If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears by The Mamas & The Papas

If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears

The Mamas & The Papas

3.43
Rating
29992
Votes
1
2%
2
12%
3
40%
4
34%
5
12%
Distribution

Reviews (page 8 of 15)

There are Harmonies, and there are Mama's and Papa's Harmonies. Luscious. The two big bits are there, and they obviously grab the attention, but the oh tracks are darned good too.

Everything besides california dreamin was mid

Not a huge fan

Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' are absolute classics but the rest of this album didn't do it for me unfortuantely. Somebody Groovy was also a great song but the rest just didn't hit. I'll definitely listen again later to rerate but for now its a 3/5

Pretty good album, LOVED a couple songs low 4

Born to be a drifting 60s hippie, forced to log in to Brightspace

Easy listening

I like this masterpiece! Perfect music and lyrics. It is one of the best (top five!) smooth and lyrical albums I ever heard! All track are perfect absolutely! My brain is relaxing , my soul is singing, my mood is becoming very great! Many thanks for listening it again!

Another one I'm filing in "cool, glad I heard it, probably will never listen to it again"

So it turns out that Mama Cass didn't actually choke to death on a ham sandwich, but what is certain is that John Phillips is an absolute monster. I suppose leading with that isn't really fair for a review that's supposed to be about the music, but it's hard not to think about how the main songwriter of the group is such a colossal waste of oxygen...so like it or not, it's going to inform my opinion here for better or worse. Okay, now that we got that out of the way, onto the music. California Dreamin' is a fantastic song, no doubt, but beyond that (and maybe Monday Monday, but we're mainly going on recognition here) there wasn't much else that stood out to me as being on nearly that same level. Overall, the sound really isn't my thing...I can appreciate the faux hippie vibes as much as the next guy, but most of these arrangements are just far too syrupy for me. The harmonies are great, of course, but some of the excessive arrangements actually seem to take attention away from their vocal talents, which should absolutely be a constant focus. Maybe its being informed by my understanding about how a lot of the hippie movement was kind of a facade, but I get a kind of "manufactured" vibe from a lot of the music, and I don't hear much all that much genuine conviction in the performances. Or, maybe it's the knowledge of John Phillips being a piece of shit that gives me that impression. Either way, another album who's impact I certainly understand, but the music for the most part just doesn't do it for me.

Dire. Just fucking dire. Imagine thinking this was good music.

California dreaming lifts a lot of the weight on this album, why is there a WC in the album cover? The Mamas and the Papas do know how to harmonize. Do not read about their personal relationships 😳 https://youtu.be/tNlwimUxUME they were forced to mime, so here's Michelle eating a banana in the middle of their performance. 3/5

I like the feeling of this album and hearing where California Dreamin came from.

This album was such a vibe, it really transports you back into the late 60s era. If I had to use one word to describe it, I'd probably say 'quintessential'. The compositions are just beautiful and, I mean... California Dreamin'? Need I say more?I'm generally not a huge fan of the 60s sound, but any album with California Dreamin' is an automatic high score for me. Some may call it overplayed or even overrated, but imagine writing a song so iconic it's known and used by generations after.

Hell yeahhhh let's gooooo!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean this is just such a happy and fun album. How can you be upset when listening to the Mamas and the Papas?

Oldie but goodish. Hate to say this but Harmonies can get a bit bland after 3 songs.

It's a little dated but I listen to this band all the time because the songs are extremely catchy, the harmonies are cool, and it's usually a crowd pleaser.

California Dreamin' is the ultimate banger. The whole album is just a vibe. Monday, Monday so relatable and Got a Feelin' is really unique and beautiful. Straight shooter is just like Beatles.

echte musik mit viel gesanglicher harmonie. mit klassikern die man kennt.

Wenn Musik aus dieser Zeit, dann diese Platte.

I love it, still charms. And California Streamin' is such a banger.

Straight shooter is one of my favourite song literally ever and this album is no skip. These vocals work together like no other. Not to sound annoying but you just don’t get albums or groups like this anymore.

this is a group that i'ev been hearing about since forever, i just never got around to checking them out. guess this is the time, i'm kinda hyped. ok right away i like this haha. good to know what inspired the lemon twigs lol. monday monday is heavenly damn. straight shooter is fun but might feel like more of the same but less good? the third track is sooo soothing and sooo pretty i call your name considered best song ever? chances are higher than you might think do you wanna dance nice little moment, lovely go where you wanna go just went the fuck off, i'm liking everything so far damn here comes the most famous song on the album... it's good, but not necessarily that much better than everything that's come before? at least not enough to justify the streaming differences. spanish harlem makes me shake my head ever so slightly. lovely. soomething groovy, despite being made of the exact same ingredients as the previous tracks, doesn't do much for me the last few tracks, while maybe smaller in scale than what came before, still hit just the same. the in crowd is a bit of a weird ending spot. not at all a bad song, just a weird one to close things up. overall, this may just be my favourite record so far. it's just all good vibes and heavenly harmonies. one word to sup it up is: lovely. definitely worth the listen!

I can believe my eyes and ears, this album is derivative and tepid. Nothing unbelievable here. Talented but unenthused by invention, this group is mothers and fathers of nothing. They are the child of greater groups and the brothers of the forgotten. California Dreamin does hold up.

This was a nice listen, kind of like the Beach Boys before they became more interesting, but with more mature subject matters and women singing as well. The vocal harmonies are the heart of all this and they are flawless. It's performed really well without being overcomplicated or overly technical. The song are written to be pop songs, and they succeed as such. I don't really have much to say about it. It's nice, easy to listen to, and not pretentious. It's not particularly interesting or challenging, but it doesn't have to be.

Pleasant but ultimately uninteresting.

Quite a debut with two iconic tracks that have more than stood the test of time and were part of the foundation of the hippie generation. The rest of the album is decent.

Wife swapping and dysfunction. All the proper recipes of the hippie generation to make a great record. The songs and harmonies on this speak for themselves. They are timeless and helped defined a new generation. But it’s hard to overlook the incestuous relationship John Phillips had with his daughter. And while that had yet to occur at the time of this album, he was one sick and twisted man.

Take me to the canyon. Straight up time capsule record here. Great songs, great vocals.

You know the hits. Overall a solid listen with nice harmonies and layers. Sounds dated but still holds up (if that makes sense). I’m torn between a 3 and 4 but ultimately will round up because 60s Michelle Phillips is fuego 🔥

Two certified classics, but I think Straight Shooter is my favorite song on this album. It's a bop. I dug this very much indeed. 3.75.5

It’s good, but not great.

Good record

Oozes mid-60s California pop, with lush harmonies, jangly guitars, a touch of folk, a bit of rock, and an undercurrent of melancholy beneath all the sunshine. California Dreamin' is still a haunting classic. Not sure about that album cover though, hah.

Mostly bad except the California Dreamin song. I generally like 60s music to some degree, but compared to a lot of albums this one seemed very boring.

Not my favorite group. Nice harmonies though.

Intresting to hear some new songs from these guys. Not a big fan but it was an ok listening experience.

What a collection of voices and harmonies. Stone cold classic.

some all-timers on here, some duds. The highs are so much better than the lows though

A couple of amazing songs on here but the rest of the album is unbelievably bland

I can believe my ears and ears. This is a good psychedelic folk/rock album full of lovely harmonies and some exceptional bangers. ‘Monday, Monday’, ‘Do You Wanna Dance’, ‘California Dreamin’, ‘Somebody Groovy’ and ‘You Baby’ are the go-to tracks here.

Fantastic album. One of my favourites!

So many classics in one album

Nice harmonies. The "In" crowd organ part is great.

Some unknown songs, some known songs, but all of them good. Some dancing was involved ;)

Perfectly pleasant folky poppy Flower Power. But California Dreaming and (to a lesser extent) Monday, Monday stand out for me. The rest is a bit same'ish - great vocal harmonies and all that, but no "wow" factor. Some songs are very Beatles like. No great art (or grammar) has been lost on the cover.

Great harmonies and arrangements but, with the exception of the singles and perhaps a couple of other tracks, the material is fairly average. “California Dreamin’” and “Monday, Monday” are perhaps the only Mamas and Papas I need.

It's interesting to see what the obvious classic "California Dreamin'" is surrounded with on this album to make it a whole. It is corny, almost too "in-love", but just gives me as a listener good feelings about the future, even though this one is "way" from the past.

This album gives the feeling of a fresh sunny afternoon, at the time I was outside playing adventures with my cousins. A album that uprise a good nostalgic feeling and love for the life. Okay, if you know a bit about the historical context from the 60s, yes, you can understand why this kind of music was made.

My dad used to play this all the time, so it's well known. It's solid throughout, with some standout big hits. Overall there's some good melodies, good harmonies, and really nice backing instrumentation. 3.5 rounded up.

Pretty good, bland in places. Shocked that the In Crowd is one of the least played songs on the album, to me its probably the funkiest

Good record all around, I don’t have too much to add other than California Dreamin is a great song, and I don’t really have any songs I would skip. Favorite Tracks: California Dreaming, Spanish Harlem, and Monday Monday (truly accurate)

Good, but not my favorite at the moment

This was a great album with lots of great tracks but nothing that stood out as interesting or novel.

3.5 rounded down to 3 because of a bad album cover, worse album name and the grammar in the band name.

i enjoyed

Enjoyable but a little repetitive for my taste.

California Dreaming, one of my favourites of all time!

Not bad, but not my cup of tea. While listening to it it felt like listening to all the generic 60/70s song that later on got used as a soundtrack background in a movie in those scenes where they show the main character living his serene life before adventure awaits

Kinda boring, it's cute but veryyy repetitive

Some good hits but not every track was a winner.

Not quite as much of Cass's joyful voice to the fore as I would like, but I do really love several of these tracks, including of course the brilliant California Dreaming. I also love Monday Monday which has some of my fave harmonies EVER. I've taken a star off because a couple of tracks were a bit unmemorable, and I prefer more "unbridled" Cass such as on The In Crowd and, of course, her own solo stuff (everyone should listen to Make Your Own Kind of Music at least once a month). Highly enjoyable album, though.

Great album. Terrible cover.

Califonrnia dreamin' - in times of Donald Trump...

For det meste roligt, men alligevel varierende stemning og tempo

Fun 70s vibe

Another amazing debut, with killer songs on repeat.

'And I pretend to pray.' Whatever the '60s were really about, this captures that sensibility, one that we've all grown accustomed to have nostalgia for, tho many of us were never actually there. One of the great vocal records of all time, w/ Phillips and Elliot leading a sweet and soulful charge, it no less boasts instrumental surreality and a hustling, bustling rhythm. From Spanish Harlem to L.A., you get the sense that the moms and dads may've dug this as much as the rebellious, new-dimension-seeking kids. In other words, the 'in crowd' is what you make it - whether you're dreamin' or you retrospect and wear your influences on your sleeve. However it is, 'I need somebody groovy.' My fill of grooviness is more than satisfied w/ this one.

Absolutely love the song California Dreamin'. An overall very good album with some great songs by The Mamas & The Papas.

A good and easy listen though sounds somewhat dated in terms of the sound. A laid back Californian west coast sixteen vibe. The two singles are stand out tracks - Monday Monday and California dreaming. I think I owned a vinyl copy of this once.

Ok. Just a bit old sounding.

It’s really just not my favorite style of music. The vocal arrangements were good but the panning and production really did not let these songs shrine. Album tracks do equal the singles though

i did like it but nothing really stuck out to me unfortunately. it seems like music i would put on in the background and forget it’s there until it was off. that is actually what happened. good album though! worth a listen i think

"Monday, Monday", Straight Shooter, Go where you wanna Go, California Dreamin' and Somebody Groovy are great songs. Do you wanna dance, Spanish Harlem, Hey Girl are good. Got a Feelin', I Call your Name You Baby and The In Crowd are ok. Overall it's a great album, nothing is bad and it has 5 great songs.

2 sterne

They were all fucking? Right? They had to be. Anyways, California Dreaming is one of the best songs of all time and there are alot of other good ones on here too Best Song: California Dreaming Rating: 7.5/10 (Solid) Stars: 4/5

Great early example of acoustic and harmonies blended together. Nice.

I've heard this album plenty of times in the past. I don't know if it's the repeat listens, or what, but I just can't give it a 5. There are a lot of great tracks on here, but as a full album it felt like it was lacking something, and a few tracks fade away from my interest so quickly. 4.5/5

Classic!

Great classic sounds, interesting musically as well

I know far more of these songs that I thought I would. I laughed when this came up in my rotation, yet now I'm going, how do I know these? Because it's a solid album, dated sure, but the songs still work. It makes me think of how far music has moved since they were considered counter culture. It also is interesting that they are now the sound of the late sixties. After thinking about it and listening to the album I swear that's why I know there catalog.

7/1001 Not a bad album, but nothing special either. I try to put myself in someone’s shoes who would’ve heard this for the first time in 1966 - it probably would have made big impact. The harmonies are what has kept TMATP a part pop culture for 6 decades. Most prose have heard California Dreamin’ and maybe even Monday, Monday - so they do stand the test of time. Those songs are iconic, but the rest of the album kind of sounds like a watered down version of The Beatles. I didn’t hate the album, and the times that’s California Dreamin’ and Monday, Monday show up in a commercial or movie or in a grocery store will be more than enough for me.

Enjoyed California Dreamin' and quite an inoffensive album overall. Don't love it - ok for background. Quite pop-folky. 5/10

Not even California Dreamin' could save this one

Classic 60's pop with a handful of must knows.

Loved it and the vibe. Great album for the weekend.

Beyond the novelty and laughter that may surge from the fact that you HAVE to listen with both earphones... it's just fine. Maybe it is a product of its time. I enjoyed 3, 4 songs the rest didn't make me complain or anything, just made me feel "it's playing, may just as well listen to it". No negatives of the top of my head, but I don't know if I'll revisit it. A 5.

Easy listening and good times

Sublime.

I enjoyed the album, as I do with most rock from this era. I only knew California Dreaming beforehand. My main gripe with the song is the mix, as it felt like the band was split down the middle in my headphones, which gave me a headache at times.

Pretty basic album besides California Dreamin'. Their take on Do You Wanna Dance was also good, and the rest of the album was definitely worth having on in a vibe, but so clear that one song is head and shoulders above the rest.

Monday, Monday is underrated compared to California Dreaming. I feel like that song was around more when I was young. Some good songs to start the album. Then, some duds up to California Dreaming. End well. There's some good sunshine pop on this but I am glad I own the 7" with the two big hits on it. There no reason to own the whole album.

Good but old has a time and a place but I can’t see myself going back and listening to it

Ist okay

many have essentially said that california dreamin is this record's greatest strength but the actual greatest strength is the only one the album (and band) rly needs, which is that Their Voices Sound Amazing Together. it would take more and more dedicated listens to rly pick out and remember the individual songs but the wall of the band's harmonies is an ecstatic, comforting experience no matter what the material is. and the material is rly good anyway....extremely pleasurable, occasionally perfect sunny melodic 60s pop that just sounds absolutely incredible. a record so warm it could keep u alive in the arctic all by itself

Most songs here are a little bland and forgettable, but California Dreamin'... holy shit, what a masterpiece of a pop song. I don't hate this album, but there's just nothing that interesting here, and it's pretty outdated. At least it's short... 5/10

I enjoyed this although probably wouldn't put it among my elite/top albums. Saved a few songs from it!

Classic 60s sounds/album. Enjoyed listening to it!

Beautiful boring music from your mamas and papas. The type of album you just don't enjoy but can't claim it's not good. Got many classic tunes that I never noticed are from them, especially "California Dreamin'". Maybe 3/5, I'm not yet old enough to like their music.

mér finnst þetta snilld. allt sem ég vil. samsöngur og nördaskapur. set 4,5 af því að lögin eru frekar misgóð.

This album rocks, had fun looking up the lore of the band while listening as well

Folk Pop, 1966 -> 3

60's groove with some HOF hits. Varying levels of composition and degrees of difficulty, but overall worthy of your time.

This album was a little too corny for me. With such a focus on the vocals you get these amazing harmonies and performances but are forced to suffer through the cornball hippy platitudes. The lyricism and production texture of the album just makes me think this was cooked up in a lab for maximum profits. Rating: 2.5

Folk rock with gorgeous vocal harmonies. Quite a short listen clocking at under 40 minutes which makes for a pleasant listen. Fun fact: Cass Eliot was a member of the band until they broke up in 68'

60s pop with solid harmonies usually does the trick for something that is at least pleasant sounding. From what I know about this band, that is exactly what I'm expecting from this album, especially since it has "California Dreaming" on it. Looks like it will be squeaky clean. Safe and edgeless music for the whole family. Predicting that it will be fine, but nothing special. Monday, Monday The production on this song definitely hasn't aged well. Extremely 60s. The harmonies are pretty good. As for songs about not liking Mondays this one is pretty okay. Has some decent lyrics. Decent. 3.5/5 Straight Shooter Does a bit more with the band, the guitar is alright, though the percussion is just annoying. Has some country vibes. The alternating vocals and the harmonies they create sound pretty nice. Decent. 3.5/5 Got A Feelin' Creepy sounding. The instrumental has some unsettling energy, especially the ticking clock. The voices are pretty nice. It was a good decision to keep the track short, any longer and the ticking would've been annoying. The layering of the two different vocals is the highlight here, paired alongside the strange instrumental it works out into a decently executed song. Not mindblowing by any means, but I swe what they're going for. Decent. 3.5/5 I Call Your Name Really standard 60s pop song. Extremely uncool, has less edge than a circle. The harmonies are good, but the song is really uninspiring, does very little for me. Average. 2.5/5 Do You Wanna Dance I didn't know I could grow even whiter by listening to a song, but I think I'm starting to become translucent. This is a song where the stereo really does a number on me. Sounds terrible in my headset. Makes me nauseous. The song isn't terrible, but the production has aged so badly that it's nearly unlistenable on my setup. A victim of time. 1.5/5 Go Where You Wanna Go I don't like the vocals. Earpiercing. The recording quality does not help. Annoying chorus. Terrible sounding strings. Not good. 1.5/5 California Dreamin' Quintessential 60s song. It's cultural impact is still felt to this day. Used in plenty of media to indicate the time period. Covered many times by different artists and has plagued many an accapella troupe. Really catchy and fun to sing along to. The dark undertones in the lyrics and the haunting echoing backing vocals create a sinister feeling which keeps going throughout the track. A track where the dated production does it some favours by upholding the eerie atmosphere. Classic that has stood the test of time. A bit overplayed, but still pretty fantastic. 5/5 Spanish Harlem Corny. Both in terms of lyrics, composition and lyrics. Just extremely dated and lame. Ick successfully acquired. A relic of its time best forgotten. 1/5 Somebody Groovy The datedness has somehow come full circle and transformed into charm. Doesn't sound all that great. "Groovy" used to describe a person is a slang term which I'm really glad didn't stick around. Average. 2.5/5 Hey Girl Sounds really empty instrumentally, genuinely has demo vibes. Production hasn't aged well in the slightest. Forgettable lyrics. Did not like. 2/5 You Baby Kinds sweet. Sounds awful, especially the backing vocals, awful recording quality, sounds really muddled and unclear. Aged poorly, though there's an okay song buried in there. 2/5 The "In" Crowd Quite a decent concept. Still sounds horrible, the mix has a lot of problems, though mainly with the vocals. The organ is snappy and fun, the band performance in general is pretty good. Ruined by the mix. 2/5 This has aged extremely poorly, it sounds absolutely terrible on my setup for the most part. Some songs were almost entirely ruined by it. Much of the writing is extremely basic and forgettable, and to modern ears a lot of it also comes off as corny. Some of the tracks have a bit of charm, even some of the charm coming from how dated it sounds, though most of it is just bland. The harmonies, the singing ability and the synergy between the performers remains at a high level throughout, though doesn't quite do enough to carry the album. Apart from a few hits (mainly California Dreamin') there's not much on here worth caring too much about. There's plenty of other music from this era I'd rather be listening to. Dated. 2/5 Fave track. California Dreamin' Least fave track. Spanish Harlem

Mostly quite forgettable and 400% too much stereo. A couple of cool tunes tho. 3 stars because of the hot girl on the cover.

1. California dreamin 2. Monday, Monday 3. Somebody groovy

Yeah. Chill.

Classic bangers, really enjoyed it from beginning to end - some kinda boring tunes that blend into the background of this era, but overall not bad!

I know and love this album cover, they're all cramped into that bathtub and it's awfully quaint. I have enjoyed "California Dreamin'" since 3rd grade when our school made us sing it in front of our parents, which is actually sort of confusing because it's not a very cheery song for a bunch of children to be singing. VERY good, though. Like, in my top 100 songs and probably top 3 folk-rock songs ever (for me, at least, with my limited repertoire). I look forward to listening to the whole album through -- I think I have before, but not closely enough to remember anything. Very, very pleasant to listen to, but I'd expect no less. I liked Monday, Monday, which is apparently the group's only Billboard #1 hit, but I hear it much less than California Dreamin', so I don't know. I do think I've heard it before, and it was very nice, but not quite as excellent and iconic as California Dreamin', but I'm sure I'm biased. Straight Shooter was nice and perhaps a little edgier than I'd expect. I mean, it was no punk-rock, but even hearing the word "shoot" was like... ok, what are you shooting? At the end of the day, they're supposedly a counterculture band so I guess they're not supposed to be totally clean, and California Dreamin' is kind of edgy, too... But it was a great song. A highlight, I think. Very cool, city-slicker sorta vibe that could fit well into an action movie soundtrack or whatever. Got a Feelin' was beautiful but not super remarkable. ALL these songs are about to go on my oatmeal playlist, and I'll get to know it better then. I Call Your Name is nice and soulful, very buttoned up and girl/boy or mama/papa next door kinda vibe. Very sweet and just nice to listen to. Do You Wanna Dance has a nice, rhythmic sorta start to it and almost tricks me into thinking it's a song by the Smiths or something with it's sorta melancholy guitar before it eventually becomes another sappy, lovely prom night ballad. That's no critique, though. It's lovely, of course. It's groovy. It's good. Doesn't stand out, but it's hard to do that in such an awesome collection of songs. Go Where You Wanna Go brings a nice grin to my face. It's a nice, gentle ... hedonistic ... ballad? Not totally morally upstanding by the standards of the sixties or by today's: "a girl like me can't love just one man". I mean, good for you, Michelle Phillips. The genius annotations are telling me that she cheated on John Phillips with Denny Doherty. Drama! Kinda fun. And, what I've been waiting for, California Dreamin'. That little riff at the beginning is so great. I don't know what instrument that is... guitar, I guess? But it's addictive. And beautiful. That call and response is, too. And followed up with that solo verse backed up by the rest of the band... just sooooo great. For sorta the first time in the album, he gets a little messy with the vocals. He's desperate, disillusioned, exasperated with the gray skies and the brown leaves. Then there's this great flute solo, I think, which is unique and awesome and I love it. Can't get enough. I love California. Spanish Harlem is nice and a little island-y. Those nice latin instruments really make it just that much better. I don't know how I feel about the lyrics. It's about saving a latina baddie and growing her in your white American garden? I might be too woke -- it's really, really nice. Not my favorite, but certainly a standout. Somebody Groovy is a break from the sentimentality of "Spanish Harlem". Back to that Straight Shooter, maybe Go Where You Wanna Go kinda vibe, which is cool and modern and oh my god I'm liking this little guitar (?) solo a LOT! It's just really great. I hate to say this is a stand-out, too, but I might have to. I wish I was more commonly in the mood for this kind of music. Usually I'm hunting for depressing angry stuff, but this is just dandy! The kind of music that makes me wanna use the word "dandy"! Ok, at this point in the queue, I slipped in "Girls and Boys" by Blur. What can I say? Great song and I suspect that this album will show up at some point in this project. Hot, sexy, whatever. Sooooo good. And he's so aggressively British. Guhls who ah bouys who lyke bouys to be guhls... GOD this song is SO fucking good dude ohhhh my god so glad I put this in. Mamas and the Papas are great, too, but just not in this pulsating clubby way. I need a break from all the sweetness. And we're back to our regularly scheduled programing with Hey Girl, which is also really nice. What's there to be said? "He's only looking to score" or whatever was sorta funny. Off-beat. You, Baby is catchy and has a pleasant refrain going on near the end. Very poppy. Finally, The "In" Crowd is another one of the cooler songs. I don't know why it'd be at the end, but it's really really good, probably my second favorite behind California Dreamin'. It's very smooth and reminds me a little bit of some of the edgier musicals I've listened to. Like, she's doing a little bit of a character, like Gussie from Merrily We Roll Along or Velma from Chicago. A great cap for a great album. I think I have no choice but to give this a 5 -- I expected it to be more middling and uninteresting -- but it wasn't! It was really grand and cool and wonderful and I'll certainly return to it. No skips. Just all awesome.

I find 60s music kinda boring

Solid sunshine pop.

Stratospheric highs, obviously, but enough weaker tracks to drag the album down a point or two.

I'm always amazed when I hear something from this era that sounds like the Beatles. Not because I view this band as a massive rip-off or something like that, but rather just how far superior The Beatles were tonall the other groups from this time period who have a similar sound. Why do I say this? The Mamas & the Papas in 1966 sound very much like early Beatles. By contrast, The Beatles around the same time were releasing Revolver, and very shortly after this, arguably one of the greatest albums of all time, Sergeant Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. When you hear such quintessential 60s hits like "California Dreamin," you think of how representative of the era that song is. You don't think about how innovative it is. I'm not saying this Mama's and Papa's album is bad. Actually I think it's quite good, but it's nothing new under the sun. It's nice melodies, with some excellent harmonies, and some catchy, poppy tunes in the mix. Is The Mamas and the Papas debut album worthy of being on this list? Probably. I'm guessing it was pretty influential, and like I said it is good. But, man, if this 1001 album challenge has taught me anything it's that the Beatles are worthy of all the accolades they have, and I've also learned that if something is coming out in the sixties, it needs to not sound like this to truly impress me.

sounds pretty good. doesn't age as well as other music from this era.

Really great, on par with Pet Sounds for me.

Great singles and covers

A great classic 60s sound. It's warm, soft, catchy, and has some glowing harmonies. The whole record is a fun listen, but the first half really stands out. Monday Monday, Straight Shooter, Got A Feelin', two excellent covers, then Go Where You Wanna Go. And the party continues with the group's most well-known track, California Dreamin'. And gosh darnit, that song is highly regarded for a reason. It showcases the best harmonies the 60s decade (and possibly all of musical history) has to offer. I don't see how anyone with half a temporal lobe could dislike this kind of music. There's nothing offensive, nothing grating... just pure, sweet, simple musical talent. I noticed a few jazz (or jazz-adjacent) chords in the vocal arrangement, which seems pretty darn progressive for its time. Kind of like Dylan's turn toward a more electric sound in 1965. As another reviewer wrote about the harmonies, "the forward-looking eclecticism of this record is part of its genius." Really, the only things I can fault about the album are (a) that its tail end is a bit lacklustre, and (b) hopping on the "counterculture bandwagon" is actually much less impressive than its sounds. These guys/gals were not part of the vanguard, even if they spearheaded a very specific subdivision of it. You can kind of feel them clinging to the pop meta even despite their harmonic experimentation. On a different note: we have another record where the top-rated review gives a lower rating on account of the band members being horrible people. I'd like to mention that removing every "morally bad" artist on this list would probably leave less than 100 albums. (In other words: it's not a good criterion to judge music by.) 4/5 Key tracks: Straight Shooter, I Call Your Name, California Dreamin'

They have catchy jams but I predict a 3. I don't skip past it, but I also don't feel like for me it was a "must hear".

In spite of sounding a lot like The Beatles, this record is filled with catchy hooks and melodies, specially the ones coming from the female singers. I only wish I didn't search about John...

When it comes to harmonic/folk pop groups of the 60's, you probably think of the Mamas & The Papas. Almost everything sounds recognizable here, even if one hasn't heard much of their discography. Very groovy, thanks in part to the production crew harnessing the talents of each vocalist. Everything sounds like sunshine and roses, despite what the songwriting is displaying to the listener. Regarding the album cover, stuffing the group in a bathtub for a photo was certainly an artistic choice. Apparently the cover went through a few reprints, firstly due to the inclusion of a toilet being deemed "indecent" (different times...)

Good classic songs of the era. California dreaming is a great song. Album overall was good, I’ll come back to it when I’m in the mood for this typical 60s era music.

Lacks the oomph to be a real mega-hit but I do like this kind of thing

Fun, feel good album

They have such a unique style. I wish we had more acts nowadays like them. 7/10

Really enjoyed this very much. It's all of a keeping with California Dreaming, which is obviously lovely, and they're at their full power when they do the millions of harmonies thing. It's a tiny bit trite in places maybe, but it's a very enjoyable thing to let wash over you.

- paar Banger sind definitiv dabei, aaaber zwischendurch ist es dann auch echt mal zäh und etwas viel Geleier 2,75 / 5

3 - I'd rate this more a 3.5 if I could. Classic California folk rock from the 60s. Album includes some of their most recognized songs.

Plenty familiar with the radio-hits from listening to the Oldies station growing up, but never listened to a full album of theirs. It's good! Just a nice American folk album with great harmonies. I'm also pleasantly surprised that I'm just learning that the strings sample in Jens Lekman's "Maple Leaves" is from "Do You Wanna Dance" Always thought it would have come from a more obscure song from the era.

Why so much panning from left to right, its like they just discovered stereo.

Being forced to listen to the most famous song about Mondays ON a Monday was both awesome and horrifically cruel

Rating: 5/10 Meh.

I immediately hated it because it reminded me of a musical

Great album

Nostalgic Laurel Canyon comp. Doesn’t evoke an album feel, but it was kind of before that time. The hits are undeniable and defining of a sound, place, and generation. Its drawbacks are of the era. I don’t need them singing Spanish Harlem. Leave that to Phil Spector’s stable. These throw away knocked it down a couple for me. But fun nonetheless.

Solid album, really enjoyed listening to this one. I'll go 4 on this one - some big hits, but it was all enjoyable.

Some nice songs on here. I like California Dreamin’

Good stuff

Decent stuff, of course a few of their best songs are on here.

Not going to compete with the top comment here!

Álbum clásico sesentero, que contiene el archiconocido tema "California Dreamin’". Musicalmente es muy bueno, transporta directamente a la atmósfera hippie de su época. Las armonías vocales, aunque excelentes, acaban por hacerse algo irritantes. Además, todos los temas suenan un poco igual y el álbum incluye varias versiones de otros grupos. Merece estar en esta lista por su relevancia histórica, pero no me termina de convencer.

Lovely album. Definitive of the Laurel Canyon sound. What’s not to love?

Wonderful album!

I love how this sunshine pop / psych follows a soul structure in both compositions and in how almost every song is a cover

Makes me wonder why the Beatles got so famous… awesome music. Similar to beach boys but kind of on another level and the vocalists are all very in sync. I think this may have some irony to it given the band’s story.

Cute! Didnt know they sang so many classics

California dreamin is a classic and evokes an era so well. But the rest if it I couldnt warm to. I dont know why but i dont imagine id like people who enjoy this music. Its too twee and smug.

I know Monday Monday and expected I’d enjoy the opening track and it would be all down hill from there. I was wrong. The next track was awesome and the rest of the album varies from decent to excellent. A surprise enjoyment

Today they would have to bill themselves as a Beatles/Beach Boys tribute act featuring a fucking pervert

Sry, I am too young for this.

Worst band name ever.

I like music.

Looooove

Nostalgic!

I feel like sound quality really affected my enjoyment of this.

I liked having this on in the background! Super tranquil and not like the sad stuff we’ve been getting. I kinda liked this as a palette cleanser.

1) ez a borító HOGYAN történt? 2) all the leaves are broooooooooown and the sky is graaaaaaaaaay (igen, ezért meg a monday mondayért kap hármast, amúgy kevesebb lenne)

Ah, peak 60s pop. Just don't google John Phillips.

There are the two mega-hits "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin" on the album. But in total it sounds a bit too aged to me.

All the leaves are brown ALL THE LEAVES ARE BROWN

Ha! Perfect opening for a Monday morning. Thanks 1001! I think the opening song set the mood - really tipped me off on the right foot for the start to the week. Warm harmonies, effortless melodies. Short, sweet songs. Feels like a soft breeze through a ‘60s dream, and I was born in the 80's! It’s folky - sunny, but not naive. The balance of voices is striking, like if The Beach Boys went folk with a touch of jazz. Of course it's a carbon copy of the Beach Boys formula, they were successful! Playlist Additions: - Monday, Monday - I Call Your Name - Go Where You Wanna Go - California Dreamin' - Somebody Groovy

The big hits are timeless classics that you know well. The rest seems a bit more stuck in a time capsule for me. Very mid-60s pop.

well... this shit was sonically pleasing, but it wasnt very interesting. best songs: california dreamin,monday monday

Whew, that was one big load of cheese

This album gets top marks simply for the song California Dreamin'. Solid 60's hippie pop. Favourite songs: California Dreamin', Straight Shooter, Somebody Groovy, Do You Wanna Dance, Go Where You Wanna Go, Spanish Harlem Least favourite songs: Got a Feelin' 4/5

I'm utterly offended by the obscene cover art... That aside, this album is totally groovy. A number of recognizable hits, no 20-minute-long ramblings, full motivation for multiple playthroughs. Everything a good album should be.

I can’t get over the album cover. What possessed them to all climb into the bathtub. That’s some good kink. Although after what I read on Wikipedia about one of the Papas I’m now concerned these people could have been related. Which would be bad kink. Is it me or does that toilet look kinda gross? I can’t tell if that’s just an ugly yellow tint you get in old photographs or if they needed to do some scrubbing. Those boots are kinda awesome. I could see myself picking up a pair just like those if I ever was going to rock some hippy retro vibe. Sadly I can’t speak for the music on this album just the cover. as it was so vanilla. I will give it a 2 for the boots alone.

Typical 60's feel-good music, in a very positive way. Very nice harmonies and several all-time classics.

So nostalgischer Klang und viel Chor, klingt so gut

This would be a 1 if not for California Dreamin'

He laulavat hyvin kauniisti ja California dreamingista hyökyy 60-luvun nostalgia (vaikka silloin vielä sitä vuosikymmentä elettiinkin). Sanoitukset on muuten liian 50-lukua mulle, love me ja my baby jne. Vahva kaks puol.

Lähes lynchiläinen levy: 60-luvun makeiden harmonioiden taustalta alkaa pilkottaa jotain kummallista ja synkkää. Lisäksi LP (a) sisältää yhden ikiaikaisen hitin, ja (b) paranee jatkuvasti kuuntelun myötä, mikä kertoo hyvistä sävellyksistä. Ajatella, olin tulkitsemassa tätä kakkoseksi ennen kuin jokin veti minut takaisin.

I was ready to slam the SINGLES BAND stamp on this one, but to my surprise, a few of the deep cuts ("Straight Shooter," "Got A Feelin'") are actually pretty nice. Still, not sure this makes it out of the "Great 60s Albums" bracket and onto the "Greatest Albums of All Time" list.

This is the first time I’ve listened to this album as a whole piece, and I rather liked it a lot. None of the songs seem like filler and they all have a place, even the many covers. Copy/paste to read more: https://open.substack.com/pub/richcain/p/project-1001-if-you-can-believe-your?utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

Simply a crisp, light, nice album. It’s pop with a tinge of psychedelic and they’re all great singers who wrote great tracks. California Dreamin’ is a classic 60’s jam that still sounds fresh 50+ years later, what a song. 4 stars

хз , средненько, мне не оч нравки, 3/5

Love this album. Spanish Harlem and Gotta Feeling under-rated gems. While California Dreaming and Monday Monday classics for the ages.

По мнению А: 4/5 По мнению С: 5/5 ИТОГОВАЯ ОЦЕНКА: 4/5 (12.02.2025)

I always liked how Michele Phillips ate a banana while singing on live TV because they wouldn't let the band actually play live. Also Mama Cass apparently had some killer parties. But this album is pretty stale outside the big hits.

An album, more precisely a sound, synonymous with the time and place it was created, that's worthy of its place in history really only because of its two classic hits.

I have an old "Best of" on vinyl, but I don't think I've ever listened to an actual album of the Mama's and the Papa's (what's with the apostrophes by the way?). This is all firmly in classic territory - beautiful harmonies, some fabulous songwriting mixed with standards, but who would have guessed how many sexual shenanigans were going on behind the scenes with such a light, mainstream, radio-friendly sound?

I actually hate "California Dreamin'". The rest of the album is fine, but it's not something that I'd care to listen to again.

My only qualm with this album is that there isn’t enough Michelle Phillips and Cade Elliot led songs. California Dreamin’, The “In” Crowd, and I Call Your Name are by far my favorite songs from “If You Can Believe You’re Eyes & Ears.” Michelle and Cass’ voices are so lively and beautiful, especially together. This album is a must listen to if you like 60s country/folk music.

Lovely 60s album. California Dreamin' carries though.

The mommas and the papas have mastered how to stay timeless and still make you feel like you’re in the room in them in ‘66

I had no idea this was the California dreaming album, I have heard that song since I was a child so it really brought back some memories there. Fire album

Liked it pretty cool. One song I already really liked. Lots of potential to love. But also I think one that most people would hate.. not me however so I guess who cares.

I'm sorry this either needed more PCP or more black people. It's music like this that makes the exorcisms at Elvis shows make sense. Pleasent layered vocals and some catchy hooks, but if I'm going to listen to something white from this era, why not just throw on Rubber Soul or the Beach Boys. Like can you imagine watching Jimi Hendrix open for these jingle jangle, step side to side and snap mfers. Nothing bad about the music, but I'm just like this is what y'all listened to when you wanted to have a good time? Rating: 6/10

8.5/10 Great front to back album. Probably would be higher but the fact that this album has so many covers takes away from its genius for me. I know that’s the way of the 60s but it still didn’t hit the same as completely original works. Harmonies and the California sound really make this one for me and I love the incessant work that went into arranging this one. Favorite Song: California Dreamin’

that’s what I’m talking about!!

Not bad. Has some deservedly-famous songs on there.

A very "nice" album. I don't really think, that this is great music. But it's so very nice, that I have to give it a "4".

Barasta alveg ljómandi skemmtilegt, eins og við mátti búast. Lokin á Monday monday örlítið fölsk, en þar er væntanlega við upptökutæknina að sakast og við fyrirgefum svoleiðis.

Solid album with classic 60s sounds. Harmonies and vocals are wonderful. Lyrics are typical 60s

60s folk rock

this is a pretty good example of bubblegum pop music from around this time, with mostly peppy lyrics and toe-tapping sounds. there's a bit of emotional stuff in here too. while i wouldn't say that this album is one of my favorites in terms of sound, it's pretty significant. i think probably one of the greatest aspects of the album, as well as the band itself is how they harmonize with each other, calling and responding in a satisfying way.

I feel like I've heard all these songs before even though I don't think I have. I did enjoy them and might give this another spin. 3.5/5

so much fun.

Two of the best 60s and a lot of iffy filler. I wanted to like this more as I am a huge fan of "California Dreamin" and "Monday Monday," but it wasn't there for me.

Obrzydliwa okładka, znane totalnie, choć tylko punktowo. Jest to zle, wesole i nudne

One of the goated songs, album will always be a vibe

Good album

This really didn’t age well.

A lot of dirty laundry with these folks huh? 4 part harmonies are lovely but deceptive.

Easy listening but not very exciting.

Good songs, good vibes, good music. Always liked their singles, but never stopped to check out any albums. This felt like a good place to start. Cheers for the excuse.

Bland and boring. Only California Dreaming holds water. Glad we've evolved passed this kind of music

I'm sure it's a great album but I was in a bad mood

It’s the Mamas and the Papas. It’s nice, it’s what you’d expect.

Solid, enjoyable harmonies. Standout songs: Monday monday California Dreamin

Avi really likes this one! Great harmonies, their voices are amazing. Definitely very 60s, the lovey-dovey vibe gets a little saccharine after a while, but some great songs overall. I liked “Do You Wanna Dance,” a song I always associated with the Ramones, and of course, California Dreaming.

great harmonies

decent album

Great start to the project, love the mamas and papas. this album is a whole vibe.

Not really my style

Monday, Monday, etc

I think they were featured in some horror/thriller media I watched so now I only get sinister vibes when I listen to them. California Dreamin still a banger.

I won’t spend much time describing this as it’s unlikely anyone with ears hasn’t heard most of these songs: it’s fairly standard 1960s American pop. Fortunately, it’s done really well.

I had already listened to "California Dreamin'" in movies/tv shows but I never looked it up to see by which artist it was. It was an okay album.

Fantastic album

As I get into this one, it feels like a 2-3/5. I'm familiar with some of it. It's okay, but not hard hitting. Post Listen: 2/5. Not my style.

some objective bangers on there but nfm.

Classic 60s, reminds me of Lost! 4/5

I never thought of them as a band appealing to adults but this album is a lot less child-like in content than I realized

A sonically powerful debut that showcased the mood shift of "family bands" from being all positive to grounding in reality of life at the times. Really puts you back in time

meh there were some good songs

A treasure. Great album. Great harmonies. This is every bit a part of many great memories from back then.

A couple of daytime radio classics, but does it really move you? Not quite poignent enough to avoid the feeling that it's just a great, beautifully executed example of light music of the time. But doesn't stir the hardened 21st century soul.

A rich and colorful record that had me feeling like I was laying in a field of flowers looking up at the sun. I enjoyed the variety on this record. Like I said, first you feel like you’re laying in a field then at other times you’re dancing by the water or floating through thin air. Along with many records from this era, it just has such a natural feeling to it. You can hear and feel every instrument and touch. Of course I’d listened to California Dreamin in the past as well as some others from The Mamas & The Papas but I don’t think I’ve ever played a whole record through. Boy am I glad I did! Truly a band for the ages. Favorites: Straight Shooter, Go Where You Wanna Go, California Dreamin

Don’t like the musical vibe of the songs, especially the first song. Had a few decent moments but nothing to write homemade about. Feels like a strange collection of songs that don’t quite work together

This album has 2 of my favorite M&P songs Monday, Monday and California Dreamin'. The rest of the album is pretty good. I have always been a fan of the layered harmonies that the M&P produced.

Great tracks. The challenge for me is a number of the tracks that I like, I prefer done by other artists.

A few very recognizable songs.

Groupe inconnu. Belles harmonies vocales, mais rien d'original par ailleurs. Au final l'album est plutôt ennuyeux, je n'y reviendrais pas. =>2/5

I see the vision but it’s not for me… this is like what I imagine in my head when I think of generic 60s music

10/10 absolutely love!!!! The harmonies, instrumentals, everything.

Lots of harmonies, takes a little while to get used to. They made a lot of songs feel floaty and dreamy. I didn't think I was going to recognize anything, but knew a few. I really liked the dynamic or like the mood changes throughout songs, it's not something I can think of other people doing. The mood changes along with the lyrics that don't always follow traditional rhyme schemes kept things interesting. I appreciate the experimental aspects of this album while still feeling a bit poppy.

I can’t give any record with California Dreaming less than 3 stars. I did like this a lot. You can tell stereo was a newer thing because they used the shit out of it.

California Dreaming cancels out how much I absolutely hate The “In” Crowd. I wish there was more of that sound, kind of dark and some mystery behind it. Staying at a 3 because the music isn’t bad and the harmonies are great but there’s just something that doesn’t connect with me here. Maybe it’s knowing too much about the John Phillips thing. I also heard this group compared to how the cast of Glee would sound singing folk music and I can see that too.

Another album on here I own a physical copy of. I rescued this gem from the clearance bin, marked down from $1 to only 25 cents. What a bargain! Their harmonies are up there with The Beach Boys and The Beatles for The GOAT, in my opinion. Not a bad song on here. I’m not always in a mood for hippy folk rock, but when I am, it doesn’t get much better than this.

Catchy tunes...fantastic harmonies. Great folk rock.

Great time

Just like The Byrds, whose Fifth Dimension was sent to me a few days ago, Mammas and The Papas is also a band that I criminally never listened to. Obviously, I already knew the legendary classic California Dreamin', but I had never listened to an entire album. I was surprised by the spectacular sound of the album, and especially by the harmonious vocals that border on perfection. I really liked the covers of Do you Wanna Dance and I Call your Name, which I already knew from the work of the Beatles and the Beach Boys. Just like Lynyrd Skynyrd's debut that the site sent me yesterday, this is also a great debut album! 5 stars!

pretty great debut album. You're doing alright if you drop California Dreamin and Monday, Monday on your first record. I grew up on this music

21/1001 Getting the obvious out of the way, California Dreamin’ is one of the greatest folk rock songs ever and the rest of the album sadly doesn’t hold a candle to its quality and warmth. Now that’s not to say the rest is bad. Far from it Straighter Shooter is a wonderfully uptempo song with a great guitar riff, and in a similar vein is Somebody Groovy. Monday, Monday is another great song. Simple and mellow and it just works. Apart from a few other songs, there sadly isn’t much else to write home about. Some uninteresting attempts, leaving the rest a bit disappointing. 3,5/5

These harmonies! California Dreaming makes me feel. Cass, we love you.

A few classic hits here.

A couple of hits but nothing else that is memorable.

Sweet harmonies, I thought I knew this album but I was wrong

This album was alright and was pretty good for its time. "California Dreamin'" is a classic as always. There's not a lot to the Mamas & the Papas other than "IYCBYE&E". Half of the songs were just generic '60s stuff. Next album please... 3 stars for "IYCBYE&E".

I appreciate this word being in this list. Monday Monday and California dreaming are classics - didn’t realize the ramones covered them with do ya wanna dance. Also many references to them in once upon a time in Hollywood. Great stuff. Also it should be noted that momma cass did not choke on a ham sandwich.

Still a good listen.

This is a pretty good album, but just not my taste. It is fine, and that's about it. High 3.

was ok. very much of the era

Not what I usually listen to but I enjoyed got a feeling and california dreamin'

Ooh those harmonies.

Surpassingly good, but not my preferred genre

this album was pleasant and inoffensive but not really anything special for me. california dreamin is obviously well known but dare i say my least favourite song on the album?? maybe i've been overexposed to the 60s i need a break

Listening with my RØDEs and a dac/amp so this sound quality is incredible. Fuming I wasn't born a boomer who could've experienced the 60s in california as they happened. Copying the Beatles but everyone else was (listen to straight shooter again if you disagree with me) and it works because I quite enjoyed it! Straight Shooter and You Baby were personal favourites. Definitely not the most interesting the 60s had to offer by any means but it'll be a good relisten in the summer. Wish we could give half ratings on here bc I'd probably put it as a 3.5. Still hate John Phillips.

I knew every single song. Their place in folk rock history is secure

Listened to this album before and really liked it.

Can’t have the mamas without the papas just like you can’t have Houmous without Chutney! 2.6

After I heard this excessively mellow version of "Do You Wanna Dance" I had to stop the album and play the Ramones version just to make things right again before I proceeded. The musical equivalent of a dental spit and rinse. I want to dance with the Ramones, or even M+P's contemporary Beach Boys make me want to dance with Carl Wilson when he sings this, but I do not want to dance with these guys at all. But, M+P were incredibly rock n roll in their own way: The dichotomy between John Phillips' decades of unspeakable debauchery and the sweet tones of his band is staggering. Another huge one is how unhip they sound now and yet there was a time when they were the hippest band in the world, staging the Monterey Pop Festival, etc. But they were their own undoing because after Hendrix hit the stage at Monterey, these guys lost their cultural relevance like a switch flipped.

I'm really surprised that I'm more than a third of the way through this collection, and this is the first Mamas and Papas album, and even more shocked to discover that this is the *only* Mamas and Papas album. Nonetheless this seems like a good selection, as it has a few of their radio classics on it (although it *is* missing most of their singles, perhaps not surprisingly). I didn't grow up listening to them, and have never really found their style and sound all that compelling, so listening to this album didn't really do much for me, and a few of the tracks were a little grating (mainly the cover tunes, e.g. the Beach-Boys-esque take on "Do you wanna dance" or several of the final tracks on the album). But they have a place in the pantheon, I know, and I'm glad to have been exposed to a full album of their sometimes weirdly dark folksy tunes. I'm also struck that my favorite Mamas and Papas tunes are cover versions by later musicians (a bit like Bob Dylan, I suppose).

Great debut and I especially love the soaring vocals on Go Where You Wanna Go.

Enjoyed it

I already am a little bit familiar with the Mama's and Papa's with their song "Dream a Little Dream of Me", which I love. Very good, chill album.

Influential and iconic sound, harmonies are insane. Just not my particular taste most of the way through

I thought I would hate it based on Monday Monday but it's really nice I like it a lot. Lots of 60s pop vibes and I love the back and forth between the mamas and the papas. Side note: the solo on 'I call your name' is absolutely ridiculous and I love it. Fave song: I call your name Least fave song: Monday Monday Would I listen again: I might, but more likely I'll just pick a couple songs to listen to

Pretty damn good for a first album. Several singles on here are their most popular and well-known songs. All the harmonies are really interesting, and the chord progressions can be surprising. All in all a solid effort.

It was a good listen. It would be a great album to listen to when you’re cleaning the house or just want to put on some easy listening type music!

The soundtrack of my very early years. Great harmony, still.

Didn’t finish. Very one dimensional but good harmonies.

Good harmonies, but otherwise a one hit wonder. I like my California beach pop rock to be happy, and most of these lyrics are a downer.

I liked it. I was really into this 60s style in high school and it's a lotta fun. I do think the songs start to blend together, but it is comforting. There are some fun instrumental parts here and the vocal harmonies are great. Actually a 3.5. Liked Songs: "Monday, Monday" , "Straight Shooter" , "I Call Your Name" , "Go Where You Wanna Go" , "California Dremin' " , "Somebody Groovy" , "You Baby" , "The 'In' Crowd"

liked songs: California Dreamin' ALL THE LEAVES ARE BROWN This album is so 60s. It's not bad, it's just very 60s. 3

Worst thing you can be is boring. This is so inoffensively dull I had a headache from halfway through.

So I thought this was bringing back some core memories, but then I realized I was thinking of the Carpenters. But this is good stuff. They worked the angle that they weren't the prettiest (and to be fair, I think a lot of popular music at the time didn't care as much about aesthetics as today). But what am I saying? I don't know! Listen to it! Or don't!

Solid album full of hits I remember from the "oldies" station as a kid. Nostalgia aside, this is still a great album.

Overall, this album is not too bad of a background listen as it is melodic and not invasive. Nothing too exciting though, apart from California Dreaming, which has over a billion listens on Spotify, whereas most of the other songs have a couple of million.

Not bad music at all. Very easygoing but a little boooooooooring…

love california dreamin, chill vibes feels like driving the coast kind of music

Never has a band been so sweet and perfect in the recording booth, and so toxic off the mic. So rarely do you get a group that checks off boxes for drug addiction, alcohol abuse, sexual abuse, a love quadrangle, and various misdemeanor arrests. The love quadrangle and cheating in particular makes the juxtaposition of smooth harmonies and the lyrics of a song like “Got a Feelin” seem almost agonizing. This album has challenged my preconception that The Eagles were the greatest vocal harmonizers of all time. Now, the record does take a bit of a dip after California Dreamin, where it starts feeling a bit repetitive, but I can’t sing it too much - because the final song “The In Crowd” was a nice pickup in energy and confidence. I can totally see this being a pop music revolution for its time, it even stands up to the impossible gold standard that is the Beatles/Beach Boys in the early 60’s (speaking of the beach boys, this version of Do You Wanna Dance is arguably better than the beach boys for me, its more intimate). Candy-sweet anthems that took the yearning of teenybopper music and elevated it to something slightly more mature with spectacular, tight vocal arrangements. Soft 4/5 stars!

This one’s a real treat. Again a pop album where I knew the hit singles (Monday Monday and California Dreaming), but was surprised by the strength of the album tracks. This is beatlesque/beach boysesque psych pop at its finest. Beautiful vocal harmonies, tasty guitar and keyboard licks. Very memorable melodies and great songwriting. My favorite is probably Got a Feelin’. I wanted to say that this album got very strong Rubber Soul influences, but I see it got released just a couple of months after Rubber Soul, so maybe it’s more of a parallel development kind of thing.

Slow and repetitive

Classic 60's sound, feels very nostalgic.