What's Going On by Marvin Gaye

What's Going On

Marvin Gaye

3.94
Rating
29756
Votes
1
1%
2
6%
3
24%
4
35%
5
34%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 14)

So smooooooooth

This made me feel optimistic

This is some old cheesy easy stuff and his voice was great but I think I was just expecting a bit more. chill.

Yes. Just yes.

Beautiful voice and incredibly mellow groove throughout, would listen again

so much was said in 35:32 that truly makes you think about the world around you. mastery of the genre, and of music as a whole.

Solid soul album. A bit more down tempo than my preference but still great.

fav songs: what’s going on mercy mercy me (the ecology) right on lush, circular, restrained, spiritual 80/100

Smooth tunes with hard hitting social commentary lyrics.

Great album

I'd give it a ten if I could

Smooth, soulful, politically aware. One of my favourites.

Good timing for recommending this on Valentine’s Day

Brother, brother, brother what an album. Songs 10/10, transitions 10/10, voice 10/10. Great songs with some jazzy flares

Estilo musical muito bom Um álbum envolvente

Soul gospel og rnb. Det er et album hvor alle sangene har flydende overgange og fortæller en samlet historie som generelt handler om krig, kærlighed spiritualitet osv. det er et virkelig godt album og meget smukt musik. Natur lader det også som om og menneskers indflydelse på verden teknologisk osv. det er sgu meget godt og tidsløst det er helt sikkert. Det er ikke 100 % mig af en eller anden årsag. Jeg er f.eks. mere til superfly Curtis Mayfleld tror jeg, hvis det kommer til soul. Men det her er også virkelig godt.

A few classics but not enough to rate high.

What a banger out the door! It is a great album, doesn't move me as much as I thought it would. I like all the mixed instrumentation.

This is an amazing, lush, sweet album. The love Marvin has for his fellow man and humanity and the world at large is here in BUCKETS. But this is not the ROMANTIC live album everyone thinks it is. There's so much soul and emotion here, Marvin practically weeps for what we're doing to the environment for our children and each other. This is not your sex album, though. You thinking it is. My rating: 5/5

Ah! C’est si bon, ooooh là là, magnifique en tout point, il mérite bien sa place dans le top des classements. J’ai même pas de joke à faire, chapeau Marvin! - Salut Cyril! Bonne année un peu en retard, I guess! Ça fait un sacré bout aussi que je ne te suis pas revenu, c’est peut-être même mon dernier message sur la liste originale, avant que je te rejoigne sur la colline de Sysyphe! Ah, avant de me perdre dans des suggestions de films, je me permets de m’interrompre pour t’annoncer la bonne nouvelle: Ping Pong Go sort un nouvel album au mois d’avril! Il y a beaucoup de très bons artistes invités à collaborer aussi, donc les stars de l’heures comme Lou-Adriane Cassidy, Thierry Larose et Arianne Roy. Aussi, Angine de Poitrine vont potentiellement sortir un deuxième album, mais ils sont pas mal cryptique là-dessus… Donc, on parle de flim? Je te recommande grandement Parasite, honnêtement je connais personne qui n’a pas aimé, vraiment tu peux pas te tromper avec. Get Out aussi est très bon, quoique pas autant que Parasite. Mais si t’aimes les scénario tordus à la Lynch, tu seras servis! Dans la même veine de l’horreur/thriller moderne, il me serait dur de ne pas mentionner Ari Aster. T’as dû entendre parler de Midsommar, c’est pas mal le film qui l’as mis sur la carte, mais c’est selon moi son plus faible ( et ça en dit long, ça reste un très bon film malgré tout, ça en dit long sur le gars!). En avant goût, je te propose son excellent court métrage The Strange Thing About the Johnsons, disponible gratuitement sur YouTube, pour te donner une idée du bonhomme. Pour ses longs métrages, je te recommande de commencer avec Hereditary ou Midsommar, les deux sont d’excellente déconstruction de l’horreur basé sur des drames familiaux extrêmement efficaces en eux même, mais il sait les pousser encore plus loin avec les éléments d’horreur très bien dosés. Après ça, son dernier film Eddinghton qui porte sur la pandémie et les ravages qu’elle a provoqué sur le monde est peut-être sorti trop tôt pour certains, mais c’est selon moi le meilleur film sorti de 2025, donc deux gros 👍👍. Finalement, un des films les plus weird, absurde, profond, rocambolesque et excessivement bien construit que j’ai vue de ma vie revient à Beau Is Afraid, une odyssée de l’âge moderne incroyablement personnelle qui me hante encore aujourd’hui. C’est VRAIMENT pas pour tout le monde, mais si t’as envie d’une expérience cinématographique unique, y’a pas d’autres choix. Sinon, en vrac, si t’es un peu calé en SciFi et en grosse intrigues géo-politique, je te recommande les Dunes de Denis Villeneuve, donc le dernier opus va sortir cette automne. En parlant de notre Denis cheri d’amour, je te lance en vrac Incendie / Prisonners / Arrival, tous de phénomènal thrillers à leurs propres sauces, vraiment tu ne peux pas ne pas aimer. En restant dans le québécois, Les chambres rouges de Pascal Plante pour un thriller juridique profondement glauque et sinistre et Viking de Stéphane Lafleur, une comédie dramatique simili scifi sur… pas mal de chose finalement! Si t’aimes les huis clos et les problèmatiques reliées aux relations humaines, je te recommande! Ok, ça commence à manquer de temps, je vais juste t’en pitcher une couple: - The Whale - The Lighthouse - Whiplash (film de musique!) - Ex Machina - The Zone of Interest - Interstellar - Poor Things - Sound of Metal (film de musique!) - Her - Birdman - The Ballad of Buster Scruggs - La La Land (film de musique!) Je pourrais continuer de même longtemps, donc fait moi signe si t’en veux plus! Ok, côté série maintenant! Je suis définitivement moins calé que le cinéma, principalement que tout les shows ont 4-8 saisons, tu peux rentrer tellement de films là-dedans! C’est drôle, j’ai commencé les Sopranos le mois passé, j’ai presque fini la saison 1, à date j’adore! J’aime la structure lousse narrativement, ça devient presqu’un documentaire. Tout les personnages sont incroyables aussi, je pourrais les suivre 24/24! Mad Men et The Wire, j’ai essayé vraiment fort, mais je m’en suis lassé avant d’atteindre la fin (s3 pour Mad Men et s1 pour Wire). Mad Men tournait en rond après un moment, genre on sait que c’est tous des gigolos pas fiables, donnez moi plus de meeting spicy et moins de « J’ai changé, Betty, pardonne mes actions d’hommes des années 50 », suivie de 36 scènes de baises dans les bureaux de l’agences. The Wire, y’a ben trop de personnages là-dedans! J’avais un calepins pour noter les noms/surnoms/alias/roles de tout les personnages, pis même là j’avais de la misère à me retrouver dans cette soupe de jargons policier. Je comprends que c’est plus immersif, mais mon cerveau de TDAH y arrive pas. Par contre, Breaking Bad et sa prologue Better Call Saul son mes shows préféré de tout les temps, je te recommande vraiment BCS si tu l’as pas regardé, la qualité des épisodes sont beaucoup plus consistantes que BB, et les personnages tout aussi brillants dans leur écriture et dialogues. Je partage ton inquiétude vis-à-vis de Severence: le show est incroyable, mais la finale de la deuxième saison m’inquiète un peu concernant la suite de la série, j’ai peur qu’ils ne savent plus où aller avec ce scenario de dingo. Ouf! Je pense que j’ai fait le tour, à la prochaine!

A stone cold classic album. But ... sometimes it seems a little Preach-y

This an incredible album from a timeless artist. It's message is still as important as when the album was made. Love it.

It's a classic for sure, but just doesn't resonate with me

So far we've had albums lead by guitar, drums, samples, electronics, etc., but this is the first album where the BASS quietly carries the entire composition. This album flows seamlessly and does not waste any time. The first 6 tracks all feel connected until you reach "Right On," where it's like "let's dance!" Then in the same song it's slows back down into the next track, and then you ride out smoothly yet mournfully with inner city blues. Surely an album with musical and philosophical influence spanning decades. 9/10

Oh man, so many thoughts . . . . Here's one: this album epitomizes the debt we 3 owe to Mombo. She must have bought this album around when it was first released (May 1971, a year before we moved to Florida), because I'm pretty sure I remember listening to it in South Bend. Anyway, safe to say, probably a pretty small minority of white kids growing up in the 70s whose mother bought this album. Thanks, Mom (for ALL the music)! I remember listening to this in the 80s (probably 90s, too), and feeling like it had been forgotten, but in the past 20 or 25 years or so, I feel like I've been hearing it (the hits, at least) more often. I bet this is one of the highest rated albums (by all the people who rate it here, I mean -- not just us). 5 stars (though, if I had the option, I *might* rate it 4.5 - but maybe 5).

James Jamerson on bass! (He only used 1 finger) This record has soul, heart, spirit, it's groovy, and it has stood the test of time. There is a unity and distinctive sound to it, despite how relaxed the studio sessions were. What's Going On elevates my mind, but I also feel it immediately in my body (a rare combination in music)

Beautiful album. What a voice delivering social commentary. Artist tragically gone way too soon. Some of the tracks are fairly mellow but WOW. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

An appropriate assignment during Black History Month, especially since I recently finished reading Kristin Hannah's "The Women" about Vietnam War combat nurses in which references to music including Gaye, The Beatles, and Hendrix really help set the scene. Definitely deserves its spot on a list of albums to hear at least once before you die. Fantastic instrumentation and smooth, soulful vocals. Powerful, meaningful lyrics. Still highly relevant, unfortunately.

too much talk about God but overall, a banger album.

The music is great, sounds like something that would play in a quiet, expensive bar. Also good music to put on while you make love to someone. There are some standouts on this album such as “Whats going on” and “Come Get To This” i absolutely adore the instrumentation throughout this record, however some of the songs were blending in with each other and i couldnt tell the difference between them, i was also expecting a little more.

Не мой жанр песни

Good but wasn’t in the mood for it unfortunately

I had high hopes but a little disappointed. Good to have on in the background but few stand out tracks for me.

Marvin Gaye!!! What’s going on?! Brilliant and transitionally fluent in the blend to the next track. Could listen to this on repeat!

Don't have anything to say, pretty nice

Beautiful voice but again not my vibe/grocery store music

- Was really only familiar with What’s Going On, didn’t realize that this opener was a leading idea for the entire album - What a vibe, what a transport back in time to a moment in US history - Made me sad that we are still trying to solve all these same problems today, felt timeless in this plea - Jazz flute! - “Who really cares? Who’s willing try to save a world that’s destined to die?” -love that this can be interpreted as a call to action and throwing hands up in resignation - Surprised at how overtly religious the album is - continuous transitions between tracks makes it extra groovy - ran out of time to finish - Doesnt grab me sonically, but appreciate it for it’s thesis of love at a time where it was sorely needed!

Good vibes, easy to work to. A little samey.

Kind of hated Save the Children.and thought Flying High and Wholly Moly were mediocre. Basically the rest are good to amazing

Went down so smooth, just a lovely listening experience from start to finish (except for the cabasas in Right On which drove me absolutely nuts)

I like the Anchorman jazz flute in "Right On." Also like "Inner City Blues." This is obviously good (Rolling Stone has it #1 all time) and socially important and profound but also just not my thing.

I've been meaning to listening through this album, so thank god I was given a reason to do so! I know I'm not adding anything, but it's sooooooo good!!! It's so smooth and groovy, you want to keep listening through every song without skipping. This is definitely a must-have vinyl purchase!!!

Historically, it mixed the pop with the politics of the time. Groovily, it just soars musically above everything else from the time period besides Coltrane.

I'm not gonna lie, part of this rating is peer pressure from knowing just what a classic this album is. But some of its earnestness hits me as unintentionally hilarious.

I mean what can you say about an album like this? Marvin was a beacon of soul, an avatar of rhythm. The grooves are so deep on here you run the risk of falling out between the notes. It's a wonderful album, but not totally consistent, at least to my ear. There are a couple tracks that kind of drag it down, and for it it'll get a 4/5 from me.

I know this is supposed to the greatest album of all time according to some lists. I find it kind of not so great. It may be over hyped and a product of its time. It's not bad, it just doesn't have much to hold my interest for repeated listenings.

One of the greatest albums of all time. Soulful, melodic, great lyrics, perfect message

Notable Textzeile: Who really cares? Who's willing to try? To save the world That's destined to die Was für realistischer, klarsichtige, niederschmetternde Texte, die hier in das süßeste Gewand gekleidet werden. Oft etwas zu süß für meinen Geschmack, aber ich habe großen Respekt vor der Entscheidung und konsequenten Umsetzung. Und könnte ohne den God-Part gut leben, in dieser Welt scheint er uns nicht mehr zu retten. Trotzdem außergewöhnlich. 3,5 wird zu

It’s everywhere bro

I listened to this on a rainy bus ride to my friend’s celebration of life. Great soul and R&B tunes. Inspired flourishes that make What’s Going On sound like nothing else.

Fantastic, incredible voice, this album is such a statement. Marvin Gaye's reputation in my mind is mostly about sexy music. He may be sexy, what with that voice and all, but this is not background sexy music. Maybe that comes more from Let's get it on (that would make sense). This is political and painful and demands attention. Love it. I love the mix, good music, but the voice is all the way out front. The orchestration could have been out of date, but somehow is perfect. Title track is amazing, loved "Mercy Mercy Me" What is that sound on "Right On"? It's cool as hell! Favorite song on the album, jazz flute and all! This one captivated me even more than I expected, not an everyday listen, but a 5 star experience.

Love it. So soulful.

Great vibes start to finish.

Pretty gaye

Brilliant! 4.5. Lots to enjoy here, really felt like something special, can only imagine how it felt in 1971. Cool story behind the title track as well. Loved What's Going On, but also a big fan of Mercy Mercy Me (picking that one!!), Right On and Inner City Blues. Brilliant!

A mí lo que pasa es que el Soul en general, no me gusta.

What's Going On is a perfect song but the rest just feels like an afterthought. Almost like the lyrics are improvised. I mean two good songs and the rest seem pretty bad.

This was really cool. Its really straightforward, he doesn't want conflict, he likes the ecology, and he seems really spiritual. Kinda role model music, everyone should inspire to think like him. Also I love the transitions between each track, its like he's telling a story to kids. Dare I say.....10/10

There's no real catchy tunes here but the vibe it gives off is nice after awhile. Might grow to love it work more listens

yk considering theres not nothing to berry gordy's accusation of Lack Of Commercial Potential, its kinda wonderful that this album is still one of the most easily likable and Obviously Good records in existence. its a triumph primarily of form...i wouldnt be surprised if many of the "conscious" soul albums inspired by this one have better and more coherent points to make about the world and its problems. but im equally sure none of them just Blow Ur Mind the way this one does...hung together as one of the most coherent album suites of its decade, to the point where im not sure i even think of it as a suite more than just a single multipart Song. its not a blues album, but imo one of the big connective points between the blues and soul is that theyre both genres about Filling The Space...audible expanses waiting to be occupied by The Human Spirit. or something like that. in that way, both the space and the filling here feels like a to-this-point culmination of this particular thread of black music. and man like can u ever imagine Not Being In The Mood For This Album. crazy talk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Y'all five star mafia making me feel like a cretin here. I can appreciate the talent and I recognize the cultural and historical significance, I just didn't think it was that fun to listen to.

Solid gold

Marvin Gaye seems like he has one foot in the sixties and one in the seventies in this one. I was expecting some straight 70s R&B and got that, but, like, sort of psychedelic too, which was a cool surprise. Great album for a slow Sunday around the house. I loved it.

Perfect album

Can you imagine being as cool as Marvin Gaye is in the 70’s? I can’t. But it’s fun to pretend for a while when you listen to the album.

Musically, 5 stars. -1 mark for the preachy God/Jesus bits

I would like to thank the 1001 albums generator for introducing me to a genuinely new experience: actively liking a soul album. It's a genre I've loathed my whole life, repelled by its inspid subject choices and flat rhythms. This is the opposite, a personal and political concept album that lays down some classic grooves beneath the swelling strings and soulful vocals.

I feel like Marvin was telling me a story, through his rhythms.

Groovy af. The bass goes hard af. Mfer has a voice of an angel. Easy listen. Chill vibes. Great when you're unwinding and want to listen to something relaxing.

Kind of boring, really didn't make it for me. All the songs look the same. At any moment the instruments or his voice doing something a bit more exciting or virtuoso. I'm sure it's a nice album to make passionate and romantic sex tough (by experience, Marvin Gaye's albums are great for this).

YUHHHHH what is going on?? Love an album that flows

Remember hearing this on the smooth jazz radio before i was old enough to switch channels, so sadly I can't stand this album

While I recognize how talented he was, and what an incredible voice he had, and can appreciate the music, I don't feel an urge to listen to this again. And by that measure, it gets no more than a 3/5 for me.

Surprising in some respects; a little too Jesus-y in others.

Marvin knew what was going on

does marvin gaye have a clue fr? makes me wanna learn to slow dance

This is the first record that I actually own on this list which is kind of exciting for me. I got to listen to it and it’s original form - on vinyl, through headphones and in stereo. It’s perfect. While the individual tracks may be not as memorable as the title track or the singles, the album, as a whole, was meant to be experienced as a singular song cycle piece and listening to it in that way is how to experience the smooth interplay of the vocals, the musical backing, the messaging, the atmospheric arrangement, and what is ultimately the encapsulation of Motown in its most perfect form. The only downside to this album is that while it was released over 50 years ago its messaging is still relevant today.

Fattest and slimmest.

A construção do álbum como uma experiencia contínua é impressionante. Soul não é um gênero que escuto com frequência, mas é fácil perceber a qualidade dos intrumentalistas.

Already very familiar with this album given that it's one example of my mother's musical tastes rubbing off on me. An amazing soul album, and I can count myself as one of the many bass players who have stuck a foam mute on their bass trying to imitate James Jamerson's parts on this album. 8.5/10

top 3 - Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Save The Children, Right On. Man, he has an amazing voice. Great from start to finish. I really like how the songs blend into each other as well! It’s sad how young he died though :(

I’ve had this album for a good 30 or so years, and for whatever reason it’s not one I reach for when I want to listen to something from beginning to end. That’s been my loss, because hearing now in full reveals what an absolute masterpiece it is; an insanely talented set of musicians, great songs beautifully arranged, and Oh, that voice. Effortless yet controlled, expressive but subtle. The album is 35 minutes of beautiful, lush, ambitious and thought provoking magic. As with many albums on this list, go for the original release and ignore the 50th anniversary version unless you’ve got a real need to hear every possible version of What’s Going On recorded. (I want to point out here that there have been many subsequent singers compared to Marvin Gaye, but you need to hear him here at his absolute peak to understand he’s beyond compare)

NOT FINISHED!!

So smooth. The title track is, of course, essential. Several other songs approach that quality. But there’s some real treacle on the album here and there, too.

Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Jeg elsker Marvin Gaye!! På denne vakre vakre dagen hvor lille baby Tulla er på vei til verden så får jeg et dog alvorlig album men med et så slående budskap: You see, war is not the answer For only love can conquer hate You know we've got to find a way to bring some lovin' here today // soleklar femmer. en av de beste albumene noensinne.

Perfect no notes

This genre is not really my thing

4 / 5 stars thoughts while listening: - gaye has a very beautiful voice! - the instrumentation on this album is so fun and vibrant - i don't resonate really strongly with some of the messages in this album because i'm not really religious, but that's okay!

очень приятный альбом, если поставить на фон в доме то вообще будет супер расслабляюще. по сравнению с прошлым альбомом это была терапия

what's going on 1971 united states soul

i wonder how many people exist today because of this album

That was beautiful, man.

now we're cookin' with sex

What's going on Marvin?

Some classic tracks. They don run together at times.

Amazing album definitely switched up my taste a bit

started of really strong, definitely has some good songs, but halfway throught just got a little bored.

Fine album. Great to relax to, it's groovy and full of sentiment. Might have to listen more than one time to digest the lyrics, which are the highlight of the album, considering when it was released.

Good overall but definitely some odd ones on here

4/5 Instrumentação linda: baixo e orquestra brilham. Os vocais de Marvin são, como sempre, primorosos.

Listening session: january 26th, while commuting to internship Listened to before: yes of course Thoughts: man is there a smoother record than this, especially when listening front to back? Favourite tracks: What’s Going On, Wholy Holy & Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)

Ja det här är bra! Som basist måste man ju nästan älska allt James Jamerson medverkar på. Gillar de sömlösa övergångarna också. Jag är inte är helt förtjust i God is love eller Save the children, men Whats going on och Mercy mercy me är ju verkligen bangers!

Mycket snyggt och smooth, ibland kanske lite för smooth och snyggt för just mig. Men som album betraktat ändå en femma!

Bitvis enkelspårig ljudbild men overall är det nice, sweet smooth upplyftande

Silky smooth! Men är det världens bästa album någonsin som många hävdar? Nä.

Ägnat dagen åt att försöka hitta svagheter här. Men till och med gurkan, och då menar jag bokstavligen instrumentet gurka den här gången, är väl avvägd. Otroligt elegant helhet, med ledmotiv som återkommer och låtar som går in i varandra. Närmast oantastligt album. Bara början och slutet gör det till en 5a.

Ett till album som brukade sättas på när man var basic junior. Har därefter fått höra att det är världens bästa album. Av någon anledning gör det mig otroligt irriterad. Det går inte att utse världens bästa album, knappt ens rimligt att välja 1001. Men ah det är ju en femma hehe. Stort fan av Marvin Gaye!

save the babies! perfektion

Imbecill! Kättare! Grobian! Sötvattenspirat! Odåga! Blotare! Bondlurk! Dårhushjon! Enögda kannibal! Grottmänniska! Vrålapa! Pestråtta! Sabotör! Huuuuuur kan du bara he en stark fyra till världens bästa album?! Fuuuuuuuuuuu

The title song has always been mediocre for me. But then the album just keeps on with more of the same. No thanks.

Ok easy listening

Never listened to Marvin Gaye, so might as well start with his........11th album. Jesus. I really liked the concept of songs running into each other as it really helps to stay in the groove of what is a very aware album. I'm not a huge fan of motown, but i'll admit that somehow the motown beats with Marvin's vocals works really well and isn't AS annoying as a lot of R&B. The album covers a range of social problems plaguing the world and the US from Vietnam vets struggling after coming home, to environmental issues. Marvin had to have been one of the first artists to express concern about the changing environment. It's a nice album that touches on issues. My main problem with it is that all the songs are half thoughts and just come across as vapid. It feels like Miss America type statements that initially sound awesome......but dissolve as they continue. Save The Children starts with a great concept of the overall pointlessness of everything when the planet is eventually going to die anyway, but if we really care, we should at least take care of things for future generations (the children). From there the song just devolves into generic cries about saving the children, saving the babies. What's Happening Brother suffers the same fate with a great concept of the issues vets face when coming home with homelessness and unemployment etc and he touches on this........and then the song peters out as if he had a great thought but didn't know enough about it to expand. I dunno, the album sounds good, but the writing is lacking for me. This kind of musing may have been revolutionary in 1971, but today it just sounds like pandering or virtue signaling on social media. "I'll just throw out a #savethechildren and there, i've done my part." Obviously that is reductive, and I know Marvin was a sensitive soul that did actually care about people and has done a lot of good through his music, but I just wanted a bit more from these songs.

The great songs on here are among the best ever. What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues. Man, how appropriate for our times today, too.

Stone classic

Stunningly gorgeous. Need to revisit more often. RYM: Y (#44) Saved a song: Y

Amazing album, felt immediately moved from the first track. Powerful and way ahead of it's time. 9.5/10. Only wish it had more songs to listen to.

In za zaključek tedna, Marvin Gaye! Dober teden. Tale album sm leta nazaj že poslušala, ampak se slabo spomnim. "What's Going On" - dober in še vedno relevanten. U, lep seamless prehod med drugim in tretjim komadom. In med tretjim in četrtim. In še tako naprej. Najs. (Taka napol distopična misel, ampak kokr k najdeš youtube kanal, kjer nekdo vrti plošče neke pol ure in ni nobenih reklam.) "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)" mi je mogoč pikico ljubši k prvi komad. In to zaključi prvo polovico albuma. Drugi komad ( "What's Happening Brother") mogoč mal preveč spominja na prvega in nasplošno je mogoč celo preveč tight celotna kohezija albuma. Sicer pa, čudovit album.

The quintessential soul album that perfectly captures the human condition with such sincerity that its hard to believe any other album will ever come close

Respect, but not my cuppa tea.

better than i expected

This album features some of the best songs ever recorded.

As pertinent today as it was when it was first released.

Listened to it on repeat SEVERAL times because I got a bit distracted lol. Kind of preachy but I liked it.

I like this because it feels different from this list.

Main track good but the rest is a dirge.

Felt like listening to a gospel album and not in a good way, has some good songs on it. Marvin is also a really good singer

Yes, of course, obviously.

listened to this before feels good 9/10 2026/1/24

I feel like this was the first album in a minute that I've really enjoyed like in at least a week. I was still exhausted when I listened, but there's such a warm and inviting tone to the album that really just feels very comfortable. Favorites: Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky), Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

"What's Going On" is one of the all-time great songs. The background chatter makes it feel like you've walked into an ongoing conversation at a party. There's sax, bass, soul, jazz, and even scatting building up a pretty vibrant blend of sound. But it's the shifts just after the chorus that really define the song. These jazz-fuelled diversions pull the music slightly off balance, like a musical representation of the turmoil on the streets at the time, the civil unrest that begged the question what's going on? It's a testament to this song, and equally depressing, that the lyrics work so well when applied to the goings on of today still. The whole album is centered around the title track, intentionally so. It's apparently soul music's first concept album, with each song flowing into the next, with a singular lyrical and musical vision throughout. The musical themes of the title song echo through "Mercy Mercy Me" and "Inner City Blues" (coincidentally the other two standout tracks on the record). Rolling Stone have named this as the best album of all time. I wouldn't go that far. A lot of the songs here don't really stand up too well on their own. But as a complete piece, those weaker songs work to supplement and build the impact of the title track and the themes that it introduced. It all comes together to create a politically charged piece, that (unfortunately) is still very relevant today.

I understand its relevance and importance, but unfortunately it does nothing for me musically

Very jazzy and chill but overall a 7.5/10

Didn’t finish. I get it, it’s just not for me.

Sounds like an easy Saturday afternoon - Soul and comfort

1. What's Going On - 10 Such a great track. Gaye's vocals are so smooth on the track and the instrumentals are just in perfect harmony with each other. It's all so subtle to allow Gaye to increase the tone and intensity of the lyrics when needed. Brilliant track. 2. What's Happening Brother - 8 Love the line about the ball club winning the pennant in on this track. Lyrically it's really good. Instrumentally it's right in line with What's Going On. Fun track. 3. Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) - 5 I'm not as big a fan of this track as the others. It's very mellow but the whole track just feels like a bridge between What's Happening Brother and Save The Children. 4. Save The Children - 3 Listen I love the message but the track is just not great. It's speaking and singing and the tempo, pace, and pitch change too much to really get into the groove of enjoying the song. 5. God Is Love - 9 Great song. Great message, great lyrics, great instrumentals. It is a little bit like an interlude, especially give its short length, but its so enjoyable. 6. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - 4 Instrumentally it's good but it is quite a filler/pass over track. It's just too simple and not really in line with how great the rest of the album has been so far. 7. Right On - 7 Great soul track. Instrumentally it's brilliant. Lyrically it's very strong in the opening part verse or two. The last about three minutes where it changes tone I didn't enjoy as much, but overall it's a fantastic track. 8. Wholy Holy - 2 It's not really a great track. Very spritiual and religious track but lyrically it's not as good as anything else on the album and the fun instrumentals are gone for a more melancholy taste that doesn't strike a great sense of rousing enjoyment. 9. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - 8 Classic Marvin Gaye. This is exactly the kind of track you come to an album like this for. Absolutely awesome listen. Average Rating: 6.22 Adjusted to 5-Point Scale: 3.11 Rounded Down: 3 Stars

It's remarkable how songs retain their relevance in 2026 as they did 50 years ago. Some great songs - with an edge of challenge to them. Enjoyed listening to this.

5/5⭐️

I LOVEEEE I LOVEEE I LOVE I LOVE I LOVE

Good, chilled out vibe.

What's going on? So much. Vietnam, violent racism, riots on campuses, police shootings, a government attacking it's own people. So still relevant? Also edge of 70's big strings and whacky show tune key changes, soaring backup voices, those congas! killer songs, lush sound all around, the weirdest spoken call and sung response with himself, and Marvin soft, urgent gorgeous voice pleading for peace. I didn't realize this was a concept album, soldier returning from the war and looking around at what America's become since he left. Amazing artist, Marvin went through a lot and produced a lot of great music in a short life, the Jesus and God part was an arrival for him, but if it's a bit much (it is for me), check his great Let's Get It On from 1973, full-on 70's Soul, his spiritual call for Peace and Love becomes a spiritual call for Sex and Love, less Jesus, more sexual healing. Mercy.

This is such a heartfelt, soulful album with a great groove throughout. Marvin's voice is 👌 The songs segue into one another nicely too, making it feel like one 35-minute-long musical experience. My top song on the album is Wholy Holy. It's so peaceful.

I’m a sucker for soul music. It’s a pretty failsafe genre (imo) for a chill evening. Cleaning the kitchen up after dinner or cooking always pairs well with soul. I’m not sure it is a relief or sad that the lyrics of this album talk about how the world is dying physically and emotionally. With the hatred, and suffering of people. As well as, fish being poisoned with mercury, radiation in the sky, etc. Since this album was recorded in the early 70s and it still rings true today. Marvin Gaye is trying to find ways to make people care about the world and each other. Yet nothing seems to have changed. Does this mean that the world is not doomed and it just always feels that way to some extent? Accepting that no matter what timeline you live in. There always seems to be some sort of atrocities happening. Maybe the world just needed Marvin Gaye to stick around on this planet a little bit longer RIP. Maybe the world just needs more soul.

This was such a smooth album

Marvin got groove, but also talks about Jesus a bit too much... Just let me enjoy the tunes man, save it for Sunday. I could see this one growing on me over time though though, some of the instrumental sections were tight.

Pues en general bien, no es mi estilo, pero no me desagrado en ningún momento, al contrario, creo que el instrumental me hizo adentrarme

beautiful but edgy

I'm not musical, so I can only speak to the vibes, which this album has. Enjoyed the smoothness of the songs.

Beetje saai. Wel mooi opzich. Te goddelijk

Truelly a great album, it's hard to think of a better one

Honestly, 3 great tunes and the rest just riding on vibes. Thought this was going to be a slam dunk 5 but ended up middle of the road 4

me gustaron los sonidos y creo que es evidente q tiene una temática… algunas veces no distinguí el cambio d canción estuvo bien pero no me encantó

one of my favorites

This entire album feels like one continues amazing song. Such a vibe.

Probably it would be three on first listen but i think i would really like it if i listened again for some time. Also love the intro and the unusual percussions

Wait this was an album of different songs? It all blended together.

amazing listen from start to finish

Habe ich 2005 als Gratisbeilage der Samstagszeitung bekommen.

Man kennt "Whats Going on" und denkt, das könnte ja ein gutes Album werden. Und dann muss man sich anstrengen nicht einzuschlafen.

This album made me feel like I was flying

very nice. album that flows, didnt know when songs were changing. beautiful

Groovy, lovely.

Not what I expected, but again, was pleasantly surprised. A lot softer than I thought.

Couple of classic songs that deserve the praise but a the rest doesn't grab my attention. Owned the album for probably 30 years and listened to it a maybe a handful of times.

also listened to this on my personal 1001 list. banger.

Probably the most sonically cohesive album I’ve listened to so far with this, but this album didn’t really get any emotional response out of me so I can’t give it any higher than a 4

This album is incredible. I feel so much soul and groove from marvin's voice and instrumentals. wow. Loved the first track, what a great start to the album! The use of strings, saxaphone, flutes throughout this album in contrast with these chord progressions scratch an itch in my brain. it just works.

Marvin Gaye has a phenomenal voice and it’s so cool how all the songs flow into each other in the album. Favorite song was What’s Going On and What’s Happening Brother was a close second.

A lot of enjoyable tracks.

This was the vibe, ohhh I loved it

lo escucharía más a menudo si donde vivo lloviese pero estamos a riesgo de sequia asi que no

vibey, good album. i listen with the overlay thing where the songs overlap for a couple seconds or whatever and this is one of the best albumbs i've listened to with that. like, save the children into god is love??? crazy favorite song: flyin' high

not bad just not for me

4.499999/5 stars

Nice and beautiful album of one of the greatest soul musicians.

This album never gets old and is part of the fabric of the American social justice moevement to this day. Gaye's words have the same impact and message today as they did when he released the album,

That was a great album, my only disappointment is its length and possibly the lack of a standalone hit. But as far as album criteria goes, it flows together seamlessly from track to track. It's by a GOAT artist of the Motown Soul genre. After reading the Wikipedia, I can see and agree with how highly this album ranks on many lists. Right On hits a good spot for me, it's so groovy.

2/5, great album but really not my thing.. enjoyed the title track What's Going On, as well as Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Not my thing, but I see how people would like him! Very vibey music

Certified classic. Marvin Gaye is the man. No notes

Smooth as hell

Favorite song on the album is Inner city Blues. There’s a reason it’s considered a classic. Powerful messages but delivered gently with vocals. Other favorite tracks: what’s going on, mercy mercy me, and right on.

Fantastic album, i stone cold classic

I mean what can you say that hasn't already been said about this? Beautiful, soulful, poignant. A masterpiece of an album.

Soulful and full of life. Great lyrics with regards of the situation of black people and social issues that make their mark even today. It flows so well and it keeps you hooked from start to finish. 100% recommended.

Kinda boring not gonna lie sorry Mr. Gaye. Also a lot of love and god in these songs so loses a star cause of that too.

Beautiful album. I love how it all blends together. Marvin Gaye was ahead of his time. Will definitely be going back to this one.

Muito bom

ima prelep glas, sviđa mi se kako gradi melodije i harmonije instrumenti, i produkcija generalno, super zvuče ovaj žanr, neki soul/r&b, je uvek lep za slušanje, opusti me prosto peva, koliko sam pokupila, o svetu i ljudima i društvu i to je lepa promena, za mene barem sviđa mi se kako skoro svaka pesma prelazi u drugu skoro neprimetno u right on u desnom uvu mi drka neki kao narezani lenjir i to mi smeta ali sem toga nemam neke kritike omiljena pesma možda inner city blues? ne razlikuju se previše pesme pa nisam nešto pamtila po nazivima, ali mi je to skroz ok, ovo je više kao jedna pesma od pola sata nego album, sviđa mi se to

BEAUTIFUL. I thought it was well done for something of its time. It gave a funky groovy vibe which i enjoyed but at some moments it felt repetitive to me. Other than that, i most enjoyed save the children

a no skip album, the lyrics and intruments are just heavenly

Too drunk to comment

Classique, j’ai plus accordé d’importance aux paroles lors de cette réécoute et c’est un album tellement important

Incredible album ! Was blown away by the musicianship Marvin’s vocals are just gorgeous particularly on mercy mercy , what’s going on Right on They seem to dance beautifully around James Jamersons bass lines notably on the opener what’s going on Save the children had some great string section moments and Marvin displayed such emotion in his vocals The jam on the track right on I loved Some interesting chords kept me so interested in where the music was going next Will be giving this many more listens in the future

What's going on is I had a spicy goddamn burrito last night and was up all night with ring sting. I had the album on in the background in the living room but the songs were punctuated by my flaming asshole

From the first track that warm classic motown sound we've all grown to love wraps around you like a comforting weighted blanket, you can't help but be enveloped and sucked into the world of this album. Transitions like Save the Children into God is Love are seamless, I can imagine that this was groundbreaking stuff back in the day - it's as if the listening experience continues and it just keeps on going, really nice jamming to this. Every track has a richness of sound to it, each listen reveals something new - be it bongos panned quietly to the left, horn patterns at the right, a quiet piano, strings playing their own melody. Then into mercy mercy me, wow - this transition really makes you smile, from the brightness of god is love, including the bright bass tone and "harsher" quality of god is love - into mercy mercy me where the entire tonality drops down akin to a warm hug, dropping the bass into the background with a much warmer tone, letting the percussion with reverb take centre stage. Throughout, Marvin's vocal performances are next to none, it doesn't even seem like he did double tracking - his voice carries itself with little help required, the same can be said of Jamerson's bass riffs, the famous story of him even playing one of the songs drunk after being dragged from a bar to perform. Right on is a hypnotic jam, reminds me of a latin track with the percussion going on in the background, near the end of the track when it drops out for a few mins and the drums kick in crispier than fried chicken, how can you not smile?? A definite solid addition to my library I'll listen to again and again.

Album was really good. I had already heard the hits off this album growing up! I really like how the entire album blended together into one big song. Marvin’s voice is majestic as always.

Everything sounds the same. Is that the point?

What a way to start the album. Save the Children - love the effect of having the calls to action vocalised as an echo such an effective choice. As cohesive as albums get this is IT. There is an eerie sound that runs through all of the tracks it's calming but stands out making you pay attention to what he is actually saying. In a way I interpret it as a sound of hope - it is calms us but is so uncertain. The flow between tracks is so seamless when you recognise it changing I genuinely was like "what's going on". Fav song - What's Going On Overall 7.5/10

Sympa. À réécouter

1/8/26, 9:08 PM, Algebra 2 HW 1. What's Going On - 8/10: Really nice, soft, relaxing and smooth track. 2. What's Happening Brother - 7/10: Relatively similar to the first. 3. Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) - 6.7/10 - Forgettable, but still not bad. 4. Save the Children - 8.3 / 10 - Really like the talking in between singing. 5. God Is Love - Just an interlude, so too short to rate. Seems forgettable. 6. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - 6.5/10 : Forgettable, but easy on the ears. 7. Right On - 6/10 : Too long for me, sounds like the rest of the album. 8 Wholy Holy - 7/10 : Not bad track either, but sounds like the rest of the album. 9. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - 7/10 : I mean, it's not bad. It just sounds literally the same as everything else.

Me siento sacada de una romcom o una serie de los noventa,aunque el álbum se sienta un poco corto son puros temazos,pero que triste que lo mató su padre( Es un poco irónico por algunas partes de god is love).

I was originally going to wait to listen to this album more towards the winter time, but I have been in such a Marvin Gaye kinda groove now and I had to come back and gush about this album. The user score is underrating this album in my opinion, it is near perfect if not perfect, and I think this album should be necessary at all costs to listen to regardless of your taste. Marvin Gaye is a once in a billion artist and this album is a shining example of that statement. His charisma mixed with his signature silky smooth vocals makes this album such a heartfelt and deeply emotional connection to each and every person who listens to it. I really hope at some point in my musical journey I can delve into his entire discography, but for now I jump forward to this masterpiece. This album feels exactly like how it does to see snow outside your window as a kid mixed with some of the most impactful and harmonic lyrics. There is so much I can say but I would be retreading the same paths already gone over and over again, so I guess I will cut it here. If you haven't given yourself the blessing of hearing this album, stop what you are doing and turn it on, please?

Album No. 0119 on my list. I was really, really looking forward to finally listening to "What's Going On" by Marvin Gaye. I had only ever known the title track (which I thoroughly enjoy), but was aware that this is considered to be one of the greatest albums of all time. I had really high hopes and expectations to be honest... ... well, and I can't deny that I'm just a little bit disappointed, frankly. My love for the title track has certainly not decreased, but honestly, there was not much more going on on the album (lol). It's not bad - really not at all. The thing is groovy, sexy, somewhat political, and sounds pretty good. But I've really expected more to be honest. Groovier, sexier, more political. None of the tracks really stood out or was memorable (I've listened to the album three times now, and still...). I think I get why this album is considered to be important and why people like it, but I'm afraid it's not really my cup of tea. I really want to like it very much and I guess it would look good on my album wall, but I just don't love it I guess... I'm sorry! "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)", and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" will be added to my playlist. 3/5 stars.

4 just for the title track and Mercy Mercy Me. Rest of the album is good but not quite up to those singles

Герл я слушала

This just isn't a hateable album. I'm yet to find anyone that hears the name Marvin Gaye and says "I hate that guy." Hell, it's hard to find someone that dislikes his music. Half the time when his name is brought up the response is "He's a great songwriter, love his stuff." It's am amazingly relaxing listen more than anything, just something about those strings. The lyricism is amazing as well, backed up by one of the best voices in Soul. Marvin Gaye could sing a Terms of Service page and make it sound like prose. Lastly, of course, saxophone bonus points.

My main gripe with Soul Music is about singers "screaming" too much. I don't know why they need to sing high notes all the time but that's a torture to the soul 😉 But Marvin is a different story! Although being a political record Marvin' wonderful singing, melody and calmness makes this record delightful. Great album and a reminder to listen to Marvin more often.

Obviously the song "What's Going On" is a 10/10, but on average the songs are meh.

it was pretty good i had never heard of him before

Unbelievably good.

I really couldn't enjoy this.

What's Going On? Not a lot

5/5. A truly unique album from a man who epitomizes Soul. Everyone should give this at least a single listen. It is not amazing all the way through — some songs, especially those at the start, are comparably plain when set against the better songs. But those better songs are incredible. "Mercy Mercy Me" and "Inner City Blues" are legendary. Gaye is a wonderful singer the whole way through though, and the instrumentation is spectacular. The ominous choral backing and strings on some songs imbue them with an otherworldly quality. A joy to listen to.

Had heard of this artist in name only, and upon first listen soul music is not my typical style, but this was enjoyable enough. Upon second listen and closer review of the lyrics I was able to follow the narrative, but after 4-5 songs in a row around love/God it started to feel less interesting (as compared to the opening and closing tracks). Overall I recognize and appreciate the significance of this artist/album, the statements made, and was glad for the exposure.

Zuhause, Gerstetten, Deutschland. Ganz okay.

i listened to it once and thought, oh this is a bit disappointing all the songs sound the same.... then i listened to it again and suddenly i just GOT IT. like it's not perfect but there's something so raw and vulnerable about this, i can't really put it into words. i love music where the artist has an idea and just goes for it and maybe it succeeds and maybe it doesn't quite hit the mark in places but you can just feel what they're feeling. this is one of those albums. this is also maybe the worst review i've ever written because i literally cannot explain myself here hahaha. also his VOICE. oh my DAYSSS. marvin gaye could sing the dictionary at me and i'd be like omg 5 stars.

If I’m truthful, Marvin Gaye’s music has never been very interesting to me. It all kind of sounds the same, so I was excited to listen to this one because I’m determined to acquire a taste for it. I used to feel the same about Frank Ocean. I couldn’t really hear what made it unique until I listened to it a lot, and now he’s one of my favorite artists. I think this album was a good introduction; it’s short and sweet. His lyrics are genuine, hopeful, and call for peace- the accompaniment reflects that. Whatever instruments I’m hearing (flutes, strings etc.) create a really magical sound at times. He also just has a really soothing voice. This album brought to mind a few artists that I think may have been influenced by Marvin Gaye including the aforementioned Frank Ocean and Michael Kiwanuka. Fave tracks: What’s Going On, What’s Happening Brother, Right On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Too religious, a lot of the songs sounds exactly the same.

Chill stuff

Listened casually as I wrote and generally enjoyed!

Nice album not for me

A+ voice A+ band A+ writing A+ arrangements No skips, basically all highlights. Track order is very thoughtful. Really annoyed at myself for not listening to this earlier. Excellent album.

Come on.

One of my top favorite soul releases ever! If you can't feel the emotion Marvin is pouring out here, you must be dead.

7/10, enjoyable but not my deal

Sevemedim mlsf :(

Veel christelijke verwijzingen

This is a difficult one to rate. It’s considered by many to be one of the greatest albums of all time. It’s pretty great, yes, but it’s far from the best Soul album I’ve heard so far. I don’t know, I can see why people love it. The most important thing I can do here at this point is at least recognize its greatness, which I do. The singing voice is the big draw here, in my opinion. If we’re talking about voice alone, it’s a 5. Damn, this man can sing beautifully, and does. Everything else is pretty good too, but after about 10 minutes you’ve really got the gist of the entire album already. It all starts sounding the exact same song to song and you don’t even know which song you’re on at parts. It’s great as a whole, and I can see why people consider this so good, but I can’t say I’d personally return to it, which is ok. My favorite song on this one is the titular opener, “What’s Going On”. This is the first of 3 Marvin Gaye albums I have rolled for this project, and I’m going to guess prematurely that if I gave this one a 3, they’re all likely to end up getting 3’s as well. I get the striking suspicion that the important messages this album provide are better than the music itself. Not a bad thing, just an observation. The themes are all moving and powerful, that much is true, but a lot of the music itself is forgettable and even a tad repetitive. It’s not really for me but I definitely respect it, and I would happily listen to it again if it came up naturally.

Album’s best : TOUT je suis choqué bordel

Nicht besonders eindrücklich

Heavenly!

Not that long ago that I reviewed "Here My Dear" which showcased Marvin at his lowest. Here he is at his best, conveying (on record, at least) empathy for the world around him in a way that's beautifully and touchingly expressive. This is a record that sounds important to Marvin and undoubtedly was, in that he had to fight for it against the wishes of his company. Topics arrange from pleas for understanding of the plight of black people ("What's Going On"), returning Vietnam vets ("What's Happening Brother"), drug users including himself ("Flyin' High"), the future ("Save The Children") religion ("God Is Love"), the environment ("Mercy Mercy Me"), empathy ("Right On"), unity ("Wholy Holy"), and the ghetto ("Inner City Blues"). This is a lot for one album to tackle in 35 minutes! The actual tackling of subjects ranges from very well-articulated treatises to scattershot musings, but more important is the delivery. Marvin's voice could melt butter and never leaves anything feel anything less than earnest, and it's surrounded with a luscious, shifting soundscape that continues from track to track, making the album feel like an extended suite. As much as any album, this deserves to be heard as a single piece. If you read any of my other reviews, you'll see that I'm not a fan of maudlin or overly-sentimental material, but I am a fan of earnestly-expressed emotion that is delivered in a compelling way, and in that regard there's nothing that measures up to What's Going On.

Hm, let's see what's up next... Marvin Gaye! I don't know much Marvin Gaye, let me think... "Let's Get It On", "Sexual Healing"... Ah, so this is gonna be a sultry, sexy album. ~35 excellent minutes later~ Okay, I wasn't expecting anything so deep and political... and I *certainly* wasn't expecting so much about God and Jesus. Had no idea Marvin Gaye contained so many multitudes. Not to mention the excellent production, and the connected 'song cycle' nature of the album... It's a fantastic album that really showcases and champions the album as an artform.

The rest of the album couldn't live up to the title track. Good listen just expected more.

Marvin’s got the vibes.

167/1089 such a stunning opening/title track. His voice is so rich and smooth, accompanied by some complex and deep production/instrumentation. The album as a whole was pretty good and enjoyable but didn’t quite hold up to the first track for the full time imo Mercy Mercy Me and What’s Happening Brother were my other faves 69/100

Suitable for; reading; sleeping; working; drinking wine and chatting.

First few seconds of the first song 'What's going on' my first thought was: not for me. BUT WOAH it switched up. On the third song right now and it's got a really nice flow. Fucking love these instruments too and his voice too like DAMN. Still the instruments are so whimsical. Very chill album and I will definitely save this to listen to it again.

**Marvin Gaye – *What’s Going On* (1971)** In-depth review: lyrics, music, production, themes, influence, pros & cons --- ### 1. LYRICS – Conversations with America - **Voice of a Vietnam vet**: Every song is spoken by a returning Black soldier who finds his country still ravaged by racism, poverty, police brutality and ecological decay. - **Conversational tone**: “Mother, mother / There’s too many of you crying… Father, father / We don’t need to escalate” – Gaye addresses his family, his community and authority figures in the same breath, collapsing the political into the personal. - **Poetic devices**: Heavy use of anaphora, rhetorical questions, internal rhyme and repetition (“What’s going on… what’s going on…”) that make the words feel spoken-sung, almost sermon-like. - **No question mark**: The album title omits the “?”, signalling that Gaye is not asking for an explanation—he is *telling* us what is happening. - **Scope**: Anti-war, anti-brutality, anti-drug, pro-ecology, pro-love; yet never slogan-heavy. The absence of explicit party politics lets the songs age gracefully. --- ### 2. MUSIC – Jazz-soul suite - **Key signatures**: Mostly mellow F-major / D-minor grooves that feel like one long continuous suite. - **Groove science**: James Jamerson (bass) recorded most of his parts flat on his back with a bottle of gin—yet laid down sliding, syncopated lines that became textbook funk. - **Rhythm-section colors**: – Double-layered congas, shaker and triangle mixed *wide* in stereo field. – “Micro-percussion” (finger snaps, soft knocks on wood) creates a living-room ambience. - **Orchestral glaze**: Detroit Symphony strings arranged in long, non-vibrato pads—more Gil Evans than Motown. - **Saxophone as narrator**: Eli Fontaine’s smoky alto opens the title track; its phrases are *quoted* later by Gaye’s multi-tracked background vocals, blurring instrumental and human voices. - **Seamless segues**: Tape loops of city traffic, party chatter and rainfall knit tracks together; the final groove (“Inner City Blues”) mechanically *locks* back into the intro of “What’s Going On”, making the LP an infinite loop. --- ### 3. PRODUCTION – The first self-produced Motown record - **55 musicians, 10 days**: Cut live at Hitsville U.S.A. with only a 4-track recorder; Gaye bounced sub-mixes to free tracks, creating subliminal “ghost” layers. - **DIY overdubs**: Gaye plays piano, Mellotron, box drum and all multi-layered background vocals himself—unheard-of autonomy for a Motown artist at the time. - **Spatial mixing**: Drums dead-center, bass slightly left, strings hard-left/right; Gaye’s lead vocal *floats* 10 % off-center, giving the impression he is standing in the doorway between channels. - **Innovations**: – First R&B LP to use EMT plate reverb on *congas*—gives bongos a singing sustain. – Early use of tape-speed manipulation: final chorus of “Mercy Mercy Me” is +3 % faster than the take, adding subconscious urgency. --- ### 4. THEMES – A spiritual State-of-the-Union | Issue | Lyrical Moment | Musical Mirror | |---|---|---| | Vietnam | “Brother, brother, there’s far too many of you dying” | Military snare flams tucked low in mix | | Police brutality | “Don’t punish me with brutality—talk to me” | Bass line *descends* (feels like hands thrown up) | | Urban decay | “Rockets, moon shots / spend it on the have-nots” | Pocketed 7/4 bar slips the groove, mirroring social disorientation | | Ecology | “Oil wasted on the oceans and upon our seas” | Single sustained Hammond chord = toxic haze | | Spiritual plea | “Wholy holy—don’t you know we can make it happen” | Wordless 10-voice gospel cluster drifts in | --- ### 5. INFLUENCE – The template for conscious pop - **Immediate**: Stevie Wonder demanded (and won) full creative control a year later; Earth, Wind & Fire, Curtis Mayfield, and later Donny Hathaway all adopted the “social-suite” format. - **70-80s rock**: Paul Simon cites the LP as the spark for *Graceland*; Pink Floyd studied its tape-loop transitions while making *Dark Side of the Moon*. - **Hip-hop & neo-soul**: Sample source for 2Pac (“Thugz Mansion”), Kanye (“Otis”), Alicia Keys, Common; Janet Jackson loops “Inner City Blues” on her *Velvet Rope* interludes. - **Canonisation**: Rolling Stone #1 on 2020 “500 Greatest Albums”; U.S. Library of Congress National Recording Registry. - **Activist soundtrack**: BLM marches 2020 blasted “What’s Going On” in 30+ U.S. cities—lyrics still tweet-length relevant. --- ### 6. PROS & CONS (even masterpieces cast shadows) | PROS | CONS | |---|---| | 1. Seamless song-cycle flow—rarely duplicated. | 1. Uniform tempo / key can feel monotonous on Side One. | | 2. Lyrics still headline-news relevant 50+ yrs later. | 2. Jam-session sections (“Right On”, “Wholy Holy”) meander—some listeners find them formless. | | 3. Jamerson’s bass lines alone are a university course. | 3. Sparse melodic variation—hooks recycle the same pentatonic cells. | | 4. Production innovations (quad-ready stereo, tape loops) ahead of 1971 curve. | 4. Sparse melodic variation—hooks recycle the same pentatonic cells. | | 5. Opened Motown’s creative floodgates; without it no *Innervisions*, no *Songs in the Key of Life*. | 5. Over-romanticised “vets’ POV” concept—only 2-3 songs explicitly reference Vietnam. | --- ### 7. BOTTOM LINE *What’s Going On* is less a collection of songs than a 35-minute meditation—an album that dissolved the border between personal heartbreak and civic heartbreak. Its mellow surface invites you in; its layered poetry keeps you returning every time the nightly news matches a 1971 headline. Flawed? Slightly—side-two jams can dawdle, and sonic sameness risks hypnosis. Yet those “flaws” are also the reason it feels like one continuous breath rather than a playlist. Marvin Gaye proved that social protest could wear a velvet glove, and popular music has been trying to duplicate that balancing act ever since. > “Love, baby—love. That’s the only way.” > – Marvin Gaye, 1971

Well as ive heard from the entire world this should be a slam dunk and to me its good but its not perfect. And that shocked me a bit. This is always lauded as one of the best records of all time. And everything here is very good but only the big ones grab me. The title track, mercy me, and inner city blues got me. And the funny thing is looking at the most listened songs on his page its these 3. Im basic as hell I guess. The other songs are all good too just not that noteworthy to me at least. And thats just kinda disappointing. Thats the undertones of the record as a whole for me. It should get me much more than it does. Not that the 4 is a bad look but still has a bad feeling about it

Smooth and smooth say listening

Jajajajja Kan de hele dag aanstaan! En ook nice, de radio die erna komt poahhhh een en al sfeer

За последнее время я полюбил соул.

Première écoute de ce classique, le son est très semblable à l'idée que je m'en était fait. C'est agréable à écouter, une musique toujours jazz et parfois funk.

A great album to get in the mood for NYE

This album is an absolute masterpiece, and imo the most cohesive, successful concept album. The weight of what this album holds is just extraordinary. It of course needs to be placed in the context of the tumultuous time in which it was written - I time of deep challenges and conflicts. The Vietnam War, fights for equality on many fronts, awakening to environmental catastrophe, cultural/generational divides, income inequality, a fast-shifting economy. And Marvin Gaye is feeling this on profound levels, and shares with us the ways he is processing and confronting this politically, socially, and spiritually. The music is unsurprisingly fantastic - his miraculous voice, exceptional musicianship, and a flowing, cohesive musical journey from the beginning of the album to the end. I appreciated the repetition of musical motifs tying things together as well. And overall the depth of feeling is so palpable - the range of emotion (despondent to angry to hopeful) is so relatable. I appreciate, too, that the album is both universal and also so clearly speaks to the Black American experience at the time. A work of artistic genius and musical greatness.

Impecável 4/5 estrelas Destaque para a percussão de Right On

"War is not the answer, for only love can conquer hate" - What's going on. "War is hell, when will it end? When will people start getting together again ?" - What's happening brother "Self destructions in my hand" - Flying high (in the friendly sky) "And if you want to love, you've got to save the babies" - Save the children "And all He asks of us (peace) is we give each other love" - God is love "What about this overcrowded land, how much more abuse from man can she stand?" - Mercy mercy me (The Ecology) "Oh, true love can conquer hate every time, give out some love and you'' find peace sublime" - Right on "People we all got to come together because we need the strength, power all the feeling" - Wholly holy "Who are they to judge us simply because we wear our hair long" - Inner city blues (makes me wanna holler) 5/5 album. The themes throughout this album are captured so beautifully, from the struggles of addiction, to the price of war but ultimately how we all need to love each other is just 10/10, no notes.

2.5/5 This albums would work more as an instrumental album than what it was released as. I didn't enjoy what Marvin Gaye's lyrics brought to the table. I did not enjoy Wholy Holy, Save The Children, and Right On. I disliked how he would sing whatever words after he was narrating. The soundscape and the vibe are what i enjoyed most about What's Going On. It didn't click for me as it did for others.

It's funny, because just recently I saw a Spotify playlist called "Marvin Gaye's clueless ass" with song titles asking questions including the first two here. ("What's Going On" and "What's Happening Brother") Old Soul, R&B, is not something that normally appeals to me, but this is good stuff. Very evocative of the times and yet timeless. It's easy-going but in a pleasant way.

That's the genius shit. Dead at 45, as terrible a loss as Lennon. Fucking guns. "With the world exploding around me, how am I supposed to keep singing love songs?"

I like it a bit, don't like the christianity in it, some songs are reallyyy good though so 6/10, might change my mind though I'm very subjective

gezellig, groovy, happy

Инструментал Right on🤌🤌имбища Хороший, но я б 4,5 поставила из-за некоторых песен.

what a hopeful album. also his voice? damn

This album feels like listening to a preacher but ironically enough you don’t want to leave cuz you’re actually intrigued but whatever he’s saying so you keep listening you’re trying to figure out why the way he talks makes you oscillating between states you feel now joy and happiness but after you fall into despair and anguish towards the world you stay till the end but when you leave you find yourself thinking about what he meant when he said a place when love is king

Nice and relaxing to listen to whilst recovering from a hectic Christmas. Really enjoyed this one

100% solid gold Soul classic! If the lyrical content was studied on every national curriculum we might have a better world some day. Probably the best ’concept’ album ever recorded.

I want to be the sort of guy who loves Marvin Gaye, but every time I listen to anything beyond one of his timeless classic, mega-hit songs, I’m just bored, even as he’s trying to preach important messages that he clearly feels passionately. “Save the Children” is a tedious drag. “God Is Love” feels completely empty. The musicianship here is incredible. The horns, the drums, the bass guitar (oh my GOD the bass guitar!), and of course the voice. It’s all great, it all melds incredibly well…and I’m just not that into it.

Fa cara d'àlbum que no m'escoltaria, d'aquests així massa calmats pel meu gust. Me l'he escoltat una vegada sencer i no m'acaba de fer el pes, li poso un 2.

Bueno, pero la diferencia entre What's Going On y el resto de canciones es muy grande

Good stuff

I liked the overall vibes in this one.

A true soul masterpiece and by far his best album. I know it's on everyone's best ever list. I like the album a lot, but I don't think it's the best album ever recorded. But it's definitely worth 5 stars. It is the bar that is set for what a soul record should be.

Not as good as hunky dory, not really my jam.

Whats going on...that's the question. Sadly I can't answer cause this wasn't for me...I did however love Flyin High and right on! Fav tracks: 1. Flyin High (what a voice) 2. Right on 3. What's going on HM: Mercy Mercy me 4/10

I love this guy's voice. It is soulful and creates a mood beautifully. The album made a great soundtrack to the post Christmas recovery in our house.

I enjoyed the lyrical composition of the album. I enjoyed the conversation surrounding social injustices and having a relationship with God. Overall I enjoyed the instrumentals, but felt the album was a bit "one note"

I wanted to give it higher, but the overtly religious tones in the middle were rough, and it just really falls flat at the end of the album. Can't go higher than 3 stars, and most of that is coming from the title track.

Impactful.

This is a good album. Very refreshing to hear a full album lacking any romantic love songs. Four stars. (Favorite track: What's Going On.)

A classic, but not quite an all-time listen for me

nice music

My soul left my body 5/5⭐️

Very nice songs😽 Really like them because they're sometimes relaxed but also catchy at the same time 🙏🏼 Jazz like (I don't really know😔)

Really enjoyed this, his voice, the melodies, how compact the album was. On the surface level it's easy listening but the lyrics are so moving.

musik that twoja stara listens to

Still pretty solid! Much like his other album (Let's Get It On), I can tell it's pretty good, but it's just not really my style of music.

SOUL. There's no genre quite like it, and Marvin Gaye delivers on its promise in spades.

Smooth as hell, definitely no *bad* songs, and a good album overall, but I just do not understand its ranking as the best album of all time. Right On, however, is an awesome song.

This is perfectly fine. The transitions between songs are a joy, and you can't get much smoother than Marvin Gaye on the mic, but musically it does very little for me. Personally, I'm learning I prefer my Soul with a bit more Funk. I frankly don’t see what gets this to "best album of all time" status for so many. Countless 5* reviews on here bring up Marvin's social commentary as the key to its importance, and one even describes it as 'visceral' -- in its release context, sure, but it feels way overstated for what I'm hearing today. I respect Gaye's message immensely, but it just doesn’t land with the same punch on a fresh listen, and as a result I do not see the timelessness others see in it. I realize that, by writing this, I'll have to respect the opinion of someone saying the same about To Pimp a Butterfly in 50 years' time. I'll have to live with that. Let’s Get It On remains my favorite Marvin project. Standouts: What's Going On • Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) • Right On • Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)

Perfectly cromulent album that is pretty good with some highlights here and there but definitely not the best album of all time. Stevie Wonder did more interesting social commentary during this period imo.

This is a great album. I love the loose feel of the playing and wow, can Marvin sing! The political themes are (sadly) even more relevant today. He'd still be asking what's going on if he were around today.

marvin gaye my goat

3.5. Nothing special

What's Going On: 5/5 What's Happening Brother: 5/5 Flyin' High(In the Friendly Sky): 5/5 Save the Children: 5/5 God is Love: 5/5 Mercy Mercy Me(The Ecology): 5/5 Right On: 5/5 Wholy Holy: 4.5/5 Inner City Blues(Makes Me Wanna Holler): 5/5 Verdict: 5/5. Holy shit.

One of the best albums in existence