Rust Never Sleeps

Once again, I do not get the Young craze. Crazy Horse adds a certain sauce here, but Neil always finds a way to ruin it with his sad, sad, sad fucking voice. Little to say. Two stars, and at least one of them is because Kurt Cobain really likes that lyric. Fave tracks: - My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - Sail Away - Powderfinger

Not much to say; I like how thr first/last tracks mirror each other. I don't hate but I don't love love his voice. Probably not his best album but not bad either. 2 to 3 stars

A mostly live album with overdubs, you've gorra laff. I couldn't get into this at all, a solid reminder that I don't like Neil Young.

Well at least with each Neil Young album on the list I get one closer to not having to listen to Neil Young anymore. Similar to the Dire Straits album this is very technically proficient its just also... rather boring to me. I liked Thrasher, mostly because I pretty quickly identified it as a callout song against Crosby, Stills and Nash. Its unquestionably all very poetic, and the writing is strong here, I think I just find this era of Folk very sleepy. I guess I was also pleasantly suprised that a song called "Pocahontas" was politically a lot better then I expected It would be. File this in the "not for me" portion.

Neil Young being Neil Young… I sigh whenever I read Neil Young's name on one of the albums on this list, because I think he is severely overrated. The problem is always the same. The song might start out well enough, but as soon as I hear Neil Young's whining singing voice, I just can't stand to listen any further. 2⭐️

no me gusta

Fine.

Another Neil Young album; didn’t connect with me this time. (Continue to wonder about the random generator, why it seems to repeat artists?)

More Neil Young. What is the deal with giving him so much spotlight on this list. More of the same as the other albums that we've been subjected to. Nothing special.

Hey, it's more Neil Young! This means more wavery-voiced delivery of cryptic, half-rhymed lyrics that are inexplicable ("Ride My Llama") where they're not offensive ("Pocahontas"). The music is universally slow and simple, and the songs are frankly hard to tell apart from one another, though there are a few nice guitar parts and some good vocal harmonies. If you haven't guessed, I'm not particularly a fan of Neil Young, and this album does nothing to change that.

Hard to imagine an album featuring such nuggets of wisdom as welfare women make better lovers isn't at least 4 stars but if not for Hey Hey My My this would have been a 1 star album for me.

an album for young country boys who also like to rock. favourite song was sail away.

Officially adding Neil Young to - artists whose song I sometimes like better sung as a cover.

omg dawg not again

Efter att ha läst Youngs självbiografi från 2012 står det klart att Young saknar självdistans och humor. Finns därför inga förmildrande omständigheter för hans floskeltexter och rätt mediokra gitarrock. Svag tvåa.

Sinceramente no es mi estilo, no lo pude terminar de escuchar.

I was not in the mood for this. Bit boring.

Yeah, Neil Young. Have to see how I feel today… I feel like my mom used Bob Dylan and Neil Young to torture me as a teenager. I mean I don’t feel that way, she DID use them to torture me. Now the thing is, I deserved to be tortured. I was a very angry punk rock teen. But the experience lingers. I have since forced myself, through sheer will, to appreciate the artistry of said artists. But the feeling still lingers. The feeling of wanting to crush Neil Young like a squirming bug beneath my shoe. It’s not just his voice. Or the style. I’m a HUGE fan of Jason Molina. But… f* you Neil. Really. 2 stars cause you undeniably are an artist. 2 stars cause you torture me still. Boolean rating: honesty? No. I could die without hearing Neil Young. I’d just lack that well roundnesses, but I would be happier for it! After all, it’s better to burn out than to fade away. Sorry, I wrote this before I remembered it had been in Kurt Cobain’s suicide note. But then I thought, no, I would leave it. It’s all part of the conversation. That’s part of what I’m here for.

i suppose i can appreciate some of this from a lyrical standpoint, but not my speed

Not for me

Oooh aaah, I see there's a distict lack of percussion on half the album. That will unfortunately be 1 point taken off of the final score. Better luck next time, Mister Young and Misters Horse.

Me pasó parecido a lo que me pasó con el de ayer de Nanci Griffith, pero me gustó un poquito más. Le daría a este 2 y media si se pudiera.

There's not much to say about this album. I found it quite boring to listen to. I don't think this kind of music is for me.

Tranquilo

it’s fine, it didn’t do much for me and idk why. it was nice in the background! prob 2.5

I wasn't hallucinating that they were singing about welfare mothers.

Boring apart from the occasional slightly interesting part

no thanks- 3.5/10

tiene varias country

Taitava bändi ja taitavaa soittoa, muodollisesti pätevää musaa mutta tylsää, puuduttavaa. Neil Youngin ääni ei oikein iske vaan nimenomaan puuduttaa. Kuitenkin, taitavaa, oikeaa musaa. 2/5

Nice and pleasant, but not for me sadly. Surprised to read about this being the proto for grunge! It's so interesting how connections are everywhere.

yet another live album bro. i also can't stand country. the rock portion was better but that harmonica was ear piercing Would I listen again: no Deserves to be on this list: no 2.3

The shrill beast rears its ugly head again. A good ballad or two to start the record gives way to the inevitability that Neil Young’s voice can’t be endured for a full album. 2/5 “Welfare Mothers” was a new low

Buena voz, album corto. Rock chill

Not as bad as Tonight's The Night, but not good either. Neil Young doesn't have a good voice. He sounds annoying and thinks his vocal range goes higher than it does. There aren't even interesting instrumentals to back him up. Not as bad as some other music on the list, but this is bad.

Not bad, but not really my thing. A bit distracting

Didn't like Neil's half, did like Crazy Horse.

Me gusto mucho el album, no es tanto mi onda. la primera canción la rompe ( My My, Hey Hey ) potente forma de iniciar un álbum Es mejor consumirse rápidamente que desvanecerse lentamente. No se porque parece que esta sufriendo mientras, como si estuviera apunto de largarse a llorar. 2.5 estrellas.

Meh

Meh

I like Neil Young, but didn't like this album so much

Nice

Nothing too Crazy

If you like Neil Young then this hits all the right buttons.

this made me feel like i was there when he was chain smoking the joints that inspired these songs and probably also smoked them with him because it felt like a trip. the hey hey my my hey hey gimmick is the best part of this for me. without those songs bookending the record i would kinda hate this?

Listening session: march 26th, while commuting to internship Listened to before: no Thoughts: a bit too boring and American for me Favourite tracks: Thrasher & Sail Away

la primer parte un embole, a partir del 7mo tema se pone bueno

I love some NY songs. Did not love this album.

I see the appeal of Neil Young, but it's just not my jam

Well good to know that I am not a Neil Young fan. The first half was unbearable, I hate slow acoustic songs especially with Neil's voice that I do not like. The second half was better, but not enough to save it. Won't be listening again. Favorite Track- Sedan Delivery Least Favorite Track - Thrashers ⭐️⭐️

Oh Neil, you're writing is great but that is completely offset by your voice... Sorry, not sorry...

Tedious Americana

Boring instrumentals, boring lyrics.

Pretty boring overall. Everything sounded the same. Album was quick to get through and I didn’t find any of the songs reigned above the others.

Neil Young's music sounds so similar, and this one is exactly what you would expect. Mediocre and forgettable outside of the first song, I have no love for this one. Really not for me

Just okay, if not entirely forgettable, instrumental music made completely insufferable by audio throughout of a large rat biting the testicles of a donkey. Implying that the sometimes grungy guitar sounds of this album influenced later grunge music gives the donkey credit that he never deserved.

Garchita, pero garchita en serio. Ni una canción buena.

1/3. Boring live album, slipped right by me. I like Neil’s voice for about 5 minutes and then I get tired of it. Not sure if I’m missing something visual here, but I’m not sure how this pushed any boundaries for live albums.

Not a fan of Neil Young

4,8/10 Sympa

Great opener. Then boring folk before mediocre rock ends the album. Too much Young in the 1001.

not as good as harvest. native vibes were cool

"Hey Hey, My My" would sounds amazing with a more rocking singer. Neil Young's singing is the worst thing about Neil Young songs. The music is good, the band is solid, the songwriting is decent, but the vocals just don't fit. I'm also annoyed that he slags off the other members of CSNY, calling them dead weight. Fuck you, man! You might have been the most popular member of the band (for reasons that will always evade me), but you were not the best member (and easily the worst singer). I was between a 2 and 3 for this album, but denigrating his former band members, who I will always prefer, knocks him down a peg. It also balances the time I rounded "Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere" up to a 3.

first half is very boring, it gets better in the second half but not enough to save this for me fav song: Welfare Mothers

He's a legend but this album didn't quite hit for me. Some good tunes but not a cohesive collection. Some great guitar work and Hey Hey My My is a banger.

Neil young sounds old and crazy horse isn’t that crazy. His voice gets on my nerves. He sings like the old guy from ready player one which also annoyed me. Other than that it’s kind of just a dude with a guitar album. 4/10

Falls somewhere between reflective & depressing. Perhaps "stage not studio" isnt the environment for Neil's voice to shine brightest. I also largely find it hard to resonate with the harmonica. Example = refer to 34 on my list where I was genuinely surprised by a studio album of Mr Youngs The last track on the album - a heavier version of Hey Hey rocked unexpectly hard. To be honest, both versions of "Hey Hey" would be the only things I really remember though. 2.5 stars

Kinda below sub par. Have no true opinion any of these songs. Rust may never sleep, but it sure put my mind to sleep.

2/5. Wasn't particularly blown away by this album, but also wasn't entirely offensive. Not really much to say, just fine. Favourite Track - Powderfinger

Sleepy time music

Still in the process of evaluating why I didn’t like this as much as Neil Young’s so stuff. It didn’t have the same charm.

ik hou niet van mondharmonica.

mid

I need Neil Young in smaller doses

Album #797 for me and i hope to god ive reached the end of Neil on this list. Musically good but his whiny ass voice is insufferable

Not much to say. The first half of the album is acoustic, the second half is electric, but it's all boring, mid-tempo rock with nary a moment of excitement.

it's fine but im not a fan of folk or his voice

Ne so gar nich

7 Neil Young albums! 7! The first song is fine, but then, as soon as the second song starts, you are reminded that everything this man produces is exactly the same. After that it gets tedious.

Pretty rubbish to be honest. Didn't see the appeal of any of these songs but there was some nice guitars. Could possibly improve with a second listen but that won't happen any time soon.

Not my favorite album tbh. I see the vision but my eyes simply are not built for it.

Boring

Did not give my full attention, but zoned in and out of washed-up rock. Sounded quite slurry man in a pub trying to convince himself and others to 'rock on'. A damning review I know but only because I've heard is other (much greater) stuff.

I can handle Neil Young for a couple songs, but after a while it gets old. This album is not too bad.

This one wasn’t for me again

Neil Young’s voice sounds like how a harmonica would talk if it could

beautiful, but boring as fuck.

Nicht so besonders

It was fine, never really vibed with Neil Young

Fine, didn't really connect. I plan to do a Neil Young deep dive one day and maybe this will stick

It could be a 3 ig

This guy really does seem like a whiny little douche

This was very dull. My second Neil Young album on this list and both have been poor. Musically it’s absolutely fine, just not captivating in the slightest.

It was okay. Not really my cup of tea.

Just synchronized noise, would expect to hear this is a 60 yr old history teacher's office

Not a fan of the lyrics or vocals. The instrumental was NICE though

Quite a nice listen actually. This gives me nostalgia about family gatherings and a lovely man I briefly dated, probably wont rush back to listen though.

Not my cup of tea again. Too country

If your in a good mood, and you just need to get depressed, never fear, Neil Young is here. Melancholy drivel. Cheer up dude, you get to make music for living. 2.0

I really liked thrasher, but the rest were not really my style

It gives of country vibe with a bit of rock. I like the instruments but not the lyrics as much.

This album sent me into a 2am rant after hearing the first 5 songs and declaring that it is completely unimpressive and certainly not unique, boring bullshit that should not be a must listen. I had flashbacks of Nebraska with Bruce Springsteen essentially sitting around a fire with an acoustic guitar telling stories in a singing voice I am not fond of. Thankfully things picked up after the first five songs and everything starting with Powderfinger was actually pretty decent with some pretty good guitar. I don’t take back what I said about the first five songs though. At least he sings better than Springsteen.

Eh. There are so many incredible live Neil sets out there these days I don’t see needing to revisit this. Kind of meanders professionally until sedan delivery which is strange and fun and rips pretty hard before concluding with a crunchy, unenjoyable rendition of my my hey hey. 2.5*

Fine, but not really to my taste.

This album was an unexpected fusion of rock and country, not sure how I feel about it still. Favourite track: My My, Hey Hey (out of the blue)

I once again do not necessarily understand the Neil Young experience. I like Crosby, Stills and Nash more

I tried to research and figure out what I'm missing, but I just don't find much appealing about Neil Young and his whiney ass folk music.

Very clean production for a live album but thats about the limit of the praise for this. The songs are overlong the singing is a hard listen. All in all an album that belongs in the archive

Another one? 🥱 voice still whiny

Feels like a time capsule of the political climate of the 1970s in America. Came out in 1979, four years after the end of the Vietnam War. Neil Young was about 34 years old, and the war had spanned most of his formative years. The goal is to send a message. Favorite Moments: Guitar solo in Powderfinger, Hey Hey, My My (into the black) Not my favorite From the internet: "Rust Never Sleeps" reflects Young's determination to avoid creative stagnation and adapt, as immortalized in the lyric "It's better to burn out than fade away".

it's just OK. 12/28/2025

Not for me. I liked Powderfinger and Thrasher, but other than that the songs mostly droned on and I'm just not a fan of Neil Young's voice

Not for me.

2/5

I was bored by this. And maybe rock and roll should never die, but I felt a little dead inside listening to this. Sorry not sorry.

Good album but not my vibe.

eh didnt finish it

There are better Neil Young albums in the world, and you shouldn’t be required to listen to this one. It’s a split live/studio album but a bunch of the live stuff was overdubbed in the studio so, who really knows what’s what anymore. To add an extra gimmick, side one is acoustic and side two is electric (yes, like Dylan did in 1966). Neil Young can’t really sing on either side, but that's never stopped him before. The only real standouts for me are “My, My, Hey, Hey (Out Of The Blue)” and “Welfare Mothers”.

one song gave me vibes that it should be the backing song for a camcorder video of sweet moments but i just dont think it's an album for me

why is he out of tune all the time…

Ugh

I hate to be a dick... but its just so God Damned boring Best Song: Ride My Llama Rating: 4.0/10 Stars: 2

Mother always said if you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say anything and I don’t have anything to say. That’s not true. I have a bunch of nice things to say. Starting the set with an acoustic version of My My Hey Hey and then ending it with a super heavy grungy version and calling it Hey Hey My My is top shelf chefs kiss tasty. That version of hey hey my my is where the roots of grunge music can be traced all the way back to and then ironically strung all the way forward with the lyric “It’s better to burn out and fade away”, included in the suicide note of the man responsible for the grungw explosion in the early 1990s, Kurt Cobain. Another nice thing I have to say is that the melody and timbre of Neil Young‘s voice in Pocahontas is in its own echelon of sweetness, and if bee’s ever had to collect songs to feed and nourish their queen instead of pollen Pocahontas would her sonic main course. Ok three. Thrasher is better thsn I realized on second listen. Fuck, so is Sail Away, now the mother always said addage I started with doesn’t match the thing. Well that’s unfortunate. Don’t listen to me. Listen to Neil Young. Stand Out- A tie between the closing track Hey Hey My My, particularly the dirty, grungy tone, of the electric guitar and thrashing guitar solo that are pretty much the ground zero of what what eventually become mainstream 90s grunge rock and Pocahontas and it’s royal aviary delectibility.

not my vibe

I just found it boring. A shame.

Just okay, if not entirely forgettable, instrumental music made completely insufferable by audio throughout of a large rat biting the testicles of a donkey. Implying that the sometimes grungy guitar sounds of this album influenced later grunge music gives the donkey credit that he never deserved.

Okay album. This was my least favorite NY & CH album on the list

Neil Young is great and all, but I don't really get it.

Honestly, the musicality is nice, the vocals are honest and emotional, but the energy is just a drag for me. Listened to it in pieces and could not have told you when it started to repeat. Really have a hard time telling you one song on this album.

Cowgirl in the Sand

Done. Not my cup of tea tea.

WHO GAVE THIS MAN A HARMONICA

Moja opinia o Neilu Youngu nigdy nie podniesie się z tych pierwszych absolutnie okropnych doświadczeń z jego muzyką. Liczba jego albumów obecnych na tej liście (9) to jest dla mnie coś kompletnie niezrozumiałego. Jeśli w przypadku Davida Bowiego ubolewam nad tym, że to ja nie rozumiem jego fenomenu, tak tutaj ubolewam nad tym, że najwidoczniej to Young jest fenomenem, bo jego śpiew to dla mnie nieporozumienie. Czasami miewa ciekawe aranżacje, a potem otwiera gębę i czar pryska. Nie łapię tego, ani trochę. Zresztą nie znam nikogo, kto by kiedykolwiek powiedział "Jestem fanem Neila Younga" albo kto by go puścił przy ludziach. Nie wiem, może to tylko jakiś dziwny amerykański wymysł, który z jakiegoś powodu zrobił karierę w tamtych rejonach. Jedyne, z czego mogę się cieszyć to, że już 6 z tych albumów mam za sobą.

One really great song. Not overly Neil Young singing like a muppet. Decent.

inget gott tecken när man är trött på ett album halvvägs igenom andra låten. sen när det väl kommer nåt nytt känns det fel, låtarna var inte dåliga (inte superbra heller), men albumet var det

An empty sandwich. The two slices of bread being the excellent 'My My Hey Hey' and 'Hey Hey My My'. But the rest is very forgetable. Songs about going to the dentist and a particularly dodgy song about hitting on single mums on benefits aren't that great. Especially as, even then, he sounded like a whiney 80 year old. 3 (-1 Harmonica tax)

Not bad but wasn’t crazy about it

"I want to sleep with Pocahontas" she was like 16, Neil

Don’t mind the opener but the rest is bland. Just not a Neil Young kinda guy!

rđa nikad ne spava za razliku od mene dok ovo slušam. na(ne)sreću me budi jangov meket

Musically it’s a bit generic biddle but I like his voice and it’s very Karl Dilkington ‘song with a story’ lyric

There's a tic I have when I'm listening to music, it only comes out right before a song gets so bad I have to skip it, I get this feeling, then ask aloud "what the fuck is this?" then skip to the next song. I bring this up because "Ride my llama" ... what the fuck is this?

Docking a point for the offensive Welfare mothers song and all the native American woo woo themes.

Shoutout to the college magician and the guy who hated him. 2/5

boring obnoxious snobbery. i forgot about this album while still listening to it. 1.5/5

Man I hate his voice

A second Neil Young album in a week? You're killing me, Smalls. Or his voice is. Or the boredom. Please stop. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): N/A ⭐⭐: Didn't like it, didn't hate it. Saved no tracks.

Here's what I'll say about this album. He sounds very good as a live performer. It's just that I don't like his music.

Niel Young isn't fun or interesting.

Not stellar

The songs themselves are fine—moody campfire ballads and scruffy garage-rock. But Neil’s delivery just doesn’t land for me... I'm an anti-Youngite. I found myself wishing for cover versions instead, because the melodies and lyrics are undeniably good, yet his voice and ragged style make the experience feel more like endurance than enjoyment.

Oh dear, not another neil young album havent we suffered enough

247/1089 - A little less annoying than the Gold Rush one.

2.2

Boring

Was going to be a 1, but the last few songs saved it. I'm sick of acoustic guitar!

So very much not my thing.

Welfare mom's?

Great start and finish...the middle not so much. Also Pocahontas was terrible.

Seems Neil was passed his peak here

I slept through it :) 2 star

20.58, hima, sennheiser, qobuz aika turhaa ränkytystä ja monkumista. lämpenin kyllä loppua kohden, vika biisi säröllä oli rokkenroll

not the neil i would reach for

Enjoyed the mix up of styles but not a big fan

A bit slow for my liking, but he is a Canadian classic.

Well chill, maar niet het beste werk van de man denk ik.

Better than Ragged Glory, but Neil Young still baffles. He is not a good singer, though sometimes almost characterful. He can be nearly poetic – “the aimless blade of science” – before collapsing into bathos – “slashed the pearly gates” – or plain cliché - "There's more to the picture that meets the eye." Thrasher is almost Everybody’s Talkin’. The album and songs sound thrown together, the lyrics hardly crafted, but Young has clearly been thinking long and hard about some of the themes. Still, “better to burn out than to fade away” is hardly an insight, and Young does not seem convinced himself: the acoustic version fades away, the electric one burns out. Which is it? The first sounds like a demo awaiting a decent band, the second like a rehearsal waiting for the band to get out of its own way. Neither is the finished article. Why bother? 2 This is survivable. With Neil’s lyrics - which are always turgid and childlike in some degree, never elegant, never truly poetic - everything he does runs somewhere around a fine line between passable and boring. He gets away with it here through the novelty of presenting an album in two halves - a soft, sweet acoustic half and a fuzzy rock band half. If all was done in one style then the album would be intolerable. Christ that drumming is bad though. And the singing not great, the guitar playing pretty bad and the sweet West Coast backing vocals always misplaced. Who thought the handclaps on Welfare Mothers was a good idea? Or anything on Welfare Mothers? Shite. 2/5

Far too chill for a rock album as far as I'm concerned.

Or you could just make a punk album, that would be a sick genre switch

You can never go wrong with a classic. But was I in the mood?

99/1001. The story of Johnny Rotten: well i just ended up hating P.I.L's Metal Box in the last review. But I don't know about Neil Young, some people claim he's the profet and without him there wouldn't be any grunge and whatnot. For me this is not music to mildly hurt some for. So the same amount of stars as mr. Rotten.

I don't think I clicked with this one as much. While the songwriting and instrumentals are fine throughout, nothing on here really wowed me outside of "Powderfinger". I'll at least give the album that it gets much better when it gets more electric on the b-side, but other than that, this one didn't land.

Takie figo fago

There's a drum kit on the cover, and the first time you actually notice the drums is over half way in. False advertising.

not really my taste, but i know my dad really likes neil young.

Not for me

No me aburre pero no lo pondría por elección propia

Ufffff que embole hermano

This album starts out really strong with My, My, Hey, Hey (Out of the Blue), then confused me with a weird blend of Rock, Country and Folk and in the end ruins all the rapport that it built with My, My, Hey, Hey (Into the Black). At least gotta respect the album's flexibility. 2.5/5

Realmente no me esperaba este final. Empieza super country y luego evoluciona mas al rock, las ultimas canciones me gustaria volver a escucharlas otra vez

Mmmmm el bodriazo de la semana. Nota: 2.5

i liked it more than i thought i would. slightly goated?

Eh? Like it wasn’t terrible but I didn’t jive with a lot of it

Sleepy, too mellow for me. Listened while cooking

Believe it or not, I thought this album was pretty bland. There’s nothing really here that makes me think this should be a good album.

Previously rated: Harvest (2/5) After the Gold Rush (3/5) Tonight's the Night (3/5) Ragged Glory (3/5) On The Beach (3/5) Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere (4/5) ********************************************* I just had Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere three albums ago. I didn't really want another Neil Young so soon, but random is random. At some point between that album and this one, Neil developed that awful whiny, nasally singing voice that I can't stand. That ruins anything good that might be here, like the last track Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) which almost sounds metal. I think this is one they could have definitely left off the list. That's seven albums from this guy (not counting any CSNY). We are done with him now, right?

Just not my type of music.

I'm sorry Neil Young, what sort of lyric is: "Welfare mothers make better lovers While they're washin' you can hear this sound now Welfare mothers make better lovers Di-vor-ceeeeeeeee" ??? And while we're on the topic of lyrics: "I'm gonna ride my llama From Peru to Texarkana I wanna ride him good" ??? This is my second Neil Young album since starting the project, and I found this album less dull than the last one (I think I've moved on to "questionable" now), but I still hate his voice. 2/5

Ik had misschien wel verwacht dat ik dit album chill zou vinden. "Our House" en "Harvest Moon" vind ik prachtige nummers. Maar dit album vond ik eigenlijk best tegenvallen.

a bit repetitive but a good sound highlights: Sail Away, Powderfinger

very repetitive but short so it’s okay i liked the first song most

It’s just all a bit samey

Rust never i sleeps but i do motherfucker!

Neil Young's whiney voice is an acquired taste that I have yet to acquire despite the multiple exposures delivered by this list. File next to Dylan under 'Annoying delivery of interesting lyrics made more annoying by the addition of harmonica'

I got thrown by the opening track, it's a live recording, and it had a fade-out, felt a bit jarring. The rest of the album was okay, but yeah usual Neil Young, harmonica and whine. 2.5

Meh at best. First track was good, rest mid.

Didn’t listened

4/10 - nothing really to write home about. A very forgettable and somewhat generic set of songs. However I do appreciate that they are played very well live

Neil Young has an unreal ability to consistently be the worst part of any album he appears on.

It was okay

Not for me

I didn't overly love it but the guitars were awesome

country ass

Average. Not a fan of the live album.

I'm a fan of Neil Young but not a fan of him trying to be a "must see live" performer

Scusi Neil Young und du Crazy Horse, irgendwie hets mi ned gross catched und es isch tendenziell eher es geskippeds album gsi. Biz unfairi zwei rostigi Pferd

Kinda just boring.

1. hey - 2.5 2. trazher - 1.5 3. llama - 1.5 4. pocahontaz - 1.5 5. zail - 2.5 6. finger - 1.5 7. uuelfare - 0 8. zedan - 1 9. my - 2.5

A few decent songs (Thrasher, Pocahontas, Powderfinger) and utterly forgettable ones (Ride My Llama, Welfare Mothers, Sedan Delivery) sandwiched between an absolute banger cooked two ways. It's fine.

Haven’t listened to hey hey my my in years and had completely forgotten it’s existence so that was a nice surprise. The rest was kinda forgettable.

Didn’t enjoy this one, his live album Weld is better (and all electric). Late 70s Neil seems really erratic, wonder if fewer drugs and an editor could have helped him not release so many poorly constructed songs.

Why must y’all torment me with so much Neil Young? --This was better than some other albums but all Neil Young has a low ceiling for me.

Pretty boring. Almost like a folksy version of nico & the velvet underground. I appreciate Neil Young's songwriting but pretty boring all together.

The beginning of the album was okay but by the last couple songs I was feeling a little over it… not bad but I probably wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to the full album again!

Nope. I don't like live albums for the most part. This is one of them. It's not that the music is bad and sometimes concerts are fun to listen to, but 90% of the time for me, it's annoying. 2/5 because it's not terrible.

i do not like this man i do not want more neil young records

Beginning to think I’m not much of a fan of Neil Young

I was excited when I heard the first song. I’ve always loved it. Then I didn’t recognize or like any of the other ones (except for the last one). Lol

Is was kind of boring for me. Not my favorite. I could see liking it more if I grew up listening to this or had more ties to it.

Kinda lame Favorites: My My, Hey Hey(Out of the Blue), Powderfinger

I like the guy's voice a lot it has a nice nasally and kinda weak sound, like a thread pulled tight. Big fan. Otherwise a generic and boring album, not my thing. 2/5 stars.

Not a bad album. Not really in my wheel house.

Love his songs but this would not be the album I buy. He is great alone or with CSN&Y!

I knew this was the case but I really start to notice how much outside opinions influence my perception of an album and how by listening to random albums you don’t really do the artists justice. Upon first hearing (and this was my first time listening to Neil Young) I didn’t really enjoy the album. I quite liked the instrumentation on the beginning track and liked its connection to the closer. The fact that it’s a mix of live performances and studio recording is really cool as well. I quite like the intonation of Neil Youngs voice and find some of the distorted guitar, especially in contrast to the first half of the album, intriguing. But I did not really enjoy the music while listening to it or reading the lyrics. I understand the appeal and the ideas behind some of the lyrics but it doesn’t resonate with me. After reading some comments and how the album is structured I immediately started to look at this album as a piece of art more than I did before and upon relistening some of the songs did value them more. But I think it is correct to rate this based on my first listen and I didn’t really enjoy it. Some of the songs like Powderfinger dragged on for me because I didn’t like them. I am sure this would change with time and I’ve read that this album is NOT the best introduction to Neil Young. But as it is, I didn’t really like it but will be coming back for the intro track.

Fedt nok egentlig, bare ikke så meget mig. Starter lidt country agtig, og bliver mere og mere rock

Rust may never sleep, but I'm afraid if I fell asleep, I wouldn't be able to tell if a new song is on. Boring.

Was hard to get through, wasn’t quite country but felt country adjacent and I just wasn’t a fan. Heard people call this an acquired taste, could be the case.

What a powerhouse combo. A mentally ill horse and Crazy Horse?? I kid poor Neil, but I’ve never been able to get behind his odd vocal delivery. That sounds like blasphemy considering my nationality AND my enjoyment of folk music, but I just haven’t been able to get behind the crooner of the free world. To be fair, my exposure to him has been minimal (hence my reference to his big hit) but nothing so far. Please make this good. I’m losing my once ample street credit by the barrel. My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - Oh alright. I know this one. I hate any lyric that uses the phrase “rock n’ roll” but I’ll be damned if this isn’t a beautiful song and performance of said song. Could do without the moronic whooping from the crowd but a hell of a start. Even with a harmonica solo. What is happening to me? Thrasher - This one is entitled “murder in the pit.” Oh it’s about threshers. The song itself is pretty dull, but imagining the beautiful scene lyrically painted by Neil Young, interspersed with he emergence of denim clad long hairs, makes this a fun one in a sense. Ride my Llama - I will not AND I don’t think Neil rode from Peru to TexArkana. Not even possible. This song is incredibly mid and whilst I abhor such a lack of detail, I’m also losing my cognitive abilities by the hour. Pocahontas - YIKES. “I would give a thousand pelts to sleep with Pocahontas, to find out how she felt.” Indigenous cosplay and fetishization all in one. At least the wordplay on that line is there, but otherwise, this set reparations back a millennium. Sail Away - Would you? That would be great. No more teepee content, Neil, please. You grew up in Winnipeg, be more aware. Oh never mind. It was the 70’s!!! I feel like I’m writing that every day. This is the big pop hit, but can’t hold a candle to Christopher Cross’ “Sailing.” I’d like to hold a candle to both this song and the Cross one. I’m sure the sugary boredom would ensure an easily touchable husk. Powderfinger - Look out Mama, there’s a white boy singing some boring rock. Oh did he say boat? Whatever. Welfare Mothers - Oooooohh mama, rockin’ on down to the crazy rock n’ roll party *clap clap*. Raucous butt rock of the most stale and boomerly persuasion. Sedan Delivery - Back that freighter up to port, we need to unload these 2002 Toyota Echos into their natural habitat; Rural Nova Scotia. This is damn near a punk song that makes me think of shitty sedans, so this is a ten star classic. How he pulled this out after like 8 tracks of the most inoffensive, boring dad rock I’ve ever heard is a Christmas miracle. Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) - The outro? The same pretty song ans the first, except with a loud riff. Juxtaposition is whatever. I don’t know if you read any of that, but Neil still doesn’t appeal to me. There’s a distinct lack of likability to his voice, and while the poetry has its moments, I leave nonplussed by the Canadian’s output here. There’s the first track, which is great, and then I had to wait until the penultimate song to enjoy myself again. This album is thoroughly forgettable and will leave me here, wondering what it is I did to deserve bad albums playing in my ears 4-5 days a week. Oh yeah. I signed up for it. Maybe I’m the crazy one. You can lead a crazy horse to his anti-psychotics, but you can’t make him adhere to his prescribed medication regimen. 2 HIGHLIGHTS: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue), Sedan Delivery

IT was OK. You have to REALLY like Neil Young to sit through an entire album of his stuff.

My rating may make it seem like I didn't like this album, but I actually rather enjoyed it. There's just something that strikes me as "off" about this one, unfortunately, and I'm not sure that I can say exactly what. Favorite track: "My My, Hey Hey"

forgettable folk rock

eh

I know half these songs but they just never did it for me and they still don't. It's either musically too light for the lyrics or aggressively distorted with little to show for it. Welfare Mothers is always fun but other than that there's nothing that I haven't heard before. I'm sure it was groundbreaking in 1979 but even then it just sounds like Springsteen lite, without a saxophone, keyboards, or coherent vision.

Killer opener, but I could take or leave the rest.

Ever wondered what grizzled old hippy Neil Young was getting up to at the height of punk in 1978? Turns out he was recording this mostly live album with a mix of acoustic and electric tracks, reuniting with Crazy Horse for a series of gigs. Musically it’s pretty much by the numbers folk-rock with no real surprises. However, the lyrics read like something that someone who’d taken bad acid in 1970 might write. He starts by name checking Johnny Rotten, then on the next track he asks what happened to his old friends (presumably referring to Crosby, Stills and Nash) then remembers that he got bored of them and abandoned them because they were just dead weight to him. Ouch. There are then couple of tracks that give the impression that he got stoned and fell asleep watching westerns on TV and somehow started dreaming about a man from Mars too. Very weird. Cowboy-tastic!

It was okay. Kind of all sounded the same

nao curti + ao vivo

I believe that this is my fifth Neil Young album so far? I still think he's pretty good, and I still don't think his vocals are that bad. The first half of this album is a slower, more acoustic half. The songs do slightly bleed together into one I have to say. All very nice and very lovely inoffensive stuff, but nothing that I would actively choose to pick out necessarily. The second half is where the grungey hard rock comes in, and I like it a hell of a lot more than the first half. Young is a great guitar player. The solo on 'Powderfinger' is great and the fast rocking riff on 'Sedan Delivery' is a proper foot tapper. There's not much more I can say that would add anything extra to my previous four reviews of Neil Young albums. I would have given this a three, but I did say I was going to be harsher in my ratings. First half would be a 1.5, second half a 3. Overall I'm rounding down to a two.

I actually had the first song already in my liked songs… otherwise this shit’s weird his voice progressively got worse and the names kept getting weirder I might like welfare mothers??? Specifically when he sings DIVORCEE - it kinda was giving?????? I don’t hate it? But it did give me a headache sooooo

I never really understood what made Neil Young popular or lauded. This recording sounds like it was taken from the next room over, the music (aside from sedan delivery) isn't wildly innovative for the time, and lyrically it feels only fine. Maybe it isn't for me?

Did I dislike it? No. Did I like it? Not especially. It was OK but pretty much unremarkable and not deserving of a spot on this list. Would I want to listen to it again? Not really. 2.5/5

Second half starts to sound a little like rock and roll—but first half is just the same, whiney cords and pretty much the same, whiney lyrics from the same, whiney voice.

Squeaky voice, can’t stand it.

Sounds like every other Neil Young work I've heard. Interesting, but not that engaging. He sounds quite morose. Lots of guitars, some of them pleasant enough, but not enough variation in mood or tempo, for me.

Something of a disappointment. Neil Young is at his best when he's not making a bloody racket. He's making a bloody racket for much of Rust Never Sleeps. I guess the clue is in the title, right? More harmonies, less lumberjack please.

Not a fan of Neil but he tries

Oh Neil.

The last 3 songs of the album were good, the rest of the album was not good in my opinion

I'm not big on Neil Young. But I do enjoy "My My, Hey Hey" and "Hey Hey, My My"

Having listened quite my share of Crosby Stills Nash & Young and Neil Young's Havest in my days, I was surprised to have absolutely no love for this album. One listening of this album is enough for me today as I even have too much of Neil's voice.

Did not like it this slow kind of music is not for me

I think I get it why it has been so popular. But I find it actually quite boring. Then I even made the effort to listen and read some lyrics. And I think it matches perfectly to the music…

⭐⭐ – – – 1[.8] of 5 stars. It's okay. A lot of the same guitar work all the way through, with not a lot of variation. It just didn’t do much for me. Plus it's the second Neil Young I've gotten in a row. I saw a review that said "If you're not really a fan of Neil Young before, you probably won't enjoy this one," and I feel that's the case for me.

YOU HAVE GOT TO BE SHITTING ME. Rating - 2/5. > fuqqqq you for real and you can tell him i said that. This guys voice PMO and now he is my biggest opp cus we got 2 shitass albums from this guy in a row. Thrasher wasnt HORRIBLE. Its so slow i cant do this can we plz hurry up. Like the lyrics and stuff arent bad i just dislike the music and singing. Ride My Llama is a sick title ill give him that. Why did he pronounce “llama” like that tho. HIS VOICE IS SO ANNOYING IF WE GET ANOTHER NEIL YOUNG ALBUM IM GONNA KILL SOMEONE😊. Powderfinger has good instrumental. I liked the guitar on Welfare Mothers. Sedan Delivery had good instrumental too. Also will give him props cus the opening track and closing track are matching. >thumbs up: Idk tbh…. Welfare mothers💩

Not my thing really- too masculine, too many sailing and hunting metaphors, too many harmonicas. Wouldn't turn it off if it came on, won't turn it on again

Didnt love it

Meh, no es lo mío, al menos este disco

Neil Young 😴

mix of two different albums, one more acoustic, one more metallic-rock.

it's absolutely not my type of music. Such a dull thing, not for me. Sedan Delivery – the best here

not terrible, but not my thing at all and not something i'd go out of my way to listen to. i don't have much to say about this album, i just didn't enjoy it all that much.

I appreciate Neil but I’m very much only surface level fan. I think the center of it for me is that what is its strength of showing Neil’s comfort in being able to handle a wide spectrum of genres, is a weakness for me. He and the band jump from grungy rock to acoustic and a lot of genres in between. And that strikes me that I may have the weakness and need more time with this release for its critically acclaimed status to wash over me. Or not. Having said that my favorite cuts are “My My, Hey Hey (both versions) and “Sail Away”. Since most of the album left me cold I give this a 2 out of 5 stars.

Second album avec NY, le premier étant 'After The Gold Rush' (2/5). La première face chant + guitare ne m'a pas du tout intéressé (aucun intérêt pour moi) ... j'ai sauté d'un morceau à l'autre pour arriver à la face 2. Cette seconde partie, avec un groupe plus complet, n'est guère plus intéressante. Rien d'original, même si quelques chorus de guitare agrémentent les morceaux. Je n'y reviendrais pas. =>2/5

didn’t get round to this on the day as i couldn’t give an album a respectable amount of space works well in the space of a relaxing gap before work but may need to relisten for it to grow on me

Neil Young makes another appearance on the list for an album that's good for its content but not his best. Plus it's part "live" with tracks from other albums so I have a hard time with these as must listeners. I still liked it it but lower rankings for these concert albums. Young hasn't burn out as he is still touring and putting out new material...he may fade a way though...2.0.

Mixed reviews for Rust Never Sleeps for me. This album started out promising with a great opening track. Neil sticks to the solo acoustic sound for the rest of the first half which isn't groundbreaking but is still effective. His style is tried and tested and while Rust Never Sleeps isn't his best work, Side A is still another example of why he should be recognized as one of the greats. I was surprised how unimpressed I was by Crazy Horse and the entirety of side B. Overall I found it to be very generic filler that I think weakened the overall experience. It's hard not to feel like Neil Young has too much representation on this list. He's an amazing musician, and I love a ton of his music but some of the entries are a real stretch for something I needed to hear before I die. Nothing against Neil, but a few of his albums should be removed/replaced on this list. Rust Never Sleeps is fine, but overall nothing special. 1.95 stars

It’s ok.

Neil Young‘s voice is a taste I have not yet acquired.

I liked the contrast of the two sides (acoustic vs country rock), but Neil’s voice really got on my nerves.

I've always found Neil Young's voice to be annoying, but the instrumentals were good enough to avoid a 1-star

I have lost my taste for Neil young.

This album was alright. That’s about it for me. I could see where someone who grew up with Neil would see this album as a triumph, but for me it sounded like a lot of other albums from the time like Mountain, late career Grand Funk RR or Guess Who. The second version of Hey Hey My My was different than I’d heard on classic rock radio (the first version), being electric and crunchy. Overall, there was nothing that grabbed me, and you know how much I like being grabbed 🤣

Weer een Neil Young album? Wat is dit? De Beatles? Eerste nummer is heel nice, een soort country/folk/americana nummer inclusief mondharmonica! Ik hou er altijd wel van als er bijzondere instrumenten gebruikt worden in een nummer. Bedoel heb ooit een sitar album 4 sterren gegeven omdat het een onbekend instrument is! De mondharmonica voegt ook zoveel sfeer toe aan dit album, bizar eigenlijk! Jammer dat er verder na de eerste paar nummers niet meer zoveel mee gedaan word, dan verzand het album toch weer vooral in een rock album en daar hou ik gewoon niet zo van. De versie van Hey, Hey, My my op het einde laat me dan ook volkomen koud. Waar ik de versie aan het begin mooi vind door de eenvoud is de versie aan het einde weer met de standaard scheurende gitaren... Zucht... Ik vind Neil Young het mooiste als het klein blijft, beetje zoals Johnny Cash op zijn, naar mijn mening, beste nummers. FAVO: My My, hey Hey, Welfare mothers,

The album opens strong with My My Hey Hey. And then the next few songs feel a little samey. I am mixed on folk music, and really like artists like Dylan and Cat Stevens , but most of this album feels weak with some pretty bland tunes. Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery have a better sound, but bizarre lyrics. 2

An album of two half’s both of which failed to ignite. Is he singing out of tune on the last song?

I’m quite fond of some Neil Young, Harvest/After the Gold Rush are both on regular rotation…..but this isn’t on my the same level

My default stance is one of loathing when it comes to Neil Young, but I may yet come round.

No es realmente mi gusto, hubo buenas ideas y cosas en el disco pero no es algo que escucharia otra vez

A bit of a whiny voice. Some nice chord progressions and the vibe is ok but not really my thing.

The only thing interesting about this album is whether the lyrics of Welfare Mothers or the extraordinarily bad attempt at punk rock on Sedan Delivery is more cringe-inducing. Good Lord; enough with Neil Young! I’ve heard 4-guitar suburban dad garage bands that are more engaging than this. Enough already.

Has its moments (first and last songs). Can't say much good about the rest

listened to his song Farmer John again. much better than this album

I like this more intellectually than when I actually listen to it. Cool album that I don't like all that much. Too low on musicality for my delicate sensibilities.

It’s fine. I still don’t get the Neil Young fuss.

Just not my jam.

it’s okay

It's okay. Couldn't listen to everything all the way through.

This is the second of seven Neil Young albums on this list - at least he's back on spotify which made it easier to listen to this time! My impression is he is overrated - 7 albums from one artist seems like overkill! I didn't mind the last track

at least it was short

It's alright, but its no Harvest Moon. Neil Young itches that bit of old school folkish vibe in my brain, but I do find his voice to be a bit grating after a while.

OK, this is album #5 by this dude. Promised I wouldn't listen to another after #4. I did and nothing changes my opinion that this guy is one the most overrated musical artist I've ever heard. Happy this was only 35 minutes. 2

Same Ol Neil Young....one great song, one that puts ya to sleep. Altho this album was more sleepy than up.

Not for me

Pretty boring

I'm a moderate Neil Young fan. I enjoy him in small doses. Listening to this album, I enjoyed the production, performances, and the music. However, I get tired of his whiny voice and self-righteous musings. Not his best stuff.

Started off okay, My My Hey Hey was good, gave me sad girl vibes which is always enjoyable but the rest of the album so was boring that I started dissociating and didn't really pay any attention to the rest of it. It felt quite disjointed and more like a bunch of rag tag songs that were just thrown together to fill the time. Tried to give it another listen this morning and ended up dissociating instead again. Unfortunately for me my brain decided to start paying attention again during Pocahontas which is totally my fault for having the ability to hear because what the actual hell were those lyrics?? Off-putting enough that I promptly removed the album from my search history so that I never have to be reminded of it again. Did I hate it enough to give it a 1? No, it wasn't an awful album to listen to, it just lacked any personality. If I could give it a 1.5 I would but alas

This album was really hard to listen to for me, I found it REALLY BORING. I didn't manage to finish.

Pretty good. Definitely more grungy than what is typical from Neil Young.

Not really familiar with Neil Young beyond "A Horse with No Name." Usually when a singer sounds like a muppet that's a plus for me, but I couldn't really get into Rust Never Sleeps. Seems like there is some good lyric work though.

Ok