Reviews (page 7 of 14)
Gay was too crazy of a birth name, so he added an E at the end to remove some confusion
Great album full of soul 4.5⭐️
It is a classic for sure. I didn't want to replay it as soon as it was over, and a little bit too much Jesus for me. 4.5 stars.
So smooth.
I mean it's Marvin Gaye. How could this not get four stars?
was good. this one should probably be on this list.
Smooth music. Good sound.
A voice for the ages. And this album feels as relevant now as it did back when it was released. A total classic. Favorites: What's Going On, God Is Love, Mercy Mercy Me Would I listen to it again: Yes
Absolutely fucking love this record
Always hits
Voice like honey, beautiful arrangements, and lyrics so vague as to be meaningless. Maybe this hit harder in 1971, but in 2025 it's too broad to work as protest music.
Still holding out for the same optimism now. I enjoyed it but it wouldn’t be an album I’d listen to a lot but great singles off it.
Okay. Kind of boring.
Love this album. Hits harder with everything going on lately. Great choice for today.
Classic album.
Starts on an incredible high and kinda floats along musically at this blissful high point for the whole album. It delivers when it touches on explicitly political elements, the commentary is moving and doesn't take you out of the music at all. It really does feel (perhaps unfortunately for us) like everything talked about here could be relevant for today. While that's very depressing it seems like this record will be timeless.
What a fantastic listen. Every song is a masterpiece. Gaye's vocals are simply just a joy to listen to. I love the continuity of this album and the fun instrumentation and composition of each of his songs. Definitely a new favourite album.
What a beautiful sound. Lush strings, twinkling bells, a flurry of woodwinds here and there, lots of small percussion, and layers of gorgeous vocals. It’s soothing, healing music for a broken world. The lyrics and the emotion of it all were hitting today. Everything Marvin Gaye sings about here — inequality, war, pollution — is top of mind in the news. His pleas for love, peace, understanding are as necessary today as they were half a century ago.
A truly remarkable album by one of the most attractive voices to ever pick up a microphone. It might sound corny but as I hear the first lyrics of "What's Going On", I feel parts of me start to calm and melt a bit; I feel a warmth and a joy and my early morning restless leg shake start to relax. As the song builds and energizes, I'm feeling my eyes wander away from my work laptop and onto the album art of this beautiful man sharing his craft. This music is taking me away from my stresses, and I am thankful. I love the jammy "Right On". It's a great little laid back track to groove to. This album has a nice blend of songs that groove on by and then songs that stick around in your head. This is a difficult one to rate for me. "What's Going On" is a really special song, and there are no other weak points on the record as far as I'm concerned. Marvin Gaye was a special artist, but I feel that this isn't his best work- and that "United" is. With that being said, I think this is a strong 4, and just short of being high enough for a round up to 5/5.
Great, easy-listening album
Marvin Gaye always trying to grasp what is happening... Love it
4.5
Listened Before: N This album was a strange one. There's a decent amount of good songs here - but the ones in between are terrible. Slow and boring. I can't believe the same album that contains a banger like Mercy Mercy Me contains a song like Right On. Rating this one a 4 for the good songs and a 2 for the bad. Averages out to a 3 I suppose. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: What's Going On
So light and deft while also being socially conscious - and interesting mix
All time classic, I listened to the excellent Detroit 2022 mix. So good!
I loved the song “What’s Going On” as a kid. I remember my Dad explaining what he was singing about to me, and learning that music could be political and have important messaging.
Masterpiece. The collective performances from the musicians on this record are effortless, near-perfect. Marvin's songwriting is pensively focused on war, poverty, ecological destruction, and drug addiction — the abstracted way he writes about these topics of universal struggle has cemented this record as forever timeless. The album also flows along seamlessly from one track to the next: this is one of those records I almost always have to listen to all the way through. I've listened to it hundred of times front-to-back and will surely listen to it hundreds more before I expire. Thank you Marvin!
One of the best discovery from this list. Never listened to an album of Gaye before, just knew the sexy songs. I was not expecting this depth and this story
Such a classic voice. While not my favorite genre how can you not get pulled in by his smooth singing?
Sublime. 4/5
Classic
Величие. Мастерпися. Король всех королей
Pretty enjoyable.
Really enjoyed how smooth the transition was between each song here, but at the end of the day I still just don't love Soul.
Это отличный альбом и я его буду точно переслушивать еще много раз. Такую кайфовую музыку мало кто может сделать! Закрываешь глаза и вот ты едешь по серпантину вдоль лазурного побережья средиземного моря на красном кабриолете. Это прекрасно. Тем не менее, темы в текстах затрагиваются серьезные и за это тоже выражаю респект. Отличная запись.
How the hell did we go from this to what passes for music in 2 generations? Pure Motown. Is it the greatest album of all time (per Rilling Stone) no, but it is damned fine and thoroughly enjoyable, as well as historically relevant.
Awesome.
best album of all time for a reason bro
Listenable.
It's definitely good, I'm a little dubious on being #1 all time Will I listen to again: 84%
Great album!
Classic
Classic. Bought this at the Rideau place mall (?)
Oh, I'm kinda excited to give this one a go. I mean, I was excited because it's nice to close a musical knowledge gap. and this was fine and I get why people like it but it's just not for me.
Good soul album
Still relevant today 5/10
As I read in another review on here: I can recognize a nicely made cup of tea, but I still prefer coffee.
Absolutely amazing!
I have mixed feelings about that album. I like some melodies but I don't find it cohesive. And it is so American sorry but I can't relate to it... 2,5/5
Great stuff, didn't realize it was kind of a theme album
Pretty overrated for me but a couple good songs at least
Muy lindo.
226/1089 - Very lush and rich, a bit too much sometimes with the strings and choir. Singing is impeccable and the backing band is great, especially the bass player.
Not so long ago, about four and five months, I listened to the track 'Ain't no Mountain High Enough'. An incredibly sweet track, but I thought it sounded a bit crispy, probably because the technological limitations from that time. This made me wonder if this album could suffer from the same issues. Nothing could prepare me for how good this album sounds. In fact, it sounds so good, it made me question if this record was produced in heaven. Everything is so clear and beautiful. The singing, the bells, the choirs... The lyrics too! with the main subject being to love and care for everyone. A very sweet and groovy album. The only reason I'm not giving it 5 stars is because there is still room for it to grow on me and I don't think it hit me like other records in the 'favourite' category did.
What an album! Great music, great arrangements and excellent lyrics and the voice! Start to finish classic, love it!
tbh didn't caught me
This is soul
Magnificently soulful and societal.
From the viewpoint of a baffled vietnam veteran comes Soul, which features a series of relaxed grooves with a heavy bottom, filled by thick basslines along with bongos, conga, and other percussion. Although by popular opinion anmasterpiece I drowned in this dense soundscape.
basically socially aware(na 70tky)modern worship music-vacsina mi evokuje zhudobnene kazne nejakeho americkeho pastora tbh(gospel a soul v jednom,trochu jazzu).miesanie vokalov mi prislo zbytocne "zahmlene". trochu mi pripomina stevieho innervisions.pocuvala som to pri oberani broskyn u babky(nie idealne).sedenie na terase nejakej neo-brutalistickej vily v ZAR je jediny scenar,v ktorom si viem predstavit,ze si to vypocujem este raz
Nevedel som sa do toho ponorit. Paci sa mi velmi kontext vietnamskej vojny. Z albumu som si nedal do savenutych pesniciek nic, to ale neznamena ze celok je zly. Nepustil by som si ho znova, ale viem si predstavit pisat o nom esej na ulohu z hodin na anglicke eseje v prvom rocniku. Na moj vkus velmi religiozne, chapem vsak ze to je pointa albumu a to jedine co zostane vojakovi po navrate domov.
I love the message in this album. I love how much he can do while still making this a fun, upbeat, interesting, and impactful album. It's very nostalgic and funky and yet you can't help but feel moved from the way he sings and what the lyrics express. Fantastic album.
It's a seminal and massively influential album, full of soaring melodies and layers of beautiful instrumentation. It does stray into the "cheesy" from time to time, that's for sure. I don't think it's Gaye's strongest work, even if it is his most famous and praised.
Timeless in the best way, relevant in the saddest way. At times it feels like being neck deep in rising water, but with a hand outstretched for you to grab ahold of
Marvin Gaye’s What’s Going On is more than just a collection of songs, it’s a full damn experience. The tracks flow seamlessly into one another, pulling you into a story that feels both deeply personal and universally relevant. It’s no wonder this album is often called one of the greatest of all time, as these are some of his most iconic songs, and they showcase his genius as both a vocalist and storyteller. You can feel his passion and purpose in every note.
Perhaps this album suffered from high expectations because it always appears on top 5 of all time lists, but I was very excited to listen to it and wound up a bit disappointed. It seemed very meander-y.
Good album. Despite how bad the world can get, just spread love where you can.
I was initially intrigued by this offering. I liked what I knew of Marvin Gaye, and I was excited to listen to an entire album. But man, this has a lot of filler. That's what's going on: Meandering, there-are-a-lot-of-problems-in-the-world stuff that at times borders on comical. "Save the Children" is a prime example. Of course, there are great tunes on here too, but I'll probably stick to the top tracks when listening to Marvin Gaye in the future.
I think I need to listen to this a few more times before it sinks in. But, at first blush, I like it well enough...even with some of the dated 70s studio sound.
4/5 - I needed to hear this because I know it’s one of those “soundtrack to people’s lives” albums, and it has a beautiful, smooth sound with darker subject matter than the earlier Motown records. Enjoyable listen for me, but I hadn’t listened all the way through before, and I didn’t really connect with it.
I enjoyed this. Cheesy at times, but he's a good singer.
heard this many times already What's Going On - 5/5 What's Happening Brother - 5/5 Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky) - 4/5 Save the Children - 4/5 God Is Love - no rating Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - 5/5 Right On - 4/5 Wholy Holy - 4/5 Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - 5/5 Average score: 4.5/5 (rounding up) essential, period
Masterpiece. This time I really focused on how much the melodies return throughout the album
7/10
The songs on this are great.
Here we go, the "why is he so clueless?" album... Jokes aside, Marvin Gaye's What's Going On is a (still) brutally modern album in its themes. To think that in 1971 he was preaching for the end of atrocities such as war, environmental destruction and financial struggle and none of these themes got even remotely better in 2025 makes me sad. This album is a love letter to love (no pun intended) and should be a manifesto for a better world. Marvin has one of the purest and most angelic voices I have ever heard, capable of soothing you even if he's really singing about horrible things. The arrangements are relatively simple yet so lush. The bells (or I at least think these are bells) that accompany almost every song create a Christmas-like vibe which makes you develope hope in humanity while listening to the album, all of this while adding nice texture to the songs while never really being out of context. This album also has an incredible pacing, for sure it is short (35) minutes, but in such a short time (time that absolutely flies by the way) he manages to pack SO much thematically and does so while having the songs flow into each other seamlessly, adding to the the album a nice consistency and, again, a great pacing. My only "problems" with this album are the "aaahhhhh" choirs being slightly overused and the entirety of "Wholy Moly": a slow tempo song that doesn't add anything to the album, musically, vocally or even thematically (we already had God is Love about religion), but other than that, this is really a flawless album. One last thing I noticed is that the album feels recursive to me, let me explain: the ending of Inner City Blues mimics the sound and the lyrics of What's Going On. To me this is Marvin Gaye's way of saying that all of the problems he talks about seem to have no end and, like history, the evil in the world is cyclical. It's like he knew the world was not gonna change for the better, but he decided to bless our ears and try to purify everyone's hearts nonetheless. Either way, this is just my opinion. So try not to pay too much attention to it.
I did not use a private spotify session for this one. Never sat down and listened to a complete Marvin Gaye album but I did know several of the songs off of it. I liked the flow of the album.
FANTASTIC! One of the few albums on this list that you really should listen to before you die.
Nice album, given the current status of the world. Good flow between songs, nice theming 5/5
This was okay
What's Going On - 9/10 What's Happening Brother - 8.5 Flyin' High - 9 Save The Children - 8 God Is Love - 9 Mercy Mercy Me - 9 Right On - 10 Wholy Holy - 9,5 Inner City Blues - 9 90/100
awesome
i like 👍
Smooth anti-war music is a big thumbs up from me. Unlikely that I’ll listen to this again but definitely worthy of being on this list.
I’m not a big soul guy
4*
Jako mi je drag ovaj album, onako smirujuć i wavy 🤗 4/5, 8/10
Some albums don't need a debate. This one is undeniable. Please stop portraying that you like music if you give this anything less than 3 stars.
Deserves all its accolades. Gaye's voice is beautiful, lush arrangements and social conscience. Mercy Mercy Me is my favorite track.
The album flew by. After I finished it I went back to listen to the title track again and ended up letting most of the album play through a second time.
I can’t share the sentiment of the hysterical woman screaming in the background. Not terrible, just not my type of music
god what a beautiful album. he’s got an incredible voice. keeping this one. still relevant, which always hurts my feelings
Such a beautiful album from start to finish. Marvin Gaye’s finest work and perhaps the greatest album of the 70’s, if not of all-time. An essential album for any true music fan.
Standouts What's Going On Mercy Mercy Me Inner City Blues
A Motown album with something to say. Because it had something to say it was actually released on a minor label owned by Motown. Beautifully performed with thought promoting lyrics. Listen to it in one sitting. Stand out tracks. What's going on Mercy, mercy me Inner city blues Worthy of 5 stars
Très chill, des tubes connus, good vibe, king
Toujours agréable à écouter Mais c’est un mindset particulier : Album assez calme
Totalement ma came, j'ai adoré. J'ai liké quasiment toutes les chansons de l'album et je pourrais totalement écouter ça régulièrement, 5/5
Such emotional depth. Often you struggle to hear just how impassioned an artist is with their lyrical content. Not here. Sheer, raw emotion and beautifully crafted from beginning to end.
#1 album of all time??? Not quite. It’s good but come on, people.
It sounds like a soft blanket and a hot mug of chocolate in a cold day.
It's a terrible feeling listening to this beautiful, sad music knowing that everything bad in the world in 1971 is still happening in one way or another 55 (!) years later.. benefits being stripped away from veterans, police brutalizing peaceful antiwar protesters, the vulnerable being vilified and oppressed, children overseas getting bombed and starved with our government's support while also stripping school lunch and medical benefits from the children in our own country. The music on this album still feels just as powerful as I'd imagine it was back then, with the message ever-enduring.. and unfortunately it proves that nothing ever changes due to man's animalistic greed and selfishness. Anyway, a great album and Inner City Blues is a banger.
53/1001 Marvin Gaye - What's Going On Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ✅ At first, Motown bosses rejected this for it being too political and not on brand for the label, but Gaye convinced them to release it. The themes on this are still as timely now as they were back in the 70s. It's an album that musically looks back with the soulfulness and yet is looking forward with anxiety about the future and a nation tearing itself apart through hatred, suffering and injustice with the backdrop of the Vietnam War. The songs are flow into one and feels as they should all be listened to in one sitting. An absolute all-timer for me.
YES.
It's a classic. I don't generally listen to soul, especially from this era, and I've still heard What's Going On and Mercy Mercy Me, both of which are all time great songs. But it gets a little preachy, and I just wasn't feeling half the tracks, so it's a 4 instead of a 5. What was the deal with Save the Children? Good message, really bad song.
Just not that interesting. Pleasant enough but wildly overrated as I see it.
This album proves that I don't always listen closely enough to the lyrics which are a lot more interresting than I at first. Did know Mercy Mercy Me but never really listened to the lyrics. As an atheist the frequent referals to God and Jesus seem like a cop-out to me but if it helps you navigate this life then who am I to judge.
Unbearable boring.
A classic
Not my favourite, but great vibe, some great songs, definitely see why it’s here
Very pleasant listen. The overall messages of the album are very straightforward, and the music is delightfully smooth. "Whats Going On" and What's Happening Brother" were my favorites, both from a musical and a thematic standpoint. Makes me think I probably like soul music in general.
What an album, the perfect example of the whole being greater than the sum of its parts, a very cohesive and well put together album that is super easy to listen to and super chill and doesn’t overstay its welcome, the vocal performances are amazing and the groves are super awesome.
Great
Awesome. Would love to have.
BEST SONGS: - Flyin' High - Right On
Listened to before, great album.
One of the best albums of all time.
This has been one of my favorite albums since I was a kid, and it's a little heartbreaking to note that the issues and societal ills Gaye addresses directly in these songs -- environmental crises, racism, poverty, police brutality -- haven't improved in the more than 50 years since the album was released. A gorgeous, powerful, inspiring, and often heartbreaking collection of songs.
I think that there's a difference between having lived in the time and listening to this when it was new and playing on the radio and listening to this same music now. I'm looking at this through the lens of when this used to be the vibe of the day but it plays well both then and now. I liked how the songs blended into one another though there was a span where I was thinking that it was a very long song but 2-3 songs had actually passed. Overall, excellent stuff!
Marvin Gaye’s magnum opus. Deeply moving album that continues to resonate to this day. Sadly, Gaye’s concern’s regarding America’s social, racial, and ecological ills have not diminished in anyway. The use of Gaye’s layered vocals (used in a kind of call and response manner) are a brilliant touch to the stellar production of this album. I’ll never tire of listening to this record.
Incredible passionate work, I’m not the biggest fan but man is this album gorgeous. Emotionally the lyrics hit and I resonate with the message. Unfortunately, the music doesn’t resonate much but I think that could change with more listens. 4 for now but could improve!
I forgot that the first few songs string together. This is an album that is renowned but I find it good, not great. The title track is tots obvi great but everything seems pretty derivative of that. Top tracks: "What's Going On," "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)," "Inner City Blues"
let's see just how 80s we can be on this shit. I've never, ever, been a big super 80s guy, and this reeks of it. It stinks.
We didn't listen
Considered the greatest album of all time, it was a correct album indeed.
1971 "Wos gorn arn" as they say in my neck of the woods. "Ass gorn off!" It's obviously a classic, and in places decent enough, but too many references to children, Jesus etc for my tastes. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ actually, yes Revisit ❌️ Not my bag ★★☆☆☆
Really really solid album Love the sounds and tones and textures Pure 70s sound. Can see where a lot of the hip hop sounds and samples originated from.
Has some amazing tracks and the whole album flows very well. Found the middle tracks a bit hit and miss so might find myself skipping them.
This one's tough. Knew it by reputation. Don't think I've ever listened to it. Feels familiar because I think I've heard it sampled in a million rap songs. Great performances and message. Inner City Blues is a highlight. It's great but I don't know that I'll revisit it much
Already got this
Great!
Never been super familiar with Marvin Gaye before listening to this. What's Going on is not exactly the song I thought it would be. More energy than I expected! There's no real standout songs on this albums but everything flows together beautifully and on the whole makes for a cohesive, well put together album.
Perfect soundtrack for the times. Still relevant.
abwechslungsreich, cooler Rhythmus, bisschen an Stevie Wonder erinnert, aber nicht das, was ich sonst höre und sehr viel Gott
classic
One of my favorite albums of all time and the greatest protest/socially conscious record ever. Still completely relevant, every song, every lyric, not a thing has changed since Marvin first sang these songs. And of course, the music is incredible and Marvin’s vocals are impeccable. A desert island disc for me.
Good songs on its own. As an album I was bored.
Cool, earnest, and relevant still today. I could have done without the religious content, but it was delivered in such a genuine and smooth way it didn't bother me in the end.
Right on…excellent protest anthem for peace and justice and harmony
While he certainly has some great stuff... this album wasn't it. A real snooze fest.
A nice soul offering. No song really stood out for me, but it’s well crafted enough as a whole, the music flows smoothly from start to finish. As usual with Marvin Gaye, it’s oozing with sweetness to the point you sometimes feel like you’re drowning in corn syrup – but since it’s clearly his forte, I can’t really hold it againt him, and anyone probably knows what to expect when playing a Marvin Gaye record. As often with soul music, Jesus is also involved at some point, which I always find a bit weird – but I understand it comes from the gospel roots of the genre, so why not. Not really my kind of soul music (Marvin Gaye has always been a tad too much on the soft & sweet side for me, I like my soul a bit groovier). But it’s still a good record overall.
Low 4, great vibes, vocals, grooves
Sweet mother of Jesus.
Not my vibe but sounded rather nice
What’s going on. His voice is really good and soothing. However, most of the songs are similar to What’s going on? Sometimes I could not ever tell the difference.
he’s so right. what IS going on
Simply Perfect. Marvin said this album was God speaking through him. If there is a God, Marvin's God is who we need right now.
honestly thought this was gunna be a hard five -- but it gets a little rambly preachy at times
In my collection, of course, no doubt about this record, the best "songs to make love to"' record. An all time classic! 5/5
Right on.
Phenomenally good!
Again, not one I'll return to, but fun enough.
нормалек, но я бы его на 1 место не поставил.
Sexy Jesus
Good stuff. Too much religion for my taste but not so much as to ruin it
Have never heard the album before—just the hits. Very enjoyable.
A bonafide classic stuffed with classic songs, how this isn't in the top 20 is a mystery to me, almost makes me wanna holler... OK, maybe a little too religious, but it is what it is.
Ethereal and awesome. I don’t realize when it ended because it feels like one idea.
Seemed very generic to me
I am not too found of the music, melody and arrangements but love the texts and sometiemes the voice.
The love/save the children’s side merges beautifully in the Soul. Shitty lyrics, but overall, quite a nice vibe.
amazing no notes. surprised at how much i liked this
6.5/10 Highlights: Mercy Mercy Me Whats Going On Inner City Blues
First: This is one of my all time favourites, but I tried to listen to it freshly. The only thing I could say against it that the songs all kinda sound the same when listening on a superficial level. But then, I'm on the train, watch out of the window and listen to "Mercy Me" and it brings tears to my eyes like no other music does. So graceful, forgiving, loving. The sound of Marvin's voice: divine. The bass line: so funky. The background vocals. Everything fits so well together. And there's like 5 tracks like this on this album. On top of this the fact that Marvin evolved from the Motown sound and pushed for artistic freedom, recorded the album without any support, then was opposed by the Motown founder, went on strike until a single was released and was so successful that the full album was released. This alone is quite a feat, together with the fact that it's a superb album - there can't be anything lower than 5 stars.
Pretty great r&b/soul music
Slow soul. Political compared to previous popular soul music. Some jazz elements too in Save the Children. Not my cup of tea but okay. Not many hooks, mostly ballady. Tracks flow together which is nice Best track - Mercy Mercy Me, Right On 3 stars
Şarkıları mutlu maniler gibiydi yinede fena değildi şarkıları daha az dindar olsaydı büyük ihtimalle 2.5 tan 3 verirdim ama 2 vericem Whats going on şarkısı olmasa büyük ihtimalle 2 bile olmazdı
27/07/2025 The music was just very samey....
Perfect
Just a gorgeous album. Marvin Gaye pointing out and sometimes solving the world's problems in the most beautiful soulful way.
4/5
Just a very good album! 4/5
The album was truly amazing and thought provoking
Day566 - does it get much better than this? i don’t think so
Iconic.
10/10 perfect album no flaws
Voor luisteren: het eerste album in dit project dat ik al heb gehoord. Ik vond dit een paar jaar geleden heel goed maar ik heb er al lang niet meer naar geluisterd. Tijdens luisteren: begint heel goed, verliest het dan een beetje, vindt het dan bijna onmenselijk hard terug, verliest het dan iets meer dan de eerste keer (die ratel brrr), en vindt het dan terug op een mindere manier. Opgedeeld in 5 delen rank ik het zo: 3>>>1>>>>>>>>>>>>>5>>>2>>>>>4
Concept album about God, the environment, and love for fellow man (?). Hear a lot of Prince in here.
I’d heard many good things about this album but had never listened to it. They were all true, this album is great!
Good backround music for web surfing, but not my first choice
A beautifully crafted album, Marvin Gaye delivers a short but varied selection of songs where his voice and songwriting steal the show. Top Three Tracks: What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Least Fav Track: Wholly Holy
First, the burning question - is this the greatest album of all time?? No, it isn't. Rolling Stone's ranking of it as such was a blatant reaction to BLM. For all black musicians' innumerable contributions to music, the album format was traditionally utilised to greater effect by white musicians, who refined the album. This is why Revolver and Pet Sounds usually sit atop these lists, and I don't think I'd put this album above either of those (although, I think this was better on first listen than Pet Sounds) However, it is a very, very good album. Like the best albums (in my view), it's a journey. There's this magical, natural transition between songs, and the first side has this wonderful ongoing crescendo that can't but sweep you up in the almost religious power of the music. This is in no small part due to the orchestra which complements Gaye's lyrics perfectly. Truly, this is soul at its finest. Unfortunately the LP format necessitates a break in the middle of the album, but the songs on side 2 are strong too (even if I feel that Inner City Blues doesn't quite fit in with the rest of the album). Gaye's lyrics are famously deeply political, touching subjects as diverse as the Vietnam War, environmental issues, racism and drug abuse. However, the album remains positive and hopeful throughout, and he emphasises his beliefs that God forgives, rather than condemning those responsible for these issues. Unfortunately, some of my ratings have been a bit biased by foreknowledge, and this may be one of them. I've never heard this album before, but I got it today knowing that it was a big one. I am not sure I can honestly say I'd be giving 5 stars without this bias, but fuck it, objectively it is a 5-star album. I think the title track is my favourite song here; however, Save the Children is where I realised this is a five star album, and is certainly a contender for the spot.
I respect the concept and the meaningful lyrics, but I just struggle getting into this style of music.
An album I have heard endless times since childhood in fact I remember in grade school (5th or 6th grade) writing a review for the school paper (Silverwing Elementary School) once! Now here I'm all grown up writing another review. This is a Top 100 album for me and quite possibly the greatest soul album ever released (with the only real contender to the throne being Curtis by Curtis Mayfied from a year earlier,1970) it's flawless, powerful and beautiful, the Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band of soul music. Some people marvel at how relevant 'What's Going On' is in 2025. I don't. I think as long as humans roam the earth (for better or worse) this work of art will be relevant. Lord have mercy!
Enjoyed this. Don’t think I would, but I did.
Good album. I was expecting legendary, and it fell short of my expectations. 6.4/10
so groovy
Really great sound and drew me in with the story.
Excellent album that got even better on a 2nd listen. Each song flows into the next, and the music is engaging throughout.
sad that I wasn’t blown away by this, but still really enjoyed it
fuck them kids
Really thought I’d like this more
Smooth
I wanted to wait until I got this on vinyl to listen to it for the first time but this felt like fate - what an album. Played it all weekend. Easy 5 stars
Great album 👌
Despite sounding pretty confused about the whole thing, this album is actually a concept album about a man returning home after the vietnam war. Musically, politically, and spiritually one of the most ironically cognizant albums of its time and for generations to come.
very chill but powerfull lyrics
Classic, no doubt, just not my cup of tea.
It’s a nice album, nice to listen to whilst your doing things like cooking. I don’t think this would be one of sit down and listen to. It’s pleasant but I don’t find it to be amazing, better as background music in my opinion. Fav tracks - What’s going on? - What’s happening brother? - Mercy Mercy Me - Right on - Inner City Blues
Amazing. The instrumentals, backing vocals and lead vocals are perfect. They make you move no matter wherever you are and however you feel. Despite the album only being 39 mins long i think it still suffices.
Good but very forgettable... I'm writing this after a few hours and already have a hard time to recall anything... I did not hate it, and the bass was cool and overall sound was good, so yeah, it's ok...
Toll
I wanted to give it more stars but for some reason I just wasn't feeling it. It's good, but not great. I did like Right On better than the hits on the album.
This is a landmark that you should probably read other people's opinions on. This type of music, and Gaye in particular, is often so smooth and pleasant that it fails to catch on any part of my subconscious attention. This makes it pass right through my brain as if it hadn't been there. Marvin Gaye is like weather so pleasant that you could be convinced that air doesn't exist (which, as a Canadian, is rare; the air is usually biting and occasionally violent). My rating doesn't matter -- you should listen to What's Going On on reputation alone, on someone else's recommendation. For me, this is 3/5, but that's highly personal and probably says more about me than it does about the album.
Great albums need 3 key elements: Music (lyrics, composition) + Production (engineering, mixing) + Influence (how did it change the art of music?). Granted, these are all subjective because, well, it’s art. But it is tough to argue this isn’t one of the greatest 10 albums ever produced. Easy 5.
Classic album
Marvin Gaye on a Friday? Lucky me ! What's Going On is arguably one of the most influencial albums to come out of the 70s and you can clearly see why. Beautiful 70s Soul music, it has everything you need, funky basslines, backed by incredible drums, flairs of brass and strings, all brought together with Marvin Gaye's almost heavenly vocals. The title track starts this album off with a bang, with everything in the 70s Soul formula included. This album is said to have "Revolutionised Black Music" and you can see the impact this album had on Progressive Soul, in famous albums to follow. It's subtle use of orchestral pieces fits in exceptionally well with every track. This is easily a multiple listen type album and I'd be doing something criminal to rate it any lower than a 5. Marvin Gaye, gone too soon but left us with arguably one of the greatest albums of all time before he went. 5/5 MTW Fuming at his dad for killing him. Near perfect record. Baby making music. 4.9/5
Good
I was stoked when this album popped up. Never listened to it, though I had heard a few of these songs a number of times. What really stood out to me was two things: 1. The way this album never really seemed to break, at least up through Mercy, Mercy Me. Everything just flowed into each other. I thought that was very cool. It did lead to the first part of this album sounding relatively homogenous, but since that sound was great, that didn't end up being a negative. 2. That this album has a really distinct and serious viewpoint, very pointed, and yet was light in it's approach at the same time. Excellent dichotomy. Mercy, Mercy Me is a song that I absolutely love. Admittedly, I am more used to hearing the Robert Palmer version, but the original is awesome. Great tune. Of course, everyone has heard this one and the title track too, which is a great song as well. But there were a bunch of other ones in this which were excellent like Flyin High. Right On was the one track that I wasn't really enamored with. This seemed to go on too long and wandered a bit aimlessly at times. The theme is good, no doubt, but this could have been much tighter. But that's nitpicking. Inner City Blues is a great tune, excellent way to close this album. Really great album.
It's okay. Just doesn't grip me at all. Also a little too Christian for me.
I thought it was boring, every song sounded the same to me.
This is a pretty decent album. I enjoyed his voice and the instrumentals.
Best one yet! Definitely recommend
Truly some baby-making music. Honestly, every song on this album was just good listening
Good positive message throughout, just not really my vibe.
This album was a nice surprise. I knew I was going to like it because it's Marvin Gaye and "What's Going On" and "Mercy Mercy Me" are two of my favorite songs by him, but I didn't expect to love this album like I did. I know I've criticized albums for songs sounding the same, but this felt like one long song but in a good way, which apparently was the point since this is considered a "song cycle" album. The story it told was compelling too. Perhaps it's just the world we're living in right now, but a lot of the songs and the vibe really resonated with me. This is definitely Marvin Gaye's best album, and it deserves its place on the list.
Good
It's like a mega-mix, but with socially conscious anthems instead of party bops. Don't know why I never listened to this before, it absolutely lives up to the hype.
Automatic
Should be a 4.5, maybe a 4.75
One of a kind
Wonderful Marvin!!!
Je me suis régalé pendant 35min (il y a 32 secondes que j’ai pas trop aimé mais ça reste ok) Après meilleur album du 20ème siècle c’est pas ce que je dirais même si c’est excellent
Du petit miel pour les oreilles
Dad- 10 Mom- 8.5 Mike- 8 Lori- 8.5 Michael- 8.5 Miles- 7 Cole- 7 Avg- 8.21
Truly a triumph. Top notch crooner tackles social issues, big and small, with so much emotion. It's captivating.
Classic. Such a socially conscious album. I knew What’s Going On and Mercy Mercy Me going in.
I had no idea how political this would be. A real great example of a concept album. Silky smooth music and vocals combined with strong lyrical story telling. Good shit
Delightful. I listened, then listened again. Just because.
Better than Let's Get it On. A good listen all the way through
Me gusta
Marvin Gaye is soothing at any time. But right now, I'm listening to this album just after Limp Bizkit, and in comparison, Gaye is absolute bliss. It's not just his amazing voice, or his outlook on life, or the blend of calm and passion. It's also the flawless production, which still holds up entirely, 54 years after release. And it's the breadth and depth of quality throughout the album. Fantastic record by a fantastic musician.
The songs are just so perfectly crafted. The production on this and obviously Marvin’s vocals are just on point. Album openers dont get much better than ‘What’s going on’. As someone who quite often finds soul music a bit blah, i cannot speak highly enough about this album.
When one of the greatest songs in the world is your opening track, you set yourself up for listening to a masterpiece - thankfully, this is exactly what this album is. The title track remains as relevant today as it was in 1971 and, along with every other track on the album, demonstrates that politics and protest music doesn’t need to sound angry - sometimes, it can sound as beautiful as this.
The album generator has taught me to approach an album where the most famous song is the first track with an element of caution. But this time I needn't have worried because this is a fantastic album. Yes, Gaye has a gorgeous voice, but also the lyrics are amazing, the music is beautiful. Just a great, great record. 5/5
Can't believe I've never sat through this in one sitting. Wow.
This is one of the greatest albums of all time. So much soul, so much groove. It’s a shame more people don’t know this album by heart. I bet Lamp’s a bitch too
Ron burgundy is great on the backing jazz flute
Incredible
real nice
Favorites: What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, Save The Children, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)
4/1001 :: Marvin Gaye - What’s Going On Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ➖ Rating: 7.5 Fav Tracks: Mercy Me, What’s Going On I’ve been looking at this album for years wondering if I should buy it on vinyl even though I had never listened to it. It’s easily considered one of the greatest albums of all time and it’s something I should like right? Well, I thought it was really good but frankly I’m not sure I would ever listen to it again… First of all the production is quite impressive. I feel like Abbey Road inspired this type of album where the songs flow seamlessly into each other. Also, with Vietnam in full swing, Marvin’s approach to political commentary makes this one really special. Capped off with his lush voice and all the beautiful jazzy instrumentation it’s a graceful record. All that said, it’s something I can appreciate but not something I would generally reach for and that’s OK.
Masterpiece
Eternal. Fantastic vibe and songwriting.
Sounds so good. I don't care much for the entire "Save the children, love each other" kind of preaching, but I can't deny the fact that I really enjoyed listening to it. The albums flows really well from track to track.
joyous and beautiful. loved.
Bueno, esta ok. Es s'àlbum de despedida de Barna.
What's Going On 4.3 What's Happening Brother 4 Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky) 3.4 Save the Children 3.2 God Is Love 3.5 Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) 4 Right On 3.6 Wholy Holy 3.4 Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) 3.5 Score: 3.655555556
Pretty easy to review this album as it is one of my favorites of all time. It's a really brilliant protest album that has stood for quite a while as one of the all time greatest. The beats and the lyrics are phenomenal, I could listen to it over and over and never get tired of it. The album is pretty much perfect as far as I'm concerned. I enjoy the entire thing from beginning to end. There is never a point where I space out, it has my attention the whole time even after so many listens throughout my lifetime.
Not exactly what I expected but damn close. I thought it was going to be more about banging. Still good. But won’t listen again. I’d like to give 3.5 but alas just a three.
Heard before. Some nice track. I like the overall feeling of the album more than any specific track. Good for background listening.
This is such a touchstone - I know in my own reviews here, I've already used a variation on "this was supposed to be [artist]’s What's Going On." As well as proving that I'm not that original, I think the fact that you can use this album as shorthand for a socially conscious masterpiece says it all.
Soul när det är som bäst.
Cover 6 Good album. I know some people love this one. I wouldn't say I love it. The theme is consistent throughout but not one I would listen to often. Marvin has a lot of "great" songs spread out over a lot of "good" albums.
Huge amazing
Started well, then... Best track-What's Going On
opens with a quiet cacophony of voices, giving the impression of an intimate club set and fades into the title track, drawing me right into the groove
A smoothly glowing album to listen to in the Italian sun. I’ll listen again as I feel it may be a grower!
Lite väl gospel ahh texter för min del. Men nice vibe att ha typ under en middag om det inte var för texterna. Smörigt men ändå bra!
Loooooooove. Eternal.
Me imagino que esto voló un par de cráneos en su momento. Meh meh, pero mejor que el anterior. Nota: 2.9
Classic, will always get all the stars. This record is it!
Konačno da me nešto natjera da odslušam ovaj album. Definitivno nisam očekivala ovakvu apokaliptičnu atmosferu, ni da je u pitanju koncept album. Nešto mi fali. Nemam pojma zbog čega, ali nisam oduševljena. Ovo ću morati opet odslušati da odlučim zvaničnu ocjenu. Kao da se sve previše pomiješali zajedno pa nema efekta.
4 stars only because Save the Children is about 2.5 minutes too long.
A smooth, funky, and deeply moving album where Marvin Gaye masterfully addresses war, the environment, racism, and hope. It's easy on the ears but hits hard with its political and emotional messages. A complete classic that still feels hauntingly relevant today. 5/5
J - 3/5 Best Track - "What's Going On?" F - DNL
Something of a “Pet Sounds” of Motown, with incredibly rich orchestration and a fantastic vocal performance from Gaye. It’s also an unavoidably “important” record, dealing with a variety of political themes that still resonate today. The big three of “What’s Going On”, “Mercy Mercy Me”, and “Inner City Blues” are tremendous, and “Right On” is a great groove. Some of the other songs, notably “Save The Children” fall a bit flat and feel dated. But on the whole, it’s the real deal.
“save the children” is HAUNTINGLY beautiful. even though the rest didn’t really catch my eye, so to speak, i did mess with this album. very chill and laid back, yet it made an important statement. i can definitely see why this is in apple music’s top 100 albums. 4/5.
Nice album with a message that resounds today. Percussion on his works is always a centerpiece which I enjoy.
Love this album. 4.5 if I could, this is where not being able to give .5 ratings sucks. Oh well. Still love it
Kommer lige over til 5/5 fordi produktionen er SÅ god. Jeg elsker hvordan alle numrene flød ind i det næste
Virkelig lækkert produceret plade med et meget godt flow.
Really great sounding album. Meaningful and important lyrics.
An iconic album that is a pleasant listen start to finish.
Never sat down to listen to this album. Didn't realize it was progressive R&B, which is interesting. I never realized how similar whats going on and mercy mercy me were. Just thought it was a motown kind of sound, but it turns out it was deliberate. Kinda cool, but I am not sure about it. This whole album is just one long song, that is pretty cool. It also feels like "I heard it through the grapevine" will happen at any moment on that later tracks. This was a complete album, with themes connecting the end to the beginning and vice-versa. Excellence.
Meh
Niet genoeg geluisterd nog maar zeer nice. Conceptueel sterk en vrij direct maar niet perse opdringerig (los van wat praise-Jesussy nummers) Aangename productie, heel lush allemaal. Daardoor voelen de drums wel erg zachtjes waardoor er (misschien naast Right On) niks echt knalt. Hoeft ook niet altijd, maar ik mis toch soms een snappy snare drum. Er zijn wel veel leuke percussie elementen die wat meer die rol overnemen soms. Verder natuurlijk een goeie stem, coole transities tussen de nummers voor een seamless listen. Ik ga hier nog wel eens meer induiken. Beste: Whats Going On? / What’s Happening Brother / Wholy Holy / Mercy Mercy Me Minste: Save the Children Albumhoes: Ja, de vampierkraag in de regen + dat medieval lettertype = 5/5
Ik kon hier erg goed naar luisteren, alles voelde erg zwoel aan en dat kon ik zeker goed gebruiken tijdens deze warme zomernachten. Er zijn niet echt nummers die er voor mij uitschieten. Wel leuke muziekelementen, zoals de fluit op right on.
Cool, eigenlijk veel meer mijn ding dan ik had verwacht
Fijne muziek, sommige nummers zijn een beetje te Jesus-heavy voor mij.
Luistert lekker weg, geschikt als achtergrondmuziek bij pannenkoeken bakken op een weekend ochtend (geprobeerd). Ik vind het geen album om aandachtig naar te luisteren. Heb wel een zwak voor mercy mercy me, ooit ontdekt via een cover van Eddie Vedder met Julian Casablancas (ja deze bestaat echt!). Ook het origineel is genieten. Vond alleen de overgang vanuit het nummer ervoor erg awkward.
This motherfucker don’t know nothing about nothin 9/10
Incredible album. Nothing more needs to be said. 33-34 minutes of musical perfection.
good stuff
Скучно
really liked it!
70's soul and a concept album. Life story is tragic. I wonder if my parents listened to Marvin? I hope so.
very inquisitive album. idk what's going on either
What’s Going On and Mercy Mercy Me are amazing, but I find it hard to really connect with the other songs. They need some sort of hook or recognizability that the other two songs have
It was pretty good. He’s a hip hop legend
One of the best albums ever in my opinion. Six stars.
An interesting listen. The well-known songs are the best ones. With a few exceptions this album is like a long EP.
Groundbreaking!
I listened this album quite heavily a few decades ago. The album has really original atmosphere and I really like how the songs are connected together. Vocals are really great and there are many interesting vocal arrangements. Lyrics paint a quite pessimistic view of where things were going in a turn of a decade (60's/70's). Regardless of that, the overall impression is still hopeful.
peak produção!!!!!! que voz, que homem!!!! 4,5
The Hits are awesome but overplayed tbh. Really good though
Actual classic
took me three days to listen to this but i did. fav song: Inner City Blues.
4/5.
A beautiful album by a beautiful person.