Reviews (page 13 of 14)
very smooth i enjoy had it in the background tho and didn't feel invested enough to give it a good hard listen. got a couple good songs offa it
Big upswing for me with Mercy Mercy Me and inner city blues. Rest of the album wasn't my speed. I don't think I'll add the songs to my library but there's some settings where I think I'd quiet enjoy this in the background. 3/5 for me again!
>Feels like a fancy bar didn't unknown location I'm poor so I can't go this is nice thank you >You get a verity of music >Nice for a lone drive would recommend
Waking up on a good Wednesday morning not feeling a single worry and thanking god for all the good things in this small world kind of vibe, (4.3/5)
Not my favorite
Album was good and blended the songs pretty well, but i think that is what i didn’t like about it. It felt like more of the same but still solid enough to listen through it.
Initial thoughts: ngl yall, soul music isnt really my thing. i correlate it too much with lobby music. BUT (dont cancel me yet) BUT, this was album was a pleasant experience nonetheless. Final Thoughts: Strong start, follow ups were mid but ultimately brought back by the back half.
A smooth album overall, not my style, but still a great album.
Pretty chill but not a fan of the jesus songs. If I had a restaurant this would be good to play in the bkg.
Nice listening
Protest
The fact that this album came out in 1971 blows my mind. I can see and feel it's influence as a concept album across the decades. Gaye's seemingly effortless vocals and messaging are just as impressive and important 50+ years later as they ever were. High Point: What's Going On Low Point: n/a Surprise Hit: Save The Children
I enjoyed the music, but this was not my style.
I liked the soulfullness of this album but I felt a little lack luster towards the end of the album. Still was a great listen.
Straight 5.
Part angel's prayer, part biting social commentary. The vocals contain so much – sincere despair, heartbreaking resignation and tempered hope for better days. The modulation and occasionally wavering in the singing are highly engaging. The delicate mood and achingly lovely tone are sustained across the entire record. The title cut and “Mercy Mercy Me” and “Inner City Blues” are the top cuts, but the quality is of a whole and never much falters. The lush arrangements somehow seem both elegantly understated and overwhelmingly powerful. Not sure how he pulled that off. Damn near perfect -- the beauty and excellence makes one want to holler in praise.
It's good, I like it. It's just that the album sounds like an album-length version of the first song. It's done well though.
One of these perfect super-classic timeless albums that sound 5* from the first second.
This may be considered a super classic album, but I really did not like this at all. Man, the endless whining on these songs, seriously ...
Very nice, elegant, meaningful, but I do not get the 'best record ever' vibe.
A work of art, best enjoyed on vinyl.
It was just so influential, I enjoyed it quite well, but its the significance that takes it all the way.
Ya había escuchado este album antes, le di otra oportunidad pero simplemente no es para mi, honestamente no puedo entender por qué está en el pedestal en el que lo ponen, de todas formas el mensaje sigue siendo relevante a día de hoy y eso es por lo menos admirable, más allá de eso, se me hace un album promedio sin mucho nuevo o digno de recordar
not my type...
Love some Marvin Gaye great album got to be in the right mood
Beautiful album where the songs just flow into each. 50+ years later Marvin Gaye may just be the coolest person who ever existed.
Sweet sexy grooves
It looks like today we have some baby-making music! I suspect that I probably know more songs by Marvin Gaye than I realise. In high school, I remember learning Let’s Get It On on guitar and feeling super cool, but I honestly can’t think of many more Marvin songs off the top of my head. Let’s listen! Songs I already knew: Mercy Mercy Me Favourites: Mercy Mercy Me, What’s Going On It’s strange, but I recognised the title of What’s Going On, but not the actual song. Regardless, it was an enjoyable listen, as was the rest of the album. I enjoyed how the songs would tend to bleed into one another, making it feel more like a full album experience. My only critique, and it is a fairly big one for me, is that each song sounded a little TOO similar for my taste, meaning that as the album approached the end I found myself getting a little bored. I will say though, that this album got me pregnant.
Not a single bad song on this album. His voice is smooth and relaxing.
The title track is bussin', respectfully
Marvin Gaye is a treat, What’s going on is such a directed emotional album, puts you in a certain mood listening through it.
The same old thing keeps happening.
Not my kind of music, but clearly a very well made political statement that's very well delivered (and also offers some fine music). Here's an album that actually deserves to be in a list such as this.
I have both pity and envy to those who haven't yet heard this album. My 100th album on this app!! It's been a great journey of music discovery so far.
No amount of words can give justice to this. Perfect in every way
I'd imagine a five is way too low for this fucking masterpiece! Beautiful album, fantastic concept record done perfectly
I understand why this album has the reputation that it does — every track has an absolutely immaculate groove. Marvin’s voice is delicate, inviting you in to the song only to hit you with a powerful belt at a song’s climax. The players on this are _phenomenal_, including the GOAT James Jamerson, and the engineering is clear and immaculate. I can’t wait to listen to this on headphones
Fav Songs: What’s Going On, Right On Least Fav Songs: Flyin’ High (in the friendly sky), Save the Children
i dont love marvin gaye, but whether or not its your favorite, you can tell he crafted this with love and care. bells ruminating in the background, songs blend into the next song flawlessly. its a great album. i just dont love slow soul. no offense. excellent.
Je connaissais cet album avant mais le fait qu'il ne soit pas dans ma rotationest révélateur : c'est un excellent album mais étonnamment je reste à quai un peu trop souvent. Je pourrais écouter plus souvent "What's going on", "Mercy, mercy" et sans doute redonner sa chance. La voix, l'orchestration, le groove de l'ensemble, ça mériterait d'y revenir quand même
Really nice touch imho
What it lacks in punctuation it makes up for in pleather collars. Would be a 5 but for the lack of a question mark and the God stuff
I appreciate this good man’s work… but it’s just not for me, sorry Marv
Smooth
Yeah cool but don't like it?
Short and sweet! Some highly played songs that I didn't really recognize which was interesting.
very chill jazzy and vibey; i feel like i could fall asleep to it a lot of the songs sound very similar but i still enjoyed listening to them all
A classic for anyone’s collection who appreciates motown style soul and melody’s whose lyrics are so profound. I remember this album back in the day when growing up and after so many years it was pleasant to listen again. I saw him in concert while working security and he put on a fabulous show. So much talent, it’s a shame he’s been gone almost 40 years!
pretty good
I love Marvin Gaye, and I wish I had the context to this album before I listened. As a stand alone musical experience it fell a little flat for me. It's something I'd have on in the background but not the centerpiece that I expected from this album. Feeling a bit let down but I don't want that to sway my review into the 1 or 2 stages. A side = Pretty good. B side = really fell flat for me.
A fantastic illustration of how good music can make slightly wet politics groovy and sexy. I tend towards a more austere, radicalism rather than this fluffy goop but, do you know what? Who fucking cares? Bop after bop. The album feels like worn leather in an expensive old car, and smells like fresh tobacco, pepper corns and caramel. What's more, Gaye sings about how fish are full of mercury and I simply never considered that before. He's on a long list of people I think the CIA killed with very little evidence and that makes him something of a little martyr for those sweet little fishlings. Rest in strength Mon Frere!
Legend
Introspective sounds of the revolution. A totally different energy from Sly's Stand! album. It's a compact statement with amazing songs, production, and performances.
I am sure I reviewed this...very solid entry and enjoyable.
Short, solid, quality album that takes you on a journey. I only knew a couple of the tracks, but it felt very complete.
What happens when a 70s soul singer confronts the realities of war and addiction? When he stops singing love songs and starts singing protest songs? You get something that's both angry but remarkably calm. It's doubtless an important album. I really appreciate both the skill and meaning behind it but unfortunately I didn't love most of the music.
Very good
i'll tell you what's going on, a classic 70s album style of 2 hits and a load of filler. I know its a protest album and that's cool but it doesn't really do a lot for me.
So Gaye.
classique. y retourner pour sûr. 8.5/10
nice of him to ask. thank you marvin
Brilliant. Love it so much. Still so relevant and powerful
Its okay
Many of the tracks feel like the same song
3/5
This album is just gorgeous. I’m not an expert on soul by any stretch but this one just makes you feel things. Always into a good concept album as well.
one of the GOATs
I found this a little dull and generic. Sorry Marvin.
Jes! Tää on about täydellinen soul-levy! Nuff' said. 5/5
Tässä on jotenkin ihan maaginen tunnelma, kuin oma maailmansa. Nimikko, Mercy ja ICB ovat aina olleet isoja lemppareita, mutta pikkuhiljaa muillekin biiseille on syttynyt. Vitoseen taipuu. Saisi olla vähän pidempikin!
Täydellistä, kun Marvin saa kans erinomaisen musiikin lisäksi sanoa jotain maailmasta. 5/5
Amazing: This was just a perfect soul album and put you in the perfect mood for just life in general. From first song to last I felt that it was fresh and creative even though it's over 50 years old. Marvin Gaye you are a perfect musician and I would 1000% listen to this album again without a complaint.
This is really one of the Greatest Albums here.
Such a beautiful record, and Marvin is singing about issues that are just as relevant today.
I’m slightly torn on my rating. I totally get the cultural and political impact this album had, but do I enjoy it as an album as much an others here? Nope. There are some bangers without a doubt, but other songs I’d be happy to skip. Don’t judge me.
This album is amazing. Yeah, hot take, I know. This album is also horribly sad, partly because the issues that Marvin Gaye addresses on this album are the same now as they were then. This album is beautiful and it’s both a miracle and a tragedy that it was then and will always be the definitive statement on race and the environment in America. Such a bummer, such a great album.
Good album - too much god/religion - slightly annoying.
Nice but a bit samey. At least the samey parts are good. Favortie song: Mercy Mercy Me
Let’s Marvin gaye and get it on
Rating: 4.3
Classic soul, R&B album by the late, great Marvin Gaye. Without a shadow of doubt his best album. Nothing but knockouts, and what a voice the man has. Backed by a great band. it stands out to me how each song flows into the next one. The album touches upon some dark topics, but the songs seem lighthearted, but if you look up the lyrics. All in all, excellent album that I love to listen to! 9 out of 10
Got a bit samey.
It was enjoyable! Definitely not my genre but very well made and nice lyrics
Marvin Gaye and Incubus being on the same list is pretty bad. Those two things don't belong on the same planet. Man, the high points on this album are like nothing else.
Not sure I can add anything that hasn't been said before. Even my personal reflections feel a bit moot. There's a great biography out there called something like His Divided Self, a window into the sad, strange life of Marvin Gaye.
This was a more morose affair than I anticipated, but yeah - classic for a reason. Surprised by how many versions there were on Apple Music. Anybody listen to "The Detroit mix"?
Good album as a cohesive whole
didn't fully get the hype when I listened to it first years ago but then I got good headphones and could hear Jamerson's basslines, then learned more context, now it's one of my favourites lol
Já, ég hef annað álit á Marvin Gaye núna en fyrir 25 árum, en sorrý. Þessi plata er samt stórkostleg á allan hátt.
22nd August 2023 Listened in the morning in bed while having a sleepy baby on me. Who knows how we fill our days now! Powerfully political soul, the title of the album perfectly captures the laid back friendly engagement with the political cry.
Iconic cover and from the first note of the album you're transported to another world. It's a troubled world and not unlike the one we're in now so not much has changed in 52 years. It's Monday morning and i'm getting ready to go to work for another week. This is what music is supposed to do - affect you. The notes and singing are smooth and groovy but the subject matter is one of strife. This gets a big fat 5 'cos it's simply one of the greats and what this chart was set up for.
This is a great album. I heard talk about Flint's water in the opening...man, nothing changes. 5/5
I don’t think I’ve ever heard the album mix of the title track. I found it a bit distracting. Awesome album overall.
There aren't many albums better than this.
A groovy yet emotionally charged album, Marvin Gaye looks around and watches society crumble apart, with songs about kids starving on the street, families being torn apart by the Vietnamese war, the aftermath trauma on those veterans, drug addiction, and the environment literally threatening human existence. The lyrics are simple enough that you can follow along and understand the messages he sends, never dragging too long or going on unnecessary tangents. Everything is relevant and to the point. It's hard to find a more consistent album. You really can't tell when one song ends and another begins. The mood flows perfectly and gradually shifts with the songs. Themes persist and are revisited but twisted. This creates a pretty fun experience, with the audience watching how the same melodies can be altered to create different effects and tell different stories. Marvin Gaye's vocals are top notch, smooth and sincere, easy to listen, clear, and yet has a lot to say. But not too much. The instrument is sparse and light enough to relax you and immerse you in the music, especially due to its atmospheric and diverse sounds, with all sorts of instruments (including woodwinds, brass, different percussions), synth effects, and back vocals. It's at times funky to sing or dance to, and at times like a beautifully happy or sad movie soundtrack. I'm also incredibly impressed by the production. Very few soul albums from the early 70s are up to par in terms of the clarity and mixing, as good as Stevie Wonder. This album flies by in 36 minutes. You couldn't argue that any track on here is unnecessary or could be cut. In fact, any less and you'd be complaining it was too short. Melodically, every song transitions well from one to the next. Of course, you got your hits ("What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me"). You got your interlude ("God Is Love"). You got your epic ("Right On"). And you got your satisfying closer ("Inner City Blues"). I don't have the faintest clue how you could improve this record.
Nah 2
Powerful classic
Resplendent, if a little homogeneous. Even if some of the tracks feel similar, if they’re all this well-written and passionately voiced it hardly matters.
Truly no words to describe this experience Let the music speak for itself
Top album
chill and introspective and kinda sexy even?? so good
damn, no one did soul like marvin gaye. his voice is remarkably smooth, a great accompaniment to the music. i don't think he was capable of making a bad song. his music creates such a sense of calm and contentment, almost making it easy to not pay attention to his significant lyrics. and speaking of--i'd be a fool if i didn't mention the over-arching theme on this album. what's going on reflects issues in society and gaye's changing perspective, a definite turning point of his career. all of the topics are important, even to this day, and gaye gives a lot of social issues significant time on this album, all while making great music. gosh, who knew soul could sound so political yet remain easy listening?
This was primarily a soul album, but with a significant amount of groove and funk to it. The way that all of the songs flow into the next works incredibly well here considering so many of the songs are topical and addressing social issues. Most of the Marvin Gaye that I have heard is 60s era Martin Gaye, so hearing this was like experiencing a new side of his music for me; I definitely feel like he's moved on to trying something a little different by this point. That said, his music does seem a little bit "darker" at this point, which makes sense, considering the transition from the 60s into the 70s. Marvin Gaye was always very smooth in the 60s, and he shows here that despite a change in genre, topics, and overall mood, he just STAYS smooth.
Bien, normal.
Niet slecht, maar niet mijn stijl
A classic for a reason. Listen to find out What's Going On.
It's a really good album but I just don't like high pitched male vocals. Figure I better give one of his three 1001 offerings a rating above 3
I know this is an important album, the greatest of all time on some lists, and possibly the first Motown protest LP. I like the hits, especially Inner City and the title track, though I agree with the critic who said the party sounds in the background are out of place. Right On has a nice jazzy latin vibe but the remainder of the LP is a bit soft for me.
I get that this is supposed to be a concept album and the songs segue into each other but the entire first side dragged a bit for me. What’s going on is indeed a classic song though. Side two was a bit of a relief because it added a little bit more variety and it ended with the best song in the album in my opinion - Inner city blues. I know this was the “top album of all time” on a few lists, but it got a bit too preachy for me and dare I say it… over produced.
Surely everyone knows and loves this album. One of the most important albums of its genre (or any other); THE highlight of Marvin Gaye's career: it was all downhill from this point onwards, but what a highpoint!
Excellent 4.75/5
Magnificent vocals... Gone too soon
Groovy and lots of his beautiful voice!
I am a very big fan of this album. I have previously listened to this album, but I re-listened and it is still great. The vocals are nearly unmatched, and the composition as well as the message are flawless.
Awesome album. Classic with a smooth vibe. Feel good tone throughout. Highly enjoyed this album.
Marvin Gaye is rightly consider a, if not the legend of soul. His voice is so distinctive and evokes pure emotion. I only became aware of the context after listening to the album but the themes of global and social destruction and despair definitely felt prescient
Alright, some Marvin Gaye. Can't go wrong there. What a nice smooth voice. Very nice. 4 stars.
5 init
Makes me wanna holler with joy
What else did you expect
I hadn’t heard this uninterrupted for over 20 years, and am thankful for being given a weekend for this. Perhaps the only song cycle/concept album that I consider flawless. A student flatmate once complained that the record was samey, which I worried over, but now doesn’t bother me. Its consistency is a marvel.
I've thought highly of this for a good while although don't really listen to it that much. Reading its back story, and that of Marvin Gaye in general, surprised me how radical this album actually was. Of course, it also contains some great tunes. A bit preachy but can't really ding it for that. And, what a piece of shit David Ruffin was! Full marks here
Perfecto de inicio a fin.
No need to write anything here, it's What's Going On by Marvin Gaye. People who don't like this are empirically wrong.
Love the sound, but there’s a bit too much about Jesus.
Nothing notable.
Sould music at its finest believe he recorded it in europe somewhere to get away from demons, maybe fighting demons is ehat they should call it. Still solid
Aaaaaahhh. That's better. Cheers Marvin.
It's got some great tracks ... it's got some alright tracks.
Great album, high production, everything just flows. Mercy Mercy Me is a particular favourite.
Masterpiece of an album with what is, in my opinion, the greatest singing voice ever. "What's Going On", "Mercy, Mercy, Me" and one of my favorite songs ever, "Inner City Blues" (which is also the theme for what I think is the greatest TV show ever, The Wire). 10/10
Think of one aspect of this album and tell me it’s not perfect. Lyrics, production, instrumentation, chords, structure, etc. Pure vibes coming off this thing. 5/5
One of my top five albums of all time by one of my top 5 favorite artists of all time
You know that longing, earnest saxophone that opens behind the chatty greetings of “What’s Going On?” You're hearing it in your mind now and your head is starting to nod like you’re saying “No!” to everything other than the riff, the song, and its ideas. Right? Eli Fontaine, a session sax player, was just warming his chops in the studio over the track when Gaye told him to go home. Gaye said, “We’ve already got what we need.” Somewhat incredulous and probably taking it as a dismissal, Fontaine insisted that he was only “goofing around.” Gaye responded with, “Well, you goof exquisitely.” Simply put, one of the greatest albums ever, ever made. 'Nuff said.
Really enjoyed listening to this album. Seems that the world hasn't changed much since Marvin was singing about "What's going on"
Highlights: What's Going On Leave Em's: Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) Overall Thoughts: I am a big proponent for this album as a whole as I think the messages that it pushes are great. This album seems pertinent to today as well and it would be good if more people deeply listened to this record. This album lost points in my book for not having very much replay value, or my thinking that many songs individually were nothing too special. None of the songs were poor per say, but some were slightly boring musically. Marvin's delivery is really good and the instrumentation does a good job or not inhibiting the goal of the album. There is wisdom laden throughout this project but I won't be taking a lot of the individual songs with me when I go. Score Breakdown: 3.700 & 5 -> 4.350
Little bit too preachy for me but it has a nice vibe
it's what's going on, duh it's good. obvious picks are the opener and closer, but it's generally pretty solid throughout.
A couple classics on this one. The rest is fine. 3.5/5
довольно неплохо
Как мне показалось, мы послушали просто мужскую версию Эрики Баду. Разве что аранжировки более симфонические, тогда ещё не придумали ни синтов, ни семплов, ни драмки. Блин, ну кайф-кайфный, мне прям понравилось: особенно, что он не затянут. С удовольствием переслушал ещё пару раз. Прям хорошо.
Smoooooth!
Not bad! I’m not really into soul music but it’s alright. I didn’t mind it but I probably wouldn’t listen to it again.
Fabulous album. I was working the entire time on something and the lyrics kept pulling me back to focus on them. Great empathetic messages the still ring true. Very groovy music. Great all around
A true classic. Not easy listening, as it is soul in its purest form, but if you dig deep you will find everything: smooth arrangements, meaningful lyrics, one of the best singing voices ever. And timeless songs like 'What's Going On' or 'What's Happening Brother'.
big grooves
An utter classic. Few things sound as good as this album. A watertight backing band and Marvin at the peak of his vocal prowess. The kind of love this album has is interesting-- it's sensual, but not sexual. It's love for your family, your kin, your siblings, your community. A love that there's hopefully a better world down the line, somewhere. Marvin, I really want to be able to say we were able to bring about that better world. I wish I could have more time to digest this album. A high 4/5.
Feel good music, cool vibes. Fantastic start to the album, with the party acoustics. Love it.
Good soul album that lyrically touches on lots of heavy topics. Gaye's voice is so easy on the ears. No major standout tracks but no duds either.
I expected slightly better I'll be honest. One or two decent tunes, but the rest were so so and the album is only 35 mins long
Blir soul bedre?
I'm not crying. YOU'RE crying!
Masterpiece
4.4 Not quite enough to round it up but MWAH. fave songs: whats going on, mercy mercy me
I just can't get into this album. Unironically, I think I can't relate well to the subject matter bc of my privilege. I also don't like the sound of it
This album is the opposite of Gay(e). Every song was nice and different. It only gets a 3 because i can’t really picture myself revisiting the album or really listening to any of the songs again but i enjoyed this listen through, just like I did the first time I listened to it last year
Turns out What's Going On and Let's Get It On are very different albums. This feels like the platonic ideal of R&B. Seriously still holds up. BT - What's Goin On - What's Happening Brother - Mercy Mercy Me - Right On - Inner City Blues
Great vocals but a bit too slow for me with no diversity in the songs.
Very influential and important album, but for me listening to this 50 years later and not being a soul fan, i cant give more than 3 stars
La musique coule de source, on se laisse emporter, si bien qu'il est facile de perdre de vue les messages sociaux importants qui sous-tendent cet album.
4/5. It’s almost a perfect album but some of the songs meander a little too long. The content is so important but I find myself waiting for certain songs to finish to get to the next one. It’s still quite a good album, with a wonderful message and beautiful singing and instrumentation. Just not perfect songwriting.
One of those perfect albums
trop catho
Inspiring, hopeful, reflexive. One in a million.
Bon. Critique sociale, guerre du Vietnam, tensions raciales. Chaque chanson de l'album se suit super bien avec l'autre ds un loop. J'apprécie plus à chaque écoute, mais au début moyen.
Some absolute all timers but a slightly soft middle.
This is one of the great socially conscious albums, a thoughtful, elegant rumination on troubled times. It's the greatest work of Marvin Gaye's career, one that still has resonance 50 years later. These songs come across as a series of conversations on war, the environment, faith and social struggle, all expressed with great thoughtfulness and pathos. You can really feel the uncertainty and sadness in Gaye's voice, who has never sounded better. The songs are artful and soulful and a pleasure to listen to. The middle of the album is a little weak, which keeps this from being a solid 5. But it's a unique and unforgettable work, a high water mark of its genre and its time. Fave Songs: What's Going On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler), Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Right On, What's Happening Brother
Buena voz tranquila y a medio tiempo de un cantante con mucho reconocimiento. Voz negra. Para escuchar muy tranquilamente
One of my favourites and part of the soundtrack to a lot of my teens.
What's going on? You are listening to one of the top ten albums of all time. That's what's going on. A collection of marvelous songs. of a legend in his peak and with an astonishing production. All songs go on in one flow talking about love for people and more important the world we live in. An album stating concerns about our behavior towards nature in 1971. What a visionary and too bad how we failed him!
Good album.
Everything is good about this album.
I expected more
Ett av de allra bästa soulalbumen, ibland det bästa.
Transcendent and resplendent. This... might be a legitimately perfect album.
Surprisingly tight, and the concept was very strong. A low 5, but a 5 nonetheless.
a masterpiece with his Let's get it on.
A little altruistic, but that's what the times called for.
Sé que es un clásico, pero yo nunca pude terminar de entrarle
What a great album. Wish it was longer. Great flow. A classic and still very relevant to today.
Some to most albums are just collections of songs, this is actually an album album. Phenomenal and peak soul.
listened to this one multiple times this weekend, such an incredible album. amazingly (and depressingly) this album released in 1971, but all of the critiques it had about society still completely apply today. marvin gaye also has one of the best voices ever in music, further carrying this album.
Ja gewoon goed, heerlijke classic
Echt een prachtig album!! Zie dit al helemaal opstaan in de auto naar vakantie oid. N.b: hadden we maar naar Marvin geluisterd in de jaren 70 dat de wereld naar de ju zou gaan 😢😢
Hoewel r&b en soul mij niet per se liggen, springt dit album er voor mij direct uit. Toevallig onlangs nog een artikel gelezen over dit album, hoe What’s Going On over ongelijkheid gaat, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) over het klimaat, waar Marvin relatief vroeg mee was. Hoe het hem lukte een politiek album op Motown te uit te brengen. Dit album is niet je standaard r&b/soul album en dat hoor je direct. Hoe naadloos de nummer overvloeien, Save The Children > God Is Love > Mercy Mercy Me voelt als 1 lang nummer. Prachtige teksten zonder pretentie, wat soms lastig is als je een politieke boodschap over wilt brengen. What’s Going On is natuurlijk vandaag de dag een nog megahit, waar velen denk ik toch de boodschap erin missen. Zijn stem is zo zacht als boter en dat helpt ook. Hier en daar een hint van jazz (percussie op Save The Children, de blazers op Mercy Mercy Me) wat het album meer diepte geeft. Na het luisteren en deze review schrijven zie ik op rateyourmusic.org dat dit het nummer 1 album van 1971. In een jaar waar gigantisch veel goede muziek uit kwam, muzikaal innovatief en vooruitstrevend (Masters of Reality, Tago Mago, Maggot Brain), spant dit album volgens die snobistische gebruikers blijkbaar de kroon, en dat zegt voor mij al genoeg. Alom geprezen en gewaardeerd, het is onmogelijk dit album niet leuk te vinden.
Mega beautiful : )
Soulful and socially conscious, this album is full of joyful music Trojan Horsing a not so subtle plea for equality, peace, and racial harmony. It’s a cool stylish way of delivering an impactful message.
Long time listener, yet it still gives me chills
What's going on is iconic. I really disliked some of the songs though. Save the Children seems like a parody.
Ganz nett, holt mich aber nicht hinter dem Ofen hervor.
One of the shining gems of soul, perfectly capturing the restless times in which it was made. Marvin Gaye’s finest hour on record.
It's fun to see, at some point, the album tying itself up in a full circle. Otherwise, nice jams. Something I could and would listen to again.
Smooth and an easily approachable sound. The title track and Inner City Blues stand out the most for me... both soulful with a an amazing melodic and groove. Enough of the rest keep the cool vibe going that the album is very enjoyable.
Stronger all the way through than some of his other ones. Good continuous theme as well.
While I personally only care for Marvin Gaye's music in very small doses (too cheesy), this album has great flow and makes protest/social commentary music beautiful
Classic smooth Marvin Gaye vocals are always enjoyable to hear.
I had higher hopes for this. On the one hand the social commentary was fantastic and Marvin Gaye is so smooth vocally. On the other I was a little bored and felt it was more preachy than I needed.
What a phenomenal piece of 1970s r&b. Marvin Gaye’s voice is equal parts unreal and perfectly mixed. Each snare hit and slide whistle mixing wonderfully and the sonically perfect piece.
One of my favorite albums of all time, absolute groundbreaking masterpiece.
The title track is one of my favorite songs. Such and easy, loose, relaxed tone for kind of a heavy song. Then the second song sounds like it was a demo for What’s Going On… so, ok it’s good but he already captured that on track 1. Mercy, Mercy Me is a near perfect song and another of my all time favorites all the way to the sax solo at the end followed by the unsettling choral bit. The rest of the record is quite good as well.
Really liked it. the title track is a classic.
Considering how much I didn't care for the other Marvin Gaye album we got, I was shocked by how much I liked this one. Great songs and messages and extreemly well made. It's pretty good.
Undoubtedly one of THE voices, but lets not pretend that there arent extended periods on this album where Marvin is waffling on about nothing
Over-rated, a few good funk tracks, but too much of the album sounds similar, like one very long song. Excellent bass playing and beautiful noble, if naive message. Lovely sound, but just not The Best Album In The World as so many critics claim. Very good all the same.
Another great Marvin Gaye album
Muy interesante tanto en su mensaje como sus melodias. Relisten
Politiek conceptalbum van Marvin Gaye. Het album vertelt het verdeelde Amerika ten tijde van Vietnam door de ogen van een terugkerende veteraan. Hoge productiewaarde en mooie boodschap, met nummers die wel lekker klinken. leukste nummer: Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) Gaye was een voorloper van natuuractivisme door de milieucrisis te behandelen in het nummer "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)". Volgens een verhaal zou producer Berry Gordy niet hebben geweten wat "ecology" betekent.
Can't believe I've never listened to this album the whole way through. It's got a great feel to it and the whole thing is so cohesive. Reading the Wikipedia page about this album, here's one of the most random facts I've heard about a musician. "Around the spring of 1970, Gaye also began seriously pursuing a career in football with the professional football team the Detroit Lions of the NFL, even working out with the Eastern Michigan Eagles football team." That's insane - he would have been 31 and he just decided, ya know, I think I'm going to start playing professional football. Too bad it didn't work out, I'm sure my Lions could have used him. Anyway, back to the music. Going with 4 stars for this one.
Meh
Some good songs, solid 3
Importante escutar e conhecer o disco do hit. Soul agradável.
I always found this album to be a little bit overrated. Yes it has some very good songs (What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues) and it’s strong evidence of the mastery of Gaye, but what about the stuff in between those 3 songs? Maybe I’m missing something, but it’s a lot of filler in my mind. Also, Save the Children is not a good song. Going against the grain here and giving out a 4.
Very mellow and enjoyable. It would be a great record to put on and relax to. I'm excited for his other albums. My favourite songs were What's Happening Brother, Save the Children, and Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology).
Whats going on 4 Whats happening brother 3 Flyin high 3 Save the children 3 God is love 3 Mercy mercy me 4 Right on 4 Wholy holy 2 Inter City blues 3 3.22
My second soul album that I listened through, and this one blew away the competition. Really nice and smooth
Very strong lyrically. Enjoyable musically. Pleasantly surprised.
Half way through track one, that's a big yes. I really love the vibe, and his voice, the listening was extremely smooth. Well played Mister Gaye. Tbh there were not songs particularly shinning bright but just a really good overall experience. Favorite Songs : What's going on, Mercy Mercy me, Right on Rating : 4.5 / 5
Quite an experience, short enough to listen multiple time in a row. I don't know what it was but I like it... A lot. The musicalities are not too different but there is variety in beats and productions. Not very rememberable... Solid 3.5, leaning on 4.
Love music
Obviously some amazing hits but nothing I would listen through again as a whole album.
What can I say about this album that isn't already said, its a damn classic. One of the first soul albums I brought on record. Holds a special place in my heart.
I think it would absolutely break Marvin Gaye's heart that over 50 years after the release of this album, and nearly 40 years after his death, nothing has changed. This album is still as lyrically relevant as ever. Musically, it's gorgeous, with lush strings and deep, resonant bongos creating such a warm atmosphere. It's a masterpiece. Nothing more need be said.
This album goes alright. Not as super special as some make it out to be though.
Well I think this has to be full marks as a cultural touchstone alone. The songs do have a similar kind of sound but the lyrics and vocals and sentiment are spot on.
Cooler than a poor bear in sunglasses. Great from start to finish. Inner City Blues, Right On, and Mercy Mercy Me are the highlights.
Soul.
smooth and groovy
I liked it, lovely voice
R&B/Soul. Me ha gustado. Un 4.
Bien, normal.
He's done it again. Favorite track: Inner City Blues
Undeniably smooth but not enough goop for my goopy goblin gamer brain.
A bit too much call and response, but it's smooth as hell. Best track: What's Going On
Not bad but I don't really care for it
Cool
Obra maestra
A classic
Inner city blues
It's smooth, it's epic and it's important. What more could you really ask for. Marvin's estate really needs to take it easy on trying to sue everyone under the sun though. It makes them look bad. It would be an extremely sad thing to ruin this dudes legacy with such crap. Amazing album though. Score: 80 Art: 70
Beautiful music and vocals accompanied with such a poignant and deep message. Every song connects to the next and leads you on a groovin', socially conscious ride. What's Going On and Mercy Mercy Me are all timers.
Always awesome. Chill and cool.
- Heard this before - One of the most important albums of all time - Not something I listen to very often, but when I do I can easily see why it's considered one of the best of all time - Fav songs: What's Going On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler), Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)
Nice smooth tunes. Nothing particularly outstanding to me on that listen, but I enjoyed the whole groove throughout.
A solid groove with very politically conscious lyrics. Hard not to enjoy, even on a surface level. Favorite tracks: "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me"
I don’t think there’s a top 10 list out there where this album isn’t present. It’s simply the best at everything it’s doing; best Motown record, best protest record, best vocal performance, etc. Of course you have to mention the lyrics, which are unfortunately, timeless. But what this manages to capture most is the world Gaye saw that was worth fighting for in the midst of all the chaos.
Maybe we’ll never find the answers to Marvin’s musings, as the injustices of the past bleed into modern day, but as much as our revolving reality makes us want to cry, you just have to remember, always, to try.
most overrated motown album. the singles are great the filler is sludge
Classic album, all of the songs are what’s goin on
The pinnacle of 70s soul? If not, then at least one of the peaks. Despite the meandering religiosity of the middle of the album, this thing sings true.
хороший. вечером пришлось кино про Бакли смотреть
I wouldn't say I'm an actual fan of soul music, but fuck it's a nice fun easy listen. I'm already most of the way through and it hasn't annoyed me at all. The vocal lines go on weird detours at times, but that's about the biggest criticism I have. 4/5.
Marvin Gaye's ”What's Going On” is a masterpiece that transcends the boundaries of time and genre. Released in 1971, the album tackles issues of social justice, war, poverty, and police brutality, making it an album that resonates with people even today. Gaye's smooth, soulful vocals and jazzy instrumentation make the album a joy to listen to from start to finish. Songs like ”What’s Going On”, ”Mercy Mercy Me” and ”Inner City Blues” are truly powerful and showcase Gaye’s brilliant artistry. Whilst it’s not the greatest album of all time like Rolling Stone claims, it’s certainly one of those albums that feel really special and easily fits into the debate for top 30.
Got to give Marvin a lot of credit for attempting to change the world with a single album. Everything flows together extremely well and the songs are both musically listenable as well as being lyrically important. It's hard to be lectured at for that long though, so I can't give it a full 5 stars even though it might deserve it simply for its importance in musical history. 4.5 stars
Clear contender in my opinion of the best album about social justice ever produced. Gaye, a beloved son of Washington DC, was taken away far too young in the tragic shooting by his father. Who knows what he may have achieved and it is a poignant reminder that sometimes those who burn the brightest also burn the shortest. There's nothing I can say about this album that won't have been better said elsewhere. One thing I will mention is that Gaye's family released a new album posthumously called "Your the Man". It truly is worth your time to go and give *that* album a listen if you haven't heard it. Really beautiful and there are some showstoppers on it, especially 'Piece of Clay' if you have time for only one song with its piercing guitar and glorious organ. In that song, he speaks of the relationship between a father and son with respect to the false expectations of a father. Heartbreaking.
I think this exists as less of an album and more a shot in time that weaves together the malaise of the black community in the early 70's. I'll never be able to fully appreciate this album for that. Looking back at this from 2023 and listening to it with my limited knowledge of MG, I do find it eerie and haunting. Like something is gently tugging at me to wake up to something I don't want.
"What's Going On" is iconic, but I actually prefer "Mercy, Mercy, Me." Overall, this album packs such a strong statement, and that message stands as its legacy and warrants its inclusion here, even despite a few weaker tracks and a bit too much praise and gospel for my taste.
Brilliant application of leit motif to a contemporary music album.
It’s amazing in hindsight how wrong people in power can be, to the detriment of their own interests. I’m referring to the struggles Marvin Gaye went through to get this album made, one rated as the greatest album of all time by Rolling Stone and highly regarded by many. Motown executive Berry Gordy didn’t even want to support What’s Going On, one of, if not, the most famous soul songs ever. Gordy reacted somewhere between “that’s the worst thing I‘ve ever heard” to “the sound is out of date.” Motown’s quality control board also turned the song down too. Another Motown exec believed in the song and released it without Gordy’s knowledge. As we now know, it sold absurdly quickly, which finally led Gordy to approve Gaye to write and record his proposed protest album. The obstructions to getting this album concept off the ground is eye opening. The album itself is a good time. The famous songs are famous for good reason. I could do without Save The Children.
2.5
9/10. Fellas, it is Gaye
This is a great album, but I’ve always felt that it’s missing something to put it over the top. 9/10
Wat een geweldige en sfeervolle plaat. Voor herhaling vatbaar.
Easy listening
Dit vind ik een erg fijn album!
Echt een vrolijke Frans vind ik Marvin niet.
I'm well over 700 albums into this thing and this is the first time I've wondered if it's a mistake to dock an album points for the sins of the genre. What Mr. Gaye has created here is an undeniably great record. The lyrical content is deep and nuanced, heavy and beautiful. His delivery is, by and large, top-notch. The performances by the Funk Brothers are every bit as fantastic as one would expect from some of the greatest studio musicians ever. And yet, I can't quite dig it. There are a lot of elements to this album that just make me shudder. But everything that I dislike about "What's Going On" are staples of the genre and not specific to Marvin Gaye. It's the jazz flutes and the saxophone solos and the weird speaking/singing echo and a dozen more little things that are classic markers of 70s soul. I hate them so much. But should that be counted against Gaye? He's created a masterpiece here. It's exceptional for the genre. But it's also exceptional despite the genre. At the end of the day, I think I still have to count the sins of the genre against the album to some degree. The artist chooses their genre, after all, and they choose what elements of the genre to keep. Marvin Gaye chose this and, while it's an exceptional example of the genre, it still has the cheesy stink of 70s soul.
Jag har faktiskt inte lyssnat på honom tidigare förutom Ain’t no mountain high enough. Men den e ju en klassiker. Bättre än jag förväntat mig, kommer lyssna på igen antagligen. Sen en upptäckt va att en del i what’s going on är introt till välkommen hem. Men man lär sig ju nya saker varje dag.
Hmm. Jag gillar. Jag ville ge den här en fyra men… Skulle jag dock själv sätta på den här skivan? Kanske. Mest troligt inte. "But who really cares? Who's willing to try... to save our sweet world?"
GOATED
Best Marvin Gaye album ever. Hands down. Start to finish this is great. Standouts: What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues 3.5/5
Very good soul album with great sociopolitical commentary on USA's state at the time. A classic album through and through.
incredibly soulful and catchy music with protest lyrics that feel incredibly heartfelt and real. the combo of funky easy listening with hard-hitting lyrics of love and war is an excellent vibe. 4.5/5 4.5/5
Nice voice but album bored me. I hate 'Save the Children'. I don't hate children and if a child needs saving then yeah, let's save them but this song half makes me think we should just leave the children if it's going to produce more songs like this
Lyrical and musical masterpiece
Marvin Gayes masterpiece. Just an absolute beautiful album, which sadly a lot of the themes are still true today, over 50 years later.
Ok, I've never actually listened to this before. It's a concept album, each track into the next. I knew the themes it was going to deal with, but I had no idea this was the way it was going to be told. So good in its story, it's writing, and just overall vibe. I completely understand why this hits best ever lists. I'll be giving this one another spin
Vietnam war sucks
Vissa låtar är bra vissa är rätt kassa alltså
Annoyingly smooth
Really nice album! Perhaps not all songs stand out that much to me, but the overall feel of the album is very nice, and it's something I can definitely see myself revisting, it gives a certain mood for sure - in a good way! In addition, it feels very nicely produced and Marvin is a killer singer!
If I wrote an album about radiation, war, protests, racial tensions and how the world seems to be ending, this would not be it. This album touches on all these subject matters and still manages to feel positive or melancholic at the very least. Enjoyed the album thoroughly as a mood piece and I feel this could become a favorite after a few more listens.
Extreem smooth, hele album is vloeiend.
Great album, but I think the myth has surpassed the music.
A beautifully arranged and produced album with a powerful message that unfortunately never seizes to be relevant despite being over 50 years old. The way Marvin harmonizes with his own voice on the layered vocals is sublime and I've yet to hear another artist being able to do it in the way he does here. I give it 5 broken unsynchronized clocks, because it is timeless! 🕣🕜🕛🕖🕐
Very familiar with this album. Aware of its legendary status, but I just can't get into it.
It’s certainly very very good. I think it’s reached the #1 spot on Rolling Stone due to it just be so timeless and unworthy of any hate. At the same time it touches on many sensitive topics which are still relevant today. I’ll give it an 8 for now but I won’t be surprised if I regret not giving it a 9 or 10. 8/10
Makes me wanna give 5 stars, throw up my hands.
This is a MOOD
Naturally this is going to be five stars - it's Marvin Gaye for crying out loud.
He still doesn't know what's going on
Marvin's got soul, there's no denying that. A couple of songs were a little leaning, but overall a great album.
Great bitta bass playing
If it wasn’t for the importance of the message, this wouldn’t be considered a classic.
Kind of some good staff, but no more.
I need more time with this one.
Great album, great voice and emotion
One of the best !
The five-star tracks really are five stars, but this does drop a fraction on side two until the final track. Also think Let's get It On is the better album, so have to be able to recognise that. Definitely a 4.5.
REally blown away by this one. Easily my favorite so far. FLows so well all the way through
I enjoyed this, rather relaxing and groovy