Reviews (page 10 of 12)
Have I heard this album before? How do I recognize so many of the songs? Not bad, not my thing.
This one didn’t do that much for me. There’s good songs and moments (The piano was unexpected but cool), but the mediocre songs level them out more. It’s kind of boring and not that fun to listen to. It’s just mid, not much else to say.
Probably my least favourite White stripes album, it has its charm but the rocky garage edge is gone, it's offering us Werther's originals when we wanted Mountain Dew Code red.
Conceptualmente es muy interesante, se vuelve muy pesado al final. Se escucha muy lindo igualmente, destaco las guitarras sobre todo. Diria que es un disco solido, pero no creo volver a escucharlo conscientemente
not really my thing
Not my favorite White Stripes album but there are some really good songs here.
A bit of a miss for me compared to their previous two excellent records. It still had some great songs, and I liked the change to more piano and acoustic based songs, but the songwriting just wasn't up to snuff sometimes, and Jack's singing bordered on annoying in places. Also, why is Michael Cera dressed up as Jack White on the cover?
A mix of songs I really liked (Blue Orchid, The Denial Twist, Take Take Take, As Ugly As I Seem, Im Lonely), and then a few I really didn't like. So this one lands right in the middle for me. The overall album wasn't super cohesive.
Solid album. Good 70's style blues rock. First time I ever noticed how much his voice sounds like Robert Plant. A little long, a few tracks could've been left off.
As I get older I really appreciate artists who don't confine themselves to one particular genre and have an obvious love of music. I dont think is my favorite TWS album, but I always appreciate Jack's artistry even if I find him a little much as a person. Also, everyone needs to leave Meg alone. She rules.
all songs sounds the same😬
Interesting sound, not a huge standout for me but nice to listen to.
Honestly never been a fan of The White Stripes but I understand and respect the talent; just not for me. 5/10.
I agree with the other two albums, White Blood Cells and Elephant, being on the list, but if I was to pick a third it would be either their self titled debut or De Stijl rather than this one. I feel like they were losing the plot a little bit in their final two albums, this one and Icky Thump. For me, the album never really gains momentum. I of course say all this as a fan who has listened to all the albums many times, and the criticism comes from a place of love. But even my favorite songs on this album are not among my favorite White Stripes songs.
Not listenable but a few good tunes
The rock stuff is pretty good. Otherwise all of it is a bit to slow.
It's ok. Too long and I don't think more than one White Stripes album needs to be on the 1001 album list.
I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet)
Always thought this album was a bit of a disappointment after the masterpiece of Elephant. Still, not a bad bit of music.
Driving, rambling, jangly. Surprising amount of marimbas
It's alright. Some good guitar but grating at points.
One of white stripes more mediocre albums, blue orchid is good though
Not bad
Enjoyed but not as much as Elephant.
Weirdo's die witte strepen. But I can dig it.
Er staan een paar fijne nummers op deze plaat!
3+
It was okay. I think it’s a little too hard for my taste. 3 out of 5
Ugh Meg
🌓 Great start but gets too slow and boring. Take, take, take saves it a bit.
Satan?
7/10. Pretty good rock album but nothing made me go "WOW!"
Favs: - ▫️Blue Orchid
I like The White Stripes and I think they were a huge part of the 2000's indie sleaze/rock scene, but this album was just meh for me. A couple of bangers but the filler just doesn't do anything for me. Jack White sounds like he's talking about high school problems with the amplified power that the band had after White Blood Cells/Elephant dropped. Idk, this album is ok. I wouldn't put it on except for Blue Orchid
Has lots of different instruments they use, not really consistent but some good songs here and there. Love the vocals though
The White Stripes go acoustic! Favorite songs: as ugly as it seems; Blue Orchid and Little Ghost. The marimba, acoustic guitar are markers. The style is very Jack White, but the acoustic vibe is good Anna welcome change. The range as a musician is insane. Meg is always underrated and her voice on Passive Manipulation was enjoyable.
This album is the perfect musical equivalent of a golf course you tough out the front nine specifically to be able to play the back nine. The album starts out great with "Blue Orchid" but then falls into a disjointed mess for the first half of the album. Meg's "Passive Manipulation" signals a change. The second half of the album flows exceedingly well and ends on one of, arguably, the greatest garage rock songs of the early 2000s.
My first reaction was "too many White Stripes LPs on this list." I gave it a listen - eventually - and there was some decent stuff on here
Some bangers but otherwise nothing jumped out
Prefer the more raw sound of their earlier albums, this has a lot of interesting ideas and use of negative aural space, but it just doesn't totally hit me in an emotional way. That being said, the last two songs are PHENOM. Favorite track: Red Rain, I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet)
Blue Orchid naar The Nurse is een hele rare overgang, wtf. Ik dacht eerst dat ik gebeld werd ofzo. Het is sowieso een heel ander album dan Elephant die we eerder gehoord hebben van hun. Minder pure rock en veel meer melodiën eigenlijk. Weet nog niet zo goed welk album ik prettiger vind. Ik snap dit album niet zo goed eerlijk gezegd. Het gaat alle kanten op, het is totaal niet de rock die The White Stripes bekend maakte, het is super experimenteel. Ik kan me heel goed voorstellen dat mensen die fan zijn van The White Stripes die een absolute verschrikking van een album vinden. Het loopt nou niet echt lekker door ofzo. Ik vind de kleinere nummers lekkerder wegluisteren dan de geluidsorkanen die sommige van hun nummers zijn. FAVO: My Doorbell, As ugly as I seem
Poeh, nog meer White Stripes, kan ik dit aan? Eerst nummer is volgens mij heel bekend en ook wel erg lekker catchy en uptempo! Nummer daarna is direct een terugval op wat ik al eerder van ze gehoord heb, te depri voor mij Ik vind dit album een stuk beter dan Elephant, puur omdat er wat meer pit en tempo in zit. Desalniettemin vind ik alle zang maniertjes en intonaties van Jack White gewoon vermoeiend. Wederom een rock album wat ik snel zal vergeten. Favorieten: Blue Orchid, Doorbell
Alright but has skips
I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet)
you have to admire jack white’s passion but he’s such a perfectionist he squeezed all the life out of this record
Not near as good as Elephant, but a few highlights
Eh it feels like a collection of demos
Another band that’s I’ve heard a lot of songs, but this was the first full album I listened to in its entirety. Dig the simplicity of the production, the seeming spontaneity of the music, and the overall force of the music. Surprisingly tender on a few tracks, especially the closer. Like Ringo, Meg White provides just what the song needs, and plays with heart and soul but isn’t showy or overbearing (except on My Doorbell, but obviously intentional).
Wavy instrumentals for a rock album Really strong start on first 2 songs Doorbell song is a bit weak Overall a bit odd, not what I was expecting Not bad, not great, not something I would have on my playlist
Not bad, but I'm a little surprised this is on the list. I haven't listened to all of their albums, but I've yet to hear one that was better than their debut, which seems like representation enough for a list like this.
Better than I expected
Interesting but still 3*
I liked this White Stripes album much better than White Blood Cells. A lot more unique, experimental, and varied.
3.5 stars
Solid album. Some real high points like “Take, Take, Take,” but also some forgettable moments that I was tempted to skip.
Was definitely a white stripes album
A couple of good songs, one great one in My Doorbell, and a bunch of filler. Forgettable even the moment it ends.
Buen disco de rock suave con guitarras armoniosas y buena voz. Bien compuesto, aunque le falta algo para hacerlo más diferenciador
2.5
Liked the popular singles. Denial twist stood out from the song I didn't know
Macht Spaß. Wenig punkig (wie die Vorgänger), aber gut verspielt und zum Kopfnicken.
Very early 2000s sounding. Nostalgic for sure.
My fav songs were all ones that felt like classic White Stripes, like Blue Orchid, or were trying to sound like a specific genre, like Little Ghost being a country song. The choice of instrumentation in a lot of songs is weird, and just feels like Jack White got bored or is intentionally trying to distance himself from what made The White Stripes successful
More folksy than I thought it would be, but fantastic lyrics.
Nah
A few songs I really don't like, but most of the album is pretty enjoyable overall.
OK, didn't really stand out to me. Reminds me of how I felt the first time I heard Elephant. Maybe re-visiting this 10+ years later I will have the same "Wow, what was I thinking?" experience.
Meh
Not their strongest album by any means. Not sure how this makes it into this list. It’s solid enough but at this point in their career the best was behind them.
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would there is a couple of awful songs on this but generally a decent album that I would play again
I think I’ve got album fatigue so it’s hard to rate them. Can’t say I’m a huge fan but the album was alright. 3*
One
I enjoyed and was happy to leave the album on repeat. Not a go-to band for me but didn’t kick them out of my head.
UN bon album de rock alternatif, mais je suis vraiment pas fait pour le son des White Stripes. Pas que je n'aime pas ça, mais ça ne me fait pas tellement vibrer. Mais je peux certainement comprendre l'attrait. C'était un album très bien fait. 6/10
Fine listen but never really feel like listening to too much of The White Stripes.
bien
Heard it before?: Yes Enjoy it?: I do, very similar sounds throughout out with the looping/bouncy drums compared to their other records Favourite song: Track 1 - Blue Orchid
I was going to give this a 2 but I thought that might be too harsh. The reason is that I love The White Stripes, I think literally all of their other albums are some of the best that 2000s rock has to offer, but this one falls short for me. It feels like they wanted to experiment a bit but they weren't completely sure where exactly they wanted to go with it, so it just kind of meanders throughout the runtime. Surprised that this was selected for the 1001 albums, but hopefully we'll see De Stijl and White Blood Cells too later.
Mostly fun.
not as good as their other albums, but had some bops
Not a fan of that garage rock at all
Not an album I'd come back to, but that's purely personal taste. It's a surprisingly good album, just a tad too theatrical for me to get fully immersed. 3/5 Fav track: as ugly as I seem
Someone must really like the WS, as this is the weakest of the three albums of theirs I’ve heard, and I’m not a fan of them generally. This is ok, entertaining enough. The one that sounds like a quiet song from “White Light/White Heat” was a nice surprise, though it went on too long, like this album. I assume one of their more popular albums is on this list as well, so I’ll put more work in on my nascent theory about them being the Tim Burton of classic rock.
Was about to start rambling about how disappointed I was when I bought this excitedly on the day of release in 2003, then realized this is actually the *next* one in the series of diminishing returns after White Blood Cells. You know the formula, this one has a country flavor on top of the blues/rock backbone. It's fine
Kyllähän tuon kuunteli varsin kivutta läpi. Tuli erään espoolaisen bändin laulaja vähän mieleen tuosta soundista. 2,75*
Ei parasta antia, mut varma kolmonen
Quite a change from their previous album, Elephant, which had the signature song - Seven Nation Army. Liked this one too though!
It's OK
Not as good as elephant and not as strong of an album overall. It starts out strong for the first few songs and then starts to dip and never really recovers. Their sound is good when it includes more upbeat drums. The slower songs don’t show their strengths as much. Good album but not fear. 6.6/10
Was aight, not their best work by far but had some good moments
"Get Behind Me Satan" is the fifth studio album by American rock duo the White Stripes. This album was a change from their guitar-based previous album "Elephant" with more piano and acoustic-based melodies and rhythmic experimentation using instruments like marimbas: less guitar riffs and plays down punk, garage rock and blues to a certain extent. According to lead singer and guitarist Jack White, it has a theme of truth in the songs which is mostly told through relationships. The album was widely acclaimed and reached #3 in both the UK and US. Jack uses a falsetto throughout the opener "Blue Orchid." A fuzzed-up guitar driving the melody. The typical White Stirpes drum beat provided by Meg White. The song is about the devastation of something valuable and some think it's about Jack's break-up with Renee Zellweger. "My Doorbell" is piano soul with a prominent drum beat and actually one of my favorite drumming on any White Stripes' song. He's waiting for death. "Little Ghost" brings the bluegrass with a fast-paced acoustic guitar. Layered vocals. This is unique for them. "The Denial Twist" has hard piano notes. The classic Meg drum beat with a tambourine. I think he's giving advice to someone who's been dumped. "As Ugly as I Seem" also has an acoustic guitar and real nice melody. A slow song. Jack's best vocals on the album. A good deep cut. "Red Rain" alternates between a blues and rockin'-distorted guitar. It's goes soft-loud-soft (always a fan). No, not a Peter Gabriel song. All six White Stripes' albums are worth listening to and this is no different. These songs are slower than the typical White Stripes and I do like the variety of instruments carrying the melodies. I wish they could have flushed out some of the piano and acoustic guitar songs with a band but I guess that would be what Jack did with other bands and solo. There seems to be more there with the melodies he created.
I liked it more than I thought I might, especially the second half of the album
After the insultingly-terrible White Blood Cells I was actively not wanting any more of this band, but this is demonstrably better (which, when the bar is the floor is almost literally impossible to not meet that criteria) - it's rather apparent within a song or two that this is definitely more constructed, a little more full-sounding ... aside: wtf I have never understood the enjoyment of what is generously called stripped-down or raw music but in every single way is just a euphemism for "...ehh...more than half the band didn't show up for recording but we're gonna lay down the track anyways! can you play drums?" Ok anger abated (yes White Blood Cells angered me). There's more experimentation here as well, some harmonies, I like the liberal addition of piano, plus a few interesting (guitar) effects to broaden it a bit. I still don't like all of it - e.g. "Instinct Blues" is more indicative of the sloppy/gross earlier sound. I think by the time the 2nd half comes around I'm like "ok enough already" I suppose this also reenforces one goal of the exercise for me; I had absolutely (ill)formed an opinion about this band based on White Blood Cells and a few singles I loathed, and even if I'm not gonna put this record on I (finally?) get it here. Hell maybe they (like almost every act) simply needed to mature. Just didn't need to release anything before this that sounded like bad demos... Drummer is still an unprofessional shambles though that if anything actually detracts from the songs. Come on. 5/10 3 stars.
Enjoyed this, I really like and respect The White Stripes.
Not in my edition of the book! 2005. 3.5 stars. Perfectly acceptable stripped down millennium rock. Not their best work - see The White Stripes or Elephant for that - but still good. 4 stars if you like their sound, 3 stars if you don't.
He fell off
Glad to get this since it’s a White Stripes I haven’t heard before. Personally I would choose Icky Thump, Elephant, and White Blood Cells before this one. So maybe there’s multiple white stripes on the list? Which is egregious imo. Wish this project was more Blue Orchid than Little Ghost
birkaç şarkı dışında ortalama bir albüm arkadaki enstrümanlar çok etkileyici bir şekilde kullanılmamış ve bazen fazla “basic - simple” geliyor söz yazarlığı konusunda da çok çok iyi bir albüm değil ama yine de gayet ortalama bir albüm
The only White Stripes album I actively don't like, this has no place on the list.
Always a fun sound but definitely an unnecessary amount of album inclusions for them.
Another white Stripes album, another 3 stars. Solid rock music but not more
Not what I was expecting, a mix of stuff on here. Some nice tracks
3.6 - I like this record and I like Jack White but he's clearly overrepresented on this list. What I like best about this particular album is that he's muted the thrashier and yelpier parts of his voice, choosing to go warmer and more mellow. I like the use of acoustic piano and folky guitar. But he's too often playing the bluesman again, scatting and rapping his blend of down-home lingo. I do enjoy the poppier tracks here ("Doorbell", "The Denial Twist"), as well as some of the downtempo experiments ("Blue Orchid", "The Nurse"). But the rest I find just a little annoying, or forgettable probably because I'm burnt out on Jack White and wish he'd fuck off for a decade.
Honestly, not White Stripes best work. A lot of filler and songs with the same chord progressions.
Best Song: Blue Orchid. Jack White's ability to occasionally construct an absolutely chunky riff rears its head once again. Worst Song: The Nurse. Why play one bad song at once when you could instead play three bad songs at the same time? Overall: A classic White Stripes album in that it's packed full of bite-sized bits of "okay". A couple iconic riffs, a few nifty little ditties, and a lot of forgettable thrashing in between.
I wouldn't say I've followed these guys super closely but I did know there was a point where Jack disappeared up his own arse and Meg fell off the radar. I guess this is that point. Talented guy but dial it back with the weird hillbilly folk nonsense, fella. 3/5.
Després de dues obres mestres seguides, havia de venir inevitablement la baixada de pistó. Curiós que estigui a la llista, ja que segurament es tracta d'un dels treballs més fluixos de la banda. Jack White en pilot automàtic, fabricant temes 100% de la casa. Però es clar, Jack White en pilot automàtic en aquell moment estava per sobre dels millors moments de la gran majoria de bandes contemporànies
Track 1 - Blue Orchid Thudding bass drum beat, thick sludgy guitar, crashing cymbals, jacks incredibly unique almost feminine voice contrasts the thickness of the guitar, vocals and guitar share melodies throughout the song, great opener 7.5/10 Track 2 - The Nurse Incredibly unexpected marimba intro, carefree and melodic opening, increasingly out of time guitar and drum clash with marimba rhythm, chaotic cacophony of thundering guitar and drum blasts, palm muted pulsing guitar riff, deep underlying drone of vocals in the instrumental interlude contrasts the light marimba rhythm, random bursts of piano, guitar and drums, really random song 6/10 Track 3 - My Doorbell Playful piano melody, rattley drums, crashing cymbals, megs signature drumming clear as ever, maracas add an extra dimension, jacks vocals sound distanced from time to time, like he’s in a corner, a lot different from the guitar dependency from elephant, gets a bit repetitive, still entertaining 6.5/10 Track 4 - Forever For Her (Is Forever For Me) Jacks signature winey vocals shine through, once again piano reliant, light acoustic guitar, return of the marimba, light maraca shakes, solid chorus, twiddling piano line for chorus that continues through fade out 7/10 Track 5 - Little Ghost Fast paced bouncy country guitar, unlike anything on the album so far, very country based with simple tambourine accompaniment, a little more twang in the vocals, banjo type chords, experimental 7/10 Track 6 - The Denial Twist Swaggering drums and thudding piano chords, changes time sig in chorus, fuzzy dull bass line, draws from classic rock and roll influence 8/10 Track 7 - White Moon Sad reflective piano, simple kick beat with maraca, smart rhyming in the lyrics from jack, picks up more before heading back into the normal verse, shows the vulnerable side of jacks voice, long drawn out resonant piano notes 6.8/10 Track 8 - Instinct Blues Very raw recording style, like early delta blues recordings, swaggering riff with pounding drums, jacks signature boosted vocals, some awesome guitar lines, crashing drums, changes in tone back to the start of the song, simple lyrics, heavily driven octave guitar, classic blues phrasing, passionate vocal and instrumental performance, rumble of feedback present throughout the whole song, big punching end 9/10 Track 9 - Passive Manipulation Short little interlude with Meg on vocals, nothing to see really Interlude/10 Track 10 - Take, Take, Take Acoustic and piano, simple drums with maracas, acoustic and piano shares same melodies off and on, sounds like two slightly different vocals coming through each ear, clever vocal panning to and fro from left and right speaker 7/10 Track 11 - As Ugly As I Seem Plodding acoustic guitar, simple beat on some percussion instrument, nice balance between lead lines and chords on the guitar, instrumental doesn’t have too many changes throughout the song, repetitive again 7/10 Track 12 - Red Rain Echoey slide guitar, interesting bell melody, thudding guitar and drum lines, very roots focused, swaggering drums, bluesy slide, warped vocals, song fades and comes back in strong, song goes full circle, ends with echoey slide and bells 9/10 Track 13 - I’m Lonely (But I Ain’t That Lonely Yet Powerful but melancholy big chords, bluesy piano solo, sounds a bit like a billy joel type song but more drunken saloon diddy, reflective lyrics, jacks vulnerable side to his voice on display, chords and vocals die out but comes back in for a final finish, great closing track 8/10 Final Thoughts: This album is like night and day to their previous album, the meteoric garage rock landmark, Elephant, This album is a lot more experimental than Elephant, using the marimba on tracks like The Nurse and Forever For Her and was strikingly different to the raucous riff-laden Elephant by the fact most of the songs were piano led. This album also sees a change in style for the band, turning to their roots influences in blues and country, whilst still regaining the rawness, dirtiness and simplicity of the production on their previous LP’s, as shown in the swaggering, swampy riffs of Red Rain and in the fast bouncy country rhythms of Little Ghost. The album was well received and received a Grammy for best alternative album in 2006. This album showcased the versatility of Jacks writing and musical talents, whilst also reaffirming megs simple but effective playing style and it’s key place in the creation of that signature white stripes sound. The album also showed that their is space for experimentation in even the most simplistic of musical styles, as well as pushing the boundaries of what could be done in the sonic toybox of garage rock and alternative music as a whole. Final Rating: 7.25/10 Best Song: Instinct Blues or Red Rain Worst Song: As Ugly As I Seem Most Underrated Song: The Denial Twist
Overdone, particularly in the loud-quiet-loud sense. Those tensions put one on edge while listening and so even the cool bits ("The Nurse," say, with the interesting marimba bits) become disconcerting to listen to. The virtue of simplicity is the power it can create, somewhat counterintuitively, but this lot way overplays its hand (see "My Doorbell" also with marimbas), leading to a too-close similarity across songs (see "Doorbell" to "Forever for Her"). One just doesn't see (or hear) this anywhere near as cool as Jack and Meg seem to want one to. This just isn't as surprising or strong as the earlier records.
Not my fave
This album had two really good songs (blue orchid and the denial twist) and the rest of the album was just okay.
I have to admit, I enjoyed the White Stripes previous albums to Get Behind Me Satan. I know some duo artists are suppose to expand their sparse sound by introducing additional instruments, but I prefer the guitar-heavy sound from the pair. No wonder White preferred in a larger band format after the Stripes, so you can't deny a guy for expanding his musical horizons.
kind of a fuzzy mess. 2.5
I didn't like this nearly as much as I thought I would. Two familiar tracks, and the rest felt hollow and shallow.
I maintain that The White Stripes excell when performing low(er)-fi acoustic pieces, anything other than that and its incel rock 2.5/5
The first album cycle of The White Stripes I can vividly remember, mostly due to the omnipresence of two singles. 'Blue Orchid' has such a murky depth to the guitar tone that I'm only half-expecting it to explode, though it never does. As we all know, it's the drumming (always the drumming) that uplifts Jack White's certain kind of outraged doggerel. Meg White proves that you can be a bad musician and still make important music. 'My Doorbell' fully commits to the wacky honky-tonk cabaret that was simmering below the surface on 'Elephant' but reaffirms their childlike embrace of playtime. Back to the album, I don't know how else to say this, so I just will, but the whole record *sounds* like Jack White's moustache here: a Luciferian touch of old-timey medicine show antics with some added wisdom that's more on the sly side. Could be that the marimba sounds like a skeleton rib-cage xylophone, or that songs like 'Little Ghost' and 'Red Rain' have bizarre atavistic qualities in their instrumentation. Gotta say: I never cared much for 'The Denial Twist' as it seems like a rewrite of 'My Doorbell' only with harder edges for boys with long sideburns. It's not an easy record to pin down, and they ultimately sound a little unsure of where to go next after 'Elephant.' And, you know, a lot of is forgettable. C+
Removed Album #44 (List: https://pastebin.com/cSThNiK9) From the Vault #46 (March 13, 2026) Here we are. My second White Stripes album, and the last album to be included in the original 1001 lineup. At the time of writing, I listened to Elephant around 430 albums ago and Jack White's solo album 60 albums ago. Future me, please let us know the album gap when this eventually appears on my list: [625 since the last White Stripes album and 259 since Jack White's solo album. The White Stripes now have the largest album gap on my project] I really didn't like Elephant. I thought it was a total junker. Garage rock in general is among the lamest, weakest genres of music for me, and this hippie-dippie, suave, overly-confident garage rock revival boolshite is fake and disingenuous to me. I just hate the blown out sound - shit's terrible. I've understandably avoided the White Stripes to this point, though I'm willing to give them a fair shake on this second album like I have with all of the other artists on the list. Here goes. Yeah. More of the same, really. It's a vapid point of criticism, but I need to get it off my chest: this is Reddit music. Now, that isn't necessarily a bad thing since Reddit is an aggregate of everything popular and things are usually popular because they're good, but come on. The top scholars and academics at Reddit university are blasting this in their cars on the commute home after a long day of arguing with people on the Internet, their Richard Dawkins bobbleheads bouncing around rhythmically on their dashboards while they feel euphoric in this moment, but not because of any phony god's blessing. What can I say about this music? It's got that early album demo feel to it. There's a lingering emptiness which hangs over these tracks that only becomes more apparent the longer I'm exposed to this music. The album really wears its heart on its sleeves, too. It lifts a lot from 70s rock and blues music, which I can't say I'm particularly animated by. This album doing it so blatantly doesn't win any favours from me, either. As usual, I'm not a fan of the blown-out, skin-deep guitars, though to this album's credit they don't feature as prominently on this release - there's a greater level of variety in the instrumentation. My biggest problem with this album is that Jack White can't rock. There's something deep inside him which inhibits his voice and gives us this warbling, squalid sound. Overall, this album was profoundly boring, but nothing about it insulted me - I was just content to let it run. Time to figure out why this album was removed. Included in the original 1001 lineup and pulled from the 2008 update. The book entry says that "By their fifth album, The White Stripes have come to represent that rarity, a credible modern rock band with a career - rather than a lifespan comparable to that of the average butterfly." I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean. Rock was a pretty disposable genre during the early-to-mid 2000s, but rock musicians have always had far more longevity when compared to that of their peers. It's not like it is with pop or hip-hop musicians, where people are only willing to stick around so long as the music is good or dominates the airwaves. "They achieve a surprisingly sophisticated and forward-looking sound because they have to struggle against the inherent restrictions of their basic setup." The rest of the entry talks about the many musical influences this album has, though that's about it. Wikipedia says that this album was recorded in Jack White's home, was self-produced, is described as their "most misunderstood" release and was generally well-received by critics, but garnered a polarised reaction in relation to the minimal instrumentation and production. It also had a pretty good run on the Western and European charts - it grazed and infiltrated the top ten in a bunch of different countries. I can understand why this was removed. Three list albums is definitely these guys punching above their weight. I'm not even sure if two albums are warranted, if I'm honest. This band is popular and well-regarded, but I think they lose major points due to their lack of originality and the music not being all that good in my opinion. Their previous two albums seem like bigger deals than this one, so I will cooperate in the removal of this album. In place of this album, I humbly submit "Zuckerzeit" by Cluster for inclusion on the list.
An album that starts off absolutely terrible, why is the first three tracks A. On this album and B. Justifies its inclusion on the list. It does get better, but a much weaker album then their other ones.
You know a flat VII chord hates to see them coming
Disappointing
i feel like this is too deep into their catalogue to be the highlight of their time. its good but it started to feel algorithmic by this album
I like a little Jack White/White Stripes now and then but probably would not re-listen to a whole album. Quirky and theatrical. 2 1/2 stars.
288. Ok
Besides a few of the singles which are great the white Stripes don't really do much to engage me. Doubt it'll get another full play through.
Man I just don’t really care for the White Stripes it’s the type of rock that feels so stuck in its time. Nothing sticks out as far enough for me. The doorbell is one I had heard before but even then it doesn’t help me enjoy it anymore even if the lyrics are the main selling point. Music is the whole experience. The stripes are flyover country and 3 albums is far too many when so many artists were skipped out on. It’s not the white stripes fault but I find myself not interested in the legacy or even moved by the art
meh rau
whatever
I don't know man. I think even Satan would be like "I'm good, bro."
For all the accolades and praise Jack White has gotten, this band has had a continuing issue of sounding thin. They just can't fill the space with their sound, not even an octavio (which takes what you play, doubles or halves the frequency, gives a lot of fuzz and overlays it) can make up for it.
I don't hate it, but that's not a resounding approval. Reading up on this, they shifted from what was familiar to them, but still maintained their essence, and I think that shows.
Creative and innovative. White pushes the boundaries, while performing like an old rocker.
Is there anything good here? Maybe "My Doorbell" is passable but its lyrics suck. Just a pass. 2/5.
Unsatisfying hipster drivel
except for the first song, not at all what I was expecting. More americana type, not something I really liked
Their sound is generally appealing hence their success and this is apparent on a number of the tracks here (Doorbell) but too many of the songs made me think their was no edit switch in use. Nothing or no-one to say it's not strong enough. The Rita Hayworth song FFS (Take Take Take). I'm never going to forgive either the them or the next 5 generations of their offspring for inflicting that dross upon me.
Just didn’t do it for me.
not a fan of the vocals if I'm honest
Unfortunately, after Blue Orchid and the Interesting drumwork on The Nurse this album slowly meanders downhill into a state of poppy piano heavy meh. 2.4/5 -> 2/5
13 songs I knew their biggest songs and I really enjoyed them. The album began with Blue Orchid, so I foolishly thought the rest of the album would be similar in terms of quality. God damn, the rest of this album sucks, and I didn't expect it. It just drags on and on through each uninteresting, uninspired song to reach an end about as exciting as a wet fart. I give this 2 stars, and not 1, simply because of the first song being actually really good.
I give Jack & Meg credit for experimenting and reinventing their sound after some albums of the same (awesome) riff fests. Problem is, the result of the experiments is not my cup of tea, I find it mostly boring. While the instrumentation varies more, the songwriting is really monotonous. Also, it's just so frustrating to listen to a guitar God playing easy piano chord progressions for so many songs. 2/5 - below average
I wanted to like this, I really did, but I got extremely bored very quickly. One continuous noise for 45 minutes as far as I could make out. Jack’s nasal whining did nothing for me, but Meg’s drum work did offer a little bit of salvation. Not enough though. 2/5.
More interesting than good
Inte min sorts rock
Not even the album that has the one or two White Stripes songs I like. Jack White has long since admitted that Meg can’t play drums and the two piece has a pretty limited sonic pallet, and he’s cashed in the Stripes for a full band. Unfortunately in doing so he’s proven that he has less to say than we already thought.
honestly quite weak, blue orchid remains a banger
favs: blue orchid instinct blues take, take, take red rain im lonely (but i ain’t that lonely yet) rating 1.9/5
On today's episode of "this is the worst album by an already mid artist but you should listen to it first!"... The White Stripes! Seriously, why do I have to listen to this? I wasn't too averse to listening to an album by this band but I heard the first song and it was alright but it didn't really go anywhere and ended weirdly, but then I listened to the next song and it did the exact same thing. Then, I checked on AOTY to see how this was rated and see people say the first song is the best? Oh god, I knew I wasn't going to enjoy it very much. The vocals are actively bad throughout, I'm not going to lie. The guitar parts are fine, but boring and don't do much. The piano is corny and awful, and I know they were trying to do something different here but I don't know how they weren't afraid to even put these songs out. Well, it was actually probably just for the money actually. It just feels like they're trying so hard to do some different but have no idea what that is and just end up sounding really stupid, and the lyrcis and their delivery (in all ways) is awful. It's not good.
Album #137: Get Behind Me Satan - White Stripes Genre (W): Alternative rock, blues rock, blues, pop, country, experimental Singles: Blue Orchid, My Doorbell, The Denial Twist I have not listened to this album before. Thoughts?: Normally I enjoy albums that are extremely versatile. However, with this one, I feel like the White Stripes are trying too hard to do multiple styles at once. What worked with Gorillaz was that they stuck to a core sound, which was hip-hop. However, with this one, it just seems to jump from genre to genre without warning. It makes for a strange, unpleasant listen. Favorite tracks: Blue Orchid, My Doorbell, Little Ghost, The Denial Twist
I liked “The Denial Twist” and some of the instrumentals, but Jack White’s voice really does not work for me.
Not my favorite white stripes
I like The White Stripes and all but what exactly were they thinking here? A bunch of little half-formed ideas here that lack the bite of their best stuff.
Kinda interesting music, dog dirt vocals.
I feel truly neutral about this album. Nothing to keep me here and nothing to make me walk away. Just OK
Nothing stood out and made me want to listen again.
I thought I was ready for something besides angsty singing while someone slams their hands onto the piano. They proved me wrong by having someone angsty sing while someone angrily strums a guitar repeatedly without changing chord. I guess different isn't always better.
just noisy tbh…… did not love
I remember having mixed feelings about this when it was released, and this is the first time I've listened to it since then. The album opens with a strong guitar riff, typical of their earlier work. I didn't love it, but I didn't hate it. But I because quite frustrated with the album by the time Little Ghost came on. Much of this album seems to be trying to position itself as experimental and eclectic at the same time. I think these two ideas contradict each other. The result is an album which seems to wear its influences as costume rather than celebrate them, as if the image is more important than the sound. This just made the entire thing sound hollow and insincere to me. Some good riffs saves it at times, but I found the rest of it a bit grating. I can't explain it.
Not my style
An interesying listen? I'd always heard about the White Stripes and was expecting more.
Seth - 3.1/5 Logan 1/5
i just don’t really like the white stripes sorry the music doesn’t hold up very well with time
Ik weet niet helemaal waarom, maar ik vond het niet echt een lekker album om naar te luisteren (op een paar nummers na).
Boring tbh, after the first 3/4 songs it really starts to fall a bit flat and sort of feels like you’re at the end of a drawn out jamming session. White Stripes definitely have some bangers and were a good band, but this album doesn’t massively advertise that. 2.0/5.0 Best Song: Blue Orchid
Dull, not their best by any metric. Just the same vibe riff over and over.
I don't get the hype behind The White Stripes. Never have and thought I'd try this an be open minded but it just wasn't for me
White Oichid babay!
Les musiques en elles-même sont écoutables, par contre il n’y pas de cohérence entre les musiques qui s’enchaînent. On passe un peu du coq à l’âne…
I got the White Blood Cells CD when it came out and dug it, didn't really follow them after that. This Get Behind Me Satan album is very mediocre, so much so that I listened to WBC for the first time in 20 years to see if I still like it and I do, it fucking rocks. Perused the other later albums and they also rock. I think this might be their worst album. Not sure why it's on the list!
white blood cells clears
Get a bass player! Or play Seven Nation Army
This album feels like being edged by a better album where every track circles being interesting but never actually gets there. No standout tracks to me. Rating: 2
I am sad to say I did not enjoy this. The production quality is low, which from a band as big as The White Stripes at this point in their career was clearly a choice, but I don’t think this works as a cohesive album. To its credit it often reminded me of a 2000s Hunky Dory, but without much of its charm. The singles I know, and enjoy, but beyond those there wasn’t much to love about this album.
I don't understand the hype around Jack White at all. He's prolific - I'll give him that - but I can't stand any of it, really. And, this album cover is pretentious and off-putting. 2 stars.
Trying to fill shoes too big for them
I don’t really like the white stripes that much. this album not for me.
For me part of maturing and getting to an age where I give pretty much no fucks about other people’s opinion of me is admitting that The White Stripes are overrated, they have a handful of really good songs across their catalogue and hats off for showing that a two piece band can fill large venues but a lot of this album is pretty rudimentary and boring, Jack Whites voice grates almost as much as Meg Whites drumming and their best songs/ ideas are on the singles so you need not buy the whole album 2.3
++: Blue Orchid, Forever for Her (Is Over for Me), I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet) +: My Doorbell, Little Ghost, As Ugly as I Seem +-: The Denial Twist, Instinct Blues, Take, Take, Take -: The Nurse, White Moon, Red Rain --: Passive Manipulation 4,0/10
This album was big when it came out, and we couldn't escape the White Stripes. We still can't escape Jack White. I myself prefer Jack Black - funnier, more range, and seems like a great human overall. Jack White kinda gives this lady the ick. The album itself has some overplayed tracks and then some boredom. If you've heard the hits, you have a fair sense of what the rest of this will sound like.
Interesante
really? in a vacuum i would give this a respectable if unremarkable and sometimes irritating 3. (i can only be made to hear about jack white's problems with women for so long before i start to resent it.) but because it has been presented to me as one of the most important albums of all time i have to give it a 2. presumably it was removed from the book once the contributor(s) recovered from mid white guy blues-rock fever #previously listened (partial)
Was nice to get this behind me
Did not like it as much as I thought I would.
Eh
Not their greatest album, but still a good listen. I start to get bored towards the end
Blue Orchid - firmly eh. The Nurse - I didn’t like it but it caught my interest. My Doorbell - Liked some of the gimmick and the rhythm. Forever for Her (Is Over For Me) - Okay. Little Ghost - Fun!! The Denial Twist - Enjoyable. White Moon - Marginally better than Blue Orchid. Instinct Blues - Okay again. Passive Manipulation - Really could use better delivery. Take, Take, Take - I really like Rita as a name. Besides that, felt like I got something from this one. As Ugly As I Seem - Kinda felt that. Red Rain - Alright. I’m Lonely - Finally peak. At its best when it commits to the blues. Also, beautiful album cover.
Hits a nostalgic cord for me, but pretty meh for otherwise.
Its pretty obvious that this album is meant to be experimental, and thats completely okay! Most of the songs on here are just not for me. Some good songs but as an album? Not my cup of tea Songs I genuinely liked: White Moon, Instinct Blues, Red Rain (this one was half good half meh)
this album makes me think its creators really like led zeppelin and then it makes me think I should listen to led zeppelin, track 1 is a 3.5 but the rest brings it down, I got very bored
It opens on the best song, then I kinda didn't process the rest of the album after that.
Not for me.. I just couldn't really get into it.
Jack White is a talented dude and has not only depth and breadth of knowledge of American music but also the skill to rearrange and reconstitute it to match his vision. This record is no different - White flexes his talents as singer and guitarist across these various tracks, all of which are stamped with his style and personality. Trouble is that, aside from "My Doorbell", the music on this disk (or pretty much any White Stripes record) ain't really my cup of tea.
Pre Listen: The only White Stripes song I know off the top of my head is "Seven Nation Army". That song defined a genre for a while, and also somehow got associated with "gamers" if I recall right. I think it's a decent enough song, a bit overplayed, but fine. Taking those expectations going in. Notable Tracks: The Nurse - What were they even trying to cook here? What a mess, horrible all around. Least favorite song on the album, skipped 3/4ths through. Little Ghost - My favorite on the album. Wasn't expecting a folk sounding song on here, and it felt like coming up for a breath of air while drowning in cringe. White Moon - Another low point. Skipped at 3/4th through as well, just wanted to tell the vocalist to shut up already. Post Listen: This album sucks. Overall the instruments, vocals, lyrics, pacing, theme, style, all of it sucks. It sounds amateurish at best, shitty theatre-kid melodramatic on average, and intentionally piss-poor amateurish at worst. They employ random experimental music techniques here and there like audio chopping, stereo manipulation, and distortions, but none of it works, it's just at random. Credit where credit is due, the variety in styles between songs is noteworthy. The inclusion of a marimba on some songs is unique, even if they didn't pull it off. The sound mixing is very well done. Those three reasons, and how this album isn't entirely unlistenable, saves it from being a 1. I can see emotionally stunted young adults and teenagers adoring this album because they struggle to comprehend feelings of sadness, and believe they're irreparably depressed after breaking up with a partner they've had for less than a month. I'm not looking forward to the 2 other albums from these dweebs on this project. Low 2/5.
This album feels… tired. The rhymes are tired. The playing is tired. Even the rhythm is tired. It’s making me tired. Loved Elephant. Honestly. This is making me… sad. Get behind me tapped out White Stripes. 2 Boolean: false
First track is one I know and it's pretty decent, if a bit on the repetitive side (which is pretty much my impression of The White Stripes based on their big singles anyway). Aaand then the second track started and it immediately became pretentious crap that's unpleasant to listen to. This album definitely deserves _some_ credit for the variety and instrumentation (plus it has piano so yay); there's some interesting choices here that were quite refreshing but it's a shame the music itself isn't better. Really don't like the vocals. They're so grating throughout. Just really not for me, and don't understand how this has received so many high ratings. Far too much of it is just naff. Saved from a 1 by the piano bits.
The 2nd song was in your face in a very cool way. Unfortunately that challenging music experimentation only seemed to last that song. Ah well. The rest was boring 2
Rock that didn't excite me at all.
(53/100)
Despite enjoying them when I was younger, I just really don't get this band that much. These songs aren't that good. 2.
A little corny, nothing as electric as Seven Nation Army
This album is kind of a mixed bag for me, many portions and songs like Red Rain are so good, however, songs like take take take are genuinely some of the worst songs ive ever heard. Theres this one portion in take take take where the band had structured the audio to rapidly switch between earbuds and it was genuinely sooo bad and it hurt my ears. 4/10
I'm sorry this is really bad!! I haven't thought about The White Stripes since about 2007 (who has no offence) and I thought that maybe with fresh ears I'd actually be into this but..... it's early 00s indie slop and not good. It's channel 4 core and with no Don't Tell the Bride or Dinner Date for visual stimulation it is not enjoyable at all...
Couldn't get with the different sound or whatever they were going for. I am all for artistic growth and what have you, don't need to have every album sound the same, I get it, but this just wasn't it and not what it wants to be.
i hated this ngl i like to say that i am a person who can listen to almost anything and i stand by that but this is my almost i just want a fan blue orchid wasnt bad but it just wasnt playlist worthy day 2!
무난
Blues rock and garage rock built from marimba-driven grooves, raw percussion, piano, sparse guitar work, and expressive vocals feels like watching a street magician deliberately throw away half his tricks just to prove he can still hold a crowd—eccentric, unpredictable, and more interesting than consistently satisfying. The album abandons many of the duo's established strengths in favor of experimentation and texture. The results are uneven, but rarely boring.
Not good.
I don't like the style
3/10
5/10 - hmm i remember this from my late teenage days but it's not really stood the test of time, a couple of known tunes but just kind of ends with no real highlights.
I've never really been a fan of The White Stripes, and this album does nothing to convince me otherwise. It starts off with "Blue Orchid" who fools fans of previous album Elephant into believes that this will be more of the same. It is not, and Jack White's guitar takes a backseat in this album of strange numbers, including the Broadway-esque "My Doorbell" and an almost comedic blues number "The Denial Twist".
Not my type
Какой-то кантри хазбин отель ватафак вообще ну хер знает 2,5 бы поставила, а так два
Before this album most of my knowledge of The White Stripes came from a The Simpsons bit. "Get Behind Me Satan" was fine. I didn't connect to it much in any way. The last track "I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet) was probably the closest I got. It's sentimental in that specific way I'm a sucker for. There is a twang to Jack's singing that I appreciate, but "Passive Manipulation" made me realize I might prefer Meg as lead vocalist. I wish that track was longer. The instrumentation all seems pretty simple (positive). There was a marimba (I think) used in a couple tracks in the first third that gave the vibes of like some sinister beach. "Red Rain" incorporated a xylophone in a really stilted but pleasing way. Jack White is really good at creating new vocal and auditory stims: "I'm thinkinAboutTheDoorbell".
This album was a really weird one for me. Liked the intro track, then my interest drastically faded in the middle of the album. Cool guitars can only take you so far. The highs were high, but the lows were lower. Can't say I'll be revisiting soon. Rating: 5/10 Favorite song: As Ugly As I Seem
Felt gay while listening to this album
Couldn’t do it. I do not like his voice…
Was not a fan of this album, i do like the white stripes, but i feel like they have better ones than this, there were a couple of a good ones on here such as the opener
It's not their best work, in my opinion.
Kinda came and went. Rarely did I stop and think to myself "oh this sounds good", mostly did I stop and think to myself "how many more songs". Not offensively bad, but pretty meh.
Not a huge fan of the songs. Not bad just not my style, the voice and the lyrics didn't convince me. The instrumental was good though
It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t memorable either.
A couple of catchy tunes but otherwise a bit throwaway
empezó bacano pero se puso todo aburrido después
My Doorbell was ok-ish, the rest just droned on with nothing remarkable. My last White Stripes album on this list.
This is #day631 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… time to cross out another band from the list, as this is my third and final record by The White Stripes. I really do think Elephant alone would've been just enough. Instead, you get two more records you supposedly must hear before you die. Well, I don't think so. This isn't a bad album by any means. It's quite experimental, which is fun, but… Not for me. This is a 2 out of 5. Looking forward to #day632.
meh.. já sabia minha reação antes mesmo de ouvir. pensei que seria pior, nota 2.5
boring but inoffensive
Some very hooky riffs and moments, but I just can't get past the archness of it all. Feels so self-consciously louche, like Johnny Depp in a perfume ad. Also, if ever a band showed why all other bands have bassists, this is it. The songs would have so much more punch if they had some bottom, instead of sounding like they're being played on a gramophone.
not bad but not for me
The singers voice ruins it for me, somehow i can stand dave mustaine but not him lol.
Despite a handful of strong songs, this is one of their weaker albums - the rock swagger overshadowed by more piano-led melodies, and it loses some of their charm and energy as a result
hmm its not good atleast i didnt like it
Beyond Blue Orchid, I was actively waiting for this album to end. Congrats to Jack White for being my first ever 2, and continuing the trend over half a year later Favorite Song: Blue Orchid
I've listened to every White Stripes album multiple times except for this one. I couldn't remember why I always skipped this one on Stripes revisits but now I recall - it's because it's not very good. There are songs I like on here a fair bit but they are almost exclusively the slower tracks like As Ugly As I Seem, I'm Only, or The Nurse. The usual blues rock tracks are fine and all but some of the weakest efforts of their career when compared to what came before & even after on Icky Thump.
Exploración de diferentes estilos durante el álbum, predominando blues en esencia La primera canción del álbum es un clásico En las demás tal vez se podría encontrar algo underrated Lo disfruté, pero me parece que definitivamente no es lo mejor del grupo ni de Jack White si incluimos su carrera solista Por eso le doy un 2.4
Blue Orchid starts this album off with a bang - a fantastic track that smacks you in the face with memorable guitar riffs and iconic vocals. However, the album wanes for me as it goes on, with the rest of the tracks not landing as well. In all honesty I’ve never been the biggest fan of The White Stripes and maybe their style just isn’t for me, but I can’t help but feel the rest of the album lacks something.
4/10 Blue Orchid is a good song, but the rest of the album... meh
badass album name, unfortunately doesn't live up to it. ive listened to a couple songs by these guys and enjoyed them but this album just feels so boring fav song: The Denial Twist
couple of songs that broken through a bit, but mostly just a slow listen.
Dentro de todo es escuchable.
Millennial, raw, and tolerable.
I should like White Stripes but I dont.
Does not having heard a White Stripes album before now make me a bad Michigander? Not sure, but with Jack White being a saint around these parts, it was about time I gave an album a shot. This was fine, I guess. I think I would have preferred to listen to something that was more garage-y like their earlier stuff, because I was not expecting the level of production that this album brought. They do a good job of creating a full sound with just the two of them, just wasn't what I wanted to hear from them. Final note: I am firmly on the side of Meg White being a great drummer. You don't need to be a virtuoso to be impactful and play with feeling, and damn I felt every fucking hit she made on that kit.
Favorite songs: Blue Orchid, The Denial Twist, As Ugly as I Seem I remember enjoying the earlier White Stripes albums when they were released. I didn't enjoy this one.
I've been a casual Jack White fan for a while, but this just didn't click with me.
Not a classic by any means, but there are a few good tracks on here. Always had a soft spot for Blue Orchid
This was a 1 or a 2 but maybe just edged a 2 but it’s not one I’m likely to listen to again
One can only hope there are more White Stripes albums to come, what this one is doing on this list is anyone’s guess…2 stars. Tom.
Such a weird choice for the list. The whole album feels uncomfortable. Like they’ve had an identity crisis and are trying to prove that they’re more than the white stripes. Despite the whites stripes being awesome.
I was 16 when this came out and loved White Stripes. De Stijl, White Blood Cells & Elephant were all 10/10 to me. I taped the first radio play of Blue Orchid off the Zane Lowe show and must have listened back to it a hundred times before the album came out. It might be one of their best songs ever. I was psyched. Then I bought the album and found out 10 of the 13 songs here are meh. 2 stars because the good songs are very good.
Oh it's the band who sings seven nations army ... nevermind
Bizzare album - 2.5. White Stipes most well know songs are all punky but most of this album was not that. Ive always liked Blue Orchid. Also quite liked Instinct Blues and Red Rain. The rest not so much. This is another 2.5 but I think I'll give it a 3 cuz id much rather re-listen to this than that Bowie album.
the nurse is diabolical. So bad. it sounds like if 'silence occasionally interrupted by metal clanging pipes' was 'pretty mid but cutesy primary school song occasionally interrupted by a guitar with murderous intent' im genuinely unsure how they have managed to gaslight themselves into thinking this was something the world needed to hear. this song makes the album Irredeemable but I will say some nice things red rain is the right around of weird for me. its probs my fave. the other less experimental songs are also fine or decent, sounds like a disorganised mika sometimes which isn't terrible. it did go a bit yee haw ? at times which wasn't my favourite but wasn't terrible
a very experimental album, and a real mixed bag... ★★★☆☆ BLUE ORCHID - good, annoying vocals ☆☆☆☆☆ THE NURSE - abhorrent (one of the worst songs I've ever heard) ★★★☆☆ MY DOORBELL - alright, reminds me of MIKA ★☆☆☆☆ FOREVER FOR HER - didn't enjoy ☆☆☆☆☆ LITTLE GHOST - really hated this, country is not for me ★★★★★ THE DENIAL TWIST - my favourite, I love this sound ★☆☆☆☆ WHITE MOON - annoying ★★★★☆ INSTICT BLUES - pretty good too ★☆☆☆☆ PASSIVE MANIPULATION - short and bad ★★★★☆ TAKE, TAKE, TAKE - I liked this a lot! ★★★☆☆ AS UGLY AS I SEEM - I don't enjoy ballads like this much, but it wasn't bad ★★★☆☆ RED RAIN - I like the heavier sound, but still found the song a bit annoying ★★☆☆☆ I'M LONELY - yeah man whatever AVERAGE = 2.31 at least nobody can call this album samey. for the most part I found it annoying
Me saca un poco de mi zona de confort tbh, no estuvo taaan mal, pero si fueron pocas las canciones q agregué a la playlist 🫢
This is my first time listening to alternative rock, so I was not used to it at the start. It got better towards the middle when it had more of a melodic line. The whole album is very experimental and slightly incohesive, sometimes resembling random sounds bashed together. 2/5. Favourite song: The Denial Twist
Overhyped
J’aime beaucoup certains sons et j’adore the White Stripes mais celui ci ne m’a pas marqué
What the fuck. The album starts super strong with blue orchid and then it just falls to absolute trash. Maybe I just don't get the vision but this was absolutely crazy. And not in a good way. Every single aspect of the tracks felt wrong. Anyways I can't give it a one start because the first few songs were okay but that was a hard listen. Rating : 3.2 Favorite track : Blue Orchid
no es mi tipo de música pero mencion especial a "the denial twist" que me encantó
Not for me but cool
no es para mí este álbum jijis
Sometimes may be good, sometimes may be shit
meh
248/1089 i’m sorry but at some point i really checked out of this one and all the songs started to sound the same to me. It’s not necessarily that i think they’re “bad” it just couldn’t hold my interest at all Blue Orchid was the clear standout 30/100
Help. They have one good song and it’s not in this album.
Not my favorite White Stripes album. Favorite song: Blue Orchid
Top ugly
I’ve wanted to listen to more from them! They’re really talented. Fav song is ‘The Denial Twist’.
..
The White Stripes were no strangers to experimentation at this point, as their previous two albums contained a fair number of detours. This one pushes even further beyond garage rock, but it mostly just proves they're better as a garage rock band. There is some good stuff here: "Little Ghost" is a fun folk romp and "Take, Take, Take" adds new elements to their raw rock sound. But a lot of the rest of the songs fall flat or are underwritten. "The Nurse" just doesn't work, the piano songs all kind of blur together, and "Instinct Blues" sounds goofy despite its dirty blues. That goofiness also does the album in, as many of the songs here attempt a quirky or cutesy feel, to mixed results. Kudos to the band for not writing another "Seven Nation Army," but this one just doesn't come together cohesively.
I liked Little Ghost - overall not really my cuppa.
Haven't we already had a White Stripes album? I could just about see how they might make the list once but twice makes me feel there's a backhander somewhere. It's fine just... ordinary.
Ikke så stor fan nå heller
Some bangers for sure, bags a lot in the middle & end. Not their best, not my favorite.
Did not like this one as much
You know, I really find Jack White annoying. I've given his music a chance on numerous occasions including this one and I just can't get into it. I find it to be retro in all the worst kind of ways. Palatable tracks: "Passive Manipulation" and "Red Rain"
please shut up. don’t make me listen to this again.
this album felt neverending and jack white’s voice is grating me. these songs are literally doing NOTHING. make it stop!!!!!!!!
Well I get why they took this one out. For one it is a transitional album, they get properly weird on Icky Thump for the whole thing (still a very patchy and goofy album that I don't like). This one lays their influences barer and I like that idea in theory but the songs are just not there. This isn't even a band I like but I want there to be electric guitar if I'm going to listen to them and a weird amount of songs here don't even have THAT .
terrible idea.... unbearable
It's weird going from a banger that is Blue Orchid to a song with a xylophone but alright. And the rest of the songs are head-scratchers too... Standout: Blue Orchid
They hit a wall that every two-piece band hits, the direction they chose to go in was incredibly annoying
Eh, it was fine for a moment. Not interesting
Production is good but it’s not great even for the white stripes
Un poco decepcionante, aburrido, sin alma. Un paso atrás para su discografía.
Good listen but probably won't return. There are some very low lows in this album.
I get why some people love this, but it’s not for me. Not totally unlistenable, though.
Enfadonho.
I’m bored but guess I liked blue orchid
Scrapbook dog ends
Just … okay? Some spots are higher points than the lower lows.
iconic album name
My 4th favorite WS album
I get them confused with The Black Keys, and I am always disappointed when it is not the real The Black Keys.
Just didn’t do it for me.
It's like Black Orchid is from a different album, as the album quickly degrades afterwards. Disappointing.
I thought I liked the White Stripes, turns out I like that one song from the White Stripes. Blue Orchid was okay, but the album quickly descended into what seemed like shit David Bowie impressions and weird noises (David Bowie basically). "The Nurse" was particularly difficult to get through and took me back to an encounter I had with a nurse when I was a kid. I had my TB injection at school but had a reaction that made my arm swell up enormously, so I had to spend a week in the children's hospital and missed my school trip to the millennium dome.. the one stand out memory I had was the nurse that would come in at night and give me my injections.. I pretended to be asleep whilst she did it, because she was horrible. Jammed the needles in and seemed to make sure it hurt.. you know, real Letby vibes.. for all I know it could have been her, before she got famous.. I was around for her earlier work. I'm glad I wasn't around for the White Stripes earlier work, as that feels like it would have been marginally worse. 2 stars because apparently the Millennium Dome was quite shit anyway.
I genuinely can’t tell if they were trying while making this. Except for on Blue Orchid
Ikke helt forståeligt med så meget Jack White på den her liste.