Reviews (page 4 of 13)
"Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine." A strong opening declaration!
I'm obsessed with Patti Smith's voice and more surprised I'd never heard of her before (I'm rather uncultured) but wow! A catchy song to open an album with but for some songs I found them unnecessarily long and repetitive, making them somewhat boring to listen to (but I enjoyed birdland! a bit bizarre to me but nonetheless entertaining) Favourite song on this album is probably free money for the catchy instrumental and I quite liked the vocals, but Horses was a very good listen) Overall, some songs were a bit long and boring and the stories told by her lyrics were intriguing and bizarre, but i was fun and the instrumentals were very enjoyable as well as the controlled and gradual start to each song and later the explosive and chaotic ending.
Bare ren kærlighed.
cooool, like it
I always thought Patti Smith was considered punk rock, but that doesn't seem to fit here at all. Art rock maybe. Another artist I should have paid attention to at the time. This is very good.
Gloria: In Excelsis Deo — holy shit that's an opener. The opening line is confrontational and it means every part of it. Whole song is filled with rebellious energy. This is punk. That final chant and repeat of the opening line is a perfect climax. Redondo Beach — a sad story with honest lyrics. Doesn't shout as loudly as Gloria, but it doesn't hide either. The melody doesn't slouch either. Birdland — a very chaotically portrayed story of a boy losing his father and that grief driving him towards God at the expense of his mother and all women. Piety becomes a dehumanising force. Religion is depicted as birds that flock to the lonely boy, supposedly to convert him. The boy is constantly yearning to be taken to the ship, perhaps Noah's Ark, the first culling of heathens and the first saving of the believers, a chance for a new life in the next world under God. The vocals build and build and every call for the Ark feels climactic. While sometimes the lyrics and the performance go absolutely haywire, it adds to the internal struggle of the boy and the rebellious nature of Smith's songwriting. Free Money — really strong vocal perfomance here. More simpler lyrically, but they are still perfomed with relentless energy. That guitar riff throughout is also great. Kimberly — another song with strong imagery. I thought the end section dragged a little, but otherwise a solid song. The rise on "the sky is falling" is an earworm. Break It Up — that crying guitar is beautiful. The chorus builds and hits harder each time. Am starting to think she was just crazy though. Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) — I don't even know what to think about it. Very chaotic. Does tie itself together (I think). The overlaying and overlapping vocals were very cool. Felt a bit too chaotic for me at times. Elegie — a sombre elegy for Hendrix. The piano was beautiful throughout and the vocal perfomance was emotive. Do personally find it strange when poetic language masks the real tragedy; why flaunt your poetic ability when you're grieving or trying to remember or honour someone. Favourite song: Birdland Worst song: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) Overall: amazing album. Stunning lyricism and rebellious chaotic energy throughout. Sometimes the chaos was a little too much and sometimes the poeticism lessened the emotional impact towards the end, but there are many songs here I can imagine myself listening to more and more and enjoying more and more.
Emerging from the melting pot of New York's CBGB Club, Patti Smith combines poetry wrought from memory and a punk attitude before punk got its tenure. Patti Smith delivers one visceral performance after the other and not without substance, with some frankly excellent lyrics ranging from tragic tales to the human abstract. Horses starts off with a bang with Gloria, a song that thoroughly embodies the spirit of adolescence. With its changing swings in tempo, unappologetic denouncement of religion, and the hypocrisy of worshipping lust, the disillusion of the narrator comes to a boil as the song crescendo. Musically I would describe this a mishmash of punk, prog and rock & roll that serves to elevate the lyrics and performance. Redondo Beach tells the story of the tragic passing of a girl after an argument and sets it over a ska groove and somehow it works perfectly. A unique melancholly is present in between the mournful lyrics, pained vocals and upbeat 12 bar blues. Birdland is a 9 minute epic concerning the inner turmoil of a young boy after the passing of his father. The dreamlike imagery evokes a disconnect from reality that the boy feels and in a way be thought of as a detatchment from humanity. The heavy desire to not be alone is felt in the boy's wanting to go with the ship; the ship being symbolic of souls being taken away. The inhuman quality of the dead highlighted by the refrain is two-fold, we find that to be seen as inhuman is no different from being dead, a political sentiment that can be interpreted from lines in the song. On the otherhand, the yearning of the boy to go with the ship connotates death as freeing, possibly from the shackles of humanity. Patti creates a contrasting abstract of death as both a freeing and oppressive force which only serves to highlight the the boy's internal conflict. Free Money is a powerful expression of the obsessive desire to escape poverty, even if it means stealing. The desperation is built up as the song goes on, shifting from sombre to a manic climax as the singer repeats 'free money' over and over. Kimberly is a melodic punk ditty that is reminiscent of Lou Reed's song writing but still unmistakenly Patti Smith with her raw spontaneous vocal styling. Not the most interesting melody Break It Up interestingly is cowritten by Tom Verlaine and anyone familliar with Television will recognise his signature wailing guitar work. Honestly I'm not sure what this one is about though like other songs there is imagery of death. However, the passion is there with every passing chorus becoming more and more inflamed beautifully ending with the repeating group chorus. Land: Horse / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) is the centre piece of album with its run time comparable to Birdland and includes the album's namesake. Split into three parts, though I don't have the time to parse the lyrics, they are chaotic cobweb with the vocals overlapping each other at times. The song is avant garde in its approach reminiscent of The Velvet Underground - a likely influence given that John Cale produced the album. Land of a Thousand Dances seeming to be the bulk of the track is bookended by Horses which seems to be the introductory section and la Mer(de) being a ending. Overall, I don't think I haven't spent enough time with this track to come to a conclusion with its seemingly impenetrable artistic scope. Musically its excellent with the unusual avant punk blend and Smith's unique vocals being the highlight. Elegie - the final track is a haunting elegy with instrumentation sounding like it resurrected. A fitting end to an album which has many themes touching upon death. Overall, horses is a spectacular album that defied my expectations. Even without listening to the lyrics, the album is written superbly with fantastic performances from Smith and her musicians. Lyrically the album is one of the best I've heard, seeming as I don't often consider lyrics too deeply is indicative of the poetry put to song. At times however some of the songs can become repetitive and the lyricism can burden the songs with their need to be heard. Thinking back to Land, it can be hard to become engrossed due to the lyrical density. Favourite Songs: Gloria, Redondo Beach, Birdland, Free Money, Break It Up, Elegie Least favourite song: Kimberly (if I had to pick one) and Land (if I had to pick two) Rating: 4.5/5
Fine! Interesting to see this labeled as punk.
Nuevamente, esta pagina cumple su propósito y me da descubrimientos que de otra manera no hubiera encontrado. Debió ser divertido grabar este álbum, se siente como una adolescente jugando en su cuarto, pero si llegué a aburrirme después de un rato aunque es disfrutable. terrible canción la 7
Patti Smith is an absolute badass. She can rock and bring the fire. Amazing first album with an opening line that absolutely cannot be beat. Gets a little slow and draggy at times. The only thing keeping it from a 5er
Not my cup of tea or my favorite of her songs.
This is a very good album. A lot of emotion.
i want to like it but i don’t. her memoirs slap tho.
It's alright
Quand en écoutant en l'album, on a l'impression de se faire engueuler, c'est pas bon signe. Patti Smith hurle plus que ça ne chante, ça en devient énervant. Certaines instrus sont même pauvres. Je n'ai pas du tout accroché. Note : 2 À réécouter : Non
I love the cover, iconic.
Me gustó, no sé si es un album que escucharía habitualmente, pero me relajó bastante.
I feel like some albums aren't meant to be listened to. The music is secondary to the message. This is one of those albums.
Increíble, creo que este es el primer álbum de los que me tocaron hasta ahora que realmente me sorprendió, en lo musical, lo lírico y lo interpretativo, es una cosa tremenda de principio a fin. Nacido en lo punk pero trata de llegar a algo más, lo único parecido a esto que escuché es Marquee Moon de Television.
3.5 rounded to 4. I understand the context for this album, but I just can’t really like the music. The album isn’t bad it just isn’t amazing to me. I enjoy hearing her voice, so that’s always a bonus. The album itself is defiant. Favorite song: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo
Patti walked so that so many others could run. I appreciate this album, and I’m sure after a few more listens I’ll want to change my rating to a 5.
It doesn’t happen often, but here’s an album that deserves to be on this list. A better combination of lyrics, voice, musicians, and producer would be hard to find.
Another one praised by critics I see. It wasn't terrible but I didn't like it that much. It was boring. I don't get what is punk about this aside from the whiny vocals.
How is this 1975, and how have I not listened to this in its entirety before? I'm aware of how iconic this album is, and I've heard some of the tracks before, but I had no idea how good those 43 minutes would be. PJ Harvey Siouxsie Sioux Courtney Love Kim Gordon You all knew... On the 'buy list' Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ✅️ ★★★★★ (9/10) Total reviewed : 278 Already owned : 62 Purchased : 15 To buy : 3 Nope : 198
I had never heard that before, I quite enjoyed it.
Great album!
I like punk, avant garde and far from the mainstream musics but not this album.
Punk and poetry are meant to convey a message, right? Communicate some sort of meaning? Or is expressing abstract emotion and feeling? No idea. And I've no idea what Patti is rattling on about. But she does it passionately and wildly and the music builds up and crashes repeatedly. Often rousing, rarely uninteresting. Definitely a unique album and worthy of a place on this list. Did I personally love it? Maybe not. But it's good. I expected more songs about Horses.
I get sick of her delivery every once in a while but the compositions she puts together on this album are really rocking. I'll have to give this one another listen someday.
ein horse
50 years old and still making great music. That deserves a compliment.
First song was fun, but it was downhill from there. I heard a live performance by her the other day and listened to her address the crowd. I lost a lot respect for her at that moment, which has affected my view of her music. She’s definitely not punk.
The influence this album had on punk is evident and I do like how she blended other styles of music to make this album. Smith is also clearly a brilliant lyricist with a poem-like quality to her lyrics but I think this just isn't my kind of music. Nothing wrong with it, it's a good album but not something I would add to my regular rotation although Free Money definitely is a highlight. This is an album I can see my opinion changing on after subsequent listening.
not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue
An unexpected joy. So much of this album feels like a heartfelt confession. In some ways, this reminds me of the Nick Cave album, but here I found the stories of the songs to be compelling. Added to the rotation: "Gloria: In Excelsis Deo" and "Kimberly"
The first time I heard this album I didn’t really care for it. Listening again now, it’s starting to grow on me. I still don’t love it, but I’m finding her voice less offensive, and I’m appreciating the music and the themes more. I can also see the influence, as it’s kind of punk, kind of Rolling Stones… it’s a fusion of things, but it’s done by a woman (obviously) which I think was new territory at the time.
This was ok i guess, it felt a bit slow at points and I couldn't really get hooked into it. Don't feel like i have much more to add apart from that.
Punk rock classic that stands the rest of time braving spoken word and catch tunes
It's got attitude. Not gonna win any vocal awards, I don't think she cares! It has a cool punk droning type sound, can hear Jon Cale's influence throughout. The Gloria opener is blazing hot, then a bit of the ska feel in Redondo Beach (sounds like early Police songs). I know her spoken word poetry over experimental drone rock isn't for everyone but I really dug it.
Gut - sehr gut.
konji
Some amazing songs on this record. This record definitely influenced music and the direction it was going.
Bien sin fliparme
This is an album I respect more than I enjoy. I'm terrible at understanding lyrics, and that's the major appeal of this album, so a lot of it went over my head, but what I did understand I enjoyed. Something that will probably grow on me with another listen or two.
A great energetic and varied album. Patti is really emotive with the raw vocals, and the instrumentals are really solid throughout. “Gloria” is a great opener, I love the way it builds and explodes into the chorus. I’m not so much of a fan of the next track, “Redondo Beach”, the reggae style doesn’t do much for me and I think Patti can stray into sounding a bit grating here. “Birdland” is absolutely phenomenal, a 9 minute epic that starts with some soft smooth instrumentals with Patti almost whispering over the top. It builds slightly as Patti breaks into song. It’s over quickly though and we’re back to spoken word with the guitar dancing around in the background. From here it gradually builds, Patti and the piano picking up energy towards the climax and then fading again. Excellent. “Free Money” is probably my favourite track. The instrumentals just sound great on here, and Patti as well. I love Patti’s spoken word on “Land” with the furious guitar underneath. The sort of repurposing of Wilson Pickett’s “Land of 1000 dances” works surprisingly well. “Elegie” works really well as a haunting closer, the dark bass with the intermittent distorted guitar chords give it a lot of atmosphere.
This wasn't a very pleasant listen. I still hate spoken word. There's some parts I like, even more parts I really dislike. This just isn't an album I would listen to for fun. It didn't catch my attention at all.
MUITO BOM
Excellent album. Need to spend more time with it to digest it all, but I really dug it.
vibes, no creo que lo vuelva a escuchar
I knew I loved this album but I hadn’t listened to it in years. I sat, washing the pots, waving at the birds and as Gloria kicked in, it was a transcendental experience. I love this album. I love Patti Smith. And this is without a doubt a must listen.
QUEEENNNNN
Album No. 0196 on my playlist. I've been looking forward to properly listening to this album for a long time. I had never once listened to "Horses" in its entirety (and only had known "Gloria: In Excelsis Deo"), but I've been fully aware that this is an iconic album, a milestone of 70s music, and Patti Smith's opus magnum. When I first listened to this, I found it quite okay. For no particular reason whatsoever, I just started listening to it a gain after the first run. And what can I say? "Horses" really grows on you. I ended up listening to the whole thing four times in a row. It instantly (well, during the second play-through) became an absolute favorite of mine. This is certainly one of the greatest records I've ever listened to. Lyrically, the whole thing is absolutely brilliant, I love Smith's voice and style of singing, and the music perfectly matches the raw, unpolished energy of this. This is ceratinly an awesome proto-punk album. Just very very great, and one can easily justify putting this on the 1001 album list. Love this record and will listen to it over and over again and will certainly explore Patti Smith's music more (the only other song I had known so far was the obvious "Because The Night", particularly due to the involvement of Bruce Springsteen, my favorite musician). Until then, I'll add "Redondo Beach", "Free Money", and "Land" to my playlist, in addition to the already mentioned "Gloria". Great, iconic, interesting! 5/5 stars!
Very enjoyable, but not something I think I'd be listening to over and again
Wtf
(87/100)
Siento que canta un poco sobreactuada, en plan alguien que quiere ponerle drama y no sabe hacerlo de otra forma, o que quiere llamar la atención demostrando lo bien que canta (aunque creo que este no es su caso, pero para que me entendais) y eso, hace que me guste un poco menos, aun así, reconozco el potencial. Ojo, muy fuera del resto del estilo músical que suelen quemar en los 70's.
7/10 Buen álbum, no tiene ninguna canción que sea una locura pero todas cumplen, mantiene un buen nivel, tranquilo y relajado para pasar el rato sin prestar mucha atención. Uno de los temas me hace acordar al final se "Escuela de Rock".
requires a certain mood
I’ve only known Gloria for years so good to finally do this one!
I had heard a lot about this album but never actually heard it. As a big REM fan I knew her from E-Bow the Letter and later on Blue. This was good but I was probably hoping for more from hype.
really well crafted, just not my exact cup of tea
pretty good. not quite my stuff
unexpected Banger - erinnert mich lowkey an bcnr und dire straits. Kann nur vom sound reden und free money ist crazy song wirklich, ziemlich antikapitalistisch, auch für diese Zeit sehr beeindruckend.
Oh this was a good one. Loved every minute! You can tell how influential she was as well as who was influencing her.
solid 70s rock album, started off strong and kept me engaged through the whole thing
Very poetic, would listen again
Obra maestra del rock. Joya de 1975 que nunca envejece. Patti eterna
I can understand some people not liking this but you can't deny that it's an inflection point for music that occurred. Me, I think it's wonderful.
I know of Patti Smith but I know nothing about her music. Maybe she has better albums? This was rather dull
Shades of things to come - I hear elements of Patti Smith's voice in Debbie Harry, Sharon Van Etten, Kate Bush, all sorts of other fantastic musicians. Ultimately I didn't think the album itself was particularly memorable, but I could see it growing on me given enough time.
I hear in this a lot of artists I like more - Poe, PJ Harvey, Siouxsie, Tori, so on - but it is, unfortunately, Poetry. Music gets worse the closer it gets to Poetry. I'm glad I gave it another listen because I do like it more than I did on my initial attempt but a track like Birdland makes me want to give it the two I originally planned
Well written and performed, but not necessarily the most interesting
Patti Smith's vocal presence is grating (reminds of school bullies). The album is emotionally taxing — specific imagery (boy hitting locker) is disturbing rather than artistic. Revolutionary for 1975, maybe, but unpleasant to listen to. Needed upbeat music to recover from the mood it created.
I had to actively fight the urge to cover my ears, even with earbuds in...why must Yoko Ono's reincarnation make me suffer on this dull Monday?
Great poetic punk rock.
Hell yeah, Patti Smith. Such a solid album.
Not really my kind of thing
Any good album should stand on its own, and this one does, but I believe it is enhanced by a reading of Patti Smith’s memoir “Just Kids” which goes into her early days in New York City, barely scraping by as an artist and poet; her relationship with the photographer Robert Mapplethorpe (who photographed the cover of this album); her meeting Lenny Kaye (who compiled the Nuggets box set and is a legend in his own right) and them eventually forming the Patti Smith Group and recording this album. Songs like “Free Money” take on an enhanced meaning when you understand how poor Smith was. As for the music, it doesn’t sound much like what we’ve come to think of as punk, though it doesn’t sound much like anything else either. I guess the stream of consciousness ramblings of Bob Dylan are a musical touchpoint here, but Smith is doing her own thing, drawing from the Beat poets and the French symbolists. Lenny Kaye and the rest of the band match her with a sound that comes from the primitivism of garage rock but has an almost jazzy spirit of improvisation. Horses unquestionably belongs on any list of important and influential albums, and ranks pretty highly among them, in my opinion. If I have any criticism of this album, and I say this as someone who has listened to it many times over the years, and owns multiple physical copies of it, it’s that it’s an album that I think I appreciate most intellectually. It doesn’t speak as deeply to me as other music that I’d consider to be my favorites. That’s really on me, though, and this is a five star album.
come on now...
Not really my cup of tea
an unpopular opinion but i never liked her
Fucking exceptional. Patti Smith was likely your favorite artist's favorite artist in the late 70s man. You can see her influence on and contribution to this type of punk and post punk singer songwriter music echo throughout the next decade or more. Ramones, Television, Tom Waits, Nick Cave, the list is probably longer than I know.
Aight
I can't say enough about this album. A brilliant, raw, vulnerable and ugly offering that tells stories with unapologetic emotion. 9/10
j'aime pas comment elle mange ses mots exprès
My rating 2.6. Critics tell you this album needs to be respected. I respectfully disagree.
The music is ok, not good not bad. I really don't like the vocals or her voice. And I really don't like the speak-singing. 2.5
Love horses in art.
A beautiful album i barely even understand as its true narrative is hidden deep in its lyrics and spoken word passages, pretty sure it’s about personal freedom though, could be wrong. My standouts would be Break it up for being a clear banger and also Birdland and Land: Horses for being more spoken word.
This had been on my long list for awhile. Really solid album. She's got a great voice and a poetry to her lyrics. Definitely worth a listen.
really enjoyed the lyrics but the music less so… punk isn’t really my go-to genre. ‘birdland’ had my favorite lyrics.
One of those albums I'd been meaning to listen to for a long time and finally did about a month ago before it popped up here. Tremendous album of proto punk with an avant/art twist. Gloria kicks it off with a bang, reggae vibes off Redondo beach are lovely and side one ends with the fabulous Free Money -rocking out but precise drumming, so that while it feels like it might break down somewhere but never does. Side two continues in a similar vein, the 7 minutes of Land ebb and flow fantasticly. Who knew punk songs could be 7 minutes? The version I listened to with a bonus live track, My Generation, was the icing on the cake. Loved this album and definitely one that everyone should listen to before they shuffle off this mortal coil. 5 stars
I don't know how I was aware of, but ultimately slept on, this album for over 40 years, but it was fucking phenomenal. Patti herself sounds like a proto, mid-70s PJ Harvey, rooted in the Velvet Underground, adjacent to Television, and a direct influence on everyone from Kim Deal to Carrie Brownstein. That alone makes it a pretty great listen. But the rawness of the vocals and fragmented lyrics against that tight rhythm section and angular 70s NY guitar...chefs kiss. Effortlessly cool.
Favorite tracks: Gloria, Birdland, Free Money, Break It Up, Land Her endless charisma, her ever-fascinating and poetic lyricism with vibrant storytelling, her voice like a bolt of lightning that sunders the land, the peak of rock and roll musicianship with especially noteworthy guitar work... What is there not to love about Horses? This makes me love being a woman.
This one was hit or miss for me. Some of it was pretty good, but a lot of it was boring or unimpressive. I was expecting a bit more punk rock attitude from what I'd heard about Smith's influence and her place in the movement. Instead, it was a lot more artsy and poetic, with a couple ballad-like compositions in the mix. After this listen, I feel like maybe her music had more impact live than could be captured on a recording. I wouldn't say this was bad, but it didn't really do a lot for me. I'll put it on the borderline of OK and good. Overall: 2.75/5
Decent listen.
Average listen Very unmusical
4. Good and unique
Raspy female rock vocals match 70s rock vibe. I never love the lingering discordant guitar solos but this felt “cool”.
Hatte am anfang echt Potenzial, aber leider hat es mich nicht ganz abgeholt. An Stellen war der heulerisches Gesang echt zu viel (anfang von Birdland z.b) 3/5
A wonderful and iconic record. #johnsvinyl
has its moments
Красивый альбом
Pues la recordaba como más... más... algo!
Patti Smith and Bjork are 2 sides of the same coin
1.4/5 I'm not the biggest fan of her voice and it was a pretty bland album. I know she's a big artist but this album didn't really do anything for me.
Great but was NOT in the mood for it.
Ça me tentais pas vraiment d’écouter ce style là mais j’imagine que ça devait être cool d’entendre ça à l’époque
JESUS DIED FOR SOMEBODY’S SINS BUT NOT MINE!!!! 🗣️ raw, poetic and so so influential. Patti is one of the OG cool girls chanson préférée : Free Money P.S. ça fait trois albums déjà (Physical Graffiti, Neon Bible et celui-là) qui ont une toune « plage » pis je tiens juste à souligner à quel point j’haïs ça. why is this a thing
So this is the album with Redondo Beach!! Great + very creative musically. Loved something in every song. 4.5 stars cos the 0.5 needed a teney bit more dopamine scratching
I am slightly aware of Patti Smith, and I have 2 songs liked by her - with 1 song from this album ("Redondo Beach"). I can't remember why or when I first heard that song but I do like that. So, I'm very interested to dive deeper into this album. After 3 listens I ended up liking "Gloria", "Free Money", and "Elegie" - in addition to "Redondo Beach". The long spoken word parts of several of these songs remind me of the Jim Morrison/Doors "American Prayer" album - and not in a good way. Just didn't like most of that. Apparently this is supposed to be so ground breaking and innovative and influential. That might be, but it's not a perfect album by any stretch. It's just ok to my ears - having liked only half the songs. Liked songs on Spotify: 4/8 Rating: 3/5
Always a good listen. So many styles, timeless.
This album was around when I was growing up and into great music, but I never heard it in full. Now, far too late in the game, I’m hearing a young Patti Smith and I can’t believe how much she sounds like Carrie Brownstein of Sleater-Kinney. Wait, let’s reverse that. How much Carrie Brownstein sounds like Patti Smith. Godmother of punk indeed! Love the energy and showwomanship here. These songs must have been amazing live. This would probably move to a 5/5 with more time, my subjective 4/5 probably says more about my being a latecomer here.
Brilliant Album and artist. At the end, I was convinced that Patti just kept speaking and saying interesting things whether there was music or not. But the most amazing part to me was how beautifully interwoven her vocal style flowed with the music itself. The energy and intelligence and poetry is tight and impactful from beginning to end. What a great album.
Pretty fun, the opening track is energetic as anything. 'Free Money' is a banger. The rest of the album unfolds rather nicely. I enjoyed it quite a bit.
4/5
It had glimmers of promise but too much talking over itself for me
4.5 (43:10, 8 tracks, debut, 1975) Punk (Art Punk) Should this album be part of this list - 1000%, one of the most influential albums of all time. Do I love this album, not really, I love punk but it's a bit too artsy and not enough 'punk'; however I respect the hell out of this album. It's like a non-Christian reading the bible just because of how many cultural references and literary allusions point to bible passages. Not listening to this album before you die would be a shame for any audiophile. This album, more so than any other (this is #202) is the most important to have 'listened to before I died.' Still I give it a 4. It's just not a classic. If I was given 100 albums to take to the deserted island and which I'd never get off . . . this wouldn't be one (though if I did take it, I bet I would learn to love it more.) RESPECT! The album cover features a black-and-white photograph of Patti Smith slinging a jacket over her shoulder. Singles from Horses "Gloria" Smith, supported by her regular backing band, recorded the album at Electric Lady Studios in September 1975, choosing former Velvet Underground member John Cale as the album's producer. The music on Horses was part of the minimalist punk rock aesthetic of the time. Smith and her band composed the album's songs using simple chord progressions, but also breaking from punk tradition in their propensity for improvisation and embrace of ideas from avant-garde and other musical styles. With Horses, Smith drew upon her backgrounds in rock music and poetry, aiming to create an album combining both forms. Her lyrics were alternately rooted in her own personal experiences, particularly with her family, and in more fantastical imagery. Horses was additionally inspired by Smith's reflections on the previous era of rock music—with two of its songs being adapted in part from 1960s rock standards, and others containing lyrical allusions and tributes to past rock performers—and her hopes for the music's future. Horses experienced modest commercial success and reached the top 50 of the Billboard album chart, while being widely acclaimed by music critics. Recognized as a seminal recording in the history of punk and later rock movements, Horses has appeared in numerous lists of the greatest albums of all time. In 2009, it was selected by the Library of Congress for preservation into the National Recording Registry as a "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant" work. By 1974 Patti Smith and her backing band frequently performance live in NYC; a popular act in the underground rock music scene. Their highly attended two-month residency at the New York City club CBGB with the band Television created hype. Clive Davis, scouting for artists for his label Arista Records was impressed by her live performance. Davis offered Smith a seven-album recording deal with Arista. Smith had written poetry for several years before becoming a musician, and entered the music industry because she thought "the presentation of poetry wasn't vibrant enough". For her debut album, her primary aim was to merge poetry and rock music, which then developed into a "larger mission" to "pump blood back into the heart of rock'n'roll". The title Horses reflected Smith's desire for a rejuvenation of rock music, which she found had grown "calm" in reaction to the social turmoil of the 1960s and the deaths of numerous prominent rock musicians of that era. "Psychologically, somewhere in our hearts," she stated shortly after the album's release, "we were all screwed up because those people died ... We all had to pull ourselves together. To me, that's why our record's called Horses. We had to pull the reins on ourselves to recharge ourselves ... We've gotten ourselves back together. It's time to let the horses loose again. We're ready to start moving again." Smith later reflected that she had envisioned Horses as a record bridging the "great artists that we had just lost" and the next generation of rockers, who she hoped would "be less materialistic, more bonded with the people and not so glamorous", and that from a more humanistic perspective, she had also aimed "to reach out to other disenfranchised people" like herself. Smith said, "I was consciously trying to make a record that would make a certain type of person not feel alone. People who were like me, different ... I wasn't targeting the whole world. I wasn't trying to make a hit record." At Smith's suggestion, the label planned to book with producer Tom Dowd at Criteria in Miami, but Dowd's close association with rival label Atlantic Records stalled these plans. Smith had a change of heart and instead set out to enlist Welsh musician John Cale, formerly of the New York City rock band the Velvet Underground, to produce Horses after she was impressed by the raw sound of his solo albums. Horses was recorded at Electric Lady Studios in New York City, with Smith retaining the same backing band with whom she performed live at the time. They recorded several songs that were already fixtures of their live sets, including "Gloria", "Redondo Beach", "Birdland", and "Land". Allen Lanier of Blue Öyster Cult and Tom Verlaine of Television participated in the recording sessions as guest musicians, performing on the songs "Elegie" and "Break It Up", respectively. Cale recalled the band initially "sounded awful" and played out of tune due to their use of damaged instruments, compelling him to procure the band new instruments. Cale wished to augment the band's approach on certain songs with string instruments, but Smith vehemently opposed this idea. For several years after the album's release, Smith often downplayed Cale's contributions to Horses and suggested that she and her band had ignored his suggestions entirely. My picking John was arbitrary, I looked at the cover of Fear and I said, 'Now there's a set of cheekbones.' In my mind I picked him because his records sounded good. But I hired the wrong guy. All I was really looking for was a technical person. Instead, I got a total maniac artist. I went to pick out an expensive watercolor painting and instead I got a mirror. It was really like A Season in Hell, for both of us. But inspiration doesn't always have to be someone sending me half a dozen American Beauty roses. There's a lotta inspiration going on between the murderer and the victim. And he had me so nuts I wound up doing this nine-minute cut that transcended anything I ever did before. Cale said in 1996 that Smith initially struck him as "someone with an incredibly volatile mouth who could handle any situation", and that as producer on Horses he wanted to capture the energy of her live performances, noting that there "was a lot of power in Patti's use of language, in the way images collided with one another." He likened their working relationship during recording to "an immutable force meeting an immovable object." Smith would later attribute much of the tension between herself and Cale to her inexperience with formal studio recording, recalling that she was "very, very suspicious, very guarded and hard to work with" and "made it difficult for him to do some of the things he had to do." She expressed gratitude for Cale's persistence in working with her and her band, and found that his production made the most out of their "adolescent and honest flaws". 1. "Gloria" 15:15. "Gloria" relies on a simple progression of three chords (E major, D major, and A major). Smith characterized Horses as "three-chord rock merged with the power of the word". Consequence's Lior Phillips noted that the minimalist quality of the album's music "matched the tone of" the nascent punk rock genre, which had emerged in NYC in the mid-1970s, and counted Smith, Television, and fellow CBGB regulars such as the Ramones as practitioners. William Ruhlmann of AllMusic cited Lenny Kaye's rudimentary guitar playing and the "anarchic spirit" of Smith's vocals as being representative of punk. Tarr wrote that the band "proudly flaunted a garage rock aesthetic" on Horses, while Smith "sang with the delirious release of an inspired amateur", emphasizing "honest passion" over technical proficiency. Smith's vocals on the album alternate between being sung and spoken, an approach that, according to Peter Murphy of Hot Press, "challenged the very notion of a demarcation" between the two forms. AllMusic critic Steve Huey observed that Horses borrowed ideas from the avant-garde, with the music showcasing the band's free jazz-inspired interplay and improvisation, while still remaining "firmly rooted in primal three-chord rock & roll. . . essentially the first art punk album." Smith and her band's musical improvisation differentiated them from most of their punk contemporaries, whose songs rarely diverged from straightforward three-chord structures. Throughout Horses, they also tempered their punk sound with elements of other musical styles, balancing more conventional rock songs with excursions into reggae ("Redondo Beach") and jazz ("Birdland"). Fiona Sturges of The Guardian described Smith's lyrics on Horses as being steeped in "intricate phrasing and imagery" that "deliberately blurred the lines between punk and poetry", while CMJ writer Steve Klinge found they recalled the energy of Beat poetry and the "revolutionary spirit" of French poet Arthur Rimbaud, one of Smith's primary influences. She left the genders of the songs' protagonists ambiguous, a stylistic choice she said was "learnt from Joan Baez, who often sang songs that had a male point of view", while also serving as a declaration "that as an artist, I can take any position, any voice, that I want." Smith's experiences with her family inspired specific songs on Horses. "Redondo Beach", whose lyrics concern a woman who commits suicide following a quarrel with the song's narrator, was written by Smith after an incident involving her and her sister Linda. The two had gotten into a heated argument, prompting Linda to leave their shared apartment and not return until the next day. "Kimberly" is a dedication to its namesake, Smith's younger sister, and finds the singer recounting a childhood memory of holding Kimberly in her arms during a lightning storm. In "Free Money", Smith describes growing up in poverty in New Jersey and recalls her mother fantasizing about winning the lottery. Other songs were penned by Smith about notable public figures. "Birdland" was inspired by A Book of Dreams, a 1973 memoir of Austrian psychoanalyst Wilhelm Reich by his son Peter, and revolves around a narrative in which Peter, at his father's funeral, imagines leaving on a UFO piloted by his father's spirit. "Break It Up" was written about Jim Morrison based on Smith's recollection of her visit to Morrison's grave in Père Lachaise Cemetery, as well as a dream in which she witnessed a winged Morrison stuck to a marble slab, trying and eventually succeeding in breaking free from the stone. "Elegie" is a requiem for rock musician Jimi Hendrix and quotes a line from his 1968 song "1983... (A Merman I Should Turn to Be)". It was recorded, at Smith's request, on the fifth anniversary of Hendrix's death, which fell on September 18, the final day of recording. Smith said that the song was also intended to pay tribute to other deceased rock artists such as Jim Morrison, Brian Jones, and Janis Joplin. Two songs on Horses are partial adaptations of rock standards: "Gloria", a radical reimagining of the 1964 Them song incorporating verses from Smith's own poem "Oath", and "Land", which features the first verse of Chris Kenner's 1962 song "Land of a Thousand Dances". In "Land", Smith weaves the imagery of the Kenner song into an elaborate narrative about a character named Johnny—an allusion to the similarly named homoerotic protagonist of the 1971 William S. Burroughs novel The Wild Boys—while additionally referencing Arthur Rimbaud and, indirectly, Jimi Hendrix, whom Smith imagined to be the song's protagonist, "dreaming a simple rock-and-roll song, and it takes him into all these other realms." The characterization of Johnny in "Land" was also inspired by photographer Robert Mapplethorpe—who was a close friend of Smith and shot the picture of her used for the Horses album cover—and his experiences in the New York S&M scene; in her memoir Just Kids (2010), Smith refers to Mapplethorpe and Burroughs, sitting together in CBGB, as "Johnny and the horse". The cover photograph for Horses was taken by Robert Mapplethorpe at the Greenwich Village penthouse apartment of his partner Sam Wagstaff. Smith, shrouded in natural light, is seen wearing a plain white shirt, which she had purchased at a Salvation Army shop on the Bowery, and slinging a black jacket over her shoulder and her favorite black ribbon around her collar. Embedded on the jacket is a horse pin that Allen Lanier had given her. Smith described her appearance as recalling those of French poet Charles Baudelaire and, in the slinging of the jacket, American singer and actor Frank Sinatra. She recounted that Mapplethorpe "took, like, twelve pictures, and at about the eighth one, he said, 'I have it.' I said, 'How do you know?' and he said, 'I just know,' and I said, 'Okay.' And that was it." The black-and-white treatment and androgynous pose were a departure from the typical promotional images of female singers of the time. Arista executives wanted to make various changes to the photograph, but Smith overruled their suggestions. Clive Davis wrote in 2013 that he was initially conflicted about the image, recognizing its "power" but feeling that it would confuse audiences unfamiliar with Smith and her style of music. He put aside his reservations and approved the cover after realizing that he needed "to trust her artistic instincts thoroughly". Feminist writer Camille Paglia later referred to the Horses cover photograph as "one of the greatest pictures ever taken of a woman." In 2017, World Cafe presenter Talia Schlanger wrote that "Smith's unapologetic androgyny predates a time when that was an en vogue or even available option for women, and represents a seminal moment in the reversal of the female gaze. Smith is looking at you, and could care less what you think about looking at her. That was radical for a woman in 1975. It is still radical today." Smith herself stated that she had not intended to make a "big statement" with the cover, which she said simply reflected the way she dressed. "I wasn't thinking that I was going to break any boundaries. I just like dressing like Baudelaire," she remarked in 1996. On September 18, 1975, the same day that they finished recording Horses, Smith and her band performed a promotional live concert at an Arista convention held at the New York City Center, where they were personally introduced by Clive Davis. They previewed five songs from the album: "Birdland", "Redondo Beach", "Break It Up", "Land", and, as their encore, "Free Money". Lisa Robinson reported afterward in NME that the "stupendous, truly exciting" performance was met with a highly ecstatic response from the Arista executives in attendance. Smith had originally requested for the album to be issued on October 20, the birthday of Arthur Rimbaud, but due to a shortage of vinyl, the release date was postponed, in what Smith described as a "magical" coincidence, to November 10, the anniversary of Rimbaud's death. Commercially, it performed respectably for a debut album, despite receiving little radio airplay. In the United States, Horses peaked at number 47 on the Billboard 200 album chart, remaining on the chart for 17 weeks. The album also managed chart placings in Australia, Canada, and the Netherlands, where it reached number 18. To promote Horses, Smith and her band toured the US and made their network television debut performing on the NBC variety show Saturday Night Live, then traveled to Europe for an appearance on the BBC Two music show The Old Grey Whistle Test and a short tour. "Gloria" was released as a single in April 1976. Smith's cover of the Who's "My Generation", performed live in Cleveland, served as the single's B-side. Horses was met with near-universal acclaim from critics. Music journalist Mary Anne Cassata said that it was roundly hailed as "one of the most original first albums ever recorded." Reviewing the album for Rolling Stone, John Rockwell wrote that Horses is "wonderful in large measure because it recognizes the overwhelming importance of words" in Smith's work, covering a range of themes "far beyond what most rock records even dream of." Rockwell highlighted Smith's adaptations of "Gloria" and "Land of a Thousand Dances" as the most striking moments on the record, finding that she had rendered the songs "far more expansive than their original creators could have dreamed." Jonh Ingham of Sounds penned a five-star review of Horses, naming it "the record of the year" and "one of the most stunning, commanding, engrossing platters to come down the turnpike since John Lennon's Plastic Ono Band". NME critic Charles Shaar Murray called it "an album in a thousand" and "an important album in terms of what rock can encompass without losing its identity as a musical form, in that it introduces an artist of greater vision than has been seen in rock for far too long." At the end of 1975, Horses was voted the second-best album of the year, behind Bob Dylan and the Band's The Basement Tapes, in the Pazz & Jop, an annual poll of American critics published in The Village Voice. Horses cemented Smith's reputation as a central figure of the New York City punk rock scene. It has frequently been cited as the first punk rock album, as well as one of the key recordings of the punk movement, appearing in professional lists of the best punk albums of all time. "Pipping the Ramones' first album to the post by five months," Simon Reynolds wrote in The Observer, "Horses is generally considered not just one of the most startling debuts in rock history but the spark that ignited the punk explosion." Horses has been described as a landmark for both punk and its offshoot genre new wave, inspiring "a raw, almost amateurish energy for the former and critical, engaging reflexivity for the latter." "intelligent and self-conscious, yet visceral and exciting" sensibility, identifying its influence on the alternative rock, indie rock, and grunge movements that followed the punk era. “I still feel the chill of Patti Smith's suspicious gaze when I look at the cover of Horses, but now I feel like I can explain it a little better." Various musicians have credited Horses as an influence. Viv Albertine of the Slits said that the album "absolutely and completely changed" her life, adding: "Us girls never stood in front of a mirror posing as if we had a guitar because we had no role models. So, when Patti Smith came along, it was huge. She was groundbreakingly different." Siouxsie and the Banshees frontwoman Siouxsie Sioux, naming "Land" as a recording she considered particularly influential on her, remarked that "apart from Nico, Patti was the first real female writer in rock." R.E.M.'s Michael Stipe bought a copy of Horses as a high school student and later stated that the album "tore [his] limbs off and put them back on in a whole different order", citing Smith as his primary inspiration for becoming a musician. Similarly, his R.E.M. bandmate Peter Buck cited attending the four Atlanta shows Smith played on her first US tour as the moment he started to seriously consider forming a group. Morrissey and Johnny Marr shared an appreciation for the record, and one of their early compositions for the Smiths, "The Hand That Rocks the Cradle", uses a melody based on that of "Kimberly".[97] Courtney Love of Hole recounted that listening to Horses as a teenager helped encourage her to pursue a career in rock music, while PJ Harvey recalled hearing the album and finding it "brilliant—not so much her music but her delivery, words, and her articulation. Her honesty." KT Tunstall wrote her hit single "Suddenly I See" (2004) about how she felt inspired to embrace her musical ambitions after seeing Smith on the cover of Horses. Horses has often been named by music critics as one of the all-time greatest albums. Lars Brandle of Billboard wrote that the album had come to be regarded as "one of the finest in recorded music history." In 2003 and 2012, Horses was ranked at number 44 on Rolling Stone's list of the 500 greatest albums of all time, later #26 in 2020. NME named it the 12th-greatest album of all time in a similar list published in 2013. In 2006, Time named Horses as one of the "All-Time 100 Albums", and The Observer listed it as one of 50 albums that changed music history. 1 "Gloria" is a radical reimagining of the original 1964 song by Van Morrison. It retains the iconic "G-L-O-R-I-A" chorus, Smith transforms it into a fierce anthem of artistic independence, religious defiance, and sexual fluidity. The song famously opens with the line, "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine," adapted from Smith's 1970 poem "Oath". This serves as a bold dismissal of her Jehovah’s Witness upbringing and a claim of personal responsibility for her own "sins". Smith described the track as a "declaration of existence," using it to both acknowledge and disclaim her musical and spiritual heritage. For her, the song represents the "right to create without apology" from a stance that transcends social or gender definitions. Though often interpreted as a lesbian anthem due to its female muse, Smith has stated she chose to keep the feminine pronouns to sing from a male perspective, a technique she learned from Joan Baez. This approach highlights her goal of being an artist "beyond gender". The lyrics describe a raw, almost feverish encounter with a woman named Gloria. This imagery subverts the male-dominated garage rock of the 1960s, reclaiming the narrative for a new, more explicit and self-empowered era. "Gloria" is widely considered a foundational moment for punk rock, influencing future icons like Michael Stipe and Bono. 2 "Redondo Beach" is a tragic narrative about a woman who dies by suicide by drowning following an argument with the song's narrator. While the upbeat reggae-inspired rhythm feels jaunty, the meaning is deeply rooted in grief and remorse. Smith wrote the lyrics in 1971 as a poem after a rare, intense argument with her sister, Linda. After Linda left their shared apartment near the Chelsea Hotel and didn't return by nightfall, a worried Smith spent the night at Coney Island. The song is a "morbid fantasy" born from that fear; in the song's version of events, the sister (or lover) never returns and is instead found "washed up" on the shore. Smith often introduced the song live by saying, "Redondo Beach is a beach where women love other women". This led many to interpret it as a lament for a lost female lover, an interpretation Smith encouraged even though the literal inspiration was her sister. True to her overarching artistic philosophy, Smith stated she was singing from a voice that was "beyond gender," allowing her to take any perspective regardless of her own identity. Redondo Beach itself—a city in Los Angeles County whose name is Spanish for "round"—was chosen as a symbolic, distant location for this emotional tragedy. 3 "Birdland" a nine-minute improvisational piece based on the 1973 memoir A Book of Dreams by Peter Reich. The song explores a child's grief and the surreal ways the mind processes loss. Peter Reich was the son of Wilhelm Reich, a controversial Austrian psychoanalyst who believed he could control the weather and harness "orgone energy". The song follows a young boy (Peter) at his father's funeral. In his grief, he imagines his father isn't truly dead but is instead returning in a UFO to rescue him. The title "Birdland" refers to a specific moment in the memoir where the boy sees a flock of blackbirds and, in a hallucinatory state, believes they are the approaching spaceships of his father. Smith and her band improvised the entire track at Electric Lady Studios. She has noted that she felt the spirit of Jimi Hendrix watching her during the recording. Smith connected deeply with the story because she felt like an "alien" herself as a child—tall, skinny, and disconnected from her family. Smith described the song as her message to a new generation of "prophets" who would "dream in animation" rather than just material success. Interestingly, the same book inspired Kate Bush's "Cloudbusting". 4 "Free Money" is a song about the longing to escape poverty through dreams of sudden wealth. While it is often mistaken for a traditional love song due to its "Oh baby" lyrics, its true meaning is deeply personal and rooted in Patti Smith's childhood. Smith wrote the song for her mother, Beverly Smith, who grew up in scarcity and frequently fantasized about winning the lottery. Her mother would make lists of things she would buy for her children, such as a "house by the sea," even though she rarely actually bought a lottery ticket. The lyrics reflect the anxiety of being broke, such as the memory of her mother closing the blinds to hide from debt collectors. The "free money" represents a miraculous salvation from the "burdens of reality". Some interpretations also link the song to her time in New York City with artist Robert Mapplethorpe. During their early years, Smith supported Mapplethorpe with her meager bookstore wages, and the song captures that shared dream of financial freedom. The track begins as a vulnerable piano ballad before exploding into a fast-paced punk anthem, mirroring the frantic, desperate energy of someone trying to "will a fortune into existence". "Every night before I rest my head / See those dollar bills swirling 'round my bed" – Illustrates the nightly fixation on wealth as a form of escape. "I'll buy you a jet plane, baby" – Symbolizes the desire to transcend their circumstances and reach a "higher plane". 5 "Kimberly" is a song dedicated to Patti Smith’s youngest sister (4th child). It blends a memory of a real-life event with intense, apocalyptic imagery. The song captures a moment from Smith's youth in New Jersey. During a massive electrical storm, Smith stood in the doorway of a barn holding her baby sister, Kimberly, while watching the sky. As the lightning struck, Smith felt a deep, protective connection to her sister. She described the experience as feeling like they were the only two people left in a world that was "ending" or being reborn. Unlike "Redondo Beach," which explores a fictionalized tragedy involving a sister, "Kimberly" is a pure, exultant tribute to family bonds. True to Smith’s style, the lyrics move from a simple memory into a hallucinatory space. She uses metaphors of "bats," "skulls," and "the wall of fire" to describe the raw power of nature and the intensity of the moment. The song's rhythm is driving and propulsive, mirroring the "shaking" and "breaking" of the world described in the lyrics—symbolizing the transition from childhood to adulthood. "The stars were like holes in the sky" – A classic Smith image representing a porous reality where the divine or the cosmic can leak through. "Kimberly, the world is moving" – This repeated line highlights the unavoidable passage of time and the shifting landscape of their lives . 6 The final three tracks of Smith’s Horses all explore rock'n'roll mythology in various ways. In her memoir “Just Kids” Smith says: “In ‘Break It Up’ Tom Verlaine and I wrote of a dream in which Jim Morrison, bound like Prometeus, suddenly broke free”. I had this dream. I came in on a clearing. There were natives in a circle bending and gesturing. I saw a man stretched across a marble slab. Jim Morrison. He was alive with wings that merged with the marble. Like Prometheus, he struggled, but freedom was beyond him. I stood over him chanting, break it up break it up break it up…The stone dissolved and he moved away. I brushed the feathers from my hair, adjusted my pillow, and returned to sleep. Tom Verlaine and I composed these words. Break It Up" is a visceral, collaborative track about the desire to liberate a trapped spirit. It is most famous for its connection to Jim Morrison and its co-authorship with Tom Verlaine (of the band Television). The lyrics were inspired by a dream Patti Smith had while visiting Jim Morrison’s grave at Père Lachaise Cemetery in Paris. She began screaming, "Break it up! Break it up!" to set him free. The song serves as an incantation to release the "Gilded Bird" (the artist's soul) from the confines of death and physical form. Verlaine wrote the music and played the distinctive, spiraling guitar solo. Smith’s vocal performance starts as a low moan and builds into a frantic, ritualistic shout, mirroring the physical act of trying to break through a barrier. The song isn't just about Morrison; it’s about the struggle of any artist to remain "unbound." It deals with the tension between the physical body and the transcendent spirit. The imagery of being "chained to a rock" evokes the Greek myth of Prometheus, who was punished for bringing fire (knowledge/art) to humanity—a fitting metaphor for the tragic rock stars Smith admired. "I was dreaming I was dreaming / And I saw you there" – Establishes the surreal, subconscious landscape of the song. "Ice, it was ice / But it was melting" – Represents the thawing of death or the breaking of a frozen, stagnant state. 7 "Land" a 9+ minute epic, is a surreal, poetic journey detailing the "dream, life, death, and resurrection" of a character named Johnny. It explores themes of violence, sexual awakening, and spiritual transcendence, with references to William Burroughs and autobiographical elements. The song opens with a brutal, cinematic scene of a boy named Johnny being attacked in a school hallway. This imagery is often interpreted as a reference to a, possibly homosexual, experience, which links the character to a young Robert Mapplethorpe. As noted in this Dig Interpretations post, the song portrays a journey from a "beaten down" state to spiritual liberation, using the "coiled snakes" of Hermes as a guide, suggesting a transformation through suffering. The song breaks into a raw, cover-like version of the 1960s R&B hit, highlighting a sense of raw energy and rock-and-roll. It is a complex, three-part suite—Horses, Land of a Thousand Dances, and La Mer(de)—that blends surrealist poetry with raw rock and roll. The song's meaning is multi-layered, involving both literary allusions and personal tributes: The narrative centers on a character named Johnny who is physically attacked and raped in a school hallway. This triggers a surreal, metaphysical journey—what Smith called the "dream, life, death, resurrection and soap opera of Johnny". Johnny is a reference to the protagonist of William S. Burroughs' novel The Wild Boys. The imagery of "Johnny and the horse" also connects to Smith's close friend, photographer Robert Mapplethorpe, and his experiences in the New York S&M scene. The song serves as an elegy for fallen rock icons, specifically Jimi Hendrix, whom Smith imagined as the protagonist dreaming a simple rock song that spirals into other realms. It also honors Janis Joplin, Jim Morrison, and Brian Jones. By weaving in the 1960s R&B hit "Land of a Thousand Dances" by Chris Kenner, Smith bridges the gap between classic garage rock and avant-garde poetry, name-checking figures like the 19th-century poet Arthur Rimbaud along the way. Interpretations often see the song's "sea of possibility" and "black mare" as symbols of transcendence from the pain and pressures of society, though the journey ends in a disintegrating, "dreaming drowned man" state. 8 Usually spelled “elegy,” the song’s title refers to a poem of mourning or memorialization. In The Poetry of Mourning, Jahan Ramazani notes that elegy is “among the oldest and richest of poetic genres.” The alternative spelling in the song’s title is indicative of Smith’s general challenge to established poetic and artistic norms and her general penchant for putting a distinctive stamp on those norms in her work. Elegy and mourning are consistent themes in Smith’s work. Many songs throughout her career are dedicated to particular individuals (“Grateful” to Jerry Garcia; “About a Boy” to Kurt Cobain) and her album Gone Again is a long-form elegy to her husband, Fred “Sonic” Smith and her brother Todd Smith. An elegy is a poem or song of serious reflection, typically written as a lament for the dead. Derived from the Greek word elegeia (meaning "song of mourning"), the form has evolved over centuries but generally follows a specific emotional arc: In classical literature, elegies often moved through three distinct stages of grief: Lament: A direct expression of sorrow and grief for the loss. Praise: Admiration and idealization of the deceased person's life and character. Solace: A final shift toward acceptance, consolation, or the idea of an afterlife. Unlike a eulogy (a speech of praise given at a funeral), an elegy is a poetic or musical work focused on mourning and melancholy. They are usually deeply personal, reflecting the writer’s own struggle with loss. In Patti Smith's work, an "Elegie" (her specific spelling) is the final track on her 1975 debut album, Horses. It serves as a haunting memorial for rock icons who died young, specifically Jimi Hendrix. Smith even borrows lyrics from Hendrix's song "1983... (A Merman I Should Turn to Be)" for the final lines: "I think it's sad, just too bad, that all our friends can't be with us today". Beyond Hendrix, the song honors other fallen rock legends including Jim Morrison, Janis Joplin, and Brian Jones. The song was co-written by Smith and her then-boyfriend Allen Lanier of the band Blue Öyster Cult. Smith used this alternative spelling as a way to put her own distinctive stamp on a classic poetic form, challenging traditional norms. The lyrics use metaphors like "trumpets and violins in the distance" to represent memories and longing for absent friends, creating an atmosphere of melancholy and nostalgia. The theme of the elegy remained central to Smith's later work as well; for instance, her 1996 album Gone Again is considered a long-form elegy to her husband, Fred "Sonic" Smith, and her brother Todd Track Listing: Favorite Songs: Gloria and Land 1. "Gloria" (part one: "In Excelsis Deo" / part two: "Gloria (Version)") Patti Smith (part one)/Van Morrison (part two) 5:54 2. "Redondo Beach" 3:24 3. "Birdland" 9:16 4. "Free Money" 3:47 5. "Kimberly" 4:26 6. "Break It Up" 4:05 7. "Land" (part one: "Horses" / part two: "Land of a Thousand Dances" / part three: "La Mer(de)") Smith (parts one and three) Chris Kenner (part two) Antoine Domino (part two) 9:36 8. "Elegie" 2:42 Band Patti Smith – vocals Jay Dee Daugherty – drums Lenny Kaye – lead guitar Ivan Král – guitar, bass Richard Sohl – piano John Cale – production Robert Mapplethorpe – photography Tom Verlaine – guitar on "Break It Up"
nää för irriterande röst
Classic New York style punk, put me in a better mood listening to it
Strong album - Gloria is great. Enjoyed the journey of Land. Can see why and how this was so influential.
Some interesting moments and ideas. The attitude is a very enjoyable fuck you… but also, no great songs.
Nice, Patti Smith. I haven't listened to a single second of her music, but I've seen this cover while poking around on the list. It's kind of cool. I like the slung-over jacket pose. There's nothing this music can be other than punk, right? I mean, she is wearing the pants and all. Here goes. Yup, punk. I was worried I was going to be wrong for a second after listening to that opening, but I was quickly proven right. This is early onset menopause music, I gotta be real with you. I am a true and honest respecter of women, but there is no easier way to signal that your womb is barren than to be a punk musician. In this album's defence, the instrumentation is more artsy and mild when compared to that of your traditional punk album, but come on. Women can't rock. It fucks up the vibe in a similar way to when women enter a space or hobby which is traditionally dominated by men. Again, I am a proud, card-carrying respecter of women, but what I mentioned is a universal truth bomb that we all need to accept if we're to advance as a species. Why am I gatekeeping a genre of music that I don't even like in the first place? Love of the game, baby. This wasn't my thing, if you couldn't tell. Smith doesn't carry herself all that well on these tracks and regularly devolves into senseless babbling as a result. I couldn't get into the songwriting, either. There aren't any good hooks in here, and the lyrics are verbose to where they lose all focus. I don't mind the instrumentals. The guitar riffs are decent, but there isn't anything in there which sticks out to me. A tepid listen overall. Book time. "Horses rewrote the rules for female pop stars and provided a new road map". A "...truly unique sound that influenced such artsy acts as the Talking Heads and R.E.M." A timeless work, and "...a completely realized piece of art, starting with the exquisitely honest cover portrait of Smith". Well-received by critics, but only had modest success on the charts. She is "...rock's premier punk poet". A lot of big claims with this one. Wikipedia says that this album is more avant-garde than its punk competition and blends punk with poetry. A "...seminal recording in the history of punk and later rock movements". I mean, yeah. All of these are good qualifiers. I cosign this inclusion.
Старушка не брила подмышки, но мы ей это простим
Just because someone is an incredible poet and a great mind, does not always mean they should make music..
parece ser algo mas melodico/pop, onda alanis morrisette, no le tengo mucha expectativa muy buen album la verdad, es como si adele cantara las canciones de pink floyd pero patti tiene una voz también con la rudeza de la vocalista de heart, me gustó mucho
Niekedy v polovici 80. rokov som ju počul prvý krát, hneď ma ohromila...
4/10 Catchy but not for me
Meh. Not for me. I’m not the audience.
I am going to be honest here, I had never listened to a Patti Smith album but I had read Just Kids, and that gave me the worat of impressions on her, how do people praise her??? . Ok, so I listened to the album and it is ...meh. The instrumental is good but her voice and interpretation does not help. Her fixation on death on the lyrics and her clear references on Rimbaud also make me feel like I am in a funky Portry reading. It is not bad, but it's not as great as they market her. Also, she is not punkthis is pop rock, she used so many good people on her band that it is hard to credit just on her her achievement (also she just got famous becsuse she tagged along with the famous guests in Chelsea Hotel). The song is OK, but I still think she is a horrible person. 3/5
Ok so I've always loved Patti Smith. Early punk rock with a female singer? I'm in. But most punk doesn't have this kind of songwriting. She was a brilliant lyricist. I think the lyrics are where this album really shines. And maybe it's simplicity - it was a band in a studio recording music and that's a great thing that is sorely missed these days of having like 25 different producers for each song on any given album. So much of the music I love wouldn't be the same if it weren't for this album. I don't think this album is quite up there for a 5/5 but it's a strong 4/5 for sure.
What a fun surprise. This album makes me want to buy a record player so I can listen on vinyl. I love that her voice isn’t “good” as much as passionate.
It's definitely interesting. Far more interesting than her later work in my opinion. Not something I'll be following up on, but it really has 1975 New York vibes.
Did not really like much of this
I can see why this album Is on this list, unlike many others in this 1001. However it’s not for me.
Not really my type.
horse girl
STANDOUTS: Gloria, Free Money, Land I don't have much to say about this, but it is a very lesbian album, so here's the transcript for Billy On The Street - Lesbian Lightning Round. "Okay guys now it's time for a special lightning round today I'm running around New York with a pack of wild lesbians. They're going to chase after people with me and help them answer questions. Let's go let's go lesbians Let's go. Sir, sir for a dollar who's sexier, Britney Spears or Kesha? Kesha. Kesha. What do you think lesbian? Kesha. What do you think? Kesha. Yes, here you go here you go correct let's go lesbians let's go. Sir, sir, sir for a dollar, sir for a dollar who's sexier, Britney Spears or Christina Aguilera? Britney Spears. What do you think lesbian? Britney Spears. What do you think? Christina. Oh, oh, what do you think? Christina. What do you think? Britney. Britney the answer is Britney yes here's your dollar yes let's go lesbians let's go here we go lesbians here we go lesbians come on. Miss, Miss for a dollar who's sexier Meryl Streep or Britney Spears? Britney Spears. What do you think lesbians? Britney Spears. What do you think? Uh, Meryl Streep. What do you think? Give me Streep. What? Give me Streep. Streep. What do you think? Streep. The answer is Meryl Streep let's go let's go lesbians. Oh my God lesbians, lesbians move out of my way. Oh miss, miss for a dollar who's sexier Adam Scott or Ronald Reagan? Ronald Reagan what do you think lesbian? Uh, Ronald Reagan. What do you think? Ronald Reagan. Adam Scott or Ronald Reagan? Scott. What do you think? Reagan. The answer is Adam Scott, you're wrong let's go let's go here we go rounding the corner with a bunch of lesbians here we are Manhattan can you handle it? Oh sir, sir for a dollar who's a better host Steve Harvey or Terry Gross? Harvey. What do you think lesbians? Steve Harvey. What do you think? Steve Harvey. What do you think? Steve Harvey. What do you think? Terry Gross. The answer is Steve Harvey here's a dollar let's go lesbians let's go let's go lesbians excuse me lesbians coming through watch out. Miss, Miss for a dollar who's better Emma Stone or Taylor Swift? Taylor Swift. What do you think lesbians. Taylor Swift. What do you think? Taylor Swift. What do you think? Oh the- the answer is Emma Stone let's go she's wrong these two Lesbos always wrong lesbians we're going to circle the corner lesbians move out of here I got lesbians coming through. Sir for a dollar who do you prefer Emma Stone or Taylor Swift or Anne Hathaway? Who is it? Anne Hathaway. What do you think lesbian? Anne Hathaway. What do you think lesbian? Emma Stone. Oh here comes slow lesbian look who just got here what do you think? Emma Stone. The answer is Anne Hathaway, yes you Inn take it take it let's go lesbians let's go oh lesbians Jews lesbians, lesbians Jews, careful lesbians and Jew lesbians and Jews hi Jews we're lesbians let's go. 7.5/10
I listened to this album a few times a couple of years ago as I read the book, Please Kill Me: The Uncensored Oral History of Punk by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain. Smith plays a huge part in that scene in New York City in the 1970s. Either as a muse, a fan, or an artist. For some crazy reason, I always disliked Patti Smith. I think I saw her perform once in her later years, and it just didn’t appeal to me. I think I did like Horses when I listened to it a couple of years back, but truthfully, I don’t remember. I like to listen to music when I read or study. I know, it’s weird. It blew my psychology professor’s mind when I told him. So, when I read Please Kill Me, or other books on a specific music genre or act, I listen to that music to kind of put me in that scene, so to speak. So, in addition to listening to Horses several times, I listened to everybody from that scene. Track 1 is Gloria: In Excelsis Deo, and I’m sure most of you have heard this somewhere. It’s kind of the song Smith is known for, well, that and Because the Night. It’s a part cover song of the Van Morrison written song performed by him and the band Them. The first part is all Smith, and the G-L-O-R-I–A is Morrison’s. It’s a great song. I never appreciated it until reading Please Kill Me. It’s like a controlled explosion or a slow-motion explosion. It builds and builds before exploding into G-L-O-R-I–A. “Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine.” Just a powerful lyric. She’s basically saying she owns her body and her soul and isn’t subject to what men think women should be. Track 2 is Redondo Beach, and it’s a bouncy little reggae song. The song is about a young girl killing herself by drowning after breaking up with her boyfriend. It’s a sad song, but has beautiful lyrics. You can see the movie play out in your head from Smith’s lyrics. She’s a poet. Track 3 is Birdland, and it’s a nine-minute improvised story/poem about a little boy who thinks his father is flying a UFO or something. Not my favorite track on the album. As I’ve said before, I’m much more of a riff or groove-oriented music listener. Lyrics are almost always last for me in enjoyment. This song is mostly lyrics, though there are some very cool, weird sounds being made on guitars in the middle section. I think it’s supposed to be the UFO. The producer of the album was John Cale of the Velvet Underground, which is why you have weird guitar sounds all over the album, I’d say. I just listened to Cale’s Paris 1919 and loved it, but it was said to be his most commercially sounding album. Cale was a big shaper of the music coming out of New York City in the 1970s. He was an elder to most of the young bands and artists. Track 4 is called Free Money, and it's a song about dreaming of becoming rich by winning the lottery, but never buying a ticket. The song was written to kind of show the almost desperation of some of the artists in that era, hoping to rise out of their poverty by hitting the lottery and becoming a famous rock star or artist. More importantly, the free money will supposedly put an end to all their troubles. Another powerful song. Track 5 is Kimberly, and it’s the first of what I would call an upbeat rock song. The lyrics are probably not upbeat, but musically, the song sounds like rock music from that era. It has a solid bass line, and an organ kind of holds everything together. There’s also some great rhythm guitar work throughout it. The song was dedicated to Smith’s younger sister, Kimberly. Track 6, Break It Up, comes in like a Queen song. How unexpected, but it sounds great. The guitar has that Brian May sound that only Queen possessed. It’s kind of a We Are the Champions for punks. Hmmm, the song appears to be about the spiritual liberation and resurrection of Jim Morrison, according to whatever AI Google uses. That’s weird. But it’s a banger of a song. Track 9 is a three-part punk opus called Land: Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances/La Mer(de). It’s very similar to Gloria as Smith just, seemingly, stream of consciousness, tells the story of Johnny and some horses and mixing in Land of a Thousand Dances. You know, the song the WWF wrestlers sang back in the 80s. I’m sure it’s pure poetic bliss. The song isn’t bad, but not my favorite on the album. It’s a little too artsy for me, dawg. Track 10 is Elegie, and it’s a song about rock legends who died young, especially Jimi Hendrix. It’s piano, bass, and guitar. It’s really a great song. Like many of her songs, Smith talks more than sings. It’s under three minutes long, but maybe the best song on the album. In the end, I do like this album, and I can appreciate how fresh and new it must have sounded in the disco era. The album was widely hailed by critics at the time. However, like most older albums that were the lead in the start of a new movement, it doesn’t pack the same punch it did in 1975. However, I think it’s good enough to be a must-listen, especially for poetry lovers. The album is almost a poetry reading with music under the poems.
Let me preface by saying that I adore Patti Smith as an artist and as a person. I've seen her live (amazing), have read a lot about her, and have read her books/poetry, and recognize that she's important in the making of DIY music and punk rock. I have tried but NEVER gotten into this album since I was 15. I give up. Not sure why it continues to be on lists like this other than the fact that it was racy and bold for its time (especially when it comes to production and its budget). It feels overblown at all the wrong moments and pretentious overall. Everything feels sloppy and half-assed, and the poetry is not among her finest. So, what's the story here? Is it like how people drool over "blank canvases" from famous artists and talk about how much of a statement they make? Maybe the fact that it gets a rise out of me still means that it works. But I'd like to never, ever listen to it again. 20-something years of trying is enough. Going back to my X-Ray Spex recordings for the time being!
Nope. Not so obnoxious as to warrant a 1; that is reserved for the truly horrible. But as much as I wanted to like this it was not meant to be. Too much narrative, disjointed singing with a less than pleasant voice. 2/5
I think this is incredibly cool, and that Patti Smith is incredibly cool. But I think I definitely need to spend more time with it. Let's get the easy stuff out of the way. Patti Smith is an incredibly cool woman with an incredibly cool aesthetic who was making like New York proto art-punk with the noise cellist (John Cale) from The Velvet Underground. This is a list of attributes that gets you pretty far with me. She was early enough to the game that she was still piecing punk together from constituent components. There's a focus on poetry and intricate songcraft and avant-garde influence that couples with more conventional punk touchstones here to create something that feels just as singular as the stuff from bands like The Stooges and The Velvets that came out a little earlier. I will admit, I haven't gotten fully to the bottom of it, but Patti Smith does end up somewhere a little different than those two bands. The least punk stuff on Horses ends up in a bunch of strange, occasionally sad little nooks. Redondo Beach is a *really* early incorporation of dub into punk, and Birdland is lengthy and fascinating. But my initial favorites are songs like Gloria: In Excelsis Deo, Free Money, Break It Up, Land, and Elegie. There are moments when these songs just *are* punk, but in a way I'm not sure anyone else has really duplicated. Horses kind of became a stepping stone on the way to the more generally accepted punk sound, so it feels more like a moment where it's components are in transcience than a settled sound. And so it never really got *fully* emulated. I will also say, that even on a first listen, these songs are *so* good. It really is the moment to moment simplicity combined with the intricate full pictures. It's also Patti Smith's lyrics (which I have *absolutely* underdiscussed) as well as her performances. It's also a very particular tension that runs through this album. Like the seasick intro on Elegie (my favorite of the less punk cuts). I can already tell that this is gonna grow on me like Dylan does. I *will* be back. It's undigested, and there are a couple songs I haven't figured out. But most of this is still just fantastic.
An album called Horses by someone named Patti. I was expecting lots of fiddles, maybe a Home on the Range cover. What a pleasant surprise this album was. Supposedly this influenced the nascent punk genre. I wish it had influenced in more, there isn't a simple power chord driven song in sight. Just a collection of great, mostly sparse, songs sung with feeling and played with intention.
Before: Patti Smith, Yay! She was a little ahead of my time. In 1975, I only knew about bands they played on the radio and they definately didn't play anything by her in the smallish southern US town I grew up in. In my late years I've tried to develop an appreciation of her music but have not been successful to date. Maybe this time around I will. As of this moment I have only one track from this album on my favorites of 1975 playlist. During: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo is pretty good. I did not add that to my 1975 list because part of it is a cover but on my second listen today I decided to add as I think her version is quite different and much better than Van Morrison's. Birdland is, um, interesting. During my second listen I decided to add that to my 1975 list as well. By the time we get half way through Free Money I'm getting kind of annoyed. Kimberly is just as annoying. For some reason I "liked" it in my app at some point, only god knows why. Still, I'm determined not to skip through anything. I mean it is the punk rock goddess herself, I am blessed to be listening to today. Break It Up continues to annoy me further but I'm a gonna stick with it. Next up is the one track from this album that I added to my best of 1975 list prior to today, Land: Horses / Land, Of A Thousand Dances / La Mer(de). As an aside, I usually listen my album of the day in the morning and I have a lot of stuff going on in the mornings so there are often frequent interruptions during my initial listen. So during one of these interruptions, a song by The New Eves pops into my head and I'm thinking about how similar that song is to what I've just been listening to and wondering, would we have The New Eves today if it weren't for Patti Smith? They are clearly influence by her work, which they themselves have confirmed. So back to Land: Horses / Land, Of A Thousand Dances / La Mer(de), this definately my favorite of the album. I'll rate it a 4, I think it's my favorite so far. 4 Gloria: In Excelsis Deo 3 Redondo Beach 4 Birdland 2 Free Money 2 Kimberly 2 Break It Up 4 Land: Horses / Land, Of A Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) 2 Elegie -------------------------------------------------------------- 2.9 AVERAGE After: 3 - my personal rating 5 - suitability for this list 5 - relevance ------------------------------ 4 - composite rating
I peeked at the wiki for run time and accidentally saw the genre, what a curveball. Horses by Patti Smith in the 70s is a punk album. It is a hard listen, not because I'm uncomfortable or the music is particularly upsetting or boring. It's got its own brand of energy that works well enough. The band sounds pretty good with what they have and though Patti Smith has a SUPER unusual singing style to me, it's not extremely jarring. I'm just not sure the parts come together here to make something that great. If Patti Smith began her career as a poet, moving to music because she found "the presentation of poetry wasn't vibrant enough" (per wikipedia), that means to me that the music is more of a venue for her poetry. That's... okay, I guess, but it kinda defeats the purpose of it being a composition in my eyes. Like, so much focus on the lyric but not on the rhythmic or melodic aspects of poetry. No melding with the music, almost. And again, at that point, why bother putting it to music? I feel like this was probably landmark for a lot of different people and acts, with the mid 70s being so soft/yacht rock-y and easy listening heavy. But aside from recognizing this album's place in punk music and its offshoots and liking a few things here and there about the album, it's not all that great to me.
Ehhhhhhh I’m not interested
I saw Patti Smith open for the Indigo Girls at Red Rocks years ago and it was hands down the worst live performance I've ever seen. I wasn't too familiar with her music so I've always wondered if she just had on off night. While that may have been the case, this album suggests she didn't have much to work with anyway.
It's not what I was expecting when I saw that the album was punk rock, but it matches, and it's a wonderful listen. Loved the piano, loved the spoken word. Thank you to all horses
I am quite amazed I have never listened to this album before. Apart from Because the Night, I know very little about Patti Smith. I ma not sure why, but I just never really explored her music. It is never too late. It is also so evident where PJ Harvey got her influences from. Gloria is an incredible opening track. Redondo Beach is a fantastic mix of rock, punk and reggae. I love the way Birdland just grows and grows and grows. It is fantastic. Free Money wraps up a near perfect Side A. Side B is maybe not quite as good as the first Side, but it is still damn good. Break it up and Land: Horses are both superb. Land:Horses is possibly my standout track. This is damn close to a 5. I think I want to own this record. 5 stars
I guess I can say I've heard of Patti Smith, but I am honestly not sure if I've ever listened to a single track of hers. That being said, her association with the CBGB-era was enough to pique my curiosity. It's a unique sound and not bad, but why all the praise for being a punk rock pioneer? It's not very punk, even compared to other stuff that was coming out at the time. I didn't love it, didn't hate it, but have no desire to ever return to it.
Not a bad album. I never listened to her much at the time because it wasn't my type of music.
I know this one is touted as one of the first (maybe the first) punk rock albums and has a stellar reputation. I can see why, great energy and songs throughout.
226/1089 i think this album was given to me at the wrong time. For some reason i just wasn’t really receptive to it/in the mood when i think it would otherwise be right up my street. There were parts that almost hooked me and i can appreciate it but I’ll have to revisit 65/100
It's got that fantastic mid seventies new York sound I love, but loses marks for white reggae
Heard it before. Patti is completely feral and I mean it as a compliment. And "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine" has to be one of the best album opening lines ever 4/5
Love Gloria and Horses.
*1975. American punk rock. *Starts out strong with a cover/reimagining of Van Morrison's band's "Gloria." (Not the same as the 80s Gloria, although it seems like there's some overlap to me...) *I thought I was really going to enjoy this - I really didn't. :/ RATING - 5/10
Odd one. Not my vibe, but I respect what I feel like is true intent and passion.
Feels like poetry being recited to a beat in some cases. The lyrics are pretty progressive and counter cultural. Overall, not super engaging but I can see the appeal for others
not my cup of tea
Amazing! I'm a massive pj harvey fan but I've never checked out Patti Smith. Who knew they were so similar. Also some great Dylan vibes here. Loved it
He Saw Horses 1001 Albums Generator 237 (2/27/2026) Here's an album I was excited to finally listen to. As a big fan of other bands from this New York punk scene (like Talking Heads and Television), Patti Smith's Horses is an album I've been aware of, but somehow, it has escaped me. I was surprised how prominent the piano is. I mean, is the epic Birdland even a punk song? It's more like a psychedelic piano rock song, and it's awesome. The other epic is the medley Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de), which starts out with an ambient soundscape with Patti losing her mind before it breaks into a cool punk song. Tom Verlaine does great guitar work on Break It Up. Also, Patti's voice is really interesting. I feel like later women in punk like Siouxsie and PJ Harvey owe a lot to her performance here. I think it generally works, although it was grating at points. Redondo Beach is a little bit silly. I know that reggae and punk have always had this surprising relationship, but I don't think this is the best example of it. Elegie is also a bit of a limp way to end the album. Besides that, Horses is a cool album. 4/5 probably. Favs: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo Birdland Break It Up Least Fav: Elegie
I’m probably more into the idea of Patti Smith than I am into her music in real life. The lyrics are interesting, and the music isn’t bad, but it doesn’t really appeal to my musical sensibilities. 6.5/10
Very good singing voice but I thought the music was mostly quite meandering and dull
You can see why it influenced so many people. I still don't like her voice.
Je veux aimer Patti Smith, je comprends que c'est un personnage mythique, et dont l'influence me touche directement à quelques connexions près... J'embarque pas.. Je vais me réessayer à écouter cet album (grand album semble-t-il) quand je serai plus disposée à l'entendre
This one's just not for me, which is unfortunate because she looks so cool on the album cover. I listened to it a while back, and I'm still just not understanding it.
It was ok, but not sure i’d listen to again
Nope, not for me!
🫤 Two solid jams but the rest is just meh
Large animals that typically live on a farm, and can be used for sports, and transportation.
на вигляд схожа на шарлотту генсбур. нє, ну прикольно
Good, a lot more spoken word than I expected. Not my cup of tea but grand
The live version is much better IMO. Not the biggest fan of her vocal style but I get why people are and what it meant at that point in history. Cool shit
love this
Fijn album, mooie stem. Zou ik zeker nog eens luisteren
that’s absolutely right ms. smith. I love this shit
she really shmeared her pussy on this album
To moany-squeaky. This is probably what goofy’s wife (RIP) sounded like while getting it on.
Couple of nice songs. Kind of interesting album, but not anything crazy
Not my mood again, Patti's voice is cool i guess. Very long songs (Birdland is 9+ minutes), i don't really listen to the lyrics, music is kinda boring and repetitive, a lot of choruses. Sometimes sounds like VU, but not the kind i like. Didn't listen attentively, not for me.
muy buen album desde lo vocal en especial, eso me gusto mucho y me parecio muy interesante para la epoca, todo es genial pero destaco la voz de patti, dos o tres temas no resonaron mucho conmigo pero el resto si lo hicieron. 8/10.
After 50 years, this album still holds up.
Hard to ignore Velvet Underground influence and despite its importance to the '70s NY scene, was a good 1 time listen to appreciate music history, but too much of the same.
Classic Gold
This is good. One to play again.
If this isn’t a 5, what is? The teeth of time have done nothing (and by that I mean: absolutely nothing) to this album. It's an undeniable, an unf*#%withable classic! Sublime poetry, electrifying perfomances, standout songwriting (plus, the cover portrait is nothing short of iconic). These songs hold up effortlessly today - and they’ll still hold up 50 years from now. This album is such a towering achievement that it overshadowed many of Patti Smith’s later albums. If you create something this profound, this singular, this lasting… well, that’s just the way it goes… I guess.
This album is a great example of why albums are great. None of these songs individually stand out to me, but as a whole, it’s pretty great. Can see why it’s so influential.
"Jesus died for somebodies sins, but not mine" - what an opening line! Started off strong, her mumbling in Birdland was not for me Favs: Gloria, Redondo Beach, Kimberly
239/1001 :: Patti Smith - Horses Heard before? ✅ Would I revisit? ✅ Rating: 8 Listen before you die: Yes A true poet and artist Patti Smith and this album is prefect for this list. Because people should listen to this before they die. This album is not the best album I’ve ever heard but it’s always interesting and a lot of these songs are not only challenging but very good. Gloria & Free Money specifically are both awesome. The only issue here is the spoken word songs are too long for an uninvested listener. They’re trapped on an album almost 50 years after their inception. I say trapped because they weren’t created to be experienced this way and I think that works against them. They were supposed to performed live in a shitty New York City bar where the drinks are flowing, the cigarettes burn and Patti is dipping in and out free form poetic passages. It takes a special someone to pull this off and that’s Patti’s magnetism. Lastly, everyone should also read Just Kids. Masterpiece.
I enjoyed the tracks more when she wasn't singing.
i didn't think it was anything special
I went into this album with a pessimistic attitude. Some years ago I had read her memoir “Just Kids” and found it annoying. Or at least it didn’t inspire me to really give her music a listen. But I ended up really liking this album and it’s proto punk vibe.
Põnev ja kuidagi palju iseloomu näitav plaat. Siin ühtegi sellist bänger hitti pole, aga pika kuulamise peale ei tüdinenud sellest stiilist. Minu jaoks just täitsa piisavalt kiiksu, aga mitte midagi erilist. 3.4/5
Strange songs & strange intonation.
Bob Dylan if he was a scene kid who discovered garage rock. After a 2nd and 3rd run through, I’m starting to get it more. The lyrics are deep, it’s raw as fuck and the vocals are jarring at times, but that’s the point. It gives me similar vibes to Dylan. Many people including myself are quick to write someone off because they don’t sound like you’d expect or want, but I think I see it now. So much influence. Free Money gives me 90’s alt vibes. Redondo Beat gives me Police and Cars Vibes. Favs: Free Money, Redondo Beat
I think this is a classic and what is more punk than female rebellion if we are being honest. Every song sounds like it had defined an era. I literally hear so much the strokes, blondie, Pink Floyd, the Ramones,I even hear sultans of swing. I can just feel the oozing of artist who heard this record and its effect back then and made changes. I think for that alone and presentation it’s a 9 for sure The 3 song run from Gloria to Birdland wow Redondo beach is obviously so reggae but it’s also so strokes. Also also birdland singing is so artistic and really showcases the range even from the droning guitar I will revisit this one again
Sometimes, the art kids are right.
That's the way it's gonna be, little darlin' We'll be riding on the horses, yeah, yeah. No? Shame!
She's cool, but not digging the music. 2.5
4.0/10
I bet this absolutely raged at CBGBs back in the day.
This is incredible. I swear I nearly transcended during Birdland. So much to appreciate about this one—songwriting with a lot of flair and exciting buildup, extremely tight performances, and the most badass aura in the vocal delivery. Despite all the years I’ve been aware of Patti Smith, I never listened. This album is a reminder that going through this project is worth it.
Muy legendarion será, pero no es para mí.
spennende!! // okei jeg har fullstendig misforstått. jeg trodde patti smith var easy listening. her tok jeg helt feil. jeg tror jeg må høre/lese bedre en annen gang. birdland og free money feks var helt grusom å høre gjennom nå.
Not for me.
A bit embarrassed that I’ve never listened to this before. Some great songs, some ok ones but overall worth the hype and I should’ve listened much much sooner.
Not a big fan. Her songs made very little sense to me, not sure why this is on the list.
It all became mumble jumble
Fine. Lyrics were kinda weird and all over the place. Thought she sounded vaguely like Bjork in parts.
reminds me of a female Leonard Cohen. too much of the talk/sing style, repetitive lyrics, and don't care for her vocals.
I love this record! I'd been listening to it just a couple of weeks before while reading Bread of Angels. Is it perfect? Of course not.
Hot damn, this is a powerful album from the powerful persona of Patti Smith herself. Smith might not be the best songwriter I've ever heard, but she is unique and stylish. Her greatest talent lies in her ability to render her lyrics masterfully in the songs themselves. She is always raw and passionate, maybe a little unhinged, but always authentic. I also love the production of this record. Apparently, Smith herself sought out John Cale, formerly of The Velvet Underground, to produce. That was a great decision, as the album's recording fits perfectly with Smith's vocal tone. She is always up front in the mix, but the band chugs along right behind her. The arrangements are another strong point. They are sparse and driving, another fitting complement to Smith herself. Cale didn't shy away from using multitrack magic, but it was always used to enhance the immediacy of the music. I would love to see some of this intelligent rawness return to music production. This album proves that a hi-fi record can still retain the energy of a lo-fi album. I'm not familiar enough with this album to know if I'll listen to it in heavy rotation, but it grabbed me from the first line and never let go. Five stars.
I really like this and it has clearly been so influential (I hear PJ Harvey, I hear Nick Cave and others) but something stops me giving this a 5. I think it’s that it veers into the self indulgent at times. Would have been great to see this live though
Didn't like a single song
This was pretty good. Patti sometimes loses me when she goes full on beat-poet, but maybe that's just because I wasn't paying much attention to the lyrics. I could definitely see this one getting better with more listens. 3.5/5
Somehow never listened to this. I really liked it. It seems that Nick Cave really borrowed a lot of these sounds / singing style. Good job Patti 4/5
Lots to enjoy, Kate Bush meets Leonard Cohen. But maybe a little clinical at times?
Enjoyed it but probably won't go back to it.
A few more listens and this could be a 4 star!
Loved the vibes and lyricism but found the instrumentals quite bland. Gloria was the easy highlight
The songs on this are okay. Nothing particularly special. Seems a little bit self-indulgent and like it wasn't finished being written before they decided to record. The mix is kinda tinny, thin, and very uneven sounding in a lot of moments. Definitely far from my favorite of these albums. Break It Up is maybe the best of these songs. 2.1/5
Timelessly hot album cover? Check. Fascinating autobiography? Check! Excellent start to an album? Are my sins my own? Check! Have I spent probably 20 years trying to *like* this album? CHECK! CHECK! maybe someday.
multiple 9 minute tracks that made me want to get up and do something else, i did not enjoy HORSES by patti smith
I'll give her the round up, but truly, this was a 2.5. Birdland got very...spirited and I probably spoiled myself a little by reading about the album before listening because it's described so much as this like proto punk sorta poetry thing and I found it to be meandering and squonky?
An album that I’m SUPPOSE to love, but I don't. I appreciate Patti Smith and her lyrics and voice and that she was groundbreaking in the punk scene, so I feel like I must give it a 3, but all I really want to hear from her is Because the Night and Dancing Barefoot.
Слушал и думал о Джиме Моррисоне и всяком (всяких) прочем (прочих).
I actually used to hate this album but I really love it now. Could be a 5. Just real honest creative expression, feels way bigger than just a lil post-punk band. Ughhh 4 or 5 or 4 or 5… it is REALLY good I’m gonna give it a
#266/1001. This one I picked from my recird shelf, a cheap and crackly copy, but somehow it fits. Perhaps she is the main reason punk broke out in NY. Or perhaps she just continued where the velvets went too pop. Or perhaps let's just look at the back cover: compacted awareness .. gems flattening .. long streams of resin tools .. kool system of destine wax sculpt..drums tongue and waves slapping .. the feel of horses long before horses enter the scene .. molten tar stud dead w/bones and glass and the teeth of women ... veins filled w/existance .. beyond race gender baptism mathmatics politricks ... assassinating rythum .. c-rude transending .. soul-ar energy in the shape of a laughing pack of scarabs dressed in coats of milk armour..grace greased w/merc and henna ... hair wires .. neither the desire nor the ability to stop i plop on the bed pink electric immediate some human light bulb these bands around my neck should reveal what state i'm in .. only history (gentle rocking mona lisa) seals .. only histoire is responsible for the ultimate cannonizing .. as for me i am truly totally ready to go ... sonic klein man its me my shape burnt in the sky its me the memoire of me racing thru the eye of the mer thru the eye of the sea thru the arm of the needle merging and jacking new filaments new risks etched forever in a cold system of wax .. horses groping for a sign for a breath ... charms. sweet angels - you have made me no longer afraid of death.
I feel like I would've liked it better if I liked her voice but I just can't get into it
One of the most famous artists that I've never listened to. Didn't miss much. Lyrics are great, vocals are hard to listen to.
This may be the first album I rate less than a 3... as the first 3 tracks have done nothing for me at all. Especially "Birdland", I've never understood this "raw vocal style"; it just sounds like tone-deaf ranting. The lyrics themselves are smart and relatable though. "Kimberley" was just as unenjoyable for the same reasons. Heck, the instruments are great, such as the smooth bass and the insane drum roll on "Free Money". The problem is Smith and her - damn I feel bad for saying this - "singing". It's hard to even appreciate the instrumentals when she grates the ears so badly over the top of it. Then... there's "Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer (De)". What is going on here? So she can sing!? So it can sound like something enjoyable? This track stands starkly against the rest as testament that there is more to Smith than the wailing, telling a story with peaks and troughs reflected perfectly in the monologue and song switching throughout. "Elegie" is similarly evidence of Smith actually having a singing voice and easily became my favourite song on the album, with almost Floyd-like guitars and Smith's voice being genuinely beautiful and haunting over the bassline. It will be interesting to hear more Smith to see if anything else exists like Land: Horses and Elegie.
canon!
What can you say? Patti Smith is pretty good.
wasn’t feeling this yst, got through one track before quitin on it. this one might be on me folks
Technically, I should love this album. It just doesn't do enough to catch my attention
I read about how Patti Smith was sort of the Godmother of punk. I would not doubt that is true, but I was delighted when this album was over.
Hmmmm. I dunno. Certainly didn’t hate it. But it felt a little too pretentious for me. Like I’ve said with a lot of other punk adjacent stuff, I’m sure this would’ve done a lot more for me back in the 70s, but I did like some of the songwriting and I think smith has a very fun voice. But some of this kinda felt like slam poetry over rock riffs. All around meh?
Just an absolute gem.
A record so original I feel most are afraid to take inspiration from it for fear that they might seem tone deaf in the attempt. Great lyrics and overall melody.
I'm a big fan of a lot of the songs on this album and Patti Smith - however I can't say that I had listened to the whole album as a whole before and it did become a little much for me, I prefer the songs in little doses rather than a whole hour of it. I wanted to switch gears to something different a couple of times.
Good? I guess? Fine?
Very imaginative, upfront punk vibe, I can feel how it would inspire generations to come. I'd need a few more listens to really set in.
Liked the energy in this one.
Favorite track(s): Gloria, Birdland, Free Money, Land Did this album invent rock? No. Does it sometimes feel like it did? Yeah. Heard before Previous rating: 8/10
I love this slightly controlled chaos! 4/5
I love this album! It feels like a revelation and one I will definitely be listening to again and exploring more of. Patti Smith has such an awesome voice and such a wonderful way of playing with it. This album feels years ahead of its’ time.
Smith was one of handful of New York musicians trying to create a new form of rock and roll in the early 70s but when the resulting aesthetic consists of hypertheatrical poetry readings over cruddy garage rock backing, it's pretty much dead on arrival.
A classic
Enjoyed some songs. Standout songs: Gloria:In Excelsis Deo Free Money Land: Horses/Land of a thousand dances/la mer(de)
This album is outstanding and has had a significant impact on both the punk movement and literature as a whole.
High concept and evocative lyrics. The instrumentation is more of a backdrop for the poetry, though.
8/10 I have to admit I probably missed a lot of details and I need another listen, but the songwriting is consistently great and I loved that opener a lot.
Epic artist. Loved this album.
not my cup of tea but great dynamics and sound
It had been a while since I last listened to Horses, but damn this album still hits hard. Gloria is a fantastic opener and it really doesn't dip after that. On this listen I found myself enjoying some of the longer cuts (especially Birdland) a lot more.
Pretty good! I've heard "Because the Night" before but not this album. I liked it, grungy and powerful.
2.5/10
Seminal certainly. Didn’t really do it for me
I've heard this previously but re-visiting this, I found myself enjoying it so much more (I already enjoyed it). Gloria is such a great opener, and some of the piano-driven tracks make this wonderfully enjoyable. Free Money is also a standout for me.
I can almost smell the velvet underground inspiration I thought I was going to like the album a lot more than I did after the first song, I actually enjoyed that one a lot. It just kinda deteriorated a bit from there. Will absolutely give Patti credit for her vocals, there’s so much talent there; they fit great on more upbeat songs and slower more melodious sounds. I just don’t think anything’s very catchy after the first couple songs, and I didn’t resonate with the lyrics all that much. I can 100% picture the person that would love this album and have it as one of the greatest of all time, it just ain’t me
Didn't leave a single impression on me
Female proto punk, good sound, big on historical significance. Saw the 50th anniversary tour stop in Chicago, it was better live (with a 78 year old Patti Smith) than the studio version. I remember first listen didn't grab me, but 2nd and 3rd did. Probably favorite thing was Gloria (1st track) making a second appearance in Elegie (last song) as a kind of reprise. 3 1/2, but 3 for our purposes here.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard a better opening to an album. The first song got me so excited that I was really disappointed by every song after that. This album gets a 3 mainly for how amazing that first song was, the buildup in it was just phenomenal. I don’t really care about the rest of the album in all honesty.
There's a lot that could be said about this album, and the impact that it has on music as a whole. I mean she basically invented punk rock, new wave, and probably poetry as well... Smith’s debut album Horses is placed in the genre of punk rock, but somehow I feel that punk is kind of inaccurate. She certainly doesn’t sound like what punk became. It may be that ‘punk’ is simply a term used for music by artists who are determined to renounce conventional notions of ordered beauty. Adopting a minimalist, bratty, antiestablishment mindset. I don’t know, but to put Patti Smith in the same genre as the Sex Pistols and the Stooges feels criminal. Admittedly, I spent a good chunk of my listening time with this album deciding if I liked or not. I was a bit mixed on Patti’s voice and couldn’t tell if it was annoying or not. It did eventually grow on me. Lyrically, the songs were hit or miss. While I enjoyed something like Kimberly, Birdland was a little underwhelming. Honestly, most of the album felt like it was for a specific group of people. But most of the songs were enjoyable, despite not fully understanding the songs. Did I need to listen to this before I die? The impact of this album alone, makes it a definitely.
Deliciously half-sung half-spoken declamatory beatnik-like performance by Patti Smith with great, creative art-rock instrumentation built around it. There's this barely contained anger on the verge of exploding that keeps you holding your breath. Such a great album.
🥇redondo beach 🥈kimberly
My first time listening to this album even though I know it has influenced countless artists. I can see why that is because it is pretty damn great. I regret not listening to it sooner. The opener is a scorcher. Favorites: Gloria, Free Money Would I listen to it again: Yes
Speaking of epic debut albums (re: The Stone Roses and Pearl Jam, as I've already spoken about), here's another record to add to that list. Patti Smith. Fearless poet, rebellious rocker, all-round genius of a human being. With 'Horses', her deep, often autobiographical musings ('Redondo Beach', 'Kimberly', 'Free Money') join forces with tributes to fallen public figures (notably Wilhelm Reich on 'Birdland', Jim Morrison on 'Break It Up' and Jimi Hendrix on 'Elegie') and two sprawling odes to 1960s rock ('Gloria', 'Land') to form an absolute behemoth of a record that changed the way people approached songwriting. Patti Smith is, without a doubt, one of the finest lyricists in music history, and she's a pretty bloody influential vocalist too. While not conventionally pitch-perfect, her edgy attitude and intense live performances turned her into one of the most important influences on punk rock, alternative rock, gothic rock, grunge; you name it. It's pretty rare to set your legacy with your debut record, but 'Horses' is that impressive a record that Patti Smith could've quite easily ridden its coattails for the rest of her career. But she didn't, she kept creating and only continued to deepen her importance to popular music, not only as a solo artist, but with the Patti Smith Group too. As far as New York punk acts are concerned, she's just as, if not more important than The Ramones and Blondie. 'Horses' blew me away when I first heard it and it still blows me away to this day. A truly, truly remarkable listen. Best songs: The whole album
I have to say, I was a little let down. I hyped it up too much in my head. Patti isn't much of a singer, but that's ok. The musicianship is very punky/new wavey and leaves something to be desired. The songwriting itself I find a little uninspired, but overall, it's ok. The only overwhelmingly positive thing I can say is the lyricism, because Patti is a true poet and you can feel every single of her words. All in all, a 3.5/5
very cool
Required.
Yeah sorry- wasn’t good back then, hasn’t gotten better with age. Punk Rock generally sucks, and I suppose this is marginally better than your average Punk, but at its best it’s just tolerable, and at its worst it’s grating and annoying and makes you want to scream. Plus one for Patti’s voice which she wasted on Punk Rock.
Personal and defiant!
I understand that I’m supposed to get it, but I really don’t.
a collection of the different sounds people make when they stub their toe
Didn't do anything for me.
Fine music, but not my thing.
really different, 6.2, very fiona apple, portishead, bjork, joni mitchell, hole coded.. strong for the time period!!
She was kind of ahead of her time, but it didn't really do anything for me.
I did like how well defined the album felt whilst being experimental (wow almost what art rock kinda is). Didnt speak to me tho
For me, not a fan of art rock experimental albums. But when I’m tired and don’t really care about anything. It just works better but not like great cause I’m not like a fan of it. There was a steady beat, her vocals were alright. Not to bad.
Never heard of album or singer. Starts off so good. Gloria is a great song all around. It’s a roc track with very unique vocals. I enjoyed it a lot. Rendondo beach is good not great. Good songwriting. Not as much of a fan of bird land but I appreciate the change of pace. Patti has a great voice. Good piano on this one. It just keeps going. And keeps getting better. Piano is so good on free money again. Love how it starts slow and turns into a real rock banger. Really like this song. Kimberly is a little goofy but not horrible. I like the organ and bass. Break it up is fine. A lot of the same good elements from the rest of the album, this one just doesn’t hit as hard for some reason. I will say I think it has the best guitar on any song. Land is a banger. What a background track. Vocals work so well over it. Élégie is ok. Good change of pace from land for sure but not my fave. It’s a good album overall and blew away my expectations. 3.9 stars.
This didn't do anything for me. Free Money was alright I guess.
This album seems pretty underrated on this site. Sitting around a 3.3 despite being ahead of its time and one of the coolest albums ever
I know this album is iconic but it's never really clicked for me. Not bad, but also not great in my opinion. Favorite track: Free Money
Bra
Listening to Patti Smith felt like wandering through a chaotic city, each person passing by heightening my annoyance until the inevitable breaking point. The experience was a visceral anxiety attack—a blend of frantic rhythmic drums and chaotic oooo's, uueeerr's, and tooo's that mirrored my inner turmoil. Did I enjoy it? Probably not. But as a punk lover, I couldn't help but respect the raw honesty and emotional depth. This album captures the frustration and chaos of modern life, my life, making it a wild ride worth experiencing.
Incredible voice
Great 70s album
Didn’t like, can see the appeal, esp at the time. Historically significant, kind of drove me crazy. But def made Fiona Apple possible in the ny zeitgeist
Getting tired of all the dad rock.
Very reminiscent of Velvet Underground. Some interesting songs and good lyrics.
3.9/5 godmother of punk
We have more critically acclaimed poetic people releasing music! I straddle this line between obsessively loving the output of extremely ar(u)tistic people and believing them to be pretentious dorks, feebly pawing at the just out of reach mobile of praise from other nerds in their echoing sphere of influence. I don't know exactly what it is that tips the scales. I think I have a pretty good idea of when people are creating something that they themselves enjoy, or when somebody is attempting to hit the requisite notes that indicate creativity to simpletons. Perhaps I'm all wrong, and it is I who is the simpleton and I just drool and mash my keyboard. No matter. This is all opinion and subjectivity at the end of the day, and as dusk dawns on this meandering, drivel-laden paragraph, I end up sitting firmly on the proverbial fence. Horrible singing and obnoxious music darkens what is a palpable poetic spirit. Poetry that really doesn't do all that much for me. It's not a wholly unlikeable darkness, but it still makes it hard to see.. I'm gonna give this a deserved 2 stars (uniqueness only) and power scoot outta here. Where did I put that Birdland receipt? My new budgie is uhh "broken." 2 HIGHLIGHTS: Birdland
Didn’t understand the hype around this one. Sounded like nonsense and noise
Very solid experimental. 5/5
Excellent album. Punk vocals and attitude meet poetic lyrics and avant-garde songwriting with a rock-ish sound. It’s a lethal stew.
This cover is what I aspire to look like. The album itself is pretty good: I am not 100% how I feel about it. Sometimes I love it and sometimes I think it's, ya know, all right. But Patti Smith is rad.
A great cross between art rock and the then nascent punk rock movement. "Gloria" is probably one of the strongest cover songs and album openers of 1970s rock. 8.5/10