Oracular Spectacular by MGMT

Oracular Spectacular

MGMT

3.62
Rating
31084
Votes
1
2%
2
9%
3
30%
4
40%
5
18%
Distribution

Reviews (page 8 of 16)

I think this may be the most contemporary album I've received up until now, but you'd be hard pressed to believe that when listening to it. This really hasn't aged well at all, and honestly I found the bulk of it absolutely insufferable. MGMT attempt to mask what is a fairly rudimentary of the time indie album with a heaping of disorientating electronica warpage, going for a psychedelic vibe, but it ultimately culminates in an unconvincing and grating listen in the main. I was of course familiar with a couple of the singles ("Electric Feel" and "Kids", the latter of which in particular was unavoidable for a time in the 2000s to early 10s), and both are admittedly catchy, but they come nowhere close to compensating for much of the dross on offer either side of them. "Of Moons, Birds and Monsters" is also passable in that it is afforded more breathing room than the other unfocused tracks, and it offers a more tasteful ratio between the 'tronica and the indie, but it's hardly anything exemplary. Overrated, overstated, overwrought and overindulgent. This is the sort of album, for those of this era, that your mate from secondary school / college who tried acid at a party once, and thought he was the dog's bollocks, would probably have had screeching out of his Sony Ericsson push up phone.

God level singles with a lot of muck. The soundtrack of Obama optimism

Very nostalgic for a millennial like me. The second half wasn't as good as the first though.

Good modern indie pop album.

Just like that I'm waiting tables in college again

I'm sure some of this is nostalgia but I like this album a lot. The highs are extremely high and the lows aren't that low. A lot of it is kind of middling though and blends into the background

I listened to this album after my boxing class and felt a sense of sadness especially at the song Youth I feel like during the time they were creating this song so much of what the world was known to be had changed so much.. so in a way I felt like that’s what the song and the overall album encapsulates, this feeling of fleeting moments but hoping for the best in the end of course Electric feel is well known to me it’s like the backdrop to so many movie soundtracks I wonder what it was like for them to create these songs and watch it suddenly become a pillar in the sound of 2010’s , that organic growth in being a well know, is it has satisfying as pushing your music through various streams online and watching it become popular through virtuality, I’m sure there’s similarities to what that had to do to accomplish the feat but I sometimes listen to music created during the 2010’s especially the early 2010’s, there was this rawness that I miss hearing, not this feeling that I’m being feed lines that are curated to become popular but it felt personal, and this album feels personal, I’m going to continue to listen to the rest

A more recent banger! Even given it’s now almost 20 years old, still!

I forgot how undeniably catchy some of these songs were, and I liked hearing the ones that weren't ubiquitous singles, too.

Je to skvělé, poslechnu si určitě další alba. Líbilo se mi The Youth, Electric Feel a Kids.

the loveliest. About childhood. As well as about mine. Lovely and touching. 9\10

not bad rate 3.5 if possible

I loved the energy of the album!

Really funny that the three singles from this album were written as a joke to parody late 2000s pop music and they became three of the best pop songs of all time. Rest of the album is new for me and is pretty ahead of it's time as Psychedelic Pop/Rock had a resurgence in the last few years, but doesn't hit as hard as the singles. Of Moons, Birds & Monsters was pretty good though.

There are tracks on here that everyone's heard at least once. It's trippy and feels kind of like an out-of-body experience when listening to this entire record through. It's got great production and head boppers, then before a track ends, the mixing gets distorted and messes with your head and in a good way too. Favourite Track(s): Electric Feel, Of Moons, Birds & Monsters Least Favourite Track(s): Pieces of What

• they really had us in a chokehold then, didn't they? • 5 ★ just for the nostalgia

Loved this album when it debuted and still do!

not for me

Un grupo único, con una trayectoria singular. Tal vez estén en el punto justo entre The Flaming Lips y Tame Impala. Todos sus discos tiene estupendos momentos y alguno, como este debut, tiene temas que se han quedado en la memoria colectiva. No es su mejor disco (LDA o Loos of life son más completos), pero este tiene 3 pelotazos como el megaéxito Time to pretend, Electric feel o Kids. Solo por eso se justifica el disco, que además es muy disfrutable con otros buenos momentos como Weekend wars o Of Moons, Birds & Monsters. También alguno más convencional como The Youth. Produce Dave Friedman, otro signo de calidad.

Electronic melenium Pop. Ranked 494/500 best album according to Rolling Stone.

Maybe it’s the nostalgia talking, but this is such a wonderful album. The production is very reminiscent of 2007 but somehow doesn’t sound dated in 2025. Time to Pretend is my favorite track, it just gives such a youthful, exuberant vibe.

Another record that I don't think I've listened to but know the popular songs off of. Kids and Electric Feel are fantastic. Usually not a huge fan of synth/psychedelic pop, but this is some really good stuff. Of Moons, Birds, and Monsters is a fantastic and beautiful track as well.

It’s a good Album, refreshing and easy to listen. Sometimes vocals and melodies can get too repetitive, you know what you’re getting after a couple of songs, however the synths and guitar parts save the record.

Historically I've been down on the so-called 'Alternative/Indie' boom of the mid-late 2000s. The music of the period sounds, to me, like a soulless jumble; bands replete with singers who looked the same and sounded the same, guitarists who played the same shoddy riffs; songs that covered the same ground and pushed exactly zero envelopes. The entire period affected an air of effortlessness and superiority - only it wasn't effortless at all, in fact the desire to appear effortless was tragic along Titanic lines. I came into 'Oracular Spectacular' with the same critical apparatus in place. I expected to hate this record; I expected be filled with a desire to time travel to 2008 and do ghastly things to the band. To my surprise, the critical apparatus disintegrated and I found myself getting more than a little verklempt. This was an incredible listening experience. The whole record is effortlessly anthemic, cosmic, etherial...and yet completely grounded. This is, for me, the apex of its genre. In a sea of bands with the emotional range of an electric toothbrush head MGMT rises from the depth and proves that there is something there, below the surface, below the ripples and the bubbles and the affect and the costume and the same dead eyes and blank faces and haircuts...there might just be something more. This is a heavy rotation record.

So that's who wrote all these catchy songs! Pretty fun album, both angular and smooth.

Some of my favorite songs of all time are on this album. Love the MGMT sound. But the hits are hits and some of the misses are pretty boring in comparison.

Listened to about half of it so far. I recognized a few tunes and already have these tunes in my collection. Album as a whole is OK.

Nice pop

Suddenly you hear "Kids" and you think, "Did they make this?" The album instantly improves. "Kids" isn't on my playlist yet, but that's about to change...

MGMT was very mucha flash in the pan and the songs are incredibly derivative, but these guys can write a goddamn hook. Not to mention that “Kids” and “Time to Pretend” hold a real special place in my heart because of how they coincided with my own coming-of-age out of college and into adulthood. It’s not the best, but it’s also not the worst.

hated this less once i realized they were trolling

Not bad. Reminds me of my year abroad, but I think other than that, I would probably just pass over this.

Only knowing the 3 big songs off this album, I'm genuinely glad I got to experience the complete album.

It's the first time I hear this band. Sound design is definitely appealing. Songs seemed repetitive and hipsterishly pretentious at first but I started digging it closer to the second part of the album. Overall it was a nice listen. Fav tracks: Kids, Of Moons, Birds & Monsters The Handshake

This was more psychedelic than I thought it would be. Good trippy bohemian style pop. The 3 singles really carried the album, with the other songs seeming mostly muted, especially at the end.

Kind of album you would Shazam at Kohl's and then forget about. Doesn't mean it isn't good.

this came out right as i was starting university and my best friend at the time was obsessed with it. now i'm twice as old lol.

5/5 no notes

Wow fast nur banger, hat voll den nicen vibe auch generell

First song made me think this might be something. Then, absolutely nothing.

Actually quite interesting, could be 5 star. Unfortunately "Electric Feel" made it's way onto my coffee shop's playlist, and I heard it hundreds of times in a year. I simply can't stand that one

Indisputable bangers on this one, but not really my thing overall

MGMT is one of those bands I heard in early middle school when I was “beginning to discover music” and while I think it definitely influenced me, I have no desire to bring this back into my life. It just doesn’t hold up. That being said, whatever they’re doing nowadays with shit like Bubblegum Dog rules

Very good before their time fs

Woooahhhh sweet. Never listened to the whole album. I’m excited. Time to pretend is so fucking good, deserves all the attention it gets. And Kids always lives up to the hype, so fucking good. Fun album with good vibes and killer singles, some of the rest falls flat but I think it’s mainly because the highs are so high. 4/5⭐️

I enjoyed this album more than I thought I would. Saved 2 songs.

While I certainly do know the two big hits, I had never listened to this album. It’s decent pop. Some similar sounding tunes.

Ganska kul album. Höga toppar, ok mellanspår. Rolig ljudbild men tappar när det blir för flummigt och såsigt. Singlarna svinbra och hållit över tid. Andra halvan tappar en del. Synd de inte vågar gå mer ”kommersiellt/poppigt ”. Bästa spår: Kids Betyg: 6 av 10 (ev 5,5 egentligen)

Now that was interesting. I of course already knew MGMT from my youth - "Kids" and "Electric Feel" were everywhere when I moved to LA in 2010 - but I hadn't actually sat and listened to the album. The album itself has a remarkably different sound than the three headline acts (including Time to Pretend). While those three have an electronic, indie-pop sound, the rest of the album is MUCH more accoustic, much more thoughtful, almost melancholy. Kind of a mix between shoegaze and folk. To be honest, I'm not entirely sure that it works cohesively - it feels like the band was shotgunning stuff at the wall to see what stuck. The result? Three all-time bangers and a full album that is never greater than the sum of its parts.

I really liked this 17 years ago, but it hasn't held up after repeatedly hearing it for all these years. It was definitely innovative at the time though. I think I've moved on from the content too.

I like the singles

Sometimes you are just two songs, and that’s fine.

The youth are starting to change Are you starting to change?

One of my desert island albums, perfect no skips. So much fun

First track amazing definitely going to become one of my favourites. Not too fond on the second track weekend wars though. Same with track three if I am honest. Track 4 Electric Feel is good imo still not hitting the highs of track 1. Kids is biblical dare I say more. Track 5 isn’t great definitely a miss on this project. Track 6 Pieces of What is quite good when you get into it. Last few tracks were an actual vibe bro. 10/10

Kids and Time to Pretend are classics I've heard many times before, Electric Feel is another good single, Of Moons, Birds & Monsters was the stand out of the album tracks. Creative, immaculately produced, good vibes, I like it.

Throwback to high school. Enjoyed the album as a whole, will probably only return to the 2 liked songs: Time to Pretend and Kids

Such a seminal album and band of this era. Fave song: Time to Pretend, Future Reflections

This album came out when I was in middle school, and I love it just as much today as I did then.

Bloody good stuff. Solid pop going on here. Great album.

Enjoyable for the most part. The first half was definitely stronger than the second. Kids, Time to Pretend, The Youth and Electric Feel were standouts to me. 4/5

Not the best MGMT album but they are a reliable band and Oracular Spectacular is still full of great songs, such as Electric Feel.

Thoughts before listening: One of my favorite albums from my mid-20s that produced 3 all-time bangers and overall is full of great indie psych-pop tunes. MGMT kinda fell off after this album for me (some people disagree), but I did really like their 2024 album. Review: Few indie rock songs from the 00s have had the staying power that the big 3 from this album have. "Kids", "Electric Feel", and to a lesser extent "Time to Pretend" (my personal favorite) are all timer songs that have remained in the public conscience much longer than a couple college kids putting out whats essentially a psych-pop one hit wonder likely ever imagined. While those are the big songs, I actually like quite a bit of this album with "Weekend Wars" and "Of Moons, Birds, and Monsters" being solid deeper cuts. The album leans harder into the psych side of their sound in the second half of the album and loses some steam, but overall it still remains one of the best albums from the 00s indie rock world. 4-stars

Had a couple of good songs, but wasn't my cup of tea.

Fun album, but nothing really special. I like the tracks with short catchy Synth lines, like Time to Pretend. I think I'll listen to that one again, but other than that I don't think I'll replay this one very often.

There’s so much unique and fun ons this album

Solid album.

Spectacular album. One of my favs

Not for me

Some early aught hits , not too bad

Heerlijk album! Niet alle nummers even goed, maar nog steeds top.

nostalgic, EXTREMELY psychedelic - would be very fun live, definitely got me in contemplation

———————————— A low 3 or a high 2, so…3 My non-musician scoring system. 5 - Love it. Would play anytime, buy, see live… 4 - Good music. 3 - Average playlist. Depends on time and setting. 2 - I can’t listen to whole songs. 1 - No.

Album of the the summer for the 18th year in a row

Nothing too spectacular

The singles are amazing. The rest of the album falls flat

bonzinho

Some of the greatest electronic hits of all time with forward thinking melody and synths. That said it's lacking some depth outside of the leading singles

Not a fan. Good production but very of its time.

Time to Pretend and Kids are standout tracks, tracks that preceded the album by a couple of years though. I never got into the album itself at the time, still not my cup of tea, and much preferred the follow up Congratulations.

3 stand out singles but the rest was pretty meh.

Soundtrack to early college years. While the big songs are fine the back half of the album really has some hidden gems. I'm actually not a huge fan of Kids or Time to Pretend but there's a lot of cool production and songwriting. Holds up, its a 4. 1=Crap that shouldn't be here 2=I didn't like it but get why it's here 3=I thought it was ok or even like it, get why it's here, but won't revisit 4=I like it, will revisit 5=This is some of the best music I've ever heard and will continue listening to it

Superb songs with an exciting sound and some surprisingly poetic lyrics bête and there.

Some bangers here. 8/10

Could feel my 2008 fringe growing back just listening to this.

Just love

Played this cd a million times

i remember my daughter having this album back in the day and now i finally listened to it. this album was pretty groovy. psychedelic with kind of a modern twist. maybe my daughter knew something that i didn’t back then. she’s always been the coolest.

Couple of fun ones

Good fun. Time to Pretend is an excellent track.

♫ Listening to "Time to Pretend" by MGMT (Time to Pretend - SOTW, 2007) ♫

I bought this on iTunes! Kill me now. My local bar plays it constantly. This feels like the soundtrack to Gossip Girl. Xoxo. Pretty up and down album that endures.

One or two tracks hold up. 1.5/5

I never knew MGMT, only by some memes with Eletric Feel. Even though I am a 90's kid, it just didn't make its way to me I suppose. That's what I love about this project, I had a streak of bad albums that took me a while to recover from, but I'm so glad when I got back I got an absolute string of bangers, and this one takes it. Cheerful party music that wasn't afraid of sounding meaningful. And I'd bet at the time they were considere shallow, but anyone that listen to this album will be able to say all tracks still hold up in lyrics and melody. An absolute must-hear-multiple-times-before-even-generating-the-next-suggestion. The only track I didn't quite enjoy was 4th Dimesion, so... Fav Track: all of them

I'm mean its fine isn't it. you can see why the singles were the singles, they were a good bit better than the . Its not amazing, but its certainly not bad.

I did not use a private Spotify session for this one. I have heard a few of these songs on the radio, a lot, but have never listened to the album. It's music with a good beat, interesting lyrics, but leans way too keyboard heavy for me. I am fine with just hearing these songs on the radio without playing the album.

Good album

Better than I expected, but still not for me

Fantastic album, lots of hits and everything else is great.

OK. I really liked this, a lot! I thought it would be something I simply or merely enjoyed just because of its alternative roots and base energy, but it is more clever than that, always changing up and not ever getting stale. I remember liking a few of the songs on this album that got some marginal air play back in the day, but I am very glad now to be reintroduced and able to listen whenever I want. Cool Beans!

A lot of unique and interesting variation in between songs, Moon Birds was OK too, I think I'll go with a 3 here

Pretty damn good. Falls off a little bit in the end but the first five songs are about as strong of an album start as u can get

Im realizing i may have gotten my Vivid and MGMT ratings confused. But the three pop hits from this album are truly unbeaten. And I see the vision for this being their slightly more modern take on the soft bulletin. All in all, great stuff.

downloaded electric feel, time to pretend, kids and of moons, birds & monsters. a few classic millennial songs on here. i still like frank oceans version of electric feel bettee

Decent - their later ones are better

Whiny crap

There are three hits on them and they are bangers - pop perfection. The rest is OK but feels a bit like filler. All in all, a fun album.

Des pièces foisonnantes, à décortiquer, mais qui s’écoutent fluidement comme du pop rock entraînant

Better than I thought it would be.

I didn't know the songs I've heard of theirs were theirs. It was an enjoyable album, though a lot of them turned into mainstream songs.

It was indeed spectacular!

Indy Rock original

Love this album!

Incredibly nostalgic for a time that was and also for the time that has never been anywhere else but in our teenage dreams and wishes. I first heard "Time to Pretend" while watching "Skins" - and this whole album could basically be a soundtrack to every coming of age story. Great listen! Once again, I wish I could rate this album 4.5 stars/5.

A lovely throwback to a band I found very mid.

Throwback. Good electronic nostalgic sounds

3 killer tracks plus average supporting tunes.

Songs: Time to Pretend, Kids

yet another album that gets better on a re-listen

An album I loved when I was younger but aside from the big hits I found I wasn’t as high on it this listen through. Although it must be said how pervasive this sound became in the late 2000s/early 2010s due partially to this album. So good job lads (3.5/5)

As someone who grew up in the 2000s, I obviously know Time to Pretend, Electric Feel and Kids by heart, because they have been all over the radio in 2008/2009. I do feel like they are all part of the canon of 2000s commercial pop hits, that are also just really good songs. However I did not listen to the album, up until now, even though I am a pretty big fan of Little Dark Age. This is a good album, even though the drop in quality between the three hits and the rest is obvious.

Love it!

Actually a pretty good effort... sort of reminds me of early David Bowie...surprisingly... the two guys in the group say they have the Talking Heads in their blood... but, i heard NONE of that... lol... but, i did hear Donovan... and T Rex a bit... modernized with sampling of course... fairly strong tunes... "kids" being the "hit"... but the record peters out at the end... four stars... a score that could be five if you are under 40... and three if you are over 60...

Rating (1-5): ✩✩✩✩ Will I be listening to this again: Of course, I already had saved a few of the songs :) What do I like about it: Sounds like most Alt/Indie Pop music, wich I enjoy very much ;) What I dislike about it: Actually enjoyed it weeee Higlighted songs: The Youth, Electric Feel, Kids,

And we’re off! Great start

Bowie-esque. I’m glad it came out after Uni. Remember them being everywhere. Glad they’re not anymore.

irritating

It’s fun, I love their sound, but there was nothing standout beyond the songs I’ve already heard

Youthful feeling

I've never sat down and listened to this record, but much of it is familiar. I don't generally love an over emphasis on synthesizers and drum machines and what not, but this record does all of that really right, and there's at least 3 tracks on here that I already revisit somewhat often. For me, this record is creeping up on a 4-star rating because I genuinely really enjoy parts of it and will listen to those tracks again. I think I give it a 3 because there aren't quite enough of those to qualify it as a hard 4, but this is probably my favorite record presented in 1001 so far, with the exception of Wish You Were Here, which is a hard 5 star record.

Some absolute, world level tracks that made a huuuuuuge splash and still resonate today....but surrounded by relatively mid content. This album feels like it looses steam on a front to finish play-through. Trim the second half and you might have a five star EP. 3.5 stars.

Three bangers and the rest is not too bad.

Listened before?: Yes, many times An album for the youths, that I loved when I was a youth.

Reminds me of Arcade Fire and Foster the People. I really like the first half but then it falls off after that. I definitely prefer their later Little Dark Age album.

June 2025 four

Nostalgic is probably making this a bias rating but I love this album.

It's interesting, I like it. 3.5/5

I remembered the big hits, but never really liked them back in the day. The rest of the album veered between annoying and background advert muzak. There was a tiny hint of something better early on, but by the end it was just a slog to get through. Pretty dull 2 star fare.

Good tunes

Love this album, has to be 5 stars as these guys wrote this and pioneered the sound of psych pop that I love today. Inspired so many

This is one of those albums where I recognize why people might like it. It’s well made, can be catchy, and has a high production quality. But… it’s just not for me. Kind of feels too clean? A lot like the rich kid who wants to be indie and gets really into raves? I found myself more interested in the filler tracks and wanting to turn off the singles.

4.5/5. Love how fresh and relevant this album remains, first listened to these songs when I was in jr. high and these songs continue to be bangers. Indie sleaze supremacy please.

Pretty good album with a distinct sound and a couple of absolute bangers. I dig it.

Great albumz

Classic for me - makes me feel like im back in high school

Man, I used to hear these guys on the radio so often back in 2013 that when I saw that the album came out in 2007 I was quite surprised. I have heard Time to Pretend, Electric Feel, and Kids so many times that I was like "Oh this song too". Lot of bangers for them but I also find this kind of corporate music basic as well, that's why it isn't 5 stars for me.

Like the vibes, quite fresh Fav song - Kids 3/5

Excellent

Actually, not half bad.

pop moderne plutot, j'aime bien !

I thought this would be a great album and I was right.

This is an amazing record that you don't think you'll like but every song here is well written and instantly becomes a favorite because it exists in a place that defies everything you expect and becomes the kind of record you urge everyone to listen to because it's so perfect,

Killer front half, forgettable back half. I do like synth-pop and I recognize their impact on modern synth-pop but I'd imagine their other albums are better.

right up my alley. objectively probably a 3, but the memories make it higher.

Great album. Never heard anything besides the classics (Pretend, Kids) which, by the way, are contenders for some of the greatest songs of the century so far.

Classic.

MGMT is one of those music acts that I heard about, but never focused on listening to, despite their popularity. I got to say, I really dig this. It’s a nice blend of pop and electronic that doesn’t really drag or turn into background music. And it doesn’t come off as too indie either, if that makes any sense. It’s party music that doesn’t feel like party music. I was only eleven when this album came out, so it’s nice to finally get to hear it after all these years. Hopefully I get to see more from MGMT on here to see how they progressed. Favorite track: Kids Other hits: Time To Pretend, Weekend Wars, 4th Dimensional Transition, Of Moons, Birds, and Monsters, Future Reflections

Now this is an album that never gets old for me. I own this on vinyl and it has one of the strongest "A sides" of any album ever. "Time to Pretend", "Weekend Wars", "The Youth", "Electric Feel", and "Kids" is an INSANE run of songs!! Unfortunately the B side isn't as great but I do like "The Handshake". Overall this is one of the best indie albums of the 00s and the perfect coming of age album. Definitely a challenge to pick a favorite song here.. Favorite track: Time to Pretend 4.5/5

One of the best to do it

maybe it's not a 10/10 album but it has great songs and i love the nostalgic feeling

Greit nok

Cool album!

2007 was a fantastic year for entertainment. This album was a real nostalgia trip, and it still holds up excellently today.

Вполне норм, но такая, легонькая электронщина попсовое Не мое немного

130/1089 - Well it sounds like pop music. I read that this album was made "ironically" which I call total bullshit on. You can't do things "ironically," that's just a smokescreen for doing what you want to do without others judging you. Maybe you can start things out ironically, but putting that much effort into releasing an album definitely takes willpower and some genuine love and respect for what you decide to record. I obviously am putting my own experiences and viewpoints into writing this but I am so sick of irony permeating society and the people I interact with on a day-to-day basis. Got off track from the review, well made pop music but not really my thing and seems frontloaded.

Rating: 4 Notable songs: electric feel, kids, time to pretend This album was such a breakthrough and defining piece of art. I still listen to these songs actively in my playlists. As an album I'll admit after the first 5 songs it does drop off, but the impact as a whole gets its a solid 4.

This was such a cool album when it first came out, and I loved how MGMT managed to get recognized by mainstream culture. One of the things that always stood out to me was how psychedelic it sounded, but with synths and keyboards driving the music. They found the perfect balance between being forward thinking while still maintaining that retro, vintage tone and texture in their sound. Even now, some of these songs are still enjoyable, despite all the radio play they’ve gotten over the years.

This album was very solid. The first track, Time to Pretend, was probably my favorite, but it was truly hard to choose the best song from this album. It brought back a nostalgic feeling in me (which is odd because, to my knowledge, I didn't know of this band and/or album prior to this listen). The music was great, the vocals were soothing, but it was the lyrics which really made an impression on me. This album was creative and a breath of fresh air.

love this low key electric pop vibe

I feel about this the way boomers feel about Led Zeppelin

Phenomenal childhood nostalgia, their hits were absolutely fantastic and the other stuff was pretty good too.

Good stuff. Handshake best track

Was really looking forward to hearing this album someday, glad it popped up here! Novel. Well recorded debut, highly talented guys breaking with that mid-00s alternative rock/dance trend (like Snow Patrol, Arcade Fire, Killers, etc. etc.). I like music that confronts the artist's escaping youth and the shallow enduring pain that goes along with lost childhood, lost innocence. 21 Pilots do this well, also. I really liked this album, the sounds, the songs, a lot of sonic variety. I'll put this on again. Better than a 3 but not quite a 4 but yoou have to round up sometimes.

2 half decent songs

2.5/5.0: Mixed

liked this more than expected based off of the singles

Ok pop album with two big hits?

Modern day psychedelic album. 4/5

So I didn't know who these people were but I knew the first and fifth songs, and they're not absolutely amazing but they're pretty nice. The rest of the album was alright, and it was okay playing it in the background, as it is fairly chill.

this was surprisingly very enjoyable and I had no idea I actually knew some of the hits

überraschend bekannt und gutes dabei

Apathetic dogshit carried by a two short riffs that can’t even sustain interest for the duration of the songs they’re on, let alone 40 minutes of this crap.

first time listening to the whole thing but its evidently a classic...

It's impossible to come to this album with fresh ears. I really liked it when it came out, but through no fault of the band's, I think it wore out its welcome about 10 years ago. Objectively, it's an eccentric, eclectic, arty synth driven pop album, and it is done quite well.

This was EVERYWHERE in the late aughts. Solid work, but it didn't age particularly well because of the imitators.

Album cover is meh. 1. Catchy. Great song. Nostalgic. 2. Ok. Pretty flat throughout. No ups or downs. 3. Also, meh, overall, generally not making much of an impression. 4. Radio hit. Unique interesting, like song 1. Good beat. Fun lyrics. 5. Their biggest hit I think. Also funky, fun, great beat. 6. Dark. Mysterious. Like it. 7. Daniel Johnston-esque. Reminds me of a country/blues singer I can't place right now. A tempo change! 8. Fun. Tempo changes here and there. Guitar solo. Head bopper. Bluesy. 9. Space oddity synths. So David Bowie. The chorus saved this from being boring. 10. Also good. Fun. OVERALL: the best songs are on side A with two of the weakest songs. 7/10.

Really great album with more really good songs than I remember. Will listen to this again for sure.

not for me

Immaculate vibes, truly. One part nostalgia and one part undiscovered bliss

Classic 00’s era album - so many radio hits on here , but are actually good songs too. I should come back to this more often.

Super nostalgic and still very fun

I was pleasantly surprised by this, I enjoyed almost every track. I think particularly the opening two but the vocals were consistently pleasant and there’s nothing better than restrained use of synths, they’re certainly present here but not overused which is welcome. I also like the psychedelic sound on here, this was an all round good time.

Great album! Fun and simple.

Three five star songs and a bunch of 2-3 star songs. Not a bad record but not as good throughout as the standout tracks.

Favorite Track: Time to Pretend

Mal öppis anders.

find MGMT huere geil. aha nöd gwüsst dasi de song kenn, aso time to pretend. tönt extreeeem geil. die plätschrige snyths und so huuere cool. sehr nostalgischi musig. weekend wars au seehr cool mega amdersch very classical harmony. the youth isch suuuper cute bitz radiohead sehr geil. kenns glaub vode konzert haha. ooooh modulatiooon so schöön suuper. electric feel und kids hani afoch so löse lose well insane bangers huuuuuuere gueti songs beidi. zurecht roese hits. 4th dimensional zügs etz au sehr cool halt chli weird aber da chönds. of moons loht etz chli noh s isch immerno meeega kreativ. aber jo begeisteret mich weniger. the handshake isch jo au en haaammer song. das isch es verdaaammt guets album.

bin seehr gspannt AHHH DAS SIND DIE time to pretend findi seeehr cool, au wenn michs glaub wür störe wenn alles so upbeat isch hahah okee unbegründeti sorg, weekend wars tönt ho um einiges andersch au wenn das jz nöd mis lieblingslied wird hahahaha ahh jaa electric feel kenntmer KIDS KENNTMER MEGAAAA FEST d stimm passt da halt echt super und de (für mich) summer-vibe git eifach e gueti luune) jaa isch nöd nötig so lang aber suuuper lied 4th dimensional findi no cool aber nüt unglaublichs jaa sither laufts für mich rifach chli ah mier verbii ABER finds sehr erfrischend und nöd schlecht galteret für 2000er electromusig glaub es knapps 4i. pretend, electric feel und kids sind suuper und de rest eifach meh

Бодренько так, слушать можно иногда. 6,5 из 10.

Favorite Tracks: Kids Time to Pretend Electric Feel

I was familiar with them, but damn, this is good.

Got to be 4 for Kids alone

There’s a few classic songs on here but mixed in with some pretty forgettable ones too. Was interesting to listen through the album as I reckon I’ve never heard the non-singles before. Held my interest but probably nostalgia playing a bit of a role there.

Good electro-pop, but don't know that I'll return to it. Feels like it walked so Tame Impala could run.

I liked this album more than I thought I would! I’ve getting more into this style of pop lately. This album had the perfect balance between cohesion and diversity! I was surprised to realize that “kids” was on this album, but it didn’t even end up being my favorite track! Favorite Track: The Handshake

A rule of thumb this list has not challenged is that a great pop album (think most of Madonna's imperial run from Virgin through to Music) delivers four great singles. Plus well a load of other stuff. This album delivers three great singles, plus a load of other stuff. Hence three stars.

MGMT occupies a club in my head with Foster The People; Peter Bjorn and John; and Portugal. The Man, although the latter came later IIRC. I actually always liked PBJ and P.TM better than MGMT and FTP, considering the latter to be mostly fluffy, shiny music that you might randomly hear on the radio or while shopping at Old Navy. It's not bad music; just vacuously catchy without much substance. That said, I really enjoyed listening to Oracular Spectacular in its entirety. I won't become an MGMT superfan anytime soon, but they are really talented and I will probably listen to this album again at some point.

Hollow wannabe Rolling Stones tracks with a farting synth on top. Such garbage that you half expect Oscar The Grouch to pop out of it.

Boring album with an overplayed hit.

Pop Prince wannabe. Meh.

College era

FINALLY SOME GOOD FUCKING FOOD!!! I love MGMT and this is the kind of groovy I need to get through the day. this is probably one of their best albums too, ugh, love it

The singles were, I suppose, the sound of the summer nearly 20 years ago. The rest of the album is pretty forgettable.

Horrible

I first heard Kids in 2013 or 2014 when I was in 9th or 10th grade. My art teacher, Mr C, had a indie rock Pandora station playing all times during his classes. Mr C’s music taste ending up having a huge influence on my own for the rest of high school and beyond! This album is an easy 5/5 for me. Fav song is the iconic: Time to Pretend

Electric feel, kids, and time to pretend were the soundtrack to my college years.

Three or four terrific songs, and an original sound that has held up for almost twenty years.

Pretty forgettable, like most of the music from this decade.

Definitely some envelope-pushing melodies and production. I can't really say that it's as incredible now as it was then, but the band has only continued to expand their sound since this debut. I can definitely see the vision on the album as a whole, even when (in my opinion) that vision isn't realised as well as it could be. Top 5 (no order): Kids, Of Moons Birds and Monsters, Time to Pretend, Electric Feel, Future Reflections Some weaker and less impactful songs, but none that I would consider forgettable. I think if I had become an MGMT fan when I was 14, I'd have been obsessed with this album. Even so, I have to appreciate and respect what this album does. 7/10

The hits were great, classic songs. I didn’t realize it came out when they did. Overall, as a cohesive album, it was pretty solid, not sure why the whole album is on the list, though, for a debut though it’s fantastic.

Favorite Track: Time to Pretend

Some interesting songs here with a rich sound.

Better than I had memorized it.

3 absolutely top of the heap tracks packed amongst, unfortunately, some really unremarkable filler. I listened through several times to see if I was missing something about the other tracks, and I can’t even recall the songs as soon as they have ended. I remember listening to some of this back when it first came out and thinking, guess I’ll stick with the hits. It still holds true now that I’m listening to it almost 20 years later with intention. That said, Time to Pretend, Electric Feel, and Kids are in a league of their own.

Time to Pretend is an amazing song ruined by the Minecraft Movie. Everything else is good but doesn’t hit that same level in my opinion.

pretty fricken good actually

Debut album. Indie / Pop. Time To Pretend is a banger to open up with and great lyrics. Electric Feel is another really good track, both the melody and lyrics. Kids is a superb track and the best on the album. Pieces Of What and Of Moons, Brids and Monsters are also good tracks. Really good production on this album. Very good, some bangers and some depth.

Maybe it's my nostalgia taking over, but I love this album so much. It's just... incredible

Alt-electro-pop yeah! This one passed me by in 2007, but loving it in 2025.

оказалось что знаю три! возможно с половиной! песни, сильно больше чем думала. норм, интересные, но задавленные, долго слушать сложно)

Oh, this takes me back to the mid-2000s golden age of indie pop. Shout-out to CBC Radio 3, where I probably first heard all the hits off this album.

There are some BANGERS here. This isn't my absolute favorite style of music but this is pretty good. "Time to Pretend" I had no idea was by them. "Of Moons, Birds & Monsters" impressed me thoroughly. I think this is a solid 3 album. Liked Songs: "Time to Pretend" , "The Youth" , "Electric Feel" , "Kids" , "Of Moons, Birds & Monsters"

liked songs: Time to Pretend, Weekend Wars, The Youth, Electric Feel, Kids, Of Moons, Birds & Monsters Very good pop 3.5

3.7 At first I thought this was going to be another naff 2010s spacey poprock album (this list has contained a fair few already), but it turned out to be better than expected. Like with a lot of the genre I doubt this will stand the test of time (I can't remember anyone even mentioning MGMT in the last 15 years?), but enjoyable to absorb the first few listens. Last half of the album definitely weaker than the first half.

Great new wave french touch

Great, I had forgotten how much I enjoyed this album, and it was nice to be reminded of it

Some songs that went on to become classics, but the overall album is okay.

3.8, I've heard the top 3 songs too many times but they're all bangers

I'll be honest, I thought I might get into this one more than I actually did. Other than the 3 singles that were everywhere back in my college years, I don't think I had heard anything else off of this album. I suppose I never hated the singles, but in part due to their popularity, and definitely not really being my kind of "sound" at the time, I guess you could say I didn't really like MGMT. I feel like I've heard some random songs of theirs pop up on streaming radio here and there since then, and was actually kind of impressed that I was into them. Again, I think any dislike I had for them was more of me being a contrarian than actually giving them an actual shot. Now, what I do enjoy is hearing the old school keyboards and electronic influence, but what I don't really enjoy is the songs themselves. Nothing really stood out to me while listening, and I guess part of me was expecting more of an outright synth-y assault compared to what I got. I guess its hard to truly judge since I've heard them a million times, but it does seem the band (or more likely the label) got it right with the singles they chose, they do seem to be the strongest songs here. I bet if I gave the album a handful more listens I could probably find some other stuff to enjoy, but overall not much to grab me on a first listen. Much like The Strokes album I reviewed recently, there also wasn't much offensive to my ears to really turn off from the sound. So we'll just throw this album in the pile of "hipster-haunt background music that I don't mind."

The hits still hit and the rest of the album is very listenable.

I'd always heard this was a solid album but never gave it a listen. I really enjoyed it, a few nostalgia songs mixed in with some good ones I'd never heard.

The singles from this album were so overplayed on release that I assumed I didn't like them, but revisiting this it's actually a great album. Well, the first half is a fantastic collection of trend-setting and catchy psychedelic pop songs and the second half is a bit of a slog.

If they make a musical about being a millennial in the late 00s early 10s, this would be the score.

Boy, tough album. Has three amazing nostalgic songs, but the rest is iffy. Probably another 3.5, just because I got so bored along it but tough to give an album with 3 bangers a 3.

Has Oracular Spectacular aged well? I think so, but I’m extremely biased as this album ranks highly among the most formative of my youth. I still love it. It’s an essential work of synth-pop/psych rock and in my opinion a modern classic. Though when I think about it in 2026, I can’t help but feel distracted from the music itself and more focused on how it’s perceived today by the larger culture. I fear a future in which some bullshit term like “Urban Outfitters-core” is used to describe a past era of indie music as dated and cringe, with the album art for Oracular Spectacular becoming a visual shorthand for “millennial cringe.” Don’t even get me started on “indie sleaze.” I could be fearful of this for other great oughts albums, but MGMT’s debut seems the one of the most likely to fall victim to this kind of dismissive pigeonholing. Lest we forget, it was huge. “Kids” and “Electric Feel” were ubiquitous. So was “Time to Pretend,” which popped up in a fuck-ton of movies, TV shows, video games, and commercials. The band opened for Paul McCartney at Fenway Park in 2009. Jay-Z asked them to make a song for The Blueprint 3 (he scrapped it). This level of commercial success was great for Andrew VanWyngarden and Ben Goldwasser’s pockets, but not so good for their minds and souls. They were uncomfortable with the their newfound and unexpected fame and creatively they were disinterested in trying to do anything like Oracular’s three big hits ever again. I recall choruses of disappointed fans around 2009-2012 complaining online, “I saw MGMT and they didn’t even play ‘Kids’…what the fuck??” So this is the strange dilemma MGMT found itself in during the heyday of indie blog rock. Oracular catapulted VanWyngarden and Goldwasser into the limelight on the backs of three throwaway pop songs written essentially as a joke in their Wesleyan University dorm rooms. In the span of three years they went from singing covers at college parties backed by an iPod to opening for of Montreal, (still backed by an iPod) to signing with Columbia and recording their first album with legendary producer Dave Fridmann. Soon they were playing major festivals and touring with Radiohead. If they had any idea they would become so big so fast, they probably would have made a very different album. Or maybe taken it more seriously. But that’s part of what makes Oracular Spectacular sublime. It’s not serious. This is the work of guys in their early twenties dicking around in the studio with the dude who produced Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots. Look at their weirdo tribal hippie get-ups on the cover, watch one of the music videos, note how they wore capes on Letterman. Gen-Z or whoever else can make fun of it all they want…the band was ostensibly making fun of themselves in the first place. What else makes it outstanding? The seven other tracks I haven’t even mentioned. MGMT’s story is fascinating in that it is so wildly unlikely in just about every conceivable way. They became huge on accident and will almost certainly never put out another album as successful as Oracular Spectacular.

Iconic songs, but I’m kinda tired of them, not their fault

It was fine background music. Kids is a bop.

For about a decade this was the soundtrack to every snowboarding video ever made. Still stands up.

A fun one. First half much better than back half.

Stand outs : Youth, Electric feel and kids. Rest is alright ayouths is especially catchy. 4th dimensional transition is interesting.

I know that I basically love all aughts-era indie but this album really is something special. Just banger after banger. Such a great coming-of-age album.

Has several hallmarks of music i don’t like. Techno, high pitched waffly male singer, etc. But this is really good! Seems strongly Bowie-influenced in a great way. Despite its techno roots, this album is (intentionally) underproduced and sounds homemade/DIY. Also, the tracks have a high degree of musicality, which I appreciate— it’s FUN listening. A four.

Once the internet was invented, MGMT were inevitable. Still, if you look at play numbers for the tracks on these albums, the three popular tracks have 10+ times more plays than the rest. Shallow? Fated to pretend? You be the judge. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing. Youth is for the cocky and confident. Mgmt are ok, and were fun for a while, but if you think the youth is starting to change, maybe it's just you getting older. What does all this mean? I don't know, but what I do know is that the second half of this album was ass compared to the first, and I probably won't listen to it again on purpose. 2.5 stars rounded up.

Probably on the better side of good.

The 3 hits are worth price of admission alone, but the other songs are pretty good as well. There is a noticeable drop off in the last 2-3 songs, though.

Enjoyable album, the songs I’ve heard before/the singles are generally the best ones, but some other good stuff on there.

Okay. Couple of good records.

Far too nostalgic for me to give anything other than a 4. I'm level-headed enough to not give it a 5 but "Kids" and "Electric Feel" alone make this a millennial essential.

Brilliant album, played it to bits when it came out but had forgotten about till now! Great to revisit and remember.

Enjoyed this.

Honestly, this whole album was kinda mid. Nothing bad about it, two songs approaching a billion plays, likeable, but kinda all sounds the same.

I was pleasantly surprised by this album. Only knew the band through "Kids" which was all right but often sounded to me as an "indiewashed" dream pop update for the 2000s. This album has a lot more to offer that foes into the direction of space rock and psychedelia as well. Not every track is great but it's certainly a great mix of catchy and dreamy.

This is the first album I’ve gotten that I had already listened to because I liked it when it came out. I haven’t listened in years, and it’s still really good. Kids is a great song, and there are a lot of other strong ones. I forgot how much I like Pieces of What.

Will relisten great album 9/10

super phonky and vibey. I'm definitely coming back to this. great songwriting too

Vibey but not always my vibe

i wish i was a millennial (ew) just so i could experience being in uni 2007-2012

Millennial hipster beach party with a couple joints vibe

With the addition of kids it boosts it to a 4 Edit Apr 15 2026: 4 --> 3

This album is much more than the hits. One of the best of the 2000's

great album, no misses.

Shoutout to Saltburn for putting "Time to Pretend" back on my radar. Solid album! There are some more experimental songs that, while fun for a listen, I probably won't come back to.

Brilliant album, some really good massive summer hits and nice variation of tracks to keep it interesting while still being MGMT.

Great proto-vapourwave / shoegaze pop fun. Kids is definitely the outlier in terms of tone.

I listen to Time to Pretend on the regular - excited to see what other songs I like off this album. Oh, I also love Electric Feel and Kids. Rest of the album was inoffensive, and easy to listen to. I liked this album!

Really cool weird sounds and pretty interesting album overall. Definitely not the type of music I usually listen to but it wasn’t bad.

Pretty good psychedelic album, wish I could give it a 7, but it was a really good chill relaxing time. Made my car ride a lot better today

solid vibes, got better around the end. wouldn’t put most of it in a playlist but it’s good enough to maybe relisten