Funeral by Arcade Fire

Funeral

Arcade Fire

3.54
Rating
30876
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
31%
4
31%
5
22%
Distribution

Reviews (page 11 of 15)

I don't get the appeal of this.

Fairly generic indie pop for me. Didn’t get too much out of it but it was relatively pleasant the whole way through.

It’s been some time and the monumental „funeral“ got some cracks that even the dramatic biografy of the record’s creation cannot fill.

Meh. Twangy. Not a fan.

I’ve always had a bias against them as they seemed like Spin Magazine Indie hipster darlings but I enjoyed it well enough.

Not their best, but still amazing. I wish I could give 3.5.

Much nostalgia

pleasant

Dull, warbly

This is a really solid and well produced album. You can tell they put a lot of thought and effort into each song. My only gripe is that some songs are a bit on the forgettable side. Other than those few, really solid. 4/5.

Die Exzentrität des Albums ist “abwechselnd bizarr und anderswo wiedererkennbar, gleichermaßen schön und erschütternd, theatralisch und aufrichtig, sich jeder Kategorisierung entziehend und dabei versuchend, neue Genres zu schaffen” so lobte es Kritiker. Dem ist kaum was hinzuzufügen. Man wird es 20x hören können und der krasse Indie Sound wird wohl niemal langweilig werden. Ganz star sind “Une Anne Sans Lumiere”, “Crown of Love”, “Wake Up” und natürlich “Rebellion”. Let’s do it again 😊.

Great start from the band. A few shaky songs but it's great to see their experimental roots.

Didn’t seem very special for me

was kind of cool

Funeral changed the trajectory of indie music in many ways. I’ve loved this album for a long time, but it’s lost a bit of its luster for me over time.

Eclectic artsy, rock, and alt.

Best Arcade Fire album but that doesn’t mean that it’s good. Can’t wait for them to be in the “worst artists” section after I rate this.

There’s just something about this style of vocalist that I dislike heavily.

Really liked the "Neighborhood" songs I also really like how Haiti transitions into Rebellion (Lies)

Otra de las bandas que me recuerdan a mis "veintis". Y con ello, viene el recuerdo de la sorpresa ante esta música nueva para mí, de la necesidad de compartir mis impresiones con otras personas y, entre ellas, mi primera novia, siendo esta banda una de las que más nos acompañó y a la que viajamos a ver en el primer Lollapalooza que se hizo en Argentina en 2014. Un disco hermoso, excelente para ser el primero. Me encanta cuando las bandas lo dan todo en su primer trabajo porque no tienen nada que perder pero, a la vez, se la juegan todo para pegarla.

I probably liked this more after seeing them live then when I tried listening before seeing them.

Just not my kind of music. The songs were boring and dragged on. 2/5 Won’t listen again

Favourite tracks: wake up; rebellion; neighborhood #1

This is good. The singers voice is a little whiney but not unbearable. Maybe it’s because I know these guys are Canadian that holds me back from being all in. I’d give other albums a listen. There’s good flow from track to track. The music is catchy and crisp. Lyrically It’s not simple which is a bonus. Choice cut: Crown of Love

really enjoyed this album good indie music play this at my funeral and we will get along 4.7/5

Very interesting album is here. The voice is very expressive. I read the Wiki, and saw the female band member. I think this explains some of the lyricism in the sounds. I don't know that I'll come back to this one, but I will say that I enjoyed it. It feels like the band just let loose with all their influences and came up with really engaging stuff. I read comments that the songs move seamlessly from one to the other - this is correct. Well done!

Was only familiar with "Wake Up" prior to listening. I've always dug this era of indie rock, but perhaps I've only been exposed to the tip of the iceberg, or the more "poppier" acts. This album seems to alternate between high-energy and low-energy which I wasn't totally expecting (although I guess with an album title like "Funeral", one should expect some melancholic vibes). I guess what I'm trying to say is that I didn't really warm up to the "overall" experience, while some of the separate "parts" were well-orchestrated.

People have told me, knowing my musical tastes, that I would like Arcade Fire. So I have at various times listened to them including this album. Whilst liking their music it never completely grabbed me so I largely dismissed them and never, until recently when I bought Neon Bible cheap from a charity shop, bought any of their stuff. Listening again to this album in full there are many good songs and my appreciation of Arcade Fire has improved. I would buy this album if I came across it cheap and certainly give any new releases a listen. 3/5 13/5/24

Un album en ébullition, des émotions à fleur de peau aux arrangements polyphoniques et aux envolées musicales lyriques. Très bon mais ça me sature vite

Like the last album from this band, it is okay but not a great album. I just don’t understand the stories or points they are trying to tell through their songs.

It is like watching tv and then without doing anything you slowly start to tune it out

Preferred "The Suburbs" over this. Not sure what whoever that mixed this was thinking but his voice was absolutely buried under the instruments, could not tell a darn thing he was saying. Musically it was nice but seriously I could not tell you a single word that he said and that kinda annoyed me. Also I felt like Win's voice sounded better in "The Suburbs" than it did in this but it wasn't an awful album just very meh.

this is the 2nd album by Arcade Fire on the list-i enjoyed it marginally more than the 1st. the music is great & interesting. really enjoy the use of different instruments, but just do not care for the vocals. will I seek it out to listen to ever again-nah.

One of the finest albums of the last 2 decades.

Classic, reminds me of my youth

Hard to separate out feelings and memories associated with this album and appraise it rationally. Now I feel you need to be in a certain mood to appreciate it and maybe my affection for it has dimmed slightly with time. Still a classic. 4.2

Damn this is one emotional album. I'm not even really paying attention to the lyrics, but the delivery of the vocals alone is passionate enough to make me feel things that most music can't.

Just never been too into them. I usually like 2 or 3 songs per album of theirs and this is the same way. Just ok as a whole.

Decent. Didn't really grab me - all a little samey maybe. I think it's the vocals that bother me.

Solid album, but missing a little oomph

Maybe nostalgia or nationalism but in my opinion it does not get much better than this album.

Really enjoy the use of orchestral instruments

Good album, have some classic songs on it

Solid album

It’s fine. I like their next couple of albums more.

It feels at first like decent instrumental and composition. But it doesn't hook, and I don't care for the timbre of the vocals. Meh.

I really like this one! I have heard individual songs but never listened front to back

First, Let me say that I’m surprised that this album is 20 years old. I feel like I only heard of Arcade Fire 10 years ago, maybe. Saw them on SNL. They bleed over into that Indie folk scene with bands like Mumford & Sons; Who, by the way, I did actually enjoy… For about five minutes. Only so many songs can have people shouting “Hey” from the back of a cave before I get very bored with it. Arcade Fire is edge easier than that, but it did leave me with some of the same feelings. I could see enjoying this more on a day when I was contemplating life or sad about this or that. Most days, this isn’t my thing.

My 2nd. Arcade Fire album on this list. I still don't get the hype. There's not really anything wrong with the music, but it's just not all that interesting either. Fine as background music.

Not terribly familiar with this band, just the one or two hit songs they've put out, but I did like this record on an initial listen, and will have to explore further.

4/24/24 I already liked “Wake Up” and had listened to the album before. Wasn’t giving it my full attention today but listened casually. Enjoyed it but something about it is too cerebral? for me or something like that.

Ich kannte weder Band noch Album: Viel Sound - Viel Interessantes fürs Ohr - Gute Ansätze - die mich aber schlussendlich nicht mitnehmen. Schade.

One of the albums that I hold dear to me, Neighborhood #3 and Ready to start belong close to nice memories of the time.

In a nutshell: "the game changer" of indie rock This was my first listen of any Arcade Fire album, only knowing singles from Neon Bible. And why the hell did I not find this album in my twenties?? It's such a unique mix of music. You hear it and you instantly recognise the band. Guitars, xylophone, cello, divine harmonies, Regine's vocal range, strings. Thoughtful, earnest, daring, with a "throw it at the wall and see if it sticks" approach. Funeral feels like a chronicle of nostalgia and loss. Not via osmosis (because the band were grieving the loss of family members at time of recording). To me, the songs capture that weird time in your life when you mourn the loss of your carefree teenage years, and you realise that shit is getting REAL. But you kinda get a sense of hope that things will eventually will be okay. I didn't expect this album to be so gripping. This is definitely a classic Overall: 9/10

a great debut sullied by a horny man

Good album with some great songs

Banger album. A top tier echelon 2000s indie rock album.

I still think this album is massively overrated compared to some of their other work, neon bible and reflektor both better but it’s still got some great songs on there

Came out when I was a senior in highschool.. Album changed everything to popularize indie rock. Still holds up today and will be a forever classic!

Glimpses of something better to come. A sound first album.

Enjoyed this.

Had I been in my late teens, instead of my late thirties, when this came out, I'm sure it would have been played to death. I wasn't, and it didn't, but that doesn't make it any less of a fantastic album.

I really don't understand this. Why is it on the list?

Nice indie pop music that can be on in the background or searched for deeper meaning. Not terribly familiar with Arcade Fire other than a single from their 2022 album I found last year, but I’m a fan. Easy listening, 4/5

As someone from eastern Canada who was in their late teens when this came out, easy 10. By far their best, and still great today. In the Backseat still gives me goosebumps.

This was a pretty good album, I enjoyed it Top tracks: Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies)

Best ever

Seminal Very Enjoyable Little bit too weird

An All Timer. Play this at my funeral

I liked the instrumentals of this album, did it have an orchestra? I should revisit this one with more attention

FINALLY. Some decent music! A colleague at a university job was a huge indie hipster and told me to listen to this back in 2006. It was one of the front-runners into an entire genre of music. And in my opinion, the saviours of music in general. This feels like a turning point to me. An actual influential album that not only sounds good but means something. A rarity on this hellish experience that is this terrible list.

охеренный альбом

It's not bad, but there are tons of bands that do a similar sound better. The lyrics feel like they're trying too hard to be deep.

There is no doubt that this album is really good and a landmark, but it has just never clicked with me fully. I prefer Arcade Fire's next two albums over this.

I go through phases of listening to Arcade Fire - when I’m in the mood I LOVE this album

It either starts off a little too indie for me, or I just wasn't fully prepared for the sound/style when I started up the album, but god damn it's growing on me. Really good indie music. Raw and unique. It doesn't blow me away by any means, but it is really solid album to listen to.

I went back and forth a lot on Arcade Fire’s Funeral these past few days. We’ve already had one album by the band—Neon Bible—and this is certainly the better of the two. (Neon Bible should not have been on this list, imo). There’s this sense that Funeral changed the world when it came out. Everyone talked about it, talks about it; how it “changed indie music forever,” and such. I agree it did serve as the cornerstone of all indie music everywhere for a good decade or so and did pave the way for so many great indie bands thereafter. Really that legacy continues even today. It is a modern classic and absolutely essential. But it’s never quite clicked for me. And my problem is purely in the way the album sounds. Arcade Fire’s indie ambitions are great as ever, but their means are just not totally capable of capturing that ambition. The production is a bit flat. A bit hollow. And it does not service the spirit of the music it contains, which I agree is masterful. (Although I will say, Arcade Fire has this cringe-worthy tendency to make the scope of their music *too* grand and *too* all-encompassing, in a kind-of-annoying, Bono-y way, and that as a practice is all the more evident after the release of their most recent two albums, which are literally, un-ironically titled WE and EVERYTHING NOW, but is even evident here in smaller doses with the bands first four, critically acclaimed albums; but I digress). Funeral is much rawer than Neon Bible. But I get the impression it could have been even rawer. If the band would have maybe leaned more into their low-budget hyper-local means at the time instead of reaching for a sound they just couldn’t attain. That vision would eventually be attained on The Suburbs, the bands best album by a long shot, in my opinion (and it sound AMAZING compared to Funeral), but with Funeral…Funeral is not quite a swing-and-a-miss by any means, but it is a pretty hard cut at what amounts to a foul ball that easily had the distance for a home run. Though it’s still a shot heard round the world, for good reason.

Woah. I really really remember living through this exact moment in music, or rather, the aftermath… 2007 was when I started listening to actual music, and this was already extremely in the air. Just the way Win Butler phrases things and sounds so stylized and intense here, that’s a super familiar sound. Charlie summed up 100% of my thoughts as well with his review, I 100% agree. A bold, intense, beautiful album that is shooting higher than it has any right to. I’m glad Arcade Fire got a chance to refine this sound in The Suburbs, which is really the band’s masterwork and what this first album is leading to. But there’s something about that desperate, intense wildness of Win and Régine on these records, plus the really desperate guitar, it’s kind of unmatched on any of their subsequent records, which were always going to sound more “perfect.” This was recorded in a week! That’s an achievement in itself. That’s insane. An album that promised to all of its followers and acolytes that there’s beauty to be made by just bleeding your heart dry, giving it your all on the bandstand, and perhaps rock is not dead, but it’s ready to wake again. 4/5

The album is best experienced listened to from beginning to end

1-fuego; 2-laika :(; 3-Ne pas comprender; 4-Not bad; 5-:( (good way) 7-Beat Switch :) 10-very good; Bom álbum, boas ideias e bem executadas. 3.5/5

One of my favourite albums of all time - vivid memories of listening to it for the first time on cd.

Tem alguma coisa no instrumental, não sei exatamente dar nome, essas coisinhas de indie, q hj em dia não me agradam

wasnt bad but not necessarily something I am drawn to listen to. Slightly slow. 2

I was not interested in this at all. 1/5

When I got recommended this album, I had already heard it many times, and I knew I liked it a lot. That makes this review pretty easy! After revisiting the album today, I can confirm it's a 4-star project. Good stuff.

Indie pop not my thing they sound like bi-polar hippies on an acid trip. A fast song and a slow one full of hate the other full of love. Too much emotions going everywhere without any order just a few good songs I liked as singles but the album doesnt do it for me. Not a bad album just not my liking

Don't know how I loved this album before. Honestly, it ain't all that.

What an amazing album!

6/10 Wake Up is fantastic, and Arcade Fire is talented. However, even though I enjoyed these songs well enough, I don't feel anything special about them. 4-5-2024

Genuinely uninteresting

Amazing album from the godfather of metal.

Previously rated: The Suburbs (3/5) ********************* Not terrible music, but it's just so generic and forgettable. What do they have against guitar solos or drum fills? All I remember from listening to it yesterday was a whistling tea kettle and a song with strings. I didn't remember anything from the other album either. Arcade Fire makes music that is just there. It doesn't really do anything, and it doesn't do anything for me. Normally I'd give an album like this a 3 like I did The Suburbs, but that generic-ness just annoys me into dropping it a star.

Мне совершенно непонятен поинт одного овощеподобного музыкального критика, что этот альбом создал самые отвратные тренды в инди-роке, и оттого якобы плохо прошел тест времени. Это мои личные абсолютные пять, первые для меня в 1001 (все до этого - пять с компромиссом, так сказать). Да, этот альбом заставляет задуматься о вот этой проблеме разделения артиста и творчества, но честное слово становится абсолютно поебать, когда он самый поет PURIFY THE COLORS, PURIFY MY MIND на первой же песне. Это ультимат камин-оф-эйж альбом, который в моей жизни возник в тот самый период. Он очень по-детски игривый музыкально, и точно также юношески чрезмерно драматичный, но одновременно с этим такой наивно серьезный порой - все пересекается с темами на альбоме, форма и лирика. Это лучший альбом очень хорошей группы как минимум. Лучшая песня - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels).

Not to my taste, disliked the male vocalist's voice in particular

Not more Arcade Fire ......

Whatever my feelings about Win Butler, this is an important album by an important band. 4.5/5

Too cool for me. (?!?) I like indy rock but Arcade Fire is a bit much.

Never heard of them, interresting enough to be added to favorites and explore some more.

Found this one pretty bland

I honestly do not get the mass appraise for Funeral, by Arcade Fire. Yes, I have to give it to the production, which all together is sound and unique for most tracks. But the vocals could have been done much better on many of the tracks. I feel if there was better vocal layering, my thoughts on this album would be far more positive. That being said, highlights include Une aneé sans lumière, Haiti, and Wake Up. In Wake Up, I see the Arcade Fire thats vocals I wanted throughout the album. All in all, Funeral is an alright album. Best Song: Wake Up Worst song: Une aneé sans lumière

For a certain generation (in which I'm included), this album marked a shift in musical taste. It also opened the floodgates for every liberal arts major to go start a bedroom band and not be afraid of making music that they wanted to make. And for that, I'm eternally grateful. But how does this one hold up? While I think the band would go on to make overall better and more cohesive projects, this is quite the way to make yourself known, and most tracks here are indie anthems 20 years on. Too bad Win Butler ruined it all :/

I’ll proudly serve as pallbearer for this triumphant introduction to these instant indie rock icons until my very own final day.

Loved it in 2004, love it now.

Already heard it before, but such an excellent album.

5.5/10 dull again.

Such a pretty album. At times it feels like it's giving you a warm hug. And wake up is a gorgeous anthem of a song. Fav songs: - all the neighbourhoods - Wake Up

Surprisingly ok. Not great, not awful just ok.

Surprisingly good. Half the tracks were meh to me but the other half had a little merit. Not enough to put it up there but enough for me to not turn it off if it was on.

#174. I listened to this yesterday, and as I'm trying to think about it now, I realize I already don't really remember what it sounds like. Arcade fire is just that memorable I guess. I'm pretty sure I remember thinking the girl kinda sounds like Björk on the last song. Not sure if that's a positive or a negative, but that's what I got. 2/5: hipster folk Song added to playlist: In the Backseat I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

Pretty decent. There aren't any bad songs on it, but most of the songs just aren't something I'd listen to otherwise. light 7/10

Удивительная группа конечно сочетающая в себе много мало сочетаемых друг с другом вещей. Альбом очень красивый плавное течение музыки на нем то и дело обрывается очень драматизированными надломами. Такое надо переслушать где то в начале сентября.

Ok album but not for me

Some great songs and influential for the time.

great for a debut album

One of the best albums I have gotten so far from this site. Nearly Perfect

The songs are consistently good but there isn't anything that really stands out to me. I can see where people would be fans but I don't think I'll be looking for concert tickets anytime soon.

not a fan of arcade fire.

Pretty good listen. Though I have a hard time putting it above 3 just because there wasn't a lot replayability for my tastes. 3/5

This came out when I was twenty. It was overhyped then, it remains overhyped now. Just a bunch of maudlin, navel gazing, fluff. Nothing interesting musically. Lyrically equivalent of a suburban teenagers diary, which, I guess is the point, but it does nothing for me. Cliché after tired cliché.

There’s an ebb and flow to this album. It’s also hard to detach it from what came after. Wake Up is still their best song.

Odd voice, instrumentation is really solid. Haiti is a nice and chill song. Alright album but I don't think I'll listen to it much again, not my cup of tea.

Sad boi music but weird makes sense its canadien. Fav songs tunnels and in the backseat

A good album with a number of iconic songs, most notably "Tunnels," "Wake Up," and "Rebellion (Lies)." I'm not sure it is Arcade Fire's best work, but it does perfectly encapsulate the angst of its time.

Pretty cool!

I didn’t know I was an arcade fire fan! For some reason I thought they were more like imagine dragons. I thoroughly enjoyed the folk influence and the less produced sound

Surprised but not surprised how good this album is. Obviously, legends start for a reason. Standouts for me were the hit track Rebellion (Lies) and I love Wake Up. A 5/5 album for sure deserves its spot on this list.

Great indie album.

That’s a great record

Actually didn’t hate this album. The music videos are weird though.

good mix of twee and sleaze... weird bjork ending -- not cohesive? idk

Interesting Indie Rock. I almost like the music. 4/5

I don't need to listen to this; I know every word, beat change and guitar riff. I knew this album before I was born, it's in my DNA, It came to me at a very important time in my life and I've loved it since. Regardless of what came after, this is perfect.

Very 2000s, in a good way

Didn’t listen. Not my style

I'd never heard this album before, though I'm very familiar with "The Suburbs." I like their brand of dreamy rock, though in smaller doses.

Funeral was an excellent example of creative experimentation combined with peak musicianship. Each song twisted and turned in ways I never expected and brought something new to the table. I wasn't sure what to expect for the next track. Being released in 2004, this was a highlight for the alt rock and indie genres. This band knows that they're doing. My favorite track is Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles). Album added to my Spotify library.

christ almighty... at least now i know what it was like to sit in a hipster cafe for 50 minutes in 2004. (despise the album art btw)

This album really felt like something new when it came out. I still think it's their best one.

Not bad but not my usual vibe

Totally underwhelmed by this album. I was totally expecting to love this album and it just didn’t resonate with me. It was kind of boring. There are other songs by them that I was more impressed by.

Alright with the album, but not anything special.

I liked Arcade Fire. Saw them at Jazz fest Energetic with some chunky guitars.

There was one song I liked on this album and after listening to the entire album, I can’t remember it…

Hmmm yeah idk. Just for how big of an explosion this band had I’ll give it a 3. However, let’s subtract 1 because I think they screwed up the indie band influence for a while there

Surprisingly enjoable

Favorite song was neighborhood number 3

moody ass album. Highlights: Crown of Love In The Backseat

Arcade Fire's masterwork of a debut and magnum opus. Wide-eyed, elated, emotional--you name it. 100% deserved the success it met at the time. I've actually discovered most of this album live, during the band's European tour, right after this record came out. It was a joyful riot onstage, and an excellent show. Too bad the band's reputation has recently been tarnished by some allegations regarding Win Butler's private life--at odds with the man's quite self-righteous public image so far. To be fair, if you take into account the testimonies about what had occured between Butler and those "love interests" he has had different sorts of interactions with, it clearly transpires that Butler is a not a full-blown "sex offender". Sure, those testimonies differ in some key moments between what his version of the events was, and what the other involved persons said about them--and yet the whole picture is still cohesive enough to convey the brush strokes of said events. And if what they suggest is mostly pathetic on a personal level, it's not necessarily "malicious". The word "sexual assault" was admittedly mentioned for one case, but it seems that said interaction didn't last for very long and didn't go very far, "technically" speaking. Emotionally speaking, it's a very different animal of course, and I understand if anyone strongly disagreed with me in the interpretation of said "private" events, whose exact nature we will probably never fully understand from the outside. What becomes abundantly clear when you connect the dots, though, is that Butler was at least a self-centered hog at some point--and quite an immature one at that, especially for someone his age. Besides, if you add the "power dynamics" that are inherent to the differences between who Win was and who those "love interests" were, the whole thing does paint him as quite insensitive, and also astonishingly reckless to boot. *Aggressively* sexting with women who are between 18 and 23 is for instance not the brightest move a famous 36 or 39-year-old rock star can make these days. And asking for "secrecy" about his exchanges with those women ("sexual" exchanges or not) sounds a little suspicious as well. It's almost as if Butler had used his celebrity to actually "cover" for the grey areas in those interactions. Where said celebrity could have led him to err on the side of caution for everyone involved instead--if only he had thought a little more about accountability, responsibility, and if he had acted somewhat selflessly of course. In other words if he had truly "cared" about those young women he was supposedly enamoured with... Butler's public response, "explanations" and "apologies" haven't fully dispelled the whole unsavory picture, by the way. The man feels sincere when he states he didn't fully understand what was going on, and when he says he now regrets what he has done. Yet for most of this public response, he spends a lot of time talking bout himself, his marriage, his depression, his sufferings at the time, yadi, yada. But it's not about *you*, damn it! Even there, for his "apology", Butler doesn't process the point of those women calling him out is to let other voices be heard every time they feel pressurized to act contrary to their feelings or better interest, just because a famous male gaze is in the vicinity. Not to mention male gazes that are not famous at all, and yet bring with them their own power dynamics as well. The "objective' description of such an unfortunate situation hits too close to home for Butler, I guess. Even now. So here I am, spending three paragraphs about those recent revelations, instead of talking about Arcade Fire's debut album. The thing is, I needed to precisely address all of this to *also* express why I still CAN "separate the art from the artist" for this particular album, in spite of the importance of those matters. Because... a) Everybody can make mistakes in their lives, have serious lapses of judgment, or act like a selfish fool. I'm certainly taking this subject seriously, and I hope that what I've written up there demonstrates that to en extent. Yet, at the same time, I'm certainly not saying artists *should* be "role models". As long as certain lines are not crossed, at least... b) Those sad events happened LONG after the legendary debut that *Funeral* is was released. So it's still possible for me to listen to it without thinking too much about them. What *Funeral* evokes to me these days, is when I visited my friend Théo on his French island two summers ago; and when, on the first morning I spent at his place, he woke me up by having his stereo blast... "Wake Up". Him all smiles at his little joke, me still confused and sleepy and yet internally laughing as well. Good times. You see, *Funeral* has been ingrained in the consciousness of indie-heads for so long now--far more than lesser album *The Suburbs*, which is where the Grammies and the rest of the mainstream world caught up with AF--that nothing can tarnish the gems in it. Those songs can be played at any moment, and they will lighten up the mood or the room instantly. c) Speaking of the Grammy Awards, I sometimes wonder if reaching that sort of mainstream success is not what made Butler lose his way, on both a personal and an artistic level. And if you only focus on the music in Arcade Fire's latest albums, you can feel like something was "broken". For instance, many moments in *Reflektor* were already quite boring, to be honest. But that couldn't be worse than next album *Everything Now*, a cheesefest of unprecedented magnitude within the Canadian band's discography. And don't get me started on the supposed "return to authenticity" that *WE* was. Sound-wise and songwriting-wise, it felt like a PR ploy, a somewhat artificial attempt to return to the glory of *Funeral*. Yet there's no way to return. Except when you spin that first album again... d) I wish I had more space or time to properly describe the joys of *Funeral*. Alas, this tentative "review" is already too long at it is. I could have ranted on how "Neigborhood #1 (Tunnels) is a perfect emotional opener for the album, on how " Neighborhood #2 (Laïka)" is such a propulsive banger displaying an equally perfect chorus, and on how "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" is so insanely tight, intense and driven--thanks to its massive and relentless rhythm section--that you feel that the walls around might just crumble whenever you play it on a high-fi system. I could also have stated that "Crown Of Love" is a torch song for the ages, that "Wake Up" is obviously another mind-blowing anthem, because of how its heavy guitar riff leads to those incredibly epic "ooooh-oooohh" vocal parts... And the climactic build-up of "Rebellion (Lies)" is also a fantastic moment, as is last ballad "In The Back Seat", a cinematic closer where all the emotions explored throughout the record join in perfect unison. Here, as elsewhere, the string section literally *shines* in ways both elating and melancholic. And Régine Chassagne's vocal contributions are simply, utterly heartfelt AND powerful. Jesus H. Christ, what an album. Even a supposed "deep cut" such as "Haiti" (where Chassagne is also taking up lead vocals duties) is a keeper. It is a somewhat "naïve" composition, in spite of its very topical subject matter. Yet this also harbors great hooks and endearing details aptly conveying the whole Haitian culture and its tumultuous history. So that's it. 5/5. I can totally understand if the latest news about the band and his frontman would have other reviewers dismiss this record for purely ethical reasons. As I said, I believe I take those matters quite seriously. But I still feel that this debut remains "important" for the history of popular music. And I just can't personally "dismiss" my subjective feelings about it, to use the exact same word. Frankly, I just wish Arcade Fire could split as a band so that everyone could move on today. Win's brother Will has already left this sinking boat, by the way, and what he does with his new band is quite interesting... Sorry for the harsh words, Arcade Fire *hardcore* fans. Sometimes, you just know it when an act has *said* everything it needed to say. And with *Funeral* on my music shelves, there will always be one *good* thing to remember the band for anyway. Number of albums left to review: 258 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 325 (including this one) Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 185 Albums from the list I won't include in mine (many other records are more important to me): 238

What a debut this is. There's so many big hits. Catchy hooks. Big choruses. I absolutely love all the layers of instruments, the violins in particular coming through, but also the dual vocals. It has a really big depth of sound and tons of energy to it. Parts of this album are just absolutely joyous. After this album came out I saw them at Brixton Academy London, and seeing everyone on stage at the same time really was something, but having the whole crowd sing back the melody to Rebellion Lies minutes after the song had ended was something else. A great memory, and great collective experience. This is a brilliant album.

Ei huono muttei kyllä oo mun lempparibändi. Kaipaan jotenkin jotain isompaa! 3/5

Mitä tästä sanomaan, varmaan tärkeimpiä ellei tärkein indie rock -levy ainakin genren mainstream-nousun osalta. Kaikki bändin hyvät elementit on kertaheitolla kasassa debyytissä. Omalta osaltani vähän väsynyttä, että annan taas näille vitosen. Jälkikäteen Neon Bible olisi ehkä pitänyt jättää neljään. Tämä ja Suburbs kyllä ansaitsevat.

Sitä hyvää indietä

Every song sounds the same, like all the most annoying early '00s indie-pop laying ground for what would become rote radio-fare in a few years. Big, chorus-like songs, with some dude shouting about boring shit. Some of the musicality is interesting, but the vocals are annoying. Aren't there like, fifteen people in this band? Why didn't the other people revolt against the irritating singer? Sometimes a chick sings for a bit but she sounds like she's singing through one end of those yogurt cups connected by string from across a field. 3/5. Don't get the hype. Band seems highly punchable.

Rebellion (Lies) bangs so hard.

One of the most influential indie rock albums of all time.

I can't say that I've ever found Arcade Fire all that exciting as a band. I think, sadly, that the era when I could have gotten really into them might have passed me by. However, I will say that this album helped me understand their appeal much better. The songs are well written, and the production on the album is excellent. I've also heard that the lyrics are very good, though it was difficult for me to catch a lot of the words on the first pass 4/5

I like a lot of this album, but not all.

Dystopian hope Enshrined in sweeping dirges Composed in beauty

Ja wel mooi chill om naar te luisteren tijdens het leren maar zou het niet perse nog een keer aan zetten

Not as good as I hoped. I bet it could grow on me, as I like the newer stuff you hear on the radio, but not grabbing me by the lapels on first listen.

I feel like I should know Arcade Fire a lot more than I do, but the nice part of that confusion is that I'm pretty sure this is my first listen to an entire Arcade Fire album. I enjoyed it, but didn't fall in love with them or their sound, and wonder whether this is their best album to include (without bothering to follow through on whether there are multiple Arcade Fire selections or to figure out which of their albums is considered their all-time best)? I'm impressed at the band's longevity so far, though not so impressed by recent (and likely justified) "sexual misconduct" allegations that sound a lot like Ryan Adams (but without as much fallout so far). Overall, a strangely forgettable album, especially for one that won a Grammy and has been ranked as the 2nd best album of the 2000s....

Though I got this album over a year ago, apparently I forgot to rate it. Well, it's pretty good--I'd listen on the radio: dramatic, sort of fuzzy rock, but nothing is too memorable other than their clear passion for their sound.

Masterpiece

An ok album

Haven't listened to this for quite a while, great album, atmospheric and some great tunes, love the rhythm section and strings. Also listening to it on a lot better pair of headphones then 20 years ago and it sounds great. I had a couple more arcade fire albums then drifted away from them, this was still my favourite

It has cool songs on it, but at the same time I don't feel that has something that makes it special of other albums of their style. A personal thing Is that I really like the cover, it's nice.

Just barely a 4. A lot of lyrics that I enjoyed but also not my favorite like.. sonically for a lot of songs. Love the opening two songs, especially Neighborhood #2 (Laika), plus the last song.

A bit slow for my liking

Really enjoyed as a whole album

I like arcade fire tbh

I was 19 when this album came out, and obviously it felt like the most important piece of music ever recorded, as things released when you are 19 tend to do. I really resent who I was at the time so I expected to hate this, but it brings me no pleasure to announce I am incorrect and misty-eyed while listening to it in my driveway. Five stars.

Absolutely beautiful album. Pleasant, cohesive, emotional

Likely the most formative album in my music listening career. Six stars.

Nicht geil, aber auch nicht scheisse.

Had heard some of the songs but didn't know who it was until now. Fun album to listen to

Forgot how much I love this album, not a single song i'd change from it. If the 4 Neighbourhood songs don't get you going then I don't know what will, especially Tunnels and Power Out, both give me goosebumps every time. Then you've got the singalong chorus on 'Wake Up', the ending of 'Crown of Love' with that sick disco drum beat, and the way 'Haiti' transitions into 'Rebellion'. What an amazing album experience, peak of 2000s indie right here.

Wow. Actually wow. It sounds like Nostalgia

Early '00s indie classic and began an impressive run from Arcade Fire. Uniquely alone in their catalog, Funeral carried a childish nostalgia that wasn't recaptured.by the band. Hopeful and naive at times. The band would become a little darker from this point out. On this listen, maybe the first start to finish intentional listen since I listened on CD. I noticed a lot more texture, especially as the album ended. Listening to the sounds slowly escape from the band and merge into silence. An impressive and important album for its time.

Have heard before. Doesn't hold up as well as I expected.

Absolutely raucous crazy breakthrough in its moment and still makes me sing along. Love this one.

Entertaining lo-fi indie-rock with some nice flourishes. The track Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out) really reminded me of New Order for some reason.

I remember when this came out, I remember the first time I listened to Rebellion (Lies), it really is a Proust madeleine. This kind of albums introduced me to a part of indie music I still love today. There is kind of too much of everything: too much instruments, too much people singing at the same time, mostly out of tune but it has its intrinsic quality. You can feel the collective listening to the album, and they tend to swap instruments from time to time which is also nice. It carries some nostalgia in the sound itself, even more so years after its release.

Pleasant to listen. Not spectacular, but a great debut.

One of those bands that I knew I had heard before but couldn't have told you what they sounded like. Turns out, I like them! I've heard at least a couple of songs from this album, and I think the band is even better heard in a full-album context. Pretty solid album.

Easy listening, fun presentation. Favourite track: Crown of Love.

Love love love this album.

Never was a big fan. I think the blogotheque show ruined it for me. Guy seemed like an ass

Early 2000’s alt. Seriously not bad I like maybe 2 or 3 songs here.

Very nice, it surely help me go through the day at work ;-)

Meaningless is the only word that comes to my mind when listening to this. I see what they were trying to do but they really didn't hit the spot. Seems like the band you really want to like but simply can't. Unfortunately it's absolutely not memorable. I almost had a hard time listening through the whole thing.

This is really not my cup of tea. The whole album sounds kind of pretentious, as if the band wanted to appear sophisticated, without really being so. And above all is the wailing voice of the singer, who always sounds like he's in sever pain. Personally, I don't really see, why this album was so well received when it first came out. It's neither something new, nor something special

A few good ones but not really my thing

Anthemic, again! This is the 3rd AF, I've had pop up. I'm still struggling with getting to like them. I'm sure they're great live.

Football

I could not wait for this to be over, from about song 2. I hate to rate it so low because I think this is more personal preference than a comment on it's quality, but I found this super annoying.

Pretty good! Not my usual groove, but liked it!

Step 1 - listen to The Moon and Antarctica. Step 2 - ignore that you don't have Modest Mouse's sense of bizarre whimsy or ability to mold atonality. You just have a singer with a squeaky voice. Try to be like Modest Mouse anyway, Step 3 - ????? Step 4 - profit Arcade Fire has always seemed like the band you are supposed to admire. I try, I really do. But I'm not sold on the quietly restrained, driving eighth notes, supposedly building up to something that never quite gets there. And I have this sinking feeling that this and The Suburbs aren't the only albums of their waiting on the list to disappoint us . . .

This album rules. I see much hate for it but i think its genius, the songwriting is top tier and its just a fun, beautiful, emotional listen all the way through.

This is pretty great.

Not a fan of Win's voice. Music is interesting, but replay attraction is low.

New to this band. I like it but nothing standout or that would make me want to check out the rest of their albums.

Paar hits, bisschen Kitsch

Flashbacks. Mag die Produktion und gute Songs dabei

like indie rock opera vibes, at least first two songs; will see how it progresses. 1st song has the good piano in it. Second song has a lot of energy. Lyrical melodies remind me of modern The National. End of track 3 a an energetic vibey drive. The music isn't really bad by any means. Not necessarily my tastes. Wouldn't really listen again honestly. 3/5

I really liked this album. I listened to it all weekend, probably 4-5 times through. It was mellow enough to fit into any situation. Had a few love songs that fit well with other media I was consuming. One of my favorites of this journey so far.

Not really my type of music it's too twee Rebellion is ok in small doses.

Not my favorite of theirs but I like it

Loved this album in high school and love it still!

Love this album. Very consistent.

Great band great album.

A little better than expected as someone who never really "got it" with Arcade Fire. This was solid.

Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels) // (Power Out) // Crown of Love // Wake Up //

this was the first album I heard by Arcade Fire and what a joy, plenty of great racks and with two singers adds that little variety. Lots of favourite tracks, all the Neighbourhood, Wake Up, In the basement and especially Rebellion (Lies)

a partir da sexta música você começa a mergulhar nas melodias.

cutesy rock album 8/10

This is a perfect album, IMO. It was one of my favorites growing up and I have it on vinyl in my house. Each song is so gorgeous and has its place. It's hard to even name a favorite because there are no mediocre songs on this album, but Tunnels, Haiti, and Wake Up are all special. The shitty thing about this album is that Win Butler (front man) was accused of being an abusive and shitty person to women in 2022. For an album that's so pure, this makes the music hard to listen to now. Overall: 8.5/10

Pretty good album. I liked most of the songs but nothing stood out to me. - 8/10

I'd heard of Arcade Fire because they've performed 5 times on SNL, and after reading the wikipedia article for the album I had high hopes. At first all the songs have the same blaring instrumental with some guy shouting in the background. But after multiple listens I did enjoy a lot of the tracks. Edit -- I don't see myself listening to anything on this again, listening to it for a week straight kind of drained me.

trying to catch up on the albums I missed and I just listened to a 70s album that sounded like every other rock album ever and was boring. ik this is like 30+ years later and maybe its time maybe something else but this feels elevated compared to a lot of the other rock albums on this list. there's some monotony but its monotonous good if that makes sense... 8.4/10

Didn’t listen super closely but it had some cool moments. 7/10

6/10 - It was pretty good. Nothing stood out a great deal but nothing was terrible. I liked a few songs.

I liked it ok, wake up was good 7/10

These songs all kinda sound like the same song, so it loses some points for that. That one song is pretty good though 8.5/10

solid album i liked haiti a lot but over that it never went that high again... 3.0/5.0

i don't remember what i thought of this one. Reminded me of my dad to

So many songs which I do love. Love how the piano makes me sad. And also I never really grew up in the suburbs yet I think it must've been a very melancholic experience.

It is crazy that this is almost 20 years old and doesn't sound dated.

This is a great album right here. I feel like I've been getting a weirdly high amount of indie rock lately. I'm not complaining, I'm just noting that it's a thing. And why would I complain? Funeral by Arcade Fire is an amazing album. This album is very consistent in its tone, but in a good way, rather than a mind-numbingly repetitive way. There's common theming throughout the album making it a light concept album of sorts. The sound is very good. There really isn't a bad song on here. The writing is thoughtful, which makes sense given that a lot of the theming on this album comes from some of the band members having recently lost some of their relatives. I like the singing. The balance between the two main singers is nice. It's crazy to think that this was Arcade Fire's debut album. I can totally see why this is considered one of the best albums of the 2000s. I like it. 5/5.

Remember when that Big Brother contestant said she was into a new kind of music called indie? (I checked the date and it was 2007). Everyone thought it was the most hilariously stupid thing to say. Because, obviously, indie was a 1980s thing. But reading the reviews on the Wikipedia article, and some of the reviews here, there does seem to be support for the idea that indie started in the 00s. This album, and the Big Brother comment, may mark the start of a cultural fragmentation, alternative versions of reality existing in their own bubbles. Fittingly enough, Arcade Fire address just this kind of problem. Their response is to build tunnels connecting people by returning to childhood. The primary emotion is nostalgia, in its original sense as a kind of homesickness. They’re not the first indie band to do this, REM got there first in the 1980s, obviously. They didn’t invent this kind of music, or this kind of sensibility, but they do it very, very well. And listening to it, you’d be forgiven for thinking that indie did in fact start in 2004.

Very, very interesting. Never heard of them before. Wish there was a 3.5 rating.

It’s growing on me and I’m glad I listened to it. I probably won’t listen again but I’m glad I gave it a shot. Worth it.

I like Arcade Fire. 3 albums on this list is a bit much.

it was fine. i wouldn’t be mad if you put this on but i wouldn’t care about it either could i write poetry to this? n

Dear Mr. Dimery, We get it. You like Arcade Fire. It's your book and you can do what you want with it. But, of all the recordings made in the past 74 years, you felt the need to include no less than THREE Arcade Fire albums? Even AF themselves probably don't think they are that important. And I'm guessing that they are some real pretentious, self-absorbed fucks. Do better, Bob. Do better. One half-star. Bumped up from a zero because I once pretended to like this album to impress a girl. It worked and I never had to listen to it again.

I really like 4 songs on this album (Neighborhood 1 & 3, Wake Up, and Rebellion). The rest is boring and points to the boring direction they went in after.

Can't quite believe this came out 20 years ago. I was 17 when Funeral came out so the 00s indie rock period is what I'd consider "my" era of music. For it to be 2 decades ago makes me feel old. Anyway introspection aside, I saw AF live several times and consider myself a fan. I am probably slightly biased because of my rose tinted glasses, but I still like this a lot. The highlights (Tunnels, Wake Up, Rebellion) are great tunes and Arcade Fire really had a distinctive sound that stood out among lots of indie bands competing for attention at the time. Loved it on the re-listen

Pretty decent album but a tad too mellow for me at times. Still all around something decent to listen to.

Only liked two songs, Kettles and Wake Up. The album was quite irritating, wanted to skip a lot of it. Sounded like a lot of songs belonged in tv/film. 1/5

I was just hoping for some sort of melody or hook or something, but, alas, it’s just looping shit with whining vocals, like Radiohead.

N: 3 J: 4

Wonderful album, plumb full of world influence and indie pop know how. Influential for a reason.

Yeah, this is yet another one of those albums that was part of my formative years and will receive 5 stars based on that alone. Even now, it's such an anthemic listen that I can't help but get fired up by it. The album has such a great flow to it (which makes sense, considering the "Neighborhood" concept that connects several of the tracks on side 1). The instrumentation is dense and epic, like a rising. Yet, they feel right at home when they slow things down too. The entire feel of the album conveys the charming nature of the band's humble roots. It feels huge, but it still feels kind of Canadian. And it makes my Canadian indie-boy heart proud to see this one on the list. A true classic of the genre, and it deserves to be.

Not my style, too loud

I like this album a lot. It feels a little samey after a while and compared with their earlier albums, but I love their sound and lyrics

Awesome, awesome, awesome. The album just gets better the longer it plays. IMO it’s a masterpiece. Stunning album.

Good record, loved it when it came out

All time favorite

Couldn’t even finish it. Whiney as fuck, with an underlying hint of sexual predation and narcissism.

Sind schon einige sehr bekannte und renommierte Songs auf der Scheibe, die auch meinen Geschmack treffen. Einiges ist mir aber zu theatralisch und aufgeplustert

I found I got more into this record towards the end. Not sure why it took so long. Definitely an "indie" feel to it. Perhaps it is worth another try down the road...

It just felt like music my mom would play in like 2014 or something. I did not listen to the whole thing.

Arcade fire- I knew the singles but I don’t think I ever heard the whole album. The string arrangements are cool on songs like kettles. Cool how songs flow into each other. “Wake Up” is a great song. “Rebellion” is cool too. I like when bands have multiple singers and I like the songs Regine sings like “In the Backseat.” I don’t know how to rate this one 4, 4.5?

Objectively a pretty decent album, I’ve just never really liked this style/phase of music and I hope it doesn’t ever regain popularity. For me it lives in that world of stomp clap Mumford and lumineers and it just doesn’t work for me. But it is a decently made album. The drums in track one feel distractingly terrible to me but they didn’t bother me on the rest of the record

Wake up is super catchy but I feel like every other song is a lesser version of the song. His voice is cool.

Found it pretty pedestrian

Not my style

Podría haberlo puntuado antes, pero hacía muchos años que no lo escuchaba entero y quería saber si lo bueno era el recuerdo de años felices de conciertos y mucha música, pero me he llevado un sorpresón porque me ha gustado igual o más. Un disco muy bien cohesionado aunque hay saltos y cambios de estilo que se integran fenomenal. Lo voy a recuperar.

It's OK, but not really something I'll listen to often

Not my music. A bit boring...

I had them pending... At some point I have listened to U2 and at other times to ELO... But a lot of personality!

1. 3.3 2. 3.1 3. 2.7 4. 3.6 5. 3.8 6. 4 7. 4.7 8. 4.7 9. 4.8 10. 4.7

died for a bit but im back now hi (im gonna stop rating individually im lazy) like: tunnels, the french one i think i have to be in a very specific mood to enjoy this and its not my current one fs

it felt so dreamlike at times but i found it hard to focus while listening but it was good. i really liked crown of love and in the backseat

Started a 2 (pretty derivative and I don't like when high vocals back a main vocal but just an octave up) but then Crown of Love was a banger with a great ending and upped it to a 3, and the rest of the album carried that momentum all the way up to 4. Good stuff, was just what my run needed.

This album shaped my musical taste during my formative years. Sent me on an indie-rock journey and opened my world to a whole new genre! Songwriting, originality and performance (especially live performances) are all top notch. Knocking off 0.5 for sub-par production/mixing. 4.5/5

Listening to the band after all the allegations around the lead singer hits differently. But objectively this is an incredible album and I think one of their best Strong albums from 1st to last and stood out so much in its day when first released 4

den var sgu meget fed! Aldrig hørt Arcade Fire før

En af de absolut bedste. Skrev for et par uger siden at Tigermilk måske havde det bedste åbningsnummer på en debutplade nogensinde, det var slef fordi jeg havde glemt at tænke på Neighborhood #1

Klassiker 👌

No me gustó

The first descriptor that came to mind for this record is theatrical rock. Elements of folk throughout, but it also reminds me of a circus at times with its vibrant and wacky sounds. Enjoyable listen still.

This album was indeed fire. I think Arcade Fire is that upbeat type of sound that can brighten anyone's day. It landed on a day when I needed it, so the timing was great. Definitely interested in more Arcade Fire!

It's aight. A few exciting songs, although I didn't listen to the album very closely in terms of lyrics. I feel like I would have liked this album more a few years ago, but unfortunately some songs are overplayed now. Crown of Love and Rebellion are still great tracks

One doesn't hear the krautrock and bossa nova the editors claim to hear, and one does hear emo-adjacent vibes (which editors try to claim they don't, revealing the axe they pretty clearly wish to grind). Overall, this is a intense, driving, rock-centric sorta record that sounded fresh and new a decade-plus ago and retains much of its energy today. Solid all the way around, though slightly overwrought at times.

It's ok. Nothing really stands out for me. Bit too many droning sounds.

This felt try-hard when I was 25 and it still does 20 years later.

Kedelig første halvdel. Muligvis acquired taste. Jeg bliver ikke fan af det her album. Rebellion lies er fed, men ikke ventetiden værd.

Et album der holder dig på tæerne. Det kræver ens opmærksomhed ved konstant at skifte i stemning og og retning eller ved at smide små finurlige guitar-figurer ind fra højre. Det har ikke så mange massive sange som The Suburbs har, men den aktive lytter keder sig aldrig.

one of the best

alt goodies

Wie Talking Heads, aber durch den Lead-Sänger hektischer. Trtzdem finden sich coole Lieder!