Tommy by The Who

Tommy

The Who

3.3
Rating
29519
Votes
1
5%
2
18%
3
35%
4
27%
5
15%
Distribution

Reviews (page 12 of 14)

I don't like this album, really not my kind of music. I don't like the who. Sorry.

Might be a breakthrough back in 1969, but for some reason it did not resonate with me. I understand that it is a masterpiece based on the musical complexity, but still, not for me.

Aangezet terwijl ik aan het vliegvissen was. Ik weet nog dat vrij in het begin ons Tommy geboren werd. Daarna ben ik qua verhaal volledig afgehaakt omdat ik al vrij vroeg in het album onverwacht een brasem aan de lijn kreeg. Ik herinner me vooral het gevoel dat ik heel lang naar een gedateerde musical aan het luisteren was. Niet mijn album, maar desondanks niet getwijfeld om liedjes te skippen of het album af te zetten. Tussen de 2 en 3, maar ik vind een 3 te hoog.

This album is a clear concept rock opera album that's quite strong. The album includes Pinball Wizard.

What if a band that wrote really good 3-minute rock songs drew out an idea for a 70-minute album? What if that album told a story? And what if the songs were subsumed to telling the story? And what if the story was extremely goofy? Pinball Wizard is a very dumb idea for song but is way better than it has any right to be. The rest is extremely boring. Random guitar parts throughout sound good and I always love JE on bass - but these songs are such a drag.

It has some great tracks, but I've neve been a big fan of The Who

It's Tommy. It's a classic. 5 stars.

Long album that can be slow at times. Probably deserves a more in depth look at lyrics but its hard to follow over an hour long album. Always like an album that tells a story though. Pinball wizard is great but hard to get into many of the other songs

There are a few songs I enjoyed, Pinball Wizard is a classic. Didn’t really care much for it though and struggled to make it all the way through.

Comments not needed,

So, on this one, I'm kind of torn in terms of a rating. I think I have to approach it a little differently than I might otherwise, precisely because A) I'm intimately familiar with this record B) I think it's actually a somewhat important record, in terms of being ambitious C) I have a soft spot for the band. I wouldn't argue with someone who gave it a three strictly based on the quality of the tunes and the musicianship, but that said, in context, this is a pretty great record, though I like earlier Who more, and for a big grandiose mess, I strongly prefer Quadrophenia. The "rock opera" and "concept album" would never have gotten real momentum without this record and how successful it was.

Pretty great, but I think the songs get a little thinner in the last third of the album.

Not quite go the power, passion and absolute intensity of Quadrophenia, but still fantastic. Also can't unhear the soundtrack versions of songs by the Acid Queen and Elton.

Veldig gid stemning, men jeg kom meg aldri gjennom

It's fine, doesn't really do it for me

Didn’t get into it at all, bland

Mediocre singing in songs that range from boring to stupid. Severely overrated in my opinion.

Not a fan of mellow The Who

It's not perfect. Like many double albums Tommy would have made a killer single album. Put Christmas at the end of side one. Then side two is The Acid Queen, Pinball Wizard, I'm Free and See Me Feel Me/Listening To You, finishing with Underture. Shame to leave out Cousin Kevin but there we go. It's still a great album though and I love it.

interesting concept album with cool music i guess it will stay relevant just out of its sheer odd story

went in with expectations and got really let down! Album is much more instrumental than I thought it would be and sounded almost more in the prog-rock space, felt really drawn out

The ambition of this record is fairly astonishing. A double album telling the story of an abused deaf, dumb and blind kid. It could only happen in the sixties. Here you’ll find some of The WHO’s finest moments. The album that started to secure their legendary status. It’s a record that should be heard. Even if rock ain’t your thing, listening to the whole thing from start to finish is a must for anyone who appreciates the LP format.

Such a unique classic. The instrumentation is great. The lyrics can be weird but I think that is part of the charm.

Gotta love The Who, this album is ground breaking in it's approach to story telling though the medium of an album. The best part of this album might actually be the humor that they employ with songs like Tommy's Holiday Camp and pinball wizard. I also enjoy the tones of this instruments, but that is more a product of the 1960's. Idk if this is The Who's most impressive album, but there is a lot of dynamics that makes it belong on this list

Absolutely gigachadded

Strong 4, based rock opera

I never got the hype

Ahh Thomas. Weird and wonderful.

The Who’s best

The Who's magnum opus still rocks nearly 60 years later. Well worth a listen.

4/19, 21%

Wow, never really been a fan of themed albums or ‘rock opera’ but had to give this a second spin and will be diving into more of the stuff from The Who I haven’t delved into.

A perfect album.

Not the worst The Who album, but at this point the should rename the band to "The oh it's you on the list again"

I hadn't heard this album in my entire life outside of "Pinball Wizard" here and there on the radio or at someone's house. I knew that the album was a rock opera, but I didn't know it was billed as the first of its kind. Having the full picture of Tommy's life before and after "Pinball Wizard" has changed how I experience the song. Tommy was a wild ride with some shocking and unexpected moments throughout. Overall, the composition and performances are extremely solid and I enjoyed the musical aspect completely. The concept and story was a little unclear at times if I hadn't read the Wikipedia article on it, I probably would have missed the flow of the story.

I go in and out of appreciating and understanding the Who. In particular, I never really got Tommy before, but this time it clicked for me. Overture lays out all the musical themes to come, the songs then build up through Tommy’s back story. A highlight is definitely Keith Moon’s drumming, he’s like an artist painting a picture of movement and time. One instance that stuck out to me was on Fiddle About, the drumming speed and sound accentuate the terrifying action of the song. Pinball Wizard might be the most overplayed Who song, but hearing it in the context of the album breathes new life and meaning into it. The second half of the album in general is pretty awesome. Go to the Mirror is probably the next closest thing to a single and it’s great. Not sure I’d casually listen to a 75 minute rock opera, but when in the mood it is definitely one of the best.

Classic!!! Rock opera was born. Musicality of this album is masterful. Love it now and loved it then.

No rock operas for me please. Get back to the three-minute pop song format. Some lyrics are darker than black metal.

Influential and visionary. This is one of the most celebrated albums in rock history, no doubt about it. If I find it boring or not is irrelevant.

One of the OG rock operas. There are better concept albums, better "rock operas", and better Who albums that cover all those conditions (Quadrophenia is the correct answer, for anyone reading this who's wondering.) However, there is greatness here, though it is a flawed work. Underture happens to be one of my favorite tracks on the album. Pinball Wizard is overrated. The final track, We're Not Gonna Take It, descends into moving theme. Fiddle About is painfully uncomfortable. I mean, having Tommy's Holiday Camp as the second to last track, one could make an argument that this album's theme is the cyclic nature of abuse. Definitely doesn't age well. Good, not great. Meaningfully impactful on the state of music at the time. I despise the child abuse themes.

Tremendo discazo. Es como de teatro, no sabes cuándo un tema termina y arranca el otro. Luego busque y es 'ópera-rock'.

Very forgettable and boring concept album.

Good rock album. Would need to give it another listen. Not into long albums!

I like the Who and know a lot of their other work. Can't say I've listened to this before but feel it would be better having watched the film. Pinball Wizard and Sally Simpson are more what I was expecting of this album

Aldrig lyssnat mycket på The Who och är det något album som har bistått med "låtar i förbifarten" är det "Who's Next". Så detta var spännande! Första låten "Overture" känns lite som en klassisk öppningslåt på ett album, lite som ett interlude för att kicka igång skivan. Dock känns det som att den typen av låtar ofta inte är mer än max 2 minuter långa. "Overture" var en 5 minuters fulllåt, men som ändå gav den känslan. Vet inte om det är bra? Lutar åt att det kanske var lite onödigt. Sedan när andra låten visar sig vara 40 sekunder lång och exakt det jag trodde att första låten var tänkt att vara, kan jag inte känna mig något annat är lite smålurad. Det som fortsätter efter det är ett gäng låtar av ljummen rock som jag i denna värme inte känner inspiration att känna in på djupet. Dom är okej. Vi är framme vid albumets mastodontare, "Underture", där första halvan var otroligt ointressant. På ett sätt som gjorde mig lite orolig när jag såg att den var 10 minuter lång. Den gör ändå något miniförsök till förändring ett par gånger, men inte på något sätt som gör 7 minuter värda att spendera innan det händer. Inte ens nära. Som en person som är svag för mastodontare måste jag erkänna att det här är albumets sämsta låt. Det riktiga minilyftet kommer när albumets mest lyssnade låt rullar igång. "Pinball Wizard" är ändå en rätt bra låt. Det är en akustisk gitarr som lägger till mycket känsla och driv till låten. Bättre! Det är väldigt många kortlåtar genom albumets gång (1-2 min) där många innehåller ett körande som påminner om The Beach Boys. Inte orimligt då det är 1969. Detta gör nog att albumet känns längre än vad det är, 24 låtar borde vara längre än 74 minuter. Som helhet slår inte albumet några rekord i min bok. Visserligen gillar jag albumkonceptet där man får följa Tommy's resa och det är ett anständigt omslag. Musiken blir i längden lite svår att gå igång extra på, även om det är väl genomförd rock. Det är också, precis som "Underture", alldeles för långt. Bäst: "Pinball Wizard"

A great if unbalanced album. This is one of my favorite albums and I love to listen to it for all the great parts and not so great parts

I'm not a big Who fan and didn't like the film at all, so I couldn't quite persevere with this one. Appreciate the concept but it's not for me.

There's some seriously dark themes for a record in which the best song is about pinball. Seriously, pick a lane-- the songs about SA are, like, RIGHT next to Pinball Wizard. It's interesting as an earlier concept album, but it's definitely not the best, most well-thought out, or most interesting concept. Most of it whizzed right past me. 3/5 letters lit up. Multiball activated!

Didn't realise it was a concept story telling album until near the end, so I didn't give the correct attention. But I did enjoy quite a few bits. WIll listen again.

The first true rock opera, you can't help but admire the ambition behind this album. Pete Townshend was only 23 when he put it together, so it's hard to be tough on him if a few sections of this are a little clunky. Awkward, exposition-laden lyrics are a fixture of musical theatre, and that's basically what we're doing here, right? There aren't many hits here, or even many songs that could stand on their own. But despite all of this damning praise, I really do think that this album is a feat worthy of celebrating.

Probably only gets a 3 because of my very specific Almost Famous nostalgia

Tommy is such a weird album to me. I get why people enjoy it, but it's not what I go in for when I want to listen to The Who. The whole opera concept is goofy and most songs are pretty bland. There are a few instrumental standouts and pinball wizard, but otherwise there isn't enough Entwisel magic or Moon weirdness to make this enjoyable.

Pinball wizard is a great song. Cousin Kevin should have been better given the name of the song... Overall I like the 2nd half of this much better. I would give 2nd half 3 stars and first half 1 star

Underture was awesome. Pete Townshend and Keith Moon are awesome. Lots of classics that just keep bringing up Mr. P. Wizard. Never realized how fucked up the story of this album was until reading about it. Great listen.

Pretty disappointing album for the praise that I have heard from it. A bunch of really weird mini songs that I didn't enjoy too much. They really liked singing about pinballs

Cousin Kevin is pretty cool. This had some good songs and a lot of songs that just happen and aren't exciting in any way. Pinball Wizard rules obviously and is way better than any other song on this rekkid. Can dig the bass on Go To The Mirror! too. I'm Free is a jam too. Overall a pretty boring album besides a couple songs. This album should've been 30 minutes shorter.

Interesting but it did drag on a little.

Genre defining, a staggering display of raw talent. REALLY boring.

While Tommy himself can't talk, his album speaks for itself. Favorite tracks: 'Christmas' and 'Cousin Kevin'

Dette er den typen album hvor man faktisk må følge med, og det har man jo dessverre sjelden tid til. Men konseptet med en "historie" er stilig.

Music for another type of dad. Not really into it - way too up their own ass.

I dig the who but never cared for this album. Bold in its concept I feel like it just misses the mark for trying to keep up the joke

A few classics, nothing crazy

The term "rock opera" is slightly embarrassing these days but this one must have been exciting back in 1969. It's impressive and definitely one to be experienced as a whole (and ideally live). Most songs wouldn't work on their own though and you really need to be in the mood for a full length concept album to appreciate it. But it's definitely an important album in the history of rock.

ganz cool, aber vieeeel zu lang

I love me some unhinged Keith Moon, but this album is a bit of a chore overall. Some of the songs simply overstay their welcome, feeling like it's nothing more than Pete Townshend indulging himself. I understand this album's inclusion on this list, but I feel like there's been better albums of it's sort since.

Esperaba mucho más de The Who. No se por qué, pero antes de haber escuchado la banda, yo pensaba en The Who como algo equivalente a Pink Floyd o hasta The Beatles, pero me doy cuenta de que mis expectativas estaban más que exageradas. Es el segundo álbum que escucho de ellos y es el segundo que es alguna clase de concept álbum, esta vez siendo una opera sobre la historia de un chico o algo así. Para mi mala suerte, no me gusta fijarme más en la letra de lo que me fijo en la música, así que no puedo calificar la primera. Dejando fuera la historia, las canciones difícilmente tienen la suficiente personalidad como para diferenciarlas entre sí, cosa que es horrible tomando en cuenta lo tremendamente largo que es. No es que sea malo, pero tampoco tiene mucho que ofrecer.

Some weird tracks that are 1-2mins long on this track. Pinball wizard is the standout, 5/10

Good film, soundtrack doesn't quite hold up.both now dated. Influential rather than a must listen

kolmatta albumia viedään tältä bändiltä jo, ja tiedän että ainakin kaksi vielä tulossa vielä (en, en katsonut spoilereita, yleinen musiikkitieto heh, sen verran tiedän sentään heh). olikos tämä sittemmin tarpeellinen lisäys, noh ihan hyvä tämä on, maailman ensimmäinen tommyesque tyyppinen albumi, saa seleväksi tommy nimisen henkilön kokemuksia heh...... VITTUAKO KIINNOSTAA...liian pitkä eyesight to the blind (the hawker)

Om alla skrev rockoperor hade det inte varit så många krig. De hade inte haft tid.

A three act play about the rise and fall of a blind, then not blind, cult leader who at first wasn’t a cult leader but then is a cult leader but then isn’t again.

I love the Who- magnificently gifted and oddball with disastrous concept albums and insane members. This whole album sums them up and the world would be a lesser place without them.

Mjae. Har nog svårt för rockoperor

"Tommy" is the fourth studio by English band The Who. It is a rock opera and a double album at that. Pete Townsend composed most of the songs and wanted something more than just three-minute pop/rock songs. It tells the story of Tommy who witnesses and is traumatized by a murder his father committed, is abused, is given LSD by a quack, plays pinball to feel, snaps out of his state and gathers a religious cult who eventually rejected him. Alright, simple enough. Townsend was inspired by Indian spiritual master Meher Baba in the writing. It was originally hailed by critics. It has been very successful selling 20 million copies and spawning a 1975 movie and a 1991 Broadway musical. The album opens dramatically with the mostly instrumental "Overture." Townsend on piano and accompanied by the instrumental Ensemble group The Assembled Multitude. Keith Moon's drumming a highlight (and throughout this album). The classic guitar riff you'd hear later on. Tommy's father is believed dead. Tommy's born in "It's a Boy." I always liked the vocals and backing vocals. "Amazing Journey" describes Tommy developing his mental state after witnessing the murder in the previous song, "1921." This is when you really start to hear The Who take off. Slow-fast-slow-fast. Pyschdelic sounds. Speaking of journeys, The Who take us on one in "Christmas" Great backing vocals. They go all over the place and introduce the thematic lyrics of "Tommy can you hear me" and "See me, feel me, touch me, heal me." Tommy does not recognize it's Christmas. Townsend takes the lead vocals on "The Acid Queen" as the quack and his parents give Tommy acid for the cure. The band then does a good job taking us through his mind with some extended dramatic jams continuing on in "Underture." Not quite prog but not entirely not prog. Shit, maybe I'm on acid. Side three gives us "Pinball Wizard." That acoustic guitar and electric guitar riff. Tommy plays a mean pinball with only his sense of smell. One of my favorite Who songs. Tommy finally gains some senses in "Go To the Mirror!" Another song of journey. Daultrey pleads him to "See me, feel me, touch me, heal me." Great melodies and the band breaks out in the glorious ending. The entire band sings in "Tommy Can You Hear Me?" Great harmonies. Tommy breaks his mirror and gains sensation in "Sensation. One of the more pop tunes on the album. Tommy becomes a rock star of sorts in "Sally Simpson." Sally becomes a follower even if they're worlds apart. "I'm Free" was one of the singles from this album. Some more great guitar combos and riffs by Townsend. Tommy's on the rise with his movement. Tommy's journey comes to a crashing end with his followers in "We're Not Going to Take it." The band combines everything here with the melodies, Moon's drumming, the harmonies and the recurring thematic lyrics and choruses. There is no doubt this quite an achievement. With no break between songs it comes off like one long song. There is some filler but the album moves at a decent pace for a double album. But, there're classic guitar riffs, lyrics, choruses and songs. Moon's drumming. The music builds drama. And, the band plays like tight band. For a historical perspective, check their performance out in "The Rolling Stones Rock and Roll Circus" where they performed on a break from the recording of the album. Mind blowing.

Great Album. A Classic!

Hieno bändi ja upeita biisejä, mutta tää on ehkä vähän liian rokkiooppera. Reilusti kuitenkin plussan puolelle! 4/5

Kolmonen tällekin wholle. Hyvää, mutta mitään kummempaa en koe.

Alkaa kyl vähän kyllästyttää nää päättömän tarinan päälle rakennetut rock-oopperat. Myöskään musiikillisesti en ollu erityisen kiinnostunut. 2/5.

Good listen, not great not bad. Some decent songs in there

Its fine, took me a few songs to realise it was an opera and l enjoyed it more after that but theres a lot of WTF

Jo men det var ändå ett bra album. Men frågan är vem fan är tommy?

Vem fan är Tommy, jag får nog fråga runt lite. Jag tyckte inte det var det bästa av the Who men det va la bra

now an amazing 54 years old but still great to listen to

Love me some pinball wizard but this was too long without enough going on to really get into.

Uneven and I don't think I'm in the mood nor am I gonna get through it.

Huffing the incense fumes a little too hard, Townshend writes a spiritual journey that goes…somewhere? Hard to say. Some of the instrumental journeys get a touch lost. But the playing is great, the riffs rock, and unlike many of his contemporaries Daltrey obviously doesn’t believe he’s actually the character he’s portraying. That’s worth something.

Some good lil ditties. Some unnecessary ditties. Glad we’ve gotten over singing about girl’s Daddy’s. Anyways smash the patriarchy.

Such a good album! One of the earlier ones I have on vinyl. So good!

Meh, didn’t really do anything for me. Fool me once, Shame on you. Fool me twice…won’t be fooled again

Respect to The Who but not into rock operas, unless it's Dracula's Lament

This album is extremely famous for how much of a true concept album it was so long ago. Judging it now, a lot of these songs have some filler aspects to them. I think when you compare the music on this album to the Who's other music it's actually fairly simplistic and not overly impressive. It would probably be my choice for only third best Who album. That being said, there are some absolute gems on this album. The See Mee Feel Me recurring theme is hauntingly beautiful. Pinball Wizard is of course an all time classic, and a standard for aspiring acoustic guitar players to do some proper damage to their guitar bodies trying to play. It's kind of a shame you have to listen to Fiddle About right before it, which isn't a bad song musically but is just hard to not cringe when hearing. This album is certainly greater than the sum of its parts. The story is kind of cool and the use of recurring musical motifs to enhance the storytelling of the lyrics is great. In the end though, this album feels to me like just baby steps towards the masterpiece that is Quadrophenia.

The first ever rock opera is a great album. It was made during the best period in The Who's history, in the late 1969 and overall the end result was very good. The album is long since it is a double album, and this might explain why it has some songs that aren't that consistent. So I don't give it a 5, but it is a stronger 4 record.

I listened to this and enjoyed it in my youth but wow what an album.

What a disappointment.

Very good concept album I enjoyed this album but at some parts ot was a bit boring but overall it was a good album

I can appreciate what they were going for with this in terms of scope and trying something new. I applaud the risk-taking that made this album possible on many levels. That said, it did very little for me.

At first, I was disappointed. Truly disappointed. Maybe my expectations were too high. They were based on a couple of songs I knew, and this album seemed um... nothing special. The only song I truly liked was (obviously) Pinball Wizard. Everything changed when the fire nation attacked. No, wait. That's not what happened. This album was a massive surprise after reading its description. Wow, one of the first rock operas? An album that tells one whole story? I'm impressed! I admit, it's not one of the best albums ever, but pioneers usually aren't perfect.

I find The Who a great singles band whose work gets too flabby on an album This was no exception

Annoying, not even using the saying when I say it sounded like a broken record

Another epic and long concept album made by a rock band, after "The Wall" by Pink Floyd (although timewise it was the other way around). We have an interesting story on this album, but music was all over the place. I liked few of the opening tracks, very lively and essentially "The Who". But this recipe got very tiring and I had to sit through another hour of those songs. It's a cool concept, but I have to use an emergency exit.

Never really understood the acclaim. Didn’t “get” the film either. A few excellent songs should not necessarily make a phenomenon. Low three for good intentions. Underwhelmed. Bring on Who’s Next, please.

Some great moments but it goes on a bit.

its a pretty good album and the standout hits are recognizable, but I get why we don't see more of the tracks from this on greatest hits albums.....

Absolutely mental, too long though.

I should like this more than I do - I'm a sucker for concept albums with a bit of narrative behind them - but this didn't quite work for me. It all merges together a bit, and not in the good way that you'd expect a concept album to. The intro to Pinball Wizard is incredible, shame really they put a song about pinball after it. Needs to be a bit tighter (really should have ended it after Smash The Mirror rather than the nonsense about a cult), and the lyrics aren't quite there in most of the songs to rival something like The Wall (which has a similar journey but builds a world much better). 3/5.

Classic album.

Paar Nice nummers! Maar blijf niet per se een fan. Wat een belachelijk lange versie ook dit trouwens hahaha. Favoriete nr.: 1921 baddest nummer: tommy’s holiday camp!

So self-indulgent. Feels like it took the entire weekend to listen to. Rock peaked in the 70s but its decline started right when the rockers thought they were this important.

sooooo longggggg. strong first half into a bloated and vapid second half. circusy, cheesy, overwrought. fuck this album.

I fucking hate The Who.

Great album. Fully enjoyed it

I listened to it twice and mostly it just merged into one long song with the obvious moment Pinball Wizard jumps out at you. Ultimately not a very interesting or listenable album.

The who is really hit or miss for me!! And besides Pinball Wizard this rock opera feels more self indulgent than interesting to me. Controversial but I'm more with James here.

Let’s get this out of the way: rock operas are dumb. The story is usually so thin and vague that it becomes meaningless, and they seem to be an excuse for artists to write ranging songs with no melody. This is my second time listening to Tommy and I still just don’t get it. If you take each song on its face, none are very good and many are asinine. Why is pinball mentioned in like 3 songs? Does Tommy play pinball? Do I care? I understand why this is on the list but it’s just not for me.

This is a conundrum. It comes in the middle of some classic Who releases, all of which I consider much better than this. However, Tommy is a classic because it popularized (but did not create) the rock opera - for better or for worse. Its extended life as a stage show and movie in an of itself probably secures it a slot on the list. There is some great music here, along with some that is merely good. It probably says more about the band's quality of work during the period that among The Who Sell Out, Who's Next and Quadrophenia, I place Tommy fourth.

A brilliant concept album in which you can actually follow the story. It features some of Pete Townsend’s best writing and a few staples of classic rock. I don’t think it’s the Who’s best album but it definitely deserves a 5.

I’ll give this a 5 for what it represents more than what it is. The story is insane and I would not listen to many tracks on their own but as a whole this is an impressive work. How Pete Townsend thought of this I will never understand, but it is a true rock opera with a full story that you can more or less follow if you follow close attention. The drums sounded fantastic on here and I loved “underture”. The Pinball Wizard intro will also always be fantastic.

Great, but somehow I feel it's lacking just a little something

I liked this! It did run a little long, though.

Tommy, can you hear me?

- Amazing Journey: So far this album is very much based on the vibes of the music moreso than the lyrical and vocal content. I've never listened to an album like this before and it's not what is usually in my rotation. - Eyesight of the Blind: Definitely my favorite song on the album so far. 60's music isn't my favorite ever, but I can definitely see the appeal of this album. Pure good and chilled vibes. - Christmas: Okay, scratch what I said before. This is now my favorite song on the album. TOMMY CAN YOU HEAR ME? - Underture: I won't lie I listened half way through and skipped it because of its length. I'm more of a lyric person, hence the reason I rarely like ambient music. Sorry The Who fans, I couldn't sit through this one. - Go to the Mirror!: I love this song! THE BOY IS HEALED! - Sally Simpson: I love the storytelling in this song - We're Not Going To Take It: Shocking lyrics but a satisfying ending to this album nonetheless. OVERALL: I can definitely see the appeal of this album, however, it's not for me.

Really enjoyed this concept album. Want to check out more from The Who.

The people who reassessed this albums high regard and realized it was actually not very good are right. Pinball wizard is still a banger though

I recognize what they did here, though The Who don't really connect with me in general. I do give them credit for having both an Overture and an Underture. That's quality punning.

They should make a movie out of this album.

Good stuff back half of album Carrie’s

To be honest I expected a lot more from this. I’ve heard it’s some grand, detailed rock opera, which I guess it was in the storytelling aspect, but the music that accompanies the story is just so bland and forgettable. It’s almost completely devoid of riffs or hooks that catch the ear and help you remember each song. 4/10

The first rock opera, Tommy set the stage for mainstream rock (as opposed to more niche prog rock ) to get serious and expansive. The original is vastly superior to the movie soundtrack despite the latter's star cast.

I was excited when this generated in for me, but boy oh boy was I let down. I was maybe too hyped for a rock and roll tour de force which, I felt, I just didn’t get. There’s nothing too much wrong with the album, except none of it is memorable at all. Pinball Wizard is only a fragment as it’s one that EVERYONE knows but the rest of the album is almightilly forgettable. Maybe one I’ll have to go back to in the future.

Album narratif homogène

PREFS : Overture, 1921, Amazing Journey, Christmas, Cousin Kevin, The Acid Queen, Pinball Wizard, Go To the Mirror!, Sally Simpson, I'm Free, We're Not Gonna Take It MOINS PREF : Underture

Pinball Wizard is the only song that stands alone. I'll never pull up 'Fiddle about' and listen to it again.

Me gustó bastante,un poco largo lo único, me gusta el instrumental y la historia

Long and kind of interesting, especially the really long bit with the molestation. Sloppier in timing and pitch than I expected. An achievement though.

Está bien pero me emboló

Ok so this was a really interesting and weird album, and I celebrate creativity as punchy as this. But 75 mins for an album is a pisstake

Banging, but I think i still prefer Oliver Reed and the tunes from the movie, which introduced me to the material. Thoroughly bizarre as a concept, but with some insanely evocative musical moments

buenisimo pero tambien un poco zzzzz

Pinball wizard och I’m free fortfarande bra, annars känns albumet lite väl flummigt.

I liked it way more than I thought I would; once I learned that the album is a detailed story I could start to pick up on certain motifs in either lyrics or musical repetitions. Its fascinating how they made the lyrics work with the music and just how clean it all came out.

For a long time pretty much my only exposure to the Who was a cassette of that greatest hits album with the Union Jack shirt on the cover. And I don't know why I didn't branch out more because I loved that tape and listened to it a lot. Later my brother gave me a couple LPs and I bought Sell Out on CD. But I'm still a fairly shallow fan - I don't believe I ever listened to Tommy start to finish before, for example. Pretty interesting. It mostly skates the Rock Opera dilemma with its opposing pitfalls - overly wordy, unpoetic songs to drive exposition on one side, versus managing the vaguest narrative that can only generously be labeled a "concept" album on the other. To the degree this errs it's more to the latter side, which is good - the music being the main point however lofty the concept aspirations. Without outside interpretations supported by years of amateur analysis plus a couple of filmed/staged interpretations, I don't know I'd have extracted a very coherent story out of it. But there is a lot of good music and the themes running throughout are strong, and it was certainly an audacious move for its time, particularly from a band whose star (by all reports) seemed like it might be waning. Well worth the time.

Rockopera van The Who, dat het verhaal verteld van de blinde, dove en stomme Tommy. Album is veel meer dan alleen "Pinball Wizard" en zit muzikaal en vertellend goed in elkaar. leukste nummer: Amazing Journey Het album is gebaseerd op de wijsheden van Meher Baba, naar wie later het nummer Baba O'Riley is genoemd.

An absolute epic. Going to watch the movie. Amazing music and lyrics.

moments of brilliance surrounded by an hour of mediocre bullshit.

It's alright.

Stone cold classic. Top marks.

So good. It's a long record that sounds much shorter due to the short songs, varied characters and themes. I was surprised to find out that Tommy came so early in The Who's career.

I love Pinball Wizard and was super excited to listen to this because I love The Who and that song but damn. Disappointed. This felt like a wannabe, off-brand The Wall but worse. Sad face.

For an album that tells a story this one tracked better than the Wall though reading the Wikipedia page about it I missed a lot. That being said not my cup of tea mate. Pinball Wizard is kinda catchy but still not for me.

Doesn't get much better then this. First rock opera. Beautiful music composition, powerful and thoughtful lyrics. Incredible album! 10/10

Pretty fantastic.

Boring but liked the drumming

achei a sonoridade parecida com Beatles, o que me surpreendeu pois achava que era mais pesado. álbum muito longo nessa versão deluxe, mas gostei num geral. uma das músicas me lembrou Bohemiam Rhapsody, achei interessante verificar essa influência. não prestei atenção suficiente nas letras para opinar com base nisso.

Overall, gostei - combinação do vocalista com os instrumentos é bem boa, faz com que seja uma banda/álbum fácil e gostoso de ouvir. Dito isso, achei que o álbum em questão tem muitos solos instrumentais, que contribuem para deixar o álbum um pouco maçante. Outro ponto é a duração, com mais de uma hora e 24 músicas, achei que ficou repetitivo e cansativo, acredito que seria possível passar o pente e selecionar apenas 10~13 músicas e não acho que o álbum perderia qualidade ou deixaria de mostrar suas características.

Overall not GREAT imho, but glad to have listened to it. Handful of really good songs, and I can appreciate how important this type of sprawling concept album was at the time. Don't think I'll be listening to it front to back any time soon, but I'll probably be back to some of the singles. 3.5 rounded down

Everybody knows Pinball Wizard. What a track. What a video. The rest of the album is a typical Townshend rock-opera affair, some great, some passable. You'll probably enjoy the music from this album much more if you watch the Ken Russell film of the same name (featuring the band and the album's music).

Some great tracks, some meh tracks, but musicals just aren't for me.

I enjoyed it but I doubt it will ever be an album I ever reach for

Grungier Beatles. Quite an enjoyable listen with a few hits.

Some bangers, some not so banger. Probably wouldn't listen to the whole album again

I mean, it's Tommy. 🎶🔥

This is a very interesting full length rock opera. I feel as if it is too long, but it does share a cohesive story throughout and the transition between songs is very cool.

Pinball wizard was by far the best

Not feeling it even though it’s iconic

Couldn’t get all the way through it. Weird in parts.

Tommy figured his shit out. Go Tommy!!! 3.54

I had never listened to this. I thought this would be great, but it was really only good for Pinball Wizard.

A little worse than the wall But the wall is pretty good I just wish this album was a bit shorter

An imperfect, too long, but like… amazing album. The story is what gets me. It’s so funny, moving, strange, dark comedy. I loved it. And this is a really groundbreaking album. It feels like the confines of rock and roll and being pushed against, cracking at the seams. Can we do full stories now, with instrumental interludes? A whole character arc, a whole life? I’m sold. It’s protean, in some ways, and at some moments still massively moving. 5/5

The only track on this album I was familiar with before today was "Pinball Wizard," and it appears I wasn't missing much. Maybe my bad mood is coloring my opinion, but while listening I mostly vacillated between boredom and actively wishing I was listening to something else. I like The Who. I like "Pinball Wizard." But I don't like "Tommy."

I know this album is supposed to be an epic, but I found it hokey & a little dull. I know this band is crazy talent, but I never really enjoyed them - they're my least favorite of the big rock English bands of that time.

Such a great album. Been a very long time since I've sat down and listened to it.

This is a weird album by the Who. I haven't seen the film Tommy in a long time and don't remember much about it but after listening to this album and reading the wiki, this plot is way over contrived. The songs are mostly mediocre, with the big standout being 'Pinball Wizard'. Aside from that track, I could mostly lose the whole album. Also, has a super creepy song on it that I'd rather never hear again. I like the Who but can't give this album much of a recommendation. Standout Tracks: Amazing Journey, Sparks, Pinball Wizard, Go To The Mirror!, I'm Free

Super fun album, it definitely feels an hour and fourteen minutes long, but it’s not long for no reason. I need more listens to dive into the story of Tommy and dissect the lyrics, which I’m sure will just deepen my enjoyment of the project. Really energizing instrumentation, these songs have a timeless quality to them by not feeling forced into a specific box. Just a bunch of songs collected together to fulfill a bigger theme. Faves: 1921, Eyesight To The Blind, Christmas

couldn't finish it off sadly, didn't like the film that much icl

weird - I actually love a lot of songs by The Who but I guess not this "Rock Opera" thing. The drumming was EXCELLENT as could have been expected, and the recording seemed quite good. It's just not very interesting music I guess.

This album was dogshit. Some high points here and there, but couldn’t drown out the ridiculous storyline that needed to include a snippet about Uncle Eddie finger banging the protagonist. Who’s Next should have completely eclipsed the need to listen to this “rock opera”. Two genres that I have yet to see belong together.

One of my favorite albums. I'm a sucker for a good rock opera, and 1969 just contained some of the most killer music ever.

virkelig god intro. Trompeterne går HÅRDT. Det her album er optur. Som koncept og sådan er det rimelig nice.

Listened Before? N An amazing album..... that's not really for me. I can appreciate it from beginning to end, and while I was surprised at the serious tone it took (was expecting more of a tongue-in-cheek story, this just seems like a tragedy), I still didn't really jive with it. Again, much appreciated, just not for me. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Pinball Wizard

Set standard for rock operas.

прекрасный альбом, музыкально дико кайфанул, лирика тоже отличная; Sally Simpson и I'm Free очень сбили вайб альбома (в один момент я будто оказался на диком западе) барабаны слева даже на мониторах в какой-то момент утомили в идеале поставил бы 4.5 чувствуется, что прожил некоторую историю

Discazo (LNM)

It's been at least 20 years since I checked this album out. It didn't leave a lasting impression on me on the past. I listen to Quadrophenia once in a while. Tommy just doesn't reach me overall. It's good, but just that. Each of the four sides have their worthy moment, and the low points aren't that low. There's a fair share of great songs, nothing spectacular. The rest is ok, nothing really bad. I guess it's just bloated. I understand that they are trying to tell a story, but balance is necessary. I could cut this down to 45 and make a really good album (except you might be totally confused about who Tommy is). That's it... it is just overstayed. Indulgence has hobbled this beauty. PS- I was surprised to learn this album was from 1969. From my experience with it, I imagined 1973 or 74. After hearing it again now, I can hear the timeframe. Liked songs: Overture, Christmas, Pinball Wizard, Go To The Mirror!, I'm Free, We're Not Gonna Take It

16th February 2023 Listened while in the office. Dinner and stayed at Karuna and Ed’s place. Would be great to see with the show and pinball wizard is a classic but not sure it stands up as an album.

The Who is cool and this is a solid example of those work. But - it’s a score/soundtrack and you know how I feel about that.

Never realized this was the first rock opera. Love the format and the album.

I feel like there could be a 4 star album hidden in here if it were edited to be 30 minutes shorter.

Couldn’t finish it

An epic album that opened up new possibilities for what a record could be. While some of the "filler" tracks do little more than propel the story forward, the "meat" of the album is powerful and soaring and includes some of the greatest rock songs ever written.

I'm a little surprised that I've never listened to this whole album in my life. I struggle to rate it because I compare it to the Wall and it doesn't even come close. So if the Wall is a 5 this is a three. But if I'm rating it in a vacuum then I suppose it's a near a 4. There are some good songs on it, no question. But in general doesn't hold up in my opinion.

Heel vet! Mooi conceptalbum, gave nummers, maar misschien toch een beetje preachy.

Self-indulgent and insufferable. I turned it off after Cousin Kevin. I don't give a shit about Tommy or anyone else in his family. It gets a second star simply because I recognize the cultural influence, but I still think it's shit.

Perhaps the greatest rock opera ever created? The Who were maybe the most complete group of talented musicians ever. Every one of the four lads shine incredibly bright on this theatrical and gripping record. Moon is an absolute beast behind the drums, and Daltrey's range of emotion is unparalleled. His naïve hope on '1921' is heartbreaking, and his desperation on the "See me, feel me" refrain first included on 'Christmas' is out of this world. The entire run from 'Go To The Mirror!' is a tour de force culminating in 'I'm Free' and 'We're Not Gonna Take It'. A dramatic end to a deeply personal and moving journey with sharp criticisms of postwar Britain. "If I told you what it takes to reach the highest high, You'd laugh and say 'nothing's that simple'. But you've been told many times before, Messiahs pointed to the door, And no one had the guts to leave the temple!"

Tommy is arguably one of the greatest rock operas to ever be recorded. And it was released only a year and a half after the ridiculous The Who Sell Out. What an evolution! The Who is easily one of the greatest individuals on each of their instruments with especially Moon shining ever so bright; there’s barely a minute where he doesn’t show off some energetic fill. The story itself can feel slightly rushed at times (“Pinball Wizard” and the sudden emergence as a cult leader), but aside from that I simply have nothing bad to say about this masterpiece.

Really didn’t take to this. It definitely has some good highlights, like Acid Queen, and Underture, but for some reason from start to finish I just wanted it to end. Musically wise it’s great at times, lyrically it annoyed me although I know it’s not a typical record in that respect. Kept going into See Me Feel Me, which is a song I love but without actually playing it fully. Not a bad album, just not for me.

Heard Tommy lauded as the first rock opera and assumed this was based on a solid album underneath. What was that? Equal parts boring and disturbing, seems like they'd decided on the mad story first and then arranged some music around it as an afterthought. Pinball Wizard is alright but I don't need to hear anything else from this again.

Very strong outing by The Who. Not sure about some of the longer songs, but the majority of it was good enough.

I enjoy a good rock opera, unfortunately this isn't one of them. Found it very difficult to get through the +1h runtime. Highlight was "Pinball Wizard".

I say this every time one comes up, but not a fan of a concept album generally..... However, this was the most interesting one I've heard. The story is quite dark in parts really, but I kinda found some of the lyrics a bit funny/daft too which made it hard to take seriously... "You won't shout when I fiddle about" and "do you know how to play hide and seek, to find me would take you a week" spring to mind. So Tommy is born blind, deaf and mute.... Gets bullied by a cousin, molested by an uncle, but is really good at pinball.... He is then miraculously cured and becomes a famous preacher who starts some sort of cult where you learn to play pinball without looking, hearing or speaking? Does that sum it up? Pinball Wizard is the best track by far...I never realised the lyrics were "that deaf, dumb and blind kid sure pays a mean pinball"! Makes sense now! Still not convinced by the concept or concept albums but it was interesting at least

Really interesting rock album by the legendary band "The Who". While I don't really like this album too much, I did enjoy how it tells the tale of Tommy and his life. 3/5. Favorite Track: Underture

Kesken jäi, ei iskenyt tämä. Liian konseptuaalista.

Excellent

Honestly, who cares.

Interesting album to listen to from beginning to end. So good that I listened to it twice (2nd time the live version)

I love The Who, but I have to say I think this album is vastly overrated. I know, I know, it's the first rock opera and they broke new ground for concept albums and it's ambitious and all, but musically it's just not that interesting. It seems like Townshend was more interested in telling the story and the music is just there to support that goal. Some of it sounds more like a broadway musical than a rock n' roll album. 3 stars.

So, OK, there's the grand pretensions of Pete Townshend writing a rock opera, that sprawling tracklisting, and the fact that the obviously surreal narrative drive of said opera is so heavy that it can distract you from time to time... But the thing is, the music on this album is *so* good, whether it is the one of the timeless songs this amazing record harbours ("Pinball Wizard", "We're Not gonna Take It/Se Me, Feel Me" ,"The Acid Queen", "I Feel Free"), or the one of the less famous cuts ("Cousin Kevin", or that long incredible instrumental that "Underture" is), that it's bound to be included in such a list. Ironically, I find this record more easily *digestible* than *Who's Next*, even if it has all the characteristics of a concept album. Evidence for me that it's an all-time great, in spite of its all-too-grand and frankly delirious ambitions on paper... Number of albums left to review or just listen to: less than 700, I've temporarily lost count here Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: approximately a half so far (including this one) Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: a quarter Albums from the list I will certainly *not* include in mine (many others are more important): the last quarter

Listens: 2 Enjoyed: yeah This would be around a 4.5. probably my first rock opera and I fel it works pretty solid as both an album and it holds some legendary singular tracks. My only issues were some of the song transitions were a bit rough/ blunt. And the final quarter of the track dived a little

It was ok, not my favorite album but I didn’t dislike it

Nice and effortless sounding album overall. Thoroughly enjoyed it.

A solid take on a rock opera, wins big nostalgia points for 'Pinball Wizard' alone which I listened to a good deal when I was younger. Do wish the band had been a bit more experimental and out-there with the instrumentation on this one, but without the context of the full show I'm missing a huge deal of dialogue/staging that would make more sense alongside the somewhat passive arrangements here.

Didn’t love it! Not my jam, at least not today. Will probably revisit one day as I know it’s an important record (all of these are), but the mix was too jarringly bad to me.

I know this quite well. Like it. Don’t love it.

Rock opera, very musical-influenced. Interesting listen. Need to be heard as a whole, but had some catchy tunes in there.

Собственно несколько вещей, которые нужно знать об этом альбоме: 1) ровесник моей мамы 2) в рок-альбоме есть ВАЛТОРНА 3) 75, мать его, минут, я надеюсь гуру, в честь которого альбом написан, хотя бы разок его послушал... 4) Грэмми за лучшую упаковку (что блин, за это дают Грэмми?...) Стоит послушать: Christmas (текст выше всяких похвал) , The acid queen, Cousin Kevin, Underture, Smash the mirror.

Полный The Who, очень люблю слушать полноценные альбомы с плавными переходами. Из-за этого не могу потом выделить конкретные композиции т.к. альбом кажется монолитным произведением, однако ничего поделать не могу и просто получаю удовольствие. Под Томми читал статьи о влиянии античной философии на учение Отцов Церкви, полностью удовлетворен результатом, настоятельно советую.

Enjoyed listening, nice album

Довольно жизнерадостное начало и даже воодушевляющее. Как будто тебя готовят к большому путешествию, но потом начинается облом по тексту и повергают в пучины экзестенциальности человека и как на него влияет общество. Главный вопрос, который я хочу задать альбому и людям, добавившим его в список 1001 альбома: как вообще думаете, альбом стал великим из-за посыла или из-за музыки? Лично я склоняюсь к первому, так как история сильная и важная, безусловно, но музыкально он не настолько крут, как те же Пинк Флойд того времени

очень спокойный, но не цепляющий. под настроение не подошел :(

Увертюра прикольно, этот ход мне особо нравится в пластинках, когда есть что-то "для настройки" и задания вайба. К тому же, это рок-опера вроде как, судя по описанию. Даже с сюжетом типа...) Забавно в общем, на Sparks я понял, что получаю примерно те же самые эмоции, что и от Pet Sounds за авторством The Beach Boys: я хочу погрузиться в сюжет, но вот музыка не везде мне кажется гипер-интересной и разнообразной. Плюс в описании так пафосно сказано, что это "рок-опера", мне как-то пока разнообразия не хватает, прежде всего в инструментальном плане: отличия между звучанием песен есть, но они минимальны. Underture: вот это конечно дикая вещь. Натурально симфония, с несколькими действиями, тональностями. Абсолютно без текста, что позволяет сфокусироваться на музыке, всех-всех деталях и интструментах. Мне в какой-то момент чем-то напомнило "Время вперёд" Свиридова. Возможно, из-за темпа произведения. Но мне прям нравится, тяжело такую музыку конечно слушать на постоянной основе, но раз в месяц кайфануть — ха-ра-шо. Pinball Wizard: да, я потом прогуглил, что это было коммерчески успешный сингл, но подумал об этом ровно во время прослушивания. Хороший поп-хит, для ознакомления с творчеством The Who вполне сойдёт. Sally Simpson: тут я услышал кантри, возможно, я не один такой. Но прикольно, пожалуй себе добавлю. Клавишные очень хороши. Tommy's Holiday Camp: ахахах, чёрт, какой шикарный орган-синт, ну или что это вообще. Похоже на хоккейный орган чем-то. В общем звук прикольный, ещё и стерео наложилось хорошо. We're not gonna take it: снова как будто симфония, ну и такой светлый финальный трек. Завершающий, финальный, итоговый. Как гимн всего хорошего (в музкальном плане) в этом альбоме. В целом, надо переслушивать ещё раз и внимательно читать текст. В нём наверняка скрываются объяснения тех или иных ходов в аранжировках песен. И судя по синопсису, история глубокая и неоднозначная. По музыке — однообразно, но качественно. Чувствуется, что запись была сделана давно: местами присутствуют довольно всратые стереоэффекты, которые в блюпуп (уж простите) наушниках звучат непривычно странно. И баса что-то маловато. Кстати, до этого, я кажется не слушал The Who, пару песен добавил себе и может быть даже послушаю ещё какой-то альбом. Мне звходит их темп что ли... как будто боевик какой-то немного, всё время погоня за чем-то. Но нужен ремастер. 4 звезды за плотность звука, но однообразность и недостаточную вариативность аранжировок. Сюжет — ну такое, на грани реальности и фантастики, с мешаниной всего (это я перечитал краткое содержание и чёт обалдел слегка от количества мыслей, которые до нас хотят донести). P.s. first review done, получается. Посмотрим, как надо будет оценки ставить...

Музыка: 4/5, кайф, но надоедает Текст/концептуальность/что-либо ещё: 5/5, чистый кайф Удержание: 3/5, слишком много ненужных выебонов Неочев факт: левое ухо прям болит

Ballsy and brilliant.

Like #13 Pinball Wizard, #21 I'm Free.

Hmm, I can see why this album is on this list and by all accounts should be the one I like. But I just couldn’t get into it. Sorry, Tommy

I just don't find The Who very interesting outside of the big hits.

What could serve as a better harbinger of the coming of the 1970s than an overwrought concept album? Like nearly all double albums that I've encountered on this list, I think this would be better as a single album. However, I do have to admit that this does seem to be a genuine attempt at a rock opera, with overtures in the beginning that presage what will come later in the album. Overall the album is pretty good, though I found the first half of it a bit of a slog. Also the story for this concept album is pretty dumb. But hey, it's not the worst Who album that I've reviewed here (not the best either, though) 3/5

Love this story!

This seems too focused as a one man obsession and while the band motifs can be heard it just doesn't come across as coherent. There are interesting ideas but the very good bits are well scattered.

classic!

Never really liked this album.

Are you kidding me?!?

Pete Townshend's habit of playing lead as if it were an overamplified rhythm guitar irritates me no end. Then the prospect of three and half hours of this, between studio, demo and live versions was more than a little offputting. So I limited myself to listening to the studio versions. It started off OK, with keyboards, but quickly evolved into overentusiastic rhythm guitar as expected. Musically it didn't improve from there. As a narrative exercise in musical form, Tommy is reasonably impressive, but as music it is not. It is also quite evident from the streaming numbers on Spotify that many people have started listening to this but have given up after four or five tracks. The first five tracks all have 2 million plus streams but after that only Pinball Wizard, I'm Free and Christmas of the remaining 19 tracks mange to pass 2 million. I guess that there is only so much of The Who (and Townshend) that people can take in one go.

Just so not my style, I’m sorry

The Good - Ambitious approach to album making for it's time. A thoroughly thought out plot that is worthwhile and original. Some very catchy and musically interesting moments. Clearly influential. The Bad - Overly long, struggled to pay attention, especially during the instrumental passages. The lack of musical interest made the plot difficult to follow. Not a fan of the singer's falsetto. The Ugly - Controversial opinion time. I HATED the drumming on here. Understand that Keith Moon is regarded as a legendary drummer and whatnot, and maybe on another album he sounds better, but here the drums just sounded flat yet excessive and at times disruptive to the work as a whole. Summary - Respectable and important work, that alas is not for me, and I have no interest in revisiting. 2 pinball machines out of 5. 🕹️🕹️

I've always wanted to like this more, but could stand for more rock and less opera.

This album was much stranger than I remember. I think if it were released today, many would consider it 'experimental'. I did enjoy it. But some of the songs were a little disjointed from the general vibe of the album.

Did not resonate with me at all. Rhythm is pretty boring.

не успела ничего понять (ну и оперу не каждую с десятого раза понимаю)

I really liked the beginning to Tommy, maybe first 3 or 4 songs, plus Pinball Wizard is great. However it definitely fell off for me.

Did not hit in the slightest

It wasn’t the first concept album, but Tommy is arguably the one that made it a viable art form-and changed the Who forever. Towering, anthemic, and surprisingly vulnerable at times, nearly every song is a gem.

Too long, not very interesting

it's good. story is whatever, but I like when songs have a very apparent meaning, so at least it helps with that. Christmas, The Acid Queen, Pinball Wizard, We're Not Gonna Take It, and particularly Go to the Mirror (it took me way too long to recognize how good this song was, ngl) are highlights. I like the vocal harmonies and the use of drums to emphasize certain sections.

it's funny how this is like a groundbreaking work in terms of being conceptual and more orchestrated than a typical rock album and very pretentious and then the premise is a blind kid who is good at pinball, just the stupidest shit anyone has ever thought of the instrumentation on the opener is good "it's a boy" is irritatingly precious even if it's short 1921 also irritates me, it feels a bit like trying to cram a narrative into a musical framework rather than just writing a good song really that's the whole thing, the who could write a good wrong song occasionally but too often they got lost up their own ass being silly and/or pretentious the whole sound of this album is a little too cutesy for me it's not the worst thing I ever heard but I don't really enjoy it. I write this as I am only on track 4 of 24. keith moon's drumming is still excellent when they really let him go off. but i am already incredibly sick of daltrey's falsetto. sparks is another kind of neat instrumental but it feels more like an intro to a song than a proper song eyesight to the blind is fine but basically forgettable and the intro to 'christmas' with the 'ah ah ah ah ah ah ah ah' background vocals is teeth gratingly bad again just WRITE A REGULAR SONG OH MY GOD the "see me touch me feel me refrain is meant to be like, Conceptual or Something as a motif they use several times but it and the TOMMYCANYOUHEARME just get under my skin a ton honestly i was going to say this album has at least some decent bits but so much of it is so incredibly long and so much of it is so bad, i just cannot stand it as a whole do you think it's alright/fiddle about is just atrocious. godawful. who the fuck thought it was necessary to have 2 minutes on the album dedicated to songs about child molestation. i doubt i will hear a worse 2 minutes of music anywhere pinball wizard is okay i guess. i almost certainly prefer it as a single outside the album though. the back half of the album is sort of blandly unmemorable. still kind of irritatingly precocious but doesn't grind my gears as much. "we're not gonna take it" starts off not great but honestly i like the back half. still not an album i would be compelled to revisit much at all.

ok so my issue here is that the story is too like, hamfisted. it's over an hour of just like mostly exposition. the parts that are supposed to be emotional feel fake. i would not want to read a novel written by this dude, he's never heard of "show don't tell" and honestly the fact that the story is about like a character disassociating due to trauma and finding ways to cope with it makes it a little offensive imo that it's treated in such a clumsy way. its giving the same vibes as like when white people write a story about racism the music is fine. there were parts i liked and parts that were kinda boring. pinball wizard was fun. a bit too long

the who more like who cares about rock operas am i right? this was like the most Fine album i’ve ever heard i really just can’t care though

The "Who" in "The Who" is finally explained with the release of "Tommy". Tommy is a person in this album that does things. Idk this album was ok. I think I'm just not a fan of The Who. Don't tell Peta, but i lied about listening to Quadrophenia so i could pretend I'm a music listener person. I only listened to about half way through before I got bored and switched to another album. A lot of this just felt.. idk... not my thing. I liked Underture.

i was not going to listen to all of this but i will say. this was written under the influence of many MANY drugs.

I love concept albums. This one in particular sounds like it could be a play or even a musical. However, I feel like I didn't enjoy it as much as I thought I would. I do like that the songs blend in together, though. Also, I don't know why but this album gave me Wizard of Oz vibes, no particular reason. No track really stood out. Fave track(s): Go To the Mirror!

Everything here is pretty great, which is why it's insane that the whole thing ends on a fucking FADE OUT????

Bro think he Genesis

Ok album not their best but yielded some good singles.

It was alright. Favorite song: “1921”.

Was going to mark it down as it's better with the film, but listening to this by itself tells such a clear story as well as being such great music.

If this was Queen everyone would be pissing themselves, but it's The Who.

I listened to this album start to finish while driving. I had higher expectations than I should have due to knowing some songs by The Who previously. I will say that the album flow was well arranged and the songs often seamlessly transitioned from song. I always like that. The lyrics were all straightforward to my ears and seemed as though they just looked around the room for objects of inspiration. The standout song on this album is Pinball Wizard.

I liked it after I figured out the real meaning of the lyrics. Interesting concept for the time

what's happening in his head? ohh i wish i knew i wish i knew

A landmark of musical history. This is a great example of where the music and lyrics are so well done but unless you are aware of the story it probably seems very disjointed and meaningless. Maybe just downright creepy. I do love the music and some of the tracks absolutely stand up today but it’s not something I want to listen to on its own. I’d rather watch the film, so it’s all in context.

I want to live The Who but I just can’t get into it

This is epic and so broad in musical scope…I think I prefer the soundtrack version more, but certainly admire this undertaking!

genial, baita sons e história muito interessante

No me dejo ratear el anterior todo mal :(

No lo terminé esta largo, después lo voy a terminar, por ahora esa nota creería que va a ser

All in all it's pretty ridiculous, but the original ambition and really solidly launching the idea of a Rock Opera had so much impact on rock music. I love when bands take big swings like this, and overall it really works.

Rock operas and other mega-ambitious pop music projects often fail for reasons having to do with basic incoherence but Townsend knew what he was doing and built this to work narratively and musically. The silliness and creativity of The Who Sell Out is put to better and more focused effect. It's sort of mid-tempo throughout (as if to keep things under control) and some songs are too quickly done, but generally everything works on its own terms, which aren't necessarily transcendent, though there are moments – "Christmas" is the highlight, but "Overture" and "It's a Boy" and "Acid Queen" and "Tommy Can You Hear Me?" are all strong and almost moving. One admires the concept and, for the most part, the execution. It is quite strong which is impressive enough, considering just how much worse it could’ve – and probably should’ve – been.

There are some really good songs on this album. I've seen it performed, too, as the rock opera for which it was written. Kind of works in a weird way, but the songs are engaging and entertaining. Pete Townsend is musically very interesting and an incredible guitarist and vocalist.

J'ai passé un moment sympathique avec ces Who malgré un genre musical attitré totalement fantaisiste (hard rock) sans aucun lien avec le genre réel de l'album. Cette écoute a toutefois failli être gâchée par ma N+1. Je vous joins l'échange confidentiel en question que nous avons eu sur Teams : « - Robprocédurière ? - Quoi ? - Pourquoi ce processus est en cours de traitement depuis deux jours ? - Parce que c'est mon premier processus du genre alors j'y vais lentement, je prends le time... - Tu veux qu'on le fasse ensemble ? - Ouais carrément. - 12h15 ? - Non 12h22 parce qu'il restera Tommy's Holiday Camp et We're Not Gonna Take It à 12h15. - Pardon ? - J'y peux rien si la trackliste est longue comme le cul. » Je leur accorde donc un trois sur cinq.

C'était absolument ignoble comme tout bon album des Who qui se respecte.

This is the soundtrack to the Who's less good film. There's good songs to be found in here though. They are a rare band where the drummer's songs are the best and most disturbing! Fiddle about, eww. There's still some excess fat on here - two ten minute overtures and a closing track which runs a long time on very little. But by and large it's good.

Too folky for my current mood

I love this album for various reasons and find it musically interesting but it's not my favorite combination of rock and "opera". Theoretically meets the criteria for a good show but overall feels flat to me. I love "Pinball Wizard" and "Go To The Mirror" as stand alone rock tunes. This is a great album but can't rank it above a 3 since I wouldn't typically listen to it front to back... and I not sure I'd want to see it performed live.

I am OK with the deaf dumb and blind kid playing pinball, but I am not OK with all of the familial abuse suffered by poor Tommy. I’d like to go back to before I listened to this. I will stick with the radio edits that came from this album and attempt to forget the rest. I guess because it was the first rock opera it should be on this list of albums to listen to before I die but I really wish it wasn’t. I hope Jesus Christ Superstar is also on this list.

Having listened to a couple of early albums by The Who, the significance of "Tommy" really comes through. The scope of the album, the vision of Pete Townshend, and the ambitions of the band are big and eccentric and you can understand why this is a landmark album for the band and for rock and roll music. When the band is brilliant on this, they shine. The interplay of the vocals is masterful, the harmonies on songs like "Tommy Can You Hear Me?" are fantastic, and Keith Moon proves he's got chops for days. Not to mention, what an out there premise this entire album rests on. 10 stars for creativity and commitment to an artistic ideal. But there's a lot of dead weight, and for all his stellar abilities and singular voice on his instrument, I was so tired of Moon's drumming by the 3/4 mark that it detracted from the album. It encapsulates my admiration/repulsion to this band. There's no question that there's genius at work in so many elements of this band, but somehow, some of that genius is what undermines my enjoyment. I know this is better than a 3-star album, but I can't imagine a time when I'll be looking for something to listen to and decide to listen to this from start to finish. That's why it's a 3-star in my book. A brilliant 3.

The Who were so busy racing to develop rock opera technology, they never stopped to consider if they should. The story has always seemed kinda silly to me, so it's hard to take most of the songs with any degree of seriousness, even though many of them are enjoyable enough. Quadrophenia is a million times better.

A high school favorite album here. I appreciate the effort of this rock opera more than the actualization. Always though Quadrophenia was a better album and story. But when those trumpets hit on the first song and lead into It’s a boy, I’m reminded how important this album was to me and how much I still love this album , story, and these songs

This is a tough one. As a little girl I was taught this album is the best. It is, at the least, a cultural touchstone. Listening through it now I am finding I still love it, possibly somewhat nostalgically. There is no getting past my programming. That said, I can still confidently assert Pinball Wizard is an objectively great song.

Generally hate The Who, so approached with extreme prejudice. As expected, Tommy is over-blown, over-long and not particularly interesting. Hopefully this is the last Who album on this list.

A classic album but one that probably has not lasted the test of time and does sound a bit dated now. Not quiet a masterpiece but worth a listen none the less.

A timeless album and I have enjoyed it to the max.

Not my favorite thing, but I appreciate the ambition.

"So it's like an opera, but it rocks!" Ugh. I like the Who, and they undeniably have some classic bangers under their belts. This album has some classics: Pinball Wizard, Go to the Mirror!, I'm Free but it's also saddled with some tracks that might be better if they weren't shoehorned into a narrative. Smash the Mirror has good riffs, but could it have been better if didn't have to be about a deaf, dumb, and blind kid's therapy session? I get why this was mind-blowing in 1969, but let's be honest: the story the album is built around is kind of dumb. I think Townshend's operatic narrative tendencies are better served with longer individual songs broken into different parts - think A Quick One While He's Away or Rael from The Who Sell Out. There's no idea being beaten to death over 90 minutes, you can tell a more detailed story with only three singers (which is harder with something like this where rivals Tommy and the Pinball Wizard are both sung by the same guy), and you aren't forcing ideas to fit into a framework they might not be best served by. A bad album? Not by any stretch. An overrated album? Probably more accurate.

It's funny how many reviews are either 4-5 stars calling it a masterpiece or 1-2 stars saying it's garbage. Usually this tells me this is mostly due to differences in genre preference, but with Tommy I think it's mostly due to how one perceives the execution of the concept. I seem to be the rare reviewer who falls somewhere in between. I see Tommy as both a work of creative genius and a confusing mess. The Good: Well, it's completely unique being the first true rock opera and essentially creating a new genre of music. There are songs that work as standalone tracks independent of the story (i.e. the singles, most notably "Pinball Wizard" which is undoubtedly the best song on the album). And then there are songs that you wouldn't necessarily put on just for fun (or catch on the radio) that are beautifully composed and interesting. The bad: Despite the aforementioned comment about the good, some of the songs just aren't good (e.g. "Holiday Camp"). Others come across as mere filler. Now, I remember seeing my local high school perform this decades ago and I really enjoyed it. Middle school me liked it so much I watched the VHS of the official concert for it (Phil Collins was in this, right?) many, many times. But, something about the album by itself just doesn't connect, and it's easy to get bored. The ugly: the story itself doesn't make any sense. I read the synopsis before listening so I get what is SUPPOSED to be happening (not that it seems like it's a great story by itself anyway) but at very few points during the album is the plot actually comprehensible. Overall, I agree this is a must listen album, but perhaps we would be better served watching the concert for it and seeing some of the action take place on stage so it makes more sense and not just hoping it ends soon.