The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady by Charles Mingus

The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady

Charles Mingus

3.33
Rating
29180
Votes
1
7%
2
17%
3
30%
4
27%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 10 of 14)

Opening track is amazing. So intriguing immediately, makes me feel like i'm in a dream fantasy world. I love the sound of this record, the trumpet is incredible. Such an incredible album. Maybe one of the best pieces of music I've ever heard. 5

Very 60s jazz. Felt like I was hearing the soundtrack to a mid-budget spy movie. 2/5

Even for Jazz, I didn't like it too much. And I like Jazz! Closer to a 3

Day 3 - June 4th, 2024 Anyone got a pack of reds? 4.5/5

I'm not well versed in jazz, so it's gonna take a few more listens for me to feel solid in my rating. But on first listen I really enjoyed this.

Sounds like the type of jazz going on in a 70s detective shows, with the lead narrating over the music about the crime they are getting ready to solve.

This type and era of jazz is right in the sweet spot for me. I hadn't heard this before, but I really enjoyed it. They just don't make em like this anymore, sadly...

An all-time jazz classic for a reason. 5.0/5.0: Iconic

1. zolo dancer - 1.5 2. track b - 1.5 3. track c - 1.5 4. mode d - 2

An all-time great, the best Jazz composition ever made. Mad genius front to back, and track D is monumental. Top 5 albums ever made handily, and this site's score feels a little racist, ngl.

Creo que iba tocando una nota sin tener en cuenta la nota anterior.

This was fine, but nothing extraordinary in terms of defining Jazz as an art form. Part of the album reminded me of the Taxi Driver score. The last track goes on forever.

This wasn't too bad. Kinda liked it as background music.

I’m familiar and a big fan of Mingus Ah Um, which should be on this list! But first time listening to this album, this is different a bit more experimental Jazz, but I still enjoyed it, personally I prefer bebop jazz, to the experimental side of it. But this one had a nice mix of the two, added to my rotation.

Quite the journey. LOVED the start but it dissolves into a bit too much randomness I think. Still a really interesting listen.

Mingus is great, but this album doesn't hit me right. As much as I wanted to like this, I didn’t.

I listened but not enough but enough where I know I’m just not a jazz guy. I’m sure it’s decent for a jazz album.

Chaotic. At times dissonant, at times lyrical, but always interesting.

Absolutely loved the last song, the rest I enjoyed but I would prefer a bit slower of pace. Maybe jazz is to much stress for me. Had a hard time deciding between 3 and 4

Jazz escapes me…

I really tried to listen and immerse myself but just still not appreciating the genre. I did appreciate this one and connect a little more than others before

I appreciate this as some good jazz music but jazz is something I only listen to on occasion. Have to me in the right mood I guess. But next time I'm feeling like some jazz maybe I'll explore more of Charels Mingus' work.

One of my favorite quips from reading Charles Mingus’ biography was the story of how he would stop a show if people were talking or clinking glasses, and if they didn’t cease the noise, he would pick up the mic stand and throw it violently into the audience demanding silence. A bit too far? Yes, but they sure shut the hell up after that. He was there to put on a show and felt it was highly disrespectful to interrupt it by not paying attention. That energy absolutely makes its way into his avant-garde jazz. Charles plays an aggressive bass on 4 very well constructed ballet movements that feel graceful and violent at the same time. This is top notch jazz for anyone who doesn’t know the genre well and is looking for a more unconventional place to begin exploring beyond the well worn standards.

This was certainly lively! Lots going on. Appreciate the talent and the emotional chaos of this, but jazz has yet to find a special place in my heart. I could see this being a favorite of jazz fans though.

just was not feeling this. sorry charles

Beautiful, dark. Kind of haunting?

I may have to listen to this again. I really like Mingus, but felt that this was too far out there. Though there were parts that I really liked. Did not think it was the masterpiece that everyone else does. 3 stars for now.

That's not my taste in musik.

Big band isn’t my favourite style of Jazz, but the way Mingus subverts the genre on this record to create an atmospheric and nightmarish soundscape, with interpolations of blues and flamenco, is astonishing.

Didnt really enjoy it. Maybe not in the right mood.

I’m not sure if I understand this. A lot of noise. Some pleasing parts.

BL: listened to this album once before due to it being heavily lauded by 21st century jazz heads on the web. Me being one of them myself was interested to sample the wares. I remember not thinking much of this, though I was around 15 or 16 at the time and hadn’t developed the taste for jazz that I have now. So I will see how it holds up on the relisten AL: this was a very good album. While to me it pails to something like Headhunters by Hancock this stands out as an amazing piece of song cycle jazz and I’m very glad to have heard it. I think it’ll take multiple listens to fully dissect everything going on here, but I’m sure I will be coming back to it. FT: “Track C - Group Dancers” 5/5

Full of dissonance. Difficult to comprehend.

Jazzy and lots of sax initially, but more than that. Very interesting piano on Track C. Then it becomes a Latin sounding fusion piece. Super cool. There's some great parts in the last two pieces too. Really a mix of genres (often alternating instruments and styles in the same track) but often melodic. Not really my thing; maybe it should be.

Album 412 of 1001 Charles Mingus - The Black Saint And The Sinner Lady Rating : 5 / 5 Not top rated in the sense of a competition with something like Automatic for the People or Dark Side of the Moon...but top rated because it is one of the best jazz albums I've heard. I'm no aficionado, but I know what I like.

Favorite Track: Track C-Group Dancers

This album was incredible. I can get why they call it one of the best jazz records of made. Mingus killed it with this one.

Fantastically chaotic

Elegant in its chaos. I’d enjoy seeing this performed as a ballet like Mingus originally wrote it.

You want tripped out jazz?! You got tripped out jazz mother fucker! Mingus might be at the height of his career on this record, bringing in Spanish influences, African rhythms, and complex time signatures that keep you glued to what you're hearing.

I believe jazz to be intrinsically romantic and cinematic, and this album is a grand, sweeping sonic narrative—a heart-swelling, emotionally epic journey that encapsulates the seductive and transporting powers inherent to the genre.

4 Tracks of very upbeat, high tempo Jazz. Gonna go on a limb and say that the other tracks aren't cleared for Spotify, but from what I heard, this deff leaves me wanting more. Update: apparently it's just 4 tracks?!? Added them all, would love this in LP form!

What better record than this one

Would give this 0 stars if I could. Just noise. I cannot understand why people would like this.

Enjoyable (particularly the second and third tracks) , but I don't know enough about jazz to fully appreciate it

I don’t have any frame of reference with jazz music to know how it fits into the bigger picture. Easy to listen or work to but nothing Id put back on if I had a choice. Rating: 3.1

A nice easy Listening instrumental

This is the worst kind of jazz for me. No beginning, no middle and seemingly no end. It just meanders on like they are warming up their instruments before the show begins. But the show never did begin.

That's some proper jazzing by Mingus right here. I can only hope there is more stuff like this on this list.

Unfortunately just not my thing, although I will say (unlike other music from this genre) I did genuinely notice that the songs were different. So yeah I guess it was one of the better instrumental albums, but still just not for me.

It was ok. 2.5/5

Charles Mingus's "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" is a groundbreaking masterpiece that transcends the boundaries of jazz, merging various styles and influences into a cohesive and innovative work of art. Released in 1963, this album remains a pinnacle of Mingus's career, showcasing his unparalleled talent as a composer, bandleader, and bassist. In this review, I'll delve into the album's lyrics, music, production, themes, and influence, while also highlighting its pros and cons. **Lyrics:** Unlike many jazz albums, "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" doesn't feature traditional lyrics. Instead, Mingus utilizes the language of music to convey his narrative. Each movement tells a story, rich in emotion and imagery. From the fiery passion of "Track A – Solo Dancer" to the melancholic introspection of "Track E – Group Dancers," Mingus's compositions evoke a range of feelings without the need for words. This allows listeners to interpret the music in their own unique way, deepening their connection to the album. **Music:** Mingus's music is complex and multifaceted, blending elements of jazz, classical, and avant-garde into a rich tapestry of sound. His compositions are densely layered, with intricate arrangements that demand attention to detail. The album features a large ensemble, including brass, woodwinds, and strings, allowing Mingus to explore a wide range of textures and timbres. From the chaotic cacophony of "Track B – Duet Solo Dancers" to the haunting beauty of "Track C – Group Dancers," Mingus demonstrates his mastery of musical expression, captivating listeners with his dynamic performances. **Production:** Produced by Bob Thiele, "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" is a testament to Mingus's meticulous attention to detail. Thiele's production captures the raw energy and intensity of Mingus's performances, while also highlighting the subtleties of his compositions. The album's sound quality is exceptional, with each instrument given its own space to shine. Thiele's skillful mixing and mastering ensure that every nuance of Mingus's music is preserved, allowing listeners to fully immerse themselves in the experience. **Themes:** Thematically, "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" explores the duality of human nature, as represented by the titular characters. Mingus uses his music to delve into the complexities of good and evil, love and hate, redemption and damnation. Each movement tells a different facet of this overarching narrative, weaving together themes of passion, longing, and despair. Mingus's compositions are deeply introspective, inviting listeners to reflect on their own inner struggles and contradictions. **Influence:** "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" has had a profound influence on the world of jazz and beyond. Mingus's innovative approach to composition has inspired countless musicians, from jazz legends like John Coltrane and Miles Davis to contemporary artists like Kamasi Washington and Esperanza Spalding. The album's fusion of genres and styles has paved the way for future generations of musicians to explore new creative territories. Its enduring legacy continues to resonate with audiences around the world, cementing its status as a timeless classic. **Pros:** 1. **Innovative Composition:** Mingus's compositions push the boundaries of jazz, incorporating elements of classical and avant-garde music to create a truly unique sound. 2. **Emotional Depth:** The album's richly textured music conveys a wide range of emotions, from joy and passion to sorrow and despair, resonating deeply with listeners. 3. **Technical Mastery:** Mingus's virtuosic performances and the exceptional skill of his ensemble demonstrate a high level of technical proficiency and musical expertise. 4. **Influence:** "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" has had a lasting impact on the world of jazz and contemporary music, inspiring generations of musicians with its groundbreaking approach. **Cons:** 1. **Complexity:** Mingus's music can be challenging for some listeners, particularly those who are not familiar with jazz or avant-garde music. 2. **Length:** With six extended movements, the album may be daunting for listeners accustomed to shorter, more concise musical compositions. 3. **Intense Themes:** The album's exploration of dark and existential themes may not be suitable for all listeners, particularly those seeking more lighthearted or uplifting music. In conclusion, "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" is a timeless masterpiece that continues to captivate and inspire listeners more than five decades after its release. Mingus's innovative compositions, emotive performances, and profound thematic depth make this album a landmark achievement in the history of jazz music. While its complexity and intense themes may not be to everyone's taste, for those willing to delve into its depths, "The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady" offers a truly transcendent musical experience.

Not a jazz fan

I'm not usually into recorded jazz, but this was great!

A really interesting album - more of an auditory experience than anything. Lots that I didn’t really understand but still enjoyed - my favorite parts were the piano solos and the flamenco guitar sections. I also loved when they played with rhythm and seemed to have two different meters in different sections. I don’t know if I’d listen again, but I thought it was really cool and they were all clearly masters of their crafts and a tight ensemble!

I loved the first side of the album, but wasn't so excited about the second side.

WOW. I probably would need 10+ listens to even approach appreciating this correctly, but even with my 2 I was pretty in love. The instrumentation is great and the piano work is also great!

Really good overall and definitely unique listening experience, but not really my thing to go back and listen to

As a jazz musician myself, it feels a little traitorous to give this such a low rating. But really, Mingus could have done so much more to make this more accessible to a wider audience. The organised chaos of avant-garde jazz is just a little much even for me to handle, and it brings a consistently crazed, dizzying mood to the table that makes it harder to engage with that it should be. Still, the music is dark, energetic, and filled with humour and little winks to jazz contemporaries and predecessors. There's definitely some Davis and Ellington influence with the rapid, wavery trumpet and sax lines. Interesting mutes on those wind instruments during some parts, though it could just as easily be the musicians trying to play as weirdly as possible. The wah-wah, almost kazoo-like sax timbre in Duete Solo Dancers was the clearest example of this. I also liked the wild, interweaving melodic lines on, like, 7 different instruments at once. This happened very often in the track Group Dancers. Cool mood transitions in this track, too. And, obviously, fantastic, dynamic bass playing. I'm not a fan of extended jazz tracks on albums. They're much more forgivable when recorded live, but of course this is a studio album. The 19-minute album closer is, by its own admission, a medley – and in fact the song includes several near-silent intermissions. Break them apart, Charles! 2/5 Key tracks: Duete Solo Dancers (track 2/4), Group Dancers (track 3/4)

Good album; sounds like something from a movie soundtrack. I like how they mix a bit of classical into the jazz.

I usually don't like experimental jazz but this was compelling for some reason that I can't articulate. I think that's the point of experimental jazz, so I have to give it props.

Beautiful, vibrant.

cool mixed bag solo dancer single solos and group dance group and solo dance

It's jazz and to make things worse it's avant-garde jazz, which means it sounds like a collection of random noises played by "musicians" who were in different locations at different times.

I dig this jazz. Was not expecting jazz when reading the artist's name. Thought it was some psychedelic solo 70s artist.

Adventurous and unsettling, definitely not for everyone. Interesting blend of loveliness and chaos. Fave Song: Track C – Group Dancers

High Quality Jazz! I had never heard of Charles Mingus before. It was a beautiful surprise! I liked!

A bit of cacophony, a little too much happening for me

Great album all of the songs were great and the sax goes so hard. No complaints here.

There are a couple of Jazz albums in here I'm looking forward to but this wasn't one of them. It would have been, if I had heard it before. Which I *think* I had not. Magnificent. Not easily digestible at times - Wikipedia taught me the term "Third Stream" - but it's all good every time Dannie Richmond starts drumming again. Been playing this all day.

It's... jazzy .. I hate jazz. This isn't even good enough for me to recommend to people who like jazz.

Don't have much to say. Some alright music but not very remarkable. 2/5

Some cool moments but I found it much too anxiety inducing.

I’m just not into jazz, no matter how much this challenge will try to make me be into it. Just not my thing

It is decent background music, but it is no Miles Davis.

Trumpet both good and bad

I would really like to give this a 3.5 but I can't so imma give it a 3 because I didn't love the chaos. I really liked the piano and trombone but I felt that it felt kinda scattered and spastic in places and I didn't love that. The trumpet was cool at first but I kinda got over it after the first little bit. Other than those two things it was pretty groovy.

solo instrumentals were nice, but when they all played together it often felt jumbled. too many discordant notes. enjoyed the flamenco guitar featured in one piece. last track went on entirely too long.

Very interesting Jazz, fun instrumentation and interesting techniques and sounds. Pretty good!

Krasse Musiker, aber das ist die Art von Jazz, die mir zu verspielt ist.

I found myself not really liking jazzy albums that much any more, whereas this was grand. Could have done without that last medley, though.

Hmmm— some really interesting moments here but nothing really stuck with me. I understand and appreciate its importance, but can’t seem to find a reason to listen to this one again.

Jazz is not my listening pleasure but I can appreciate the originality of the album.

This is what by brain feels like on a bad day, so it sucks that I enjoyed it so much.

Chaotic jazz.....1.5

Good high energy jazz. The last song is to long for me. But overall great energy.

I'm no jazz expert so if there's going to be a wrong opinion here then this is it. This sounds like the backing music to a 1940s cartoon where half of the characters are smoking oversized cigars for no apparent reason.

Really enjoyed the jazz on this album

Not for me. Too experimental. Too hectic. Too much jazz 😉

I enjoyed this better than that John Zorn album but that's really not saying much. This type of jazz is not for me.

This might be my favourite album I hadn't heard before so far

5 / 10 Jazz. Siempre me parece que hacen un trabajo de 10, pero que no es lo mío.

When it’s just a solo instrument it’s ok, then when they all play together it’s utterly horrific!!

I haven't given jazz much of a chance before. I still can't say it's for me, but felt like I could start to get why it's enjoyed.

Im so 🤷‍♀️ about this. its fine. lost me at points. not something i would relisten to.

Not giving it a one bc the last track kind of reminded me of Matilda the musical at parts which gickelt my ummy bone.

This just didnt work for me

Jazz just rubs me the wrong way. I don't know why, I have never been able to formulate a rational reason it just does. This was no exception.

One of my favorite musicians of all time

great slow burn jazz blues album 4/5

Gear: Grado Hemp Album-Art: coole Sau im Zentrum Mix: über jeden Zweifel erhaben - da passt einfach alles Musik: Faszinierend. In Fachkreisen wird das hier anscheinend "guter Jazz" genannt. Mehr geniale Rhythmus-Einfälle - weniger selbstverliebtes Solo-Gedudel. 👌 Wertung: 🚬🚬🚬(🚬)/5

This hurt my brain

Wow, this is much better than I thought. This album is entirely instrumental jazz. I never got bored while listening. It might be because I really like jazz. I've never heard of Mingus before Friday. 4 stars from me.

That's one incredible musical achievement by Mingus. A love at first listening to me. The creativity and flow of this piece never stops amazing me, and I always find new details every time I come back. A must for each music enthusiast.

Interesting. A good album.

This was an interesting listen and I would listen again. I liked how the music seemed to be telling a story, with conversations going on. It was interesting to read afterwards that this was written partially as a ballet. I liked it more than I thought I would.

Clearly talented. I'd give it 2.5 if I could.

good, but forgetable

damn [Comments after the initial listen. This was all I could articulate in the moment. This was pretty great. All I can probably do now for this 1001 album challenge]

I have now acquired a taste for freeform jazz.

Seeing this album labelled as avant-garde jazz on Wikipedia made me expect worse. I mean, I see that descriptor and I'm expecting... Like, noise, honestly. Atonal and with everyone playing in a different weird time signature, but I'm supposed to appreciate it because, I'unno, it's hard to play a trumpet in 30/31. However, it turns out I really can't hear what's so avant-garde about it. At most it sounds like the jazz Frank Zappa would have The Mothers play—and that's a big compliment in my book. The same one I gave THIRD by Soft Machine, actually. (Though give this album the benefit, only one song approaches 20 minutes, and even then it's because it's comprised of three smaller movements). I'unno, I just really dug it. It's one I'd throw on whenever I'm in the mood for something like it, sure. Sometimes I need a little THE GRAND WAZOO, y'know? And this isn't even the album by this guy that got on the Rolling Stone 500? Gosh, you can only imagine how good **that one** is.

Good. Ass. Jazz. Nothing much else to say.

This album makes that Bill Evans album look like a fucking preschool recital, holy shit. What an instant 5. The layering on every instrumental is perfectly done, the mixing is fabulous, and the avant garde composition of the piano, the brass, and the percussion — good lord, the percussion — is a masterclass in jazz. For 1963, this is experimental as hell, but it’s aged beautifully well. The quickest 40 minutes of an album experience I think I’ve had so far, but in a really pleasing way that had me encapsulated the entire time. I’m really deeply impressed by how much this sort of touched me, and I’m glad I listened to it. Fantastic album, easy 5.

pretty good jazzy album I liked the licks that kept coming back YYN

Sounds like a smoky room

I’m no jazz expert, but enjoyed this a lot.

A challenging listen which I don't think is just a jazz album. With the dissonance and odd rhythm choices, I'm reminded of Stravinsky's 'The Rite of Spring'. The big band approach is taken and turned on its head with the instruments seemingly communicating with each other, depicting different voices and personalities and coming to a cacophony by the close.

Jazz! Parece música de filme de sábado a noite.

Amazing jazz album, so well composed and performed, keeping you engaged the entire time, love how progressive the sound can get, you don't know where it's gonna take you

I desperately long for the day when Jazz "lovers" pull the 20 inch dildo of pretention out of their asses and admit that their beloved genre is actually just steaming shit most of the time. There's about a good minute and a half per song, then 5+ minutes of crap. How this has a 3.3 is beyond me, it didn't offend me quite enough to drop it to a 1, but it was just straight up not good.

Heel moeilijk album om te reviewen. Dit is echt experimentele jazz, en maakt ook dat het echt lastig is om hier naar te luisteren. Er zijn stukken die geniaal zijn en stukken die ik nooit meer wil horen, ik heb geen favoriete nummers hier, omdat deze stukken telkens in hetzelfde nummer zitten en elk nummer complete chaos is en absolute stilte. Wat een reis was dit album zeg, ik moet ff bijkomen.

The type of jazz I like with just a bit of cacophony perfectly thrown in

En etsiskellyt enkä paöjoa löytänyt samanlaista soitantaa 4 biisiä albumiksi läppästy.. Missään vaiheessa en toki unimpressed... Masters for 1963 year..

I don't listen to a lot of Jazz. Maybe Big Band Jazz (Sintra and such), but this style is foreign to me. This was good music that created an atmosphere. I can see myself enjoying this album again. Sounded like it could be a soundtrack or a movie score. This album generator finally has done what I was hoping it would do, turn my ears on to music that for whatever reason has passed me by.

Amazing melodies

A true masterpiece. Top-notch composition and performances. 5/5

Ich bin sicher CM ist ein ganz Großer im Jazz - für mich aber zu Free Jazzig. Konnte ich leider nicht zu Ende hören.

Not my steeze. 2/5

This might be the first jazz album of this era that I’ve enjoyed! Maybe I’m ready for jazz now, maybe this just rocks. I’m going to try more. Jazz has always been there my whole life. Movies, films, holiday soundtracks. So I’ve never really grabbed on. This album grabbed me. I love the mood it sets, the journey it takes you on, and the international feel some of the tunes have. Chaotic, cacophonous, energetic and inspiring!

After countless listens, this album never seizes to amaze me. The way the seemingly chaotic and disparate parts weave in an out of the melody, while always remaining in precisely the right place, no instrument is ever lacking, no instrument is ever overbearing. The whole thing is a perfect cacophony of seamlessly arranged unpredictability, complete with an immaculately timed flamenco interjection. To say I adore this album would be a gross understatement. Inject these sounds into my veins. When I die, I hope they take my ashes, mix them with vinyl and press them into a copy of this album. The entirety of the human experience can be summed up in these short 39 minutes. If the world were to end tomorrow, I hope somewhere there is a concrete bunker with a copy of this album and a record player to play it, so that future interstellar explorers may stumble upon the remains of our civilization, and know that once, a species lived here, that was capable of great art.

Amazing, fast paced, funky jazz. I listened on my way to work running late driving in the rain and it kind of fit the vide perfectly. It's like was anxiety sounds like lol. Really enjoyed.

the red drives me insane, im glad its always there. the option to show my insides, hope no one stares. it stings, it hurts, i love not to care. alone, sitting atop my back broken chair. in my own lair, im a prisoner. im a lioness, so mystical. when i set sail, through the cyclical. and my mind flails, egotistical. mingus the goat, more like the feds

I’m no jazz connoisseur, but I can tell this is very good. Just how good a jazz album is I think becomes a little subjective once you get past the virtuosity of the performers and the craftsmanship of the composition. Both of those are clearly top notch on this album. So then I ask myself, what does this album make me feel? Sexy chaos.

Trube, jazz, OK, ali nije za bilo kad

Advent-grad jazz king. Edgy, but great jazz artist, and composer. His music to this day is one of a kind. Great album.

One of the all time greatest albums.

I love jazz so much.

I was pleased with the flamenco bits.

I prefer my jazz either groovy or moody. This is neither. It’s a grand chaos, but rather unwelcoming. As if one stopped by a derailed party completely sober. Stay a bit and let the chaos seep into you, or follow your urge to move on.

There might be more consequential figures in the history of jazz - no one is shoving Miles, Trane, Monk, Billie, Duke, Ella or Louis off the 7-headed Mount Rushmore. There might be more popular jazz musicians - Brubeck, Herbie, Getz. But I'm not sure there is a better, more versatile jazzman than Charlie Mingus, whose bass playing is so good he was sought after by almost everyone I've already named, and who was so gifted he proved to be an excellent pianist as well. The Black Saint and The Sinner Lady is a towering achievement. A 40 minute ballet, with liner notes from his therapist, composed for eleven players (an undectet?), you could listen to it every day for a year and find something new to appreciate each time. Of particular note is the classical guitar of Jay Berliner, who would go on to play on Van Morrison's Astral Weeks, an equally towering work. But I digress: Mingus is king.

Big band jazz that covers all sorts of ground, including folk music, classical elements, and jazz solos. Never lulls or drifts into wankery. Radiohea'ds National Anthem horn section sounds inspired by the final track.

lil too much going on for my tastes

For Jazz - not a favorite gene of mine - this is really good. There are times that this album can be addicting. 4/5

Good album, not my kind of music

Weird and cool

Jazz is definitely a music style that isn't supposed to be paused and returned to mid song. I did that a few times with this album as I made my way through it which made me re-start a few songs. When listened from start to finish the album is absolutely slapping with funky jazz. Easy to listen to and great music to do something to.

Wasn't convinced at the start, but as the album progressed I became slightly hypnotized by it. I really enjoyed the final track with it's softer parts and it's rises and peaks. The band really knows how to express scenes and feelings wordlessly to paint a picture.

This is HARD jazz, in a good way. Shits so personal feels like their instruments are describing a divorce or something. 4.0

I'm not saying it's bad by any means, I can appreciate the jazz. This album feels more like a fever dream than an album I would choose to listen to more than once

Sorry, this is just not my cup of tea. It makes me very nervous.

WOW! Great Suggestion!

3 stars because I'm not sure how to rate this (I don't listen to jazz)

Musically sound. Not my style but would be his background music

Jazz altijd 4 sterren.

These cats were definitely cooking but god damn did they burn the food. Last two songs of the album were better than the first, though. Rough start, okay finish.

This music just gives me anxiety for some reason. Very talented musicians, but the sound is so frantic that I don't like it much.

The musical achievement on this record is difficult to fathom. Mingus heard this in his head. And it was recorded in ONE DAY.

- I am by no means a jazz aficionado, but I at least know that 1) Charles Mingus was incredibly influential in the jazz world and 2) that this jazz is not in any way generic or boring. - I did like the second half (tracks C and D) more. There were more unusual moments sprinkled throughout these that caused me to perk up.

I do love brass...

Short album. Definitely need to be in the mood for it, but I liked it. Sounded kinda familiar.

Very good

I'm not cultured enough to rate this high

4 songs, 39 min 25 sec.

This isn't a single composition. It's certainly jazzy. Music that begs for you to be doing something else instead of paying attention to jazz. Although I suppose that some people will enjoy it. I appreciate that he's got more musical ability in his left pinky than I have in my entire body, it's just not my style. It's like how some people like coffee and appreciate it while others don't.

Definitely a challenging listen. There are parts where it is focused on a few instruments, or a fragile balance across instruments, but each of these four tracks finds their moments to choose a cacophonous frenzied drunken animals on instruments approach. It seems to devolve to a play whatever you want as long as it is loud and fast. This did not help me on my journey to better understand jazz.

If you liked the Black Saint part wait until you get to the Sinner Lady part. Fire energy. Really cool melodies across the whole ensemble.

only 40 minutes. Good Jazz jams. Some recognisable tunes

Too chaotic for me. It was not an enjoyable listen for me and I do not think it is a relevant record, so it's under the bar compared to the rest of albums in this experience.

Està bé, però el jazz em costa molt. M'agrada l'estil que té com allargant les notes, com si s'arrosseguessin per terra amb mandra. A part d'això, no puc dir molt més perquè no en sé. Vale, no m'esperava la guitarra allà enmig, m'ha sorprès positivament. Expected Lorenzo Rating: 4

Sounds exactly like the music you'd expect from someone named Mingus. Make of that what you want.

One of the best jazz albums I’ve ever heard, end of story. This was great!

Not sure

Nice of them to include the soundtrack from Ed, Edd & Eddy on this project. Not my preferred jazz style to listen to. 6/10

This is the rainy days jazz that I love. He did some things with that trumpet I have never heard before. 9/10

I normally don't listen to jazz voluntarily. This was okay. It didn't annoy me and I was able to code to it fairly well. It wasn't jarring or distracting. I will try to give this album a few more listens to see how it grows on me.

Not for meeeee

This must be what other people experience when they hear heavy metal and say "it's just noise". I gave it a go but honestly it was like listening to Jez try and play the saxophone for half an hour. Not for me.

I don’t listen to / know much about jazz but this was a very nice listen.

I gave it a good go, sadly Jazz, much like mushrooms, is just not for me

Genuinely one of the greatest album that I’ve heard EVER

Spanish guitar! Then a well-deserved five star.

Pretty cool and unique jazz album and I don't think I'll hear something like that for a while

I find full instrumental albums pretty hit and miss. This was mid imo

Definitely dig this... It’s so cool and expressive. Inventive. At least a 4.5.

Really cool theme for the album. The "dance" variations provided a listening anchor for me to ground myself in. It gets hectic for C and D, definitely not just a "throw on" album. This one takes some concentration. Mingus is the man. Need some more exposure for sure. Does being behind the bass give a deeper perspective and feeling? Maybe

I like some jazz albums, but this one was not it for me Top tracks: None

Meni yllättävän meluksi välillä, mutta pysyi sentään kasassa. Kiva rakenne levyllä, selkeät ”teokset” (ennemmin kuin biisit). Sekin toi järjestystä paikoin näennäiseen kaaokseen joka ei ole kaaos. Taitavaa, ja torvisoittimista pidän yleisesti. Ei vaikeaa kuunnella, mutta ei suosikkiasiani kuitenkaan. Kakkonen tuntuu silti vähättelyltä.

Melkein kiinnostavaa siinä määrin kuin bluesia. 1+

This was sublime. Such a contrast to the two country albums I was served (Steve Earle and some hick). Love the elongated tracks. In 2024, this is an amazing contrast. Anyone reading thins should listen to BSatSL on repeat.

The wild energy of the music propelling the dancers across the stage in my mind, bounding between chaotic and serene, my only complaint is that it was over too soon. Beautiful.

A well-made jazz album with a good feel. Not too bad Mr. Mingus!

Very much jazz

Not well suited for analytical computer work.

More traditional jazz, very intricate instrument work but more difficult to get into a flow with it, enjoyed it in parts, especially the blues-y ending to Group dancers

Fuck you you fucking fucker, its Jazzzzzzz

Yikes. While I enjoyed the movie “Whiplash”, generally speaking full-on Jazz is just not my bag. I would choose to chill with some SD 10/10 times over this. .5/5 rounding up.

Deserves more of an in depth listen

Can't even scrub through this. 1001 albums to never listen to.

Sometimes I read the global reviews and just shake my head. This is one of those times. This album gets dubbed “avant garde” but in my opinion it’s highly accessible. Written as a ballet piece, the movements make sense throughout the tracks. There’s a nice blend of bop, orchestral and flamenco music. Not sure why I’ve never listened through a Mingus record before but this is worth every minute.

As much as I enjoy Mingus, this one's difficult for me to access. Maybe if I listened several more times?

I did not enjoy this as much as Miles Davis stuff.

It's the genre, not the ablum

First listen-through was highkey one of the worst musical experiences of my life. It felt like one of those sections of a rock song where everyone just plays whatever they want to make it sound chaotic on purpose, but for 39 minutes straight and with more trombone. The second listen-through made me rethink my entire life experience because it wasn’t even close to as bad. How could I hear it so fundamentally differently after just one day? I do think that there’s still something I’m missing about this album though, because I was still very glad it was over after the second time through.

Day boi Mingus

I’m a simple man. I see the boi mingus, i’m happy.

Track A - a lot of fun Track B - somewhat less fun Track C - mental Mode D, E, F - not sure what is going on

Not sure what good jazz sounds like, I guess this is good.

3/10 Chaos, but not completely. My ears don't work right for this 2-27-2024

Not my cup of tea but a worthwhile listen

Fiati in primo piano e un'atmosfera che mi fa immaginare le grandi città americane nel dopoguerra. Il basso non risulta il principale protagonista, probabilmente perché questo album meriterebbe ascolti con impianti di qualità migliore rispetto allo streaming. Ottima musica, ma non fruibile in ogni momento del giorno, se comparata ad altri standard di questo genere musicale.

Just brilliant.

I liked the blues sound combination of piano and sax.

Sehr experimentell.

extemporaneous jazz always a hard hitter.

Ok Mingus baseline fun times. Brought me back to my jazz band days

Some pretty decent jazz that liked to add these weird, sinister, off-key sections that didn't always flow super well. Points for originality and overall brevity, but not my first choice when it comes to jazz.

Amazing, don't know much of Jazz, but this got me hooked. Especially track C

I'm not the biggest jazz noodling fan but this album was pretty good. Could see sticking this on if I was in the right mood.

This is one I have on vinyl

Fuck this is getting bad

This was fun

Really moving and weird jazz, I've never heard anything like this before.

Not my kind of music but I admire how the artist can make you feel like you are being pulled in opposite directions. It’s disorienting to listen to. But kinda cool

It pretty out there. I liked it

Oh yeah Charles Mingus. Wonderful. Yesterday was a perfect day for jazz too🤘🔥 pouring rain, slick city streets, nobody could find their lane, it was madness🙄😂😂 just a slow roll home after work with Mingus cranked on the car stereo. Lovin it

Stökjazz. Rätt jobbigt.

Wanted to like it more than I did. Too eclectic and seemingly random for me.

Feels like noise for most of it. Nice noise I guess

awesome jazz

cool but not for me

Not something I'm likely to actively listen to, but it was fine in the background.

Didn't care for this style of jazz

Género particular el jazz. Siempre lo conecté con la noche, para una reunión de dos, íntima. De estarse conociendo con alguien. Siento a éste disco más experimental e individual. Caótico, en partes. Más para acompañar un estado alterado por sustancias.

Not for me 2/5

Clearly these are some talented musicians, but I just can't into the music they actually play.

I loved how this incorporated Jazz with elements of traditional Asian instruments.

Love the experimentation on this. It’s also nice to hear jazz that doesn’t overstay it’s welcome.

Good background music

Definitely a headphones kind of listen, I definitely got more out of this than if I had left it on in the background as I worked. This is the type of dissonant, experimental, hep cat/beatnik kind of jazz that I'm less inclined towards but as far as that style goes I did find myself enjoying this album more than others. Also points for being brief, when i saw this was four tracks I was worried they'd each be 15 minutes or more, but the first three were all reasonably brief.

Maybe great, but nothing I am able to listen

I personally hate the posturing and posing that goes into loads of jazz. The directionlessness of the songs. The noodling in a twelve bar for 9 minutes. The prevailing sense of snootiness. However, this record shows everything I love about the genre. Every song has intense use of dynamics and structure. Each piece is sculptured thoughtfully and imaginatively. There are shocking instrumental turns everywhere you look. This is an album, a fully realised statement, not a meaningless pile of noodling. Anything less than a five would be daft.

Only listened to a bit, will listen to today.

How many vintage B&W movies do I have to watch to get this? I am an unsophisticated lout and jazz in general bores the 'eff out of me. I did listen to this and I recognize the musicianship - I played a horn myself as a youth - but, I just don't enjoy it. Maybe it's all about instrumentation for me - I enjoyed the Spanish guitar on track 4 very much.

One of my favorite Mingus albums. This has been in my rotation for years. Gives you a strong feel for what this genius was up to.

Would have loved to see this live. Top musicianship Great blend of all the instruments

Mingus was always just a name to me…now I know more about him after listening. I appreciate the effort and can understand why he’s a big jazzy deal but…maybe.

What a wild ride. So many different paths to travel. Chaotic/serene. Fast/slow. Beautiful solo parts by every instrument and then collision of group effort. One of a kind

Known for being a volatile dude with an angry temper who believed in collective improvisation, Mingus gives us a good example of art imitating life on this one I suppose. Maybe I would’ve enjoyed this more while watching the ballet for which it was written. Too erratic for my taste.

It’s Mingus, ya dingus! This one falls firmly into my “jazz=3” rule, since I’m too dumb to know any better, one way or another.

I usually listen to Jazz to get some chill vibes and relax. This was a little too chaotic for me.

I’ll say one thing about this album…it is definitely JAZZ. .25/5

Fantastic record. Felt like it was taking me around the world and across time with all the different styles of jazz. A blend of serenity and intriguing chaos. Was hooked nearly all the way. About halfway through track D I was ready I was ready to move on.

There's a lot of talent here and a lot of chaos. A lot of the album feels like an "everything, everywhere, all at once" ordeal. I'm not sure what the intention or design of the concept is, so maybe I'm missing something there, but, purely as a listening piece, it's a bit much sometimes. The piano and Spanish guitar interludes with the accents and highlights of the other jazz instruments are really special, though, and there's just a ton of talent across the board. Some more cohesion would be superb and really put this one at the top. Fav tracks: N/A, but movements 3-5 stand out more than the rest.

More jazz! This is very good but not my favourite genre. Listens: 1 Fave Track: ?

I don't understand jazz. I can enjoy jazz but fail to get the emotion behind it, as I am more of a "words give emotion" person. This is all just fucking noise to me. Maybe it makes me stupid and unrefined, but there are other jazz albums I would put on instead of this. The chances of me listening to this again are nil. This album may belong in the book as an example of jazz that isn't as good as the other jazz in the book.

Je ne comprends décidément pas le jazz... J'ai l'impression qu'il n'y a pas de cohérence, pas d'harmonie mais un empilement de sons pas cohérents.

This was a lot of chaos

Most jazz sounds very random to me. 1/5

Like all great jazz, Mingus puts us inside a Time Capsule that’s inside a Time Machine. We’re right there listening to art created in the spot and we’re also confronted by music that no genre or era has caught up with. It’s not for everyone but it’s meant for everybody, and it rewards repeated listens like the most timeless music always does.

Jazz galore! These jazz album suggestions are not bad

Mas duro que el puto pan de ayer

luscious impressionistic jazz music that makes you think. a seamless blend of groove, whimsy and chaos... only a few different tracks but containing very long lengths, jam packed of solos that just go on and on and on, keeping you engaged all the way through. this one's pretty good.

No, don't care for this.

One of the weirder / more intricate Jazz albums I’ve ever listened to. Find it a hard one to vibe with, but this probably is because it’s a more advanced album in the genre. Would be a good repeat listen in a few years.

Couldn’t finish it. Too many complaints from the rest of the house

It was very jazz.

Love ❤️ Jazz.., this instrumental experimental was fantastic!!

Mommy was 3 months pregnant! I loved the infusion of Spanish guitar into the progressive jazz.

Really weird, going in too many directions for my taste, lacking basic rythm and groove

Ух ты! Я никогда не слышал этот альбом. Я люблю Мингуса, но я не знал, что он это сделал! Для меня это правая сторона Орнетта Коулмана. Музыканты были потрясающими!! и контртромбон: что это было?! Очень круто.

Still hate jazz

I love some good jazz and some crunchy horns

Not a huge jazz person. There were parts that weren’t bad but others, I don’t know. It reminded me of a recurring stress dream. IYKYK.

3.5/5. This was good. I like jazz.

Kind of a cross between big band sound and jazz.

Jazzy, high energy, chaotic at times, interesting, happy and excited though

Jazzyyy Cecilia

He continues to impress me with some of the best jazz I've ever heard.

Okay! Alright! Enough of that!... I've suffered through the first track on this album. It literally sounds like music the CIA would use to torture & interrogate terrorists using sleep deprivation. This shit ain't for me. Fuck jazz. 👎👎

It has moments of delicacy and beauty, and of utter stormy cacophonous noise. Putting aside the stories about Mingus (aggressive, violent bugger, essentially) it feels like these people are all playing for their lives. Quite a thing to behold

felt a bit manic and was definitely not good music to work to, but i appreciated the jazzy big band style with the longer form songs.