Reviews (page 3 of 13)
Pretty good. Enjoyed the punk
Did not like this. It made me think of the sister in “Friends and Neighbors”
Really cool, definitely something I’ll revisit
Ugh
это что-то популярное и ценится, но мне не зашло как-то простенько и местами раздражает манера исполнения маловероятно что переслушаю 2.8
The first time I looked into Patti Smith was for all the wrong reasons and I left unimpressed. This record is a much better place to start. It's easy to appreciate her vocal style against all these simplified rock based genres. It's a stunning piece of work, but it's very artsy. I'd listen to it again the same way I'd revisit an opera. It's always going to be exciting, but I'm not going to be rushing back to it every day. I don't think a day or two is enough for the words on this record to seep into you. I feel like she's giving me everything I wanted from Dylan. A smooth poetic backing with an obvious rock and roll essence. I look forward to giving this an occasional spin in the future. 4.2/5
Not for me
First time listening. I get why this is a classic album. Poetic enough to be deep, rock enough to be cool, but some pop elements thrown in.
I’m a sucker for GLORIA
Was alright. Free Money was maybe my fave. Generous 3.
Dunno what everyone else was listening too cos this was amazing.
3.5
Never got Patti Smith. This album has done nothing but reaffirm that. Style over substance. Birdland got fat and squarely right on the end of my fucking nerves. Thought I was listening to Pheobe Buffay.
Experimental
fine
Low 3, was not my favorite. Everything felt long.
This album rocks. I especially love "Gloria: In Excelsis Deo". Kickass opener to an album and a really cool take on the Van Morrison song.
Undisputed classic
An enjoyable album, maybe not the most gripping but she's good at what she does.
Brilliant album, “Redondo Beach” is one of my all time favourite songs of all time. Tom.
Decent record, couple of really good songs but nothing really grabbed me.
Iconic. Changed the musical landscape at the time, changed me 40 years later. Can there possibly be a stronger opening line to the opening track on a debut album?
I recognise the name, but I’d never heard any of her music before. I wouldn’t be the first to put it on myself, but it’s certainly not bad. Two stars…
Lou Reed muié
What a difficult set of songs. Musically I had no problem jumping on board between the piano and rock guitar, its very good. Vocally is where I got hung up, I'm not super particular on very in depth and clever lyrics, and definitely not poetry. That wouldn't be an issue on it own but she is specifically not trying to let the lyrics blend into the song in a traditional sense on a lot of songs. She wants you to confront them head on when she rattles off stories or metaphors in her high nasal delivery and that creates a struggle for my attention away from the music. When it works well I feel like she occupies a similar space to Stevie Nicks and everything comes together really well. When it doesn't i sit with my brow furrowed trying to keep an open mind. The songs were the worst on the first listen so I imagine they will age better on more and more listens but for sure a difficult album.
Horses opens with Patti Smith's version of Gloria, an instant charmer oozing with her own style of music. Then the album takes you to Redondo Beach to chill for a while and from then on it's mostly filler songs until the Land "trilogy" which is supposedly the album's magnum opus but far inferior to the aforementioned songs. Still, Horses is a unique album from a unique artist. I liked it a little less upon my second listening. Nevertheless, a must listen.
346/1001 Patti Smith - Horses Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ✅ An album and artist that inspired some of my favourite bands and artists. The way it verges on completely breaking down, but doesn't, the poetry. Yeah this is utterly fantastic.
Horse shit
Do not like patti smith, awful songs, boring.
Started off ok but dragged on. Not bad but wouldn’t listen again.
like it
i may have listened to “Gloria” before and probably had no idea this version was by Patti Smith??? (how lame of me) i don’t have much to say about the album besides it being pretty decent
Gloriaaaaa
favs: redondo beach birdland kimberly gloria: in excelsis deo (live) redondo beach (live) birdland (live) free money (live) break it up (live) elegie (live) rating 2.5/5
Putting the possibility that Patti Smith is the coolest person alive. Gloria is so good, and this album keeps delivering bangers. Free Money, Break It Up, and Land were also awesome as all hell. Kicks ass.
This album is kind of a mixed bag for me. I like her best when she is making something new out of something old, like her takes on “Gloria” and “Land of 1000 Dances”. The shorter originals, like “Redondo Beach”, “Free Money” and “Break It Up” are also not bad. However, when she channels her inner beat poet chanteuse, like on “Birdland” and vast parts of the “Land” medley, she loses me.
no me termina de enganchar la pati pero reconozco que el album esta muy bien 7/10
Fun & fresh. Couldn't believe this album is more than 50 years old. EDIT: Holy shit, can't stop listening to this album. Absolutely deranged. This is 5 stars no doubt.
Okay Patti, pop off
It was fine. Didn't love it, didn't hate it. 2.5/5. Raising to 3.
Ok
Effortlessly cool
I want to like this, and I do like some of it. But there are moments where things just drag on with a flurry of words that just doesn't work for me. I can see why this was influential, just not for me
It was a cool experiment hearing punk lyrics with toned down background.
I am pleasantly surprised at how much I liked this album. Each song further lured me into enjoyment. Reminds me of 4 non blondes. Creative lyrics (that I actually listened to!)
#169/1001 🇺🇸 My love of Patti Smith grows and grows over the years. This album is one of those unique records that just blows all conventional music out of the water. Her words, her voice, tenderness, vitriol... rapping and singing over John Cales production. Just perfect. Best tracks: Free Money, Birdland, Kimberley, Elegie.
saved: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de)
How do I do this without feeling disrespectful? Listen, I know Patti is a pivotal figure in punk rock history, but I just don't really get this album. I guess 1975 was still kinda photo-punk and maybe we just collectively decided that this wasn't exactly the right direction? Maybe she goes on to make a bunch of more punk punk? All I can say is that I listened through this one at least twice and just couldn't get excited for it. On the music alone, I'm a soft 3 stars. Considering her influence and perceived importance, I'm like a soft 3.5 stars.
What an excellent cover of G.L.O.R.I.A. "Land" is a solid second fave track on the album. And Elegie is so moody.
really appreciate the poetic story telling in the first two songs. as i’m in the middle of birdland i am the target audience for this type of piece but im also getting older so i am changing too! there were moments i was reminded of fiona apple whom i love so i was excited to see what came next. i was familiar with fiona apple prior to patti smith which is why i phase it this way even tho i obviously know smith came first. Free Money is more what i would look for in a playlist to put on first as i go about my day. i know this is ridiculous to say a bit bc of the context of the song but if i ignore that for a second i can just feel the instrumental which could sometimes be more important to a song than the story. not that it’s true here it’s just a statement LOL. as the album went on i found myself enjoying it less and less. not to say that it’s a terrible album but ill most likely only relisten to gloria and redondo beach! maybe i’ll revisit again in the future but until then, ttyl patti
"I’m relying on the historical significance, and my desire to continue listening, to push it over the line." -well put, other reviewer.
Not really into it. Pretty annoying voice. Decent sounding band though.
Not horrible but not something I’m super into
I like horses.
That's a cool cover. You can hear some Lou Reed here.
I thought I would be able to hold on to something, to find a way in, but I didn't. This didn't do anything for me. I don't get it. It wasn't upsetting or anything, just kind of bland.
Great variety, I see the appeal. Not quite a masterpiece for me.
At first I was surprised this was labeled as punk, but after listening, I understood why. I enjoyed this and have a better opinion of Patti Smith now.
For years I have been wanting to get into Patti Smith and eventually her group projects as just about anything I heard from her I was utterly infatuated with. Whether it was the killer closer Elegie or the funky Redondo Beach, Patti Smith has held a silent chokehold on myself that I have been waiting to finally dive fully into, and today is that day. This project feels like the female equivalent to Lou Reed's Transformer as Patti doesn't have a necessarily amazing vocal range but damn can she write a song. Her brash and more brute-like vocals bring such a stark contrast to what a lot of other women in Rock and even Punk were doing around this time and instantly made her a stand-out act. The longer tracks like Birdland and Land may turn off some listeners but I promise those songs fly by much does most of this album, and yet it never feels rushed or half-assed, just a really well paced album from front to back. All in all Horses is just a stellar rock album that feels both very artsy and accessible in ways I adore in both directions unless you are my father and can't stand her vocals. Really happy I hung onto this release and gave it a proper and well deserved listen through because I was anything but disappointed at how killer this was.
Patti Smith wants to be free - from the expectations placed on her (including but not limited to on account of her being a woman), from her immediate environs. Ultimately, from her body entirely, to evolve to a higher plane of consciousness. So one thing I find really striking here is that, despite that desire - a despite how freewheeling her poetry gets - she maintains a semblance of structure. Pop the hood on "Gloria" and "Birdland," for example, and you'll find Carole King-style piano figures undergirding everything; I did a double-take on the former tune to make sure I hadn't accidentally put on something off *Tapestry*. And the latter track's conclusion morphs into a classic Chubby Checker tune, albeit slowed down to a funeral march. Smith doesn't hate structure, not per se; but what she *does* consistently do is bend structures to her own fierce will. On the more conventional tunes you can hear her bumping up against them; take "Redondo Beach," a jaunty proto-reggae track about a (female) lover's drowning on which the irony of the chosen form is the point. Or "Kimberly," about her beloved sister, on which a soothing organ figure provides the lullaby that Smith herself, in her chaos, could never muster. Perhaps most notably on "Gloria," she signifies by refusing to change the song to suit her; she covers the lyrics completely straight (pun intended), from the male perspective, even as her unmistakably female squeals of delight fill the song's margins. And that is the overwhelming message of this monolith of an album: *she will conquer*. On "Birdland" she works herself into a frenzy, gnashing her teeth as she growls. On "Free Money" she rebukes the bill collectors of her impoverished youth with prophetic fury. And "Land" edges her audience; she vamps endlessly, holding out a release that always seems just about to occur - the famous "na, nananana" vocal from "Land of Thousand Dances" - and yet it *never* happens, not in nine minutes. On the same track's Morrisonesque spoken-word middle section I realized this is a rejoinder record: *there's more than one crawling king snake in this grass.* Like a lot of self-consciously arty music (like a lot of art, period) this album probably only works if you're willing to buy into it - but I am, and I'm always enthralled.
wow. this is seriously one of my favourite albums now, it’s perfect. multiple 5 ⭐️ songs. the writing!
I know I am supposed love this legendary album but I don't
ikke helt min greie
I have been meaning to listen to this album since I listened to her memoirs a few months ago. Such an interesting album like nothing I've ever heard. Patti Smith is very cool.
klFucking shit cunt ba
Patti Smith’s Horses was fine, but it never hit me the way its reputation suggests it should. I get why people love it, and I’ve got nothing bad to say about it. But I don’t have much praise for it either. It just kind of exists in that middle ground for me. So while everyone else is gushing over it, I’m over here in the corner refreshing the page, waiting for the next album so I can move on.
After years of hearing how great and influential Patti Smith is, this album only influences me to empty all my stomach contents into the nearest trashcan. If this is the sort of thing that people resonate with then I must be part of a small subset that just doesn't get it. This doesn't evoke anything positive or endear itself in any way to me.
Not really that punk, but I quite like bits of this. Gloria is a cracker, the rest tends to drag on a bit. I’ll probably go back to give it another listen at some stage, but not that highly rated for me right now.
The vocals shocked me, they are vulnerable and powerful. I enjoyed the guitar and verses complimenting the emotional weight of her voice. I especially loved Break it up
Not my style, but not bad music.
- I liked this, but I wish I could understand the lyrics better because what I could understand was cool. Her vocal affectations make it a little hard to hear what she's saying. And, they make her sound like someone else, but I can't really place who - sometimes Debbie Harry, but I keep thinking that's not who I'm trying to think of. Maybe a mix of Debbie Harry and Television? - I think I liked the energy and confidence of this more than the actual music, which didn't really leave much of an impression even though it had that Velvet Underground feel to it. - I'd say a 3.5 - I definitely liked this more than a lot of other 3s that I gave, at least.
terrible voz y la usa bien de protagonista, buen disco un poco corto y con temas muy largos. 2 se destacan nomas.
Not the greatest but I can appreciate it for the time.
Patti has a good voice it’s just worse album. I’m not sure what I was expecting for that because I had no context on the type of music she plays for wasn’t terrible.
It really grew on me
This was kind of disappointing? Not that it was bad, just felt like it had gotten overhyped for what I felt about it, it was fine. Maybe a little too spoken word poetry-esque for my taste? "Gloria: In Excelsis Deo" and "Free Money" were the standouts for me
Pretty dang good. Sounds great. Still has great energy after all these years.
Love this, own this, was pleased to have an excuse to listen again.
Very good. Not quite a 5 for me.
Didn’t hate it. Probably won’t come back to it.
I'm not crazy on her singing nor her spoken word style, but I think she used it very well on Kimberly. I enjoyed Land a lot, too.
A good album, but I don't love it. It was largely quite standard 70s rock with some more ambitious or punkish moments but I don't really see why it's considered a punk album Others have said it, this does feel like one you're supposed to like but it didn't do much for me Some occasional annoying vocal moments like when she sounds like the seagulls in Finding Nemo on the first track and that weird drawling thing on Birdland Highlights: Track 9, Kimberly
It took me a few attempts to make it through. It was fine, but I didn't like it at all.
An incredible album. Punk poetry atop classic rock, Television-style noodlings, with a little reggae-lite track thrown in for good luck.
Heel conflicted want dit begint echt zo goed, zeker "Gloria" is echt een banger, maar de rest is zo anus das insane. (2)
patti <33
Patti Smith was a relative latecomer to music, being a poet first and foremost, and it absolutely shows. This is clearly an album a long time in the making and showcases her lyrics alongside her fantastic voice. One of the best debut albums of all time.
I don't think I get this one the way that other people do, it's cool at least, it rocks, no issue but can't really join in on the cult following that it seems to have, its energy is pretty fun though its actual sound isn't particularly captivating
I know I listened to this album, but I can’t remember a whole heck of a lot about it. I remember it being an interesting blend of punk and folk, but I’d definitely use “interesting” to describe this album over any other adjective. For better and for worse.
Hit and miss. Some of the tracks are decent, and I’m kind of into the arty feel of them. Others though are completely underwhelming and kind of boring. Bits of this come across as pretentious and I’m not into that. It’s interesting hearing the influence across this though, both before and after. There’s a very Velvet Underground feel to many tracks, and it’s easy to see the influence on later bands like Sonic Youth. 2.5 rounded up.
Punk/Rock Favorite Tracks: Gloria, Redondo Beach, Birdland, Free Money, Kimberly, Break it Up, Land Least Favorite Track: Elegie This album was a slow grower on me, but I throughly love the album. Some of the tracks starts off slow, but they get progressively faster as time goes on, hitting you with the energy that you would expect from an album like this. 9/10
This was a great find. I was unfamiliar with Patti Smith, and to find this album was a treat. There's an obvious Bob Dylan influence, but what I hear most is a more angry Jim Morrison. Hearing the proto punk sound come through was great.
Unique sound and talent. Fav tracks: Gloria, Redondo Beach Saved a song: Y RYM: Y (#474)
pink is a mood a vibe a feeling never a #rule
I didn't enjoy this. That said, I surmise value here because it's progressive-protopunk with a woman at the helm. Points for long-form compositions as acoustic poetry, with a unique edge. I'll go 3 since I've been such a cranky old man lately.
Described as "minimalist punk rock", which sounds like an oxymoron Fave track: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo
I don’t get the appeal, sorry. 2.5/5
Bien.
This album is not for me but its importance and its place in the punk family tree cannot be diminished.
raw, unbothered, quite the rocker, Kimberly is my fave song so far... Elegie really reminds me of The Last Dinner Party, wonder if it served as inspiration
hm
Oh, look! I'm giving a punk album a 5 star rating! (my least favourite genre on the list as of now, 231 albums in) Horses is simply amazing. Patti Smith W. "Birdland" was my favourite. I loved "Free Money" and "Break It Up" too.
Ok
..
Cool!
Not sure what I just heard! Kind of a wild ride.
paar bangers, ook wel paar vervelende nummers.
Mid
Nope, not a fan.
Indulgent
weeeeeee liiiiiike birrrrrrrrd laaaaaaaand
Never a fan of the NYC art rock scene but I figure I listen to this anew and I tried to get through it long ago and could not. Still can't.
okay that fucked hard
Patti is a legend but I found it difficult to listen to this. It just seemed boring compared to her more punk stuff. I really wanted to like it, but could not.
Listened
Really fun! Captured a similar energy to the violent femmes
05/31 Boring
Eh, not really great.
Stone cold classic. Her and Television sit at such an interesting place predating and inspiring countless punk bands yet they have more jazz influence than any that came after. It has gotten better every listen, her voice as the songs pick up intensity is amazing. She set the template for so much of what came after. I’ve read some questionable stuff about her personality during this time but that doesn’t detract from the tour de force that is this album. Rating: 4.9
This is a personal top 10 album for me. Right out of the gates she says "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine"...holy shit. When this album is not good it's still good, and when it's good it's fucking great.
A quite singular and charming sort of album. I know Patti Smith as a poet and guest on a few other people's songs, but have not listened to her work before. This was really enjoyable and on the right side of experimental without being too weird for my taste.
Pas une si grande fzn
Bem mais ou menos
Pretty great album, even if Birdland is a bit too long, the rest of the tracks make up for it! Great lyrics and nice variety 4 Heard before? Yes Owned: Yes 77/307 (24%) Will I get: Already have
Har faktisk aldri hørt denne før. Ingen spesiell grunn. Bøter med full uttelling, for denne er så god som de sier.
Litt punk, litt rockeopera og litt slampoesi. Ekte klassiker
Horrible. Reminds me of Kate Bush. Dissonant and talk/yell singing, weird poetry-like readings, hated most of it. A few songs were survivable. She even managed to butcher covers like My Generation - so bad.
Patti Smith was possessed by an anti-autism demon when this album was made
Yessssss so beautiful, Patti Smith was a punk and had a stunningly powerful voice, the lyrics are stunning the music is loud I love it all. 5.0/5.0 Best Song: Gloria: In Exelsis Dio
Don't mind it but it doesn't blow me away. It is a nice enough listen, and i do like her voice a lot it's very unique
yeah lowk this looks boring as shi im not listening to it
Excited to finally take some time off to listen to Ms. Smith. This is pretty much as I expected - pretty freaking good, but not too interesting, so at least 3 strong stars for sure, 3.5 on RYM. But honestly this could be 4 as well. P.S. After a couple of revisits definitely one to REVISIT.
I imagine that your enjoyment of this album comes down to how much you enjoy Patti Smith's whole deal. I wasn't a fan. If I had listened to this without knowing what it was and you told me that this was PJ Harvey before she got good, I would have totally believed you.
I like this album and understand why it's so highly rated. I like the way she uses her voice. Would be great as a Pitchblack Playback because of the imagery, although I hated the 8:44 track about the kid and his dad and going UP UP UP. Think it must have been really fun for her to perform but listening to it feels like getting dragged behind a car. Love Free Money and reminds me of night visions I used to have as a kid, that the shapes in front of my eyes would turn into presents during the night and I just had to capture as many as possible under my duvet. Groovy and danceable and cohesive.
perfect, love u patti 💋
Raw, rough and distinguished. So many elements of style on this record, for something that's labeled as a Punk record. This is one I know I'm going to need to listen to again to fully grasp and appreciate it. The songwriting and musicianship is soft and easy most times, but the lyrics are gritty and unorthodox through and through. Off first listen, I like this one.
An album that I appreciate more than I actually enjoy. It isn't that it's bad, there's just nothing on here that compels me to regularly listen to it.
couldn't make it past song 3. had to turn it off.
No matter how many times I listen to this album, I still feel like it needs another chance. Just seems to be not my thing. That said, Free Money seems to still out for me. Rating: 5/10 Favorite Song: Free Money
I know this is an important album but I didn’t like it much.
C'est ok pour du punk mais je suis vraiment pas la cible
lang geleden en was beter dan ik me herinnerde... nu, als je je debuut kunt openen met een straffe zin, dan zit je gebeiteld...
Fine
This was solid. Plus I just moved to NYC.
Michael Stipe loves this album, his favorite. I’ve tried…but I just don’t. I don’t like her voice.
I don't understand how anyone can listen to her and enjoy that awful sound coming out of her mouth. Unlistenable.
I will admit that I probably didn’t like this as much as I could’ve cause I’m kinda in the middle of a fight with my girlfriend right now, but this was really solid. I didn’t really know her vibe going in, so this was a lot more energetic than I was expecting, which was cool. I do think it’s pretty homogeneous, but again that could be cause I’m mid argument. I’m not sure. Good album though.
if christian rock was lesbian???
Poetic (prog-)punk that reminds me of the Velvet Underground's atmospheric and spoken word tracks. It's fascinating listening to this as a result of how simple chords can be experimented with. I've always wanted to listen to this based on the cover, and now I get to do so. Opener "Gloria" was spectacular. I don't really hear that many songs that turn punk a few minutes later. As for the rest, the long songs didn't seem too lengthy; in fact the punk beats were trance-like. I think this still reinforces the fact that I'm more of a music than lyrics-person, as the words and their meanings went through their head. Next time, I'll pay closer attention the lyrics and understand more of the poetic side of this record (3.5-4).
Toen ik erachter kwam dat dit weer een rock album was van deze site, had ik er spontaan echt geen zin in MAAR!!! Ik ben nu bij het derde lied al (Birdland) en ik vind dit best leuk en uniek in het genre! Dit is niet per se iets wat ik vaak ga draaien op spotify, maar dit kan ik wel echt waarderen Tot nu toe vind ik het echt een steady 8/10
better than Waves? no, but still amazing.
A bit meh, bit of shrieking. Not mu jam
Overall: 3.56 (rounded to 4) Consistency: 3.75 Originality/Innovation: 4 Enjoyment: 3.5 Virtuosity: 3 1. Gloria: In Excelsis Deo - 4 2. Redondo Beach - 3 3. Birdland - 2 4. Free Money - 4 5. Kimberly - 4 6. Break It Up - 4 7. Land - 5 4. Elegie - 4
Looking at some of the comments, this record looks like its a fairly divisive one. I'm definitely in the pro camp for this record. It's a record that I own and its pretty familiar to me. Someone else described this is the intersection of rock and roll and beat poetry and that feels like a very apt description for the record. You're getting a mixture of what might be called spoken word performance with traditional song structures. I really love Smith's voice, but her vocal approach isn't always conventional, which is fine by me. Smith often gets placed in the punk camp, because her involvement in the NY scene and the often incendiary quality of her performances, but it doesn't really fall under the aesthetic qualities that I associate with punk. That isn't a criticism for me. It's a great moody rock and roll record and should be a point of discussion in any list of the best records of the decade and century.
Finally listened to this after so many years. Sounded different to me the second listen than the first.
She is hit and miss for me. This wasn’t my fav album.
Każda piosenka ma dobre i słabe momenty, ale jakoś te słabe za bardzo wpływają na to, że raczej nie przesłuchałabym tego kolejny raz. Nie jest to złe, nie moje klimaty. Najlepsza piosenka z tego albumu to free money, Kimberly chyba. No średni
Mmmmm. Perhaps I was not in the right frame of mind of mind for this album. Second half nearly put me to sleep.
I’ve always meant to listen to this but never got round to it. It did not disappoint. I like her voice and the songs were great too, even if I’m not super used to this style of music (old)
Has some great songs, but at some points its a bit too much of person talking over some postrock music(?). I do love some of the songs and think I'll appriciate it more with more relistens and reading into the lyrics. 1. Gloria: In Excelsis Deo 2. Kimberly 3. Free Money
Goddess!
Damn this is mid. Its even just rambling sometimes. Why is this in here?
Too folky for my taste. I like the tone of her voice though. Not too much to say about this
Pretty neat but not my cup of tea
proto-punk, bacán dentro de todo. nunca había escuchado a patti smith, definitivamente un sonido muy interesante. su voz resalta muchísimo, super avant garde a su tiempo. lo podría llamar pretencioso pero siento que sería una palabra muy dura, es ambicioso. Land es muy interesante de escuchar.
Great band, passionate delivery
enjoyed!
Goat.
Okay the first time through I didn’t like it. The second time I did! Not my favorite of all time but definitely liked it more on a re listen. Marking as 4 so I’ll come back to it in the future.
Need to get more into the middle of the album. First two and last song already top
Does it live up to the hype. Probably however this is not punk. It's more like storytelling with a tune.
This one probably doesn’t get the greatest review from a lot of people, but I enjoyed it. Maybe it’s the Velvet Underground effect since John Cale produced it, because parts of it definitely have that same artsy, loose, half dangerous feel. It’s also the kind of punk rock album that’s so different from the usual idea of “punk” that it somehow confirms its punk credentials anyway. It doesn’t sound like a bunch of later copy and paste punk records, which weirdly makes it feel more legitimate, not less. And that cover of “Gloria” was pretty damn solid. Favorite song: “Gloria”
I am very glad there is talent that can improvise tracks like Birdland, but I don’t find I want to listen to it.
so much emotion. it holds up.
An album I would replace this one with: PJ Harvey - Uh Huh Her (2004) 4/5
At times annoying, i feel like other albums of hers are probably better.
I don't really like Patti Smith. This album is good, has some powerful songs on there but she doesn't raise any emotion for me. It's fine.
"Gloria: In Excelsis Duo" is an attempt at punk. "Redondo Beach" is minimalist blues (if that's even possible). "Birdland" is a 6-year old kid trying to explain their day to their parents. "Free Money" is a hybrid between Lynard Skynard's "Free Bird" guitar solo and Fleetwood Mac's "Dreams" if a cover band somehow butchered both of them. "Kimberly" is slam poetry about a woman. "Break it up" is about having sex. "Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de)" is incoherent ramblings of a lunatic to the same drums, guitar, piano, and bass for almost 10 minutes. "Elgie" is depression and mental instability in song form. You can DEFINITELY hear the Velvet Underground inspiration in this one. God it sucks. I hated the Velvet Underground album and now I have something as bad if not worse thrown in my face. It's a 0/10. I have to give it a star, but it doesn't deserve it. This shit sucks ass.
Bad ass. Can't go wrong with some early Patti Smith.
Almost 15 years ago I had a summer where I only read non fiction books, all sorts of memoirs and things from musicians and actors. I think 5 books in a row mentioned Patti Smith and/or Horses as a cultural touch stone if not major influence (David Byrne and Morrissey both heaped praise, some comedians used her as an example of NYC starving artist lifestyle inspo, etc.). And then I read her book, Just Kids and finally listened to this album and it all just clicked together beautifully.
2.3 To be honest, the vibrato vocals just put me off the entire thing. Very gritty, I actually thought it was around the PJ Harvey era so pleasantly surprised to see it was several decades earlier. Fair play. But sorry that voice is a no for me, is what it is.
Es wirkt wie ein elektrischer Urknall: roh, literarisch, kompromisslos. Patti Smith schleudert Spoken‑Word, Punk‑Ahnung und Beat‑Poetik in einen Raum, der bis heute nachhallt. Wenn man dieser Schaffensphase imaginär „Because the Night“ zurechnet, gewinnt das Album eine zusätzliche Strahlkraft – als hätte sich die rohe Energie von Horses schon in Richtung eines kommenden, melodischeren Triumphs aufgeladen. „Gloria“ eröffnet mit ikonischer Frechheit, „Birdland“ schwebt zwischen Vision und Ekstase, und „Land“ bleibt ein fiebriger, hypnotischer Monolith.
her book "just kids" is really good
leider nicht meins. 1.4 sterne
Rock and roll energy, raw spirit, all the feels. Essential
🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑, though may well have been a 🌕🌕🌗🌑🌑 if I was in a worse mood So I only knew of Patti Smith, as it turns out, from a song title I will not be writing out here, but luckily I had forgotten long enough to leave my impression of Horses untarnished. One thing with Punk that seems to hold true even as far back as this proto-punk is that it can sound a little flat without a lot of drive and a properly monotone yell, and at its worst, I think Horses is that. Not at its worst, interestingly, are the nine-minute, fervent, spoken-word that I suspect have incited many an eye roll since the seventies. I, to my own surprise, kind of dug them—they're the kind of thing I think I was socialized to dislike but have really come around to now that I've fully embraced my own pretentiousness. The first and last songs are the only ones I can see myself coming back to frequently, but that's more than I was expecting from this album—really fun and exciting. This Patti Smith gal is really something, hope she doesn't have any controversial takes on race in her future! 1: Bad | 2: Okay, No Desire to Revisit | 3: Good, Conditionally (OR Inconsistent Mix of Qualities) | 4: Great (OR Technically amazing but missing the sauce emotionally) | 5: Amazing
Often I don't get past Gloria because it is such a good song, but every time I do, I hear something different.
It's fine, abrasive
What an album! What a cover! This is an excellent and highly influential album. Rooted in a garage band aesthetic but with intelligent literate lyrics, this album set things up for the second half of the 1970s.
I don’t understand the hype. Maybe I just had to be there. She’s got a really nice spoken word voice but the rest is nothing special. The second to last song has some insane lyrics lmao.
i know this album very well and i like it and i feel like i've always wanted it to be just a little bit better than it actually, truly is BUT HAVING SAID THAT there are some high high HIIIIIGHS here and it has possibly the best first 15 seconds of any album ever.
Not completely my cup of tea, but the artistry here is really phenomenal. Patti Smith definitely deserves her iconic status.
Raw, impassioned, punk, and the tunes. Land is a shamanic tour de force.
1/5
I’d not heard this album before, something I should’ve listened to by now, as I’m totally aware of Patti, I’ve read a couple of her books…..this album very good in places, and yep, I enjoyed its force, and toughness
Interesting, country kinda sound
not my thing 1/5
I don't own this album. I've never put it on myself, or played it in a jukebox. But, I don't mind when it comes on somewhere. When it's not on, I don't think about it.
A chier
Bit arthouse so I suppose typical 70s New York, she is an inspiration for others and some tracks really click but for me the album is limited with moments rather than a body of great work
Not my favorite.
Best Song: Free Money. I really like the segment around 1:30 where she starts singing over the drum roll that crescendos behind her. Worst Song: Redondo Beach. The surf rock / beach energy didn't seem to fit the vibe of the rest of the album. Overall: There is a raw creative energy that runs through this album. Everything feels thoughtful and purposeful. I respect the vision that the artist had in making it. It isn't common to have this quality of vocals, vocal artistry, and arrangement. That said, I sometimes wished there was less of a "rock" focus, and that she had instead staying in a quieter, more melancholy sound.
Interesting
Gotta love Patti Smith
I haven’t listen to a lot of Patti Smith music so I enjoyed this dive. The lyrics more than the music drew me in.
5 stars!! I know this album from seeing it on countless *Greatest* lists, but never cared to take the time. Understood her to be among the CBGB American punk forefathers & consequently had next to no interest. This is not (my preconceived notion of) that. This is fantastic. This is much more Tom Waits or Leonard Cohen than Ramones or Misfits. This is broad & experimental & avant-garde & I’m here for it. Love
A weird hodgepodge of Velvet Underground and other influences, 'Horses' has a challenging sound that warrants re-listens. Some of these songs are sprawling soundscapes and the album is diverse. Top tracks: "Birdland," "Gloria," "Break It Up"
--Gloria…could be a sick karaoke song if I could learn all the words --Redondo Beach…that bass is slick but vocals not doing it for me --Birdland…the spoken word stuff ain’t working for me. Oh god, we’re only half way through the track --Free Money…great rhythm guitar. similar spoken word attitude as “Birdland” but this feels much better --Kimberly...skip --Break It Up...I feel like Patti walked so Kathleen Hanna could sprint --Land...not a good sign that two of my favorite parts of this LP (not full tracks, mind you, fractions of tracks) were written by people with no help from Patti Smith --Elegie...not my thing
i'm not sure exactly what i was expecting but it wasn't really this
Great for loving
Just amazing. Everything about it. The songs, the lyrics, the performance, the production, the cover photo. In recent years I've had a major Blue Öyster Cult obsession and I already knew the link via her relationship with Allen Lanier, lyrical contributions and friendship with Sandy Pearlman, but it hadn't really registered with me how much of a sound they shared at times if not an image. But even the scifi lyrics of Birdland, the furthest away musically, sound like a theme BÖC could have warmed to.
I loved this album! Haven't listened to Patti Smith proper but always down for a 70s arty feminist musican a la Stevie Nicks x Lori Anderson.
Big ol' classic you just can't deny tbh. Brought a real intellectualism to the punk scene and proved that you could have raw power without sacrificing conceptual heft. Love it
It's always hard for me to get behind the spoken word aspect of albums like this, but otherwise, I enjoyed the music. The instrumentals were interesting (definitely see the Velvet Underground influence there), I didn't mind Smith's voice, and the lyrics were dynamic and ahead of their time. I see the influence it had on future artists, but I probably wouldn't give it another listen myself.
Ella es poesía
A tough one. I get her cultural impact, and I do enjoy some of her songs, but for the most part I find Patti Smith just too dramatic. Particularly the longer, spoken-word ones. Did not enjoy this album at all.
Didn't love it ... didn't hate it. Never really listened to Patti Smith ... at only 45 minutes, this album felt like it was running a bit too long.
This album feels like it is dripping with “cool 70s” energy. I can see girls back then wishing they had the effortless edge and charm that Patti had. But I think that energy doesn’t carry much weight today. The music is fine, but it certainly doesn’t feel cool now. It just feels like old rock, and despite what places claim doesn’t really feel Punk at all. It wasn’t a bad listen, but I think it’s not as timeless as some people might think.
Een dulle teve noa mien erte
Curiosamente me tocó escuchar el álbum el mismo día que se anunció que Patti Smith será galardonada con el Premio Princesa de Asturias de las Artes y puedo ver porqué. Un estilo único dentro del “rock/punk/alternativo (si es que ya se podía considerar el género en esa época)” con esas letras y estilo de canto. Mi favorita: Land. Ya me dieron ganas de leer su libro.
Wow
I kind of liked it. Definitely had some interesting lyrics.
first time listening to this, what a treat. definitely need to run through a few times, but you can hear the punk sound emerge in real time as you listen through
I love the weary voice and punky vibe. Weirdly relaxing record.
Land: Horses is an absolute trip. The lyrics in this album scare me a little. Awesome stuff.
Manure
Listened to it a couple of weeks ago, good album but not sure why it is considered a classic
3.5/5
"Gloria" is the only one here I particularly care for, I think it does a really good job of building up tension. The rest is sort of like, we're told that she's a punk predecessor, but she's not really punk in form, and the original spirit of punk was kinda anti-intellectual so that's not her either, so I'm not really sure where she comes in? "Redondo Beach" sounds like worse Blondie, the rest is in the vein of "Gloria" but doesn't grab me all that much.
Just didn’t hit for me this one tbh
female-led alternative rock music. despite many sites calling this punk, it's more like a mixture of art/jazz rock music. the album is essentially patti puking up every last thought in her head. it took me a bit to get into it, but as i focused i really started to get into how... simple it is, i guess. what else do you need besides a drummer and a guitarist playing a few simple chords? despite the sound being what it is, the material itself is absolutely not. i think this is an artist i'll pay attention to in the future...
Didn’t love this as much as I wanted to :( Patti is obviously SO influential but the album itself…idk. Gloria is a RIPPER of an opening track and Elegie is perfect but the stuff in the middle just felt kind of muddled to me
Gostei
I dig it - both as an artefact of its time where it fits nicely on the shelf next to Television and Velvet Underground, and as a birth mother of PJ Harvey and everyone who kept it gritty through the 80s and 90s.
The amount of ones on this one is honestly surprising. It's a solid album with a lot of soul. It's cool, it's lyrically well written, and it fucks
Really cool album that's a combination of punk and more classical solo rock. It's another case where this seems like a really important album and I get why it's here I just didn't like it as much as I expected to.
This album is at times incredible, and at times done with a microphone and band in the box? It could be a rock opera. It's a poetry slam. I can hear generations of women singers coming after using Patti's affectations.
Enjoyable enough - I've never really listened to Patti Smith and feel like I've been missing out. Lots of energy.
Low 3 stars. I really don’t like how whiny the vocals are at times, especially because at other points Patti Smith chooses to actually sing and it’s beautiful. I think what saves this album from being a 2 star for me are the instrumentals. There are some really beautiful and cool songs on here if you don’t pay attention to the vocals. I will say, I get the appeal and how this was seen as groundbreaking for the punk scene, due to how bold it is. Patti Smith is very poetic, but I just cannot deal with her whining and cadence. Makes it boring and hard to listen to, but can respect the history.
Album 174. Horses (https://open.spotify.com/album/0OeuSeP8wp8n8OuTqYb61C?si=rqGx21dmTIqt95UL38TJmg) — Patti Smith (1975) Okak, a week or two ago I added almost every Patti Smith's album to future listening (except this haha). That's her debut album, cool. Next couple days I'm finally gonna listen to all her albums. Basically, I already listened today Easter (https://open.spotify.com/album/1p6cWoueuunhpgy6131zAd?si=Da9GNi1oTfOD50EFPrHRlg) album too, it was great, I've loved Because the Night from that album for a long time. Well, back to Horses. I don't know how to describe this..minimalistic (a little bit) punk rock, but it's so raw that it becomes hard to listen sometimes. But poetry, poetry of Patti Smith is great. And the album has so much energy and passion. She has a very specific voice and I like it. 3/5 Liked: — Gloria: In Excelsis Deo — Free Money
Have I listened to this album before? No How familiar am I with this album? Somewhat familiar How do I feel about this artist? Nothing but respect for Patti Smith Favorite song(s)? Land: Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances Overall Thoughts: I enjoyed this just as much as I expected to, which was a lot. Birdland could’ve been a 4 minute song.
There's something primal about this. It's the sound of a troubled woman excise her most personal demons in public. It's raw, sometimes almost uncomfortable, but also beautiful
This was more an exercise in poetry rather than music for me, but it’s hard to draw a line between poetry and music anyway. I like when people do weird things with their voices. But I’d say some songs were drawn out, but I think that makes sense if you view them as poetry rather than “songs”. Maybe, I will like it better if I listen again. 3/5 - 4/5
This album is a classic aparently but I never hear anyone talk abouth it. Lets see then. Well thats one hell of a voice. I dont think im a fan. She defitively listened to a lot of velvet underground. I hate this band. I dont like punk to begin with. I tried with this one but.. No... Not for me/5
Pouco desenvolvimento instrumental e forte poetismo. É um pouco chapado? claro, mas as abordagens nas diferentes musicas são bem legais.
2,5/5 3 ou 2 músicas boas. Em geral, criativo, só que senti falta de alguma música que seja realmente marcante
se isso é punk, eu sou um coqueiro +gloria
Gloria- is this gonna be jesus core... Omg it isn't I quite like this. Is she gay? Apparently she's straight... Sure. Redondo Beach- ok this is fun Birdland- I like this intro. Oh ngl I don't really like the speaking idk why. I like the bass in the outro. Ngl I had no idea what the lyrics were so I should probably listen again but I didn't really like it much. Free money- I like this intro the piano is nice and the bass is good. Omg drum entry! I like that song my favourite so far Kimberley- I like this so far. Ooo I like this bit a lot. Again idk why I just don't really like the speak singing she does 😭 Break it up- that was good I liked it. Also the vocal thing was creative Land: Horses etc- I like her speaking voice in this now? Idk send help. I didn't really like it very much but it was sok Elegie- I liked this song! Ranking: Free money Elegie Gloria Break it up Kimberley Redondo Beach Land Horses Birdland
Perfect, seminal. An album I always come back to and am never disappointed by
A good listen
2.5/5
No me gusto y no me engancho
I just love it
Not for me
Kinda bluesy start then rips right into rock. And what’s that now?! Ode to Van Morrison?! This one song has convinced me that I definitely need to investigate further.
Partially known. Solid album.
5/10
Horses was just a really odd album to me. I honestly did find it odd that this album is considered punk considering how minimalist it sounds in comparison to a lot of other punk rock albums are typically very aggressive and chaotic but apparently this is what punk used to be for a lot of people, and I'm glad it changed because I'm not the hugest fan of this. The music itself was pretty decent even if it is different than i would expect from punk music, the main issue though is the vocals as i feel like Patti really loves to ramble and i don't really like that and these lyrics aren't great either so there is that. I feel like this album could have been good but these vocals really hold it back. Best Song: Free Money Worst Song: Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer (de)
I thought this was great … genuinely an album I’m pleased to have heard before I died
J’aime pas sa voix
Respected more than liked how melodramatic her vocals get (despite the great minimalist cover). Kimberly’s the best
I tried to give this a 2. Nothing worked here.
so much character. proto pj harvey
Raw proto-punk and poetic rock built on loose guitars, minimal piano, steady rhythms, and intense, spoken-sung vocals unfolds with restless, confrontational energy. Listening feels like standing in a dim loft where words spill out in long, unfiltered bursts over a band that shifts beneath them. The result is powerful and distinctive and at the same time its free-form approach feels uneven.
Это же просто ахуенно
Punk chords and beatnik poetry combo unexpectedly successfully. Patti Smith seems to be a genre of her own, and I haven’t heard her better, though still listening to “Easter” again later, with a nod to my partner in crime here. Smith’s choice of Cale was intelligent: few could capture this punch of these performances without losing clarity or adding chintzy distractions.
A masterpiece, always welcome and one I will always pay full attention to when the chance arises, much like "Marquee Moon". Top opening line on a debut album? On any album? "Birdland" is still remarkable 50 years later: 'It was as if someone had spread butter On all the fine points of the stars 'Cause when he looked up they started to slip' All the bickering here as to whether this is "punk"!? Just like the Ramones debut (later) this kicks open the door established by early '60's R&R with a sneer; Smith's addition of Rimbaud to the mix is the only practical difference. Didn't know Tom Verlaine was on "Break It Up", although pretty obvious. Lenny Kaye does sterling work throughout. Side note: no Wikipedia when I first heard these momentous records (see Electric Ladyland prior) so we just *didn't know* these things automatically. One benefit of running through this 1001..! John Cale here too, of course - two bolshy auteurs butting heads to knock out a once-in-a-generation achievement. 6
diosss me enamoré
Omg actually adored this- have never heard Patti smith before!! will absolutely be adding to the rotation
Really like the first song. I don’t really like the almost her raw “talking” singing voice.
I hadn't heard of Patti Smith before this album popped up (Rather, I hadn't connected her name with what I had heard of hers), and didn't have a good idea of what I was getting into just from the album name and cover alone. Looking through reviews, I found a lot of people calling her "Female Bob Dylan" which does reign true. I also found many people who gave this album 5 stars saying that it's her lyrics that inspired them to give this album such a high rating. Perhaps I'd say similar if I understood anything that she was saying. While I do appreciate clever and poetic lyrics in the music I listen to, I am far more drawn to the musicality of an album. This album is not for people like me. I can respect what Patti Smith was for the punk rock scene, but this album did not capture my attention at any point.
I really liked this album. Reminded me of Fiona Apple 7/10 but if i listen to it intently in a dark room, could be a 9 or even 10 Saved a Song? ----- ✅ Saved Album? ------ ✅ Will Listen Again? --- ✅
Such an experience, makes one feel like they're young and gay and cool in 70s NY.
nope. The first song, there was a part i liked, when they were singing "gloria" but then i realized, i only liked it because it sounds like the song "victoria" by the kinks, written 6 years prior. song 2 i liked the instrumental. song 3, i liked it until she started singing..
Interesting. Not one I’d return to though.
Didn't do it for me. Not bad, but not my jam or interesting enough to become my jam.
What an icon
Not for me. 1/5
Not my cup of tea but different for the time.
That was a fun departure. It felt kinda punk rock
Infinity/5 stars! I love Patti Smith!
pop-rock, ya la primera se caga en el cristianismo, en general bastante alegres y movidas, se deja escuchar aunque tampoco mucho, 3/5
4.5
eh her voice kinda annoyed me, i liked the hunter gets captured by the game a little
Didn't love or hate
Will need a second listen at some point! Loved all the nice piano intros and had some great lyrics but maybe just not my thing. Faves were Kimberly, break it up and elegie
Patti seems extremely cool however album is not my favourite however it was a good way to stay awake on the plane and did enjoy elegie at the end
3/5; fine album.
A striking debut that feels raw in a very deliberate way. 𝘏𝘰𝘳𝘴𝘦𝘴 isn’t about polish — it’s about attitude, presence, and a kind of poetic intensity that holds the whole thing together. Patti Smith moves between spoken word and singing almost effortlessly, giving the album a loose, unpredictable feel. Not everything lands equally, but when it works, it’s genuinely powerful.
One of Rocks most poetic album with some amazing RnR and singles
4 - BAD
Was a beautiful mess!
Album #119 Patti Smith: Horses Undisputable classic, Horses is the greatest album that Lou Reed ever made. This is one of those albums that always shows up on the corporate greatest albums of all-time list, and for a long time, I just assumed that it was a ‘good for its time’ boomer album that would just be some nonsense. However, when I finally decided to listen to Horses, I quickly realized how wrong I was. This album is the opposite of dated, it still sounds so fresh and powerful almost 50 years later. The CBGB club in New York produced some of the best talent of the late 70s and early 80s, whether it be Blondie, Talking Heads, or Television, and yet if you asked someone from the scene at the time who the best act at the club was, more likely than not, you would get the answer, Patti Smith. This album is the essence of punk, high energy, empowering, and defiant, yet it doesn’t sound like anything else that was being released at the time. Patti Smith has such a unique and undeniable style that it was hard for contemporary acts to even replicate. That being said, her influence started to appear years later, once music caught up with her, notably PJ Harvey, having a lot of Patti’s elements in her music. This album never fails to hype you up, and I have never listened to it without it hitting. Every song paints a picture and has its own style, yet remains consistently great. I really can’t find a dull moment on it, so naturally, it must be a masterpiece Best Songs: Gloria, Kimberly, Free Money Worst Song: None Score out of 10: 10.
Patti is a queen
Never listened to this before. Talented but…
A lot of spoken word. A couple of the songs have fun music, but overall very much not for me.
Rock, 1975 -> 3
Patti Smith’s reputation precedes her, I’m ashamed to admit I’d not listen to this record before. It deserves its place in any list of albums you must hear before you die. Patti is brilliant and I’m glad to have met her here.
Que mujer. amo la locura del álbum. no la conocía desde este lado más experimental, dramático, sentimental, ruidoso.
This may have the most startling debut album opening track since the Beatles went "1 2 3 4". What a calling card! The cover photo, surly, defiant, tells you what you're getting.