Reviews (page 5 of 13)
Highlights: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo, Free Money, Break It Up Lowlights: Birdland It's just slam poetry set to music. Birdland definitely made me think I was going to hate everything going forward but most of the album was enjoyable. I kept thinking this is something you could hear in like a low budget movie in the 80s or 90s because they didn't have money to license a major artist.
Let's start off by saying I respect this album and everything Patti Smith stands for. That being said, there's very little I find worthwhile on this. Gloria is a great punk rocker, but the rest doesn't quite find that level of fire. The poetry is good, but in an album setting it feels pretentious and forced. The rest is generic garage rock in a style that grinds my ears.
she has better songs
Funky wunky
not for me
Une incontournable.
Il y a beaucoup de Patti en musique des fois je me perds. Je pense c'est la première fois j'écoute cette Patti. La 2e écoute a été plus fructueuse, j'aime l'énergie un peu free et la voix écorchée. 3e auteure compositrice interprète cette semaine, et dans des styles pas mal différents, mais toutes très talentueuses, ça rock!
C’est bon mais pas complètement convaincu! La première chanson etait incroyable avec un bon crescendo. Ensuite c’est beaucoup de la chanson a texte, il faudra que j’y revienne et porte plus attention
Actually really good, would never have tried this otherwise Will I listen to again: 100%
It’s fine
Remarkably famous album that I've never listened to before, and I'm so glad this project got me to do so. Not a perfect album, but I see why it is so loved and so important. Lots of reviews decrying this as "not punk", but there are obviously shared aesthetics and values to the more "traditional" punk music - this album is very obviously a key block in the foundation of the DIY movement of the 70s that had such a profound impact on music and well beyond.
Never really paid much attention to Patti Smith but knew she was considered a lauded songwriter. So far it's much more upbeat than I expected. Good stuff, glad to finally hear one of her albums. I'm guessing in 1975 this must have blown people's minds, very intricate and visual lyrics.
I don't love the vocals but I love the mood it sets and the accompanying instrumentation. I've never heard anything quite like this. I don't know if that is a good thing or not.. but I did put it on for another listen. Birdland sounds like a Grateful Dead jam set to some snazzy poetry. OK on that second listen I've come to appreciate the vocals.
langweilig
Didn’t like it very much
Awesome!!!
What a sweeping album. Her voice is like it’s from another planet and I found myself turning over the lyrics in my head.
1: Kimberly 2: Land: Horses/ Land of a Thousand Dances/ La Mer(de) 3: Gloria: In Exelsis Deo
I get it but its not for me Yeah not for me
Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine
This is meant to be punk? I don't know, sounded like pretty generic rock to me.
1. gloria - 0 2. beach - 1 3. bird - 0 4. money -0 5. kimberly - 6. break - 0 7. land -1 8. elegie - 1
Would not buy
This was ok. Patti Smith gets a lot of love and I’m sure it’s well deserved, but listening to this album without doing any other research I thought it was just ok.
Yeah, early punk! Not a fan of the poems but the music is cool.
I’m admire this album and Patti Smith a lot. Incredibly important to the history of punk and everything after. Just not my favourite listen.
New to me and will definitely spin again
дуже poetic, я б сказала цей альбом serves better as an artwork than a thing you would listen on a everyday basis, але енівей love those punk vibes
Gibt mir nichts
I really liked her memoir but her music? It’s aight.
oh very very good
Nice
Temp
*began laughing hysterically* *combusted on spot* *the last segment played backward with me returning back to my prior state* oh shit. here we go. so, horses is significant for me. a really solid album. but its story for me actually started last winter when my inner critic told me, "your hair looks so messy and you're serving patti smith on the horses album cover, gurl." i sighed and wrote the following review over the summer after straightening my hair. its really freeform rambling nonsense so please beware. “OK, so please tell me how i should style your hair.” the barber asked me. “just make it less patti smith and more kurt cobain, although i respect them both. I mean: make it less fluffy and more flat.” “What?” She failed to understand. “Maybe I’d like a straight permed bob, please.” A week after leaving from the barbers, I, with my shortened hime cut, went abroad the plane to New York and was scrolling through the entertainment system. “Horses” was there but without many songs, because of copyright. So I just postponed my plan of listening to it. Ha-ha. About two weeks later, Horses strikes again because I need to wash my hair and wait until it dried without a hair dryer in my hand. And here I was sitting in my dorm in an east coast university during my summer program, thinking whether I should go to the bathroom for a nice little wash. And I picked up my pajama and my shampoo and my towel and went to the bathroom. When I finally decide to put on the album, it’s half past 8. I’m outside with my shortened hime cut slowly drying. “Not my fault that the world became terrible and people lost their rights. or should I say… advocates died for somebody’s future but not mine.” I let out a slightly ironic snicker as “Gloria” began to play. Who cares about rebellion when there's good old homoeroticism? look out cause here’s the feral child. Look at how she transformed into the lover of Gloria. Look out for the homoerotic narrative. Look at how she spelled her name. Come on, spell it out! G-L-O-R-I-A, spell it since spelling is indeed fun! I warbled self-referential meme under the setting sun in front of fashionable girls waking around, a beautiful autistic wallflower that doesn’t care about anything else. Sadly halfway through Redondo Beach I need to go back inside due to the sky getting dark. That song is shit anyway. Back in the little room. I blasted my head open with Birdland. But thousand year later it stopped and changed track. and I swayed with the piano riff. As life blood floods from the sky in 7/4 time. Capitalism is serious and I don’t hate it. But I’m just so being trapped in cringe culture I lost every chance to do it all because I..I just can’t make the world go around. life sucks and there’s no reason. it’s just a cringe issue or maybe, if i get rid of all these thoughts everything will resume. If i’m not cringe I can buy everything like its just a vinyl record to me, one i really enjoy and love in my little brain. new cars I mean caviar and a five star daydream and most importantly a jazzmaster and wank it until it weeps, since its all worthless right now. Nothing is worth fighting for until we load up on drugs and build a little empire upon some crazy garbage called the blood of the deranged upper class and reestablish a better capitalism with nobody getting to own more than ten million and less than ten thousand and again and again and again redistributing everything owned until it finally become socialism and then communism, but USSR told us that when we meet the new boss it will be the same as the old boss so was everything worth fighting for? I don’t know. And every night before I go to sleep I saw the world being driven around with these green and red beautiful bills and sparkling coins I dream about consumerism and how it will make me love my life so abundant as it is a dream more happiness than ever before as we hunt for eternal happiness as next moment is probably when we'll die as the sensation of investment is as crispy as a bite of an apple like all those white doves we fled into the sky with dreams and hopes but still outrunning bills and guilt of being the worst like nothing is ever a reality like we were meant to live in dreams and sleep in reality. So when I sleep I put my head on the fluff look at everything I ever wanted and I drifted into unconsciousness don’t know how to feel it is so shallow oh it’s so shallow as the world turns loveless it spins and spins like what it once was and will be the same as it ever was and what once was. i believe that I really need a better weapon to slay all the dragons the music is as warm as a heavy blanket hazy as every other dreams so if i play it i could make all dream become reality i suppose so tell me how to get rid of all these problems is it due to cringe or is it due to financial crisis but the radio dropped dead. hallelujah. Money makes the world go round and I am loving it. A week later the fight resumed as I finally bothered to wash my hair but also disturbed due to extracurricular activities. Side Two. Kimberley was underwhelming until I realized that it’s literally a mirror that I stands in front and saw me and Miss L. Her eyes sparks like Vega the star and we stood together as the storm unleashes and the world collapses, we stayed for tomorrow and what else? Imaginary things often give us a better future to live in. Break it Up is truly underwhelming. So I took a rest. A week later i resumed the game, washed my hair, and as it's drying in the wind, i hit play on the supposed most overwhelming track on the album: Land. I was a listener at first. but it starts like a raindrop and forces me into a sudden flood, taking me swiftly to the land of 1000 dances where its just a simple big party moving all my hot steps. the hot steps dropped cold, as a drop of water in a creaking black pipe flowing under the shared history of all things over it. there's a dancehall, in a city, in a metaphysical country where we shared music and dance all night. she's there and i'm there, life's there. life is a dancehall, come and throw your troubles away-- they used to say. so real. performance is the ultimate goal of the human life, and in the beat in the melody we united in harmony. suddenly the dancehall's door blasted open and out came a flood and even though the floods pushed people died but it still can't keep Johnny down. twisting through the towns until we falling down the pale white at the platonic idealistic land upon toward the bright horses in the distances, and toward there we disintergrate in all the mighty glory of songs, as another children was born into the world whenever the music plays, a pulse that underlines all of mankind through every lock of hair through every end of the blood veins through the cord through the song and life is no party and no disco but we are one when we dances to the song as it never ends, our hair flying in the wind. Elegie ended and my hair dried. at least it dried, i mean, seems like that there's a long long rope ties me to the past, as the beat goes on. it's not a comedic device. its something that i really think about a lot, how patti connects and pays tribute to things that influenced her, like the famous poets and the garage rock/pop standards. this album is very good, better than what i had expected but im not sure if this is a joke or not. what starts with me complaining about my puffy hair leads to me deciding to listen to Horses and my three-liner mutated into such a monster while my original 3.5 also transformed into the 5 that you all see here. i am in awe of the human mind. 5/5 post script: why does this arrive on a day which i need to wash my hair before it got too greasy, since horses is my bathing album due to the review above.
Honestly, the only thing that is interesting about this album is the choice of the album cover. A classic that conveys many subtexts based upon the historical events of the U.S. in the early 1970s. Beyond that, this album seems less punk, and more like guitar and piano bar era Bette Midler stuff. Not that there is anything wrong with that, but while this album may have been earth shaking in 1975, it seems fairly tedious these days. More poetry performance art that hopes to pass itself off as music than actual music. You can hear Bob Dylan and The Velvet Underground inspirations all over this record. Unfortunately, I am not a fan of either. Thankfully Patti Smith and colleagues spared me the squawking harmonica. HORSES is one of those albums that we are supposed to enjoy, but I never have. I prefer Tori Amos and Kate Bush albums to Patti Smith records. I suppose that the argument could be made maybe there wouldn't have been the Tori Amos' and Kate Bush's of the world without Patti Smith tweaking the world's ears with albums like HORSES, but to me it just feels like undercooked ideas that are not quite ready yet or too intentionally non-sequitur for my tastes. I need music with more hooks, pleasure, and optimism. Just realized John Cale produced this. That tracks, as I've found over the years that I don't most of the things of his I've heard, whether they were with The Velvet Underground or his solo work. 2 stars it is for the potential cultural cache it may have carried in the 70s.
“Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine” No notes
Pony ...
Would never have found by myself, but would be cool on vinyl
I love the opening song which is the best version of Gloria IMO. Horses is another poetic masterpiece on the punk vein. Patti definitely set the tone for women on the punk rock poetry music form.
Just kind of boring.
Really sexy and dark. She's like if Joni Mitchell had a hot evil twin. I'm a sugar not spice girlie so it wasnt PERFECT for me, but I had a lot of fun listening.
Gives Maureen/Pheobe Buffett vibes.
Meh . Alot of the songs felt like they dragged on forever but likeit wasnt horrible
Rough on the ol ears
Abrasive x pure noise tbf, no redeeming features at all
Jag gillar Patti som personlighet, kanske rentav som person, och som författare (Just kids är fantastiskt, inte minst som New Yorkskildring där i skarven 60/70tal) Poetrock däremot, det är sällan en bra idé. Ett stort Nja, varken poesin eller rocken är särskilt kul här. Bara Free money sparkar lite rumpa. Klarar tvåan men då är jag jävligt snäll
PS har för mig mest varit den där som spelade in en av Springsteens sämre 70-talslåtar (vet att hon själv var med och skrev Because the night). Horses känner man så klart till men tror aldrig jag lyssnat på den. Tycker att det låter bättre än vad jag väntat mig. Det punkiga anslaget funkar bra. Patti lyckas faktiskt låta cool. Något som är få förunnat. Allra bäst är medley låtarna. Inledande halvcovern på Vans Gloria och finfina Land. Oerhört driv i dessa spår. Inte samma klass däremellan. Som helhet klart godkänt. Uppe å snuddar vid fyran.
Kanske att texterna förtjänar mer tid en ett dygn? Nu blir bedömningen efter den tid jag hunnit spendera med Horses. Jag hör finns vissa musikaliska kvaliteter i till exempel Gloria. Free money håller jag som albumets bästa spår, tydligt influerat av Springsteen. Hittepåreggean i Redondo Beach hade jag gärna varit utan. Patti sång låter lite väl effektsökande emellanåt. Bäst är hon när hon pratsjunger.
This was very up and down. Sort of liked “Free Money” and “Land…” but most of the rest didn’t work for me. There are some songs I like by Patti Smith, but they weren’t on this album. This a 2.5 for me, but I’m rounding down.
Passa de ano tranquilo tbm, mas nada mais q isso. 3 honesto. Se fosse um álbum mais curto ainda levava um 4
O mais fraco ate aqui
Nada a declarar, nem lembro o que eu escutei
Birdland sozinha derrubou uma estrela desse album. De resto uma mistura de Jennis Joplin, Dolly Parton e Feist.
Groundbreaking. Immeasurably influential. Perfection. 5
Chefs kiss
Patti Smith is just one of those artists I've never really "got" for some reason. I know how much of a legend and trailblazer she is, so definitely appreciate that. And I feel like as a fan of punk and a lot of that genre of music, I should have liked her. But I just could never get into her. It was good to listen to this album and give her another shot, but it just isn't my thing.
Guns blazing
baby mash potato do the alligator
This album makes me nostalgic for a time and place that I wasn't a part of. Outside of a few singles I'd never really listened to Patti Smith until I moved to NYC nearly two decades ago. It was reading Just Kids that turned me onto her use of words, clashing poetry and prose, to really paint a picture. This album feels a bit like that as well. Poetry and Punk smashing into each other and mixing and finding a balance. It reminds me of the art my friends and I make in dingy basements around the city. It's about finding yourself and community by sharing whatever is inside. Gloria: In Excelsis Deo
Really liked this. never listened to the full album before. Obviously had heard Gloria. I liked the beachy vibe of Redondo Beach, unexpected. Also interesting how it sounds like spoken word in some songs. I want to read her book soon.
This album is lightyears ahead of its time. I understand why it doesn't land for some people but it has everything for me. Playlist track: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo
Eh, it was okay.
she ANGRY fuck yeah
Somewhere between rock and punk, you'll find the easily identifiable sounds of Patti Smith.
Mixed feeling on Smith's debut. I like some of the shorter melodic tracks like Redondo Beach, Free Money, Kimblerley but the longer songs don't as does the more spoken word/poet moments. So just ok for me.
Quite a frustrating one to be honest. This is my first time hearing of her and therefore first time hearing her stuff. I can't help but feel like Smith could easily make better music than this. When she sings properly, it's great. But when she starts doing weird noises and different singing styles it just sounds so shit. The music itself is so boring it hurts. At least with many of the other boring albums I've had on the list previously they've been somewhat pleasant to listen to. I know it's supposed to be minimalist. But there's a difference between minimalist and laziness. Maybe Smith isn't being lazy. But that's what it sounds like. If it makes it any better I wasn't sure whether to give it a 2 or a 1, so this is probably the best album I've rated a 1 here. Good job Patti.
I didn't like this album. Lots of talking and yelling and just making noise.
Good stuff
Dette er sikkert å banne i kirka, men dette likte jeg ikke i det hele tatt. Bråkete, rotete, masete.
Decent - high energy
Charming and timeless. I just love her voice and her poetry.
Really liked some songs, really disliked others
Pretty enjoyable, sounds like she is hurting her voice sometimes. I can see this being influential.
this style is a bit too talky for me. There were some interesting lyrics but I wanted more to back them up
I didn’t hate it, but it didn’t resonate with me. There are some catchy parts but all in all I probably won’t listen again.
Knowing everything I know about my personal music tastes, it feels like I *should* hate this album. And I admit that there are moments here where this album is a tough listen (particularly with Patti's vocals). But there's just something about it that keeps drawing me in. I think this will grow on me a lot in the future. 4/5.
Patti was/is an incredibly influential musician and influenced many artists who music I really like. There was some really cool stuff on this album but some of this was tough to sit through. In particular "Birdland" reminded me of the avant-garde performance piece that Idina Menzel's character does in RENT. I've always assumed it was lampooning the art rock scene in general but this made me feel like Patti could've been direct inspiration.
Loved the first track so much. The rest was a tough listen, which I know is the point, but I wouldn’t return to it.
Eclectic, sometimes frenzied, sometimes meek. If Jagger, Dylan, and Siouxsie Sioux had a daughter… …but it seems I need more “toons” (melody), and less a fan of solo vocal artists with the voice as the central instrument.
This album is a force of nature and I know it deserves a 5, but I’m not a huge fan of the “singing” the entire time. Patti Smith is a total rockstar and she deserves better than this (my rating)
Because the Night was a major part of my five years at Uni. This isn't quite as good.
An album I’ve long heard of, but never heard. Breathtakingly original. As a Fiona Apple fan I feel like I just found the origin story. YES
Cool ballad album. Voice can be annoying. Need to listen again
Eh, she screams a lot
She is the godmother of punk for a reason. This is a complete MUST of a record. 9/10 [KEEP]
Not bad.
Cool early punk influences not totally my thing but I liked it enough
this album was jst alr, it feels longer than it was and patti’s voice got a bit annoying on the back end of the album, maybe i didn’t like this as much as i would have if i didn’t want to listen to other albums when i listened to this, but overall i didn’t leave with much
Liked most of this it’s just a shame the bits I didn’t like i really didn’t like. (Namely- bird land)!
Gloria and Land are the standouts but others fall flat
Fire. Loved her voice, the lyrics and psychedelic nature
I had already heard this album in passing 20 years ago, but I barely remembered anything about it, so it was nice to give it a refresh. I was skeptical at first, the instrumentation seemed a bit basic in some of the tracks (for some reason, I misremembered this record as much more punk than it actually is). It’s also not easy to get right away into the very particular mood of the album and the poetry of the lyrics. I gave it a second listen in the evening and it did the trick – I was entranced. It’s a beautiful, moody album with a wide range of emotions and atmospheres, and vibes ranging from a more punkish version of the Velvet Underground to Joplin-style blues and spoken word poetry. Grace and Elegy are gorgeous pieces. It’s not a perfect album, some tracks are less inspired than others (Kimberly was not very interesting, sounding almost like 80s pop, and Break It Up felt very conventional). But overall, it’s extremely creative, and it really allows Patti Smith’s charismatic personality to shine. It's a pity she's such a hit-and-miss artist - some of her later albums are awesome, but others are really terrible in my opinion. But early Patti Smith definitely kicked ass ! Will certainly listen again. 7/10
This album bored me and I didn't understand anything about why it was included in the 1001 albums to listen to...
Clearly not the best of Patti Smith. Despite her amazing voice, I felt disappointing by the lack of punk vibe.
First song of the best, I get the spoken word appeal but didn’t quite do it for me
G-L-O-R-I-A Always cool to hear the origin of an Easter egg you heard first in a different song as a nod. This was a pretty solid post punk album, favorite song was Free Money.
I find it hard to understand what she is saying buy I can appreciate and really get a sens of each feeling she expresses through her words. Gloria: In Excelsis Deo - 4/10 Redondo Beach - 5/10 Birdland - 4/10 Way too long a song for my liking repeating the same for too long. Free Money - 6/10 Kimberly - 5/10 Break It Up - 6/10 Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) - 6/10 Only because it lasts too long with the same rythm and melody. Elegie - 4/10 Even though I don't particularly find it within my usual music choices, I can feel the emotion that was put into each record and appreciate that. I would like to research her story to understand more the place where she writes.
"Horses" by Patti Smith is a groundbreaking album that blends poetry and rock and roll. It's raw, energetic, and super influential will probably listen to it again I enjoyed it but I just need to give it a few more listens and I think it will eventually grow on me.
Honestly a very mid album. There was some highlights which were the shorter songs but almost every song had these slow talking parts that I did not like. I think the top three songs are free money, Kimberly, and then elegie. The worst song of the album is probably bird land as it’s too long and the good part is super short and the rest is ass. At first listen I kind of liked Gloria but after the second listen I liked it even more and it may crack the top three. The album is alright it’s just the slow talking parts where it’s the same boring notes and just her talking. I also think if she made the long bird land and land shorter they would’ve been way better. Other than that the songs are pretty good.
Annoying vocals at times. I'd like it if she talked less and sang more.
Not for me. Vocals are kind of annoying.
Horses for courses
Had a REALLY HARD TIME teasing out the whole "punk" thing. Arty poetry based rock, sure. Critics are always falling over themselves when the next generation does something novel. The album is merely okay. I never really "got" Patti Smith. I guess there's an interesting twist on songwriting here that definitely breaks from the mainstream. Stylistically crude (maybe that's why some see "punk" here), definitely part of the Art Scene more than the music scene. Like the Velvet Underground, who I also struggle with. Influential though, I can see a path to Bjork ,The Pretenders, Nina Hagen possibly... just leaves mewondering why this is so "important?" There were and always will be a thousand poetry writers who can almost sing, why this?
My favourite Patti Smith's work and one of the best albums of all times. As it's been repeatedly pointed out in other comments, does anyone remember an opening line as powerful as "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine"? Every song is a poem and there is not a single filler. And of course the music and Patti's voice are terrific: pure raw energy.
Is this album provocative, rebellious, culture defiant, fused with a slam poetry style presentation? Maybe. Does this connection to self identification, or lack thereof, with culture at that time mean it is artistically deep, innovative, or lyrically complex? Not in this case. I was disappointed because this album has such raving reviews. Saying “Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine” is powerful, and many revere it as one of the greatest opening lines ever. But then go nowhere with it after? At face value it was attempting to push boundaries, but stating provocative things in a punky voice is just stating the obvious. The envelope was nudged. I think…
What an absolutely dreadful voice. The songs weren't much better either! I suspect a lot of drugs were involved in both the making of this album, and the process of selecting this as one of the 1001 albums 1 ⭐️
Her voice properly gets on my nerves. Actually, not her voice, that has a really nice tone, but her singing style is incredibly grating. I struggled to get through this.
Lyrically very strong, musically kinda boring. I think I'd have to re-listen to this. For a debut album, not an easy feat.
I never gave Patti Smith a chance, but I’ve realized her music doesn’t quite speak to me. However, I can see how her sound influenced a lot of music.
Okay!
Really quite enjoyed this, knew a fair number of the tracks, not sure where from. Couple of stand outs, added it to my interesting albums to listen to again list. Despite my daughter playing me Phoebe Buffay and saying they have the same style.
i kinda liked it, fineee nothing special
She is not a good rock singer. Her pop album is much better.
Didn’t really find much to appreciate here. Indie rock with vocals that were trying too hard and not enough at the same time.
this is how I discovered I don´t like punk... some good songs tho
Pretty chill album 👌
не зашло особо...
My favourite thing she's ever done is the book Just Kids, but this is a close second, and a perfect example of the ole "abrasive singer + beautiful arrangements" formula
I liked this fine but it did not speak to me. My favorite poet/singer is Miss Polly Jean and always will be.
The queen of cool, poet warrior, legend. This is someone taking basic rock and roll and pop music, shredding it into pieces, and trying to find something new in between. Naturally, it’s a bit of a mess, but it’s on purpose and while it’s not perfection it’s still rightfully a classic that grows in each listen.
Ikke alt på 70-tallet var bra
Very good
WOW - what an amazing look into what I imagine is a major influence of the 80s/90s punk scene. You can feel the emotion and anger throughout, backed up by a beautiful instrumental mix. The only comment I have is on Smith's shrill vocals, however it should not take away from what is an amazing album
4.0
An all time classic. My intro to Patti Smith years back, who has now become one of my all time favorite artists and greatest inspirations. I’ve had the pleasure of seeing her live multiple times, including this year performing the album in full.
A lot of nay sayers on here but weirdly I thought the opposite and this album is much better than I remember! You can hear all the artists she influenced in all of the songs, good stuff.
Conflicted. The mother of punk rock and cultural influencer before everyone pretended to do that. I don’t like it though…it’s prototypical and not for everyone.
81/100. A strong, influential record with a calm yet cool and dark demeanor. It blends poetry and punk with a raw edge, and her vocal delivery adds a unique intensity.
Ah Patti…original worthy of praise. Just what we needed in 1975. Her version of “Gloria” has been a big part of my playlist this past year so was psyched for this album to pop up.
Okej album men mycket som är rätt tråkigt? 70-talsviben är där, men låtarna är för repetitiva och hennes sätt att sjunga är ibland de sämre delarna av Janis Joplin. Några låtar/texter var bra dock och mycket känsla overall!
4/10 - не слушал
I read Patti Smith’s book, but I hadn’t listened to much of her work, so I’m excited. Holy angst. Very groovy, yet also very punky. The second song has a reggae vibe? I don’t like the spoken word song so much. Fav song is ‘Redondo Beach’.
Clásico. Indiscutido. Poeta y punk. 8/10
I have to be in the mood for this, but I’ve never been sure what mood that is. The first time I heard this I thought it was incredible. Other times it has passed me by. I dont think I’ve ever owned a record that does this to me. I think I prefer the lyrical aspect of it more than the music at times. Perhaps thats it. Totally get why it is seen as one of the most influential punk records of all time, wouldve been incredible to see her live back in the 70s. Those shows sounded insanely good
Reading that this was meant to be 'poetry punk' makes a lot more sense, as the music did seem to just be background for extended raving lyrics for large chunks of this. Quite liked a lot of the music in there but punk music is rarely improved by sticking around longer than it needs to so I think you'd have to half the runtime to make some of these songs land properly. Okay for one listen but the poetry side of things didn't appeal to me. 2.5.
It was alright. Quite liked Elegie, but otherwise a bit meandering. Wasn't stirred, nor roused. Perhaps I didn't pay close enough attention to the lyrics. I relistened to Gloria on the basis of other reviews. I didn't get it.
I've listened to this before. Think it starts better than it ends. It does feel pretty punk to me and I like spoken word so should be right up my street. She makes Gloria her own, I do like the original version too though. Redondo beach is great too. 3.5
I especially liked the opening and the closing song, with some detours in the middle of the tracklist not being my cup of tea. But overall I enjoyed it.
Vaya coñazo esta señora. Ignoro de dónde viene su prestigio. A duras penas habla con ritmo. De cantar ni hablamos. Y las canciones son realmente malas. Sin embargo, queda bien decir que uno ama a Patti Smith. Seamos serios: no aporta absolutamente nada a la historia de la música. Nunca nadie quiso ser Patti Smith. Creo que no lo voy a escuchar. Ya lo sufrí una vez. Esto es para gente sorda que quiere ir de intelectual y moderna.
It could survive on attitude alone.
Classic
Not really a fan of her sound/voice, can’t really get past it. Need to have a proper to songs individually and read the lyrics.
Don’t love her voice
This is one of the classic albums I've liked less the more I've listened to it over the years. The first time I listened to it several years ago, the transgressive lyrics and energetic crescendos clearly demarcated it as an important rock classic. It is clearly ahead of its time and is very novel for 1975, since it generates its emotive power from Patti Smith's charisma and songwriting skill as opposed to any kind of technical experimentation, virtuosity or progressiveness that typifies that era in my view. The issue is that its also one of the more inconsistent classic albums. Gloria, Land and especially Free Money are really amazing songs but the other songs are too monotonous and plain, to the extent that they become kind of aggravating. I personally think that lyrics are the least important part of music and good lyrics can only amplify a great song. But no matter how much of a "poet" Patti Smith might be, it doesn't matter if the majority of the songs are too limited to make her poetry shine through. I think it's telling that one of the oft quoted lyrics from the album is literally the first line, because whatever else of genius she says is buried behind a wave of identical droning chords that they are missed by the casual listener. It's very reasonable for someone to adore this album if the magic sauce of Horses' acclaimed songs applies to the rest of the album in their view. Equally I can clearly see how some people see this as trash - most of the album is quite annoying if you are not in the right headspace for it. I think it's fair that this album is critically and culturally preserved and I lean towards it being on the positive side. But it is still very unrefined and probably salvaged somewhat thanks to John Cale's production. Given it was Patti Smith's first album, released when she was only 29, those flaws are completely acceptable, and clearly, ameliorate the album for many people.
12/23/25 I enjoy the weird things she does with her voice. 7/10
I can hear later albums in this one so I can sense it's influence. However just didn't really enjoy this one
Really enjoyed this. Heard a few of the songs before and the album works well together.
Is soothing punk a thing?
What a fascinating blend of lyricism, musicianship, and attitude. I think she'd scare me if I met her in real life, and maybe some of her music kinda scares me, but in a good way.
A couple months ago I put this on to remedy one of the biggest blind spots of my entire music-listening life. It was absolutely incredible. I don't know what I was expecting. Somewhere along the line, I got the impression that this was in a class with Joni Mitchell, Janis Joplin, and Stevie Nicks (all artists I admire, but maybe don’t love). It appears the only thing that connects all those artists is the lack of a Y chromosome and a truckload of talent. Patti’s sound is so unique and ferocious. Why did I put this off for so long?
Fuck this album and Fuck Birdland
Cool album. Love that early New York punk sound, mixed in with the avant garde of the times. Definitely unique voice, has a bit of a Blondie timbre to it.
I appreciated this record more than loved it. I like the creativity and commitment to really try something new. I don’t really know if I would listen consistently or even again, but I liked what she was going for. 3.75/5.
birdland sold me a bit
Not for me. Too pretentious for my taste.
It's nice. I've always had such a hard time connecting to it though. I like the energy of the band, and Patti's vocals are always very theatrical. The album just sits weird in my head though, like so what just happened actually? Stars: Birdland and Kimberly
Really solid. Very truthful and biogrpahical, glad i found it beyond redondo beach
Gehört in die sammlung
"Gloria", "Birdland" y "Break It Up" are great. Much better than expected.
don’t piss me off no…just no you absolutely do not need to listen to this before you die and i’m so happy i don’t have to listen to it again
Ok
It's a shame that the couple actual songs were short lived because the rest was just slam poetry yelled over uninteresting instrumentals
When Gloria and Redondo Beach come on, I wonder why I don’t listen to this album more, but as the album goes on the spoken word begins to grate a little. I think this deserves a closer listen to me, then maybe it’d be a 5.
A very dramatic album. Loud and atmospheric.
Great album with very strong personality
An album I've always heard I should listen to, but never have. I did not expect it to be so punk rock coded (I think I expected more Bob Dylan-esque singer songwriter). Nitpick: I did find her voice get a little nasal/whiny for my tastes a couple times. I suppose it shouldn't surprise me that I enjoyed this album, I mean, it's on this list for a reason. It was just different than I expected in a good way. Solid 4 for me.
The album gets better as it goes
I think if I wasn't on a bus journey I probably wouldn't have finished it. Very experimental and the tracks are very long. Not really my vibe
Lush
Look, I'm all for powerful, opinionated, musically talented women who had to be scrappy and fight their way onto the male-dominated music scene, but this... well, it ain't it for me."Birdland" is nine minutes of gorgeous piano and Patti Smith whine-talk-singing all over it. For several measures in the middle she sings the same damn note for what seems like an eternity. "Free Money" seriously reminds me of a Tori Amos song- that may be the only redeeming quality this album has. PH WAIT - now that we've reached the middle of the song, Smith is back to the whine-talk-singing on the same note again. Nope. I just don't get it. Vocally, she just isn't strong. Poetically more so, but not enough to save this for me. "Kimberly " features more one-note singing. Is this Smith's schtick?
New to me. Not my fave, but I appreciate her art.
I was expecting 70's singer songwriter. This is not that. It was interesting. It felt a bit like Björk in the delivery. Not the pixie dreamgirl, but how the music takes turns you didn't expect.
Reminds me a lot of Jeff Buckley and Stevie nicks really like it
I got to see Patti Smith perform Horses in its entirety a few years ago. She played some extra songs too, including a cover of Purple Rain (this was in Minneapolis shortly after Prince died). She also recorded the entire audience singing Happy Birthday to send to John Cale. This is a great album to listen to and one of my favorites (Gloria is also a contender for my favorite song of all time), but the experience will always pale in comparison to hearing it live
energetic
A good album. Very raw. Very Patti Smith. But not her best work.
Wasn't quite my cup of tea but well made. Glora: In Excelsis Deo is a good song.
On one hand I get it, on the other, I don't.
Not really my thing but she is obviously VERY talented
I understand this album’s importance and Patti Smith’s importance, but I just didn’t like the music.
Nicely done. Love the edge on it.
Awesome. Birdland is my song.
I understand why I should like this album more than I actually like it.
Hope I get reincarnated as Patti Smith. Still hate Bird land, but the rest is wonderful.
Didnt end up listening to the whole album. Not my fave
Not for me.
4+
Wtf is this shit? Why would she sing like that? This album is irredeemably bad, and "Birdland" has gotta be one of the worst "songs" I've ever heard.
11th album with group. I wanted to relisten and rerate this. I’ve been thinking I might’ve been too harsh. After listening to it again though my opinions are pretty much the same except I’ll swap Elegie for Kimberly. Good Songs - Gloria: In Excelsis Deo, Redondo Beach, and Kimberly. Bad Songs - Birdland, Free Money, Break It Up, Land: Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances/La Mer, and Elegie.
Iconic voice, messing with pacing enough to make us uncomfortable. I enjoy how it seems to thumb its nose at the rock band trope. It sounds like (at the time) it should be like a Mick Jagger at the front…
2/10
Not a dan
God, she was so damn cool. 4/5
An all-time classic: if this list was 21 albums…rather than 1001, Horses should still be on it. The Van Morrison/Them cover to open the album, plus the title track Land:Horses, are highlights but it’s strong all the way through.
I must have heard Patti Smith before but obviously not tracks from this album. The album seemed punk-ish in places, which seems about right from the year it was released. I'm not normally a fan of punk, but this seemed to be a softer version of it, less out to offend than some of the later bands. She has a distinctive and strong voice which came over well and fitted with the music. I set out thinking i wouldn't like the album but in the end it turned out OK.
I love her voice, I can sense the power and dedication she puts into her songs Fav song - Kimberly 3/5
1 song in...i dont think im going to get this album. im sure it was crazy 50 years ago, but it's missing me. Hits me like an Always Sunny song break, The Gang (Charlie and Dee) goes art punk. I guess "Free Money" is alright.
Snarling fierceness from the opening to the beginning. One of the all time great debuts.
Weird in a good way. Something about Birdland reminds me of St. Vincent, also loving the shreds on that one. Kinda punk I like it, never heard of Patti Smith before. I love love love the intro to Elgie. Favorite Track (this listen): Elgie - Wishing the song was longer; beautiful vocals and spoken word, and the guitar is singing too :P
3.69
Це цікаво, хоч я більше слухала музику, але до лірики варто повернутися
2.6
Favorite Song: Free Money Least Favorite Song: Kimberly Fun listen, but not my cup of tea unfortunately. Patti Smith's powerful voice and the iconic opening line might be the only memorable things about this.
Pretty interesting and different compared to other punk albums I've had to listen to. Usually they sound the same, but this one was like electric Leonard Cohen. Is it great? No, but anything named 'Horses' deserves some respect.
Not gonna claim to get this one eh. Redondo beach…? Like….huh?
Love It. Own It.
I already I know I love this album! What a feat. So raw.
An album of its time , when women in rock were few and far between. This was one of the albums you were supposed to like. I bought it in my 20s and hated it! But over the years it’s grown on me and have begun to understand Patti’s place in music. A woman doing her own thing who didn’t care if you like it or not
Never listened before but really enjoyed it. Some cool New York rock that reminded me of television.
such a strong and beautiful album!!!!!!
Masterpiece
reminds me of kate bush, very whimsical
First time hearing this iconic album. It was exactly what I expected from it and also nothing like it. Years ago my now-husband and I went to a Patti Smith art exhibition at a big gallery. The art was carried by attitude and determination, but not much raw talent. There was a hush surrounded the exhibition, though. A sense of "I cannot believe Patti Smith herself will be here later today." And so this record carries that too. Attitude, determination, some but not much raw talent, and a cult of personality. I liked some songs: Elegie and Free Money. But overall, Smith as an artist doesn't work for me.
good...trippy
CLASSIC
I like some songs but its okay
I like the aesthetic of this album probably more than the album itself...but I digress. Redondo Beach is a fave and Patti is the ultimate cool girl. Why would I give this less than 5?
I was surprised how her voice seems like other singer after her. I see some of Blondie and Siouxsie in here. Dramatic and poetic songs, some of them longer than the usual punk songs, but this make more interesting. Just two songs got me more actually.
Punk rock poetry.
It just sounds like a classic albums Opener is superb The instrumentation is great
This was my first Patti Smith album I have listened to. Might even be the first songs I knowingly listened to. I listened twice and a lot of it didn't resonate. Maybe if I get to know her, Patti Smith, this album will feel different. It's like high school and right now, Patti is one of the girls I didn't know or found annoying because of how cool she was. Then I see her a number of years after high school and realize we have more in common than we realized just on the surface in high school. Maybe it's like that? I dunno. I am sure I will go back and revisit this at some point.
Yeah, this is very much my thing. Really getting into this 70s pop rock
I love Patti Smith so much. Totally biased over here. But really, this is so, so good. There's nothing here as monumental for me as Pissing in a River, but the whole album is just a delight.
best one so far, never listened to punk before
This was pretty good. Sounds like a raw, angry, rock and roll version of Joni Mitchell. This is an example of bad background music, but when you stop to listen, it really rocks. This is active listening music.
At ground breaking and challenging album from Patti Smith 1977 definitely feel the punk and the poetry in this piece has opened up a lot of pathways in my brain about how poetry can be presented in a musical context.
Opening with “Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine” goes so hard.
I expected more from this. Didn’t gel with her voice either tbh
Just an absolute racket
Several great songs, although some of them are similar to each other. Magnetic voice, makes her a singer eady to recognize. Some of her songs I would listen to it again.
better than I thought it would be
Album is not something I typically listen to, however I’m glad I did because I know it’s considered a classic.
A bit shouty. Still enjoyed it. Like a punk Joni Mitchell.
I of course knew who Patti Smith was, and have heard plenty of her songs and know of her importance in music history. But yeah, honestly never sat down and listened to one of her albums. This is a masterpiece. I get it.
(CENSORED) The only solid song on here is Gloria and I’d prefer Van Morrisson’s ___ in my ___ over Patti Smith‘s whining voice in my ears any day 🍑 Top candidate for most overhyped album of all times
Cracking opening, but suffers from the same problems Patti Smith always exhibits. Dull music, bad mix, lyrics veer wildly from evocative to overwrought.
This is one of those discoveries. What a revelation. Fucking amazing, I just love this album. And it belongs on a short list of fantastic debuts.
It started interesting, but went downhill quickly from there 1,5/5
Great voice but not really my cup of tea. Very repetitive sounding. Album gets quite boring quite early to be honest.
Loved the production and the boldness of the lyrics. Lots to love in here in general and lots to get your teeth into. However, there wasn't any song that screamed "listen to me" again but I'm kinda glad I got to listen to it at all.
I mean, its goddamn Patti Smith, playfully covering "Gloria" and "Land Of A Thousand Dances", but raw as all hell. She comes swinging out the gates and doesn't let up for the duration.
I like this album quite a bit. Didn't actually think I would like it so much. 4 stars.
What a debut. What a time. What a woman.
Yeah it was ok. Heard a lot of things I liked.
Rad.
Good
Totally captivating. Words don’t do this experience any justice. Patti Smith is so emphatic and animated in delivering some of the most unique lyricism you’ll ever hear in anything rock/pop adjacent. The vocal inflections are unreal. Usually, with an artists you kinda sacrifice unique lyrics for catchy delivery or appealing instrumentals. Not here, she has it all. I’m just floored. “Gloria: In Excelsis Deo” and “Birdland” are my picks from the record, but really this is just front to back amazing. Easy 5/5, no need for a long write up just go listen to this masterpiece
Not my music, but dayum there's a lot of power buildup here. Some nice solos though. Will rate better later.
Kinda scares me, but I like the songs
Mixed bag. Liked some tracks, not sure about others
I'm sure i would've been blown away as a contemporary, but it feels like all those early punkers were really working to hit that "wretching" sound.
Have this album, big fan.
134 Pucha Patti, yo creo que en otro momento de mi vida te habría amado. Ahora como que no nos encontramos muy bien, igual me gustaron varias canciones, pero a ratos me desconcentraba y no la escuchaba mucho.
Gloria kicked ass
Easily one of the best album openers we've gotten so far, at least if you're asking me. Any cover of Gloria feels like a guaranteed banger, but Patti Smith's might be my favorite. Land is a transcendent trip that I'm always happy to take. Indulgent, however, is a perfect way to describe some of the other songs on the album. It can feel like a little much at times. Big ups to Lenny Kaye and his guitar work on Horses. 3.75/5 Favorite Tracks: Gloria, Redondo Beach, Break it Up, Land
Patti Smith alternates high & low with some high highs and low lows. Part of it is that you really need to indulge yourself in the scene, right, like her whole mileiu. And that stuff can be really annoying when it runs too long or feels too indulgent. That's definitely the case on Birdland. But Land? That's the best song here! The shorter stuff is roundly good, taking its cues from the VU with some dashes from the 70s singer-songwriter school. Favorite Tracks: Gloria, Redondo Beach, Kimberly, Land
A few of these kind of sounded Sleater-Kinney-ish, which I wasn’t expecting.
Äe jag hade svårt för detta. Inte dåligt men inte min smak.
Ugh.
Not so bad but not so good
Although it is highly rated, I still don't hear any compelling vocals here. Influential and talented lady. But not something I would want to listen often.
I couldn’t finish it
And a half. Very good
A bit much for a Sunday night when you’re slightly hanging but still powerful
I like this. Cool dude
Not my thang, she had a great voice but some of her songs were pretty wack
Not going to lie, this one made me sleepy, it wasn’t bad but it wasn’t engaging for me, probably bc I don’t really like this slow, relaxing type of music.
Big fan of Patti Smith's books but never could fully get behind her music
It's ok. Her vocals grate on me after a while though and not enough of the songs hit the mark.
Good
oh da bin ich mal gespannt, kenne glaube keinen Song von ihr...mhh schon gut, toller opener aber Punk? ok. c
Still sounds as vital today as it did 40+ years ago. It was fun to hear it again as a full album.
I recognize the historical significance, but don't quite fit in with the adulation. I am afraid I thought Horses pretentious or maybe just not all that much. It's okay. Maybe I'm just reacting to the deification.
This has always been in my top 10 albums. I love everything about it and can sing along to almost all of it. Free money is the most phenomenal song. Patti is an amazing writer and talent!
I've been a fan of Patti Smith ever since Easter — the first album of hers in my vinyl collection and my favorite of her catalog. This album never beguiled me the same way Easter does, but today's listen landed. I always thought PJ Harvey was something of a sister artist to Smith, and much like Harvey's raw debut is not my fave in her collection, the rawness and immediacy of this record is undeniable, and is a bold introduction. For me, it's a 3.5, but absolutely gets the bump as it's the only Smith release on this list and is such a pure distillation of who she is as an artist.
I've tried with this one before. Today I was able to appreciate how much she's influenced a generation of musicians, so there's that. But it's never done anything for me. I guess I like the idea of Pattie Smith more than the reality. Cool cover, though.
I've long connected with Patti Smith's words, sounds, ethos, and nature. Even before I started reading her books and learned the shared similarities of growing up in a small New Jersey town. Is this her best album? Not in my mind (that might be Gone Again or Banga). But Horses is a perfect introduction to her style of rock-n-roll feminist poetry with a nod to punk and avant garde artists who helped her bloom. I'm extremely grateful to live at the same time as Patti Smith and I urge you to read any of the books she's published. Her words...thoughtful and real.
not all music can be poetry and not all poetry can be music. i would say this album fits within the latter statement 2 stars
I can't get into her and I've tried
Patti was great! that Smith guy though, ugh
Got a song about myself and horses so almost an instant classic
respect the vibes but this ain’t for me
this ain't the Chelsea hotel, we're modern idiots
she sounds like a goat
The album was angsty and slow with early country/bluegrass roots. Had some good moments, but other parts made me cringe a bit.
It's very reminiscent of Neil Young to me. It's fine, and I appreciate it was groundbreaking at its time. But it doesn't grab me like other music does.
Contender for best bookends ever, also all the poetry in the middle
Wow this was great I wonder what some of her other song-WHAT IS THAT ONE CALLED????
The sound of bitching put to tape
Who thinks this is good music . . . ?
Meh
This album was an impressive Venn diagram of things I don’t like
4 Stars I have been familiar with the fact that Patti Smith exists for many years, since reading the oral history of punk rock "Please Kill Me" which described her influence on punk rock music. A few years later in high school I heard an excerpt of "Gloria: In Excelsis Deo" and though it was interesting but never pursued it more. Then when I started collecting vinyl I came across Horses one day and bought it. I may have listened to it all the way through but I don't remember it. I thought of it more as a relic than an album. So when I got this album, I thought it would be another case of an album that has value as a part of musical history but isn't so much an enjoyable record in itself. But when I put it on, I quickly realized I was wrong. The influence on punk music is clear, but the freshness of the music and the raw emotion is still enjoyable. Some of the spoken word stuff is a little harder to get through, but honestly it is not too over indulgent in that regard. The record is solid all the way through and I now finally view it as a genuine classic. This is good stuff and deserves the acclaim.
Alright album, I didn’t like the opening track but the rest was pretty good
First Listen. 4.5 Not sure how I never listened to this before. I really enjoyed it and is one I will listen to again. I liked the proto-punk, stripped down sound.
Day 91. Loved this, will be checking out the rest of her discography 9/10 Highlights Gloria Free Money Break it Up
Patti Smith is one hell of a wordsmith.
Pure class
Glad this list got me to listen to the album, sounds more timeless than I expected ver god songs.
This album caught me off guard completely. I was not expecting poetic and punk, so the first couple of tracks were a bit of a shock. Once I settled in, Patti took me for a wonderful ride. Great lyrics, solid (but sometimes too punk) vocals, and great guitar and song structure give this album a great feel.