Reviews (page 7 of 15)
Bebop noise
Ok
Lovely piano in pt. 1 Brass is gorgeous Very calming 7 mins is a bit long but worth it I think and it’s easy to do other things alongside the song— the time flies by Pt 2 A bit pacier than part one, more of a dance song than a sit and talk one Excellent saxophone (? I think) part Like the slowing down and acoustic at the end Pt 3 Again pacier than part two, lovely speedy sax and piano parts rushing into each other (pursuance, I suppose) Pt 4 Contrasts nicely to 3, slows down considerably— fits the title psalm well Builds up a little but never too much Darker tones perhaps than the others Heavy piano in the middle with a slow sax riff melting over the top Almost sounds like deliberate choking on the highest notes about 1:30 from the end Overall an incredible saxophonist
YEAH
Rv
I’ve never really been able to get into this kind of jazz, but that’s not to say it’s not a great record - sounds great, musicianship is off the charts, etc. I need more listens to really appreciate it.
Of course one of the great jazz legends. Not so great as giant steps or blue train though.
Nice jazz easy listening without being too boring
I already have this album on my playlist. A true classic by a legend.
Been a minute since I’ve heard this album. It’s tough for me to keep up with it but it’s still a very enjoyable listen. I still like some of Coltrane’s other records better.
When this was released I suppose it was groundbreaking, since modal jazz apparently was the greatest new thing in jazz. However, as I listened to this album it I’m unable to comprehend its magnificence. To me it is long rambling sax playing with no beginning, end, or melody.
Modal jazz.... post-bop... every day kids are coming up with new genres !! This is nice. I like a tenor sax, and there were no hidden unpleasantnesses. But does it rise above "nice"? Afraid not.
John Coltrane's **A Love Supreme** is widely regarded as one of the most important and influential jazz albums of all time. Recorded on December 9, 1964, and released in 1965, it represents a pinnacle of Coltrane's artistic and spiritual journey. This review examines the album's lyrics, music, production, themes, and influence, along with its strengths and weaknesses. ## 1. 🎵 Lyrics and Vocal Elements While *A Love Supreme* is primarily an instrumental album, it features a notable vocal component in the first movement, "Acknowledgement." Coltrane and his band members chant the phrase **"A love supreme"** as a mantra, repeating it with increasing intensity. This simple yet powerful refrain serves as the album's core spiritual message, reflecting gratitude and devotion to a higher power . In the final movement, "Psalm," Coltrane's saxophone playing is intended to mirror the words of a **poem** he wrote, included in the liner notes. The poem expresses thankfulness and praise to God, and Coltrane's saxophone phrases follow the rhythm and inflection of the text, effectively making his instrument "speak" the lyrics . This innovative approach blurs the line between instrumental music and vocal expression. ## 2. 🎷 Music and Composition *A Love Supreme* is structured as a four-part suite: - **"Acknowledgement"** introduces the iconic four-note motif, which Coltrane explores in all 12 keys, symbolizing the universality of divine love . - **"Resolution"** features a melodic and rhythmic drive, with Coltrane's saxophone and McCoy Tyner's piano creating a sense of determination and peace. - **"Pursuance"** includes a dynamic drum solo by Elvin Jones and showcases the band's improvisational prowess, blending intensity and technical mastery . - **"Psalm"** is a slow, meditative piece where Coltrane's saxophone mimics the cadence of his devotional poem, offering a solemn and uplifting conclusion . The album seamlessly combines **modal jazz**, **free jazz**, and **spiritual influences**, with the quartet (Coltrane, Tyner, Jones, and bassist Jimmy Garrison) operating at peak creativity. The music is both intellectually complex and emotionally accessible, making it a landmark in jazz history . ## 3. 🎛️ Production Quality The album was recorded at **Van Gelder Studio** in New Jersey, with engineer Rudy Van Gelder capturing the performance with clarity and depth. The production is minimalist yet powerful, allowing the raw energy and emotion of the quartet to shine through . However, some critics note that the **stereo mixing** is unconventional, with Coltrane's saxophone hard-panned to the left channel and the other instruments predominantly on the right. This can feel unbalanced, especially to modern listeners accustomed to centered mixes . Despite this, the production effectively conveys the intimacy and intensity of the performance. ## 4. ✨ Themes and Spirituality *A Love Supreme* is Coltrane's **spiritual declaration** to God, reflecting his gratitude and devotion after overcoming heroin addiction in 1957 . The album's four movements represent stages of spiritual awakening: - **Acknowledgment** of a higher power. - **Resolution** to pursue a righteous path. - **Pursuance** of that goal. - **Psalm** as a celebration of divine love . Coltrane's spirituality was eclectic, drawing from Christianity, Islam, Eastern religions, and universalist ideas . This inclusivity resonates deeply with listeners across cultural and religious backgrounds. ## 5. 📀 Influence and Legacy The album's impact extends far beyond jazz: - It influenced **psychedelic rock** artists like The Doors, Carlos Santana, and The Byrds, who incorporated its modal experimentation and spiritual themes into their work . - It inspired the formation of the **Saint John Coltrane African Orthodox Church** in San Francisco, which uses the album as part of its liturgy . - It remains a **benchmark for artistic integrity**, inspiring musicians across genres to explore spirituality and improvisation . ## 6. ️✅ Pros and Cons ### Pros: - **Spiritual and emotional depth**: The album transcends musical boundaries to offer a profound listening experience. - **Innovative composition**: Coltrane's use of modal jazz and thematic development set new standards for jazz suites. - **Timeless influence**: Its impact on music and culture remains relevant decades after its release. - **Cohesive performance**: The quartet's synergy is unparalleled, making every moment feel essential . ### Cons: - **Unconventional mixing**: The hard-panned stereo separation may distract some listeners . - **Challenging accessibility**: The album's abstract and spiritual nature may not resonate with all audiences . - **Lack of traditional structure**: Those expecting melodic hooks or familiar jazz patterns may find it disorienting. ## 7. 🏆 Conclusion *A Love Supreme* is a masterpiece that transcends genres and eras. Its blend of musical innovation, spiritual depth, and emotional resonance makes it a timeless work of art. While its production and abstract nature may pose minor challenges, its strengths overwhelmingly solidify its place as a landmark album in music history.
It would be disrespectful to give less than 3 stars, but I'm not a jazz girl
At first thought, this is just chaotic noises. Any one instrumentalist on their own was enjoyable enough and talent can be gleaned from their style and quality of play. Together however I find this album, and this style of jazz incoherent and garbled. But this is coming from the guy who loves Ken Burns' Jazz and has watched it multiple times, but never made it past the 1950's, so I guess it's just not my thing. I enjoyed the album enough as more of background noise after awhile.
7/10
Finally, some bona fide jazz! I’ve been waiting for the Generator to give me something in this vein and a John Coltrane album was honestly the perfect place to start. A Love Supreme isn’t unlike a tasty sandwich – it’s got good bread as the first and last thing you taste, but the real flavor comes from what’s packed into the middle. "Acknowledgment" and "Psalm" are good jazz, but "Resolution" and "Pursuance" (particularly the former) really steal the show here with Coltrane’s sharp, killer saxophone melodies and the rhythm section’s tense, fast-paced grooves. I went into ALS crossing my fingers for a five because jazz is a genre I have so much admiration for and I’ve heard so many good things about this album in particular, but I unfortunately can’t ignore the noticeable dip in quality between the middle and outer tracks. Even "Pursuance" doesn’t quite reach perfection, as it ends with a baffling three-minute bass solo from Jimmy Garrison, which (despite some amazing performances from him on the rest of the album) comes across more like chord noodling and scales practice than something truly inspired, bringing my enjoyment of it down ever so slightly. A Love Supreme is solid four star album, largely because it’s built around what could very well be one of the greatest jazz recordings of all time ("Resolution") and stays on its feet pretty well during its other 25 minutes thanks to its solid writing and instrumental chemistry. Will most certainly be coming back to this one! Highlights: Resolution, Pursuance
Relaxing background sounds.
Jak na jazz bardzo fajne
I enjoy this album more now after having listened to a lot of music and reading about the story behind this album. It's actually really inspiring. The instrumentation of course is great here aswell 9/10 Favourite: Pt. I - Acknowledgement Least Favourite: None
I feel like the more I listen to critically acclaimed jazz music, the more I can understand the importance and influence, but that doesn't mean I have to live it. It's not bad, it's just that jazz isn't my cup of tea, but I appreciate finally having the time to listen to a jazz masterpiece.
3/5
Somewhere along the way I have repeatedly tried giving Coltrane a go and I found myself very resistant except when he was more or less a sideman. But for whatever reason, A Love Supreme totally hit for me this time. I was expecting the be bop and modal workouts to turn me off or sound atonal, but I was all in from the jump. It’s a singular work, not a note out of place, etc.
Absolutely love jazz, wonderful album
jazz really isn't my sort of thing but i thought it was great
79/1001 :: John Coltrane - A Love Supreme Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ✅ Rating: 9 Listen before you die: Yes As far as jazz records go I don’t know if it gets better than this. And of all the jazz records I’ve heard in this project this was the most exciting. Power, rhythm, freedom, it’s all there. I will be returning.
Great
100% classic, played by a master.
Fabulous jazz classic. Probably not for people who aren't already into jazz. It is almost ecstatic and impressionistic at times. Going off into near pure emotion. Masterful artists walking the very edge of spinning out of control.
Having the sex record. Supremes style, hell yeah, dude!
jazz is not for me. 4th track was alright tho
Beautiful album!
3.75
Coltrane's magnum opus. A perfect record in every conceivable way.
This is my first Coltrane album. It’s great but it’s jazz so I don’t really get it. But I do like it. Not an unpleasant moment within and I bet with repeated listens I would appreciate it more. I listened to most of this album on my stereo and move to headphones for the last track. And I am only noticing Coltrane is coming out of just the left ear and the band is centered and to the right. If you listen to just the right channel it sounds like he’s playing along in a different room. Very cool. This feels like the kind of music you create your own narrative to.
9/10
Really pleasant old-school jazz. It's short, though, at only 32 minutes.
kept forgetting that i was listening to music. at one point the album ended and i don't know how long i was reading on the subway before i noticed. i don't get jazz yet.
Dope
1-2 Classic jazzy elevator music, fine But wouldn’t listen it to
another arguably iconic and quite experimental jazz album. a suite, split into four parts... the album was recorded in only a day after coltrane experienced a spiritual awakening of sorts. modal jazz is a kind of jazz that, surprise surprise is based off of modes and scales, changing and hopping from one set to the next, and you can feel that even if you're not musically inclined. it's definitely all over the place when it comes to where the chords go, but that doesn't make it bad... in fact, quite the opposite. it's transcending jazz, this mere quartet pretty much whisking you away to the clouds. historically significant and an album that people do like in this day and age... i like it.
A perfect all-time classic
Wonderful album. Part IV!!
This is technical and beautiful and really well done. Great album.
An amazing and fulfilling slice of music.
8.5/10
It was ok- not the best jazz I have ever heard according to my taste but not bad.
A classic, one of my favorites. You really can’t go wrong with Coltrane.
If nothing else, this 1001 challenge is challenging my perception that I hate jazz. Can’t say that I loved this, but I was fascinated by how much it pulled apart each player then managed to pull back together
Im to tired and lazy to write a full thing but this is one of my favourite albums of all time and im glad it’s here. Best jazz you’ll ever hear John Coltrane the goat. Favourite songs ALL OF THEM in giving this a 9.7 4.8/5
I just like how peaceful saxophones are. 4 stars
This is clearly a phenomenal performance, but I think I may have been having some audio sensitivity on the day I listened and the brighter trumpet timbres and sustained notes were piercing to my ears.
it simply is not for me and provokes a negative physical reaction when i hear it, but i can understand technically why it's lauded
now THAT is some noir movie jazz. hell yeah. liked this one 👍
Only occasionally set my teeth on edge. I shouldn't really be so flippant but I feel like there's enough love for this album out in the world that it can take me being a little flippant. This is jazz that I can respect and understand but it's still jazz and I'm still inexplicably a brass player who doesn't Get Jazz. 2.5
j’aime bien le jazz, quand ça sonne pas comme si quelqu’un avait lancé une batterie du haut d’un escalier
Har lyst til å like det, men får det ikke helt til. Mangler nok struktur. Jobbigt att lyssna på. Mulig jeg har den i feil setting. Fungerer nok bedre i en dyr skinnsofa i et stor Hollywoodhus kl 23:30 med et glass whiskey.
Awful mess
Masterpiece.
Lækkert
God cykleplade! Virkelig fedt kontrolleret kaos, det sidste nummer er helt fantastisk.
classy jazz
On initial spin, didn't really dig it.
If an album was an anxiety attack! I’ve never been able to understand this kind of jazz, where it sounds like no one can hear each other, and everyone’s just soloing in their own dimension, jamming wildly, then smashing it all together in post and calling it music. I'd personally like to launch that saxophone into the sun.
I love Jazz. Having said that I’m not a huge fan of Coltrane. But this has its moments.
Up until about 10 years ago, I was jazz agnostic. I didn't know many jazz albums and it wasn't ever anything I would reach for. But over the last decade, I have really come to appreciate jazz and it is now maybe 20-25% of my overall listening. This one doesn't need any more praise than it already gets, and deservedly so! My favorite Coltrane album is more than likely Olé, but we are splitting hairs - this deserves to be one of the first jazz albums someone should listen to, and is so obviously a 5 star album that it shouldn't need to be said.
Cool moments here and there
I like this kind of jazz
Amazing
No notes. If you like Jazz, hell, if you don't, you listen to this. A masterpiece.
Can't believe I used to hate jazz. Or mustard.
I like jazz and this is classic jazz. Top tracks: Part II and III (particularly drum bit)
as a non ball knower about Jazz, this is lovely. Furious and frenetic, paced to within an inch of its life. It's four dynamos at the top of their game.
GOATED
Boring
I'm starting to get fed up with jazz. Most jazz albums sound the same. "A Love Supreme" is still a nice album, though. The first part was my favourite. I'll listen to the next album tomorrow because I'm a bit ill. 3 stars for "A Love Supreme".
Not a jazz fan
I'm surprised but I like it.
It’s jazz. It’s some damn good jazz, but it sort of limits its own repeat listenability for me with its genre. I think I prefer Blue Train.
I like jazz
Good. Easier to listen to than some of his contemporary genre mates. Some catchy melodies at times.
Loved all 4 records and played it on repeat all day
Favorites: Pt. I - Acknowledgement Pt. II - Resolution Pt. III - Pursuance (drum solo intro, piano part, ending bass back and forth) Pt. IV - Psalm (slow and epic) Meditative, yet entertaining.
Flawless. Just weird enough to stand out from most basic jazz classics, deliriously expressive, but still wholly accessible.
John Coltrane was clearly on another level when he composed this deeply intimate spiritual odyssey. The playing all around is superb and the compositions, while not as melodic as some of Coltrane’s other work, convey a sense of journey, with a beginning, middle and end, as well as a kind of conflict and, in the Part IV Psalm, a coming to peace with it. There are some iconic moments that make you sit up and take notice and function like signposts in the wilderness.
I've been listening to Part IV - Psalm on repeat, and I'm certain that Mos Def / Yasiin Bey took the saxophone riffs and incorporated them into the vocals on "Rock N Roll" off of Black on Both Sides – a song which name checks Coltrane. Anyway, I'm not a jazz head but figuring out (trying to figure out) what this piece of work meant to other musicians is one way to measure. How do you figure out jazz beyond how it feels?
Not a jazz fan but even I get this one.
Meh, not my style
Come on. It’s perfect. Never will happen again. The magic of it all lining up. Everything from the cover art (which Coltrane always had down) to the production to the playing.
I enjoyed this short jazz album! This kind of jazz felt more chaotic and energetic than most jazz I’ve listened to in the past. Overall, I would listen to this album again depending on my mood since it’s not the mellow kind of jazz that you can just have on in the background which is typically what I prefer.
I know this album and along with Kind of Blue (on which Coltrane also appears), this is quintessential modal jazz. Liked Songs Added: A Love Supreme, Pt. I - Acknowledgement A Love Supreme, Pt. III - Pursuance
Sexy
I like jazz. Love Coltrane, but I know that there is so much happening in the music that I am not fully comprehending. At times it sounds like random notes, but I believe they all have meaning and are purposeful. I need to sit with some jazz aficionado to unlock the decoder ring. Sure it’s up to the listeners interpretation, but I need to know what to listen for.
I don't know shit about Jazz but I enjoyed it.
Coltrane is a glass of whiskey on the rocks. It’s an early evening smoke on the patio. The second I hear the opening notes I’m transported back to a dinner party with friends. The music can get chaotic and sometimes repetitive, but it’s remains woven into the fabric of our past.
This was a great album. I listened to it while I read up on Finnish Sauna Design esentials, and it was just a nice ambient album to listen to.
This album just made love to my brain and cuddled me after
Even if nott genre, it made me reflext on my life raw, on a square park bench, in my tuscan city centre. Even brought me to tears near the end, seeing the leaves wobbling, the people walking. Maybe just a bit too technical for my ears, sadly.
A brilliant and timeless jazz record.
A classic! Chose introduction (part 1) and psalm (part 4) for the playlist.
Oh yess jazzy times. finally, amazing, masterpiece
Yeah this is was cool to listen to on my walk to the train after work. Not sure I’ll ever listen again tho tbh. I like the drums on the third track a lot.
Unmatched
10/10
Acompañamiento agradable para el trabajo, pero mi opinión sobre el jazz sigue siendo que se debe disfrutar en un club, fumando y bebiendo.
Some parts sound good but others are too raucous for me
jazzy
Brilliant but a hard listen
Didn’t enjoy that at all, maybe that’s just jazz. A few good sections overall a mess
Great music, I like lyrics. Not for me.
Supreme supreme
An amazing early offering of the magic of Coltrane. It takes a little time for the album to build but it is one long composition that ends in a crescendo. No doubt that this is indeed one of the greatest jazz albums of all time.
I did not know John Coltrane and I don't listen to much jazz, but I should listen more of that because I enjoyed that album. I especially liked the drum solos in the parts 2 and 3.
I'm not a jazz man but good saxophone playing John
There's a reason it's considered such a classic. I'm not an expert in jazz, but you can out this on and just bathe in the vibes. Perfection
20/08/25 4/5 perfect introduction to jazz
Elvin 🙏🏻
This is why a lot of people say they "hate" Jazz. Confusing, tuneless, random sounding... But if you like Jazz, or even put up with it now and then, you recognize why Jazz elitists put this album at or near the top of all-time bests. It breaks every tradition while maintaining some elements. It's an intense listening experience, not casual. If you can bring yourself to really pay attention, an entirely new world of mood and feeling comes to light. Technically, the musicians are Jazz GOATs. Elvin Jones is especially incredible here, I can here some proto-Bonham during Jones' solo in "Pursuance." McCoy Tyner is also amazing, and the whole rhythm section has that magical thing that "just happens," a peak experience. Rare genius. Then there's all of Coltrane's mysticism, which comes through in his playing. It is free, as in unconstrained. The Apple music review describes it as "an evocative play between tempo and non-tempo." A massive work of self-expression. Definitely analogous to post-modern visual art: non-linear, creates its own rules, unstructured. This is powerful music. I can't imagine how this was created, and I've tried many times. Like Keith Jarret's live album, it's not something to listen to casually, it takes a few listens and an open mind to "get it." It's worth the effort though.
I don't get improvisational jazz. Part II is superior to part I. Jazz makes me feel stupid because I absolutely do not understand most of it, this included. This is what is on at a snobby, rich young New Yorker's loft during a party in a movie. I can't imagine real people listening to this even as background music on a day-to-day basis. I feel about the saxophone the way I know many people feel about the harmonica in Bob Dylan's or Neil Young's music. I think I'm just more of a standards and jazz trio kind of person.
Beautiful listen.
4.1/he's damn good
Pas pour moi pas assez de connaissances en jazz
nada que decir only bangers
We put this album on for a drive across the island I live on. I think I'd picked the score from the first 3 notes. The drums on this album were really top notch. A real highlight. The horns, not so much. It was just that sporadic jazz style that I think if I watched live at a show, I'd eventually shout obscenities at. I like jazz, but this seemed like one of the albums that sent people towards Jazz fusion (something I don't like!). My wife said, 'this is good background music.' I'm inclined to agree. Middle of the road 3 stars here. When do we get to the Dave Brubeck?!
This albums is like explaining string theory to somebody who doesn’t understand it. You’re giving fantastic examples to help explain the thinking behind the theory, and all of its subsequent implications, but the person you are talking to isn’t really keeping up.
Great jazz album good drums
Supremely cool but difficult.
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die: 22/1001 It seems so out of sync with each individual part of itself that it was difficult for me to enjoy. Technical, for sure. Demonstrating talent, duh. Produced excellently, no doubt. But all together, it felt like I was listening to a master saxophonist while my child was in the next room playing the snare drum my ex wife got him for christmas in an attempt to annoy me. Podium (forgone) I don't know, maybe I'm the problem. Maybe my ears aren't mature enough to understand this. It feels like an abstract piece of art the artist put a story behind to make it resonate. Like the marketing won while my ears didn't. As I read through other reviews people are attaching this theoretical meaning the artist wants you to have but that you'd never have without them. I don't know how that makes it good? I'm no jazz aficionado, but I've certainly heard better and enjoyed others. Maybe this is one of those genius pieces of work that come off so weird while making it seem so easy, like you could do it, while technically being a masterclass at what it does. Either way, it didn't land for me and I did not enjoy it whatsoever during any of my listens. I can't help but give this a 1.5/5 stars for those reasons.
Jazz is an affront to the senses, and this steaming cowpat of dissonance does nothing to prove otherwise.
Well, this might be the best jazz album I’ve endured so far.
Still not into jazz
se é jazz é trotos
Good listen -3/5
omg i feel so much emotions from this album i like it i can listen to it when im chilling with my friends
solid jazz
Scho extrem Jazzy, Song 1 het no e cooli Rechts/Links Akkustik. Isch aber doch sehr repetitiv und het grad nur sehr wenig repetier-potenzial
harður djass, frekar flókin. sem tilgerðarlegur maður gef ég þessu annan séns. 3,5.
Albums like this remind me Im not a fan of jazz. Just not music I'd choose to listen to
This is #day372 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… all that jazz, right? Well, maybe not "that" jazz. This kind is hard to pigeonhole, unless you call it "avant-garde" or "free jazz," which is already a form of pigeonholing. I guess that's how we are: always trying to explain things. I don't know if I can describe A Love Supreme versely enough. But I like the way it makes me feel. Like, I know this is the kind of jazz I'm after: loose, chaotic, yet somehow precise. Isn't that what jazz is after all? It feels like a narrative, a free verse, spoken entirely through instruments. Some call it spiritual. And I think they're onto something. Maybe I'm biased because this is the kind of record you're supposed to admire... But to hell with it, this is a 4 out of 5. Looking forward to #day373.
Surprised by how much I enjoyed this one. You can hear his talent.
Exciting edgy brass
Still don't like Jazz - but this was okay.
Very jazzy!
John Coltrane made an excellent jazz album. He is a monolith. This album inspired a lot of people that I love to listen to. I sort of hear the musical conversation and improv, and it is interesting. All that said, I just didn't enjoy the experience of listening to it. I felt like I would miss part of the conversation, and I have nothing to catch myself back up, the music just keeps moving. I'm glad this album was made, but I'm not going to pretend like I understood what was happening.
Jazz
A singular listening experience, even for someone who doesn't love saxophone.
I like the parts where the music was like doo da doo
Jazz is just bad and this is the worst of jazz.
Jazz that is smooth and keeps you invested throughout the whole album. Every song feels very impactful and leaving an impression on you.
With the background knowledge that these songs were recording in a single session, it comes together as quite an impressive feat. I do find that the overall sound of the album eventually wears thin on my patience.
Exceptional
Soy plenamente consciente de que tengo muchísimo que aprender del jazz, pero hay momentos en los que me pierdo completamente tratando de seguir la música. Eso hace que se me haga difícil escuchar de vez en cuando y al final lo disfruto menos. Hay partes en las que la velocidad que lleva y la disparidad entre instrumentos me lleva a sentir algo parecido a la ansiedad, pero en otros veo una armonía espontánea muy satisfactoria. Todavía estoy en guerra con este género y el poco conocimiento que tengo de música como para llevarlo bien JAJAJAJ. Aun así, está más que aprobado, solo que la valoración incluye mis sensaciones finales. Destacaría sobretodo momentos de la parte de Resolution
Jazz.
most of this album gave me a headache, but that's the case with most Jazz music. I can appreciate his talent and artistry, but my ears can't.
Very solid, experimental yet accessible, 7/10
I would to have listened to him live!
A good record, but this could have been awesome it they all had only played the same song at the time.
okay jazz
Listening to this album is very soothing. It almost feels like you're sitting on a leather chair with a smoking pipe next to a fireplace. It really gives off a very calming vibe. I've heard the name John Coltrane but never really listened to this music, also didn't know this was an instrumental album but I think it defiantly works as an instrumental album. Good album and would definitely listen to this again! Favorite Tracks: Acknowledgment, Resolution Rating: 5/5
Too jazzy for me
This is immaculate.
Another amazing jazz album! Saxophone was next level!
A LOVE SUPREME A LOVE SUPREME A LOVE SUPREME I'm not a good judge of jazz, but this was enjoyable. 4*
I liked it, congruent and short
This album made me really appreciate silence.
Liked it a lot; but still learning how to interpret jazz as a whole.
Pretty fantastic.
No filler anywhere. Just Coltrane pushing a single idea until it burns. It’s the sound of someone who means it. If you only hear one album before you die, make it this one. Then go back and listen again.
Didn’t like it at first but it grew on me after a couple listens. The drummer is really good. And the saxophone sounds so cool.
I’m not really one for jazz, but because of j cole on night shift, this would be my go-to, should I want to listen to jazz music. It’s good, I’m just an uncultured soul that does not get the genre as a whole. That rhymed. How fun
I have to be in the right mood to really enjoy jazz, and sadly today I was not in that mood. I can appreciate the quality of Coltrane's play though.
en fin
I like this album but I don’t think I have the knowledge to appreciate what makes it so great. I enjoy it but I don’t think I understand it Fav tracks - All
Now I get it...
Day570 - not enough good to make up for the bad
Awesome smooth jazz
Very good. 4 stars.
Funky A bit long for my preference Good instrumental
I like the parts where it sounds like the drummer and his drumset are falling down a set of stairs. This is another one that I heard again and again how groundbreaking and great it is. And yeah, it’s pretty great. He is an absolute wizard on the saxophone.
A historical landmark in jazz, for sure. Is it interesting, captivating? Maybe this is sacrilege, but eh? Quite a lot of talent on display, with some impressive solos. But I guess it didn’t leave much of an impact
Absolut entsetzlicher Jazz-Chaos Dreck. Das ist doch nicht schön, das ist einfach nur Kuddelmuddel, als ob n Hund ne Katze durchs Orchester Jagd
zu jazzig für mich
Que álbum de jazz!!! Moondrop May
Before listening: I truly enjoy Coltrane, but I admit that I can’t tell one jazz saxophonist from another. It’s part of the reason that I’m doing the list. Can I develop the ability to distinguish one saxophonist from another? One piano player from another? An so on and so forth. Good liner notes- learning that Coltrane created this article in order to give thanks to God really changes the understanding of this album Part 1– Acknowledgement- it opens with a longing, wailing note as if pleading for understanding, it closes with a slow chant of “A Love Supreme” Part 2- Resolution- I won’t admit to knowing enough about jazz to differentiate between songs, but the transitions and the feel on these albums are noticeable if you sit down and listen Part 3- Pursuance/Part 4- Psalm I have heard all the songs on this album- sometimes as part of a randomized Spotify playlist, sometimes as background music while teaching. Listening to it straight through in the car is something completely different. It really is an experience, with four distinct tracks that flow into each other- the best rock equivalent is Dark Side of the Moon. I highly recommend WBGO’s extensive writing about John Coltrane. https://www.wbgo.org/music/2019-09-23/deep-dive-the-presence-of-the-past-in-john-coltranes-expressive-and-searching-music
A Love Supreme is often called a masterpiece, it lands more as a powerful idea than an enjoyable listen. Coltrane is clearly reaching for something higher, turning his saxophone into a voice for his faith and struggle. The opening chant in “Acknowledgement” sets a strong tone, but from there the album gets intense and sometimes overwhelming, especially if you're not already deep into jazz. The musicianship is top-tier, with the whole band playing as if they're in a trance. Still, the album feels more like a personal spiritual journey than something meant to connect with everyone. It’s bold, heartfelt, and important, but also dense and not very welcoming. For many, it's a sacred experience. For others, it feels like being on the outside looking in.
Good enough jazz.
Probably good if you like this kind of music
Immersive and kaleidoscopic piece of work - makes me want to be a bigger jazz head - which I will!
Favorite Song: Pursuance Such a great jazz album with super impressive drum and sax solos. I love jazz, but for me it usually fades to background music. This had my full attention for its entire runtime! [4 Stars]
great
Not for me beyond this listen. It was a good experience, and I bet I could appreciate it deeply as a live performance. Fantastic artistry but doesn't connect with me in an album setting.
Part 4 was quite nice and gets it a bonus star. The rest (minus the guy repeating “a love supreme”) I found irritating like somebody else’s kid badgering you nonstop for attention.
This is a wild album. I feel like I need a few more listens to really get it.
My first album! Just recently started playing jazz, but I haven’t listened to too much of it. This was absolutely amazing.
Luister ik later🙃
Puf es q tienes q estar en el mood para escucharlo
Me falta cultura para disfrutarlo de verdad xdd
no sabría diferenciar las canciones entre si la verdad si me hablas de jazz lit pienso en esto no es un género que escuche pero no está mal le pongo un 3 xq no me da ganas de arrancarme los oídos pero tmp lo volvería a escuchar ngl mira sabes qué, voy a ser más estricta. me ha aburrido viva así que lo voy a bajar a un 2 2/5
Great musicianship and did not sound bad, but I don’t see myself returning to this any time soon.
Good accompanying music. Coltrane’s playing is a bit over the top. Not my cup of tea.
Jazz might be the most consistently great genre of this list of albums.
Jazz isn’t my favorite but it was pretty good.
Это шикарно.
Come on, how could anyone not love this?
Not your normal jazz session. It’s momentous. Fantastic music. Not much else I can say.
Good one of the better jazz albums ive heard
3.5
3.0
a love supreme
This is an amazing piece of work by 4 premier artists who were on another level. The fact that it was done in one take with little to no practice is insane. Beautiful work
Picks up as it goes along - gorgeous work from the whole band (that drum performance!). Not hearing the spirituality or the 'speaking in tongues' that this record gets compared to - the sax playing sits in the background often and there's enough other stuff going on here to enjoy without the mysticism.
One of the most beautiful things humans have ever made, full stop, and on par with the Sistine Chapel as a work of Christian art.
Part 2 was great
Album very Jazz. Contains much sound. It is rated
I mean, if I wanted to go to a lounge and experience some real live jazz like you see in the movies, this is what I hope I would hear there. It's got squeaky saxophone, terrible bass solos, gratuitous drum solos, and not a lick of rhythm or melody, nor a hook to be found. Very jazz.
I really enjoyed the music but don't think I would return to it
Good solid bit of jazz. Probably needs more than one listen to fully appreciate it but my initial listen was pleasant enough
I continually forget how good this album is. Every time I re-listen, it blows me away. I remembered the part where he repeated the title of the album over and over. Love that part. I was pleasantly reminded of how amazing the drums are. Looking forward to my next listen. 4/5
Jazz!
Sup
Ok
+fast and upbeat +love the chanting of 'a love supreme' +jazzy in the best way possible +dont know how to analyze jazz help +interesting section around 23 min where it slows down and only one instrument plays +transition to psalm is gorgeous -my con is that there are no cons for me +album cover is so cinematic
Yeah, it is perfect. I still like "My Favorite Things" more though.
Jesus Christ! This goes on a bit, doesn't it?
Controlled chaos
I played tenor sax in high school jazz band. Coltrane is THE guy.
Not a jazz guy but obviously a classic
Did not care at all.
Already knew this one. Solid. Worst Song: Part III Best Song: Part I Added to Liked Songs: All four were already liked
3/10 Music is about connections - between the notes and rythms, harmonies and voicings, about how individual elements fit to make something bigger than the parts. Jazz fights this. Each instrument is on its own journey - they often seem to wilfully ignore each other. So where is the magic and the beauty? I can't find it in the jumbled mess of a jazz track. I don't want to hear the tip tap of a hi-hat, the tedious meandering of a double bass, the incessant stabbing of a discordant piano. And most of all, I don't want to hear the rasp of a reedy clarinet searching through every note to see what fits. So no, I don't like jazz. I don't get it, and that's ok. You don't have to get everything. I could say I wish I did see it, but I don't need to. I'll leave it, thanks.
I don’t know if I’m in the minority here but just not my favourite, didn’t do much. 2 stars
Do I even need to say anything?
I’ve listened to this album many times, an absolute classic and am always happy to revisit
Very nice.
Enjoyed it
listening to this album bumped my anxiety up to 11. I can tell it's good. I don't know what it is, but I don't think I'd ever be willing to listen to this intentionally
Magnífico
Solid, love me some jazz
1.5
To me, and I'm sure this is my fault, it sounds like a rambling mess. 1/5
It's a jazz classic, very cohesive and the performances are excellent. Coltrane on the saxophone is amazing, his improvisation is top tier and he manages to make the sax sound so alive. "Psalm" is the standout in this sense, his "recitation" is so interesting. Aside from that, "Resolution" is great, I loved the main motif. Overall, it's a pretty influential jazz record and the quality of the performances by Coltrane and company both justify its presence in the list and its status as a classic.
i also liked this one as a fan of jazz. no real standouts but all were super chill. enough said. pretty perfect. 5/5.
Kind of meh
This is 4 guys jerking themselves off onstage for 31 minutes and that description just about describes my favorite and least favorite parts of the album.
Too dramatic and long winded for me.
This is a decent album. I do not listen to a lot of jazz, but there are some good moments in this album when every instruments compliments each other. There are moments, however where it feels like the sax, piano, and drums were all on their own mission to see who can play the loudest and craziest, which at that point was a low on this album for me.
Whilst I can appreciate the technical brilliance of the musicians and the high quality of something recorded 60 years ago jazz is not for me
Very scattered, not much resolution. Not getting the hype
Both confusing and catchy. Want to dance to it but really can't. Would listen again.
Whoa! Awesome freestyle jazz. Bohnam studied part iii before he made Moby dick I would have to believe.
Loved the drums in this one!
Not bad but for me it is a little much too art for art's sake. My first full album jazz experience by the way.
Sounds great, wish it was longer
Must be an amazing album if you're into jazz, but it’s just not for me. While I can appreciate the artistry and musicianship, the style doesn’t resonate with my taste. It’s a well crafted work, but I find myself wishing for something different.
Easy 5/5. Absolutely legendary jazz album from an absolute jazz legend. This is truly one of the greatest albums ever made, from start to finish.
I respect the jazz, but I do not love the jazz. I know this is good, but it’s a lot to listen to as a casual listener.
Coltrane fuses two nascent branches of the blooming jazz family tree in the early 60s, elevating the playful, spaced-out cosmic spirituality and afro-futurism of Sun Ra, and imbuing it with the unapologetically chaotic, avant garde free jazz of both Ornette Coleman and Eric Dolphy, bringing a level of seriousness, sophistication, and technical mastery to a genre he nearly single-handedly pioneered with this release: spiritual jazz. This is, without a doubt, one of the most important and impressive records ever created. Coltrane's quartet during this era had no small part in the excellence on display here. McCoy Tyner, Jimmy Garrison, and Elvin Jones were already virtuoso's on their respective instruments, and Coltrane enlisted Rudy Van Gelder to record and engineer this record at his studio — Gelder being the most prolific, important recording engineer in jazz history was able to capture the raw, powerful nature of the quartet with his precise, spacious production techniques, cementing the final recording as a true masterpiece.
A Jazz album that is a mini symphony that tells a personal story of John Coltrane. Jazz albums don't only need to be a highlight of an artists work and that is why this is received as one of the greatest jazz albums. Great solos toward the end by the band. Best to listen in one sitting since its a short and sweet four songs.
I don't normally care for instrumentals, but this feels different. I has so much heart and emotion thanks to the jazzy and moody nature. I'll start to get used to the piano solos, or the bass, and then right when I'm ready for a change, that sax comes in and wakes up the whole song. Loved it.
Simply put, one of the best Jazz albums of all time. It doesn't take much to hear why either. The sonic intensity of the playing on this album is mesmerizing, and the intro "acknowledgment" sums this theme up of a burning intense love perfectly. Sporadic/unpredictable doesn't even cut the grass, it's more like thermonuclear level jazz playing. The tightness, the ferocity, spiritual jazz is an indescribable medium. Coltrane is a literal canonized saint because to some, works like this prove he was able to work in tandem with the divine. Master storyteller without saying a word, and one that stretches far beyond language at that. Merely felt. An album about love, heat, reconciliation and possibly in that carries a grand tone of redemption and triumph. Brutally perfect album. Even for 65, it sounds older and as ephemeral as time itself. Coltrane forever.
I have usually liked all the jazz albums on this list, but this one was just okay for me. The music is inherently good, but the solos went on for waaaaay too long.
Not a huge fan of this sort of intentionally disorganized sounding jazz. Obviously very talented musicians, but much of it is lost on me. I enjoyed it but it gave me anxiety.
In high school I joined the jazz band. Not because I liked jazz, or really band, all that much. But jazz band met before school. And that required driving to school and not taking the bus. Which mean that for the whole year, I had an excuse to drive to school. And no senior was going to ride the bus. So forever more, my love for jazz only extends as far as the ability for it to gain me something else. I can drive any time I want now, so my need for jazz is pretty low.
A masterpiece. All components are perfect but the drums are such a delight to hear. Parts three and four are heavenly.
I don't know that I loved it. I like to feel jazz a little more in my body than I felt this. But I wasn't waiting for it to end. 3.5
Impressive on the playing side and very unique in it's harmonic moods. I'm more into Blue Train, Giant Steps and My Favorite Things. "How Deep is the Ocean?" maybe being one of my favorite jazz songs ever. I have heard this is one of the hardest albums of his to get or it takes a lot of jazz listening but I'm sure this is the definition of a "grower" album
Spiritual jazz masterpiece
Amazing great WOW
would rate this album a 5 if it was called the white supreme
Amazing. One of the most beautiful, transcendent albums ever recorded. Incredible soloing on all instruments obviously, but stunning comping all the way through as well. Santana says when he enters a new hotel room on tour he plays this album to cleanse the energy, I totally get it.
Shite. Not for me at all. I’m sure it was phenomenal during the recording but to my ear it’s just wankery making it up as they go along.
Decent jazz but boring overall
One of the greats
3/5
I appreciate the artistry.
ya like jazz? edit: ok, I listened to this a few more times, and can definitely say that jazz grows on you. 7.5/10
I'm not a big jazz person, but this was a cool album. It feels like a very complete work. The last track felt the best to me.
Beautiful
I mean, there's a reason why I have a son named Coltrane. 5/5
380/1001
I loved this, very glad I got to listen to this today.
coffee
A pleasure to revisit this superb recording. An absolute gem!
די משעמם... קצת מוזיקת מעליות
Guys, I've got some bad news. I think I hate Jazz music. I went into this with an open mind, and even a good friend talking me through what the "structure of Jazz music" entails. None of it helped. This was just bad. I don't understand Jazz music and I don't know if I ever will unfortunately. A big reason I started this challenge was to broaden my musical horizons, and in many aspects I believe I have succeeded. However, I tried to listen to this album and find ANYTHING to enjoy for multiple hours, and I just couldn't. So, I'm sorry John Coltrane. I gave it my best shot, and I still didn't enjoy it. However, each musician is clearly very talented, and for that reason this wasn't absolute torture. A 2 star, very low 2 star, but still a 2 star out of 5 nonetheless. I'd feel bad rating 2 albums a 1 star in a row anyway. Maybe I shouldn't, this was still pretty bad.
I can see how someone would like this. I am not that someone.
Classic jazz piano. Love Supreme indeed.
Amazing. Known this one for a while. Tremendous long form jazz.
The absolute best
I always look forward to listening to a jazz album in the hopes that this will be the one that makes me get it. It wasn’t this one. It sounded laborious and mundane, the exact opposite of what Ryan Gosling promised me in La La Land.
I felt something.
This is a spiritual jazz album heavily featuring the tenor saxophone. The album is separated into four parts leading you through the journey of coming to know the Lord and embracing his supreme love. I can appreciate that. However, I myself am not a jazz fan nor am I particularly religious. I can't deny the talent Coltrane has though, and I think that if you are a jazz lover you will really enjoy this album. It just wasn't for me.
I know this is a cornerstone of Jazz and I’ve tried over the years… Just don’t get it.
A suitably weighty choice for album number 500.
It's ok but sometimes strays too far into jazz masturbation. It's only half an hour though so doesn't overstay it's welcome.
Incredible
A super iconic and monumental Jazz album. While I have found myself enjoying a lot of jazz on this list, I don't consider myself a super jazz fan. More a genre I have appreciated from afar. While I did enjoy this, not as much as say a Miles Davis album. 7/10
Sublime.
I have to be in the right headspace to listen to chaotic free-form music like this, and today may not have been that day, but I always respect the boundless creativity and musicianship behind it.
About as classic as it gets.