Reviews (page 11 of 15)
I’ll admit I never heard anything besides Old Man and Heart of Gold before this venture. It was a good first listen.
Love this album. Probably my favorite “version” of Neil; he’s such a chameleon with the type of music he’s played over the years. Earnest and yearning themes from such a young man. Guitar work on acoustic cuts and the backing band and singers are my highlights, as well as Neil’s songwriting. Almost theatrical on the orchestral cuts which was a nice surprise, having really only known the hits. He leveraged his friends well; love hearing Linda Ronstadt cut through on the background vocals of “Heart of Gold” where you can’t miss her voice; so nice. And love how Neil unintentionally pissed off Lynyrd Skynrd with “Alabama” inspiring them to write “Sweet Home Alabama” in a musical retort. Art pushing art! The classic cuts and universal themes that resonate to this day push it to top tier for me.
It’s good, just not as good as everyone makes it out to be
What are you doing Alabama? You got the rest of the union to help you along What's going wrong?
Oh wow, what did I just hear? When I started collecting vinyl, I jokingly wished I liked certain artists more because their albums were so well regarded on LP. Neil Young is at the top of that list. But I had never heard this masterpiece before. And it's odd too because I am very familiar with the singles from this album, Old Man, Heart of Gold, Needle and the Damage Done. I've never considered myself a Young fan, but, of course, these tracks are canon classic rock, and I always thought they were great. What's unfortunate is that I wasn't aware that they were from this album or that they even were from the same album. When listened to together as part of a full album project, their magic opens up. I've only experienced this one other time, with Marvin Gaye's What's Goin On, and while Harvest didn't quite capture my heart the way that album did, it's still a masterpiece that I plan to get on vinyl and listen to over and over. Five stars.
Yeah, this was good. Fun enough. Not the most inspiring, but the lyrics were great. If the other writing had kept up, then you’d have one stellar record here. 4/5
Pretty good, there’s better by You g.
To give a love You've gotta live a love I really need a maid.
I am a teen of the 70s, and I tend to prefer the music from that era. I like many of Neil Young's songs, but not all. Still overall, his music is a favorite.
This was great, the emotions hit home, especially in the second half. More interesting than I'd expect from what seemed like a "country" album. Another one that I was raised listening to songs from so also pushes it up a bit.
Not bad for a Neil Young album, but please, no more.
Great
Neil Young is a walking contradiction: one of our loudest rockers is also one of our quietest, most introspective tune smiths. Sometimes he does both on one record. This time, he leans into the introspection, delivering some of the finest , most enduring songs of his career. “Heart of Gold” and “Old Man” are instant classics. The rest is a mix of beautiful and haunting, with some of the best playing from top notch musical collaborators.
hands down Neil's best album. my favorite of his songs are on here, Old Man, Heart of Gold and The Needle and the Damage Done are all classics.
Recorded in a barn with a broken back, Harvest somehow still feels like comfort food. We played this LP about seven million times back on 130 College Ave—so it’s less an album now and more a permanent room in my memory.
Neil’s best album! Wish he could still write this well)
"This track seems kinda thin." "I hear you, what are you thinking, adding an organ or something?" "No, we need a...shoot, what's it called?" "Banjo?" "It's like a banjo.." "Mandolin?" Snorts enormous rail of 70s Colombian bam bam... "Ahhhh...London Symphony Orchestra....that's it. Get me those guys."
Mostly just underwhelming.
Not the best but not the worst Neil young I’ve gotten on this list. Just glad it’s back on Spotify honestly.
I like Neil Young, but this album didn't do it for me.
Glad I got this album after old Neil pulled his head out of his ass and put his music back on Spotify. The hits are 5/5, the rest is solid other than "There's a World" which sounded like a mash up of 1940's theatre production with Neil on vocals. The lyrical pairing to the theatrical sound of "A man needs a maid" is bizarre. Leaving the Orchestra out of this album would have made for a much more cohesive experience.
One of the greatest artists of all time. Looking forward to seeing NY and Crazy Horse in Chicago!!!
So many classics! And a great songwriter!
Admittedly, Neil Young has never been one of my favorites. He’s had a few songs here and there that I’ve enjoyed, but overall I just never found a great interest in him. This album changes that. It’s a fantastic album.full or heartfelt lyrics together with a slice of Americana. it is Ernest spot in my future rotation. I’m sure Neil would be thrilled.
Heart of gold & old man
Great overall album. Classic for sure.
damn good album
Great album to chill out to. A bit samey but enjoyable throughout
This is definitely Neil Young’s best solo album. “Out on the Weekend,” “Heart of Gold,” and “Words (Between the Lines of Age)” are my favorite songs here. I wish they’d kept the entire album as more low key and acoustic. There are a few songs that just feel out of place, especially “Are You Ready for the Country?” Solid album, though.
I don’t need to listen to this because I’ve listened to it before. But I will because it’s 5/5 thank you algorithm.
Wow. So, mostly good and listenable, with a few classics I was familiar with. But I cannot get over the track “A Man Needs A Maid.” What a bizarre track! Beautiful orchestrations set to the biggest whiny lyrics. Reading about his back injury and background only helps minimally - that song just really threw me for a loop.
Very good album, behind Rust Never Sleeps and After the Gold Rush. A Man Needs a Maid isn't great, though
Much better than the average two but wouldn’t listen to the album through again
my kingdom for a heart of gold
The album that first got me into Neil Young. Although he's amazing at rocking out as well, Harvest is such a classic. It feels a little dismissive to call it Folk Rock, it does lean into that but there are other elements that elevate the sound beyond acoustic guitars and harmonicas. the strings on A Man Needs A Maid are particularly beautiful, and electric guitars on Alabama fit the tone of the song perfectly. His lyrics are incredible, he has something to say on all these tracks, be it a political message or something more inward looking. I also like his voice, it seems a little polarising but it evokes the emotion of each song perfectly whether that be sadness, anger or whatever else. Brilliant
awesome
High and haunted voice Coos folk songs powerfully Harmonica rocks
Glad it’s back on Spotify. I will definitely listen again. I didn’t like it as much as harvest moon on first listen
A man needs to edit one song off the album
A man needs a less misogynistic metaphor. Otherwise really impressed with the lyricism and sound quality
The maid song deserves criticism but I’m going to use this opportunity to call out a later album by him titled “Harvest Moon” … like, try harder?
So Neil definitely wanted a bang maid, right?
Great album with some incredible tracks and beautiful guitar tones. I think for some tracks the production is a little grand for my tastes.
chill
Great album by Young. Some truly great lyrics throughout and the overall tone is great. 4/5 Will listen again
Liebliches Gesäusel und einfache Instrumentierung, dann die Orchesterwand: irgendwie hatte da jemand beim Produzieren keinen roten Faden. Und ich bin mir sicher: 70er-Musik mag ich nicht (allles).
Heart of Gold, was für ein Klassiker. Auch sonst gefällt das Album durch die akustische, entspannte Musik.
vrlo chill :)
Good old Classic Folk Songs - pleasant songs
Not my thing but I appreciate the vocals and the instrumentals. Alabama was the best of the album. It's all a bit too country/Christian for my taste, but still a pretty good listen
While I wouldn't call myself a fan of country rock this was a really solid album. The highlights here are definitely the two lead singles Heart of Gold and Old Man, but the songwriting and lyricism on display is excellent across the board.
One of my all time favorite albums
Love Neil and love this album even though the purists would say it was a sellout. Some classic rockers, and two of the best introspective acoustic songs in Neil's gigantic catalog makes this an easy five star album for me. It sounds so frickin' good...like you are sitting in the room with the musicians.
Terrific. I think I’d listened before but I listen to a lot of the Live at Massey Hall album and it was a good reminder of how wonderful the album tracks are too.
Good
love neil young, makes me think of my mum and dad. easy listening which can’t be faulted. would listen again obviously.
Good, some weird songs that don’t seem to fit with the others, but still good.
Some top folk hits, but filler as well
Disco muy sobrio y agradable, ideal para escuchar relajadamente. De lo mejor de Young.
Cd bien relajante y tranquilo. Bueno para estar relax y escuchándolo
A pleasant and chilled Neil Young Album. Orchestral elements used sparingly, which adds to their effect, making you sit up and take notice when they come in. Has Heart of Gold on it. Rating: 3.5/5 Playlist track: Heart of Gold Date listened: 12/04/24
I think it was Linda Ronstadt, who sang on this album, who described Neil Young as "a sketch artist" and that's a really apt description. His songs seem like fragments of images and ideas distilled and lifted from longer stories. Many of them are eminently singable and have stood the test of time in cover versions and campfires. Needle, Heart of Gold, Old Man... Between the solo acoustic, the grunge blues jam track, the orchestral backing and the intimate band sound, this album captures all of Neil Young's personalities and traits. Wistful vocals, always reaching for the nostalgic turn, for this idea that a better situation exists just out of reach, the simple riffs, the dirty guitar tone. Neil Young made this album and then just kept making it, really.
I don't know what to say about this that has not been said before. Neil Young was touched by grace on this. (with the obvious exception of "man needs a maid", what the hell were these lyrics?). 'Words' is the one song of his that always hits me right in the feels, no matter how many I have heard it. And one thing that really got to me this time in ways I had not noticed to this extend before is Ben Keith's pedal steel. Subtle, aching, intentional. My dad is a huge fan of Young, and this is probably one of the first records I ever heard. To this day, hearing this record reminds me of him, and of the turntable in the living room, or of the many hours we spent on some road on our way somewhere... I can smell the car when I hear this. Some records are that: a direct line to love and belonging to one another across generations, and to smells, emotions, feelings from a time that has passed and of which I have grown nostalgic without realizing. Today I sometimes join forces with my daughter and my mom to tease him endlessly about his enduring, unextinguishable love for "Nelle Youngue" (pronounced with a heavy french accent), including his more tedious productions of late. But deep down I recognize there something beautiful and precious about sticking with an artist no matter what, because they woke something up in you that cannot be tamed. This album, for me, encapsulates the best of my dad. He sticks with people. He is grounded and deeply connected to the place he is from (he actually lives less than 5 ks from the house he was born in). He values friendships, and cares for people and for the world. He loves hosting, and to be surrounded. He is a simple man, but also a quite complicated in many ways. And we have had our differences, disagreements, misunderstandings, frustrations at one another over time, but. There was always this deep love for music, and this album which he gifted me in so many ways. "There's a world you're living in No one else has your part" He definitely found his part, and is playing it beautifully. As for the album, I don't think this is even my favourite one of his, musically speaking (On the Beach might take the crown). But this is definitely the one I carry with me and know the most intimately. How do you even rate this?
Great overall album. Love 'Heart of Gold', The Needle and the Damage Done", and 'Old Man'. His voice didn't bother me as much on this one as the other 2 I've gotten in this project. 4/5
I just don’t like his voice. Old Man is a favorite across covers but A Man Needs a Maid left a bad taste in my mouth that followed the whole track list.
This 2 has some qualifiers. 90% of this album was a drag. It felt plodding, shallow, and empty. It made me tired to listen to, like nothing going on most of the time and when it picked up neil proceeded to drag it back into tired slumber. That said, "The Needle and The Damage" and "Words" saved this album from 1 territory for me. Both tracks synergized well with Neil's style and I felt myself getting into the songs when his vocals came in instead of groaning.
More Neil. Good songs, but still not my jam.
Great album - some of the lyrical themes seem a little dated, maybe, and Young's voice is, clearly, an unusual instrument, but this is packed with quality start to finish.
I really wanted to like this. But it didn't have the range I was looking for. The obvious all-timers hold up, but the songs outside of that didn't really grab me.
Decent
couple of tracks seem to come out of nowhere
Neil at his finest.
I don't like the song about the maid omfg. Overall, did not enjoy. That's probably controversial. Oh well. 2/5
I’ve never been a Neil Young fan. I know: people who love him love him. I respect him but he’s not my thing. On the album the radio friendly Old Man and Heart of Gold are good. Country has a nice bluesy feel. The rest of the album was tolerable.
Heart of Gold, Old Man, Needle and the Damage Done. All classics. Not one I reach for often but still iconic. For some reason this got me into a My My, Hey Hey rabbit hole this weekend. Never realized there were 2 different versions of this song: - My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) - Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) Both are great but I prefer the lyrics of Blue but the Black rocks! Anyway, the godfather of grunge is awesome!
Excellent record! That early 70's country rock vibe is almost perfect here. Heart Of Gold is of course the money-maker but Maid and The Needle are both pretty fantastic also. The orchestra-backed pieces like Maid are kind of interesting to me -> odd for Neil Young in a way, and maybe reaching for something a bit like Elton John's Madman from the year prior...?
Classic.
I really enjoyed this, I had always been resistant to Neil young just because I felt it was for old people. This was fantastic.
Great track, really took me back to working in the butchers. Enjoy all of the vocals and guitar throughout
The best Neil Young album in my book
Bueno.
I'm not a big Neil Young fan. I listened to this album. It has its fans. It's Neil Young. Next, please.
Not my favorite, but a classic for sure.
Well, it was better than the last Neil Young album I listened to. I liked Old Man, and the one from the start of Hot in Herre.
Synonymous with singer song writer and for good reason. Dude's smooth and mellow delivery is legendary. Great album.
After After the Gold Rush, Young releases Harvest, his most accessible and laid-back folk rock album. "Heart of Gold" and "Old Man" are the two strong pop hits that lead this record and set the tone. The deeper cuts are slower and more patient but generally solid, most of them having memorable hooks. The two outliers are "A Man Needs a Maid" and "There's a World" which employ the London Symphony Orchestra. I can see where he's getting at with the juxtaposition between the excessive orchestra vs the mundane lyrics, but it sticks out and doesn't sound good at all. The former would work well as a ballad based on live performances, but would be more forgettable. "There's a World" is just bad, and his musical-like singing is the lamest I've heard. "Out on the Weekend" and "Harvest" are fantastic openers and are the ones most likely to grow on you. They're slow, patient, and soothing with great lyrics. "Are You Ready for the Country?" is a solid country song but a bit dull. "Alabama" is the hardest song on here and inspired by the famous Lynard Skynard hit. I think it's ok but forgettable. It's a nice change of pace from the slow second half. "The Needle and the Damage Done" is a pleasant minimalist folk track. You can hear the despair and disappointment in his voice. The claps are a bit weird, it's in a weird spot on the record, and I don't understand why it's so popular. "Words" is our long epic closer that reminds me of Everybody Knows This is Nowhere. Ties together all the strengths of this record into a satisfying end. Some regard this as Young's strongest album. With how mature and sophisticated the sound is, I can totally see why. I did find the deep cuts underwhelming. And although the record has a distinctive cohesive vibe, some tracks stick out too much. I was hoping there would be some other track I'd love as much as the 2 hits (or like cuts from other albums).
The dog dies :( Also apparently he kicked the dog because the dog was bad. Apart from that pretty fun. Even made me a bit nostalgic for a North American country past I never had. Anemoia?
A good album from one of the greatest. He's only just reappeared on Spotify and I can finally listen to an album.
Nichtssagend.
An absolute classic. Took me a long time to appreciate Neil Young but this is defo one of his best! Nice, relaxing and dare I say it, reflective kind of soft rock. My review doesn’t do it justice.
Good think Neil is back on Spotify ;-) Classic album with some high-water marks. BUT I still remain with Harvest Moon as my fave of Neil's.
a couple good gems on here. a little boring overall.
was not expecting there to be songs with full orchestras on them. Thank you Neil!
I just don't get Neil Young. Not enough energy for me.
Canada's greatest soul singer. Seriously. That voice. Harvest is a great album. It still sounds timeless, despite the social commentary of the time. Good effort, dude.
Wow. Never understood the Neil Young reference in Sweet Home Alabama until now.
There are some really good and amazing songs on this album, but, to me, Neal Young's voice can get to be a bit much. All in all, a pretty solid album but hard to listen to straight through.
Sounds like Neil Young. Some hits songs
7. country? nunca ouvi nada desse cara. sinto que é musica triste de morador do sul dos estados unidos. Melhores: Primeira do album, old man Final: album de pai? dad rock? me vejo voltando nas mais animadinhas, que tem mais um perfil organico mesmo de country rock, A Man needs a maid? Não li a maioria das letras mas me parece que ele é triste.
Really nice listening, Neil brings a serious gravitas to his music and excellent musicianship.
So this is definitely one of Neil Young's stronger offerings, but I still don't really care for him all that much. Some songs have great parts but they are ruined by either bad lyrics, terrible singing, or just a totally boring instrumental. A couple songs manage to avoid those problems though, so I'm giving this a 3. But it is a low 3. Close to a 2 but wouldn't feel right rating this album as such
Didn't listen because Neil's not on Spotify anymore, but this is one of my favorite albums. 10 / 5.
The only song that I knew from this playlist was Heart of Gold. Pretty chill for background music.
Unique voice and writing. I don’t think I can appreciate this as much as other people for being historically important. 3.4
Classic "pastoral" album with a heavy edge, a great one!
Classic
Very soft and pleasant music, good for relaxaion, even though can be boring at times. Also good lyrics ("Every Man Needs a Maid" does not count)
Och, een heerlijk album om de brakke vrijdagochtend mee te starten. Dit is mijn favoriete Neil Young plaat, al ken ik ook bij lange na niet de complete discografie. Wat heeft deze meneer veel muziek uitgebracht. Als je de samenwerkingen met Crosby, Stills en Nash er bij telt, plus Buffalo Springfield, vertegenwoordigd Young de 1001 album lijst met plus min 8 albums. Een muzikant in hart en nieren. Het scheelt echt dat ik dit album op vinyl heb, want ik heb toch écht een hekel aan alles op YouTube kijken, slechte kwaliteit, advertenties... Enfin, terug naar het album. Het is er typisch zo eentje die je vader aan je laat horen toen je nog jong was, om er vervolgens geen goed woordje voor over te hebben. Maar dan word je oud, en voelt het gehele album opeens extreem nostalgisch aan. Je denkt, had ik maar geluisterd naar m'n old man... Kampvuurmuziek is het misschien, ja, maar emotieloos staren naar het vuur zit er niet in. Hier zullen tranen weggepinkt worden. Heart of Gold is zo puur. Een perfect nummer met een mooi thema en veel emotie. Klopt van top tot teen, en blijft een fijne om aan te zetten op een brakke dag. Telkens als ik Old Man luister lopen de emoties wel een beetje op. Ik kan me helemaal plaatsen in de tekst. Hier moet je niet te veel woorden aan vuil maken, gewoon lekker luisteren. Alabama spreekt over de situatie in het zuiden van de US in de jaren '70. Veel racisme, verdeeldheid, criminaliteit. Dit nummer bekritiseerd het racisme en geweld. Als tegengeluid kwam Sweet Home Alabama, die ook wel de problemen aan de kaak stelde, maar de focus legde op de Southern culture en tradities. Ben ik de enige die zit te wachten op Nelly's Hot in Herre bij het intro van There's a World? Neilly Young? Nee? Oke... Conclusie: Harvest blijft een diepe indruk op mij maken. De kracht zit hem in de perfect uitgevoerde muziek, vocalen, in combinatie met diepe emotionele motieven en politiek beladen thema's. Veel nummers zijn tijdloze classics geworden. Waarom geen 10 dan? Tja.. dan moet echt élk nummer perfect zijn. A man needs a maid, There's a World, en Word zijn absoluut niet slecht, maar zijn wel kleine vlekjes op een anders perfect album. Rating: 9/10 Highlights: Heart of gold, Old man, Alabama, The needle and the damage done
Deze had ik al eventjes niet gehoord.. Hoofdzakelijk vanwege de eigenwijze, seniele man achter het album, die nog steeds geprikkeld (snap je hem, prik) is omdat Spotify anti-vaxxers een podium gaf. Grow up fucking hobo, we willen je prachtige discografie weer ontdekken. Dat gezegd hebbende, het beluisteren van Harvest voelde best wel als een herontdekking van een klassieker. In mijn gedachte was het een ultiem kampvuur-album, en was ik vergeten dat het hier en daar nog best wel groots en orkestraal was voor Neil's doen. Dat dit het mentale plaatje was ontglipt wordt snel verklaard, want dat symfonische geneuzel als in 'A Man Needs a Maid' en 'There's a World' laat me koud. Het doorbreekt een voor de rest enorm consistent album, met een aantal career highlights van de beste man. De titel kampvuuralbum heeft de plaat voor een significant deel te danken aan de opener 'Out on the Weekend'. Wat kabbelt dat nummertje fijn voort. Ben normaal geen groots fan van het oorverdovende getetter met de mondharmonica, maar in deze song voegt hij echt wat toe. Enfin, ik wil kamperen, nu. De titelsong sluit naadloos aan, en moet eigenlijk gewoon altijd samen met 'Out on the Weekend' afgespeeld worden. Een waardig nummer om de titel van het album te dragen, ietwat simpel, maar waanzinnig effectief. Waar sommige andere nummers een hoop strijkers en andere Disney-esque effecten van stal haalt, laat 'Harvest' zien dat Neil eigenlijk gewoon het beste is als hij lekker dichtbij z'n roots blijft. De grote singles, 'Heart of Gold' en 'Old Man', was ik zeker nog niet vergeten ondanks hun lange afwezigheid op het streamingplatform. Dit zijn wellicht de bekendste werkjes uit z'n oeuvre, geen verrassing gezien de thema's die weerklinken bij het grote publiek en de akoestische instrumenten die het goed doen op de radio. Het zijn gewoon sterke country rock songs, maar hun succes overschaduwd wel een beetje de rest van het album, waar minstens zoveel muzikaliteit inzit. In 'Alabama' bijvoorbeeld, wat misschien wel m'n favoriet van deze plaat is. Daar hebben we ook eindelijk die befaamde elektrische gitaar die we uit duizenden herkennen. De song onderstreept dat Neil niet echt gecharmeerd is van het primitieve volk uit het Zuiden, en voelt als een spirituele opvolger van 'Southern Man'. Het zal hoogstwaarschijnlijk de druppel zijn geweest die de emmer met moonshine liet overlopen in Dixieland, met als gevolg dat de rednecks van Lynyrd Skynyrd het southern anthem 'Sweet Home Alabama' uitbrachten. Naast dat het topic aansluit bij het werk op zijn voorgaande album 'After the Gold Rush', komt hij ook sonically en instrumenteel veel meer overeen. Het is een beetje een vreemde eend in de bijt op 'Harvest', maar had graag meer vergelijkbare folk rock langs horen komen. Al met al is het gewoon een puike plaat, die zich met speels gemak voortbeweegt. Die easy going vibe is misschien wel de grootste kwaliteit van het album, en een voornaamste reden achter z'n succes. Echter mag Neil van mij wel iets vaker bijten, zoals hij dat ook deed op 'After the Gold Rush' en later op 'On the Beach'. Het is bij vlagen wonderschoon in z'n eenvoud, maar het mag soms best wel wat spannender. Die verrassingsfactor is nagejaagd op de orkestrale songs, maar die vielen daardoor simpelweg uit de toon. Afijn, zet godverdomme je muziek weer op Spotify, door de stront getrokken hippie! 8/10 Highlights: Harvest Old Man Alabama
Waar sommige americana/country albums je op je zenuwen kunnen werken is Harvest wél een van m'n favorieten in dit genre. Ik vind Out on the Weekend een heerlijk nummer en echt een typische opener voor een plaat. Een makkelijk nummer waarmee je het album inglijdt. Een persoonlijke favoriet. A Man Needs a Maid en There's a World zijn twee moeilijke nummers waar ik echt aan heb moeten wennen. Gelukkig levert Maid ons dat (cover weliswaar) wel een puntje op in de laatste popquiz. Het zijn wel de minpuntjes op de plaat. Neil laat voor mij zijn kwaliteit zien bij songs als Heart of Gold en Alabama. Ze zijn niet onwijs ingewikkeld maar zijn raak en er zit altijd een moment in het nummer dat de muziek openbreekt en de stem omhoog gaat. Ik vind dat altijd euforisch. De algehele song-writing kwaliteit van Harvest is super hoog. Wat Neil later is gaan doen met oneindige solo's ontbreekt op deze plaat gelukkig nog. Een compacte plaat met een reeks sterke songs, dan heb je mij hoor #fanboy. 9/10 Highlights Out on the Weekend Heart of Gold Alabama Needle and the Damage Done
Nope. I’ve tried you, Neil Young! I always suspected I wasn’t a fan and now I’m sure. Please let this THIRD Neil Young album in two months be my last.
Probably the easiest listening of my all time favourites. Geffen Folk Rock sounds like anathema to me, but of course Neil’s incredible talent for being shonky but persuasive gives this album his usual underlying grit. Tuneful, thoughtful, tragic. His best.
What a treat of the album. Always been a casual fan of Neil Young but this is my third album of his from this list so far and I'm becoming a big fan of his.
O esplendor da força das melodias envolventes com a delicadeza das composições e execuções que devem ser ouvidas sempre.
I've never listened to Neil Young before. I have now realised that was no true loss to me. Painfully dull.
Son 4ème album. Bien content qu'il soit de retour sur Spotify! Pas mon pref, mais bon pareil, beaucoup de ballades, dont la chanson touchante pour son ami mort d'une overdose.
Definitely the best Neil album so far, had some genuinely good songs on it. Reminded me of Fleetwood Mac in some place, particularly liked Alabama. Felt that the quality varied a lot though and there were still some duffers, particularly any stripped back song where Neil's not very good voice was more prominent. Double bad if he had to hold any notes for longer than 2 seconds. Generally though I did enjoy it and would listen again so it has to be slightly better than average, 3.5
Harvest is good. Finally on Spotify. Heart of Gold is such a classic, and I also like the title track, and Old Man. Absolutely fantastic songwriting, and his wailing compliments the whole thing.
The best Neil Young album we've had so far and the only one I'd heard prior to starting this list. Heart of gold, out for the weekend, and old man are all great but I think the needle and the damage done is the standout track. Not sure I can quite give it a 5, but it's close. I don't like a man needs a maid 4.5
Neil Young is the best.
I was already familiar with this album and it's a good one. It's one of his more mellow albums, full of great stuff. Heart of Gold is one of the first things I learned to play on guitar. My favorite track is The Needle and the Damage Done.
# Playlist track - Heart of Gold # Notes - It's an interesting listen. Possibly with the exception of Every Man Needs a Maid. - It's a shame it's not available on Spotify. Fuck Joe Rogan. +1 Star for Neil.
I thought I would enjoy this more, the lush (for Neil Young) orchestration on some of the songs seem to take the bite out of them. The last song Words seems the best balance of grit and grandiose. Some key songs here keep this from being a middle of the road effort.
I'm sorry this album isn't on Spotify. It's one of my favorites and Neil Young is also one of my favorite artists. Classic album and it is a must-hear. There are some tracks on here that are probably a bit overblown (A Man Needs a Maid), but it's very hard to knock the album when 8 of the 10 tracks are fantastic and Neil Young loves trying new and different sounds every time he comes out with an album.
Neil Young is consistently good and that does not stop on this album. I doo feel like his style does get old after a while, but the album is short enough to where it doesn’t drag because of it.
Synonymous with singer song writer and for good reason. Dude's smooth and mellow delivery is legendary. Great album.
No Neil Diamond, but this album had a heart of gold 4/5
This was a tough listen. Really did not like this album. A Man Needs a Maid is terrible. It all just kind of sounded like whiny country music performed by a man who can't sing well. There were maybe two songs on this album that were decent, but the rest I would be perfectly okay with never having to hear again.
3,5
out on the weekend- idgaf. 3 or 4 harvest- its whatever 5 a man needs a maid- boooo 2 heart of gold- dont care 3 im skipping these next songs cause i dont care needle and the damage done- 8 because im me. i dont wanna listen to the rest
A near perfect album.
Amazing!
10/10 great fucking album
Out on the weekend 👌🏻 Are you ready for the country 👌🏻 Old man 👍🏻 Good voice and use of instruments. Not very notable or memorable tbh. Not bad either, I wouldn’t be mad if someone put it on tho.
Beautiful
Already a favorite. Very relaxing "sit on the porch" kinda vibe.
Neil Young wasn't even 30 when he recorded this album. Wise beyond his years, and a genius storyteller. This Canadian figured out America in a way that America still hasn't.
The orchestra backing on the track's "A Man Needs a Maid" (meh) and "There's a World" (I think I liked it, I swear I have heard the orchestra music somewhere else though) are jarring. I dig the sounds, kind of reminds me of Metallica's S&M, but they just don't seem to fit with the rest of the album. I would definitely listen to this album again if it was easier to find and play.
Top notch. 4.5
Just still not a fan of Neil Young.
pretty smooth, some cool moments
Neil Young has such a distinct voice. Few iconic 70’s songs on the album that never age.
Neil Young really has a great way of transporting you to the exact setting of his songs. The folk bordering on psychedelia is a really interesting feel to his music. Favorite track: Heart of Gold
A few strong numbers here, but nothing to write home about and nothing surprising
for me NY is the master of capturing my attention without my knowing exactly why. i love this “middle of the road” album even though my faves are the “ditch trilogy”. the layering of the rough guitar sounds with simple rhythm backing and soaring pedal steel is magical.
It’s nice but it didn’t blow me away. Admittedly I’ve heard it before but other than Heart of Gold and Out on the Weekend, it pretty much passed me by.
We love a stone cold classic on a Friday! What else can I say about this album that hasn’t already been said?
It's Neil Young, so it's obviously at least a 4. Old Man is clearly an incredible Song. Great lyrics, great chorus, just an amazing song. But the song that blew me away was Alabama. At first the chorus knocked my socks off but the whole thing is incredible
Cool cool cool
Great album with lots of emotion. His voice adds power to the lyrics and one either likes that distinct voice or they don't. Only issue for me, is that on so many albums of those days, there are what I call the throw-away songs that were needed to fill out a vinyl record.
As the old joke goes, I played this so much on vinyl back in the day it destroyed the record: you should see the needle and the damage done. Anyway, it's the album that got me into Neil Young, and still my favourite.
man isnt this like the 4th neil young album? …and because he isnt on spotify, i had to listen on youtube… and ever since the last time i did that, the algorithm keeps thinking im a huge neil young fan and keeps serving me up neil young news every time i search ANYTHING. im not going to listen to this one, lest google thinks im a super fan
This is one of my favorite albums. It sounds great, and it’s bonkers!
9.6
good ol' Canadiana. Great listening. Love the harmonica.
stone cold classic
Great album. Lot's of hits.
Not on Spotify. 1/5
Not my favorite Neil Young album but can appreciate it for what it is. The final 3 tracks are my favorites on this album. The orchestral sections can be a little much at time but they definitely add to the emotion of it all.
I would call my self a casual fan of Neil Young. I've always enjoyed his frenetic, raw, emotional guitar playing in several songs. I've known that this is a legendary album and am glad I finally listened to it in its entirety. There's several awesome tracks and a few surprises throughout (hello symphony orchestra - didn't see that coming!). A very enjoyable album. Favorite tracks: Out on the Weekend, A Man Needs a Maid, Heart of Gold, Are You Ready for the Country, Old Man, Alabama, Words.
This album was fine. Would make for good background music. Neil Young’s voice gets grating after a whole album though. I’m good for a Neil young song here and there but a whole albums worth was too much.
Great voice and good music
Clean voice, enjoyable, Cool orchestral elements. 3*. I just don't think I'm a Neil Young fan.
Great album.
No thanks. Can’t do it.
Young spends much of this album yearning for love and fulfilling relationships amid a life of fame, success, and empty pleasure. And it makes for pretty damn good music. Fav Tracks: Out on the Weekend, Harvest, A Man Needs a Maid, Heart of Gold, Old Man, Alabama, Words (Between the Lines of Age) Least Fav Track: There's a World 10/10
Other than live albums and compilations, this is probably the strongest Neil Young album out there. There's really not a single bad track on it. Yes, even the slightly dodgy song about maids is a good one in my books. I understand that some people don't like Neil Young's voice and there is a bit of a downtempo theme to most of the songs. However, I adore Neil's voice and also the slightly melancholy feel to many of the songs. This really is as close to perfection as I think is possible; definitely one of the most important folk rock albums ever made. If I could give this a six then I would, but I'll have to settle with a five.
I liked this a lot, shame it's not on streaming but that just means I'll have to get a physical copy!
Uno de los mejores discos solistas del legendario canadiense, y uno de los LPs más connotados del género folk/country. Su producción casi esquelética, que se entrelaza con colaboraciones teatrales con diferentes orquestas (entre ellas la de Londres), crea un compacto de poco más de media hora de paisajes hipnóticos por la vida rural norteamericana, produciendo al mismo tiempo algunos de los singles más icónicos de la historia, como "Heart of Gold". Sumamente recomendado, sobre todo para cualquiera que quiera empezar a escuchar Neil Young.
Yet another album I love from Neil that I'll just have to put on at home outside of any streaming context. Highlights: Heart of Gold, Are You Ready for the Country, Old Man, Alabama, The Needle and the Damage Done.
Heart of gold och Old man är fantastiska, men de är tydligt en nivå över resten. Bra och stabil skiva dock.
Solid.
Some really good songs. Not feeling the orchestral parts too much. Will I listen to again: 50%
might be good songs in here but i can't stand his stupid voice
Quick listen. All around solid album
Really enjoyed this albim
Really enjoyable. Good texts and solos
Decent Album and some iconic songs
Rounding up from 3.5 stars. Certainly Neil Young’s most commercially successful record - for me it pales in comparison to his other output in the 70s. Also - the George Martinesque orchestral arrangements in ‘A Man Needs a Maid’ really make the misogyny that much worse.
not on bastard spotify old man definitely the standout for me so far. really like the gradual crescendo album just got better towards the end not sure if that was just me warming up to neil young or whatever but cool like the last song and the range it shows
Some classics here!
I can see why people would fawn over this, but I just find it whiny and boring.
Maybe I’m going soft with my reviews but this one seemed like a fiver
Let's get this out of the way - Neil Young's music is not my cup of tea. Having said that, based on my limited exposure to the genre he's easily the best at these folk, singer-songwriter affairs. This album is so musically interesting. It's very minimal, with the London Symphony Orchestra only providing additional instrumentals to a couple of songs. There's so much richness with just strings and a few other instruments though, to the point that suddenly having a full-ass orchestra doesn't feel out of place. I came out of listening to this record thinking to myself 'Oh boy, I think I just became a fan of Neil Young?' I'd give this 4.5 stars if I could. Standouts are Out on the Weekend, Heart of Gold, Old Man, There's a World, and Words.
El álbum está muy bueno en general, se me hizo corto y me gustó le doy un 8/10 siento que hay temas aburridos por así decirlo
would be better if on Spotify
Some bangers in here.
The first few songs are kind of rough but the album picks up in the second half. Having to endure the YouTube ads didn't help either.
4 stars, maybe 3.5. I liked a lot of the songs and the general sound but I see why my mom doesn't like Neil Young's voice.
This sounded like the soundtrack to an Oscar worthy film, but at the same time sounded like a guy singing on his porch. Beautiful.
Amazing album
This is quite simply one of the best albums I’ve ever listened to. I can’t believe I haven’t given Neil Young the attention he deserves. Every single song on here was absolutely beautiful and completely melancholic. 10/10 will not shut up about this for a while.
This is a very special album, I learned lots of songs on this album on guitar!! The song There's a world is really bad, most of the other songs are great! 4 stars
Really makes you feel like you are in another place and time. I wouldnt't be able to listen to it non-stop, but this album really gave me melancholy for a time I don't even understand. It's both calming and extremely sad at the same time.
Favorite song: Old Man and Heart of Gold
Exceptional album. Really enjoy this one and have listened before.
Good bangers Voice sounds feeble against orchestral backup Non-bangers weren’t exceptional
don't care for
All around solid classic rock album. Sucks he took his music off of Spotify though
Some of the tracks are absolute classics.
There is such a raw tenderness in Neil Young’s vocals like a man amazed by how overwhelming it all is and his voice is almost cracking and breaking from being in awe
If there ever was a soundtrack to my youth, this is it.
4 stars
A distinct sound and Heart of Gold was played constantly at the time. Pleasant enough but not earth shattering. 3*
About as middle of the road as it gets.
Bit dull for my tastes
Not my favorite Neil Young album.....but a classic. Favorite Heart of Gold.
This is my second Neil Young album and the guy is obviously not for me. I find his singing very flat and all the songs much the same, with A Man Needs a Maid sounding like some kind of a parody. I was trying to decide between 2 and 3 stars but since I've skipped a few songs i.e. didn't listen to them all the way to the end, I've decided on 2*.
Out on the Weekend - 7.5/10 Harvest - 7/10 A Man Needs a Maid - 7/10 Heart of Gold - 7.5/10 Are You Ready for the Country? - 7/10 Old Man - 7/10 There's a World -7/10 Alabama - 8/10 The Needle and the Damage Done - 7/10 Words (Between the Lines of Age) - 7/10 TOTAL - 65/100
Its okay. I like it fine, but I feel like a lot of the stuff I already know well from that era is the same, but better. The most famous track on this album is probably Heart of Gold, which is about as good as one of The Band's worse songs.
Loved revisiting Neil Young early in this list.
no esta en spotify
Chill
A beautifully recorded album that I struggling to find much personal connection with. Heart of Gold, Old Man, and Needle and the Damage Done are the only tracks I truly enjoy and/or stir strong emotion. Dig Tim Drummond's bass tone.
Beautiful record - my favourite Neil Young album.
Just bad.
Neil Young pulled everything from Spotify. Can't listen
This album is a solid folk album. Most of the songs are pretty pleasant. Some haven't aged well (Man Needs a Maid - not just the lyrics, but also how over the top and melodramatic the song is). All in all: not bad, not excellent. 3/5
One of the quintessential albums by Neil Young. Most others pale in comparison.
Classic old folk. Easy listening and good album but didn’t really capture me like I thought it would.
I dislike country-inflected rock and pop, and I don't care for Neil Young's voice (sorry!). So this album sits well outside my usual envelope of taste. the only track on the album I knew before I played it was 'Heart of Gold', and that irritates me. I did like 'The Needle and the Damage Done". 2/5
Some of these songs are pretty good. Too bad Neil Young sings them. I hate his voice. Favorite song: old man
Two things: Neil Young is not that great of a singer AND why do I enjoy listening to him? He's such a paradox. 🤣 👍👍
I really enjoyed this one. I wasn't so big on CSN, but I do love me some Y.
Classic album
decent, average 70s soft folk. 3.5/5
There are a couple songs I don’t like, but the ones I do are brilliant enough to make up for them.
Great album!
A classic. Too bad Neil won’t put it on Spotify 😂
Ja man mooi Neil young is wss wel de oudst klinkende twintiger ooit
Good but it did feel like I'd heard all the greatness that took from it and came after so this didn't it like crazy, I much prefer On The Beach's musical palette, but the songwriting and production here is still phenomenal
Look man, sometimes these albums don’t really need reviews. I’m not saying critics always got it right, but we have 52 years of evidence saying this is one of the greatest albums of all time and I think they nailed it in one.
Hard to rate these albums I’ve listened to 1000 times so they’ve gotten bit stale. This one has three very well know excellent but overrated songs, that I’ve heard too many times: Heart of Gold, Old Man, and Needle and the Damage Done, one excellent and underrated song: Out on the Weekend, one pretty good song: words Two decent songs: Are you Ready for the County and Alabama Two forgettable songs: a man needs a maid and There’s a world which are both crappy and overproduced. Overall it’s a classic album but not Neil Young’s best
Man, I love Neil Young. His vocals suck, his guitar work sucks, and his band is sloppy, but something about all of the elements together is pure folk magic. The poetry and melodies are timeless, beautiful storytelling, backed by some of greatest singer-songwriters of the generation. My dad introduced my to Neil Young when I was young, so this album will always have a place in my heart. Stand out tracks include: “Heart of Gold”, “Old Man”, “Alabama”, “Needle and the Damage Done”, and “Words”.
The moustache tattoo that I got lasered off of my finger came back after listening to this album. Love the folksy vocals, wailing steel guitar, and how varied the instrumental accompaniments are, ranging from raw guitar and drums to a full orchestra. "The Needle", "Old Man", "Harvest", and "Heart of Gold" are all standouts.
Really wish he would put his music back on Spotify
I know every word from every song on this one. It's like an old friend.
Very Neil Young
Like his last album on this list, I enjoyed this considerably more than I was originally expecting.
Nice vibe through the whole album. Chill to listen to.
No es mi estilo
Favourite Song: Old Man The orchestral moments seem to contrast the more folky. While nothing overly captured me, I did enjoy the blend of genres. Unfortunately, the album was not available on Spotify which did slightly alter the listening experience as I had to use YouTube. I don't imagine the original release had a McDonald's ad midway through.
Fantastic record from him. I've listening to Old Man for a long time now. What a great song written by such a young person. Still annoyed he pulled his work from spotify. 4.5/5
Yeah, Neil Young is Neil Young, and Harvest isn't a relevation in that regard. It sounds like pretty much everything else he's done and particularly similar to earlier efforts. This is lazy, I don't like his voice, and it's telling that he has to have a star-studded list of collaborators to try to elevate it. Even the supposedly seminal Heart Of Gold isn't great by any standard. He's a wannabe Bob Dylan who never ever ever got close to that quality of output. 2, and that's generous.
Are we nearly done with Neil Young now? To be fair, this is one of his better efforts, and has the song that everyone knows and is actually half decent. I think it just scrapes a 3 on the strength of Heart of Gold, but it's still a singer songwriter style without the lyrical dexterity that makes people who do that well successful.
Forgot how good this album was
Not my usual style, but pretty good.
Neil at his best. I wore the grooves out of this CD in the late 90s.
Harvest moon is my wedding song
All time classic
One of my favorites, a lovely record through and through. Perfect for crooning and yearning
Loved “Are You Ready for the Country?”, especially the guitars in it.
sadly not on spotify :')
Growing a serious appreciation for this guy. I've always liked this album but it's another one that hits differently as I'm older and I would easily rank it alongside On The Beach. I really like the ambition here even if it feels a bit strange in places. Specifically, 'A Man Needs a Maid' and 'There's a World' are the kind of songs I would like to know more about and what was going on at the time that put them together. Really, the whole album seems to make itself painfully obvious about a rich story and narrative and it does a great job of sucking you in while keeping things very concise. Sad, but in a good contemplative way.
Words is 5 stars
Worth it
Excellent album. Multiple hits, great guitar tones, awesome song writing
Since Neil Young is famously not on Spotify, I had to piece this album together from other sources. I *think* I hit most if it, and what I heard, I enjoyed. “Old Man” is such a great song both lyrically and musically. “Heart of Gold” is much simpler, but has a melody that really sticks with you.
I know this album very well but it’s been a long time since I listened to the whole album. I always loved this album and still do. Glad I listened again after so many years.
Great album
Still not on Spotify - which weirdly meant I was probably more focused on listening, since I wasn't driving or reading while listening to YouTube. A wonderful album, probably my favourite of his, with at least three stone cold classics and, in Old Man, one of my favourite songs from the "album era". Reading about Alabama also led me (through a classic wiki-dive, but on genius.com) to be reminded of this song: https://open.spotify.com/track/1STSziov35uhw9dnnxh92g?si=MG4x0jqOSmiJ9BEd4STkoQ and a few others from the same album, which is always a good thing anyway, and gives context to the legacy of that song and Southern Man.
Good album for the rainy drive home. Recognized quite a few songs from my dad listening to classic rock on the radio a lot. I liked how he mixed it up more than I would have thought for a folk guy, heard some big band elements, piano, etc. Not a big folk fan personally though.
A classic!
This album is a timeless classic. That being said, there are some tracks that divert my attention. But the opener and closer are pure magic.
classic
Enjoyed this a lot. I knew a few of the tracks already, but the lesser-known ones are every bit as good. Particularly strong finish - final three songs are bangers
Nice
One of my top 10 albums!!
An album of hits and whiffs.
It was OK, some tracks (such as Heart of Gold) better than others. It was short, being less than 40 minutes. I give it 3 stars.
great collection of classic Neil Young tunes
Love Neil Young. Saw him in concert. Amazing!!!!
another neil young album! i really liked the first one i listened to, and surprise surprise i like this one too. compared to the sometimes melancholy feel of the first one, this one feels, while not OVERLY cheerful just a tad more positive in terms of mood, swapping that pre-grunge sound for more of the humble and hunky-dory country... according to an interview it's a bit calmer due to neil unfortunately hurting his back; he couldn't stand up and perform during that time. very glad he was able to pull through and still make some beautiful songs despite his condition.
Either I'm being beaten into submission or this is just one of the betterNeil youngs albums of the many ones on this cursed list. But it's still Neil Young, knock a star off for the overspill of crap I've had to listen to.
Fuck off it’s one of my all time favorite albums.
The best songs on this album make me want to rate it a five. There is a very authentic sorrow and pain behind his voice. The worst songs on this album make me want to rate it a one. He’s being such a whiny bum and he doesn’t even sound good while doing it.
Lots of classic songs. Pretty flawless album. Would be 5* but not so much to my taste. If you’re into this sound it’s 5. For me a strong 4.
Goooooood.
I feel like Neil Young is the king of bad lyrics with really good music. The instrumentals are so good, but I just don't care about most of what Neil is saying. Old Man is a good song, though.
Ganz großes Tennis
This one really depends on the mood. Sometimes it hits a chord, sometimes I find it grating.
Nice album full of amazing songs from the legendary songwriter. 4.9/5 Fav: “Are You Ready For The Country” Least Fav: I have none.
I'm aware that this is a classic and a listen through showed beautiful melody and lyrics. But I had to find it on YouTube and the ads really disrupted my flow.
Super....mega!
I've only ever listened to the top 40 hits from this album. It's really so much more country than I remember. I was 7 when this came out and didn't hear it until I was in college. Went down a rabbit hole and now have to watch the Harvest Time documentary.
The one and only - milestone! "I hope Neil Young will remember ..." had to be earned ;-)
Had to go to youtube music to find it. not my vibe today. I can see it being a good one on a day I'm feeling far more like a chill sound.
As a kid I could never understand why my parents liked him, with a voice like that. Now I get the vibes and can appreciate it on a certain level, but it’s not a go-to album in my rotation. I thought Neil was a great addition to Crosby, Stills & Nash though.
Like everything Neil Young makes, it is easy to listen to and has some rather clever lyrics and musical decisions here and there. I couldn't tell you a Neil Young album I love top to bottom, but this is yet another one I could easily throw on while doing something and enjoy.
Beauty and boredom, all rolled into one.
Sounded like one, long monotonous song that made me question the point of existing. Well, perhaps it wasn't quite that bad, but I do fail to see the attraction and why so many people rave about Neil Young. Maybe that says more about me than anything else.
I have this album but I haven’t listened to it in a long time. Still great!
Not available on spotify
Before I started this project I really underappreciated Neil Young. Everything I've heard of his is solid.
Groundbreaking? Not sure but like the play on words. I bet the hardest song for him to sing was only 2:03 long. Reliving losing your friend to such a terrible drug has got to be hard.
Highlights: Heart of Gold, Old Man, The Needle and the Damage Done, Words Lowlights: A Man Needs a Maid (what was going on there?)
Harvest is at times incredibly simple and other so huge. Young’s melodies so strong, simple and unique. He mixed his classic Neil Young electric guitar in with his unique acoustic playing style and adds in grand strings on songs like A Man Needs a Maid. Heart of Gold, Old Man and The Needle and the Damage Done are all masterpieces 9.0/10
Not my jam
1/4/24. Gotta give it to Neil Young, he can write a song. Mostly acoustic driven with some tracks having accompanying strings and background vocals. Many of the songs would be fun to learn on guitar!
"Harvest by Neil Young is like a musical crop yielding a harvest of quirky brilliance. It's the only album where you can simultaneously sway to the tunes and contemplate the deep, philosophical implications of the harmonica. It's so good that even scarecrows would ditch their posts to two-step in the fields. Neil Young didn't just plant seeds with this album; he cultivated a garden of musical hilarity that leaves you wondering if your ears just experienced a musical harvest festival.