What's Going On by Marvin Gaye

What's Going On

Marvin Gaye

3.94
Rating
29756
Votes
1
1%
2
6%
3
24%
4
35%
5
34%
Distribution

Reviews (page 8 of 14)

No notes. I am a sucker for songs that go into each other

From the first listen, love the funky vibes of this lp. I feel like a fool for not listening to this earlier; wow! I'm swimming in a pool of lush instrumentation that sounds better as the record progresses. Thoroughly enjoyed this and felt Marvin pouring his heart out on 'Wholy Holy'.

Fascinating bit of soul music. Meanders a bit, but that's rewarding if you just let yourself follow the movement. The singles still stand out to me more than the rest of the tracks, but it's solid.

Iconic album but with a some amazing songs. 4.5 stars

Good album. Love the transitions.

Perfection of the expression of the soul.

A beautiful album

Приятное, текучее звучание

when I look at the world, it fills me with sorrow

The top end of this is as good as anything in his catalogue. Like, "Trouble Man" good. But I forgot how much preachy meandering he stuffs in between the beauty.

I've never understood why people around here act like the mercury in the fish is news when Marvin Gaye knew about it in 1971. Come to think of it, all this shit was supposed to get fixed in the 70s. Five-star album, though.

A classic album one long prayer in my mind and done in such a soulful way. Got to listen to it in the order it was designed.

Hm, this gets a lot of praise but maybe this album just didn't click with me. Good musicality, Gaye is an icon, but the album was ok for me, 3*

Good stuff!

A cool dude.

Yah I had very mixed feelings about this album. Like genuinely strong feelings both positive and negative. Like right off the back, I totally prefer the b sides. Like the second half of the album I like way more than the first half. Really the only songs I actively didn’t enjoy was the religious songs. But I don't have constructive criticism for that, I just don’t like religious songs. But there’s literally nothing else you could even possibly criticize. The instrumentation is heavenly and buttery smooth which could also describe his perfect vocals. I totally understand why this album is always in lists of greatest albums of all time, it’s so endearing. I didn’t love it immediately, it did grow on me over time, but man this is an all time classic.

Really good album!

- super soulful ballads - jazzy elements - nice hand drum beats - easy to listen too and super catchy - no song that stood out in particular - „Inner Child“: probably favorite song

"Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" will be the last song I ever listen to via this project. What a triumphant way to end it.

A true classic. Nothing more to say.

Groovy, meaningful. The definition of soul music. 4/5

Don't like it a lot

"Mercy mercy me" +2, solid album from start to finish, social commentary and catchy.

What can I say that hasn't been said. If this isn't a solid 5, some of y'all are not truly listening. This is why it's called Soul now, because you invest yourself and your future self in this masterpiece. The beginning of a legendary run of albums.

Kind of boring but nothing wrong with it

Good, languid tones, but it starts getting real preachy fast. I do feel like Gaye was trying to address the ills of the world in his own way, but perhaps looking back on it in 2025, it comes across as a bit sanctimonious.

Curiously it seems as though all the songs seamlessly transition, it makes for a nice uninterrupted listen. The sentiments of the songs are in the right place but not all the lyrics hit home, especially on save the children. Marvin has a great singing voice.

Can't deny that this is inherently good music, however I just couldn't help feeling bored during parts of it. Overall really solid, but not 5-star solid.

Groovy with great vocals, what more could you want? The songs all did sound very similar, that's my one complaint.

So ahead of his time it's impressive.

Well, certainly one of my favourite albums. And historically important. No wonder Rolling Stones consider it the best album of all times (status: list from 2020).

Top tier soul album, the transition from God is Love to Mercy Mercy Me is transcendent

Lost me at "God is Love" yeah right.

At one point I've disconnected my headphones and didn't realize. Never knew that this is the original for Ecology. Pretty okay.

Classic fantastic album

Great album

It's Motown, it's Marvin Gaye. A good combination for a good record, especially if it's Blues and Soul. Inner City Blues is my favorite, and still as relevant as it was 50 years ago. Most other tracks are too religious for my taste.

Impeccable. Important. Too much religion for me and “Save the Children “ is a bit much for the modern ear. But still , a masterpiece nonetheless.

Not bad, could listen to this while sitting at a beach bar chilling.

El disco tiene música genial, llena de soul y de ritmos envolventes. Obviamente me encanta la voz de Marvin Gaye, pero el álbum me pareció que tiene letras que un tanto flojas o más bien, no tanto lo que esperaba en un disco de soul y amor. Temas de religión, naturaleza, etc. que me sonaron más a querer quedar bien con algunos sectores que a predicar el dulce amor del soul.

Points for the undeniable talent on show. But the music does nothing for me

A great album, Honestly timeless. 0 skips, all great grooves. The flow from song to song is virtually seamless. Being forced to listen to this daily would not be a punishment.

Wow! Social injustice, war, police brutality, environmental destruction - I had never heard this album and it's not my typical choice of genre but this album was great from beginning to end.

Good album, but a little too soft from time to time.

100/100.

The album you play when world peace happens. Favourite Songs: What's Going On, Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky), Save the Children, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler). Least Favourite Songs: God Is Love.

at it's best it's beautiful soul, but there are a few slow patches and it can feel a bit samey at times too.

4/5 Cries for Help That Sound Like Heaven Review: This album is a velvet-wrapped scream. Marvin Gaye doesn’t just sing—he testifies. Every track feels like a sacred moment in a conversation humanity keeps avoiding. It’s soul music with actual soul—bleeding, grieving, loving. You think you’re just vibing, but halfway through, you realize your heart’s being rearranged. And it still manages to sound cooler than any other album in its wake.

I liked it. The hits were the highlight

me encanta la musica de negros!! super chill este disco no lo conocia y al artista tampoco. un gran descubrimiento. me gusta como junta canciones entre si. definitivamente volvere a recurrir a el en algun momento . 8,5/10

I’ve tried hard over the years. It’s fine but not mine.

It is a decent record I guess but in no way can I connect with it. Too much love and jesus for my taste

A stone cold classic. I haven’t listened to the album in over 30 years. The song that I loved this time around was “Right On.”

A pagentry of soul

Easy 5 star

Man, that A-side is utterly fantastic, showing exactly why albums are so important, and can often triumph over a song-by-song listening experience. So much to say in one medley, and it all is not only peaceful and catchy, but thought-provoking and even devastating in modern contexts. However, the B-side is extremely ho-hum to me, to a pretty bad extent. You have two tracks too long and aimless for their own good, and a bible thumping cheese-fest sandwiched between to only lead to a lacking finale. I can see why one would like the final track, but after that glorious string of songs on the A-side, and even other Marvin Gaye tracks off other albums, I know better exists, and it deters me from it a little bit. A good album, certainly, but the best of all time just feels like a stretch.

A classic.

Amazing voice and grooves, though didn't connect with a lot of the songs.. kind of like it more as background. Standouts: What's Going On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Look I like ‘What’s Going On’, but I don’t think I love it. The singles from it are excellent and incredible, but the rest of it is a bit repetitive. However, it’s hard to ignore that it’s a landmark record and all the context around it. Its universally acclaimed, praised and loved, it’s just that I probably like some of Gaye’s other stuff more. Sorry…not sorry. 3/5, but adding another 1 for impact and legacy so 4/5.

great album. All kinda flows together though. Not a lot of changes. Like Neil said, “it’s all one song.” Still an incredible album.

It seems like so often when "What's Going On" is used in movies it's some light-hearted, loving sort of scene. I've been lied to this whole time. This is a Vietnam war protest album. Oh damn this album got very religious

The production value is pretty incredible. Delicate but wonderfully layered. Love the strings and the background vocals. An easy 35 minute listen. Not my music, but I can appreciate it for what it is.

I absolutely love a concept record, and this one is more relevant than ever, even if it was made some 50 years ago. The connections between each song are so beautiful and masterfully done, keeping the flow of the story clear in the listeners ears. The instrumentals were impeccable, fitting the tone of each song, but also the album as a whole, perfectly. I especially enjoyed the back and forth nature of the song "Save the Children," which provided an interesting but beautiful structure. The thing that held this album back for me was it's mellow and laid-back vibe, whereas I'm one who is partial to albums that pack an auditory punch. For this reason, I at times felt bored or out of touch to the album if I weren't to be actively the lyrics. This doesn't mean it isn't a great album, I just appreciate something a little louder and more aggressive. Overall, this was great. 3/5 stars

I quite liked this - it might be something I come back to and get obsessed with. Listening 50 odd years on, I feel that the music holds up, and some songs had a lot to say. :)

Easy 5/5

Absolute Classic album. “What’s Going On” is a soulful masterpiece that’s both a snapshot of early 1970s America and a timeless cry for compassion and justice. It’s emotional, beautiful, and deeply human, with just a touch too much God

quiero escucharlo más veces, porque no estoy habituado a este tipo de música. El último tema es un pepino

A classic for good reason. Big fan of the multi-layered jazz arrangements.

Great voice, fun to listen to

A true classic

Marvin Gaye’s What’s Going On is often described as a “landmark album,” which is confusing because it’s not a building, a statue, or even a hill. But metaphorically, it’s a hill—a big soulful one where Marvin stands at the top shouting, “Guys, the world’s on fire!” Released in 1971, at a time when America was knee-deep in war, smog, and moustaches, the album was Marvin’s way of asking, “What’s going on?”—a bold question considering nobody’s really known since about 1842. The songs are smooth and sad, like a dolphin weeping into a velvet cushion, and they tackle issues like environmental collapse, inner-city poverty, and people generally being a bit rubbish to each other. One track, “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)”, is basically Marvin apologising to the planet, which is impressive because most people don’t even say sorry when they hit a pigeon with a Segway. Listening to the album is like attending a very funky United Nations meeting, where every delegate is Marvin Gaye and they all brought bongos. It changed the way people thought about soul music, turning it from “Let’s dance and fall in love” to “Let’s sit down and have a serious think about systemic injustice while still dancing a little bit.” Marvin went rogue from Motown’s usual policy of singing about sugar and heartbreak and instead created a sonic tapestry of concern, sorrow, and flutes. The album still sounds fresh today—like it was recorded in the future and sent back to warn us, which would explain why it’s so eerily accurate about everything we’re still ignoring. In many ways, What’s Going On predicted the modern world: rising inequality, environmental disaster, and the constant sense that nobody knows what they’re doing—including, probably, Marvin himself, who at least had the decency to ask.

A really thoughtful album that has some much going on. Fun and uplifting songs that are easy to relax to. A little too religious for me personally. I also really enjoyed how the album does end on a more serious note, that despite all the positivity there are still bad things happening; helps keep its message grounded. Top tracks: What's Going On, What' Happening Brother, Inner City Blues

Oh I just know this is going to be so, so good. I think I’ll probably listen to it late at night tonight while I’m packing for Gdańsk. :)) Yupp. Easy 5/5. Wow, just wow. His voice and the production are both so silky and so, so emotive.

Marvin ilohuuli huhhuh

Não é um álbum ruim, achei bem feito e produzido. Entretanto, não acho que ouviria novamente. Nada dele realmente me pegou.

Marvin’s soulful plea of “why can’t we just get along?” Political, funky, and oh so smooth.

Fave track: Mercy mercy me. Would I revisit this: no.

What’s Going On is a phenomenal album—one I’ve returned to time and again. It’s more than just music; it’s an emotional and social statement that still resonates today. The title track What’s Going On and Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) are absolutely stunning—both musically and lyrically. They’re timeless pieces that blend soul, jazz, and heartfelt commentary on the state of the world. There are moments of profound pain throughout the album, powerfully conveyed through the lyrics of songs like Save the Children and God Is Love. Gaye’s voice is filled with both sorrow and hope, giving these tracks a deeply human quality. Favourite tracks: What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me Least favourite: — (Honestly, it’s hard to pick one) Album artwork: Iconic. When you think of Marvin Gaye, this cover—his solemn, thoughtful gaze in the rain—instantly comes to mind. It’s as legendary as the music itself.

Cinquante-quatre ans après sa sortie en mai 1971, "What's Going On" de Marvin Gaye demeure une oeuvre d'une pertinence saisissante, un chef-d'oeuvre qui a non seulement redéfini la musique soul, mais a également offert une chronique sociale et politique d'une Amérique en pleine mutation. Cet album concept, porté par la voix suave et poignante de Gaye, reste une écoute essentielle, un voyage musical et émotionnel qui transcende les générations. Dès les premières notes de la chanson-titre, "What's Going On", on est enveloppé par une atmosphère à la fois douce et mélancolique. Les arrangements orchestraux luxuriants, mêlant cordes, cuivres discrets et percussions subtiles, créent un écrin sonore d'une richesse inouïe. La production, assurée par Marvin Gaye lui-même, est d'une finesse remarquable, chaque instrument trouvant sa place avec une clarté et une chaleur qui servent magnifiquement le propos. C'est une rupture stylistique audacieuse avec le son Motown plus calibré pour les hits radio auquel le public était habitué de la part de l'artiste. L'album se déroule comme une suite de réflexions, une conversation intime et universelle. Marvin Gaye, inspiré notamment par le retour de son frère Frankie du Vietnam et par les troubles sociaux qui secouaient les États-Unis, abandonne les thèmes romantiques habituels pour aborder des sujets graves et urgents. La guerre du Vietnam, la pauvreté, les inégalités raciales, la brutalité policière, la toxicomanie et, de manière pionnière, l'écologie, sont au cœur de ses préoccupations. Ce qui frappe à l'écoute de "What's Going On", c'est la manière dont les chansons s'enchaînent de manière fluide, créant une narration continue. Les transitions sont soignées, les motifs musicaux se répondent, renforçant l'impression d'une oeuvre unifiée, d'une véritable symphonie soul. La voix de Marvin Gaye, multiple, capable de passer d'un falsetto éthéré à des intonations plus graves et directes, est l'instrument principal de cette narration. Il ne chante pas seulement, il témoigne, il interroge, il supplie. En conclusion, "What's Going On" n'est pas seulement le meilleur album de Marvin Gaye ; c'est l'un des albums les plus importants et les plus touchants du XXe siècle. C'est un appel à la compassion, à la réflexion et à l'action, porté par une musique d'une beauté transcendante. Un 3 sur 5 pour un album majeur.

Sunday morning

# 479 : What's Going On : 13/05/2025 It’s decent. A couple classic bangers, and a great soul album, but there is a good amount of filler in there as well. Not sure why it's ranked as number 1, or why there is so much hype, more for it's importance I guess than it actually sounding good. Lack of transition between songs made this album drag on into one big boring mash. Title track was the best for mind. Number 1 in Rolling Stones 500 Greatest Albums of All Time! Number 17 in Apple Music 100 Best Albums

• great depth - a couple standout singles and quality songs throughout • love the lyrical content and song-cycle quality; if I were a bigger fan of the orchestration and genre it would be a 5

Marvin Gaye was such a soulful singer. I can only imagine how this album, especially its title track resonated, at the time. I think it resonates with me today. Maybe I shouldn’t have (or should have) been reading the news while listening to this. Some of the synth orchestra pieces still come off as dated, but it still works when considering the context. Mercy Me is right there in the pocket of the times, but I have to say that the groove of Right On was a key track today. That song is due for a Renaissance. This might be his most politically motivated album, but I respect the call for hope and togetherness it provides. This is a classic!

Random thoughts: * This is Marvin Gaye's masterpiece. * The social consciousness album still means as much today as it did in 1971, part because the music is so good and we still have so far to go as a country and civilization. * What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, and Inner City Blues are the standout tracks here but the whole album just flows wonderfully. * I'm going to have to listen to this one a few more times.

Had higher hopes

I have listened to this album. I think I like it more than I did prior. I always liked Marvin Gaye’s songs. I would own this on vinyl.

I actually don’t rate this album, at least within his body of work. IITA here?

loved it

3 stars Feels controversial because this was listed as the #1 album of all time by Rolling Stone. And maybe I’m ignorant. I like the title track and generally like the album. But it’s more of a vibe than an album and it feels one note that is a good note but still just that. I wanted to get it and like it more than I did, but playing it through a handful of times maintained my feeling.

This album is genuinely a classic, I’m so glad that I listened to it. It’s all the way through. It’s one of those that I can appreciate the influence hat on modern music, while being so smooth, the court progressions are great. Marvin‘s voice is amazing, And the messaging behind each one of the songs is premier. One of the best of all time. Five out of five.

I love everything Marvin Gaye does. First album in a while that finished and I thought “oh done already?” So good. No notes

Good but underwhelming. I like the strings, background sax, flute, and the atmospheric vibes. The vocals are strong. Nothing particularly piques my interest though.

Fun album. Standouts for me were "What's Going On" and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)"

Favorites: What’s Going On, What’s Happening Brother, Save The Children, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Man, words cannot begin to describe the genius of What’s Going On. Marvin Gaye stands as the voice of the oppressed and takes a stand against inequality on the back of some of the most gorgeous soul you’ll ever hear. A timeless record, both sonically and topically, and one that feels just as poignant in 2025.

Vibing to this. No standout tracks on first listen

great but not the best

At first I thought this might be a 1 (just because of the genre?) but I do not hate it, it could be playing in the background.

Exceptional album

It's funny, because just recently I saw a Spotify playlist called "Marvin Gaye's clueless ass" with song titles asking questions including the first two here. ("What's Going On" and "What's Happening Brother") Old Soul, R&B, is not something that normally appeals to me, but this is good stuff. Very evocative of the times and yet timeless. It's easygoing but in a pleasant way.

Chilled soul but no standouts

Would relisten

So smooth.

As perfect an album as there ever was.

One of the greatest jazz albums

Gaye tackles a variety of social, political, and racial topics throughout this record. You can hear the anguish in his voice. Timeless, in a somewhat chilling way.

One of the greatest R&B records and one of the greatest pieces of art ever. Marvin Gaye poured his entire soul into this album and created one of the most heartfelt, emotional, and beautiful soul records of all time. The concept and the message behind the album are so pure, so timeless, and the writing is absolutely at its peak. The production is top notch too, lush, smooth, layered, and it really defined what soul could sound like while shaping the genre forever. Marvin himself is one of my favorite vocalists, and his performance here is nothing short of divine. his voice carries pain, love, hope, and beauty all at once. Honestly, I can’t really find a single flaw with this record. It’s a perfect 10/10 album in every sense. Every time I return to it, it gives me such a good feeling, almost like a reminder that this kind of greatness exists to make life better. It’s one of those rare albums that feels alive, like it still breathes decades later.

Oooh hello Marvin okay let's go. Marvin another guy that I've listened to THE HITS and I love them, but I don't think I've ever really listened to an album front-to-back. Something I'm really appreciating about this 1001 albums exercise is that I am very much a SINGLES guy. I listen to SONGS, and rarely listen to ALBUMS. I think it's because I crave the vibe shift, the mood shift, eclectic arrangements, etc. It's nice to commit to a mood or vibe of an album for 30+ minutes, and need to do it more often in my casual listening habits. Inner City Blues Make Me Wanna Holler > Right On > What's Going On > Mercy Mercy Me The Ecology > Save the Children > What's Happening Brother > God Is Love > Flying High In The Friendly Sky > Wholy Holy These animations that Spotify has linked to every track on this album are annoying as hell. Who told the music streaming industry that songs need looping animations attached to them, they are so annoying especially when it's retroactively added to an album from 1971. Get over yourself. But that is not Marvin's fault. This album is p good. I didn't like how earnest it was at first then it really grew on me haha. I do agree we need to get together and work together and save the children. I agree with you Marvin! We should love one another! I don't think any song really slapped me in the heart, though. Maybe "Make me wanna holler, throw up my hands" on the last track, that lyric made me go "Oh hellooo" and then all the vocal vamping in the back half. That track the standout gem for me, but overall this album is all perfectly fine, but is it GREAT? It doesn't seem to be the case. It's prob a high 3 I think, not quite cracking a 4? Maybe it's a low 4? It's riding that edge.

It was okay I’d relisten but not that much

Marvin Gaye, simply the best...

Undeniable, but the only MG album I revisit is "I Want You"

I listened to this one. Definitely want to relisten someday, because I didn't really care for it when I listened. Gonna have to rate this 2/5, because I don't want to desaturate my current ratings. I liked the song "Save The Children". R&B more like BBQ

I like how the songs blended into each other. But not a big fan.

Bara með því að lesa titlana í albúminu sé ég að þetta sé bullandi kristið.. áhugavert Ég hélt að whats going on lagið væri lets get it on en neibb allt annað lag allt í lagi Þetta er ekki alveg my vibe Hætti að hlusta eftir lag 1 ehehe.. nenni þessu ekki sorry Marvin

Great on repeat

Absolutely beautiful, great messaging, Marvin Gaye is one of the greats

I've finally given this a listen after years of seeing it on "Best albums of all time" lists. I don't think I would go that far but it certainly is sonically dense. I listened to it 3 times and still don't feel like I scratched the surface of this project. Def will be coming back to it.

Blended right into a long Sunday drive

This is a gem. The entire album just flows

War is not the answer

Chill album.

Only words like lustrous and sublime apply here. Rich, deep, silken sounds dripping with soul. Maximalist Motown production sweet and smooth like honey. I could listen to Marvin sing the phone book - in fact that would be pretty cool.

it is what’s going on by marvin gaye

Opens like the gates of heaven with “What’s Going On” and proceeds to lay down a yellow brick road of smooth social consciousness. By the end, I was wishing cultural appropriation was culturally appropriate.

I liked this, kinda repetitive but that’s ok! He knows what he does best

Marvin Gaye is a man of many questions

First listen to a Marvin Gaye album.

Couldn’t really get into it. Not really my thing.

Critics love this album. I find it boring.

Iconic and powerful, too much of a focus on Christianity in my personal opinion though. Overall, 8/10.

Really enjoyed this

A classic - What's going on, mercy mercy me, and inner city blues are the best. I really like it, would listen again, but it's not a true five for me. Just a little too...something.

An alright album.

The threat the children are facing in "Save the Children" is too nebulous and undefined. Save them from what, exactly? What's going on? What's happening brother? An okay album overall.

vier minus

Too religious and a little too mellow for me, but it’s still pretty good. Marvin sounds great and keeps things simple (none of the pretentious vibrato that some soul music has), and there are some solid sax parts in a few songs.

A Classic. Such a distinctive, soulful sound that has never been replicated. These are great songs, unlike the M. Gaye album i reviewed earlier, which was all his sound, without the song. A five.

Wow! Vibrant, fun, and full. I wasn't alive when this word was used but I can only imagine it was labeled as "Groovy." Its so interesting how this sound feels so nostalgic to me, without any previous connection to it. The lyrics lose me a little bit, but that's okay because overall love the messaging. Great album and very deserving of its spot on the list.

Meh. Het is wel goed, maar het is ook duidelijk dat het niet voor mij gemaakt is

Five stars and a therapy session.

Who wouldn't love the voice of Marvin.

This is an incredibly cohesive album. The songs are not the same and do not sound the same, but each one flows into the other one so well. A very impressive example of a concept album that does not feel disjointed. I knew 3-4 of these songs but had never sat down and listened to the whole thing. It's hard to pick out the highlights but I will say that God is Love and Wholy Holy are the only two songs that I would not consider to be worthy of the rest of this album. What I find to be so exemplary is how Marvin Gaye is writing protest music but it is just so laid back and within the flow of the orchestration. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) has always been my favorite track on here and that has not changed. Good statement album.

One of the great albums I've ever heard. Legendary voice and delivery. A landmark in song construction and in social commentary

Nice! Good album!

Repetitive but nice

If you didn't know that it was a concept album, you can think of it s a song cycle. Either way it works. REALLY well. People older than me probably remember when this came out. 14 years later, Marvin Gaye was gone, and a re-examination of this music made people realize how great this album is. My only gripe is I felt the strings in "Mercy, Mercy Me (The Ecology) were a bit heavy handed, particularly combined with the mellotron. But otherwise, this a classic album, one I will come back to over and over. Top tracks: Title track, "Wholy Holy," "Inner City Blues". (But as a whole, the other tracks are almost as good.)

There are greater 5 star albums, but I'm still giving it 5 stars. It's at least a 4.5. For a soul artist, Marvin Gaye finally pours out his soul, not just with his vocals but with some deep, deep lyrics and themes. It's his writing that really makes this album a standout. He tackles some bleak subjects but with a hopeful attitude (most of the time). My biggest gripe is the finishing touches - he set out to transition from one song to the next so it feels like one big song, but the splicing is off, especially on the first half of the album. Still, these songs are powerful. Not just the well known ones (title track, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues) but also the lesser known ones (What's Happening Brother, Flyin High, Save the Children). Right On might be the best song on this album next to What's Going On - complex lyrics, wicked grooves, jamming for 7+ minutes.

Smooth grooves over hard lyrics. Musically outstanding, both the writing and the playing, and I love how most of the tracks flow into each other. Plus, Marvin Gaye may have had the smoothest voice in history. If you didn't pay attention to the lyrics, you'd think it was just some smooth let's get it on type music. But then the lyrics create such a jarring contrast. Protests, war, drugs, pollution, poverty. Yet there are also moments of hope on the album. There are a lot of albums on the 1001 that make me question their inclusion. There's no doubt that this is an essential album and demands a close listen. Outstanding - and sad that a lot of it is still relevant. Favorite tracks: What's Going On (I liked a comment on Genius - notice that it's not a question. He's not asking, he's telling us what's going on), Mercy Mercy Me (so smooth while talking about the destruction of the environment - but, hey, that sax solo is awesome!), then the entire second side - Right On, Wholy Holy (love how this track is almost like a relaxing breath after the tension of Right On), and Inner City Blues.

I love this album for years, but them I began to tire of it and play it much less. 'Save The Children', for example, is a bit too earnest and wearying. But I listened to it again today after a break and it was great.

Loved the album. The music is soulful and smooth. The lyrics are powerful--would like to listen to it again to pay more attention to the message.

Didn't really hit like the reputation would suggest. 3/5, nothing bad, but songs toward the start ran together too much for me

Very smooth and tender. Catchy without hooks. The rhythm is its main ingredient

In a nutshell: "when will people start getting together again?" Bam. Right in the feels. "What's Going On" could be an incidental concept album (as inspired by Marvin's brother): troop returns from Vietnam. We walk a few miles in his shoes as he tries to process how dramatically the world has changed. Over fifty years on, we are in an eerily similar state of events. What is going on indeed. There are some similar sounds and melodies reused throughout the album but I think there are some variety within them to not sound boring. Also, I wonder if we can draw a line from Marvin Gaye to Kendrick Lamar... Overall: 8/10

I don't normally like soul music but I like how smooth and jazzy the songs are. He's a fantastic singer and the instrumentation is lush and groovy.

The title track of this album is my favorite Marvin Gaye song, but the album overall is still smooth and gentle enough that I can't stay focused on it. I assume it's fantastic if you don't have ADHD getting in between the rest of your own brain and the music?

Banger after banger, suspected this would be high scoring before even listening

Rolling Stone rated this the best album in the world in 2022. I would be hard pressed to disagree. Granted there are a lot of albums out there and I primarily consider myself to be a rock fan, but this album just can't stop getting better. As a bass player myself, James Jamerson is a god of the trade and no matter how grueling the vocals are about the reality of life in that era, we will always know what's going on.

Great album. Some classic songs. Great music for snuggling.

Love this one

A very smooth, pleasant album What I didn't like was some songs just ended abruptly? Almost as if songs were jumping tracks Overall enjoyable, I really like his voice 4 ⭐️

I mean, exactly what you want, done well. First 5 star album!

I didn't like this as much as I expected to. The title track is great, but the rest of it all blurred together for me.

I expected to like this more than I did, that being said it’s still good. I liked and was somewhat surprised and impressed with the socially conscious lyrical content, “trigger happy police” is far too relevant today. Overall after the first few songs it all sounds too similar for me. I’m going to say 3.5 rounded up to 4 stars, but that’s probably a bit of a stretch.

I really enjoy this one. I don't listen to it often, but I really should. It sounds great, love the vocals and the lush orchestration. A triumph in all senses. I like the way it flows together from one song to the next and that elevated Motown sound is really great.

Five stars

1 1 .75 .75 1

Less a collection of songs, more a continual meandering groove. Quietly powerful.

Smoooooooooooooooth

The Motown Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. Denser in sound than any Motown album that came before, Marvin Gaye seized creative control of his music with both hands and created an enduring message of tenderness in a cruel world. It's over 50 years old and still stands as one of the greatest albums ever recorded.

Obviously

I sort of get it, just doesn't hit for me.

Total classic. Very good 10:10

Some great stuff, some a bit more forgettable. That said, some really timeless and compelling social statements that feel all too relevant today. I'm probably at a 3.5 on it, but the social commentary bumps to 4.

Ik vind het album echt wel goe, de soul is echt aan het soulen. Het eerste nummer “what’s going on” is zo een mooi nummer. Ik vind het dus echt een aanrader.

A great opening song but the rest is just average in my opinion. 3 stars or C.

I like this album because I like his vpice

I rate Whats going on a 5 star because the beat is good and the dynamics are good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. I rate Mercy mercy me a 5 star because the beat is good and the dynamics are good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ and the drums and gutr are good. I rate Inner city blues a 5 star because the beat is good and the dynamics are good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ and the drums and gutr are good.

Song: whats going on this song is okay it is good but it is not a song i would like to listen too but it kind of sounds like i had heard it before Song: Mercy mercy me this song is good but i do not really listen to these songs these are actually the kind of song i skip and it turned scary at the end Song: inner city blues This song is goof this might be my favorite one of the album but i do not listen to these songs very much

I like this album because it sounds very classical. The meaning behind the lyrics are very interesting.

I don't like this song because the start is not that good. I would not recommend this song. I don't like this song because the beat is not that good in the start

I like this album because I like the singers voice. I like the soft instruments behind him and how they sound. They sound soft and go with his voice well. I would reccomnend this album.

I like this album because he has a very good voice and it goes well with his lyrics and there is a good beat. I also like this song because I think it has a special meaning since he is coming home from Vietnam im guessing war

Do you want to listen to some music that has some nice guitar? Well in What's Going On you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has some drums? Well in Mercy Mercy Me you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐. I kind of recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has some nice guitar? Well in Inner City Blues you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song.

i like the songs i like the beat i like how he sounds . But i think all the songs sound the same . i guess i recomend it

I don't like this because I don't like the instruments that are used in it and the repeatative lyrics. I would not dcommend this album to someone else because I don't think they would like it. I give it 2/5.

the first song i like sounds good it sounds like my style of music and the backround music is not that much so i like the lyrics i dont really like. so i give it 3

The first song started off good his voice is actually good and the lyrics are good. I can only understand a few of them but from what i can hear it sounds good the background music is good. the second song is good ig its like something his voice is good and the background music is good but its kinda sounds weird

Why is he in the rain? I thought "What's Going On" was okay. I thought the singing voice was strange but the music was good. "Mercy Mercy Me" was also okay. I like the lyrics because they deliver a good message but the music and singing aren't the best. "Inner City" was the best. The music and singing were better. I would not recommend this album.

the first song is okay I don't really like it that much there is not much to say about it. the next song is also kinda the same there is also not much to say about it it is okay. the last song is still the same there is not much to say about it either. overall I don't really like the album.

What is he looking at on the album cover? I thought "What's going on" was pretty good. It wasn't anything special but it wasn't bad. It sounded kind of older because of how slow the song was but it wasn't too slow that it wasn't enjoyable. "Mercy mercy me" was also pretty good. I liked the lyrics and the message through the song. It was the same kind of slow as the song before. "Inner city blues" was the same as the other two. Not bad but not the best song I've ever heard. I would rate this album a good four stars and I would reccomend this album for anyone to try because you never know if your going to like it unless you try.

For What's Going On and Ecology alone, this album is an all-time classic. The rest is icing on the cake

Masterpiece!

Loved it.

Yeah. So very of its period. The smoothest of the smooth yet with a hard-edged message. 4/5. The 192kHz/24 bit remaster I am listening to (2011?) is technically superb.

Pretty amazing album. Love how it is so melodic and lush and at the same time tries to be a little politically confrontational. A true classic. 4.5/5

Great start to the album. Soulful and powerful lyrics. Less memorable near the end but great listen

Amazing album- maybe should go into the category of what is old is new again 5/5 #musicsky #albumsky day 16

The Rolling Stone Magazine's most recent album ranking has this listed as the greatest album of all time. I wouldn't be lying if I said I wasn't excited to listen to this album. Interestingly enough, this album isn't among the highest rated albums in this generator(granted, it does have high ratings). From a political standpoint, Marvin Gaye was ahead of his time. He beautifully sang about racism, police brutality, populist issues, and even threw in some of his religious beliefs to prove these ideas can coexist. Overall, it was a great soul album with some of the best singing I've ever heard, as well as an array of instrumental talent throughout the album. With that being said, it's still far from the greatest album I've ever heard in my entire life. Favorite Track: "What's Going On".

The songs are composed well, and I can appreciate the historical context. Lyrically, it's interesting, especially given the concept Gaye focuses everything on. Maybe it's just my taste, or maybe I wasn't in the right mood for it, but I'm not especially impressed by it on a first listen. Certainly not enough to deem it one of the greatest albums ever. It's all listenable, but it also fades into the background after a while. Perhaps I'll circle back to it later to see if I feel differently, but for now at least I've heard it.

I knew there were going to be some great songs, but Inner City Blues really ended this album perfectly.

Grooves, vibes, and honest beauty. Obviously opening with WHAT'S GOING ON might go down as one of greatest album openers. My album highlights are MERCY MERCY ME (THE ECOLOGY), INNER CITY BLUES (MAKE ME WANNA HOLLER)

Good, but not something I would choose to listen to

Peak easy listening

Good vibes to listen to around the house

5 for importance 3 for enjoyability

3.5 - fantastically made album just not really my style and the lyrics didn’t resonate with me

An absolute masterpiece. One of the few vinyl albums that I've added to my collection in the recent vinyl resurgence.

Od svih klasičnih albuma ovaj mi je nekako najklasičniji baš se nekako osjetiš ko govno i josip bošnjak ako ovo ne voliš

Mercy mercy me ( The ecology) was my favorite. Groovy and fun. Smooth

1971. Soul. R&B. progressive soul. psychedelic soul

Heard it before. Listening to this album is always a pleasure 4/5

Timeless, lush record. Every track is a winner on this one. Only track that I'm not super hot on is Save the Children. A little too on the nose for me, but still good music wise. Don't got a ton to say about it, other than I appreciate that this album has two inductees on the "Marvin Gaye's Clueless Ass" playlist with What's Going On and What's Happening Brother.

Some of these songs are magical. Others are just a bit too much "talking" singing, and I really don't like that.

Sounds much the same throughout, even if it is beautifully done. Final track is fantastic.

custom_rating:9

7/10… 70er Soul / Motown

Amazing, cohesive, powerful record

I've Got To Give It Up and award 2 stars only. I know it's seminal, etc and will reward repeat listens but not doing loads for me tbh

Indifferent, don't see what the fuss is about

Great album. Smooth and easy to listen to.

"What's Going on" [+++] "What's Happening Brother" [++] "God Is Love" [+]

One of the greatest albums ever made. The RnB and soul heals you spiritually. Not a single miss on the album, just a timeless classic. Marvin Gaye THE GOAT

"Who's willing to save a world that is destined to die?" I think I need to give this a re-listen. Not because it's not good (I think it's a wonderful album), but because I probably didn't appreciate it enough to understand why it's considered one of the greatest. I will say this, however, that the production of this album is gorgeous. It doesn't go a volume too high or too low. And, obviously, Marvin Gaye's vocals are unmatched. Hidden instruments, background voices, connecting songs — they're the blueprints that inspired the greatest albums of today, from Frank Ocean's Blonde to Kdot's TPAB. Again, I just think I need to give this a re-listen. Maybe it was the lyrics? It lacked poetry? I don't know.

Nothing much, how about you?

There’s no denying the cultural importance of What’s Going On. It’s a landmark soul album with a social conscience, smooth arrangements, and Marvin Gaye’s signature velvet voice tying it all together. But as an actual listening experience? It doesn’t quite hit me the way it seems to hit others. The grooves are mellow and often beautiful, but they can also blend together a bit too easily, making the album feel a little samey by the halfway point. The lyrics are thoughtful and heartfelt, tackling war, poverty, and environmental concerns with sincerity, but musically it stays in one gentle gear—never really lifting off or surprising. Songs like the title track and Mercy Mercy Me stand out, but the rest can drift past without leaving a strong impression. It’s an album I respect a lot more than I truly enjoy, and while it’s undeniably well made and meaningful, it doesn’t quite move me enough to call it great.

An all-time classic for a reason.

Too happy for me, if that's a legitimate critic. I feel like it totally is. In every single song I feel the need for a progression that highlights a major chord turning minor. But Marvin Gaye is no Shmulik Kraus. It's a good album, but it's not something I'll choose to put on. I'll choose The High Windows (very very weird how I decided to compare these two albums that have absolutely 0 correlation. And, well, that's exactly why I did.) I now read the description of the album on the site. Oh! I guess I didn't listen to the words haha... apply my review to the music solely (don't. He could've still made a "Soldat De Chocolate"...)

Beautiful, if steeped a little too long in the gospel tradition of soul.

👍🏼

Poetic jazz. The revolution will not be televised.

Timelessly poignant, especially in the first half of 2025

Couple huge hits. Pretty good music.

Marvin never misses

It’s Gaye

Pure class. Can't fault it.

When you get perfect vocals with perfect instrumentals, an easy 5 star album. Thanks for the update Marvin!

Meh, generic stuff

Like, a bit disappointed

Gaye took Come to My Garden's hippie sensibilities out of the garden and introduced it to the men sleeping under newspapers on park benches. all of a sudden, the flower power shifts from being carefree to being pointed, giving serious thought about the condition of the world as it strolls from topic to topic. it doesn't have any concrete solutions. Marvin is wearing a coat on the cover to shield himself from the rain, but his face is still soaked. he isn't blind to trouble outside, he just wants to survive it. i always wondered why i'd never heard a single from this thing, despite hearing so much of Marvin Gaye's music casually. turns out it's because it's only complete as a whole piece. this is probably transcendent on vinyl.

This is very, very good. Like, very silky smooth. Very rainy day music. However, not catchy at all, which is understandable. But it doesn't particularly appeal to me specifically. Like, these songs will definitely go on some playlists but I doubt they'll be a part of my daily rotation even though they are very, very, very good. I think I just tend to like faster paced stuff, which is why Stevie Wonder's Innervisions edges this out for me -- it's more exciting, I guess. Inner City Blues is very good. Mercy Mercy Me has been in my ocassional rotation for quite some time. This is the kind of music that makes you breathe a little deeper and look a little longer at the sky and snap your fingers a little bit. Pretty peak. A strong, strong 4/5?

Draped in pleasantries A smoothness beyond reason Pleads for betterment

Incredible flow. A masterpiece!

Another good Marvin Gaye album. I think I like this one a bit better than Let's Get It On. 3.25/5

Mr Gaye is pretty good, but just not really my style. I enjoyed this ok, but overall I'm not feeling like putting this back on. 3/5

Rolling Stone got one thing right when they recently ranked this the #1 album of all time- deserved. A+

I needed this album! So full of soul ans rebellion, but amazingly smooth and infectious. A classic for me no doubt!

I experienced this album as flowing from one end to the other. A great voice. And some great songs. Lived it.

Lyrically very strong. Musically stays in a narrow space.

5 stars for the song “What’s Going On” alone.

Definitely not an album made for me to hear. It definitely has it moments but not something that I enjoy nor really like to hear. Probably for who it refers and what it tries to do it's fantastic but yeah. I would give it around a 6/10.

SAVE THE BABIES‼️ Literally perfect. Musical intercourse. This is an all timer if there ever was one. This album is overflowing with soul and beauty its impossible not to be swept up in its grandeur. All of the songs here are great on their own but together they create one of the finest album listening experiences of all time. The title track is a top 5 song of all time. I MEAN IT. That song and the album as a whole never get old no matter how many times I hear it. Favorite track: What's Going On

Stone Cold Classic. Nothing else to say. 10/10

Most songs I knew. I wasn’t as impressed as I thought I would be

Well, I guess it’s time for me to admit I don’t really like this album very much. It’s overproduced, overorchestrated, and most of the songs kind of float around and don’t go anywhere. The sociopolitical messaging is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

I've got to be honest: This was surprisingly lame.

SMOOTH AS SILK AND BOLD AS BRASS

Few vocalist will ever reach the summit of Marvin Gaye's talent. This album still stands up today as one of the most gorgeously arranged R&B albums, and Gaye's voice will stand as a gold standard for generations to come.

i didnt listened to all of the album, but it was cool, kind of. give me the next gonna give it another try for sure

One of the best albums ever.

Soulful and powerful.

Good album - some classics.

It's Marvin Gaye. It's good.

Absolutely one of the best. Poetry and music.

…and on and on. I like this album but no doubt it’s samey. But it’s Marvin

It's Marvin 'one song split into many' Gaye...but it's still Marvin

Funky, soulful, iconic, a slice of history that should be paid attention to (because it seems we're entering that kind of time again). What's going on? What's happening brother? What's happening my man? Who the fuck even knows? And who's going to do anything about it? I appreciate these kind of messages and these albums. But they can get preachy. It's a fine line to walk. A whole album of this isn't necessarily something I'd want to return to much. I like the song segues. It makes the whole project seem like a complete movement. This is the definition of an album-composed and thought out Bangers-What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, God is Love, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues Skip-Right On, Wholly Holy

I like this but it’s far from the best album ever made (if the Rolling Stone top 500 list is to be believed). No album can be at the top of any list if one of its songs is “Save the Children”. But if you listen to the amazing title track and it gets you amped up, you can get absorbed in this albums unique sound n’ vision for the brisk run time. Standouts: “What’s Going On”, “Right On”, “Inner City Blues” Outside homework: The Strokes cover of “Mercy Mercy Me”

I don’t think it’s possible to rate this album any lower than 4 stars with the absolute classic tracks included. However, the rest of the record is very much just filler for those classics. I know it’s kind of a concept album deal, but it seems like even at this runtime it’s more of a padded EP.

What can you say about one of the best albums of all time?

Definitely a 5 star album. His voice is so smooth and the song writing is amazing. I heard Mercy Mercy Me before and What's Going On but nothing else before. I loved that all the tracks blended together really nicely after Mercy Mercy Me and I really liked the extended Right On. I'll be revisiting this in the future for sure.

What a classic. Important lyrics that touched on real problems that are all too relevant even today. Beautiful grooves. James Jamerson's bass on this album is a masterclass. And Marvin Gaye's voice is amazing.

Meh hab ma mehr erwartet

Was excited to listen to this full album, but came away a little underwhelmed. Some really good highs, but overall, came away feeling like it all blended together and wasn’t super memorable.

Now, then, and always a 5. Beautiful, soulful voice, grooves, and sax, gently and urgently calling a nation to its conscience. Sterling.

Sehr entspannend, aber nichts zum einfach so hören

Incredible. Easily one of my favs of the time and genre. One of those unique voices that guides you on a journey.

i mean cmon

if someone said this is, in their opinon, the best album of all time, i wouldn’t even be mad

I love how "soulful" and heartfelt all the songs sound. 9/10

88% Best: What's Going On; Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology); Right On; Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Must-Hear? Yes

Timeless

Loved this album, great music, 5 stars all day!

It was fine. It sounded like Marvin Gaye. Other than that I don't really remember much about it. I didn't even realize when the album looped because it all just blended together.

Marvin Gaye - What's Going On It's albums like these that make music more enjoyable to listen to. From start to finish, this album is incredibly consistent in terms of quality and it really trascends through time as an unique album from any other that was made by then. This is a generational album made by a generational artist like Marvin Gaye was. Rarely will anyone be able to replicate what Marvin did with this. This is beautiful. 1.- What's Going On = 10/10 2.- What's Happening Brother = 10/10 3.- Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) = 9/10 4.- Save The Children = 8/10 5.- God Is Love = 8/10 6.- Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) = 10/10 7.- Right On = 9/10 8.- Wholy Holy = 8/10 9.- Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) = 10/10 FINAL SCORE: 9.1/10

Absolutely essential.

Bardzo ciekawy album. Rodzaj społecznego manifestu, bardzo spójnego i konsekwentnego. Połączenie pokojowego przesłania pokolenia dzieci kwiatów z czarnym chrześcijaństwem w stylu gospel. "What's going on" to fantastyczny utwór, jako jedyny mający strukturę singla (może jeszcze "Inner City Blues", ale brakuje mu chwytliwości). Reszta to bardziej album koncepcyjny, utwory przechodzą jeden w drugi z pełną płynnością. W zasadzie jest to jedno długie jam session. Ciężko wczuć mi się w chrześcijański aspekt albumu, ale jednocześnie widzę w tym najczystszą wersję przesłania Jezusa, nie sposób tego nie docenić. Plus niezależnie od punktu początkowego, dochodzimy z Gayem do tych samych wniosków. Muzycznie jest to mega dobra i rozbudowana produkcja od Motownu, Gaye miał świetny zespół za sobą. Brzmienie jest bardzo czyste, czuć klasę muzyków, mimo często dosyć oszczędnych aranżacji, które dają w pełni wybrzmieć tekstom i głosowi Gaye'a. Solidne 4/5

I knew Mr Gaye earilier but I haven't had a chance to listen to his full album. After this honestly... nothing changed. Sometimes you see things like coldplay here and you question credibility of this whole endevour. The Man is a classic for a reason and has no wonder he earned a spot or two on this list.

Another one of the best albums of all time