Tigermilk

Les pièces de Belle & Sebastian pourraient bien nous parvenir des années 1970, mais elles n'en ont pas le maniérisme. Leurs arrangements intemporels ne les font pas paraître modernes, mais les tirent hors de la nostalgie pour leur conférer une identité et une efficacité propres

I’m not a fan of the lazy enunciation and low-energy vocals. Makes it sound like the singer is bored and uninterested. The band arrangements are pretty decent. Some of them are even catchy. They are trying a lot of different sounds.

Yeah definitely enjoyed this album.

Well, these are just pleasant little twee-ish pop songs, aren't they?

Just had another Belle & Sebastian album a few days ago and enjoyed that one -- I liked this one too! Cool indie vibe

Feel like this would be good to leisurely kayak to.

Better than the other Belle & Sebastian album I’ve heard, but still a little too cutesy emo for my taste.

Love it, great bass playing. Also sounds a bit like TV Girl?

3/5

man i feel like such a hipster piece of shit every time i listen to belle and sebastian because god damn i do really like their music. this album reminds me a lot (in more ways than one) of a twee 90s version of donovan, which feels very much up my alley. they're just really pleasant, charming songs with solid production. a nice time to listen to. is it my favorite music of all time? no. but do i like it? yeah...

I wasn't ready to listen that album, it seems at first that the man singing was whispering instead of clearly expressing himself but the music became louder over each song. It's not unpleasant to listen but I felt no energy from it. I can understand people who will listen to it but I honnestly am not a big lover of this type of music.

Very pleasant - washes over me

Lovely and sweet, without being cutesy. Artistically it's so unique, but also not really that interesting for me.

3 pretty decent indie album

Up until about 2005 I genuinely thought that Belle and Sebastian had figured it out, that they were the one band people would obviously enjoy, if not love. Still kind of crazy to me that that’s not the case, especially with their early stuff in mind, but apparently it is.

Cool sound

I didn't really much care for this at all. I thought I would, but I didn't.

This is one of my all time favorite albums and the uncontrollable glee I felt when it popped up only reaffirmed that. Such catchy tunes that have a sort of timeless indie sound. Knowing the backstory of the album, which was essentially funded by a public Scottish arts fund for out of work musicians, only adds to its genius because of how improbable its existence is. My favorites as always were "The State I Am In" (which amazingly endures as one of their best songs despite being the very first song on their very first album), "Expectations," and "Electronic Renaissance."

Their music always seems to grow on me massively after more listens, i except this one will too. Still loved it on first try anyway, their style of folk/indie rock is instantly catchy.

7/10…indie pop / britischer indie

Listened on the back of a motorcycle through mountains. Very nice moment. I like the spaciness of the sounds at points and the liberal use of flute.

The sharp ‘S’s took me out immediately. The songs all kind of blur together…

Nice chill background music

Was not liking this at all. Maybe it’s because I had a terrible day on top of it but this just contributed. Of all the Scottish albums I’m pretty sure I could have died without listening to this Ken and been alright with that. Fav song - the state I am in Least fav- electric renaissance Specific rating 2.4

Solid! (My reviews will hopefully increase in quality after deadlines...)

Lovely combination of folky and indie pop that appeals perfectly to me. I love the singers voice and the mix of tragic lyrics with upbeat music. Just a few uncomfortable lyrics and the weird tone shift that is Electronic Renaissance stop it from being a 5 for me. Favourite: She's Losing It or I Don't Love Anyone Least: Electronic Renaissance

This was a fun album. However, flow of the album was a bit disjointed with electronic renaissance in the middle and I was getting a little bored towards the end. Favourite: She’s losing it Least: Electronic renaissance Rating: 3.5

Good, but does start to drag near the end.

Cute and quirky sound, but not really my taste. Very fresh sound regardless, would not be surprised if this album released today. Very good indie chamber pop album, if you're into that sort of thing. Top tracks: We Rule the School, I Don't Love Anyone

The music is pretty boring. Basically hipster BS. This singer is as unimpressive as Nick Drake with his weak wail. Not sure why this is on this list at all. Does not belong on the top 100,000 albums of all time. The last thing the world needs is more Nick Drake wannabes. News flash, Nick Drake didn't actually write great music. Having said that, it is probably a Pitchfork darling. ::rolls eyes hard:: Instead of this weak nonsense, give me Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass anyday. I'll give 2 stars just for the production and engineering.

не зашло

I adore this record. It fills me with hope and joy. Forthright and utterly unpretentious, both musically and lyrically (which is extraordinary for a debut). Ear worms in abundance. Gorgeous and super interesting production.

A charming record, with beautiful, long, melodies, well-crafted lyrics, and lovely, minimal arrangements.

I love this album! First time listener but I’m hooked. Driving music, excellent vocals, smooth delivery. Definitely adding to my home collection.

Favorite Track: The State I Am In

Belle & Sebastian has just never done that much for me. I did like I Don't Love Anyone.

This album feels like a collection of experiments at trying to find their sound. The songs are very good, the overall product isn't necessarily cohesive. It feels a little more interesting than If You're Feeling Sinister, though I did really like the trumpet on that one. Again, sets the blueprint for the kind of indie that I grew up on.

Strange to get Belle and Sabastian 2 days in a row. But that makes this one look inferior compared to Feeling Sinister. Definitely an influential album but feels too slight and DIY.

5/5

i was introduced to belle & sebastian the proper way: a mix tape from a weird goth girl a grade ahead of me in the early 2000s. i liked salinger and mcsweeney's and wes anderson so this shit was catnip to me. unfortunately they never had the good graces to give it a rest; they grew into a parody of their worst tendancies and we just grew up. "we rule the school" is the high point here, but the real dorks know their EPs were always better than their albums.

A decent album.

The twee aesthetic still sucks ass. Also, None of them are named Belle nor Sebastian. ⭐

Never heard of them before this, but glad I have now. While I’m past this genre of music on repeat, I liked it a lot. Listened to it twice. Not gonna lie, the cover was a bit distracting on my screen.

Pretty incredible that this was a truly independent recording. This story-telling singer songwriter style of lyric isn't my favorite. I definitely liked the brit-pop leaning songs more than the folk-pop leaning songs. 3 days to record all of this with a relatively new band roster. The finished product is a testament to incredible artistic vision.

Don’t remember too much, but remember enjoying it.

3,75?

This is my second album by Belle and Sebastian (my first being If You're Feeling Sinister). It was literally my second album ever reviewed on this generator. Nothing to get too excited about, this is generic indie pop. The impressive thing is that they are from Scotland, and for once I didn't absolutely hate it. This album cover is completely fucked though. Favorite songs: You're Just a Baby, She's Losing It, The State I Am In, We Rule the School Least favorite songs: Electronic Renaissance 3/5

Nice sounding album but not as relistenable as if you're feeling sinister

Not my thing but some interesting and delicate melodies Voice gets a bit grating at times

Enjoyed this much more than expected. Lots of fun tracks, good lyrics, soft singing. Never too loud or boring. Very interesting and well made.

Cool, varied and interesting production

Beetje irritante stem, maar verder goed

This album is quite relaxing, and sweet.

I like it, the sound seems to be just right up my alley. Jangle-pop ish, for sure indie sounding. This is what I love about the 90s, a sound like this seems familiar to the era. Love this album

A delightful album that I've been listening to for decades

I will never be a fan of Belle & Sebastian, but I found this much better than "If you're feeling sinister". At least a couple of songs which were not very boring.

This album is quite relaxing, and sweet.

What the fuck is that album cover. Why the fuck am I listening to music about child brides. This album is like if Neil Young's son tried to follow in the footsteps of his father because Stuart Murdoch's voice is just so squeaky and grating. I'm giving this a 2 instead of a 1 because if you take out the vocals entirely it's actually a decent album. I found myself bopping along to the instrumentals and enjoyed it until old mate Murdoch started singing again.

Belle and Sebastian have consistently occupied a peripheral place in my music listening habits, often falling into the category of music I will enjoy if it happens to be playing, rather than actively seeking it out. Their debut album, "Tigermilk," presents a blend of clever, reflective, humorous, and melancholic storytelling, all set against a backdrop of catchy and jangly indie-pop melodies. The craftsmanship is evident in the mostly catchy upbeat rhythms, which are beautifully enhanced by rich melodic vocal harmonies. The album opens with what may be its finest track, "The State I am In," foreshadowing their future work. Other notable tracks include "Expectations," "You're Just A Baby," and "I Don't Love Anyone." "Electronic Renaissance" stands out as an a odd-ball track, yet it does not detract from the overall listening experience. This album is a fun listen, being bittersweet and nostalgic, while also comforting and uplifting. It ranks among the finest indie-pop records of the 1990s that I have encountered. A must listen.

Too soft and clean for me.

Getting this right after Nick Drake is mad. He must have been a huge influence on them

Kind of melancholy. It was good, but it's not for me.

Pretty solid, though I'm putting it in the "Nevermind" category of album covers I probably don't want on my phone while at work.

would def come back to this

Smooth, goes on easy. Well put together and enjoyable! 4.2

Hey, Not bad. Some good stuff even though I have never heard of them.

Alright easy listening music, reminded me of a milder version of the shins with less melodic singing. Overall I didn’t mind it, but it wasn’t exciting. Favorite songs were: Expectations I Could Be Dreaming - more energetic than most of the songs 6/10

100% an album with music on it. Album cover: (C-) A little on the nose.

This album was nice. For some reason I thought Belle & Sebastian were a 2000s indie pop couple (Matt & Kim?) and not a 90s band from Glasgow. I enjoyed this album. It was pleasant background music but not much more than that. None of the songs stood out too much. I notice that none of the songs on this album were in their Spotify top 10, which is interesting. My favorite songs were "The State I Am In" and "Expectations". It's possible that its just because I was still paying attention in the beginning. 6/10

Nice and easy.

A very rare find as a result of this list. How this has escaped me I will never know. Music that’s right down my alleyway. Reminds me very much of Roy Harper’s work. Will be added to my own collection soon. 4/5 21/2/25

Still a top album and it's bonkers that it was created as the final project for their course at college

It was nice enough, not really listened to them before and wouldn't be against listening to more

I thought this album was really sweet, really pretty. A lovely autumn album.

Found this a bit of a struggle to get through as it kept blending into background music. It’s all nice with some great lyrics but didn’t grab me

Liked the storytelling

Not my favourite B&S album but still pretty great. Some amazing songs on it for a debut album

all singers are great, lyrics are quite sad and very well writen. Favourite songs: expectations, she's losing it, electronic renaissance, I could be dreaming, we rule the school. Overall around 7/10

About 30 seconds in I was very dubious and this one but holy crap what an album. Stunned me how much I enjoyed it

I used to kinda like B&S, and I expected to thoroughly hate this album after almost 30 years. I will say that it was cold and rainy outside, and this album felt so “right” for the day that it gained an extra star.

Not for me.

After listening to one song of the album, we can derive everything that comes after. It's nice but so predictable that it loses a one-star rate.

This group was totally unknown to me and what a pleasant surprise! This was chill and an enjoyable listen. I'd welcome hearing it again. The cover features a topless woman breastfeeding a stuffed tiger but oddly the question that popped up in my mind was, "Why is she sitting in a bathtub?" Lol

Pleasant enough I guess although also really weird. I liked the other one a little better I guess and am not prepared to argue we needed one on the list much less two. I didn't hate it, also didn't love it.

Pretty enjoyable chill indie pop. Reminded me a bit of Father John Misty and Sufjan Stevens. Standouts are "She's Losing It" and "I Don't Love Anyone".

This was a pleasant listen. Nothing earth shattering instrumentally or vocally, but a decent listen. 3 stars seems fair.

Lol what an album cover. Anyways, not as bad as I thought it would be. Some easy songs to listen to. Im gonna go three because there’s not a lot to hate just nothing I enjoy.

Interesting

It was decent.

Had not listened to this in years. I don’t listen to B&S much anymore and this is not the first—or even second—album of theirs that I think to put on. But unsurprisingly this was great and I really enjoyed revisiting it multiple times today. Just great songs and great music.

A fun, upbeat album that I really enjoyed. Recording quality had some issues, but I did like the album, which is great for putting you in a good mood.

Not very interesting, even if they are Scottish.

good

Unreservedly recommended. Different and interesting with gorgeous melodies.

I really didn't expect to like this as much as I did. I had heard bits in passing before and thought, no thanks, that's not for me. By the third song I was coming around and at the end I went back and listened through again. Musically it's eclectic yet cohesive and at first seems to be lacking any punch, but the punch is kept for the lyrics. I'm not a huge fan of the singers lisping voice which really drags this down for me.

i was looking out for something special, but i didn't find it. a pretty okay album.

too slow, making me tired

This was a great album. So fresh and innovative and covering a pretty wide spectrum of their capabilities. Happy to be able to put this one in my rotation.

Meh? Feels very generic.

Look - I found this much more enjoyable than I though. I wouldn't recommend or listen to it again. But it was nice and glad I did listen to it. Can't place where / when you would play this album... not driving music, not party music, not working out or cleaning music... more sitting a field of wild weed flowers with the wind blowing having no responsibilities in life.. ever!

All B&S albums are beautiful in their own way. This one moves with the grace of a cat in a spacious, warm house. It sounds like their third or fourth album, doesn’t it? Composed, skillful, moving and confident. Get this: it’s their FIRST. That magic only comes from the earth and the air.

Considering this is one of the most hipster-coded albums I've ever heard in my life, it’s really not bad. Best song: I Could Be Dreaming

Liked it a bit more than I thought I would. Some interesting instrumentation, good harmonies.

It's okay. A happy, sing-songy album.

Trevligt men tycker låtarna låter för likt varandra, det var som att lyssna på en albumlång låt

2.5.

A solid debut, but the follow-up is the classic. Borderline 3/4.

A blueprint for that hipster indie whispery vocals. I dig it when I’m in the mood

Love love love Belle and Sebastian. This is the third album of theirs that I heard, love the first two - If You're Feeling Sinister and Dear Catastrophe Waitress - love all the songs, loved the flow but this one wasn't as good, for me. The flow wasn't as good and the lyrics weren't really as impactful as the others I've heard before.

Great stuff

See previous Belle & Sebastian review.

Loved it.

I went into this expecting to hate it, but it wasn’t bad at all. Kind of soft-spoken, kind of quirky, but not in an annoying way. The vocals are delicate, the lyrics are smart, and the whole thing has a quiet charm that sneaks up on you if you’re not paying attention. It’s definitely not something I’d blast in the car, but for a chill afternoon or background noise while doing something else, it works. Favorite song: Expectations Least Favorite song: The State I Am In

It's pretty but not my thing.

Folk, Rock, 1996 -> 3

I had low expectations for this and it certainly surprised me, by the end I was actually enjoying it.

This was a pleasant surprise.

was a little twee at the beginning but got so good

Worth of a listen

On par with the Beatles

not bad, but wouldn't listen to it by choice.

I loved electronic renaissance and Mary jo. but other than that, I wasn't super in love with this album. I don't like his voice but I do like the sound.

In a time period where popular music was changing, the authors feel that uninspiring UK pop that sounds as bland as other albums of an earlier time period should be on this list. The only thing that Tigermilk by Belle and Sebastian does that is listworthy is force you to remember that Nirvana, Pearl Jam, grunge, alternative and shredding music is happening at the same time across the pond. 2.5/5

4.5

I really like the music although there is no remarkable track. Easy on the ears. But I don´t like the vocals. 2,5

Not bad.

Well for my first studio album in a while, Tigermilk was quite a nice surprise. The album incredibly chill, in fact, it was probably one of the most chill albums i have done for this project. The songs did mostly seem to follow the same formula being that of a folk pop rock formula but it wasn't really something i minded too much and it did help some of the more interesting songs stick out more. I did go into the album thinking that the production wasn't going to be all that good but after listening to it, i thought it was pretty alright. This album was actually a great surprise for me. Best Song: The State I Am In Worst Song: My Wandering Days Are Over

I don't love it hate it. There are some really fun things going on with the music, sometime complex but child like in the melodies. They do do well together and build some beautiful songs. The music is very contrasting to the deepness and darkness in the lyrics. It's very fitting knowing they were in college and sort of coming of age individually and as a band. I will say I appreciated tracks 5-10 better. I didn't dislike the first four, but I'm kind of over hearing a women's perspective on things from a man's perspective....mainsplaining is really and I'm kind of over hearing how they think we perceive things. Overall I would check them out again but not going to rush to do so.

In the early 2000's I was a big fan of this band. We've parted ways since then but it was fun to listen to this again. It was my "sensitive boy" music phase. Tops for me on this album are: The State I'm In, Expectations, You're Just a Baby, I Don't Love Anyone.

This is enjoyable in a very non-threatening way. The songs are melodious and yet still quite unmemorable. There’s certainly a time and a place for this music. Rainy days, doing your taxes, driving through soybean fields, or maybe washing dishes. Highlights include “You’re Just A Baby”, “We Rule the School”, and “Mary Jo”.

I really liked the diversity in these songs and especially enjoyed the instrumentation. Lots of super pretty sounds from horns and violin and even some flute action. I don’t love the lead singer’s voice though and that kind of made the whole thing feel a little too fluffy and soft for me.

Just off. 1/5

Very chill album, with some incredible instrumentals and nice effects. Good beats and interesting vocals.

Quite lovely. Love Belle & Sebastian, though nothing stood out quite like their singles that I’m so fond of.

better than expected

Well it's a Belle and Sebastian album. Ergo it is good. I don't know this one as well as the others. Mad how they just had their signature sound immediately.

Softer indie rock. Simpler sound but enjoyed the time.

3.5? I need to give this one more try.

Have had a couple of songs from this album on a few of my playlists so know them word for word - but have not gone back to the original album for many years. Whilst it is the dictionary definition of "Whimsy" I do really like it esp State I Am In / My Wandering Days. A high 4.

Ok

i rlly liked this album and the kind of alternative/folk kind of vibe to it

Having never listened to this full album, I always thought Belle and Sebastian were kind of boring. After giving this thing a spin, I've gotta say, I kind of dig it! It's still not what I would consider "exciting" music, but that's okay. I can hear a lot of inspiration for the next generation of indie acts. 4/5

Dreamy

A very and sweet album, but given the band released another, much better one later that same year that is also on this list, I don't think this is necessarily essential. Key tracks: The State Am I In

I really liked this. So very pleasant and whimsical sounding. At times I get Cranberries vibes, other times feel like Natalie Merchant in the 80's, and then straight-up hotel lounge music! This album is why I've trodded through 515, mostly weird 70's folk music, to discover something new that I actually like.

Nice background music for driving around on a Monday morning. Can't see myself really going back to it, but it was pleasant enough.

Very slow, didn't engage with me. Pleasant sounding though.

Meh, was ok. Maybe it would grow on me with a few more listens

What

Kurde, jakoś trudno napisać mi coś więcej o tym albumie. Nie bardzo wiem, co mógłbym powiedzieć. Podoba mi się. Tak najzwyczajniej w świecie. Lubię ten wokal z wosku i young age angst. Brzmi jak coś, czego Karolina by słuchała jak miała 20 lat, taki vibe mniej więcej. Lubię dużą spójność tego albumu, wydaje mi się, że w tym gatunku konsekwencja to dobra rzecz. Lubię większość tekstów, dobrze mi się tego słucha. Będę wracał raz na jakiś czas pewnie.

I forgot to write down notes and now I struggle with remembering anything about this album. I think this is also appropriate review of the whole expierience.

Podobało mi się. Śpiewane historie z ciekawą aranżacją muzyczną. Faktycznie czuć czasem inspiracje klasykami jak Nick Drake (nawet wokalnie, jak w "You're just a baby"). Bardzo dobrze imo sprawdziło się "przelamanie" w postaci "Electronic Renaissance". Imo po kilkukrotnym przesłuchaniu płyta zyskałaby dla mnie więcej, ale trzeba iść dalej :D It was fiiiiine. 3,4 / 5

Mega dobry indie pop z bogatym podkładem muzycznym, inspiracja dla całego gatunku. Przyjemne słuchanko. 4

feiner, gemütlicher indie pop :)

Very cool precursor to some chamber pop music in the 2000s.

Sufjan and Steven

Eh

Few artists manage to deliver something truly good on their first album. Belle and Sebastian, for example, managed to do this with "Tigermilk". An album full of feelings that manages to create a different atmosphere with each track. The compositions here are exquisite and the melodies transport you wherever the Scottish band wants. It could be 5 stars, however (and this is my only complaint about the album), I don't understand why a 10-track album needs to be over 40 minutes long. Of course, this doesn't ruin the experience, but it's something to think about.

Weirdly like it. I feel like I should hate everything about it, but the lead singers weird lisp situation is kind of charming. Songs have very nice melodies and instrumentation never does too much. Also really fond of some of the experimental bits like on Electronic Renaissance. Yeah, good stuff. Fav Songs: The State I Am In, Electronic Renaissance, Mary Jo

While I respect the stories and characters interwoven in the lyrics which are easy to get lost in, I can never get over the Belle & Sebastian sound. Non offensively trickling along with whimsy and tweeness that in an absent moment rips you from the words and into a gentle irritation. If this record goes on in the background it's game over.

Was alright. Good for the vibe it was going for. Kind of felt like background music but it may have been my day.

Big 1960s inspired vibes. Just doesn't do anything for me. It's fine but for this kind of sound I'd rather listen to Simon and Garfunkel.

Definitely a different sound. But a few songs in I was really starting to dig it. Gonna have to put more of them in my rotation for sure

My god this was boring. I guess I didn't hate it?

Everything you expect from this band. A little twee, but lovely and clever. It’s been cold and rainy where I live and this vibe just fits, somehow. Love this album.

Pleasant enough but puts me to sleep. The singer’s lisp kinda annoys me. Extra star for Isobel Campbell.

booba

I remember seeing them in 1996, at Maxwell's in Hoboken, if I recall, to a half filled room, and then only 2-3 months later to a packed hall down in the Bowrey as they exploded overnight. An amazing album from start to finish.

same vein as the shins, wilco, etc

Tweeee

Flashing back to downstairs in the old original 13th Note on Glassford Street in Glasgow, Belle & Sebastian were releasing new EPs every other month and life was simpler, or I was simpler, but I digress... Upbeat, but not overly jaunty, twee, but not overly cutesy, just a chill laid back jam session in your living room with old friends.

Nice, calm, and enjoyable.

NINETEEN-NINETIES SAD BOY CLASSIC 10/10 album art, too.

Pretty good stuff. It’s nice to listen to on a quiet morning while getting ready to do very little. Perhaps put on a checkered flannel shirt and grow a beard… drink a flat white

Some interesting tracks, some absolutely average and boring ones as well. All combined into a rather disappointing album by Belle & Sebastian. It's not my type of music, as I have realised the first time I listened to the band, at the very first week that I sterted using this website.

very cute

An easy listen from a pop group that would not usually hold my attention for the entirety of the album.

It was interesting

Not sure this is "must-hear", but I enjoyed it.

I like this band but I find this album to be a bit average. I am sure I will get one of their other albums at some point but just not overly impressed

Belle and Sebastian just isn’t my thing.

3.4 2x enjoyed the music but none of the songs were standouts

Surely one of the albums of all time. Bit like the Young Rascals album but modernized. I liked the songs and vocals were quite nice to listen to, but I don't think I'll listen to it again.

Dreamy,

Boring

Nice and easy listen 3/5

A near perfect piece of chamber pop and rock that still holds up.

3.75

Gen Z Simon and Garfunkel.

A very bland and forgettable album. Not bad just nothing i will remember.

An album right out of the pages of 70’s folk rock, and it’s not bad. Not for me, but not unpleasing.

Nowt to sing home about but still pretty chill

Just bland - some interesting Melody but that’s just about it

Gave this a couple of listens. Never been a fan of this twee indie pop. Lyrically interesting but nothing musically that makes we want to listen again.

Love this album as much as I did when I first heard it.

I believe you have my stapler. I Iike to listen to the radio at a reasonable volume. I didn't receive my paycheck this week.

Alright, but not Grrrrrrrrreat!

cat's piss more like

Repetitive

As I listen to this, I get the feeling that it was recorded on school nights in the basement of a house filled with kids and a wife who shushes this guy for playing to loud. Everything is so subdued and soft. "Don't be too loud tonight." She scolds, "I just put the kids to bed." It's like the whole thing was recorded under a blanket washed with that laundry detergent they make for infants. Like his doctor told him that if he got to upset or energized, that his heart would explode. Like he was trying to prove to his grandmother that all rock music didn't have to be abrasive.

Not my fave Belle and Sebastian

Lovely stuff, what you'd expect from a Bell & Sebastian release. Instantly catchy and heart-warming,

I was eating this one up. I loved the laid back feel of the tracks here. There's a few moments that are cool but very out of place. I loved Electronic Renaissance, but it really does not fit on this album. Favorites were She's Losing It, We Rule the School, and I Don't Love Anyone.

This album sounds like flannel. Very much reminds me of something like Vampire Weekend. The instrumental on I Don’t Love Anyone is very similar to Only Wanna Be With You by Hootie and The Blowfish. Favorites were The State I Am In, She’s Losing It, I Could Be Dreaming, and I Don’t Love Anyone.

怪叫一出我真是没绷住

Gross, has left a bad taste in my mouth 🤢

Meh Was alright, but not for me really. Inoffensive coffee shop music 3 ⭐️

Only thing that got me excited about this album was the titties in the artwork

Pretty basic indie rock. I didn't like how the vocals were mixed so much louder than the guitars and stuff since the vocals were the worst part. Ian is going to love this one.

Ok

Had not listened to Belle & Sebastian in a while. They're always nice, nothing exceptional about this album in particular

Tigermilk is the 1996 debut album from Belle and Sebastian, originally released in 1996. I definitely enjoyed this one more than the other Belle and Sebastian album I got earlier in this list. The songwriting seemed a lot more inspired and personal on here. It wasn't cringe dramatic hipster rubbish. Don't get me wrong, this is still a very hipster album in my eyes, but it was pretty enjoyable. The production is great. I like that they stick to the folk rock sound but add in some interesting electronics here and there. A bit melodramatic at times, sure. But nothing overbearing. Probably their best record that I've heard.

This sounds like something...I can't place it though. If Wes Anderson decided to have a house band for his films, this would be who he would hire, maybe Zach Braff too. I bet this is The Shins' favorite band. I'm not sure this is something I'd listen to again, but it's ok. The Kooks' She Moves in Her Own Way owes a lot to You're Just a Baby. This project is warping what I think of as "good". This album is only good in the context of this project. The chatting over I Could Be Dreaming is distracting, reminds me of Simon and Garfunkel's Silent Night. The lead singer reminds me of Nico, and I bet these guys love The Velvet Underground. If Oasis was the mid-90s White Album Beatles, Belle & Sebastian was the mid-90s The Beatles Beatles. Maybe the mid-90s Donovan is a better comparison?

best

Part Nico, part Nick Drake. Has its moments. Is it just me or is the bouquet drooping?

I enjoyed this - a lot of good songs. Just on the right side of a whiny voice, with good lyrics

I have never heard this before and it's really good. Very good full sounding music that is a little bit experimental without being annoying. Sort of contemplative music. I will definitely be listening to this again.

I didn't hate it but its a one and done for me.

Decente, tranquilito

An easy listen but not something that's going to stick with me. Good length, sounds good. Enjoyable but nothing crazy. Plain old Jane but in a good way 3so

Absolutely stunning. Wonderfully witty lyrics. Have fleetingly listened to some Belle and Sebastian before but they were big before my time. This is fabulous!

Twee, as others have said, but very enjoyable. Reminds me of Nick Drake.

Fund and enjoyable, but quite monotone.

I think I will always favour Boy With The Arab Strap (5*) but they had to go here first.

Kinda indistinguishable from all indie folk pop 1994-2004. Enjoyed the 2nd half a little more than the first Artist #771 on last.fm - never heard this album before

Boring

Prachtig album, af en toe echt goede teksten, en goede muziek. Soms wat eentonig.

It sounds just like them. I always thought it was a duo because of the name, funny how it's just a qunitet of guys that reached crazy heights from a music business class

Enjoyed this a lot

4 stars because I would listen to this again and again.

Decent indie pop album with some 60s whisper singing and very lesbian vibes on several songs.

Juno.

Surprisingly nice and pleasant album. Easy listening that reminded me at times of Ezra Koenig/Sufjan Stevens/Cat Stevens/Lou Reed/etc. A band that I haven't listened to before but certainly would again on the right occasion. 7.5/10 (3.75/5)

One of the definitive bands of 90s indie, this is the opening of a near perfect run of three albums in a row for B&S. The seeds of this are sown by the bands on the C86 compilation, but this is the cream of that crop of quiet British indie pop, making them the heirs to the Smiths. The melodic phrasing in the vocals is full of surprises, like a familiar nursey rhyme that goes off in unexpected directions. The horns bring such a bright energy and harmonic complement, the jangly clean/acoustic sound and simple but lively rhythm playing gives it an infectious joy. I'm sucker for this combination of bright poppy upbeat music paired with wry melancholy lyrics, for the disco flourishes, the tremelo guitar, the sing-along choruses and intimately observed and self-depreciating verses. It's gorgeous autumnal music, bittersweet and wistful, relaxing and uplifting.

Aways found B&S a bit limp-wristed and watery at the time, but it's such a perfectly evocative sound of the mid-90s, but somehow it has a Nick Drake-esque timelessness.

Like this new-to-me album quite a bit!

Уютный альбом с одной из моих самых любимых песен всех времен и народов. Альбом сто процентов недооценен на всех музыкально-задротных порталах фанатами группы Black Keys, которые пишут, насколько группа Belle and Sebastian скучная. Лучшая песня - We Rule the School.

It was an ok listening experience, honestly just sort of washed over me, no songs in particular stood out. It was all a little trite but I understand it was 1996 and they were music students so it was unavoidable. I really don't understand why they didn't choose 1998's Boy with the Arab Strap, which has a lot more of their more famous songs and an overall more mature sound.

Never much been into Belle and Sebastian. I enjoyed some songs but it's very twee and very posh. It's got a nice defined sound, and some of the songwriting is clever. Listening: On the first sunny Autumn day Favourite Track: Expectation

good

not at the same level as The Boy with the Arab Strap but still a very good album

Twee gentle Scottish Donovan inspired inoffensive samey cardigan wearing filkie rock. Hard to dislike. Difficult to love.

At first I wanted to dislike the ultra hipster feel but I can't deny that I was entertained by the varied instrumentation and clever lyrics. A few of the songs completely missed for me, but most of them had me listening intently. I hear the Violent Femmes, Wilco, and many other bands I enjoy lurking inside the muted arrangements. But most importantly, listening to this album brought forth strong emotions and imagery of my daughter coming of age and leaving our house for college. Any piece of music that can stir my soul like that (especially one that I have not heard before and has no nostalgia attached) is worth four stars.

no spoko nie mam czasu żeby słuchać tych albumów kur

Det er lidt stenet det her. Men ikke kedeligt. Jeg fik lyst til at høre et par numre igen sidst på dagen. Jeg er i tvivl om det er noget som jeg husker om 100 dage. 🤷 Hvis det skulle ske, så justere jeg gerne én karakter op. Der er vel også en form for points for album art. 😂👌

Et rigtig fint og interessant lydbillede. Stuart Murdocks vokal er beroligende og dragende. Et hyggeligt søndags album.

Nice for a slow fall day. Easy listen.

Many of the songs are well written and hummable. I particularly enjoyed Expectations, with a nice addition of trumpets. However, Electronic Renaissance is horrible, and I find myself nodding along to a song while at the same time being outraged from the toothlessness of it all. 5/10

Is this a nepo-band? The singer is just not good.

I feel like this is one of the quintessential hipster bands. Many critically acclaimed albums, minor commercial success, and at the core of it, velvet pop sensibilities that few other bands imitate. Although it's not what I love about pop, I can't help but really like this style for how unique it is, and how well crafted it all feels. I could easily see myself coming to love this, and I would strongly recommend it to anyone with interest in indie pop.

Счастливая сегодня, и музыка сразу вся нравится:)

Probably a bad idea to wear a watch in the shower.

Nice. Soft. Background. Not full of internet but pleasant to listen.

Quite twee, very gently lilting indie boy. Easy listening and cool album art. Expectations was def a standout

לא שמעתי את כולו אבל מרגיש טוב

Akustisvetoista pop vähän rock. Vähän kyllä keskinkertaista, mutta ok kuunneltavaa silti. Parhaat: Electronic Renaissance, My Wandering Days Are Over

A band my mum loves and which I’ve only managed to see as a more boring smiths, which in it self is not really that interesting of a band. I however realise that that’s not a fair way to describe them and once the electronic part of the album begins that becomes clear. It’s not a perfect album by any stretch but it’s an amazing debut and they’ve clearly created their own style in it

Proto-emo goth giants showing off a style that I just can't get into.

No aptos para sábado de limpieza

Os quiero mucho Sebastián e Isabel 💛

I don't know, the cultural rift between this album and my taste is rather broad. :D

A solid, but unspectacular, entry on this list. There's a lot of 90's/00's indie groups (whom I really like) that clearly took some inspiration from these guys, but I don't get quite as much from this one.

This was, twee?? Ugh

The voices are so monotonous that it is the right music for people who have trouble falling asleep.

A very lovely album! I think If You’re Feeling Sinister is a masterpiece, and this is not as good as that, but it has the same twee, flowery vibes. My fav song is I Don’t Love Anyone!

Man, I’ve never been in on B&S. I’m usually a pretty twee guy but there is something about their sound that turns me off immediately. Can’t place my finger on it though. Maybe one day I will like them

Very soft nd tender music, always liked these guys but seem to frequently forget they exist

Fun little 90s indie album

I've always considered Belle & Sebastian to be one of the most inoffensive indie acts that never really became anything - they seemed to earn exactly the levels of tepid enthusiasm and moderate critical acclaim that they deserved. I almost smashed 3*** before I'd even got halfway through the album as it seems the 3***est album ever by the 3***est band of all time. But I held off, listened to Tigermilk three more times this week and enjoyed it a lot.

De har gjort så många bra låtar. Detta album har jag dock inte hört förut. Man hör att kvalitéer finns och det skulle ju bli bättre.

B&S are indie darlings. Their best album by far is 'Boy with the Arab Strap' which doesn't get a flag on the 1001, which is a real shame. This is still a winner though, and I'm glad to see Tigermilk on the list. Debut albums can be rough, but there is a lot of polish in this. Songs are mostly simple but joyous. It's still a band working out how to make music together, the use of synths is pretty rudimentary, but the building blocks for a long career are here.

Mi si spezza il cuore ma non ho proprio provato nulla. I testi hanno delle storie avvincenti dentro ma la voce mi scoccia e la musica è poco interessante :(

sai che c'è? temevo molto, e invece mi sono piaciuti. indie al punto giusto.

Serene, melancholic, genre bending. An interesting voice bolstered by unique instrumentals. Pretty solid listen throughout. 8/10

Relaxing sound

fínlegt og skemmtilegt gáfupopp. stundum of krúttlegt fyrir mig en svona er lífið. 4

приятные, даже получше чем предыдущий их выпавший альбом. но надо вслушиваться

Pretty lovely

There's something about Belle and Sebastian's style of soft folky/indie that really appeals to me. They sound different to other bands and have tied down the skill of songwriting perfectly. First time I've heard this album and really enjoyed it. 4/5

Det här är harmlös dussinmusik. Man hatar det inte men älskar det inte heller. Det är okej men inget sticker ut och griper tag i en, man bara flyter med och sen är det slut. Måste finnas 1 miljon såna här band i världen. Electronic Renaissance står dock ut som asjobbig låt.

Kommer ihåg att belle & Sebastian var all the rage förr i tiden. Lyssnade aldrig då. Känns inte som man missade något anmärkningsvärt. Det är inte dåligt, men det lyfter inte heller. Känns som en "Bob Kasper"-skiva, lagom att sätta på i bakgrunden när man har folk över på middag.

Enkel och lätttillgänglig mellanmjölk. Det är inte dåligt, men utan energi och man har svårt att hänföras. Svag trea för lyssningen är ändå rätt behaglig.

Great debut especially since it was literally just some college project. Their sound is pretty close to fully formed and while I prefer a few of the albums that came after in terms of songwriting this is still really good

What an imperfect blend of strained, subdued vocals and a sporadic blend of instruments. One which is expertly mixed and places an exquisite emphasis on the feeling of the music, regardless of the melancholic lyrics. This one continued to grow on me throughout the listen. But ultimately I was entranced by the incorporation of all of the magic that indie acts to follow, copied. It has solid riffs and arpeggios, harmonization and quirky songwriting. Hard not to enjoy.

Enjoyed this much more than expected. Lots of fun tracks, good lyrics, soft singing. Never too loud or boring. Very interesting and well made.

Buen disco, música agradable sin grandes innovaciones.

Some nice songs but nothing really stands out

I don't know, something about this album didn't really grab me. On paper, this falls under the category of an album I should've enjoyed. I'm a big fan of quite a few 90s soft rock artists, and the songs I did enjoy were a pleasant listen. However, I just wasn't wowed by this album. It wasn't a slog to get through; it just disappeared into the background as I was working. They're not all winners! Notable Tracks: - The State I Am In - She's Losing It - I Could Be Dreaming 5/10

Electronic renaissance bannnngsssss

Liked it more than I thought. I thought it was gonna be pretty boring with an emphasis on lyrics and while I’m sure the lyrics are still really thoughtful, there was a lot of cool instrumentation that kept me engaged and made each individual track stand out. Rating: 4.0

# 284 : They've done a pretty decent job. I think Its OK, I could listen to it and a couple of things stood out. It's fine background music and almost had me foot tapping, almost. The State I Am In.

inoffensive folky stuff, won't be revisting

Inoffensive, easy listening indie. Hard to fault but not something I'd put on myself. TL:DR it's a B&S album

This album gets better as it goes.

Nope. Not gonna do it. Fingernails on a blackboard, mixed with children's songs and bubblegum. But not in an interesting way. One star due to rounding error. I don't have to listen to this before I die.

Another band and album that I have never heard of, but thats why we are here. I enjoyed this album enough to give it another listen

01) The State I Am In - 8,0 02) Expectations - 7,5 03) She's Losing It - 7,5 04) You're Just a Baby - 7,5 05) Electronic Renaissance - 7,0 06) I Could Be Dreaming - 7,0 07) We Rule the School - 7,0 08) My Wandering Days Are Over - 7,0 09) I Don't Love Anyone - 7,0 10) Mary Jo - 7,0 TOTAL: 7,25 (73/100) Current ranking: 149/247 Cheerful indie pop songs that sound cute at first, but over time that cuteness is lost and they become borderline irritating in their cheerfulness. It's not bad, but it's not something I'll remember after the next two or three albums...

4.6 - This was a great album. I felt this was a lot more raw and lovely than some of their more popular stuff is

The first guitar flourish in 'The State I Am In' is an absolute joy. Fave Track: The State I Am In, I Could Be Dreaming, Mary Jo 3.9/5

Modern folk. Not bad