Reviews (page 6 of 15)
Pre-Bruce Dickinson Iron Maiden feels so weird to me. After he became the lead vocalist, he just became Iron Maiden. I mean, Paul Di’anno’s not bad at all. It just doesn’t scream Iron Maiden to me personally. Though what’s even weirder is how despite all that, this debut still stands on its own. Honestly, if you don’t like Iron Maiden, this might be for you. It’s really just at the point where the band was finding themselves, like all bands do on their debut. So you get a more melodic, nuisances approach that might be more accessible. Don’t let Eddie on the front scare you. For me, I respect this album. It’s important and Iron Maiden wouldn’t exist without it. Having a debut stand out is very hard, so I give this one props. Favorite track: Prowler Other hits: Phantom of the Opera, Transylvania, Strange World, Charlotte the Harlot
Cool, but kinda funny that this was heavy metal. Seems tame compared, but i understand it was ahead of its time. 3/5
I did not need to hear this before I died. In fact, by about halfway through I was actively wishing I wouldn’t make it. This, AT BEST, belongs in the book 1001 Albums to Hear Before You Turn 12. Just when you think it can’t get worse than Charlotte the Harlot, they hit you with the 10 minute long opus Phantom of the Opera (fast twiddly bit, dramatic bit, fast twiddly bit, repeat until will to live is fully sapped) which is enough to make you reassess your relationship to the work of Andrew Lloyd Webber. I imagine this is suppose to represent a turning point and the start of the new British metal scene or whatever, but really who cares?
Nicht das beste Maiden Album, trotzdem ne 5
Holt mich einfach nicht ab, ich erkenne, dass es gut ist
Kannte ich nicht war aber wirklich gut
Listening to this album I am surprised that I didn't enjoy the last Iron Maiden album I listened to nearly as much. This album felt raw and real and totally rock and roll. I previously thought that Iron Maiden felt like they were trying to hard, but this felt totally authentic. I will have to go back to see if this is a classic case of first album was their best or if my initial feel around their music was just off. This also felt pretty in touch with blues influenced heavy rock of the era (Led Zppelin, Black Sabbath) which I love, and not trying to be something new just for the sake of it.
My knee jerk reaction when listening to Number of the Beast a few weeks ago was that this is some corny as hell 80s metal, but after a couple listens I started coming around to it and found myself enjoying the album overall. Listening to their self-titled debut album now and I can confirm I am a full convert! The melodic, ripping guitar solos, the driving bass lines, and tight solid drumming. I also love when a metal band slows down like in Remember Tomorrow and Strange World. This was a great time and I am happy the generator has opened my eyes to Iron Maiden.
Vibes: 2/5 Instruments: 4/5 Production: 3/5 Emotional Value: 2/5 Storytelling: 1/5 Album Cover: 0 Stand Outs: Phantom of the Opera, Charlotte the Harlot Overall Rating: 2.2
Did not like it as much as I rhought I would. I just find it a bit boring compared to newer rock/metal
One hell of a debut album, better with every track.
Pretty good. More punky than I'd thought, but classic of the genre for a reason.
Si bien los vocales no son tan impresionantes como los que le ibamos a ver a la banda con Dickinson, igual funcionan y hay algunas canciones de estructuras evolución súper onderas. Phantom of the opera se anota gran momento
mal posso esperar…
Great album
It was alright. Middle of the road heavy metal.
Easily their best album. Paul's vocals combined with killer riffs, solos, and overall songwriting give this record a unique sound that they never replicated later on. CLASSIC! 10/10
Not my normally type of music but I was quite surprised! Good for a gym work out!
Let's be honest, Iron Maiden deserve every bit of praise they've ever had. Whilst far from their best album, this debut is phenomenal. It's creative and it doesn't overstay it's welcome! Later albums benefit from having Bruce Dickinson, a real force majeure, but this doesn't feel as though it suffers for not having him. Great band, great album, thank you for making me re-listen to it again
Mér finnst það næstum óþgæilegt hversu fínt mér þykir þetta stöff. Gæti alveg hlustað aftur og aftur, og það þrátt fyrir að mér finnist Bruce Dickinson er mun flottari söngvari en þessi Páll. Fjarki, næstum gegn eigin vilja.
Charlotte the Harlot was misogynistic but overall good album. Had some nice melodic parts which were unexpected
More instrumentals than I thought
This was great, loved the speed and squigglies, as well as the melody. Couple of slower duds but overall great.
Iron Maiden's self titled debut album is a fine debut, and an incredibly influential album, boasting some truly mighty tracks. The energy is front-loaded, particularly with the first five songs (including "Sanctuary"). While the quality dips slightly on side two with tracks like "Charlotte The Harlot" . The album was recorded with the late Paul Di'Anno on lead vocals. I had the pleasure of seeing him front Iron Maiden live on their 1981 "Killers" Tour, and he was a brilliant singer, blending a raw punk sensibility with powerful rock delivery. The undeniable standout track on the album is "Phantom Of The Opera." It is a stunning, foundational masterpiece. Brutal in its execution, yet absolutely epic in its storytelling, this track is the template for Iron Maiden's long-form epics that would follow. It features incredible tempo changes, great drumming, frenetic riffing, blistering guitar solos, and phenomenal bass work. The tempo switch at 4 minutes 34 seconds, leading into the stunning guitar solos still gives me 'the chills' to this day. This is a song that clearly influenced the thrash metal bands that followed a few years later. The one drawback is the production. The overall mix could be crisper and sharper, a flaw bassist Steve Harris agreed with, which is why he brought in the legendary Martin Birch to rectify the engineering on their second album "Killers". Despite this one technical issue, and though this is not my favourite Iron Maiden album, it is a five-star debut that laid the groundwork for a legendary career. A final mention must be made of Derek Riggs’ stunning artwork. Across seventeen studio albums (as of 2025), Iron Maiden has famously never appeared on any of these covers, instead opting for the iconic presence of their enduring mascot, "Eddie The Head", in various guises. 1 "Prowler" (5/5) 2 "Sanctuary" (5/5) 2 "Remember Tomorrow" (5/5) 3 "Running Free" (5/5) 4 "Phantom of the Opera" (5/5) 5 "Transylvania" (instrumental) (5/5) 6 "Strange World" (4/5) 7 "Charlotte the Harlot" (4/5) 8 "Iron Maiden" (5/5) Total - 43 Average - 4.78 162/1001 90/162 albums reviewed were new to me.
I find with so much metal….the playing may be great, the actual songs don’t do much for me.
some iconic songs, too many guitar solos lol
The band shows obvious potential on their debut, but it doesn’t quite click for me. The main weak point is Paul Di’Anno’s vocals, which feel limited and rough in a way that drags several songs down rather than giving them character. Still, there are bright spots — 𝘗𝘩𝘢𝘯𝘵𝘰𝘮 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘖𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘢 is by far the standout, the first moment where Iron Maiden’s melodic twin-guitar interplay and dramatic songwriting truly break through. Overall, you can hear the blueprint of what the band would later become, but for now it’s more promise than payoff.
Not really heard pre much Maiden pre Bruce Dickinson but you can hear the sound forming hear in a slightly grittier fashion. And some tunes I knew as well. Some great playing
Heavy Metal is so overrated. 1.5/5
Yeah baby
Kako god se odlučim da ocijenim ovaj album kad se probudim sutra, zauvijek mi je najdraža Maidenova Remember Tomorrow ali u izvedbi Opetha. Ja sam metalhead ali ne za klasični metal. Ne kažem da mi je Maiden loš ali nije to to.
Classic album. Revolutionary at the time, but the production quality isn't great. Great guitar playing, great bass, solid drums. The singing is not as polished as on later albums though
This is a really solid early 80s metal album. Much better than some of the "metal" that was starting to come out at that time.
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would! "Remember Tomorrow" "Phantom of the Opera" "Transylvania" and "Charlotte the Harlot" were faves
Soy una abuela? Aprecio el nivel de músicos de Iron Maiden pero no es mi vibra.
i lv it
Dug it!
I'm not super familiar with Maiden, I know bits and pieces, I've heard the odd album but possibly nothing from this earlier iteration of the band. It felt like a slightly looser version of them than the Dickinson lead band that spawned many of their big songs. And it really works for me, it carries a trace of 70s blues oriented rock that just softens it out a little but the Maiden trademarks are still there too. I think I prefer it and so I may be checking out a little more of Di'Anno lead Maiden.
Lifelong metalhead. This is probably Maiden’s worst album, and is absolutely its worst pre-90s. It’s not even the best of the two featuring their original singer. Chintzy production, transparent and awkward songwriting, and Di’anno is a far inferior vocalist to Dickinson. The elements of what the band would become are there but any of the next 5 albums deserve a place on this list over this one (I peeked and their greatest did somehow manage to get included). Only a group of Very Smart critics would have picked this, probably because of its perceived influence on NWOBHM. But an album that someone unfamiliar ‘should listen to’ in 2025 should have something to offer that listener in 2025. You shouldn’t have to have a PhD in early British heavy metal to appreciate it.
Nah
bra, men svakere enn de andre
Iskreno sam iznenadjen koliko su mi se svidele balade
Absolutely fantastic, I like it very much. 4.5⭐
Great cover artwork and interesting listen. Not as heavy as I had imagined and story telling not overly dominated by guitars. Surprised.
A great debut from metal legends Iron Maiden. Raw, fast, gets your head banging.
Liked this one, but I do prefer Iron Maiden’s later stuff. Favorite Song(s): Phantom of the Opera, Iron Maiden
(4)Iron Maiden’s debut album, hit the charts at #4 in the UK. Paul Di"Anno the lead singer on this album. His vocals are more punk than compared to Dickinson’s operatic harmonies. This album feels like a late seventies album, the hooks reminiscent of Blue oyster cult, or hawk wind. I have always appreciated Iron Maiden for their love of literature. The track “phantom of the opera” is such a song. “Iron Maiden”is a track the band plays as their final song before their encore. This is the first appearance of that song.
Being a metal head in the ‘80s and early 90s meant that you knew and listened to Maiden, even if you didn’t want to. Every house party, car, smoking pad, etc. was playing Maiden. This earliest album is a debut of one of Britain’s and the world’s biggest bands. It’s also is unique and historical, though not their best. It was a first so it’s due respect. Steve Harris made a workhorse machine of a band. For me, there were three standout: the title track; Phantom of the Opera; and Remember Tomorrow as a 3-2-#1. Paul Di’Anno was a good Rainbow-esque glam singer with a helluva range but if you get the chance to listen Dickinson do the same songs on Live After Death, it’s obvious who was the better singer. The original drummer Clive Burr also is impressive and Think it’s awesome that Maiden does an annual show to raise money for this medical treatments. I don’t know if I would have put this Maiden on the Top 1001 but for historical reference I get why it’s here.
Random thoughts: * I don’t have much to say about this one. * Never listened to an Iron Maiden album straight through unless we already did that for 1001. * Iron Maiden always freaked me out because of the scary album covers and t-shirts. * I’m unequipped to properly rate metal albums. There was thrashing, there was speedy guitar licks and solos, there was shrieking vocals. It checked all the boxes! Rock on!
A fun listen. Good heavy metal rock
It's mostly good, but I wasn't in the mood for the extended shredding.
Pretty basic rock. I thoroughly enjoyed a few of the solo sections, but some of these are slog to get through the repetitive parts. Mixed bag for me. Hard to rate.
I could only think of the joke in Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure.
I really like Iron Maiden, but as this is their first album, I feel that it is a bit tame in comparison to later releases.
väldigt välskrivet, men känner att själva spelandet inte riktigt är helt där alltid, som att de har skrivit saker som är lite för svåra för dem. stundtals väldigt burkigt ljud, låter som att det kommer genom en konservburk, speciellt i basen. bra, men kunde varit mycket bättre
I mean, vad ska man säga? Startade en helt ny genre i princip, många klassiker som fortfarande spelas idag.. Ändå är det Maidens sämsta 80-talsplatta, JAG KAN GE EN FYRA MOHAHHAHAA
This album is kind of a lot to deal with on a Monday morning, but it woke me up, I guess.
Fine album, but a band who clearly unlocked potential with bruce. Running free is the best song though.
Not huge on Maiden, but prefer the more 80’s leaning stuff which is weird.
second Iron Maiden album i got. Not much else to say than i already have. I'm sure they are great musicians i just really don't like metal. And Number of the Beast was at least more interesting than this.
4,5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. Siitä se story alkaa
Tajusin, että tykkäsin tästä maidenista enemmän mitä Dickknsonin laulamana.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Kuultavissa jo maidenin maneerit. Hyvä lätty vaikka laulu ei niin miellytä.
Overall, great fun but you need to be in the right mood for this sort of thing - not really my comfort zone. Reckon my Iron Maiden collection will start and finish with The Number of the Beast.
Boring…
I wasted my youth NOT listening to more metal
Great! A 4.
The picture on the cover looks like an anorexic Donald Trump having a bad hair day. Is this the best thing about the album? Quite possibly. I would have considered scrapping a 3 after listening to "Strange World" unfortunately the album ended with the title track "Iron Maiden " This track is a virtual caricature of a bad heavy metal song. 2 star
This was better than I expected. Not as much of a metal hair band caricature as I thought it would be: decent songs.
Iron Maiden er ikke så verst, altså. Melodiøst og fint.
Goofy album cover but perhaps best Iron Maiden album?
No private session used for Spotify. Iron Maiden was lumped into the bin of satanic bands that I tended to avoid when I was in junior high and high school. This wasn't as heavy as I expected and seemed more hair metal than heavy metal.
RANKINGS OF THE SONGS 1) Iron Maiden - 9.3/10 2) Prowler - 9.2/10 3) Transylvania - 9.1/10 4) Running Free - 9.0/10 5) Strange World - 8.8/10 6) Charlotte the Harlot - 8.6/10 7) Phantom of the Opera - 8.5/10 --------LINE OF LIBRARY------------ 8) Remember Tomorrow - 8.3/10 AVG - 8.85/10 Personal Ranking - 8.9/10 Great riffs, vocals were alright. The bass and drums were great, and I loved the melodies.
Didn’t know they had another vocalist for the early albums. Pretty good!
fantastic thematic unity between their sound and visual style but not very interesting music
Best Song: Transylvania. Goddamn this song really jumps into gear at around the 2 minute mark and does not relent. Worst Song: Charlotte the Harlot. This track deviates the farthest from the "Iron Maiden" sound, enough that it might as well be any other band of the era. Overall: You can definitely see the bones here of the greatness to come, but sadly Paul Di'Anno can't hold a candle to Bruce Dickinson, so this version of Iron Maiden always feels like it is lacking. Instrumentally it still rips, and Di'Anno's vocals are solid, but he's up against one of the greatest of all time.
I prefer the Bruce era, but this is a genre classic that set Maiden on a path to glorious heights.
It was alright but kind of boring. Disappointing when you think about how many t-shirts are out there. 1.8 outta 5
Classic
I wish I could get be put in an Iron Maiden
Unpopular opinion: I actually prefer the earlier, Paul Di'Anno-fronted Iron Maiden albums. Bruce Dickinson is very good at what he does, but his operatic vocal style wears thin on me after a while. The musicianship is also leaner and less polished than their later work, which I find appealing. Old Iron Maiden just hits different.
Knock a star for Paul Di’Anno. A killer first album otherwise
I prefer the Dickinson albums, but this is good enough for a 4.5 plus the ol' metal bump
Music is a 5. Vocals are a 3.
I fell asleep listening to this
I’ve finally listened to one of those albums with the scary (but very fuckin’ cool) ghoul on the cover! Hell yeah!!
This record is a classic. The production is the only real flaw. It's OK, not great with a raw and unrefined mix, but at the end, it is a truly undeniable record. A metal classic that definitely deserves to be on this list and should be listened to by everyone.
5/10
It’s as if the clangers dropped acid and recorded an LP. Worst album on here so far
This is good. Better than the other iron maiden i think. the guitar is really fire. Phantom of the Opera is very good. The stabbing guitar reminds me of Lucretia by Megadeth which is probably my favorite song of this genre. Fire
Like many bands' first swing at bat, Maiden's debut doesn't exactly give the best idea of where they would go, but it has some solid rock tunes and great musicianship. It's unfortunate that Paul wouldn't be able to compete with Bruce, but thank God Bruce did eventually show up. Almost like your lead singer is important to the band's sound and direction.
Pre-Bruce Maiden will always be viewed through a different lens, but this is a band that arrived complete with their sound dialed in, just waiting for the right pieces to click into place.
Great first album
A real theatrical album but not one of my favorites from Iron Maiden
Found myself head banging to this one. Favorite track was "Remember Tomorrow" and made me realize that a lot of 70s/80s are the other side of the coin of schmatlzy ballads - they are essentially ballads that go hard, and I love that.
This was far more interesting than I was expecting. I loved some of the more bass-forward stretches of the album, and overall it had a really exciting pace. I still don't fully understand the disconnect between how aggressive the album covers were for these 80s albums and how comparatively tame the music is to modern rock, but that's ok. 4/5
I don't think it's the best Iron Maiden that's out. But you can see the vision in this debut and it has just enough of the good stuff of later Iron Maiden to justify a 4.
9/10 Very good and interesting instrumentally, some lyrics feel creatively lacking though.
This did not sound anything like I thought it would. After I finished the album, I listened to the most recent Iron Maiden release. "Total Eclipse" from 2022 sounds like what I expected Iron Maiden to sound like. Maybe they were finding their voice when making the s/t, but the vocals are so boring. I like the instruments, but I'm actually shocked they had a 50-year career following that boring first release. Their scary imagery does not match the tame vocals
Nice to revisit, never liked di’anno’s vocals as much but all the rough ingredients are there for the classic stuff.
I like this more than I expected to, but I didn't really enjoy it. I am unlikely to recognize any of this songs if I heard them again but I feel no need to ever listen to Iron Maiden ever again
I don't think there's a band out there that has a more iconic cover art and title style. One of the most influential heavy metal bands and you know you've made it when sensitive Christians start burning your albums for reasons they just conjured up. They first started burning albums in 1966 when the Beatles said they're more popular than Jesus, and the Christians had so much fun buying albums to burn that they kept looking for excuses to do it afterwards. I do like that this was back when there was an actual singing element for metal compared to now which is mostly incomprehensible throat wailing. There's a nice melodic progression to the songs that is very heavy, but still very musical. Make sure that you listen to Sanctuary as well as it's left off the 2015 remaster on Spotify. Although Iron Maiden wasn't the first heavy metal band, they are quite possibly the most influential on the metal genre as a whole, inspiring bands like Metallica, In Flames, Anthrax, Alice in Chains etc.
Whenever I listen to Iron Maiden I remember that I should be listening to more Iron Maiden. Great album, melodic and catchy while still having fast metal instrument parts.
I was entertained. For being the first from iron maiden, not bad
I was so hesitant at first, but then my face started to melt.
First time listening, pretty enjoyable, like a more polished Sabbath.
very good album
surprisingly very good, high 4
Not bad by any means, but not necessarily my preferred style.
Quite a classic, with much left to come. Not quite my favorite album of theres, but its interesting to see the start.
I like this album. It's their first, so the sound of this album is more raw, and one of the rare albums that doesn't have Bruce Dickinson singing. It reminds me a lot of Metallica's first album "Kill 'Em All". Just a killer studio sound. I'll rate this 3 of 5. Favorite tracks are: Prowler, Phantom of the Opera, and Transylvania.
So cringey.
Like the primordial goo of modern heavy metal. Fast, loud, not quite fully formed. Phantom of the Opera and Transylvania stand out. What a relief after forcing myself to listen to Scott 2 all the way through. Like a juicy steak after starving for two days.
To be honest, Paul Di’Anno’s voice isn’t really my taste, but I can’t help being drawn to Dave Murray’s fluid guitar lines and Steve Harris’s bass work. Prowler is of course great, but in Remember Tomorrow the interplay between the two guitars and the bass line is something I could follow endlessly. What fascinates me about Iron Maiden is that, despite being labeled as heavy metal, their sound isn’t just about power or volume. It’s built on a delicate, precise three-voice structure — two guitars weaving harmonized melodies over a restless, melodic bass. That sense of construction and accuracy gives their music a unique kind of intensity.
YES ...men det är inte så bra. Det är lätt att se var de är på väg (som band och som genre), men det betyder inte att den förtjänar sin plats i kanon.
Very solid rock album. Great guitar and drums. Gives the vibe a true metal band through and through, but in a very enjoyable way for someone not familiar with the metal genre.
wanted to hate it and mostly did, but get the vibe others may dig.
Rv
This album was really good! The start was a bit shaky, but after hitting Phantom and Transylvania, the riffs and solos go to the next level. I also really liked the lead guitar tone. This was one of my favorite classic metal works I’ve listened to. Favorite Track: Phantom of the Opera
It's no wonder Iron Maiden is so influential in heavy metal. This is mind blowing, especially for 1979. This feels like THE ORIGINAL heavy metal band. Sure, Led Zeppelin blazed the trail, but Iron Maiden sets the standard. First time I've heard this album, and just ... Wow. My rating: 5/5
classic earlier metal, with vocals that are almost half punk in style. great musicianship, though I'm not a huge Iron Maiden fan due to the clash between the guitar style and the vocals.
Except for strange worlds, i found myself wishing that i was listening to black sabbath. Ewwww. I wonder how modern music manages to sound so much punchier. Nirvaaannnaaa. TWO!
Geht so
First time I’ve ever listened to Iron Maiden, and it was surprisingly good! Solid “classic” heavy metal
high 3 - not their best project but still really solid
Running Free Phantom of the Opera Iron Maiden
5/5
Surprisingly diverse with obviously skilled musicians and strong production. Definitely heavy metal.
Good album ruined by its production. I casually enjoy Iron Maiden but prefer the Bruce fronted stuff.
Iron Maiden before Iron Maiden
Only heard two songs from it before and honestly, it's such a fun album. A slightly less "heavy" version of metal 3/5
I liked their later stuff better, but this was a great start.
I had a hunch & listened to two other Iron Maiden albums. This debut should not have been on this list. Look, it still shred, but their signature style & polish was missing.
I’d never heard most of these songs. Definitely not as good as other Iron Maiden stuff but after the last few days, it was a good listen. Bruce Dickinson sang the national anthem at the Kings opening game this year - neat
not my jam, but bearable
Лет 15 назад он меня очень впечатлял, но сейчас совершенно нет) кроме пары песен, слушать особо нечего. Но, тем не менее, класика хэви-метала, нужно иметь уважение
Great classic album
I was surprised to find a bluesy bar band that totally shreds instead of Iron Maiden. Then The Metal Showed Up on Phantom and barely let up on the back half. This is a solid debut. Bruce Dickinson is whom I'm used to but this guy is very good. He doesn't have the gravitas of Dickinson though. Can't wait for Number of the Beast to show up. Soild 4
I mean it’s fine! Some tracks are pretty good, even. Real Billy Hargrove shit. Put me in a fast car and play these tunes. But I don’t know how much staying power it has for me. Musically there’s some cool stuff happening; I love the guitar work. But the rest kinda falls flat, I guess. Thematically, our last metal album was much stronger and, context taken into account, much more relevant.
I've listened to the Iron Maiden hits quite a bit. I even prefer the Iron Maiden pinball machine over all others (Run to the Hills bangs, fight me). But I've never gone back to listen to their first album. I heard Ghost's cover of Phantom of the Opera when they released it a few years ago and I wasn't a big fan of the song then. When I listened to the album in it's entirety, everything hit. I loved it. What an album. I gotta listen to more Iron Maiden
What a legendary debut album. The variety, innovation, instrumentation, it’s all there. Not quite as perfect as some of their other projects, but still an absolute pleasure to listen to. (4.5)
I've never listened to a full Iron Maiden album before, and this is not the Iron Maiden I'm familiar with, so this was an interesting listen. It wasn't a life-changing experience for me, but like the Elvis album, it was cool seeing where so many artists have pulled influence from. "Phantom of the Opera" and "Transylvania" was a great 1-2 punch. I doubt I'll ever revisit this one.
Expected to like this more than I did. First track kinda banged but overstayed its welcome. Didn’t know they had a vocalist before Bruce. Would have been better with Bruce.
As the knight adjust his helm and steadies his lance, the driving riff of "Transylvania" bursts in. This album is joust-core, duel-gaze, meant to be played loud over the clash of a friggin' medieval battle.
Great
Yllätyin kuinka paljon tykkäsin tästä. En siis olettanut että en ois tykänny mutta tykkäsin enemmän ku oisik olettanu. Hyvä energia ja ei oo liian heavyä mun makuun. Mageet kitarat.
What it says in the tin…
Everything was in place from the get-go. Obviously things change when Bruce comes in but belongs on the list. For me three stars is a pretty good album for a classic five is indispensable. This is a three.
Pioneers of metal, not my favorite Maiden album but still awesome
Maiden rules. While they are undeniably heavy metal, they also bring a gift for rhythm and groove and leaven the thrash just enough, giving space for slower melodies and the singer’s nice voice (apparently this is pre-Bruce Dickinson.) And when they rock, I dare you not to headbang.
Excellent! Love this Maiden era.
Poggers
Pas aussi bon que le Maiden qui l'a suivi, mais toujours meilleur que le métal qui se fait aujourd'hui! Un beau mix de proto-métal et de prog, ça slap.
Yee haw
Beaucoup de bon riffs mais je trouve que ce style là vieillit pas très bien.
Bedre enn forventet pga annen sanger
Woo band firing on all cylinders. It’s been a long time since I last heard this. Good listen.
Too heavy and obnoxious for my general liking, not a big fan of Iron Maiden
Straight banger.
Feels like very average hard rock now? None of the hits I would have associated with Iron Maiden are here, but the sound is very clearly getting there. I enjoyed it, and will bump it up one for originality
I dont care for this version of metal. It's Iron Maiden do 1/2 star for cultural significance. 4.0 plus .5
Sounds like a mix of metal and rock. Good but I don't know how often I will come back to it. 7/10
Metal Goes Pop vol 1
Not great but ultimately much more fun and less annoying than I expected, high 2 low 3 Fav song: Phantom of the Opera
More varied and interesting musically than I was expecting. I did keep thinking, "wow, these guys really want me to think they are SO DARK and EDGIER than they actually are."
This was definitely a case of don’t judge by the cover. Pleasantly surprised to find this less heavy than I’d expected.
Classic rock album
80s training montage music.
it was fine, it was good. not the metal I reach for but important to history.
Listens: 4 Standout Tracks: Remember Tomorrow, Transylvania, Iron Maiden A completely respectable entry into the List, and the Heavy Metal Genre. I am really starting to appreciate the genre, which I honestly had reservations about before starting the List; Mostly because I always lumped all of the various forms of "metal" into the Heavy Metal genre. Although bands like Slayer, Turbonegro, Venom (for example) and other death/black/thrash metal bands share the same root of heavy electric power guitar, bass and percussion, I feel like there is still a world of difference between the aforementioned bands and bands I would consider to be more "traditional" metal, like Black Sabbath, Metallica and Deep Purple, and now Iron Maiden. I am again being reminded of the video game Risk of Rain 2, which has excellent music that sounds very similar to what I am hearing on Strange World (sans the singing).
Hate heavy metal. 2/5
Mostly I’m thinking yeah
Before: I'm glad this has come up, a couple weeks ago I mentioned I really don't have much perspective on this era of rock, and ZZ top left me so disappointed. I know this is considered heavier than that, but I'm excited to investigate deeper. After: I feel like a ding dong for comparing this to ZZ Top at first haha. Anyways I really liked this one! The guitar tones had me hooked, and the clearness of the drums in the mix really stood out to me. I also appreciated the range that the vocalist brought. He was giving different and interesting performances on every track. It suffers a bit from cheesy lyricism at points, but at others, the imagery was strong and fun.
This is really fun prog-metal. The riffs were really fun to follow and the drumming was interesting especially alongside the riffs. There were also some fun bass lines happening in the background. I really enjoy albums where it's written and produced in a way that you can feel the energy and this is one of those. I also really love the dual lead guitar sound. Harmonizing riffs speaks to me.
I love that you can listen to virtually any Iron Maiden song and know immediately that its Maiden. Even for an early album, their sound is so distinct. Its the high pitched dubbed guitars, its the operatic vocals, the drums are often kind of simple, but they're heavy and booming. I think more than anything, this band thrives at creating a world within the album and within their music. I'm not really sure what every song is about, but I know I'm in it. It feels like a movie. Even the kind of silly songs on this record (Running Free or Charlotte the Harlot) still feel like they're part of the overall story and progression of the record. Even if that story is kind of cheesy or silly, it doesn't really matter. Its better enjoyed when you lean in. I don't revisit Maiden often, but I'm always glad when I do. Today was no exception.
Ok. Not really for me but had its moments.
Better than I thought it was going to be.
Not for me
Actually better than I expected. While I have always liked metal, I never quite got Iron Maiden. Never seemed to have any emotion in it and while I have heard a lot of folks worship their technical prowess, I couldn't really hear it. When "Prowler" started I thought 2 things: 1. I was right. This sucks. 2. This singer is worse than Bruce Dickenson. Then we get to "Remember Tomorrow" and he actually sings good. Are there multiple singers? Nope. It's just that when he leans in to be a rock star, his voice fails. The good one shows up again in "Strange World". "Phantom of the Opera" and "Transylvania" have what will come to be known as the Iron Maiden signature sound. Good songs. Would love to hear them redone with better production. (The Ghost version of "Phantom of the Opera" is really good.) While I like it more than I expected, I don't think it will make the rotation. Will put "Phantom of the Opera" and "Transylvania" on a playlist or two though. Let's call it a 3.
By the time this was released I had moved on from this type of music. I knew of it but avoided it and have done so ever since. Chance today then to perhaps listen to the album in full. Which I did but found despite its brashness, my mind wandering. Cannot think of any circumstance again when I would play this or any other Iron Maiden album. 2/5 27/9/25
Not that it was bad, just nothing caught my attention. It definitely sounds of an era
I wanted this to be a 5. It wasn't. Great album, but it is a far cry from the best metal out there. Hoping for another Iron Maiden album that is a little more refined later on.
This album was really good. I'm starting to realize that I really like metal music. What isn't to like? Heavy drums and guitars and interesting vocals. I didn't get completely into this album, but I would love to come back to it in the future.
Enjoyed first listen and might return
Музыка: 8/10 Разнообразие: 7/10 Тематика и вайб: 8/10 Цепляемость (отдельные песни зашли): 8/10 Реиграбельность (можно ли рандомно врубить на фон): 9/10 Итог: 8.0
I like this. It's a very rocking time, with a great tempo and quality to it. There's something of the Black Sabbath to it, where the music is really quite melodic, with some great riffs, and interesting shifts in rhythm and tempo. I really like the squealy guitars, and I'm also impressed with his singing. The cover art maybe belies the sound a bit, as you might expect something aggressive or even ear-splitting, but this is really quite accessible. 3.5 rounded up.
I've already listened to his album (17). The best is yet to come for Maiden, but the bones of the formula are there already. Iron Maiden is a killer song.
Not my kind of metal.
I-ron Maiden-fly.
I just don't like metal.
Odio il metal
Metal! Love the limited lyrics - mostly just wailing on every instrument they have.
Metal with some godd bits. Not all of it is screamy scary angry noise. Dude on the album cover looks like a lot of Americans right now (January 12, 2026) Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): Remember Tomorrow, Running Free, Phantom of the Opera, Transylvania, Strange World (guitar bits are fantastic). ⭐⭐⭐: Liked it. Saved some tracks.
somewhat hell yeah, somewhat repetitive
recording feels....empty? hollow? the music is fine, but something about the mix is off. other than that, it's a decent debut!
The album
The guitar work on this album is amazing. This album is amazing musically.
point8.
Great classics, thx
Classic early maiden, setting things up nicely for the greater stuff that was to come
too hard for me
6/10
Удивлен тому, что поставил другому их альбому 4, но это разъебная музыка, которая разбивает жанры и звучит отлично до сих пор. Лучшая песня - Phantom of the Opera.
Iron Maiden is definitely an album i really enjoyed. It is always good when i get another metal album for the stockpile as i love nearly everything that genre puts out and this album is absolutely no exception. It is definitely a more basic album as it is an album that came out in 1980 but that doesn't make it any less enjoyable. This album is still fast frenetic and has all the great guitar riffs, crushing drum beats and everything else you could want from this genre. Granted, this album's basic nature does make it a little bit forgettable but i never at any point disliked what i was hearing. This is an absolutely great album that i still really enjoyed from beginning to end. Best Song: Remember Tomorrow Worst Song: Charlotte the Harlot
8/10
Очень круто! В каждой песне чувствуется гигантское влияние на музыкальную индустрию. Впрочем, даже они всего лишь жалкие пародисты Арии))
Did not like heavy metal when I was younger. This did not move the needle.
Raucous, no surprise there obvs. But I feel that even if I knew this album intimately I would struggle to sing along 😐
Not as fun or crazy as expected to be honest.
Operatic without being cringe, and absolutely 🔥. Four stars. Is this list turning me into a discerning metalhead?
listenable metal
Great debut album that instantly established their sound and were innovators in metal. Very talented musicians and lotta music, notes, and ideas packed into the album. One of my favorite notes was the huge grand finale on the last song. This would be one of the best live play through albums cause it plays like a concert.
ok
Good noodling. Even some singing instead of screeching. One even sounded like Pink Floyd. Ok!
Enjoyed this to the earlier (later) Maiden. Had good debut album energy, and thought Strange World was fantastic.
Yeah, okay, maiden minus Dickinson is definitely not worth listening to
Another impressive debut for what later became an iconic heavy metal group. I know these early heavy metal albums tend to be a bit abrasive, but this sounds pretty damn good for only having been recorded in 13 days. More emphasis on the instrumentals here as opposed to later releases, as we have a few long stretches that showcase Murray, Stratton, Harris, and Burr's contributions. I didn't think there were any super notable standout tracks after listening, but then again, I don't think Iron Maiden was much of a "singles" group in the first place, rather more of a "sum of its parts".
I only started this and didn't finish, but was fascinated. I have not listened to this band really before. Great voice.
Im not a rock guy but really good album nice cohesive and fun
4/5
Cover 6.5 Although they sound completely different, whenever I hear the name "Iron Maiden," I think of either Judas Priest or Megadeth. Probably because of the imagery. Megadeth I know. And really enjoy. I haven't really given Iron Maiden or Judas Priest enough time. Like my To Be Read list, my To Be Listened list keeps stacking higher and higher. However, I've now gotten at least one Iron Maiden album out of the way. And I do like it. It's funny how much more tame this style of "heavy metal" is, like Kiss, which was once considered loud noise. I was also never a hige Kiss fan either, although I've tried and there are songs here and there that I do like. That's basically why I haven't bothers with Iron Maiden or Judas Priest. They're too old sounding, I guess. Yet, it do like oldies and 70s music. I don't know. I guess it's just not for me.
Najgorszy z albumów maidenów, bo na wokalu inny gość. Dickinson ma jednak niepowtarzalny wokal
Really good, I enjoyed that.
I see why the bad is heralded so highly in metal circles. It was chill.
Not really for me... 2.5
That opening track is such a mission statement. It's hard for me to really appreciate Iron Maiden without Bruce Dickinson though - especially as a lot of other elements aren't fully formed yet either.
So much good stuff on here. 5/8, 87%
Cool guitar band. Don't know how I missed them, probably because I thought they were much heavier than this. I think this is a good intro album into them and I would definitely listen to some more of them based on what I heard on this album.
The remaster of this album pushes it up to five stars for me. I always liked the material, but the production on my original tape copy was just a little bit too rough around the edges. Actually being able to hear the instruments properly makes a huge difference. Also, there's more classics here than I remembered. Nicely spread out over the album, with the tracks that aren't played in concert as much, but are still quality. Paul Di'Annos vocals aren't quite as good as Bruce Dickinson's in my opinion, but they come close.
Такие драмы квин, не могу...
I like the music well enough, but even the original vocalist doesn't move this into a regular listening rotation.
More technical musically than I thought they’d be
I thought I knew Iron Maiden but this debut had really changed my opinion
7.1 / 10 Way better than I expected. These guys rock! Literally. Way more like hard rock/classic rock than the metal that I’m used to hearing. Definitely would listen again.
I expected to hate this because metal is so not my genre, but wow, it rocks. Some great guitar parts, and not terribly screamy. Listened before? N Saved to library? N Favorite track(s): Prowler, Running Free, Phantom of the Opera ⭐⭐⭐: Liked it. Saved some tracks.
Hella hard. 2/5
Few good songs great band tho
fav track: phantom of the opera
Wasn't expecting to be into this but it's very fun actually, liked this more than their other albums that have been on here
Masterpiece of punk moving into metal
The structure of what Iron Maiden would become is there, but this album is maybe a bit raw for what I want my IM to sound like. Super solid debut album, though! 4 stars.
I've never really listened to Iron Maiden, but I can see why they became so popular. Really liked this album.
Raw, scrappy, and fun
Similar to Black Sabbath in recent weeks it’s shocking to think this is the bands debut release. Equally staggering to imagine how this must have sounded in the landscape of 1980. Surely Kiss and others were doing their thing but the scale or sound and volume of guitars at least to me seems relatively novel. I’m more a fan of Bruce Dickinson era Maiden but you cannot deny their sound even from day one. There are several 5 songs on this album - consider Phantom of the Opera (especially from 3:00 to the end) - but as I do not see the album as a 5. I mean I have to leave room for later work. 4/5
Loved this Getting back to Metal roots🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
Good record! I had an unfair aversion to Iron Maiden before listening to this. A tightly performed and very fun album. Self-titled tracks are a flex.
not really something I typically listen to, but it's a solid record and I legitimately enjoyed it. The mix has it's issues, like the vocals just seem too dry and don't feel like they belong in the mix. The songs hit hard and the riffs scream throughout the whole record. Maybe it's time I listen to some more Maiden and get hang with Eddie for a little bit.
Not too irritating for metal
Nothing much to say about this one, I liked it
First half was dynamic
Album No. 0027 on my list. I had not listened to this album in a couple of years, and I think it has always been overshadowed by the subsequent Iron Maiden albums with Bruce Dickinson. I have to say though - it's a great album! I personally enjoyed many of the songs very much - beyond the Maiden classics "Running Free" and "Iron Maiden", "Prowler" and "Phantom of the Opera" are my favorites. While he certainly had different vocal qualities compared to Dickinson, Paul Di'Anno was a great singer and I like the more raw, less melodic energy of his voice compared to Bruce's later efforts. Still not my favorite maiden album, but very cool stuff that I'll listen more to in the future - 4/5 stars!
Listening to albums like this is part of the reason I'm doing this project. I wouldn't have thought to listen to this record and I certainly didn't expect to like it. Thought I knew what Iron Maiden was all about, but I was wrong... at least with respect to this album. It's pretty damn good! Much more melodic than I would've expected and less screaming than I anticipated. In fact, the guy can actually sing. That said, I'm generally not a fan of the heavy metal genre, lyrically it's not exactly poetry, and it's just not really music that moves me personally, so I'm not going to rank it that highly for ME. But that said, objectively, it's definitely a good album. 3 stars.
I very much enjoyed this album listen! My first time listening to an Iron Maiden album in full and I thought it was great. I would definitely listen to this electrifying metal album again in the future! It was especially great to listen to at the gym as well.
Bless their hearts.
I made it through 5 songs, which is a success for me and metal.
Awesome. Not a bad song. I prefer this foen to earth and varies version of maiden with di'anno to dickensons high grandiosity
Great.
Stærkt album. Fed og variende metal oplevelser med strejf af den karakteristiske britiske rock lyd. Starter stærkt ud med "Prowler," rammer en smuk bjergtop med "Phantom of the Opera", men desværre rammen titelsangen der afslutter albummet ikke lige min øregang helt rigtigt og får derved ikke den afslutning albummet ellers fortjener.
As far as Heavy Metal goes, Iron Maiden is pretty sweet. Probably more accessible than most is, and I enjoyed it because of it.
Running Free is still my all time (perhaps only real fav) Maiden track. This was a great listen, while reminding me via Charlotte the Harlot of how I don't actually like them all that much. So a three.
My parents’ music
It was fine.
Loved it
Turns out it's not Iron Maiden I hate. It's Bruce Dickinson.
Hmm won’t listen again but reasonably raw
I’m not the biggest fan of Iron Maiden fan at the best of times, but I’m definitely not into pre Bruce Dickinson Maiden. There were some decent instrumentals across the album, but I just find their variety of metal quite dull and overblown.
"Iron Maiden" is the debut studio album by English heavy metal band Iron Maiden. It was met with immediate critical acclaim and declared "the heavy metal sound of the 1980's with its blinding speed and rampant ferocity." Hit that on the nail. At the time, Iron Maiden was Paul Di'Anno (lead vocals), Dave Murray (guitars), Dennis Stratton (guitar, backing vocals), Steve Harris (bass, backing vocals, primary songwriter) and Clive Burr (drums). The album reached #4 on the UK charts. Overlayed guitar riffs start things off in the opener "Prowler." Gritty lead and backing vocals. A song about a pervert. Guitar breaks and a guitar solo. The band keeps adding to the speed. "Remember Tomorrow" starts out slower with stretched guitar notes. Dramatic vocals as Di'Anno tells a story about his grandfather as a WWII pilot. They really get the soft-loud-soft dynamic going. Metallica said this song was hugely influential in songs like "Fade to Black." I see that. "Running Free" was the first single. Tom-tom drums, a plodding bass and a guitar riff. Di'Anno said this song was semi-autobiographical about his 16-year old skinhead self. A standard sounding song and one not far away from sounding like the band that they opened for, Kiss. "Phantom of the Opera" is anything but standard. Operatic, layered guitars. A very fast beat. Multiple time signature changes. We'll, I guess, they had to get their prog rock side out. They sure did. Epic. The album ends with "Iron Maiden" and really foreshadows what they would sound like. Very fast. Driving. Melodic guitars. An underlying melodic bass. Very catchy vocal chorus. A bass solo. Yes! Lighters out! Driving. Raw. Fast. I think the murky production actually helps this giving it an edgy sound. Di'Anno's vocals can be gritty but he's got a good scream. He's just different than Dickinson. They hang on to remnants of prog rock and even punk. Not a bad thing in 1980. There's their highly influential sound and a few songs ("Remember Tomorrow " and "Strange World") that would influence heavy metal soft-loud-soft songs and ballads as well. Steve Harris is an absolute beast on bass, drives the music and shows why he has been one of the best bassists in any kind of music. This is a great album and a lot of fun to go back to. I recommend you do the same.
I’m not usually a heavy metal listener, but this was a great first spin. The guitar work was nice, the album was short and easy to get through, and while many of the songs blended together, I wouldn’t turn it off if it came on again.
I like this much more than I thought I would
Iron Maiden has never hit for me. I feel like I *should* like them (love a bunch of their peers), but they're just not for me. Cover art is always amazing though
Growing up i always wanted to get into Iron Maiden. Loved their album covers and the cool Jean jackets my peers wore. Then I remembered why I didn't....the music.
top3 : - strange world - phantom ot the opera - remember tomorrow
Liked the guitar parts. Super intricate
Love it
I'm going to be honest... this isn't my cup of tea. It's just not my genre, but I give it respect for not being just noise. I hear the intent, I hear the lyrics, I recognize who Iron Maiden are/were. They belong here, I'm not the best person to judge this because it's just not my class... but respect to them and for making it welcoming.
Really feels like a first album, put together before they'd properly found their feet. However, I must commend it for trying different things, using great dynamics, and making best use of the sonic materials they had to hand.
Surprisingly good for me (not a metal fan)
Classico. Di Anno una voce incredibile e pezzi che so a memoria
I rather liked this but I feel I’d need more listens to appreciate it more. Some good tracks, particularly Phantom of the Opera.
When I see or hear Iron Maiden, I think of Bill and Ted's excellent adventure. This is as 3 as it gets. Don't love it, don't hate it, wouldn't turn it off, wouldn't seek it out.
There are better Maiden Albums than the self titled.
Perfect album for when you lack the proper tools for carpet removal so you use a hatchet.
I really really liked Prowler. The rest was okay
This was a solid album and marks my first official listen of an Iron Maiden album. To be honest, I was not expecting to enjoy it so much. I don't typically like any songs that are intense and heavy, but the guitar and drums were so good that I didn't find myself thinking that it was too much. I loved the gritty feel of the album!
Iron Maiden Wants You For Dead 1001 Albums Generator 102 (08/22/2025) Iron Maiden by Iron Maiden (not to be confused with Iron Maiden by Iron Maiden off the album Iron Maiden), released in 1980, is their debut album. I mean, this is what metal is all about, is it not? While other metal bands were futzing around with the rock and blues inspiration that metal originally came from, this album separated the wheat from the chaff. From the first note in Prowler (imagine starting your career with a song this good, by the way) to the powerful self-titled closing track, Iron Maiden showed definitively once and for all that metal was really a distinct genre in its own right. Not only that, but the sound of this album is all over the place. I love the speed and pure aggression of Prowler and the title track, but the obvious star of this album is Phantom of the Opera. While Maiden would much later become just an extremely boring prog band, at this point, they had the songwriting chops to justify a long song like this. The fluctuations in tempo and the virtuosic guitar solos are incredible. Like all of Maiden's first 7 albums, the true quality of this one is not in the few true standout tracks; it is in the quality of everything else around it, and unfortunately the "filler" here is not their best. Remember Tomorrow and Transylvania are awesome, but I really don't like Running Free, and Strange World is one of their most plain ballads from their early career in my opinion. Also, I am not a huge Paul Dianno fan, and I think that Maiden really gained their footing as true greats when Bruce Dickinson joined a couple of albums later. I can't necessarily hold that against this album, but the couple of weaker tracks keep this classic from 5/5 territory. Pretty clear cut 4/5 for me. Favs: Prowler Phantom of the Opera Iron Maiden Least Fav: Running Free
Prawler was a good song, the others were kinda bland
It's whatever, rocky.
Gonna get ya
I like it enough I guess.
surprisingly nice
🫠
1. This is PRECISELY what I needed after being forced to listen to Cold Play. 2. I was a teenager in the 80s. I used to walk by the smoking section of my high school (yes, in the 80s public high schools in California had a section on campus where kids could smoke - and 95% of them wore jeans, IM BS/OO or JP tees and black leather jackets summer or winter) with my nose in the air, pitying the wayward fools who listened to such trivial novelty music. In my 50s I LOVE IT. 3. This album sounds like they haven't quite figured out exactly how they want to use their prodigious talents; exactly what Iron Maiden's sound is. But their explorations are so F#$ing INTERESTING. 4. Puts KISS and even, dare I say it?, AC/DC to shame. 5. Perhaps the best use of Chorus effect on guitars ever.
patika vairāk nekā es domāju, ka patiks riktīgi vaiboju līdzi! tie ģičas rifi tiiiikk kruti īpaši patika "Running Free", "Phantom of the Opera" un "Prowler"
Much better musicianship than I thought
Wow. This was a really solid debut, and quite a bit different from their later work.
Still not my cup of tea
I am a huge fan of the rock genre and I have heard of the Iron Maiden before. This album was packed with exhilarating tracks that it was over before I knew it. Easily replayable and never missing a beat, I have great thoughts about this album. This was the band's debut album which makes me curious about the other albums they have and whether they will appear in this 1001 list. Overall, I had a great time listening to it while reading Serial Experiments: Lain wiki.
Good instrumentation, I’m not going to purchase the album- but won’t turn it off either
What can I say that concerned parents in the 80s didn't already? This album was corrupting the youth, and the youth were right. Long live Heavy Metal.
Early Iron Maiden pre- Dickinson is not great. Kind of slow and boring