Funeral by Arcade Fire

Funeral

Arcade Fire

3.54
Rating
30876
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
31%
4
31%
5
22%
Distribution

Reviews (page 13 of 15)

The album was fine. Perfectly pleasant. There was a time when there was quite a hike around this group and I just never got it.

When this album first started, I was pretty certain I wasn't enjoying it. The vocals sounded affected — I was wondering if there was a connection to Modest Mouse in just the vibe and overall sound of the band and vocals. And then, song by song, I started falling under the album's spell, and by the middle, I was fully on board. I wasn't able to give this a close enough listen to get into the lyrics and meanings of the songs — this one definitely warrants another listen — but I heard enough to get swept into the emotive, creative, well-written, well-produced songs.

I practically wore out my copy when this was released. Then I stopped listening and haven't really revisited since. It still holds up, though I'm not quite sure it reignited a spark to put this back into regular rotation. (Not that I have time for a rotation with all these daily albums coming at me.) Anyway, this is a confident and astonishing debut. They've got hooks for days and the arrangements are creative and memorable. I'm not sure why I'm not connecting with it like I used to, but that's on me, not them, I think.

Every time I played this the music just kept getting lost. Like it just drifted away in the background of my kitchen. Underwhelming

Very Arcade Fire. Kind of all the same. No memorable melodies. I feel like I am supposed to really like Arcade Fire but … meh.

First listen was while I was cutting the grass; overall impression was this is solid early-00s folk-indie that reminds me a bit of The Decemberists. 4 / 5 Second listen I felt pretty similarly; however, no particular songs stood out to me. I'd say this is a 3.5, but I'll round up.

Never really listened to Arcade Fire besides Wake Up. Glad it's on this album because it's a top 100 song for me. This album so far is a unique intersection of rock and folk with a touch of emo. I love the beat switches in their songs. Rebellion is also a familiar song. Good album, will probably listen again.

I'm happy that this is on here. I've always heard of Arcade Fire but never listened and have always wanted to. The Neighborhood songs are awesome especially #3 The speed up part at the end of Crown of Love was a very welcomed surprise I know Wake up it's a great fit in this album to be a single That album was very good. For me it definitely peaked in the middle then fell off with the last two songs. But still an album I will be listening to again. Strong 4

Only really listened to Reflektor by them which I hear is insanely different from their usual style, so I'm excited. Pretty good listening. Then Neighborhoods #3 (which reminds me of the song Reflektor with less electronics). Damn I just kept picturing hearing that song live. Probably fuxxx. Wake Up is an obvious jam. Didn't even realize that was by them but knew the song. Haiti song makes me happy. Loved the buildup in In The Backseat. Great album. I think I like Reflektor better but was trying to not be biased. I know this is critically acclaimed but just felt kinda stagnant at some points. Really enjoyable though.

Sentimental bias but I adore this album front to back. Bummer about Alice, though. RIP.

Listened while cleaning out a drawer filled with old stuff and felt a little emotional. Good album.

Always been on the fence with this band....lets see....

Perfect album

Fantastic top to bottom. So much depth to their sound - they're incredible at making you feel a vibe

This reminds me a lot of "Funeral for a friend" by Elton John, which I really appreciate.

It sounds like if Cage The Elephant forgot how to write catchy hooks, I enjoyed a few moments alright though. Probably won’t listen again any time soon.

I really like the overall vibe of this album. The sound. The atmosphere. It all works pretty well as background music to everyday life. Thats kinda what this album feels like though, just background music. Some tracks attempt to stand out more than others such as Laika, Crown of love, wake up and Rebellion however, even those dont really take the album to a different level. On the whole I'd say Funeral just kind of meanders. The only reason this would be a "must listen" album is because while not pioneering a genre of their own they did popularize a sound that spawned countless imitators. Quite a few of which did it better. Despite my previous criticism I do like Arcade Fire and have listened to this album, Neon Bible and The suburbs a number of times. (both of which I enjoy more)however as the years have gone by they just don't stand out for me the way they used to. This album is a high 3 low 4 to me now.

New sound to me, liked it

I had listened to this album a few times before and didnt really get the hype, but this inspired me to listen again. And it clicked pretty hard. Great album, tunnels will be stuck in my head for a while

Good album but not as big a fan as I used to be in my teens

Almost blasphemy not to give this one a 5/5, but it really only ventures into greatness from 'Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)' an onwards. The three-track stretch of 'Wake Up', 'Haiti' and 'Rebellion (Lies)' is peak Arcade Fire and defining an entire new genre, giving us artists such as fun. (wuhu).

I still have a hard time understanding that Funeral is a debut album. Arcade Fire revolutionized the entire genre with this. There is an edge and a sense of awareness to this that their more polished and pretty contemporaries lacked. Arcade Fire, for me, peaked early on. They just don’t get any better than this.

Great debut album from Arcade Fire. This is one of my personal favorites of the 2000s, an emotional, grand journey from front to back. A must listen for any indie enthusiasts

I thought it was going to be better than what it was.

A greater guitar-driven effort from Arcade Fire I overlooked in favor of their progressively synthier discography that followed. There’s no denying the genuine emotion here, but something felt unsatisfying - my best guess would be how homogeneous the instrumentation and mostly upbeat melodies feel throughout the entire LP, never really throwing any curveballs or even mildly deviating from expectations once the first track is done. This was a decent listen, but just never shifted into a gear that demanded my attention.

great stuff from mtl!

Meh. Whole album is similar sounding and there's no real progressive story. A bit pretentious and folksy without the charm behind it.

One of the albums that cemented the importance and ethos of the indie rock early this century. Love this album!

Pretty good album. Unique sound, has a genuine, honest feel to it. 3/5

Ok, I didn't hate it. If you put this on in the car, I could listen to it. Some songs were better than others.

Had this on heavy rotation in the 2000s, but hadn't listened for quite a while. Still stands up as a top notch album. Probably Arcade Fire's best, the next couple of albums were great too, until Reflektor went downhill. Also, shame Win Butler turned out to be a creep.

omg!! better than my expectations. first five songs or so were really great, rest of the album was still quite good but didn't reach those heights in my opinion. i was pleasantly surprised because i've listened to arcade fire's newer stuff and not liked it very much, but this is actually awesome. there's a homeliness about it that i like a lot.

Pop rock, kinda Indy feeling

But overrated to be honest

Always thought this wasn't their best album, and still do, but don't think you can argue with the tunes on here. Shame the lead guy is called Win and is Pervy Pete

Never heard of this band or album but absolutely loved it. Not hard to see why it has won son many accolades, they're well deserved.

Big at the time, pretty Middle of The Road nowadays

I can tell there is something deep in here. Wake Up is a good tune. That closer was so powerful, this is worth a deeper dive.

Excellent indie

It was okay

I was going to post about 'warm' and 'cold' albums but instead will reflect on how extra-ordinarily back-loaded this album is. The first four tracks are indistinct, hesitant, a bit sound and fury signifying not that much. And then the three punch of Kettle, Crown of love and Wake Up delivers something else entirely. The rest of the album maintains that level, perhaps its part of that uber-indie vibe this album has to make people work a bit first. Anyway, not their best album but very good.

This album is my best. Made me love this band. Still do.

As I said in another review, I like the first two Arcade Fire albums so this was an easy listen, however I really do wonder if they needed 3 albums on the list. They are a great band but did they need 3?

Ik vind dit een heel lekker album. Fijne nummers en mooi geheel

I wanted to be cynical about this (probably due to his recent indiscretions) and say that on reflection they didn’t deserve the godlike indie reverence they received, but it’s just banger after banger.

it seems like the same thing over and over again and i’m not that crazy about that particular thing

Second thoughts are this is a very good album, and definitely an 8.5/10 This album is incredible, at each track is laced and has its own unique personality. The instrumentals are superb, there is not a single bad song. There is not much to say in a negative light, other than the fact some songs may sound similar, and some have basis indie riffs. Favorites: #1 / Une Annee Sans Lumiere / #4 / Crown of Love / Wake Up / In the Backseat

Indie elevator music.

kinda cool tbh

"Funeral" is the debut album by Canadian indie rock band Arcade Fire. Indie rock, chamber rock, art rock and baroque pop. Yeah, sure. Well, everyone in the band seems to play all instruments. And there are all instruments. The album was recorded in Montreal and produced by the band for a mere $10,000. The album title and the basis for several songs came from several bandmembers recently losing family members. Multi-instrumentalist/vocalist Régine Chassagne lost her grandmother and her husband Win Butler and his brother Will lost their grandfather (both multi-instrumentalists as well). The song themes include alienation, loss of innocence, frustration with and tensions in governments and family ties in neighborhoods. This album had widespread critical acclaim propelling them to indie rock icons. An organ hum, undulating strings and a repetitive piano melody open one of the four neighborhood songs in "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)." The drums kick in and the song keeps building with the pace picking up and increasing. I've had a lot of songs building over the past two days. The song is set in the 1960's with two kids sneaking off to each other through tunnels leaving parents distraught with the Vietnam War, assassinations and sex, drug and rock and roll. There's been a few songs I've heard where as soon as I heard it I went out to immediately buy the album and "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" did that for me. A pop beat, jangly guitars and an initial xylophone melody. Layered guitars. One of a few anthems on this albums. This song was inspired by the 1998 ice storm in Montreal resulting in a week-long blackout. Overall, about alienation. "Crown of Love" has weeping strings and a piano and then totally changes towards the end going basically disco. The second half of this album has several songs where you see the music style change within the song. Welcome to big anthem #2 in "Wake Up." Also, Arcade Fire welcome to permanence as arena-level artists. '"Oh-Oh-Oh....-Oh." You know it. Guitar, drums, strings. Another musical change at the end with Régine taking over lead vocals from Win. Loss of innocence and trying to reach someone who's suffered trauma. A repetitive piano and bass help build tension in "Rebellion (Lies)." "Every time you close your eyes. Lies. Lies." Maybe the struggle for a government you want to what currently is. Yeah, this is a pretty landmark indie and overall album. The songs are musically optimistic and uplifting despite mostly lyrically dire landscapes. Most songs build with a chamber/baroque pop start ending in more of rock and roll realm. It's quite a feat writing a few anthems on your debut album. I do like several of the subsequent Arcade Fire albums quite a bit. But, "Funeral" is without question my favorite and their best.

comfort album

couple of very good sons, others are mid and very similar

easy listening/chill

Least favourite band in the world for me (in other words, havent heard a bigger carp than this)

Good stuff

It came out at a time when I was too busy with kids etc to pay attention to music. Parts flickered with recognition - was OK

I remember buying this when it came out and despite it being full of great track was a little disappointed. Stands up well now and one of the better offerings by AF.

Alright, unpopular opinion here, considering the accolades this band has received…I don’t get it. I remember reading something a long time ago about how they are the highest awarded or selling or something, and I tried to give a few songs a listen and didn’t enjoy it. I thought since a few years have passed, and my musical taste had grown, maybe I’d understand it now. I gave the album two full listens and I’m still lost. I don’t see anything special about any of it, and actually wanted to turn it off multiple times, but figured I HAVE to be missing something. I still don’t get it hahaha. Listen again: nope Purchase for my collection: no Favourite Song: In the Backseat (only because of a few riffs mid song. The whining is annoying).

A defining moment of the indie rock scene of the first decade of the 2000's. Considering that indie rock really saw its heyday in that period, that's really saying something. The album begins with what remains one of my favourite Arcade Fire songs and one of my favourite songs in general, "Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels)". Set amongst an incredibly rich and artfully arranged array of instruments, this song is a masterclass in album opening songwriting that gradually builds to a powerful and memorable crescendo. That the band is able to maintain such quality throughout the entire album is a testament to its greatness. They oscillate between harder-hitting and energetic tracks ('Laika', 'Power Out', 'Wake Up', 'Rebellion') and more subdued, reflective pieces ('Une Annee Sans Lumiere', '7 Kettles', 'In the Backseat') in such a seamless and purposeful way, making for an extremely enjoyable listening experience that is never overwhelming, despite the thematic and musical heft carried by these songs. While Arcade Fire would go on to release more popular albums, in my opinion, this remains their magnum opus. Absolute freakin fire.

very solid album

This is the third Arcade Fire album that I have gotten on this list and I can confidently state that I am not a fan. Their work just isn’t my preferred kind of music. Although I think I liked this album the best of the three. Not for me but I can understand why others enjoy them.

Love this album!

I know upfront I like this one. Rebellion (Lies) might be my favourite AF song.

height of early naughts indie then, just a pretty good album now Favorite Tracks: Neighborhood 1-4 4-4.5/5

One of the most well textured projects I have ever had the pleasure of listening to. It carries its air of melancholia flawlessly with soaring strings, strained vocals, and beautifully crunchy guitar tones.

Not for me, but a good album never the less, i found it interesting to hear that the genre can also be desrcribes as "baroque pop" great description 3/5

This is the second album I've reviewed by Arcade Fire in this generator. The first one was The Suburbs. Of the two, this one is my favorite. Arcade Fire are a Canadian indie rock band from Quebec. Overall, not a bad album. I'm not a huge fan of indie music, so I wouldn't rush out to buy this, but I didn't immediately want to shut it off either. A fairly average album. Favourite songs: Rebellion (Lies), Wake Up, Neighborhood #3 (Power Out), Une Annee Sans Lumiere Least favourite songs: In the Backseat, Crown of Love 3/5

Cool album! I liked this one better than the other one of this list (The Suburbs).

Bra gjort Montreal!

Had it on in the background and wasn't really locked it but there was something there that made me want to give it another run. Listened again with headphones on and yeah, now I get it.

The nostalgia is strong today. Not much of a fan outside of this album but I can't get enough of this one. straight up (Arcade) fire

A great debut by Arcade Fire, it has the typical sound that we have come to know of Arcade fire, but at the time of release, their style was quite new and fresh. Filled with lots of emotion and atmosphere, I think it's one to add to the record collection! Best: Neighbourhood #3 Worst: Neighbourhood #4

Grew on me over the course of a day. Swelling orchestrals, a raucous energy. I can only imagine how much better it would be in context of it’s time. Will continue listening to this one I think. Cannot wait to explore the lyrical content.

I had listened to The Suburbs on a recommendation before listening to this and really liked it so i was hopeful. it’s definitely not as good but there are some really great moments, the best of which comes at the end of Crown of Love with the switch from 6/8 to disco 4/4

This wasn’t my cup of tea. The instruments were fine, but the singers voice just annoyed me. It wasn’t horrible, just really boring. I’m starting to wonder if I really need to hear all these albums before I die.

Expected better, nothing fabulous

This resembles so many other early 2000s "indie rock" albums that I am amazed I ever found interesting.

Top 3 Songs: 1 - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) (1) 2 - Wake Up (7) 3 - Rebellion (Lies) (9)

64 albums in and this is my second Arcade Fire one. So that doubles my historical Arcade Fire listening experience. I didn't get what the hype was about on the previous one and I'm afraid this one's the same. I'm sure that if you're a fan this is sublime or something. I'm obviously not a fan. It's not horrible, but I won't listen to the album again out of choice.

Rockindie 2004.. jahas jahas..Paskinta paskaa btw rummut aina samat rummut pum pump pum pum pum menee tahtia.. Se pelastaa että oikeesti conceptual hyvä alnumi ja hyviä kappaleita.

This is a band I find that I'll never fully appreciate. The music doesn't engage me and I do not enjoy the singing at all. There might be good lyrics in this album, but it's hard for me to focus on it when I can't enjoy the rest.

BEST DEBUT ALBUM EVER (in my opinion haha). There are definitely more influential debuts, but for my money this album is the best home run for a bands first time at the bat. Just so perfectly put together. The energy that runs through this thing is so insanely positive and breathtaking. Love it.

it is definitely a good album. No song drags the experience down but the songs itself aren't that great and wonderful. It's good but it doesn't achieve the 4/5 7.5/10 (3/5)

Indie pop that’s just experimental enough to make people think they’re smart because they listen to it. There’s a cohesive, expansive sound to the record, but the songs don’t really accomplish anything, go anywhere or have any bite to them; it’s just a lot of sound that ends up being not very memorable. Didn’t get the hype when it came out. Still don’t get it now, but this might be the record that spawned a thousand imitators trying to cash in on the “indie sound”, which ultimately ruined indie rock. In that regard, “Funeral” is a fitting title, indeed.

reminds me of a bad modest mouse song.

They brought an original sound, which is not easy to do. Worth a few listens, at least.

This was quite good. The vocals are quite distinctive. Not sure if this is something to worry about later since Morrissey's vocals were also distinctive. There is good pace to this album.

This is a terrific debut release. It’s well-developed with lovely arrangements – the violins and accordion make for a big sound – and lyrically they tackle heavy themes. The one weak link might be Win Butler’s vocals, which don’t hold up when he really tries to belt it out.

Back in 2004 I walked into my local record shop and started to thumb thru the racks of records when this music came on that really caught my attention. I had never heard anything quite like it before. It was so unique and so original sounding. I asked the clerk who it was and he proudly announced it was this new Indie band from Montreal called Arcade Fire. I grabbed it and couldn’t wait to get home to listen to it. I still think this is probably their best release and one of the best Indie albums from the early 2000s. The songs on the album are similar sounding but yet very cohesive and the segues from song to song are just perfect. This is a very high 4, almost a 5 for me.

Killer album

Please, this is not one of the finest albums of all time

Fresh and new, it was interesting.

This album was really good. my favorite track by far was crown of love and I will be adding it to my playlist. I highly recommend the full album if you like indie/alt music.

Reminded me to listen to more arcade fire, but I prefer the suburbs as an album

the third arcade fire album on this project but their debut album (excluding their ep). it contains a lot of their usual morose, melancholy sound. some indie music can be real misses for me, but with arcade fire, i know they are dependable, based on the other two albums i've heard of theirs throughout this project. like with their other albums, they created a theme on funeral. it can be moody but they do stay on theme. "crown of love," the standout, breaks your heart, and it's not like "wake up" makes you feel any better. i like all three neighborhood songs, and they really tie the album together. i found myself disappointed by régine chassagne, the female vocalist, and i'm not sure her voice is strong enough to carry a song by herself, but at least there were only two solo songs. also, this guy win butler sounds like a real piece of work. unfortunate arcade fire makes such good music.

This was hypnotic and easy to listen to! It had a very intimate feel to it. Either way, "Funeral" is an apt name for this album; it feels very burdened and sad. While I definitely feel like this album spawned something within the indie movement, and certainly pushed Arcade Fire into stardom, I only averagely enjoyed this.

There's just too much indie rock that are the same-ish on the 1001 list. This one mixed things up a little bit through the tracks but I still needed to pause the album halfway through and listen to something else as a palate cleanser before continuing.

Nice record, but nothing special, for what I'm concerned.

the pretty sounds from this album seem to scratch an itch in my brain that has been nagging my subconscious for several months now. ive wanted to listen to something like this for so long, something that feels like a mix of neutral milk hotel (especially with the album art!) and my bloody valentine. but at the same time i feel like saying the above is an injustice to how uniquely all of the records elements synergise together. you dont see some of the instruments and individual styles used together as often as some of the songs on here do. im a big fan of the sounds on this record; theres something spectral about them, maybe its got something to do with the theme and the title of the album, "funeral". its strange. but in a good way. i really feel the depth of the emotions that come from the vocals, especially with the dude. i feel like as enthusiasts of music we dont really talk enough about the little vocal intonations that go into adding to the whole experience of a record. i notice the same things in film, we love talking about the grand and loud emotional performances of actors and often avoid the performances that convey so much through subtlety. theres some french weaved into here as well, which im definitely a fan of. i think it goes well with the themes and sounds. my top 3: power out is definitely one of my favourites on this album. i just like the sounds and lyrics a lot. 7 kettles is really interesting to me, the way they used the sound of the kettle and very smoothly weaved it into the song. rebellion is definitely my favourite. it sounds dreamy yet ambitious at the same time. and i really love the theme of it as a whole. PS in the backseat is such a beautiful outro. it makes me feel the same way id feel as a child when my favourite adventure movie was ending, or when i finished reading 13 reasons why. its just a peaceful grieving. so good

Definitely very good 00s indie but not my favorite 00s indie.

Solid 4* album. I love the genre!

This is the first album I'm going to have to recuse myself from giving an objective rating. Hearing this album at 14 / 15 years old really did change the type of music I enjoyed. I keep revisiting it thinking my enjoyment of it will diminish but nope, still as good. I can't believe they made an album so genuinely earnest that somehow isn't cheesy. 5/5

Solid indie album, enjoyed the vocals. Nothing felt too interesting though.

J'aurais dû mettre 4 à l'autre car celui-ci est meilleur (trop généreux)

les chansons que j'ai aimées sont les moins écoutées je crois que je suis pas le bon public

Nice album, nice sound. Some songs were a bit boring

Wasn't really familiar with Arcade fire before this and quite enjoyed this

Very clean with some very nice songs on it. A lot of the album disappears into the background a bit though,

One of my all time favourites. One of those albums which I have to listen to as an album. Broad, wide open instrumentation, vulnerable voice, great melodies. Amazin album.

What a great album... that's utterly ruined by mopey, whiney, emo vocals. Win Butler needs to pull himself out of his own butthole, grow a spine, and act like he actually wants to be here making music. I wanted to fail this so hard because of these vocals but the music is just SO good. I have to give it multiple stars for the musicianship alone. I want a no-vocals version of this album. I'd listen to it on repeat. All day long. But add in these vocals and the gag-inducing, self-indulgent lyrics and I'm out. I couldn't wait for it to be done.

A few good listens, but not my cup of tea

An amazing debut album from one of my fave bands. It's very close to a perfect record, except for a couple of so-so songs.

Pretty much a perfect album. It’s classic indie rock, packed with emotion and catharsis, incredible songwriting, and inspired musicianship. This album will always make me feel like my heart is spilling out of my chest.

Ever wanted to listen to Emo music but hated how terrible the vocalists were and how shallow their lyrics were? Well, guess what: There’s not only an album, but an entire band about that. Think if an emo outfit grew out of adolescence and dumped all the awkwardness with it, and you would have Arcade Fire. This is their debut. First album. And it sounds as grandoise as a progressive rock record recorded by a veteran band. The confidence they have on this record is staggering. I mean, again, this is their DEBUT! And here they are, giving some of the most rousing stadium-stompers this side of the early 2000s! Gone are the indie “slacker vibes” that bands like Pavement brought to the table, now these indie outfits have something deeper to say. The production gives the songs a cinematic quality to them: that kind of sprawling sound that seems larger than life. And nowhere does the album lose any of its momentum. It keeps building, and building, and building, until it finally climaxes at “Rebellion (Lies)”, another impressive anthem. It’s no secret that this album gets the praise it does, this is the real deal. No other 2000s indie act could boast such an explosive debut (maybe barring Franz Ferdinand but I’d argue that’s a different case), at least over in North America. A great driving album where you’re on a long rural highway and can pay attention to the lyrics a bit more. Standout Songs: “Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)” “Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)” “Crown of Love” “Rebellion (Lies)”

A great album I’ve never paid much attention to. Hard to believe it came out in ‘04. Wake Up famously made the trailer for Where the Wild Things Are look good and the first track is a classic. My faves were Crown of Love and Rebellion.

I’ll start with the positive. This is a a very well arranged, orchestrated and produced album. Unfortunately it feels like Win Butler wants to be David Byrne but he does have the funk and soul to make it work.

This is some of the whitest music I’ve ever heard in my life. I guess some might call this “ambitious” but I think it’s just a bit over the top and not very compelling.

not a fan of sexual assault, or the music

I just can't bear his weak whiny voice. Would have given it one star but I know there is far worse on this list ...

Putting the fun into funeral.

emo for pyros

Reminds me of 1st Bank Center with Kyle. Great album, great time. 4.5 for memories. Maybe 3.5 for music.

J’étais pas sûr d’aimer à ma première écoute, mais dès que je l’ai relancé j’ai tout de suite accroché. C’est un bon mix de rock et d’arrangement syphonique, les chansons flow l’une dans l’autre, pis bonus c’est des Montréalais

Tunnels: I see this as another song about love, definitely not an oversaturated topic. Whiney voice, definitely a song for indiehead teenagers. Other than that, it sounds fine. Laika: God I hate that voice. Sounds like an indiehead's wet dream. You can tell this song's main audience were college kids. UASL: Better voice. A song about losing someone close to them, much better. Power Out: Maybe I'm just getting used to it, but I don't dislike the voice. Another song about losing someone. Kettles: A song about an inactive society/government. Better voice Crown of Love: Another love song. Fine voice, oversaturated topic Wake Up: About the loss of innocence. Kinda annoying voice. Good subject matter. Haiti: A tribute to Haiti. Fine. Lies: A metaphor for how we choose to "sleep" and cover our eyes to the atrocities in the world. Best song in this album to me. In the Backseat: About how their youth was taken so they were "in the driver's seat" way too soon when they would have rather waited. 2nd best song to me 2.8/5

Love this album

Indie rock. No está mal.

Can't rate this without nostalgia.

AJ: This band has a song or two I really love. Just a couple of really great songs. Wake Up hits me in the feels. I don’t know why it affects me so much. Just does. Couple cool tracks here, but they’re pretty strange. Honorable mention to Keep the Car Running. Not on this album but it’s the other song of theirs I love. Random stuff on Spotify after the album ended has been top notch! •The Strokes- Soma •Skipped vampire weekend •The Shins- New Slang skipped, but went back and listened and it’s cool. Skipped vampire weekend twice. Ha! •Franz Ferdinand- Take Me Out 🔥 •Flaming Lips don’t use jelly •Modest Mouse- Float On 💨 Cat: they’re pretty good, nothing jumps out at me as great. Weird voice, melancholy lyrics, I liked the dancier tracks (Power Out, Rebellion) and I liked Wake Up.

not what I expected but really good, should revisit later

Another one of those where I have to separate the artist from the art. This album could have gotten way out of hand, but they balance the melodrama with true earnest intensity and rich instrumental arrangements. Nothing on here seems fake or overdone or contrived, which is a massive improvement over their contemporaries. That they achieved this with a debut album is all the more amazing.

Sounds like an indie album from the early 2000s. To be fair, this album probably popularized the sound. Big production, emotional vocals, varied instrumentation. There are some strong singles but the rest of the album feels a little same-y.

It’s a type of music that I would like, but somehow don’t. Spacey and airy vocals, interesting music styling and choices. It’s like and Indy-folk. There are a few songs I enjoy, but ultimately forgettable.

its fine didnt listen to it too heavily but also didnt feel the need to

If the people who invented and created recording equipment knew it was going to be (mis)used this way they would have never gone through with it. I hope they called it funeral to celebrate the end of their musical career because they realized they should have never even begun to try and make any music.

this is a great indie-rock album. Really takes me back to my early/mid-20s.

This is a super important album to me. I listened to it for the first time my freshman year of college and it was during that formative period where your musical horizons tend to expand in lockstep with your social horizons. It's one of those albums that I distinctly remember the first time I really heard it, and it will always be one of the most complete albums of all time in my opinion. I will always get a little bit of a chill when I hear the opening chords of Neighborhood #1. I don't need to listen to it again, but I'm going to anyway, because it's a fucking masterpiece. Standouts: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Une Annee Sans Lumiere, Crown of Love, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies)

Vraiment préféré celui-là à Neon Bible. Les compositions sont meilleures, le style est plus unique, le son est plus recherché en général. Même si je suis moins fan d'albums indie rock, c'est le genre d'album qui est très solide et qui vaut la peine d'être essayé. Mérite amplement sa place d'album phare dans le genre. 8/10

Rainy day, perfect to start off this challenge. Also I already had "Wake Up" liked?? No idea when but when I was listening to the album I was like, oh I like this one and sure enough I already had it like :)

Pretty good. The album's songs include a range of tempos and melodies; vocals are fair, and the arrangements are tasteful.

Cool album. Enjoyed the piano and the strings. Interesting sound.

minne om vgs

Levyllä oli omat hetkensä, mutta en kyllä tule enää ikinä kuuntelemaan uusiksi.

Ei nyt kovin jääny erikoista mainittavaa. Siedettävä

Too raucous for me

Strong two star. Two good songs, maybe three. This is the new brian rating system 1 good song = 1 star

A couple good songs but I think this band could take any song and make it boring. Concerts must be a snooze fest

Easy to listen to indie

I’d give it a 7.5 out of 10. The first half was pretty boring with the neighborhoods but got much better.

I think its insane they wrote the soundtrack for her which has Song on the Beach and I LOVE THAT SONNG. Anyway these are some nice indie vibes, they reminds me of the Perks of Being a wallflower and they make me think of weddings with mason jars and twine lol. I think they were the blue print for this style of white people music. also like the lighter version of joy division. Also I feel some Black Country New Road kind of vibe to some of the songs. I bet they were inspired by Arcade Fire, or its kinda folky.

10 tracks at 48 minutes for an album that sounds like one song. This album is probably only here for 'Wake Up', a phenomenal song that does a lot of heavy lifting to keep this album good. 3/5.

Great debut.

It’s ok. Rebellion (Lies) is great. It’s a 2.5 that I’ll round up because it really like that one song.

The album itself is a 5/5 but Win Butler ruined it for me.

Good patiche of all the pop rock that came before it. Solid release. Too bad about Butler.

I know I'm supposed to hate Arcade Fire now because the singer is a bad person, but I've never listened to an Arcade Album song before, so I don't know how that works. I guess I will dislike the man for being a bad person and see what the music is like. Phew, moral quandary navigated! Not sure about his voice. It's actually not that bad. Solid, I like the 'Neighborhood' pieces. 3 / 5.

Liked it alot

Couple of solid tracks but didn’t blow me away. Obviously don’t have the nostalgia that this album (or band) brings. The good is good enough for a 4.

I’m familiar with this album and have a few songs from it that I really enjoy. It was nice to listen to it again after a long time.

Will I die from a nostalgia overload? Probably, yes. But it'll be worth it

Obvious 5, so good.

When this album came out it blew my mind. I was just in the throws of discovering new indie rock that began around 1999. Bands like Built to Spill, Spoon, Wilco, Yo La Tengo, Luna, Modest Mouse, Eleventh Dream Day, pj Harvey, The White Stripes, Idlewild, Interpol, The National, GSYBE, pavement, Silver Jews and dozens and dozens of others had dominated my listening for the last few years. Then this album comes out and takes the Indie music world by storm. A band from my home town, shining a light on our music scene and dominating the talk around indie music. And then the accolades start pouring in from the likes of Bowie, Springsteen, David Byrne, Coldplay and U2. Anyway the music on the album is bold and beautiful and big and way too accomplished to be a debut album. And the live shows so incredibly energetic and epic. Well for me this was an album that defined an era, both musically and culturally (on a small scale). And the songs are all absolutely forst rate. SUre, no really new ideas nut the execution of the ideas they do have is nearly flawless. 5 stars

Didn’t really vibe with this album it’s a 3.5 stars really but I’ll round it up to 4.It’s indie rock that’s pretty good.

Great stuff

They sort of all merge together. Which isn’t a bad thing.

Some good jams

I interesting. Liked some tracks more than others.

Trying to be super arty-rock. But ultimately failing. Critically acclaimed but for the life of me, I don't know why. Let's list the art-rock tropes used on this album: 1. Weird album title that has nothing to do with the songs on the album. Long mysterious sounding titles with numbers and parenthesis: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), etc. (By the way, the 4 "Neighborhood" songs appear to have no connection with each other) 2. Foreign language titles (also mysterious): Une Annee Sans Lumiere 3. Unintelligible lyrics on several songs 4. Repetitive chanting 5. Added violin and accordion for artsy ambience 6. Constant driving quarter note bass drum on seemingly every single song, except when they throw in a sudden weird tempo change (usually accompanied by a key change or new chords). Very artistic. Here's a tip . Try writing a catchy melody. I tried to like these guys when this came out - but I just can't do it. I don't get it. Someone tell me what I am missing. 2 stars for effort.

Good album!! This is great to have in while working or doing something else. Nothing really stood out to me in a good or bad way. 3.5/5 stars

Amazing guitar sound, and I think all the orchestral arrangements were done in a good way to add something to the album without overdoing anything. My big hang-up here is the same with so many indie rock acts of the 21st century - why is the lead singer's voice so ... whiny. The "Neighborhood" saga is my least favorite grouping of tracks, the standouts here were Une Annee Sans Lumiere, Wake Up, Rebellion, and In the Backseat. I can easily see why this made the mark it did in 2004 and is considered a top album of the decade.

Not for me. Singer sounds very whiny.

Keep setting me up for spikes and I spike. Another one of my faves. Had it on repeat in high school.

Enjoyed this album. Need to give it another listen though.

After reading the wiki, it impresses me that this album was all but complete after one week. Crown of Love hits feels. Wake Up is a classic to me. But Haiti and Backseat with the female vocals really surprised me, they were softer and yet more of statement pieces for me. One thing that alludes to the "Indie" realm for me here is the unpolished, unrefined sound with some classical instruments is a cool juxtaposition.

Wow, mid 2000s nostalgia is rushing over me. It's like alt rock with a folk and punk undertone. (Honestly their aggressive songs remind me of the stranglers a bit!) But they have so much range and a lot more heart than other rock bands of their time. Great lead vocalist(s), and great use of so many instruments: all the standards plus strings and xylophone or some shit. Each song is its own standalone great track. The album is so easy to listen to. A great road trip album for sure.

One of my all-time favorites!

Beter dan andere album

Good album, would listen again but not one that I would rave about

don't hate it. don't like it. boring. like a messier lumineers. I appreciate the occasional gritty singing and angst. But something about it just... didn't feel right. It all felt blended through the mess yet still not cohesive.

Nah. Less than 24 hours since I listened and I can’t remember it at all. Has not hit the spot.

It's fine

That one song sounds like that one song by Kodaline.

bcnr vibes. track one bangs. driving rhythm is really cool. I like a good indie clip on the vocals. what on earth time signature is track 2. the backing vocals work in a cool way here. still cool. cool guitar lead here in track 3. softer vibe. the mixing of the drums is very specific but sounds good. I like this song quite a bit. I like the whole melody being built off a simple phrase. fuck yeah. the sliding bass oh yeah. banger. on about track 4 now. I love the simple sliding bass. reminds me of pattos bassline on track 6 of iwutbf. what an instrument. this all just works so well. the mix is so full. holy shit this is mad. 10/10 song wholeheartedly. that song had me groovin. I think a picture of houses at nighttime would be a better album cover for this album. not a bad cover but the music gives vibes of the sunken suburbs in Derek Mahon day trip to donegal poem. the subtle building here in track 5 is cool. I like this feature on the website of taking notes. makes more present listening experience. this song is yet to Get a heart but I'll mention it's really cool to use kettle whistling in the music. this is cool mixing technique have 2 violins panned hard left and right double tracking the same thing then have 1 cut out and then change. I'll have to try that when recording mark for guitar or something. track 6 I think I recognise this chorus. this is sick. I get why this album is so famous. I prefer the use of strings here than on the last track. the start of the verse section gives ed Sheeran vibes. this chorus slaps tho tbf. I'll definitely be revisiting this album!!! this song is kinda Concorde. I wonder why the next song is so popular. oh that's a cool drum groove. vocals sound cool. track 8 is nice but not anything mad at least on first listen. I need to get new headphones these ones get uncomfortable ridiculously quickly. hell yeah track 9. I love a good hard panned clean tone small electric. the structuring of this song is cool. makes sense. shaped like a series of ramps. was that a key change or a dodgy chord change. mmm . I like the soundscape trach ten. mmm . chune to end it on. I like that technique of simplifying the melody that was big and grandiose into something really small to end it off. as far as the album over all I definitely preferred the first half to the second. the first half blew my mind the second have was really quite good. it lost me a little with neighbourhood 4 kettles, but that was probably just the pace change and from how much I messed with neighbourhood 3 power out. very cool

A bit too orchestral for me but I’d listen to some songs again

This is the sound of 2004 at UVM. Start to finish it's so lovely. Doesn't hit quite as hard as it did back then, the sound has been so redone. But still brings it back.

I've listened to this album since it first came out, but now it doesn't feel as strong as it once did. 3.5/5

An all-time fave.

I was already a fan of this one, but I hadn't heard the whole album in a while. I had thought The Suburbs was my favorite Arcade Fire album, but I think I was mistaken. This one is a near masterpiece.

Meh. Little disappointed. I had higher hopes for some reason. 5/10.

I really dislike this style of indie rock. There were moments where I almost felt like I was having a good time. But overall so bland and same-y.

I've heard this album so many times. The songs are so familiar, and it's interesting listening to this album for the first time in at least 5 years... I still strongly identify with the music, but it's different now. My mindset has changed, and the songs have different meaning to me now. What an album!

Is win butler a weird fucker? Yes. Is this an impressive debut? Also yes.

Reminded me how much I like bass guitar with good headphones. And how much I don’t like distortion on vocals.

A great record... 9/10 Give me something I haven't heard lol.

The good parts were good, while the not so good parts we’re a big miss. Definitely can see how the big melodic pieces leads to their next album.

Well, this is much better than any overplayed Arcade Fire song I've heard on the radio. Genuinely a really good Album with unique sound and ambition. Only got a 4* because it won't get much airplay from me in future, but enjoyed the couple of run throughs so far.

Brings back vibes from my college days at the Dalton Depot.

Started out as a traditional sounding Indie album but the last half was superb. The use of strings added to the great textures of sound.

Arcade Fire, I piss out your candle of hope. Who gave the marching band a synthetic orchestra? This record failed to stick the first time around, and 19 years later it still lacks hook. Lots of soaring, lots of different sounds crammed into the packet, but almost monotone: twee. Too many parentheses in the song titles.

Really liked this when it came out, perhaps because I saw them live many times with various indie luminaries of the age (The National! The Killers! Wolf Parade! Modest Mouse!). It's still pretty good although parts are a bit over-earnest and awkward.

I thought it was well played, but not my cup of tea.

It’s okay, prefer other indie albums during this era. Mostly upbeat and somewhat repetitive

I do enjoy me some Arcade Fire. Wake Up and Rebellion (Lies) are such great tracks.

This slaps. Hell of a debut! Fave tracks - "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" is a fantastic opener. "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" is awesome, and "Wake Up" is great too!

much more exicted about this one!!! was pretty good i do prefer a shorter album it was chill 4/5

they're awesome, hell yeah

Goes into the waily end of the rock-folk-indie-alternative spectrum which does grate on a me a little. This album definitely sounds like the mid 2000's and it does produce some bangers.

Great album

Extra for that song from the Where the Wild Things Are trailer which was better than the actual movie.

This album sounds like the final week of summer break before your first year of college - the time is about 8PM, the sun is setting, you're lying on a hammock in your backyard, thinking about all the fun stuff you did with your friends and how nervous you are about the future. The atmospheric pressure is about 1035.2456 hPa and the ozone level is about 339.19 AQ. You know what I mean. How did they do it? I don't have it in me to rate this anything but a 5/5.

Ágætis plata. Ekki þeirra besta.

so relived you guys didnt like it either. Its well made drawn out, droning bedroom music for a new generation of depressed teens. too harsh?

Out of this universe...... very, very nice :-)

There are some lovely melodies at play here, and the lyrics are clever. But the whole album comes off as somewhat cold and remote.

Absolutely brilliant debut album. Sadly it's also the high point of their career so far. Their second album was very weak, followed by a string of very good to excellent albums. Their most recent is awful - preachy and irritating. Not a good look when you consider the trouble Win Butler has gotten himself into.

Win Butler might be a creep but this is a nearly perfect album

Too me this album is perfection. ⭐️☄️🤍

Not really my kind of music.

indie rock at its indie rockiest. 3/5

FUCK YOU, WIN BUTLER

I feel like I’m half a generation off when I hear this album. I was 26 and heard “Power Out”, probably on MySpace and I loved it. It takes me back to an in between time and space where I was nowhere near being a kid, but also didn’t have a lot of grown up concerns. All the same, it’s not a part of me like the music I was listening to 10 years earlier. Really good songs from start to finish. But when I listen to it, I get this feeling of borrowing someone else’s stuff. Not my own. Another generation’s.

Some of the worst of 2000s indie rock. This is The Lumineers for people who think they are too cool for The Lumineers. Bad art masquerading as good art. Go find something else, really anything else to listen to. You ain’t missing anything here.

Arcade Fire is one of the bands that makes me wish it was still 2004.

What an amazing album. The full experience is brilliant. Saved tracks: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Wake Up, Haiti, Rebellion (Lies)

Pretty good, but it didn't hold my attention very long as outstanding. Probably a personal music taste preference though.

God bless the Millennials.

Good stuff

triste esperanzador y divertido, todo ello bien cohesionado. me ha gustado(4,5/5 ONN). Vibrante, con fuerza y muy musical, me ha gustado mucho. No os perdáis un directo suyo. (5 LNM).

One of my formative albums. Neighborhood songs are all great in their own ways, but Wake Up is my favorite and a top level pantheon song for me. Goosebumps every time.

listened to before: yes!! favorite song (overall): crown of love least favorite song (overall): don't think i can choose one, love them all saddest song: neighborhood #4 (7 kettles) most upbeat: neighborhood #3 (power out) best instrumental: haiti pros: call him pretentious but win butler can write a song about growing up. both funeral and the suburbs make me feel an empty nostalgia. however, listening to this album as i'm getting ready to graduate, and becoming an adult and everything is changing, it hurts a little more. the lyrics and the sounds, after listening again, i think i like this project more than the suburbs. cons: arcade fire is so near and dear to my heart, i cried listening to this, therefore i can't give it any cons. best moment: beginning of neighborhood #1 (1+2 choruses)

Never really understood the appeal of Arcade Fire. This is a wholly unremarkable set of songs until you get to ‘Wake Up’

hey this is pretty good! starts off great but neighbourhood 3 and 4 are kinda unnecessary I feel. Best tracks: neighbourhood 1 (tunnels), crown of love, wake up

One of their finest albums

A great album,. Wake up and Rebellion are 2 of my favorite tracks from this album and period

Goed album. Voor mijn gevoel veel verschillende stijlen en erg origineel. Wel een album wat je vaker moet luisteren om het te gaan waarderen. Hij wordt zeker opgeslagen en krijgt nog een kans.

Prima, beetje op een zeurende stem heeft de zanger.

Mijn vader is fan van Arcade Fire en ik kende wel wat nummers van hen, dus ik was benieuwd naar hoe een heel album klinkt. Wel echt van een onwijs koude kermis thuis gekomen want holy shit wat vond ik dit saai

Klinkt als een voorbode voor wat voor kut muziek er rond 2010-ish allemaal zou komen. Één van de meest opgehypte albums van deze eeuw, en dat is exact de reden dat ik het altijd heb vermeden. Het klinkt als een auto reclame, met veel gezeur tussendoor. En de zanger is een viespeuk.

Truly one the finest debut albums by a Canadian band, Funeral shines on almost every track and continues to be Arcade Fire's greatest achievement. I saw the band during the Funeral tour when it came out and I can't think of a better concert I've seen and the intensity and pure physical energy the band puts fore during their live shows was something to see. I've seen them since and the songs from Funeral are still the highlights of the shows. With Win Butler's recent douchey (toxic) behaviour with some fans, I can't bring myself to give 5 stars, the music and album deserve it, but the band has left me with question marks.

Mostly energetic but fairly samey, didn't connect except for a few songs Favourite track - Wake up.

Probably the closest album so far to my interests

Wanted to love it so badly. The production is simply too much for me and it crowds the very well written lyrics

Definitely worth several more listens.

It was fine. Nothing groundbreaking

I was able to listen to this while reading. I enjoyed.

Great first choice, masterpiece from Arcade Fire (that apparently just got worse after this)

Great album. Well balanced.

Again, can't rate the music high because of the disgusting person in this band.

It is beautiful record though I felt I was in an indie move in 2005. It seems dated and a product of its time still I will probably add it to the collection.

Great album! Wasn't a fan of Arcade Fire before, but I like this kind of indie rock. None of the songs is a clear radio hit, but the whole record maintains a pretty high quality from the start to finish. I'll soon listen to this album again, but it looks like a sure thing to buy a vinyl.

This record is so so good! And what a great experience to listen through the whole album with the lyrics in front. Musically, Arcade Fire is great, but the lyrics is where they truly shine! Key Tracks: Neighbourhood #1 - #4, Crown of Love, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies) 9 out of 10

Meh, wrong album at the wrong time. It is ok though. 2/5

It’s bittersweet. I feel like that’s the best way I could describe it. It’s great.

Probably their best album

I remember buying this when first released a lot of hype about it. Played it lots and then never went back. Not in a massive rush to go back again

Pretty much a modern classic. They arrived as a force of nature. The album hold together well. Its epic in a U2 kinda way, it hit the loud quiet dynamic like the Pixies and it feels emotional. 4.5

Tunnels ok, reszta meh

Never bothered with them before better than expectwd

Liked this a lot, from a time before the hipster crown jumped in and ruined it.

Fun indie pop rock

Probably due to emotional associations back when I listened to it more regularly, still a great album.

Funeral, the debut album from Arcade Fire, is a masterpiece that has stood the test of time. Released in 2004, it was a pivotal album for me during my college years and marked my introduction to the world of indie rock. This album grabs hold of the listener and doesn't let go. The driving drums and soaring violin melodies set the stage for an album full of emotional intensity and musical depth. "Wake Up", one of the album's most well-known tracks, is a rousing anthem that still gets heavy rotation on my playlists to this day. But it's not just the upbeat tracks that make Funeral such a memorable album. "Crown of Love" and "In the Backseat" showcase the band's ability to craft intimate, introspective ballads that are just as powerful as their more energetic tracks. And "Rebellion (Lies)", with its relentless energy and catchy chorus, is an anthem for anyone who has ever felt frustrated with the world. All in all, Funeral is an album that has had a lasting impact on me. It introduced me to the world of indie rock and pulled me deeper into that scene. It's an album that I still return to time and time again, and it's one that I highly recommend to anyone who loves passionate, emotionally charged music.

Exceeded expectations!

5. Top notch

Couple bangers, in general a v good rock album

Not 1st listen. Probably one of my favourite albums from the 2000s, the opening track still gets to me 10 yrs after the 1st time I heard it (didn’t know it when it was new). HL: “Tunnels”, “Wake Up”, “7 Kettles”, “Crown of Love”, “Rebellion”, “In the Backseat” Dec 10 2022

My lord is this overhyped. I remember rolling my eyes at the hipsters slurping this band. Honestly, some of it isn't too bad, but plenty of it is. That opening song in particular is just bleh.

I didn't enjoy this but I can see why some people do

Wow - this was disappointing. I really like later Arcade Fire and honestly didn't realize I don't like the songs on this album.

Pretty good! I definitely enjoyed The Suburbs on first listen quite a bit more, but this isn’t bad still. Biggest complaint is that the vocals are so hard to hear behind all the instrumentation. 7/10

I personally like Arcade Fire, and I think they have a great sound, but going through this entire album, I have to admit that the themes don't feel super established in a lot of tracks, and the vocals do leave a bit to be desired.

They were obviously inspired by Neutral Milk Hotel. But this music doesn't have the same intensity; it feels a bit watered down, and its enormous influence on 2000s indie music is somewhat of a tragedy. Still, there are some great moments, most notably "In the Backseat."

A landmark album for the indie rock genre in the 2000s. Arcade Fire's best work.

Super good neighborhood album

Great album. I’ve owned it for a long time although I rarely listen to it. “Haiti” would find itself on a list of my favourite songs ever.

Pretty good

This is an easy 5 for me. Not a bad song on this one, packed with full sound and great energy. It’s just such a well crafted album and they do such a great job building a song towards that burst. I’ll never stop returning to this one. 5 stars

A beaitiful landmark in 2000s indie rock, full of rich lush instrumentations, plenty of strings and horns that fill the space and bring out the power of the songs. The lyrics are optimistic, and both vocalists are expressive, with the ethereal back vocals supporting the mood and complexity of each song. The songs are cohesive yet independently complete. Each song has its hook that stands it apart, each one as memorable as last. Not a single bad track, they were all memorable in some way and bought time between my favorites. It's incredible how over half the album could compete for not just the lead single, but for the claim to one of the best songs of the decade. I was a bit disappointed with Neon Bible, but that only brings out how special and genius this record is.

i really enjoyed the album, never heard it before until today and it did not disappoint very wonderful

I know some songs from Arcade Fire, but this was my first time listening to their debut as a whole. It's a great work, musically and lyrically. I don't have any bad comments about what I've listened to now! It was delightful to (re)discover a band that was just "a standard indie rock band" until today.

Interesting composition and quality recording/mixing. In The Backseat is a an excellent composition, with a slow build and strings that set it apart from other tracks. Vocals are emotionally charged. This album on the whole is very listenable, but heavier in lyrics than I expected.

That's perfect. Another Arcade Fire album, right as my life turns around. Fuck. 5

Not quite 5 but very close.

Too folksy for my taste and I find Regine’s vocal to be super annoying.