Reviews (page 8 of 15)
my first steely dan album. not sure how I feel about it yet. is it bland and boring? without a doubt. but not offensively so. I'm perfectly happy to leave it on in the background and float away in its fuzzy sound. not a single song is even slightly memorable, but it's not awful. slightly toasted white bread of music.
Production sounds great and the musicianship is unquestionable. This is my third Steely Dan record and I think I could tentatively call myself an enjoyer. This isn't as hook-y as 'Can't Buy a Thrill', which is still my favorite, but it left a better impression on me than 'Countdown to Ecstasy'. Dad rock maybe, but good, smart dad rock.
Shit
Pretty solid SD album, anchored by Rikki, a definitive song of the seventies.
Great album, steely Dan is know for excellent session artist, this album shows that
Nice little indie vibe. Reminded me of the velvet underground
Great :D
Loved it! I never listened to much early Dan, but this is a terrific record.
I recognize that this is good, but I really am not a fan
niet me ding
That was surprisingly good - I listened to it during a car journey and I was in a good mood all the way despite some pretty bad traffic
This is my 3rd Steely Dan on the list. I think I feel bad for them because every album so far has had some of the greatest songs I’ve heard in the list mixed with stuff I just couldn’t vibe with. Deacon Blues is still in the top 10 of songs I’ve discovered this project. This album is a little different. I knew Rikki already but other than that song nothing on this album really stands out as something I’d want to listen to over and over again. But it’s also the most consistent listen of there’s I’ve heard
Middle of the road dad rock. Few of these songs would be out of place in a 70s sitcom opening
Not a band I’ve ever understood the hype for. Two albums we’ve had now and only one song has stood out as ‘good’. Although Parker’s Band stood out for sounding like it was from the Peanuts Christmas special.
Gøy
An album to bond teen girls and middle aged dads - make a reference to this album on a road trip and you will be raised to the highest levels of approval in dad world logic. Didgeridoo kinda beat that makes you wish you owned a boat.
It was fine. Adult contemporary I guess?
5/5/2025: solid, just not quite my vibe.
You always hear so much about them, then you listen, then you move on. This is a definitely a keeper. The 70’s all summed up in one album.
Good album!
Appreciate it, but do not vibe with it
First Introduction to Steely Dan, it’s pretty nonsensical, almost always a piano or some sort of keyboards, the harmony vocals and jazzy instruments mixed with late 60s sounding rock gave it quite an interesting sound. Great album overall, I’d rate it 4.5, unbiasedly it’s probably more like a 4.0 or 3.5. It’s a good album but admittedly I like it better than it actually is, + album standouts: Rikki Don’t Lose That Number, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, With A Gun, Charlie Freak and Monkey In Your Soul, honorable mention to East St. Louise Toodle-Oo, not one the best tracks but one of my favorites.
Trashy tunes! 1/5 rubbish bins
As a Caucasian 39-year-old man, I am legally required to give a Steely Dan album a five star rating.
I just… don’t think I like Steely Dan. I’m not sure why because I like stuff like The Eagles and Grateful Dead which they sort of remind me of. But I just don’t find them interesting or memorable at all. At least not so far.
Unremarkable
Good
I listened to it but forgot to come back to review. Then I realised most of it wasn't memorable except for the single "Ricky Don't Lose That Number". Maybe because looking back it sounds like generic 70s pop.
This is peak '70s chill, man. It’s the kind of record that makes you wanna lean back in a recliner and let the hi-fi do its thing. Smart, but never smug. Cool without trying too hard. 11 songs clocking in under 35 minutes is super impressive too. Spins: 3 Playlist Additions: - Rikki Don't Lose That Number - Any Major Dude Will Tell You - East St. Louis Toodle-Oo - Pretzel Logic
Sympa sans plus. Plus calme
Will be back for more!
Ikke like bra som Aja og Gaucho, men en fin gjennomlytting. Litt varierende i kvalitet utover plata, men de som scorer høyt er veldig bra 3,5/5
Enjoyed the album. Nothing special that I could point out. This particular sound I have heard before. Plus I didn't have enough time like I usually do to breath with the album to think over it carefully. But from my one listen, the album is nice and gets your going. It's moving in the sense that it lifts my spirits. The final rating based on my current music taste: 6/10 21 April 2025
To me this sounds like the embodiment of my memories of inoffensive AM radio. Real Boomer music here. It’s all very competent and pleasant and may even have been innovative for its time but there’s nothing here that gets me excited.
Don’t know what I was expecting but it wasn’t that. It was kind of all over the place and you never knew where it was going to next. Weird album. but not bad weird.
It will not take any Pretzel Logic to come to my conclusion on this Steely Dan album. Which is kind of a bummer. The opening track Rikki Don’t Lose That Number is one of my top five Steely Dan songs. It’s followed by Night by Night, another good song, and I thought we were off to a good start. Unfortunately, it was all downhill from there. The only other song I like is the title track towards the end. The rest of Pretzel Logic reminded me more of songs better meant for a B-Sides release. Just not good material. This is a 2 rating for me. 2/5
Not really a fan and was really glad when this was over.
sleepy
Partially listened before Fav tracks: Rikki Don't..., Any Major Dude..., Through With Buzz
Light easy-listening funk. Solid musicianship. Sits pleasantly and unobtrusively in the background.
OK. Middle of the road
Not my jams
All Dan is great, but not all Dan is created equal. This is certainly overshadowed by Aja and other late period masterpieces, but still a great album in itself. 4/5
Inoffensive, middle of the road album. Standard Radio 2 fare, but not really my thing.
Rikki Don't Lose That Number is giving Sims 2 build mode in the best way. Nostalgic and I love it instantly. LOVED it. 4 or 5 stars, probably 5.
Not their best
Gentle rock and roll. A few good tunes, enjoyable
3.5
I like Steely Dan
Feel like I need to give this one a few more listens. The three “hits” are super groovy. But some of the songs sound a little kitschy to me on first listen, which I know is sacreligious to say about the Dan. I’d never cut it off, but might not grab for it either.
precise, yet swinging - wise, literate, sharp tales with a band rooted in jazz, looking for the next wave to catch
always loved this one
not my favourite of their albums ( i'd go for goucho or can't buy a thrill) , slightly too many clunkers amongst the gold. 3.5
Overall: 9/10 YEAH STEELY DAN WOOHOO STEELY DAN GIMME DAT STEELY DAN WOOHOO YEAH My love of the Dan kind of started out as a joke cause all my friends would laugh whenever I would play them and constantly yell STEELY DAN, but after a while the joke turned into a full on obsession. Now I listen to them pretty much every day. I love all of their albums but I think this is the one they really hit their stride. There's more emphasis on the jazzier elements compared to the first 2 albums and Donald Fagen sounds more confident than ever. I think I slightly prefer Aja but this is a close second for me. I wish Gaucho was in the list but it's not like it's going anywhere lol Fav Song: Rikki Don't Lost That Number Least Fav Song: Through With Buzz
Reminded me of the music my mum would play on road trips when I was a kid
Lively and funky. I like the harmonies and groovy instrumentals. A classic feel like a musical.
couple good jams on here. I feel like if I listened to this album 10 or more times I'd fall in love with it. Will I do that? unlikely.
Not interesting
Meh
Ongelofelijk comfortabele dadrock. Ik gaf ze hier al een keer 5 sterren, en bij dit album is het vanaf het begin af aan twijfelen geblazen tussen de 4 en 5. Het is heerlijke paparock met een gitaartje, pianotje, drums, bas en de zang verre van het slechtste van deze lijst. Af en toe een blazertje. 34 minuutjes. Ik hou het toch op een 4 en dat is deze keer niet omdat ik geen twee vijven wil uitdelen, maar meer omdat er echt geen enkel nummer van dit album bij me is blijven hangen. En dan reserveer ik de 5 sterren toch liever voor de Neverminds en Siamese Dreams's van deze wereld.
My only knowledge of steely dan was that there was an insufferably annoying person I knew in college who made steely dan their entire identity. They were always like 'duuuude you have to listen to him it will change your life' and I never did because they were annoying. Honestly after listening I can kinda see where they're coming from, some pretty catchy stuff in the beginning but the last 5 songs got super boring. idk if he ran out of ideas or if his ideas just weren't gripping enough to maintain an entire album. Either way, my life remains pretty unchanged.
Overall, I enjoyed this, it was easy-listening soft rock. There were some interesting instrumentals here, like the intro flapamba in "Rikki" and the cover of Duke Ellington's "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo", relying on guitar wah-wahs instead of a brass section. Perhaps most of the tracks were a little too soft-rock/clean, everything was a nice mainstream neat package.
Another day, another chance for me to not have an interesting review. The best part of the album is the album artwork. Musically, things are fine and interesting enough. The blues-y guitar is nice, and the vocals are only slightly tainted by that 70s pop jangle. A 3.5 rounded up
Getting started. Song 1: a little too poppy and smooth. Vapid? Maybe. We'll let 'em cook. Alright, getting better on this second track. This album feels super uneven. Half the time it's the most boring radio-friendly rock, but then its got these wonderful interludes like East St. Louis Toodle-Oo. Basically, any time they're singing, it's worse, but intrumentals are solid. Bizarrely, all the most popular tracks are the worst ones (thought Night by Night is good and pretzel logic is okay). 3.5 Rounding down
*Gordon Ramsay voice* "Delicious. Finally some good fucking dad rock" (and by good, I mean four stars). The emergent-yacht rock sound of some of these songs is great. And I think its what I want from my 1970s rock, a group that doesn't take itself too seriously and is willing to have fun with their music.
this was a fun album. some of the songs were surprisingly complex, other songs I didn't even notice while they were playing.
quite good for bg, but nothing stood out, only 2 songs saved
There's a lot of competition for this title, but this is my favorite Steely Dan album. It's so tight, front to back. To me, it's always felt like the most Beatleseque album in their catalog. The songs are mostly short, catchy pop tunes that each have their own sonic flavor and style. "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" is one of the most purely enjoyable pop songs Steely Dan ever wrote. It's a great opener. And the funky "Night By Night" is a fantastic, high-energy follow-up. I also love the folk-rock of "Any Major Dude Will Tell You." Later in the album, there's an instrumental jazz cover ("East St. Louis Toodle-Oo") and the blues rock of the title track. There's a lot of different styles on this album but they flow seamlessly from one to the next. This is a fun album to try to decipher the lyrics on. Other than "Rikki," which is a pretty straightforward love song, most of these songs have lines in them that make you go, "Wait, what is this about?" And for me, that's one of the fun things about Steely Dan. "Parker's Band" is about getting high and listening to Charlie Parker, "Pretzel Logic" might be about time travel but I take it be a metaphor about nostalgia, and "Monkey in Your Soul" is about... I have absolutely no idea. But that horn solo is awesome. And shoutout to the album cover, which I really want to frame and put on the wall one day.
There's an attention to detail that is perfected on Steely Dan records. I think it's part of their lasting quality- that you can put these albums on no matter the year and you can always appreciate the artistry and production. Every note feels intentional, every section is tight, and everything is really locked into a BPM. There are a few tracks on this record that I don't fully connect with, like as I listen to "Barrytown" it feels like a bunch of musicians going through the motions without much connection to the actual song. It's almost a bit too perfectly attached to a metronome grid. It's not often, but noticeable. Aside from that, this is a really spectacular rockin' album. Great mix of genres, great performances (the guitar work really hits a ton of different styles and techniques), and I feel like there's something else deeper going on here too- like I have no idea what "Pretzel Logic" even means. Great album cover. Composition wise it's great but I love the black and white and how the guy and his cart kind of blend into the nature behind him. If you squint it looks like some weird amorphous thing on one plane/layer. Also it's another great "moment in time" photo- which I've mentioned before on this list as something that I really enjoy.. like it stops me and makes me think "where is this guy now?".
I down with the Dan. Why don't people sell hot nuts and pretzels where I live. Still, I'm a man of a certain age and I've been swept up in yacht rock since those early YouTube days. And whether or not this album is on the boat, I'm all aboard for the smooth vibes. Four easy stars.
very solid. i think i prefer aja and can’t buy a thrill, but steely dan rarely disappoints.
Reminded me of my Mum's abusive boyfriend so it was a hard listen.
Much better than Coldplay
Love me some Steely Dan - this one is great, not quote their best. Few new tunes for me.
Obviously great musicians, but for me, it all comes out largely generic.
Highly killed musicians, but I can never help feeling, like with Coldplay, that if it wasn't for the voice, it's largely slightly bland and generic.
this album starts with the only steely dan song i know so i already at least kinda liked it immediately. i don't consider myself a fan of this brand of jazzy rock but it was a really fun and enjoyable listen. i may not have loved every song but i have nothing bad to say and i can imagine it was a blast to write and record. this is an easy 4 from me. album cover looks like danny devito. 4/5 where is his brother irony steve
as a Steely Dan Stan it’s really hard to not immediately give a 5 any time i see them show up in this exercise it’s just not as loaded as Can’t Buy a Thrill or Aja but it’s still a great album
THE DAN RIDES AGAIN!!! I love the Dan. Not my favorite of the Dan. Rikki don’t lose that number is a top five Dan though. When the Dan hits, it just hits. Not as strong as can’t buy a thrill but still the Dan continues to provide jams in only the way that the Dan can, bite sized morsels of incredibly tight pop jazz.
Another great Steely Dan album. Rikki don't lose that number is a fantastic song. The way the chorus develops halfway through is so good. Forgot all about this one. Night by Night is also a fun song. Very groovy. Barrytown is great once you get to the chorus. Pretzel Logic has a great blues vibe to it with great guitar. The composition in Charlie Freak is super unique with the arpeggiating piano lead. I don't know if this album is better than Can't Buy A Thrill, but these white bois certainly know how to catch a vibe. Strong 4/5
Is this better than the debut? Idk, but someone else could make that argument and they might not be wrong. I love the compact songs here - 11 songs 33 minutes that’s what I’m talking about. Favorites are Rikki Don’t lose that number, night by night, with a gun, and Charlie freak. Strong 4/5
This isn't quite where Can't Buy a Thrill was, but it's still a great album. Also my daughter loves Steely Dan and stops crying when I put them on so bonus points for that.
I like the style of music they play, like a mix of 70s easy rock and blues is a great combination. Unfortunately, it just seems to lack any real big songs, maybe just not great writing?
This is the sound of a suburban dad in socks and sandals and its fucking awesome
Never listened to this album by Steely Dan. It's so good! Instrumentally, they are one of my favorite artists. It's just produced so perfectly. An album i'll be coming back to for sure
Wow - this album is awesome. The instrumentation, the vocal performance and layering, the unique identity and sound, chord progressions... This is something I am really wanting to revisit. It gives off such a feel good vibe. I really had a hard time picking a favorite track - the opener is so killer and really sets the tone for the whole album. If I had to pick a favorite though it would be "Any Major Dude Will Tell You". The guitar riffs on that one feel almost nostalgic in a way. This is a classic - it has to be. I loved it all the way through. 5/5
Nice
It's good, a step back but i can see what they were going for. Would result in much better albums
I listened to this driving down a 2 lane road at sunset, surrounded by Joshua Trees, pink sky, orange hills. The vibes were right. Some interesting and unique arrangements. I like the country rock more than the jam band stuff.
Im not sure what to make of this. It was entirely bland. I listened twice and cant remember a single thing.
These guys suck
Music critics love Steely Dan and I'm paying the price. Rikki Don't Lose That Number is the hit off this album and maybe one of their biggest hits. Night By Night sounds like porn music. Any Major Dude Will Tell You is one of the stupidest titles of a song ever. This album may have launched easy listening as a genre. They say these guys aren't technically "yacht rock" but if that's the case I'm not sure what yacht rock is. These guys make The Eagles look like Megadeth. East St. Louis Toodle-Oo is terrible, Walter Becker and Donald Fagan are the most fart-sniffingly pretentious "rock" musicians ever. They want to travel the Southland in a traveling minstrel show? Maybe they could play East St. Louis Toodle-Oo?!? This album is short and feels like it goes on forever. Rock musicians, but particularly rock musicians I don't like, love cowboy themed music.
On paper this album has things I should love - great musicianship, varied tones and styles - but it just felt empty. There's very little emotion or feel behind any of this, it's just bland musak for yachts.
There a couple of tracks on this album that I really like, but most of it is a bit too vanilla for me. I don't think I would seek the album out again, but certainly wouldn't mind if somebody twisted my arm to give it another listen.
5.5/10 Inoffensive and not particularly exciting, but the execution is very good I suppose. Highlights Barrytown
Classique depuis 2011
Fun! Not as refined as aja
Favourite tracks: Any Major Dude Will Tell You Barrytown Parker's Band
3.5/5. Sometimes I am simply not white nor old enough.
Prior to Steely Dan, Fagan and Becker were in a band called Leather Canary. Guess who played drums in that band? Chevy Chase. I've heard that Chevy is a dick in real life... It's a shame he wasn't in this iteration of the band that put out this album. It feels like It could use a bit of the rough. WTF is this toodle-oo bullshit?
This album was a pleasure to listen to. It was easy listening and relaxing, so I’m sure I’ll revisit. I liked the instrumentation. I did have it on whilst not giving it my full attention in the car. I had a sense it was stronger in the first half but that may be because I was listening more intently then. Either way I enjoyed :)
Fine. Great cover, interesting at times, pretty unremarkable otherwise.
Now I get what yacht rock is.
I'm always down to listen to some Steely Dan. Almost all of their albums contain high quality music. This album makes me think of Fleetwood Mac and everything that's good about the soft rock from the 70s. 4 stars
Heerlijk
Ok
Really fun album full of funky/jazzy/rock tracks that as a whole are unique, but retain trademark Steely Dan sound. First half is full of feel good(ish) tunes that make for easy listening, back half is cooler and darker with creative and cryptic lyricism and storytelling. Fav track: Rikki Don’t Lose That Number
This album has elements that I'd typically like quite a bit. 70s rock with variety in sound, pretty solid songwriting, cool instrumentation, cool guitar tones in certain songs, and some jammy elements, but I just really couldn't get into it. I've never been against Steely Dan, but I just haven't really been able to connect with it.
This was fun. Cool fusions of sounds. Jazz, psych, soul, rock. I enjoyed this!
Enjoyed it. Apparently was their third album that started their studio perfectionism. Didn’t perform publicly after this album for decades. Overall kind of saying they’re done with the past and they want to move forward on their own terms.
Don't lose that number ... ganz nett sonst
There’s no doubt this belongs on this list. I don’t need to love it to respect it.
Nice easy listening album.
Rating: 3/5 | Favorite Track: Night By Night --- Eh, it’s fine. None of the tracks really stood out to me with the sole of exception of the funk rock of Night By Night. I just get quite bored by this safe sounding jazz rock and blues rock.
Pitam se koliko puta mogu poslušati ovaj album 🤣 a što ga više slušam, više petica bih mu dala. Ovo je bez dvojbe petica!!! U mojih sigurno top 15, a vjerojatno i top 10 albuma. 5/5, 10/10
I like steely Dan.
2.5
3.5
7/10 Enjoyed the first couple songs, got a little repetitive
I'm down for any Steely Dan album, anytime. Listening to this reminded me of how much an old boyfriend of mine loved the tune "Night by Night." And this is probably the only "rock" album to include a Duke Ellington tune.
Starts strong but meanders through the middle.
The definition of a pleasant listen. Nothing all that special but it has a nice vibe to it.
Good record
I really just can't get enough Steely Dan. Not my favorite album of theirs, but still a really good album.
Loved this.
Really great, very easy to listen to
Generic rock. Won't listen again
Maybe my vibes were off but I couldn’t even make it through this one. Headache? It’s lame dad music from 1985.
Listened behind the desk at work, fun tunes but not so memorable
The grooves are pretty good. The singing is little cheesy. And the lyrics are about nothing. I recognize the musical ability of this band, but they consistently fail to evoke any emotion from me. Just not my thing I guess.
Un mix folk/jazz/rock pas inintéressant du tout. -1 pour la voix reloue du chanteur.
Fun album and funky
Good rock album, but I can't really say anything more. There's nothing that was outstanding for me, just some old regular rock songs
Bro why are all steely Dan albums ever made on this fucking list, they’re all the same
A very strong album musically, lyrics are a little out there on some of the songs but overall a very good album. Instrumentally, the guitars, saxophone and keys were extremely strong, I liked listening to this.
Kinda looses it's way half way through. Maybe more of a 3.5.
Rags to time
im not usually a fan of old rock but damnnnnn this album is a vibe! i liked it so much i put it on to go to sleep, so that’s pretty awesome
17/03/25 Steely Dan has to be one of my best finds on this so far.
Great classic.
If I’d have been around when this first came out I’m sure I would have popped my puss to this. Liked some of the instrumental bits. Kind of feels like an album a fictitious band in a film would make, to me. Overall not for me
Think I preferred Can't Buy a Thrill. I could be completely talking out of my arse and displaying my ignorance but this does feel really similar. It's still cool, I just didn't find find it as strong and there isn't as much that feels as stand out as that album. The big exception is Monkey in Your Soul, which has cool dirty bass contrasted with the smooth and sleek organ East St. Louis Toodle-Oo feels kind of disruptive, felt like a daft little thing that kind of interrupted the flow of the album and stood out slightly awkwardly Another thing that wasn't a deal breaker but did mildly bother me was the thought that this is kind of too perfect. I never thought that with Can't Buy a Thrill, but the sleek production and flawless performances did weirdly (and very mildly) frustrate me. A weird point, not entirely sure what I'm trying to say I could see myself moving to a 3, but I'll say it's a good 3.5 and give it 4 Highlights: Monkey In Your Soul
Keep on reeling
lo amo anche solo per il titolo
"Pretzel Logic" is a return to a more structured, concise, and intricate song structure, contrasting with the extended instrumental jam-like pieces that characterized their previous album, "Countdown to Ecstasy." The tracks on this album are skillfully blended with jazz elements and catchy pop hooks, while maintaining a sense of cohesion throughout the album. The lyrics are a a blend of darkness, humor, and irony, while the band's signature perfectionism and meticulous attention to detail remain evident. In addition to hit track "Rikki Don't Lose That Number," notable songs include "Any Major Dude Will Tell You" and "Barrytown." "Pretzel Logic" is arguably Steely Dan's best album and appears to be a turning point for the direction of future albums. Overall, the album feels like a fun Late night FM radio experience. (Not quite a 4 star, sitting closer to a 3+)
Passa una cosa amb aquest àlbum: està en aquella franja estètica dels 70 on estaven a punt de parir el so dels 80 i tot plegat és francament horripilant. Vist en perspectiva sembla paròdic, i no ho és, però alhora és injust jutjar-ho per això. Seria valorar-ne la qualitat amb un presentisme poc honest. Deixem-ho en que destila talent, originalitat, diversió i cursileria. Hi falta la força que sí hi ha en títols més depurats de Steely Dan.
This was fun! A bit short, which is a shame. But I really enjoy led this one - nice instrumentals and fitting vocal work. 'Night By Night' was my fave.
Not the biggest Steely Dan but I’ve listened to their full 1970’s catalog over the years. In my opinion, this album is not better than Royal Scam, Aja or Cant Buy This Thrill - those are all 4-Stars for me. I do appreciate the Beckett/Fagan contribution to music. They write interesting music combining some cool Jazz, R&B, Funk and Rock elements. Lyrical compositions are very solid. I have to be in the right mood to listen to Steely Dan - they are not a band I can listen to over and over.
Stupid fucking computer
'We hear you're leavin', that's okay.' That's Donald Fagen's entry point into this record, to whom I'd like to say: 'don't worry, no one is leaving just yet. It's only just begun.' It's a good thing I didn't leave, b/c I'd have neglected a singular album due to my suspicion of its neatness and sterility. But by the time they cover Duke and then pay homage to Bird, I was all the way in. If it ever feels too smooth for school, just remind yourself of what any major dude'd tell you: 'Any minor world that breaks apart falls together again.' Tho they may hide it, for all the best reasons, Steely Dan is always breaking apart and falling together: too weird to be entirely on kilter. 'Won't you turn that bebop down.' I will not. Nor will I quit this rugged tidiness.
Pleasant surprise, I'm slowly becoming aware of my transition into a yacht-rock aficionado.
Now HERE'S something I can wag my finger to!
Not a strong steely dan fan and not a strong steely dan album.
Well now, that's a massive improvement on the last offering from this lot. I'm coming to the understanding that although I can appreciate the prog that is jazz based, I just don't do other jazz based music. And a fair chunk of this album was more blues based than jazz. And that is why I preferred it. Ricky is one of their classics, and it makes me think if I were to buy any of their albums it would be a best of. There were some really bright spots in this, and it was a massive improvement, a 💯 % improvement to be honest so it's getting a 2
I know there’s some randomness in the daily selection, but 3 Steely Dan/Donald Fagan albums in such quick succession could create civil unrest. So so bad.
Steely Dan appear to be the Black Hole of music. Into the event horizon disappears this bands’ and their merry gathering of session musicians’ credibility, whilst sucking the enjoyment of music out of people. If I was talking literally, that this Black Hole was a real thing, and it were even possible to escape an object like this, Steely Dan and their session musos would be propelled into the far future. This monstrous group would then be able unleash more shit like this on my descendants. In this strange scenario of my own making, before these musicians return, I would now be hoping Earth will be hit by a nine and a half mile wide asteroid* to save others from this beige misery. *An object somewhere between 8-9 miles would be of a sufficient size to destroy all life on Earth, but it is best to make sure there is no margin for error when the stakes are this high.
While I do love the tight harmonies on the title track, the rest of it is a bit too easy listening (read: hokey) for me. Unfortunately, I have an inexplicably intense dislike for "Rikki Don't Lose that Number."
east st. louis toodle-oo is so silly and goofy 🪿🪿🪿 i loved parker's band it was funky as HELL charlie freak has very interesting instrumentation what the hell is that lil buggy buzzy sound i feel as if im listening to a fairytale or a sea shanty and this song sounds so fresh even though it's 51 years old holy shit overall a rly good album, deffo not something I'd go back to because this type of music isn't my go to but it's deffo an album I'd blast during a road trip i appreciate the craftsmanship and the musical choices they made and i completely understand why it was critically acclaimed but yeah not something I'd blast in my day to day life
Rikki Don't Lose That Number 4 Night by Night 3.7 Any Major Dude Will Tell You 3.4 Barrytown 3.6 East St. Louis Toodle-Oo 3 Parker's Band 3.4 Through with Buzz 3.3 Pretzel Logic 3.5 With a Gun 3.4 Charlie Freak 3.6 Monkey in Your Soul 3.7 Score: 3.509090909
Does nothing for me. Just boring music to me. I don't hate it. Don't lose this number is okay, but possibly only because of its familiarity from radio play. Nothing else stood out to me in anyway
I love steely dan
ik denk toch wel dat dit album het meest tot zn recht komt als mn vader het aanzet op de platenspeler en gaat dansen
barrytown strong 💪
would vote 3.5. It's very good, maybe just not as much to my taste
Pleasantly surprised! again, it’s not something I’ll return to often but the album has a great sound and it was a fun listen
Ultimate Dad rock. Easy to listen to and good to put on any time you need something light.
Another approach to Steely Dan. This one is less polished and a bit more interesting than Aja. Still, I feel like I'm listening to a masturbation contest. Not for me, but slightly better than Aja. 2.5/5
A fine addition in terms of production and generally solid songwriting but nothing feels as good as from their other works like deacon blues, or reelin' in the years. The playing is there and it's nice to have on in the background but just not as memorable.
Eerste album met Michael McDonald en Jeff Porcaro. "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" de directe earcatcher. "Night by Night" mega tasty met een lekkere solo. "Any Major Dude" leuk riedeltje, maar meh. "Barrytown" beetje 70s Springsteen. "East St. Louis toodle-oo" blijk ik te kennen, vanwege het wauwelende deuntje dat gebruikt is in een reclame (?). Cover van Duke Ellington. Rare eend in de bijt. Wel tof. "Parker's Band", leuke uptempo rocker. Niet heel memorabel. "Through with Buzz" is heel kort en niet heel boeiend. "Pretzel Logic" is bluesy en heeft te gekke vocale partijen. Heel gelaagd. Toffe blues solo.
i like pretzels
They're very good at their instruments I just don't like the genre they like to play But I didn't think i would ever give a Steely Dan or Steely Dan-adjacent album more than a two, and here it is at three?
Not a fan of this music. It really just bores me.
Luv Steely Dan. Simple as. 'Night by night' and 'Pretzel logic' are highlights even if it doesn't reach the heights of Can't buy a thrill and Aja
This album gives great examples of Steely Dan's pure and effortless mastery of music and their instruments. This was great to jam along to on guitar as well. It's not as interesting as the other Steely Dan albums I have listened to. Apparently, they were going for a slightly more pop-friendly track listing.
I think I’m down with the Dan, bro
Other Steely Dan albums didn't click with me until a few listens, perhaps this will end up the same. The highs of Aja and the Royal Scam aren't reached here. "Rikki don't lose that number" might be one of their biggest hits, but it's dishwater dull.
Going into this I've listened to it before but I only really know Riki and Any Major Dude. One listen never really does a Steely Dan album justice, almost every song is dense with layers without being overwhelming but it means that a lot is gained by focusing on each instrument after listening to how they work with each other. It's still not beating Aja for my favourite Dan record but that also took a few listens to love. The mid section of Pretzel isn't my favourite but I'll give it a few more listens and who knows. Highlight: Riki Don't Lose That Number
It’s okay. I don’t actively dislike Steely Dan, but I’m never really moved by their music, either. Charlie Freak 2.5
First three all heat
omg I have one song from this saved which is the most streamed one.
Such dad rock. I do like some Steely Dan, but this album I don't like as much as the others.
Good. Down home-y vibes
You can definitely feel them starting to head in the funky direction - and i say that in the best way possible. Rikki is a classic, any major dude is of course a crowd favorite. But the self-titled track is probably my favorite on here. So blues and groovy. Can't buy a thrill is still probably my favorite, AJA a very close second. Then Pretzel Logic. Such a great band - always so so so tight. Idk how people don't like SD - it makes no sense to me
Actually acceptable and not as bad as Aja which made me want to not have ears.
I know several Steely Dan songs but this was my first album! This was a very chill, very enjoyable listen. I love how cleanly they harmonize, and they're a great bunch of musicians. Standouts for me are Rikki Don't Lose That Number, the title track, and Charlie Freak.
A 7. Now I fear the monkeys in other people's soul.
Great record. I love everything they have ever recorded, including Fagen’s The Nightfly album.
It's a shame this album had to compete with the release of Sam Fender's new album People Watching (5/5), otherwise I may have given this album some more attention. It was still an enjoyable playthrough that surprised me a bit, as someone who likes Steely Dan, but historically only a few songs.
Here I am, 42 years old, listening to Steely Dan. The conversion to midlife is complete.
Enjoyed. 4/5
"Rikki Don't Lose That Number". Classic. Skipped through the rest of the album. 3 stars.
First time listening to this album, but the third one from Steely Dan that i'm listening to. It was quite good. Think i prefer both "Aja" and "Can't Buy A Thrill" over this one though.
From what I’ve heard from Steely Dan, I like “Can’t Buy A Thrill” more. Still, nothing wrong with this: very chill and laid back, jazzy feel. 3/5 rounded up. Favourite tracks: Ricky Don’t Lose That Number, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, Pretzel Logic, Monkey In Your Soul
"Pretzel Logic", what does that mean? I can't do anything with it and I come from the land of real 'pretzels' but of course it fits perfectly with "Steely Dan" the band name is just as stupid. OK, 'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' is a catchy song. The rest, however, is not my thing. But I must also say, I like Donald Fagen's voice, it really has a good feel. The guitar, on the other hand, annoys me. As a fan of jazz-rock, fusion, I don't know if I should really put this album in that category, but the whole thing is also very diverse. So OK, 2.5 stars for "Brezel Logik", rounded off to 2. The rest of the album is really boring.
3.5
I think this lackluster score more so reflects my lack of appreciation and understanding of this era of music. I hope to one day be able to appreciate this album. Though there was quite a wide range and diverse sounds explored.
One of my favourite Dan albums, especially with "Rikki" and "Any Major Dude".
At best, dentist office soft rock. At worst, East St. Louis Toodle-Oo.
This project has made me a Steely Dan fan. Amazing!
ok literally so fun, maybe one of my favorite albums from this project yet. steely dan is cool . 4/5
Ihan passelia musisointia, paria kappaletta voisi kuunnella enemmänkin. Ok.
Thumbs UP! Good stuff.
Easy flowing and lovely music. Always had a special place in my heart for Steely Dan mainly because my favorite artist, MF Doom sampled them so much. This record is sequenced and mastered so beautifully, it’s so easy on the ears. Nice one.
I see a lot of what I presume is Americans bemoan the amount of dull British bands on here. Although there may be a hint of truth to their complaints, let Steely Dan show the US is not immune to producing inexplicably popular dullards like Steely Dan. 2*
Якщо на перших двох альбомах - Can't Buy a Thrill та Countdown to Ecstasy гурт Steely Dan тільки формували свій унікальний #jazzrock -овий саунд, що виділявся просто заворожуючим інструменталом та блискучим продакшеном. То вже по першій пісні Rikki Don't Lose That Number стає зрозуміло, що Pretzel Logic буде більш "поп орієнтованим", "м'яким" та чіловим. Альбом буквально просякнутий літнім настроєм та немов "випромінює помаранчеве сяйво каліфорнійськийського сонця". Найбільш визначною рисою цієї роботи, я вважаю його неймовірно крутий продакшн. Завдяки якому, доволі "насичені" інструментальні партії, що могли б легко перетворитись у "претензійний" прогрессів рок, відчуваються доступними та не виходять за рамки "поп звучання". І далі, Steely Dan будуть тільки покращувати свій скіл у створенні складної та цікавої, але в той самий момент, "легкої" та розслабляючої музики, піком якого, безумовно, стане їх #yachtrock шедевр - Aja (1977).
Heard a different Steely Dan album before. With this one I'm conflicted. On the one hand no songs really stood out to me. On the other I kinda liked the album? Something intriguing about it 3/5
Some fun songs but they're mocked by George Carlin for a reason.
Entertaining throughout, though perhaps with no true headliners. But very consistent and enjoyable.
This album must have been one of the last four in.
Album cover is so hard and the album doesn’t quite reach its level. But the music is still good enough for an enjoyable album!
Fun and groovy, nothing much else
I feel like I rate a lot of albums here 2 or 3 since must don't leave a big impression on me. Same goes for this one, it wasn't bad at all it was actually quite enjoyable, however it is nothing special really. I will give it a weak 3 star rating.
For me this album starts and ends after the first song. Sorry Rikki, but 2 stars or D is my ratiing.
What a great album, the instrumentation is marvelous: very virtuosistic, but not flashy at all, always serving the song. Great songs, some very catchy, great riffs, an awesome album.
Pretty fantastic - haven't heard it before, other than Rikki of course. I think here they pull off the type of album a lot of other bands aspire to. Note also that my hipster 18 y.o. son has a weird liking for these guys.
Really interesting, I quite liked it
Good tones and enjoyable listen but not for me, it lacks something - perhaps the vocals? 4.6/10.
Pretzel + a biracial rapper??
Me like steely dan. 4.5 stars
Love Steely Dan
003.Pretzel Logic; Steely Dan -not much has changed in society's attitudes since this was made, unfortunately. -Timely.
"Rikki" is a pretty solid groove if you wish Wings was meaner. "Night by Night" is for people who wish Wings wasn't so funky. "Any Major Dude" is the about the eighth best Wings song ever. The rest of the album is on par with Wings' Venus and Mars. If comparing Steely Dan to Wings doesn't reduce your Dannist adversary to a stutter, substitute Styx in there.
Spent the listen clocking samples pulled for other songs and Michael McDonald's backing vocals. [This is fine]
Wait... do... do I maybe LIKE Steely Dan? Am I unhip? I'd only ever heard about Steely Dan as a) the butt of a joke or b) that noodly band that only uncool dads like. I was surprisingly into this and I don't know what to make of that.
I love a half-hour album.... but I didn't love this one.
I'm not the biggest Steely Dan fan, but I feel like their earlier stuff was edgier, their later stuff was smoother, and this just missed.
Okay I do not like this bandbut this was not as terrible as I thought it would be. I really liked the east st Louis instrumental. 3 more SD lps on this list, ugh.
I'm a 50+ year old dad. Of course I have this album. I think we all get the Steely Dan discography when we turn 50. Sort of like getting your first AARPA invitation. I assume this is on the list mainly because the author was also a 50+ dad. 3 stars = 1 for being Steely Dan, 1 for being a passable album cover (something Steely Dan seems to have struggled with) and 1 for me being over 50.
Выпал действительно их хороший альбом
Я остался доволен прослушиванием альбома Steely Dan «Pretzel Logic». Музыка этой группы сочетает в себе элементы джаза, рока и соула, что делает её уникальной и запоминающейся. Тексты песен также заслуживают внимания — они полны иронии и юмора. Оцениваю на 4 из 5.
Not as good as Aja, but my second favorite album of theirs that I’ve listened to.
Guess they never miss huh
Brilliant album. Played it three times today. I’m loving discovering acts like this that I had never heard of.
GOAT
Pretty good 70s grooves. Made me listen to the Dan the rest of the day.
Not my favourite Steely Dan album, in fact I would probably rank it lowest of their '70s output. Of course, that doesn't mean that it is a bad album; it is a very good if transitional one, and the guitar solo on "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" is worth the price of admission alone. Like all Dan records, it is incredibly well played, produced and arranged and there are pointers here to later LPs which I play more often; the direct steal from Horace Silver on Rikki teases the jazzier direction. This is probably the point where Steely Dan gave up any pretence of being a 'band' and became a two-man project which strove for perfection by hiring the best session players for each track.
Listening to this album was like having someone in “The Friend Zone.” You really like this person and quite enjoy their company. But there’s just something you can’t quite put your finger on that you don’t want to bang them. Same with this album. Just couldn’t quite say I loved it, but has potential with a re-listen.
Not as good as Aja, but still a solid listen. 3.5
Just didn’t really stand out to me. Very few songs that I think I’d come back to
Steely Dan is just all right for me. I don't mind listening to it but their music never sticks.
Boring dad rock
My first time hearing Steely Dan and it wasn't bad. There are elements of rock, blues, jazz and pop mixed in. I also like the mix of instrumentation and the clean production.
A curious listen indeed: I've only heard the album once, years ago, yet so much of it was so familiar. First 4 tracks were splendid to hear, and there were a few later cuts I really dug as well. Only one I didn't care for was East St. Louis Toodle-Oo, bit too silly for my taste. Generally great outing from Dan though, not my fav of theirs but it's a great entry nonetheless.
Varför lyssnar jag aldrig på Steely Dan. Så bra! Fyra plus.
Fine
Boring
Strange collection of songs - some that define the Dan (gonna try to make this abbrevation work) sound, and some others that sound heavily influenced by their contemporaries (Zappa, CSN, Big Star). Probably a 5 by almost any other abnds standards, but I think feels like a 4 by Dan's standards, still trying to find their sound, breaking away from the down the middle classic rock. I think Dan might be America's greatest band?
Very good but not their best. Love any major dude and Barry town, but the rest of the album feels a little rote compared to the highs they hit on Can’t Buy a Thrill and Aja. I think they are leaning a little closer to blues on this album, but they are at their best and most unique when combining rock and jazz
Super happy that we got this! Ive hit SD a few times in my life without it sparking a deep dive. The experience so far with Cant Catch A Thrill and Aja is mostly stuff that ive heard at least once PL was a fun middle ground (literally came out in between Aja and Cant Catch) and almost completely new to me. From what I read, this was the bands final album that they would go on tour with. Night By Night wouldve been awesome to hear live. Also, during my reading, it seemed like this was a “comeback album” from their second album flop…. Wait… I loved some tracks off of their second album - Countdown to ecstasy. My Old School is an all timer. Why the hate? My review for PL may sound harsh, but Ill still give 4.25 stars on this The first 8 tracks are all killers. We get a radio hit (Ricky), Parkers Band, Pretzel Logic, Night by Night, Any major dude and whatever east saint louis was 😆 (okay, wasnt a huge fan of that, but it was fun for one play) The last 3 tracks were lacking for me. With a gun sounded like a white album rip off. Charlie Freak’s piano was annoying to me. Monkey in your soul didnt appeal to me due to its simplicity
Love this album. Lotta weird songs on here. Such specific weird characters in every song. Not one of my favorite Steely Dan albums but still a real good one
Very different from the later albums we’ve gotten so far, but still a great one. A little more accessible, less jazzy, but can’t knock them for that. Skunk still rips some unexpected lines on a lot of these. Major Dude is in the running for favorite Dan song, also loved Parker’s Band.
Nice jams
It's fine. 2.5
Night by Night and Any Major Dude are two of my SD favs....know the album intimately.
Very Fun album
Funky album. Enjoyed listening to it. Doubt I'll listen again
I’m a sucker for this genre.
Not quite the genre for me
OK? That was really my overriding thought listening to this album; one of the only thoughts I had, actually. I mean, it’s alright. It was what it was. But I instantly forgot it as soon as I listened to it. To summarise, it’s the kind of album you’d see someone’s dad clicking their fingers to and saying “I remember when I was a lad…” and that’s just not my thing. And I love 70’s music. It didn't even have Dirty Work on it, so I couldn't even have my Tony Soprano moment when I listened to it in the car, which left me infinitely more disappointed than I already was with this album.
Third Steely Dan album I’ve had. Already had Aja which I guess is their most famous. First thing which came into my head when I began listening was the long hot summers in the UK mid 1970’s. Then checked my notes of the first two SD albums I reviewed and saw that I said the same thing about them. So that’s final then. Steely Dan records are meant to be played on long hot summer afternoons with tequila cocktail in hand. In my book that’s a win. 3/5 31/1/25
#484. After the first song it gets a bit uninteresting. 3/5: grandma rock Song added to playlist: Rikki Don't Lose That Number I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link
3.5
Rock with hints of jazz and fun guitar licks. Would recommend giving a listen.
Sounded very generic to be honest, and like it should be background music. I appreciate songs that are story-like in their lyrics but I don’t feel it’s done well here, and there are so many better examples of this genre.
definitely steely dan
I thought they were folk/bluegrass, but was pleasantly surprised they were more jazzy. Nice!
High school days staple, overplayed tho
great instrumentals and easy listening but idk I found it overall very forgettable
Logic indicates that these pretzels... are making me thirsty! But, in all seriousness, Pretzel Logic represents the end of an era for Steely Dan as they would eschew the now profitable and necessary touring circuit for the comfort of the world building recording studio, thus beginning a time in their career that they'd be most well known for. And it starts with this album, a half-hour run-through of pop and rock infusions with jazz that provides the bedrock for the trademark lurid lyricism of Donald Fagen. Pretzel Logic doesn't look like much when it compared to other Steely Dan records but it holds its own just fine. Favorites: Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Night by Night, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, Barrytown, East St. Louis Toodle-Oo, Parker's Band, Pretzel Logic.
Solid musicianship if not the most exciting ever
Almost the very definition of mid. Not sure about including 4 SD albums on this list although the snippets I heard from other albums suggests something a little better May lie ahead. Expecting more from a Band named after a Dildo in a Burroughs book, though...
Mid 70’s mediocrity. Opening track is the strongest and is the one everyone knows. Had promise but just turned into a sea of “meh”
Easy listening.
Yacht Rock supreme. Chill vibes and fun listen, yet nothing special.
3.5
Overall a pretty pleasant listen! I knew of "Ricky Don't Lose That Number" of course but I never thought I enjoyed that song. Listening to it again I thought it was catchy and enjoyed the album overall. I think I'll go with a 3.
A couple good songs, but not even close to their best stuff.
the original, always liked this one
Really enjoyed this. Heard it’s influence on a lot of songs, heaps of vulfpeck/side project stuff. Catchy moments, great songwriting and production. On extra listening, I liked it even more, good stuff.
It's alright and I agree with the general opinion that it's by no means revolutionary when listening here in 2025. But I can definitely see the unique project and a great album in the 70's. Pretty cool with the Jazz inspired piece in the middle.
почему опять....
Mid. Not great but not unlistenable either. Favourite track: East St Louis Toodle-oo
Surprised by this one. I only preciously knew the Rikki song but the whole album has a great 70s rocky jazzy super bluesy sound. Very nice.
i liked this album kind of a soulful soft rock, opening song was my favourite. a nice mix of instrumentals, rhythm and lyrics- would like to listen to more steely dan
Rikki Don't Lose That Number Barrytown East St.Louis Toddle-Oo Pretzel Logic
legalzinho, fiquei com a sensação de ser um rock meio genérico daquela época; ainda assim é bom, gostoso de ouvir, teria que prestar mais atenção na letra para saber se tem algo que o torna mais especial
Some of these melodies are Beatles songs, right? Barrytown for sure … but which one…
I tried but only made it to track two.
Another fun album with a good variety of style and music. I am still a Steely Fan!
Not nearly as clever as they think they are.
There were elements of this album that I liked better than Aja. But those elements didn’t last long enough for me to say I enjoy Steely Dan.
I’m understanding and respecting these sophisticated compositions more in my older years. The jazz within is quite good.
I still don't really like Steely Dan but I appreciate their music. The Toodle-Oo song was great. I'd listen to them more if they did more songs like that.
I'm not sure what's happened to me, but I think I enjoyed a Steely Dan album. I'm typically indifferent. 3.5* rounding up? I guess?
Inoffensive middle-aged dad rock. And there’s absolutely nothing wrong with that if that’s your thing. Sometimes though you just need a bit of excitement in your life to feel young again. Didn’t get that here though, just quite dull.
More middle of the road 70s dullness that this list laughable calls rock!?!
Really struggling to compute (from reading about them) why this was considered in any way innovative and ground breaking. Just very very dull. Saved from a 1* by a couple of half decent tracks towards the end.
Pleasant surprise!
Way to go for dissing East St. Louis
4.5 great album. Favorite songs: Rikki don’t lose that number and Any major dude will tell you