Reviews (page 6 of 14)
getting thee sacred souls vibes, mr. gaye i was unfamiliar w ur game
I like this album because I’m a big fan of Marvin Gaye
Not what i normally listen to but i enjoyed it a lot
Swirling magical cyclic dreamsoul. 'A mind torn between apocalypse, sex, personal disaster·and reverie'. Favourite track; inner city blues for obvious reasons
Its definitely above average but the music itself gets a bit boring quickly. The mastering is impeccable though.
Jazz flute!
i like the jazzy bits
CLASSIC
Respect.
It's Rolling Sonte Magazine's Greatest Album of All Time for a reason, and I'm all in on it.
This album is a 3.5, but because of the title song, it gets the nudge.
This album is difficult to rate, because the title song is one of the best soul songs ever, but the album loses steam as it goes along. The first few songs are 5 stars, the end of the album is 3 stars. I'll take the average on this and call it a 4 star album.
Did we not already do this? The irony of giving three 5s in a row to then not give one of the most critically acclaimed albums of all time one is not lost on me. I just don’t think I vibe with soul music. The concept of this album is incredible, the lyricism is as well, smooth as hell, I just wouldn’t reach for this to listen to it outside of the list.
undeniable classic
Not a lot!
not my favorite, for sure a classic and some good songs on there that i enjoyed!
Classic
easy on the ears like the political aspect of the lyrics especially with what was going on at the time, also giving an escape from reality.
soulzy
Marvelous Marvin.
This is a pretty universally highly-rated album, topping lists like Rolling Stone’s 2020 & 2023 Best Albums of All Time Lists. The album is pretty short, only 9 songs long, and each of them is pretty good. The best is the title track, which is just an all-time song. Gaye’s reaction to the Vietnam War and the reactions to it’s protests can be pasted onto many modern movements, and certainly have. It’s also just a really fun listen! The other tracks on here didn’t quite meet the heights of this one, but every time I started to tune out, a new groovy section came in and rocked my socks off! Listening to this as a complete album is the ideal way to listen to it, though. It's a concept album, so all the songs flow into each other in themes and musically, creating a really unique sonic experience you'd miss out on if you weren't listening this way.
Timeless album, I love this thing.
Suave
A classic.
Obviously, one of the most heralded albums of all time. My only issue with is it is that there is so much oversinging that it's hard to suss out what is being sung at any time. It's an album requiring multiple listens to really get the feel of the musicality. Message-wise, it seems to be a solid fare. I get tones of civil unrest and pining for something better. I'm sure when it came out it was revolutionary. Hell, it even rings true these days as well. I can see myself going back to this. Nothing about it is offensive and largely a beautiful offering.
4 out of 5. I see why this album is so highly regarded now, what an experience.
1. What's Going On - Very pleasant. Not the biggest fan of the background talking and the onomatopeia stuff in the latter part 2. What's Happening Brother - This was an even more pleasant listening experience all the way through than the last one 3. Flyin' High - Another very nice track. More moody than the last two which I like a lot. Forerunner for favorite track. 4. Save the Children - Continuing with the moody atmosphere. Not as much to my taste as the previous one. Except that the instrumental gets reeeally nice at the end 5. God is Love - Don't really have a lot to say about this one. It's a short one and the religious themes don't really appeal to me. 6. Mercy Mercy Me - Even though this one could also be seen as a pretty religious song, it's more subdued than the last one, and all in all, this is another very pleasant listening experience. Another possible favorite. 7. Right On - Pretty fun. It's a longer one, but has interesting enough sound and distinct parts to keep me engaged all the way through. 8. Wholy Holy - Veeery calming. Again, the explicit religious stuff is a bit off-putting for me. 9. Inner City Blues - I like this a lot! Another fave contender definitely. Summary: A very pleasant and nice listening experience. Marvin Gaye is one of those artists that I have heard of a lot and of course has some recognizable songs (though I had to check the discography, couldn't name any off the top of my head), but all of the song in this album were new to me. I could see myself tuning into his discography again in the future if the mood strikes me.
I love the flute! Very easy listen/ soul music. I had heard of Marvin Gaye but couldn't have told you what type of music he sang. Very soulful, though I don't much care for the religious undertones.
One of the GOATs, gorgeous original press on vinyl. Sounds great on any system.
It's nice music to listen to. Really nice voice, the music is fine too, but half the time I miss more intensity, trumpets, guitars,.. more passion! It feels just too chill out for me. 3/5.
first two songs FIRE, third i felt like i was listening to frank ocean, the rest is really mid
Not bad - i liked it mostly however the sounds were generally the same throughout so as i got halfway through i got a bit bored of it but the first few songs were fresh!
It was alright, I liked the first track the best. It was very smooth and classy. I can imagine a classy, jazzy character playing this in the background of a romantic, happy scene in a movie. Most of the album blended together. There was only one song that had a weird sound in the background that I really didn't like, which made me skip that song. Good otherwise and I'm glad I tried it out but I don't think I'll be reaching for it. It doesn't quite "sing" to me but feels pleasant to hear in the background. 3/5
On my Mt. Rushmore of albums. If they changed the rating of this to 10 stars, I’d still want to give this one 20.
nice and smooth
Just straight beautiful. There’s not many albums with such a storied history as this, that deliver not only in its musical enjoyment, but also its messaging. I’ve never heard protest music be so beautiful, so soulful, and so uplifting. 5/5
I really enjoyed this one. Marvin’s voice is unctuous. The arrangements and backing harmonies are first class. Hopefully I’ll remember to pull this one out for a dinner party sometime soon.
Não entendo a fascinação em torno deste disco. Um hit e duas faixas interessantes: "Right On" e "Inner City Blues", apenas. No restante aquela chatice de cordas melosas e vocais lascivos cheios de yeah, yeah, yeah. Mesmo no universo da soul music existem discos bem mais interessantes.
Classic soul from the master awesome vocals on this man
One of the smoothest experiences that the world can confine to a 35-minute runtime, magical, sweet, and I certainly can't imagine much else matching up in its time
The intro of the title song starts a groove that doesn't stop, just an awesome album.
Beautiful, just beautiful!
We enjoyed the album but did only realised the song changed at the last song and the album was over!
Firstly, this album looks super short, only 9 songs and 35 minutes long. I really like it - it's super vibey but not too low energy where i'm falling asleep.
Kind of weird to hear these socially conscious lyrics in a made for loving voice. I don't think this is as great as its reputation would suggest.
Best Song: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler). There is a darker, more interesting energy here than in the rest of the album. Worst Song: Save The Children. I can't say I was a big fan of this call and response between the lyrics being spoken and then being sung. I can't help but feel the song would have worked better with just the sung parts. Overall: Not his best album. Everything feels like it comes and goes too quickly to really institute any sort of "vibe". Pleasant listening, but easily forgotten.
This album really was made two decades ahead of its time
Whilst the many talents of Marvin Gaye are fully evident, listening to this album unfortunately just confirms that I simply do not like the majority of his work.
Pretty outstanding - even an atheist can dig Marvin Gaye’s gospel inspired sound.
Not my taste, but nice bass lines.
Of course, I've listened to this before. This is possibly the tightest, smoothest 35-minute album of all time. Packed with unforgettable tunes and powerful messages, this masterpiece of production is Gaye at his most memorable. Why is he so confused, though? What's going on?
didn't caught my attention
This is one of those super influential and experimental albums that everyone should have to listen to from start to finish. It's such a shame Marvin Gaye was taken from us so young. It would have been amazing to see what his musical journey would have looked like.
Yeah this is really fucking good 5/5
This one got my gf pregnant
This was good R&B I could chill with. Not my top genre, but I’m slowly finding more and more things I like, and What’s Going On has a few songs I think everyone enjoys. Solid album length, good vibes.
great reset to remind the people why we stay the people
I think this is the most lush album that's ever existed. Barely songs imo just full lush sounds while Marvin Guy writes us his op ed essay about what the fuck is going on in 1971 America. Classic/10. A truly singular album that will never be recreated again by a once in a generation artist.
This is one of the best albums of all time. I love the soul and the themes throughout. I hate that so many issues from the 70s are still happening 50 years later. This album will still be one of the best albums of all time in another 50 years. Best Songs: What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, Right On Worst Songs: NA
Two Marvin Gaye albums in a row. This one is a fair bit better than "Here, My Dear" that I listened to yesterday. That being said, a couple tracks really fell flat for me ("Save the Children" and "Wholly Holy"), and "What's Happening Brother?" felt so much like just a variation of "What's Going On?" that I thought I had accidentally hit the replay button...so it still *only* ranks as a 4/5 for me.
Love the way each song segues into the next. I was feeling very nauseous this evening, and this album put my head, chest, stomach to rest.
Slightly disappointed … It wasn’t bad but I expected more from such a classic album
A classic. still solid. A little too polished and intentional for it to be a 5 for me, but still great.
It's just very, very good.
4 stars, totally my jam
Album #6: What’s Going On - Marvin Gaye Genre (according to Wikipedia): Soul, progressive soul, psychedelic soul, R&B Singles?: What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler), Save the Children Have you heard any songs from this album or group before?: I’ve listened to this album twice before. I love it. I can’t wait to hear it again. I have also heard other Marvin Gaye songs like I Heard It Through the Grapevine, Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, and It Takes Two. Thoughts?: I love this album so much!! I was elated when I got the opportunity to listen to this album for a third time. The story behind it is inspiring, and its messages are timeless and important, especially in today’s day and age. Everybody needs to listen to this album at least one time. His voice is perfect for the album, soft, reserved. The album reminds me of Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood, and his philosophy about the world. “There’s one thing that evil cannot stand, and that is forgiveness.” - Fred Rogers, quoting his professor. Favorite songs: All of it!! As a writer, what can you use this music for when honing your craft?: I would use its messages to inspire works filled with social commentary. File correlations: Possibly File #004: C*O*M*A*T*O*S*E
Man, when you talk about albums with high expectations - this is definitely considered in the top 10 best albums of all time on nearly every list I've ever seen. I guess that's why say never meet your heroes, because this was certainly not as good as I was expecting. Don't get me wrong, every song on here is fantastic, though I was a bit bored during Flyin High, but it's just missing that pizzazz that inclines me to giving this a 5. Maybe I need to listen to it a couple more times but I just don't feel what makes this album "perfect". I think I'm going to put a spoke in this review and relisten in a few months, since I feel like this will grow on me. Regardless, awesome album and great listen, will certainly be coming back to see if I can get it to the 5 I'm sure it deserves.
The only album I've ever bought as a gift where I thought that I really should have just kept it for myself. Marvin Gaye has a reputation for being a horny songwriter but this is what I know him best for and for me, it is him at his best. This album is a long letter written to address a bunch of issues and at no point does it feel preachy or corny. It's a sincere, heartfelt and tender album. It definitely helps that the arrangement, lyrics and vocals here are S-tier. Seriously, this is a beautiful album. Highlights: What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology),
4.56/5 Stars Top Songs: What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me and What's Happening Brother
Im not gay, i just wanna boogie to some Marvin
One of the best albums oat. This was the first soul album I ever listened to and fell in love with it. Yeah tbh it doesn’t hold up quite aswell when I first listened to it but it’s still amazing. Marvin Gaye was soooooo ahead of his time, with him giving himself adlibs throughout the whole album. Rip legend Fav Song: Mercy Mercy Me, What’s Going Ob 9.5/10
3.5
As influential and important as this album is, it’s just not my style of music, I’m not really one for slow sappy soul like this.
This album is a departure from Marvin’s earlier Motown pop music, as he moved into singing about social and climate issues with this album. One track leads into the next, so it seems the album is connected by the music and the stories he is telling. Good music.
I don't know if I've ever heard this version of 'What's Going On' before, which seems insane, but it's not familiar to me! I've definitely heard something other than the A Perfect Circle cover, though.... maybe one of the charity ones? This version is way more peppy and wispy than what I'm used to. It's a good song, but not what I expected! 'God Is Love' has a weirdly abrupt ending. I like that this album is so lyrically different (broadly: "global issues") from the other Marvin Gaye album we had (broadly: "getting it on"). Sometimes it's hard to tell if you're dealing with a concept album if you've only ever heard one album from an artist! Musically it's still, like, christian jazz(?), which is mellow and pleasant (modulo occasional weird percussion), but nothing all that revelatory. Highlights: 'Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)', the title 'Wholy holy'
Classic, and definitely has historical significance…but not something I’d venture back to often.
Very chill vibe, amazing for city walls on a winter morning, or just music to chill, overall a solid 7/10
Love this, particularly last track inner city blues. Simple, elegant, cohesive, really captured the essence of the time.
I remember listening to this when Rolling Stone updated their top 500 albuns list around 2020 and this took the number 1 spot. Not sure it'd be my number 1 but it's certainly up there and it's certainly a 5/5.
Arrasou, sinto muito
One of the bests ever
I really liked the vocals on save the children. The whole album has a gospel feel. I always enjoy a good saxophone too.
Meh
Decent. I know it gets a lot of love but I only found it alright. Can only give 3 stars
Never gets old.
Yes
i love let's get it on but this album doesn't do much for me although i do like mercy mercy me
Amazing Just beautiful
Oh I’ll TELL you what’s going on - Marvin Gaye’s putting out the #1 soul brother album of the 20th century and making it stick. So sweet and buttery smooth, so timely it’s timeless. Jesus he was only 45 when he died. Goddammit Marvin’s dad.
good but a bit repetitive
Oh I know what's going on!!!!
It’s peaceful, political, emotional, and timeless without even trying. Zero skips, zero flaws. Just perfection.
Not every song is a classic but overall a tremendous talent.
Broo, I actually thought the album was cool. I'm into soul music, but this particular album has some songs that are totally out of place, despite its fame. Now, if you want a top-notch experience listening to Marvin Gaye, I recommend another album of his, Let's Get It On. That one is fucking amazing
Two to three absolute belters not sure about the god songs so 3
A powerful album, a testament about America in the 60s/70s. Struggles we're still having and will probably continue to have way past my demise. But this album will still be standing and be listened to by generations past me. Be thankful there's such beautiful, powerful music/voices in America.
An astoundingly beautiful voice in a horrifically prophetic context.
This album fucking rocks never listened to him before, but I absolutely love this one. maybe a 5/5 or a 4.5/5
God album
A classic for a reason! While the songs do sound similar that seems to be part of the point and vibe of the album - easy to listen to and has a lot of passion/character behind it which I think is what I look for in music
I can see why it's appreciated but a bit too smooth for me
ibr it just faded away into nothingness after the first couple tracks
I am a huge soul/R&B lover. I love motown, quiet storm, blue eyed soul and even new jack swing. I am a huge fan of Marvin Gaye and this album does have some bangers on it, but I have to say that I am not as impressed with the totality of this album as many others are. I know this often ranks high, if not at the very top, of many greatest album lists, but to me there is a lot of filler on this record that cannot be balanced out by stellar tracks like "What's going on", "Mercy, Mercy me" and "Inner city blues." I personally feel "Let's get it on" is an overall better album. I know this put's me in a small minority but her I am.
Absolute classic, proud to own it on vinyl. My personal GOAT for Soul/R&B. Timeless tracks and the instrumentation beautifully supports Marvin Gaye's vocals
I am alright, thanks, Marvin the Homosexual. What's up?
Peak
Soulful and with a message... BUT a bit repetitive. What's going on is a banger.
A short album with an incredibly strong message and incredibly great music. But as corny this may sound, why is the music still so relevant today? This album talks about racial inequality, class inequality, police brutality, and war that we as U.S. citizens don't want a hand in, and in the last 10 years as I'm writing this, why is it still happening? Why couldn't this album be a time capsule or a history text book of sorts of what was happening in the late 60s to early 70s instead of being damn near 100% accurate of what's been happening right now? Let's hope something changes and when it does we can look back at the music of now and think "Hey this is just like this masterpiece of an album from 1971."
Pretty good . Better than I was expecting, but not good enough to enter my rotation
First listen
nöd wük aktiv glost aber relativ meh vo dem woni glost ha
There will be a time when the music doesn’t play and the children don’t sing. What a beautiful POV. The sax blowing through the noise at the beginning of the title track? Inject that shit in my veins. (Ecology) may be my favorite tho.
Classic from a classic!
I've already listened to his album (35). Classic with a capital C. James Jamerson's playing on this album is the Holy Book of electric bass guitar.
I don’t get why people like his music
5 stars, despite mentioning Jesus. He makes up for it by mentioning fish being poisoned. Makes me want to listen to Enjoy an Album again.
3.5
I have Let's Get It On, the other Marvin Gaye album I've heard for this already for this project, just a smidge higher than this one. I do think though the message on this is King it is actually message wise one of the best protest albums ever written. My personal favorite song of his all around is "Mercy Me" which absolutely Shines on this even with its kind of orchestral psychedelia that it does towards the end. It's too dark to be Soul strings but really fits the mood of the conflict. If I got to say why this one's probably a little bit less it's mainly because most of the sounds sound very similar on this whereas on let's get it on there's more of a variety but I do think on this one the message is King and it is a good album even even though it's a bit samey at times. 9.6 ★★★★½
A really nice and important soul album. The bass playing is especially great. 4.5 stars
I think this is a really good album. The title track, "Mercy Mercy Me", and "Inner City Blues" are all great, but some of the deeper cuts like "Save the Children" and "Wholy Holy" I'm much less high on. 4 stars.
4.5
Very luscious, soul-searching, mankind-saving vibes on this one and an outright classic fo sure in lots of ways. It would be a 5/5 for vibes but maybe only a 3.5/5 in terms of actual iconic, heavy hitting bangers. There are 3 different ones (oink) - one right at the start with the title track, right in the middle with Mercy, Mercy, Me and right and the end with Inner City Blues. The other tracks tend to blend together into this groovy but gloopy elevator motown gravy. First side is a suite of increasingly elevatorish versions of the same song and on side two you have Wholy Holy as the most elevatorish nadir. Despite the elevatorish drawbacks I have to say because of the high points this is still a quite splendid listen.
The sentiment behind this album and Gaye's voice are beautiful. Musically I'm not into it, so while I can appreciate the album, I didn't really enjoy it. I just don't like this genre of soul/motown. The two hit songs are not much different than the rest of the album, which speaks to the cohesiveness of the concept.
Save the Children might be one of the worst songs I've ever heard. It was unintentionally hilarious, though, I'll give it that. Album gets an extra star because of his voice, but minus several million for the actual music and especially the lyrics.
A classic. I was a little irritated listening to it in Apple Music because they inserted space between the tracks. Concept albums like this run their tracks together so it feels more like what it is: one unified work.
So smooth. Everything a guy like Sinatra is not.
Anyone who gives this fewer than four starts is either racist or dead inside—or, sure, has some incisive and thoughtful critique that eludes me because I don't really know shit about music. To that point, I don't think I ever realized before today that this album is kind of just one long amazing song. That's neat.
Ha Gaaaaaaaaye
The title track is an absolute HEATER and is one of my favorite songs. The rest of this album………. Is maybe not great? There is far too little structure in most of these songs. Mercy mercy me is fine, inner city blues is fine. Rest is really forgettable. WOKE rolling stone said in their 2020ish reranking that this is the greatest album of all time, which I assume must be a sociopolitical statement because the message is ham-fisted and the music is boring.
Anymore I get annoyed when the albums are this obviously "save the world", "everybody love everybody", and "will someone please think of the children", but when it sounds this damn good with peak Motown productions and put through Marvin Gaye's sultry voice it plays. Orchestras add such depth to anything they're on (see Gordon Lightfoot before and after stringed production). Half-assed internet research also reveals that three Detroit Lions sang backing vocals on the title track. How about that.
Maybe the strongest contrast between the dark subject matter and music I've heard. Flows better than hot syrup. Marvin's voice is up there as an all time great.
What’s Going On is an exposition of the very question it asks, both explicitly and spiritually. Like a mix of Bach’s sacred cantatas and Baldwin’s writings, it is undoubtedly one of the ‘greatest of all time’, and, depressing as it is, shall remain culturally relevant forevermore. I am by no means religious, but there are some art pieces that evoke such a spirituality that I question whether divine intervention was a factor in their fruition. This is one. It is such where you agree with his every word, and tap your feet to his every groove. A rare experience, and one that could only be borne of a deep understanding of the hardships of humanity, and the occasional beneficence of a higher power.
I think the only flaw you can really have about this album is that a lot of the songs sound the same. It's impeccably played and produced, they just don't make em like this anymore. And of course important commentary on society blah blah etc etc 4.6/5
pauroso
Questo è un album da ascoltare prima di morire. Voce incredibile e pezzi bellissimi, e pure la transizione da un brano all’altro è stupenda. Poi ho scoperto che msrvin ghey è ststo ucciso per errore dal padre RIP
album di una bellezza assurda, rientra nella mia top 10 5/5
Saw what album was today's and honestly, I felt immediate relief Love u Marvin Songs added to playlist: - What's Going On - Save The Children - Right On - Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
not my kind of thing
Apt title, because most of the 39 minute runtime of this album is a study on the title track. Lmost every track is a variation on the original theme, which while interesting to a student of music, can be rather one-note to the layman. Perfect transition into "Mercy, Mercy Me" is a plus.
Can't go wrong with mr Gaye, no bad songs but a few didn't hit as much as his more popular songs did
The king of Gaye. Smooth as fuck. With a solid song list, I enjoyed this a fair bit. Like 7/10.
Smooth and easy to listen to. Enjoyable for sure.
Not bad. I like his voice. The music isn't right up my alley, but I try not to punish artists unless they make my ears bleed. Marvin does not. Would I seek this out? No. Would I get mad if it was on? No. 3.
This cat knew EXACTLY what was going on. Highlight was "right on" even though everything here was silky and soulful. My one off put was the more religious leaning parts, not that the content was bad, just felt like they didn't hit quite the same. 4.5
Amazing voice and compositions, but it got just a tad boring after a while.
Not really my thing, but obviously still a great listen
Essential? Yeah, probably. Great listening? Far from it. What's going on Marv? This album drags.
Bästa skivan!!
Not my favorite Marvin Gaye album but decent
Ok je commence à mieux cerner ce qui me plaît et ce qui me rebute un peu dans la soul. Les alliances choeurs - percus sont parfois tout à fait savoureuses, le groove est bon avec de super solos de saxo et même de flûte traversière, une belle basse qui soutient le groove ; mais je suis pas fan du côté un peu féérique porté par le son xylophone / triangle, les jetés au clavier, avec des accords parfois un peu entendus, les vocalises trop langoureuses... Cette dimension qui sonne un peu comédie musicale et joie facile Au total je passe pas un mauvais moment, c'est doux et c'est quali, parfois positivement enveloppant et dansant, mais y a un truc un peu mielleux qui se retrouve aussi dans les paroles et qui me laisse un peu indiff voire me saoule. Voilà j'y vois plus clair sur la soul ça fait plaisir ; je vois bien que l'album est très bon et je suis contente d'avoir enfin découvert Marvin Gaye ; je laisse un 3 pour le compromis, qui reflète bien le sentiment très ambivalent que j'ai avec des moments où je me laisse vraiment emporter et d'autres où je décroche, et au global une couleur qui est pas celle qui me parle le plus je crois Typiquement dans Right On il y a vraiment les deux : les percus sont originales et au poil, genre ça gratte l'oreille en rythmant le tout c'est excellent, le passage solo de flûte en duo avec le clavier c'est génial ; mais les moments plus langoureux avec les cordes traînantes et les notes de xylo genre comédie romantique en accompagnement du chant du même registre ça me termine
Pas mon album pref de sa part, ni le plus abouti selon moi (alors même qu’il est souvent classé comme son meilleur album, voire meilleur album de la décennie/de tous les temps, dans certains cas). J’aime bien le côté un peu floaty, un peu suspendu qui est une caractéristique commune des morceaux—et ressort surtout dans Save the children que j’ai vraiment apprécié (j’irais même jusqu’à dire qu’il s’agit de mon son préféré de l’album). Les paroles m’ont un peu rappelé l’incipit de La Peste de Camus, for some reason, avec ce petit côté poétique/dystopique sur fond calme. Une belle proposition qui pour moi vaut un 3,6 arrondi en-dessous : un album très agréable à écouter, un énorme projet derrière qui a laissé sa marque dans le paysage de la soul music, mais qu’il va me falloir réécouter pour arriver à plus l’apprécier que d’autres de ses albums. Ceci dit, je recommande d’aller lire un super article qui explique pourquoi cet album devrait être un 5 automatique (je me suis presque laissée convaincre) : “Why Marvin Gaye’s “What’s Going On” may be the greatest album ever” (sur Medium).
This was boring, so bland. I really had expected more from such a name. Pretty crap.
Disappointed in this. I expected more from such a big name. I really thought I was getting in to soul from others I've had on this journey, but this was boring. Some of the orchestration sounded like things you'd hear on Chrisrmas songs, so it seemed a bit odd too. I'd have an afternoon snooze to it but that's about it. Not that there's anything wrong with his voice. It's nice. Just the music was dull and a bit cheesy. Not what I wanted, sadly.
Got to listen to this in Spatial Audio. A true masterpiece. Wow his voice is so good.
Very soothing with some powerful messaging.
Oof. Well, this album is in every "Best Ever" list that's ever been published and I'd never listened to it before, so I was looking forward to it. But, but... it's an unlistenable, jazzy dirge. It's basically one very long song with few tempo changes and Marvin whinging about the state of the world. It has the dullest backing track imaginable. Goes on a bit.
Some bangers here, but pretty mid.
I feel I’d be doing a disservice to music if I didn’t give this 5 stars. Voice of a generation.
Classic and timeless love this album great vocal jazzist already had it downloaded but love it still
Beautiful soul music, but I don't love the strong religious messaging of it. Other than Mercy Mercy Me, I didn't recognize any of the songs.
This is literally one of the greatest album I've ever heard. Makes me wanna be a better person.
An absolute classic and an amazing listen start to finish.
Calm and kinda chill. Relaxing
I could post lyrics that over 50 years later are still relevant. I could go on about how his life was cut way to short. I could say how this concept album is one of the best anti war albums ever. I could go off on the music, the lyrics the social impact this album has. Instead I will say this. What's going on is simply one of the best albums made.
Not his best album
Very Christian
I can't say individual songs will go to my library, but the album as a single piece of art if a masterpiece. It's musically amazing, i could listen to it all day. Marvin Gaye's voice is amazing, but the production and the actual melody is just outstanding, the best album of this project for me so far
Feel like my reviews are slowly getting worse, but I just don’t have too much to say about it. Can appreciate that this is probably a top album for fans of this style, but just doesn’t really move me the same.
Der US-amerikanische Soul-Sänger Marvin Gaye veröffentlichte 1971 mit What’s Going On ein Werk, das sich deutlich von der bis dahin üblichen Motown-Ästhetik abhob. Die Aufnahmen entstanden in den Detroiter Studios Hitsville U.S.A., Golden World Studio und United Sound Systems sowie teilweise in den Sound Factory Studios in Los Angeles. Gaye produzierte das Album erstmals selbst und formte daraus eine zusammenhängende Suite aus Soul-, R&B- und Jazz-Elementen. Thematisch greift er Krieg, soziale Ungleichheit, Umweltfragen und Spiritualität auf. Zu den prägenden Titeln gehören „What’s Going On“, „Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)“ und „Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)“. Das Album verbindet elegante Streicherarrangements mit einem fließenden Rhythmusgefühl, das den introspektiven Ton der Texte unterstützt. What’s Going On gilt als künstlerischer Wendepunkt in Gayes Laufbahn. Seine Produktion ist ausgewogen und atmosphärisch dicht, ohne Pathos oder Übertreibung. Ein nachdenklich-menschliches Werk, das auch heute noch Relevanz besitzt.
good
This sound is so timeless, but I couldn’t help but feel like this record was just missing a little extra something in every song. Best Track: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
Imagine releasing 10 albums and then dropping this.
5/10 Oof- I bought this on CD 20 years ago based on it's reputation. Didn't get it then, still don't get it. Just fiddly meandering, with songs that are instantly forgettable to mine ears. Marvin Gaye is one of my top three most overrated artists. At least it was better than Here, My Dear...
Absolutely brilliant, start to finish.5/5
The king of baby making music
Controversial opinion,but Marvin Gaye is just alright. Estate of Marvin Gaye please don't sue me.
Very chill and groovy, with great messages/lyrics. What is actually going on??
This dude is confused asf Favorite Track: Inner City Blues
Second album proposé par le générateur après 'Let's Get It On' que je n'avais pas vraiment apprécié (noté 2/5). Même constat pour cet album : belles lignes de basse, mais les morceaux sont un peu trop lents à mon gout, j'ai du mal à accrocher. =>2/5
Five stars for mercy mercy me alone. One of my favourite songs ever. It levels you the second it starts.
i enjoyed this it was nice and smooth and he has a really good voice - don’t know if i’ll listen to it again but i thought it was a really enjoyable listen
Never before have I seen such strong willed political commentary that manages to be so wholesome at the same time. This album sees Marvin giving us some genuinely refreshing takes in such a beautiful way, but presents his ideas in such a way that he is showing how he is definitely not a pushover. And not to mention jow beautiful the actual music is, put all of that together and you have a damn perfect album.
Lovely
Pretty good
Is there a greater state of nihilism than not loving a Marvin Gaye record? I’m sorry world. But I suspect I might be in good company with my brother in song reviewing. It’s a protest record I suppose, but he sings about the wrongs of the world in such vague language that it feels meaningless. I feel like I’d legit enjoy the instrumentals somewhat more. All that said, I like the trifecta of tracks 6, 7 and 9. I’d give a higher rating to an EP that dispenses with the vague whingeing about the wrongs of the world and leans in to the groove of Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues.
Just a great unified progressive soul soundscape, almost a play of progressive soul
Marvin ♥️♥️♥️ when I lived in Harlem there was a Hennessy billboard around the corner from my house of him ♥️♥️♥️ he could sing the phone book and I’d be smitten
This is one of the great albums of all time. A timeless masterpiece. The progression from Lets Get It On to this is incredible. This is a lush jazzy beautiful heartfelt call for social change. You can feel his pain and heart breaking for the state of Black culture with a deeply vulnerable and raw delivery.
SO good! I listened to What’s Going On a few times in a row. The lyrics, his smooth voice…loved it.
MG brings sexy to socially conscious music. This is an album in the truest sense of the word. Three absolute classics rise like hymns. In between the groove never flags. While not always a party the players are all having a great time. As immersive as any album of the era - vibes, knowledge and melody collide to put you in the room.
Amazing; can listen all day!
01) What's Going On - 10,0 02) What's Happening Brother - 8,0 03) Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky) - 7,0 04) Save the Children - 7,0 05) God Is Love - 7,0 06) Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - 10,0 07) Right On - 7,5 08) Wholy Holy - 7,0 09) Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - 8,0 TOTAL: 7,94 (79/100) Current ranking: 220/714
Classical music.
Isso aqui é de tirar o fôlego, te deixar sem palavras. Definir e falar sobre What’s Going On é uma tarefa herculeana, de dificuldade imensa. As canções deste álbum são experiências espirituais, e as palavras escapam quando você tenta sintetizar essas experiências. Mas vou tentar. Ajuda que este é um disco que sou bem familiarizado por já ter ouvido-o incontáveis vezes antes. Acredito que este disco e sua produção tenham sido um milagre. Simples assim, intervenção divina. Marvin Gaye era um ótimo artista, não se engane, mas analise a discografia dele e perceba que este álbum realmente se destaca de forma sobrenatural. Ele invocou alguma coisa inexplicável na produção dessa obra. Leia sobre sua produção, e complicações, ninguém queria que Gaye lançasse este álbum, ninguém acreditava nessa sonoridade. Tremendamente errados, eles estavam, e agora o disco reside confortavelmente no panteão dos maiores álbuns já gravados. Que história, hein. Isso aqui é um verdadeiro álbum, de capa a capa. Todas as canções possuem ligações temáticas e sônicas. O disco inteiro é como uma enorme e gigantesca canção. E que canção maravilhosa. Os vocais são angelicais e os instrumentais o adornam maravilhosamente, com menção honrosa à este fantástico baixo. Assim que você termina de ouvir o álbum você sente vontade de ouvi-lo novamente. Viciante, em essência. Muito se fala sobre a importância do comentário social levantado por Gaye neste disco. Eu dou crédito à isso, mas o meu foco é inteiramente na música, no som. O som que ele teceu é inigualável. As letras, se quiser analisar mesmo, são até simples, quando se olha para além do conteúdo incomum para um artista Motown na época. Mas a forma com que ele entrega seus vocais mostra o quão pessoal essas angústias realmente são. A violência que ele pessoalmente presenciou, os relatos do irmão veterano de guerra, a perda de uma grande parceira na vida, problemas familiares, enfim, toda escuridão de sua vida é transformada em 9 canções e 35 minutos de música absolutamente perfeitas. Não há defeito à ser apontado. Um disco perfeito. Parabéns à todos envolvidos. Toda vez que ouço este álbum meu espírito se enche. A alma transborda. 5/5
Behagelickt. Musikk fra ein legende Beste sang: What's going on
Marvin Gaye might just be the greatest soul singer I’ve ever heard. There’s a weight and tenderness in his voice that feels almost otherworldly — every note seems to carry both sorrow and hope. 𝘞𝘩𝘢𝘵’𝘴 𝘎𝘰𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘖𝘯 is more than an album; it’s a living, breathing statement about love, faith, and humanity. From the opening title track to 𝘔𝘦𝘳𝘤𝘺 𝘔𝘦𝘳𝘤𝘺 𝘔𝘦 and 𝘐𝘯𝘯𝘦𝘳 𝘊𝘪𝘵𝘺 𝘉𝘭𝘶𝘦𝘴, the music flows as one continuous meditation, blending lush orchestration, subtle funk grooves, and Gaye’s deeply emotional delivery. Even over fifty years later, it feels completely timeless — a record that could have been made in 2025 and still speak to the same struggles and questions we face today. It’s soulful, political, spiritual, and profoundly human — one of those rare albums where every second feels essential.
Masterpiece. Sounds more relevant today than ever.
A really amazing album. An album about trying to figure things out. Political fear, war, violence, ecological disaster. An incredibly timely album, but one that also feels timeless. The production and musicianship is second to none. One of my favorite albums before starting this 1001 album journey, and it was a great experience getting to relisten to this.
The big hits on this album alone are enough for 5 stars.
Fine. Another one that's easy listening without any real standouts. Almost want to drop it to a 2 for that but it's still probably a 3. Nothing really to dislike.
First listen, but listened to it again later in the day. I think I'm a lot worse at describing what I do like about an album than what I do like about it. What's Going On has been on my list for a while, and I'm glad it was recommended; it's a stunning record! Gaye's voice, and the harmonies on the strings are absolutely beautiful. The sound overall is measured, and tasteful, but not to the extent that it becomes dull in the slightest. I also love the contrast between the haunting, angelic sonic palate, and the often plaintive lyrics. There's an intensely bittersweet yearning to the whole thing, and although it overflows just as readily with faith, and hope for a better future, it never comes across as naive about the sorry state of the world it is criticizing. What's Going On is also superbly paced. The first six tracks flow into each other nicely (I love it when an album does that, it's so exciting!), and Right On being a groovier, more rhythmic track than the ones that precede it saves the whole thing from becoming perhaps a little bit too languorous. Overall, the last three songs are certainly more understated than the rest, I feel, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, though I do like the first six a smidge more. I actually enjoyed my first listen better than the second, which is kind of rare for me. For that reason, I'm not sure if it'll grow on me over time to the extent that most albums do; but thankfully, I already like it a lot. Fav. Track: What's Going On
La verdad que me parece muy relajante melodicamente, y para que mentirnos, anima al folleteo, pero el de un dia fresco de lluvia que se vive lento.
Classic
So smooth it should come with a warning about operating heavy machinery.
Very beautiful, no notes
This kind of R&B/Soul is too smooth and chill for me. I think.
No notes. Perfect album. Unfortunately, just as relevant today as when it was released.
First time I've heard this album! Love the vibe. Every tune is a great one.
PERFECT 10/10
Not nearly as memorable as I expected. Apart from the overplayed hits, rather uninspiring which is a shock
I don’t like soul. I don’t think I’ll ever come to appreciate it. I like complex, grandiose, instrument-driven music, and soul is basically the opposite of that. It’s just not the type of vibe I enjoy, and this album doesn’t do much to differentiate itself from other soul records. So for me, although I can’t say it was hard to listen to, it was underwhelming. 5/10
It pains me to call this a three-star album... the title track and "Mercy, Mercy Me" are two of the greatest soul songs ever written and recorded, and the entire album has such a chill, sweet, spiritual, peaceful, joyous vibe... but the other songs are just largely not doing much for me. Kind of sounds like they just continued to play the "big" songs for another few minutes and Marvin vamped in some lyrics on other topics. These also-rans would surely be highlights for a lesser artist, but there you go, for me this is a couple of jaw-dropping singles and a bunch of filler.
I like Marvin Gaye for the cultural relevance, the emotion and depth of the lyrics and his fantastic voice. This is a great album, but I just don’t see myself listening to it very often. 4⭐️
Nah
Hard not to bump this one up based on his talent alone
It is the most perfect production and orchestration and vocals and lyrics and timing and vibes of any album It’s like a movie score And it gave us “there’s a riot going on” in response
Marvin, so much is going on and a lot of it is not so good, but you keep a cheery disposition through it all. Every song is upbeat and sounds happy, even if the lyrics are serious and I wouldn't want it any other way.
I initially listened to this right before bed and didn’t love it, but I listened again in the morning on a beautiful sunny fall day and it definitely changed my opinion of this album. It’s much more of a walking through the city in the morning album for me. I don’t think I’d go out of my way to listen to it again but I’m glad I gave it a try.
Already knew the artist and part of the album. Relaxing, souly, the lyrics are kind of cringey sometimes. Nothing really bad to say about this one though. Not the best album I've ever heard, too.
Classic, great production, beautiful storytelling, everybody needs soul and anti war art
Do I even have to say anything about this one? Very few albums in the world of music have a reputation like that of What's Going On. Critically speaking, this is easily one of the most highly praised albums of all time. It's a shoe-in for a list such as this. It's easy to see why all of this is the case. What's Going On is a crowning achievement in popular music. What's Going On does things that had been done in music before. This wasn't the first album to tackle Vietnam. It wasn't the first concept album. It wasn't the first soul masterpiece. But never before had these elements been blended together in such a smooth, soulful way from such a mainstream artist as Marvin Gaye. It's albums like this that show us as a collective people what music can and should be; an artform. Music is, ultimately, a creative expression of the individual or group behind it. It allows people to express their complex thoughts in ways that will hopefully resonate with others. This is where What's Going On stands above much of its competition, especially of the time. The song cycle that forms the album acts as a complete artistic statement while also comprising some fantastic songs in their own right. The title track, "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)," "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)," and the other 6 songs work together to paint a picture of sorts. It also helps that the sounds and instruments at play are just gorgeous, while also having a sense of soul and slight funk-influences to aid in enjoyment. Despite not being much higher than the instruments in the mixing, Marvin Gaye's voice sticks out through its beauty. The lyrical themes of the album speak to the listener, while still remaining deeply personal to Gaye himself. I really don't have any issues with the album. While I myself wouldn't go as far as to call this the greatest album of all time, I can absolutely see why so many others have. It's a true work of art that only ages better and better with each passing year. It's What's Going On. 5/5.
Does not get any better than this
One of the best albums ever made
A bona fide classic. Not much else to say.
it’s brilliant, urgent without losing its lushness. his voice is so beautiful and compelling. fav tracks: what’s going on; right on; inner city blues (make me wanna holler)
it all flows together perfectly like a big orchestral piece and feels more like a meditation on the thesis of the album as defined by the opening titular track, than it does an album with many distinct songs. for that reason many of them blended together and i couldn't always tell that the song had ended and changed to a new one, but once i let go of the expectation that it would be a conventional album like that, then i really enjoyed it and appreciated it as a whole. this definitely has to be listened to in full and in order. Fav tracks: What's Going On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
A good album that's a nice listen with messages that are honestly still relevant today. Can't deny that Marvin Gaye is an icon, but through no fault of his own this isn't really my type of music so it's not quite 5 stars for me.
A little too religious at times but a great album
Fun, timeless soul. As always, still relevant. Great singer and artist. Gone too soon.
What's Going On and Let's Get It On sound similar. I had Let's Get it On a few months back but listened to What's Going On instead. A bit embarrassing, but there we are. Listening to What's Going On at least assured me that I didn't like it very much on a second listen either. On the contrary, Let's Get It On was more enjoyable. I think it ultimately came down to the songs. I like the songs when they are distinct songs with structure, I do not enjoy his music when he goes in a more free-flowing, unstructured direction. After the first couple of songs, this is what happens on What's Going On and I just found it hard to get into. It meanders and feels like an extended jamming session that would be fine if you were watching it live or just into the music but it didn't do it for me.
This album is a 35-minute-long song in the best and worst sense possible. It is a kick-ass song indeed, but it lacks the tonal diversity that I believe all five-star records require. I'm ranking this as a four-and-a-half-star album because of its musical excellence. However, I must admit that I believe that its social relevance has a greater weight than its music when we think about this album. It is not bad per se, just felt it was something important to point out.
This is a short album, but somehow it still starts out stronger than it finishes. It's a great album, but not a 5.
Come on these are gimme’s lol.
Vocally superb, but not my cup of tea.
How about What’s Going On? Released in 1971, it wasn’t just Marvin Gaye’s masterpiece, it was a miracle it existed at all. Motown didn’t want it. Berry Gordy thought protest songs would tank sales. But Marvin had just lost his singing partner (Tammi Terrell), his brother had come back from Vietnam traumatized, and America was coming apart at the seams. He wasn’t interested in pop anymore. He wanted truth. So he made an album that felt like a single, continuous thought. The songs flow into each other like chapters in a sermon or movements in a suite. He’s mourning, questioning, and pleading, but he’s also making you move. That’s the trick: the groove saves the grief. Even “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)”—a lament for the planet—sways like it belongs at a summer block party. It’s protest you can dance to. Philosophy you can sing along with. And over 50 years later, it still sounds like the most beautiful cry for help ever pressed to vinyl. Spin it. Stream it. Listen to it or just dance. You’re rewarded any way it happens.
Solid
mercy, mercy me (makes sense that this is the soul album of reference)
3,2/5
Enjoyable overall, but doesn't do enough to absolutely love it.
Oh God.... That's beautiful
Probably the greatest, most soulful anti-war album ever recorded. A beautiful listen! 5/5
What's Going On is a very good album worthy of many accolades. However, I do have one bone to pick which is with "Save The Children," which contains one of my most disliked song topics: children. I will simply have to defer to Norm Macdonald for the rest of this review: When I was a child, they said 'The children are our future.' Then I grew up and they said, 'No, actually, it's these other children.' I know a Ponzi scheme when I see it.
Classic. No notes.
1 connue
Dans le brouhaha et le fouillis de saint lazare j’ai pas trop réussi à me concentrer sur l’écoute
C'est étonnant la décontraction de cette album Le mec est trop chill mais les sons sont oufs et politiques (parfois)
Sonically the album is perfect, the funky base lines, the jazz drums, and the gospel/soul vocals in the background blend perfectly together. Combined with the political lyrics about Vietnam War, Police Brutality, Poverty, Systemic Racism and Environmental Degradation, i think this album shows how you can blend mellow music with political decisions and that’s the beauty of humanity
Ein absolutes Meisterwerk! Marvin Gaye verbindet seine Stimme mit zeitlosen Botschaften. Das Album klingt heute noch so frisch und relevant wie damals. Jeder Song ein Highlight, pure Gänsehaut! Die Songs fliessen ineinander wie ein einziges grosses Kunstwerk: elegant, emotional und voller Botschaft. Für mich ein Meisterwerk der Musikgeschichte und ein Album, das man nicht nur hört, sondern fühlt.
I have dipped in and out if this before and found some of the production quite overblown... However...when it hits its groove it's incredible.
Timeless
This is a cool, soulful record with some gorgeous production. Not the sort of thing I'd listen to regularly and perhaps quite sonically similar overall, but it's decent for sure. Favourite tracks: What's Happening Brother, Wholy Holy, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler).
Absolutely one of the best for me. It would be a fine collection of soul pop songs if that were all they were, but then the progressive and conceptual side is so strong. I love how the tracks have such a strong message. I love how the tracks evolve and search and find new forms. There is so much beautiful modal mixture and unexpected modulation that moves the music in unexpected directions.
Smooth easy listening, no standouts though.
Really cool love the music and the vibe the only thing that’s holds it back for me it how much religious songs there were
Well I was expecting more of this album. There are some great songs in here (What's Going On/ Inner City Blues/Mercy Mercy Mercy) but the album feels a little bit all over the place. I can understand why this is on the list but it's a 3 for me
Marvin’s finest work! What beautiful consciousness and tone on this album. A Masterpiece!
Captures the mood of the early seventies with some great vocals and arrangements. The title track is still the standout for me on a very soulful album.
Social conscience & amazing soul
Album Art Review - The Man - Marvin looking peak. Cool font for the album title and artist's name. 6.5/10 Marvin is on the Mount Rushmore of soul singers and mayby my favorite. This album cements his transition from Motown crooner and collaborator to a political Voice of protest and the oppressed. We need him now!! Absolutely iconic Songs like What's Going On, Save the Children, Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues are just as relevant today as they were 50 years ago and still sound great.
The titular track was one of mom's favourites so this hits a bit different. Very mum music. Would pair well with some Kennny G or Simply Red.
Y’a une raison pourquoi c’est un top 5 all Time dans 3/4 des listes
Classique des classique
Yurp its a banger
35 délicieuses minutes de soul distillé. Quand j'écoute cet album je deviens Chrétien pour une demi-heure, bravo Marvin.
Not a bad album, it was pretty chill, enjoyed having it in the background while I was doing stuff.
This is one album that I’ve never quite been able to get. Not bad by any means, just now what I enjoy listening to.
Very good album
Such an amazing voice but the album felt pretty uneven to me.
Still missing you, Marvin ♾️ What's Going On ♾️ Mercy, Mercy Me
A legend and I know this one is top, but I love his older motown records more
Sings great. Good band. But it's a little boring.
This was a nice classic sound. Felt like i was sat in a conversation pit having a cocktail
Masterpiece
Ja wat moet ik hier nou van zeggen, ik weet het niet zo goed. Opzich wel lekker, maar niet helemaal mijn genre. Wel een heerlijke stem en emotie.
This was good, but I wouldn't say it was better than that. It had soothing parts, fun parts, and deep parts. That said, much of it was just kinda boring/bland to me. Nothing here was bad, I just didn't find it very interesting as a whole. Right On was probably the track that stood out the most due to what it did with the instrumentation. Having more like that would've made me like it more. Overall, I enjoyed it but can't rate it super highly. Overall: 3.1/5
Impressive
Nice. Very mellow protest album
excellent listen
His eleventh album. Soul. The themes are powerful and Gaye seems very heartfelt. The album is cohesive and the vocals are wonderful. There's no stand out track for me. Theis album requires listening to as a whole. Beautifully done !
"Who really cares to save a world in despair?" This was unexpectedly political but very enjoyable. Most of what he's talking about in this album is still, sadly, very relevant today.
Absolute jams
Some loungey hours that I looked. Quite preachy but it's his style. Best songs at the end that are less hits and more soul.
Classic for a reason, really love the production and songwriting, the voice at times a bit too melodramatic for me.
10/10 The thing that kept coming to mind while listening to this album was just how good Marvin Gaye’s vocal performance is, Every note, from start to finish, is absolutely stunning. The instrumental composition and performances are also exceptional, but it’s so hard not to have your entire focus pulled by the vocal that you have to make a conscious effort to absorb everything else that’s going on. But just discussing the vocal performance here does the album a massive disservice. It’s a remarkable piece of social commentary, a masterclass in mood and tone, and an intensely personal exploration of the world around Marvin Gaye circa 1971. What’s also important to note is that releasing something like this was an incredibly bold move. Motown had typically been a hit single factory up to this point, and Berry Gordy didn’t even want to release the title track, only to turn back round and ask for a full album when it became their fastest ever selling single. It’s a fascinating work that really toys with the idea of this being a selection of individual songs, rather than a unified piece, and there are places where you can’t even tell where the transitions between songs happens without keeping an eye on the track count. There is so much groove and soul to this album that it almost drips out of the speakers, but it’s all laced with a deep undercurrent of wistful melancholy that just hooks into the emotional side of the brain and holds on tight. And with all of that said, it’s actually an album that is far greater than the sum of its parts. Looking at individual tracks, one might not fully appreciate the gravity of the work, or truly connect with the string of feeling that threads through the whole album, but listened to as a whole, it is a truly remarkable work that only gets better with repeat listens. What’s Going On - What a song. It’s got such a groove, an absolutely stunning vocal performance, and manages to be a successful social commentary without bashing you over the head with it. The composition is brilliant, with so many different elements that provide depth and nuance without overcrowding. It perfectly balances the groove with a feeling of melancholy to present a really unique tone.The strings are great, the percussion gives it a little bit of pep underneath everything. And the production is fantastic too. So well balanced. What’s Happening Brother - This is kind of a part 2 to ‘What’s Going On’. It carries the tone of that first track but takes the groove in a slightly different direction. I love the almost aimless stroll of the bass line. The backing vocals add a different flavour, and again Marvin is on point with the lead. It feels effortless. “And tell me, friend, how in the world have you been?” The delivery of that line gets me every single time. Flyin’ High (In The Friendly Sky) - And we drift into a dreamy number about heroin addiction. It’s a bit meandering, but when you connect it with the subject matter that really hooks things up and makes sense. There are some stunning moments in this and it touches base in various places in a remarkable way before drifting off again. Save The Children - And we slip into another track. Marvin’s voice soars and oh good lord, that vocal tone. It’s so rich. This track builds in intensity as the drums gradually become more full, and the saxophone drops in with some great little hooks. The final minute throws in a different groove, it’s almost like a different track and an intro to the next track. God Is Love - The combination of the funky bass, slow strings, the subtle groove of the drums and Marvin’s vocal doubling makes the hairs on my neck stand up every time. There’s something about this track that just hits me so hard. It’s just exceptional all round. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - And quick transition, the groove sticks around but the tone switches to more of a lament. There’s a lot going on in the instrumentation for a lot of this album and it’s easy to miss it because Marvin’s voice just demands your focus, but when the instrumental section for this track has it’s moment, the players get to shine. The groove of the bass, some brilliant horns, piano, percussion, celeste (I think?), strings, the whole works. Right On - Continuing the theme of the second half of ‘Mercy Mercy Me’, there’s a bit more space for the players to have some fun. This is such a great, jazzy groove that oozes soul. There are places where it maybe drags a tiny bit, but there are also some really beautiful phrases and riffs that pop out here and there, and Marvin’s little bits and pieces of vocal are a delight. Wholy Holy - This is a more sparse effort that softly ebbs and flows. It feels like the parts drift away from each other and then just thrust back together again in little bursts. It keeps teasing little resolutions, but quickly returns to points of tension, setting us up for the finale. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - Marvin’s vocal through the intro here is the epitome of soul. It’s so smooth and when he doubles up it’s so, so clean. The groove is restrained, but it just pulses so nicely. The build of the instrumentation is pretty special, too. The control of how instrumental parts dip in and out is exceptional. I absolutely adore some of his vocal harmonisations in this track. And then we get that lovely piano and vocal duet before the congas come in and we drift away.
This man’s voice is absolutely gorgeous. Mercy Mercy is one of my favorites of his. That said, there are some tracks on this album that I don’t enjoy all that much, which stops it from getting all 5 stars.
Classic album. Generational Talent.
obvio
The most chilled political album of all time? Some great songs on here but also some filler. Save The Children is nothing short of awful and other tracks all pass you by without impact. Inner City, Mercy and the title track are excellent .
Amazing
Perfect album
Love it. Own it.
My favourite forever. This is more than a record. It's pure art, magic and a manifesto.
It's Marvin Gaye.
Decent album, but not much going on.
Great voice, needs another go.
Marvin Gaye singing about praying is surprisingly almost as compelling as Marvin Gaye singing about fucking.
Stunningly so good
malo slabije od prošlog gejovog albuma, tu ima nekih brija, al i dalje solidno
4 stars
Slightly weaker than other Marvin Gaye albums, but still really good.