What's Going On by Marvin Gaye

What's Going On

Marvin Gaye

3.94
Rating
29756
Votes
1
1%
2
6%
3
24%
4
35%
5
34%
Distribution

Reviews (page 11 of 14)

STANDOUTS: What's Going On OVERALL: 3/5

perfect album

Great artist, great album. One of the best of all time.

Can't go wrong with soul music, and can't go wrong with Marvin Gaye.

I didn't get this album unlike so many others. It's culturally significant,but musically meh. Too religious for my liking.

I’ve been expecting this album for a while and I’m glad to finally listen to it as part of this list. It manages to hit that sweet spot of dealing with some really heavy shit while being insanely easy on the ears at the same time. From Vietnam to racism to urban struggles it’s all there and each song perfectly tackles each issue it’s aiming at. What’s going on and inner city blues are my favs.

It's hard to rate an album like this simply because the three big songs, What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) and Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) are GREAT, truly classic songs. But the other six tracks feel like they would have been part of the extended singles of those hits or filler.

Classic, but not really my thing.

Et af de helt store, soul, politisk, nostalgisk

I'm sorry, I try not to play the " all sounds the same" game, but boy do the first six tracks sound like a medley. Sur the production is top notch and it's a complicated piece of R&B, but it still comes down to the quality of a Man's voice, and sure this is high quality, but I/we need more

holy crap make it stop

‘Like a warm summer’s night by the docks’ 7.8/10 - enjoyable listen hosting an array of flavourful instrumentation. The soulful tones formed an engaging story across throughout the. track list. Some sections felt flat and struggled to meet the over ambience the album sets with its highs. Favourite song - Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Best song - Right On

One of the finest soul albums ever made - wonderfully written, performed, sung by the late great Marvin Gaye. I especially loved the production of the album, so smooth, it was wonderful to listen to.

On m'aurait demandé de noter cet album il y a 15 ans, j'aurais probablement dit : "Nope, c'est pas ma came du tout !". Et cette critique aurait très certainement englobé toute la musique soul et RnB. Mais comme il n'y a que les cons qui ne changent pas d'avis, et qu'il faut savoir écouter plus loin que le bout des ses oreilles : des heures d'écoute de tous horizons plus tard, mon avis actuel est tout à fait opposé. Quel bel album que celui-ci. Marvin Gaye semble nous confier ses réflexions de manière confidentielle, avec une voix sereine et chaude. La musique oscille entre jazz, classique et soul, les textes sont beaux, le concept de l'album en lui-même est saisissant... Je n'ai décidément rien à dire si ce n'est que selon moi cet album mérite l'auréole qui lui est décernée !

Hmmm. Well, firstly, the fact it’s a near-continuous suite of music, with a cohesive message to boot, is right up my street. But the music itself isn’t really up my street; it meanders in a pleasant but slightly boring way. I don’t even enjoy the 3 standout singles *that* much, really. Lyrically, I find it well-meaning but ultimately a bit… fluffy? Probably unfair as the topics of addiction, poverty etc are heavy, and at any rate a pure-hearted ‘c’mon guys let’s all be better, yeah?!’ is exactly what’s called for sometimes. But it does feel a bit like a dumbed-down Sunday school sermon a lot of the time (or so I imagine, I never went). I’m trying to justify scoring this higher, but then again if I'd listened without knowing it was considered a GOAT candidate, I’d probably give it three stars and move on, so…

Very earnest but goes down easy.

Marvin Gaye. What’s going on. Nuff said.

such a wonderful & joyful album. What's going on & mercy mercy me are the standouts for me. It doesn't have high relisten-ability in my life, but every time it's on I can appreciate how important it was for its time

I want to like Marvin Gaye records more than I usually do after listening to them. I understand it…the cultural relevance, his fantastic voice…this is a great record, but I just don’t see myself listening to it very often.

Phenomenal album, it’s truly one of the greats

Legendary soul singer, but not a style i can listen to for long

Utterly sublime

incredibly powerful music, feels like it's genuinely challenging the world and established music, which in 1971 I guess it was. 4.4

Great voice for cozy songs

I really liked the vocals and instrumentation. Good 60s rock

Simply one of the best albums ever recorded. I've already listened to this album many times so this was just another enjoyable re-listen. Can't say much more than what's already been said by other reviews. 5 stars.

The worst album that Marvin Gaye ever created, and the one that would absolutely destroy his career. At, least, according to Motown boss Berry Gordy, who, for all his genius, just didn’t get it … until “What’s Going On” snuck onto radio and the rest is history. Is this the greatest album of all-time? That really depends on who you ask, but personally, this album resonates more with me than “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band,” which is what had been No. 1 on Rolling Stone’s list of the greatest albums. That is, until younger, more diverse voters were added to the pool and elevated this classic to the top. “Sgt. Pepper's” is fantastic, revolutionary, visionary, all of that and more ... but it just doesn't have the same cultural cachet. This album is the touchstone for pretty much anything. It spans time and space ... and is as relevant today as it was when Marvin Gaye was facing pressure from Gordy to stick to love songs. It is timeless and yet urgent, and deserves its reverence.

I can think of some people in the world who should listen to this record.

legally i cannot give this under a 4

listened to the first six tracks two years ago and remember feeling in awe of how lush the production was. pretty immaculate arrangements on some of these tracks. I didn’t pay full attention on this first full listen so I haven’t grasped all of the lyrical content yet, but from what I’ve picked up on in the first third it’s very conversational and feels very natural. his emotions feel so real and naturally conveyed in his performances. need to give this another listen to fully grasp it (which is gonna be the case for most of these albums that I’m listening to for the first time) but this is obviously very good. 7.5-8

Beautiful. Simply beautiful. This is a fantastic album. The vibes are immaculate. 10/10 Would I listen again? Absolutely

"What's going on", "Mercy mercy me (The ecology)" y "Inner city blues" me han encantado. Me gusta como suena el disco en general, con auriculares es un gustazo. Una pena que muriera tan joven.

There’s a lot of context that makes this album more impactful than just a listen. But to keep it simple, this is a masterpiece. It’s a formal lament concerning the brokenness of the world and humanity through one man’s eyes. That man happens to be Marvin Gaye and he makes you feel what we’re often uncomfortable to engage with. But it’s still hopeful because he believes that love is the solution. It’s beautiful and brilliant and sparkling.

Is there an easier 5 stars? Is there a better advertisement for this process than either introducing someone to this or reminding them of its glory. The answer to both is no. Better, more eloquent people have written volumes about the soul, the sadness, the live, the romance, the depth and the musicality of this. All I can say is it's always welcome in my ears.

It grew on me a bit over time, but I thought the first half was pretty mid. It kind of came across as music for a charity concert for a while. I did enjoy the last few songs.

good i think

Why can't the entire album sound like Inner City Blues. Still a decent album though, great lyrics.

Classic Soul.

Vraiment spécial, à réécouter.

What's Going On is a hell of a groovy jam. Beautifully buttery vocals over a cheerful bouncing melody, speaking to the political unrest of the 60s/70s. Interesting that they mixed in crowd vocals through a lot of the song -- gives it a really interesting atmosphere. Really love how this album just bleeds together as if it is one continuous track. I couldn't give it too much dedicated focus on the first listen as I'm heads down with work, but I was grooving along all the way through. Beautiful vocals and lived in, vibrant instrumentals. Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues were two of my favorites that I was able to separate out. Otherwise, there are no misses here. This is pure magic. 5 / 5

Smooth easy listen album. 3.5 stars for me

Jam after jam after jam after jam. Honestly no stand outs, but just solid throughout. Gaye is definitely going to be more heavily involved in my weekend mornings going forward.

I like how this is just one long song essentially. Couldn't tell where the transitions were at all. Such a smooth flowing album that felt like it was over in a breeze.

Great Monday morning listen. Very chill. Definitely flew by

Lots more jazzy than I expected. Not much jumps out at me beyond the singles, but I respect the craft and intention that clearly went into this album and can see why it was a critical success.

The album in its entirety is overrated in my opinion. A lot of the interlude elements connecting the tracks I find boring. However at the same time some of Marvin Gayes finest songs are on this album. And that is magic!

What an album...!

Meh. All OK songs. One famous. Maybe I feel better about it because the songs can be used for hand dancing music

It's a classic, I understand that. And from my first listen its a very good listen, but I think I'll perhaps need more time and repeat listens to fully appreciate it.

Good album but not for me. I liked the first 2 tracks a lot but after that it just got boring.

Marvin's going green and political but in a soulful way. For me it jumps the shark tank at Save the Children but then back on track. I didn't realize the album is only 36 mins long. Great rhythms and Marvin's voice is butter.

He's mostly singing about social and environmental issues - so why do get the get the distinct impression that this album is trying to seduce me?

I mean, it's f'n What's Going On. It's a top-ten album of all time for a reason.

Great production, perfect for chilling out in the garden.

Great, so much soul and a great story.

Funky and smooth listen. Quite enjoyed it

Yes. It’s absolutely lovely. The structure of the album is magnificent how all songs fade into one another. The topics are complex and noble. Marvin is a very talented singer, and the instrumentation is beautiful. I find it a nice background accompaniment.

Genre-defining. Great voice, beautifully constructed songs. Easy listening, but without being boring, the hard-hitting lyrics are almost masked by the softness of Gaye's voice. A stand-out album.

I love the vibes of this album, Marvin Gaye's voice is so beautiful

A couple of classics, but much of it all blurs into one

Exactly as expected, very samey

Enjoyable listen

This is my favorite Marvin Gaye album. 9/10

Marvin’s best album. Smooth, funky, short and sweet. 8/10

One of my favorite records that I own.

Is this the greatest album ever recorded? If Rolling Stone is to be believed as of 2020 it is. It was no doubt a political act on the part of the magazine. In 2020, one of the great years for the BLM protests, one of the great years for protests in general, to honour one of the great protest records as not just that, but the greatest album of all time. But, I’m more interested in What’s Going’ On’s connection to the album that it succeeded. Sgt Pepper’s is the ultimate Hippie Record, full of psychedelic sounds and a vibe that’s mostly peace and love. It’s a good record, I’m never gonna deny that, but for so many people peace and love is the unrealised dream. What What’s Going On has to it’s advantage, is the same thing that Sgt Pepper’s best song also demonstrates. The reality of A Day In The Life, the dichotomy between the lives of the haves and the have nots. Gaye presents this topic with the clear eyed lens of a realist, which makes for one of the most heartbreaking albums in recorded history. Because it’s all still there. The bigotry, the state sponsored violence, the drug use, the fucking climate change! We are much closer to Gaye’s version of life than we are to Paul McCartney’s. But despite all the doom and gloom, What’s Going On is still a record full of the joy of music, the joy of human interaction through this weird cultural experience that we all love, and also through the knowledge that there are people who will fight for the basic dignity of all humanity, no matter how hard the bastards try to keep is down. So, and I say this with as little irony as my deadened Zoomer Heart can muster, Right On, keep fighting, keep fucking fighting

Compared this to the last review I submitted for a Marvin Gaye album, the voice is still perfect but the songs are better.

chill album ya dig

Yeah this was definitely a cool album. I’m not sure it I’ll ever go back to it in the future but it’s definitely worth a listen to.

i forgot to write a sentence for this and am doing this half a year later because i LOVE this album me me wanna holler, the way they do my life!

Tolle Stimme. Ein bisschen Kitsch ab und zu ist ja ok.

Und wieder Marvin Gaye: Ja und wieder ok - aber ebene nur ok. Stört nicht - Quietscht nicht und frisst kein Brot. Aber begeistert mich auch nicht.

Great opener and closer. Solid throughout.

Uno de los mejores discos de R&B/Soul de la historia. Impresionante desplante de Gaye en el micrófono, y la clásica producción de Motown hace de esta una experiencia sumamente agradable al oído. Y a pesar de ser una obra sumamente pop, Marvin se da el tiempo de hacernos reflexionar con letras introspectivas que ahondan en diferentes problemáticas de la realidad afroamericana. Sumamente recomendable.

Some great tracks, but not enough to get a 4 from me

Plätschert so vor sich hin 2/5

Smooth maybe too smooth. 3 stars

Some of the tracks kind of blend together. But it’s smooth and his voice is great. Activism with a gospel bend. Playlist choice: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Marvin Gaye fans will likely enjoy this Marvin Gaye album.

I’m going to finish this tomorrow, but it’s so good. I can’t see myself changing the rating

Marvinin ääni on hunajaa vaikka tämän levyn matsku on semisti pliisua, ainakin omaan korvaan. Niukasti taipuu kolmoseen.

Marvin takaa laatua. Toimiva kokonaisuus. Solidi kolmonen

Silky smooth voice but it's just 1 long song.

This album definitely hits hard while being easy to listen to. Songs about racial injustice, poverty, war and pollution by one of the great soul voices. Hugely influential at the time and it still is relevant today.

I can appreciate Gaye's great voice even though the genre is not particularly my favourite and this kind of albums always sound a bit dated to me. The age particularly show in the arrangements; some songs have great background music to go with Gaye's voice, some others are a bit dull and boring with too many strings and mellow melodies. When the brass come or the rhythm kicks in, it's another story!

Bien, normal.

I tell you what: The very similar drum and percussion arrangements can get annoying no matter how great the rest of the album is. That why I give it 4 stars even though I want to give 5.

Wow. Entire album is deep

A very good album. Big on social justice, great musically. Some minor lyrical hiccups - sociopolitical lyrics are hard, but rhyming mercy mercy mercy with fish full of mercury is a bridge too far for me...

This is the first time I've heard the entire album, though I know the big hit songs. I actually thought all the songs sounded more or less the same, but I like the sound.

Iconic 70s soul

Great album. Not my style but I still enjoyed it.

Excellent! Marvin at his best!

When I saw this album, my gut response was that it's unfortunately become a tad overrated since Rolling Stone decided to name it the Greatest Album of All Time. That's a somewhat bold statement, but it doesn't mean this isn't among the best albums ever, period. And then I listened to it again, and realized that maybe Rolling Stone was correct. In reality, it's a top 20 all-timer, and Rolling Stone will likely name a different album number 1 whenever they do another one of those lists again. But make no mistake. Overall, this thing is a marvel.

I like it, beautiful, deep but simple

Love his voice and groovy style. Great messages about war and society too. It does kind of sound like one big long song though.

Mellow, really solid

Mellow and samey.

I knew several songs. I enjoyed it. The album did not carry on too long and most songs were appropriately edited. I would listen to it again.

I was underwhelmed to be honest

Was only previously familiar with the title song, which is pretty good. But the rest of the album is pretty samey. Not really my cup of tea (and a bit preachy)

Such a groovy album that never lets up, and much more about positive messaging and humanitarian concerns over his other thirsty album.

I really enjoyed this album :) chill, not boring, good vibes all around

Soft and soulful. Didn't really strike me right for get a 5, but was good

Much better than the earlier Marvin Gaye album on this list. Songs flow together beautifully, the vocals are on point (of course), and the backing instrumentals are good too. Above average and would consider listening to again in its entirety. 7.5/10 (3.75/5)

Overall just a solid album with good vocals and a nice band

Not my style of music but can appreciate the vocals. Lots of the songs sound similar but Inner City Blues is a highlight to close it out.

Marvin Gaye's voice alone carry's this record.

My 8th grade science teacher used to play this album every day. absolute classic. Nothing bad to say.

My last favourite track is the title track... The rest is great though.

What's Going On? The Vietnam War.

Beautiful. Everyone in the house loved it - me, my husband, and our eighteen-year-old tabby cat.

I guess I'm a philistine but I found What's Going On super overrated. It's not awful, but Rolling Stone's No1 album of ALL TIME? Things I liked: his voice, arrangements (e.g. the jazzy elements and strings), bravery. It must have been pretty ground breaking to have a black man saying these things in 1971 Things I thought weren't worth the hype: some of the lyrics.. yes it's political but it's not all that hard hitting? Save the children, love will win, people should come together, Jesus left us something to believe in... Not a great deal of substance here. The first two tracks are basically just saying lots of things are bad without really having a great deal to add. The other thing I didn't like is I was pretty bored listening to it. The tempo is all kinda middling and the tone is quite dour. Even listened twice to make absolutely sure I didn't find it as good as the critics and I don't.

6/10 nice and vibey but not.much more for me

What’s Going On Flyin’ High Mercy Mercy Right On Feels majestic. Almost makes me imagine ascending into the sky. Fills the room with beauty. Ending wasn’t as amazing as the beginning but was still good

Wish it was longer!

Wow, the deluxe edition on YouTube has literally 6 versions of “What’s Going On”. The album is alright, but sort of boring. Not super impressed.

As Spencer distinctly put it, I am definitely a Gaye guy. Like any other elementary school kid, I was infatuated with him after titans and then developed a true romance after some contestant on American idol performed “you’re all I need to get by” (I’ve tried looking up and down to find out who it was but alas, I cannot. Regardless, it really made me look into Marvin more). I did struggle in giving this a four because it has one of my fave songs of all time with inner city and obvs what’s going on is an American staple. Whenever I listen to this on vinyl, I very actively listen to those two songs and then for the middle section kind of just casually listen. So I did have to go back and reevaluate a lot of the middle songs. Gaye’s voice and music style is on another level and already take each song to a higher tier than plenty of his contemporaries but I can’t in good conscious say that these middle songs (for me personally) are life changing. I’m sure the meaning behind the lyrics are incredible and obviously he touches on a number of bold themes of God, racism, environmentalism, and so on, which at this time is I’m sure an achievement in of itself. The last thing I wanted to say about this album is the “free flowing” aspect in which most of the songs seamlessly blend together has not aged well for me personally. This is not Gaye’s fault at all and I think I’ve read somewhere that this is one of the first albums that has done that. Unfortunately this has been done and copied ad nauseam in modern music that it just annoys me. I have no problem with it as a musical device and honestly it works perfectly for this album, it’s just the whole, being born in a different era thing and having heard it to diminishing returns so many times. Now, as for the song “what’s going on”, plenty has been written and documented about the importance of this song in post Vietnam protest song culture and for good reason and I really don’t have anything too unique to add. The one thing I’ll say is just how poignant the phrase “what’s going on” is to truly describe the indescribable of war and its tumultuous effects that literally transcends to this day. True poetry. The first 40 seconds of inner city changed my musical life. I remember exactly where I was the moment I heard it. That single repeated distorted Eb minor7 chord, then the bongo, then the sultry scat, and then finally a bass line that will make yo panties drop. Just perfection. Like an ogre, there are just so many layers to this song that are all beautiful by themselves and make a perfect song. I feel guilty in loving this song because of its lyrical content and what black people during this time must have gone through but man does Marvin just put it all on the line. I really want to give this album a five just because of this song. (Of note John Mayer does a cover of this song that has aged extremely poorly unfortunately). Also I find it comical that rolling stone retroactively made this album their number one album of all time after they got so much shit in not having any black artists in the top 15. It’s a little too late RS.

Still a 3 for Marvin. Some bangers, but it felt like it had a bunch of filler for only being 35 minutes long. Good vibes though as always.

Absolutely an album I expected to see at some point on this list. Between the talent of Marvin Gaye and the social commentary, this is not only a great album to listen to but an important work of art in American history. It’s brief, but the only reason that’s bad is because I want to hear more of Marvin’s voice.

The songs all flow into each other on this album, and not in a bad way. It's not just one really long song split up into sections. It's a really cohesive album from start to finish. It's almost hard to see how some of these songs became standout hits when the album works so well together as a whole. It's short, It's strong, hard not to love this one.

Easy listening. Beautiful voice.

I may be wrong but I think he might have been a jesus fan. Classic album but I need to be in a specific mood for it. This album demands rainy days and much looking out of the window whilst self reflecting. Sadly its sunny today so I'm gonna put on some twisted sister instead

Yeah. Definitely a genius.

An enjoyable, easy listen.

5.0 + Now that I've almost finished this massive, multi-year listening exercise, it's nice to circle back on "What's Going On", an album I've loved for many years, and realize just how great it really is.

In its historical, socio-political context I understand how this was an important record, but it doesn’t really seem to deviate from a single musical motif the entire album.

Some consider this to be the best album of all time. So I started off with high expectations, but unfortunately it didn't do much for me... 2.5/5

What’s Going On (Marvin Gaye) 1. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) 2. What’s Happening Brother 3. What’s Going On 4. God is Love 5. Flyin’ High (In the Friendly Sky) 6. Right On 7. Wholy Holy 8. Inner City Blues 9. Save The Children

Glorious. 5 stars. should still be on the list, imho.

Didn’t do anything for me at all

First time listening to Marvin Gaye, really liked it

So good. First time I listened to it I didn't really pay attention but songs were getting stuck in my head so I've listened to it 3 times already. Marvin Gaye has so much influence in all my favorite genres

What a wonderful album , great production, amazing concept , love IT

Yeah this is easily one of the greatest and important records ever made. So goddamn groovy the whole way through, and masterful writing

DER Klassiker! Schwer nicht zu mögen. Säusel auf hohem Niveau. Ach das war nett damals (:o)

too velvetty for me today

Gear: Meze 109 PRO Mix: glasklar, smooth und teils überraschend verspielt Musik: inhärent düsterer, zeitloser Klassiker in Sachen überragender Vocals, Instrumentierung und (leider) Lyrics Wertung: ☔☔☔☔☔/5

Classic album that I own in 2 formats. Love it.

God is invading your privacy right this second. Stop praising him, he's the same as google. Not a fan

its ait not much more to say

An all time great album

All time album but all the songs kind of sound the same.

Timeless, ahead of it’s time

3/5. Good album, but it was not a good day for me to hear it.

A wonderful feel good soul album. I can see myself revisiting this when I need a pick me up.

Eh. It all kinda sounds like one song.

Great album. Listened to it once when I was younger but couldn't get into it. Right time/age now. Appreciate him not overdoing it and making an hour long 14-track album which kneecaps most of the best ones. Few weaker, softer, more biblical tracks stop the covered 5*, but it sure comes close. 4.5*

I enjoyed this album. It was a little more subtle than I was expecting and would have liked to hear Marvin Gaye's range more. The music was solid and it worked well with his Lyrics. I hope we get more Gaye and a chance to see more of his range and style. Ultimately this album left me wanting more.

One of the more important albums to exist. It's messages are timeless and can so easily be applied to the world we find ourselves in today. Behind beautiful, soulful, and expressive vocals the bass adds another dimension to the album which gives it such a masterfully crafted sound. What words can't express, james jamerson plays out on his strings. This is one of those rare albums that captured lightening in a bottle and used it to benefit the world, not only with sound but with its messages.

It was fine but not really my thing

Yeah! Nice slow songs good lurics

4.5 - great chilled album!

Perhaps the album's impact was profound upon its original release in 1971, but I really struggle to see or hear any justification for this record's commonly celebrated status as "greatest of all time". While I intend to listen to it again potentially to temper my opinion, the album as a whole, minus a few moments, seems to my ears a long and monotonous murk of reverb, strings, and dramatic vocal improvisation. Not my thing!

It's hard to pinpoint what makes this album so great. The fact the Gaye knew what he wanted despite Berry Gordy's pleadings with him to not do a political album; his masterful songwriting; OR the themes woven through the entire album by the Funk Brothers to the point that it sound like one seamless track. 5/5.

Stoned and spiritual!

A masterpiece that got me more into music as a teen.

What a voice.

Fish full of Mercury. Thermometurbot.

still going on, marv

Phenomenal album 10/10

Beautiful

mmmmmmmm Marvin

I love Marvin Gaye this ones my favorite out of the albums we've listened to of his

I enjoyed this album much more than "Let's Get It On" from a few weeks ago. However, even as groundbreaking this concept album is, in the end it just felt like a 36 minute version of "What's Going On" so it felt a little drawn out.

Overall good, but definitely recycled the same musical elements on several tracks (clarinet anyone?).

Honestly, boring and preachy.

Another record that I was already very familiar with, but which is unreal so it's nice to be reminded of

Really nice

Love the vocals, the rhythms, and the instrumentals. Definitely a fantastic album.

Like a perfect album. Really strong messaging, though not too specific, that’s important to be expressed especially at the time. It rocks. RIP.

Not a fan of Soul music, so me enjoying this album genuinely took me by surprise

j'avais déjà écouté avant flm de réécouter

Un titre ça va, plusieurs c'est trop.

nice! wtever

Er. I’m not sure. I liked the songs I already knew. I don’t think I realised it was a concept album and the continuous nature of it made it feel like one song that made me a bit woozy. I know it’s important. But I think I might have to come back to this one. Too early to tell on one listen.

Classic, everyone should definitely hear this album.

The quality of this album far exceeds my enjoyment unfortunately

Marvin Gaye’s glorious magnum opus is as life-affirming as it is soulful. It’s a testament to moving forward in the face of adversity, and while I think the album is actually a little overrated, I very much have to respect what it is and what it did for soul music.

3/18/24. Marvin Gaye is one of the best singers we’ve had. Songs here flow beautifully into each other and carry a significant message that still resonates today. Also love the classic R&B sound with the Philly-soul elements.

Marvin Gaye could sing about dish soap and you would be grateful for it. Kidding aside, this album is a poignant and visceral sign of the times in US history. He preaches with eloquent vocals that provide soul for the body and mind. The overall instrumental sound is amazing, and his angelic voice is almost too good to believe.

Smooth and enjoyable

I like this a lot.

Absolutely fantastic. Big fan of Marvin Gaye and Whats going on is THE best album he did. Music a delight to Listen to. First class production and meaningful hit home lyrics especially on 'Makes me wanna holla'. Superb stuff from the man who had the voice of an angel.

Good album, great performances especially from Marvin Gaye. Tracks flow really well together, nice listening experience.

It's often said that pop culture goes in cycles, but if there's any evidence that all of society goes in cycles, too, it's that this album is as meaningful and resonant in 2024 as it was in 1971, 1991, etc.

What struck me today was how in retrospect a lot of this album's apocalyptic political messaging becomes a metaphor for the more troubling aspects of Gaye's personal life. I had to stop in my tracks for a moment after really listening to "Don't go talking about my father, God is my friend". The use of uplifting music to mask, misdirect, or emphasize pain (personal or political) is nothing new, but this has to be one of the most consistent, well-executed examples of it.

The first 2 songs' titles make it seem like he is really confused

Blind album and artist. Just not my thing unfortunately. I loved the title track though

Was never sure if this album was overhyped just due to the tragic story but it actually is really good.

He’s just one of da best of da best.

Very nice, like a preacher who can sing

Este disco me llego un viernes y se quedó todo el fin de semana y creo que ahora estoy embarazado.

Smoother than a babies bottom. That is sat in a silk baby seat. In the back of Roll Royce Silver Shadow. Possibly driving on Crucible snooker table beds. Which is a bit weird considering it's an album with a pretty bleak theme of PTSD and anger. But that's Marvin's voice. It's an album that you could chuck on at any time an not be annoyed by. Equally there aren't that many highs to it. Just smooth listening.

Oh my god it’s beautiful. I love this album. Lyrically and musically it’s perfect.

The title track is very groovy and a very good song the second song is much slower but still very strong this album works as both a good album and also a strong statement

if you skip any song on this album i really don’t like you like actually what is wrong with you wish i could give it higher than a 5

marvin gaye is hands down one of THE MOST talented people to ever bless the earth this album is INSANELY good very powerful message godly progression throughout the album shit just flows into each other 5/5 MOTHER MOTHER

Not awful though

I applaud the concept of this one, but I’m not sure I would have caught on had I not read the background.

come onnnn

The album is good. Many of the songs easily blend from one to another.

I had already listened to Inner City Blues at some point and had it liked. Three stars feels like such a nebulous space but this isn't good enough for four. This is why I like half stars! Favourite track: Save The Children.

Smooth and soulful, definitely a nice listen. There are some really cool grooves in here. If I was more into R&B or Soul I would give this five stars, but four stars.

Easy listen, nice groove and a sense of cohesiveness.

An exquisite work of art - such depth, such soul. It is hard to overstate the beauty of the voice and the orchestration. Gaye could have recorded anything he wanted and continued to make radio friendly, high quality jams. But, instead, he chose thoughtfulness and introspection and social observations on the ecology, Vietnam and the suffering of black people in US society - and created a masterpiece.

I liked it more than Mike.

Marvin Gaye, the epitome of Motown. With James Jamerson on bass you know the rhythm section will be on point.

Good music to get lost in

I really just equate Marvin Gaye with date night music, but this album was much more than that. There's some really good, deep lyrics in this album that surprised me. The title track is fantastic, and it sets the tone for what is a lovely album all around. Maybe could've used a bit more variety, but Gaye knew his sound, and he leaned into his strength well.

It’s pretty damn good.

Just not my type of music but the lyrics and voice a v good

Great album! So many classic songs with my favorite being Inner City Blues.

A couple good songs in here. What’s Going on and Mercy Mercy Me were decent. Right On was the best track. The rest of the songs were meh at best. I was going to give a three star but Save the Children is straight up one of the worst songs I’ve ever heard so that knocked it down to a two for me.

Let's go baby, I'm in for some soullllll. Though its themes are a little overly saccharine for me. God is Love is a little too much. Inner City Blues is a bop though.

Relaxing. Ambiente Sound aber nicht mehr vo dem Album mitgenommen.

A little too slow for my tastes. Good for easy listening I guess.

Not my jam, but would listen again. Easy listening music.

so less than 60 albums in and this is already the 2nd repeat artist. Didn't care for it as much as the previous entry "lets get it on".

Overall: would not have listened to unprompted, outstandingly positive surprise. -large open (but not empty) room sound, clean but lively -"Flyin' High" is seamless "progressive" section -broad, but consistent instrumentation (especially bass+congas(?)+chime accents) -song transitions really smooth, sells the "concept album thing" of all songs being different sections of one big piece well -"God is Love" reprise of beginning "What's Going On" -"Mercy Mercy Me" neat Saxophone Solo (stand-out timbre) -"Mercy Mercy Me" favourite until now, but cleanest cut yet after it -did not expect the "Bossa" -"Inner City Blues" really groovy and reprise again

Great album. Love Marvin, and overall good vibe from this one. Very soulful and peaceful.

I love this one 9/10

Magnificent. I love that sometimes I listen to this album and really focus on the lyrical power, and sometimes you can just let the sound envelop you. The recurring motifs in the music work superbly throughout, with the title track coming back into your consciousness throughout the album, meaning this works as a concept album pretty perfectly. There are a couple of minor things I will say - Save The Children is quite a poor song to the point of being skippable, and the scraper on Right On renders a really great song a bit irritating. But these are tiny quibbles that might point to me holding this otherwise faultless album to really high standards. Feel free to hate me, but a perfect 5.0 can't have a song that you want to skip on it, so it gets a magnificent 4.8 and a place in the GOAT conversation.

Mercy me

Awesome grooves and a lot of soul.

Eh, not my gear. A little less funkier and a little more preachier.

One of my favorite albums of all time. I love how the songs turn into the next. That makes for a wonderful listening experience when you listen it as an album from end to end.

Marvin Gaye has a beautiful voice and this album truly highlights it. Easy to listen, enjoyable from beginning to end.

Lovely, mellow album with a classic track or two. 3*

I'll give it a four. It didn't really chime with me yesterday (probably because there are about 10 versions of the same song on the Deluxe version of the album I was listening to) but its undoubtedly a good listen.

My ex-girlfriend, Hazel, introduced me to this album in 1998. I have loved it ever since.

Make it easy: 5/5. I wish I could give it 6/5. I know this album well, it is one of the albums I would qualify as "important". Something everyone should listen to before they die. This is music with a message. That can be really hard to pull off without being overbearing, but Marvin Gaye nails it here. The music carries the message but the message doesn't get in the way of the music. The iconic songs "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me" and "Inner City Blues" are... well... iconic. Among the best. The rest of the album ties in and it all ties together. There's a reason this album is near the top of everybody's "Best Albums" lists

Amazing voice, amazing album. Sadly, the title track is as relevant today as it was in 1971.

Motown’s crowning achievement, a timeless and beautiful album. The gorgeous music shimmers and gleams while Marvin’s voice yearns for happier times. The album is deeply political but never preachy, infused with purpose and emotion. Love the way that melodies and sounds repeat and develop over the course of the album. Incredible work by an incredible artist. Best song: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Great album

Classic bedroom music 7/10

"What's Going On" by Marvin Gaye, released in 1971, is a timeless masterpiece that transcends the boundaries of traditional soul music. The album is a concept album that addresses social and political issues of the time, including poverty, war, and environmental degradation. Tracks like the title track "What's Going On," "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)," and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" are not only musically captivating but also lyrically profound, showcasing Gaye's vocal prowess and songwriting genius. Musically, the album blends soul, jazz, and gospel influences, creating a lush and immersive sound that perfectly complements the album's lyrical themes. Overall, "What's Going On" is a groundbreaking album that remains relevant and impactful to this day. It earns a solid 4/5 rating for its artistic vision, musicality, and cultural significance.

A stone cold classic.

Mjög gott concept albúm. Vel gert. Góð ádeila. Geggjuð rödd.

It's a 5. Perfect album from start to finish. It's soulful, it's funky, it has everything you could want. The grooves on some of these tracks are all-timers, the instrumentation is lush and it's just a good time.

This album has definitely stood the test of time. The production and lyrics hit, and if you told me this came out in the last 20 years I would’ve believed you. Favorite track: Title Track

"WAR IS HELL WHEN I WILL IT END, WHEN WILL PEOPLE START GETTING TOGETHER AGAIN." I heard this album for the first time during covid and this line hit so hard. This is a perfect concept album of the Veteran struggle and may be one of the most perfect albums ever created. Not in my personal top 5 but Objectively I KNOW. When the notes HIT ON THE SAVE THE BABIES OH MY GOD. How can you make music that has so much meaning be so catchy and groovy. GOD IS LOVE IS SUCH A GOOOOOOOD INTRO TO MERCY MERCY ME AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH! IF THIS IS WHAT CHRISTIAN MUSIC WAS LIKE I WOULD BE DEVOUT I CAN LISTEN TO THIS FOR DAYS :) Mercy Mercy Me was my intro to this album through The Strokes cover which is also good but not to the level! Anyways love

A question asked in the early 70's, in the most beautiful way ever, Gaye's voice, that can be asked in today's world. Just what is going on? This an album with some many beautiful lyrics that are still relevant in the world today. This album is not only beautiful, you can feel his pain and yet, remains just a wonderful listen. These are the albums I live to hear. You FEEL his music, his words, his wonderful gift of a silky smooth voice. Ready the story behind the album made the listening experience even better. One of my favorite songs by Gaye is the opener What's Going On and have to be honest and say I probably didn't get the message of the song until this week. Shame on me. Listening to the entire album, his messages, the struggles and still be a sensual album is not easy to do. But damn, it's Marvin Gaye. This guy is definitely one of the best ever. Top 3 for me, What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues. I'm not going to rip of the flute parts in Right On. Ha. 4.5

5 My building’s fire alarm went off at 5 this morning due to someone smoking, and by the time everything was sorted, it was time to drag my groggy ass to the gym… on leg day, no less. So, I didn’t start the day in a particularly good mood, but instead of putting on some familiar comfort music to power through my workout, on a whim, I decided to check out my album of the day, a certain What’s Going On by Marvin Gaye, to see what all the hype is about. The next thing I knew, mid-squat, I had the biggest smile on my face and found myself looking forward to the day ahead. What a magical album. I enjoyed Let’s Get It On, but this is next-level - and applicable in non-sexual situations, which is an additional bonus. I can’t even really describe what makes it that way, but there’s something so enchanting about Gaye’s work here that makes you want to stop what you’re doing so you can just sit back and listen. I didn’t even bother trying to keep up with what song I was on in order to make note of specific highlights, I just found myself enjoying the moment I was in, an experience that’s greatly enhanced and kept suspended by the nature of each song’s segue into the next - it’s beautifully executed and effectively keeps you in a perpetual trance for the duration of your listen. The album also feels ahead of its time in that regard, though truthfully, I don’t think it’s ever been done better than this right here. An immersive and fantastic experience from start to finish. I’ve somehow never heard this before, and yet I knew after my first listen this was going to be a 5. At its heart, music to me has always been about emotion, and this made me feel a few quite deeply, reminding me of what I love about the medium and why it has and always will be my favorite thing this fucked-up world has to offer. A great album to end the week on and start the weekend, the kind that reminds me of the good in the world and makes me want to share love with those that I love - because what IS going on? RIP Marvin - you have a newfound fan in me.

Such a great, sweet listen. 4 stars

An established classic, but numerous listens to this album have never stirred anything particularly deep in me. A 3.

Really good, very listenable enjoyed from start to finish

I had two Marvin Gaye albums in a row. This one suffers from the same issue I had with his other album. This first song is awesome and then the rest of the album is forgettable. This has the slight edge because I think there’s two other songs that are good. But the highlight is the first track. 3/5

Not my kind of jam

Rien à dire de plus, un classique. 9/10

An absolute classic. The musicianship is amazing too. Particularly when you think that James Jamerson was playing lying down because he was too drunk to stand up

This is one I’ve been looking for too. It’s incredibly hyped and I haven’t really heard it. I found it a little underwhelming. It’s good. It’s light and airy, yet thematically important. But lyrically it’s pretty simple. Not necessarily a bad thing. The album kinda just floats along which I guess is what many love. For me it’s not exactly my jam. 7.2/10 10

Good listening. Calming and interesting. A little heavy handed at times.

Love this album. So cool how the songs flow into each other. The whole thing is so tight and cohesive while simultaneously feeling really organic and loose. The orchestration and arrangements are so good. It totally has its own sound. Marvin Gaye was such a brilliant singer and songwriter. I love all the vocal layers. These are the greatest bass lines on this album I love how they play off of and compliment the vocal too.

One of the best records of all time.

I love everything about this except the percussion

favourite song: save the children shouldve heard this before

I must admit I listened to this one without paying too much attention. It's Marvin Gaye, potentially good and transformative for its time. I'll listen to it again later just to be sure, but I'll give it a 4-star rating just based on my confidence, even knowing I didn't even note when it finished in my listening session.

It’s a must listen. But is it great? The three singles are. The band is of course superb. Marvin is probably singing the best he ever did. The cultural impact of this is still felt 50 years down the track. But according to the wiki article, Greg kot was in a minority, feeling that the three singles were worthy, but the rest of the album was 'meandering introspection'. I want to disagree but I can’t. It gets five stars, but not for itself, but its context.

There are 3 great tracks here - the title track, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) & one of my all-time Gaye faves - Inner City Blues(Makes Me Wanna Holler). That’s enough to make this a great record, although I have to say the other half-dozen tracks don’t thrill me greatly. Still, the big three are outstanding, for many reasons & there’s no doubt that this album had enormous influence over the music that was to come. A great listen.

I would listen to Marvin Gaye, here at the height of his powers, sing the telephone book. This deliberately cohesive suite of smooth, but politically right-on, soul was massively influential. Berry Gordy hated it until it sold a zillion copies and spawned three hit singles. And it a fantastic listen. I am tempted to sing the praises of this album at length, but, really, you should just go listen to it. This is one of the few absolute, no arguments, must-hear albums on the list.

Classic, and we already own collector's vinyl.

A politically aware album reflecting the ongoing changes in 19702 America

What's Going On? Not much honestly.

I was expecting some experimental avant-garde metal prog, but I find myself very disappointed.

To be honest, I always thought this album was overrated and I still think it's the case. Nevertheless... It's still a great smooth soul/motown album and considered its reputation, a spot on the 1001 is well deserved. I'm not a fan of Marvin's way of singing, but musically speaking, the strings arrangements are brillant here and the percussions are creative, varied and well done.

immense levels of grooviness. 4/5

Undeniably a classic, smooth as hell from front to back with something to say. One of those albums where I would actually take your musical opinions a little less seriously if I knew you hadn't heard this.

What a beautiful album from a legendary singer whose life was cut way too short.

Very good and I knew some of his songs.

songs dealing with the anti-war movement, drug addiction, an increasingly darker world, apathy, and love. Religious undertones throughout, harkening back to a childhood of belief - and presumably a continued belief. Inner city blues comes in to end the album with a very honest consideration of how the inner city black families see the lack of support from the government, even the rest of the country.

Great album, seems like a concept album really. Same motif follows throughout. Unique sound, nice groove

Legit a top 5 album ever. Loved it

Beautiful music

great R&B soul

Social and cultural significance: 5 stars. Musically, I’m just not that into it: 2 stars. I would seek this album out to listen to again like I would with Sgt. Peppers or Sticky Fingers.

- production is so pretty i love the strings and the chorus and everything - marvin gaye's voice is so beautiful - the music kinda has a hazy dreamlike quality esp with the chord progressions which use lots of extended chords esp extended minor chords and the progressions aren't straightforward pop progressions theyre like slow shifting backgrounds so each time you shift to a new chord it isn't clear where in the cycle you are and you just get like lulled in and also each song transitions smoothly into the next one, also the production contributes to this to bc its so full bodied and theres so many different parts and instruments so the texture is always so filled up and its just like this luscious shifting soundscape that envelopes you - i know this is not very insightful at all because im so unfamiliar with this kind of music so im really just noting the most obvious and characteristic traits of it - but anyways the warm, encompassing, slightly meandering nature of the music is the perfect accompaniment for the sentiments expressed in the lyrics of peace and love, and against war and pollution. its like the music creates the tranquility gaye advocates for god thats so corny but yeah - the final song stands out a bit stylistically compared to the rest of the album i feel like it has a stronger groove and a clearer structure with a slow build in the instrumental and strong hooks - my thoughts are kinda dumb asf im just not familiar enough with this music to give any real insight but you know what i enjoyed listening to the album it was something new for me and there was a lot of beauty in it and i felt very at peace

Good vibes but sanctimonious. Some abrupt endings, was Max accidentally skipping whilst out for a run?. Why was the triangle so prevalent?

classic motown sound

Super great. Almost a 5, but I think the whole album is a little disconnected.

Netter 70er Soul.

Not much more you can say about this album that hasn't been said, it's iconic.

Ok good. A bit too much about Jesus and God. Between a 3 and a 4

Better than I remember, no filler, vocals at their best.

Classic album. Solid outing.

Nothing to add. Stone cold five.

LOVED this one! How can you go wrong with Marvin Gaye? That voice, those lyrics. The power in his words. This is the kind of album that makes me grateful I'm doing this "challenge."