Reviews (page 4 of 12)
Summer in the freezing Sask winter.
Oh mama, que maravilla
How do you express this much existential dread, frustration, confusion, and powerlessness in the face of an increasingly volatile and bizarre world, when so much love has been stripped away from you? Gaye was still reeling over the death of his closest friend, duet collaborator Tammi Terrell from a brain cancer rumored to be spurred from domestic violence. He'd never actually stop reeling from that lose for the rest of his life and in 1971, this album captures this man staring into the abyss. Known for the more universally-palettable Motown love songs of the 60's, this would forever be a turning point for Gaye. Sonically the backing band of the Funk Brothers keeps him working through his pain with lush grooves. These groove are frequently punctuated by spacious dropoffs supported by pensive orchestral strings, allowing Gaye to soulfully ponder the deeper questions. All this to be said, my favorite part of this album is my favorite part of a lot of Motown albums: James Jamerson. Between him on 5 tracks and Funk Brothers bassist Bob Babbitt on 4 others, there is iconic bassline after iconic bassline on this album. I can just focus on the low end of this entire runtime and just swim in it. I read that Jamerson was pulled in from a bar blackout drunk for the title track, which he recorded on the floor, and testament to his talent, still sounds like a million bucks. With so much tragedy and trauma in these artists' lives, they sure knew how to make the most of it when the tapes are rolling. Fortunately for us, we have records like this to turn to when the world is spinning as fast as the room was for Jamerson on that bass track.
So good it makes me want to holler (though in a conscious fashion). He does human sexuality and social commentary equally well. As with Let’s Get It On, the mood and tone are sustained throughout to great effect – with some songs seeming slight but meaningful variations of the one before – and the voice goes high, higher, highest, with lovely modulations to make or emphasize a point. Three full-on classics (title cut, “Mercy Mercy Me” and “Inner City Blues”). The thoughtful music suits the seriousness of content, though there are plenty of smiles to be had and lovely touches all over the place (e.g., flute, vibes and sax on “Right On;” strings on “Wholly Holy”). Hard to believe Berry Gordy could have been so wrong about this record – and overlooked its most obvioius flaw, which is that it's far too short. 4.6 for 5
Masterpiece. What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues are classics 5/5
Bello, bello, sulla fiducia e rispetto all'altro suo ci do 5
Such a vibe. Funky and groovy, but also expressive and emotional. Really enjoyed this. Had me up and dancing. Love Marvin’s smooth, soulful voice. Also love the background harmonies/adlibs and jazzy instrumentals. Gospel energy. Meaningful lyrics.
Absolutely brilliant, start to finish.
Glorious from beginning to end. The bass playing alone is worth 5 stars. Yes, there's a little too much Jesus for my tastes. Yes, the middle part of side one (Save the Children) is a bit too earnest. But damn, the great songs are simply transcendent and the song cycle is so moving and majestic the way it ebbs and flows, I can't begrudge a few minor complaints. The dude had a vision and he executed it flawlessly with some of the greatest vocal performances of all time. Truly magical.
What an amazing album. Obviously, "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)", and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" are the major standouts and three all time Motown songs, but the songs between do so much to tell the story and build to the peaks that those songs bring. Beautiful, devastating, and as poignant as ever. Who really cares? Who's willing to try?
On of my favorite albums. Not much I can say about this album that hasn’t been said, I have no special memories attached to it or any significant moment when I first heard it, just an album that has blown me away every time I listen to it and it still does. Just perfect.
An awe inspiring album chock full of love and adoration for life. This albums tracks seamlessly lead into one another and the whole 36 minute long album is so impressive. Being a fan of hip hop, there are a ton of samples I've heard over the years taken directly from this album. Classic stuff. Easy 5/5.
uuuh i already knew this was gon' be a good one.. but daaamn the voice. & my mood was such that I could take his heartfelt, somewhat cliché lyrics seriously. but didnt realize before how good of a songwriter he was. d chords of "save the children" zb gheied gfühlt am aafang eifach continously abe. vlt quintezirkel-shenanigans 😅, aber sehr effektiv im unsettling sii.
A masterpiece!
Death, despair, destruction, an unresolved crisis of faith. Marvin Gaye's life had spiraled into the very depths of darkness by the early 70s, the most troublesome of decades that he'd live. His singing partner dead of a brain tumor and his clean cut image wrapped too tightly by the Motown machine, he had broken down and began to harbor hopes of being a Detroit Lion. But common sense and letters home from his war-hardened brother in Vietnam reinforced Marvin's place in music and what came forth, bit by earnest bit, was one of the most revolutionary albums ever made. For What's Going On not only put a spotlight on the litany of ills that was doing damage on Earth, it also put on the map ecological issues that was just beginning to make headway at the time. Over the ensuing decades, What's Going On's relevance has strengthened in the face of difficult days as Marvin would transform from crooner to chronicler to fallen icon. One listen, or many other listens, would make the listener understand why this is as highly heralded as it is.
Here are just some of the things that, on their own, would make this album worth 5 stars: - The piano glissando between the end of God is Love and Mercy Mercy Me. - The successful deployment of the word 'inflation' in a song lyric. - The right kind of unironicness. - The fact he can make you cry by simply asking "Tell me friend, how in the world have you been?" - The menace. - The prescience. - The love.
One of the greatest albums of all time. Each song is eerily relevant to the times we're currently living in. Continues to be a balm for the mind & body in the heaviness of today's world. Like all profound works of art, it transcends time & space.
Just a great listen, the way songs segue into one another makes this a great sit down and listen from start to finish record. His voice is sensational.
This is an album where I can remember exactly where I was and what I was doing when I heard it for the first time. It's a classic for a reason, an album with perfect flow, gorgeous instrumentation, and of course Marvin's silky voice. It's easy to listen to on repeat, with themes that remain relevant, then, now, and maybe always: "Picket lines and picket signs /Don't punish me with brutality / Come on talk to me / So you can see /What's going on"
That this album remains at least as relevant now as when it was written is maybe an indictment of our times but it was and still is a masterpiece.
Up there with the best vibes ever recorded.
Amazing album. So many memorable songs.
Basically a masterpiece, this album was phenomenal.
Incredible album. The production is so incredible, the whole album sounds ethereal and other-worldly; just beautiful. An easy 5 stars.
Spectacular. Not the greatest album of all time like Rolling Stone thinks but its simply wonderful Best Song: Mercy Mercy Rating: 9.0/10 5 Stars
10/10
Favorite song is still Flyin’ high.
Brilliant blend of soul and message. Everyone should listen to this hopeful music. Gaye is one of the best soul singers ever, and this collection of songs is amazing.
One of the greatest albums ever produced.
Been awhile since I listened to this album as a whole. Forgot how he tossed away the love songs to do a whole album with important messages with this one. Such a fantastic concept album that should not be missed. Saw some reviews claim there are only 2 good songs, and what baffling statements
Marvin the fucking Grayet! Was mit mir on gaht isch, dass ich das Juwel vo Album es ganzes Wuchenend vo vorne bis hine, vo hine bis füre und vo obe bis une (und biz vo links nach rechts) wie e sanfti salbi us glücksgfühl und schönheit a mis trummelfell und um mini ghörknöchli gstriche, dezue min Hammer, Amboss und Steigbügel mit de sanfte Stimm vom Marvin und de tolle instrument massiert, und gliichziitig mis Mittelohr mit de Sentimentalität vo sine lieder kräbelet han. O boy o boy o boy, a freaking lot is going on! What's going denn mit dir on Marv? 10 vo 10, 5 vo 5, 13 vo 13 und 319 vo 319 für de Marvin Goat
oh oh folks, it's happening... eigentli chönt mer meine ich müessti vorbereitet si für de moment will das isch das album wo ich mich am meiste druf gfreut han… dass es aber so früeh chund hani nöd erwartet und mir fehled daher chli d'wort anyways… keis vo mir gschribnigs review wird dem meisterwerk eh chönne grecht werde drum da eifach es sammelsurium vo mine gedanke über s'objektiv betrachtete beschte album aller ziite: revolutionärs konzept, thematischi inhält wo über 50 jahr spöter immerno krass relevant sind, sehr schöns storytelling, ikonischs album cover, und mit de musikalische superlativ muessi glaub erst gar nöd ahfange… ich wünschti das wär s'erste album woni jemals glost han, ich wünschti das wird s'letschte album woni jemals wird lose
A truly flawless album. One of the best works of art ever made.
🙌🙌🙌
One of the best of all time - and I'm only 3 albums in. Dreamlike, gospel, of the times.
never listened to this all the way through; so beautiful, well produced, poignant, and maaaaan marvin gaye voice. yup
“Divided Soul” is still one of the best books I’ve ever read. A life with the most extreme highs and lows. Quietly, the classic tortured/genius artist. Totally reflected here.
A timeless classic. Hard to think of an album which deals with themes of poverty and war so effectively. A shimmering window into the psyche of 70s America on the street - almost makes you feel like you're at an anti Vietnam War protest. I'll never get tired of listening to it. (Shout-out to Mum for first playing it to me!)
Good rainy day music
Otherworldly
Shockingly, an album I only know a couple tracks from. Excited to dig in. Holy shit, what an album. Didn’t talk lose the whole thing was such a protest anthem. Super relevant today. And the way the first several tracks blend together is wild. Felt like one big song in a great way. Also never really realized how great his voice is. Listening to Save the Children while feeding my 10 week old baby was powerful stuff.
Everyone knows "What's going on", but I was surprised by " What's Happening Brother" being the following track title. At first I thought that was silly and redundant and got me thinking maybe I actually like the Let's Get it On album better. Further into the album I realized how smooth the transitions between songs are, then "Mercy Mercy Me" hit, and to quote the kids these days I was like nah this album is fire. The song cycle of this album is somehow even greater than the sum of the parts. It is done so well. His collar on the cover is legit, and this is a contender for an album I want on vinyl. I'm gonna go give it another listen now. Favorite track "Inner City Blues" 5/5
One my most listened to albums last year. Always relevant and always inspirational!
What's Groovin' On?
This is a classic album that spans generations. Even 50+ years ago people were already asking “what’s the matter with the world today?”. Marvin explores a myriad of complex social topics such as poverty, inner city struggles, faith, returning from war, addiction, and concern for future generations. 10/10 album that cannot be overhyped… it’s that good.
So damn smooth!
As a concept album just really worked for me.
Genius, an all time great album. It is a complete album, it is completely genius. 10
already heard . classic and beautiful - fav is whats happening brother
The atmosphere achieved by this album is nothing short of brilliant, especially considering its genre. No electronics or funky effects, just expert instrumentation and layering. The vocals are the more obvious stand out. His voice is smooth as butter, setting the standard for this type of music. Wonderful background vocals as well. So much emotion behind it. Great lyrics as well, political and unflinching, while also feeling personal and intimate. While it's obviously a seminal R&B record drawing from jazz and other historically African American genres, I feel a lot of influence in modern rap and hip hop. People like Kendrick Lamar must have listened to a lot of Marvin Gaye. A lot of the tracks flow right into each other, more of that jazzy influence that makes it feel like a cohesive story. I'm blown away by all of the different instruments. Stellar percussion. Moments where the strings, flute, sax, horns, get to stand out. And then his voice is an instrument in itself. It's a masterpiece, plain and simple.
So good I don't know if I need to listen to anything else ever again.
Had something cool written for this and I don't wanna write it again. This album is incredible.
This album is not overrated. It really might be one of the best albums ever made. A political statement that feels as relevant today as it was back then. The transitions between songs especially the one between God Is Love and Mercy Mercy Me are great.
An absolute classic. Non-stop bangers. He was taken from us much too soon.
God. Incredible. Album 226 and it might be my favorite one so far.
Beautiful, beautiful album, which I'd never heard all of before. I was working outside when I listened to this and just loved the whole flow of it. I found myself dancing throughout and singing along when classics I know like "Mercy, Mercy Me" came on. Listening closely, I really paid attention to the doubled vocals and what Marvin Gaye did to perform dueling lead melodies at times and deliver harmonies at others. This album just feels like one where everything all came together exactly the right way. And it just feels good to listen to.
pff. need i say more?
i think thats whats called music. so fucking good, smooth transitions, and that groove
Favorite track: what's going on other picks: what's happening brother, mercy mercy me, inner city blues
tremendously cohesively beautiful; pleasant albeit melancholy; a warm bath on a rainy day of a record
Lovely gospel-inflected groove and soul. I mean, how can you argue with a voice like Marvin's? Just let it wash over you, even if you aren't a believer in any god. It's got something for everyone.
Another one I can listen to on CD. Bought it years ago as some list told me that I should. Not initially my bag but listened to it enough that its grown on me and now I love it - other than save the children which is a skipper - super smooth vocals and great arrangements with powerful vocals with tracks that blend seamlessly to together. Whats not to like (other than save the children).
I suppose I could listen to this voice again and again. I'd give this album 4.5 stars though, if I could.
One of, if not the, greatest soul albums of all time
Very nice.
I don't *quite* hold this in the same gilded esteem as 25 years ago - it's a little over produced and some of the sentiment is a little cloying..however it still has enough quality for 5 stars as a bona fide Classic of its genre..
One of my all time favourite albums. Timeless classic!
It’s become overrated over the years but still hits hard. Borderline 5 stars.
This album has it going on.
Perfect in every way.
Smooth as eggs
PERFECT. what can i say that hasn't already been said
I've heard a few of these songs before, but had never listened to the entire album. It's incredibly cohesive, it feels like one 35-minute long song. I'm a total sucker for that kind of theme album. And I'm also a sucker for singers with a really strong falsetto. So this really fits the bill. Gaye has the full toolkit, he's just got an amazing voice, but the falsetto is his secret weapon. My favorite vocal performance of his on this CD is "What's Happening Brother", which I'd never heard before - the first chorus there gives me the chills, as does his line when he asks "How in the world have you been?". He's just an A+ singer, full stop. This CD just has a wonderful sound too. Despite the cohesiveness from song-to-song, there's a real diversity of voices. Gaye himself has a couple vocal modes depending on how much he relies on falsetto. On top of that there's backing vocals, keys, plenty of horns, bongos, usually a little weird stuff like glock, and the occasional funk guitar. The CD is impeccably produced too - listen to the deep echo on the drum sound on "Flyin' High" and how different it makes that feel vs the rest of the songs. Here's the real test - I listened to this over and over again, and every time I just wished there was more of it. It's incredible.
Absolutely lush and beautiful and timeless classic, despite how grounded it was in a specific time and place
it is a classic. Full of amazing songs. Keeps you from the first song to the last. Starts and ends powerfully
Street lights, a soft breeze on an autumn afternoon, a grey sky, a light drizzle, and a lot of hope...I don't think I can express how much I love this opening title track. It's really that ethereal, beyond-life string section in the second half that feels like the musical equivalent of going through life with perpetually teary eyes. And the way the core melody is flipped to the punchy 'What's Happening Brother', while still sounding wholly unique is something out of this world. And I think that's what Marvin Gaye's album here is, out of this world. Gaye's view on the planet, its state, and its people is refreshing - absolutist, but nothing short of genuine. He sounds like a man who cares, especially on a song like 'Save the Children' where he delivers a message so obvious, a message universally "accepted", yet time and time again, and 50 years after this album's release, we come to see that the obvious isn't actually all that obvious. If we start to perceive Marvin's "idealist" views on the world as shallow, or even "idealist" - then the bare minimum will always seem out of reach. God, there's so much love on this album, it burns. Not to mention how this sounds like it came out in the late '70s as opposed to the early '70s, music was not sounding this lush around this time. The keys, the harmonies, the bongo and conga-based rhythms, the seamless transitions, and, Marvin's soul-scratching vocals merge into one another so beautifully. This is an album that unveils life's deeply buried treasures. This is soul music, music that gives you hope for the impossible, and music that will make you feel seen.
Classic. Such a beautiful album
This album still brings me to tears.
just the definition of smooth. Songs blend together like butter, his voice is and will always be one of the most magical of all time. One of the prettiest and most influential call-to-actions of all time; just impeccable. No notes 1.) what's going on 2.) inner city blues (make me wanna holler) 3.) what's happening brother
In 1971, Marvin Gaye gave the world this beautiful album. The music and the vocals are uniformly amazing. https://open.substack.com/pub/richcain/p/project-1001-whats-going-on-by-marvin?r=4ztyq&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
It's a good album. Possibly a great album. But the "best of all time"?? Come on, that's nonsense and you know it's nonsense. I'm not trying to detract from the fact that this is a really good piece of work, but. "Come. On". Lyrically groundbreaking sure, but musically quite safe. Some stand out songs but tonally and textually quite samey in between. The second track is almost a cover of the first track. Maybe intentionally, but it adds to the sense that it isn't breaking ground musically.
I like hating on the so called "best albums of all time" and I started this like that. the first 30 seconds hit me like oh this is insane. I looove it. But then later I realized that this is just not exactly for me. It is a very specific mood and the listen was absolutely a fun time. Not fillers on this one and in its genre and time this is of course one of THE best ones. I would for sure put it at 5 if it resonated with me more. I need to listen to this in like 10 years again. A very strong 5 for me
Me gusto
Every year since about the time I was born, me and my family would take a summer trip to Long Beach Island. It’s a little beach town on the east end of New Jersey, about a hour away from Atlantic City. Starting in the early 2000’s, my parents would have a mixtape of songs that would sedate us through the car ride to LBI. The first half consisted of songs that were more recent… at least for the early 2000’s. A hodgepodge of songs like I Try by Macy Gray, It Wasn’t Me by Shaggy, a censored The Real Slim Shady by Eminem and some other stuff. It’s the second half of the mixtape, however, that is relevant to the album. That side consisted of songs from the 60’s and 70’s, with the likes of the Carpenters, Dionne Warwick, The Fifth Dimension and more. It was when I heard songs like Rainy Days and Mondays, California Dreamin’, Raindrops Keep Falling on my Head, and even Sweet Caroline. But the first song of this side was always What’s Going On. Thanks in part to the song being a part of one of my School Spirit Days, where all the grades of my school had to perform a synchronized dance routine to a chosen song, I was always familiar with What’s Going On (the song). It has always been a part of my life, being played every year on that drive down to vacation. I mean, maybe a song denouncing police brutality isn’t the best song to hype up for some fun in the sun, but I didn’t make the mixtape. Besides, Marvin’s silky smooth vocals with the serenading orchestra behind him was always relaxing to me, no matter the mood the song carried. For more than 28 years, I have not ventured past that song to hear the other tracks on this album… until today. I can confidently say that, in my opinion, this is the pinnacle of soul in the 1970’s. I know I not giving a hot take by saying that, but it is 1000% true. Never has an album addressed multiple issues of the time, from the aftermath of the Vietnam War, to life in the ghettos and even to the environment, with a sense of concern and subtle optimism. The flow of the album is remarkable, as Marvin seamlessly travels from one track to the next, never missing a beat. There always a nostalgic feeling along the album as Marvin ponders what the future will hold, something that somehow still applies to this day. We all try to keep a sense of some optimism despite looking at the world around us and wondering what else can go wrong. And even though Marvin may be a bit too dependent on the power of God (which he probably does a little too much), his message for love is much needed for all people. As of today, me and my family still go down to Long Beach Island, though we now go down in September rather than in the midst of summer. And while things have certainly changed, we still listen to the same songs on the way down. And while we never know how many years we got, I know that every year I’ll be hearing that familiar Marvin Gaye song again, just as I have for the last 20-something years. Favorite track: What’s Going On Other hits: Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Wholy Holy, Save the Children, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
Flawless
Heard before. What’s there to say?
Grew up thinking Marvin’s tunes were all just about ‘getting it on’ as he would put it. But he’s got far more depth to him. Is this the greatest protest album of all time? Greatest album of all time? Rolling Stone seem to think so, it sits on the top of their list. Which I remember being shocked by when I went to listen to the list a few years back. Listening to it this week, it does still seem very prescient and relevant. What is going on? The title track and Inner City Blues in particular are gorgeous. Simpsons: Yes
Man that intro just hooks me straight away. Nothing bad to say. Love soul, love good social commentary, just love love love.
I was excited to see this album when I got it today. It's a fantastic mix of funk, R&B and gospel music. Beautiful lyrics and Marvin's singing is so smooth and silky. Definitely an album someone should listen to at least once before they die.
obviously awesome
Stone cold classic.
♥️♥️
This is smooth and cool. An album for all occasions
I remember first listening to What's Going On three years ago for the album's 40th anniversary. I can tell you from my experience then and now is that this album, even if it came from a time long before I was born, still resonates. There were protest songs here and there before Marvin Gaye and the Funk Brothers wrote and recorded in 1971 - you had the likes of Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Fortunate Son", Buffalo Springfield "For What It's Worth", and the various acts of the Woodstock festival that protested the Vietnam war. What's Going On was also written as music in protest of that war, with the narrator as a veteran coming home to find is country in turmoil. But much like those great protest songs that have long endured, the language that Marvin and his songwriter collaborators conveyed are more universal and can be applied far beyond their time. Whether it is the pause and reflection of their surroundings on the title track, the despair at the destruction of the environment on "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)", or the plead for compassion during hard times on "Right On", the narrator encourages people to be aware of the issues that are impacting the world they live in. Helping the message get across is Marvin's smooth vocal delivery that gets the word out in a manner that never felt overbearing. Pairing him with the Motown soul instrumentation that has aged like a fine wine resulted in an experience that feels timeless yet poignant. All this to say What's Going On deserves its place on this list, and I for one am glad to have revisited it. This album can be comforting during trying times, and I hope people continue to learn and spark conversation to better themselves and the people around them as music like this can inspire to.
Another perfect record. Gaye meditates on all aspects of a world he is trying to make sense of over a great groove. He expands the scope beyond the normal themes. He pushes into ecology too! This was a turbulent time for all in American history but especially black culture. Unfortunately, it seems just as relevant on the eve of the 2024 election as it was when he penned it.
- First real listens of Marvin Gaye - (7)/9 songs added to playlist - CONCEPT ALBUM!!!!!! - Soul is a such a beautiful genre - Grooving a lot - Could see this becoming a study album - Beautiful tone shifts and very cohesive
Such a gorgeous album with a beautiful message.
Super album
This is another big album in the Castagne family lore. Its one thats always been around in my life, but that I haven't sought out independently. Marvin did not disappoint. It has a very light, floating sound, and it all flows together as an album extremely well. My favorite songs: - Whats Going On - Mercy Mercy Me - Inner City Blues I do have to deduct points for Save The Children. I love a song where they stop singing and talk real slow and soft to you, but I also now know tha tI do not love a song where they holler "SAVE THE BABIES" at you over and over. I could not take that song seriously. Album cover: (A-) Marvin is a beautiful man and he really should come in from the rain. He'll catch a cold.
Initially found this via the /mu/ boards (lol) when I was ~15 and didn't fully appreciate it. In college, I learned from and listened to the album's bass player, James Jamerson, who has become one of my favorite bassists ever. Just listen to that MFer go -- and he does it all with 1 finger in his right hand. Some of the best basslines on the planet. This album has one of the most consistent senses of groove across it that I've ever listened to. I like the blend of percussion, backup vocals, and strings. Marvin's voice is beautiful. "The Detroit mix"' accents the masterful rhythm section (go check them out if you actually read this). There's so much to enjoy on this album and it's so easy for me to return to over time. It sounds like a party. An all-timer for me. 5/5
This album is fantastic. This is my first time listening to a full album by Marvin and he's delivering the goods. The first three songs flow into one another so well. They are all so layered and benefit immensely from a nice pair of headphones. I loved all three of them. "Save the Children" was a step back for me, I didn't like this one as much. Despite this I would like to affirm that I do support saving children. "God is Love" and "Mercy Me" are right back to the smooth flowing ways of the beginning of the album. I like "Mercy Me" a lot, it's got me moving in my seat. "Right On" is my favorite track yet. It's got a few tracks that are just OK, but many more that are excellent. 9/10
Not many times do I listen to an album and know within the first 5 seconds that I will love it.
One of my most treasured possessions is an original copy of this LP. I love every single second of this album. It is musical perfection to me. I listen to it regularly (not the original LP, that's too precious). Although only a few tracks were released as singles I feel like every single track stands on it's own and would have had success as a single release. The fact that it grows in popularity as time goes on is a mark of it's quality.
Ja tak!!! jeg har hørt det her virkelig meget. Selvom det er overspillet etc. Føler jeg at det er en klassiker af en grund. 4 eller 5/5!!!
This is my second, and therefore, last Marvin Gaye album to review. I listened to this album at some point before starting this project, but that’s the only time I listened to it. I loved Let’s Get It On, so I’m assuming I’m really going to love listening to this album again. Like Let’s Get It On, What’s Going On is fantastic. The orchestral arrangements were beautiful and served as the perfect background to Marvin Gaye’s smooth voice. Even though the strings and woodwinds were at the forefront of the sound, the bass and percussion provided a really great rhythm section that was fun to groove to. I loved the lyrics on this album as well, the social and political commentary they provided really captures the societal ills of the late sixties, while also capturing the forward motion of the seventies that looked to fix these societal problems. The old feel of the orchestral arrangements and the forward-looking lyrics stood in contrast to one another, but that contrast was absolutely beautiful, and made this a great sounding album. “Mercy Mercy Me” was my favorite song on the album. I loved the lyrics, and it had my favorite grooves of the whole album. What’s Going on is a piece of pure soul, executed to perfection by Marvin Gaye.
A wonderful soulful album. Everything is great on here. There love and protest, joy and sadness. Full range of emotions on display with excellent production and backing instruments. A perfect album.
Genuinely excellent album that endures decades after its release. Truly a delight.
Incredible!
Easiest 5 stars of my life
Another titan we have been waiting for. A few years back I’d listen to this album while falling asleep. It’s so breezy yet the lyrics are very political. It’s a testament to Gaye that he was able to thread that line. I kept most of the songs but overall this is another five star.
Jajaja Schitterend
legendary
After a few sub-par albums in a row, the 1001 list is back with a bang! Absolute classic.
Sublime
One of the most important recordings of all time. A call to arms delivered in a positive, forward-thinking and soulful way.
Iconic album I've heard much about, didn't disappoint
Es gibt für mich die ganz ganz großen Alben. Alben die einfach die Nummer 1 in der Musikgeschichte sind. Davon habe ich einige. Und dazu gehört "Whats going in?" von Marvin Gaye. Ich lege die CD ein und bin eins mit dieser berauschenden Musik. Es ist in jeder Zelle der Musiknoten eine Offenbarung. So tief, so groovy, so kritisch, so melodisch, so leicht, so Niveauvoll, so rhythmisch, so prachtvoll Manchmal kann ich es nicht fassen, was es für große Musik gibt
Mercy mercy me always makes me cry!! Nobody makes albums about the world ending like this anymore 🙄
Unfathomably beautiful. Always leaves me a little more hopeful.
Now THIS is what I'm talking about. 5*. Amazing singer, great songs, timeless lyrics.
This album flies by. Serious stuff done in a super smooth way. What's going on is the ultimate protest song and is still relevant 50 years after Vietnam. Unlike previously thought, not shagging music.
Some of the best instrumentalists of their time come together to create the most boring album possible
Very smooth and good vibes
Truly one of the greatest pieces of acoustic art! Everything in and behind this album is so beautiful, unique, incredible, captivating and much more. Powerful and sad what happened in his life but this album will for sure live forever!
5 stars all the way!
Oh fuck yeh. Fever dream masterpiece. Yehhhh what’s happeniiiiiin
Only thing wrong with this album is that it is too short. It’s a beauty.
Peak Marvin. Peak Funk Bros.
Back to back 5 stars for maybe the first time, about 980 albums in Not much to say about this that hasn’t been said a thousand times over - it’s an immaculate master class of soul and a truly vital record
There isn’t one bad moment on this album. It’s about as close to perfection as a soul album can get. I’ve never heard an album flow as seamlessly as this; the only break was after Mercy Mercy Me, which made perfect sense in the context of the songs. That still didn’t disrupt the flow though. Even the last couple bars brings it back around to the opening themes. My goodness we lost a great one when we lost Marvin.
A beautiful and meaningful work of art.
Music can, and often should, say something. A beautiful, cohesive experience from beginning to end, with high re-listenability.
This album is one of the all time greats. Everytime it comes across my path I have a great listen.
10/10.
10/10
Easy 5. Soulful with a message.
Soulful, honest, a singular vision. As true today as it was when it was first released. I love this album!
Buttery
es bueno :v
This album is soul-healing. It is my go-to album whenever I feel at odds with the world or seek peace and spirituality. There is no question that this album has influenced me as a person. The topics he speaks about are still relevant in today's world. The evil that we as a collective let foster throughout this world is unprecedented. The division I see daily in our world is heartbreaking. Albums like these always help me stay hopeful for the future—our future. Best - What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky), God Is Love, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues (Makes Me Wanna Holler) Worst - absolutely no bad songs 6/5
Top ever
When asked if Marvin wanted to make an album denouncing the Vietnam war or make a sensual masterpiece he just had one word: "Yes" 5/5
the aural equivalent of drinking a really smooth milkshake whilst floating peacefully on a lilo except you're in the middle of the ocean and theres a war on, but it's still really nice
Got me laid 5/5 would play again
Has there ever been a time in the last 50 years where someone hasn't said "Still feels appropriate today"? Bit sad that really. Great piece of work.
Landmark album and a classic
Een klassieker. Een pareltje. Heerlijk om naar te luisteren. Prachtige teksten en een stem die je aandacht trekt op de juiste manier. Dit is niets minder dan een 5.
1e album op vinyl!! Ez 5
What an incredible voice. There are several standout tracks, like the title track, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues. But then the rest of the tracks weave together in a way that is really unique for a soul album.
"What's Going On" and "Mercy Mercy Me" have always been favorite songs, and this album does them justice. A meaningful and beautiful album.
The two tracks that I know are enough to carry the album alone, but the rest was also quite nice to listen to.
It's really nice that we're getting good albums in our last week. Please let the next one not be crap!
I love What’s Going On… but until this project had never listened to a Marvin Gaye album. Glad that has changed, and as soon as I started listening to this album I had no problem with a third album from Gaye on this list. This album hits an awful lot of society’s ills in an unbelievably smooth and cool style that goes down so, so easy. What a lush way to comment on society. Terrific!
Marvin's masterpiece. "Picket lines and picket signs" within the first couple of minutes. Tell It Like It Is, Marv. This still sounds 100% relevant in 2024. Mercy Mercy Me has an almost spiritual feel. The album has so many layers, without ever feeling cluttered. At the centre is still a collection of simple soul songs. Plus it's proof that an outstanding album need only be 35 minutes in duration.
Deserves all the praise. 'What's Going On' is as beautiful as records get, and the concept-like feel, makes it an especially addictive album.
It’s been 53 years since Marvin Gaye raised these questions … And it’s as relevant as ever. What’s going on?!
Excellent album. The title track is one of the best songs ever made.
One of the songs that exemplifies the idea that music is a reflection of the times in which that music is made.
this mf clueless
A sublime classic
I didn't need to listen to this one again, but I did it anyway. Voted the number one album of all time by Rolling Stone in '20 and I can't say I disagree. A true classic.
Lekker
Classic. Love the use of soul music for protest songs.
Great voice and vide
4.5
It’s called soul for a reason, I think I might have ascended a little bit
First full listen through and as good as I expected
Can’t ever go wrong with Marvin
What's Going On is the eleventh studio album by Marvin Gaye, originally released in 1971. Marvin Gaye had long fought with Motown to allow him to have full creative control over his records. Motown was a commercial label, and they were mainly concerned with appealing to the pop crowd to sell records. But times were changing. It wasn't the 1960s anymore, and it took more than just AM radio airplay to gain true success. The public wanted more. So with that, Motown finally let Gaye produce his own record. What we had previously seen from Gaye was typical of many other Motown artists: Love songs, heartbreak songs, made-for-radio hits, etc. Not saying that's bad at all, in fact, I believe some of those Motown tracks are some of the best songs ever. It just highlights how big of a turn this was for Gaye. He trades in his love songs for emotional, introspective tracks about topics like the Vietnam War and Poverty. His lyrics paint a picture of early-70s America, along with foreseeing future issues such as climate change. Unfortunately many of these lyrics still hit home in a similar way that they did in the 1970s. I guess we never did find out what's going on.
What's Going On is a post-war, post-civil rights, post-hippie assessment of America at the time. It's clear that Gaye cares about a number of issues that have plagued (and continue to) Americans everywhere. He strings songs together in a seamless manner to get his point across, that these are interconnected and overlapping issues. Gaye takes soul to another level with this album, and I can't help but feel like we're listening to one of the most important albums of all time. How does that happen? How are we so lucky?
Der Klassiker schlechthin. Ein Perfektionswerk der Sonderklasse. Vielleicht das beste Album überhaupt, wenn man das so sagen darf und kann. Ein Meilenstein und ein Meisterwerk in jede einzelne Note verpackt. Man fängst das Album an und es läßt einem nicht mehr los. Nebenbei hören funktioniert nicht, weil es mich gefangen hält. Meine Frau weiß bereits, wenn dieses Album erklingt, dann bin ich nicht mehr ansprechbar.
What can I possibly add? Marvin has already said it all better than I ever could plus he has an orchestra.
A vaunted album that lives up to the hype. There isn't a wasted note. Thank goodness he didn't join up with the Lions to become a football player and made this instead. It's bittersweet, powerful, beautiful, immaculate--how many adjectives can I throw at this? I know that I'm not even being articulate. I'm too in awe. This really is an album everyone should hear before they die. I even appreciate the Jesus stuff! The production holds up, too. There isn't anything about this that sounds dated. It's a towering achievement. Highlights: What's Going On?, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Right On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
I hate that Marvin Gaye is super cool, and that probably my grandma liked him as well. Am I becoming my grandma?💀
What's Going On is Marvin Gaye's finest work, and regarded by some at the greatest album in popular music. For this album, Gaye wanted to create a protest album, expressing a view of the Vietnam veteran, who has returned to the United States, and is disappointed by what he sees. Gaye's sweet, soulful voice brings an elegance to all of his work, and brings an earnest element to these beautiful protest songs. Gaye met with resistance from Berry Gordy for the direction of recording, but Gaye's persistence was well worth it. The album met with immediate critical and commercial success. Over time, it has been recognized as one of the most significant recordings of modern music.
Totally succinct. What a success!
I enjoyed it
An example of a album is so well put together its better than the sum of its parts. Fantastic 5*
What's Going On is a masterpiece of storytelling, reflection, analysis, heartache, optimism, pessimism, a full spectrum of emotions delivered in a truly elegant and memorable composition. Every part of it delivers, one of the strongest and most important records we've had through this whole thing.
I'm not quite as sold on this as you guys - it definitely has some weaker points - but it is still a brilliant listen and one I will regularly come back to. It flows wonderfully, it feels like an album designed as a whole rather than individual songs stuck together. Does it sound a little bit samey? Yeah. Are there a couple of weak tracks? Yes, Save the Children makes me cringe quite a lot, Wholy Holy isn't up to the standard of the rest either. But that's because the rest of the album is really, really good, it tells a story, it cuts, and it's just a great listen. I don't think this is at the top of my list, but it's probably still a 5/5.
What can you really say? This album is incredible. A perfect spin and valid as a “best of all timer”
Is there a better “socially conscious” pop album? It’s perfect - everything sounds sonically wonderful, I love the way that’s it’s almost just one long song that flows and changes and transforms.
I got this in the heat of a political crisis. I chose to revisit a few days later and heard news of a murder by police. Fifty-three years later and the question still lingers: What’s Going On?
Marvin's masterpiece. I am in awe of its greatness each time I listen to it.
What’s goin on? What’s happening? Who are you?? How did you get in my house???
Had the day off today so I just kept listening to this album. Never gets old!
Hard to talk about this album objectively because it is by my count one of the three 'all-around' best albums of all time (Pet Sounds & Songs in the Key of Life being the other two.) It is otherworldly in its grace... makes me wanna yearn and pine, but also marked by some incredibly thoughtful lyricism and orchestration... It's really hard for me to quantify but I just really adore this album and think it's unbelievably special. When I was 16 I bought the vinyl and would lie on my floor in the centre of my bedroom and be brought to tears by this album's beauty. Some of the most sublime music I've heard and it was a blessing to be able to listen to this today...
Favorite Track: What’s Going On
Classssicccc!! Also I wonder if Marvin ever found out what was going on
There isn't another voice that is as smooth as Marvin Gaye.
The archetype for 70's Soul Music. If you listen very closely, you may detect a "message" about social justice and the American experience as it relates to the marginalized groups of the time.
This is a masterpiece
Superb!!!
Smooth, relaxing. Enjoyed it!
Soulful album just started listening to it. Seems like the first song (its title track) is the most popular. Made in 1971, it has 9 songs and is only 35 minutes long. I love the vocals. On Whats happening brother there is a nice percussion hand drum type beat going on that compliments the melody. One song i added to my goated playlist was Flyin’ High (In The Friendly Sky) The vocals again hit so hard and the melody was there. Save The Children was good but kinda like a interlude in a way talking about the messed up world and what children will have to face when they get older. God is love was another one im adding to the goated playlist more traditional African percussion in this religious soul song. It talks about loving your neighbor and thanking god for everything. Very light hearted track. Mercy Mercy Mercy is a song about climate change it feels like it talks about animals dying and such. Right on talks about different people and love. The flute is really nice in this one. Wholy holy is another religious track that talks about getting together and believing in Jesus and God. Make me wanna holler I couldn't understand since no lyrics on Spotify but the beat was there, and there were more traditional drums. Part of its talking about racism I think. Final ranking 8/10 Y
O que era o álbum mais inesperado e sui generis do Marvin Gaye até então se tornou seu Magnum Opus, e não à toa. O conceito, a experimentação instrumental quase jazzística (principalmente na música Right On, que também absorve elementos de música latina), a produção suave que faz as músicas passarem como se fossem uma só e as letras, que até então na carreira do cantor eram muito focadas apenas em romance, agora tomam liberdade para discutir a sociedade americana na época, após a queda da contracultura e a desilusão que todos estavam sentindo, mas chamando de maneira encantadora para que se supere o derrotismo e volte a se lutar pelo que é justo.
Definite classic. I know there's a lot of cool music theory about how the songs perfectly meld into each other but just in terms of style, muscianship and lyrics, Marvin's bringing it all here. One of the quintessential R&B albums of all time. Thanks mom for saving the Vinyl
On of THE GREAT voices laying down love and humanity for all. Impeccable backing and such a great backdrop for the vocals. Could listen over and over.
Pretty great, prescient. Not enough has changed since these lyrics were written
This was incredible. Soulful, musical, thoughtful, and ultimately tragic. I'm sure this was even more powerful furing the Vietnam war, but it sadly still works today. I've heard other R&B music on this list that I really liked, particularly Al Green, but this one really did reach into my soul.
Excellent. Marvin is wonderful.
a gorgeous album full of themes involving humanity and finding our place in it. anti-war sentiments, love, racism, religion, the environment, police brutality… all delivered through gaye’s signature buttery smooth vocals. this one is an all timer, kids. don’t miss out. highlights: “what’s going on” “save the children” “mercy mercy me (the ecology)”
das isch s erstr jamerson album woni han glaub und es isch e freeeeud. hans auscho agfange durelose aber glaub nonie ganz glost. de title track isch sooo schön und de bass isch extreem geil. boah d melodie bi whats happening brother bruuudi. flying high isch au huuere schön. het alles sochli de glich sound. bass wieder fantatisch. save the children goht geg de schluss huuuere los mit swing und doubletime drums und sache. bgvs soo schön. es goht alles nohtlos inenand ine und god is love isch chli meh uptempo und d congas träged wieder mega. mercy mercy me het chli en olötzlichere übergang aber isch geil. d snare goht jo dumm mitem ewige hall. he de scheiss isch jo meega schön. de marvin singt soo guet. right on isch etz die zweit siite vom album und isch viel bluesiger. mit guiro und geeeile querflöte. uuuh wie d drums am schluss wieder inechömed mmmmmh. übergang zu wholy holy isch wieder uuuhuere schön. inner city blues congas time conga time und mega dumpfi kick huere cool. bruuudi bass wieder duuuumm. isch glaub de bob babbit. yep. sehr cool irgendwie nice wie alles mit de akkörd mitgoht au wells so lang uf eim akkord bliibed. boah sie blibed so lang ufem vieri (?) aaaaah und am schluss machted nomol whats going on.
"What's Going On" is the 11th studio album by American soul singer Marvin Gaye. It was the first album credited to Gaye as producer and also to Motown's in-house session musicians, the Funk Brothers. It was a concept album with songs seguing into the next song and told from the point of view of a Vitenam veteran coming home to witness hatred, suffering and injustice. Introspective lyrics address drug abuse, poverty, the Vietnam War and promoting ecology. Commercially, it hit #6 in the US and #56 in the UK. The album is considered one of the greatest of all time and a landmark recording in popular music. In 2003, it was inducted into the National Recording Registry by the Library of Congress for its artistic significance. The Four Tops' Ronaldo "Obie" Benson inspired Gaye for the lead single "What's Going On" as he described the police brutality he saw at an anti-war protest in Berkeley. The song begins with people talking and an alto sax solo. Gaye's great voice comes in. Very soulful. Strings and a great bass. Multi-tracked background vocals throughout. What a way to start an album. "Save the Children" was an emotional plea to help disadvantaged children. Strings and congas. A sax. Loud background singers. Gaye talking and singing a response. The first side rolls along and closes with "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)." The guitar riff, congas, dual-layered lead vocals. A great sax solo by Wild Bill Moore. A plea for the environment. "Right On" opens the second side. Funk rock, Latin soul and most of all jazzy. The flute, piano, bass and what sounds like a zipper. Interesting song. The album closes with "Inner City Blues (Make Me Want to Holler)." Piano keys start then the congas come in then multple percussions then the bass then Gaye singing. Every instrument going, creating a bluesy funky vibe. Strings and a flute join in. A serious tone as Gaye describes urban poverty. The song fades out with the percussion and a sax. This album is deeply soulful. It's jazzy and funky at times. The strings add an air of classical music. One of the critiques of this album is that the three singles are great but everything else is "blah." I didn't think that; the songs flow together and build within the song. Not a throwaway song that I heard. What can you say about Gaye's voice? One of the best ever. I have to mention the outstanding bass playing of Bob Babbitt. The layered production of multiple vocals, the core band, the strings and the horns also works for me. A true classic album.
Ez dump on badz
already heard this one, such a classic.
If you are going to make a list of at least 15 albums that "you must hear before you die", or "you would take to a desert island", this album has to be on this list. I believe that if an alien from Mars starts studying the history of the human race, at some point he will have to go through What's Going On to understand some things. The song that gives the album its name is also among the best compositions of all time. This isn't even my opinion, it's facts! And the rating cannot be anything other than 5 stars.
Such a fantastic album, Marvin Gaye knows how to make music Top tracks: What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)
4.75. Actually an amazing album. So beautiful and illicits actual joy from me.
Nearly perfect.
When this was released I didn’t give it a second thought. This was peak Prog Rock time for me and anything else didn’t get a look in. As regards soul music I’d go further and say that in 1971 I had a hatred of the whole genre. Times have changed and there is no doubt that this album has become highly regarded (or should) by every music lover. It’s yet another example that this list occasionally throws up an album you don’t personally like but cannot deny that it is a masterpiece. I might be wrong on this, but this album is perhaps the best example of that rule. Unlike in 1971 I do and enjoy listening to this album. Not particularly because I like it outright (although each play I become fonder) but because as a music lover I should be aware of its pedigree and be able to relate to it when it is talked about. Accordingly my 5 star rating is made because of its musical standing rather than my musical preferences. 5/5 14/6/24
Wow. Personal enjoyment: 5/5 Relevance to this list: 5/5
Easy 5. Absolutely classic perfect length, perfect vocals, perfect production, perfect vibe The way some of the songs slide in to each other are outstanding, and the flow of the album is so good because of this. one of those ones thats so hard to talk about because its just brilliant. opener and closer are so so good. LOVE IT 5
Have listend to the album previously, but not very attentive. Now, for the first time I dedicated myself fully to the listening expierience, lay down, put on headphones and closed my eyes and brother, brother it was beautiful. So many things to discover, so many different elements in the instrumentation, that I haven't noticed before, maybe because the sound is so warm and smooth and perfectly fused together and the same goes for the album itself. More than once I wasn't sure and had to check, if a new song just started.
Took me almost twenty years to crack this album, but I finally did. Immensely enjoyed it. Heavy rotation all day.
Goddamnit. I wanted to be the cynic who would give this a 3 or some shit but this is so fucking good. 5/5
Spellbinding
Marvin's anthemic album detailing the subjective plight of the common man, specially the common black man in America is one of my all time favorites. The man started out as a Motown darling who used to be in line with Smoky Robinson and Aretha Franklin became a soulful and socially concious mastermind of modern music at the time of this release. The logevity of this album holds truth in circumstance of great music. It will withstand the test of time.
perfect album
Great artist, great album. One of the best of all time.
I’ve been expecting this album for a while and I’m glad to finally listen to it as part of this list. It manages to hit that sweet spot of dealing with some really heavy shit while being insanely easy on the ears at the same time. From Vietnam to racism to urban struggles it’s all there and each song perfectly tackles each issue it’s aiming at. What’s going on and inner city blues are my favs.
Et af de helt store, soul, politisk, nostalgisk
One of the finest soul albums ever made - wonderfully written, performed, sung by the late great Marvin Gaye. I especially loved the production of the album, so smooth, it was wonderful to listen to.
On m'aurait demandé de noter cet album il y a 15 ans, j'aurais probablement dit : "Nope, c'est pas ma came du tout !". Et cette critique aurait très certainement englobé toute la musique soul et RnB. Mais comme il n'y a que les cons qui ne changent pas d'avis, et qu'il faut savoir écouter plus loin que le bout des ses oreilles : des heures d'écoute de tous horizons plus tard, mon avis actuel est tout à fait opposé. Quel bel album que celui-ci. Marvin Gaye semble nous confier ses réflexions de manière confidentielle, avec une voix sereine et chaude. La musique oscille entre jazz, classique et soul, les textes sont beaux, le concept de l'album en lui-même est saisissant... Je n'ai décidément rien à dire si ce n'est que selon moi cet album mérite l'auréole qui lui est décernée !
Utterly sublime
I really liked the vocals and instrumentation. Good 60s rock
Simply one of the best albums ever recorded. I've already listened to this album many times so this was just another enjoyable re-listen. Can't say much more than what's already been said by other reviews. 5 stars.
The worst album that Marvin Gaye ever created, and the one that would absolutely destroy his career. At, least, according to Motown boss Berry Gordy, who, for all his genius, just didn’t get it … until “What’s Going On” snuck onto radio and the rest is history. Is this the greatest album of all-time? That really depends on who you ask, but personally, this album resonates more with me than “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band,” which is what had been No. 1 on Rolling Stone’s list of the greatest albums. That is, until younger, more diverse voters were added to the pool and elevated this classic to the top. “Sgt. Pepper's” is fantastic, revolutionary, visionary, all of that and more ... but it just doesn't have the same cultural cachet. This album is the touchstone for pretty much anything. It spans time and space ... and is as relevant today as it was when Marvin Gaye was facing pressure from Gordy to stick to love songs. It is timeless and yet urgent, and deserves its reverence.
I can think of some people in the world who should listen to this record.
Beautiful. Simply beautiful. This is a fantastic album. The vibes are immaculate. 10/10 Would I listen again? Absolutely
There’s a lot of context that makes this album more impactful than just a listen. But to keep it simple, this is a masterpiece. It’s a formal lament concerning the brokenness of the world and humanity through one man’s eyes. That man happens to be Marvin Gaye and he makes you feel what we’re often uncomfortable to engage with. But it’s still hopeful because he believes that love is the solution. It’s beautiful and brilliant and sparkling.
Is there an easier 5 stars? Is there a better advertisement for this process than either introducing someone to this or reminding them of its glory. The answer to both is no. Better, more eloquent people have written volumes about the soul, the sadness, the live, the romance, the depth and the musicality of this. All I can say is it's always welcome in my ears.
good i think
Classic Soul.
What's Going On is a hell of a groovy jam. Beautifully buttery vocals over a cheerful bouncing melody, speaking to the political unrest of the 60s/70s. Interesting that they mixed in crowd vocals through a lot of the song -- gives it a really interesting atmosphere. Really love how this album just bleeds together as if it is one continuous track. I couldn't give it too much dedicated focus on the first listen as I'm heads down with work, but I was grooving along all the way through. Beautiful vocals and lived in, vibrant instrumentals. Mercy Mercy Me and Inner City Blues were two of my favorites that I was able to separate out. Otherwise, there are no misses here. This is pure magic. 5 / 5
Marvin's going green and political but in a soulful way. For me it jumps the shark tank at Save the Children but then back on track. I didn't realize the album is only 36 mins long. Great rhythms and Marvin's voice is butter.
I mean, it's f'n What's Going On. It's a top-ten album of all time for a reason.
Great production, perfect for chilling out in the garden.
Great, so much soul and a great story.
Genre-defining. Great voice, beautifully constructed songs. Easy listening, but without being boring, the hard-hitting lyrics are almost masked by the softness of Gaye's voice. A stand-out album.
This is my favorite Marvin Gaye album. 9/10
One of my favorite records that I own.
Is this the greatest album ever recorded? If Rolling Stone is to be believed as of 2020 it is. It was no doubt a political act on the part of the magazine. In 2020, one of the great years for the BLM protests, one of the great years for protests in general, to honour one of the great protest records as not just that, but the greatest album of all time. But, I’m more interested in What’s Going’ On’s connection to the album that it succeeded. Sgt Pepper’s is the ultimate Hippie Record, full of psychedelic sounds and a vibe that’s mostly peace and love. It’s a good record, I’m never gonna deny that, but for so many people peace and love is the unrealised dream. What What’s Going On has to it’s advantage, is the same thing that Sgt Pepper’s best song also demonstrates. The reality of A Day In The Life, the dichotomy between the lives of the haves and the have nots. Gaye presents this topic with the clear eyed lens of a realist, which makes for one of the most heartbreaking albums in recorded history. Because it’s all still there. The bigotry, the state sponsored violence, the drug use, the fucking climate change! We are much closer to Gaye’s version of life than we are to Paul McCartney’s. But despite all the doom and gloom, What’s Going On is still a record full of the joy of music, the joy of human interaction through this weird cultural experience that we all love, and also through the knowledge that there are people who will fight for the basic dignity of all humanity, no matter how hard the bastards try to keep is down. So, and I say this with as little irony as my deadened Zoomer Heart can muster, Right On, keep fighting, keep fucking fighting
Compared this to the last review I submitted for a Marvin Gaye album, the voice is still perfect but the songs are better.
i forgot to write a sentence for this and am doing this half a year later because i LOVE this album me me wanna holler, the way they do my life!
Uno de los mejores discos de R&B/Soul de la historia. Impresionante desplante de Gaye en el micrófono, y la clásica producción de Motown hace de esta una experiencia sumamente agradable al oído. Y a pesar de ser una obra sumamente pop, Marvin se da el tiempo de hacernos reflexionar con letras introspectivas que ahondan en diferentes problemáticas de la realidad afroamericana. Sumamente recomendable.
Ja
This album definitely hits hard while being easy to listen to. Songs about racial injustice, poverty, war and pollution by one of the great soul voices. Hugely influential at the time and it still is relevant today.
I tell you what: The very similar drum and percussion arrangements can get annoying no matter how great the rest of the album is. That why I give it 4 stars even though I want to give 5.
When I saw this album, my gut response was that it's unfortunately become a tad overrated since Rolling Stone decided to name it the Greatest Album of All Time. That's a somewhat bold statement, but it doesn't mean this isn't among the best albums ever, period. And then I listened to it again, and realized that maybe Rolling Stone was correct. In reality, it's a top 20 all-timer, and Rolling Stone will likely name a different album number 1 whenever they do another one of those lists again. But make no mistake. Overall, this thing is a marvel.
Mellow, really solid
I really enjoyed this album :) chill, not boring, good vibes all around
5stars
My 8th grade science teacher used to play this album every day. absolute classic. Nothing bad to say.
What's Going On? The Vietnam War.
Beautiful. Everyone in the house loved it - me, my husband, and our eighteen-year-old tabby cat.
Yeah. Definitely a genius.
5.0 + Now that I've almost finished this massive, multi-year listening exercise, it's nice to circle back on "What's Going On", an album I've loved for many years, and realize just how great it really is.
Glorious. 5 stars. should still be on the list, imho.
Yeah this is easily one of the greatest and important records ever made. So goddamn groovy the whole way through, and masterful writing
Gear: Meze 109 PRO Mix: glasklar, smooth und teils überraschend verspielt Musik: inhärent düsterer, zeitloser Klassiker in Sachen überragender Vocals, Instrumentierung und (leider) Lyrics Wertung: ☔☔☔☔☔/5
Classic album that I own in 2 formats. Love it.
An all time great album
One of the more important albums to exist. It's messages are timeless and can so easily be applied to the world we find ourselves in today. Behind beautiful, soulful, and expressive vocals the bass adds another dimension to the album which gives it such a masterfully crafted sound. What words can't express, james jamerson plays out on his strings. This is one of those rare albums that captured lightening in a bottle and used it to benefit the world, not only with sound but with its messages.
It's hard to pinpoint what makes this album so great. The fact the Gaye knew what he wanted despite Berry Gordy's pleadings with him to not do a political album; his masterful songwriting; OR the themes woven through the entire album by the Funk Brothers to the point that it sound like one seamless track. 5/5.
A masterpiece that got me more into music as a teen.
Fish full of Mercury. Thermometurbot.
Phenomenal album 10/10
I love Marvin Gaye this ones my favorite out of the albums we've listened to of his
Another record that I was already very familiar with, but which is unreal so it's nice to be reminded of
Love the vocals, the rhythms, and the instrumentals. Definitely a fantastic album.
Classic, everyone should definitely hear this album.
Marvin Gaye could sing about dish soap and you would be grateful for it. Kidding aside, this album is a poignant and visceral sign of the times in US history. He preaches with eloquent vocals that provide soul for the body and mind. The overall instrumental sound is amazing, and his angelic voice is almost too good to believe.
I like this a lot.
Absolutely fantastic. Big fan of Marvin Gaye and Whats going on is THE best album he did. Music a delight to Listen to. First class production and meaningful hit home lyrics especially on 'Makes me wanna holla'. Superb stuff from the man who had the voice of an angel.
It's often said that pop culture goes in cycles, but if there's any evidence that all of society goes in cycles, too, it's that this album is as meaningful and resonant in 2024 as it was in 1971, 1991, etc.
What struck me today was how in retrospect a lot of this album's apocalyptic political messaging becomes a metaphor for the more troubling aspects of Gaye's personal life. I had to stop in my tracks for a moment after really listening to "Don't go talking about my father, God is my friend". The use of uplifting music to mask, misdirect, or emphasize pain (personal or political) is nothing new, but this has to be one of the most consistent, well-executed examples of it.
Was never sure if this album was overhyped just due to the tragic story but it actually is really good.
He’s just one of da best of da best.
Oh my god it’s beautiful. I love this album. Lyrically and musically it’s perfect.
if you skip any song on this album i really don’t like you like actually what is wrong with you wish i could give it higher than a 5
marvin gaye is hands down one of THE MOST talented people to ever bless the earth this album is INSANELY good very powerful message godly progression throughout the album shit just flows into each other 5/5 MOTHER MOTHER
come onnnn
An exquisite work of art - such depth, such soul. It is hard to overstate the beauty of the voice and the orchestration. Gaye could have recorded anything he wanted and continued to make radio friendly, high quality jams. But, instead, he chose thoughtfulness and introspection and social observations on the ecology, Vietnam and the suffering of black people in US society - and created a masterpiece.
Great album! So many classic songs with my favorite being Inner City Blues.
Overall: would not have listened to unprompted, outstandingly positive surprise. -large open (but not empty) room sound, clean but lively -"Flyin' High" is seamless "progressive" section -broad, but consistent instrumentation (especially bass+congas(?)+chime accents) -song transitions really smooth, sells the "concept album thing" of all songs being different sections of one big piece well -"God is Love" reprise of beginning "What's Going On" -"Mercy Mercy Me" neat Saxophone Solo (stand-out timbre) -"Mercy Mercy Me" favourite until now, but cleanest cut yet after it -did not expect the "Bossa" -"Inner City Blues" really groovy and reprise again
I love this one 9/10
Magnificent. I love that sometimes I listen to this album and really focus on the lyrical power, and sometimes you can just let the sound envelop you. The recurring motifs in the music work superbly throughout, with the title track coming back into your consciousness throughout the album, meaning this works as a concept album pretty perfectly. There are a couple of minor things I will say - Save The Children is quite a poor song to the point of being skippable, and the scraper on Right On renders a really great song a bit irritating. But these are tiny quibbles that might point to me holding this otherwise faultless album to really high standards. Feel free to hate me, but a perfect 5.0 can't have a song that you want to skip on it, so it gets a magnificent 4.8 and a place in the GOAT conversation.
One of my favorite albums of all time. I love how the songs turn into the next. That makes for a wonderful listening experience when you listen it as an album from end to end.
Marvin Gaye has a beautiful voice and this album truly highlights it. Easy to listen, enjoyable from beginning to end.
My ex-girlfriend, Hazel, introduced me to this album in 1998. I have loved it ever since.
Make it easy: 5/5. I wish I could give it 6/5. I know this album well, it is one of the albums I would qualify as "important". Something everyone should listen to before they die. This is music with a message. That can be really hard to pull off without being overbearing, but Marvin Gaye nails it here. The music carries the message but the message doesn't get in the way of the music. The iconic songs "What's Going On", "Mercy Mercy Me" and "Inner City Blues" are... well... iconic. Among the best. The rest of the album ties in and it all ties together. There's a reason this album is near the top of everybody's "Best Albums" lists
Amazing voice, amazing album. Sadly, the title track is as relevant today as it was in 1971.
Motown’s crowning achievement, a timeless and beautiful album. The gorgeous music shimmers and gleams while Marvin’s voice yearns for happier times. The album is deeply political but never preachy, infused with purpose and emotion. Love the way that melodies and sounds repeat and develop over the course of the album. Incredible work by an incredible artist. Best song: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)
It's a 5. Perfect album from start to finish. It's soulful, it's funky, it has everything you could want. The grooves on some of these tracks are all-timers, the instrumentation is lush and it's just a good time.
"WAR IS HELL WHEN I WILL IT END, WHEN WILL PEOPLE START GETTING TOGETHER AGAIN." I heard this album for the first time during covid and this line hit so hard. This is a perfect concept album of the Veteran struggle and may be one of the most perfect albums ever created. Not in my personal top 5 but Objectively I KNOW. When the notes HIT ON THE SAVE THE BABIES OH MY GOD. How can you make music that has so much meaning be so catchy and groovy. GOD IS LOVE IS SUCH A GOOOOOOOD INTRO TO MERCY MERCY ME AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH! IF THIS IS WHAT CHRISTIAN MUSIC WAS LIKE I WOULD BE DEVOUT I CAN LISTEN TO THIS FOR DAYS :) Mercy Mercy Me was my intro to this album through The Strokes cover which is also good but not to the level! Anyways love
5 My building’s fire alarm went off at 5 this morning due to someone smoking, and by the time everything was sorted, it was time to drag my groggy ass to the gym… on leg day, no less. So, I didn’t start the day in a particularly good mood, but instead of putting on some familiar comfort music to power through my workout, on a whim, I decided to check out my album of the day, a certain What’s Going On by Marvin Gaye, to see what all the hype is about. The next thing I knew, mid-squat, I had the biggest smile on my face and found myself looking forward to the day ahead. What a magical album. I enjoyed Let’s Get It On, but this is next-level - and applicable in non-sexual situations, which is an additional bonus. I can’t even really describe what makes it that way, but there’s something so enchanting about Gaye’s work here that makes you want to stop what you’re doing so you can just sit back and listen. I didn’t even bother trying to keep up with what song I was on in order to make note of specific highlights, I just found myself enjoying the moment I was in, an experience that’s greatly enhanced and kept suspended by the nature of each song’s segue into the next - it’s beautifully executed and effectively keeps you in a perpetual trance for the duration of your listen. The album also feels ahead of its time in that regard, though truthfully, I don’t think it’s ever been done better than this right here. An immersive and fantastic experience from start to finish. I’ve somehow never heard this before, and yet I knew after my first listen this was going to be a 5. At its heart, music to me has always been about emotion, and this made me feel a few quite deeply, reminding me of what I love about the medium and why it has and always will be my favorite thing this fucked-up world has to offer. A great album to end the week on and start the weekend, the kind that reminds me of the good in the world and makes me want to share love with those that I love - because what IS going on? RIP Marvin - you have a newfound fan in me.
An absolute classic. The musicianship is amazing too. Particularly when you think that James Jamerson was playing lying down because he was too drunk to stand up
Love this album. So cool how the songs flow into each other. The whole thing is so tight and cohesive while simultaneously feeling really organic and loose. The orchestration and arrangements are so good. It totally has its own sound. Marvin Gaye was such a brilliant singer and songwriter. I love all the vocal layers. These are the greatest bass lines on this album I love how they play off of and compliment the vocal too.
One of the best records of all time.