Reviews (page 12 of 14)
I remember buying this record on vinyl and let me tell you what a great idea they was. Amazing album
The best.
Kan fint ha da i bakgrunnen, men går bra å fyra nåke anna i stedet
van sommige album vraag je je af waarom ze in de top 1001 staan. Van dit album hoor je gelijk waarom het in de top behoort.
Eerder geluisterd en natuurlijk een tragische antiheld dus extra interessant
Beautiful voice, soulful stories sung through music.
the best
I love it except for the simultaneous vocal takes. The instrumentation and concept is amazing though.
Good
Yea
Solid. The cover is awwwesome. why is he singing about god doe
Gorgeous.
Beautiful sounds on this album, the vocals, the bass sounds and bass tones almost pushed this album to be my first 5 Star. This album yet sorrowful still grooves. Songs bleed into eachother artfully with consistently beatufiul instrumentations and compositions to make this album so cohesive and epic. For me this is a super strong 4, almost my first 5 Star Rating.
he sounds beautiful
Tight. Inner city holler!
this album really only has two good songs on it i mean they are realllly good songs i really like those songs
Great
Ok, don’t really need to listen to this one as it is already one of my favorite all time albums by probably my all time favorite singer.
Deep Lyrics
Weirdly, the album that I have been thinking about most while listening to this one is Rage Against the Machine's first album. They aren't similar at all sonicly, but RATM's first album is one of those that I think could have been released at any point since it first dropped and it would have still been considered a mind-blwoing accomplishment. This album is another one. If Marvin Gaye released it this year, I still feel like this album would have a huge impact. It's so excuisite, meticulously produced, and yet it doesn't sound constrained at all. It's beautiful and thoughtful, sensitive yet confident in itself. It is a perfect album, the kind that you wait for it to finish so that you can start back at the beginning and experience it all over again 5/5
Unreal gem
One of my top albums of ALLLLLLL TIME‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️ it’s simply perfection even the wailing SAVE THE BABIES yes we should!!!
Knew him before. Like hist style! personal top3 in no order: What‘s Happening Brother Right On Wholy Holy
Klassiker! Tolles Album. 6.5/10
Rhythm section is insane. Crystal clear vocals. Marvin has a silky voice. Consistent themes and has something to say. Save the Children is amazing. Nice building string section. Love the consistent tempo. Lack of variety at times. Mercy mercy me is great. Very soulful. Really like it but don't absolutely love it. 4 for me! Breakdown on Right On is sick.
3.5
Considered a classic and masterpiece, I was left a little disappointed by this album. It's nice enough but didn't strike a chord with me at all. Rating: 2.5/5 Playlist track: What's Going On Date listened: 20/01/24
I'm not sure I can describe why I don't love this album. It's "nice", but overall too smooth for me. I will say it flows very nicely.
taste is most certainly objective but anyone who tries to tell you this is not the greatest album in history is a contrarian and a liar and they’re not your friend
I land somewhere between you two on this one. What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues are top tier soul classics, but they’re the tent poles that hold this up when in starts to drag. The arrangements are great, and the recurring motifs do make this feel like a concept album rather than a collection of tracks, but it starts to wear thin at times, like he’s just scatting new lyrics over the same backing music. Lyrically it’s of its time (Viet Nam, ecological worries, racism) but it tips into self-parody in places. A three-star, mainly on the strength of those three classic tracks.
What’s Going On I remember buying it at Durham and liking it, but not really understanding why everyone thought it was so great. Listening as an older person with hopefully more of an appreciation of different types of music and more of an understanding of the lyrical and thematic scope, I can really understand how good it is. It really is fantastic. The songs are great, the sequencing, the themes and motifs slipping in and out. I love the sound, particularly the bass as the lead melodic instrument working with the string arrangements. And Marvin’s voice is just so so good, that mellow, mellifluous tone contrasting with the anger in the lyrics. When I was 20, it probably would have been 3 or 4 but I’m going to give it 5 now. I do really think it’s up there with the best albums ever recorded. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Great singing, great song flow. The bass playing is wild, just wild, a masterpiece in how much weird chromatic stuff you can do without distracting from the rest of the song. This is a rarity for me, an album I think is top tier without songs that have a huge draw individually. I suspect this is the strings & stuff smoothing over the dynamic changes I want to hear - which are there, all over - and I'd like individual songs a lot if it was more sparse. I found the Detroit Mix and that's still not quite it, I want even less stuff. I want to hear the bit of drum rattle & room reverberation at every little stop, ex. Marion Black's "Who Knows". I will admit this is perhaps absurd. music: appreciated. (⌐o_o)
How could someone possibly make something so beautiful as this. 5.5⭐️
A classic
There’s a reason it tops Rolling Stones albums list. Also the Dolby Atmos mix on Apple Music sounds incredible
Very cool
Who doesn't love Marvin? Smooth. Great lyrics. Interesting melodies, beats, mix. Never get tired of listening.
The best opening track that the rest never quite match, great album overall
Album flows so incredibly well. His voice is just amazing. Iconic album that could've been recorded today and would still sound fresh. Don't think I'll ever live down the way I treated it in educating, don't know what I was thinking. This is a perfect album.
ein/zwei gute Tracks, Rest so lala
Always a favorite. His talent was amazing
Great voice and song writing, just not my preferred style of music.
Música blues-chill.
It's a classic, just notcreally my thing. The voice is impeccable, and there are some great songs, but as a whole it's ... OK. I won't seek it out, but I also wouldn't turn it off.
"Father, father. We don't need to escalate. You see, war is not the answer for only love can conquer hate." What's Going On is the best Marvin Gaye song and generally one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard, both lyrically and sonically. Best Song: What's Going On Worst Song: N/A PS: Mercy Mercy Me is also fantastic song
Hey yo Marvin Gaye, what the fuck is going on? Love your brothers like Marvin does 🫰 P.S. +⭐️ for the Let's Get It On album
Cada vez disfruto más de los álbumes souleros y funky. Empezó fuerte, pero no terminó de mantener el hype.
Fantastic. A collection of smooth, soulful anthems with excellent singing and percussion in particular. This album contains classics like Mercy Mercy Me and the warm-yet-earth-shattering What's Going On, but also some excellent deeper cuts such as Flyin' High, Right On, and Wholy Holy. There are no duds, and Marvin Gaye is clearly confident in this style of music. It's also such a non-grating, relistenable genre that you can't help but adore it. The transitions between tracks are smooth and unforced. Add to that the groundbreaking impact this album had at the time of release, and the clear-cut, powerful messages passionately laid bare within the music, and you have an all-time classic. Easily 5/5.
Iconic. Pantheon. Epic. Vital.
Strong political statments. The ecology is goated
Marvin Gaye's album "What's Going On?" from 1971 stands as a poignant reflection of its turbulent times. Marvin Gaye, often described as "The Prince of Soul," presents a paradoxical figure, embodying both profound musical talent and personal flaws (honestly, Google it - you'll be surprised, and not in a good way.) Despite being a complex personality, his voice remains a captivating force, and the album showcases his bold departure from the Motown hit-making formula, delving into pressing social issues of the era. As a fan of Motown and Marvin Gaye's distinctive vocals, I appreciate the artistic risk he took in shedding light on societal problems that many preferred to avoid. The mellow '70s vibe and the fusion of funky bass and soulful vocals create an immersive experience. While universally acclaimed for its unembellished truth and the lens it provides into America in 1971, I find myself viewing this iconic album as just okay, acknowledging its significance while not entirely resonating with its widespread praise.
duplicate
All very lovely songs, "Mercy Mercy Me" is the most powerful and my favorite.
I don't dislike it but it's just not for me.
review notes lost to browser restart :( This is a perennial favorite for many reasons. 5.
I have to force myself to make it through this album, not because it's poor but because it seems to be the same song again and again. All very similar sounding tracks. But making the effort does pay off, his vocals are as plaintive and angelic as you'd expect, and the over-reaching sense of hopelessness and futility in a world going off the rails is annoyingly still pretty relevant. A benchmark album in terms of creative freedom and political awareness... just maybe not quite the musical epic it is made out to be.
This album flows. Without eyeing the track list its tracking is almost imperceptible. Message, influence, motivation and social impact are all there. He’s vocally sublime with layering from voices to street sounds and constant audio barrage. One of the greats when it comes to COMPLETE album production.
What a wonderful voice! I knew the two famous songs of course, Mercy Mercy Me and What's Going On, but hadn't ever listened to the album before.
Favourite tracks: what's going on; right on; what's happening brother; mercy mercy me; inner city blues
What’s going on
This album is just beautiful. That’s all I have to say.
Fabulous album! True classic R & B.
I've read about this album and was aware the sequencing was gonna be good and is well praised, but the abrupt switches from Save the Children to God is Love to Mercy Mercy Me was really well done. The album kinda sounds like one long performance so far, which is a huge plus, remind me of The Ramones or The Strokes first album in that regard, but a completely different style of music of course. Maybe if RHCP were good? The songs that change pace are right there when you need them, like Right On or the third or so song (?). ESPECIALLY Wholy Holy. The album is on the shorter side which adds to its one-long-single-song thing more by avoiding listener fatigue and increasing replayability. The BASS all over this is such groove. The strings have such a good timbre, especially on Right On breakdown and Wholy Holy. I swear I've heard them sampled by MF Doom/king geedorah. Blueprint string production. How the songs are clumped/pairedtogether is perfect. Wholy Holy really expands the string sounds introduced as a forefront instrument on the earlier song. The last 3 songs (THE STRINGS) were the best on an album that's perfectly consistent, and the first song makes me want to spin the whole album again. The timbre of the strings really elevates this album into something very special, and now I hear them so prominently on relistening. They're a little more prominent on the first side. The instrumentation is so layered and lush I can tell this would be a very rewarding album upon relistens
Classic.
I don’t get it
Classic.
listened 2x, definitely some easy listening but not really my thing. 3.1/5
Fantastic listen, not the first time I have heard this album. This album is an all time classic. Very smooth and easy to listen to.
Had always heard great things about this album. Love that it is only 35 minutes. All killer no filler. Sonically the music is smooth and groovy. This album is a great example of fantastic lyrics and instrumentation coming together to create a great work of art. Absolutely love "Right On", the flutes on this song are amazing and it is easily the standout track on the album for me. Going to have to give it some more relistens to form a better impression but after first listen I am really enjoying it.
heyayyyayyayyeyyayyyy whats going on- elevator music. its kinda what youd expect. 4. whats happening brother- dont care. 3 flying high- boring ass. 2 save the children- i cant take four minutes of this. stares. this album is a shittier version of we are the world. god is love- dgaf. its whatever 3. least its short. it feels lazy like theres cooler ways to sing a song that praises your god yknow. maybe im a hater mercy mercy me- 2. enough right on- i like the flute and the piano is nice. that weird wind up sound is fun. 5. ITS SEVEN MINUTES???? nvm its a 4 now. wholy holy- been reading some reviews and apparently people love this album. more power to em. if this speaks to them, then whatever, but i am hating this, dude. but then again im a nine inch nails fan so does my opinion count. nin fans lose their right to vote. that being said i fucking hate this song like a 2 or 3 inner city blues- this is ok. its got a good bass. it was kinda ass. favorite track- ummm idk maybe god is love cause it was a minute
Great album that speaks to the times in which it was created. Motown at lots finest.
Smooth, elegant, wonderful, dreamy but very powerful
This album has some great songs on it, but it’s real accomplishment is to knit every song on the record together into a song cycle where the entire album sounds like one song rather than a collection of songs. Then what takes that to an entire other level is that these were incredibly talented musicians and composers at the tops of their games and so the song cycle is both an amazing technical achievement and sounds beautiful at basically every second of its 35 and a half minute length. This album is deservedly frequently ranked as the greatest album of all time. Popular music doesn’t get much better than this.
BL: Second Marvin Gaye album I've received on the generator. I liked the previous album but my major gripe with it was it's length, I think it did not justify it's runtime. I will see if this record does. AL: I liked this. I didn’t think it was anything mind blowing but it was incredibly listenable and the instrumentation and production is absolutely at its best here. Some tracks are very recognisable, and some are album cuts but all were enjoyable. Didn’t have a single song I disliked to be honest. FT: “What’s Happening Brother”, “Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)”, “Inner City Blues” 4/5
i’d love to give it 5 stars but sometimes it veers into self-parody
Masterpiece. Gone too soon.
Chanceux de tomber sur ce chef d’oeuvre comme dernier album 1089/1089. Un classique 5/5*
No creo que sea de mis favoritos
M: He has a sweet voice. I feel like I’ve heard his name but haven’t listened to his songs that I know of. My faves were Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues.
Perfect album for a rainy day. Makes me nostalgic for a time in music I wish I was around for. Beautiful intro to the album with the title track. Great consistency and mood for next couple of songs Most likely good for slow lovemaking Does slow down a tad too much at the end. And the theme musically and lyrically is done so well in the title track as an intro, the middle fails to return to that peak. But then, what an ending! Great song to close out the album. Hell of a voice
Very layered soothing accompaniments but overall an album where nothing particularly stands out and each song flows seamlessly to the next without much notice.
Great vibe … easy listening
One of the bests ever
Great singer. A bit too soft for my taste
"Modern Day Marvin Gaye" would be a fantastic cover band name.
What’s Going On and Inner City blues were the strong points of the album.
One of the best albums ever made in Detroit and definitely just an amazing album. Great production, great vocals and great lyrics. Not many more albums that are as enjoyable to listen to while also having strong messages that are still relevant today. 9.7/10
Enjoyed most of the album but would only put a few songs on repeat
First Marvin Gaye album I’ve fully listened to. Almost every song was added to my playlist and I will definitely be returning to it for samples
Gorgeous. Mercy Mercy Me is an all time great song and the rest of the album is smoothy pretty and fun.
It’s decent. A couple classic bangers, but there is a good amount of filler in there as well. Not a lot to say about it. Could be a 2.5, maybe? But I’m good with 3.
Ett skönt sound men faktiskt inget jag skulle lyssna på bara sådär. Det blir lite trist efter ett tag. Påminner lite om porrfilms-musik från 70-talet.
Save the Children antar jag är fullständigt ärlig och inte alls ironi. Det är förstås omöjligt att inte uppfatta det som något annat. Inner city blues är bäst. Riktigt jävla bra. Bättre än "whats going on". Det hörde man efter fem sekunder. Skönt groove. I övrigt är det skön stämning men aldrig upp till en klockren nivå Fan sur över att man inte tycker fler låtar (på allt vi lyssnat hittills) sticker ut och är svinbra (förutom hitsen).
Tre riktigt bra låtar (What’s going on, Mercy mercy me och Inner city blues). Resten är helt okej utan att sticka ut, men med ett genomgående härligt sound. Att låtarna går över i varandra ger en trevlig helhetskänsla. Lite för mycket predikande och jidder om Jesus tyvärr.
Fantastic album. Needs more listens, but 4/5 for now!
Sweet sweet protest
Classic
2 stars for 2 good tracks what's going on mercy mercy me
Surely there's nothing left to say about the vocal performance on this one: deeply emotional, sensitive and hyper controlled, fully attuned to the music. The backing band is incredible and the sound is amazing - lush, vibrant, and rich but full of room and atmosphere - some of the best bass playing recorded to go with memorable horns parts (the sax intro to What's Going On has to be the among most recognizable few notes), keys, organ, and the full motown thing. In that vein though, there are couple of schmaltzy string songs where there's an overdose of Maj7 chords and the vocals get a bit too wailing. This always gets a lot of credit as a protest album, but the politics are really pretty anodyne - "won't somebody think of the babies" "why are there so many problems" "who did this?" "save the children" it's all pretty apolitical really especially considering what was happening in Black politics at the time.
Schöner Motwown-Sound, aber zu süß und schmalzig.
A nice album Very calming but also slightly energetic. Not my personal favourite genre though i did enjoy listening to it. Would probably not listen to again as there is better out there though it was nice hearing. Nothing bad to say about the album though something was missing just cant place what. All dongs have a similar feel and they blend nuce which is something i find cool for an album though it doesnt change how i feel on it overall not that bad. 3/5
THIS FUCKS OMG I love a choir/string background sitting underneath the melody mhm mmm yeah
Sheer Perfection 5.0
A bit boring to be honest. Great harmonies tough
This was such a great album to hear on new years day. Sounds as great as it always does.
À peine deux secondes ont fallu pour que mon sexe durcisse comme de la pierre et pointe vers le plafond. Rien d'anormal, Marvin Gaye est la référence absolue de l'ultra-sexual-soul.
Marvin Gaye, porte étandard de l'ultra sexual pop, vient nous une nouvelle fois nous dresser le braquemard grâce à ses sonorités des plus sexuelles.
I'm trying to make sure the renown on the artist doesn't mess me up here. I respect his vocal chops; however I am not a fan of the album and find the music side of things to be fairly boring. This was like listening to one, long 35 minute song. Respect to the artist, but not for me. Fav tracks: N/A
Good shit
Rating: 10/10
This album is legendary for all the right reasons. Beautiful soul music with powerful lyrics and groovy instruments that are supported by a great concept to the album that pertained to serious issues at the time I can still be reflected back in our society currently. A must listen to for all humans.
Great album, the whole thing just flows together so well with a few truly standout tracks. Probably gayes best album. Iconic: what's going on Repeats:mercy mercy me, right on, inner city blues Skip: wholy holy
Great voice, but some underwhelming songs in between
This album is a powerhouse. Songs are great, vocals great, instruments great. You can listen to it so easily
Not something I would listen to often, but beautiful. Just not a 5 for me though but very close.
Not only is What's Going On seamless, the transitions are all effortless. A little different each time, that is, crafted but not, like the record putting you back at the beginning with theme instead of sound cue.
Pretty cool guy and nice music
good stuff
Beautiful. The title track and Mercy Mercy Me are five star songs, and the rest of the album is delightful.
Pretty great, though very repetitive. One song out of the lot doesn’t really work for me, the rest is very very good.
I like it and understand how great it is. It’s just too much non-melodic sing-talking for me.
вообще не заметила как он прошёл..
Amazing voice, amazing tunes
Very solid soul/R&B/Motown sound. I like how smoothly the songs transition from one to the next. This was the 3rd Marvin Gaye album I've gotten so far, the guy just makes smooth music
Very modern words that I mostly like, music not my favourite style.
An amazing album that’s grew at easy listening on a weekend. The title track and Old City Blues are amazing songs as well as the entire track list, even if it can sound same-y (not really). A classic for the ages!
What's Going on is a classic song. Standouts: What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, What's Happening Brother, Inner City Blues, Save The Children, God is Love. 4/5
Although this album was written in thr 1970s about the social issues of that time, it could have been written yesterday because the same social issues persist today. 3 stars for the music alone, 1 more for the hood social message
Top, richtig schönes Album mit immer noch/wieder aktuellen Themen; schön orchestriert
I tried to listen as unbiased as possible even though I hated Marvin Gaye because my mom would play it over and over and over and over again. I really enjoyed the album it feels like a timeless album of being a black man in the city. My only knock is the first six songs sound literally like one extended song for better or for worse
Great sound, definitely ideal background music for me. I can see how so many artists since then have been influenced by this album - particularly one of my favorites, Silk Sonic (collaboration between Bruno Mars and Anderson.Paak). Only giving four stars because I would definitely use it as background music, and I’m reserving 5 stars for any albums that I would turn on because I want to listen to and engage with the songs.
Me likey
I think this is so beloved more for being \"important\" than for sounding great. I bought this many years ago but I haven't listened to it in probably 10 years. There are 2 almost-bangers at the end of the album, tracks 7 and 9. The title track is also pretty great. But the album is not very musically diverse. The second track sounds like a copy of the first, and most of the rest has a similar, slow soul feel. I think if this album mixed things up more I would like it better. That said, the lyrics are good, and I've always like Marvin's singing a lot.
I like sexy Marvin more than socially conscious Marvin.
I don't know if I can cede the #1 all time spot to this, but this is a damn perfect album. The way it approaches conflict, the issues it chooses to bring up, and how it centers itself on love and understanding have reverberated through generations of listeners. This is the soul equivalent to Zepp IV
This is a definite step up on other MG albums I've had on the list. The greatest album of all time? Not sure about that.
Heyyyyy whats haddenin??
This album preceded Let's Get It On by only three years?! Marvin Gaye is truly a legend.
amazing album!, 10/10
I first discovered a love for Marvin Gaye through the early Motown tracks - Grapevine, Can I Get a Witness, Ain't That Peculiar - the songs with that big beat. As I get older, I appreciate sweet, smooth Marvin Gaye 'with a message' more and more. This album is so incredibly powerful, and such an amazing statement if you consider the state of 'socially conscious' music at the time of its release, and the introduction of the orchestra and the use of the jazz elements and improvisation still sounds fresh and new. Absolutely essential.
Definitely a classic-album. Definitely an exceptional-album. Definitely an album that deserves listen after listen after listen. But definitely not ‘The Greatest Album of All Time.’
Classic
Exactly what Marvin Gaye should be.
A true classic, Marvin Gaye's beautiful voice very nearly distracts from his equally important messages - but not quite.
One of the smoothest, greatest vocalists of all time. Exceptional soul/r&b songwriting, with some era defining lyrics that paved the way for social justice anthems in all genres. I read Motown sat on "Whats Goin On" for months because it wasn't a love song and they didn't understand it. Marvin threatened to leave the label if they didn't release it. Once they did, and it exploded, it paved the way for artists like Stevie Wonder to write with complete artistic freedom. Legendary.
Fantastic album. wonderful melodies, one of the best, most recognized soul voices, and great instrumentation.
Probably the best album ever made. That simple, that honest.
This may very well be one of the greatest albums ever made. A thoroughly thought out concept album (the tracks seamlessly fit together) of a vet returning home to utter disillusionment, executed perfectly by one of the most brilliant vocalists there's ever been, backed by the legendary Funk Brothers. Nevermind the poignant lyrics that have aged even better than I'd like, to be honest, given the themes. With the death of Andre Braugher fresh in the news, it's a wild coincidence to be served another massive talent gone far too soon. I get goosebumps every time I listen.
Second time hearing “the greatest album of all time” and I still don’t get it. Obviously it’s not bad and I guess it must have been influential but it’s so slow and repetitive. Soul just isn’t for me.
Easy 5. Great lyrics, fantastic bass and drum grooves throughout. Important social messages on top of fantastic music. One of the best.
A classic in every sense. Great songs with something important to say.
Rolling Stone said this is the greatest album of all time. I don’t think I agree but it is phenomenal. Marvin Gaye curates an incredible vibe with the songs all flowing into each other. He’s talking about things that matter but in such an accessible way that you almost forget. This is what great art should do. Also the bass parts throughout were excellent.
Gaye's far too early and unnecessary death is a real tragedy. This has that rare quality of being absolutely of its time, yet immediately classic and timeless as well.
Perhaps the greatest album of all time??? Love it
Knew from before nothing extraordinary
Great album. The music seems very influenced by gospel. Strong cultural message in many of these tracks. Good listening and deep meaning behind the lyrics.
A true classic of an album. Gorgeous and melancholy and so smooth.
What’s Going On - jazzy, pretty upbeat. i like this so far (4/5) What’s Happening Brother - i don’t want this to be the only theme for this album. a light happy dance song (4/5 still funky) Flying High - this is really just the song to show off his voice. (5/5 beautiful) Save The Children - 🥺 (3/5 i hate partial spoken word) God Is Love - eh i could do without the evangelizing. minus the lyrics it’s fun. (2/5) Mercy Mercy Me - oh okay. i get Elton John from this. (4/5 very smooth listen) Right On - i’m surprised at a 7 minute song. (4/5 chill) Wholy Holy - it’s just a slow jazzy christian song. (2/5) Inner City Blues - i like the set beat for the song. good bump (4/5) i have to stop at a 3/5 because the biblical stuff. other than that it was pretty good, but it was all i could hear through those songs.
Definitely the best Marvin Gaye album. Amazingly relevant, even now.
It was soothing
Every time you play this you hear something new. Outstanding album. I've bought more versions that I can list. This really should be in everyone's record collection.
Iconic MG album that oozes class.
Pas mon truc du tout
Great!!
Really good but the strongest tracks rise above and the way they blend together makes it a slight slog
As good as soul gets. It's clean, honest and overall a great album, by one of the best soul singers of all time.
Absolute masterpiece.
Great album!
4-4.5 “What’s Going On” was stuck in my head all day, and I think catchy-ness wise, nothing on the album compares. But there are fantastic socially conscious songs that give this album so much depth, and of course Marvin Gaye’s voice isn’t a chore to listen to. I think if I were more into soul this would be the perfect album for me.
First listen to this. Lush and Gaye's voice is obviously perfection, but it's strange to listen to possibly the most sincere album ever in 2025 - the lyrics bring me out as much as the music brings me in
I really enjoyed this album it was very nice and relaxing
perfect album
Has a great sound, very chill. But the message is very deep. Fantastic album. The title track and Mercy Mercy Me are of course classics. This is the first time I’ve heard inner City Blues and it was phenomenal.
Classic Gaye. Amazing stuff right there
rare combination of a message you can move to
Classic album, of course. Not quite a 5 for me personally but maybe I’ll wish I gave it one in the future. Also, James Jamerson tears it up on this album!
Blassic
Album 244 of 1001 Marvin Gaye - What's Going On Favorite Tracks : Mercy Mercy Me While it is unarguably an excellent album, I don't find it to be the "best album ever recorded" as is proclaimed by so many. It was very relevant for the time it was released. Still relevant if you want it to be. A very, very good album, no doubt but I won't put it on that pedestal. I will recommend it to anyone who hasn't listened. While it may not be at the top of my list, it is, no doubt required listening for any serious melophile.
How can you not love Marvin Gaye? I didn't know he was killed by his own father! Imagine if he'd lived longer and how much more amazing music we could have had!
Not for me
El precursor del R&B que creo uno de los sonidos más sensuales de la historia, incluyendo la homónima What's going on
Nice rhythms, but a little boring. It's probably meant to be spherical and relaxing, but it basically sounds like christmas music with a different text.
Romantische Musik für einen kuscheligen Abend.
7/10 coffee shop vibes
Next 5 songs played by my Spotify Algorithm: Etta James - I'd Rather Go Blind Martha Reeves & The Vandellas - (Love is Like A ) Heatwave Sam Cooke - (What a ) Wonderful World Barry White - Mellow Mood Dionne Warwick - Walk on By
Var faktisk lidt skuffet. Det sagde mig ikke noget. Måske skal det lige lyttes til igen.
An absolute tour de force
5/10
There is nothing to say
Still sounds fresh in 2023. The bass and percussion drives everything forward, strings are lush. Mercy Mercy Me stands out and the 7 1/2 minute Right On.
Loved this album! Was quite a bit of a bummer. Talked to social and political themes still applicable to today.
What's Going On is the eleventh album by American soul singer Marvin Gaye. This progressive soul piece is a concept album featuring a song cycle (tracks blend into the next, intending to be played all together) with political views about the Vietnam War and thoughts on societal and ecological issues. This album was critically acclaimed and immediately commercially popular. It's considered a classic of 70's soul music and ranked one of the best albums of all time. This album has been certified platinum in the UK and gold in the US, although it sold a total of 1.6 million copies since tracking began in 1991 - 20 years after release - and there were 2 million copies sold in the first year after release, so this album should really be certified at least double platinum in the US. This is an incredible album. It's important for music history, black music, and as a personal statement by Gaye against the injustices of the late 60's & early 70's. The four singles carried this album into popularity, but the overall production was so well done that this album will remain popular for decades to come. The somber, sometimes slow, soul music on this album is not my preferred music, but real recognizes real and this album is great. This may have been Gaye's breakthrough album and he followed it up with likewise amazing albums. RIP Marvin Gaye.
One of the finest albums ever
It doesn’t really do much for me
Overall kinda slow. Liked one song and “what’s goin on” is a classic. Pretty fun to hear his music about anti war and what was going on at the time.
Great
Encapsulates a time, a movement. Emanates love and caring for a community of people.
Great little album, very jazzy and soulful. I wish it was longer. Just a little churchy at times for my personal taste. Favorite songs - Whats Going On, Whats Happening Brother, Right On. 3/5
Look, I have no issue with the overarching message of the album nor the buttery smooth instrumentation, but at some point in this album you have to acknowledge that the entire project lacks, uh, "variety". You're given fair warning after a song centered around What's Goin' On is followed up by a song centered around What's Happening, and it doesn't get any more imaginative from there, musically speaking. Sure you get the occasional bongo and guiro, but a little Latin percussion isn't enough to mask just how similar all of these tunes end up sounding.
What an incredible album. I’ve always had a special place in my heart for Marvin. I can vividly recall the time when my dad played me the title track of this album. I was 10 or 11 and we were out in the garage during a family party and this song came on and he and my uncle Ron just stopped talking and cranked it up and jammmmed. That speaks to the influence Marvin had on all sorts of people. Just lovers of music listening to a guy pour his soul into his craft. Beautiful. The album itself is incredible. Really groovy, soul Motown. Feel good bass lines and bongo/drum beats. Impeccable transitions between songs. The variety of instruments used throughout the album. Music for people who love to feel.
this is my cup of tea
A classic
Ok
Like me a bit of Marvin Gaye but not sure if these were remixed or ‘cleaned’ up versions but didn’t seem to have the right sound quality, maybe it was the visualiser videos affecting my perception. Still good stuff though.
Marvin is dope
This is really good album. Of course I prefer rap and maybe heavy metal but this album is kind and beautiful
Already heard this one :) really good love it
Amazing!!
O que está acontecendo?
number 1
Only being familiar with his popular stuff I wasn't really sure what to expect. Reading that this was a concept album about social and environmental issues piqued my interest. Certainly What's Going On is a standout track, but I like the way the songs following flow into each other with faves being Flyin' High, Mercy Mercy Me.
Some amazing five star tracks on here, and then some overly saccharine preachy schmaltzy ones, and I suspect everyone would draw the dividing line in a different place, heh. "Save the Children" and "Wholy Holy" are on the bad side for me, and probably cost this album a star over all. Fave tracks - "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)", and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" from the original album. "I'm Going Home (Move)" was a highlight from the bonus tracks...
Good album
Definitely iconic.
His vocals are amazing and he has an original sound that so many try to imitate. And then there are the percussion instruments.
Wonderful voice and beautiful musicianship
This album is a timeless classic. While I don't know if segways between songs was a thing in the 70s before this or not - but this album flows so beautifully.
I can understand the masterpiece of this album without enjoying it personally. R&B is just not my jam. It’s like too slow funk or jazz with singing instead of instruments.
Marvin Gaye is a legendary vocalist, and for good reason. It doesn't matter what he sang or how the song went, he was gonna sound like a smooth, soulful seraph. Highlights: What's Going On - A funky ballad with a message that makes you think. Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) - Now you're just showing off, man. The vocals on here are something else. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - The bass on here is great, along with the jazzy brass section. Fantastic song. Lowlights: I'm not a huge jazz fan, and this album leans heavily into the freeform vocal styles common in the genre. This isn't a flaw of the album, but a flaw of me, lol. Final Thoughts: This jazzy album was an enjoyable listen, even though I'm not a huge jazz fan. The skill and God-given talent on display was wonderful, and the message of the lyrics is still relevant today. The instrumental performance was fantastic as well.
Timeless.
An utter classic. Beautifully arranged and sung.
It's ok. Sort of just more Gaye. Liked this slightly better than "Let's Get It On" A Solid 3/5
8/10
Talk about a classic! So sad and tragic that Marvin Gaye was taken from the world so young and under such horrific circumstances. So sad and tragic that this album was released more than 50 years ago, and every single thing he's talking about is relevant still today. "Who really cares? Who's willing to try to save a world that's destined to die? When I look at the world, it fills me with sorrow. Children today really gonna suffer tomorrow. Oh, what a shame. Such a bad way to live. Who is to blame when we can't stop living?" - lyrics from Save the Children
Good, classic.
You know I always forget about soul music then listen to an album like this and remember it. Good for just chillin’ or basically any type of mood. 4/5
Brill
Very solid album. The hits are top tier although I did get a bit bored with some of the in-between. Love me some Marvin G. though.
It's a seminal album from an incredible artist with some of the best bass playing recorded. (Fun fact, legend has it that James Jamerson (the bass player) was out drinking when Gaye had the studio space for the title track. The studio pulled him in from the bar and he was so drunk he recorded and composed the whole line laying on the floor)
Really good stuff. A couple of weird things that I just didn't vibe with, but for the most part, a really quality album with some really good vocals and instrumentation. I also loved that each track flowed into the next, made for a really enjoyable listening experience. Could have done without Save the Children. That was just weird.
What's going on?" There's a masterpiece going on. Of its time, sure, yet also ahead of it on so many counts. When you listen to this record, you can sense strands of future music genres--trip hop, neo soul, and even hip hop, at least through the lyrical "program" displayed in the album. And the ecological message aged particularly well. Unfortunately, I would even add. The only (small) issue I could have with this album is that it's quite "one-note" (a flaw that many Marvin Gaye releases from the seventies have). But if you take it as a single topical "suite", instead of a batch of songs, it's easy to understand why Marvin was right to never veer off course.4.5/5, rounded up to a perfect 5 grade. Number of albums left to review: less than 400 (I've temporarily lost count here) Number of albums I'll include in my own list: half so far, approximately (including this one) Number of albums I *might* include: a quarter, approximately. Number of albums I'll never include: another quarter (many others are more important to me)
Pretty decent! Very relaxing sounding, though the music is not very interesting. But still it's not extremely predictable, so that's good.
Really nice album - better on headphones
Maybe this is a victim of its status as one of the great albums but I didn’t come away as blown away as I expected It’s good Very good Not sure I quite saw what puts it in the top echelon though
meh, that's ok
Man sings some songs
Nice but also quite dull
Fair
Good album, enjoyed almost all the songs.
Amazing music of course. I rarely listen to it straight through like I should. No one sings with such beauty about urban poverty and blackness as Marvin. It was a landmark album then and still hits today. Injustice and tragedy combined with optimism is what I feel from it.
I like this one but don't love it. Very familiar with it and have listened to it lots in the past. Musicianship is excellent throughout; I particularly like the bass, percussion (incl glockenspiel), backing vocals, flute. My least favourite element of the production is Gaye himself. I'm not that keen on his voice and although he's singing about worthy causes it just comes across as a bit naff. I'd rather hear some sleaze or blaxploitation lyrics to be honest! Nice to spot the hip hop samples throughout and I'll still score it well because the music is so good.
i'm a bit biased, i am a huge motown fan, so yeah, i adore this album. it is really the first truly great motown album, its first and marvin's first politically conscious effort. so much of this album is still relevant today, more than 50 years later. and it has aged beautifully. the production sounds timeless, marvin gaye is, of course, one of the greatest singers AND songwriters of all time. the musicianship is incredible. just a great soul record, very jazzy at times. one of those albums that truly gives me goosebumps when i hear it. this is the stuff!!!
One of the greatest albums of all time still remains timeless.
It was a good album. I danced in my kitchen while making dinner, super funky. The outro was nice.
Marvin Gaye- What’s Going On 1. Sax automatically makes every song better. But lord have mercy, the drums, the keys, the fucking xylophone hitting in the background… and then the swoon of the strings. My god if this isn’t one of the most beautiful songs of all time then I dunno what is. The vocal melodies are nuts. The crescendo on the second verse. 10/10 2. Lord the vibe rolls right into this track. That bass is thumping and the vocals sound like the gates of Heaven are opening. 3. Lord it won’t stop. This album is an entire vibe. And the vibe is let Marvin take you to soul heaven. This is a masterpiece so far. 4. Another W. Simply beautiful 5. Another W. It’s just so pretty. 6. Goated. 7. That flute is HITTIN. Another banger 8. I’m not religious so I don’t care about the message here but the magic is undeniable. Another W. 9. Excellent closer. This album is GOATED Another revelation. This absolutely belongs on this list. Not a miss on here. A simply beautiful musical arrangement from all parties involved. The social commentary is still relevant over 50 years later. This is a 10/10 🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾🤘🏾
One of the best
boring
What’s going on?!?
No new gems here. The usual songs are still amazing though.
Beautiful soul album - short and sweet. I probably don’t have much more to say that what had already been said by others on this record.
Musically, I prefer Curtis Mayfields 'Super Fly' (a year earlier) but this is such a coherent album. It's message is loud and clear and the quality of the music is consistent throughout. An enjoyable listen but, again, not really my style at the moment.. although this will certainly have a time and a place in my playlist.
It's a little bit fucked up how good this is. Such an enthralling, cohesive experience, the way songs flow into each other is incredible. Political yet deeply empathetic. Draws you in with such ease, yet there is a deepness and complexity that warrants multiple listens. Fav Track: What's Happening Brother
Classic for a reason. An iconic voice. If I'm 100% honest, I'm not totally on board with some of the vocal affectations and broad lyrical focus, so I know I'm gonna be blasphemously low to some. I think as I listen more through the years I'll warm further. Fave track: Mercy Mercy Me
Flawless - one of the most powerful and brilliant records ever. Fave track: Inner City Blues
This album has such a great flow fantastic songs calls, back to the familiar hits throughout the other songs, which is cool super listenable genius
Soulful bluesy and jazzy. A nice mellow sound that you can relax to. Beautiful voice. High 3.
Solid
Nearly gave this 5 - it’s an amazingly well produced album where nearly all songs flow together - and some fantastic songs on here too. A couple of the songs get a bit “annoying” though which has knocked one star off. Brilliant album though and listened to it three times yesterday!
listened to again an american postwar classic
A much softer voice than I remember. Very soulful singing with some jazz influence in the instrumentals. An album with the message of peace and coexistence. However, R&B isn't always my thing.
Save the babies! Save babies! Obviously Marvin Gaye is a legend who I won't hear a word against, but this work is very much of a time, conjuring up smoky lounges, velvet, overly large collars, jive turkeys and Blaxploitation. What's there is pretty accomplished of course, but also kind of short by any standard. The inspirational, call to action lyrics seem to have fell on deaf ears. Have we saved the babies? No we have not.
Yes
Easy listening
Timeless masterpiece and I can totally see why. Music cannot heal the world, but it is a powerful way to say what is needed to be said. That being said, I didn't enjoy it as much as I would like. Maybe because I wasn't a fan of that funk sound that I've already heard for many times. Again I respect it. It does have a big place in music and history, but not in my ears apparently.
Beautiful! And soooo smooth and cool! In fact the only thing cooler is Frank Sinatra stepping out of a helicopter with a glass of whisky in hand. My favourite album so far, although the last two tracks did slightly take the vibe away a bit. I would definitely recommend
A near perfect album that’s both political & charming, which is so up my alley. The only part that doesn’t work for me all the time is the percussion in Right On but still 5 easy
One of my favorites
I was very impressed by this album I am almost considering giving it a 5 but I think i’d hav to become very familiar i with it but I think this album sounded beautiful and had a clear impact but also a great sound.
800 years ago the band I was in did a guitar rock version of "Inner City Blues" which is my favourite Marvin song. I don't know if it was any good or even if it didn't suck but man, if that wasn't the most fun I had playing a cover I don't know what was. Other than the aforementioned best song, some things I love most about this album: - how the songs flow into one another, creating a full album/suite experience. - the not-quite-doubled but rather 2 unique lead tracks Marvin has for most cuts, almost a sort of self-duet Marvin has going on with himself. - it's all about the bass. James Jamerson and Bob Babbitt. Funk Brothers FTW. - "you know that woo? that single woo?" Critique: I'm not always crazy about the strings; I'd have loved to hear a lot of these songs arranged differently (i.e. without so much orchestration or even completely without) but not quite enough to knock it off a 5. The grooves and Marvin's vocals win out. 9/10 5 stars.
Classic! The title song adds a full star on its own. I feel however that there is no single album by Marvin Gaye that reaches far enough. He has so many incredible songs that a compilation would almost reach perfection exept it would feel disjointed. Anyway, as it is this is great album and wonderful concept.
Classic
Feels like I now understand a whole slew of cultural, musical references I didn't get before. It's such a sincere album, wrapped in all this smoke and jazz flute. Definitely enjoying the latter tracks more than the earlier. I have to keep reminding myself that "What's going on" pre-dates all the "We are the world" stuff. Maybe it was just more possible to make this kind of cri de coeur back then?
Banger of a classic. Great vibes.
Knocked a whole star off for the song Right On because the grindy percussion element was an assault on the ears. Was loving the album up until then, each track flowed seamlessly into the next. Great musicality, even for a genre I'm not immediately a fan of
Some great songs I hadn't heard of, the the single takes all of the attention
not bad
Great!
10/10 thanks, Marvin Gaye 👍 Inventor of Sex
Yes
I worked really well cohesively as an album and was probably great in its day. Absolutely love his smooth vocals.
I appreciate the r&b mellow vibes on the surface but if you listen to the lyrics, it’s a politically charged album. Not really my cup of tea but I very much respect it.
zu monoton, ohne gute Hits, Musik von Mavin Gaye generell gut
Increíble disco. Dificilisimo encasillarlo en un género, suena de todo.
Not really my style but it was okay.
Love Marvin Gaye
Timelessly, tragically relevant over 50 years later.
ok
Meh
More than 50 years on, nothing is quite able to replicate the spiritual but universal atmosphere, the effortless sequencing, or the sense of prevailing hope to see a better tomorrow. Gaye's vocal performances are exquisite, and the lyrical subject transcends its themes of Christianity and reaches something spiritual anyone can relate to. With all this history, you would expect the album to be heavy and flabby, in fact it still manages to excite and surprise, all these years later.
Dit is misschien wel het allerbeste soul album of all time, gvd wat goed. Dit ligt marvin zo veel beter dan zijn andere korny nummers die iedereen kent zoals LET'S get it on en sexual healing. Zo veel meer passie en emotie inner city blues slaps so fucking much. I hAvE tHiS oN ViNyL
Een banger 1e klas, smooth tunes en diepe soal. Je moet er wel echt zin in hebben. Ik mis wel een beetje de “sexy” tone die Marvin Gaye zijn latere jaren heeft geschreven, maar het voelt daardoor wel een stuk “puurder” aan.
Nice but a lot of churchy stuff
Good easy listening. Faded well into some background music but there was never really a moment where I was particularly grabbed by it. However for something to have on in the background for a vibe I like it.
Really liked this album. So vibey, listened to it twice in a row. Lauren loved it too. Really like the instruments and the way Marvin sings so softly
Classic. Moving. Sad. Inspiring. Bass with all that movement. Harmonious strings and backing vocals. Spacious Atmos mix on iTunes. Why did we lose this feeling?
There is a reason this album is iconic. It's cohesive and addresses issues that were plaguing society then, and even more so now. This should be an album that everyone listens to regularly.
Very groovy, songs flow well from one another. Got a bit bored by the end.
.pretty alright!
Classic and still relevant. I think Here My Dear is my favorite but this album is a close second
Too slow and the lyrics weren’t my favorite. This is one I will not be listening to again.