Reviews (page 4 of 9)
Just some good old boppy, enjoyable indie pop rock
If I was a guy that ordered a double Tito's with just a splash of water and essence of lime when everyone else is drinking Busch Light, I'd probably love this album. It has a beautiful well crafted sound, but it feels so pretentious.
good stuff. I enjoyed this album
Very chill indy music done well. Not as strong as the other two albums I have heard from this band.
Some good tracks but too slow for my taste.
The songs just sorta blend into each other in an okay way. Saved a song: N RYM: N
I really enjoy the combination of the retro vibe with modern day lyrics and themes. A strong debut album that didn't sound like the music being produced at the time.
Love Belle and Sebastian, but only in small doses. This album is like being served your favorite meal 12 times in a row. By the 4th time, you start wondering if it’s actually your favorite. By the 12th time…
I like how much ground this record covers; you get unexpected doses of sound. The production feels tight and thoughtful, focusing on the guitar and violin textures. Vocally it leans toward breathy and overly delicate, singing everything as a lullaby. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions The State I Am In Expectations She’s Losing It
Glad to have hear this album.
This one developed unexpectedly from the unassuming start. Another band that toes the line between the morose and the joyful. Didn’t necessarily gel with it but feel I might get there with a repeat listen. Full fat musical expression but a difficult one to digest.
Soft indie band crying over spilt milk. Everything that was bad about the 90's exists here. Electronic renaisance - What is this rubbish it literally asualted my ears. Guitair style really grates for me as its a jolly strumming that just never ends or varies. typical of the genre and time. Best thing about this album is the album cover!
This is a pleasant sounding indie album that stands out amongst it's contemporaries for being more intimate and considered than I'd expect from the mid nineties. I don't think the album would turn many heads if it was released ten to fifteen years after it was but in context it is admirably original. It's a little sickly sweet and some lyrics are a tad too pretentious for my tastes but its a nice, if not ground-breaking, album nonetheless.
This album starts off incredibly strong. The back half is still good, even if not at the same level as the opening 4 tracks. I actively disliked Electronic Renaissance, otherwise I'd happily return to any of these songs.
Enjoyed it. No Arab strap though
Pleasant in places, dull in places. Straight down the middle then.
One of the toughest of their albums to get into as it generally lacks the catchy songs that they would go on to perfect. However, it is still a great listen with some beautifully written songs. Top Track: I Don’t Love Anyone
Catchy not complicated, simplicity done really well, and with their own unique vibe. Just something about it feels like a warm hug. This album has more of an upbeat vibe than some later stuff I’ve heard. So I’ll stick here and enjoy.
Did not enjoy it
I feel like this was slightly more upbeat than their other album on the list. Still a little too slow for me, but it is well made music. Just not something I would go back to. 2.5/5 Probably won't listen again
This is more varied than I would have anticipated from the first song. I like the songs with horns and appreciate the melodies.
Pretty boring but okay as music during another activity. 3 stars or C.
10/10
A good album, I liked You're Just A Baby, Electronic Renaissance, I Could Be Dreaming, I Don't Love Anyone and Mary Jo the most.
The music was happy with vignette stories. However on the first listen it didn't grab my attention. I expect it could on a different day though.
I'm not quite sure what I make of it. It's nice, peculiar in a good way. Low 3 I think
My favourite Belle & Sebastian
Better than their second album in my opinion
I like Belle & Sebastian in this preppy, peppy, low key energetic mode. They have great songwriting chops and even on this debut have a unique, instantly recognisable sound which is theirs alone and still intact today. My favourite of their records, Dear Catastrophe Waitress, amps up the silliness and theatricality in a way that I always crave elsewhere across their discography. I could always handle them being slightly more unhinged!
Belle and Sebastian in with another 4 for me, a lower one than If You’re Feeling Sinister which may have risen to a low 5 for me, going to re-evaluate now
should’ve paid a bit closer attention but liked it
I’m not totally studied on the history of alt pop but this feels ahead of its time. Fun to listen to but almost nothing jumped out at me. 3.5
Didn't have much of an impact on me either way. Album cover is awkward though
Plutôt sympa mais rien choquant
moauiiifff
La cover de salopard Un peu trop mou à mon goût mais bon mood
I think some later B&S albums are even better (Sinister, Arab Strap), but this still an amazing debut, and an easy five stars
This is outstanding. But not their best.
Belle and Sebastian were big on the “Juno” soundtrack which I listened to for some reason when the movie came out. Teenage angst music for gay kids? Songwriting is pretty good and some of the songs are catchy but it kind of seems like the same song 12 different ways. I didn’t hate it by any means but it’s nothing I’ll be coming back to. 2.5
2.0 Liked the titties, didnt like the songs
Belle and Sebastian was an integral part of my courtship with my partner. Their albums were on frequent rotation as we sipped wine and got to know each other. Twenty-five years and two kids later, we still both smile when we put them on. Sometimes nostalgia is an integral part of how we all experience music. This band makes music that makes me happy. Tigermilk is the debut album from the band with an origin story that is wild enough that Pitchfork made a documentary about it. Pop is not typically my main jam, but Belle and Sebastian grabbed me from the first time I stumbled across their music accidentally while attending a music festival shortly after its release. This album is full of catchy tunes with arrangements unique enough to be interesting. The lyrics are smart and often moving, sometimes witty, and the singing is gorgeous. Some have likened the music to a more upbeat version of The Smiths, which is apt. The entire album is remarkably cohesive, especially considering that it was recorded over three days at a time when the band was not even fully realized. It still holds up for me almost 30-years later. If you like this album and were previously unfamiliar, I strongly recommend it follow up, If You're Feeling Sinister, released shortly afterwards. 9/10. A great album, but the rating includes a personal bias bump because I love my wife more every day and this album reminds me of where it all began.
Fantastic album...love B&S. This one is honestly bangers front to back. 4.5/5
love B&S - not my favorite of their albums though
Inoffensive - not something I'd rush back to listen to but happy to have it on in the background
This is their debut album, but when it was first released in 1996, only 1,000 copies were pressed. It wasn’t until 1999 that a larger label picked it up and gave it a proper re-release. Overall, it’s classic chamber pop, and Belle and Sebastian are definitely one of the flag bearers for the genre.
Simon and Garfunkel for Fedora wearing Brits
103 Un día, chata de estar escuchando pura música que me carga en este challenge, decidí que iba a saltarme la lista de discos y poner este disco porque tenía hartas amigas a las que les gustaba esta banda y... meh. Sorry. Tuvo momentos entretenidos, no lo odio, pero...meh?
Oh yeah. What a treat. From the first note, absolute class.
was a good background album but found it boring
I liked it a lot
This was good. Chill and solid work.
112/1001 Belle and Sebastian - Tigermilk Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ❎ Twee Scottish indie is not the one.
One of my all time faves
Belle and Sebastian walked so Sufjan Stevens could run. There is a ton to like about this album and the more you listen to it the better it gets. “I Don’t Love Anyone” is a seriously underrated track. A great songwriter, Murdoch is not quite a strong enough singer to carry this off himself though. Very good, almost great.
youre such a baby baby girl
Sounds childish.
Twee as fuck and yet still one of my favourite albums. For the most part, this are simple vignettes set to a back beat that canters amiably behind the words. The exception is Electronic Renaissance, which is like being at a terrifying rave. If this album was a cardigan, it would have a front zip, leatherette elbow patches and pockets. It’s got couthy charm, loose arrangements and a massive debt to Donovan. Love it!
the state i am in- 5 expectations- 5 shes losing it- 5 youre just a baby- 5 electronic renaissance- 5 i could be dreaming- 5 we rule the school- 5 my wandering days are over-5 i dont love anyone- 5 mary jo- 5 ok
I wish I could die without hearing music of this nature ever again. I don't think it's technically bad, I just hate listening to it.
Sebastopol loves this
Suffers from being not quite as good as its successor. I like the opening track but the rest of the album never reaches the heights of Sinister
Comfy and well made.
Incredibly mid. Not unpleasant to the ear, but just very mediocre. 2.5/5
this had some good indie songs, had a very familiar sound which i liked, good band, i got another album of theirs today (i’m in album debt)
I LOVEEEEE The State I Am In. Ive gone to listen to this album multiple times but I just listen to that song a few times and stop. #tweesummer.
7/10- I don’t think I like belle and Sebastian’s music but whenever I listen to their music I’m like this is decent. And then I kind of enjoy it. I’m just confused, I don’t like their voice and I don’t really like their type of music yet I still enjoy it
Somehow even more twee than the other belle and Sebastian album
Ez
This is at least a bit interesting. Always band I read about but hadn’t heard. Or maybe I had heard them. 2.5 because I’m wavering.
Belle & Sebastain have been described as "the most sensitive band in indie rock, patron saints for daydreaming boys and girls". And there is a place for that, and they do it well. It's a cozy album, even if the cover is a little disconcerting. But is the unique selling point of this album the legend of its creation and its obscurity (at least initially). Is there really any reason that both this album and 'If You're Feeling Sinister' are on the list? Everyone seems to agree that Sinister is their masterpiece, but the story of Tigermilk is compelling. Personally, I find the listening experience basically interchangeable.
The weakest of Belle and Sebastian's stellar 1996 to 1999 output, but still fantastic. So packed full of wit, charm, and earnestness. Only weaker by comparison probably. 4 Heard before? Yes Owned: Yes 18/1001, 18/74 (24%) Will I get? Already have
It was fine... Little bit boring but not offensive. Album cover is the best bit
Pretty chill, falls off towards the end though.
I first came across Tigermilk aged 11 perusing the indie rock section of Rough Trade Records, the shapely breasts of the cover began my sexual genesis. I convinced my father to lend me 2 shillings and purchased this album. When I heard this lispy man with no Scottish accent mention Debenhams I entered a state of clarity and turned this crap off.
Wonderful band, wonderful album. The songs are beautifully crafted, gentle vocal melodies and easy acoustic guitars wrapped in layers of different arrangements. Each track feels warm and tender, like being pulled into a big, lovely hug.
The more I listen the more I like it. After giving it a chance I was pleasantly surprised in the end.
Pretty darn good. I’ve had plenty of exposure to B&S via friends/mixtapes/etc and always enjoyed it, but for whatever reason I’ve never bought anything by B&S. While listening to this album after work, it inspired my wife to dance around the kitchen and squeak a clown horn. I’m borderline 4 and 5 here, but a debut album being this good tips me over to 5.
Yay for Belle and Sebastian! I don’t know this one as well as some others but not surprisingly it’s great.
Really close to a 5, but didn’t quite get there by the end. Still a great album.
really good album had a really solid sound that unified the album. Would be a greeat album to just listen to. they really nailed the tone being a mix of melencoly sad but bright at times too.
Wow, who knew tables could be so catchy.
With my first listenings, I wasn't sure if I liked this album, but when I had the opportunity to sit down and calmly listen to it, I did enjoyed it quite a lot. This album is wonderful, sweet and filled with beautiful melodies, interesting lyrics with very positive messages for those who are abused (specially women) and rich instrumentation like multiple guitars, flutes, horns, piano, electronics, bells and more. If I had to pick the songs that I liked the most, I would choose 'Electornic Renaissance' for how different it is from the rest, 'We Rule the School' for its beautiful flute and 'My Wandering Days Are Over. Nevertheless, it goes without saying that I don't think there's a bad song in here. My only complain would be that the vocals feel a bit rough sometimes. It is hard to tell why, but I think it is because of how it was recorded and his sibilant voice.
Day638 - for such a boring album it sure make me angry for it to be on this last
3.3 I had an initial aversion to these even before listening but couldn't think why. After one listen I thought I'd do a bit of reading and realised it was because Jack Black's character in High Fidelity referred to them as "old sad bastard music" which somehow stuck with me for the last 25 years. Yet on second listen there was a bit to like - the more Nick Drake-esque the better..the first half of the album therefore hits slightly better, with the latter half a bit on the duller and OSB-side, so the album peters put slightly.
Len Houmous claims to have drunk 3 pints of Tigermilk after one of his famous acid trips at the zoo. Apparently it was the same night when he bedded both Belle and Sebastian! 4.5 5/10 Electronic Renaissance
Abundantly adequate.
Donovanesque at times, their LGB incorporated songs grew on me. The hooks dug a bit deeper the second time through. 3.5
3.5
It's kinda enjoyable. The vocals are just so wimpy, though...
For when you're feeling a little twee. Wonderful indie debut. It makes me smile.
I was listening to album in high school once and the cool kids found out. They gave me an atomic wedgie, broke my Walkman and force fed me the magnetic strip from this cassette as punishment. I turned my trauma from this experience into expressive art and now I am in my 8th year of art school. I couldn't be happier!
From limited pop culture references and context clues (ok, they were mentioned on an episode of How I Met Your Mother along with a clip of "We Rule The School"), I expected B&S to be a variation of quiet acoustic folk music. Upon listening to this, I'm pleasantly surprised to discover there's more to the story. It's not even just a duo of someone named Belle and someone named Sebastian! All of these songs were written by lead singer, Stuart Murdoch, and originally performed solo but they've been developed further to utilize a full band (including strings, brass, and woodwinds!). The album is much more indie rock than it is folk, and it's hard to imagine what the solo versions would have originally sounded like. I came in expecting Simon & Garfunkel, but got something more akin to a Paul Simon solo album. Without a specific nostalgic reason to love this album, I don't. It's fine, but it doesn't wow me and I'm not at risk of making this my whole personality. I understand there are more B&S albums on the list, so we'll see if my opinion changes after those. "Electronic Resistance" - feels like the biggest experiment on the album. It's a nice little New Wave bop nestled into the middle of the album and if I have to choose a favorite song, this would be it. "I Could Be Dreaming" - I felt a little crazy when the female spoken word part started fading in. It's like listening to a song with a police siren when you're in the car - except you're not looking for cops, you're looking for a schizophrenia diagnosis. "We Rule The School" - the song that formed my whole opinion of this band. It's pretty non-representative of the album/band, so I'm a little disappointed that HIMYM chose this song.
Really stuck on whether I prefer this or *If You're Feeling Sinister*, which was only a couple weeks ago in this project, but they're both excellent listens. fav tracks: Electronic Renaissance, Expectations, I Could Be Dreaming
Best Song: I Don't Love You Anymore I never heard of this band before and it was ok. The music is up my alley but I found it rather uninspired and dull. 3/5.
Solid 3 star. Funny album cover ngl
Very good
Impossible to rate neutrally. This is my second favorite Belle & Sebastian album in general but my favorite that has made the 1001 Albums list.
it was always surprising to me to hear B&S described as a cult classic because it was ubiquitous for the indie obsessed crowds i found myself in during the late 90s and early 00s. it is not at all surprising that this is the launch of that cult. it's really good the entire time and perfects chamber pop without feeling inauthentic
Ughhhhh I mean on the one hand, "they say you never go with boys and you are tight" was a lyric in a fanfic I read when I was like 12 and then I looked it up and found out it was by Belle & Sebastian and this was the kickoff of a core chunk of my pre-teen/teen personality, but on the other - this album overall is really slow for me as a whole and I don't enjoy it in one sitting. 2.5
3.5
not for me.
This started out pretty lovely but it never rise above that.
PRETTY BORING BUT *NOTICES BOOBIE* HUMINA HUMINA AWOOOOOOOGAAA NOM NOM NOM MUMMY MUMMY!!!! *ahem*....
She milk my tiger till I *EXTREMELY LOUD BUZZER* She belle on my seba*EXTREMELY LOUD BUZZER* She belle on my tiger till I mi*EXTREMELY LOUD BUZZER* Nothing album that I thought i reviewed, found out weeks later I hadn’t, and found to be merely passable on relisten. Probably more damning that I didn’t remember a single track from this.
Are you feeling sinister is a Masterpiece. So the opening track left a lot to be desired. But then the second track came on. Its complex and catchy albeit bordering on overproduction. This didnt last for long as I found the rest of the album pretty mediocre. This album exemplifies the taste and bias of the author for overproduced. But talk about an album which requires multiple listens. On subsequent run through I found myself adoring the opening track + some others. I listened to the lyrics a bit closer and found them to be quite moving. The second track really doesnt need the trumpets though. It genuinely detracts from an otherwise great song. 7/10
A really pleasant pop album. Some very clever lyrics and truly great composition especially on My Wandering Days Are Over, the cascading vocals and trumpet work so well together. I was surprised to read that the group had effectively formed during the recording of this album since it has such a clear direction with its sound and style. There are a couple of minor gripes I have about the album that aren't worth mentioning outside of justifying why I'm not giving this a 5. Supremely chilled, airy and very re-listenable. I am kicking myself for not listening to this much earlier. Highlights: The State I Am In, Expectations, My Wandering Days Are Over
Very pleasant but know amazing songs, and is maybe a little bland.
I can do twee if it's interesting but too much of this is a bit too slow.
I just. They're just. Isn't it so great
Belle and Sebastian have such a nice way of singing about some fairly dark stuff. The tunes are so lovely and simple and the instrumentation matches his voice so well. This one doesn't include a lot of the songs I personally like of their output, but it is a really great album to listen through.
Much more solid than I was expecting. I love the experimental use of electronics here and the overall song quality. 7/10
hated this a lot. don’t have anything good to say so I’ll leave it at that
I outgrew this vibe and can't get myself to go back :/
I used to be such an Indie girl but it just doesn’t have the same impact on me anymore.
Delightfully chill
whatever
Charming. The songs are well-crafted and the musicianship is good.
2.5
2.5
Gear: ZiiGaat x Hangout.Audio: Odyssey 2 Artwork: 🐯🍼🍉 Production: : 🔊📀⬇️ Music: 🥸💧🛌 Rating: 🚼🚼(🚼()/5
BOOOOOOO BORING!!!!
Not a bad album but I like their later work much better.
4/10
sicky sweet music for people who i love but would never give an aux cord to listen to while looking out of train windows
Wild album cover but the songs aren't half bad!
I like 'Tigermilk' as much as I liked 'If You’re Feeling Sinister' — which is exactly the problem.
Moody movie music from the 90s. Not my cup of tea, but it had some ok moments.
One of the greatest albums around. Listened to this non stop when it came out. The sound was fantastic for a Scottish band, fresh and original.
Not a huge fan…
I wasn't swept away but I liked it. It's a really specific style that doesn't always work for me, but it was still enjoyable. 3.5/4
Lovely stuff
Enjoyed that!
Surprisingly soothing and pleasant. Works formidably as background music when all you need is to relax.
Another Belle and Sebastian record? Really? I just heard one from the list. There are thousands of great bands out there yet Belle and Sebastian get multiple albums on this list?! This record was fine… maybe better than fine. Good. Kinda catchy in places and mostly pleasant (despite some dark lyrics). And maybe if I spent more time with it, it would grow on me more. But it just wasn’t anything special to warrant more than a 3.
10/10 you can’t go wrong with any Belle & Sebastian, it all works perfectly
Brilliant early album with knockout songs that established B&S as leader of a new movement of twee pop.
I liked the sound of it and will listen again
Unlike the overly represented series of “we’ve never heard of you” UK bands we have had on this countdown, this band actually has talent and constructed a good album. There’s an early Mumford and Sons, Of Monsters and Men feel in this record which I dug. The signing is passable, not great. The musicality of the album makes up for that though, and the lyrics are decent. I really liked that the guitars were a bit harder than many which focus on a lot of acoustic playing. I see this band compared to Nick Drake, which I get to an extent, but the sound here is so much more full and complete, with a much better song construction. This was definitely worth the listen. I quite liked it.
I wasn't quite sure what to expect with this album based on the cover and band name. I felt I should probably know Belle and Sebastian, but I think I confused them with a different set of artists, as this was very different to what I thought it would be. It sounded a tiny bit like Neutral Milk Hotel (definite "milk theme" there?), and on that basis alone, I'm going with four stars. Maybe the milk was a little more watery than I would have liked, but "milk is milk" as the saying goes. I found the album never really goes anywhere; there's a slight change midway, then back to gentle indie with mumbly vocals. It's a pleasant journey nevertheless.
Almost an absolutely perfect album. Made my depression disappear for 40 minutes. Beautiful.
Not my thing, feels a little uninspired to me.
04/09/2025 I don't know how i feel about this, nothing piques my interest. Spotify listeners: 1.2 million
Ok
Great music of it's time 👐
I don’t even know how to really describe this is just so good
i liked it thiiis much
There was nothing in this album that made it for me, but it wasn't bad.
This feels harsh as i do like Belle and Sebastian, and they’re nice songs but idk maybe I just wasn’t in the mood for twee pop. I wasn’t in a Pixar film this afternoon 2.3/5.0 Best Song: She’s Losing It
Very nice album, but not their best IMHO. Some obvious standouts, but I don't love this album loads. The State i am in might be there best ever song though? And there is some stiff competition there. 3.8/5
Fav song: electric renaissance I don’t love the singer’s voice tbh. The instrumentation itself is good but not insanely good. Like a cross between Wilco, panchiko, and built to spill if they were all less good. I pinkie swear these reviews will be more detailed later..
Feels like a burned cd you’d find in your parents stuff, listen to once and think wait, that's actually pretty good and then never listen to it ever again. Stylistically like a cross between 60s British psych rock, jangle pop, and folk rock. Totally listenable, but other bands do aspects of their sound way better. Just kinda boring Standout tracks: The State I Am In, I Don’t Love Anyone, Electronic Renissance (only because it's pretty bad) 1.5/5 deserves to be on this list
Bangin
J'aime ça à moitié. Un 3 bien assis.
I prefer their second and third albums, If You're Feeling Sinister, and The Boy with the Arab Strab, but I can hear their humble beginnings of what later would define their sound. Stuart's literate, melancholy songwriting and the band's gentle indie pop sensibilities are all there, just not as fully formed or well-produced yet. Songs as "Electronic Renaissance" are not to be memorised, but there are definitely some jewels on this album, like the openings track "The State I'm in " and "She's Losing It" and "I Could Be Dreaming". Unfortunately, the production doesn't sound very clear, it's quiet muddy, and it effects the songs. 3/5
Helt greit, omtrent akkurat sånn æ forventa at det skulle høres ut, på ingen måte fornærmanes, men heller ikke veldig interessant. Garantert et tilfelle av "day late, dollar short", tror æ hadde likt det om æ hadde begynt å høre på Belle & Sebastian da det va stort, men det interesserte mæ ikke så veldig da (kanskje mest fordi æ va litt vrang) og det interessere mæ ikke så veldig nu (fordi æ har anna musikk som ligne æ like bedre).
3.5.
not bad
It’s strange - this debut feels more alive to me than If You’re Feeling Sinister, even though that one gets all the critical praise. If Tigermilk had been my introduction to Belle & Sebastian, I might have been more forgiving toward their later work. There’s a rawness here that hints at something special, but for me, their sound still leans too far into the bland and understated. I can appreciate what they’re going for, but it never quite clicks.
Not coffee, not tea
weird lyrics
Chillaxed to a fault, but a nice album with occasional glimpses of greatness. Keen to revisit at a later date.
This blended into fairly pleasant background music for me
I really like some BS. Maybe the standout discovery of this list for me. Not quite up there with the one we’ve had already, but still enjoyed it. Simpsons: Yes
Not as good as cow milk but probably better than oat milk.
I thought I'd like this more as I usually like Belle & Sebastian but it was just alright.
37/1089 it’s a nice chill vibe that i find very easy to listen to, it’s very reminiscent of 60s folky music and that’s the era i’d probably have guessed it to be from if i didn’t know Electronic Renaissance and I Could Be Dreaming are the clear standouts to me, they are the two that feel like they most elevate the style to a new level 3 stars or 71/100
Very cozy and relaxing
Me encanta Belle & Sebastian y aunque este es uno de sus álbumes más icónicos, prefiero otros como the life pursuit. Los he visto un par de veces en directo y me parecen un grupo que transmite muy buen rollo
Transports me back to my youth.
I remember being 18 and playing this album over and over on a burnt CD
I was optimistic early on, but it just never got there
This is my first listen to this work. I hear this album has been compared with works by Nick Drake, but I'm not hearing that in most tracks, I Could Be Dreaming is the exception. This feels way more upbeat than his works and feels way more electronic (typed this while listening to Electronic Renaissance, later songs perhaps less so). I'm enjoying it, but not sure it is a triumph of music. The background monologues got really annoying and didn't add much to the songs. Were they going for a Pink Floyd-esque feeling? If so, they missed the mark and just had me pausing to make sure no one was talking to me from another room. Overall, I found it pretty but forgettable.
Kan manden ikke synge eller lader han bare som om han ikke kan???
This took a few attempts to get into but once I found the right mood and weather it really hit me at how thoughtful and heartfelt it is
I’m not usually one to judge an album by its cover but in this case, come on, what were they thinking? I don’t care how arty and black & white it is, it’s still a topless woman pretending to breast feed a stuffed toy tiger. Once you get past this, the music is largely inoffensive folky, pop with one weirdly out of place electro dance number.
You can feel the craftmanship, how they carved their songs. But the result is unfortunately inoffensive and bland.
This is the hundred ninety ninth album I’m rating. I really only know this from the album cover. Adding to my Playlist - The State I Am In, Expectations, She’s Losing It, You’re Just a Baby, Electronic Renaissance, I Could be Dreaming, We Rule the School, My Wandering Days are Over, I Don’t Love Anyone, and Mary Jo. Not Adding to my Playlist - Nothing. All in all I liked 10/10 songs. Some of the gayest folk ever.
I love my twee Scots.
Basically Coldplay before Coldplay. This is not a compliment. But there are two songs on here that are pretty good so I’ll bump it up a star for that (You’re Just a Baby and Electric Renaissance).
Stuart’s lisp will be forever charming to me
*1996. Alt rock. *Boring, quiet. *Listened as background music while I was reading. That worked. RATING - 5/10
Not bad, good jams. I wouldn't mind hearing the album again, but I'm not rushing to remember to pull it up specifically, which makes it a 3 instead of a 4 for me.
Singer songwriter dude
I’m not sure what to really say but this album is really boring. I just kind of want to fall asleep while listening to this album. Favorite Tracks: The State I’m In Rating: 2.5/5
This was good, needs another listen I think
Pleasant indie folk rock.
Nice little pop album. Not hyper processed. Songs all are good. Some decent variety here, very good variety for an album that's just over 40 minutes long.
I know the band name, but can't say I've ever given them any time. There were on a bunch of late 90's compilation cd's I had but no songs ever stuck with me. Decent # of listens to "the State I Am In", She's Losing It" and what I assume is their lone hit from this album, "Expectations" (I'd never heard it, but got old Kinks vibes from it). His voice leaves a lot to be desired, flat and sleepy. He sounds like a guy at Open Mike Night. It sounded like 90's folk to me with a Kinks influence, linda cheery and light but short on jams or hooks. Not really my sound and now I know why I breezed over them back in the day. It was 10 songs that all sounded very similar.
Now I'm a man who likes a random trumpet in his songs, and I'd hate to risk that. But this was ok. Perfectly fine. It kept making me feel like this was an attempt to be Simon and Garfunkel, but just a bit more bold. Like music your grandpa would put on in an attempt to seem cool, and before he put it on he'd talk about how these guys really rock. You'd humor him, but he was cool for trying and caring, not because of this band.
Nice enough but none of songs were very memorable and I didn’t really connect with his vocals
I LOVE THIS ALBUM, it has curveballs like electronic renaissance and tender moments like Expectations (and most of the album). Teenage Harry is dancing, being reminded how to feel. Every listen I find some new little detail, I love the layered lyrics and composition. Obviously a 5/5
I appreciated tbe storytelling in the lyrics, but the music felt like it all blended into one. I enjoyed I Could. E Dreaming as one of the few songs which felt like it went somewhere… but overall, not an album I think I’ll revisit.
It's very easy listening. It sounds the exact same as Donovan. Vocals almost the same. I prefer Donovan. There better be Donovan albums on this list
Halfway through i let out a big sigh. A sigh of discontent. At this stage in my life, I have no use for this album. I have never had a use for this album in my life, and I don't think I ever will
6/10 - nice easy listening, classic belle & sebastian vocals and sounds
I like Belle and Sebastian as a band (but I do feel like their lyrics got weirder and more fun in later albums). A solid debut album that’s a perfect little indie pop moment. Expectations and She’s Losing It were the standout tracks for me
This was a background music album - not distracting and not objectionable. But also not memorable- I can’t recall a single song from it a day later. At best a 3 star.
A classic case of not judging a book by its cover. Don't get the album art but the sound is nice
Decent listen
It's not a bad album by any means but it doesn't do anything new or exciting
Nice working music but didn’t blow my mind
🎵 Day 27 / Belle & Sebastian – Tigermilk (1996) 🗯 A cult favourite, but this one didn’t hit me where it counts. I know it’s a lauded debut, but for me Tigermilk felt like little more than sonic wallpaper. Pleasant, nice, well-written, inoffensive — all the things Belle & Sebastian do well — but here, nothing really stands out to my ears. I like Belle & Sebastian a lot (I’ve got a few of their albums on vinyl), but this one pales next to what they’d go on to do later. It’s the shy first step — delicate and diary-like — but missing the sparkle, wit or standout songwriting that would come to define them. Respect it? Yes. Return to it? I’m not rushing to. Verdict: Good, not essential For fans of: The Smiths, Camera Obscura, art school crushes and soft-spoken sadness on a Sunday
The Good: Milk, it does a body good! The Bad: Turns out tigermilk is some kind of instrument… The Ugly: the album cover… This is my second B&S album I’ve seen on the list, and I do hope this is the last. I’ve done the math, and with 1001 albums to go through since the 1950s, it means roughly 140 albums per decade… which is 14 per year… That’s a lot of albums if you think about it. So, what did I think about Tigermilk? Not much, to tell the truth. It was okay. It didn’t ruin my day, like some other albums tend to do. But I was more interested in figuring out what a tigermilk instrument looks like, and then I couldn’t stop looking at the boobies of B&S founder, which led me into a whole retrospective about me getting older and becoming a dirty old man… The few B&S fans that I know are all wimps… and that is the best way I can describe this music: whimpy. At least goths are scary… 2*
this seems like a good band if they had different singers. There's something good here but the vocals always toss me. Kind of gives me a Jack johnson or Donovan Frankenreiter vibe but a decade and some early.
Tough album to review. On one hand I loved it musically. On the other hand I did not enjoy it lyrically or vocally. So I guess it’s a 3? Fine
This wouldn't feel out of place releasing in 2010. The album peaks at Expectations and then kinda coasts. A worthwhile listen, a 3.
Surprisingly enjoyable album, short and snappy with no songs I was pining to skip. Expectations, She’s Losing It, and Electronic Renaissance I could all see getting added to a playlist. Carries a Wes Anderson vibe I could see turning people away — but the layered sounds are too pleasant to hate on the value of being “hipster” to me.
I cannot stand these guys. Just a bunch of noise at 500 hz and above, tuneless meandering with pretty instrumentation.
banal
little vignettes of peculiarly british, often mundane and always disturbing experiences wrapped in twee bouncy music which somehow makes the whole thing comforting.
It’s ok. Bit confused by this, having never heard them before. Seemed quite pleasant but then noticed felt nothing memorable or outstanding. 90s indie rock with heavy folky vibe. Not sure what differentiates this from whole host of others though, except the british-centric lyrics. Im English and I think there's an over representation on this list, and as for Scotland a country of around 5 million, they have a lot of acts on here that are not exactly innovators, I have had 2 just this week. 3 Star its just ok, just after a few more listens that ok is quite enjoyable but still don’t know it should be on the list 3.5 stars
Very somber and lyrically focused which is not my usual tone not in taste but as a current regularity listen but I throughly enjoyed it . The lyrical focus reminds me of not a very talented voice but an admired artist bob dylan !
Some of this was decent, but not anything really worth returning to. I don't really think I'd consider this pop music, but it is probably better that way. 3/5
Isn’t this that coffee chain? Perhaps the cover is featuring one of the baristas (or baristos; it’s 2025 you asshat) breastfeeding their new catfish. Haters will say it’s a stuffed animal and even if it wasn’t, you can’t breastfeed a fish. Well I say you don’t understand how high we can fly. Get enough edibles in me and I, a pudgy cis male can give birth to a pygmy hippopotamus. You’ll never understand the power of the mind. Anyway. Here’s Tigermilk. The State I Am In - Arkansas uhhh Missouri uhhh things your couch might say uhhh Oregon *DING DING DINNG* YEAHHHHHH. Oh buddy. I’m going to like this one. Not because he’s introducing his child bride to alcohol, you sicko, but because it’s soft indie with nice songwriting. Expectations - What a jaunty lil tune. Sorry “chune.” I thought this was English, but my ancestors just screamed in terror as these plucky youngsters are fae Glasgow. This is another very very nice song and if I can shoehorn some in unnecessary nationalism in there as well? It’s a good day. She’s Losing It - Almost reggae. Oh god. This is too Jason Mraz to start. The lyrics are interesting, and the I actually kind of like the horns. They remind me of Neutral Milk Hotel. The first “meh” song. You’re Just a Baby - Listen, I know you want to drive my Pontiac Aztek, Ethan but you’re 3 years old. The second you got that faux-leather steering wheel in your grubby little mitts, I could see the flashes in your eyes. I can see the visions of making a particularly wide right turn due to the poor turning radius of that whale-esque frame. I can picture you waiting for the news at the mechanic that the Aztek has had most of its parts recalled. A powerful vision, but E. You’re just a baby. Leave the motoring to the big boys (me). Now hand me my driving hat. And put down that socket wrench. Uhh a decent song. Electronic Renaissance - Cooler than anything Daft Punk has ever done in less than a minute. Congratulations. The sounds are quite nice here. Suffering a little bit from repetition syndrome but overall, a minor case. Jolly good show! I Could Be Dreaming - This song is beautiful. Such interesting instrumentation and a subtly beautiful melody. Very of the time, but a pinnacle of the ideas attempted at that time. All this writing and I COULD be dreaming about a new pope deciding to overhaul the hat etiquette and ushering in a new offshoot of Catholicism that is entirely based on how ornate your hats can be. Always the type of dream I wake up from in a cold sweat. We Rule the School - I would imagine. As a kid often picked last in my impressionable youth, imagine if I got to go play sports against 4th graders now?? I’d mop the floor with those dorks. A nice song. Gentle. Engaging. Good work. My Wandering Days Are Over - This is as good a time as any to say that the lyrics on this album have been great. So odd and intriguing. I don’t even need lyrics to mean anything in particular. It helps. But if you have phrasing that sticks, or words that spur thought when placed together, I’m a happy fella. This is a good one. I Don’t Love Anyone - what a journey. Buddy doesn’t love Christmas. Nothin. Waking up on a Saturday and thinking for a split second that you have work, but then remembering it’s Saturday? Buddy doesn’t even love that. Cold as ice. But then, he loves his family? What a cop out. Mary Jo - Ankther beautiful melody. This harkens back directly to 60’s “chamber pop.” I think. God I might start saying “twee” if I get carried away here. Better rein it in. Yeah this song was uhhh bitchin’. Wow. Alright! Yeah! HELL yeah!! Woooo. Yeah! Uh huh! Ok!! Alright! Woo! Alright everybody. Settle down. Listen. This was an album that I will absolutely return to. I imagine the enjoyment will grow upon repeated listens. This was excellent. Gentle atmosphere with excellent songwriting, fantastic lyricism and an eye to the future with two feet firmly entrenched in the influences of the past. Belle and Sebastian surpass the similarly named coffee brand in both quality and enjoyability. Oh shit! I’ve got to feed that Pygmy hippo. And restock on edibles. Can you wait here and hold my ornate crown and sceptre? You’re a life saver. 4 HIGHLIGHTS: The State I Am In, Expectations, I Could be Dreaming, My Wandering Days are Over, Mary Jo
Kinda fun. Listened through. Not likely to go back you idiot.
This is a pleasant surprise, I kind of knew I needed to listen to Belle & Sebastian more, but just never got around to it, and I liked this a lot. It comes across as really earnest and vulnerable. A lot of these songs are kind of low fidelity, and the sound here is sort of baroque and pleasant, and I think it makes this album come across as small, and I don't mean it in a bad way. Like this is very intimate and personal feeling and this even comes through in the lyrics, like the content here is serious, but never crushing to the listener, with a lot of these songs focusing on little day to day sadnesses and embarrassments and some victories too. I also noticed that on a lot of these songs, the vocals sound *very* similar to Nick Drake, and I think it works here. It serves as a good stylistic complement to the songwriting and aesthetics on display here. And speaking of the songwriting, I like a lot of these songs a lot. Expectations, The State I Am In, She's Losing It, We Rule The School and Mary Jo are some highlights here, but most of the material works very well. I'd also like to acknowledge Electronic Renaissance which is one of the only real stylistic departures here, and its kind of warm, analogue synth sound fits in well here, it isn't as jarring as it should be and is actually one of my favorite songs. Overall, this is a really great collection of alternative pop songs. It feels like a lot of attention to detail went into this album, and the sound is just extremely warm and pleasant and earnest, it's kind of like a really heavy blanket, and I'm into it.
Folky, dreamy 90s pop rock. Reminds me of the soundtrack to a quirky indie film. I am not sure of the timeline of this genre of music however I can see this album being the inspiration for a lot of the same style of music that became very popular in the mid to late 2000s and early 2010s. The album itself is so inoffensive you could play this anywhere for anyone. That does hurt it's memorability though as it doesn't provide definitive aspects to latch on to.
The first five tracks on this album are damn-near perfect. The second half is a bit less memorable but still fantastic.
so nice, calm it had a great effect on me, it made me focus more on emotional part of myself i forgot the outside world, my fast thoughts and focused just on those long ones… those that are connected with emotions those that i (maybe we) should listen to more often!
"The State I'm In" is a great track and was rightfully ranked by pitchfork on their "best of the 90s" list. I enjoyed "Expectations" even more. Off to a great start! If You're Feeling Sinister seems to be the better album by this group, however.
Lekker ontspannen albumpie
Cool 90's singer songwriter album, 3,5/5
Pretty alright
Jao dosta tih loših albuma pliiiz. 1/5, 1/10
2.5 giving it a 3 since you gave it a 2, really forgetable idk what they were doing with this album, i think one good song else was shit
Not really my thing but I enjoyed some of it. Even saved a song.
kolejna pozycja od ulubionej popowej grupy szkocikow, tym razem ich debiutancki krazek tigermilk, dobre lore za tytulem, bo po kawalku ktory mial byc na albumiku, a jednak nie dojechal do koncowego traklista, no i szykowna okladka z tym co tygryski lubia najbardziej, ta pani jeszcze na jakims epku miala swoj udzial, plyta z 96, 10 trakow na 40 minutach, na tym krazku tylko wokal od pana murdocha, pani isobel tylko brzdaka na wiolonczelii, odczucia podobne jak do tych z if you are feeling sinister, ale z tym ale, ze nie ma tutaj tego wokalu zenskiego ktory fajnie zmienial tempo genialnego storytelingu jaki jest na obu albumach, tutaj troche bardziej randomowo bez konceptu, ale jak na pierwszy projekt nagrany w kilka dni, to nadal historie sa wciagajace jakby ktos opowiadal je obok ciebie, a nie nagrywal na popowy albumik, fajnie bylo sobie przypomniec o tym bandzie i przy okazji tigerowegomilka sprawdzic jeszcze kilka innych pozycji z ich dyskografii, bo maja ja naprawde bogata, na plejke dodaje openingowy the state im in, expectations oraz my wondering days are over i i dont love anyone, randomowe traki na randomowym albumik z randomowej listy, a tak daja do samorefleksji, nie daje takiej ocenki jak poprzedniej plycie, bo jednak poziom instrumentalny na sinisterze byl zdecydowanie wyzszy, ale i tak dobry albumik debiutowy
Forgettable.
Typical hipster shit, not bad. 6/10
I really adore this record. Whilst I think there are better Belle & Sebastian albums (this was only their debut after all) I do think there is something quite special about this one. There's some wonderful songwriting here and you can hear the influence of Nick Drake in particular on some of these tracks. Just a lovely listen from start to finish.
Boring
this was a good listen!! very Stone Roses esque throughout but definitely not a bad thing
Mediocre it just had nothing that gripped me
Top song: she’s loving it
There's a lovely low key intimacy present, like a bard or a sage telling you a secret fable in a hushed voice over a gentle acoustic backing. Comparisons to Donovan and Nick Drake seem inevitable but Stuart Murdoch's voice and tone reminds me of Peter Daltry, from the 60s UK psych band Kaleidoscope. Although it's fairly twee and whimsical music the lyrics are often darkly poetic and that is a nice contrast. And there's a vibrant splash of colour added via trumpet, violin and cello. All in all this is well crafted music right up my avenue.
Mellow vibes
Really enjoyed tgis mellow and sweet.
Always struck me as somewhat effete and insubstantial and re-listening today hasn't convinced me otherwise. Mostly just bland and annoying.
Wonderful, light happy daytime music.
I'd been meaning to give this album a listen many years ago, but never did. It's very mellow and fluffy, nothing offensive, but equally nothing really excited me.
all in all, I really enjoyed this. I'm more familiar with later Belle & Sebastian but this is clearly the start of their later magic. I found it more inconsistent than their later stuff but still good. Best track: She's Losing It Worst track: Mary Jo
meh.
Tigermilk - Belle and Sebastian The opening track was good not great but interesting enough to get my full attention so was the second track and all the rest of the tracks because they basically sounded like the same song over and over again. I got another album by this band that I liked better on here a few months- sorry I can't recall the title. The vocals are a bit annoying and difficult to tell if it's a guy or girl singing. I don't know I can't imagine ever listening to this album ever again, but it wasn't horrible, so I guess two stars. I wish I had gotten a Dinosaur Jr. album.
Would be good for someone 'moving to the city' montage in a film but that's about it.
1.75
Never heard this album, guessing by the number of times these songs have been played, not many other have heard of Belle & Sebastian. Just average songs here. Nothing to really get excited about... Not bad, but nothing stands out here.
I generally love the indie/folk-ish stuff, but I just find his voice so boring. 3/5
Enjoyed large parts of this but cant see myself ever returning
🥛
me & sebastian
One of my dumbest life choices has been failing to listen to Belle and Sebastian more before this
Not a bad Indie Pop album. I have never listened to it before. It didn't really draw me in, but I will listen to this one again.
A lovely run of albums with another classic for a long-term indie darling.
interesting, should relisten
Their debut album. Indie Pop. This is twee. Almost offensive by how inoffensive this album is. It's nice easy listening if you're having a quiet Sunday. Folky, Pop, Indie with a cardigan on. An average album, some nice harmonies. A little toe tap here and there. Electronic Renaissance is a decent track. I Don't Love Anyone is also pretty good.
Litt spacea og masete altså
nice.
I bought this album rather late in the day as a vinyl re-release. Despite its occasional bout of twee-ness (not unexpected given the band's name derived from the kind of kids' broadcasting from 1960s BBC), I think this is a strong debut album of confessional type songs. It benefits from not just being a singer-songwriter effort, with a proper band playing.
Not bad just not really my type of music
Meh
Almost a 2 for me. Easy album to space out on for me, though that's not saying a lot..
This is one my favorite albums of all time.
Pleasant and dreamy pop rock songs. It's fine, it just kinda washed over me and that was that. I gave it a second listen and again nothing really struck me or moved me. Just not for me. 3 stars
It was ok, I don't really enjoy this group but it's not that bad. Just not for me.
Belle and Sebastian were already one of my faves, so I really enjoyed this album
Very good, nice to hear again after years - all of their albums have a few weaker songs though, weirdly.
It’s a good for a debut and really it just does what a debut should: set up for an even better follow-up.
Pretty standard indie rock it’s solid
If it bangs, it bangs. Good ass album if you ask me
Floyd’s blonde so his 4/5 doesn’t count
I really enjoyed the start of this album it was absolutely lovely. The State I am in and She's Losing it were both fun. On "You're Just A Baby" they went full like early beach boys knockoff with the creepiness included and then after that it fell off a little but there were still some good songs. Overall cool album
I'm surprised this album made it in over the others. It felt like they were still finding their feat with this and the last track was a nod towards what was to come.
I’ve always felt like I should hate Stuart Murdoch’s voice but iI don’t. I love his lyrical and musical sense. It always takes me at least 4-5 listens for any given Belle and Sebastian song to really sink in, but then they stick with me. This album less than others, but still a solid debut.
Though I always think of this band as "fey" or "precious," they also are really enjoyable, literate, and melodic. I like the little slices of Scottish school age/young adult life and Stuart Murdich is a fine songwriter.
I forget how good this band's output in the 90s and early 2000s is. Great debut, low budget but you'd never really know it, gorgeous arrangements and harmonies. Standout tracks for me are Shes Losing It and I Could Be Dreaming. Call them twee, call them precious, but its hard to deny their continued influence on indie pop/folk. Also clearly influenced by some groups i love, from Simon and garfunkel to Yo La Tengo
I like the later disco pop more than the twee folk
Good, not great. Catchier than I was expecting.
klang ziemlich weichgespült
Nette Indie-Musik. 3 Sterne im positiven Sinn. Electric Renaissance ist für mich herausgestochen
generic boring indie where pretty much nothing happens and every song is the same. Electronic Renaissance is fun though
Surprisingly good, I would listen to it again.
Das Debütalbum der schottischen Band Belle and Sebastian entstand im März 1996 im Ca Va Studio in Glasgow. Die Gruppe, gegründet von Stuart Murdoch und Stuart David, nahm die zehn Songs innerhalb weniger Tage auf – mit Unterstützung ihrer Landsleute Stevie Jackson (Gitarre), Chris Geddes (Keyboards), Richard Colburn (Schlagzeug), Isobel Campbell (Cello), Mick Cooke (Trompete) und Joe Togher (Violine). Der musikalische Stil bewegt sich im Bereich Indie‑Pop mit deutlich kammerpop‑ähnlichen Arrangements. Die schottische Herkunft der Musiker prägt den Klang durch eine zurückhaltende, melancholische Grundstimmung kombiniert mit verspielten Instrumentierungen wie Cello, Geige und Trompete. Zu den bekanntesten und stilprägenden Songs zählen „The State I Am In“, das mit erzählerischer Dichte und sanftem Aufbau überzeugt, „Expectations“ mit seinem leicht beschwingten Gitarrenriff, „We Rule The School“ sowie das minimalistisch-elektronische „Electronic Renaissance“ – letzteres als einzige Ausnahme, ursprünglich als Demo entstanden. Die Produktion fällt bewusst sparsam und intim aus. Die Aufnahmen sind lebendig, ohne Überproduktion, und lassen den erzählerischen Gesang Murdochs sowie die filigranen Instrumentaldetails klar zur Geltung kommen. Die Texte handeln oft von Jugend, Unsicherheit und Identität und vermitteln durch Murdochs zurückhaltende Stimme persönliche Einblicke. Insgesamt wirkt Tigermilk durch seine nüchterne Produktion, die schottische Indie-Wurzeln und die Kombination aus erzählerischer Tiefe und kammerpop-Elementen ausgewogen und ein präziser Auftakt für Belle and Sebastian. Eine überzeugende Debütleistung, die mit ihrem zurückhaltenden Charme und musikalischem Feingefühl klar den Weg für das künstlerische Profil der Band weist.
This is much better. I really like Belle and Sebastian, as their music is like a sweet candy of indie-pop that you can savor for 40 minutes at a time. I don't always know what their songs are about, but I do know I enjoy the songs. As described in other reviews, the music is very cloying and I can see how it would not be someone's favorite kind of music. Still, I really enjoy it and if I have to listen to 45 different versions of the same electronica music then I should also get a Belle and Sebastian album as well. My favorite tracks are pretty much every single one. I often hear a song start out and am not sure I will like it, then it turns out the chorus is catchy and the music gets my foot tapping. A mid-90's gem of indie music.
Has some good moments, but overall unremarkable
The songwriting on "Tigermilk" really missed the mark for me. The lyrics often feel forced and awkward, like they were cobbled together in a rush. And the vocals? They sound like they were recorded in someone’s bedroom, with the singer trying not to wake anyone up. FFS, a bit more confidence and dedication would have gone a long way! It’s a shame because there’s potential here, but it just didn’t deliver.
Why is it is Belle and Sebastian and not Stuart and Stuart?
A very interesting vocal delivery that I can only compare to Sufjan Stevens, I have no other reference for this group. Nothing was really grabbing my attention until “Electronic Renaissance”. Thats an amazing song and I wish there was more on this album that sounded like it. I also enjoyed the vocal melody of “We Rule The School”. Outside of that, there wasn’t much for me here. Didn’t hate it, just wasn’t for me
Interesting and chill
Two stars instead of one because this astonishingly anticipates so much twee precious white feely feels music of the aughts. Two stars and no more because I loathe this shit, from the cover art on down. To be fair there are some actually good tunes, and the story of its genesis is impressive, but I loathe this kind of aren’t I being special and so strangely narcissistic but beautiful? Eww.
Nice!
Good.
Quite boring album
3.5 stars
Unique and interesting alt rock sound. Vocals are unusual but not bad
Wonderful memories
Não gosto nao...
4/5 am i being generous?
Belle & Sebastian; this is how I got to Isabelle Campbell without really listening to them. At the time they were the darlings of the Indie music scene. 1. "The State I Am In" 4:57 - excellent opening. Opens slow, then into a mid temp acoustic strum. Nice organ and dynamics. 4* 2. "Expectations" 3:34 - Double bass. Oooh brass! Nice. Mid temp strumming again. 3* 3. "She's Losing It" - 2:22 - Cute. Nice Nashville guitar flourishes. Love the brass, more prominent than "Expectations". 4* 4. "You're Just a Baby" - 3:40 - A whiff of Velvet Underground. Organ is nice. Good rolling guitar line. Vocals aren't grabbing me. This is a nice, pleasant listen so far. 3* 5. "Electronic Renaissance" 4:50 - Odd electronic intro, out of keeping with the album so far. Oh , some Accordion! Trying to be edgy towards the end. 3* 6. "I Could Be Dreaming" 5:56 - Atlantic "Sam and Dave" styled intro but then the muted, droning, vocals. The vocals really needed to go somewhere and they didn't. This is a little one paced now. Lacks dynamics. Is it the mix? Because the guitar at the end is rocking. Oh here come the dynamics, lift off? Not really. All nice and pleasant. 3* 7. "We Rule the School" 3:27 - Excellent Piano intro. Suites the vocals. Nice melody. Ahh there's Isabelle Campbell. Best track so far. I really like this. Oh that Flute, beautiful. Echoes of CSN and "Our House". Best rack so far. 5*. 8. "My Wandering Days Are Over" 5:25 - Nice harmonies. Strumming is back but so is a beautiful brass melody. 3* 9. "I Don't Love Anyone" 3:56 - Quirky. A bit more up tempo. Nice vocal hook. 3* 10. "Mary Jo" 3:30 - Nice flute intro, then into a late 60s influenced strum. Nice vocal melody. 3* In isolation, each song is pleasant enough. The vocals lack dynamics and range. This has all the elements that I should like but doesn't quite get me to where I won't to go. It peaks my interest but then doesn't quite fulfil. I can understand why the had/have the following they do. Would I listen again? - Perhaps Would I buy the album - No!
I like the first few songs but it gets old quickly for me. Favorites are Expectations and She's Losing It
Sonically a fun listen. Songwriting and vocals are meh. Shitty neutral milk hotel.