some sort of hard-fought streetwise wisdom. This album has entirely captivated me. And while it’s because it’s 1) full of absolutely sublime songs and 2) so pivotal a piece in the big old jigsaw of music I love … it’s also because I also feel less than young today. And while the feeling that something’s behind you might be a jarring one, it’s also an invitation to reflect on the privilege that is having something to look back on. As momento mori moments go, this is surely one of the most stirring and inspiring ever articulated. (I mean, it literally invented grunge!) In short, it’s proof if you needed it that burning out or fading away was only ever a false choice. It’s always been neither, and it’s always been both. My my, hey hey.
Realmente no me esperaba este final. Empieza super country y luego evoluciona mas al rock, las ultimas canciones me gustaria volver a escucharlas otra vez
Not a big Neil Young fan tbh but was better than I expected
A collection of 7 skippable songs bookended by 2 decent ones
The 1980 pressing of this that I have is from across the iron curtain in Yugoslavia, where Young seems to be sped up slightly, despite the clear 33rpm labels. I guess it shows just how big he’d gotten in the ~10 years since his debut to be distributed and (probably) well-received across the blue/red divide. Well, a slightly pitched-up version of him anyway. The main stories about this album need no introduction - the acoustic A side and the electric B side, the sort of hybrid live/studio feel, and of course the infamy that now besets My My, Hey Hey - Kurt Cobain’s suicide note. On the acoustic A side you’ll find the crushing opener of My My, Hey Hey to lend itself well into the subsequent, almost as impactful Thrasher, through seldom talked about Ride My Llama, and into the more bright and optimistic double feature of Pocahontas and Sail Away. The electric B side does everything the A side did so brilliantly and then some - from the cascading riff of Powderfinger through to the bookending abrasive sign-out of Hey Hey, My My, not letting up in energy or indeed quality once. That’s right, there isn’t a dull moment on either side, despite what you may hear about Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery, it’s better to really appreciate these two rather than just waiting for the gap between the more popular tracks 6 and 9 to end. That is the beauty of the album format after all. Rust Never Sleeps sees Young round out the 1970s with an unabashed reaffirmation of his songwriting genius, and Crazy Horse provide the engaging backing to propel it into deserved “greatest of all time” discussions, which I still refuse to partake in. You may have had marginally less time to focus on Young’s lyricism if you were living in Sarajevo at the time of its release, but that needn’t matter when you can just flip your record over and start again, right back out of the blue.
Wouldn't buy
Awesome
I don't love Neil Young and I don't love live albums. However, this hits some kind of sweet spot, the recording is great, and what's included comprises a set that is varied and succinct enough to give you a good sense of the multi-faceted Neil Young without it feeling like it's hitting you over the head being overly long. I quite enjoyed this.
Good music
Mmmmm el bodriazo de la semana. Nota: 2.5
3,5
Neil Young is always a good listen and I never knew there were 2 versions of my, my, hey, hey (or hey, hey, my, my).
עצם העובדה שהוא הופך צאלבום פולק לאלבום גראנג' באמצע גורמת לאלבום הזה להיות,בלתי נשכח אלבום מדהים, אין בו דילוגים, מצוין. שיר מועדף - Hey hey, my my (into the black)
Not bad, but also not very exiting. I’m also not sure what to think of Neil Young’s voice.
This is #day358 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… it's been 3 or 4 days since I last got a Neil Young & Crazy Horse album. While I rated that one a 2, I thought I couldn't follow suit with this record, at least because there's "My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)," which I like. So be it. This is a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day359.
Cool country vibes. Will deffo listen again
Love it!
“My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)” is one of the great treatises on the rock star life. This is sort of a Frankenalbum, half live, half in the studio, but it’s up there with Neil’s best. Also, Fuck Joe Rogan.
Oh how I wish I was born during the great harmonica boom of the 70s and 80s Starts as great folk rock but becomes meh rock towards the end and it’s a bit repetitive, Neil young also says some crazy shit unprompted on this album
i liked it more than i thought i would. slightly goated?
Kindof a weird album. I enjoyed it but some of the lyrics and themes are questionable. Good sound weird context.
Very chill listen, but nothing really caught my attention very strongly
Eh? Like it wasn’t terrible but I didn’t jive with a lot of it
😩😩😩 I just love neil young so much he’s my goat.
Honestamente, me aburrio, no le preste casi anda de atencion al album. Siento que en un futuro me puede gustar mas.
Not perfect but pretty darn close. Thrasher all the way.
....
My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) 4 Thrasher 3.8 Ride My Llama 3.4 Pocahontas 3.5 Sail Away 3.6 Powderfinger 4 Welfare Mothers 3.8 Sedan Delivery 4 Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) 4.2 Score: 3.811111111
Sleepy, too mellow for me. Listened while cooking
One known song from this album, it’s experimental as usual. Some great harmonica passages. Nothing terrible but nothing notable.
Ok muziek, Maar ik hou niet van Neil Young zijn stem. Jammer
It's okay. Great storytelling and the instrumentals are great in parts.
Grew on me as it went through the album, might listen again
Not my favourite Neil my a long stretch but still a great Neil. Probably rounded down a bit.
Cool
Neil Young just ain't the most interesting artist for me, last half was good though for sure
I feel this deserves to be better but it ends up being repetitive and for what is not that long of an album feeling long. But the music is enjoyable in spots.
I really like Neil Young’s voice. It was a pleasant listen. I only knew My My Hey Hey.
The album is kinda all over the map. Solid listen--like that it opens with the smooth acoustic My My, Hey Hey and ends with the gritty electric Hey Hey, My My. Clear there's a lot going on in the album, but even when not listening intently to the lyrics, I still enjoyed listening to it.
In another world I may have liked Neil Young and this album. It's a bit weak in the middle, but overall it's a pretty solid piece of music. One that I listened to everyday for years, as it was the tape in my buddies car, and he either didn't want to change it or couldn't so everywhere we went it was to the soundtrack of this album.
Believe it or not, I thought this album was pretty bland. There’s nothing really here that makes me think this should be a good album.
Previously rated: Harvest (2/5) After the Gold Rush (3/5) Tonight's the Night (3/5) Ragged Glory (3/5) On The Beach (3/5) Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere (4/5) ********************************************* I just had Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere three albums ago. I didn't really want another Neil Young so soon, but random is random. At some point between that album and this one, Neil developed that awful whiny, nasally singing voice that I can't stand. That ruins anything good that might be here, like the last track Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) which almost sounds metal. I think this is one they could have definitely left off the list. That's seven albums from this guy (not counting any CSNY). We are done with him now, right?
Range of 70s styles from acoustic, rock to punk. Excellent audio mix. Great intro and outro to classic live album.
Contains some of Neil Young's best-written and most lyrically rich songs, such as "Pocahontas" and "Powderfinger". I just wish this weren't a live album that was overdubbed. Tracks like "Thrasher" have that ugly acoustic-electric guitar sound that just takes me out of it. The first half which is basically all acoustic, could have been better with more polished studio work. The second half is more raw and electric, but the recording quality is still flawed, a little flat. The album progresses in chaos from the gentle acoustic version of "Hey Hey My My (Out of the Blue)" to the absurdly gritty version "(Into the Black)", which is interesting. I understand the raw and improvisational sound throughout is probably what was intended, but I just can't help but wonder how much better some songs could have been as studio recordings.
Just not my type of music.
Great voice and good guitar playing. No one song really pulled me in though.
Crap
Thanks to Nick Offerman suggesting this album in one of his books, I found this album just five or six years ago. As a beginner woodworker, I was inspired to listen to this in the shop (as Offerman says he did) while I wasted wood and didn't make much more than sawdust and smaller pieces of wood. Thanks to Nick, I love this album and have marginally increased my woodworking abilities. Anyway, I know Neil Young is an acquired taste and not for everyone. I was a hater for a long time, so I get it. For me, ⭐⭐⭐⭐.5
3/5
hm...My My, Hey Hey...mesmo assim, chataaato bgr 3 estrelas pro neil young
I enjoyed hearing what was a more raw Neil Young.
I have always disliked Neil Young, and have already had 2 of his albums pop up here. Those were rated with 1’s and 2’s. I loved this album, the opener will definitely be revisited
This is very good fun indeed!
Started off really enjoyable, I love Neil's voice. Did go a bit odd towards the end though, is that just me?
classic rock, a leyend
So good.
Solid opener with a song that i only know from being a staple of Oasis’s setlist. For a fairly short album theres more variety in terms of style than the previous Neil Young albums i’d listened to, presumably in part due to the live aspect but this still works as a cohesive album. Not sure of the necessity to close the album with a different version of hey hey though, especially given it is not as good
I tried to come up with an actual review, but I couldn’t.
I'm sorry Neil Young, what sort of lyric is: "Welfare mothers make better lovers While they're washin' you can hear this sound now Welfare mothers make better lovers Di-vor-ceeeeeeeee" ??? And while we're on the topic of lyrics: "I'm gonna ride my llama From Peru to Texarkana I wanna ride him good" ??? This is my second Neil Young album since starting the project, and I found this album less dull than the last one (I think I've moved on to "questionable" now), but I still hate his voice. 2/5
This is one of Young’s defining albums. I like the structure and I don’t think it’s been over done. I would have time for more albums featuring an acoustic and electric side.
Hey hey my my I love this album.
Not the best work by Neil Young, but okay.
Good stuff
This record was incredible! Another Neil Young album I love! It’s acoustic quality, along with its hard rockers at some points, make it a very good mix of a record. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Ist ok, die Musik ruhig und die Stimme angenehm. Aber es plätschert so vor sich hin, mitgerissen hat es mich nicht. 2-3/5
PASS. I've listened to it already and I truly hate it. It's boring, monotonous shit for me. 1/5
Top-shelf writing and musicianship
Great album. Love how it builds from acoustic to electric. Was a little shorter than I hoped.
Hey hey my my and my my hey hey are certified bangers. Rest of the album was aight. But 4 stars for the bangers alone.
Another excellent album from our boy Neil Young. No idea who Crazy Horse is, I guess that’s his band doing all the instruments and stuff but Neil cooked with the folk per usual. My My, Hey Hey > Hey Hey, My My
**** Don‘t like all of them, but most
Ik had misschien wel verwacht dat ik dit album chill zou vinden. "Our House" en "Harvest Moon" vind ik prachtige nummers. Maar dit album vond ik eigenlijk best tegenvallen.
Really good. As expected, yet even a little better
This has some of my favorite Neil Young songs, but isn’t my favorite Neil album.
a bit repetitive but a good sound highlights: Sail Away, Powderfinger
very repetitive but short so it’s okay i liked the first song most
Standard NY. I don't mind his voice for a couple of tracks but it's a bit whiney for a whole album.
It’s just all a bit samey
Rust never i sleeps but i do motherfucker!
Neil Young's whiney voice is an acquired taste that I have yet to acquire despite the multiple exposures delivered by this list. File next to Dylan under 'Annoying delivery of interesting lyrics made more annoying by the addition of harmonica'
Not so bad for a Neil Young's album, but this is, ridiculously, the sixth on the list (I've probably missed some bands he was in). Are we sure this isn't just a list of 1,001 albums featuring Neil Young?
I got thrown by the opening track, it's a live recording, and it had a fade-out, felt a bit jarring. The rest of the album was okay, but yeah usual Neil Young, harmonica and whine. 2.5
Fav: Powderfinger Least Fav: Ride My Llama Even though my fav song is on the grungier b-side and my least fav song is on the folk rock a-side, I’m surprised by my preference towards side A
God blanding af hans country, folk rock agtig side og så den der proto grunge hard rock side. Første del af albummet er stille og roligt og så går det ellers amok. "It's better to burn out than fade away" skrev Kurt Cobain i sit suicide letter som er direkte citeret af Neil Young. Den rå lyd og distorted elektriske jam lyd var det som inspirerede grungen og Neil Young blev også kaldt forefather of grunge. Svært ikke at anerkende lyden af dette album og rejsen rent lydmæssigt igennem er også super fed. Han var sgu god til at reinvent ham selv også i en senere alder. improvisation er også en stor spiller i lyden og det kan man sagtens høre. Det er næsten ligesom at høre noget "live". Føler lidt at konteksten af albummet og dets indflydelse på historien og neil young som mand løfter niveauet lidt på samme måde som Johnny cash der synger hurt. Det ændrer lidt konteksten et eller andet sted.
Middle of the road, don't understand how Neil Young has so many damn albums on here
Some solid Neil
WHERE THE EAGLE GLIDES DESCENDING!!! THERE'S AN ANCIENT RIVER BENDING!!! Fav song: Thrasher
My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - 5/5 Thrasher - 4/5 Ride My Llama - 3/5 Pocahontas - 5/5 Sail Away - 5/5 Powderfinger - 5/5 Welfare Mothers - 5/5 Sedan Delivery - 5/5 Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) - 4/5 Average score: 4.5/5 (rounding up) hey hey my my
Great album
One of my top 5 all-time. Since 1979 I probably haven't gone 3 months without putting this on.
This is my second Neil Young album in 3 days. The first song on "Rust Never Sleeps" is his best. I prefer the first half of this album. The second part should have been more like the first. Wouldn't it be funny if I got another Neil Young album? 4 stars for "Rust Never Sleeps".
11/10
Favorites: hey hey my my, my my hey hey other picks: thrasher, sail away
Great lyrics and distinctive tone/mood to his voice, but many songs have same sound.
Good, I prefer Weld but solid
Nostalgic! It’s better to burn out then fade away! Still not my favorite.
Little slow, but the end picks up and is very very good. Very good
Not the first to say Young’s voice kinda sucks, but there’s plenty of great writing and instrumental talent on this album.
This is the brand of like folksy singer songwriter that does it for me. Hey hey my my x2 best ever, but everything between goes so hard as well. Thank you Neil. It’s not his strongest album but I think two more listens and this becomes a 5, so I’m just gonna give it to him.
Great album all the way through. Don't have any complaints. Great songs with cool messages. Interesting song dynamics across the album. Weak 5 just because due to his voice (not as harsh as Dylan's though)
How did I never hear powderfinger and the rest of the album other than the 2 versions of the same song (which somehow is okay)? Neil Young rules and I will listen to this alone again. 5/5
Meh- couple of good tunes but overall doesn't really do it for me. I prefer some of the other live albums.
Meh at best. First track was good, rest mid.
I enjoyed listening to this I can hear the influence he had on bands I like. Some lyrics were a bit crazy but I’m gonna smile and ignore for this review 3.5??
surprisingly good
adri: 8, un tio muy majo, musica muy maja. Música de viaje cruzando Estados Unidos. mar: 7, bonita harmonica.
Marlon Brando, Pocahontas and me.
A really quality album - one his beat
Sehr cool
its better to burn out than fade away rieeeese line. aha ich kenn sie vom kurt cobain sim abschiedsbrief. wow. findi super de song. hui mit dead weight uf thrasher meinter glaub crosby stills und nash. huere nasty. ride my llama au huere verzelli time. er singt huuere guet uf dem. uuuuh cooli chords. und bass zum erste mol halloo. mit gfallts gad mega so früe am morge zum ufwache sind super schöni warmi songs mega simpel instrumentiert. und er verzellt mega de text isch voll im vordergrund. mer ghört fast nöd dases live isch. isch alles live? nöd ganz hä. sail away isch etz chli s glich wie vorher die andere aber immerno hübsch. s chömed langsam meh instrument dezue. oke zweiti siite. ha etz überall glese dass die sochli geburtsdtund vo grunge seg. finds etz huuere soft de erst song. oke verzerrti gitarre aber tönt jetz nöd würkli andersch als andere stuff vo ihm us de 70er. welfare mothers isch etz chli hässiger scho seeehr verzerrte stuff. sedan delivery no meh. schnelle best und denn halftime mit jangly verzerrte gitarre jetz gsehni de grunge. meeega grunge huere cool wie hend sie erfunt. reprise vo hey hey hey huuuere heavy verzerrt. funktioniert au mega als hard rock song. geils solo hoi. sie singed afoch über de johnny rotten. ich find s konzept vo rust never sleeps als analogie vo mer mues sich kreativ bewege zum nöd stagniere huere geil und isch au mit en grund wiso de neil young so lang relevant gsi isch de siech het afoch witergmacht und immer sache usprobiert. finds etz nöd es rieeese meisterwerk aber gseh wie das album wegwiisend gsi isch. vieri.
hahaha freumi dank dere liste die ganz diskographie vom neil young durrezlose rust never sleeps isch echt en geilee titel my my hey hey isch halt schono schön ich han mega lang eifach s cover vom axel rudi pell kennt😭 drum tönts so akustisch fast scho komisch bis jz ischs sochli wie alles vom neil young wo ich bis jz ghört han, voll easy und iwie no herzig aber nöd meh... ich freu mich aber sehr uf de proto-grunge de neil young würkt idene zitat na wie en coole und intelligente siech? hmm also powderfinger isch sicher erfrischend gsi aber s jsch doch chli ah mier verbii? welfare mothers kenni hani s gfühl! also powderfinger isch echt cool, s solo ide mitti und v.a. au de hindergrundgsang findi super! na speziell wow sedan delivery mit ihrne tempowechsel findi recht cool damn hey hey my my het megaa verzerrti gitarre hahaha find denn de gegesatz zu sinere nasale ener höche stimm seehr cool DAS SOLOOO jap das isch sehr geil gsi han echt s gfühl, das isch sochli es speziellers album gsi? RESPEKTIV halt nur die 2. hälfti. die erst han ich nöd unglaublich spannend oder kreativ gfunde (au wenn det d lyrics sehr guet seget?) aber ja es git trotzdem es 4i, au weg de kulturelle wichtigkeit
Wonderful record
More rock than I thought. Not as catchy as I like it, but a good rock album overall.
Didn’t listened
Awesome
4/10 - nothing really to write home about. A very forgettable and somewhat generic set of songs. However I do appreciate that they are played very well live
I enjoyed powder finger I felt like this album was a wanna be bob Dylan singing mediocre songs about native Americans. Only one or 2 songs grabbed me and I found it to be dull for the most part.
100/100
Good
Cover 5 The songs aren't horrible but too hippie-ish for me. Some cheese lyrics. Some of it is cringey although with good intentions I'm sure.
Rust Never Sleeps is a great album and I thoroughly recommend giving it a listen.
Mellow and pleasant yet wistful and angry. That's Neil Young for you, in general. Some of the album is partly live and some of it's partly country. It's also famously an early precursor to grunge. In 1979, this album does stand more with the recently-emerged punks than it does with the highly-ornamented, drug-soaked industry of what rock & roll had become at the time. It's meaningful that the record is so country-tinged, stripped down and borderline lackadaisical. Is it a required listen, though? It's probably worth a listen but, even as Neil Young albums go, this isn't as good as Harvest. The thing about having a list that's 1001 albums long is that it's going to be largely padding. This is pretty good padding, but make no mistake: you're here to hear "My My, Hey Hey" and "Hey Hey, My My" and those bookend the album (due respect to Powderfinger).
One of the great songwriters, in peak form.
Love the acoustic sounds and pure guitar with a focus on the persecution of natives and longing for nature in the lyrics. His voice is a bit odd, but doesn’t take much away from the experience
Good ol’ Neil. He’s just having a Crazy Horse time.
I was not expecting to become a Neil Young fan after starting this project, yet here I am. Is this better than On The Beach? No. Is this still a really good album? Yes. Plenty of good substance here to uncover. The guitar work really does stand out in this record I think, mores than most of Neil Young's music - where his voice tends to take centre stage. This record feels way more rock oriented than Neil Young's more folky tunes he's known for. I didn't hate that! Anyways, not a whole heap to write about this one. It was a lovely listen, I won't be rushing back though - there's definitely better Neil Young records I'd go to first. Favourite song has gotta be Powderfinger though, banger.
I can tolerate Neil Young as a singer but I feel like he would be so fucking annoying if he was nagging me about something with that voice
This is my first solo Neil Young album. I’ve not consciously listened to Neil Young before. My My Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - I had no idea that the Chromatics track Into The Black wasn’t an original. I quite like this version too, very different of course. Great lyrics and central chord progression. Into the Black was a nice followup to this and closer for the album. Thrasher - quite liked the instrumentals and songwriting on this. This album is a bit of a fairybread sandwich, I liked the bread more than the filling. Not great, not terrible. Highlights: My My Hey Hey (Out of the Blue), Thrasher, My My Hey Hey (Into The Black)
Neil Young has an unreal ability to consistently be the worst part of any album he appears on.
Man I love this guys voice. Surprise masterpiece 10/10
Two very different sides, I enjoyed Side A far more than Side B. Reading about the album before listening I really thought I would enjoy the more electric side more but Young's lyricism and the acoustic tone of the first half really hits differently than the second half. Powderfinger is an evergreen song but the rest of the tracks on the second half don't hold a candle to a track like Thrasher. Was tempted to give this a 4 because the tracks on the first half are just that good, but on repeat listens I found myself going back to the first track right after Powderfinger ends. Highlights: My, My, Hey, Hey (Out of the Blue), Thrasher, Powderfinger
Shit album
Best Song: My My, Hey Hey This is fine. I've never particularly been into Neil Young, he's like Canadian Bob Dylan. My My, Hey Hey is a great tune though.
Love Neil, just saw him live last night! Serendipity
Surprisingly enjoyable. He's found a bit of energy from somewhere
It was okay
Good
classic
I prefer his full band rock material to the more folky, acoustic output so things picked up in the second half for me.
My personal favorite Neil Young album
Forgot what was even in this album. Classic Neil and Crazy Horse. Got to see him last year playing some of these.
I am not rust, I'm sleepy
Me ha parecido un discazo, que va de menos a más. Es un disco muy potente con una guitarras increíbels. Neil ha creado un disco increíble.
3/5
Neil Young at the peak of his popularity. The solo songs are excellent and beautifully performed. On the solo side he sings quite superbly (I like his voice!). The Electric side is the weaker of the two, but still has some quite brilliant songs. 5*. Would I listen again? Yes, I do regularly. Would I buy this album? I did. 1 "My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)" 03:45 The acoustic version. Wonderful song, beautifully sung. - 5* 2 "Thrasher" 05:38 Again, a beautifully sung tale. Excellent lyrics. Neil Young's acoustic guitar playing is wonderful to listen to. - 5* 3 "Ride My Llama" 02:29 The narrative on the songs are interesting, including this one. - 5* 4 "Pocahontas" 03:22 A fantastic song. Brilliantly sung. I love the rhythm that you can hear Young slapping/keeping on the guitar. - 5* 5 "Sail Away" 03:46 Excellent. Lovely melody. - 5* 6 "Powderfinger" 05:30 The electric side. This is a great song. Brilliant guitar from Young. The solo is very melodic. - 5* 7 "Welfare Mothers" 03:48 The Horse does Garage Rock. This starts off and I think "Why is this here? Spoiling what has come before." That's partly the point I think. The strange juxtaposition of "D-i-v-o-r-c-eeee" with the music makes me smile. Great guitar. - 4* 8 "Sedan Delivery" 04:40 More Garage Rock. Has much the same effect on me as Welfare Mothers. Riff driven. - 4* 9 "Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)" 05:18 The electric version. Stunning. Heavy. Brilliant. - 5* Total - 43/45 Average - 4.78
7/10
Not for me
had some really good songs on it and i liked the live sound
было отлично погулять в лесу
One of the two best Neil Young albums imo. Powderfinger is one of his strongest tracks, in storytelling and musical. My My, Hey Hey are both good tracks. Rock 'n' roll can never die!
Begrijpelijk dat dit werd gespeeld op Kurt Cobain's begrafenis. Fantastisch album met een iconisch, tijdloos openingsnummer. Rock and roll will never die. Zijt maar zeker. 4.5
Awesome good voice great lyrics. Definitely prefer the acoustic side strong 4*
The older I get the more Neil Young becomes one of my favorite artists. Country Rock, Hard Folk Rock, Proto-Grunge. The riffs, the distortion, the lyrics. Another banger. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Très très cool, ambiance US, petit porche autour de la maison, rocking chair et soirée d'été
Good laid back album with Hey, Hey, My My
I would give this an album a 3.5/5 if this site let me. Very solid. Electric set goes crazy.
4/5 Classic.
I like it because the lyrics , I recommended because is pretty good you can feel the lyrics.
I think you would like to hear my review about this album because it think you would like to hear about my opinion, i didnt like the album because the instraments and the lyrics sounded depresing
Volim njega, ali iskreno ima mi puno boljih albuma od ovog, stoga malo niža ocjena. 3/5, 6/10
Banging
Powderfinger is as good as it gets. Don’t get many songs with stories that good. Rest of the album is definitely a good listen but towards the end loses a little steam
Everyone tells me I should like you Neil Young and everybody tells you that you should like me but when the time comes and we try spooning on the couch there's just no spark. Sorry, pal.
I think Neil Young gives Bob Dylan real run for his money for best American musician/poet. His lyrics are less creative, but I think are truer to the American experience (especially since they are dumbed down) and he's definitely a more talented musician. damn
Tää oli kiva!
Itselle tämä albumi kolahti oikein kunnolla. Heart of goldiakin parempi.
Toimii!
Crazy good album, so many good songs. The guitar tone on hey hey my my is ahead of its time
Ya, good rock.
Neil Young is an acquired taste. At least that's the true for me. Sure he had some songs that instantly struck me, like Rockin in the Free World. But his voice, however distinctive, wasn't really something I sought out. I've never listened to a single one of his albums straight through, so I wasn’t sure how I’d view this. It helped that this album started with My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue), an instantly recongnizable song and a classic. Thrasher is an interesting song, love the theme of it, but it just kind of sits there and then fades out. Other than the lyrics, it didn't really move me. Similar reaction to Ride My Llama, though I liked the music more and the lyrics less. Pocohontas is just a weird song - singing about the plight of the indians and then end up singing about the Astrodome and Marlon Brando? Just really strange lyrics. Sail Away I liked a lot better. I could see some people not liking this, but I thought it was just a more well constructed song than the previous few. All in all, though, an uneven first half. It's interesting how this album shifts from solo acoustic to electric with Crazy Horse for the second half. Unique and I liked the construct. Powderfinger is a cool tune, loved the lead guitar work on this. I was less a fan of Welfare Mothers, it's fine but it felt pretty basic to me. Sedan Delivery picks back up, a straight rocker with an interesting viewpoint. The highlight of this album is the dichotomy in styles from the first half to the second, underscored by the different versions of My My, Hey Hey. It's hard to say whether the Blue or Black version is really better (the distortion in the guitars at the beginning of the electric version is very cool), both are great, despite the repetition. To be honest, just focusing on the songs, I'd probably be at a 3 for this. However, given how this album has two distinct halves and the fact that he could take the same song in My My, Hey Hey and make it sound considerably different depending upon whether he goes acoustic or electric? This combines to elevate it for me, making it deserving of a 4. It's far from a perfect album though.
One of my favourites. Powderfinger and My My, Hey Hey are probably my best songs
I didn't overly love it but the guitars were awesome
Only one listen through so far. But I like Neil as chill out music.
country ass
All done!
Average. Not a fan of the live album.
Neil Young doing Neil Young, what he wants to, 4 Star
Solid Neil Young album. My 2nd in about a week and a half, and it was another enjoyable listen. I still don't think Neil Young will enter my listening rotation when the challenge is over, but I'm glad I'm checking out some of his stuff. 3.5 / 5
I am always a fan when artists do different stuff for different sides/halves of the album. Such as Low (by David Bowie) where the first half is these repetitive rock/pop songs and the second half is ambient, anyways enough David Bowie. Pretty cool how Neil Young does solo acoustic for the first half and then Electric with a backing band in the second half. This is my first impression of Neil Young (apart from listening to Heart of Gold) and I would say it was a good impression.
Side A (the acoustic side) approaches five-star quality, peaking with the stunning Thrasher. Those five songs are the best of Young's career. Maybe the contrast is an integral part of what makes the record great, but I can't help but find the B-side to be a let-down, as virtuosic and forward-looking as the proto-grunge work on it is. But man, does some of this stuff rip, right before hitting you upside the head. "I just turned 22/I was wondering what to do/And the closer they got, the more those feelings grew." This is one of those albums where I'm shocked by the negative reception it has on this site. To me, this is an obvious 4+ star lock, one of a few dozen key records in the rock canon. Never would have guessed it at 3.52 on here. An aside: this made me wonder whether Neil Young was the first to do the acoustic/electric dichotomy thing with a centrepiece song on an album, as he does with Out of the Blue/Into the Black. Yo La Tengo's Big Day Coming jumps out. Mistress by Red House Painters. Rust Never Sleeps > Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere > On the Beach > After the Gold Rush > Harvest
I'm a fan of Neil Young but not a fan of him trying to be a "must see live" performer
The movement from acoustic to electric happens so perfectly I didn't even realize what was happening on the first listen. To be honest I didn't care much for side A apart from My, My but side B more than makes up for it. Powderfinger and Sadan Delivery were phenomenal.
Preferred this over After the Gold Rush, which I already know is going to be a controversial opinion. Let’s just say I prefer Neil Young doing rock over folk, his voice is less grating for me. I do like his instrumentation more on this album, but I felt it took to long to get to a proper rock ‘n’ roll sound, it was a bit too laidback in the beginning. This is an improvement from the last album of his I listened to but its brought me to the conclusion that I’m not a Neil Young fan.
Just an insanely boring album, I couldn't even finish it.
Loved enough Young/Horse to be completely disappointed in this one. Not enough character
Great album. The second side was a bit of a shock after the gentle acoustic side 1! Loved the guitar work on Powderfinger.
Loved this. Great songs, great vibe with a huge array of sounds across the album. Super nostalgic feeling with strong production, and I’ll definitely come back to this.
Blir bättre med mer lyssning. Bra intro till Neil Young.
- neil young up there with john darnielle in terms of great guys who don’t really sing - something truly magical about a harmonica - the guitar is incredibly soulful. things that are nothing to say - the electric guitar on powderfinger was unexpected - huge fan of the bookending songs that’s very cool - something i think i would enjoy much more if it were live - 3 stars but not adding!
is good
It was really good. I liked how Neil Young could convey what is like to be a musician with some of his songs. Then, sing about how Welfare mothers make better lovers. I listen to a lot of the albums in this project on the way to work. This is an album that I have to sit down in a quiet room in order to fully appreciate.
Scusi Neil Young und du Crazy Horse, irgendwie hets mi ned gross catched und es isch tendenziell eher es geskippeds album gsi. Biz unfairi zwei rostigi Pferd
Oh maaan. Direkt mitm beste song gstarted. Hypahypa, unf frnn rifach biz boting witer. Schwirig, was sellid mit da na mache :/ Glaub muss doch fast na 3 sternlis geh
my my hey hey riitet de frechdachs eifach sis lama vo peru bis uf texarkana isch das tatsächlich neil young album #5? oder #4? ufjedefall chli zu viel des guten für min gschmack gid trotzdem 3 chritz, weil eigentlich scho noch sweet
Very familiar with these songs and love them all.
Peak Neil Yound & Crazy Horse!!
3,4/5
A great live Neil Young record.
It’s ok
Not bad.
Favourite song - Pocahontas. I'd describe this as Cowboy Rock and quite enjoyed it, apart from the distorted sound occasionally. 3 or 4
Instrumental Hip-Hop Liked "Midnight in a perfect world"
Four stars. some of his earlier albums were way better... 'nuff said... next...
Excellent Neil Young album. Another great mix of heartbreaking folk and hard-rocking guitar. The opening track is the highlight, but there are strong tracks throughout. Apparently some of the album was recorded live in concert and finished in studio — that’s cool! It definitely has a live and unpolished feel in the best way. I don’t think I’ve ever heard the reprise of “My My, Hey Hey” that closes the album. It’s really heavy! The feedback and grit is really rough. Great stuff.
"My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)" is probably Neil Young's 4th or 5th best song, and it's amazing. It's beautiful and sad, and the guitar part is so melancholic that it fits the lyrics about as well as an instrument can fit a voice. I personally admire this quality in his songwriting as I know it's hard to do- and he accomplishes this so masterfully you would think the guitar is another limb on his body. I always found the quote "it's better to burn out than to fade away" to be so sad and profound for people who have that pessimistic kind of world view. Of course this was the infamous quote in Kurt Cobain's suicide note. But this album is a lot more than that song. The rest is full of great folky rock and heavy rock tracks that go through a slew of emotions and tempos. Neil Young to me has always been about being a master of restraint; he always holds on to tensions really well, and experiments with amazing sounding fuzzes on guitars without ever once overdoing it. This album is a low-to-mid 4 for me, I think a 4.3/5. The reprise at the end is so heavy, and sick. I love it.
There was an era where I listened to this album every day. I don’t remember much about that time in my life. Other than Hey, Hey and Powderfinger, I also didn’t remember much about the songs on this album!
Classic album that got a lot of play when I was in colllege.
Classic Neil Young. Pocahontas and My My and Hey Hey stand out. Better to burn out than fade away.
Live album. Folk / Americana. My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - Great lyrics. 'It's better to burn out than fade away'. This album is obviously poetic with some great lyrics. It's hard for me to identify with though. The great plains of the US and wondering yonder etc is a world away from working class England, endless grey and urbanisation.
It's a chemical mixture of elements, so of course not.
Very good
The 16 year old me ordered this LP from Columbia House specifically for the bookend tracks, and at that time the middle was not a play through for me. Forty years later, I appreciate the full work much more. The standouts for me are still the bookends plus “Welfare Mothers” and “Sedan Delivery”.
I think this album makes it 6+ appearances in this exercise for Neil either as a soloist or as part of CSNY. That’s just silly and way overrated. Ironically it’s this album which does deserve to be here and definitely outshines some earlier efforts. One would think that the half acoustic/half electric model would be imbalanced, but the production and song choice really make it a well balanced listen. I really dug this. And it’s easy to see why bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam have cited this record as a major influence.
Really liked this, loved the chill vibes and love tracks.
Lots of Neil young in this exercise. I feel like all my reviews are probably the same. This is good and Neil has some great songs, but on my hole, the albums just don’t blow me away. 3.25
Another day, another Neil Young album. I did enjoy this one... love the riff on Hey Hey, My My. Good little variety here and an interesting approach with mostly live recordings with overdubs. Rounding up. 3.5/5
2.7 Made the mistake of reading the album blurb before listening? Precursor to grunge? Sign me up. Alas, other than the opening (and closing) track, it just didn't click at all with me. Really nothing that I would put on again. Didn't hate it, but didn't love it. Neil Young appears yet again, but not certain why this time.
second half is weaker, ya know, i said it
Just fine, not something I would find myself relistening to but certainly didn’t mind the listen
Stunning. The guitar work on this is some of Young’s best, and the decision to overdub live tracks gives these songs a fantastic depth in sound. Some of Youngs best songs on display here, and it’s always a good time when he’s recording with Crazy Horse.
Ok for background
‘Pocahontas’ captures what I find so risible about Neil Young. It starts by describing the Native American genocide in boilerplate terms: 'they killed the buffalo', 'they came with their firesticks', 'modern life is all shingled roofs and taxicabs'. It's trite, but harmless. Next though, he describes how he wants to fuck Pocahontas so she can tell him how she ‘felt’ about it, while Neil (we can imagine) noodles on the guitar and tells her how she's 'totally right on, man'. The track's final image, and I suspect Young's real fantasy, is of he and Pocahontas sitting around a fire discussing indigenous rights with Marlon Brando. Shortly after this track there's a corker about how Welfare Mothers make better lovers. Here Neil is even more out to sea than he was with the Native Americans, with the only touchstones he can conjure being the city laundromat and loitering on the street with her multitude of children. I guess you could say that anything Neil Young is about the guitar playing: make a fucking guitar album then Neil, and keep your trap shut. 1*
I’m not crazy (horse) about this album, but I respect what Young was trying to do with this project. The whole ‘rust’ concept as an allegory for rock music becoming comfortable and complacent is kind of interesting; I give him that. But I’m not in love with a lot of these songs. On to what I do love: Hey Hey, My My, and Powderfinger. All timers in my opinion. The live production is used to incredible effect to bring these songs to life. In particular, the distortion effects from the former give the song this wild and unpredictable energy. The increasing distortion throughout the song feels as if the band is breaking down - dare I say grinding on in spite of the rust. As an average guitarist, these songs also bring me a lot of joy to play. Young doesn’t aim for accuracy here. The mess of distortion and ‘missed’ notes makes for a highly accessible sound for wannabe’s like me to try emulate. So some of these songs resonate strongly with me, but I have to kind of shrug at the bulk of the material. Live Rust on the other hand is a different story, and I’ll be highly disappointed if this one made the list instead.
love the mix of classic almost 80s’ rock and some country stuff. not really my thing, yet i enjoyed it. 7/10 for me
Nežinau. Atrodo kaip ir viskas fainai, bet nu prailgo albumas. Ne mano cup of tea, B side biškutį išgelbėjo, na ir title track tikrai klasika ir nuostabi daina. O daugiau, nežinau. Nesu fanas. 2.5/5.
Kinda just boring.
I really don't care for Neil Young's voice, country styled rock, or indeed this album, though I may concur with some of the sentiments here. I don't get why this is an album I *must* listen to!
1. hey - 2.5 2. trazher - 1.5 3. llama - 1.5 4. pocahontaz - 1.5 5. zail - 2.5 6. finger - 1.5 7. uuelfare - 0 8. zedan - 1 9. my - 2.5
5 star classic
A few decent songs (Thrasher, Pocahontas, Powderfinger) and utterly forgettable ones (Ride My Llama, Welfare Mothers, Sedan Delivery) sandwiched between an absolute banger cooked two ways. It's fine.
I liked it. It wasn't a love i don't think. With neil young ive always struggled but this was nice :)
I actually ended up listening to this before bed… I really enjoyed it! I like Neil Young and I love the electric sound that Crazy Horse brings. I enjoyed the lyrics to the songs too. Very good
I’m
Haven’t listened to hey hey my my in years and had completely forgotten it’s existence so that was a nice surprise. The rest was kinda forgettable.
No notes.
I thoroughly enjoyed this one, but I am a longtime Neil Young fan. That said I understand his vocals and even his musical style may not be for everyone.
Didn’t enjoy this one, his live album Weld is better (and all electric). Late 70s Neil seems really erratic, wonder if fewer drugs and an editor could have helped him not release so many poorly constructed songs.
Why must y’all torment me with so much Neil Young? --This was better than some other albums but all Neil Young has a low ceiling for me.
I didn't hate it as much as I thought I would. Neil's voice definitely takes some getting used to but there are some really pretty songs on this album.
Kende alleen "Hey Hey, My My". De rest van de plaat ook zeer degelijk.
Some bangers. One classic (maybe 2)
Not so good , best song I'd say is Welfare Mothers, but it sounds oddly similar to Tie Your Mother Down of Queen....never been a big fan of Neil Young, but I have been trying to enjoy him more these days so I was pretty happy getting this album, and then I was kind of disappointed. Not horrible by any means of course! Just not my kind of music really..
Pretty boring. Almost like a folksy version of nico & the velvet underground. I appreciate Neil Young's songwriting but pretty boring all together.
The beginning of the album was okay but by the last couple songs I was feeling a little over it… not bad but I probably wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to the full album again!
I thought this was solid throughout. Good background music. Best track = Hey Hey,My My (Into The Black)
Nope. I don't like live albums for the most part. This is one of them. It's not that the music is bad and sometimes concerts are fun to listen to, but 90% of the time for me, it's annoying. 2/5 because it's not terrible.
Hey Hey + My My. Acoustic and electric. The acoustic side carries you along by the strength of its lyrics and imagery. Really well done. The electric side...well, it electrifies the way Neil Young and Crazy Horse tend to do. Great stuff but hampered by "Welfare Mothers," which may be ironic but I'm not in on the joke yet. As much as I expected the opposite, I'd say the acoustic side may actually be stronger, but you really don't have to decide. Just listen all the way through, enjoy, and then listen again to try to make sense of it all.
This album is great in that it covers such a wide range of Neil Young's iterations. You have the solo acoustic Neil, the electric Neil, the earthy Neil and the cosmic Neil all in one gutsy performance. I still like his studio albums better, but it is a great view of the artist in action.
one of the greatest albums of all time
I forget how much I enjoy his voice. The music is there and very American-y. He sings to you like a friend who cares.
I pretty much know what to expect from a Neil Young album at this point. It's fairly good, though in general I don't love too much country stuff and don't care for live albums. Touching though
i do not like this man i do not want more neil young records
Pretty solid, only a few songs that really stuck with me but its all solid. Easy listen, probably a 3.5
I didn't really like folk rock until I heard this album. Easy to listen to, meaningful lyrics, and great storytelling. Not perfect, but close.
I'm biased given I've listened to this forever but actually listened again and heard new things like how some of the other tracks (not HHMM/MMHH) were also recorded live, and a lot of backing vocals and sound effects I'd never heard on Ride Your LLama. It's a mad album. Half the tracks are very trippy lyrically. Then you have Welfare Mothers which I'm never entirely sure about, and the opener and closer ehich are classics. Then a Civil war song. It's great.
Perfect for a Sad Girl Walk. My mood has almost definitely impacted the rating
This good stuff. I think I preferred the acoustic parts on first listen, however I may have to give it further goes. Weirdly thrasher just reminds me of a mix of have you ever seen the rain and everybody's talkin', like quite a close rip of in some parts... but I can't seem to find anyone else saying the same online which is unusual. Anyway. Fun album.
Beginning to think I’m not much of a fan of Neil Young
So good. Only complaint is that I associate this with Cobains death.
Decent
My ancestry.ca kit told me that I carry all of the genetic traits to enjoy this fully but I just cannot fully. May need a shrink
Enjoyed this one a lot.
meh
This has been a favorite of mine since 1999. Love just about every track!
A bit light for a long listen, but still a lot of talent going on.
Still not a Neil Young Fan. Finally started to rock a bit in the last few songs and it was over. His voice just doesn’t do it for me.
I was excited when I heard the first song. I’ve always loved it. Then I didn’t recognize or like any of the other ones (except for the last one). Lol
Bro can't pronounce llama. Some decent highs but some tracks I really just hoped would end
Is was kind of boring for me. Not my favorite. I could see liking it more if I grew up listening to this or had more ties to it.
It was a nice listen, but the voice wasn’t my favorite.
Listens: 3-4 Standout tracks: Hey Hey, My My and My My Hey Hey Added to Library: TRUE The premise of "rust never sleeps" is an insightful one; something we should all keep in mind. You gotta keep moving lest we become complacent in the things we do.
Ganz nices easy listening. Und sicher weltbewegend für die zeit. Lyrisch ganz vorn. Aber reißt halt echt nich mit 😅
Very good one, but I prefer studio recordings. Great songs, great harmonies, great songwriting. Fav Track: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)
Kinda lame Favorites: My My, Hey Hey(Out of the Blue), Powderfinger
Favorite Track: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)
https://rateyourmusic.com/music-review/JesseOverPessi/neil-young-and-crazy-horse/rust-never-sleeps/255561821
5/7/2025: boring, dumb lyrics, bad voice, this guy sucks.
It's Neil Young, so it's not bad, but it's not overly good either. Nothing really stands out to me apart from the interesting album structure. I can see why this was influential for a lot of folks, but it's not really working for me.
I’ve listened to this a few times through now. The imagery and storytelling is so evocative. Interesting structure with one half acoustic and one half electric, bookended by the same song in different forms. Powderfinger is the standout for me - I’m biased because it’s my husband’s favourite Neil Young song and Hayden covers it live sometimes.
When I was 18 I actually spent a lot of time hunting down this record. I had discovered Neil Young through the radio. I bought harvest and loved it. I really wanted to find the album that had Hey Hey My My on it. Unfortunately, the cd was out of print at the time (or that's what google said). This was before spotify... so I remember going to like 15 different cd stores looking for it... and nothing. Eventually I bought a copy online... handed my parents credit card info over to some sketchy site... and boom I finally had a copy. Luckily, it lived up to the hype. I would listen to this album constantly while driving around the country in my green jeep grand cherokee. It was a 5 out of 5 for me then for sure. Recently, I actually revisited it on a whim... not as part of this challenge. And it holds up pretty damn well. I love the transition from acoustic to electric over the course of the album. I love how its bookended with 2 versions of the same classic song. The electric version of hey hey my my just hits so fucking hard. The distortion is like a sledgehammer. Thrasher is one of my all-time favourite Neil Young songs... an amazing folk song about quitting society and walking into the woods and the passage of time (or something like that). "It was then that I knew I'd had enough, Burned my credit card for fuel, Headed out to where the pavement turns to sand." Incredible lyrics. Powderfinger does such a great job of transitioning from the folk side to the electric side. On Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery, you can feel the influence of punk on Young which is just cool. Sail away and Pocahontas are just pretty (sad) folk songs. There's no real bad song on this album for me... sure some of the lyrics are a bit wonky (may don't age well). It's probably a 4 for me now? And that almost feels harsh. Perhaps it just couldn't live up to the memory of discovering to the album 15 years ago
I enjoyed this! Great opening track. Admittedly I fell asleep while listening to this on the train.
I like the guy's voice a lot it has a nice nasally and kinda weak sound, like a thread pulled tight. Big fan. Otherwise a generic and boring album, not my thing. 2/5 stars.
Not my favorite. Neil Young is talented, but too jammy for my taste.