Is This It by The Strokes

Is This It

The Strokes

3.81
Rating
31542
Votes
1
2%
2
8%
3
25%
4
36%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 16)

this is good!

5/5. It’s just so much fun man. I find I often want to attribute deeper meaning and artistic merit to albums I award my great “5/5” to, but this album goes against that. I just love every song on here, plain and simple. Each track is just fun and brings me a youthful joy, carefree and happy. Julian is a very fun singer, he just sounds so cool with everything he says, it makes you forget he doesn’t know the lyrics. The guitar interplay is so simple but it’s so memorable. The rhythm section keeps everything moving without doing anything it doesn’t need to. I’ve covered multiple songs from this album with my band, and I can confirm they’re just as fun to play as they are to hear. They’re so brilliant in their simplicity that we actually shuffled this album to pick a new song to learn in an afternoon. Is this it is fun, who cares.

light alternative sorta rocks lots of mid tempo… fun and guirky lyrics: they domt take themselves too seriously…

Love this!

it is indeed it good but most songs just sound sooo similar

good stuff

Oh, the Early Aughts. What a time to be alive. 9 keepers in 11 (82%). 1 banger (9%). 91

I was kind of waiting for this one, and I expected this to be rather good. And honestly not dissapointed at all! Very fun, garage-like rock, easy listen for sure. And what an iconig album cover too. Probably deserving solid 4 stars. But this could never rever reach the status of greateness for me, simply because it's not at all revolutionary in any sense at all, this has all been done, but it does sound fresh which I appreciate.

The Strokes had so much hype surrounding them. I remember listening to them on The End in Seattle. Last Nite was that song. I bought the CD and played it over and over. I really enjoyed listening to this again. It is a good rock album. I think it still holds up.

made me feel less depressed today lol. Really catchy hooks with a fun alt-rock voice. Whole album is kinda the same but it's good so I don't mind.

Outstanding, exceeded my expectations. Deserved all-timer, I love discovering new music to get obsessed over. Just genious from beginning to end. Try your luck and give this record a listen.

the driving beat and the way the guitar and drums work together are great

Great album. I think calling this just a "back to basics" rock album does it a bit of a disservice - certainly had a huge place with the resurgence of guitar music in the early 2000s but certainly this is way more sophisticated than Jet or The Vines. In particular, the guitar work is really great and varied, not just banging away at power chords. Some fantastic songs such as Someday and Last Nite. Great soundtrack for running across the Brooklyn Bridge which I was doing on the day this one landed on this and it felt like a sign.

I'm not sure I ever really knew their name, but I'm pretty sure I heard plenty of this album on the radio in the 2000s. And now I know who they are. What a fun, great debut from a bunch of guys inspired by 70s-era garage rock (and especially The Velvet Underground, apparently). I can also see why this album did even better in the UK than in the US, as there's a lot to The Strokes sound and style that sounds much more British than American; funny too how much they in turn inspired the likes of Arctic Monkeys and Franz Ferdinand to achieve a similar sound. I'm not sure I would have swooned over them as much as music critics did back in the day, but I'd happily listen to this album again.

I forgot how boring they are

Still holds up pretty well

I'm frequently late to things. I wore this album out (as much as one can wear out a collection of mp3s) round about 2013. I was heavy into the Strokes, this one in particular, for about two and a half months. This is a source of (very mild) shame for me, as a music lover. I come late to things. Hell, I still haven't been some places everyone else has been. I'm hoping, for instance, some Prince albums show up soon. I know I'll probably like em, but I'm pretty busy listening to Czarface right now (some 13 years after their debut - hey, the year I was into "Is This It!") The only worse thing is being onboard early. I'm also frequently onboard early, only to have the thing I like a) fall apart or b) start to kind of suck. Or c) everyone starts liking it and then I'm like "yeah I liked them first" and nobody cares because, like, who cares if I liked them first? Do I get a prize? Anyway, I already loved this record, but I never love loved it. You know. Some of the songs are a bit filler-y. And does Julian Casablancas have to sound like he's singing into a toaster on every song? It's a cool effect, but every song? But this is mostly great, and I enjoyed revisiting it, and revisiting that point in my life...2013, when everyone had long moved past this.

What a classic top to bottom that has aged like a fine wine. Really enjoyed this album, and it's one that I often come back to.

Decent enough alt rocknroll. Nothing out of this world but solid.

Always happy to have an excuse to listen to this! It's an album with like, at least 7 perfect pop songs, and it all sounds perfect. I really don't have anything to say about this beyond "Yeah, it's awesome"

I thought I was going to like this, but it just falls short. It was one of the worst times in rock history. Nothing great came out of it. Flat.

This makes me feel like I'm a teenage dirtbag kid in the 2000s. I can see why this album launched them into fame. The production is very indy/rock which I enjoy. However, I feel like it can get a little repetitive, so while the production is good, there's not much diversity. I liked some the ideas they explored in the songs, but idk Ive ever hundreds of songs about sex and drugs. Overall, it's not bad, but it's not my favourite: 7/10 Stand out tracks: Alone Together and Last Nite. *The lore about his dad is INSANE and also the fact that they had to change the US version kills me.

I don't hate it, and it's from the US not the UK, so that's a surprise. But it's part of a revival of rock that I never appreciated. Most of the tunes are the same, aren't they? Not bad, not great.

It's fine. All sounded about the same.

It's good. Wreaks of 2001. Didn't blow me away, but I can't imagine a world without the hits. The simple production is great. Cool, understated mix.

I've listened to like half these songs but not in a while. Obviously an important album but also just a good listen

Great album, New Abnormal mogs though

Banda icônica do começo do século, influenciou todo mundo que veio depois. O rock praticamente se tornou storkeano desde então, pro bem, renovando o estilo, e pro mal, com a baixa testosterona típica do indie. Fazia tempo não escutava. Parece ficar sempre a dois passos de um grande disco de rock, mas falta mais energia de uma banda garageira (tem isso no grito inicial de Last Nite, p ex), acaba sendo broxante em vários momentos. Ainda assim, boas músicas, disco importante. Vale entrar na lista.

We’ll get to this. But the answer is quite possibly.

very 2000s, not my favorite style but still some great tracks and overall a good listen

I don't like to give The Strokes all the credit for the garage/indie rock explosion that occurred in the 2000's, but they deserve a lot of it. This album being an absolutely top notch example. Say what you will about his vocal style with the effects on all the time, but it really conveys the kind of lackadaisical melancholy of Millennials. Almost impressively so. Musically, it's got an exceptional simplicity. Everything feels understated, but it all blends and plays together really nicely. It does get a little monotone because of that, unfortunately. I'd knock it down more for that, but it's just such an influential album that it makes up for that shortcoming.

...... i should call her 3.95/5

The Strokes will always be a three star band to me I reckon.

Stand-out tracks: Soma, Barely Legal, Someday, Last Nite, Trying Your Luck, Take It Or Leave It Have listened to this one even before the challenge and some tracks have been all time favorites for a while. Upon a closer listen now I realised that I like even more of the album than I thought I did. The only complaint I would maybe have is that some tracks do kind of blend in a bit, but the whole thing is generally a really good vibe. Funnily enough I think that the title track is one of the weaker ones.

I have only listened intently to The Strokes a few times. This time I noticed a discernible pattern that helped me understand their appeal. They start out with a choppy rhythm guitar often paired with a busy piece of percussion. The pace starts quick, then accelerates, at times reaching frenzy level musically. Meanwhile Julian Casablanca keeps in control, occasionally rising to a greater level of agitation. He and the band never reach roll on the floor intensity. The sound helps unite the album. The two big hits, “Last Nite” and “Someday”, sound nearly identical in the beginning before veering into slightly different patterns. Nothing wrong with a formula. The Velvet Underground featured their famed drone strum and Keith Richards and Mick Jagger mined similar riffs for countless hits. That’s heady company, and The Strokes are not in their league. The Strokes sound too much like other bands and genres to fully stand out. I hear much post-punk in the guitars including Wire and a busier version of The Smiths. A narrow window of tempos limits the variety. I enjoy what they provide, but could use a change-up tossed into the mix. Not everyone is The Ramones. Since Is This It was a debut album, I would have looked forward to future releases. Not a Strokes expert, it appears they did not develop enough from this promising first record.

im not sure if i like this is it!

The Strokes are formulaic and I don’t care because I love the formula. Sue me.

Might be on my Mount Rushmore of albums

In my top 10 albums of all time…wish I could rate this thing a 6/5

Definitely feels like 2001. Not bad just doesn't do it much for me.

Some good bits but it's monotonous

Stacked and concise debut. The poster-child of the early 2000s post-punk rock revival. Not my absolute favorite of the 2000s NYC scene (I prefer Interpol's Turn On the Bright Lights a bit more), but a triumph nonetheless. Rating: 9/10

Is this it? I actually kinda like The Strokes, I thought I was gonna be more into it. There's a lot of talent, a definite "this" sound, very Strokes, but nowhere did it sit amazing with me. It was just pretty good, easy to replay, also easy to move on from. 3.3/5

Amazing album!

Overrated (laudatory). I mean, I really like The Strokes and own most of their albums, but I've always thought they were kind of overrated. If it were me, I would've picked "Room On Fire" or "First Impressions of Earth" for this list. (Though I also recognize my First Impressions pick would be controversial--I think that one is underrated).

Not rubbish but not brilliant either. Just a decent listen. Sounds like someone I just can’t put my finger on.

Did not understand all the love for this album. It was merely fine, slightly above average garage/indie rock, nothing groundbreaking. Did not care for the lead singer's style, but some of the guitar work was pretty good. A 3/5 for me.

still a classic

An era-defining sound that I have a lot of nostalgia for, but wow, a lot of these songs sound the same. I can't deny I had fun listening to this again though.

AWESOME SAUCEEEE

Is This It 4.3 The Modern Age 4 Soma 4.2 Barely Legal 4 Someday 4.1 Alone, Together 4 Last Nite 4.3 Hard to Explain 3.7 New York City Cops 4.4 Trying Your Luck 4 Take It or Leave It 4 Score: 4.090909091

I think what people miss when they say it all sounds the same is that that’s the point: The Strokes found a sound that worked for them, and defined themselves on their debut album by sticking to it. The megaphone vocals, the panned guitars, the melodic bass, the dry production. It’s very intentional and instantly identifiable. It’s not a perfect record, but it’s a very good one, and one of the best at establishing a band’s sound.

I don't know how The Strokes do it, but they just keep sounding the same no matter what decade it is. Looking forward to reading Hyden's book named after this album. Favorite track: Hard to Explain

Classic bit of early 2000s rock. Truly The Strokes feel like a band that should be far bigger than they are, though I can see why they aren't. Love this album.

Super important to the genre, quite catchy at certain places

Still holds up.

Stella debut album, peak Strokes probably.

Few people have ever sounded as cool as Julian did here. All-timer

creepypasta background music

the strokes are catnip for whiteboys like me....

5/5. Classic of the 21st century.

more like a 3.5 if half stars were possible

Not outright bad, but pretty bland and monotonous. The rhythm guitar parts are generally the most basic strummed eighth note chords with no syncopation, there are no real highs and lows energy-wise, it’s just mid-tempo standard early 2000s rock that is trying very hard to sound cool at the expense of doing anything interesting. 2.5/5

Standouts: Barely Legal, Last Nite, Hard to Explain. These songs bring me right back to my high school/university indie sleaze days.

thoughts: - whoops, started listening out of order again - this would have done numbers on my ipod in HS playlist adds: - last nite > like a movie

Track By Track Is This It - Modern electro intro sound, tiny bit Radiohead-y. They sound like a proper rock/alt band. Very blended and cohesive. He’s kind of doggedly singing, quite laid back. Nice sound. The Modern Age - Have heard this before I think. Great flow and rhythm to this. So simple but it works. He seems to like that almost crap speakerphone/echoey effect on his voice. So much so that I can’t always understand what he’s saying but the tune is great so I’m kind of alright with it. Soma - This sounds like it would soundtrack a 2000s TV show or something. It’s both laid back/stoner-y and jovial. It’s like the emphasis is very much on the sound rather than the lyrics. Barely Legal - This has a very similar sound to The Modern Age to me. Quite decent rocky tune. Can also hear some of the garage influence on this one. It sounds SO 2000s! Can hear that it influenced Arctic Monkeys and Killers for sure (read this in the description). Someday - This really reminds me of Buzzcocks. Like a lot. Great tune. Again, simplicity is king in this universe. Alone, Together - Very Bloc Party. Jagged guitars, quite nice. Not a big stand out for me though. Last Nite - Crux of the record, but also goes very well in the tracklist. Possible favourite, apart from Modern Age. So good. So famous. The slowed ‘walking out that door’ at the end is so subtle but a quality touch. Brilliant. Hard To Explain - Nice drums, very insistent drive. Kind of here for it though. I appreciate the guitars here too. This is great songwriting, the verse and chorus blend so well, with a great flow for the whole tune. New York City Cops - More thrashy rock-from-a-garage vibe here. Even a bit punk. Quite decent energy on this one. Trying Your Luck - It’s quite a standard one for them. Not a stand out for me. A little drawly for this genre actually. Same as a bunch of other songs, as it says in lyrics (‘tell me it’s all the same’). Take It Or Leave It - It’s got their typical sound, with some punky lines peppered throughout. Potentially inspired by punk. It’s one of the slightly grimier ones on the record. Overall Review: It’s funny with this one. I feel as if I’d definitely have to be in the mood. It’s the first Strokes album I’ve listened to all the way through. Can hear its influence for sure. Very clear in many ways. I didn’t like all of the songs, some sounded samey and not my vibe but the songs I did like were very strong & I had a great time listening to those. Having said that, it’s not usually my go to genre right now and it didn’t blow me away musically or lyrically. Even so, it was a fun one. So, mixed! 3.5/5 Favourite Songs: The Modern Age, Someday, Last Nite, Hard To Explain

Someday is maybe the most 17 year old song of all time. Very sweet :)

**An ok album

Simply a cool, good, indie album. Last Nite was my fav song of the album. Trying Your Luck (my fav first listen) and Someday were my other highlights

35 minutes, this album just goes out and gets it

Makes me want to give myself a Cobain Haircut

This was a fun album, easy listen all the way through with some good hits thrown in. It helps that I like alternative music and this album certainly fits well there.

Gran disco de una gran banda como The Strokes. Nunca había escuchado el álbum completo creo, sólo conocía Someday y Last Nite. Me re gustó. La banda tiene un estilo muy particular, tanto en el sonido como en el cantante.

So happy to have an excuse to listen to this again

Is this it? Just kidding - fun, snappy album but just lacking a little depth for me.

This was fun to listen to, not much to say except that I don't like the vocal filter. 7/10

I ignored the Strokes for an incredibly stupid reason when this album came out. When I finally gave it time I felt pretty stupid.

It's .... OK.

When I first heard this album, I just came to the States. Their sound had a callback to a yesteryear that I had no lived experience to appreciate. As result, I did not really enjoy them. Fast forward to 20 years later, I can appreciate the complexity quite a bit more. They have become one of my favorite artists, although this is not my favorite album by them. 3/5

This is in fact, it.

irgendwie hat mich das gar nicht - paar banger dabei, aber insgesamt nicht meins, weder klanglich noch v writing

such an important album

Kinda a mix of Gavin and Stacey music with a bit of shouting every now and again

Enjoyment: 8/10 Replayability: 8/10 Cohesion: 9/10 Flow/Pacing: 8/10 Artistic Merit: 9/10 Weighted Average: 8.3/10 Review: This is my first time listening to this entire album, but I did already have two of the tracks on one of my playlists. Now I have to go add more. The Strokes have a unique and enjoyable sound in the sea of indie rock that sound effortlessly cool. Liked Song(s): The Modern Age, Someday, Last Nite, Take It Or Leave It Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Yes Heard Before? Partly

I respect Is This It more than I like it. And I like it just fine. I just do not love it.

the strokes, within my personal music cosmology, are an incredibly ironic band. i grew up listening and loving every band that was influenced by the strokes circa the late aughts early teens, but i never had the impulse to listen to the progenitors themselves (and i mean, why would i? if i'm content with all the great music that had been made and was continuing to be produced). i'm willing to convince myself that i only started reaching back for this genre when it was in it's twilight years: retroactively dubbed "indie sleaze," the moment had passed and we were on to bigger and better things. but i still yearned for rock you could dance to, which led me to read "meet me in the bathroom" by lizzy goodman and discovering the strokes. imagine my surprise when i actually sat down with the strokes, some 25+ years on, and learned THIS is why every band i like sounds the way they do. it's because of the strokes. it's because of this album. it's still banana-pants bonkers to me how this album came from a gaggle of well-to-do teenagers form new york city who would go on to become the last veritable rock band before the digital age took over. as a cultural artifact representing the nascent 21st century, it's endlessly fascinating to me. and, if that wasn't enough, the music isn't half bad either. this user is biased and already held this album in high esteem, but nothing's changed since the last time i listened to this: 5 stars. highlights - the modern age, soma, alone, together, hard to explain, when it started, take it or leave it

so far a nice, not great first song. Some nice pop. Some vocals that I don't like - "Someday" or "Last Nite" hate those songs. Was aiming for a 3 but going to drop to a 2 or 1 just for that song

Cocaine with Kate Moss

Good album, not great at least to my current taste, but the guitar riffs still work.

I wish I hadn't heard any commentary about this album before hearing it for the first time. Any time I've heard someone bring this album up they talk about how good it is. It made me excited when I finally got the album in the generator. However, all that talk definitely overhyped the album for me. Overall I thought the album was just ok. I can appreciate how raw and stripped back the sound is and while I wouldn't put it in my "debut albums that sound like a debut" folder, the songs did get kind of samey as the album went on. Thankfully its a short album so it never truly got boring and I thought there were some catchy songs on it. Shout out to "Someday" for being on the soundtrack to a sports video game I played back in the day. 3/5

Pretty awesome to get one of my favorite bands and albums of all time. Second time this week that’s happened. Will do a re listen but I’ve listened to this album and these songs on playlists regularly for about 20 years now. This is the Strokes at their early garage rock. It’s simpler but it rocks and defines their sound and an entire genre of indie and alt rock that emerged around this time. This album is great. The two guitars, the constant simple drums. Julian Casablanca’s vocal style. To me, this is a classic no skips album. And considering this is 25 years old now, I guess it’s entering “classic rock” for younger generations today. The two notable standouts are Last Nite and Someday, two timeless rock classics. But it’s filled with awesome songs. Hard to Explain, Barely Legal, Soma, Alone Together, Trying Your Luck. It has a distinct defined sound. The songs all go so well together. Everything works. Thematically, it reminds you of being just a young person in your 20s living life. This album never gets old. Always holds up and a comfort listen whenever want something that I know will entertain me. 5/5. 10/10.

Ну хуй знает скучненько+однообразненько

I didn’t listen to the strokes much and after relistening to this I feel the same. It’s not bad, but nothing special either.

The pinnacle of indie-sleaze - it was all down hill from here.

I went into this expecting an overhyped mediocre album. I was wrong. This is fun, witty and quite good. I suspect it suffered under the weight of expectations. Not sure if it will become part of my regular rotation, but very enjoyable 4/5

Очень круто, обожаю такой индирок 2000ых, круто

Really close to giving this 5 stars because I love this album so much. In the end there isn't quite enough diversity or envelope pushing for me to get it there, but an easy 4.5.

Ok, I have to admit that it’s great to have straight forward rock record on here, as this list could use more of them. That said, this record was far from amazing. I tended to focus on the bass a lot throughout this record and found it pretty repetitive. Not that it was horrible, but some of the best parts of this felt similar to some of The Killers debut record (yes, I know, Hot Fuss came later), but that album had two absolute bangers on it in Mr. Brightside and Somebody Told Me. This record doesn’t have anything that approaches either of those tracks. I see that the ratings on this are pretty high, but I just don’t see (hear) it. It’s solid, but unspectacular.

I like garage rock.

That was much better than I expected. I expected crappy Brit pop.

Pretty incredible debut album. Genre defining.

The first and most iconic Strokes album. All songs are great.

I enjoyed it. Not much good or bad to say.

Put this on for my listening proj and was like "awww, this takes me back" and my girlfriend said very sweetly, "Oh, did you used to hang out with these guys?" (because I used to hang out with some much much much less famous bands). That got me talking* about how the Strokes could only kind of have existed at their exact moment – when the whole of music was suddenly download-available online but before that reality had got mundane; when we somehow thought we needed a bunch of trust fund kids with overly considered hair to play psychopomp to the whole white boy canon history of music, post-90s version (i.e. reflective of punk and its progeny, more than stoner bands or whatnot), to give it the imprimatur of "right now" and make us feel like we were cool-party-goers and not weedy archivists. The early hipster era, in other words. Soon we would all be weedy archivists, and then we'd stop caring, or realize all our built-up cultural capital was worthless, or just get satiated or whatever, as the streaming era's impoverishment of musical cathexes started to bite. But in the meantime, wasn't this fun, didn't it, for a "New York minute"** or so, sound good? *(Spare a moment to hope our dynamic doesn't slide in the direction of some age-disparate couples, with me smoking my pipe and lecturing her on Joy Division and her rolling her eyes and maybe composing her "I need time to think, I've taken the kids to my parents' to look at memes" note in her head.) **(In honour of the currently (Sept 2026) very recent "Ed Sheeran Macklemore Palestinegate" I looked up the half-remembered "New York City Cops" controversy after 9/11 and was saddened to find the group did not defiantly continue to play the song after the attacks, but meekly dropped it from their setlist "at this sensitive time." One obvious lesson of that backwardlooking, decadent, self-centred musical moment – or dare I say decade, encompassing the later hipster era's Win Butlers and Crystal Castles and other monsters – of course being, don't look to musicians for your politics, if anything the reverse! True now as it was then, but now we squirm corporately and try to hide it, like Ed.)

Fantastic! More like this please.

The guitars sound like they’re wearing headphones on a train. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - Someday - Last Nite - Hard to Explain

Good but not inspiring. Someday, alone together, and last nite were favorites

peak debut

Saw this band on Conan and Julian Casablancas was so nauseatingly fuccboi hipster that I just couldn’t even hear the music. Which is a shame, because they have a great rhythm section. The guitarist steals from more than just Tom Petty, and they just sound so…constructed. There are too many great bands out there not being drowned in money to think about this one too much.

Boring brit pop, but nice album cover

This and Room on Fire are brilliant albums. Someday, Hard to Explain, Modern Age.. such a good album. Very good and influential. Good job nepo babies.

Brilliant

Good. Interesting cover switchup

Album #198: The Strokes – Is This It? ⭐⭐⭐⭐ A modern classic that doesn’t feel that old, but actually is up on its 25th birthday. Which is crazy to think. So, it is old, but it still sounds modern. One of the great New York albums, in my opinion, and we know there’s a fuckload of them, so that’s a pretty impressive feat. For me, it’s never been a five-star album. It can be a little bit patchy. There could be a few forgettable tracks on it, like Trying Your Luck and Soma. Really, those two tracks. I probably remember everything else just by looking at the track listing. I think Is This It? is an intentionally weak song at the start because this was such a hyped album when it came out. It’s real tongue-in-cheek. So that definitely gets a pass. I think that’s a pretty genius opener. This lowkey, average, forgettable song, but memorable for the context around it. Look, they’re a great band. They’re a grooves band. They have great riffs, vocals, lyrics and a real swagger to them. They do feel like an important band when you’re listening to them. They’re fun. They’re funny. They’re cool. They’re New York. They feel very New York. I never liked the Television comparison with this band. I don’t hear Television at all, and I hold Television in the highest reverence. They are more akin to The Velvet Underground, with a little bit of the Ramones in there. But to be honest with you, it’s probably a better compliment to say that they’re just their own thing. They really did kind of create their own sound with this. But if I had some reservations, it wouldn’t really be their fault. To me, this album kick-started the noughties indie scene in a way. And I think this was the precursor to indie landfill music. I went to school during this period, through the noughties, and there wasn’t much to do other than watch music channels when you were at home. And the amount of absolutely god-fucking-awful indie music that just came out during this era, I think you can bring it all back to this album. People trying to write Someday by The Strokes, and failing miserably at it. Because the thing about The Strokes is it sounds deceptively simple. Simple kind of rhythms, simple guitar lines, but if you actually listen, this is pretty complicated stuff. And it’s got a swagger. It’s got a sway inside it that most bands can’t manage. They really are a very unique band in that sense. Average musicians can imitate them fairly easily, but you’re going to come up with a pale comparison most every time. And I think a lot of indie bands tried to imitate The Strokes and fell flat on their face. But that didn’t stop them from becoming popular because, at the time, the girls loved indie landfill, young lads loved it too and they wanted to go to the gigs. A lot of shit bands became popular because of this sound that I think The Strokes kind of created at the start of the century. So I do kind of hate this album for that. It’s not really their fault, though, that they made such an influential piece of work. This is miles better than anything that came after it, in my opinion.

Boring and unmemorable.

Is This It The Strokes 2001 Genres: Rock Styles: Alternative Rock, Garage Rock, Indie Rock 1. Is This It (★★★★★) -Contexto: Casablancas compuso la canción sin estribillo y lo improvisó al final ("I'll wing it"). Es la balada/tema título del disco: retrata el after de una noche de fiesta, el hastío y la ambivalencia hacia una relación ("Can't you see I'm trying? I don't even like it"). Funciona como resumen tonal de todo el álbum: displicencia, cansancio urbano y una pregunta retórica sobre si "esto es todo lo que hay". 2. The Modern Age (★★★★☆) -Contexto: Según fuentes biográficas del propio proceso de composición, es "un lamento sobre lo extraño de la vida moderna". Tono desconfiado y a la vez con un estribillo coreable; Casablancas mezcla el hastío con energía punk-pop. 3. Soma (★★★★★) -Contexto: Toma su nombre y su idea central de la droga ficticia de la novela "Un mundo feliz" de Aldous Huxley. Casablancas usa la referencia para hablar del consumo de drogas como forma de encajar con "la gente cool", una crítica velada a la presión social y el escapismo. -Fav 4. Barely Legal (★★★⯨☆) -Contexto: Casablancas mismo reconoció en 2018 que la canción "le da un poco de vergüenza" hoy, calificándola de "sassy and youthful". La letra trata de una chica que acaba de llegar a la edad de consentimiento, con un tono provocador y desafiante ("I just wanna misbehave, I just wanna be your slave"). El baterista Fabrizio Moretti pidió no sobre-interpretarla: "debe tomarse como cada uno la interprete". 5. Someday (★★★★★) -Contexto: Habla de la nostalgia anticipada de la juventud: sabe que un día van a extrañar "los viejos tiempos" aunque los estén viviendo con incertidumbre ahora. Tono agridulce, hecho con aire rockabilly. -Fav -Frisson 6. Alone, Together (★★★☆☆) -Contexto: Continúa el costado sexual del disco (con insinuaciones hacia el sexo oral, según reseñas biográficas del álbum). En términos generales retrata una conexión física sin compromiso emocional real, resumida en la frase "Alone we stand, together we fall apart". 7. Last Nite (★★★★★) -Contexto: Narra a un chico que deja a su novia después de que ella le dice que se siente mal porque él no la registra ("it turns me off when I feel left out"); él después empieza a deprimirse y a cuestionar sus propias decisiones. Casablancas reconoció abiertamente que la canción "está basada" en "American Girl" de Tom Petty ("sí, la afanamos"). -Fav 8. Hard to Explain (★★★★☆) -Contexto: El propio título indica el tema: la dificultad de poner en palabras un estado emocional contradictorio, alternando el dirigirse a una pareja y el cuestionarse a sí mismo/al mundo, con frustración y confusión sobre el rumbo de su vida. 9. New York City Cops (★★★★☆) [Nota: reemplazada por "When It Started" en el CD de EE.UU. tras el 11-S; en el vinilo estadounidense y en todas las ediciones internacionales se mantuvo esta versión] -Contexto: Casablancas la describió como "una canción abiertamente política", escrita en reacción al asesinato en 1999 de Amadou Diallo, inmigrante guineano desarmado al que la policía de Nueva York le disparó 41 veces (los oficiales fueron absueltos). El estribillo ("New York City cops, they ain't too smart") es una crítica directa a la brutalidad policial, envuelta en una historia de fondo sobre una chica (Nina) y una noche de comportamiento al límite de lo legal. 10. Trying Your Luck (★★★☆☆) -Contexto: Es, según reseñas de la época, el punto "más melancólico" del disco, con una voz más apagada y vulnerable que en el resto del álbum. Sigue la línea de relaciones que no terminan de funcionar, en un tono más resignado que el resto de las canciones. 11. Take It or Leave It (★★★★★) -Contexto: Cierra el disco con una postura de hastío hacia el juego de las relaciones: "Girls lie too much / Boys are too tough / Enough is enough". Casablancas tapa la vulnerabilidad con una fachada de arrogancia (comparada por la crítica con la actitud temprana de Mick Jagger), lamentando vínculos que no llevan a ningún lado pero tampoco se terminan de ir. -Fav -TOTAL = ★★★★⯨ (4,23)

melhor disco da decada

Is This It was a much more enjoyable album than i was expecting. I haven't really heard much of The Strokes outside of one of their newer songs Going Shopping (that song sucks by the way) and it left a bad taste in my mouth with them but after hearing this. I can understand why they are so loved. The musicianship might not seem too special on the surface but for what it is, it is some very good stuff especially when it comes to those guitars. The vocals were also pretty decent but they were not really my favorite vocals. The album was very well paced though and was still more than enjoyable enough to be a 4 star album. Best Song: Alone, Together Worst Song: The Modern Age

I loved this! So much fun to listen to in headphones while out and about. It'll make it onto party mixes, too. Yet another band I had heard of but never got around to listen to. What a treat! (PS: I was glad to see they changed the album cover)

Day978 - twenty-five years later and it still sounds good

Starts off boring and derivative but the singles are really catchy. This was said to be one of the most influential albums ever. I think because lots of people copied a band that made a living out of copying great 1970s bands and that is the definition of post punk revival. To be generous there was probably not a lot else going on musically in early 2000s.

Uzpiso biski kad grynai viskas bent kazkiek distorition turejo, bet vistiek fire, live versijos tuo laikotarpiu labiau patinka tho

Ugh. Classic. The kind of band that makes me wish I was a cooler alt girl.

Some great riffs but vocals are really weak

It’s good, not great. Sure, art-rock fans and critics love it, but it’s just a good commercial rock record, not the "new thing" or anything groundbreaking or innovative. Listening to it again certainly didn’t change my opinion of this record as one of the most overrated debuts ever or the band as just short of Oasis and The Killers as the biggest “critics-choice” shoved down our throats as the next “important” rock band.

I like for albums to sound good. This is a muddy mess with some of the worst drum sounds I've ever heard. Had this album been done by DSardy or Andy Wallace instead of Gordon Raphael it would probably be a classic. Last Nite is such a great track that it slams even though it sounds like your speakers are positioned face down as you play it. 3 stars.

Idk back in the day it hit alot better

HOW is this so old what a bloody dream

Boring and grating.

Classic rock with a modern edge and a strangely raw feeling.

I think, throughout history, there are very few albums that have been as influential as this one. There are more influential artists, no doubt, but as far as a single release that changed the way things are done, this is in a very select club. And sometimes, things are just influential because they did something for the first time (or because they were the first white guys to do a genre of black music), but this is influential cause its just that good. It's not just about the music, though the music is really good, but it was about the way they carried themselves. It's about how cool they were. They made rock that teenagers could put on to upset their parents, and they brought rock back into a place of being genuinely inventive and interesting. Favorites: Is This It, The Modern Age, Hard to Explain

this is it

This was an album that went from downloaded & burned onto a CD to loaded onto the old ipod, and I spent a lot of time with it. Listening after a few decades, I definitely knew all the beats, all the lyrics, and all the little details I liked. I'm still not positive it deserved all the credit it received at the time, but it's definitely a big part of my music listening history.

I got jump scared by the song I recognized but otherwise....fine

Aika perus garage rokkia. Eipä tästä sillein mitään sanottavaa, oli hyviä ja huonoja kappaleita. Parhaat: Trying Your Luck, Someday, Last Nite

It's a good album. It's just not really my style, so I didn't get envolved by it, maybe I'll like it more when I listen to it a few more times.

Buenos temas, no mucho mas que decir, es rhe strokes

Low-end 4. Liked the disaffected vibe for the most part, highest on Hard to Explain and Trying Your Luck

Fantastic album. Concise, catchy, and a sound that’s instantly nostalgic

This album when first released sounded to me like nobody else and everyone else at the same time. Short so it doesn’t outstay its welcome and yet it is long enough to get you going and want to play it again.

I’ve always been a peripheral fan of The Strokes and have never listened to a full length album. I really enjoyed this project. It was an interesting experience for it made me unexpectedly nostalgic. This was not the type of music I listened to in high school yet it brought me back to that period of time into the life of somebody I wasn’t. Haha it made me think of smoking cigarettes with my friend while chilling at the skate park none of which is something I did. Anyway, Julian Casablancas voice is wonderful and fits this genre perfectly. Highly recommend this album to anyone.

A better than just decent album with good songs, angular riffs and a sound that takes you back to the 70s. I had fun.

I got this back to back with the Stooges which makes sense. Loved this album when I found it (a bit late circa 2009) and I still love it today. immediately transported back to my first trip to Amsterdam at age 19

I'm not a fan of The Strokes, the album is ok in my opinion.

The impact of The Strokes' debut cannot be overstated. At the time of its release, this record pretty much killed whatever remained of 90's rock and ushered in a new era of the genre, the Indie Rock boom, more specifically, Garage Rock and Post-Punk revivals. Of course, "indie rock" already existed, it was "invented" by the Velvet Underground back in the 60's, but with The Strokes the concept gained a whole new dimension and popularity. And speaking of the Velvets, they're a clear influence here, maybe not in the music per se, but in The Strokes' whole sunglasses and leather jacked-wearing, 2cool4skool attitude. The music itself is incredible. Not in a technical way, in fact the exact opposite. These are simple songs. They song pretend to be other than simple and straightforward. But in their simplicity lies the genius of such efficient songwriting. The instrumentation is also simple but effective, with repetitive little riffs all over the record. Julian Casablancas's delivery oozes cool and an energy that influenced the entire decade. And then we have the hooks. And there are hooks for days in these songs, which is saying something, considering how short on average they are. Thoroughly recommended. Key tracks: Is This It Soma Barely Legal Someday Alone, Together Last Nite New York City Cops Trying Your Luck Take It or Leave It

Typical early millennial pop rock. Not much to distinguish one track from another, let alone anything that really sets them apart from other bands of the era.

Listening to this album, it seems the tactic they use with “Last Night” (utilizing the intro to “American Girl”) is not an aberration but their formula. Most of these songs sound vaguely, at some point, like some other great tune. Having said that, the songs are catchy and don’t overstay their welcome.

I enjoyed the album for the most part but I’m not a fan of the distorted vocals. My only experience with the band before this was their most popular single on this album. I don’t see myself looking at their other albums unless they pop up as a recommendation

One of my all time favs, straight bangers

I quite enjoyed this album at the time but it all seems pretty unremarkable listening now. They led that skinny-jeaned, tousle-haired, trust-fund, 'indie' scene of the early 2000s but it all feels very contrived and manufactured now. The bass playing remains the real standout feature of their sound and I've just read that the bass player is the only one not to come from a wealthy, privileged background. No, I don't know what my point is either.

Never really got the Strokes. Listening now it's perfectly decent indie guitar pop. It's OK. Not much more really.

An old fav of mine. I must admit, however, it doesn't hold up well in comparison to similarly-genred albums on this list. I think it's because The Strokes are very easy listening. Very inoffensive, blend together, sit in the back ground tracks. Julian has a good voice but it does become quite samesy pretty quickly. There's not much risk taken or much experimenting being done. Couple of classic bangers on this album elevate the rating for me though.

I liked a couple of songs but I have this feeling the music all starts to sound the same

can he please stop screaming and can the bassist start his own band please

uhhh interesting album cover…I have been meaning to listen to the strokes tho I really do not like how the vocals are so muted I can barely hear what he’s saying 😭 ok I really like all the electric guitars especially on the modern age, barely legal, and hard to explain. I would enjoy these songs so much more if it didn’t sound like the recorded the vocals, put it on a cd, put the cd in a barely functioning cd player and then played the cd as everyone played their instruments, recorded that and then used it as the final track Yeah I’m conflicted on this one. On one hand I love the instrumentals of the songs and on the other the vocals bother me so much. I don’t even know if I would want to listen again, maybe I would get used to how his voice sounds after a few listens but idk everything else was great tho 2.51/5

Love this album but Room on Fire does this better for me. Mainly there’s a couple on here that I just think are ok: Alone Together, Trying My Luck, and Take It or Leave It. But given the cultural landscape at the times I can understand this being on here and rated higher and it’s still such a fun album.

Quite dull. Just guitar strumming sounding the exact same all the way through.

Good album, not my favourite of theirs but still a decent listen.

Own the US version with a different album cover, which used to live in my Jetta's CD changer. It was a gift from Michael Calomino in high school.

This is a good album to get into the Strokes. The music isn't near as crude as the cover.

This run of albums this week is literally giving me life. This was so good, indie rock at its best Playlist add: “Last Nite” because old habits die hard

I’ve heard it before! Saw the strokes last weekend so it’s a bit ironic to see this as my first pull. It’s a good album

Last Nite Hard to Explain New York City Cops Take it or Leave It

Is This It Last Nite New York City Cops

Upon my first listen of this album, I was disappointed, it seemed fairly generic and was weaker than some of the bands that they would later inspire. However, now that I have relistened with greater knowledge surrounding The Strokes and their music, it's safe to say that this is one of the greatest albums of the 2000s! My favourite tracks were 'Is This It', 'Someday', 'Last Nite', 'Hard To Explain' and - surprisingly - 'Trying Your Luck'! I remember not particularly enjoying 'The Modern Age', despite it frequently being cited as a highlight from the album, but even on my relisten, I struggled to see the appeal, it was the one of the least interesting on the album! I don't think that there were any tracks that I disliked, but 'New York City Cops' is probably the least brilliant. Sadly, I don't really enjoy any of The Strokes' work after this, I particularly don't love 'Room On Fire' even though it's considered equal or superior to this album.

Nice early 2000's indie rock record. Last Nite is a favorite of mine. Good, catchy rock music.

geit eso

I don't know why but I just don't like The Strokes at all.

Defined the 2000s? Absolute ripper album.

Hadn’t heard this before but it was pretty good! A quality rock album, nice guitar work

Really good. Sparse but so catchy, everything is in the right place.

First half is a 3, second half is a 4.

so ripe for the time. this album is 2001 rock music. it might not sound nearly as fresh and pure as it did back then, but this album laid the groundwork for 2000s cool indie rock music

ik vind het leuk, maar klopt op zich wel dat veel mensen zeggen dat t allemaal op elkaar lijkt. ze hebben een beetje een soort liedje dat wel heel goed werkt, maar blijven het opnieuw doen

Its okay. Is this the start of my white boy era ?

Best Track - "Last Nite"

It’s a nice, fun, energetic album. It’s nothing extraordinary, but it’s not bad either. If you’re in the mood for something upbeat, you’ll probably enjoy it.

really enjoyable, probably my first rock album and its great 4/5

I have heard actually a lot about the strokes. I thought they were a lot older with how much their influence is talked about. Sounds like the killers tbh. Hmm. I don't like this. Boring indie rock. Which is crazy since this is THE boring indie rock but still. Meh. Wait no. Let em get up. This is good. Ok. Wait ok speak on it. God I knew the millennials were salivating at this. Wait today is the 25th anniversary of this album that's crazy. Good. Pivotal. Insufferable. Favourite: Barely Legal Least favourite: Take It Or Leave It

Best so far, great vocals, instrumental and thematic

This is pure NY rock

it was pretty fun oldschool album, i really liked it. this album changed early 2000s indie music

Primer album de ellos que escucho. Que onda las guitaras wtf, sexo. Me gusto mas la primera mitad. 3.5

I love this album. One of my favorite indie rock albums. Just recently saw the Strokes live at Outsidelands in San Francisco and had an amazing time start to finish. Take it or leave it with Charli was the cherry on top of the show. The closest they’ve come to replicating an album as good as this imo is The New Abnormal.

My older sister moved to NYC in 2002, when she was 21 and I was 19. I used to visit her every year until I moved there myself in 2010. She lived in the East Village and later in South Brooklyn, where I lived as well. I had so many great adventures there. This album reminds me of those times.

*all-time.

Oh... it had been a good 7 or 8 years since I last listened to this album. After listening to it today, I understand why: I didn't know how to appreciate it the first time I heard it, back when I was 16 or 17. *Is This It* sounds like everything great the 2000s had to offer, and it’s definitely in the Top 5 best albums of that decade. ***BRAZIL MENTIONED moment*** Fabrizio Moretti, the drummer, is a fellow Brazilian... BRAZIL MENTIONED!!!

como me gusta este album es uno de los que formo mi gusto musicañ además de ser la influencia de muchas bandas que me gustan

sentí q al final el álbum se descoordinó, me encantó tho

Něco mě baví hodně, něco o dost méně. Je to takové hodně repetetivní a asi na to ještě přijde nálada. Je to i dost hitové, ale superlativy bych tomu nedával. Už jsem měl uloženo v knihovně, takže jsem to už kdysi slyšel, ale to že si to nepamatuju jenom potvrzuje můj současný dojem.

Such a fun album with zero skips. Also had the pleasure to hear them live recently, which just enhanced the album listening experience today, loved it!

Yes, it is. This is it

This is good but not my favorite Strokes album!

this album came out when I was at the end of my twenties and obsessed with '60s garage rock and modern Brit pop. it was fun and kind of bratty and captured perfectly how I felt in that era. I could still happily dance to this entire album.

I cannot not give this album five stars, you have no idea how many times I have listened to it.

Third in a row I’ve liked a lot but feel I need to explore further to fall in love with it. I added “I Can’t Explain” to my playlist.

It's easy to hear why The Strokes burst onto the scene with tunes like this. But it's also hard for me to hear why this got the crazy reception it did. These songs are fun and punchy, with earwormy riffs. They're all also kind of midtempo and similar. The title track is a disappointingly lifeless intro. Things pick up from there, and tracks like "Someday" and "Last Nite" pick up the energy. Casablancas has an undeniably cool voice that injects the album with attitude. But there are too many songs that choose a riff and then stick with it without any surprises. "Alone, Together" starts with a really interesting riff that eventually gives way to more of the same. Count me as part of the group that prefers Room on Fire and finds the title of this one fitting when comparing its quality to its reputation.

im straight up stroking it to this one

It's quite good and was a lot of fun when it came out. Where's it going though?

It's a good album, but not really anything exceptional. Dozens of other albums by low-fi-ish guitar bands at that time, albeit the others didn't have such a distinctive album cover image.

The upbeat music really fits the vocal style and is really catchy. Liked the music and lead man’s voice. Really good!

Enjoyed the listen with Zach to SLO

rock great guitars amazing album

One of the big "The" bands of the early 2000s. I was never really a big fan of that scene. This album is fine. Middle of the road for me. 3/5

Not my bag but pretty enjoyable nonetheless. A higher 3.

Just about enough for a 4. Don't like the way the vocal are recorded.

It could have been a 5 just didn't feel like it today

Last Nite is such a bop

This shit sounds like high school for me. So good, so much nostalgia.

This album sounds like what the music the loser main character listens to at the start of the movie does For the period when this came, it wasn't anything special, however in the modern day it stands out pretty well from other simular projects such as idk because I only listen to kanye, 🤩 8/10

Already heard part of it. This is the classic sound of the 00s. Sayint this as a 94 boy, and talking nostalgic about this "modern" rock sound, its wild. I never digged the strokes, I still believe their sound is still a bit otoo similar between songs. Still a classic that reinvented the sound of a decade. and maybe the last "big" rock n roll band.

The epitome of my music taste.

Awesome album

Absolute classic

Always feels like I’m in a pincer movement when I listen to this album. Now I feel very nostalgic about it and that whole era of indie music, but at the time listening to it’s also instilled a strange nostalgia in me for experiences I, as a 15/16 year old, had yet to have. The effect remains pretty potent, even though I never thought the album was as great as others did at the time, and the Strokes’ subsequent career makes it feel like so much squandered promise.

11 songs in 35 minutes. The worst of these ('New York City Cops') is pretty great, and a big part (first five songs plus 'Last Night' and 'Hard to Explain') is as good as it gets. I have loved this album for 25 years now. An obvious 5 stars.

It wasn’t bad there were three songs I liked off the album

Obviously knew the singles from the time. But I enjoyed the album as a whole. Nothing major that makes me want to re listen but I liked it

A bit repetitive

Great album that I didn’t bother listening to until this year. Not sure it’s the absolute classic they say it is, but you probably had to be there.

Teenage me couldn’t get enough of this. If juice box was on this album it’d get a 5

is this it ? no, not really - didn't hate it but didn't really get much out of it either. couple of bangers but that's only really because even i know them

Full of nostalgia for me. We had some sort of Strokes compilation CD growing up (one of those free ones you used to get with newspapers) and we played it all the time via the PS1 (only CD player in the house for a while!). Lots of the songs are quite samey but they still somehow feel very fresh. Loved listening to this.

8.25/10 - Heavy nostalgia here, but I think it still holds up. The music that shaped my taste (outside of my parents) was the early 2000s Indie Rock. Franz Ferdinand, The Strokes, KOL, Arctic Monkeys, interpol, and Cage the Elephant all hold a special place in my heart.

A really great album that was paving the way for Indie/Garage rock in the early 2000's. The only complaint with this album is that it is a little one note, but that's being picky. 8/10

love the guitar but, I was middle of the road on this one.

This might just be how you do it. Catchy pop rock songs that don’t really do anything all that original but that sound good, have hooks for days, and are fun to listen to. Who cares if it’s not really breaking new ground if you are introducing a ton of kids who haven’t necessarily heard the Velvet Underground or Television or Blondie to a sound you love, and doing an excellent job of making that music new? Getting in and out in 35 minutes doesn’t hurt either. This is a really good pop-focused rock album.

Yeah, it still slaps. Better than I remembered even.

Good album for a house party or just to get fucking obliterated

I'm a long time listener of indie music and one of the things this list has taught me is that indie music might be kind of bad. One or two songs from this album is alright, but altogether it's repetitive and whiny. Sorry. I do like Is This It though ngl

What do I even say. High school wouldn’t have been the same without this record. Fun, cool, stylish and for a Texas guy in the early 2000s exactly the fantasy of New York you needed

They cracked the formula of having catchy songs that age well and don't burn you out.

Great album. Love Last Night, Someday, Soma. Very 2000s.

Banger, j'adore tous leurs albums je suis pas objective

Oui, oui, et oui. Je prends toujours mon temps à les écouter, encore aujourd’hui je n’ai probablement pas tout écouté ! Je les savoure C’est ma période lycée mais c’est surtout ces dernières années que je les écoute ++

Sympa mais sans plus

Better than I remembered. Quintessential apathetic hipster indie. Not really sure it will have staying power long term.

Velmi dober👍🏼

I know this was a pretty big deal but The Strokes never really grabbed me. Listening through this at last and I didn't really get the hype. It's fine but I don't think it's really doing anything that innovative. I think most people just wanted to look cool, fair play.

Maybe I'm just being a grouchy old man yelling at a cloud, but why do all of these early 2000s post-punk bands/albums sound the same? It's like they got the same guy to do all the half-sung vocals, the same musicians to play the repetitive, droning rhythms, the same producer to make everything sound like it's coming through an AM radio receiver. (The bass lines are occasionally interesting, though.) I can't tell the bands or the songs apart, and I honestly don't care enough to try. It sounds like the Strokes were one of the originators of this sound, so maybe it was original at the time? Good for them, I guess.

Music journalist Everett True once said no band improves on their debut album. Room on fire, the Strokes’ second album is better than this. 4/5

There is something really throwbacky about this band. Every time I see them come up on the radio I think they are from the 70s or 80s and I think wow they were somewhat progressive for their time. So one off I really like them. But after a while its just a little too much samey.

I thought I would rock with this more. But beyond the hits, it was just kinda muffly and mediocre.

judging the album by its cover - hot

Love this album

This is the most bog standard album from the 00s, incredibly monotonous and tiresome. Nothing special.

Tror det är så här alla band idag vill låta.

You can really hear why this record prompted the once-a-decade guitar music bounce. Effortless cool.

Still hits hard. Great album

Up there with some of my favourite debut albums. Great catchy songs with a pretty unique (at the time) sound. Great listen.

I really liked it to start, but after Last Nite it kind of tapered off and went from a 4 to a 3

pretty good but I've not seen this cover before. it's better than the other one on Spotify 4/5

Heel leuk, maar.niet memorabel

Breath of fresh air when it landed. Holds up brilliantly well. Great album. For once the trendy & hip "it" band were actually as good as the hype. 4.5

4.35. Liked a lot. Love the influence it gave attic monkeys etc

no skips, short and sweet, i can't see the reason make a fuzz about it being bad.

Trochę monotonna? Równocześnie zbyt intensywna. Ma piosenki, które znam i które mi siedzą, ale inne gdzieś się gubią. Chcę być bardziej obecna, ten album tego nie ułatwił, ale ma spoko okładkę. Lubię ten czerwony tytuł.

I'll always think of Weird Al when I hear LAST NIGHT (wudja do?) - his polka has ruined so much - but honestly reviewing The Strokes, the album is fun, peppy and still a depressing enough tone to be cool. A little one note I might nitpick. I liked When It Started, Someday is the classic go-to I feel like, Barely Legal and Alone, Together were good, Take or Leave it to close was solid

Okay so I've honestly never listened to an entire The Strokes album, and I've also always kinda conflated them with The Shins (and The Smiths, if we're being honest). Maybe one day I'll remember which The S_____s band if which. This album was a lot of fun though. I can't remember which track it was, but there was a riff that was a whole lot like the riff from Reptilia, which I only know from Guitar Hero 2, but apparently that's on their next album. I get why people like them so much; it's a really fun and poppy but with a raw overall tone.

Great album start to finish. Assumed this was a 4 star before starting but found myself enjoying almost every song.

Brilliant album, and very influential.

I get the feeling the Strokes has been overhyped to me prior to listening and that has resulted in this feeling of dissapointment listening to this. I mean, I always heard they were a band on the cutting edge of style and this is just very much ordinary indie rock from the 2000s. I could hear it alongside Peter Bhorn and John on an advert and it wouldn't stand out to me.

Sympathique

Already one of my favorite albums from before I got this generator 🫪 I feel like The Strokes never disappoints with anything they've released.

I like the songs, but the (intentionally) bad production isn't my cup of tea. Especially the vocals are abrasive and I keep asking myself his you can sound so bored while constantly screaming? The bass guitar is really nice, though.

#428/1001. 2nd hyped band in a row (after the Vines). Last Nite is of course a classic, and Hard to Explain especially when mashed up with Genie in a bottle (a Stroke of Genius), but most of the record starts to repeat itself in a way, which gets tedious in a wrong way (nit the Ramones way that is).

Is that it? Take it or leave it? I will leave it thanks

Excellent album, such an iconic sound for the time

classic. can’t say i’ve really kept up with the strokes, but this was a jam.

Боже, как я обожаю этот альбом... До сих пор помню, как впервые его услышал, уже лет 20 назад. Спасибо Guitar Hero и песне Reptilia за то, что я узнал об этой группе и решил скачать все 3 (на тот момент) альбома. И их дебютник произвел на меня сильнейшее впечатление. Вероятно, это был вообще первый инди-альбом, который я услышал. После классик-рока и поп-панка, которые я тогда слушал, это был глоток альтушного воздуха. А какова обложка, как же стилево. Как кайфово, что дали повод переслушать, еще и в пятницу, когда приподнятое настроение. Ну и как не упомянуть влияние этого альбома на индустрию - именно с него началась волна garage rock revival и post-punk revival групп, многие из которых сами по себе стали культовыми и подарили множество незабываемых треков. Перефразируя классика, вся история развития человечества была нужна для того, чтобы Джулиан Касабланкас написал Someday и Last Nite.

Давайте уже устроим флешбом, поставим все 5 и закончим этот челлендж на высокой ноте ахаха

не хватает автотюна, потому - 4

never got into this sound. all sounds pretty samey to me

This is an absolute indie classic with some great tunes, but at the same time it feels quite one note to me and there's a few tracks that don't feel standout. It's a good album, borderline very good, but I'd definitely have a couple of other Strokes albums over this one.

Nothing special but decent listening.

The Strokes are a difficult band for me to write about, not because I can't form an opinion on them, but because everything about them is fairly straightforward, especially on Is This It. Their upbeat, polished style of garage rock is very meat-and-potatoes, and I mean that as a compliment. The hooks are sharp, the guitars are catchy, and the drums are energetic. Julian Casablancas is a very charismatic frontman, and while his sleazily cool persona can sometimes feel like a performance, it's a performance he puts on effectively. If there's one issue I have with this album, it's that the sound is a bit too uniform. Given that it's only 35 minutes, this isn't a massive problem, but it's difficult to pick out standout moments when every song sounds more or less the same. Regardless, it's still a very likeable album, and I'll never complain when it's on.

Some very good songs on here and I like the overall sound of the album. Just a bit too much of the same when you get closer to the end.

Good album, but I'm surprised I liked it less than I thought I would. I usually think of myself as a pretty big The Strokes fan, and this was a pleasant listen, but I can't give it more than four stars. What's wrong with it? It's hard to pin down, not sure I could say. I love the chugging rhythms, the prominent basslines, the confident delivery from Casablancas. I even gave it a second run-through to try and work out what didn't *quite* click. Maybe it's just not quite the sum of its parts. Maybe it's in that awkward space between too punk and not punk enough. I don't know, here we are. Four stars. Fav tracks: Barely Legal, Last Night, Take It Or Leave It,

I dig this. 4/5

Probably should be 4 stars but fond memories of this being daughters first ‘ best record ever’ and seeing them with her in London. Grat show great album

Didn't even need to listen to this bad boy, cause I know like every song by heart. Even just saw them in concert like a month ago. I know this album didn't reinvent rock or anything, but it didn't need to. It's just good music. Will always be one of my fav albums of all time, and is never not the mood. Just so versatile and listenable (and relistenable). Love the minimal production on it, sounds a bit grunge-y in that sense (RIP NYC Cops). No notes, just will be listening to this forever and ever.

It’s good but the songs all sound the same