Reviews (page 6 of 15)
Probably not the best Smiths album but still miles better than a lot of stuff on this list
Morrissey is a twat. But I still love The Smiths.
Rv
Divertido y disfrutable. Me puso de buenas y se agradece escuchar algo con Morrissey que no me parece artificial en su odio hacia absolutamente todo, y que además suena a gente haciendo música y pasándosela bien, no intentando ser insoportables a como de lugar.
Toppen men också sämre än deras övriga? Eller? När jag lyssnar på Smiths önskar jag att jag var sexton o kunde gå in i morrisseybubblan så som den förtjänar att gås in i.
The final one by the 80s indie-rock legends, that brought ringing melodis guitars and interesting lyrics back, when so many otter bands had taken the synth/electronica direction. Maybe not their best but still great, and ending it all at the top.
Couple of bangers, some stuff a bit dull
Girlfriend in a coma - Such fun, but I can't tell if it's fucked up lol Honestly- I just like the smiths so i was a real easy lay on this on. But, it was really a pleasant listen. This is prob the first album I would listen to on my own but its such a joy. I won't share you is very pretty
This is exactly what you’d think it’d be: a band completely fed up with each other while the charismatic frontman starts to find his voice away from them. The Smiths were well dead by this time, and Morrissey hadn’t quite found his solo voice. So what you get is a real doldrums of an album - well produced, but with little to no power of their earlier work. It stinks, and it’s a real bummer that this wasn’t just part of Morrissey’s solo work instead.
Not a great album from the Smiths, I was expecting a lot more on this album but I struggled getting through this one.
I liked this but also it wasn't super memorable
Classic
Just No
Iiiiim morriseeeey and my girlfriend is in a comaaaa; I'm saaaaad and I can't fiiiiind a friiiiiend Make. It. Stop.
While not top tier The Smiths it's still very good. Last Night I Dreamt...is stunning (it's amazing how much the version without the intro loses due to no build up). Marr did the right thing splitting at this point.
Obligatory “fuck Morrissey” before I give this 5 stars
Both Marr and Morrisey believe that “Strangeways, Here We Come” is The Smiths best record and who am I to disagree? Every song on this album is solid from start to finish. Marr's guitar playing is on point, really great stuff. This album marked the beginning of the end for the band. On one hand it is interesting to think about how their music would have evolved if Morrisey didn’t turn out to be an insufferable twat. One the other hand, it led Marr to collaborate on numerous interesting projects, further expanding his range as a musician and one of the greatest and most innovative guitarists of the 20th Century and also helping to expand the progression of indie rock. For his part, Morrisey continued to make decent, sometimes even good music too, albeit less experimental and interesting from my perspective. I honestly can’t remember how I rated previously selections from The Smiths, but again this album is probably their most consistent. Strangeways was released my Junior year in high school and they were among my favorite bands at the time, so there is some admitted nostalgic bias on my part here too.
Dull, depressing, emo bullshit. The music is fine & I can dig it, then Morrissey opens his music & I gotta listen him drone on about being sad or not in love or his band he has to BE in. Sometimes the song is so sad it's unintentionally hilarious, like Unhappy Birthday. Second time exposed to Morrissey on here, this time with the Smiths. Still unimpressed. 2
Big fan of the Smiths, enjoyed this one
Good background, great guitaring, some WEIRD lyrics. (girlfriend in a coma…)
Genuinely just a really good indie rock album
The best!
3/5 7/10 Blah
Girlfriend in a Coma is a weird song! I can think of a few people I would send Unhappy Birthday to. lol
Hvor går man etter man perfeksjonerte gitarbasert pop med The Queen Is Dead? Dekonstruerer og reduserer -- spesielt på gitarfronten. Resultatet er mer eller mindre vellykket, selv om det mangler mye av energien som gjør the Smiths til et så gøy band som det er. Jeg mener at Strangeways har noen av de sterkeste låtene Johnny Marr noensinne har komponert: A Rush and a Push and the Land is Ours, Death of a Disco Dancer, og Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me høres knapt ut som noe annet i discographien deres, har helt unike lydbilder, og noen av de mest geniale progressjonene siden the Beatles. Det er peak Smiths. Utover de tre låtene (og I Won't Share You, som jeg sier mer om i neste avsnitt), er låtene svakere enn det meste de har laget. Spesielt Unhappy Birthday og Death At One's Elbows føyer seg inn blant de svakere låtene de noensinne har laget. Låtene jeg ikke har nevnt ved navn har jeg mer ambivalent forhold til. Jeg synes de er gode låter, spesielt Paint a Vulgar Picture, Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before, og Girlfriend in a Coma, men jeg føler de legger seg nærmere Morrissey's styrker enn Marr's, da de går veldig mye opp og ned, hvis det gir mening. I Started Something I Couldn't Finish er kanskje det som høre mest ut som the Smiths vi kjenner fra før. The Smiths avslutter karrieren med enda en Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want-type låt, og selv om I Won't Share You ikke når helt opp til hverken den eller Some Girls Are Bigger Than Ovens, eh jeg mener Others (sykt underrated låt), bringer den nesten samme mengde komfort.
Et litt anonymt Smiths-album. Lite som stikker seg ut. Men et ok Smiths-album er ganske mye bedre enn mange andre album.
Hier soir Guillaume m'a dit qu'il adorerait avoir un T-shirt des Smiths. Avis aux gens pour les cadeaux de Noël.
Beaucoup plus intéressant à mon humble avis que les autres de Smith et Morrissey, c'est festif et comique dans la portée. Ça m'a beaucoup amusé et je compte y revenir
Crime je pense l’avoir mieux aimé que The Queen is Dead! Morissey y fait moins sa Diva on dirait, y rentre plus dans le moule de son band. Mais là on peut avoir un break et écouter autre chose, svp
Quite happy before listening to this. Now, no.
This album surprised me. I loved it. I hated the previous Smiths Album that I listened to. Maybe there is more to them than meets the eye.
Fuck that guy. But Johnny Marr is cool
1 out of 5 Just...no
Not the best Smiths album to me, a bit less consistent compare to the others but still good.
Probably a 3.5 for me. Really like the first half but the second half didn't quite hold up.
I've been inconsisent between 2 and 3 stars but my rationale for 2 here is: -There are probably other Smiths albums on this list that are better. -Morrissey is a wanker
Die depressieve, melancholische vibe die The Smiths typeert zit meesterlijk in deze plaat, maar ik mis het muzikale en tekstuele tikje meer van The queen is dead
Classic mopey boys mopin’ it up.
It sounds like pretty much every other Smith's song I've heard. Not bad, but nothing great either. Just typical depressed Morrissey while Marr makes good music.
Only one banger on here
Overrated album. Depressing with no style points. Sorry. Morrissey is the most overrated frontman alive.
Fun. I really liked this album and it went by really quick. These four guys can really write music. Morrissey’s vocals are pretty and there is never a dull moment. Maybe a little whiney (looking at you Unhappy Birthday) but whatever, it’s The Smiths, what are you going to do. Fuck Morrissey for everything else though. Standout tracks: A Rush and A Push and the Land Is Ours, Stop Me If You Think You’ve Heard This One Before, and Death at One’s Elbow.
Classic Smiths album
Love the smiths, pretty standard album for them?
Loved the start and then it kind of lost me, but the second listen made me like it much more.
It’s good but a swear all their songs sound the same
they dont know how to songwrite i think
Great album. Not my favourite Smiths album but still great. I sometimes find Morrissey’s lyrics unsettling and he’s definitely a moaner, but Marr’s music is good (although I still like the older jingle-jangle guitar sound). Girlfriend in a Coma and Death of a Disco are obvious favourites, but I like Paint a Vulgar Picture too.
Ah the Smiths. Morissey and Jimmy Marr made some wonderful songs. Too bad they’ll never out out new music.
4/5
Good band, good sound, and music.
Fairly unmemorable
Garbish
This has some of their best and a unique feel to the rest of their stuff. The songs seem to float more than being propelled. There's not a bad song here yet it's still might be my least favorite album of theirs. Rating: 4.7
I like the Smiths more retrospectively. This may not be their best album but still sounds good on a sunny afternoon.
Death of a Disco Dancer and Girlfriend in a Coma shine through what is otherwise a pretty tedious and boring album.
What a delight! It was nice to hear this version of the band beyond just the songs I had heard on this record. I’m not surprised this is the album the band itself is the most proud of. I loved this sound, and only a couple tracks were a slight miss for me. Best Track: Death of a Disco Dancer
I've never really been a fan of The Smiths, mostly because of Morrissey, but Johnny Marr absolutely cooked here. By far their best album in my opinion. 4 Stars.
best album so far
This was so weird... but I liked it.
C’est le deuxième album de The Smiths que j’écoute. Celui-ci est un peu plus à mon goût que le précédent. Quelques pièces sont bonnes, mais, musicalement, ça ne me rejoint pas. Déso.
The Good: We know before hand that this will be strange, in ways… The Bad: I cheered too soon thinking that this was my last Morrissey/Smiths album to endure… The Ugly: I’ve got 2 more to go after this one… So, about a month ago I listened to The Queen is Dead, which to my horror I actually found more than pleasant to listen to. This album, thankfully, puts me right back into not liking Morrissey at a high-high level. So, I won’t waste more time then I already have writing about an album I will never listen to again, ever. But, I will give it 2* as it’s music, with musicians and such...
This is essential Smiths. Fuck everyone who thinks this is their worst. Y'all just don't get it. This is probably their most depressing album, but with that little twist of dark humor to remind you you're listening to The Smiths. And the songs themselves are great too. A Rush and a Push is one of their most unique, I don't know if there is even any guitar on it but it atill manages to be one of their best songs. I Started Something I Couldn't Finish has one of the best choruses from any Smiths songs. Stop Me has such a gorgeous guitar part, I really love it. The album is maybe a bit toned down, not as punchy as some of their other albums, but that doesn't stop it from being one of their best.
Decent enough album. I'm not a big fan of Morrissey but he's not too over the top on this album. Good melodies, pleasant enough to listen to. Probably won't revisit.
I actually liked this album. It reminded me a little of early Bare Naked Ladies.
Overall nice.
Great album, great band. I’m a huge Johnny Marr fan so…every song is good. Classic Smiths sounds, but more instrumental variety on this album. Good straight through listen - I did three times in a row on a long drive.
This was my first time listening to a smiths album, very moody and lyrics that make total sense when I think about articles that have stated that Morrissey is a huge cunt. I quite enjoyed it though haha
Good album. Lots of cure and rem vibes
After kinda sorta intentionally avoiding listening to a full Smiths album for years this is my first pull. But situations like this are why I decided to take this challenge, listening to stuff I would’ve never gotten to otherwise. Morrissey is a shite man but I tried going at this with the “Morrissey Fan Brings Earplugs to Concert in Case He Talks” mindset every Smiths fan I’ve met has. I Listened to The Queen is Dead as prep beforehand and was surprised at how much I actually liked it. Like I can understand why so many bands spent their whole careers chasing these guys. I can understand the case for that being an album “you must hear before you die”, but with this album: not so much. Feels less like the band’s grand last statement than it does one of b-sides and outtakes compilation albums like Coda from LZ or something(ah shit that’s probably in this list too). Unsurprisingly they were imploding while making this. Still a good listen with tracks like Death of a Disco Dancer and Last Night, but there’s a real lack of a personality to this and most tracks were just like pleasant lullabies, in one ear and out the other.
I’ve never been a Smiths fan, so all the albums included on this list are pretty much new to me. On that bass I’ve got to say this one has been the least appealing so far
Not there best but still good
There was a time when I had a slight “depressed” emo phase. Good thing I grew out of it with the help of medication. During that time, I listened to a lot of The Smiths and Morrissey. The music is really good but, Morrissey is really annoying at times. He is just too dark and brooding. I really don’t need that attitude anymore.
3.5
worst smiths album worst smiths album cover also but death of a disco dancer and also last night i dreamt that somebody loved me so you know whatever fine it's good
First two songs are nice, then it gets a bit uninteresting
I think I've finally lowered my expectations for The Smiths enough that I didn't hate this as much as I thought I would. I thought that this was the best album from them musically. I didn't even think Morrissey was completely terrible and had some decent melodies. His voice still bothers me, but there were some songs that I found catchy.
For me, this is the best Smiths album and Paint a Vulgar Picture is my favourite Smiths song. An easy 5.
Ok, fine, The Smiths aren’t terrible, so what?
absolute rubbish
Dreary
Arguably The Smith's greatest work (it is) was also their last. It's all here, present and correct: a mix of insane tunes, melodies, a range of unexpected instruments and Moz's miserable lyrics. A band this great could only last for so long and what an album to crash out on. It's stuff like this that makes people say they were the most important British band since The Beatles. Best Tracks: I Started Something I Couldn't Finish; Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before; I Won't Share You
Unbekannt, gefällt mir.
Michael Jackson, Picasso, Kanye, Morissey - All terrible people but great artists. This album was fantastic. Johnny Marrs guitar is like a second singer. Morissey's unique delivery is so engaging.
Despite getting into the Smiths in my teens I just knew their singles. I've only recently started listening to their albums. While this has lots to love including many of the songs I knew (Stop Me, Girlfriend, Last Night) I don't think it's their best. A little drags. Unhappy Birthday was hilarious though. Morrissey is obviously a prick but then there have been worse people on this list so far.
i just love the smiths. is this their best work? no. but there’s something about them that makes me feel like i’m being covered in a warm blanket on a cold day whenever they come on.
To quote another song: I've never been through a smiths phase. That doesn't feel like changing. I don't exactly dislike it, but I can't really fathom the clamour. I've heard better indie bands, I've heard funnier bands, I've heard better self deprecation in music. Morrissey has an interesting voice, Johnny marr has some nice guitar bits, but I don't feel like shouting from a hill about it.
Sorti quelques mois après l’implosion du groupe, le quatrième et ultime album studio des Smiths, « Strangeways, Here We Come » n’est pas l’album d’un groupe en proie aux forces destructrices qui allaient causer sa dissolution, mais celui d’un groupe au sommet absolu de sa créativité, explorant des territoires sonores avec une audace et une maturité qui laissent imaginer ce qu’il aurait pu être. Car l’écoute de « Strangeways » est une expérience douce-amère. On y entend l’alchimie entre Morrissey et Johnny Marr non pas s’effriter, mais atteindre une sophistication inégalée. Oubliées, les guitares carillonnantes et l’urgence post-punk des débuts. Ici, le son s’épanouit dans une richesse et une ambition nouvelles. Johnny Marr, souvent réduit à son statut de « roi du jangle pop », se révèle être un arrangeur visionnaire. La palette sonore s’élargit de manière spectaculaire : le piano mélancolique qui introduit « A Rush and a Push and the Land Is Ours », les arrangements de cordes synthétiques grandioses sur « Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me », le saxophone volontairement criard de « I Started Something I Couldn’t Finish » ou encore les textures subtiles du clavier qui parsèment l’album. Johnny Marr construit des paysages sonores complexes, des décors de théâtre pour les drames et les comédies noires que Morrissey s’apprête à jouer. De son côté, Morrissey atteint une maturité d’écriture saisissante. Ses textes, toujours empreints de cette ironie mordante et de ce romantisme désespéré qui le caractérisent, deviennent plus narratifs, plus cinématographiques. Il ne se contente plus de chroniquer les angoisses adolescentes, il brosse des portraits de personnages, crée des vignettes de vie empreintes d’un désenchantement adulte. L’humour est plus noir, la satire plus acerbe, et la vulnérabilité plus profonde que jamais. C’est cette ambition musicale qui distingue « Strangeways » de ses prédécesseurs car si « The Queen Is Dead » était l’équilibre idéal entre l’hymne politique et la complainte personnelle, « Strangeways » est plus introspectif, plus sombre et musicalement plus aventureux. Écoutez la structure de « Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me ». L’introduction au piano, longue de près de deux minutes, installe une atmosphère de solitude poignante, avant que le morceau n’explose dans un crescendo de cordes et de désespoir. C’est une épopée miniature, le son d’un coeur qui se brise au ralenti. La production, assurée par Stephen Street aux côtés de Marr et Morrissey, est d’une richesse et d’une clarté impeccables, donnant à chaque instrument l’espace pour respirer et contribuer à la fresque globale. Lyriquement, Morrissey est à son apogée. Son humour noir, sa poésie du quotidien misérable et sa critique sociale acerbe sont toujours présents, mais polis par une nouvelle couche de lassitude et de sagesse amère. « Girlfriend in a Coma » est peut-être l’exemple le plus célèbre de sa tragicomédie. Sur une mélodie faussement enjouée, il juxtapose l’angoisse d’une situation terrible avec une nonchalance déconcertante (« I know, I know, it’s serious ») ou avec des paroles d’une morbidité absolue (« There were times when I could have murdered her / But you know, I would hate anything to happen to her »). Cette juxtaposition macabre entre la forme et le fond est la quintessence de l’art de Morrissey. Ailleurs, il tourne son regard vers l’intérieur avec une honnêteté brutale. « Stop Me If You Think You’ve Heard This One Before » est un tour de force narratif, une confession d’amour non partagé et de frustration qui déborde, le tout emballé dans un des riffs les plus contagieux de Marr. Mais c’est peut-être « Paint a Vulgar Picture » qui démontre le plus sa prescience. Cette dissection cynique et glaçante de l’industrie musicale, qui exploite la mort de ses artistes pour le profit, est d’une pertinence effrayante, encore aujourd’hui. Il y décrit le cycle de rééditions posthumes (« Re-issue! Re-package! Re-package! / Re-evaluate the songs ») avec une précision qui donne froid dans le dos, surtout au vu du destin de l’héritage du groupe. L’alchimie entre les quatre membres quant à elle n’a jamais été aussi puissante, même si elle était sur le point de se rompre. La section rythmique, souvent sous-estimée, est le coeur battant de l’album. La ligne de basse d’Andy Rourke sur « Death of a Disco Dancer » est un monstre de groove hypnotique et mélodique, qui ancre la longue improvisation quasi-psychédélique du morceau. Mike Joyce, quant à lui, livre une performance d’une puissance et d’une subtilité remarquables, s’adaptant parfaitement aux embardées stylistiques de Marr, du rockabilly musclé de « I Started Something I Couldn’t Finish » à la délicatesse de ballades plus calmes. Et puis, il y a la fin, ce dernier morceau, celui qui referme définitivement le livre. « I Won’t Share You ». Car après le drame, le sarcasme et l’expérimentation, l’album et la carrière du groupe se terminent sur la note la plus simple, la plus dépouillée et la plus déchirante. Sur un simple accompagnement d’autoharpe, la voix de Morrissey est d’une vulnérabilité totale. Ce « Je ne te partagerai pas » peut être interprété de mille manières : une déclaration à un amant, un adieu possessif à Johnny Marr, un message à ses fans. Quelle que soit la lecture, c’est une conclusion d’une puissance dévastatrice. C’est le silence après la tempête, le point final d’une des plus grandes sagas de la musique britannique. En conclusion, « Strangeways, Here We Come » est un album imparfaitement parfait, c’est le son de quatre talents exceptionnels qui se poussent mutuellement vers de nouveaux sommets, juste avant de tomber dans le vide. C’est un album de transition, un pont entre le son qui a défini une génération d’indie-pop et un futur que The Smiths n’exploreront jamais ensemble. Il est empreint d’une tristesse infinie, celle de la fin d’une ère, mais aussi d’une fierté artistique indéniable. C’est un chant du cygne majestueux, complexe et intemporel, qui ne cesse de dévoiler de nouvelles facettes à chaque écoute. C’est une oeuvre d’art totale, un disque qui ose être à la fois grandiose et intime, drôle et tragique, amer et magnifique. Ce n’est pas seulement le dernier chapitre de The Smiths, c’est le plus grand album du plus grand groupe de rock indépendant des années 80.
a good listen
Really don’t get why people think this is their best.
the usual 2
Un disco excelente, sino el mejor de los Smiths. A mi es el que más me gusta junto con, obivamente The Queen is dead. Carece del encanto de su debut, pero no tiene ni un solo tema regular. Portada con su admirado Davalos en vez de con Harvey Keitel, que luego sí les permitió usar su imagen. Comienzo tabernario con A Rush and a Push and the Land Is Ours, sigue sonido glam con I Started Something I Couldn't Finish y así hasta 3 maravillas como son Girlfriend in a Coma, Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before y Last Night I Dream That Somebody Loved Me, ambas con una orquestación muy atinada. Unhappy Birthday es la más floja del discol, y Paint a Vulgar Picture es una mordaz crítica a las compañías discográficas (aún no había saltado a laluz es escándalo Milli Vanilli, pero ya The Byrds habían tratado el asunto con so you want to be a RNR star). Eso habiendo firmado con una multinacional... El cierre con I won´t share es magistral. Cualquier disco de los Smiths es necesario, pero este es de los más imprescindibles. No tuvo el reconocimiento ni el éxito que mereció en su momento pues la banda se separó apenas publicado, algo que sucedió con por ejemplo Trompe le monde de los Pixies (otro injustamente tratado en su momento). Pero el tiempo le ha puesto en su lugar.
Einfühlaame runde Musik mit einer Person die ich bis jetzt noh nicht kannte. Toll Kauf ich.
The jaunty melodies hide Morrissey's dark lyrics....Girlfriend in a Coma is made so creepy by the light melody and the laid back laconic vocals
It's interesting that The Smiths consider this their best work, I'm not sure it's my favorite of theirs. The production is really interesting and I like their incorporation of new/different instruments compared to their earlier work, but I still think I prefer some of their earlier work. Still a great listen, 4/5
Hate the Smiths with every fiber of my being. I won't listen to this.
Pretty good, not as good as some of their other albums
Me like
An unsurprisingly uninteresting unimportant addition to the list coming from Morissey yet again.
Liker The Smiths godt. Albumet her er fint, ikke en favoritt men noen perler. the smiths har ganske dårlige tekster innser jeg etter å ha hørt dette albumet, men det er vel sjarmen :)
I could write many love letters to the smiths and what they meant to me growing up. It's not their best record in my opinion, but one that's wonderful to listen to. The poetic nature of the lyrics, the muscality of the melodies and harmonies, the way the songs speak of tenderness, fragility and love - all of these make for a record that's worth every minute.
Not for me
Much more up my alley than I had anticipated, very glad I finally bit the bullet on The Smiths and especially with this album.
Unfortunately I love the smiths. They just be saying anything!
I like The Smith's, always have... This is their best album, imo. Dark, brooding and atmospheric. It's on my shelves. Morissey however, is still a twat! Heard before ✅️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ✅️ Pinnacle work★★★★☆ (8/10)
First time ever listening to The Smiths. While I know this isn't THE album by the band, I still enjoyed the tracks on here. Not the best thing I've heard so far, but far from the worse and I can't ask for more than that on a Monday.
For a band that was nearing the end of its lifespan, The Smiths' final studio album is still a top-notch effort that finds the band continuing to expand their sound and push in new directions. Somewhat looser and more experimental than their previous records, *Strangeways* finds them incorporating elements such as found sound and drum machines into the mix, and on the opening track Johnny Marr completely abandons his guitar in favor of keyboards and chromatic percussion.
Pretty fun album, full of 80s pop-rock.
Marr guitar, the star. Morrisey for the mopey mob. Decent, but not special.
I feel neutral about this album.
Wow, I really loved this. 4.5/5
Fairly unmemorable to me, though I did particularly enjoy the last track.
meh
Just about a perfect album. Shame it was their last. Morrissey carries on and his music is close to perfect but not the way The Smiths.
it was enjoyable
Really loved this album. Had never heard a single Smiths song going in. Instrumentation and production are fantastic and create the vibe. Great vocal performance. Album is experimental but retains melody throughout. Little to no filler. Very fun listening.
Good
never familiarized myself much with the smiths but this was quite good
These guys are effortlessly talented. Everything they do is original, makes you feel things, sounds good, it's timeless. Fantastic album. 4.5/5
Would listen to again
This week has had 0 sunlight in the forecast, and this album helped me embrace it.
Great album
Nice classic smiths vibe but not really any stand out songs
There were some parts of the production that I thought were pretty good, and I could hear some things that sounded like they inspired Radiohead that I enjoyed. It didn’t save the album though, I disliked most of the lyrics and melodies, and I cannot stand morrissey’s voice.
Knowing how close these songs were in time to the end of the band, it's easy now to hear hints of everyone's exhaustion. On the other hand, Morrissey's whole thing is that he perpetually sounds Over It, so I don't know how reliable an indicator that is. In any event, the production here is better than on The Queen Is Dead, which is both progress and an indictment; a lot of what makes the Smiths' early work so compelling for me is the rough-hewn nature of the recordings. That said, there's plenty of good stuff here.
The Smiths at their best. Great songwriting and production
old fav
Gillar ändå deras sound, tror jag skulle uppskatta mer på omlyssning
This record sucks
Morrissey sucks dick, this album is not much better
I thought The Smiths only released compilation albums? Big up Marr and Rourke, but even they couldn't subdue the fart sniffing wanker in command. Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me will be added to my playlist (the version without 2minutes of wankyness at the start)
It's quite different to their previous records. Overall, it has a very different production feel compared to The Queen Is Dead or Meat Is Murder. Much bigger rock tones, less jangly guitar melodies. It's got all the same sharp wit and emotional heft in the lyrics in the vocal melodies. It's a shame Morrissey has decided to destroy his entire legacy - seemingly driven by spite. If it weren't for Johnny Marr being an all round good-egg I'd find it hard to continue to listen to the Smiths.
The album is actually pretty good, it's just a shame Morrissey is a colossal wanker
Strangeways, Here We Come — четвёртый и последний студийный альбом британской инди-рок-группы The Smiths, выпущенный лейблом Rough Trade Records 28 сентября 1987 года, через несколько месяцев после распада группы. Все песни были написаны Джонни Марром, а тексты и вокал — Моррисси. Альбом ознаменовал собой стилистический сдвиг в творчестве группы: в нём использовался более широкий спектр инструментов и более экспериментальное звучание, чем в предыдущих релизах. Альбом имел коммерческий успех и с тех пор считается лучшей работой всеми четырьмя участниками группы. Хочется отметить инструментал Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me, а точнее вступление, потому что оно заставило меня чувствовать чувства. Первая пятёрка. Мне понравился этот альбом. При этом не могу выделить что-то конкретное, он просто в целом подходит моим предпочтениям больше прошлых альбомов, которые я слушала. Здесь есть хорошие тексты, приятные инструменталы и голос, что ещё нужно?
Never listened to The Smiths other than their popular stuff, and I can't believe I waited so long.
the Smiths is one of those bands where ever song sounds the same to me, but it's fine because I do like that song. but they really are all the same
78/100. Really good sounding. If this is considered their worst project by many, it only shows how high the standard was throughout their discography. A strong farewell.
I knew more of the songs than I thought I would. The intro to "...last night I dreamt that somebody loved me" made it an album listening experience for me. The first two songs made me think of Madness which was surprising. There is a lot of range here and sad that it was the end of the Smiths rather than the start of a new phase.
A great album with a distinct sense of humour, not sure it's my favourite Smiths album though. Strong 4
Lyrically perfect. What a duo with Jonny Marr as well. As a good as ever
Brilliant album
It’s remarkable that on this, The Smiths’ least popular album, 70% of the tracklist is absolutely 10/10 perfection. Marr and Morrissey finished things off with so much juice in the tank. God only knows where they would have gone next. Stop Me… In particular is a propulsive powerhouse, melodic pop genius with such an addictive circular structure. Girlfriend in a Coma is such a huge single that it’s easy to forget just how compelling and frankly odd the lyrics are. Marr has possibly never sounded so consistently good. The only thing that could improve things is if there was a big burst of energy at the end, like that in plentiful supply in the first half.
Every smiths LP is a 5, this is a lower one
Make it stop. 2/5
It's fine
Thought this was going to be way more sad! I'm quite impressed
I loathe Morrissey's voice, anything he sings I dislike. Good guitar work but the songs suck cause he's singing them. I am dumbfounded by how many listens this album has, only 3 songs under 10M, that's impressive, but it still blows. The sonics/mix on this album are better than other Smiths albums I've suffered through. 2 stars from me. I'm sure it's popular, not sure of influence, radio hits are almost none ("Girlfriend In A Coma" [so overrated]). The only song I kinda enjoyed was "A Rush And A Push..."
very much right on its way to 90s pop, but some cooler, cutting edgier stuff in there. An enjoyable listen.
I gotta be honest here, I’m heavily biased because I’m a Smiths fan. I love how much this band managed to do in such a short time. Not liking each other a whole lot made quit hard to get together. This record was the last time they did so before splitting up with no chance of a reunion. It may not their most defined album, it lacks some form of cohesion or narrative at times but sonically it feels like a step forward for the band. It’s a little rougher and wilder with freaky riffs and drums. Yet Morrissey manages to still keep it melancholic and a tad whiny. This has some of my favorite songs, tho I never really admired this album was a whole. It leaves some things to admire but it’s still really good final record, glad they decided to stop after this an end on a high note.
Boring and whiny not for me 1/5
my first album i have listened to by the smiths, a band i have always heard lots about but had never gravitated towards voluntarily, but safe to say i really enjoyed this and look forward to discovering their other albums too. it also made me think back in reference to 500 Days of Summer. If you know you know.
Jotenkin masis muttei kuitenkaan, ärsyttävää muttei kuitenkaan, mitäänsanomatonta muttei kuitenkaan. En oikeastaan tiedä tykkäsinkö vai enkö. En ollut fani mutta en vihannutkaan.
Siis tykkään the smiths viboista ja silleen musiikillisesti hyvää mut laulajan ääni on välillä tosi rasittava. Oli kokonaisuutena ihan keskiverto.
Third Smiths album (of 3 on the list). My favorite of the 3
Man I hate Morrissey but here we are again. I hate to admit that I don’t hate this like I wanted to. I was waiting for that I told you so moment. Nothing. There are weak points, it’s not perfect but I would listen to another Smiths album without question. Choice cut: Girlfriend in a Coma
God I love this. Wish I had grown up with the Smiths - between ours and our parents generation I think?
Love the Smiths. Strangeways not their best… assume there are earlier Smiths albums in this list?
This is it. This is definitely the worst Smiths album. Jesus fucking Christ I cannot believe people enjoy this vapid whiny cunt.
Previous Smiths entries so far have been held up by the instrumental end. I don’t know why they pivoted to this baroque knockoff renaissance-fair sound, but picturing Morrissey’s fat gut in one of those silly outfits at least added an element of humour to this dreadful album.
After our brief stint in Morriseys solo stuff its good to be back. This album doesnt come close to the Queen is Dead or Hatoful of Hallow but the production is as always immaculate. 8/10
For the final album that the Smiths would make as presumably Marr was done being the apple of Moz’s eye? There is a good level of exploration and experimentation with what the Smiths sound is. This can range from something like the openers of both sides which sound like something they’ve never really done before and other songs which sound like proper Smiths songs with extra bells and whistles. Personally, Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me is my favourite song that either the Smiths or Morrissey ever released. Both sides are great, I don’t think that overall this is as good as something like The Queen is Dead but it maintains a consistent grim, sometimes humorous tone, the instrumentation is legitimately some of the best stuff the band has put out and Moz’s lyrics are as great as ever. A brilliant send-off for a brilliant band, it’s remarkable the impact that the Smiths have had on music despite releasing 4 albums and being together for a total of 5 years. Highlights: Girlfriend in a Coma, Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before, Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me, I Won’t Share You
Pretty solidly mid!
This is not quite the jingly jangly pop Smiths from earlier albums. This has a certain dark weight, a foreboding turn to the horizon, a grappling with fate. But it is still distinctly the Smiths with Morrissey's usual poetic lyrics and elevated delivery, and Marr's furious guitars and lush compositions. The haunting musical scope is felt especially in "Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me" and "Death of a Disco Dancer", especially its outro. Yet we still get shorter sing-a-longable songs like "Girlfriend in a Coma" and "Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before". My least favorite track is "Unhappy Birthday", where Marr's instrumentation is great but Morrissey's lyrics almost sound like a parody of himself. In general, the second half of the album is weaker than the first. Sonically, I would say that this is Marr and The Smiths at their best, but Morrissey's lyrics aren't always his best-- an example of this is "Paint a Vulgar Picture" which kind of plods along for over 5 minutes. It's argued that this is the best Smiths album, that they finished their career with their best. While some songs are their best, the album start to finish was not as strong. It's certainly not as iconic or recognizable as The Queen Is Dead. It actually feels more like a transitory album, as if they stayed together it would mark a transition to darker soundscapes. But of course, this just marks the transition away from the band, a separation and unfolding.
the smiths definitely have some really good songs but none of them were on this album. can’t knock johnny marr’s guitar playing but morrissey is just so goddamn depressing
Arch drama and jangly magic and some of the bounciest bass in pop.
Great band... maybe one of the greatest ever. Worst lead singer... maybe one of the worst ever.
Enjoying the Smiths albums. 4.
Better than expected!
The older I get the less I like The Smiths, especially post Meat Is Murder. Maybe it‘s blasphemous to admit that, I really just do not like Morrissey
Good balance between heartbreak and swagger, and smirking through tears. Morrissey’s melodrama is almost endearing, especially when he’s being an asshole on purpose. Messy, funny, oddly sweet. Spins: 2 Playlist Additions: - A Rush and a Push and the Land Is Ours - Girlfriend in a Coma - Stop Me If You Think You’ve Heard This One Before - I Won’t Share You
It’s very telling that this list was compiled by a Brit — it’s oversaturated with British sensibilities, and The Smiths are right at the center of that. The Smiths live forever in Goth and Emo history, but I’ve never enjoyed Morrissey’s delivery or voice (though I once saw a cover band that nailed his vibe without being a jerk or showing up late). Personally, I’ve always been more drawn to Johnny Marr’s guitar work, which I feel is the real heartbeat of the band. This album is… fine. It’s distinctly The Smiths, and I don’t think anyone else has ever quite captured their sound, but to quote Family Guy, Morrissey “insists upon himself.” After years of being bludgeoned by his persona and presence, the whole thing just feels exhausting.
Morissey sounds pretty flat, as always. Great album filled with the usual The Smiths depression, hopelessness and dark humour.
I’m not a big Morrissey fan. I need some more than I thought I would. It’s whiny, more melodic than expected if they enjoyed beyond the classics.
СТРЕНДЖ альбом, и очень грустно, что последний у них. Очень серьезный шифт от The Queen Is Dead. К слову, с тех пор, как я слушал в списке предыдущий альбом группы The Smiths, я-таки купил Ягуар мечты. Спасибо, 1001! Лучшая песня - Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me.
I have three Morrissey albums in my library. I didn't realize he was in The Smiths before going solo. Will definitely add this album to my library.
Great first track but I can do without track 3s bleating hipster incantations. Didn’t know where « very nice » was from though. Solid drum breakdown at the end though. Track 4 is why I haven’t listened to The Smiths until now. Proto-hipter pablum with elevatory chorus that grates the longer it goes on. Mercifully, the song ends before it goes anywhere as though they couldn’t be bothered to finish writing it. Track 5: great bridge that makes me think I’ll love the smiths. Solid chorus too. And I like his vocals on this type of track vs the next one, 6, where I feel like he erroneously gave a generation of plaintive hipster bands permission to be whiney. Track 6: notwithstanding the above, when he actually opens up and sings I like his voice (not the falsetto). Track 8: meh. I can’t believe anyone thought this chord progression was song worthy. Track 9: could definitely grow on me a lot, I like it already at first listen. Overall, I’m getting the sense that I like upbeat smiths. And loath their ballady stuff—I think I don’t believe the emotional feel / it has none. Conceptually sad, without any sadness. Track 10: case in point. Can’t stand the plaintive sadness, feels fake. Track 2: missed it earlier. I like this. More confirmation of I like upbeat smiths.
Death of a Disco Dancer is maybe the first time I’ve really heard the seeds of Radiohead (who cite them as inspo). Supports my suspicions that the band was impeccable AND that Moz would be an insufferable hang.
Doesn’t consistently hit and Morrissey is a bell but they are still great.
I feel like I should either love or hate this but it is just ok. First three songs are the best to me but I don’t think this is amazing or particularly deep. Not unpleasant but won’t be craving to listen to this.
Meisterwerk mit „A Rus & A Pusch“, „Girlfrind in a coma“ und „Las Night I Dream“. Morresey in TopForm. Und mögen sich alle Rapper und Jazz Pfeifen sich auskotzen bis zu Leberzirrhose .. kaum ein Album hat mehr 5 ⭐️ als dieses 😊👍.
Great record even if it kinda falls flat after Last Night I Dreamt, but everything before would make for a 5/5 EP. Honestly doesn’t need to be on this list, but it’s a fun farewell record for The Smiths, massive shame it could not be a farewell record for Morrissey as a performer too.
I love The Smiths. Not my favorite though.
Johnny marr <3
Not a Smiths album I’d listen to before for me it wasn’t one of the better albums
This is a record from an incredibly controversial artist. Me personally, I'm more ambivalent towards it. It's pretty good, and it's honestly kinda calming, but also very downbeat. It resonates with me in a way few of the British pop albums do.
Kjærsten min e i koma, trallalalala-la, æ vet det e farlig men æ e for opptatt med å synge trallalalala-la :) Æ skulle ønske æ begynte å høre på The Smiths da æ va i riktig alder til å synes at deprimeranes tekster over gøyale melodier va ordentlig genialt. Og kanskje også før Morrissey tok helt av, for det etterlate jo en viss bismak, sjøl om æ like sangstemmen hannes. Det e så mye i verden som e vanskelig når folk har politiske meninger som kræsje fundamentalt med dine verdier, akk. Men ok+ album, det skal det ha.
I gave the other Morrisey/Smiths albums bad reviews without listening to them, but I thought I'd actually give this one a play, and it's nice to know that it's crap music as well as a crap person. Girlfriend In A Coma saves this from a one. Oh and once again , Fuuuuuuuuuck Morrisey
I did use a private session on Spotify for this one, I don't want Spotify to think I am a The Smiths fan, for quite a while Spotify was trying to turn me into a The Smiths fan, it didn't take. Nothing wrong with this album, as in I wasn't looking forward to it's end, in fact I listened to it twice. It won't be listened to again.
This was way better than I thought it would be! I'm definitely going to be listening to this again.
The Smiths. A few short years producing peerless records and a massive legacy. They have reached a musical maturity on this record, at the top of their game. Other records hold my favorite of their tracks, and so this one ranks for me at a strong four.
unfortunately this was really good, and relatable
Great
Amazing album Classic
“I love The Smiths” “I’m sorry?” Stupid movie references aside, this isn’t their best work but it still is amazing. That goes without saying, however, that Morissey is an insufferable incel and so is his band’s fanbase.
Morrissey is annoying. This album is fine I guess, but I doubt I'll listen again.
Kinda ok, but nothing really remarkable.
= the Beatles
A 1-star improvement from Meat is Murder. Still not good. Morrissey sucks balls.
ok, but not my kind of music.
Boring.
Ez az album elvisz magával, már az első dalnál elvarázsol és nem múlik el.. végigkísér dalról-dalra. Néha vidámabb, néha szomorúbb, de valahogy mégis mosolyt csal az arcodra. Álomszép, nagyon szeretem!
Their singles are better than their albums
Pretty good for the Smiths
Really good album, not a bad track on it. At the same time not enough outstanding songs to give it all 5 stars
I knew they were coming for me but it's pretty amazing that I've made it through 645 days without hitting The Smiths, a band I have always disliked, just on the basis of the few singles I've been subjected to, while living in a house of Indie-loving Mancunians. In fairness to me, I disliked The Smiths long before I learned that Morrissey was an utter helmet; his vocal style has always made my skin crawl and it seemed like they always defaulted to jangly, over-trebly guitars and over-the-top, pretentious wannabe poetic (faux-etic?) lyrics. So it seems I owe Johnny Marr an apology. The guitars are the one serious saving grace here; Marr varies his tones, styles and basically turns his talent to making a handful of decent tunes that even Moz can't completely ruin with his crooning. I even found the irresistible acoustic guitar riff of Girlfriend In A Coma got stuck in my head for days.
Anos 80 puro, delicinha de ouvir
Not a fan.
it just doesnt stand out to me idk, maybe im missing something
truthnuke incoming, but you shouldn't care whether an artist is likeable or not if they can sing well and write good music. CRAZY, I know. This is a 5, new wave kino. All the people ranking 1 or 2 are insane.
Love the Smiths
I am a big fan of the Smiths, a 3.5 star for me. Drops to a 3 I think.
I never really liked them. I try to listen now to hear historical significance. But I dont like his voice.
Ended up listening 3 times because it was good background music while I worked. Nothing terrible about it but also nothing that screams wow. Solid 3
Morrissey is an absolute ass, but he does make good music. 4/5
Muito bom, mas não se tornaria minhas músicas preferida
My least favorite Smiths album. But still it’s The Smiths.
This one sounded closer to what I like than Meat Is Murder. Morrissey's singing was a lot more tolerable, and the music a lot less 80s sounding, but in return it lost a lot of the other album's character and uniqueness. Looks like I'm not much of a fan of The Smiths. If The Queen is Dead (I'm sure that one's also on the list) is coming sooner than 20-30 entries, I'm skipping that one altogether.
I could do without “Death At One’s Elbow” (who couldn’t right?) otherwise I think it’s perfect. (4.8) but I’m rounding up…
Strangeways, Here We Come is an album I really enjoy, even if it’s probably my least favorite in The Smiths’ catalog. The opening track, with its dramatic drum rolls and almost theatrical flair, makes for a strong start. And while I rank it below their other records, that says more about the strength of their discography—because even my “least favorite” Smiths album still towers above many of my favorites from other bands.
The way "Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before" leads into "Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me" is hauntingly beautiful.
Still not my thing.
I really liked this! Have heard of The Smiths for ages, and now I've been exposed to it :)
I, like most people, do not like Morrissey, so I didn't think I would like it. I am surprised that I do. The lyrics are meh, and I skipped through a too-long track, but enjoyed it as background music. I almost hummed along.
I love The Smiths, they are one of my favorite bands ever, but out of the 4 studio albums they have....this is the worst right? This album isn't bad at all, Death Of A Disco Dancer, Girlfriend In A Coma, Paint A Vulgar Picture, and I Won't Share You, to me are some of their best songs but I could honestly care less about the other 6 songs on this album, like goddamn. I guess if this is their last album together then I guess it's perfectly fine, and this album never changes how I feel about them personally and in the pantheon of music, but this is just an average Smiths album, and I guess that's a little better than most averages.
Fucking fantastic
I enjoyed listening to this album and all of the instrumental parts were pretty good but I can't really point to any highlights that I'd want to put on a playlist for later. I liked it a little less than Meat is Murder, so it gets a 3 for that.
If everst thou findest thyseft in the pissiest of moods; seek Jahnny Marr forget that Morry fellow.
Upbeat tunes with dark humor and morbid lyrics. Interesting.
might be clever lyrics but I would listen to it again, poetry that didnt grip me over music that didn't enthrall me.
Clearly unfinished but it got me with the girlfriend in a comma song. Cover art 3/5 but most points are for it being just one person on the front clearly adding to the "this band broke up" vibe.
What a fever dream. Did they record separately without listening to each other? The drama surrounding this chaos brings it up from 2.5 to 3 for me.
This is probably the most passionate 3 stars I will ever give! This is an album by a group of people that do not give a f*ck! They hate each other now and they cannot be bothered to work on any of the songs until they're good, this is what you get! Some are too long, some are too short, some don't seem to have their beginnings or ends figured out, Morrissey tries a bunch of weird shit on vocals, much of it doesn't work, but who cares! These are certainly talented musicians, but this album is a mess! I did laugh out loud at a couple songs which endeared them to me because I love me anything sufficiently stupid. Cover is also blah, it's threes all around for this one!
Only The Smiths could make a jangly upbeat pop tune about a girlfriend being in a coma. Some Smiths classics on here (girlfriend, stop me, last night I dreamt somebody loved me, I started something I couldn’t finish). Not as good as The Queen Is Dead but still a very good album.
I always heard a lot of praise for Johnny Marr’s guitar playing and arrangements and it’s on full display here.
Rock and roll with some other sounds mixed in
Many years ago I was at a Cubs game and there were four or five hipsters sitting in the row of seats behind me. Before the game started I was eavesdropping on their conversation; they were complaining about a friend of theirs who was not present. I guess this friend would sing 'Girlfriend in a Coma' at karaoke on a weekly basis, and only ever that song, and it seemed like they were getting fed up. I think about this occasionally; I wonder if all those folks still hang out! Anyways. Before this I've only ever listened to Smiths singles/compilations, but this album is really good.
I'm tempted to leave a keyboard smash as a review. That's how this album makes me feel. Like I'm melting into goo, and my goo is pulsing to the beat of the music. Too much? Okay!! I love The Smiths! I love Morrissey as a singer even if I despise him as a person! The other members of the band are not bad people and deserve praise! Also this was my first time hearing Death of a Disco Dancer and holy shit did I love it.
Not even the best Smiths album…
Morrissey is racist scum but I dammit I love the Smiths
I’m a big fan of the early Morrisey solo albums so I really don’t know why I have never listened to any Smiths albums other than probably a best of the Smiths album. Very good album and I knew more songs than I thought I would from looking at the titles.
Спокойный. Не совсем в моём вкусе.
I pied rush and push or something like taht
The Smiths have never been a favorite but wanted to give the album a shot. Not the type of music I like, but can see why people like them... actually, I guess I do like this style just not their music. The Smiths, REM and The Pogues all around the same time & can see the similarities. No bangers.
Their last album and for me their weakest. Girlfriend In a Coma and Unhappy Birthday are tongue in cheek but come across as parodies of themselves. In fact most tracks are fairly average (for them) until the last three which I still love and play regularly. 'Paint a Vulgar Picture' stands out. A damning view of fame, adoration, the media and music industry exploitation. And all set to Johnny Marr's magnificent guitar, from those opening riffs, brilliant rhythm backing to the magnificently short but uplifting solo which I never tire of and play loud on a regular basis! 'I Won't Share You' is a fitting full stop on their recorded output, a beautiful closer. I can't help thinking the opening track hints at Morrissey's political leanings though, sadly.
Not as consistent as The Queen Is Dead, but still a great Smiths album with a wonderful jangly guitar sound and solid vocals. Highlights are Girlfriend in a Coma, Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me, and Paint a Vulgar Picture.
Enjoyable listen, with good tunes and lyrics
2/4
Instrumentation is pretty good. I still don't like Morrisey as a human being.
Fantastic!
Intense interesting storytelling
I’ll always love Smiths albums. The drama! Every song is like an episode of a soap opera. And musically it’s so strong and varied. The A side and “Last Night I Dreamt….” are fantastic. And tell me how long before the right one???? FOUR STARS
Ganske fint The Smiths album
не лучший альбом смитс, но в целом нормик
Good but short
His voice and those lyrics! If you take him outta the equation honestly some of those guitar tones are cheesy af but Morrissey can make anything listenable. Some great songs on this one.
Toimittaa
Hørt en del før - svakeste smiths-album. Litt uinspirert
Damn it Morrissey and his stupid heel turn
This is a B/B+ Smiths album, which means that it is still really not bad (standard operating 'Morrisey is an ass' caveat here). It's more diverse sound-wise if still as always dark and miserable lyric-wise, even when sung beautifully. I just do not love the Smiths that much, try as I might. That said, I cannot get 'Girlfriend in a Coma' out of my head now
I love the mordant humor of songs like “Girlfriend in a Coma.” They definitely anticipate (and skewer) the incel mentality. But some of the tracks are just ho-hum.
Klassiker och kan vara min favorit med The Smiths studioalbum
I had never heard The Smiths before, but I will definitely be checking them out in the future. Really enjoyed this album. Can really feel that this is where Radiohead (among others) got some inspiration.
It's the worst of the studio releases, but I still just love Marr and Morrissey together. Really credit to everyone in that band who isn't named Steven Patrick Morrissey for sticking it out long enough to give us 4 great records.
Stop Me If You Think You've Heard This One Before This was my intro to the Smiths and overall still my favorite. Side one is a perfect blend of different styles. Side two is not as strong to me, but forgiven with Unhappy Birthday and Paint a Vulgar Picture. Still 5 stars
Exciting I am into the smiths at the moment.
Nope, still can't listen to The Smiths. However, a couple of songs were bearable this time.
This is a great album but their earlier stuff is better.
I don't understand this band.
I still don't really understand The Smiths. "Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me" feels like the only track worth listening to, and it's a great one.
I’ve heard of The Smiths but never really listened cool band
Girlfriend in a Coma is me, and I am her. Pretty much unresponsive this whole album. I can’t stand Morrissey’s voice. As a sad music lover I suppose it get the appeal with some of the lyrics so I’ll give a 2 instead of a 1. But jeez
It’s fine I suppose, but Morrissey is a bit of a cunt.
This seems weaker than the other albums by The Smiths that I know. At least it has "Stop Me If You've Heard This One Before."
Final Smiths album, rounding off a near perfect discography. You can hear the divide between Morrissey and Marr opening up in both the lyrics and the instrumentation. But it’s still a cohesive, fitting end to one of the defining 80s bands.
Loved it would listen again
While I rather enjoyed the lush melodies of the songs, that stopped whenever (1) Morrissey started singing or (2) when the song abruptly ended because these all felt like demos on a mini disc from the early 90s.
Historically hate Morrissey which has always made listening to The Smiths a hateful act - this is a pretty good album
Love the smiths still one of my favourite bands.
I like The Smiths, but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t think all their songs sounded exactly the same.
I don’t think I’ve ever thought about a musician as much as people do when they hate on Morrisey. This is the first Smiths album I heard back in the day & remains my favorite
I liked the other Smiths album more
Cracking
solid and short
Kind of mixed on this one. It was good but I don’t really see what all the fuss is about. I think I need to try out more of their stuff to really form an opinion. I’ll rate based on my first impression for now.
Странный альбом. В целом, мне нравятся смитс и понравился и этот альбом, но он почему-то не звучит так, как в моей голове всегда звучали смитс. Саунд тут более попсовый что-ли, более масштабный и развернутый, это не совсем то, что ожидаешь. Он обладает другой атмосферой, нежели то, к чему я привык. Но все же мне понравился, пару песен в плейлист залетело.
I think if I had a previous connection with the Smiths, I would rank this higher, but I don't - this was a first (and second) listen for me. I'm fine with it - may not ever think to put it on, but can let it ride if it's already playing.
The first track DAMN I love it
Man, I don't know about some of the lyrics on these songs, they kind of pulled me out of the experience. It's like the songs sound better if you don't scrutinize them too closely. Morrissey's singing style makes the songs sound the same. This was OK.
Favorite: Stop Me if You Think You've Heard This One Before Classic Smiths although not their best in my opinion. I don't know why Hatful of Hollow wasn't included instead, I think it has better songs.
amazing
I had a Morrissey album yesterday. This has to be some sort bad luck right? How is this guy on this list so much? Fuck Morrissey.
What can I say, I never had a good impression on the smiths, but this one is better than the queen is dead
Everything you said is exactly how I feel
Morrissey and the Smiths are a real love/hate situation for me. I love Rush and a Push and Girlfriend in a Coma, but I HATE Death of a Disco Dancer, and after about 4 songs Morrissey's voice starts to annoy me. It's always going to be just mixtape singles for me with the Smiths I guess.
The Smiths are very good at playing on your feelings, that's the thing you can't take away from them. The album is a bit outshadowed by "Meat is murder" and "The Queen is dead", but there are fine songs, such as my favorite "I started something I couldn't finish". The pleasant, slightly melancholic sound goes back to the recent past, when I was 16, when such music was like a healing ointment. Recommend it if you liked other albums.
Don't like the sounds and attire of post-punk and expected to hate it. But nah, this was good. Songs are so melodic and adventorous. 3.5, but will rate it 4 just because I was biased in opposite direction beforehand
Nothing stood out enough but has a nice overall vibe
Je connaissais pas vraiment ce groupe mais franchement j'ai beaucoup aimé même si j'ai trouvé cet album très inégal entre des chansons que j'ai A-DO-RÉ et d'autres qui étaient plus banales et qu'on pourrait retrouver facilement chez d'autres groupes, je trouve. Chansons préférées : Girlfriend in a coma, Last night i dreamt that somebody loved me (bangerrr)
J’aime beaucoup ce groupe, cependant ce n’est pas mon album préféré !
Une bonne découverte ! J'aime bien les Smiths, c'est chill et ya des sonorités qui me plaisent. J'ai passé un bon moment à écouter l'album et mention spéciale pour Death of a Disco Dancer. 4/5