Reviews (page 6 of 13)
Didn't like this as much as I thought I would.
She does an absolutely brilliant cover of The Who's My Generation (on the Legacy Edition CD, it was originally a B side on the 7" of Gloria) that had me replaying the second it ended-loved it! The album proper is pretty good but not sure how likely I'm to ever hear it again nothing wrong with it, but I found it a little boring. Some say it's the first punk album, but it doesn't sound punk to me when I think of punk I think of Ramones, Sex Pistols, UK Subs, Black Flag, etc. this to me sounds like singer/song writer stuff just a bit angrier. I get why it's such a highly regarded album, but I prefer listening to Cradle of Filth's cover of Allison Hell off a fairly recent COF album that is a complete return to form & is up there with all the early albums- if you ever liked COF check out stuff like Cryptoriana to this year's The Screaming of Valkyries- what a late career (mid career? Isn't Dani like 50?) delight! John Cale (of The Velvet Underground) produced Horses I guess he & Patti Smith butted heads a lot and a member of her group almost got in a fist fight with. Also, one man from Blue Oyster Cult (Lanier) and one man from Television (Verlaine) appear on the album.
I don’t get it, probably never will. There’s good elements of this, though. Opening line of “Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine” raised my expectations a lot. She just keeps chewing on her words so the delivery is annoying. Best songs were Redondo Beach, Kimberly, and Gloria. Calm 5-6/10
This fucking sucked
Gloria started out strong. The rest of the album didn't really make me tune in.
I enjoyed this one more than I thought I would
Wasn't very good
Birdland
This feels like a good album to clean the house to. Like, just turn up the volume and mindlessly work around the house with this on. Also kinda feels like movie montage music for such a scene. Generally, I like it. Not really adding it to my regular listening list. But I can see why people would.
This artist seemed to me like a knock off stevie nicks. I’m not even sure what genre this belongs to? Punk n roll? Apparently this album is not only one of the 1001 greatest albums but is also a top 100 album all time. It wasn’t for me. I do appreciate the artist’s sentiment, though: “it doesn’t ask to be understood, only felt.”
Started out alright but seemed to be a train off its tracks and was a mess by the end.
Few interesting songs, especially her version of Gloria as the opener, but otherwise not something id pick up again.
I can understand how it was ahead of its time, some songs have good energy, didn’t roll my eyes as hard at it as i did in the past. Still not for me…2.5 with a round down
+++
album was damn good, chill vibes
The first few tracks were bops but I didn’t really jive with the rest. It’s really clear where Geese is getting their sound frlm
good evening music
I respect Patti Smith. She's got great lyrics. I liked a recent podcast interview I listened to where she was the guest (with Ezra Klein), but I'm just not really into this punk/folk stuff. It's alright, but a lot of these songs just don't hit for me. I need my punk to be a bit less folk and my folk to be a bit less punk.
There’s nothing here that I’d ever want to hear again.
This is not an easy listen. She seems to be trying to sing poorly, widely varying her pitch in odd places, slurring words. When I could understand the lyrics, they didn't make sense. Much of the album is spoken word over background music, and it all seems like a dark, twisted poetry slam. I suppose that was her intent, to rebel against standards of music.
Yeah, it wasn’t too bad, but some of the songs had that whisper singing that I hate.
I enjoyed this.
I was lucky enough to see Patti Smith live just last year, and let me tell you at 77 she still can command a stage. An all time classic. 5/5
Jarring vocals.
I wish I liked the album better, but it's clearly not bad, Patti has a lot of fun in it, and I've liked her other songs.
when poetry and punk collide... you'll find this album somewhere in the middle.
good
It was really hard for me to form an opinion of this album as I just found the way Patti Smith's sang, irritating. Most of the time, I just couldn't wait for the songs to end, and I thought she dragged on the ending of many of the songs way too long. I liked the different instruments which added to the music, but I was biased as I just couldn't get past my dislike of the way she sang. All that said, my favorite song on the album was "Elegie" which was surprising as it was basically just her singing with a piano. Worst song, in my opinion, was "My Generation". I just felt like she was trying too hard to be a "hard-rocker". The second half of the album were live versions of the songs, and I've never really been a fan of live versions as I really don't want to hear all the clapping, hooting and hollering from the audience. The more than 17 minutes of the combination of the songs "Land: Horses Land of a Thousand Dances etc" was entirely too long.
The first album on here that Ive reviewed that I’ve listened to. Patti smith, th punk rock poet laureate. Her debut album is phenomenal Gloria is so devistating right off the rip (Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine). And while I do love some of the more traditional songs, redondo beach and free money, the long standing songs is what makes it special May not be peoples bags, and not something I listen to it too often, but it’s the Patti smith experience that I enjoy .
This album was raw proto-punk poetry; I spiraled through attraction and revulsion but could not turn away. Some of this was too avant-garde (to put it nicely) to enjoy—looking at you, "Birdland"—but there's still something compelling about music that can be this fucking weird. Patti Smith's voice, both sonically and lyrically, is strong and strange, taking me to places I didn't expect, and while I don't think this album is an every day listen, after this, I do want to seek out more of her work! Best: "Kimberly" Worst: "Birdland"
No thank you, 1/5. I'm a big defender that an "album" doesn't just have to be pure music, and I am absolutely willing to rate an album well if the experience was thought provoking or enjoyable in some creative alternative way. So I feel I was open minded when I realized this album was more aligned with poetry than traditional music. However, I imagine the song "Birdland" would be similar to the result of putting an 8 year old on a stage and telling them to make up a song on the spot, and telling a very competent pianist to try and keep up with the made up songs direction.
I really really like this one. Gloria in excelsis Deo is an instant grab and it didn’t let me go (10/10); Redondo Beach was like a comforting hug (8/10); Free Money is a fun song and honestly kind of motivating (8/10); Break it up had a mixed vibe, where the music was saying one thing but the lyrics another, and really the most thought provoking song in the album (7.5/10). The rest were good, sometimes sad, but otherwise not that remarkable. Overall, a solid 8/10, would listen again.
Not my thing
Trailblazer. Iconic. I loved listening to this intently and all the way through.
Enjoyable but didn't love. Very clear paving of the way for other acts. Will try again
If Lou Reed were a woman she'd make this album. Good thing she did because this amazing album is better than what the Velvets have done. 5/5
its alright i guess
Cover 5 My favorite Patti Smith album. Granted, I haven't listened to her whole discography.
I don't even get how this is considered punk rock, let alone one of the greatest albums of all time. Like, it's not bad at all but whenever I listen to this I'm like "So, that's it, huh?"
Not my thing
Really enjoyed this entire album. I will need to revisit this later to digest the lyrics.
This is phenomenal. Of the Television, Lou Reed, Velvet Underground, New York Dolls, et al bands coming out of that scene in New York this is the true master work. Smith manages to be sexy, poetic, and also a real rock and roll act. I only wish I had heard this a long time ago.
Great album, can’t believe it was a debut
vokser på meg. kjenner at det er noe jeg kan like å høre på
3,1/5
the good songs are very good and the bad ones hurt lol. overall i like it
It was great! Party rock similar to Janis Joplin.
Utrolig alternativt opplegg fra 70 tallet, helt ok, trenger ikke å høre igjen.
It was good. I prefer her more pop and rock songs, but this was a fine morning album.
Freaking brilliant rock and roll. The best album I've never heard before, and it will probably soon be my favorite album of the year
Just ok
I just wasn't in the mood for this. On another day maybe I would have appreciated it's heart and commitment - but today it just wasn't melodious enough for me.
Smith is one of the original punks. This albums fall pretty much as the crossroads between the garage rock music of bands like The Stooges and New York Dolls and the proper punk that would follow. The difference is the strong singer-songwriter leanings of these songs. They aren't folk per se, but the poetry of the lyrics is written in such a way that makes them feel like that. Key tracks: Gloria
Butt
Forerunner for a lot of angst ridden grunge in the 90s. Not an easy listen and certainly not an album to return to. One for the chin strokers only.
FFS i had a whole write up for this that has just disappeared. Anyway it was basically, I wamted to like this. I didnt like this. Her overuse of inflection annoys me.
Patti Smith is definitely one of the most influential artists of the 1970s. She took the beat poetry of the 60s and married it to the New York punk sensibilities of the early 70s with a distinctive voice. You can trace a direct line from her to Blondie, Chrissie Hynde and others, and further out to artists like Nick Cave. The power of this album is found in the quiet moments that purr with menace and then explode into full on freak outs. Essential listening.
Decent
This was pretty good. Never heard any of these songs before. I'm only familiar with Patti Smith from the singles that got lots of airplay over time.
Good album, enjoyed it but did not love it. A few good songs but not anything I felt a strong connection to or emotional reaction to.
I get it but not really my vibe
I liked Free Money but that’s about it. Too many spoken word type elements for my liking.
I wanted to love this, trailblazing punk (really?) that I understood it to be, but couldn't get into it 😕
Great opener, a bit downhill from there, but enjoyed overall!
Reminds me of Yoko Ono ( not a compliment). Perhaps that was the sound for the time and it got pressed on vinyl. I do admire Simone who followed a dream to make music.
My dear old friend. No idea what I can say about it that hasn’t been said. It’s been with me about half my life. Long enough ago that I got it at a used CD shop, college I think. Its meaning has only expanded for me over the year. I have fantasies about doing a karaoke version of “Free Money” but doubt I could ever keep up. But I’ve certainly said every word many times. Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine…
Despedimos la semana con una bestia como Patti Smith y con Horses, su espectacular debut musical. Imposible no escucharla y no verla como una adelantada a toda la movida alternativa/indie de muchos años después con su forma de cantar, su estética y sus letras. Lo anterior me hace pensar inevitablemente en la actualidad porque, ¿a quién tenemos de referente que tenga estas búsquedas, éste compromiso a reconvertir sus vivencias en arte? ¿Alguien tomará la posta o es algo extinto y ya no existirán músicxs así? Dejo estas reflexiones y me retiro hasta el lunes. Gracias miles por un álbum cinco estrellas.
Good tunes, like the vibe. Probably not something I'd really come back to. 3.75
7/10
Absolutely essential—and always a pleasure to listen to. Smith’s vocals are strong and gritty/rough (yes, that’s a compliment).
I guess I'm supposed to like this because everyone and their brother who is a music critic absolutely loves this album. I did not. Sorry! 2 / 5 stars because it's not god awful like Krautrock.
in between the Velvet Underground and Television, with a woman poet carving out space for the future if you don't think that rocks I am sad for the things you have missed in life. music: appreciated. (⌐■_■)
One of the greats, obviously. Gotta be a geek to not see that. A real dweeb
Mehhh
Idk about this one. Not my style.
patti smith walked so SOPHIE could run.
Brilliant record, has a punk attitude but more expansive. Lyrically intriguing.
Quite good, rather cool, very influential, but not something I’ll voluntarily revisit in the future.
I've really struggled to rate this because it was fine. I thought Patti Smith would be a bit grittier.
Easily one of the best albums ever. Gloria is a hell of an opener. I don't know what the fuck Patti is singing about for most of the album but she makes it sound cool. The band is great. Slinky and quiet and rockin. A classic. Great Cover Art.
Very pleasantly surprised. Can see her influences to the later generations. Early for her to be doing her style and singing. Loved it.
Respect it, don't really love it. 3.4/5
I think this belongs on the list, I think Patti Smith was influential for a lot of other groups that came after. I didn't have the patience for it when I was younger. I listened to it again and found things to enjoy about it. I probably won't listen to it end-to-end often but I enjoy the Gloria-based track the most.
Entiendo que este álbum haya ido ganando adeptos con los años y que al principio la irrupción de Patty Smith no fuera de la mano de un éxito inmediato. Demasiado vanguardista para la época, y eso que la sombra de Warhol estaba detrás. No obstante, creo que si esto lo hubiera lanzado un hombre en lugar de una mujer de aspecto andrógino le habrían ido las cosas mucho mejor. Dicho esto, a mí el disco me atrapa desde el minuto uno por su carácter urbano, mundano y lírico a partes iguales. Y porque Patty es una intérprete de diez. Fuera de lo obvio, no he podido evitar recordar “Miserable Lie” de The Smiths mientras escuchaba “Free Money” y “The Hand That Rocks The Cradle” del mismo álbum del cuarteto de Mánchester al escuchar “Kimberly”. ¿A alguien le pasa algo parecido?
Enjoyed this more than I expected.
I feel like I should care about this album, but I just can't. Fair play to the lass, but it just doesn't tickle any of my bones
Dette var ikke noe for meg. Fikk litt hippie-vibes.
This is one of those albums that you're SUPPOSED to love, but I don't. It's just not enjoyable to listen to. I appreciate Patti Smith and her lyrics and voice and that she was groundbreaking in the punk scene, so I feel like I must give it a 3, but all I really want to hear from her is Because the Night and Dancing Barefoot. 3⭐️
I kinda hated this like singing word vomit
damn i sure hate her voice
5.7/10 - instrumentals were good. Some songs had nice rolling beats. The piano was nice on others. The squawky style of singing just wasn’t for me unfortunately. Land (7.5) and Redondo Beach (7.2) were the best, while Birdland (4) was my least favorite…
Wow this album is so unique. Patti has a "voice" that is quite different and might annoy some with her whining and exploring her vocals but I quite like it. The songs that shine on this album really shine. The songs that don't are still interesting to listen to. I'm compelled to listen to this one again, but next time in a better setting so I can really focus on the lyrics.
“Jesus died for somebody’s sins BUT NOT MINE!” What a bold way to start an album, and what an album this is. This album is dark, angry, and sensual all at the same time. If I had to boil it down, Patti takes everything that came before her in the Rock scene (namely Bob Dylan, the Doors, Hendrix, and to a lesser extent the Rolling Stones) and splices it with her unique experiences and poetic skills to create something psychedelic and absolutely RAW. Best Tracks: - Gloria: In Excelsis Deo - Birdland - Land: Horses/Thousand Dances/La Mer (^This track especially is fantastic, first time in a while a song has had me in a trance trying to understand it, it’s INTENSE!) Worst track: - Redondo Beach
Patti Smith is legendary, and not without reason, but I think this album is a classic example of “appreciate the impact but don’t love the music” that sometimes happens with these mainstay records. Heretically, I feel the same way about Sgt. Pepper’s from The Beatles (I’m a white album kinda boy). There are some songs here that I like, but nothing here that I love. To be fair, there’s nothing I actively dislike either, but still, I find myself somewhat unmoved by what some call music’s first punk statement. Also, she said some weird shit about Mick Jagger and wrote a crazy song using the n word a lot, which feels bizarre as fuck. Her book, Just Kids, is pretty good though
I wanted to enjoy this album. I really did. I did not enjoy this album. I think Patti Smith's voice is just not for me. I couldn't get past it no matter how hard I tried. My favorite song on the album was Break It Up. My least favorite was Land.
I was driving through horse country while listening to this album, which is most likely not the best setting to consume it in. Very manic, very strange, very cool. I'm between a 2.5 or a 3 here. There were a few songs I really enjoyed, but it didn't quite land for me with the limited time I had with it. These are the flaws with one album a day; I think I could've gotten a lot more out of this with more time, and I probably will in the future.
I enjoyed this well enough, although the production on some songs left a lot to be desired -- "Redondo Beach" sounds like some of the kid's music I play for Mason. I really loved the first track, but was left wanting more over the album. I plan on relistening since there is such an emphasis on the lyrics and it deserves more attention. I'm always fascinated by the intersection of music and literature and have thought a lot about poetry in a musical space. I always think of Gilbert Scott-Heron, but Smith brings something unique to that conversation.
“Horses tore my limbs off and put them back on in a whole different order. I was like: "Shit, yeah, oh my god!" then I threw up."” -Michael Stipe I’ve been listening to this album since I was like 14 and read Please Kill Me for the first time. Every time I hear it, I appreciate more and more just how special it really is. This time I listened with the lyrics pulled up, following along with every single line and, again, it hit me like never before. This album is like the big bang. You don't have to like it, but you can't deny it. This is one of the most truly perfect pieces of recorded media ever created. Horses was, I believe, the first album released by one of the resident CBGB artists and, for that reason, has a claim to being the first punk album. By blending "intellectual" influences and contemporaries like Bob Dylan, Lou Reed, Television (Tom Verlaine is here!), and Talking Heads with the raw, simple, instrumentation of the Stooges, Ramones, and garage bands like the Kingsmen and Troggs, Patti Smith made a case for the NYC underground scene as something that demanded attention as it came to liberate us from the tyranny of masturbatory prog rock bullshit. There’s a reason she has been cited as an inspiration by everyone from Springsteen to Madonna (I'd argue there's a very direct line from the juxtaposition of sacred and profane in the version of "Gloria" on this record to that same trope being on display in "Like a Prayer") to Sonic Youth to Dua Lipa. Taylor Swift saying "I'm not Patti Smith" in the title track to TTPD was the closest she’s come to humility in the last 5 years. "Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine" sounds like some edge-lord shit today but in 1975 it was a genuinely stunning mission statement. Such a simple declaration of autonomy and rejection of tradition. The storytelling here is visceral. You've got suicide, alien abductions, sex, drugs, rock and roll, religion. The lyrics to every song are like 10 pages long and sound borderline improvised and driven purely by emotion at points. It's like she's speaking in tongues.
Appreciated some of the energetic and spitfire moments of this one, but overall struggled to enjoy the artsy punk direction. Every 70s punk album gets me closer to getting it, but it's still challenging for me to really dig.
fav: free money 🖤
Bleh. Nothing about this is interesting.
Very famous album that I must admit to have never listened to before! I was a little disappointed given all the history and hype though. I can see where Polly Harvey drew inspiration from. Really enjoyed Free Money and Kimberly but not so much the rock and roll songs. Will probably come back to it though.
Meh, not for me.
Grew on me and understand where Nick Cave got a lot of his influence now.
Props for a version of “Gloria” that I have not heard before, and her obvious influence on other artists. With two 9 minute tracks this album plays longer than it is and is not one I’ll go back to. 2.5/5
I’ve listened to this album at various life time points over the years, but it still never really lands for me. I can appreciate her place in the story of punk rock given the attitude and delivery here, but I’ll always be a bigger fan of her fellow NYC/CBGB contemporaries like Television and The Ramones. The album and her sound is definitely unique for that period with the combination of rock music and poetic lyrics, but at times she seems to be in a poetry slam competing with herself. Still, with so many bands citing this album as a major influence (REM, Siouxsie, Johnny Merr, etc.) it’s hard to discount her influence.
Some interesting/good moments and at times I loved her voice. Other times I thought it was just awful and headache inducing noice. Birdland? What the shit is that? I liked Break It Up and really cool guitar tone…but the end goes into nonsense and turns me off. 2.25
I'll give Patti Smith props for being a punk pioneer but this album has never resonated with me. Rounding up based on influence. 2.75/5
There’s no denying the influence or the conviction behind Horses. Patti Smith sounds fearless, defiant, and fully in control of her art. But for all its power and poetry, it’s not something I connect with deeply. Some tracks land beautifully, others feel more like endurance tests. I respect it more than I love it — a touchstone album, but not one I’ll return to often.
Raw, progressive, energetic and ahead of its time.
Not great. Not enough happening outside of the spoken word parts to justify the song lengths. Gloria is a good song, but the rest is immensely forgettable and not anything I wanna listen to ever again.
Very great Art Rock and Proto-Punk album. Every song here is very good I just don't find much replay value.
This album is decent. Not amazing. There are some cool tracks on here, no doubt. I loved Free Money, great song. Admittedly, Birdland was an epic tune, even if I didn’t care for it. Gloria was also good. But a few others were not as great. Land in particular, I found pretty derivative. Still, there’s a cool vibe about this album and Smith’s voice is great. Nothing I’d come back to over and over again though.
I wanted to love this but I didn't connect with it
Awesome
Decent.
Not bad, not totally my thing.
man new york rocks... shout out john cale
Funny, I was familiar with "Jesus died for his own sins, but not mine" from "Asylum" on the Crass album "The Feeding of the 5,000", but never knew it was actually inspired by Patti Smith's opening song on "Horses". That said, I actually never listened to nor had this album in my collection. I had (of course) heard of this album, but somehow, never came to listen to it. Although I would classify it rather proto-punk than punk proper, it absolutely helped create the blueprint for what punk could be, beyond just fast/loud/aggressive. Also, I can see how this album influenced later New Wave, such as Siouxie and The Banshees and other female punk acts like Nina Hagen or The Slits. It's undeniably arty, with its (spoken word) poetic lyrics, but also have some raw edges, primarily due to Lenny Kaye's rudimentary guitar work, which I quite liked. 4/5
An album I already know and love. Brilliant excuse to have a full length listen. Patti Smith owns a special section of my heart. Her music really makes me feel free and wild😝
I can't recognise a (proto-) punk. For years, I underestimated Patti Smith and tended to ignore her. She makes great music. This album is also fantastic. I think I'll listen to it again. 4/5
Fucking terrible.
Not terrible but had a decent amount of skips
One of the extremely rare 5 stars I give out and an all time great debut album. I've wanted to see her ever since this album was released and I finally get to in November. And to make it even better, it's the 50th anniversary of the album and she is performing the whole album with the original band.
Not really my jam. I can see why people think it's exceptional, though.
Definitely different. Were some parts that were quite decent, but mostly got hung up around the disturbing lyrics about splitting someone’s head up and crawling inside a skull. The sometimes erratic singing didn’t really suit me either.
I actually did see Patti Smith at a music festival back in 2010. I think I convinced a friend to go see her with me since she was “a legend.” The concert wasn’t particularly good, and I realized I didn’t actually know any of her songs. My knowledge of Patti Smith hasn’t really increased since then. I mostly know her as the original writer of “Because the Night.” I do recognize this album cover, though. So, how was it? I think it has a lot of confidence and vision, she clearly set out to do something different. The opening line of the album, “Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine,” immediately gets you hooked. The whole first track is by far the best one; the way it builds up, paired with her great vocals, makes it a very memorable listen. The rest of the album doesn’t really keep up, though. I wasn’t particularly a fan of the spoken-word parts, nor of the covers. I’m going to settle on a 3. I get why this album became famous, it certainly isn’t bland, and there are some good tracks here and there. Oh, and the CD version includes a great live cover of “My Generation.”
Ok 2.5
Yow, I didn’t get that one. I can certainly hear the velvet revolver sound. Not something my ear could make sense of.
Wow! This blew me away. Truly glad I did hear this before I died.
Really poetic writing.
Oozing with emotion and grit. Infectiously energetic, super clever songwriting style.
Uneventful
Very good, reminds me of Lou Reed. 4.49 stars.
Not bad but not my favorite
I enjoyed listening to this; it instantly got me thinking how many stars to award. Gloria is a great opener and had me thinking this could easily be a 4 star outing but for the most part, the album didn’t quite grab me in the same way. It wasn’t until the penultimate track that I found the best song on the album, Land, which elevated it towards those 4 stars once more but on reflection, whilst this brings a lot of punk spirit and is clearly influential, I’m giving this the 3 star treatment with a note to return and see how I find it next time.
Had to skip through songs. The vocals rubbed me the wrong way. I think the lyrics were interesting, but I didn't want to listen to them.
Quintessential 70’s sound. Not my favorite and wanted to skip the vocals but I can see the appeal.
I was suprised by Patti. Very intense songs, but some worked very well. Favorites are Gloria: and Horses:
Not a fan
Kul plate.
yessssssssss
heard this before some time ago Gloria - 5/5 Redondo Beach - 4/5 Birdland - 3/5 Free Money - 5/5 Kimberly - 5/5 Break It Up - 5/5 Land - 5/5 Elegie - 5/5 Average score: 4.6/5 (rounding up)
Unique. Spoken sections in many songs. Poetic. I understand why people dig her.
This album was already in my library so I heard it before I died and this list. It rocks.
First time listener. It was good.
thrilling, infuriating, baffling - all of the above, but you will definitely have a sonic reaction to Horses. No 3-stars sitting on the fence here. I'm not quite all in but can imagine seeing her live around this time would be a total five, but it's a pretty wild ride, as much MC5 as Pistols (not really Pistols at all). One of the great debuts.
Patti Smith makes me feel strong. Incredible lyrics, this fury inside her, she is so fucking cool. The world she paints in Horses is entirely her own, confident, and integrity. Psychedelic, bluesy, but the highlight is her. Her voice is not traditionally great but that's not the point. The point is her delivery, half spoken-word and half singing.
1001 Albums Challenge (20/1001) 1. Gloria (5/5) 2. Redondo Beach (5/5) 3. Birdland (5/5) 4. Free Money (5/5) 5. Kimberly (5/5) 6. Break It Up (5/5) 7. Land (5/5) 8. Elegie (5/5) Total (5/5)
Heard this album a million times but only today for the first time I noticed she ends this album with a line from one of my very favorite Jimi Hendrix songs, 1983 (A Merman I Should Turn To Be), "It's too bad that our friends can't be with us today." Prior to noticing that, I was thinking about how it's the covers Gloria and Land Of 1000 Dances where she and the band really shine. Creativity takes many forms and in purely sonic terms this album can underwhelm but if you can appreciate it for what it is, its peaks are brilliant. I love this album and I think people will be talking about the scene in New York she helped to define for a long time to come and she was a meaningful part of that. But also bigger than a scene, in terms of rock n roll, she was a musical Magellan, charting the course forward out of Altamont, leading us ultimately in to Never Mind The Bollocks. God bless Patti Smith! More than a national treasure, she deserves a special designation from the UN, like Stonehenge.
This is possibly the first time I've ever listened to this album, despite knowing for many years that it's high up in the pantheon of greatest albums of all time. "Gloria" starts it all with quite a bang, and probably ranks up there as one of the great cover songs (if it even qualifies as such); "Free money" continues the assault quite well. In some ways, though, it feels like "Birdland" and "Land" best represent Smith's vision of marrying poetry and (rock) music, and while I'm not sure I could say I particularly enjoyed either track as much as many people have, they feel pretty unique and challenging, especially for their time. I'm sure I approached this album in a more reverent way than I would have if I had never heard of it, but I can see why it's pretty seminal in the annals of rock/punk/music.
This album was on permanent repeat when I was 16 in 1980, though the heavier "Radio Ethiopia" will always be my favorite p. smith album. Finally, a female role model who wasn't conventionally pretty, cute, sexy and who didn't seem at all concerned about it. She had more interesting things to do, such as blend French surrealism with Motown and her poetry and perform with her band. Shame on this list for including only one of her albums while having multiples of (looking at the Bs) Beck, Belle & Sebastian, Bjork, Blur, Tim Buckley, and Kate Bush. List dude's the kind of wanker she didn't give a shit about.
Nice
Exhausting but pretty interesting. Need to be in a specific mindset to enjoy this though.
Pre: Don't know this album at all, is it rock, or like Kate bush and artsy? Post: it was both, artsy rock n roll with Jim Morrison influences
My girlfriend works next to where Patti Smith lives and she’s rude as hell so two stars sorry.
I love her !!!
weird
Sometimes revolutionary music is trapped in its era.
Quite cool
Another album that continues to grow on me. Patti is like the grandmother of punk 🤘 Favorite track: Gloria
Stupendous album with some beautiful songs on it.
interessante
Rating: 2.7 I liked it okay. Probably edgy for the time but just about put me to sleep in this current timeline. Not sure why this album is considered top 10-20 all time in many circles.
I just did not enjoy this album. Maybe I’m missing something? But the music did not grab me and I just found it a bit strange.
I'd never really listened to Patti Smith before but I liked this a lot. A little punky, a little Doors-y.
Não é um álbum que eu vou escutar novamente. As músicas só ficam meio legais no final; a voz tremula com certeza não me agradou. As que eu achei razoáveis: "Break It Up" e "Land" (se ela não prolongasse muito as músicas, ia ser perfeito).
Oh yessss Patrizia Schmid! S best album vo ihre, het mi richtig zum wiehere bracht! Im Galopp zu dene 4 geile Hengst!
Puvv gar nüd speziells gsi oder. Vlt biz zu rockig patti 3 hamburger mit patties grrn
Easy zum lose, als Hintergrundmusig. aber jz nid mi lieblingsmusig / style
Nice proto punk. Love the opening track. But not that many good songs I would want to hear again. Don’t particularly dig her voice.
I wanted to like this more than I did.
The vibe is impeccable. Patti Smith is one of the coolest people alive, and the highlights are brilliant. It does get a little samey, and her lyrics don't have the verbosity of a Dylan or Bowie. She's more like Cohen - takes some simplistic ideas and explores them as far as she can. I was feeling like a strong 3, just because I was craving for something a bit different, and then Elegie provided that, so a 4.
Loved it!
Легенда. И альбом отличный. Лучшая песня - Gloria: In Excelsis Deo.
First time listening to Patti Smith properly. Lots of artists talk the influence of the great Patti Smith. Wasn't amazed by it. However may grow after a few more listens
I get what Patti Smith is going for but her voice is just annoying to me. I respect the attempt though, it's something different. Just not for me. 4.75/10 (2.375/5)
O album horses é como realmente cavalos correndo em um largo campo. Mas cavalos confusos. Alguns muito rápidos e alguns bem perdidos e desconexos do grupo.
que desgosto ouvir esse album
Oh, I get why some people don't like this. But those people and I respond to music very differently. I loved it. It weaves a spell. Fascinating, authentic, and cool as.
Good stuff
Sounded pretty unique for it's time, Gloria was the star by far, the rest wasn't bad, more appreciated it for what it is than liked listening to it.
first listen hm
Fierce, intense, powerful voice as advertised. Wish she had better songs.
Not really my bag.
This was strange and I love esoteric punk stuff generally but can’t quite figure this one out. Not sure if I’ll come back
Gloria is amazing. Absolute banger. The rest was ok. Nothing I would go back for.
This is just brilliant. Reminded me of PJ Harvey so very much up my street. The standout track for me was Free Money which I think reminded me of a PJ Harvey/Kate Bush infusion which is just great
An excellent album in many ways, also I imagine quite polarising. She can’t be everyone’s cup of tea that’s for sure. However, I bloody loved this!
This was way more fun and playful than I remembered. Always loved the first track but maybe now I'm not a Christian I can appreciate it way more XD. Enjoyable throughout, inspiring in places but a tad long. Would give it 4.5 if possible
So I had never heard a Patti Smith song before, and was expecting something more traditionally folky (don't know why). This album was cool though! Did not think there'd be some reggae in there. Patti Smith has a great voice (it's the first voice that I've really enjoyed so far). Very charismatic and soulful. Some of the songs were a bit rambling but I did generally enjoy it. More of a 3.5 for me, but it's better than the other 3s, so I'm giving it a 4!
I wanted to enjoy this one but I didn't really at all. I find her voice annoying and the musicians sound like a jam band. I find jangly guitars difficult to get along with and it was all just a bit noodly and directionless. If I had to pick some nicer moments they would be on Free Money and Kimberley, but no. This album is not for me.
Great to revisit this. I still love the straight-up, dramatic, brilliantly executed instrumentation and wild, dark, playful poetry. Gloria and Land: Horses.. were always my favourites and still still stand out to me with their 60s R&B/soul references, semi-religious/sacrareligious vibes, and particular playfulness in the lyrics. There's something really brilliant for me in how it plays with and twists rock'n'roll story tropes and imagery, and that was certainly a lot of the appeal when I was younger and more obsessed with that stuff. I enjoyed the whole thing though, just as it started to get a bit samey something shifts up, a well structured album in that way. Kimberley and Elegie also stood out. I'd like to spend some time with other Patti Smith records, I haven't done much of that.
I expected to love this, but found it difficult to really get in to. Took a few tries but warmed up and eventually yearned for more. Likely just getting to it a bit late, but intrigued to listen to the legacy version at some point
Really liked this. Would listen to again and her other stuff. Last track reminded me of Kate Bush a bit.
Would like to like it more.
I'm literally a dyke who listens to post-punk and studied french literature, how have I never properly listened to this before
I don’t mind Patti Smith in small doses, but a whole album is a bit much.
Lady Paul Newman punk rock-lite. Interesting (if nothing else) lyrics and talented backing band made this a fun listen, but couldn't help but feel that the whole thing is overrated.
This album's great. Idk what more to say given realistically I know nothing about Patti Smith or her influence. I had listened to the album a couple times before the challenge. Still don't have a strong opinion Fav Track: Birdland 8.5/10 (likely to change)
Sure, why not?
It wasn’t bad album overall. There was some good, some not that good songs. Didn’t really have a favourite song from this album. Seemed like an album you would play in a coffee house.
Close to a 5. I really liked this album. I love her voice, it reminds me of Gwen Stefani a little bit. Especially on Redondo Beach and Birdland. I love a good piano in songs too. I wish it was a little longer actually. The poetry parts I usually find annoying or jarring but she worked them in flawlessly. Great album
Meh. Nothing I particularly loved about this album.
Lo-fi and kinda strange. Not really my taste, but it was fine.
Meh. Don't see the fuss.
An absolute tour de force.
never connected that pj harvey exists because of this album
I've always been ambivalent toward Patti Smith's songs, respecting her work and influence more than enjoying her music. I should have dug into her earlier stuff more.
Not for me
Opening with Gloria, apparently this is a Van Morrison cover. I guess we are in the really early stages of punk, the piano caught me off guard. Birdland is really out there, this is a bonkers track 3 for your debut album. I’ve never really heard anything like this before. It’s kind of stream of consciousness lyrically. I’m not sure this is for me. I can see how it was sort of pre-punk but I personally don’t really vibe with it that much. I think probably 2.5/5 maybe. For me 3 is neutral and this was a novelty but a bit of a struggle.
Her voice is good. But music wise it’s a bit boring and nothing stands out, at least for me. She did try spicing up the album by more emotive delivery. But her brokenness ended up sounding really unnatural and unnecessary.
i started out really liking this, and then i listened to it a second time with headphones in and had a chance to listen in a lot more for the lyrics, and honestly... it was pretty meh. i love me some poetry and spoken word, but this just didn't grip me. i'm sure Patty Smith is up there for a reason, and she probably has some really unique insights within those lyrics... but it just didn't grab me.
I think the significance of this album are lost on me. I also found my level of enjoyment depended on the environment I was listening in, at work while trying to meet a deadline was not the best way to start listening. Maybe one day I’ll look into this album, for now it’s just a generic three.
I've heard of Patti Smith before but never listened to her. I guess I was expecting more from all the praise I heard so I was a little disappointed with this album. The two 9 minute songs were way too long. I like her voice, but only for about 2:30 minutes. After that it gets kind of annoying.
not super for me
thoroughly enjoyed this one
This may be "one of the first statements in punk", and as such, a very influential album, but it's not my kind of music. I guess that's how I feel with punk in general...
I'm a little ashamed to admit that before today I had not listened to this album from start to finish, although I am certainly aware of its reputation and legend and had heard portions of it. It's worthy of the hype. Struggled between 4 stars and 5 because it's not something I would just put on and listen to regardless of mood, but it's a classic so I'll go ahead and give it 5. (Nothing matters anymore anyway.)
I can't even begin to reckon how many times I've listened to this album over the years...and how many more times I will listen as I head to no-more-land. But I will enjoy as much if not more as the 1st time I listened. Great album. Perhaps my fave....
Never gave Patti Smith a listen although I’ve heard of her. She sounds like a badass.
This is Patti Smith's Horses A very good album And I really like Horses They gallop around and around It's time I sling the baskets off this overburdened horse Sink my toes into the ground and set a different course Cause if I were here and you were there I'd meet you in between And not until my dying day, confess what I have seen
8, työmatka, koss, qobuz en oo varmaan aiemmin kuunnellu, ainakaa kokonaa
A little too high brow for my taste. I love poetic expression and experimentation in music, but the vocals got old after the first song. The concepts were difficult to understand with a casual first listen. This sounds like an album/artist that would have a dedicated following of interesting people. Wouldn't pick this up again at all, but the guitar is pretty nice.
i liked it! her vocals are super energetic and fun
GOAT. All praise Patti! I didn't properly appreciate Patti until after reading Just Kids. It's such a beautiful book, I remember the heart wrenching passages and discussing it with book club afterwards. Then Horses is just an absolutely phenomenal album. WOW. The upsweeping guitar, the rhythm sections, it's straight from Velvet Underground, New York Punk, boy this woman has power.
Stark, leider passen mir die längeren Vorträge nicht so für eine 5
This man can sing. Probably leaning toward 3.5 but upped to 4
Interesting and unique album. Different from what I was expecting & seemed like a great live performer. Gave me Bowie & Elvis Costello vibes. Must be much better live than on album. Not really memorable songs but would be fun to sing if you learned them.
Really tough listen. Patti Smith´s music is more art than music for me. And it´s an art form which just doesn´t resonate with me. Was waiting for the album to end pretty early on. 1/5
“We cannot live in a world interpreted for us by others. An interpreted world is not a hope. Part of the terror is to take back our listening, to use our own voice, to see our own light.” Hildegard of Bingen Lou Reed expelled John Cale from the Velvet Underground because Reed wanted commercial success. Thus, it is obvious why - for all the influence the smart, street-talking Reed had on Patti Smith - that she chose Cale to produce her first record. She didn’t want to make commercial rock (although, as Because the Night would later prove, she – or Springsteen - could do it). She wanted whatever it was Cale could do. Early Velvets had Cale, Angus MacLise, and Nico: a mystical tension pulling against Reed’s poetic street cynicism. It couldn’t last of course. The Marble Index suggests what the Velvets might have been without Reed’s grounding grime: a band of mystical endlessness. The mystic element of those early Velvets came in part from Cale and MacLise’s immersion in La Monte Young’s Theatre of Eternal Music. Young’s drones were not just experiments in sound but acts of duration, designed to dissolve the listener’s sense of time and place, entering Diviner's Time. The tones stretched out like an eternal now, encouraging a suspension of ordinary perception and opening a doorway to what felt like timelessness. MacLise took this into his percussion, drumming in patterns that suggested trance rather than timekeeping; he practiced the occult and drumming was part of his ritualistic practice. Cale wasn't a magician, but he bowed his viola in long, unending arcs, which is much the same thing. This was mysticism by way of minimalism: sound as eternity, repetition as revelation. The presence of that practice within the Velvet Underground created the tension - between Reed’s earthbound reportage and the others’ quest for transcendence - that gave their early work its unique charge. But Smith wasn’t that sort of mystic either. Like Reed, she was influenced by poetry, but she gravitated toward the visionary line - Rimbaud, Blake. She saw rock and roll as continuous with that tradition, and she saw tradition as alive in the present, not embalmed in the past. Thus she rejected many of Cale’s production suggestions – overdubs and the like - but she needed him to tap into the vein of drone, trance, improvisation. Without his discipline and depth, Horses might have been another garage rock punk record: urgent, but not timeless. We hear this most clearly in the opening track: Gloria. It was already a garage rock standard, but Smith turns it into an incantation. Of course, the song’s author, Van Morrison, would also make the move from punk sneer to mystic invocation on Astral Weeks. Morrison’s folk-soul incantations turn backward, dwelling in memory and longing for the lost Eden of Cypress Avenue, where Gloria is always a teenager. Smith, by contrast, seizes the incantatory mode and thrusts it into the immediate present, insisting that transformation is happening now, here, through the body and the voice. Morrison loved Blake and Yeats too, of course, but he read them as elegists. Smith read them as visionaries of the now. Her first line, “Jesus died for somebody’s sins, but not mine,” is not just blasphemy - it’s a statement of method. Transcendence, for her, comes from within. It’s powered by the individual body, the voice, the dance floor at Max’s Kansas City: “I loved to dance, and you could dance for hours to the music of the Velvet Underground.” Ecstasy is not delivered from above but generated in the present moment. The music of the Velvets may have inspired her to dance, but the moment of transformation takes place inside her and goes out into the world, elevating her and the music with it. The music is there to be grabbed, harnessed, but the magical work is done by the listener. You surrender to the music, but the transformation is your own. This is where Smith’s distance from Reed becomes clear. Reed, working with Cale’s drones and repetition, created sonic states of stasis - heroin nods, lives stuck underground. The two-chord lurch of Heroin accelerates and collapses, capturing a body sinking into itself, succumbing. In contrast, Smith seizes repetition and pushes it outward. Birdland takes a handful of chords, lets them cycle, and builds them into an expanding, accelerating vision. Where Reed retreats into sleep, Smith bursts into apocalypse. It’s the difference between descent and revelation. What it reveals, I don't know exactly. Perhaps only the revelator knows. The album's centrepiece, of course, is Land. It is no surprise that this track was later used, uncut, in the series two climax of grim, millennarian TV show Millennium, appropriately titled The Time is Now - a television apocalypse. Over ten minutes, Smith creates a vision of madness and transformation: Johnny as victim, Johnny as vessel, Johnny as energy released. It is rock and roll as ecstatic ritual. Not reportage, not nostalgia, but the moment of revelation happening as we listen: is Johnny John the Revelator or rock's foundational Johnny B. Goode? Are they any different? Compare this to Lou Reed’s Rock and Roll, written in 1970 (a Velvet Underground without Cale). Reed sings of Jenny, age five, listening to a distant AM station: the story of rock and roll as memory and as something far away. It’s already in the past tense, already documentary. Van Morrison does better when he chants the names of Jackie Wilson and Fats Domino, invoking them incantatorily - but even there, it’s memory, homage. Smith reinvigorates Gloria, and folds Land of a Thousand Dances into Land, not as quotation but as re-presentation. She brings the ecstatic tradition forward into the present. It is almost blasphemous to say she re-enacts the sacred, not merely cites it - but, then, blasphemy is her project, declared in the album’s first breath. The action doesn’t necessarily work in reverse. When The Smiths (no relation) lift the riff from Kimberly for The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, the result isn’t transformative. Morrissey’s narrator, a mother, seeks to shield her child from music’s supernatural power. As “a piano plays in an empty room,” a sure sign of music's possessive allure, she soothes the child: “The ghost and the storm outside/Will not invade this sacred shrine/Nor infiltrate your mind.” Here, music is dangerous precisely because it can open the self to other forces. Morrissey acknowledges that power but retreats from it. He likes Yeats too, but he doesn't get it. His nostalgia wants to protect what little he has or had. He won’t risk apocalypse. He won’t open himself as Smith does. Or perhaps, when Marr stole the riff, Morrissey knew the power of the original record and counterpointed that power with a mother's anxiety. This comparison also points to Horses’ unevenness. Not every track detonates like Gloria, Birdland, or Land. Kimberly is lovely, but not transcendent. Free Money surges but doesn’t necessarily ascend. Break It Up is more conventional in shape, despite its visionary imagery. Redondo Beach is simply wick. I can't excuse that one. I don't like it. Still, the peaks are so high they define the record. Maybe that make a man complacent about the other material. Maybe that unneveness is necesary. Nay, vital. But those tentpole invocations - Gloria, Birdland, Land - are the album’s revelation, its ecstatic core. Horses, then, is not a perfect record. It is a record of peaks and plains, ritual and rehearsal. But that’s part of its power. By refusing polish, by rejecting Cale’s more elaborate pretensions, but not his instincts, Smith ensured that the record kept its raw charge. It is not commercial rock, not even really punk in the narrow sense. It is an experiment in ecstatic art, channelled through garage riffs and visionary poetry. In that sense, it belongs not just to the tradition of rock but to the tradition of prophecy, of poetry as transformative speech. And like prophecy, it is uneven, jagged, sometimes obscure, sometimes gibberish - but when the words hit, when the chords string out one after the other then back to one, when Smith wails and chants and howls, the world ruptures and something new comes through. That is what makes Horses enduring. It is not nostalgia like Morrison, not eternity like Nico, not cynicism like Reed, not drone like Cale. MacLise disappeared down the mythic rabbithole; Horses sticks around. It is apocalypse - personal, poetic, ecstatic. It makes the old songs live again, not as memory but as immediate, dangerous presence. It doesn’t describe rock and roll. It is rock and roll, burning in the moment, opening the self, demanding transformation. And from that opening line on, it insists: no one else can do it for you. Not Jesus. Not Lou Reed. Not John Cale. Transformation is yours to make, now. 4.5 Of all the albums that I would call my favourites, this is the one that took the longest to grow on me. I liked nothing on Horses the first time I listened to it. Over many years this has improved to liking everything on it and counting ‘Gloria: In Excelsis Deo’ as one of my favourite songs anyone has ever recorded. I think the sin of my initial distaste is excusable. It is easy to read Smith’s singing and lyrics as shallow affectation. I was imagining Smith entirely beholden only to the (obvious) cultural references that I was able to conjure up myself - Dylan’s Blonde on Blonde and Allen Ginsberg’s Howl. They are certainly both in there but the truth is that Smith’s singing and writing is idiosyncratic and frequently brilliant in its own right. Kimberly turns a Beat style to something touchingly personal. Redondo Beach is magically concise in turning an implicit scorn for everyone who’s standing around looking so dismal into the narrator’s own sorrow. It’s a great, weird pop song. Birdland, where I think Smith is boldest in risking ridicule, is simply mesmerising. It’s a committed dramatic performance of a terrific lyric. Land… is deservedly iconic. I’ve already mentioned what I think of Gloria: In Excelsis Deo. If the album has weaker moments it’s actually the tracks that must have sounded, at the time, less dated; more 70s than 60s - Free Money and Break it Up. Perhaps a little neat and a little keen to please by comparison with the rest. Still terrific. I love the cover of the album. It is as perfectly fitted to the music as any artwork I can think of; strange, aloof, utterly beautiful. 4.5/5
Important and influential…not all of the music holds up but the power of her work is still there.
Pas aimé j’avoue
Fun interesting album we listen to at home a bunch. A little too quiet for my liking. 6.5/10
Maybe I was just in the right mood at the time but this album really hit the spot for me. The opening track is the best version of the much (over?) covered Gloria. Loved the whole album
Such a distinctive sound and feel to her music.
Icon. Legend. Muse.
This is #day400 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… finally, something decent. That record cover alone is iconic; sheer class. Patti Smith is one of those women in rock who deserve their credit. Take this debut, for example: punk poetry set against mid-'70s art rock jams. And then, what could be more punk than opening your debut with "Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine"? Funnily enough, when I hear her distinct voice, I also hear hints of Tom Verlaine from Television; those hiccupping, squalling nuances, if you pay enough attention... If memory serves, they were in a relationship for a time. Anyway, this is a 5 out of 5, of course. Looking forward to #day401.
It was alright but it didn't really have anything special
I think this is one of those records where it won't connect with everyone but will sink its teeth into a smaller base of fervent fans. Some of the frantic poetry doesn't make for a comfortable experience, but the raw energy and runaway train vibe is arresting. People have locked this into being a proto-punk album, which I am not totally sold on. But it is fascinating - interpolations of two rock and roll songs from the 60s in a totally new style, alongside Patti's original compositions ranging from the slinky dub of Redondo Beach to the piano-led dirge of Elegie. You can see Television, Talking Heads, and more synthesizing when the music is at its best - not to take away from it but quite the opposite.
Something for specialists ....
I loved Birdland, and the scratchy guitar sound on Land is great. Definitely see the lineage here to later singers I like, like Kristin Hersh and PJ Harvey. Strong stuff, a very high four.
Mid to soft, take these horses to the glue fact
I know I’m in the minority here, but this was beyond awful to me. I lasted about 20 seconds before turning it off. One of those artists where I’m truly baffled by their popularity. The vocals almost seem like a put on or something, she does this weird faux southern drawl interspersed with odd high pitched inflections and yelps. Just can’t do it.
The spoken word parts are good the rest is rather bad
Seems like this was probably a significant album, but don't know that I need to listen again necessarily.
Meh...
Didn't really feel this one. 2/5
Yap yap yap blah blah blah
It's OK. Not as good as its press but few are.
This album was WEIRD. I’ve heard track 2 Redondo Beach years ago and loved it. But these lyrics from track 7 for example: When suddenly Johnny gets the feeling he's being surrounded by Horses, horses, horses, horses Coming in in all directions White shining silver studs with their nose in flames He saw horses, horses, horses, horses, horses, horses, horses, horses Do you know how to pony like Bony Maroney? Do you know how to twist? Well, it goes like this, it goes like this Baby mash potato Do the alligator, do the alligator And you twist the twister like your baby sister I want your baby sister, give me your baby sister, I dig your baby sister Rise up on her knees Do the sweet pea, do the sweet pee-pee”
point0.
Loved this album. Artistic, poetic, and emotional. It carries pure, raw energy that feels both legendary and deeply personal. Patti’s voice and vision come across as unapologetic and powerful. A true icon.
Equestrian as an album
I'm torn on how to rate this. The album was fine. Like so many other albums, her voice was my least favorite part. She used a lot of techniques that I have been very harsh against in previous albums. It was clearly a stylistic choice as she demonstrated that she can sing well. I respect her use of them more than many others because she used them for sarcasm or emphasis, but I still dislike the nasal or breathy tones. Otherwise, the album was fine. On a side note, apparently what I thought punk was and what others consider it to be are two different things.
I liked a lot about this album. What I don't necessarily like is the mumbling and random noises, but it can work. I appreciate the story elements of all these songs. No standouts, really. Just a fine album with some fine songs
This record IS a product of it's time. But it's more than that. It's a true expression of poetry over music. It has been frequently cited as the first punk rock album, or at lest a key recording of punk rock.
Sounds like the predecessor of PJ Harvey. Currently the favorite new discovery from the 1001 albums.
Overrated
Stays fresh!
Biggest surprise of the list so far. Really liked this one, and not sure why I hadn’t heard of it before. Will check out more of Patti smiths music for sure!
FUFCK YES i love you baby
It’s a good record and important socially. Songs are pretty good. I get why - it is documenting a very important period of American music. But it’s overrated.
There’s a terrifying energy and mania to this
You can definitely hear the roots of punk rock in here. Feels like we have had a lot of similar albums recently and this on was fine
For an album so massively influential in genres I like, I'd never listened to this all the way through somehow but I think it's pretty amazingly original, and would probably go 4.5 stars if I could. The opener is just awesome with the opening lines, starting slowly and then just taking off into punk (before punk was really even a thing) fury. Her vocals are so versatile, ranging from like a Joni Mitchell-esque beauty to the snarling punk with those little yelpy inflections that would be copied by so many to come. The lyrics are beautiful in a surreally weird way and just so atypical for the genre this spawned that eventually would lean very no-nonsense and often political - she definitely thought of herself as a poet first and foremost and you can totally see why. Nothing sounded like this in 1975 and to me Patti Smith is rightly lauded as a patron saint of punk.
Turned it off halfway through birdland. Aggressive DNF. Then I thought - hey, you’re better than that. Then I got to the end yowling of “break it up” and I wanted to throw my speakers out of my window.
I enjoyed this so much more than I expected.
Staying at Chelsea Hotel and got Patti Smith which was a cool coincidence. And then I pushed play when I left the lobby and started my run. The album ended exactly when I walked back through the door back into the lobby. Good omen and great album!
I never bothered to find out what the Patti Smith fandom was all about and am glad I did! This is wonderful!
Patti Smith is my spirt animal.
a debut studio album from Patty Smith that draws from a garage punk/DIY punk aesthetic but also incorporates elements of art rock and improvisation. Incorporation of longer song lengths with extended improv sections creates almost an anthemic, epic feeling to the album without feeling too polished. Lots of repeated tags throughout the song that allows for building and billowing walls of sound that barely hang on to structure but still feel wild and free.
Had my eye on this one for a while. This is probably THE gateway album to Punk, it was good.
225/1089 - I really like the way the songs evolve over time, and how they stick to only 2 or 3 chords at most. Goes to show you that chords and harmony is just one part of the equation of what makes a good song. Her voice is very strange though.
Not for me.
Patti is my favorite woman in rock music. Love her. This is just great
Alright
Genial. Ya conocía a la artista y sabia lo mítica que era pero simplemente me ha sorprendido. Bastante guay
Honestly didn’t love it. Didn’t hate it either. Poetic lyrics and reminded me of Blondie and PJ Harvey. 4/10
Redondo beach from a NY author is such a fun surprise.
Don't really know why, but this didn't strike me as being too interesting. Some highlights, and I'm sure it was important for its time, but hearing it now I was left a bit bored.
I never thought of this as a punk album, but there are parts that I love. Worth listening to.
own
I liked the attitude and the meshing of old with the new (mainly thinking of some of the references in the songs). It was interesting, but not something I'd listen to again.
It’s pretentious, arty nonsense and I bloody love it.
Patti Smith is and remains one of my favorite artists. Yes, and it sounds like art. Hey, and that's exactly how it's supposed to be. Is that pretentious? I think so. Not everyone has to sing "Anarchy" or "Heart of Glass." This is a great album!
on first listen the vocals are a little bit raw and unfiltered and not exactly melodic and especially for a female singer. Upon further listen I actually very much dislike her vocals.
2nd favourite Patti Smith slbum
Det kan hende «Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine» ikke e den beste førstelinja på et album eller en sang noensinne, men det e jammen mæ ganske høyt oppe på lista. Og så følge resten opp og e like bra. Lenge siden sist gang æ hørte på det, men æ elske det fortsatt.
Meh
I've been waiting for this one to come up. I've listened to this album a few times over the years, it's seemingly on every 'best of' list. It took me a while to get it. When I did get it I realized this is what it sounds like to give no fucks. Pure raw art that's just electric. This album is the sound of freedom. I need to live my life more like Horses.
Shes so cool. And so many people sound (or want to sound) like her but nobody does quite this. The way she says every single word on here is so funny in and at the same time so cool. It really sounds like the most idgaf art student in the best way
sick stuff and more experimental than i remember or think of when i think of patti smith, pretty cool
First though 50 seconds in, "Female Nick Cave? No... Iggy Pop? No..." Punk, but art-y. Mix feels strange, a bit harsh, lots of treble, hardly any low end. Not terribly unpleasant though. Gloria 6/10 Redondo Beach 5/10 Birdland skipped Free Money 8/10 Kimberly 7/10 I can stop here I think. This album is everything that I like in concept. On actual listening though, I don't enjoy it, other than for it's craft and tone. I just don't like listening to it.
I have listened to this before I died. I do not feel like it made a big difference to my life having listened to this. 3 stars.
These songs meander and feel like they go on forever.
mocne 4*
good
I think this is definitely album worth listening. I like the energy of Patti Smith on the album, like instruments. I just don't know what to say I really like this album Fav. tracks Gloria: In Excelsis Deo Birdland Free Money Kimberly Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer (de) 5/5
Excellent