Reviews (page 6 of 15)
Fabulous!
Cover 4 Before this, was only familiar with Monday, Monday.
Yeah
Weird funky little album.
Some good songs and harmonies, especially "Go Where You Wanna Go", nothing especially mind-blowing however.
All bangers! No skips.
Embodies the spirit of 60s music.
Fun classic 50s vibe with newer 60s experimental sprinkled throughout. Harmonies are amazing
Some real bangers on this but also some snoozers (especially the covers) so it's a mixed bag. The vocal harmonies are still pretty amazing. Favorite: California Dreamin' Would I listen to it again: Probably
i wholeheartedly give this record minimal stars, which is 1, which i believe to be one too many. with the exception of "California Dreaming" i'd like to unhear this.
I was surprised by how dated this one sounded - I thought it would sparkle more. The well known tracks still sound great and Cass Elliot’s voice still shines but some songs, like Spanish Harlem, with those strings, sound like something by a crooner from 10 years earlier. I think I’ll stick with the Best Of…
It started well with Monday, Monday but with that and California Dreaming that was all I think I knew. It's not entirely surprising: accomplished schmaltzy pop which is largely not very exciting and hasn't aged particularly well.
Great album- some songs so iconic that i will break out into song if i so much as read the title great study music
Very interesting album. A lot of diverse vibes in each tune. A bit of simon & garfunkel, a bit beatles. Nice basslines (Somebody groovy). California dreamin is just too good, classic. Highlight(s): Straight Shooter.
Nice classic album!
9-10
Something that would be on at your nan’s house
It’s crazy to think this band was only on the scene for four years. Despite their tumultuous history, they wrote some great songs.
California dreamin is good. The rest is not
Cheerful, old-school pop with nice harmonies. California Dreamin' is an absolute gem, one of my favourite songs of all-time. The other songs are pleasant but not that memorable. Overall, a nice listen.
Why do I accept this, yet find Simon & Garfunkel rage-inducing? I'm not sure. Both of groups have songs that liberally use the word "groovy," which is cringey. And there's plenty of cringe here beyond "Somebody Groovy," like "Spanish Harlem." But "California Dreamin'" is an undisputed classic, and "Monday Monday" is lovely. The rest doesn't do much for me, which is to be expected. That said, justice for Mama Cass.
I love California, it's my home and my favorite place in the world. And given that I spent almost all of the first 34 years of my life in the gray of Ohio and the slush of NYC, California Dreaming to me is the greatest song ever written about California. Otherwise this is some dated stuff.
Such a great album it is amazing to me that they were able to keep going after having written their greatest song "California Dreaming".
California Dreamin is a classic and I Call Your Name is great but nothing else really grabbed me. How do you rate an album with an all-time classic and not much else? Has to be at least 3 stars right?
Dødsgøy 10/10 Mulig albumet traff riktig dag, men dette var bra
Super-sweet 60s pop, sounds like pure sunshine. I'd probably go for the Beach Boys if I was looking for this kinda vibe, but overall not bad.
It's alright? Even the hits I had never heard. It sounds like a softer version of Jefferson Airplane.
The Mamas & The Papas are one of a kind. They perfected these harmonizing songs and their music holds up so well from the 60s.
Hard pan stereo - slightly disorienting. Fantastic songs.
Beautiful album.
What a great little album
Decent pop songs, I’ll give this one its flowers for perseverance in culture, however manufactured the sound may be.
The only review this album needs was written May 01 2021. I have nothing else to add!
The harmonies are good, but as an album., it feels like.a hot mess. The songs are all over the place I guess they did all they did in 4 years, so the songs came as they came. Still, it feels like the record has a veneer of cheese whiz O can’t get over.
Four stars for the mamas - two stars for the papas
It's a solid album. But I've seen Chungking Express, so I've already hit my lifetime quote for California Dreamin'
Mid
Sounds great, but I can't get past the horrific abuse allegations.
This was such a fantastic listen. I love how well everyone’s vocals just blend into an incredibly cohesive and lovely sound, almost like a trance. It’s all just so good, I adored this record. Best Track: Got A Feelin’
Boring as heck
Very polished album with some great harmonies from '66 with California Dreaming and Monday Monday. A great example of sunshine pop.
Groovy, nice relaxing tunes!
The original stuff is good. The covers are very ho hum.
As lush and competent as a Beatles or Beach Boys recording. Just not quite as sophisticated. Don't let that turn you off The Mamas & The Papas, though. Mama Cass (don't call her Big Mama) is one of the best vocalists of the era. All the same, while the band remains as lush-sounding as ever (they sound like a full choir), it's still a 3.5 for blending into the 60's scene. Better than The Sonics, not as good as The Stones, not as earth-shattering as Blue Cheer. We'll round up to a 4/5 because Mama Cass never got the respect she deserves.
a bit dated....
Hee hee. Grammatical error in big, bold lettering on the album cover. I'm expecting this to be another pop rock album, if only due to the decade of release and there being a millionty billion of these kinds of albums on the list. Yup, right on the money. This is a respectable album. Between punk and 60s pop rock, if there's one thing I appreciate about the genres that I normally feel disaffected by, it's that they never overstay their welcome. I enjoyed briefly dipping my toes into some solid instrumentation, good vocals and endearing songwriting. "Monday, Monday" has pretty good vocal melody, and I like the backing vocals. The backing instrumentation during the outro of the song is pretty good, too. "Go Where You Wanna Go" has a good energy to it thanks to that percussion. The chorus is also solid. "California Dreamin'" came as a surprise. I've heard it before, as I'm sure everyone else has. The interplay between the male and female vocalist is pretty great. Gonna rifle through the book once more. Topped the US charts and had a few successful singles. Nothing much beyond that, over to Wikipedia I go. There also isn't much in here beyond a modest critical response. It was amusing to read about how this album cover was censored five different times because of the toilet pictured on the cover, however. Take me back, honestly. I've bitched about this list having too many 60s pop rock albums many-a-time at this point, but I can let this one slide. I need to hold onto my replacement albums, and that album was pretty polished for what it sets out to do. I cosign this inclusion.
i have a cold right now. so i’m kinda floating through the world. and i decided to take a walk in the woods and listen to this. and it was definitely one of the best listening environments for it. these guys are pretty damn cool. also if time travel existed i think michelle phillips would have made a good pair
Ah, another one from the childhood. Certain seminal tracks, some forgettable ones.
I knew exactly what this entire album was going to sound like before I put it on.
This album fits very well into its time frame, however it falls a bit flat in every characteristic for the time. It isn't really upliftinglike The early Beatles, it definitely doesn't sound like the Beach Boys, by far not as experimental as the late Beatles. It just doesn't really do anything. 'California Dreaming' is however an all-time classic hit and will never be forgotten. It is easily the best song on this album as well. It almost lifts it to a 3/5, however it falls just short of that. 2/5
Groovy hippy easy listening with a few great songs.
i have an immense nostalgia for the mamas and the papas, growing up listening to oldies radio in the back seat of my parents' car. the number one thing for me about them is their harmonies, which are top notch. i mean just michelle and cass harmonizing is incredible. of course, cass is an incredible vocalist in her own right, but michelle is underrated. the album here is a great showcase of their prowess. it's a little rough around the edges. the biggest fault here for me is that the track listing, particularly on side 2, is pretty meh. a lot of phoned in, contemporary covers, which is sort of par for the course for most artists' albums in this era. of course, 'monday, monday' and 'california dreamin' are great, and i also love 'straight shooter' and their cover of the beatles' 'i call your name.' but i could go without a lot of the lesser covers on here. that being said, i still like this one!
I enjoyed this far more than I expected. I've never been into this group; you could've called me a certified hater. But this album made me believe. They still have a few songs (not on this disc) that I think are shit and (apparently) John Phillips is a trash ass human, but the man can arrange some vocals. That's the strength of these tracks, both the originals and the covers (this was a time when groups covered their contemporaries, like the Lennon - McCartney or the Leiber and Stoller that appear here) benefit from John Phillips's arrangements as well as The Wrecking Crew usual brilliant performance. My one beef is the mix. The various instruments and vocals exclusively in the left or right channel is jarring to my ears. I suppose that was the audio aesthetic of the era.
not bad
It sounds like everything else from the era. Didn’t not like it, recognized lots, but until today would have told you in full confidence that I couldn’t name a single mamas and papas song.
A fine pop album, showing its age
California Dreaming is an all-timer. Monday Monday and straight shooter are cool, rest are a mixed bag. The icky lore surrounding John Phillips tarnishes the listening experience. The panning hurts my little brain. Most of the songs feel like b sides from once upon a time in Hollywood
6/10
Great album! Lovely harmonies and sound
Beautiful vocals. California Dreaming one of the great 60s tracks, the rest a tier or two below.
Jättebra men också lite så är den inte slut snart
california dreaming is goat stuff and the rest is whatever
Other than the obviously couple of songs - felt a bit generic 1960s soul. Hard to differentiate the other songs.
Does this bring back memories of first year at college. Monday, Monday and California Dreaming two of my all-time favorites. Great production for the time.
I like just California Dreamin, the rest I didn't really care for.
Monday monday is a great start to any album. Those harmonies are perfect. Straight shooter starts like we’re about to launch into ‘last train to clarksville’ and has a very similar vibe to it, which having checked was also released in 1966. Got a feeling is more gentle and whilst this drifts along nicely it feels out of place. I call your name is an interesting choice of Beatles cover and is a mixed bag with the first part feeling dated, even for the sixties with this changing for the chorus that tries to emulate the original too much and the ending is like some cheesy stage performance. Do you wanna dance also fails to quite land. I struggle to pinpoint why but it may be slightly too slow. It feels odd to include these covers when their own material felt generally stronger and obviously more cohesive. Go where you wanna go is pleasant enough and leads nicely into the undoubted classic of California Dreamin. California Dreamin has everything harmonies, soul and a great tune. In fact the only thing it doesn’t have is a ‘g’ regardless of what Apple’s autocorrect thinks. Spanish Harlem is another track that doesn’t work for me and again leads me to question the decision to include these covers. Somebody groovy suffers for sounding a bit like other mainstream music of this era and detracts from the things that made them standout. Heygirl for all that is quite enjoyable and manages to blend a more contemporary backing with their trademark harmonies, which really works. You Baby has a wonderful layered vocal element and despite being relatively simple sounding makes it an enjoyable listen . For all that i’ve said about the other tracks ‘the In Crowd’ may be in the exception both in terms of vocal and being a cover as their arrangement really works. The focus of the single lead vocal with the other voices generally lower in the mix really delivers power. I’ll even overlook the hammond organ solo which could’ve easily grated.
This was a perfectly inoffensive 35 minutes of background music (12(!) songs in 35mins - take note prog rockers.) “Monday, Monday” is lovely, so opening with it was nice and, until you get to “California Dreamin’”, the rest is all just perfectly pleasant background music which I liked. It’s not an album I’d go out of my way to listen to again, but it really was a nice relaxing time.
There was a chunk of time where, every time we saw friends, we played Singstar. The three songs none of us ever successfully duo'd were 500 Miles by The Proclaimers, Stay by Shakespear Sister and California Dreamin'. When you sing along to a track, you tend to sing a combination of both vocal parts and trying to stick to the "boy" vocals or the "girl" vocals, especially when you've had a decent amount of wine, was basically impossible for us. But it wasn't as painful as listening to us butcher Stay. Anyway, back to the album... The vocals are lovely. I have always liked Monday Monday. I liked the honky-tonk piano on the slightly oddly chosen Beatles cover. The Do You Wanna Dance cover is not as fun as The Beach Boys version or The Ramones version. I enjoyed this. Probably a 3.5 but not a 4 level enjoyment so: 3/5
Really like this album, the vocals are amazing and a fun classic vibe as well Fav songs - Monday, Monday , Do You Wanna Dance, California Dreamin 4/5
I was actually surprised because, I normally don't like music from 60's unless it's the Beatles, but this was actually fire. The strings were amazing at times, and the songwriting and singing was amazing!
Distinct part-harmony sound, great on speakers in a room Drags on a bit
Fire album. I wasn't expecting much from this one, but the sound was just really fun and it was a joy to listen to.
Classic after classic. Great album.
Mamas and Papas a real mixed bag. Some lovely tracks (Monday Monday, California Dreamin) but it's all very slow and lacking energy
caaalifooornia dreeeeeamiiin
I have to give this one a low score purely due to the mix being so bad. Virtually every single song has one of the tracks playing 100% in one ear, and another track playing 100% in the other ear. It didn't sound cohesive at all; in Monday, Monday if I turned the volume up loud enough to make out the guitar in my right ear, the vocals in the left ear were painful to listen to. Lowering the volume so my left ear stopped bleeding made it so I could barely hear the guitar in my right ear. It probably isn't fair and it might be a pleasant experience if I was in a room with speakers, but listening to this one all the way through with headphones made me want to vomit. Stereo mixing probably wasn't mature when this was produced...I'm glad that folks figured out if you want to record in stereo you shouldn't pan the tracks THAT hard...
This one did not age well. One standout songs and a bunch of forgettable 60's music.
The squarest hippie music of all time.
Better than Coldplay
Haven't listened to this in forever - it's not great! California Dreamin is potentially the finest single of the 60s, though, and gets it an extra star.
The "do you wanna dance" is super eerie. The other covers are pretty good. Very 60s. 5/10
Call this a double yellow line because it's middle of the road and brother you do not want to cross it.
Simply too dated for my ears.
I'm sure that this was very good for it's time.
Only 1 good song which is very famous. Rest of album is boring
Absolutely a classic
Amazing vocals! The album is dripping with hippie goo, but it is clear why this was such a great launch pad for the M&Ps.
It's okay.
Nice enough album, well delivered. I'm not sure how it sits in the 2020s. The two hit singles (Monday, Monday and California Dreaming) are very good.
Pretty mellow album, but it's not really the kind of album for me.
litt sånn mixed bag her, mangen sanger som e ganske kule, selvfølgelig calefornia dreamin, legendarisk. Ellers var det mye som minte om mye lignande som fra beach boys og beatles, generelt bare solid.
Не люблю первую половину 60х. Весь этот рок-н-ролл в духе beach boys и Beatles. Этот альбом ничем сильно не выделяется. Неплохой танцевальный рок-н-ролл, не более
A few big hits and a lot of meh.
Brilliant
Starts strong but loses steam as it goes. The first two tracks are excellent — catchy, well-arranged, and full of the group’s signature harmonies. Unfortunately, the rest of the record doesn’t live up to that early promise. Overall, it’s a decent effort with a few highlights, but nothing that really stands out beyond those opening songs.
I liked this album a lot more than I thought I would.
I expected this to be way more religious based, I think? California dreaming is a great song. Great vibes through the entire album.
This was fine. I had high hopes considering the strength of “California Dreamin’” which is excellent and “Monday Monday”. But the rest of the album I found a little boring. I did appreciate the cover of The Beatles’ “I Call Your Name” but I didn’t think this version lived up to the original
favorite song from the album: California Dreamin'
Never really been a big fan of this beachy style of folk, it just gets so repetitive, feels like the same song over and over.
Nice and chill, a couple classics in there too!
Sounds a bit repetitive and pedantic, but pleasant
Pretty good. A fun album with some great songs.
Finished. 7/10
I recognized a couple songs I knew off this album, which I would have never known it was this group if I hadn’t gotten this pick. Overall it was a fun experience.
Bit all over the place stylistically with some very obvious Beatles and Beach Boys influences. The album has one of the greatest songs of the 60s and some weaker covers. Not too familiar with the story of the band but based on the comments I'll be jumping down a youtube rabbit-hole later. 3/5.
Excellent harmonies and a pretty decent album too.
Very good. Sounds old in a way I thought would get boring for 40+ minutes, but it stays interesting and enjoyable the whole way through
What to do when one quarter of a pop group is very likely an incestuous paedophile? Also, where's the lid for that toilet?
bit "nicey nice" isn't it?
No thanks, I don't want to spend time with this twee garbage. Utter nonsense. Even California Dreaming really pissed me off.
My ears were surprised by their range.
This album has a lot of famous songs. The three singles, of course, but also covers of the Beatles and Ben E King, among others. I listened to the originals of the covers to compare. (You Baby's provenance is so muddled that I don't know what to call it. Is it a cover? Kinda? Not really? Is there a term for songs that are released by separate artists close enough together that nobody can really claim ownership?) They seem to trade personality for technical performance, which is not bad, but is limiting. Overall, though, it's a pleasant sound, and the harmonizing is fantastic. I'm not that into it, but it's a very well made record. Although it's tainted a bit by the big hit telling us that California is better than where you're from. Californians are the musical equivalent of vegans or Ivy League alums, but with less justification.
I enjoyed this way more than expected. There is a certain innocence - some might say cringe - long since lost. I kind of wish I had grown up in the 60s. California Dreamin is a top 30 song for me. I favorited 4 songs. 4/5
très très sympa j’aime bcp les harmonies de voix en général alors là je suis servie
California Dreamin’ is in a league of its own. Tracks 1 and 11 are decent, and in spite of the pretty harmonies, I find the rest of the album boring
Consistently strong vocals in an inconsistent track list.
A chill and harmless little album you could play in front of your grandmother. Yea, I can't hate this. This is 60s music in its purest form. Also it just casually has one of the greatest songs of the decade on it... Favorite track: Take a fucking guess...
I do love their vocals. The popular hits are awesome. The songs I hadn’t heard were ok. 3/5
I have a soft spot for the M's & P's, some of the sweetest music to come from terrible and terrorized people, but I don't know that they are really an album band. A greatest hits would probably do you better. A great undersung (though likely offensive by modern standards) album to come out of their poisoned honey universe is John Phillips The Wolfking of LA.
It splits the difference between sunny 60s psychedelic pop and 70s AM radio staples, with echoes of popular music from the ’50s. The harmonies are nice, but outside of the big hits “Monday, Monday” and “California Dreaming,” it feels pretty light on substance — delicate and pretty, but not especially memorable. I confess that this album betrays an innocence and optimism that I find hard to square with our present-day Bad Place reality. Which is a depressing thing to realize, and it’s not their fault. But I am also just now learning about the dark back story of this group, which is.
I did not know the Ramones' Do You Wanna Dance was a cover and now I do and I'm biased but that cover was way better than whatever this was.
Like the harmonies but still a bit schmaltzy.
3.5 stars. Solid album. Strong flavors of hippie culture while maintaining relevance today. Favorite songs: Go Where You Wanna Go, I Saw Her Again, Monday
Very 60s not bad but a few too many poor covers to make it a classic! Nice harmonies though.
Overall: 9/10 I seriously didn't expect to like this so much. I'm actually glad I had low-ish expectations, despite really loving the song California Dreamin'. What I didn't expect was the way this album reminded me of other 60's artists I adore (shades of The Beach Boys, The Beatles and Simon and Garfunkel). This is like Rubber Soul and Pet Sounds had a baby. Not only that, but there were moments that made me realize that these guys must have been influential on Abba and other 70s pop/disco artists. The songwriting is so good all throughout. I'll admit that the last few songs didn't wow me as much as the rest of the album but that might change as I relisten to them. It's a shame about the band's history though, truly messed up stuff right there! Fav Song: California Dreamin'
I'm such a hippie!
2 felt 2 harsh. It was alright, a bit woo-woo, but that is not the worst thing in the world
stereo audio almost dragged this to a 3
Average, except for California Dreaming which is mesmerising
I’ve never really liked the “group” vocal stuff, it always sounds more like a show choir or something- not very rock and roll. Obviously, a couple of classic tunes on here, but most of it just seems a little lacking to me
I honestly was expecting a little more just by seeing it had California dreaming on it but it was still pretty good nonetheless. It felt a bit repetitive and I’m not really a fan of their style of constant harmonies basically making up the whole song. I liked how the vocalists changed though and despite how constant the harmonies were, they did vary a bit in how they were delivered for each song, despite this though it was still repetitive but with some variation in instrumentation which I can appreciate. Favourites: I call your name, California dreamin’ and Somebody groovy. Overall, 6/10 (maybe a bit too nice).
It's good for what it is, I think I just don't care much for this era and genre
Fine. California Dreamin is great. Not my favourite 60s album.
Yeah, go on. It’s quite pleasant
Almost bang on a 3.5. Two great songs and very inoffensive for the remainder. The question is whether it’s inoffensiveness pushes it up 0.5 (because it didn’t annoy me) or down 0.5 (because it was too blah)……I think down, unfortunately, but it’s a very strong 3, which I’m sure will be solace to them.
Almost a 4.
1 great song and some tolerable background noise
California Dreamin is an all time classic but the rest was just ok
5/5. Although I'm pretty heard I've heard every 60's pop album under the sun, this one felt different. I do think it's the creativity with well known songs and taking alternate avenues with how to go about song writing. The production is fantastic and feels at a high quality compared to other albums at the time. There also feels like there is a darker undertone here, like subtle messaging with these "love" songs. This album and band feels like it inspired bands like Abba and Fleetwood Mac, a conversation within the band itself. And this one was really good as well. Best Song: Monday Monday, Go Where You Wanna Go, Straight Shooter, You Baby
Now I hope some Mama Cass solo stuff is on this list.
Four people in one bathtub? These fuckers are crazy.
Tja.. Ikke min greie ihvertfall, men åpenbart kompetent musikk. Svak 3.
A few great songs and lovely vocal performances throughout. Production and instrumentation aren’t really anything to write home about - it’s warm late-60s folk pop fare. It’s a little slight and also feels longer than it is, but it’s a good record.
Honestly a great Album for the time with a true highlight of California dreaming. That being said this album does have some more dated songs that keeps it from being a 5 for me
Dude! This album rules! Why have I never given this a fair shot I adored this. Definitely going to come back to it. The harmonies are so damn good and the arrangements are like pet soundsy. Great job wrecking crew. Aged super super well
Not sure if this was just because I had just listened to the hives or because I was in a rotten mood from a miserable night of driving uber eats through a torrential rainstorm, but this was a godsend. So light and joyful, and the harmonies and songwriting are mwah. When the worst song on an album is California Dreamin’ (no nuance take btw) you know you have a good album. Gonna say 4.5 but maybe will regret it in the future.
Porridge is too hot, porridge is too cold.
There's one big standout and the rest are above average 1960s songs.
fantastiskt höstalbum
Starting a Monday morning with “Monday, Monday” is kinda fun, but otherwise I wasn't excited about this one. Based on some of the other album selections on this list, the fact that this record contains the Billboard number 1 single of 1966, "California Dreaming'", is probably enough to warrant its inclusion. However, even if you throw that one out, you still get "Monday, Monday" "Go Where You Wanna Go" and "Do You Wanna Dance"(admittedly not the most iconic cover of this song) along with a slew of other smooth 60s pop-folk songs. Not quite my thing, but it's hard to argue with the reach and influence of this album and of the group.
I vibe with this. Lovely harmonies, some really great tunes. An all time classic.
2/5
A couple great songs and the worst version of Do You Wanna Dance I've ever heard.
Yes, I can believe them! This is totally fine.
It has always sounded nostalgic to me. Music of a time and place...some good tunes but not timeless.
Ok
I guess this is fine but it is very confused.
Great combination of vocals and a grezt representation of the flower power era.
Really enjoyed - nice chilled album
sunny, ethereal pop album. embodies LA kind of sound really well - 7.5/10
I enjoyed the harmony and the flow of the album
Can we believe what we see and hear? With John Phillips, not at all. No sickly sweet production could cover his unpleasantness. In 1960, Psycho was the first film to show a flushing toilet, hinting at the effluent that pop culture tries to imagine away. The bidet on the cover of this album makes the same transgressive move: can the four hippies in the tub be as wholesome and peace-loving as their image and their sound makes out? Can we really believe that Phillips "stopped into a church (he) passed along the way" without bursting into flames? He's tempting us to prod the surface and touch his gross, wriggling id beneath. It should be no surprise, then, that the music is so insubstantial: it's a fake front, there is no heart, because the heart is small and black. The veil of production is as garish and thin as Jimmy Savile's running shorts (I just googled Savile to check the spelling of his surname and the platform describes him as "media personality and DJ. John Phillips too is a "singer-songwriter.") Of course, one can and should separate the artist from the art, but, when the artist is toying with you, as though he were the Zodiac Killer, you don't have to be taken in. Wan, banal stuff. 1.5 Sure they are all on the cover piled in a bathtub together but that’s as indecorous as this album gets. Everything here feels clean and polished to sparkle. Careful arrangements and lovely little details in the piano and the bass, and the strings, and of course the vocals weave in and out spotlessly. But for the most part there is only the sparkle and nothing much behind it. Most of these songs weren’t worth the effort. Inoffensive fluff. Can the Polished Turd help but spring to mind? There is a toilet on the front cover. Looking at that toilet actually - did toilets used to sit lower? It just seems too close to the floor. I could research that - that’s something for me to do instead of ever listening to this again. 2/5
Wonderful harmonies
This still feels pretty creative and not overly dated. This probably blew peoples minds when it came out.
It's fine... it just sounds like a group trying to be like the Eagles or the Beach Boys. But California Dreamin' is a good song
California Dreamin' evokes the era perhaps better than any other song. Sadly, the rest of the album doesn't live up to it. Some of it is pleasant enough, but the rest is fairly dull easy listening.
Good pop album. Bass was doing some interesting stuff. Harmonies got boring fast but I can see why they've inspired so many covers.
These songs always remind me of driving through town on weekend mornings with my ex-girlfriends family, K-Earth 101 playing through the old stereo in her step-dads car, this was around 2003, good times.
An entire album of music which would work well in a '60s flashback scene. The majority of the album is solid, albeit nothing that will live long in the memory. California Dreaming is the obvious standout, of course., but it would've been good if the extended cut were on here.
ABsolute fire
Just can’t really enjoy listening to the mamas and papas since I read their Wikipedia page
Perfectly good doo wop style pop music but I’m a bit bored of the 60s bias towards ‘classics’. A lot of this is forgettable and if it wasn’t for the one big single, I don’t think we’d listen to them much at all.
I'm not disputing this album being in the list; makes a lot of sense from the political and musical point of view. Yet I did not find it very interesting or entertaining; just plain ok. 5/10
A nice, breezy 60s pop record with terrific singing and harmonies. The songs are simple and unthreatening. I like it but can't think I'll listen to this one often. Top tracks: "California Dreamin'," "Monday, Monday"
"Monday, Monday" & "California Dreamin'" are great songs that earned their place in the pop/rock music canon. I also really like "The 'In' Crowd". Everything else is forgettable
A couple of songs I enjoyed, but overall not my favorite genre.
The more I listen, the more I dislike all these 60's albums. It's obviously a fine album, but nothing really spectacular besides, you know, "California Dreaming" so just listen to that and your favorite Beatles album and call it good.
A fun album, I really thoroughly enjoyed it as a nice, easy listening exercise. The heads are pretty solid, nothing really popped to me, but I would definitely listen again. I think three out of five is good, it’s almost 4.
This mostly seems to rely on the strength of its singles. Unfortunately, the version I had access to uses the singles mixes, so I don’t know quite what the original LP sounded like.
Dupe
Defining 60s songs...gorgeous harmonies, classic songs...just over 30 mins long...what's not to like! 4/5
Me he guardado los clásicos "Monday, Monday" y "California Dreamin'", me gustó también "Spanish Harlem", pero en general me ha parecido un album que seguía la estela de los Beatles y que ya no fueron a más. Todo el mundo no pude ser igual que esos genios, pero hubiera estado bien algo más de ellos después de hacer canciones tan buenas.
No son malos, pero es realmente aburrido. Rock de semilla, medio coral.
This was the music my father enjoyed. So I knew most of the songs. Not my type of music but I did enjoy listening.
The singles on this album are absolute classic bangers. Everything else is a bit lack luster. 2.5 outta 5
Great album. Couple of iconic songs, couple of remakes, couple songs that I had never heard, but were amazing especially the final track “the in crowd”
i thought this was a very 'okay' album - wasn't exactly bad but also wasn't a very enjoyable listen. a lot of the tracks sounded like bad beatles songs so there was no surprise when i heard the beatles cover. obviously knew 'california dreamin'' before listening - most of the other tracks sounded pretty similar or at least fit the same vibe. there's definitely better options for folk/pop albums so can't see myself ever listening to it again.
4/5
Альбом одной песни. Не, вы не подумайте, так то весь альбом довольно неплох, но все же интересна, наверное, только California Dreamin. А в остальном - довольно стандартный хиппи-балладный рок середины 60х. Каких-то прям выдающихся идей не заметил, но хорошо что такая музыка есть. А еще тут опять хардпан то в одно, то в другое ухо, про существование наушников тогда люди не думали, вестимо...
3,9
Classic from the 60s. Strong pop/ folk songs with beautiful harmonies. Not 100% for me but hard to deny the classics such as Monday Monday and Californian Dreamin. Would recommend.
Great 60s record. The hits are classic, easy listening for the rest
I really love some of these songs..mainly the ones that were written by Phillips and other band members. The only cover song that I cared for was “I call your name” which might be my favorite song from this band; I think the arrangement is awesome, and much prefer it to the Beatles version. I just love their harmonies, and to me they are fairly unique. If this album did not include the other cover selections, I would give it five stars, even in spite of the fact that John Phillips was such an incestuous creep. But the additional cover songs drag it down to four stars.
Noen kule sanger, men ikke helt min sjanger
Helt ok, fine harmonier, men litt masete etterhvert når det er ett helt album med bare det. California Dreamin er en banger da, det skal de ha
Monday, Monday var ganske stilig og passende California Dreamin er en banger, rart den kommer så langt ute i albumet Litt fin sound jevnt over, men ingen har den samme oppbygningen helt på samme måte Likte det likevel Litt langt
Obviously a lot of all-timer singles on here, but other than that it's a run-of-the mill 60-s cali album
These guys can sing, that's for sure. The Mamas/Papas are a group that are of their time. One can put on California Dreamin' and instantly get a feeling for the time period. The fabulous mid-60s; the year 1966. The year before the psychedelic rush hit the world. This record is stuck in that transitionary period where the early 60s turned into the late 60s. The voices of the Mamas and Papas come together in great unison. Monday, Monday, Straight Shooter, Got A Feelin' and I Call Your Name (a Lennon/McCartney song?) are all great. But at a certain point, the record hits some insignificant points that bring down by rating by a smidge. Still, for the joy and talent that I hear within the music, I do believe what I see and hear (7/10, 4/5 on this scale)
I could’ve just put on any other Beatles album that I fw, or played the Beach Boys greatest hits and gotten more out of that experience. Not bad, but I don’t think I had to listen to this to really get much out of it. *Spanish Harlem kind of slaps
California Dreaming, while a fan fave, makes me wanna do shrooms and run through a field while the warm sun shines down. 78 degrees, no humidity type best. I enjoyed!
This is an interesting one - California Dreamin' is one of the all timers - but I think that the issue here is that the rest of the album just doesn't hold up to it in a consequential way. Quite frankly, I imagine that this is a product of its time - if I had the sensibilities of the a person living in the 60s, I might find this album to be more transformative. I'm sure that during the time period, this was quite revolutionary. In 2025 however, it feels a little middle of the road. Ultimately, I think some albums transcend time, but this ain't that.
I like the songs individually but felt like a whole album was more than I needed of this vibe.
Fun and light-hearted. This is totally the American version of ABBA. Fav song: Spanish Harlem
The singles are classics. It all feels so ... "of the time". An album I wouldn't turn off, but probably wouldn't otherwise sit down to listen to.
Too much of the same era
"California Dreamin'" is the only number that stands out on this album for me. The rest I can very much take or leave. It's a bit of a limp lettuce of an album, and as nice as the artist's voices are, I wouldn't rush to play it again, although, of course, it's very easy to listen to.
For a band where the main instrument is their voices this is pretty great
Honestamente no tenía ni idea de que este grupo existía y es glorioso
Monday, Monday, Straight Shooter, California Dreamin' , You Baby - my favourites! 💞
One of the most 60s albums ever. Everything from the melodies, to the arrangements, to the production, to the lyrics are all firmly planted in 1966. Some don’t like that, but I definitely do. The vocal harmonies are all amazing and the arrangements are great. The songwriting is very strong, even if it is very much of its time. 4/5
4/10 - not unpleasant, a bit boring though but very west coast sound
Good harmonies and tambourines, highlighted by California Dreamin.
The Mamas & The Papas are kind like the gay beach boys. That’s what I kept thinking. This is like that beach boys album but gay. It’s fine, easy to listen to. But it’s not very fun.
Great if you're into that kinda thing, no denying they're talented vocalists. The album just felt like a lot of less good than the original covers. If you dig Rockapella, this prob your Abbey Road
Good songs, good harmonies….kind of sounds like what I’d imagine The Beach Boys would sound like if they didn’t have Brian Wilson and had to rely on Bruce Johnston and Al Jardine for their musical direction; a little corny and dated but still strong harmonies and musicianship. Definitely some interesting covers on here, and I always loved “California Dreamin’ “. I’d like to spend more time with this one and let it grow on me… “Hey Girl” is a low point, a wet noodle of a song with dorky energy.
I like 60s music but nothing really stuck out to me as super interesting. On the other hand, I think I’ll enjoy it more as I listen to it more. I really liked Straight Shooter, Do You Wanna Dance, and Go Where You Wanna Go.
When this popped up I knew I was going to hate it. I'm 670 albums into this project, so I'm going to finish it, but I'll tell you - I'm not excited for it anymore. There's just waaaayyyyy too much 60s and 70s bullshit, and many of these bands have five and six albums - Bowie, apparently, has nine! That wouldn't be so much of a problem except they've left out some very obvious albums from other eras/genres and it's frustrating. I guess this is less of a review of the album and more a vent about the project. So here's the album review: it stinks. it sounds like the Beatles added a chick and some tambourines. It's such a template of 60s flower child hippie bullshit. It sounds like the Monkees. It sounds like every other hippie, flower child template album in this project, of which there are about 30.
Easy listening, made me feel like I could have been picking flowers and chatting to my friends about free love
Un classique qui n’usurpe pas sa réputation!
Nice easy listening.
First half of the album was pretty dull to me, but the second half made me pay more attention
Listenable.
3.5
Naj poznatija pesma na albumu je "California dreamin" i bez sumnje ja naj bolja pesma, ostale nisu ni slicne ali nisu lose.
was straight shooter the inspiration for the countdown timer music?
It was fine
Another 3/5 album. Not bad, not great either. Pretty good, pretty solid. Any album with "California Dreamin'" on it can't reasonably be scored any lower. A couple album tracks are nice, too. The Mamas and the Papas are better than your stereotypical '60s folkpop hippie band, so they've got that going for them.
A 4 star record with a 6 star song on it
What an album, I did not expect to love every minute of listening, but good golly did I ever. Terrible band name, but banger music.
Old
The standout here is obviously "California Dreamin", which remains one of the best songs of the 60s. I also thought "Somebody Groovy" was great. But outside of that, I just didn't find much that was too interesting to latch onto. The harmonies are solid, the instrumentation polished, but ultimately it sounds just like a lot of the California pop of the time mixed in with some staples of British invasion. Of course The Mamas and the Papas were crucial to the counterculture movement, but I don't know if this album as whole is representative of that.
The last half of the album felt stronger than the first half. I don't know whether that was simply because California Dreamin' put me in a more receptive mood or what, but it felt that way. Who gave the okay for that album cover though? What the hell!
Love me some vocal harmonies. Fav tracks - Monday, Monday, Got a Feelin', California Dreaming
Algumas boas, mas a maioria chata
Day 30 Some absolutely gorgeous harmonies, really smooth. One I’ll definitely revisit on summer walks. 8/10 Highlights Straight Shooter California Dreamin’
*1966. *Quintessential 1960s - total psychedelic California sound. *Monday Monday and California Dreamin'. *Not a big fan of the slower songs, but the up-tempo ones were fun. RATING - 7/10
California Dreamin is a banger and next to this everything else on the album feels pretty bland MOR lacking. Some lovely harmonies some shonky recording/ production.
Honestly, disappointed really. California Dreamin' is a top record and The M&Ps come with a reputation for being 60s influencers. Beyond California Dreamin' and Monday, Monday, there's not a lot on here. The kind of band for which a best of album does the trick. Extra rating on the strength of California Dreamin'
Not bad, makes sense california dreamin was the one that made it out, it’s the most distinct out of all the tracks here. I feel this sound has a weird survivorship bias where all the songs I recognize are the blueprint for this genre and everything else I don’t recognize is a weird offshoot of it - something about them just compositionally doesn’t click as well. Idk
Great harmonies and melodies, a perfect encapsulation of the 1960’s.
The title track is a great song which I have actually been playing a lot in the last couple days as the leaves begin to turn. I'd never listened to the rest, and it was quite forgettable. I did kind of like their Do You Wanna Dance too, though it's no Beach Boys.
All bangers. Not a single miss on this album. Even though Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' have been overplayed, I still don't mind hearing them and that is a testament to the greatness that is the Mamas & The Papas.
Played out and kinda stale now but hugely Influential and great use of vocal harmony accents (full but not overdone).
Everything you’d want from the Mamas and the Papas. Several good songs, and staples of their genre
This is an early sort of psych album, and overall, it’s pretty good! Most of these songs are pleasant, well made psych pop and folk rock songs, I just don’t have a ton to say about them. There are little highlights like Monday, Monday and Spanish Harlem dotted around, and especially for how early this hit the scene, I think it’s worth hearing. That being said, I think there is *one* song here that is really, *really* good, and that’s (of course) California Dreamin’. I honestly think this is one of the best songs of the ‘60s, *and* I think it’s one of the *most* psychedelic songs of the ‘60s too. Like the experience of listening to it just feels weird. It’s like a combination of the technicolor reverb, the *stubbornly* minor key, the droning vocal harmonies, and the kind of lo-fi, warm, 60’s fuzz that comes with less expensive recordings of the era. The effect of this all is a song that I really think could cause a hypnosis state or something. Like it reaches a little bit deeper into the brain than music is usually supposed to. I wouldn’t say it’s scary per-se, but if you told me this could activate sleeper agents, I’d believe you. It’s an irreplaceable song. The rest of the album isn’t really pushing it down, but I don’t think any other song here really keeps up. That being said, I’d say the full package is still worth hearing at least once.
Wasn’t expecting to like this as much as I did considering there are very few non-rock albums from this time that I enjoy.
Powerful use of harmonies in stereo sound with some absolutely classic songs.
Classic sunshine pop album. Beautiful harmonies that belie their counter cultural lyrical message.
Schlock. Laurence Welk in hippie clothes.
Delightful - a very different sixties than Revolver, but passionate and charming and tight without being mannered.
Those apostrophes will never cease to irk me, but California Dreamin' lives in my head for about half of every year. The rest is filler.
3.5
Good stuff. Probably more groundbreaking then than sounds now. Might get better with repeat listening, albeit accessible stuff anyway.
Another perhaps not lasted the test of time it is an interesting listen and quite pleasent they compriment each other well and harmonise well. A good listen all around. However not really my bag overall
so funny to read that the record was pulled from stores because the toilet on the cover was judged indecent. It's a nice album to listen to! California Dreamin' is such a banger
Quite pleasant to hear but nothing that caught me too much
Wow the Mamas and Papas sound like a wholesome bunch! Don’t read into them if you’d like to keep that opinion and just enjoy the music for what it is.
Mommy and daddy… I like!!!!!
pretty fine for me
Not particularly engaging for me though I like this style of music in general Fav song: Monday Monday prob
Beautiful
sixties pop rock, pretty enjoyable! a bit too much tambourine for me, but overall a pretty good entry. I know California Dreamin' is probably the big hit off this one, but I cant stand it. However I can recognize the talent behind the music in this case.
A collection of very enjoyable pop songs. Monday Monday especially stands out. And that’s mostly Papa!
ZzZzZzzzzzZzZzZzzzzzZzZzZz tai um grupo que cairia no esquecimento se não fizessem um filme ou série sobre os anos 60 de 3 em 3 anos (que obrigatoriamente vai tocar california dreamin)
eh anos 60 até o cu fazer biquinho. não no bom sentido. ouso dizer que só tem california dreamin' nesse aqui. o resto eh paia.
8.30, työmatka koss, qobuz eipä tästäkään oikeen mitään sanottavaa ennen kuuntelua, kiva että on mammoja pappojen lisäks. mut jos noin monta menee ammeeseen samaa aikaa ni ei sinne kyllä vettä mahu —kuuntelu o ou stereo on uusi teknologia. stemmoja jeeee ja _oikeita_ instrumentteja
This group is like The Beach Boys meets ABBA. Their sound isn't totally generic though - there are some unique songs on the album too. My favourite song is California Dreamin', which seems to be the album's most popular track. I know a clip of that song was trending on reels (presumably also TikTok) for a while, so not surprising. This was a fun and light listen. 7/10.
Good, and I love the cover album
Not my jam. Some of the hits are fine, and I guess I get why it was a big deal in its day, but I just don’t really vibe with the sound. There were other artists at that time that were doing new and revolutionary things that are more up my alley.
Un poco sinmas
Too bad the collective harmony amongst this group wasn’t as great their vocal harmony was. A staple in the 60’s hippie culture cannon. About half of the album is cover songs, but they are pretty well done.
I would never listen to this album, just not my kind of thing. But two stars because California Dreamin' is an all time greatest song.
Boring…
I was bit worried that this album might be full of California dreaming type of hippie stuff (before the hippie time i know), but there are decent 60's pop songs in this one. Not bad.
I would count playing with stereo image as useless feature that just annoyed me. Otherwise neutral shit.
That stereo-thing is maybe a bit to much...
This is lovely pop music. I have no problems having this playing in the background while doing almost anything. It's not the kind of music I would actively listen to tho.
5/5 looove this album
As 3 as it gets. Did I hate it? No. Perfectly nice mostly. Would I turn it off of someone put it on? No. Would I actively listen out for any track they wasn't California Dreamin'? Probably not. The Do You Wanna Dance cover was alright.
This was fine. Monday Monday and California dreaming stood out. Unfortunately the middle tracks felt a bit generic, not like awful, but not really interesting.
Kinda of interesting to think this would be pop music back in the day. And its very boomer of me but for this to be like lame pop back then is crazy cuz this is kinda awesome? Like its corny as fuck sure but they sound really good and the chord changes in dome of these are really fun
This was a fun album to listen to. I listen to it a couple of times during the long weekend. A lot of songs are on it songs I have not heard in a while. Glad this album is on the list.
Fun summer album with classic tracks. I can imagine grilling some hot dogs by the pool on a 100+ degree day. Or jamming to this on a CA roadtrip. Either way, very enjoyable.
Knew a lot of these songs and they were OK. Wouldn't be in my normal rotation because I am not a boomer or a filmmaker but acceptable.
I like this album, but there is nothing more to it. It had several changes in tones which I liked, but to be honest it was nothing special in my opinion. Of course I love Californa Dreamin', but other than that this album didn't feel that special to me. And because of that I feel a bit disappointed, because I like most of the Mamas & the Papas songs and albums I've listened to before, so I would rate this album a 3.4/5. Favourite song on the album of course is Californa Dreamin'.
Solid pop album. They really tried to mix up the harmonies to keep it interesting, but couldn't always do it. Still, one of the great accomplishments of the 60s. 4/5
Enjoyed this one a lot. I love their use of vocal harmonies. Plus the hits are amazing
Lovely listen. Beautiful voices and really nice songs. 4/4.5
By no means is it a bad album, actually, I can absolutely see the appeal of this being a great album; it just is not my cup of tea in the slightest. "California Dreamin'" is obviously the album's standout track; "Monday, Monday" also stood out, but the rest just blended together into an unremarkable pile. 2/5, added no songs to the liked playlist.
Classic.
Thought it would be another Beatles ripoff, but it turned out more original than I thought
what you get when a heroine addict is aggressively mediocre. There are a few songs that are played on ye olde radio but the rest are like hippies taking one step away from 1950s early 60s rock, as in there is bridge to more modern music and they aren't over it, or in the middle, but have one foot on the bridge and one in the 1950s. Not terrible, just aggressive beige.
"California Dreaming" is easily a 5 star song, but I have to say that the rest really didn't do much for me. It's a great example of 60s music and I can easily see why it would have been so popular back when it was released. Maybe I'm biased by the band's reputation, but I just didn't really find anything that special about the rest of the album. It's fine, but no where near the best music of the era. Still, it's got that one great song though.
Essentially a Classic rock version of The Beach Boys. Good, easy listen. Nothing to complain about but nothing to get excited about either.
Good
Jam packed with pop classics. Very easy listen.
Quintessential oldies. “California Dreamin’” will live on forever. Not something I would want to listen to all the time but not horrible.
i <3 mamas and papas
I enjoyed this listen.