Reviews (page 2 of 8)
I wish I had been cool enough to have heard this in 1987, but alas I was listening to Bryan Adams and Huey Lewis cassettes. I had no idea music like this existed. Fortunately I figured it out in the mid 1990s, and this band and this album were in frequent rotation. My appreciation for J’s guitar wizardry has only grown.
Nice and punchy ! 3.5
Didn't really find a lot to click with.
Det här albumet är ungefär i samma stil som the pixies men jag tycker att det är lite tråkigare. Som jag förstår det är det väldigt inflytelserikt vilket jag kan förstå, men personligen njöt jag inte alltför mycket av albumet. Jag ger det en 6/10.
Älskar detta album, men jag har tyvärr inte varit i särskilt musiklyssnande mood senaste dagarna (därför denna recension är så sen…) Jag älskar blandningen stökiga gitarrer och sångarens röst. Det kittlar min hjärna på exakt rätt sätt. Jag hade kunnat lyssna sönder detta album om det inte var så att jag hade ett till album att lyssna på. Jag ger detta album, utan starka motiveringar en 8.5/10
Really fun listen … the guitars went super hard. Didn’t matter that the singing was pretty weak. 4
(3/5) Nothing on this actually grabbed me or inspired me. I liked it fine, and I'm thoroughly impressed it was at least 5 years ahead of this style (grunge/indie/lo fi stuff.. you'd know when you hear it). So, I definitely concur this is essential listening, as they were clearly an influential band for that era (early 90s) of rock. Will I revisit it? Probably not, but it was interesting from that context. Tip of the hat to them and thanks for influencing better bands later.
I've been familiar with Dinosaur Jr. (I owned both Where You Been and Without a Sound on CD, but have lost them to time), but I had never delved into their catalogue enough to realize they'd put an album out in 1987. Having heard this one now and placing it on a timeline amongst it's "peers," I feel like they were a much more influential band than I had previously given credit, rather than the "sound like several other bands" impression that I'd previously held. While I found it less polished than those later albums, therein lies a bit of its charm and impressiveness, deploying wall of sound and distortion effects without thoroughly drowning the track beneath (looking at you, Sonic Youth). It's a very solid listen, and one that I gladly replayed immediately to pick out the best parts of. Earns a solid 4/5 for encouraging me to revisit these old friends and catch up on where they are now.
207. You're Living All Over Me - Dinosaur Jr. (1987) 9.17.26 Variety: 3 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 5 Uniqueness: 5 Emotionality: 4 = 4.4 rounded down to a 4 "Not a show, feel so down/ And I struggle right inside out/ Reach the wall, and spiral down" I know that I first became familiar with Dinosaur Jr. via the music video for "Feel the Pain". I thought these guys seemed a lot goofier, more laid back, and unembarrassedly melodic than a lot of the grunge bands I'd been hearing, and as much as I liked them, I filed them away as, at the time, there were not really any outlets for experiencing a band's catalogue aside from spending a bunch of money on CDs. And I didn't know anyone who owned any of their stuff, so borrowing that album was out of the question. Later on when the 90s were mostly in the rearview, I began to read more music writing and kept seeing references to the band and how influential they were. Then maybe in the early 2000s I was finally able to more easily find their stuff. I won't mention the methods, but I'm sure people are familiar. Pretty sure I started with Without a Sound and worked my way backwards (I would have also heard "Freak Scene" from Bug around this time from the Left of the Dial compilation that I just mentioned in the last review). While Without a Sound was good stuff, it did not move the needle for me in being impressed. It sounded perfectly of its era. Well played, crunchy, fuzzy distorted guitars over a shambolic and lazily delivered, but melodic pop skeleton. Standard stuff for 90s indie rock. When I finally got back to You're Living All Over Me I was finally a bit astounded at how out of time it sounded. When I was in middle school the grunge and modern indie sound seemingly came out of NOWHERE. All the bands that had influenced the sound were completely unavailable to me ( I had not yet discovered 120 minutes on MTV and did not have any cool, older siblings) and it seemed formed out of nothing, delivered from on high to blow our little minds. I think this is partly why something like Smells like Teen Spirit so totally upset the culture. I think if you were older, and existed on the coasts or within those scenes you were already swimming around in the bubbling stew from which this stuff came out of and it probably felt more like a natural evolution of sound for you. R.E.M. was already HUGE by the time I heard them and I had to go back way later to hear where they started from. Husker Du and the Meat Puppets ( both of which gave me similarly crazy out of time vibes - especially Meat Puppets II) were not even words I was familiar with until the late 90s. But having absorbed so much of this stuff by now, that musical evolution makes a lot more sense to me and doesn't feel as weird. It's still a little weird though. 1987 for me is the Bangles' "Walk Like an Egyptian", Whitney Houston's "I Wanna Dance with Somebody, Whitesnale's "Here I Go Again", Bon Jobi's "Livin' on a Prayer", and Bruce Hornsby's "The Way It Is". It was the year the G.I. Joe and Three Men and Baby movies came out, and big hair and Camaros were still very cool. That there were these dudes who looked and sounded like they stepped through the time tunnel from 1994 to wow us with their fuzz pedals and slacker look is not a concept I could have conceived. Anyways, I'm sure to give this a mid to high 4. I know I like Bug better, but this one is still pretty great. Having just referenced them in the review of Sonic Youth's Dirty from a couple of entries ago, I'm pretty primed to here more of that sort of thing. I'm glad that we at least are getting to the two albums from the band in chronological order, which makes writing about them a tad easier. THE TRACKS "Little Fury Things" - Distorted, noisey production all around, super melodic choruses, and some awesomely crunchy fizzed out guitar work. All trademarks of the band, and stuff we'll be seeing throughout. This one has a bit of a melancholic sound to it, and remains catchy as hell. The staticky, hissing ending is the dirty, rusty bit of barbed wire that disguises the sugary sweet pop at the center. I mentioned how as much as this band's textures and vibe influenced the grunge sound, I think, sound-wise, they were maybe even more influential on the indie rock bands who weaved in and out of and all around the big grunge acts, and who survived onward when grunge imploded. There's going to be just as much power and jangle pop influence on here as there is any hard rock or metal. And I'd argue that even though you can hear it still, most of the metallic sheen the band has exists mainly in the high end, as the doomier bass bits have been filtered out. Unheavy Metal maybe? "Kracked" - Case in point - listening to this I can definitely hear the Deep Purple influence, especially in the guitar part that comes in around :44. The speed and the guitar heroics on display clearly show a love of that 70s harder sound, but exists all in the upper registers. Even Barlow's bass is far more loose and punky than it is massive. Mascis's instincts his guitar guitar solos trend towards the facemelting varety, but they are never overly showy and are in complete service of to the song. This is awesome. "SludgeFeast" - The title of this one is pretty on the nose, being maybe the most Sabbath-influenced thing on the album, with more than a little Husker Du thrown in as well. The first truly headbanging track. When Mascis comes in with his drawling Neal Youngish delivery the vibe comes down a bit. We get a bit of the loud/quiet/loud formula the Pixies and Nirvana would turn into templates that too many slavishly followed, and some more noisey textures before Mascis goes full-Iommi near the end. "The Lung" - This one follows the more straight arrow, R.E.M.-ish bouncy college rock template, and is slightly more generic for it. It feels much more like a jam until around 1:22 when the sound fills out completely and everything comes into a sharper focus. The Husker Du comparison still stands here, but there's some of the melodic punky vibes of the Buzzcocks on here as well. "Raisans" - Just as driving, but much more low key and in the pocket for me. There's a sort of ragged power pop sound to this one that's crunchy and melodic and which reminds me a bit of the Replacements. And the warbly, vowel stretching Neil Young delivery is in full force. I think with the benefit of hindsight Mascis is wearing his influences on his sleeve here, but the synthesis of all this is a pretty unique sound. "Tarpit" - An even softer open, this time with some more Buzzcocky scratchy guitar welded onto a bigger bass sound. The vocals get more reverb, and the delivery is almost comedically stretched out, drawling, and emotionally resonant. Like he wants to savor every syllable that escapes his mouth. Which makes it pretty hilarious when hear the dude in an interview and realize that he sounds more like Milton from Office Space, and speaks in a shy, deadpan, mumble. The noise elements at the end here make it sound like the track was recorded in an industrial wind tunnel that was accidentally switched on. Or maybe the band were all burned up in the wake of a jet engine. "In a Jar" - This one is much closer to the sound I would have been familiar with on Without a Sound. It's bouncier, and poppier, it messier and with a nice groove. There's some overlap here with some Miracle Legion stuff in the casual, almost tossed off delivery, but where that band goes soft and gentle, Dinosaur Jr. decide to go prickly and punchy. I could have heard this in 1995 or so and not batted an eye. "Lose" - Mascis dips back into his Iommi mode a bit here, but there's just as much Husker Du and more than a little of the band's hardcore origin peaking through the curtains as well. The Meat Puppet influence I think can be felt here as well with the cracked vocals, which I think Lou Barlow provided. "Poledo" - Awesome. We close with a downbeat ukulele number. You don't see that too often. Barlow provides the vocals here as well, and it's got what is easily the most lo-fi sound on the album, feeling very much like a demo that got expanded upon with some experimental, feedback heavy, White Album-inspired studio trickery. No idea if Trent Reznor was a fan of Dinosaur Jr. or not, but the last third of this track in particular is very Downward Spiral-coded with it's eerie, distorted analog ambience, and the HIGHLIGHTS - "Little Fury Things" - "Kracked" - "SludgeFeast" - "The Lung" - "Raisans" - "Tarpit" - "In a Jar" - "Lose" - "Poledo" MIDLIGHTS - LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS This was a lot of fun. As much as I really dug it, and found very little to complain about ( rare all highlights!) I know that I still like Bug a lot more than this, and feel like I have to grade on a curve a bit here. It's of a very high, sustained quality throughout, but I would argue that it never swings hard over into that rare territory where I've got multiple songs ( or EVERY. SINGLE. SONG. - Looking at you Nevermind) stuck in my head on a loop. Yeah, I know it's a high bar, and maybe an unfair comparison, but the band did go on to make songs like that, and the next one has at least one all-timer on it, which we'll get to when we get to it. And as solid as every track on here is, the massive influence on this one had on the next 5-10 years of music history far outweigh the music itself. This album ( and to a certain extent the band itself) is the equivalent of Steve Nash, the NBA hall of famer known for his low-key, quietly elite and unshowy playing and who is considered by some to be the epitome of a team player. The band is enormously talented, and is one of the major artistic examples of how rising tides lift all boats. Just try and imagine the sound of the 90s without these guys. Their (mostly) invisible hand can be felt in soooooo many places, but they never got the massive payoffs that some of the bands who followed them did. I'm sure both J. Mascis and Lou Barlow are both doing fine though. They've both continued to make tons more albums, and have remained mainstays of the indie scene for going on 40 years or so, and still put out well reviewed material. I've listened to some recent Dinosaur Jr. stuff and while it does not sound like they've evolved much, they have not yet gone extinct, and the quality levels have been maintained where so many other bands from the era have disappeared off the face of the earth, become sad parodies of themselves, or just wasted away into touring legacy band obscurity. Just know that if you reach into the hat and pull out any random album, you're bound to have a good time. Possible turn-Offs might include: - drawling, lazy disaffected sounding vocals - lots and lots of fuzzed out distorted guitars - lots and lots of noodling from said guitars - melodic lines that just sort of pop up out of nowhere and disappear just as fast, leaving you with the feeling that the band is occasionally hitting paydirt by accident before wandering off into the discordant cul de sac from which they emerged You Might enjoy this if you: - love crunchy, fuzzy, melodic guitar licks - are a fan of early to mid 90s indie and grunge - have high tolerance for noise - ever wondered where a lot of your favorite 90s bands got the textures that dominated their sound ( as well as their fashion sense) - don't mind loose structures - ever wondered what a combination of influences from Black Sabbath, the Buzzcocks, and Neil Young might sound like PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Nope. FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - Machine Head by Deep Purple - The Stooges by The Stooges - Sabotage by Black Sabbath - Zuma Neil Young and Crazy Horse - Over The Edge by Wipers - Singles Going Steady by Buzzcocks - Murmur by R.E.M. - Zen Arcade by Husker Du - Meat Puppets II by Meat Puppets Contemporaries: - Psychocandy by The Jesus and Mary Chain - Daydream Nation by Sonic Youth - Surfer Rosa by Pixies - The Lemonheads by The Lemonheads - Bakesale by Sebadoh - Tim by the Replacements Descendants: - Buzz Factory by Screaming Trees - Loveless by My Bloody Valentine - Bleach by Nirvana - High/Low by Nadasurf - Ultimate Alternative Wavers by Built to Spill - Buffalo Tom by Buffalo Tom - No Pocky for Kitty by Superchunk - Icky Mettle by Archers of Loaf - Smoke Ring for My Halo by Kurt Vile - Castle Talk by Screaming Females
If an album could sound like its held together by duck tape and a mortar soaked in tobacco spit I think it might be this album. This thing felt like a bunch of parts leaning on each other and not falling down because of gumption. I enjoyed it, after a fashion, but man it was not easy to love. I can see the influence on the alternative rock that would be coming out in just a handful of years following this though and maybe I'm appreciating it through the lens of the stuff I did love and grew up with. Dinosaur Jr. is another act I've heard of but never really actively listened to. We just had Sonic Youth a few days ago and they were more to my liking. You can see how they fell into the standard alt rock. I wonder if Dinosaur Jr. ever did. The riffs and hooks were worth following, but it was too reliant on the feedback for effect. Again, at least for my tastes. Its a 3/5 that I appreciate for what followed in its wake.
Heard it before but I cannot tell you that it made an impression because I keep forgetting what this band even sounds like. Heard about them a lot when I was deep in my 90s alternative phase but I just never found them interesting 2/5
I don't think I'm much of a noise-rock person, and this is firmly not my favourite rock vocal phenotype, and this band has some of the ugliest heebie-jeebie-giving album art ever made, but I enjoyed this a lot despite all that. You have to get through the initial sting of abrasiveness to start having fun and enjoying the nice melodic elements, like sour candy. It sounds years ahead of its time. Plus their raggedy cover of Just Like Heaven is quite sweet and ridiculous.
Not sure if I'm ever in the mood for noisy distorted guitars played badly with over-use of feedback and a terrible voice accompaniment. There is also a distinct absence of keyboards to lighten the load. Sounded like someone tried to pull the plug in the middle of Raisans and then again in Poledo. Might have been better if they hadn't plugged in at all. What a disaster!
The dream team of J Mascis and Lou Barlow (when they still got on with each other) is messy noisy and sometimes hard to listen to but also pure beautiful early indie slacker rock (actually heavily influenced by Black Sabbath, Rolling Stones and their ilk) I hope everyone listened to the Just Like Heaven cover?? AMAZING!! When people ask 'what era do you wish you could travel back in time to... Renaissance Italy, ancient Rome, the Roaring Twenties in Paris or Berlin.. nope for me it would be the late 80s lo fi indie rock era in America. Anyone wanting something more melodic should check out Barlow’s side project Sebadoh. The more accessible album Bug is on the list as well so something to look forward to!
Love Dinosaur Jr, love love love J Mascis, buuuuut not mad about the production on this record and would be .5 to 1 of a star more enamoured if they could have done a better job of capturing any sort of bass tones. Also, its probably sacrilege but I like the band a lot more once Lou Barlow has gone off to be in Sebadoh. Still, it’s a fun if just bit too lo-fi mess of noise and hooks.
I understand that this is supposedly super influential, that doesnt mean I like it.
This was pretty decent. I wanted to like it more than I did, but still.
This is pretty much lo-fi indie rock perfection. It's hard to explain what exactly makes these songs work so well, and I can well see how to outsiders, this would sound somewhat 'generic'. The magic, of course, lies in the fantastic riffs and songwriting, paired with the emotional yet aloof singing which has become the blueprint for all indie singers who may not be the pinnacle of vocal virtuosity. You can hear how this is unequivocally a fully authentic moment in time that was captured, rather than the band trying to imitate a certain intended 'low-fidelity' sound. Still, I do wish the album was just a bit more adventurous, as everything between the bookending tracks does have a remarkably similar sound; that's the only thing *just* holding this back from 5 stars for me.
I’ve found Dinosaur Jr to be a little too “noise rock” for me in the past but this one was more enjoyable than expected. I still like these guys more as a greatest hits band. “Just like Heaven” was the clear highlight in my opinion.
4.5 I just had a conversation 2 days ago about how cool lou barlow is. Album is a burner. Top 5 hangover for me was after a Dino Jr show at starlite room. I was posted up at my spot with and between the 27 glass bottles of pil and not bringing ear plugs ( not that im an ear plug guy anyway) something really messed my equilibrium for a few days. Im laughing now, 18 years later, on how fucking loud that show was.
It’s hard to pin this down to one rock subgenre, there’s a lot going on here, but one of the thing that pops out to me is how this sound is a total precursor to grunge. And WOW this album sounds incredible. The guitar tones are so beautiful. “Slugefeast” is an all-encompassing colorful, gritty wall of guitars. There’s no way I’m not listening to a remastered version, but according to Spotify at least, it’s the original master. Though theyre from Massachusetts, “The Lung” has a bit of a Midwest flare to it. “Tarpit” wields this stretched, melancholy, hefty sense of weight. Guitars that distort to sound like tornadoes at the last minute, vocals that hang onto the backing track by a thread. A very humane mixture of emotions all spilled out and painted into one song. Right as the album started to get samey, “Poledo” came on. I was stunned. I don’t know if I’ve ever heard of a song so gritty and tender all at once. The phases this song flips through, all while managing to maintain a very specific sound, are astounding. I’m at a loss for words. For Dinasour Jr. to go from that gothic depth charge of a song into a whistful, lovey jam session on the two minutes of “Just Like Heaven”, ONLY for it to be interrupted by those screaming “NO!” chants, just then for the song to abruptly end — amazing. I think I’m gonna give this album a very high 4/5. There are ways in which it is indeed a true 5. It’s so ahead of its time, it’s a very pure expression of difficult emotions, it’s got some of the best guitar tones I’ve ever heard. It might be missing a sticky melody or two for my tastes, and the start of the second half of the record lulls a bit. But those are truly the only nitpicks I can drum up. I had a great time discovering this album and band
This is a band I should have liked back in the late 80's when I was very into the alternative/indie scene. I never found them as fun and interesting as all the bands I enjoyed, thus I never did much of a deeper dive. This album at times came close to being awesome. Unfortunately each time it did, there was then a moment that just knocked it down and made it more annoying for me. If it was going to be noise, then just be noise. If it was going to be melodic, then just be melodic. It felt like they needed to feel like they were challenging their fans, so each song had their thing to either make it more or not at all beloved. There were a few songs that pushed through that, so for me The Lung and Tarpit were the ones I enjoyed the most.
What a frickin' masterpiece this is! And it's only Dinosaur's second-best album. (To my shock, their best album, Where You Been, is NOT on the list. That slightly invalidates this whole exercise, if you ask me. But I will persist.)
I like JM and his sludgy tendencies...but he'll never be a 5.
Sludge and fuzz for days! I listened to this a lot in college and revisit one a pretty regular basis.
Love the noise but most songs could use some more structure. Poledo should go away. Just Like Heaven is great.
4/5 - J always sounds like J: the fuzz-sludge guitar, the doesn't give a shit voice. Huge influence on the decade to come and beyond. I really like almost all Dinosaur Jr., but it's not really enough for 5s for me.
Too shoegaze-y, too wall of sound-ish. Didn't do much for me. 2 out of 5
This flip flops between painfully dull (in that particularly male 90s way) and actually sonically painful. Oof ooof ouch please don't shout! Stop abusing your instruments! What did they do to you :( They ended up stopping doing their own crap music and started playing The Cure at the end. I'm not the biggest Cure person in the world, but it really made me appreciate them even more because they don't scream in the middle of their bloody songs for no fucking reason other than to fuck me off. 1 star
Jesus christ, this is bad. I forgot I already gave this a listen a week ago. I must have purged the experience from my brain.
Pretty decent, as long as the singer actually shuts up. However the whole singing is so whiny and boring the whole albums becomes a slog.
2.5 rounded down
Surprisingly high quality rock
gran album, me parece medio shoegaze viejo, lastima que el nombre de la banda no pega un carajo
So fun so fun; what have we done?
De klanken van het 1e nummer maken me weer 18 jaar oud 😄. Een geweldige plaat
Too much static and distortion for my taste. I was starting to enjoy Poledo and then there was a big blast of just sound. Also features my least favorite cover I’ve ever heard of Just Like Heaven
This was sort of a 3 star until I got to Poledo then really started to knock off a star. Then I got the bonus track “Just Like Heaven” and that sealed the deal - that version of the song was horrible!
Was mediocre at best.
A band beloved by a lot of people I respect, but I just can't get on board with those whiny vocals.
Having Daydream Nation and this in the space of one day has elevated my music status by 67%. Also, it turns out that T-Rex, Jurrassic 5 and Dinosaur Jr. are all different bands, but they are all fantastic!
Aldri hørt om før. En del her jeg kan like, men også noe som ikke faller i smak. Ville ikke forundre meg om Nirvana hentet litt inspo herfra. Merkelig brå avlsutning.
The music is great, but the vocals can't hold up to the fuzz.
One of the bands that influenced the bands I listened to growning up, and I regret not listening to them at the time. This album is so good.
Ok maybe I finally get Dinosaur Jr this was great!
Dinosaur JR manage to make pop music and noise seem as if they were natural to each other, as if the other needed the other to survive. J Mascis (Dinosaur JR's frontman) sincere, heart-broken-like inflection (precursor to a lot of indie rock) and introverted/shy approach to singing is probably what makes the connection between noise and pop connection meld together just a bit easier. The guitar parts are bordering on virtuosity, there tends to be these freakout sections (notably in "Sludgefeast") where the noise part really comes into play. The production is pretty lo-fi which I'm sure sparked a lot of garage bands interest in them with a do-it-yourself message being delivered. I wish the bass guitar was a lot more present in the mix I think overall it would've sounded even better, but it's still really good sounding even if it's lo-fi. I would recommend this album a lot, it's just so good at what it's trying to do. This is also certainly a must-hear album I think everyone should listen to. Highlight Song/s: "Kracked" and "Sludgefeast"
Better than Coldplay
Bit noisey
had ik echt geweldig gevonden als 15jarige
The beginning of "The Lung" is terrific. The whole album is worth the listen.
I hate guitar noise, so when the album started, I thought it was going to be a 1. However, it does give me grunge-rock vibes, so ultimately I settled on 3 because there wasn't much more noise in the rest of the album.
No Bueno.
3.
I am a fan of Dinosaur Jr, but not sure they need more than one album on the list, and this isn’t the one that I would pick. It's okay but nothing stands out as being excellent. The production is awful though, even for 1980s home recording. 2.5⭐️
J Mascis is the most underrated guitarist of all time
really great guitar rock. Adored this album
Cool Alt Rock sound, aside from some (IMO) unnecessary extensive guitar feedback segments within a few songs. 2.5/5.0
The Just Like Heaven cover is a unique take on the song and I found Poledo the most interesting song on here, but the rest is average grunge.
Not my cup of tea.
3 stars
It’s loud and it’s really out there. Not sure what else to say. 6/10
It’s two days since I had the other Dinosaur Jr album! To my knowledge they have one really good song, and that is on an album that’s not on the list. Shame.
put this one on the back burner as I was pretty busy today. Still going to give it a listen though!
a bit aggressive for my tastes, and by that i mean too much screaming. still, i liked just like heaven and the lung. its a good album, just not my taste. glad im listening to these albums
I always get about halfway before checking the wiki, and I was wondering why I wasn't liking this album, then the wiki explained it nicely. "[The band is] the missing link between Hüsker Dü and R.E.M." That makes sense. While I don't like those bands in general, they have some good stuff.
This was some pretty middle of the road 90's alt rock, so, I guess they were ahead of their time and influential as a result, so, for for them. It's not great, though.
Just good ol' righteous chooglin punk rock
Pre grunge noise rock that is fine but not really anything special. As a precurser to Nirvana i prefer Mudhoney but this would have been fun if i was 18 in California in 1987. Not sure what happened to the last track but why not.
Mascis leaves the wah-gate open and that is the thing that is living all over the record. Generally, the noise and the melodies seem to disadvantage each other - the noise ungainly and the melodies naive. As a consequence, the most exhilarating moment on the whole album is the sudden stop at the end of Just Like Heaven. Finally, something that feels like it is under the musicians' control. But the song isn't officially on the album, so it doesn't really count. It puts everything else in stark relief however. It is still good fun though. Sludgefeast especially. 2.5 This was grand. J Mascis has some style as a guitarist and an instinct for unusual and quite pretty melodies. It’s difficult to resist doing Mascis the injustice of hearing him as a proto-Kurt Cobain though. Through that filter his lyrics come up short; his self-loathing a little tame, his encounters with women lacking in psychosexual horror. He sounds young and rather innocent to be making such a racket and ‚Poledo‘ feels like it ought to close out a much darker album than it does. All the same, I enjoyed this. 2.5/5
Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: Sludgefeast, Just Like Heaven True to the genre, this is early American alternative rock. Not rock and roll. Not any flavor of metal, not country, blues or hip-hop. Maybe a tad grunge... I might take issue with the premise in the description that this is considered one of the the most influential albums in alternative rock, considering the listen counts. The Beatles are influential. Black Sabbath are influential. Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin are influential. Nirvana are influential. If you polled some random person off the street and asked them about Dinosaur Jr., they'd ask if you meant the TV show Dinosaurs or Land Before Time... but whatever. I might be more likely to believe the description, if I had ever heard even one other band cite them as an influence. Now, mind you, there are actual citations of other bands referencing Dinosaur Jr., you just have to go looking for them (Wikipedia). This album feels raw and gritty. Sometimes it sounds clear, but most of the time its washed out. It comes in an entirely acceptable 38 minutes. They didn't inundate the listener with their entire catalog for their sophomore album and respect the listeners time, unlike some other bands. Every time I see a 30-50 minute album, that makes me happy.
Cool!
This list doesn't need two Dino jr albums and I prefer Bug.
I'm not sure this collection really needs two Dinosaur Jr. albums, but at least this particular album choice isn't a complete mystery, even if it's not noticeably better or different from the other album selection. It seems like "You're Living Over Me" is probably mixed a bit better than "Bug", assuming it's important to be able to hear and understand the lyrics. There weren't a lot of tracks than really stood out for me, although a few channeled a *very* iconic Dinosaur Jr sound (like "Kracked" or "The lung" or "Tarpit"), and a few had a somewhat different style than their usual wall of sound and possibly meaningless lyrics (like the grunge-adjacent "Sludgefeast" and the quirky Lou-Barlow-penned track "Poledo"), plus the pretty amusing/fun cover of "Just like heaven" (including a strange Muppet-inspired video). And while I can't really share the sentiment, it's nice to read that this was and is frontman J Mascis' favorite album.
I loved the cover of Just Like Heaven and the odd Poledo track before it but other than that, it was kind of alright.
I've listened to a a DinosaurJr before but they never really grabbed me. This reedited is generally really great and I liked it a lot with a couple of reservations. The quality really dips for a couple of tracks and at some points it gets get samey. Still, it was a really enjoyable listen
This is 2.5 quality-wise. 0.5 stars for nostalgia
Ok
Thoughts before listening: I bet this gets bad reviews on here, but I'm a big fan. J Mascis is one of my favorite guitarists of all time, and I love his slacker drawl as well. I'm glad to see this today. Review: For such a loud, fuzzed out guitar album, there is a ton of melody in these songs. This is definitely indie/alt rock that will have limited appeal, but I'm in that subset of music listeners that love it. J Mascis is the best, and seeing him standing in front of his massive amp stack drawling catchy song after catchy song and ripping solos is a treat. This is one of their best albums, and for me personally, its 5-stars.
I liked it
Cool album, seems like a blueprint for the grunge scene
Solid project with catchy riffs.
I'm glad I listened to it but this didn't really do much for me. You can see the bones of the 90's songs this influenced. After it was over I actually put on a Fugazi album and liked that a ton more. I've seen them live and was a pretty good show... very loud!
It's okay but nothing stands out as being excellent. The production is awful though.
Kind of a unique sound for that time period. Can definitely hear the influence this had on a lot of the stuff that came in the 90s.
Good listen. Great guitar work.
Enjoyment: 5/10 Replayability: 4/10 Cohesion: 4/10 Flow/Pacing: 4/10 Artistic Merit: 5/10 Weighted Average: 4.5/10 Review: I liked a significant portion of most songs, but the random, hellish static and breathy, whiny vocals were more of a detriment than anything else. It almost gave a unique sound, but it still wasn't pleasant to listen to. They should also stay in their lane because that cover of Just Like Heaven alone takes the whole album down a point. Liked Song(s): Kracked, Sludgefeast, Raisans, In a Jar, Lose Disliked Song(s): Tarpit, Poledo, Just Like Heaven Recommend? Maybe Heard Before? No
H: DNF’d the album. Made it through 7/12 songs before I couldn’t take it anymore. This was just noise is the absolute worst way. 0/10 Z: screeches and white noise, if you don’t like that you don’t like dinosaur jr. 2/10 For Fans Of: screeches, white noise and going def.
está cabrón que todas las bandas indie queramos ser dinosaur jr. pero la neta sí todas queremos, hasta sin darnos cuenta xd recién tuvimos ensayo del sancris y estamos trabajando yet again una rola con un chingo de partes y dijo pable que el chiste está en que no suene a prog, y al día siguiente regreso a este disco y me voy patrás de oir todas las partes que tienen las rolas sin que se note, no es prog, es pop, es rock, es ruido. lo mismo que queremos nosotrxs
it SUCKED BALLS
Something about this sound and style is warm and comfortable, like a blanket.
Little fury things - 3 Kracked - 3 Sludgefeast - 4 The lung - 4 Raisans - 3 Tarpit - 3 In a jar - 4 Lose - 3 Poledo - 2 Just like heaven * - 4
Meh.
Visst är det bra, men jag förstår också varför grungen inte breakade med dem utan med Nirvana oh Pearl Jam. Soundet finns där, men låtarna håller inte samma klass. En fyra blir det i alla fall.
No
That initial blast of noise will blow your hair back. And just when it feels like its unbearable, it scales back a touch into something listenable, and then it drops another level, and it's actually kind of pleasant, and then you realize you actually kind of miss the noise and as if on cue - we're back to noise rock. I can't say that I enjoyed all of the noiseyness, but....I'm impressed with the arrangements, the thoughtfulness that went into the dynamics, the chord voicings. The fact that this went on to inspire so many indie rock bands makes perfect sense. It's an amazing blend of ingenuity and rawness.... The sound is really interesting because the tone doesn't really match the style of music, and vice versa. When a song turns to metal, like on "SludgeFeast," the only thing keeping it from sounding cheesy is the wildly thin and crushed distortion. Knowing ahead of time how rough the sound of this record was, I expected to not enjoy it, but the more I think about it the more I like it. Excellent album. FOUR STARS
Some of the songs were good but the mixing was bad, sounds poor quality. 4/10
Meh. It was ok, but I wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it again. 2.5
Fluctuates between being exactly my thing to too nerdy and basement-dwellerish for me.
Nirvana opened for DJ in the early 90s, and you can hear their influence on Cobain's writing. This is what grunge was built on. Sure, the Pixies and Sonic Youth have something to say, but Dinosaur Jr could easily argue that they are the father's of grunge. And, this album, was playing when artists like STP, AIC, Nirvana, Soundgarden were conceived.
yu
Pudo encantarme y la verdad que no. Quedó en el medio de todo siento. No me gustó el cover de The Cure. Igualmente, agradable, es mi estilo así que cuesta que falle.
Solid music that I don't mind. Nothing grabbed me to make me want to listen again, but enough was good enough to have me check other albums, including the one I own.
Really cool album start to finish. Bit of a grungy sound to it, great instrumentals with awesome guitar solos and cool noise rock influences. Indie rock in the 80s riffed way fucking harder than modern indie.
Mediocre grunge. Still listenable but lacking structure. A bit sprawling.
Nice, I wish I got them yesterday. I am not sure why for the most part I really don't like indie music, but I really like these early original waves of it. This is great stuff, easy 4 stars
I like the alternative rock sounds but the songs just don't stick. I am a sucker for melodies and in here I hear none
Not bad at all
It got a little screamy or random noisy at times. But in the end I mostly had positive feelings.
I was into Se-bad-oh before I had heard D Jr, once I found these guys fell in love with them too. This album is just fuzz and reverb, noise rock with some metal guitar licks and REM like songwriting. Love J Mascis' singing style, love how melodic it is and at the same time very doom and gloom. I was going to rate this a 4, but because of how influential this album is on a lot of the bands I listened too and even some of the recent bands in multiple genres, I am giving it 5.
Little Furry Things
Noise grunge. Not the hugest fan of the lead singer's voice. Tunes seem tight, nothing really standing out. Poledo was mentioned a lot in other reviews which was interesting but not the album redeemer it was made out to be. I guess like some of these albums if you grew up with it being a significant part of your childhood/young adulthood/adulthood it would mean more, but just as music for music's sake that's a 3 for me.
perfect
Completely new stuff for me and I found it AWESOME!
Dinosaur Jr.’s You're Living All Over Me is defined by a muddy, noisy recording quality throughout, yet several standout tracks still manages to shine. "Little Fury Things" opens with a genuinely beautiful melody, while "Kracked" keeps the momentum going with an exceptionally interesting guitar solo. "Sludgefeast" gets immense energy from its drumming and a solid guitar line that easily overshadows its lukewarm vocals, and "Lose" alongside "Raisans" deliver satisfying, well-crafted moments. Middle tracks like "The Lung," "Tarpit," and "In a Jar" hold up as decent, passable cuts alongside a pleasant cover of "Just Like Heaven." The album's most dramatic shift occurs on "Poledo," offering a gentle folksy start that serves as a welcome reprieve from the noise before taking a sharp twist into an eerie, radio-tuning midsection that fades out into pure unearthly sound.
Simply just some of the best noise rock out there. Never lets up and is unnecessarily catchy. I found it impossible to not have fun. "Just Like Heaven" on the deluxe has quickly become an all timer for me. Brilliant stuff
At first I thought what was the fuss about. It was just noisy chaos, but song two interesting things started to happen and I could kid of dig it. The random cure cover at the end was cool too.
They have a grungy sound and you can hear their influence on the 90s grunge scene.
I was excited to get this one. I have liked Dinosaur Jr. in the past, but this one didn’t quite hit for me. There were things I liked, but always something I didn’t to keep me from loving it. 3/5
This explains a lot of good stuff that came afterward, so it gets props for influence. There's also some amazing guitar work. But I disliked pretty much everything else about it.
I can appreciate the musical influence, but only moderately liked this
I didn’t hate this, but I’m sure it would have enjoyed it more had I discovered it when it came out. Poledo aside, the music just doesn’t really stand out or fill any hole that isn’t served already by another band. I likely won’t be revisiting it. It also does not warrant the gushing that exudes from some folk.
Eh. Failing to do what the pixies did well
I didn’t really pay attention much to this one since I was climbing a mountain. 2/5
Dear lord, he can’t sing a note! I tried given all the 5 star reviews, but this is just ruined by the vocals. Pity, there’s a good band here otherwise. Really not surprised I didnt discover this in the 80s. Generous 2
Not at all familiar with this band before today. I really like the sound of some of the songs like the opener and In a Jar. Some songs got a little screamy for my taste. I was really into the cover of The Cures Just Like Heaven except for the screaming bits and the abrupt cutoff at the end. I’d like to put this between 3 and 4.
This album makes quite an impression before you even start listening, both the title and the album cover are incredibly interesting and draw you in in the best way. The music itself is cool and well-executed in it’s own right, with the band giving us a blend of different takes on alternative rock that are generally quite enjoyable and intriguing. This is definitely something I’ll return to and is a nice find for not having any familiarity with it or the band. I wasn’t as certain about how much I liked some of the ideas as it progressed compared to how strong it started. 1 listen Favorite Tracks: Little Fury Things, Kracked, Sludgefeast
Not my style and none of it truly grabbed my attention (in a positive way).
I liked the just like heaven cover
I've been meaning to dive into Dinosaur Jr. for quite a while, but I never got to it. I am both underwhelmed and excited about this album because it is apparently a groundbreaking record with an outsized influence. On the other hand, I've been into grunge and alternative rock all my life, so I didn't really heard anything that's new to me.
Just after my first week of college, my lung collapsed while cooling down from my first collegiate cross country race. I had a major surgery and was in the hospital for ten days. Through sheer coincidence, three people from my high school came to the same college. They all visited me and brought me supplies, which was extremely nice. What was more amazing was that after only being there a week, another dozen people I had just met also came. One of the DJs brought me some tapes, which included Dinosaur Jr. It seemed apt that my favorite song was “The Lung,” with one verse sounding something like, “nowhere to collapse from…” Dinosaur Jr. were the more traditional side of Sonic Youth’s multitoned distortion, harking back to both 80s hardcore punk and 70s cock rock. Dinosaur inspired me to go back and appreciate some seriously heavy music I had missed.
Ends abruptly. Not for me. 4.4/10
Some interesting tracks here but a bit grungey for my tastes.
Äänekästä, ja vähän pelottavaakin (Poledo... lopussa tuli hiukan jopa Obsession mieleen). Ekoissa biiseissä vähän Foo Fighters vibaa, ja ne olikin varmaan lempparit jos sellaiset pitäis valita. Tarpitin jäljiltä sattui korviin. Vika biisi loppui oudosti (miksi edes lähteä koskemaan originaaliin).
It started off well, then felt like a garage band, then went and ruined a great Cure song at the end. Dropping from a 3 to a 2 for that.
They screwed the Cure over with their cover
fine, his voice is kinda icky sometimes. Overall sound is pretty solid though.
so this came out in '87? huh-really could have fooled me. was an overall good, interesting listen. the distortion got overused & vocals drug some of tracks down. solid 3.5 & will see which way I fall on Monday
Man, this one surprised me. Grunge precursor. It's a little too shoegaze/noise rock for my personal tastes, but I like this one anyway.
Started great, but it tails off and Poledo kinda ruins it.
Nae bad
5/10
Very good.
This cover is me, carrying the corpse of music as an art form up Mt. Metaphor in order to review the latest slacker rock record. Why do I use the term "slacker rock?" What are we slacking off from? This record ranged from inoffensive to pretty cool and that's about all I've got. Another day we can send our prayers up to whatever deity we've gambled on and give thanks that we aren't in the doldrums of 90's britrock. Dinosaur told me the meteor was a hoax and big dino government is in kahoots with the three 6ix mafia in a conspiracy to outlaw eating big fuckin' leaves. YOU GONNA HAVE TO TAKE MY LEAVES FROM MY COLDER THAN NORMAL DEAD LIZARD CLAWS. 3 HIGHLIGHTS: The lights have dimmed on a once fertile mind
estuvo bueno! me vengo a enterar que tengo una cancion de ellos guardada por la peli reality bites (una de las pelis que destaco por su soundtrack). el cover de just like heaven para cerrar el album me pareció excelente
This thing absolutely rocks at certain points
Not bad!
Not very remarkable. The vocals are slightly annoying, both in his inflections and in the sense that they are drowned out in the mix. It's still not upsetting enough to give it a 1
Does Dinosaur Jr. deserve to have 2 albums on this list? I think not. Anyway, wouldn't have been my choice. A basic problem for me is that I don't really like the main singer (J. Mascis)'s singing. Interesting (?) thought experiment, to try to imagine them with a better singer - or possibly no singer at all; there's a lot going on there with just guitar, bass, and drums, and it's pretty good - and I think the singing hurts rather than helps. Slightly prefer the last 2 songs, by Lou Barlow, just as I prefer his post-Dino Jr. work to that of J. Mascis. Wikipedia talks about D. Jr.'s influence on shoegaze, My Bloody Valentine, Nirvana, Sonic Youth, and I guess I can kind of see that. Meanwhile, though, this album gets 3 stars from me.
I like this more than most alternative rock, probably because of the melodies, tasteful use of noise, ambient textures, and space in the arrangements. I don't usually like grunge, sludge, but again, I like this more than average. It's constructive and evocative, despite the noisy guitars or whatnot, so I'd listen again. Heck, even BECAUSE of the noisy guitars
sounds fresh to this day
For 1987 this is probably ahead of its time. The wall of sound and garage industrial sound must've been pretty special to hear at this time if you were into it. I'm not the biggest fan but I didn't dislike it, some moments were even quite good.
Good proto grunge that doesn’t let up. I do wish it was a but better recorded but I don’t think the band would have agreed. J Mascis’ singing has always been divisive but I think it works just fine here. Poledo is a hell of an ender.
Some good rock songs on here
Singing was debatable but good surprisingly good grungy music
Never heard of them before. Good though.
Some of the songs I actually quite liked, altho some were just generic rock
Pleasant indie/shoegaze album. Production feels a bit flat at points but just about gets a 4
No better than an okay here I'm afraid. I'm sure that if I were 18 in 1987 I might have fallen in love with this. Oh, I was: but on a different continent where the album and band made less of an impact. It sounds like American college boy rock really. Nothing wrong with that, but I do find it a bit boring and sugar-coated for some reason. And the version of Just Like Heaven honestly isn't great – like the album, it starts well enough but then gets a bit crap. To the extent that I had to turn the track off, which is very unlike me. So, yeah, it's OK. Just about. But it lacks style and class and is no better than that.
Little Fury Things - 4.5/5 Kracked - 4.5/5 Sludgefeast - 4/5 The Lung - 4.5/5 Raisans - 5/5 Tarpit - 4/5 In a Jar - 4/5 Lose - 4/5 Poledo - 3.5/5 You can hear a lot of influences going into and inspired from this album. There's some shoegaze, some grunge, some indie rock, some noise, and it's raw and unfiltered for you to hear. I thought this came out later but I was surprised this came out in 1987 before a lot of albums that I would have associated with said genres. Unfortunately I think the album can get a bit same-y at points which bumps it down a star, but this is still a "favorite band's favorite band" type of deal. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: Raisans, Little Fury Things, Kracked, The Lung
God I love Dino Jr. This is an indie hard rock classic. All hail J Mascis and his guitar wizardry.
Really enjoyed the grungy, distorted guitars across this album. There are a lot of rock elements that I like here, but there are also some strange song transitions that threw me off (e.g., in the middle of Poledo or at the end of the album). I was torn between a strong 3 and a weak 4.
It was okay…….. I did like that they had a song called Tarpit I thought that was funny either way the artist name. It’s like they were tryna be Alice In Chains or something. It just wasn’t that good in all honesty.
Weird rock
pretty noisy
Loved the Just Like Heaven cover. It was the beginning of the 90s sound.
I mean, it is post punk
Bij het opzetten moet je meteen al controleren: staat m'n geluid wel goed afgestemd? Want het klinkt allemaal weer alsof het in de kelder van het buurthuis is opgenomen. Op z'n tijd neigt het naar een soort proto-Pearl Jam, qua zang en raggende gitaren. Maar deze dinosaurus moest wel nog een beetje verder evolueren voordat het luisterwaardig werd. In ieder geval houden ze het kort.
Het album volgend, zal ik de wellicht best interessante en intensieve muziek na deze zin niet meer noemen, want die verdwijnt volledig naar de achtergrond door de afgrijselijke zang. De 'zang'...." - Is vaak vals / de stem slaat over - Is vaak verveeld - Is vaak zeurend (Paid for my criiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiimmmmeeeeee, come on baaaaaaaaaaabbbbbeeeee, come on rescue meee, just this last time tiiiiiiiiiiiime)
Dinosaur Jr, dat is de versterkers op standje burenruzie en de gitaren vol distortion door die speakers laten blazen. Ik heb ze eerder al bonuspunten gegeven, dat hoeft niet nog een keer. Ik ga ook niet het complete oeuvre de revue laten passeren hier, want ook ik zit niet te wachten op meerdere Dinosaur albums achter elkaar. Eigenlijk is het bonusnummer Just Like Heaven het beste, omdat je de fijne melodie van het hitje krijgt samen met de muur van gitaren van Dinosaur. Verder is dit ook voor mij niet meer dan een 3,5. En laat ik dat eens afronden naar beneden, want zo best is dit allemaal niet.
Mid
Haven't heard this album in nearly a decade. I liked it back then, but I think my music taste has aged into a place where I can really appreciate this now! Great great stuff, with sloppy noise elements utilized just right to complement the songwriting.
This one was pretty cool. Feasting on the sludge etc etc. Love a lot of the guitar work, although I feel like the songs sorta fell off halfway through and blended together in my mind
An album that completely overloads your brain in the best way possible. It's hard to hook onto a specific instrument, the lyrics are incomprehensible, hell even distinguishing between songs is difficult as it all sludges together. But it rocks out relentlessly. Good sludge! Standouts: Kracked • Sludgefeast • In a Jar
Big surprise but a welcome one! Looking at this album I thought there was no way I would enjoy it, but it hooked me immediately. The riffs are so fresh and the vocal perfectly fits the music. Really sublime listening and I'm sad I never heard of it before.
This fucking rips. It’s sloppy in the best possible way. Incredible guitar tone and great vocals. Love the Cure cover tacked on as a bonus as well.
Cool
Some okay guitars I guess, but quite forgettable and same-y.
So I've of course heard Dinosaur Jr but really didn't remember what they did. At first I almost stopped listening but they are very good. Maybe not a 4 but not a 3 either. 3.5
I wish there were 65 million years separating me from this Dino crap.
I’m an 80s guy, but I wasn’t really into this in the 80s. Not life-changing but pleasant enough.
For mid 80s, this could have come out today. I really enjoyed it. A little too much distortion at times though
Un nouvel album pour Dinosaur Jr. en août. J'ai une Fender Jazzmaster en grande partie en raison de J Mascis (et Thurston Moore et Lee Ranaldo).
Amenez moi en plus du noise rock! Je suis encore néophyte, mais j'aime bien découvrir. J'ai bien aimé Sebadoh aussi, on reste proche.
Dinosaur Jr. c'est oui!
2.5
I always forget how melodic this album is when I haven’t listened to it in a while. Even the Barlow tracks on the end are great even though I’ve never really gotten into Sebadoh. Such a great album and exemplary of the noise rock that wound so greatly influenced the whole Indie scene.
Surprised to see them on this list, but enjoyable
It was nice. Something I can skate to. It's edgy. It's in your face.
Fav songs: Raisans and the Just Like Heaven cover
You're Living All Over Me basically has everything I want out of an indie rock record. Great riffs, sticky melodies, unorthodox songwriting, a unique vocalist, and heavy layers of distortion and feedback. This isn't just indie in aesthetic, but in attitude. The lo-fi recording style gives the album an organic and ramshackle feeling, making up for a lack of polish with an exciting DIY atmosphere. J Mascis' vocals are snotty and yelpy, feeling very predictive of how grunge vocalists would sound in the 90s. All these elements could make this an excessively abrasive listen, which it is to a degree, but the band's strong melodic senses help you stay invested. Take away the noise and the lo-fi production and it's almost a pop album. That juxtaposition is the secret sauce that makes this album truly special. This has long been a personal favorite for me, and every listen makes it even better.
Tarpit was pretty much torture to listen to. "Lose" was a close second. And Poledo. All three were skipped once I couldn't stand them anymore Everything else has been "very Dinosaur Jr," which is to say if you've heard one of their songs, you've heard them all. And you're probably not clamoring to talk about how great the vocals are. I can hear their influence in later music, but thus doesn't do much for me ⭐⭐.49
A: Bästa albumet hittills. Överväger o lägga albumet i sin helhet med i nån av mina shoegaze listor. De e int ba shoegaze utan en perfekt bladning av shoegaze och en nyans av rock/metal som jag letat efter i ca 15 år på basis av den musik som Pauli spelade i vardagsrummet i Pargas när vi var små (dadrock men inte stereotypisk dadrock). 5/5 älskade!!!!!!!!!! D: Säkert den enda tillåtna tillämpningen av den gitarrmisshandel som Oasis&Co företräder. Personlig och egendomlig och överlag en bra balans av alla möjliga vågskålar. 4/5
If the artist set out to create a sound that was unique, unsettling, and uncanny, they succeeded. At times it seemed like they added a layer called "chorus of the damned". I was relieved when this was over.
Favorite Track: Sludgefeast
3 1/2 Stars: As a historical album this really works. You can hear the sound that would go on to influence so many in the alternative music world. It's really good. I just probably won't ever find myself back to this record. I appreciate it's place in the music world, but not a must listen for me.
I grew up in the Grunge era and listened to the music, but I'm not sure I have ever heard an entire Dinosaur Jr. album. You're Living All Over Me sounded about like I thought it would sound. I did not care for Poledo, because it seemed to drone on and on too much for me. The cover of The Cure's Just Like Heaven was inspired, even if the background screaming was a bit odd, as was the song randomly cutting off. But hey, Dinosaur Jr brought something new to the song. Little Fury Things starts off very hardcore sounding and then evolved into a great rock song. The production on the entire album is the foundation for a lot of the sound that came out a few years later and created so many flannel-wearing rock stars, which created more post-grunge bands in response, which eventually led to a more lightening up of music in the late 90's with everything not so dark, which led to boy bands coming back in fashion, which eventually led to record companies seeing that pop songs are the way to sell records, which eventually led to producer-led albums that feature the singer as more of an adornment to the song, and eventually the homogenization of music that has ruined everything. To say this album probably ruined music may actually be true. But for now, we are in 1987 and music is still poor and the production is still not great but we like it that way. My favorite tracks: Little Fury Things Kracked The Lung In a Jar Just Like Heaven
Sounds like a high school bands first album. Sure there's good energy here, but the production is awful and the vocals just do nothing for me. 2/5
It’s rarely talked about how ahead of their time Dinosaur Jr. sounds. Sounds straight out of the 90s, DNA filled with genres like Midwest Emo that hadn’t really existed yet. One of the more interesting 80’s alternative rock bands. Ending of the album was quite something. Fav tracks: Little Fury Things, The Lung, Poledo
Just absolutely rips from start to finish
very much "would stay if they were playing at a bar" type of music. only looked up when they started playing the smiths. fav: just like heaven
The most aggressive sludge metal, sometimes seems like they get so deep in a groove they forget to add lyrids
Decent 3,5
Sometimes it feels like I'm deliberately punishing artists and/or albums that appear in the 1001 list because that list has completely shut out the work of Warren Zevon. This might be one of those days. There's nothing specifically wrong with this album: it starts out with a couple of serviceable bangers before it deteriorates into the kind of senseless noise that has never stood the test of time musically, as far as I'm concerned, even though it might reflect something the artist is trying to convey philosophically about the nature of music. And if there were only one Dinosaur Jr. album on the list, I'd probably be tempted to go one higher with my rating. But having TWO albums by these guys and ZERO albums by Zevon just pretty much shatters any kind of credibility a list like this might hope for, I'm afraid.
Let's get it out of the way: I love Dinosaur Jr. and this is my favorite from them; this is getting a 5. Shit, I own and play a J Mascis signature Squire Jazzmaster, I have some personal investment in this thing. Although, if you don't get what makes You're Living All Over Me great, I don't know if I can help. Dinosaur Jr. were absolutely crucial in the development of grunge and other '90s alternative. I think I've heard someone say they're kind of the missing link between REM and Husker Du, and I sort of agree. Dinosaur Jr. had some of the mystery of REM's '80s aesthetic, but had something that's kind of punk-y in like a noise/sludge way that would later help define grunge. And the result is You're Living All Over Me, which honestly also rocks *unbelievably* hard for an indie record. Like this thing has some very fragile alternative, pop-by-way-of-rock-underground melodies, but then you turn the album on and the first fucking guitar tone you hear is a goddamn life-ruiner. The wah/noise solo at the beginning of Little Fury Things is *crazy*, it's like a whirlwind of ceramic, and it let's you know that these guys really mean business. It's rare to find indie willing to get this fucked up. And then, on Kracked, you get more mournful melodies and a guitar solo that brings up another point about this band; that J Mascis is kind of the most deeply secret *generational* guitar God *ever*. He has real chops, but is also really willing to slam so much fuzz on his tone that he's basically sculpting the riffs and solos out of a wall of pure scuzz. But honestly, as easy as it is to gush over Mascis, the whole band contributions are also deeply important, and Lou Barlow and Murph *need* their flowers. And as this thing goes on a real magic emerges between the punk sloppiness, paradoxical nimble-ness, and understated tenderness of this thing, which come together in a context that almost feels like folk or lo-fi sometimes. It's one of those records where the band stumbled onto a certain magic in their songwriting, and just stayed in the pocket for the entire time. There isn't a bad song here. I even really like Poledo; sure, it's *really* out there, but it brings some of the more quietly weird things about this album out and boldly relishes in things like ambient, lo-fi, and musique concrete. And I think of it kind of like a Revolution 9 situation. Putting Poledo here wasn't the decision that makes the most sense to the listener, but it's here because Dinosaur Jr. took a lot from the sounds on songs like that, and I think it was kind of their way to give back to genres like lo-fi and ambient. Regardless, I think of You're Living All Over Me as a landmark achievement in rock, and I think the fact that this band is perpetually a *little* underrated has made me more steadfast in this. It's really a fantastic album, mutating hard edged rock into a sound that honestly *does* bring to mind the sympathetic monster on the cover.
Cool album that definitely sounds a little ahead of its time.
Wow. This came out in 1987, but it sounds 5-8 years in the future. You can hear the marriage of early REM metaphorical lyrics and Sabbath sludge guitars. Alternative rock, from early grunge to guitar-heavy noise all trace their DNA to this album.
Decent listen, I enjoyed the vibe and feeling more than the lyrics
Meh
Had a hard time with this one. Mostly didn't like it but it was actually not bad.
Not really my thing, too noisy, but I get why people like it.
Very good album that I am shocked this band was never on my radar in the late 80s. Definitely a must listen.
Scheiss musik
das hat meine Ohren gestört, lautes Durcheinander
Ganz cool 🦖🦕
Good, personally not my fav. But is a nice album for happy days.
Noise rock and alternative rock built from layers of guitar distortion, melodic leads, driving rhythms, and slacker vocals feels like trying to appreciate a beautiful landscape through a windshield that someone keeps splashing with mud—occasionally rewarding, but often obscured by its own noise. The album contains strong melodies and genuine emotional appeal, yet for me the constant distortion and abrasive textures frequently get in the way. What many hear as exhilarating rawness, I often hear as unnecessary clutter.
Yep, classic grunge rock. Time capsule of the time.
Not a fan.
Aika hyvä levy, mutta bändit kuten Nirvana ja Smashing Pumpkins jotka ottivat tästä vaikutteita, tekivät saman paljon paremmin. Lopuksi kuultiin yllättävä Ghe Cure-cover.
I still remember the first time I heard this album. I was 17 and just getting into listening to/collecting music as a hobby. I really quickly latched onto Noise Rock and similar because I heard Attempted Martyr by Prostitute and thought that was the craziest thing I ever heard. Incredible album, by the way. Anyways, Dinosaur Jr. and Daughters were the two bands I REALLY gravitated towards in the Noise Rock sphere. You're Living All Over Me really stuck out to me, if nothing else just for how lo-fi it sounds, same with Daughters' self-titled album. Since I'm just naming artists that are loosely related to these guys, if you like this sound, check out Big Black, The Jesus Lizard, and This Heat, along with the other bands I mentioned and probably will mention. That's enough rambling about a few years ago. The music is great. It's a really good album to give to someone that wants to get into more experimental music without diving headfirst into the really weird stuff like I did (add White Suns and Neutral Milk Hotel to that list of bands you'd like if you like this), mostly for how weird it's willing to get while still keeping a sound that's at least familiar enough to a Nirvana fan's ears to not throw them off completely. I like how totally off-the-walls the guitar sound is at any given moment. It ranges anywhere from a slightly distorted Foo Fighters riff to an approximation of the gates of hell opening and sounds like both at some point in nearly every song. I'm gonna cut myself off before I end up writing an essay. I've probably heard this album a triple-digit number of times before this list. Check out any of the bands I named if you like this, they're where I went after this.
I like their sound, but sometimes they have too heavy distortion/feedback like at the start of the album and the end of Tarpit. Or static or ridiculous effects on the vocals. The best song was Lose and the worst was Poledo.
I know my indie cred will take a hit for this, but Dino Jr have never really been my bag. Riffs, vocal lines, solos, and structure all seem to be recycled from record to record, and it just doesn't do much for me. Ill stick with "Green Mind" whenever i'm in the mood.
Love this period of Dinosaur Jr. and this era of SST records
Forgettable, noisy grunge.
Dinosaur Jr. is an indie rock band that started in the 80s. J Mascis' use of heavy distortion and slacker vocal style have been very influential on other bands. Most of the songs on this album are good but are similar to each other with some having a pop feel to them. The last two songs are different from the others on the album. Poledo is just garbage and their cover of Just Like Heaven was interesting but not good.
This had some moments but not enough of them. And the solid cover of “Just Like Heaven” wasn’t even part of the official album. Top tracks: “Little Fury Things,” “Sludgefest”
more influential than "good", in my humble opinion; this trio has better albums in their future. Mascis and Barlow eventually become great songwriters but they're not quite there at this point ******************************************************************************* --Little Fury Things...noise rock with some pop sensibility --Kracked...great guitar work --SludgeFeast...more noise. too long but nice solo at the end --The Lung...not much to it other than some nice shredding --Raisans...things are getting samey. Mascis still brings the heat --Tarpit...this is as close to a ballad as I think these guys can get. it's pleasant --In a Jar...Barlow making his presence felt on bass --Lose...not one of Lou's best --Poledo...here we go. arguably a Barlow solo track. it's a refreshing, experimental change of pace. if a little "Revolution 9" coded --Just like Heaven (bonus track)...fun cover but I'll stick with the Cure's version
YES
Surprised how early this came out, can see how it influenced a lot of bands after.
si estoy aburrido prefiero no escuchar nada
Another favorite from my youth that's always fun to revisit years later. Compared to how I remembered it, it's a whole lot more consistently good. No skips, until maybe 'Tarpit.' And it's easier to hear connections and influences now. The hardcore punk with the expressive metal-ish solos, but also the almost twee pop meekness. 'In a Jar' starts out as a jangly, bass-forward pop tune that R.E.M. might've played at about the same time. In this tune, J.'s vocal style is revealed to have a lot in common with Michael Stipe, too, just a little better, slower enunciation and a thicker drawl. Of course the fuzzed-out guitars take over at about 2 minutes, then some sheets of noise, and it's pure Dinosaur Jr. The recording isn't as good as their debut album or Bug, it's a noisy rough band and the recording makes it somewhat flat and muddy. But the songs still come through. The first album has standout tracks like 'Repulsion' and You're Living All Over Me meets that standard in about every song. Too bad the edition that includes 'Just Like Heaven' doesn't also include 'Chunks' from the b-side of that single. It's a hardcore punk cover that shows off Dinosaur Jr.'s influences and happens to be one of my favorite early tracks. 4.5/5 and I'd include this on lists, sure.
Ovo mi je bilo bordeline neslušljivo, stvarno nezz šta reći, ništa dobro nemam za reći. 1/5, 1/10
ok tiers
to me, it's the best noise rock album ever, something that will always speak to me. one of my favorites.
rock cochino con olor a kk
I just can’t get into them
Pleasantly surprised to see this on the list. Mind blowing when it came out since it was so different than everything else “popular” at the time. I felt it was a return back to basic rock, although more complex than that. J. Mascis is a genius. Odd this wasn’t in constant rotation. Looking back, this was the band I wanted to be. Influenced so many for years to come.
Always preferred the Pixies tbh
This is a monster guitar record and its great! Album is a masterpiece. 5.
Only good thing about this one was the electric guitar, way too much screaming
Loud music done right! Great stuff!!
rockt - eigentlich nicht allzu schlecht.
Guter solider Rock mit Grunge Elementen
Very good. Good noisy, good tunes. Kracked was great, Poledo less so, and good to hear the 1989 student indie disco fave Just Like Heaven as a bonus track.
Rock
Early grunge vibes
I'm a little pissed at J. Mascis, Bob Mould and Buttholes Surfers. They are kind of responsible for shoegaze and grunge. With Dinosaur Jr. being responsible for emo too. So much bad stuff that happened after. Both musically and personally for me. I disliked grunge and may still not like it but I believe this list will get me listening to some of the stuff that is good. Listening to Dinosaur Jr reminds me of the first time I dated my now former spouse. I won't get into it but at one time I was dating two women, both long distance relationships. Neither worked out but on the drive, I often listened to alt rock stuff. Dinosaur Jr was on heavy rotation. They both loved my musical taste but only one like Dinosaur Jr. Remember listening while sitting on a driftwood log on a small beach in early summer with a small pit fire. Le sigh. This album feels a like a wave of distortion hitting you over and over with guitars and a loud soft voice saying precious things to you. This was so ahead of its time that it sounds like a late 90s album. Here you can still hear clear vocals before the voice becomes more under like on Where You Been. That was a cassette that was well played for me. I honestly love this album. There are no skips for me and the impact on music is phenomenal. The bands that came from this... Some great stuff and plenty of dross. Hard to deny its impact. Poledo's singing and melody reminds me of both Liz Phair and Rheostatics. Just Like Heaven is a great cover.
I knew as soon as I heard the first song that this is just not for me.
This album sounds like shit. Very fun songs on it though.
Okay...I agree, this was good enough to make the list.
Normal
Cover très stylée, son sympa et tout était super jusqu'à Poledo qui a fait perdre une étoile c'est une vidéo de Feldup ou quoi le bail...
Dude hell yes 15/10 one of my favorite albums give it to me so good. This is an album I point to a lot (along with Dreamend's ...As if by ghosts) where the production is so DIY and experimental and doing what it can with what they had that the production itself is a super charming part of what makes this album so special. I LOVE that it sounds like unintelligible noise sometimes. I love the vocals, I love that you can't tell if the cymbals are being hit against the distortion from the guitar, it's just all so sick and so good. Masterful songwriting, all these guitar parts rules, the bass is fuzzed to hell, the drums are tight, 15/10 album.
Dinosaur Jr. has been one of the most interesting 'new band' discoveries on this list as they had completely dodged my knowledge up until a year ago. Having listened to both their albums now (that being the ones in this list, not of their entire discography) I'm genuinely keen on going out and listening more. Fav tracks: Kracked, Sludgefeast, Raisans, Tarpit
Bra! Gillar det, men tycker att Without a sound är bättre (min favorit). Gillade Sludgefeast mycket och ett extra plus är Just like heaven! Bra cover på en låt jag älskar.
Would have probably sounded better in 1987 when it was released. 3
Oh, the overly compressed distorted guitars! I love guitar rock but this is exhausting. Best tune is a Cure cover, and it's not a good cover.
Nostalgic college band. Back part of the album got a bit spacey but the raw grungy stuff was good
I really enjoyed this album. Grunge was my formative musical years and I was introduced to DJR via the triple j hottest 100 where feel the pain ranked highly in 2993. But beyond this I hadn’t really heard a whole lot. They clearly were prolific but producing mainly consistent album tracks rather than singles. This is pre- grunge but you can hear all the elements. Almost like they were waiting for grunge .. and the world … to catch up to the sound they were already perfecting. Some of the song arrangements are rather raw and there was clearly some refinement into their 90’s albums, but it’s all there. 4.5 stars (but 4 on this site!)
Listening session: may 30th, while drinking coffee Listened to before: no Thoughts: Dinosaur Jr. is a killer band name. The music is fun (especially the guitarwork), but it’s not something I would listen to regularly Favourite tracks: Little Fury Thing, The Lung & In A Jar
7/10 Pretty good, didn't like the final song though
#142/1001 🇺🇸 A great excuse to revisit this album which i'm guilty of overlooking by listening to their next 3 albums. Perfection in impeefections. Best Tracks: The Lung, In a Jar, Raisans.
Early alternative music from the 80s. I was aware of Dinosaur Jr in the 90s when I was really into alternative, but because it was the 90s, I didn't have access to a whole lot of music. Mostly I had random recordings from the local college station because I didn't have a lot of extra cash to spend on music. Here's my "kids these days" moment, because I have kids and they have no idea how great they have it to have instant access to almost any music recording they could think of. Lucky ducks. But back to this album. I thought the vocals were gravelly and out of tune at times but it was perfect for the vibe. I guess I'm just a big enjoyer of alternative music because the flaws I noticed on this album just added to my enjoyment of it. I think there was one track that I didn't like as much but otherwise it was really good.
Again - not bad, but in two listens, I connect with nothing on this album
Interesting, music was good vocals not so much..I will live if I don’t hear again
As with "Bug" instrumentally strong but vocally weak. Mix has the vocals low as well... 3/5
favs: just like heaven
250526 20:08 3.5 lee ranaldo mentioned 😋
If you told me this album was from 2026 I would believe you. This is really, really good. It’s raw, full of energy, and the songwriting is excellent. It’s obvious how influential Dinosaur Jr were on bands that came after. Can’t believe I’d never listened to this in full before and so glad I found it through this project.
It’s not my kind of music, so maybe I just don’t get it. But I don’t think the singer’s voice is great. And I expect metal guitarists to be able to shred. They seem to think that putting a few seconds of loud noise in their songs will make them seem tough, and distract from their shortcomings.
Disonnant and discordant? Fun at times, but too chaotic when all is said and done.
Volviendo a este LP (con el que estuve obsesionado en mis '20s) pensé que me iba a aburrir por la gran cantidad de veces que lo escuché. Nada más alejado de la realidad, porque la experiencia sigue siendo la misma. Las gigantescas guitarras de J. Mascis, el poderoso bajo de Lou Barlow y las frenéticas baterías de Murph se juntan para crear una colección de canciones con perfecta sensibilidad pop y suficiente experimentación para caminar tranquilamente entre el lofi, el showgaze, el punk, el sludge y el post-punk. Incluso, uno de los rasgos que más me aburrieron de Dinosaur Jr. en mi primer paso por escuchar la banda (la somnolienta voz de Mascis) no me chocaron en esta ocasión. Para, un disco perfecto de los '90s cuya enorme influencia sigue vigente hasta el día de hoy; habiendo sientos de bandas indies que buscan llegar a este sonido tan particular sin éxito alguno. Quizá un rayo en una botella, quizá genialidad; pero definitivamente el mejor disco de Dinosaur Jr. Pistas recomendadas TODAS
Whole lot of nothing to me
To me this is the starting point of all of 90s alt rock. A truly great record.
Такое ощущение, пьяный студент поёт на караоке и думает, что он умеет петь.
7/10 A little too much noise effect for my taste, but interesting
bof
This was some decent grunge.
Meh
J Mascis fucking rules man. A phenomenal guitarist, and yeah his voice is a bit weak, but thats not the focus for the band, crunching rhythms, intense guitar work and killer riffs. I personally prefer Bug and Green Mind but like, this is an undisputed classic of the genre, and takes you to places you dont expect.
Ultimately forgettable, I think.
One of the best covers.
Dude... Why did no one tell me Dinosaur Jr. was this good? This album rules! Dinosaur Jr. are another one of those bands that didn't really see a ton of success themselves, but influenced a ton of bands who did. They're one of those "your favorite band's favorite band" type of bands, you know? You're Living All Over Me is generally considered to be their best album, and I can see why. This thing is cool as hell and I love it. This album sounds pretty ahead of its time in many ways. The album released in 1987, but it fits right at home with early 90s alt-rock, which is awesome! The album's definitely on the noisier side of this sort of music, but the sense of melody is still very present throughout the album. Songs like "Little Fury Things" and "Sludgefeast" are genuine earworms and they're great. J Mascis isn't the most impressive vocalist, but he gets the job done pretty well. The songwriting has the kind of moodiness that would eventually go on to define the grunge scene. I will say that the closer "Poledo" is a little avant-garde for my taste, but it's a very bold way to end the album, I'll give it that. This album is just so cool! I can absolutely see why this is on a list like this. I love it. High 4/5.
There are some incredible songs on this album, particularly the first one, "Little Fury Things." However, there are also some songs that, while not bad, disrupt the overall flow and feeling of the album. So, it's still a great album that is a landmark, but I can't quite give it 5 stars, as it doesn't stay consistent enough for me to call it a nearly-perfect album.
I love it, the whole album consistently sounded grungy and emotional all the way through
прикольно, меланхолично, но чего то не хватает, 3/5
Another headscratcher. Is it on here because they created a somewhat unique sound. This album came out a decade before they mad minor success in the mid-90's. J.Macis can't sing a lick, but it works sometimes. His guitar driven sound is what got them noticed. The songs all blend together for the most part. The old adage, "you hear one, you heard 'em all" applies in spectacular fashion here. No hits but a pretty impressive listener count from first to last song. All over 1M but "Just Like Heaven" (15M, Cure cover song), "Little Fury Things" (8M), "In A Jar" (5.6M) and "The Lung" (4.5M) are way more respectable. Hard to say 3 stars, it's so repetitive in sound, so maybe a 2.5. You can't hate it, but you don't love it.
1001 albums to hear before you're not living all over. 102# It's not the most polished mixing or production, buttt the rock ROCKSS! loved its intensity. loud. this is my typa thing. mr. dinosaur was cooking real early, this was released in 1987? damn
The experience of listening was enjoyable, hearing grunge in an early state is very cool too. No particular track grabbed me here though. Straight up the middle kinda feeling about an album.
Wow. I didn't realise this album was so early before everything else that sounds like it. I never really liked Dinosaur Jr and on relistening to this album, I can say I still don't. The music is fine but his 'singing' does my head in. Their style predates so many other bands - famous and not-so famous - both liked and not-so-much liked by this listener. So this a rare high score from me for a band I don't like but I can totally appreciate the album's influence on music that followed.
This surprised me in a good way, because I hadn't realised this was going on in 1987. It's really grungey. (Unfortunately, 1987 was my year of hair metal. I know.) I can't go higher than three though, because it's not actually that good, and, with a very few exceptions, I dislike a drawling vocal. But I like the attitude and the raw, muddy energy.
Mmmm, maso. No mi estilo, aunque sludgefeast estuvo buena.
A band that I have dabbled with in the past, and one that I was too quick to write off as the sort of noisy, pretentious "too cool to care" rock that wasn't much for me. I don't know precisely what's changed in the intervening period of a couple of years (I have gained a much greater fondness of slacker rock/slowcore, the former of which this very much leans into), but this landed really well for me today - so much so that I'd very much consider making a purchase. It's an entirely unstable affair in that you never know whether it's going to swell into gargantuan, anthemic alt-rock territory, or collapse in on itself under the weight of its own distortion and fuzz pedals. It's a clever and tonally detached experience, whilst there is also a frantic foundation bubbling underneath to simultaneously reel the songs back towards the emotional fore. J Mascis is very much an anti-hero figurehead of the band, where his laconic vocal approach couldn't be any more at odds, at times, with some of the volcanic riffage he conjures up. It makes for an enjoyable contrast.
If someone introduced me to Dinosaur Jr. 20 years ago, I would have been all over them. Unfortunately, I don't have the same appetite for this blend of passive aggressive, angsty stoner rock as I once did, and this album didn't hit as close as I would have maybe expected. There is some later Dinosaur Jr. that I am a bit more familiar with and still enjoy quite a bit, but I feel like this album didn't quite scratch the same itch.
Just another solid, fuzzy, noisy album from the pioneers that really defined this genre. I enjoy You're Living All Over Me more than I do Bug and I am much more familiar with it. Honestly, I don't really have anything else to add.
Solid proto-grunge entry with a dash of Sonvolt thrown in. I guess you could say this album would have done well throughout the 90s as well. Anyway, a solid rocker that stands out against its peers well. Hard to believe it is only their 2nd album. I might have to pay a little more attention to them.
This probably influenced someone, but I don't have to enjoy it.
Even though I love the genre, I didn't like this music at all. What a racket. I'm not listening to that again. 2/5
I got through a surprising amount of this before my sister kicked me out to sleep, I only missed one song. It was a pretty great album though, it’s really surprising this came out so early cause it feels like it should be a quintessential 90s album. It feels very forward thinking in its sound, and it’s just pretty cool. Favorites: Little Fury Things, The Lung, In a Jar
Guitars that sound like shit? A whiny guy who can't sing? Yep, I'm in my element!