Music by Madonna

Music

Madonna

2.7
Rating
22940
Votes
1
12%
2
32%
3
35%
4
16%
5
5%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 8)

Terrible start. Try hard electronic beats. If this wasn't Madonna this album wouldn't be on the list. Did less in second half of the album to it's benefit

A pabulum of pop.

I generally like the production on this record, though it's not nearly as experimental in 2026 as it was at the turn of the century. Some tracks are very trip hop coded, which is nice. However, some of the lyrics here are pretty basic and cringe worthy in places, holding this back from being something better. Three Madonna albums on this list, and this isn't in her top three so not really sure why it's here.

Didn’t love it. I’ve never really been much of a fan but I prefer her earlier pop content if forced to listen. The dance type songs were what I preferred here.

Fun Fact: Madonna recorded "American Pie" as a parody of Weird Al's "The Saga Begins." This is largely seen as an act of revenge after their relationship fell apart and Weird Al survived Madonna's assassination attempt

Did not enjoy, did not hate 2/5

She's a queen

mittelmäßig

Pop classic

I was so disappointed by this. I thought I had listened to it a lot when I was younger but I don't remember many of the songs and found it a bit crap.

I did not enjoy this at all. Sorry.

It's a very good pop album, Amazing, What It Feels Like for a Girl are really good

After her techno heavy Ray of Light with William Orbit behind the knobs, Madonna tapped French producer Mirwais for Music. This kept things in the dance realm but with an earthier acoustic tone. The glitched out guitars, hiccups in the beats, and manipulated vocals were pushing the edges of creativity at the time, maintaining Madonna's ability to stay ahead of and create trends. I'm not a huge fan, but this was one of those records that everybody liked (or pretended not to) in 2000.

Not the best Madonna album. Fine listen

Way too much autotune for my taste. Music still has a good beat, and Don’t tell me is ok, but the rest of the album is a bit blah.

Not bad. Had its moments, overall a cool experience.

After the release of Ray Of Light, which I really liked,people thought I was a Madonna fan. So much so that friends and relatives bought this album for me multiple times. Think I still have sealed copy somewhere if anyone wants it. Thing is, it’s still sealed because this album is only a pale imitation of its predecessor. So whilst that is a bad thing the good news was that she was yet to reinvent herself with Confessions. So this album sits somewhere between both of those. Little glimpses appear of what Madonna has done and yet to achieve but not the real deal. 3/5 8/5/26

Interesting lyrics and message. I will say production is not amazing but sounds good. If you listen close you notice it’s a little patchy.

What a baffling choice for a Madonna album for this list. This is so mediocre, and sometimes it’s just not good at all. There aren’t any real highs, but some definite lows.

I don't feel like this was an album I absolutely had to listen to, but I have and we now move on.

While I like most of her music, I don't care for Madonnica. 1.5/5

Music explores electronic dance-pop through digital textures, rhythmic minimalism, and stylistic hybridity. However, recurring production techniques and limited emotional variation reduce formal diversity, preventing stronger structural development despite the album’s polished execution, commercial significance, and successful integration of contemporary electronic aesthetics into mainstream pop music during its era.

Some hits, rest of album isn't great. Very mid.

This is my second of the three Madonna albums on this list and just based on these alone I don’t understand how she maintained her icon status so long.

The content is as bland as the title. I agree that Madonna should be on this list, but I don't get why this album is here. It sounds like an album she put out just because she is Madonna and wanted to get over with it. It's not that bad, but it's not good at all. I don't find anything engaging to it. I don't understand this inclusion.

Między 1-2. Taki najpospolitszy pop. Nic ciekawego.

It's nowhere near the levels of the best Madge - Frozen, or Ray of Light, or even the early big pop bangers. For one thing, it feels like Madonna adjusting to what music was popular at the time, rather than shaping pop music, as she did through the 80s. It's not particularly bad, and there is one really cool song that feels much more modern than it is - What It Feels Like For A Girl - but overall it's pretty forgettable.

You know, I looked at the cover and thought, “Oh God, I’m gonna listen to Madonna’s country album from the year 2000, that sounds awful.” However, the first song starts and I am punched in the face by electronic dance pop. Honestly a slight disappointment. I did enjoy it quite a bit more than I thought I would, however. I liked the acoustic-techno fusion, but it’s barely there on the first three tracks, which is odd. The penultimate track drags quite a lot, though. I usually don’t listen to anything from special or deluxe editions of albums for this list, but the reviews made me curious about the American Pie cover. People are so overdramatic about it. It’s nowhere near the original and I don’t like how truncated it is, but I appreciate its uniqueness. 3/5

Waaaayyyyy past her prime.

Sorry Queen Madge, good opener but then innocuous pop

Dated pop from after she was washed.

really strange borderline annoying production choices. i feel like they produced this album without headphones on and then didn’t listen to the final product before hitting publish lol

This was Russian roulette for good songs. The title track, for me at least, really works and holds up today. And then the rest of the album happens.... I can't lie, there's probably 3 songs here that I even remotely like. I can't stand the fucking stop start thing that she keeps putting in. It irritates the life out of me as it has no purpose and without an interesting melody and exceptional vocals, it just grates on the ears. For me, Madonna has never been an album artist, but the hits here are not enough to justify having this be a must listen. I don't hate this, but this is a serious decline for Madonna at this point. And given that 'American Life' is next in her discography here, I'd say that this album set her on a path that would kill her relevance to popular culture. Fav Track: Music

hot doo doo from a butt sorry madonna

kinda cool

Al principio no me gustó, las dos primeras canciones me parecieron goofy asf, pero avanzando el álbum me fue enganchando el sonido de varias canciones (Runaway Lover, Amazing, What it Feels Like for a Girl y American Pie) y me terminó gustando, a pesar de no tener las letras más profundas del mundo (excepto por WIFLFAG) el sonido está bien hecho y Madonna tuvo la valentía de hacerlo siendo algo no tan común en la época y siendo la pop star más grande del siglo pasado, mi problema es que mi estándar en música electrónica es Aphex Twin así que obvio que todo me va a sonar a menos.

El pop de toda la vida cumplidor

she’s the best to ever do it. extremely experimental for the biggest popstar in the world at the time!

Started as decent pop album with 2-3 famous and interesting songs like Music or Runaway Lover, it quickly degraded to low grade pop scum music. However I’d like to highlight song called I Deserve It - great one.

Just so standard and boring, did not age well. Someone called her cover of American Pie a war crime and a human rights violation and that could not be more accurate YEESH

Not for me

This is generous, saved by 1 or 2 songs.

The only decent song on here was the American Pie cover

I liked a few songs but overall not big on it. 2.5 for me but I’ll go 2

Actually pretty fun. She was good at the ol reinvention Some frankie knuckles ass beats, some basic guitar and then some pretty cool guitar/loop shit on don't tell me.

Who made this list? Ugh. I wanted to like this one, but it was just so late 90s-early 2000s club drivel. And then to end it off with that horrible American pie cover? Ugh. Just ugh. 3/10

Madonna doing her autotune best

didn't like, too flat

No entenc perquè te tena baixa nota, si que comparat amb lo que es sa seva discografia pues aquesta igual no destaca tant però a mi m'ha agradat bastant dire. Mel posaria, si que hi ha qualque canço que bastant ñe pero bueno, n'he descobert de seves que m'han molat

Felt like a soulless attempt to try something new. Maybe in 2000 it worked but listening to it now it’s bizarre and unpleasant.

Ok Madonna album. The first 2 songs were very "clubby". Fine for dancing but wouldn't really listen to them. I liked the rest of the album a lot better than those. No big hits (at least that I know). Overall not bad but not sure why it needs to be on this list.

The disparity between the album cover and the sound of the music on "music" is pretty funny. The music itself was fine, the production sounds a bit dated today but I'd bet it sounded cutting edge initially. The title track is the clear highlight.

Después de haber perdido el favor del público (Erótica) y la inspiración (Bedtime stories), Madonna regresó sorpresivamente con su mejor disco de su trayectoria (Ray of light). Su continuación fue este Music, igualmente excelente. La producción a cargo de Orbit y sobre todo de Mirwais (que se la pegó y de qué modo en American Life), le permite sonar actual y en vanguardia, lo que no duraría mucho, hasta Confessions on a Dance Floor... El sencillo electro-pop Music no es el único tema destacable hay mucho más: Impressive Instant, Paradise, I Deserve It, Don’t Tell Me... Paradise remite a Moon Safari de Air. Algunas ediciones incluyen la versión de American Pie, sonido Orbit pero nome parece gran cosa. La duda es si poner en la lista este, el anterior, Confessions, alguno de los 80 o un grandes éxitos... Madonna en su cénit, de ahí no se puede esperar otra cosa que frío...

Bit boring.

Don't make me tap the sign: Y'ALL HATE FUN

Everything about Madonna makes me physically ill: her voice, her appearance, everything.

I really like the Mirwais production, but not my favourite bun of Madonna.

Kind of surprised I liked it but guessing it's because I heard it so much when it came out.

Hadn’t listened to this one before. I have always had a lot of respect for Madonna even if I didn’t gravitate toward her music- I am woefully unhip when it comes to pop music. But I really enjoyed this record. The cover of American Pie was unexpected and enjoyable.

Late effort from our madge

Banger opener then meh

How did this album get here?

Music is an album i really like but not quite to the same amount as Madonna's prior record. I'm more interested in the late 90s early 2000s era Madonna than i am in her 80s stuff and this album was definitely no exception. This album still had that same variety of electronic music styles that the album before this one did with trip-hop, ambient, house, techno and all of that and it is all executed very well here. If i had one issue with this album, it would be the fact that while the vocals were generally pretty well put together, there were some obnoxious usages of autotune which got rather annoying. Other than that though, this is one really good record. Best Song: Music Worst Song: Nobody's Perfect Side note: Last Madonna album, here are the rankings: 1. Ray Of Light 2. Music 3. Like A Prayer

Sleek electronic dance-pop built on pulsing synth loops, programmed beats, and processed, coolly controlled vocals cycles with hypnotic precision. Listening feels like being on a brightly lit dancefloor where the same groove keeps circling without much change feeling monotonous.

Sian score

This record is terrible. It sounds so dry and soulless. Madonna was an interesting figure earlier in her career, but there came a point where she wasn’t about anything except what was trending at the time. These songs do not add anything. They exist, but it does not mean they are.

Not good.

not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue

Boring and derivative.

There are some great hits on here. I enjoy them whenever they are on the radio. The overall genre on the album is definitely not my jam, so I wouldn’t put this on anytime soon though

This was really bad and then the American Pie cover sooo bad

This was definitely trash but a couple fun moments i guess

I don’t think there’s anything interesting about this album.

Wow, I hate this era of music.

Where Ray of Light was a bit dark/brooding, Music turns up the fun, getting Madonna back to her dance roots (albeit with an updated sound). Very solid album, great musical production. And because I am in the US, the awful “American Pie” cover was not included; that alone would have knocked this down a peg.

A few songs in, so far, so boring. I am not going to make it to the end of this. Is it more about having continuing sales than about being creative--see how different I am? But not too different--I'm Madonna after all, just a little techno now.

Really dull!!! And what a hateful cover of American Pie.

This is the first Madonna album I've ever listened to that didn't repel me from the outset. Android Madonna isn't all bad. And the juxtaposition of the cover, I thought this was her Nashville phase or something. And, her voice, it's musical. But, turns out her best stuff is average in my book. Not hating it is as far I can get.

Conceptually this feels like a continuation of Ray of Light in that Madonna is working with the latest musical trends. Note that I didn't say she's making them her own; the approach on this album feels a bit incohesive. Her previous album focused on downtempo and trip hop, while this one often goes for bigger dance beats. That doesn't stop it from also including a few slow songs and some that heavily incorporate acoustic guitars. The bigger songs are typically better, though the highlight is the downtempo "What it Feels Like for a Girl" with its shuffling beat and poignant lyrics. Weirdly, outside of that song Madonna herself feels a bit anonymous on this, not offering much lyrically or vocally that other artists couldn't. While this is another example of Madonna adapting with trends, and the variety does fit the album's title, it jumps around too much to ever draw you in.

Madonna lost her way in the 2000’s and to is is glorified electronic music

Пусть тот кто составлял этот список объяснит почему я должен это послушать. Это ужасно Как будто ей сказали что они сейчас будут делать популярную музыку и начали пихать все новомодные штуки в каждую композицию. Я хейтер. Мне не нравится Мадонна. Этот альбом оправдал ожидания плохой попсовой музыки и плохого скучного исполнения. Перепеть Американский пирог было сильно Треш

The 2000s were a weird era of pop. Quirky electronics and more experimentation started taking over, and Madonna really tried to adapt to the trends. It leads to some horrendous songs that have aged like milk but also some real gems. The production on Impressive Instant and Nobody's Perfect is pretty ugly and Madonna's autotuned vocals are hard to listen to. I feel similarly about Paradise, the robot sound is pretty unflattering. The album also ends on a weak note with an awkward cover of American Pie. However, there is also some clear bangers in the tracklist that make the album worth the time. Opens up with a fantastic song, Don't Tell Me is easily the best produced song here, Runaway Lover and What it Feels Like for a Girl are also pretty fantastic. In many ways this album is a mess, but it marks an interesting step in Madonna's discography.

the beats are fresh but overall it really doesn’t deliver like other songs for me. and it sounds really bad when you have an acoustic guitar and synthesized drums in this era. auto tune and that’s it.

I liked Madonna well enough in the 80s/early 90s but paid zero attention to this album. I was pleasantly surprised to find that I didn’t hate this. That is until the last track. “American Pie” isn’t a great song but whatever she did to it should be criminal. I am taking this rating down 2 stars for that song. I feel worse about humanity after hearing it.

What a strange album Madonna doing autotune - ugh The cover of American Pie - a musical war-crime A couple of the other songs are ok if listened to away from the rest of the ablum But as a 49 minute listening experience, I am very grateful for the skip button Such a shame, after 1998's wonderful Ray of Light album, which to me remains her career highlight

Other than the laughably bad autotune to the sound of bacteria music in that one song, this was not as terrible as the album cover led me to believe (the french house influence in the first half is pretty cool). It just goes to show nobody's perfect.

Did we need a cover of American Pie by Madonna? No, we did not. Do I hate myself for sort of liking it? Yes I do.

The early 90s were a bit of creative low point for our Madge, at least as far as music was concerned. It wasn’t until Ray of Light in 1997 and this album in 2000 that she found her mojo again. I’ve probably listened to Ray of Light more (being a fan of producer William Orbit) but Music has a lot going for it and it certainly confounded expectations at the time. The major issue that most people seem to have with this is the cover of American Pie by Don McClean. There seems to be something of a ‘don’t you dare touch a classic’ reaction from some music fans, but if you are going to do a cover at least try to find something different to say and I think Madonna definitely manages that. Aside from that, there’s a good mix of stuff on this album with the title track and What It Feels Like For a Girl being the standouts for me. Overall this gets 4 stars from me but that’s only because Ray of Light is even better.

sometimes chill and decent, low 3

Really uneven some really good songs and others that were just completely underperforming

Pretty polished pop going on here, very typical of what I’d expect from Madonna but too shiny and well-produced for my liking. Not a fan of the American Pie cover.

Why would you add cybernetic upgrades to Madonna? She's already a dangerous individual after assassinating Weird Al & her affiliatation with Pablo Esobar's drug ring. And whatever the fuck she did to that pie. I may trust Jason Biggs with American Pie than Madonna.

I liked Ray of Light but this is not it. The whole album feels embarrassingly disingenuous like that scene from The Matrix where Trinity tells Neo she loves him and that’s why he can’t be dead, complete with the obnoxious whisper voice.

Listened to this after lunch on a relatively boring workday. Terrible idea. Nothing interesting at all going on here. 2/5.

Surprisingly good

Amazing to write this. I've heard this album many times before - it was in a couple of movies I liked, Austin Powers I think. Anyway 5

Madonna is rock solid. This album is very different from what we are used to from the big hits. However, it is a gem.

269/1001 Madonna - Music Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ❎ I'm trying to think of why this on the list. For the most part, it's rather middle of the road balladry with a country tinge to it. Not offensive enough to be a one star, but equally pretty poor.

Ihan ok poppia, mutta tykkäsin kyllä näistä instruista enemmän kuin Madonnan laulusta. Ensimmäinen nimikko kappale Music oli ehkä ainoa missä vokaalit toi jotain. Muista kappaleista olisin tykännyt enemmän pelkkinä instruina. Vähän triphopmaista elektronista. Enkä odottanut että vika kappale American Pie on tosiaan Don McLean cover. Parhaat: Music, Paradise (Not For Me), Runaway Lover

I am not a big pop fan and despite knowing Madonna's name I am completely unfamiliar with her catalog. Because of the big name, I was expecting something groundbreaking. Maybe her voice is spectacular? But no, it's just shitty dance pop with light auto tune. I feel this can't possibly be one if Madonna's best albums, let alone an album you must hear before you die.

Surprisingly credible. I grew up with Madonna seemingly fitting in with 90s-00s manufactured pop, and as a narrow minded kid I never challenged that thought. I'm often a little bit surprised to realise that she's involved in some quite credible art. This record started with some interesting mature electronic sounds that I was quite into. This reappeared a couple of times throughout. Also featuring were some things that felt like uninteresting 90s-ish pop to me. Wish it were more consistently in that explorative electric space

1/10 A pop electronica album from 2000 featuring work by Guy Sigsworth (a man who has worked extensively with Imogen Heap, Björk and Lamb, among others)? Yes please! Oh… What? Hang on, what the hell is this? I obviously remember the big hits off this record from my teenage years, but in my head, they were way better songs than they actually are, and the production across those tracks, as well as the rest of the record is absolutely bizarre. This album is the audio version of the “How Do You Do, Fellow Kids” clip from 30 Rock, in which Madonna, her collaborators and, if I had to guess, quite a few music execs, try to make music that “The Kids” are into, despite not really understanding that music at all. It’s kind of remarkable. What’s even more remarkable is that, from a sales point of view, it actually worked. It feels a lot like the first port of call was to buy three or four of the most popular synths of the day and bash through a bunch of presets, while playing along to some hastily programmed drum beats, but then not actually developing things further, except to pile more effects, weird noises and clashing tones over the top of everything. Honestly, it’s a complete mess from a production point of view. If you listen closely, there are actually some half decent ideas buried under there, but they’re so swamped by “state of the art production techniques” (i.e. digital fuckery that’s been really badly executed) that it’s hard to see them than anything other than big steaming musical turds. And you can’t claim that these are just artefacts of the time this record came out, because a lot of the electronica techniques they are trying to implement had been used creatively, effectively and with nuance for at least a decade prior to this release. Luckily for my mate Guy, it looks like he only actually had a hand in one track on this record, which is actually the best one on there, but even that isn’t enough to save this steaming pile of musical manure. And I’ve nothing against Madonna, she has released some classic pop music in the past, but this is just a shambles. Music - The weird thing about this is that it’s a better song in my head than it is on the actual record. It’s so dynamically flat, there’s no nuance to the drum programming, and the synths feel like they’ve all been set to the one of the first presets in bank A. It apes the work of a load of dance music producers from the 90s but without any of the grit, style or feel. This is “baby’s first dancefloor anthem”, aka the kind of music you give to kids if you don’t credit them with any critical thinking. The melodies are reasonably catchy though, so this sold by the boatload. Impressive Instant - More derivative dancefloor sounds to start us off and good lord, it gets worse. There are some atrocious and pointless vocal edits in this that don’t add anything musical or interesting to the blend. This is stuffed full of terrible sounds that don’t connect together well and it doesn’t even find anything close to an engaging melody. This is complete trash of the highest order. Runaway Lover - Again, and I feel I may be repeating myself often on this record, this is another derivative, unmemorable dancefloor track that has some truly baffling moments of production. I can hear kernels of how this could have been turned into something not shit, like there’s a tiny bit of trip-hop sound like Lamb buried deep within it, but it’s been ultra-processed to the point where that feels so very far away. I Deserve It - So this is a fairly mundane country pop number, but the drum beats and synths that they use are so teeth grindingly robotic and dynamically flat that all of the charm and nuance is completely sucked out of what could have been a half-decent song. Utterly baffling. Oh, and it’s too long. Amazing - Well this isn’t as bad as some of the stuff we’ve had up to now, but it’s still very, very dynamically flat and one-paced. It kind of feels like the production team and Madonna herself are doing two different things with this track that don’t actually blend all that well. There’s a bit of grit and intensity to the track and Madge sounds like she’s singing a clean pop song. The flutey synth pad is annoying, and it feels like they also couldn’t work out how to end it. Nobody's Perfect - Oh, shit. Awful auto-tune now. And some weird whispering. I just don’t see what the auto-tune brings to the table here, and even the lead synth sounds sad to be involved in this. Again, there are some really clunky bits of production that almost sound unintentional, they’re that poorly executed. This is such a strange way to treat a ballad, because as a result of all the audio fuckery, it has no soul at all and the production actually draws attention away from the (admittedly incredibly boring) song that sits underneath it. Don't Tell Me - Right, so I obviously remember this because I was 15 years old when this album came out and wasn’t a complete shut-in. But again, my memory of it is far better than the reality. The sample chopping of the guitar part is laughably poorly executed, and that type of sample chopping had been being done expertly by a number of producers up to this point, so the age of this song is no excuse. The timing is sloppy, the cutting of the tail of the tones jars. The synth parts are really crap, the strings sound like cheap samples and it’s produced in such a way that everything clashes and feels pretty incoherent. I think there are some decent melodies in there, but they’re hidden amongst an abomination of clashing and half-arsed ideas. What It Feels Like For A Girl - This is the best track on the album by such a long way that it’s not even funny. It has a good thematic message, the melodies are pretty good and there’s so much more nuance to the synth and drum programming. It doesn’t surprise me in the slightest that this is the only track on the album that was co-written and co-produced by Guy Sigsworth. The synths and strings blend really nicely together and it’s got a really nice ambience to it. It’s not the most well developed or exceptionally interesting track, but it stands out so far above the rest that I actually quite enjoyed it. Paradise (Not For Me) - What on earth is going on with this half whisper-sung vocal intro? Oh god, then we get some vocoded nonsense. The resonant synth patch that comes in is way too loud and again, this feels like a super-weird clash of styles and tones that rut up against one another but never blend. It’s like a string of half-completed ideas mashed together. Some of those ideas aren’t actually that bad and we land on some reasonable moments of ambient trip-hop production, but as soon as the vocals come back in again, they are so bad that I’m not even sure how to describe them. Gone - Ok, here’s a plodding singer-songwriter start. The drum programming isn’t as mind-numbingly flat and robotic as I Deserve It, but it’s still pretty monotonous and uninteresting. I also don’t understand why you’d put those synth effects over the top of this, it’s just an incredibly strange production choice. This is a fairly bland track, but it’s not terrible, however it’s just got more of those odd choices that make it a hard listen. American Pie - This is a bonus track, so normally I wouldn’t review it, but I just wanted to note that this is an utter abomination.

Love me some pre 9/11 Madonna.

Not my go to but the American pie cover was interesting to say the least.

Generic late 90s/early 00s pop album. The hits have aged poorly, and I feel little reason to come back to this album. Generic pop from 2 and a half decades ago tends not to age the best.

An absolute steaming pile of auto-tuned garbage pop music. Madonna deserves no credit for her work on this album that pushes no artistic boundaries nor develops novel sounds or ideas, and the album's producer deserves none for staunchly following the trends in pop music of the day, all of which aged poorly.

Yeah alright.

Don't enjoy the electronic dance vibe. Better Madonna albums.

Not bad at all

This came up and I said, "oh cool, some Madonna, I haven't listened to her in a while, she's not a favorite, but it's something different to break the 70's and 80's rocktamist streak I've been on." I'm kind of glad every time a women artist comes up. Then I saw what album it was and I was genuinely baffled, why is this on the list. I didn't love Ray of light, but it was a huge album and an important moment in the career of a pretty iconic artist. This continued the trajectory of the previous album, but not in a great direction. A time capsule of a pre 911 sound and and vibe, but others were doing it better. I'll take Britney over this, feels more honest. Maybe I'm being harsh, but everything about this album feels inauthentic and pandering. Not into it. Not really a fair comparison, but this came out 2 weeks before Kid A if we want to check out someone experimenting with electronic sounds. Felt really long, wanted it to be over. Not quite 1 star, because it wasn't upsetting sounding from moment to moment, some of the songs are perfectly catchy if fully vapid. The most 2 star album yet though, can't imagine why it was included on the list.

Ray of light is pretty handily the better album but this is the one that I owned so it holds a special place in my heart

The first part of the album was really grating and awful. What It Feels Like For A Girl and Paradise (Not For Me) were the only songs that were at least decent, and that’s because they’re different from the sound of the rest of the album. Not feeling generous today; this is getting 1 star.

Bops, reminds me a lot of early Shakira

I used to love Madonna's music and personality. During the 80s and 90s she kicked ass and broke the mold for female mainstream pop artists. A real trailblazer. I bowed out at 'Ray of light' (an awesome album) because for my listening taste she walked a little too far down the 'clubbing' path. I hadn't heard this album and I enjoyed it. Its a shame she made herself look so odd!

Madonna trying to sound like 00's Britney - made me a little sad to be honest. While I have huge respect for Madonna as an artist, her music is just not my thing (Plus she really butchered American Pie!?) I feel sad that we live in a world where it seems people like Madonna feel they need to freeze their faces to stay 'young', and make music that sounds like someone else, just to stay relevant. BUT - you do you Madonna, maybe this was the kind of music you WANTED to make, and maybe you don't feel like you HAVE to have plastic surgery but you just WANT to. Nobody's Perfect. Girls just want to have botox, I guess.

Madonna experimenting with a lot of non-mainstream ideas. At its best, it’s a fun, danceable pop album. At its worst, it’s a complete mess. I guess I’ll meet in the middle.

Awful. Even by Madonna's standards.

Pretty good

A couple of songs were okay, maybe just due to familiarity (music and don't tell me), but most of the rest just faded away. The American pie cover didn't serve anything. High 1/low 2

It was so bland, the production is immaculate but nothing else going for it.

Great production and at times experimental. But not great song writing compared to her earlier work

American Pie of every bit as bad as I remember it, but it's still the best song on the album. The album really stands on its production which is excellent, but can't sustain interest for a whole album. So it starts off feeling like a 3 but ends up a 2 for me.

A fascinating record. Often ugly and abrasive but fearless and endlessly interesting. I suspect it satisfies neither fans of 80s Madonna; Ray of Light era; or Confessions on a Dance Floor era, though I reckon it’s been influential years later on hyperpop artists who’ve been able to tweak elements of its sound in a more thought out way with better branding. I’ll admit I got motion sickness as the ill-advised and extremely quirked American Pie keyboard cover kicked off the end of the album, but even in this I found a bizarre, awkward charm. Certainly a moment I won’t be forgetting any time soon.

The album has some strong moments in production and tune but a lot of disappointments for me as it comes after Ray of Light which is my favourite of hers and a 5 for me Music by Madonna is a low 3 for me

Music - 3 Impressive instant - 2 Runaway lover - 1 I deserve it - 2 Amazing - 2 Nobody's perfect - 1 Don't tell me - 3 What it feels like for a girl - 2 Paradise (not for me) - 1 Gone - 3

Not my favorite Madonna era.

It's just so predictable and clean. All the sounds sound like pre programmed drum machine kits from the factory, no effort to dirty them up. Bland song structures, no real hooks save for the title track. I know Madonna has much stronger material. This is a 2 from me.

Honestly I think there are a lot of better Madonna efforts that could have been on this list. IMO this isn’t one of her best. After dominating the 80s and 90s, the 2000s was not Madonna’s best decade.

The album cover had some red flags, but I enjoyed this more than I would have thought. The acoustic pieces were my favorite, the title track not so much. Favorites: 'I Deserve It', 'Don't Tell Me'

Somewhat nostalgic for me, as this was the era of Madonna I was most familiar with when I was growing up. Ray Of Light is probably the better album, though, at least for my taste. That said, Don't Tell Me is a perfect, extremely cool song.

Best Song: Don't Tell Me. A bit of a kitchen-sink production, but somehow this odd mix of elements ends up working. Worst Song: Nobody's Perfect. The transition from the ASMR intro into the heavy autotune hits like a goddamn car crash. The whole song feels like a cursed time capsule. Overall: Feels kind of audacious to just call your album "music", especially when it's all relatively contemporary, late-90s trendiness. Surely she didn't think this would be so timeless as to deserve such a self-important title.

Like 2 good songs ish

erster song banger dann wie bei Britney irgendwie kommt gar nichts ? c

Love the single Music and played it many times!!

Disco tratando de ser actual

Unlistenable

First time listening to a Madonna album from start to finish. Every song was fine; didn't skip any. The production is immaculate (arguably to the point of sterility). But the choices, in arranging and mixing, are questionable throughout. The songs consistently lack urgency or excitement. Often elements that might draw the listener in are too low in the mix, while banal elements are featured very prominently. It must be said that the songs featuring acoustic guitar sound very 90s-pop in a way I would never have guessed Madonna songs could sound. The overall result is an album that is best suited to playing as background music, perhaps while having drinks with friends, or while doing household chores. This is a fate we could never have imagined for Madonna: to be ordinary.

Many of my friends loved her music. And she was a cultural moment, especially early on. I saw Desperately Seeking Susan--with who, I wonder?--and enjoyed the story and her cool. But I hated it then, and I still dislike it. Nope!

Blech. Never much of a Madonna fan and I found this album pretty horrific

Would I listen to this whole album again? No. Would I mind if someone else put it on? No. Am I shocked it was so popular when it was released? Yes. Not as bad as I feared, but not really for me.

Inoffensive in the main, but sappy and boring. The autotune dates it badly. Two stars.

I'm surprised that another modern Madge album is on the list. And, again, though she is obviously one of the most important pop stars of all time, these later albums are just not worth being put here. Madge is flagging badly by this point. I would've though her earlier albums would have been more represented. Anyway, this album being here is pointless. Best Tracks: Music; Don't Tell Me; American Pie

Surprised that the majority of the Madonna albums have not been from the 80s. This is not the strongest entry

*2000. *The first song and title track ("Music") was catchy and poppy when it came out, but no one loved it. *Don't Tell Me and What it Feels Like for a Girl are the other singles off this album. Don't Tell is the same deal - catchy and maybe a guilty pleasure, but no one's favorite. What it Feels Like - that one's weird and creepy and skippable. *After that, it doesn't get better. Madonna did the same thing as Britney - she chose to go for the club vibe with lots of electronics. It worked much better for Brit. *I Deserve Better is a nice departure from the club music. It's closer to Madonna's Ray of Light album from 1998 which I liked (hey, I was 13 at the time...) RATING - 6/10

There is some good music on this album, but, overall, it sounds even more fleeting than some of her other albums from this time, such as "Ray of Light" which preceded "Music" and was produced almost entirely by William Orbit, which gave it even more of a late 90's electronica feel. And I believe that "Confessions on a Dance Floor" is more fun (a few albums later in her discography), as it has more of an 80's electro feel.

It was so forced although I wasn’t in the gay clubs then so It might of been banging but I couldn’t help but cringe for her shot at staying relevant…

FINALLY SOME GOOD FUCKING SONGS. Forget 80s Madonna, 00s Madonna was an artist truly in their prime, big time. This is the good fucking shit. Madonna knows, if nothing else, how to make a solid floor filler and you can’t tell me this isn’t an album full of them. Even the deep album tracks I don’t know, my hands are up and I’m going wooooooooooo - I’ve got blue sparkly eyeshadow on and butterfly hair clips in and I’m in da clurb for sure. And when I’m not doing that (girls contain multitudes) I’m crying at the perfect pop ballads. Do you know how it feels for a girl in this world, I’ll tell you what - it feels like this! So fucking good well done Madonna.

The most intensely 2000 album there's ever been? There are some bangers in here for sure, a lot of filler (much like Madonna herself these days), and it's kinda samey after a while. a lot of it sounds like scissor sisters but not quite as good - but then Madonna was there first. I feel like there's a lot better Madonna records out there than this one, but this is a fun time nonetheless

September 18, 2000 was probably the day the music died... (Sorry, couldn't skip this obvious pun) As I already hinted at in my other Madonna review, I don’t think it’s worth examining her music in isolation—and certainly not entire albums. “Music” also contains a few well-known singles (“Music,” “What It Feels Like…,” “American Pie”) and, apart from that, a lot of boredom. If that were enough, wouldn’t Whitney Houston, for example, also have to be on this list? Exactly. Long story short: “Music” sounds just as uninteresting today as it did 25 years ago.

хоть чтото что качает за последние дни

De draft punk aux Beatles en passant par Lil Wayne et Natasha Bedingfield ça va dans tous les sens mais c'est pas mauvais...

There were points where it was pretty good and some points it was pretty bad

Musically sound dance tunes, but when it’s not auto tuned, she relies on a vibrato that’s so consistent I’m not sure whether it’s actually another effect. This is not my kind of pop.

So 2000. Auto tune isnt great. This album is all over the place. Dont Tell Me was the only decent song. The American Pie cover is bad.

Not great bar one song.

just no god no this was fully bad

The title track and Don't Tell Me are pretty good, the rest are not.

I have to applaud Madonna for staying relevant for two decades and not continuing down the road that brought her huge success in the eighties. This album contained some songs that were absolute bangers in clubs around 2000. It still holds up pretty well.

Well produced, Madonna and William Orbit defo have had an influence on modern house. I like Madonna but I just think a pop album, more than any other genre, need bops. It needs catchy riffs and tricks. I enjoyed this but very little stayed with me, except for the titular track. 6.5 / 10 Best track/s: Paradise, Amazing, Music

OAD #190, Music, was better than OAD #176, Ray of Light. One thing I can say about 2000s Madonna is that she knew how to pick producers. The music is good, if a little safe. I just can't get over how inauthentic Madonna herself sounds, though somehow she manages to pull out two solid tracks at the very end of the album. I didn't listen to the bonus cover of "American Pie," and I don't plan to. And the title reminds me of Bowen Yang's hilarious 2021 Iceberg sketch on SNL. His album's name was also Music. So stupid. Box checked. I don't care. Three stars.

Not for me

Finally a female artist!! I’m glad it’s Madonna too I do like her music. Although I don’t like this album nor any songs on it. It’s too country-pop for me.

Not great. I was kinda digging it until the auto tune started. I have allergies to auto tune.

I really liked this album. It was a Madonna's last strong entry into the dance world, or at least that I'm familiar with. Really like the electronic side of this album, good beats, nice writing and production.

As someone who is only vaguely familiar with Madonna, I can just imagine someone not knowing anything about her, seeing this cover thinking it’s country, and then being seriously disappointed lol. On a related note, this album is awful.

A nice enough pop record (except the American Pie cover, which can naff right off). One or two that stuck out to me enough to save for later. And I'm a sucker for Don't Tell Me.

This is supposed to be experimental? How?

madonna krolowa popu jak szczupak krolem wod

It's okay, solid 2.5......you know, average

The production on Music is balls to the wall brilliant it's also so big, cluttered and overwhelming that at times it all but erases Madonna from her own album or rather from the sounds made by whoever was hip and happening in 1999. Music often doesn't feel like a Madonna album but just as often it feels like an album that only Madonna could have directed if not made. They say you are often more in control when you are seemingly not in control at all. Madonna is a smart businesswoman and knows how to pick them when it comes to getting hits. Her greatest talent has always been having a great ear for aligning herself with whoever is making waves at the moment and in this case, it was William Orbit and it was Mirwais Ahmadzaï- two big names in electronic dance music. Madonna is also very good at knowing when to let others take control. Music is a smart, at times creatively stunned, exhausting, colorful big future robot of an album it's also a lot of dumb fun. How much Madonna is actually responsible for that dumb fun is anyone's guess other than her wispy vocals it's impossible to tell if this is even a Madonna album (too many cooks in the kitchen and all that) or the work of a few semi faceless producers trying to avoid friendly fire in a circle jerk of studio wizardry. Regardless of how the music on Music came to be- it remains one of her most essential and daring albums. For the most part. Madonna's cover of Don McLean's American Pie is a stumbling sad mess that begs you to feel something - which I did but not certain she was going for disdain.

I had to laugh at the album summary describing it as 'Experimental', but I thought this was a fairly standard pop record, with the occasional production flourish making it at least a little interesting. The American Pie cover was absolute dog shit, but as a bonus track I won't penalise as much as I'd like to for having the whole thing end on a sour note.

I love the opening track. I remember this album being popular. I feel like I’ve listened to it before. I remember “don’t tell me” now. I still love and hate the beginning. The skipping bugs me.

Pretty good. I was surprised with how unique this sounded. Don’t like every song, but most have something interesting about them. Paradise almost sounds like a Damaged Bug song.

I liked it less than expected

Diva! Favourites: Impressive Instant, Paradise (Not For Me)

I hate this.

Favourite Songs: Impressive Instant Nobody's Perfect What It Feels Like For A Girl Paradise (Not For Me)

Liked listening to this a lot more than I expected that I would! Good energy and beats, and some interesting lyrics. Might regret rating this a 4 later on, but I really did enjoy my listen.

Didn’t mind it but that American Pie cover is ROUGH

I'm not huge on pop but this was fine... Until that cover of American pie. Oof.

Paradise not for me is a great song

Not for me. Only 2 tracks I can call favourite (normally 3) tunes. 1. Music 2. Don’t Tell Me 3. ….

Nice pop/dance album.

A concerted attempt to be current in 2000, which did not set it up to age particularly well. She could still find some songs that worked for the dancefloor but too much of this feels like her trying on clothes that don't quite fit. The last song about authenticity is a bit ludicrous when this is Madonna using clumsy autotune and dressed as a cowgirl I skipped the bonus track. You know the one

It would be a five if it wasn't for the American Pie cover, but even that is not bad (& apparently saved Don McLean from financial troubles, for which he was very thankful). Ah heck in the US that song wasn't included so I'll give it a 5 (it was still 44 minutes with the original 10 songs). It still sounds incredible today and is probably my most listened to Madonna album. It was played repeatedly in my first proper place of work. They only had a few albums including Protection (Massive Attack) and Alabama 3, which gives you an idea of their collective taste. What it feels like for a Girl was my favourite, Don't Tell Me was another great single but all the album tracks really hit die to the great production throughout despite multiple producers and collaborators. I'm made up this was in the book, as pop can be under represented (even if it was later dropped). Especially I'm happy to give a 5 to a pop girl, for what is the prevalent chart genre in the 2020s and for which Madonna was one of the trailblazers. This album was very important for what was to come.

Fav tracks: music, impressive instant, what it feels like for a girl, paradise (not for me) The album starts out with neo-electro dance beats then transitions into vulnerable pop ballads… such an epic album!!!

After Ray Of Light, this one felt like a real letdown, pretty much marking the beginning of the Madonna career slide. That last album was so cohesive, but Music just feels like a weird mix of stuff that doesn't always work. The production sounds a bit too sterile at times, and the autotune is annoying, especially on "Nobody's Perfect". It's missing the heart you usually get from her, and it feels like a bunch of generic club tracks and silly gimmicks that haven't aged well. That said, it's not a total bust. The title track "Music" is still a killer pop song, and "Don't Tell Me" is awesome, mixing acoustic guitar with some cool production. Those singles showed she was still ahead of the curve, but as an album, it's a bit weak compared to her best stuff. It's a brave try at something new, but it just feels a bit...dated.

Although I was born in the early 80s and have living memory of most of Madonna's career, I have only ever owned two of her albums: Ray of Light, and Music. Ray of Light was a big shift in her style, and Music seemed like the logical next step: a refocus on pure pop. It also feels like a shift from leading the charge in the next pop music direction to hearing a sound that will be popular and mimicking it just before or just after it becomes the main sound. That being said, she was still good at her job, and this album had at least two hits and a couple of others that reached radio play. Every song on the album is different. While not every song is hit worthy, most are enjoyable. When this album came up in my list, I was a little surprised. I'm not 100% sold on it needing to be on this list, however, after giving it a fresh listen, I am reminded that it is an overall decent pop album with some real bangers. Points deducted for American Pie, obviously.

Nothing special. However „Paradise” is great song in my opinion.

Not what I was expecting in a bad way. I was not that interesting or catchy as a pop album should be, it had some good tracks but I was hoping to get a hidden gem, but it was average at best.

Music is one of my fav Madonna songs!

muy popopopopop pero cool

i never knew madonna could slap so hard

Insipid lyrics, nothing memorable, completely skippable

Not much of a Mag fan, only slightly irritating and tolerable pop music, couple of her 'hits' on here, points lost for auto-tuning and the American Pie cover, a 'just scrapped in' ⭐⭐⭐

OMG MADONNA HI FAVS (top 3): impressive instant, paradise (not for me), gone mençoes honrosas: music, runaway lover, amazing, american pie po me hypei supper por ser um album da madonna mas KKKKK eh ne... mas tem umas boas nota final: 2.5/5

So I'm not anti-Madonna in general, I know she had some fun songs back in the day. I appreciated the vaguely pro-trans language at the beginning of "What It Feels Like for a Girl," and one or two tracks had fun club music-y things going on that reminded me of Rozalla or whatever from the early 90s. So some of this was ok? But most of it was a chore, with autotune, stupid lyrics, and as a bonus some faux-chanteusey nonsense in one of the songs. 2 stars. It would have been 1 star if I'd had to listen to the cover of "American Pie" that's on the extended version - I already despise the original, so threatening me with a cover of that song by Madonna is the kind of thing that would get me to confess in an interrogation. "Anything but that, I swear I'll talk!"

Madonna is a queen of remaking herself as times change. This was a great chapter when she started to work with wildly creative producers, which took her sound in new directions.

The most generic bang average 00's pop ever

The title track is...something in a bottle. Not lightning, but it hits all the Y2K musical brain itches. That doesn't make it a good song, or a bad song (it's an ok song) it just hits a little bit of everything. And this kind of...a little bit of everything that was happening in 2000 keeps on through the album. It's not good. It's not bad. It's ok, which actually makes it worse than a lot of the things that it's referencing. And it's important as a time capsule that seems to touch the pop music zeitgeist, but it's also entirely forgettable. Inch deep, several feet wide, and I more or less had it pegged by track 2. To be clear: I am not the target audience here. It's background music for me. Almost made a Moby joke here, but then remembered that was Gwen Stefani, but, y'know, same stuff either way. This album is also notable for Madonna's reinvention - difficult for a pop singer to do, and maybe not quite successful in retrospect, it was at least current at the time. Feels a little bit like "industry plant, but an already household name." Hell, Katy Perry didn't pull this one off. Anyway, this is a weird one I keep coming around on. Again, it's not a good album. But...maybe it is a bad one? There are pieces that really are specifically not good, but Madonna is talented and can carry pretty much anything. Ultimately, I guess that it's just kind of there, which isn't great. Takes it down a notch from the coward's 3.

There is a lot going on in this pop album, and I don’t mean that as a compliment. This album feels like watching an old movie with early CGI. At the time of release it probably felt groundbreaking and interesting to see all the new techniques being used. And now it just feels bad. It’s dated and kind of off putting. Even the catchiest songs are plagued with weird electronic drones and overlapping sounds that make them unenjoyable. It just is not for me.

This of all Madonna albums?

Madonna needs to apologise immediately to Don McLean for absolutely butchering American Pie Even I'm offended listening to that. A true hate crime was commited 2 ⭐️

Fuck this sucks so hard. Music and Don't Tell Me are nostalgic bangers but Nobody's Perfect was a haaaaard listen. She really said nothing equals nothing and that's what this album is, do better MADONNA

The more I listened to this, the more I disliked it. Sorry Madge

I mean come on. How is this album in this list… although I quite like ‘Don’t Tell Me’

Fuck me this is bad. 2 barely recognisable songs with a hit of pop attraction. Beginning to have doubt about the authors of this compendium

Going into this one, I was expecting awful. Dreading it honestly, but it was fine. Seems like Madonna hopped on the bandwagon of auto tune and electro beats of the time and it doesn’t feel exactly right for her. But What It Feels Like for a Girl is a great song.

I'm not really a Madonna fan, but this album might have made me a hater. I Deserve It doesn't suck, but the rest is a showcase of the worst trends in music at the time. It's lyrically vapid and overly edited. The heavy rhythm tracks clash with the vocals and the melodies. It plays dress-up with country without seriously embracing it. It's simultaneously empty empowerment and adolescent hedonism. The electronic manipulation is grating and meaningless. Also, the bonus track is insulting. It turns a song of grief and reflection into a flat, poppy dance track. It sands away any meaning or personality and replaces it with a polished corporate product. It truly is representative of the sound the 2000's. Also, it fails on a large, structural level, as opposed to other albums on this list that I hate on a pure, sonic, moment to moment level. Because of that, I guess it's not a one.

Just gonna put it out there... I don't think that late-90s, early 00s Madonna was really at the peak of her career or putting out can't miss, game changing albums.

Alright. When I listened to the last Madonna album, I thought it was a fluke that it was so bad, but I'm beginning to think that at some point in her career, she just got really bad.

Buena mierda. Puritos bangers. La Madonna metiéndole un autotune hyperpopero que ya quisiera la Charli. A algún tema me dan ganas de meterle unos 808s potentes y cambiar el mundo. What it feels like for a girl es un tema y medio. Toques trip hop bastante chulos también. Insertar chiste de que Carti le robó el flow bar for bar o algo. Buena música.

I really liked this but Music (the song) is one of the most annoying songs I've ever heard. Madonna's cover of American Pie also isn't that great.

Awful. The absolute worst. The cover of American Pie is the worst thing I've ever heard. Not just limited to music, either. That includes all sounds. Ever.

Starts off strong with Music, Impressive Instant, which is an attempt to get to somewhere that doesn't necessarily work and Runaway Lover then trails off until the behemoth and gut punch which is What It Feels Like For A Girl. Paradise (Not for Me) makes me hate it viscerally. French was a cunty choice, that could've been executed better. Gone then redeems the album. Why should I feel sad for something I never had, oh Madonna that is girlhood I fear. American Pie is confusing, but not as horrible as I anticipated.

It's really well made but it's still boring, commercial pop music. But that's OK, nothing bad about music that people enjoy and makes them move! I'll give it a 3 because it's much better than most current day equivalents (sorry, Taylor).

it’s fine. madonna has stronger, sharper records // fun, a little sexy, clearly built for movement, dancing // very of its time, but in a way i enjoy rather than resent // production leans into club pop without fully committing to risk, but! vocoder production is good and enjoyable // music title track is a great opener, immediate and confident // runaway lover is underrated, playful and loose // what it feels like for a girl is doing something most mainstream pop girlies today wish they were brave enough to attempt; vulnerable, political, restrained; kind of a softer courtney love energy // paradise might be my fav // gone would have been a perfect closer; reflective, melancholy, genuinely earned // then american pie happens ): the original song is sacred, it is a cultural artifact, it is already complete; covering it adds nothing, reveals nothing, improves nothing it flattens the album’s emotional landing and feels wildly unnecessary ending the record there feels like drinking a beer and waking up with a headache // overall enjoyable, occasionally great, but not essential madonna

The production is annoying and outdated, but the songs themselves are pretty good. 2.5/5.0: Mixed

this was pretty bad. i dont understand the production choices they made on this, they dont really fit these songs at all. the only song that really interested me was dont tell me and that was mostly the intro.

The first song is absolute trash. I don't care for this style of music. The album gets a second star only because it's Madonna and she's not without incredible talent, even if it's tragically misapplied on this album.

Such a sterotypical 2000's pop album, I loved it.

Actually listening to a Madonna album is a good example of why I'm doing this. Enjoyed Don't Tell Me with its fairy unique stuttering background, and the slightly more stripped back I Deserve It. In contrast, the auto tune on several songs and especially Nobody's Perfect feels horribly dated. The cover of American Pie at the end of the album on spotify is one of the worst things I've ever heard, but I think it is a bonus track. Overall a very 2000 album! 3/10

Insane how many A+ runs Madonna has had, through consistent evolution and daring to adopt new styles.

Jeden z jej najlepších.

Music ist das achte Studioalbum der US-amerikanischen Sängerin Madonna. Es erschien im September 2000 bei Maverick/Warner Bros. Records und wurde zwischen 1999 und 2000 aufgenommen, vor allem in den Sarm West/East Studios in London, mit weiteren Sessions in Guerilla Beach (Los Angeles) und The Hit Factory (New York). Das Album bewegt sich überwiegend im Pop- und Dance-Pop-Bereich mit deutlichen elektronischen Einflüssen und integriert Aspekte aus Funk, Rock und Folk. Die Produktion erfolgte durch Madonna selbst mit französischem Einfluss durch Mirwais Ahmadzaï, unterstützt von William Orbit, Guy Sigsworth und weiteren Co-Produzenten. Bekannte Songs auf Music sind neben dem Titelsong „Music“ auch „Don’t Tell Me“ und „What It Feels Like for a Girl“, die alle als Singles veröffentlicht wurden. Weitere hervorstechende Titel sind „Impressive Instant“, „Runaway Lover“, „Amazing“ und „Paradise (Not For Me)“. Das Album markiert eine Fortsetzung von Madonnas Interesse an elektronischen Klängen nach Ray of Light (1998), kombiniert mit tanzorientierten Arrangements und experimentelleren Elementen. Die Produktion erzeugt eine klare, rhythmusbetonte Kulisse, in der Madonnas Stimme zwischen verfremdeten und konventionelleren Momenten variiert. In der abschließenden Bewertung zeigt Music Madonna auf einem populären Höhepunkt ihres Schaffens, mit mehreren kommerziell erfolgreichen Singles und einer stilistischen Mischung aus Mainstream-Pop und elektronischer Klangästhetik, die sowohl tanzbare Tracks als auch introspektivere Momente umfasst. Ich kann mit diesem Popgedudel einfach absolut nichts anfangen!

god this album actually sucks

i really like some of the more introspective moments on this album, some surprising freshness for a pop album (Gone has got some real trip-hop vibes, Amazing is giving proto-hyper pop).

It's only in the last 15 years that she's become a batty old diva. Before that she was still a diva but one who made some petty good albums. I don't care too much for the autotune experiments, and the American Pie cover was brave, and ultimately a car crash, but the rest is ok. 3½

Wow. Madonna is criminally underrated. I knew this album was good but it's honestly so much better than I remember if I've even ever listened all the way through it. I don't think it's her best and it's not quite a 5 star album for me but a lot of good stuff here. Madonna's influence on 20th/21st century pop music is just insane. The longevity of her career how she came out fully formed but then kept reinventing herself to stay interesting. Really laid out a road map for all the modern pop star Renaissance we've seen in the past 25ish years Miley, carley rae jepsen, lady Gaga obviously, Britney, Christina, the list goes on. What a fucking icon.

Que moderna ela, parece muito uma vibe Britney. A mais famosa eu nunca tinha ouvido. Gostei da versão da American Pie dela. Darei um 3*, músicas boas, mas não me chamou muita atenção.

Such a generic name for an album. But this does bring massive nostalgia. Not sure that Madonna overusing autotune constitutes classic status.

I promise never to change the station on Holiday, but that's it.

Meh. A fun listen, but not for me. The end of the album really fell off for me and felt way too disjointed.

“I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows“ -bart simpson

not he best album from Madonna

"Music" is the second commercial pop album I've had within a week. Some sections were unbearable to listen to. I'm not a big fan of Madonna, especially after hearing "Music". The only thing I loved about "Music" is the backing tracks by Ahmadzai and others. If it weren't for the production value, I would've had a worse experience. 2 stars for "Music".

Um álbum dançante e gostoso de ouvir! Thumbs up pra I deserve it, que dá uma descida no ritmo sem perder a atmosfera e energia do álbum. Amazing e dont tell me merecem vênias também!

Chirpy pop, cohesive upbeat beepy ambience. I don't love it, but I have found myself putting it on in the background a few times when Im in the mood for this type of vacuity.

frankly boring

Mostly okay. Some dance floor songs, some radio songs. Madonna appears to accomplish what she set out to do here. Mostly not my thing but she does it very well so there's that. I did skip the auto tune song, using that as an effect is like fingernails on a chalkboard to me. Oh no, did not need that cover of "American Pie". Not at all.

I had it better in mind. 2,7

In which a rich, middle-aged lady shows herself to be about five years behind the club culture curve. Then has a smash hit anyway. Not saying it's terrible but it's a shame that this is how the mainstream operates.

The fact that this album was mostly produced by Mirwais is really what gives it any major credibility. Beyond that, 25 years later, I don’t think this album has aged all that well. It sounds very stereotypical of late 90s and early 2000s pop that was trying to merge with the EDM scene of that era. Overall, I highly doubt I’ll ever revisit this album in the future.

This is it. This is the year that music died. This album was the kill shot. We sat back and let this garbage become popular enough to influence mainstream music and it has never recovered. 1/10

Very interesting - this was my first time ever listening to Madonna in a real way. I’m not sure what I was expecting but it didn’t interest me in the way I thought it might. I can only imagine that this was influential for its time but personally not my favorite.

Thought this was really fun. Lot a stuff I wasn't as keen on, but some of the tracks are really smooth. The ones produced by William Orbit especially so.

Music - 3/5 Impresive Instant - 0/5 Runaway Lover - 2.5/5 I Deserve It - 1/5 Amazing - 2.5/5 Nobody's Perfect - 0/5 Don't Tell Me - 2.5/5 What It Feels Like for a Girl - 3.5/5 Paradise (Not for Me) - 1/5 Gone - 2/5 American Pie - 0/5 That was some bland and overproduced pop BS. I don't know how I listened to the whole thing, but there were some bright spots (Music is a guilty pleasure type of song, What It Feels... is an actually half-decent song). The autotuned and robotic voices really kill this thing. How was this critically acclaimed. All I'm realizing is that the early aughts were not a good time for music. Overall: 1/5 Favorites: Music, What It Feels Like for a Girl

Crazy how big Madonna got without ever actually putting out a good album

Was dreading having to listen to this but it was more fun and better than expected

A bunch of terrible lyrics and bland music held together by ear candy

Did not have high expectations, but was pleasantly surprised at getting mostly chill trip hop vibes for about half of the album.

I didn’t like it

Alrighty. Interesting... Not even sure what to say about this, not a big fan at all, but at least so far on the 2nd song it's a bit better than that Britney album I had to listen... Cannot see giving this more than 2 stars, I highly doubt even after I listen to it whole, that my opinion will change that much. Maybe even 1

When it bangs, it bangs. The bangers are really damn good, a couple of Madonna’s best singles here. There are 2/3 tracks that really don’t live up to the high standard of the rest of the album but I really enjoyed most of it. I personally prefer William Orbit’s production to Mirwais- it’s more enveloping and immersive but these are small things. A great pop album and a great timestamp in Madonna’s career. Best: What it Feels Like For a Girl Worst: I Deserve It

First half of this album was definitely a 4/5 for me but the last half realllllly dragged for me. A lot of real fun and experimental production on this thing that had me grooving on the better tracks. The more acoustic guitar centered tracks really feels like the progenitor to the dreaded 'mid' pop music that would follow in the 2000s. I feel like slower tracks aren't Madonna's forte.

too techno-y :(

i had high expectations for this since it's madonna but i was disappointed

Was fun. Not my style though. 2.5

Not her best album. I guess autotune was new at the time, but not something I enjoy.

Generic electro pop drivel

this cover of the classic song "American Pie" should be a crime

Incredible how bad this is

The cover had me expecting a completely different sound. Liked some songs, hated others. Middle of the road for me

The cover of American Pie was definitely a choice, and not really one I approve of. The rest of the album was alright. Definitely a Madonna reinvention album. I do prefer her mid-80s stuff though.

I’ve never been much of a Madonna fan, but I didn’t hate this music. I thought the production was fantastic, I think it’s different than what I typically stereotype Madonna and her music and considering this is her 8th album, it’s easy to write off a lot of artists at that point.

bastante basura, he pasado como 6 canciones, nunca mas

Not for more at all.

Weird that she has her country music costume on but the album is mostly dance club fare. Her voice sounds pretty good here but I’m assuming some electronic manipulation is likely going on. At any rate this music is not for me but is does have a generally decent sound. Fans of this style should enjoy it.

Didn't like it at the time. Don't like it now.

There was a time when Madonna was of universal significance, where everyone knew her, listened to her, bought her records. Even your Nanna knew "Material Girl" In more recent years, everyone still knows her, but less as an artist and more as a punchline. This album comes about half way between these two extremes. She was still selling records, still getting critical praise, but the days when a new Madonna Video was an event were long behind her. She was coming off the success of "Ray of Light" and seemingly could do no wrong. But Music is nowhere near as strong as that album. Ray of Light had similar studio production antics, but had them applied to actual songs, with Verses, Choruses and Bridges. The tracks on Music don't seem like songs. They're more like beats with words over the top. I imagine that Music is quite the influential album. If Ray of Light was a bit like Madonna catching up with what was happening at the time. Bjork had released Homogenic, Kylie Minogue had released Impossible Princess, Missy Elliot had released Super Duper Fly, all highly produced electronica. But Music was Madonna pushing the things she tried on Ray of Light further into the future. It's not as strong as Ray of Light, but it's probably more significant.

When this came up as my album of the day I was less than thrilled. This isn't what I want for Sunday morning dog walking in the cold rain and snow. Well, I couldn't have been more wrong. This is outta sight. Who knew I would enjoy downtempo electro dance pop so much? Quick aside, I try to not call people out for their reviews but come the fuck on, comparing her cover of American Pie to war crimes and human rights violations. It's a 4 minute version of a folk rock classic, not dropping bombs on women and children. Criminy, take a breath and actually listen to what you're saying. But anyway, this is another prime example why Madonna has been one of the most successful artists of all time.

bullshit ass title. Shoud be Kinda Shit Music. Veery early 2000s sound. Definitely didn’t age well. But also it just doesn’t have the bops I expect from someone like the big Madonna. Absolutely not an album you have to listen to before you die.

A pretty interesting pop album and quite a different sound from Madonna

I was in high school and college when Madonna first came out with her self-titled debut album followed by Like A Virgin and True Blue - and she became a superstar over the course of that time She was so pervasive and popular that you couldn't not be aware of her at the time. However, I wasn't digging it and never got into her. It just wasn't for me I guess. It seemed it was meant for the girls and not for a guy. Somehow when the Ray of Light album came out in 1998, I finally connected with one of her works and really liked a bunch of songs on that album. Maybe we just intersected since she was having kids around that time and so was I. This one (Music) came out as the next one after Ray of Light and so I gave it a chance. First three tracks don't do it for me, but I like 6 of the last 7 songs. I like the acoustic guitar + electronic vibe of tracks like "I Deserve It", "Nobody's Perfect', "Don't Tell Me", and "Gone". Plus "Amazing" and "Paradise (Not For Me)" are pretty cool. I am actually a little surprised that this album is on this list. I didn't realize it was considered "critically acclaimed". Good for her to have a few on here. Bottom line recommendation - if you are only familiar with Madonna's most famous stuff from the 80s and early 90s and that never grabbed you - give this one a chance. Liked songs on Spotify: 6/10 Rating: 3/5

This hasn’t aged well and I didn’t like it when it came out

I like Madonna but this album is not it. Some of the songs have awful lyrics and some of the performances are genuinely annoying, especially the painful whisper lyrics. 'what it feels to be a girl's was only okay track. The American pie cover confirmed the 1. Jesus Christ it's bad

One fun song that has lasted as nostalgia but otherwise horrific

ui das album und wies tönt hani soo nöd gern. so de computer 2000er choppy stuff. music isch so en schlechte soong. so bi allne ambitione wo bide madonna au bewundernswert sind mit ihrem erneuerigsdrang, ich find do isch sie ine meeeega komischi richtig. runaway lover au es nüt vomne song, sehr dance mässig aber nöd so richtig well d melodie isch huuuere moll und trurig. i deserve it isch au fett ass mann huuere lasch würkli. und s tönt au afoch nervig? amazing isch chliiii besser. aso s het chli drive und no schöni background gsäng. dont tell me het de papi us irgendme grund if ipod gha früener. de isch huere iigängig. aber de komisch start stop gitarreding findi immernonig cool. what it feels mike isch okay i guess? ich bin echt au chli überrascht wie wenig spass ich han und wie guet das anschinend achoo isch domols. american pie isch glaub s einzige cover und ich finds de best. vorallem d gitarre am schluss vo. refrain isch reeecht geil. einzigs mol woni d instrument cool find. glaub dasch es 2. jop es isch.

HAHAHAH ich hasse und liebe dance HAHAHAHAH WIE FUNNNNN??? I deserve it isch chli ruhiger aber reecht catchy de gsang bi paradise ischmer jz chli too much aber allgemein findis album so vill cooler alsi denkt hett american pie HASSI hmm guets 3 oder knapps 4i? hetmi uf jede fall positiv überrascht

I have to imagine there is another Madonna album on this list because if not, this is a sad representation of what she can do. I mean, the album is fine overall but nothing spectacular. I see why the songs that became hits were chosen - nothing else really stands out and I just feel like it is trying too hard to be a relevant pop/edm album but doesn’t hit the mark on either very well.

Why is this here?