If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears by The Mamas & The Papas

If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears

The Mamas & The Papas

3.43
Rating
29948
Votes
1
2%
2
12%
3
40%
4
34%
5
12%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 15)

The harmonies are unreal. Great psychedelic tinged folk rock. Standouts beside the hits are "Somebody Groovy" and "You Baby"

62/100 ALL THE LEAVES WERE BROOWNNNN this album was just kinda boring, half of it was mid, half of it was decent, california dreamin was unfortunately the best song and the only reason i say unfortunately is because 1. the song itself isn't that great and 2. it breaks the trend of my albums having popular tiktok sounds in them and they were never the best song until this. flip you the mamas and the papas. but in all seriousness, this album is bland af i wouldnt even say its not my cup of tea it was just too repetitive towards the back half

Kind of generic and boring. The guitar in Straight Shooter is good, but it's just kind of mid-level pop. 1/5 stars.

3 love the first track, bit hit and miss for the rest.

Solid, couple standouts, enjoyed the left and right channel focuses.

Lovely '60s record! Great vocal harmonies, great core band stuff. Obviously California Dreaming is a classic, it's worth checking out just for that!

Lovely little album, not really my thing for most of it but it's a nice time all the way, I didn't think much of California Dreamin though

I can appreciate that this was probably huge in the 60w but I'm not a huge fan. It reminds me of ABBA a little. I like California Dreamin' otherwise it wouldn't be on my rotation.

Easy listen but not groundbreaking

Not too bad

Great cloudy day music to hang out and get things done at home. Callie was bopping to it while eating her quesadilla for lunch.

Songs I heard when I was a baby

Very calm, low energy. Very nostalgic sounding.

Did not realize this is who California dreaming is by. Very solid album. Great 60's pop feel.

7/10, Some real bangers on this album. Monday Monday, California Dreaming. Some songs get repetitive due to the vocal harmony style, impressive pipes and layering's though.

Gostei desse álbum! Alguma faixas são clássicas e amplamente conhecidas. QoA Vesper.

Forgot how good this album is. Took me right back to my childhood listening with my mom.

Good stuff, just not exactly my jam.

mediocre nothing crazy

If you wanted to define the sounds of the 1960s and pulled up any album to help you explain it I think this would be a good shout. Obviously California Dreamin' is the stand out but the album bathes it's sometimes unhappy lyrics in pure sunshine pop, with a solid Beatles cover thrown in for good measure.

The harmonies were fun and the sound reminded me a bit of The Beatles. It does feel dated, but in a charming, sunshine-pop kind of way.

California Dreamin' is one of the best songs ever conceived, and the rest of the album reflects it.

Yllättävän ok, 3/5

Zwei herausragende Titel: Monday, Monday und California Dreamin'. Sonst blieb nicht viel hängen.

This one is actually pretty cool

Iconic songs

this was such a good album omg I LOVED IT

Mama Cass was the real deal, John Phillips gives me the ick.

It’s a beautiful record - I was surprised how much I enjoyed. But it’s also very much boomer jams.

I really hate the song Monday, Monday. I like Straight Shooter. Didn't realize that the Ramones cover of Do You Wanna Dance was of these moms and dads. California Banananing. It's just so old sounding. I can appreciate that what it's doing at the time is really good. But like, I'm never gonna spin this on my own without a prompting. Listened to the whole thing, only 35 mins, but it felt longer.

I'm sorry but I hate this. The singles are fine. It just makes me depressed in a musty old house kinda way.

Solid, but unremarkable besides the two big hits.

Dang I feel like a dirty hippy

4.5/5 really slept on some of the other songs in this album. straight shooter is top

If you want to listen to the Mamas and the Papas, this is the album to listen to

Chungking Express is one of my favorite movies. It's hard for me to divorce this group from being anything but the source of the song in that movie and to be completely honest, I prefer the film's other needle drop, the Cantonese cover of the Cranberries' "Dreams".

Such a good debut album.

It was ok, won't listen again

7.5/10 good/strong classics, less convinced by the rest.

monday, monday - dobar pocetak, bas jako 60te, real straight shooter - cooking vajb, svida mi se (dodano u proljeće) got a feelin' - drugacije od ocekivanog, sporija od prethodnih, dobri lyrics, dosta relatable, da sam heartbroken tinejdzerka u 60ima plakala bih na ovo i call your name - zvuci kao intro nekog filma iz 80ih, fora ali nis spec do you wanna dance - fun, dobro bi zvucalo na gramofonu (al to vrijedi i za sve ostale) go where you wanna go - svidaju mi se stihovi, so real, do what you wanna do!! california dreamin' - KLASIK, obozavam onaj "got down on MY KNEES" dio spanish harlem - mirna pjesme, ne svida mi se bas, precrkveni vajb somebody groovy - fora, funky hey girl - dobri stihovi, inspirational, svida mi se kontrast stihova glavnog vokala i backup pjevacice, malo cudno da ju tjesi i govori da ce ju cekat... you baby - super instrumental, stihovi okej the in crowd - jako dobar glas, fora instrumental overall - super vibe, kuzim zasto je popularan album, bas za slusanje na gramofonu u ogromnom bijelom stanu s pogledom na ulicu i puno biljaka i knjiga, da bar mogu davat po pola zvjezdica

Album filled with sugary songs about love with grade school lyrics. Without the obligatory cutscene of 1960s Venice Beach in the backdrop California Dreaming is about as boring as it gets. Very much feels like the product of its time and place.

Monday, Monday...pure vocal bliss. Covering Spanish Harlem is kind of an eye roll. They should have featured Mama Cass and Michelle Phillips to make a distinct cover. A lot of repetitive semi-"doo wop" songs. It's hard to overstate how powerful and yet the same time sweet and welcoming voice of Mama Cass.

Very sweet, very early 60s. The harmonies were nice, and it's layered enough to not give me the irrates. It was fine enough.

Never listened to one of their albums in full before, but obviously knew a few of the tracks. You can't really go wrong with California Dreamin', and the rest is good too. Fav tracks: California Dreamin'; Monday, Monday; Straight Shooter

Of its time. Generic 60s pop hits apart from Monday Monday and California Dreamin, both of which are superb. The latter has a case for the best pop song of the decade in all fairness

The Mama's and the Papa's deliver a timeless classic where vocal harmony shines front and center in this classic folk rock record, with multiple standout tracks. While the album lacks any particular standout or redefining feature it is an incredibly strong and consistent record

Encore un album fun! Son bien 60s, heavy sur les harmonies et la tambourine Manque peut-être un peu de grit à mon goût, un peu corny (Sauf la toune California Dreamin)

the california dreaming album

Nice vocal harmonies, I was expecting more like California Dreamin’ with the late 60’s vibe. It’s more just poppy harmonies.

Quite enjoyed this. Lovely harmonies

The hits on this album are 60s classics, but the rest of the album kind of dragged it down.

If you like the more personal stuff from Brian Wilson and the Beatles you'll probably like this.

Great album, every song a classic, easy listening

Snoozefest

Great album. Starts strong, but new string, and delights all the way through. -4/5

easy listen, so very well known songs

The old time feel to it felt nice. California Dreamin' is above the rest, but fun overall.

All the hits, all the harmonies.

Album was chill, I did enjoy altough not my vibe, enjoyed the two channel audio. Was exciting to listen to. Contains hit song "California Dreamin'".

liked this

John Phillips is allegedly a HUGE POS but his first solo album rips. Mama Cass died an ironic death at Harry Nilsonn's London gaff, 32 years old. As did Keith Moon, 4 years later, also 32. Spooky. Anyway, this is nice enough.

Not the kind of music I'd usually listened to but I really enjoyed the whole album. I think a couple of these songs are going to get added to my playlist.

It's incredibly important to note that the lead vocalist, John Phillips, sexually assaulted his daughter, Mackenzie Phillips, for an entire decade. So these guys are The Beach Boys crossed with Fleetwood Mac. That's to say, shitty vocal group music combined with every band member getting into relationships with eachother, subsequently cheating, and then writing songs about it. Overall it isn't terrible, but there's a certain point where "Easy Listening" music gets too easy to listen to and it just fades into the background. That's this album.

very enjoyable. harmonies stood out

This was lovely. I love this style of 60s music, it’s just so nice to listen to. California Dreamin’ is such a great song and is up there in my top 25 I’d say. Overall, a really solid album!

Harmonies are wonderful, but the album started to feel a bit samey. Good album, overall, but the standouts are the songs you already know.

Felt like I was raiding my father's record collection. But then I listened closer and there's a song about swinging. In any case, love the harmonies on this and the whole 60's vibe, and "Monday, Monday" and California Dreaming" are all-time classics.

Mixed feelings on this one. Absolutely love California Dreamin, has to be one of the best 60s songs and spawned some great covers. Also like it when they get doo-woppy, like on Go Where you Wanna Go. I enjoy the vocals of Mama Cass and Michelle Phillips alot more than the guys, so i like the ones where they take the lead more. But, so much of this is so sanitized and clearly just churned out to make money on pop radio that it brings it down. Didn't go in expecting edge from the Mamas and Papas but they play it so safe that a lot of these tunes just utterly lack soul and are dull listens (looking at you, Spanish Harlem)

Lovely album and such a familiar sound! Very Beatles influenced harmonies and melodies. Listened a few times and will come back it.

I felt fine about this.

Potverdikkie, dit is echt oud. Alsin, dit klinkt echt heel oud. Hele agressieve stereo panning, galmpje, zoetsappige harmonieën, tamboerijntjes dan wel een beatring (ik weet niet over er een velletje op zit). Oude Beach Boys met vrouwen erbij. Ik heb hier niet zo heel veel bij te melden. Ik vind dit voor een keer wel oké om te luisteren. Tussen een 2 en 3, veel meer is het niet. Ik hou het op een 3 omdat je er twee hitjes gratis bij krijgt en California Dreamin' vind ik wel echt een banger.

Gorgeous harmonies, terrible people

Iconic sixties sound. Although I dig my sixties rock a little less poppy and a little more bluesy and hard rocking. Still, it's a good album.

A nice album with of course the fantastic hits. I like several other songs but please no covers. A mix of greatness and some outdated stuff. 4.5 stars rounded to 4.

Monday Monday…

Another album from the sixties that I've enjoyed. In the end most of the songs sounded the same.

That stereo mix dates this so much. Really good song writing though.

solid but they really feel like a superb singles band more than anything to me

This began grating on me from the word go. Other than country, this type of 60's twaddle is second in my personal pecking order of music which I'd be demanding financial compensation to ever be subjected to. Needless to say, I passed up the opportunity to continue listening at around the halfway point. Life is too fucking short. Plus, after conducting some brief research, I learned of the disturbing lore associated with the members of this band, which makes the album cover all the more uncomfortable to look at.

Classic album I did not know that I needed

Pretty great

So incredibly boring and I can’t believe this was ever popular. (Weren’t they the best selling American band from the sixties?) California Dreamin’ is famous but not incredible and not enough ballast to save this sinking ship

I just generally don’t enjoy these multi-singer groups. There’s some good songs on here for sure (California Dreaming = banger) but I just can’t imagine myself returning to this.

High 3 Not as good as my first listen

I'm pretty meh on this. "Hippie doo-wop" would be the most apt description of the album. California Dreamin' is good. Not a bad listen, but not something I'm likely to ever listen to again. 3/5

Really quite lovely

Liked it ! I know I won’t listen to it from start to finish anytime soon BUT I’ll definitely listen to some of the songs from that album.

Dieser rechts/links Split macht mich über Kopfhörer fertig. Jeder Text hier gibt mir übelste frauenschläger-vibes - da sind die Beatles wesentlich besser gealtert (Revolver kam im gleichen Jahr raus, was macht dann dieses Gedudel auf einer muss-man-gehört-haben Liste?)

I'm just not in the mood for this today, the vocal harmony is really good but I'm going with a 2 for now.

"Monday, Monday" is a classic and "California Dreamin'" has to be considered among the best rock songs ever written. Most of the album is skippable. Without those two song, this would be 2 stars. They can only bump it up to 3 stars.

This album ranks as my second favourite album of the members sitting in a bath on the cover. 'Monday, Monday's sets the tone for the album well. Great harmonies, a nice orchestral section. I watched a documentary on the this sound (I think it was called 'The Valley Sound', but I'll only quote this in brackets because I'm not that confident! There's a nice blend of vocals and the songwriting is fairly catchy. I did enjoy it, however there is fair bit of dates lyrics which didn't sit well with me. I enjoyed the inclusion of my favourite underrated Lennon/McCartney track. However, I felt like it was music I would enjoy by myself but not with company. I mean, I wouldn't openly let people know I was listening to it... It's cool, but not THAT cool. 4 stars.

brought back memories. good album for that time frame.

Amazing vocals. Pop beats and Guitars majestic for what would become the psychedelic sound of that time. Not a bad song and every one was catchy.

This is like having after works drinks in your office in the late 60s. Your straight-laced boss who is completely out of touch with the world asks what music is cool these days. Excitedly, you hope for him to put the Doors, the Rolling Stones or maybe even some Hendrix on, but that slow drawl of Monday, Monday reminds you that you are drinking in an office with acquaintances, not partying in the club with friends. Everyone makes polite conversation, and there is a hint of the party lifting as California Dreamin comes on. But that doesn’t last long. You’re not having a terrible time, but you are painfully aware that there are far more enjoyable parties going on down the road.

Good tunes mostly.

It seems very safe middle of the road soft rock that is not offensive but not interesting to listen to either.

Fun and poppy and has all the hits.

Shockingly enjoyed the whole thing thoroughly. Great music and harmonies throughout.

This feels completely okay to me. Maybe even generic.

В древние времена рингтонов на телефонах, самая известная песня группы стояла у меня на звонке, и даже после этого я все равно очень люблю ее. Лучшая песня - California Dreamin’.

It was a bit meh, the classic songs on it brought the score up to 3

That 60s fascination with stereo separation. Album suffers from the recording capabilities of the time. Shouty vocals, bad reverbs that lead to unpleasant buildup on certain vocal parts, excessive stereo separation, a master entirely devoid of low end. Not going to listen to this in mono, but I bet that stereo field is covering for an otherwise completely undecipherable mid range. Engineering issues aside, a good album musically. Great harmonies, good musicians, varied musical structures, some obvious hits. 4*.

Impressive how immediately recognizable the hits are on this album. Easy to listen through at a brisk 34 minute run-time, and a sound that never overstays its welcome between tracks. Not exactly my cup of tea stylistically, but worth a 3 for a genuine “I liked it”.

You should count the number of times they say the word "yeah" on this album, that'd be a fun project too! Have to ignore the incredibly over-dramatic stereo mix, which is very distracting, to get to the good music. Ethos-wise, the pop world is still living in the hedonistic religion that these guys are espousing. "califonia dreamin" is a banger obviously, but some of the non-singles are a slog.

Everyone knows California dreaming. I did not previously know Monday Monday and it’s a good song. The rest of the album was pretty expected. Nice and inoffensive.

I only listened to this for California Dreamin'. Monday, Monday SUCKS

60s folk/soft rock. Not much special here other than the singles. What to pick as best..? Best track - You Baby 2 stars? Or 3?'

Crazy, I was just singing Monday Monday to my kid yesterday! Because today is Monday! It's nice when art can enter your life with subjects like Days of The Week. Anyway, Monday Monday and California Dreamin' are great tunes that rise above but are still the same as the rest of this general 60s hippie folk/pop type thing. It's good, but the hits are hits for a reason and the others are not for basically the same reason. Pleasant.

Mamas and Papas is always good. Fun early disco type stuff, I'd listen to this a few times a year.

Pleasant, but dated.

Starts off with Monday, Monday. Never knew the artist, but now I do! Same thing with California Dreamin'. Seems like this may be a recurring theme... Overall, strong Beatles vibes, especially on Straight Shooter. This makes sense I suppose for 1966 as that was a common sound of the era. Favorites: - Straight Shooter - California Dreamin' - Somebody Groovy

While an enjoyable album to listen to, not too much stood out for me other than the classics “Monday, Monday” and “California Dreamin”. Some nice harmonies throughout, but maybe I just wasn’t in the right mindset for this vibe today. Favorite tracks: - Monday, Monday - California Dreamin’

Soaring harmonies and upbeat melodies make this a classic

I lot of ear worms on this one by way of the Monkees, Beach Boys, and the Beatles. The sound is fun, the lyrics are easy-going even at its most emotional. Will this stick with me? Not as much as their contemporaries. Do they still feel important? Of course. Definitely a good record to get into the zeitgeist of pop around this era.

Nice harmonies, melodic flourishes, but lacking in the kind of consistent creativity and sophistication that would make it consistently compelling listening.

Solid, solid, solid.

High quality, but it also shows how much better Beatles were at the small things. It’s close to three but

The harmonies are amazing.

fun enough i suppose! in addition to the usual suspects, i found spanish harlem and somebody groovy to be pretty good.

This album has California Dreamin' and Monday Monday, which I was already familiar with. These two also happen to be the strongest songs on the album. The remainder of the album is overall pretty forgettable. There are some covers which in my opinion don't add anything over other versions. I would listen again because I didn't mind it, but would probably prefer to just listen to California Dreamin'.

All the leaves are brown And the sky is brown We're all wearing brown And the cover's brown Lets add some brown text And all get in the bath A very beige album for such a Summer's day

This is like being put in a time machine and transported right to the 60s once Monday, Monday comes on. Such a good song. Fitting we get this on a hot summer day because all I can picture is the beach and sunny skies when listening along. California Dreamin' is a classic. I wonder how often it's been used in movies or TV shows. Other than the 2 songs I listed, none other stand out. Still a good listen overall. I land at around 3.5 stars for this, but will round up to a low 4.

Monday, Monday a classic jam. California Dreamin' is delightful. Classic summer of love sounding pop jam with beautiful harmonies. Love Spanish Harlem. Ran through this quickly. Fine album, but not something that is lingering with me. Going with a middle of the pack 3 here.

Never heard of this album or band, but have certainly heard a couple of the songs on here. Spanish Harlem caught my ear. Short and sweet album. Low side of 4, but it was nice and pleasant.

Some 60s folk. The switching from male to female singing though was a nice change up. Pretty standard album.

I needed this after that last Pere Ubu album. Very chill sunshine pop that is some classic 60's folky pop rock. Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' are incredible. California Dreamin' specifically is one of the greatest songs of all time. Really loving Mama Cass's vocals on The "in" Crowd. Really enjoyable rekkid.

Ok, separate the art from the artist. Die Inzucht Story vom Bandgründer hat mich doch sehr stark angewidert. Eigentlich alles am Album gefällt mir, die Songs, das Arrangement, die Melodien, jeden Song geht man mit und man will das es nicht aufhört.

California Dreamin war in unsere USA Playlist. Jedes Lied was da drin war pusht das Album einen Stern nach oben. Ansonsten auch ganz coole Musik.

9/1001 :: The Mamas & The Papas - If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ❌ Rating: Light 3 Fav Tracks: Somebody Groovy, California Dreamin’ Aside from Monday, Monday, California Dreamin’ and their cover of In Crowd I had never heard this album before. The Mamas and the Papas are a product for of the time. Feels like there are no original ideas here and it’s just a 60s (or at times 50s) pop album. The music is not offensive and I understand its place in time. These songs are a good backdrop for a movie that takes place in the 60s. Overall it’s fine, but unless I’m missing something it’s pretty uninteresting and I won’t be returning.

All of these 60 signs song the same. They are good, but all the same, I enjoy them, but they have the same vibe

California dreamin and others are fine but its some folk rock

The group that invented harmonizing. Man, if they weren't too busy screwing each other and over they could've been bigger. Cass Elliot got the short end of the stick with this group and it's a shame she didn't get to enjoy her stint in the spotlight longer. 4/5

It's fine for 60's pop-rock. No surprise but California Dreamin' was the best song IMO. I could see this growing on me over time

Beautiful singing and calming lyrics. A nice chill listening experience. Songs that are easy to sing along too.

Good pop from the 60s. Although I can't help but thinking that all of these pop bands from this era are all a year or so behind the trends set by the Beatles. This album sounds like something from Beatles For Sale, which was like 2 years before this. That's not a bad thing though, there was a lot more room for pop like this, and the Beatles move on very quick from styles that they seemingly invent.

I have heard a few of these songs, but everyone is solid lyrically, production, and their harmonizing is off the charts fantastic.

California Dreamin' is iconic. Nothing was too much of a bop but I enjoyed the easy listening.

hard to rate fairly without the nostalgia bias. easy listening!

Wow, what treacly, soulless, mid-60s pop crap. Saved only by the classic song “California Dreamin’.” But otherwise, a long slog for a 33-minute record.

California Dreaming is one of the best songs ever created. It is definitely the best song on this album.

The band has a strong technical ability, but their songs are so schmaltzy and syrupy that I just can't stand it.

Really beautiful harmonies and vocals. I'm not usually a fan of lots of gang vocals, but here they work well and weave through each other in really interesting ways. The sound is cozy, comforting, and warm. Not my usual type of music but a really nice listen.

pretty cool but repetitive!!! obviously california dreamin is one of the best songs ever but the rest of the album didn’t hit too hard

Album idéal pour écouter avec mes parents. Pour leur remémorer que leur génération voulait sauver la planète mais qu'en fin de compte ils ont complètement saboté leur plan. Bravo les Baby Boomers. Dans le bain juste à côté de la toilette. Représentatif. (Message pour Steph: je ne suis pas un Baby Boomer)

Vraiment fade, j'ai l'impression d'écouter un des premiers albums des Beatles, jusqu'àHelp (mais ils ont même pas le mérite d'être les premiers à l'avoir fait). Désolé Alice... :/

Pas mon époque! Je n’ai aucune envie d’y revenir.

I enjoyed what it was. I think that what came after (and some of the same time) was so much better. I’ll never listen to this again, but it was good. I’d rather listen to The Beach Boys or CSNY. I almost dropped it a whole lot because of “The ‘in’ crowd”. What a stupid song. It’s like what someone would say if they weren’t cool. I promise!! People want to know where we are! We are the in crowd! We know what’s cool!

Bleak-wood Mac

I’ve heard the singles. Never heard an entire album. Really amazed how good it was.

This is a staple....

This was fun to listen to in the setting I did, the conservatory at Carrick. I think it would make great music for a movie sound track and to me that’s a huge compliment. I recognised some of it I think which is probs why it was on this list. Mostly just fun is how I’d describe it. Go where you wanna go and Spanish Harlem were the highlights for me.

I remember most of these songs. Reminds me of summer and my younger years.

Remember in the 60s when everyone was really into panning everything hard right or hard left? Yep, that. Sigh. Such a classic, clean sound. I’ve grown up listening to Boomers playing California Dreaming, so it’s hard to get excited about that one (again). Doesn’t resonate with me in the same way, but these are good songs, beautifully done.

Consistently strong throughout but none of the songs necessarily blow me away (even California Dreamin), just a simple selection of great tunes

They ite...

Obviously already familiar with the band and some of the songs on here. There were a few with a more country feel which was interesting.

Chill, oldie album.

Meh, it was ok.

Haven't listened to the mamas & the papas much before. Only experience of their music I've had before has been singing California Dreamin with my friends. That song I love. Thought they were a one hit wonder band. They're not. Sounds like you would think bands from the 60s would sound like, and that's probably because they're one of the bands pioneering and being the best in that genre. At least that's what I think having listened to this album.

Shouldn't be saying that knowing what I know about the band, but that's as perfect as the sound gets of the 60s flower power pure joy... I still have my "The Mamas & The Papas Greatest Hits" somewhere, so may not be objective

3 Monday Monday - It's true, you can't trust that day. Surprised by the short length of the songs, but I like it! Doesn't overstay. Great tracks, held up really well. Don't think I would listen again but great music!

It is good for a rock album but not my style I would listen to it but never pick it 3/5

i knew more songs than i thought thanks to GAP & GUFs wedding party. overall enjoyed listening to it but probably wouldnt optionally choose to listen to it unless someone else put it on. my favourite songs were california dreamin, you baby and monday, monday

Positives: Very upbeat and bubbly, charming, catchy but not repetitive Negatives: Not many stand out songs 7 out of 1

I could barely believe my eyes and ears. My eyes were flummoxed by the sight of two mamas and two papas in a bathtub. My ears were delighted to hear these tunes.

Classic 1960s summertime album, so many hits

Prime hippie time. Such a lo-fi sound, but the emotion is still captured. Really nice record with some pleasant tunes. The vocal harmonies add to it a lot along with the backing instrumentation - really captures the era of the music. Very nice and simple record.

Some classic pop songs. Cass Elliot was great. The Philipses seemed terrible, though, so I dunno how to feel about this band overall. The general sound of this album is very pleasant, if unremarkable.

It was good.

Veldig ålreit

Monday, Monday: Absolute banger, love the sound and the background vocals Straight Shooter: Decent, like the chorus Got a Feelin': Nice and mellow, very soft sounding I Call Your Name: Not a fan, drums are way too pronounced and old Do You Wanna Dance: Too slow and sounds too old Go Where You Wanna Go: I don't wanna go where I wanna go California Dreamin: Saving grace to the rest of the album Spanish Harlem: Like the lalalas, oh yeah, this is a banger Somebody Groovy: Not bad, feels very similar to the rest Hey Girl: Mid at best You Baby: Not rememberable The 'In' Crowd: Ehhhh Best Song: Monday, Monday Worst Song: Do You Wanna Dance Favorite New Song: Spanish Harlem

I was only exposed to the bangers on this album, being “Monday, Monday” and “California Dreamin’”. However, the album does have some duds. 3/5

That was a very familiar album. For me, it was easy listening and very enjoyable. I think I'd pick up a copy if I saw one. Would listen again. Their singing is flawless and beautiful.

Giving this an extra star for such a good use of stereo sound. Songs: Monday Monday, California Dreamin, The In Crowd

fucking brilliant

This is the 143rd album I’m rating. I find it very funny how much hotter Michelle Phillips is than everybody else. Adding to my Playlist - Monday, Monday, Got a Feelin', I Call Your Name, and Somebody Groovy. Not Adding to my Playlist - Do you Wanna Dance, Go Where you Wanna Go, Spanish Harlem, Hey Girl, You Baby, and The "In" Crowd. Already Added to my Playlist - Straight Shooter and California Dreamin'. California Dreamin' - I recently watched Chungking Express and it's quickly become my favorite movie of all time surpassing Goodfellas. All in all I liked 6/12 songs. Not the greatest album ever but I'll always smile when listening to Straight Shooter and California Dreamin'.

schon älter, aber ganz nette Sachen dabei

I was surprised how much I liked this. The vocals and the layering of them are so perfect!

Monday Monday Straight shooter California dreamin

maravilhoso

Not a fan of Beatles clones. One great song with the rest of the album being something I would never really listen to.

Bright, shiney melodies. Beautiful harmonies. Amazing songwriting.

Very nice sound. Some cover versions to fill it out

нормалек.

Really fun sound and some phenomenal songs. However, definitely felt like some of the songs were just fillers.

Surprisingly interesting given the 60s sterotypes I associated with this band

Good wholesome 1960s vibes

“California Dreaming” is an all-timer, the rest is just fine. It’s fine.

Meh. To samey. 2-3/10.

Classic album with some excellent songs I recognise, but won’t listen to it again.

++*: Straight Shooter ++: I Call Your Name, Do You Wanna Dance, California Dreamin', Somebody Groovy, You Baby, The 'In' Crowd +: Monday, Monday, Got a Feelin', Spanish Harlem, Hey Girl +-: Go Where You Wanna Go 7,7/10

It was fine. Nothing special and you can kind of hear how much they all hate each other

It’s just not my taste to be honest ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Ahhhhh brings me back to university. My ex-girlfriend loved this album. California Dreamin is a classic, especially

Yeah, good, I think 60s music doesn't really draw me in. Can respect it, especially California Dreamin', but leaves me wanting more

I thought The Beach Boys yesterday sounded aged. Well actually this wasn’t so bad. But it wasn’t so great either. Perhaps it’s my youthful ear but I think there’s a reason the only song from this I know is California Dreamin’. Not actively bad but not my cup of tea.

This kinda style and sound is ok in small doses

california dreamin la única buena

So good I almost choked on my sandwich

California Dreamin’ is absolute mastery, rest of the album is a showcase of good close harmony tracks. Very enjoyable

Listening on a 'Monday Morning'. Thats got to be a 1 in 7 chance. But I'm in summer, not 'on a winters day', it's June. Thats a 1 in 4 chance. But at least my Spanish Red Roses are doing well this year. All pretty innocent times. The album cover was banned because.... shock horror... there is a toilet in the picture, I mean, how could they, disgusting! Burn them! Have they no principles. In spite of their crap name and album cover, the songs took be back in time to more innocent days, not that I can remember them, my romanticised version of them. Whatever. Geeks.

it's pleasant in the background

They said "let's make an album with lots and lots of barbershop quartet vibes. Make it pop " and the world was changed

Original songs were basic, but catchy

I don't think I'm old enough to understand why this is here. It's a fine simulacrum of 60s ice cream pop.

so so so so so good. love the mamas and the papas.

Fun and the harmonizing is vocally impressive, but with the exception of california dreamin, it doesn't really reach any great heights. Best: California Dreamin' Worst: I Call Your Name

favorite track: california dreaming. Overall score: 6,5/10

Good album. Classic California Dreaming is on it.

Relax and amazing

The hits were the only specks of gold. I suppose it wasn't bad, but for a band that sounded like a cross between Jefferson Airplane and The Beach Boys you'd think I'd be more excited.

Not bad for old classic music. Good groove

Great folky sounds. Probably too depressed to really take it in properly

You gotta love the Mama’s and the Papa’s. One of the best vocal groups of their time.

Excellent album!

Surprised I didn’t enjoy this a lot more, I feel mamas and papas are more of a single band than an album band!

that's the song from TikTok

Good album.

Started off strong but fell short on the second half. Not something I expected to enjoy but I did kinda like it

Such an iconic album honestly. Highlights: Got a Feelin', California Dreaming, Straight Shooter

Enjoyed more than I expected. Made the housework quite fun. Favourites: Straight shooter, California Dreamin’, Spanish Harlem

Great album, an absolute classic! Fav songs: straight shooter, California dreaming, the in crowd

This was nice enough. I’ve always liked California Dreamin’. For such a wholesome-sounding band, they sure did a lot of drugs and had some insane controversies (incest allegations?!).

This album is the most 60s sounding album of all time. It’s almost like stock music written for a Walmart commercial set in the 60. It’s basically AI generated “60s rock.” It feels like a mix of a bunch of more interesting bands. It’s a little bit Beatles, a little bit Beach Boys, a little bit The Byrds, a little bit Jefferson Airplane, a little bit CSNY, a little bit Bob Dylan… but it’s not really as interesting as any of those other bands, except for the song California Dreaming. That’s a classic. It deserves its acclaim and longevity. The rest of the album is pleasant when it’s on, inoffensive, but not memorable. Even their cover of “Do you wanna dance” is kinda of boring. There are tons of better covers of that song, including The Beach Boys version (and the Ramones version). I think the nicest thing I could say about the album overall is that it does really summarize a lot of popular 60s rock music in a weird way? You kinda get the gist of the rock space at the time through this album. But personally I’d rather listen to almost any of their contemporaries. Ultimately, I feel that this record deserves a 2.5 out of 5… it’s fine. But because I have to either knock it up to 3 or down to 2, I’m gonna knock it down because of the final track, The “in” crowd. It’s the only outwardly bad track on this album. The lyrics really lack self awareness. Either they are bragging about being cool, which feels deeply uncool. Orrrr they’re not cool and they are do this ironically and are seemingly bitter about not being cool… which also isn’t cool and isn’t going to convince anyone that you deserve to be cool. So ya… because of this stupid final track, I’m rounding down.

Pleasant little pop album with some great harmonies. Not much to write home about though.

Ja chill

A couple of years ago, I read Scott G. Shea's All the Leaves Are Brown, which was a pretty extensive history of the Mamas and the Papas. I really didn't know a lot about the band before reading that book, but reading it gave me two things: one, a better understanding of the folk scene of the sixties, and two, the opinion that John Phillips was a massive piece of shit. I didn't listen to this album after reading the book though, because I knew I'd get to review it at some point. I know "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin'", but I think the rest of this album will be new to me. I'm looking forward to firing up some beautiful harmonies! I really enjoyed listening to If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears. As I expected, the harmonies and vocals in general on this album were outstanding. The arrangements were excellent as well, and having read about John Phillips gave me a lot of insight as to how much of himself he poured into this album. “Monday, Monday” was an outstanding leadoff song, immediately hitting your ears with a taste of the beautiful harmonies and vocals that filled this album. The string arrangements were excellent as well. This song is exactly the sort of thing I think of when I think of folk rock from the sixties. The guitars on “Straight Shooter” instantly reminded me of The Beatles, and felt less folky than “Monday, Monday.” Still, it’s a fun song, and I think it shows that The Mamas and the Papas can do more than just textbook hippie sounds in their music. “Got A Feelin’” had some really good vocals, but I found it a touch boring compared to the two songs before it. I really didn’t care for “I Call Your Name.” It’s not that it’s a bad song, but it felt really out of place compared to the rest of the album. “Do You Wanna Dance” had some great arrangements, and I thought the drums and strings sounded great together. This song felt like a throwback to fifties pop music, which felt a touch out of place, but the vocals were great. “Go Where You Wanna Go” was sneakily one of the best songs on the album. The opening vocals and strings were outstanding, and it’s one of those rare songs that you don’t want to end while you’re listening to it oscillate between its beautiful verses and chorus. Even though I really like “Monday, Monday” and “Go Where You Wanna Go,” “California Dreamin’” is the best song on this album. The cold and moody atmosphere is what puts this song above all the others on the album. The vocals are incredible and the arrangements are fantastic. I swear they could make college music courses solely about “California Dreamin’”, because every aspect of it is perfect. “Spanish Harlem” is nice, but it’s just a bit boring for my taste, and as the follow up to “California Dreamin’”, it sticks out like a sore thumb. “Somebody Groovy” is a really fun bop, with more great vocals. “Hey Girl” was pretty good too, and I really enjoyed the bass playing. “You Baby” was another fun bop like “Somebody Groovy,” but I thought the guitar riff on the bridge stood out as the best part of the song. “The ‘In’ Crowd” was a fine, but the keyboard playing was the best part of the song. I was planning on giving this album four stars, since there were some parts of it that I didn’t care for too much, but writing out this review really drove home just how good this album is. I’m not huge on folk music, but The Mamas and The Papas had a really unique sound and easily had some of the best vocals of the decade. It’s really a shame that John Phillips was such a prick; if he’d not been such an ass, maybe this band would have put out another album that could have matched this debut.

i mean its alrightt

Ну вроде неплохо. California dreaming -- легенда. Straight shooter хорошо. Остальное ок.

Borderline kitschy at times but California dreaming saves it from mediocrity. Beach boys and Beatles vibes. 3.6

Good songs, not my normal type of music I like but I did enjoy it

Classic but California Dreaming is really the only standout song

Loved the harmonies.

Not inherently offensive, but nothing special either, this album feels like a window to another time - and I’m sure, in that time, it was much more special. Now it just feels dated, despite the unique sound of “California Dreamin’” - which is all that saves it from a 2 star.

Every aesthetic impulse I have is telling me to hate this music. And I think I do actually hate it. Just look at them sitting there in their bathtub, like someone photoshopped The Shaggs onto a Papa Roach album cover. California Dreamin is a classic, Monday Monday is good too, and props to them for letting the fat one into the band long before such things were done. If only that were enough.

The classics on here hold their ground, but everything in between is horribly dated. There’s also something in the Beatles cover that irks me. As if the kids from Glee truly believed their rendition of Don’t Stop Believing to be superior. Barring California Dreaming, there’s just no drama here. Which is a shame since that song is phenomenal. ⭐️⭐️

This album is a lot and the band turned out to be a lot too (really John more than anyone), but the run time means they end right before it starts to grate and holy shit are those vocals right. Monday Monday and California Dreamin' are the real winners but the whole album is great. Glad I listened.

They weren’t saying anything.

Actually not mad at this

Refreshing harmonies. Melodic, sometimes catchy, and a tad overwrought. Still listenable after decades. "Straight Shooter" intro sounds like a Monkees tune. Or is it the other way 'round? Rampant apostrophe abuse on the album cover removes a star.

I gasped when I got this I’m so happy to have this album since I LOVE California Dreaming. It really is the highlight on this album. The other songs kinda blended together whilst I was listening. I didn’t love it, nor did I hate it. The In Crowd was pretty good too. This was my second album to feature female voices on it which is a shame how few they are. Overall: 3/5

4.25-4.5

California Dreamin is an S+ tier song. The rest range from average to great.

Great singing voices, but apart from the singles it’s all a bit forgettable. The covers are nothing special compared to the originals.

It's fine, very background, very gender-diverse-Beatles at points, but nothing that stands out as particularly worth it. Meh.

So I discovered The Mamas & The Papas, like many people my age did, through the Jackass tv show. That was the first time I heard California Dreamin, which is definitely their best song. So when I listened to this album I was excited cause I knew that song was on this album. And I had two takeaways, the first being the album isn’t really as heavy I thought it would be. The second thing I realized is that this album not really being a heavy psychedelic rock is totally fine cause they are so talented and gifted singers that they can compensate for how formulaic the music is. The album as a whole had some skips but they were perfectly spaced throughout the album to not lose my interest. After every song I didn’t care for there was usually another song I did like either immediately after or after one other song. So the pacing of the album is on point for someone like me who was expecting more of something else. The only other negative thing I have to say is that the “Mamas” are more gifted singers than the “Papas” but that only hurts like 2-3 songs where the boys take the lead. Honestly if you don’t like harmonic singing or late 60s music you are gunna struggle with this album, but you won’t struggle with “California Dreaming” cause that song is untouchably good.

Lots of iconic moments on here. Feels more like a collection of nice covers and movie soundtrack options than an album I’d necessarily pursue again, but happy to have listened while walking the pupper on his 7th birthday.

The Mamas & the Papas are a pleasant part of the 60s landscape. They were groovy and countercultural, combining folk, pop, and (some) soul into a delightful mix. Rounding to 5 despite a couple songs (not written by a Mama or a Papa) that interrupt the groove.

It is hard not to love The Mamas & The Papas! There is just a certain charm to their combined voices that makes you smile at the much more innocent side of the sixties.

Great harmonies, iconic songs and back when albums left you wanting a bit more with a short run time - but it also left me wanting a little more from the depth in the songs. Dunno, I enjoyed it just not *that* much.

I liked it, but I don’t believe I’ll ever seek it out again. The style doesn’t quite gel with me. Even at its brisk 34 minute runtime, I was ready to move on with three tracks left.

bom disco, mas nao é pra mim

Classic California sound of the sixties. Strong harmonies and production with several really strong songs.

Beautiful harmonies. Some songs were a little too old timey for me, but great album overall

Not really my cup of tea but like All the leaves are brown.

The pop music is as it should be. An absolute masterpiece. Monday and California dreaming in my heart forever.

1. Monday, Monday: the vocals are dreamy, the layers are cool, but the backing on only one side of my ears vs the lead on the other is not super smooth sounding - it feels empty in a weird way. Lyrics are schoolboy kinda love/how terrible Monday feels post weekend happiness. Nothing super notable. 2. Straight Shooter: the bass and guitar on this reminds me of a love story western kinda vibe. The vocals are immaculate, a constant throughout their work. I am taking the lyrics to be more about a drug addict looking for another fix. 3. Got a Feelin': the clock ticking along with lyrics of wasting time with an unfaithful lover. The vocals are so dreamy and soft. The drums/clock and synth put the intuitive heart-dropping feeling into sound. 4. I Call Your Name: this is a Beatles cover. I don't know what the original sounds like, so I cannot compare. I liked the tempo switch, swingy energy, along with gorgeous vocals. Whispering "John" during the cover as a nod to John Lennon, who wrote this one. I enjoy the ending of this song a lot, it kinda reminds me of a happy ending in a movie. 5. Do You Wanna Dance: very 60s sweet love song. I imagine that this was played at every school dance/wedding/etc. The strings add such romance and tenderness to the already cute lyrics. Again, the split mix in headphones is throwing me off. It doesn't blend. 6. Go Where You Wanna Go: TEA on this song, it's written by John Phillips (vocals/writer) about Michelle Phillips cheating on her husband with Denny (both part of the group). Kinda really strange lyrics and overall vibe - feels like a sarcastic song. 7. California Dreamin': I think everyone has heard this one; it's incredible. The vocals from Denny are so strong. LOVE the flute. I think this may be about the impending doom of Michelle and John, due to her affair. 8. Spanish Harlem: the background vocals are very angelic, super nostalgic track - feels like a flashback to a beautiful time. The violins, along with this imagery, are stunning. "It is a special one; it's never seen the sun. It only comes out when the moon is on the run." 9. Somebody Groovy: fun lil track, I can envision people dancing and swinging around. The rhythm backing is great, I feel groovy and easy listening to this. 10. Hey Girl: very bluesy, I enjoy the piano. Yearning for someone who has been hurt by a player, waiting around for her. The conversation lyrics that go back and forth through this album gets more of a story across, giving both sides which I love. 11. You Baby: very wholesome love song, in typical 60s feel and lyrics. This is exactly how it feels to be head over heels for someone. "Greatest thing since rock and roll" -- such a time in music and culture. Vocals paired with clapping reminds me of a heart pounding with admiration. Cute to follow Hey Girl, maybe the story follows through or I'd like to imagine so. 12. The "In" Crowd: Cass' voice is so strong and takes this song to another level, it's striking. I wish the vocals were mixed on both sides rather than just the left. "If it's square, we ain't there." Being the cool guys here, they know what is in and what's not. The lyrics kinda don't land great but it has a mesmorizing energy/beat. This whole album flows nice, most of the songs are super strong and their vocals are just unmatched altogether. The drums and synths add to the dreaminess of the layered vocals. I am super disappointed in the mixing of this album as most of the vocals were on the left side, not both and I think it would hit super hard if they were equally balanced. Who knows, could be a decade thing.. This album is huge and highly respected, it has aged pretty decently for a '66 record.

Todo o otimismo dos anos 60 está aqui, é uma delícia

The harmonies on this album are just something out of this world. Just a little bit bored by the orchestration. 7,25/10 fav songs : California Dreamin' & Spanish Harlem

A bit boring. Not particularly bad nor not particularly good. Is boring a 3* or a 2*?

I don't know why this album bothered me. Their songs are decent in small doses.

Somewhat dated. There's some good ones in here, but some that haven't stood the test of time as well.

Have always liked melodic sound. Liked most of the songs that I hadn't heard before.

nice whimsy fun

What is it with these 1960s albums and their weird headphones mixes?! They have some absolute tunes though: Monday, Monday, California Dreamin'... basically sounds like the Beatles.

Great album. Jaunty. I’m gonna strut around and shake my head like a fancy man when I listen to it!

Lots of memories getting stoned to do this in high school.

It's a little sugary, but there are some good tunes, good album

California Dreamin still hits. Album gets old after a couple spins

Fav: California Dreamin' Notes: Lots of nostalgia on this one. Good but not great. Vinyl: Yes, but not the cover actually showing the toilet. Those are rare and worth hundreds; it was apparently a big scandal at the time to show a toilet on an album cover. After the first run, the subsequent releases had it covered up.

Iconic sound, some great tunes here, a little Boomer-y for my tastes, but keeps me listening nonetheless. Undeniable talent, well arranged. California Dreamin' is as known as it is for good reason. Gets a bit redundant on repeated listens.

Ikkje høyrt før, utanom nokre hits, får lyst til å høyre meir på.

Nice … but if I’m honest I expected to like it more than I did. The group has such a big reputation and I love the music fry this era but this was just nice. Maybe it suffered because of my expectations. Vocal harmonies were spot on and the tunes catchy enough but not really my cup of tea

easy listening

Mono is not made for headsets... Having the vocals and instruments in one ear and the chorus in the other can be a bit annoying. "California dreaming" is great, of course. 3,5/5

Have heard the big ones from this, but never knew this was who it was by or explored more.

Redelijk sterke popliedjes, net geen vijf sterren waard. "California Dreamin'" en "Monday, Monday" zijn natuurlijk wel onvergetelijk.

Knockout. I have to sing along. The Beach Boys mastered harmony but the M&Ps made it soar like a finely tuned choir. And there were so many more hits to come. BRB, gotta listen (and sing) again.

Mediocre, at best. Very stupid band name and album cover.

Mmmm, it's pleasant, California Dreaming is a classic, yet I kinda wish the whole project had a bit more of a structure.

Un classique des années 60

É um álbum legalzinho sim.. Bem fácil de ouvir. Além de California Dreamin', eu gostei de Got A Feelin' e Spanish Harlem

wonderful voices and music, love

Beautiful harmonies and voices from a close-knit group. It's nice to remember people used to carry a tune without using software or going hog wild with melisma. The mix is very odd for being in the early days of stereo (all the drums on one side, all the singers on the other, for example). The songs are well-crafted and executed.

Mama Cass deserved the world. The other three? Varying levels of "not so much."