Reviews (page 2 of 8)
Good start but then I completely lost interest half way.
Not the worst album on this list by any means but pretty far from ‘hear before you die’ territory. Sounds very dated.
Starts pretty strong. This fares better when it indulges in hard pop and dance sounds of the time. Loses steam with all the ballads, which comprise a surprising amount of this. Pick the tempo up and we’re back in business.
Loved it!
What da synthesizer She is trying SO hard to be attractive, but it just ain't working
Starts off OK, second half of the album is barely listenable
I though the first quarter was complete garbage - not a fan of the experimental vocals - it was heading straight towards a 2. I thought possibly maybe this was the album sound, but no, it opened up in a good way in the last half and got rid of the terrible club music-like vocals. Mostly I think this album is an album I've completely forgot about other than certain melodic moments, so I personally don't think this is a must-hear in anyway. I feel because it has Madonna on it as the artist name that it's made people overrate it because of that and think this is a maddening release. I think I could live my life without this one. Highlight Song/s: "Don't Tell Me" and "What It Feels Like for a Girl"
Artiste connue et détestée. Je n’ai pas pu aller au bout de cet album sans intérêt. L’accompagnement electronica/dance est mauvais, et je n’aime pas le chant bourré d’effets et d’autotune. A fuir. =>1/5
This was far from a country album and too techno dance club vibe for my taste.
It seemed to be trying to do pop and dance music at the same time and it didn’t work
Better than I thought it was gonna be tbh. The back half really drags but the front side is pretty solid. I'm never gonna listen to it again, but I was pleasantly surprised.
Sounds just like an extension of Ray of Light-more house/techno/electronica/auto tune tracks. And back half of album really drags. Not really sure why I HAD to listen to this…..
Madonna stays relevant 15 years after her debut when’s she’s 42. That shouldn’t matter but unfortunately it does. Quite incredible. 4.5
Surprisingly good. Must admit its an extremely polished production. very listenable and pretty flawless. I dont buy her albums but this was very consistently good and more entertaining than I expect. Decades of production evolution, and the best music professionals money can buy. She never stops reinventing.
Madge is one of the iconic, all-time great pop artists, no arguments, and this is one of her better albums with some great singles on it. I note that this has been expunged from more recent editions of 1001 Albums, presumably because it is so similar in vintage, style and intent to Ray of Light (and Ray of Light is clearly the superior album). And Madonna is an amazing pop artist, but, as a pop artist, probably better represented by singles than albums. And the singles here are bangers. There are some production elements that date the album -- the occasionally egregious autotune, the digital glitch effects, the synth that goes "weeeeeeee-oooooooo-yoooooooooooow" -- but these are largely all forgivable. If you push into the cutting edge of fashion, then your records will eventually end up sounding of their time. I am less forgiving of the bonus track cover of 'American Pie'. Not because I feel that the song is somehow sacred -- my eternal and burning hatred of that song is a matter of public record -- but rather because she has somehow made it even worse. It is four full minute shorter than Don McLean's original album version -- thank heavens for small mercies -- but it still feels stilted and joyless and it drags on forever before coming to an abrupt and anticlimactic end. I blame the record company for the inclusion of this mistake. Everyone should own at least one of Madonna's singles compilations; they are full of bangers and show her at her best. Personally, I love The Immaculate Collection, although I understand if you also want some of her post-1990 hits as well. For me, Music would only scrape into her top five studio albums, but it is still a very strong pop album. Most pop artists would kill for an album this good.
I haven’t listen to any full Madonna records before but wow that was fun! Disco? Check! Pop? Check! Cool ass production? Check! I’m a bit young to have listened to Madonna at her peak but I’m starting to get the hype just from this album. Musssssicccccccc
(8.2)
It’s hard for me to get in the mindset to appreciate Madonna in the first place, much less 2000s Madonna.
Lots of interesting production across this album. Maybe I've been sleeping on Madonna?!?!
One decent track. The rest is garbage.
not very good, but there were a couple tracks that make it not a 1 star, I enjoyed Gone and Music.
Ah a 2000’s Madonna album. I didn’t need to listen to this, I heard the title track enough on Much Music when I was 16 and well it could have stayed there. What a terrible song, what a terrible album. I will admit that Don’t Tell Me kinda scratched an itch of mine, I think the song kinda sucks but I was into it. To pile on a bit more, I think Madonna tried to tag in late on the “Girl Power” movement with her lazy contribution of “What it Feels Like to be a Girl” and to pile on the even further, this album art is dumb. 2 stars
Think this Madonna may be going places.
proto charli xcx. idk why ppl hating this fye
Another record that immediately takes me back to watching TRL when I got home from middle school in 98-00. It feels like the singles from "Ray Of Light" just ended and then "Music" showed right up to hold Madonna's place on the countdown. I wasn't prepared for some of the aggressive autotune on this album. I know that was kinda in vogue (see what I did there?) at the time, but this feels a lot more garish than I like to remember it. What a time. I'm also not convinced this one NEEDS a spot on the list... It kinda feels like 1.) Madonna has been so broadly influential that Mr. Dimery felt that she should have several records on the list, even if they aren't specifically important on their own. 2.) There was some recency bias when the original list was made that compelled him (and/or the critics who helped him) to favor "Ray Of Light" and "Music". I'm not convinced they're her best, but I've also not listened through her whole discography.
Pop die niet licht verteerbaar is, en verder ook niets om het lijf. De 1-2 leuke nummers redden de plaat niet.
Don’t tell me, and music are classic Madonna hits, but the rest filled some auto tuned mediocrity. Definitely expected better
I know this album was sort of meaningful in the overall Madonna catalog in that it was a reinvention and produced a few bit hits. But overall, it's sort of meh and fairly forgettable and another example of an album deep in an artist's catalog that probably could have been skipped to make room for something else that is not represented.
The cowgal album cover is extremely confusing - I'm sure there's a story there but I don't know what it is ... This wasn't bad - another "this is never going to be my thing" album, but there were a few I liked (the last song in particular), and I admire the adaptability. I'm officially lodging a complaint, however, that we're getting 3 Madonna albums on here and not one early one which was (old man voice) by far her best era. I guess I'm Mr. Blue when it comes to Madonna.
I couldn't figure out what was going on with that album.
It’s Madonna
A weird one for the list, feels pretty generic. Doesn't really have any noteworthy Madonna hits on it. Varies between a few songs that I found pretty decent (Music, Amazing, Gone) and a few songs that I thought were genuinely atrocious (Nobody's Perfect, What It Feels Like For a Girl). The rest was just extremely whatever. Of all the Madonna albums, why this one?
Madonna is great, but this is not one of my favorite albums. ★★★
Really did not care for this, simply not music I would ever listen to.
Man, this was way better than I expected. Actually extremely mad fupping interesting. I personally really like Madonna's voice, and the production I think paired so well with it. A couple ones that really stood out to me were music, nobody's perfect, and don't tell me. There are a few times there where I did a double take because I thought my phone was glitching, but it was actually just the production being erratic. Really good just a few skips.
Never listened to Madonna in my life, but I did not think this is what they meant. Genuinely was so shocked on the first track. This album was such an amazing marriage of what I expected from her in an acoustic singer songwriter, and this completely new sound so typical of Y2K, but done perfectly with that weird French producer. This is the kind of sound. I absolutely love in the weird noises that go perfectly together my one complaint came up in about trek five I thought songs were running a little too long, but then I realized every time I would start thinking that about a song there would be some new sound that the producer brought in that was just so weird and awesome. Throbbing bass lines. I love that suppressed drum that uncovers into the chorus in runaway lover. Fuck fucking yes. Genuinely no skips here for me. However, the standouts for me are music, impressive, talent, what it’s like for a girl, don’t tell me, and paradise. Every song is so interesting.
Extremely interesting throughout. It’s crazy how much of this album impacted pop music today. Like charli was raised on it. Not exactly my favorite style
Interesting album honestly. Guess it was a bit of a surprise to her base. Has aged fairly well for a 2001 pop album too!
I'll never understand the popularity of Madonna. All she did was poorly copy other artists that weren't famous.
Well produced and some good tunes but a bit too soulless and calculated for me.
I was not excited to listen to this but I actually really liked it. Maybe not a top album for me but still it’s nice to be pleasantly surprised. Will come back again some day.
I really expected to hate this outside of the singles, but other than the odd dance-y song I thoroughly enjoyed this record and found myself adding several songs I’d not heard before to my liked songs playlist. A very pleasant surprise.
Auto-tune fuckery.
Hey Mr Dinnery, don’t play this album for me! Why this bog standard pop music made it to the list I’ve no idea (if it wasn’t by Madonna it surely wouldn’t be in contention). And to cap it off, a horrific cover of American Pie- you’ll wish the music died alright.
Judging from the cover, you might be expecting a country-influenced album. Instead, we get a very electronic album with some experiemental influences, in a similar vein to Ray of Light, her previous album also produced by William Orbit. It's definitely my kind of thing. That being said, not all of it grabbed my attention, but highlights like the title track, 'Runaway Lover' 'What It Feels Like for a Girl' and 'Paradise (Not for Me)' are enough to warrant a low 4 rating.
Madonna has some great songs, but unfortunately none of them were on this album. It wasn’t terrible, just pretty dull, with rather grating glitchy electronic production and vocoded/autotuned vocals, and very poor lyrics (case in point: ‘I want to singy, singy, singy, like a bird on a wingy, wingy, wingy’). Along with ‘Amazing’, the catchy title track was one of the stronger songs, although the claim on Wikipedia that it has ‘political implications’ because she uses the word ‘bourgeoisie’ genuinely made me laugh out loud. Mostly fine, but not one I’ll seek out again, hence a high 2 stars.
Banging. Sonically, this comes across as an underground album - urgent, mysterious. Good tunes, too But it runs out of steam during side 1. If it was all as good as the first 3 tracks it would be a four star LP. But, no. 2 stars
I don't think there could be a more rando Madonna album here. Sure, she's immensely influential, but this album isn't really one of her profound ones. Yea, we know the first track, but the rest just kind-of blend into forgetfulness.
ooit was deze dame relevant, maar dat is al zeer veel manen geleden
i forgot she was white
Do I have to?
just not that into her you know Will I listen to again: 0%
Título bem pretensioso. É simultaneamente fascinante e decepcionante ouvir esse álbum. Primeiramente, é inegável que a sonoridade desse disco é bem profética das direções estupefatas que a música Pop ia tomando nos anos seguintes. Por outro lado, fica aquela sensação que a Madonna simplesmente estava tentando de tudo pra tentar se manter dentro do zeitgeist. Os efeitos “futuristas” no disco são legais. Com diversos glitches e aquele autotune bem característico da virada do milênio que foi tão zombado. Realmente um produto do seu tempo, mas não vejo isso como algo inerentemente negativo. Tem um charme. Legalzinho, mas não ouviria mais vezes. Bacana. Ok. 3.5/5
No. Just no.
Not her best work, obvs. Why is this even here? Still, it’s freakin’ Madonna, and we get “Music” and “What It Feels Like for a Girl.”
Close enough, welcome back Cowboy Carter Not her best I must say, really preferred Ray Of Light, and surely there’s an album from her earlier career more suitable? Surprised to see flagrant auto tune as a stylistic choice on an album this early, sounded very distracting, and the skipping at the start of Don’t tell me was certainly a decision
Hot ass I feel like I was too harsh on the last Madonna album and have been meaning to go back and give it another chance But god damn Nobody’s perfect sounds like what everyone thinks reality awaits sounds like and the American pie cover sounds like really bad karaoke 1.5
Couple of bangers, lots of filler, mostly a good time. The music videos from this album are an odd reminder of how many times Madonna has reinvented her image.
Toen dit album uitkwam dacht ik eigenlijk al dat niemand Madonna meer echt serieus nam. Net als dat opgezette lijk van Cher met d'r hit 'Believe'. Blijkbaar hoort dit album toch thuis in een snoblijst. We doen het er maar mee. De openingstrack ken ik en vind ik daarom nog wel aardig, maar daarna begint voor mij eigenlijk het grote uitzitten. Ik vind dit redelijk ruk verder, ik kan er niks mee, heb er geen zin in. Daar staat tegenover dat het wel een prima productie is natuurlijk, Madonna heeft genoeg centen om dat allemaal netjes af te kopen. De nummers op dit album interesseren me gewoon echt helemaal niet. Ik heb hier nog het album 'Fantastic' van Toy-Box liggen, die bevindt zich een beetje in het zelfde straatje met dezelfde geluidseffecten en die zet ik 10 keer liever aan. 'Don't tell me' halverwege het album is ook nog wel aardig, die kennen we uiteraard ook. En aan het einde heb je nog wat herkenbaarheid met die potsierlijke 'American Pie' cover. Twee sterren.
Ok for house cleaning
This guy was meant for me I was meant for him This guy has dreamt of me And I have dreamt of him This guy has danced for me And I have danced for him Wow, poet laureate stuff here. The opening lyrics to “I Deserve It” illustrate the average song on this album. With her career going on its 18th year by the release of this album, the ambiguously titled “music”, Madonna shows how she was running out of ideas quickly. The music itself is pretty decent and varied in Madonna’s usual experimental style, but this just feels like someone clinging to stardom at the end of a career, not a fresh reimagining of someone who built a career on being a chameleon and trendsetter. Right on the heels of Cher, Madonna also made use of autotune immediately as it became available, which adds an element to the electronic sound on several songs. Well used, for a technology that would soon be abused. ⭐️⭐️.5
I am a HUGE Madonna fan! Im also realistic when it comes to my musical favorites. Having this and Ray of Light while omitting her eponymous debut is ridiculous. Honestly Madonna is one of the multitude of artists I adore and can admit are better suited for best of compilations. All of that is too much typing just to say 3 stars due to 3 solid singles and an album of pretty forgettable trip hop inspired songs that were common place for the time.
Stonking album, should be named Orbitals featuring Madonna
⭐⭐ Inte så speciellt, även med Madonna mått mätt finns det bättre och intressantare album. Låtskrivarmässigt tycker jag detta albumet är beige. Alldeles för få bra spår för att bygga ett helt album känns som en axelryckning att lyssna på det här albumet. Det blir en 2a. Bäst är Music, Don't tell me, Gone
Electronica/pop is not my thing but this made my morning walk go by faster. Credit to this album that I actually listened to it without skipping songs.
Feels trend hoppy in an inspired but misguided way. Production is so sick but too abrasive at times, those snares in music hurt. I think you can look at this as a sick experimental pop album or as a bad traditional pop album and I’m trying to put the traditional part to the side and just focus on if Laura Les made this. Stuff like runaway loser would bang if it came out today, like the production would be a little grosser but Underscores or Jane Remover type crew would put that out to acclaim. Maybe that’s a stretch but there’s an obvious comparison in a positive way. There are like crazy auto tune over just strange beats on here that are very reminiscent of current trends in electronic pop music. I wish my version had the American pie cover, I had to go searching for it: it is not as bad as everyone says. It’s just a pop cover, not a war crime. Makes me want to rate this album higher to counterbalance those dumb reviews but the headache I got from these snares is keeping me down at 3.
I quite liked this album and fair play to Madonna for continuing to evolve her sound, it's not easy to stay relevant as long as she has. Did she have to include all that auto-tune though?
I can't believe Carti stole the name of this album for his most recent album smh. This is a mid 4
Correct
It wasn't that bad. Very 2000s
Made me feel physical revulsion. I did not like this, and I did not finish this.
I didn't like Madonn's music when it came out 45 years ago. Little has changed. It is a a combination of bubblegum and disco, neither of which I care for.
Dug this album
Just generic and boring. 80s Madonna had much more fun music
2.5
This album is poop from a butt.
Actually pretty cool production . Most songs are cool idk why I’m surprise but I am
Not in my edition of the book! 2000. 2 stars. A non-essential Madonna album that has was not innovative at the time, and which has not dated well. No idea why this is on the list. And the cover of "American Pie" is an abomination.
I don't like pop music. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ❌️ Revisit ❌️ ★★☆☆☆(4/10) Default Total reviewed : 420 Already owned : 93 Purchased : 21 To buy : 5 Nope : 301
Tää levy ei ole parasta Madonnaa ja levyn hitti on bonusbiisi ”American Pie”-cover. Ei oikein jäänyt mitään erityistä biiseistä mieleen, vaikka Madonnaa on tullut ennen tätä kuunneltua.
I’m not a massive Madonna fan, but I can appreciate that Ray of Light was a good album that basically reinvented her to a younger audience. This sadly, isn’t a very good album and has pretences of having country vibes, simply by wearing clothing in the videos and album cover like it’s a western movie and having a few guitars. It was given more airtime than it deserved on release. I’d argue that Confessions on a Dancefloor has more reasons to be on here that this album.
You're lucky to get this '2' rating Madonna...on the strength of Music and Don't Tell Me. I guess it's hard to be edgy when you are in your 40s.
Bleh 3/5
Very generic 2000s pop Fine for what it was but there’s no reason to listen to this again 2.5/5 Favorite: runaway lover
The opening song "Music" recaptured some of Madona's pop queen status reflecting a sound of the times. However, many songs after felt liked an exploration of experimental sounds missing their mark. Instead of having a pulse on the 2000s, it flatlined.
Good title track. Bored thereafter.
**An ok album
Why was this even in the fucking book?
I love Madonna and this was pretty cool
Not nearly as bad as I thought it would be. Kind of makes me wanna try some other one of her albums.
Not a 1 because I’ve heard 1s on here and this ain’t that bad.
I wish they had included her album Something to Remember instead. I do like Madonna, but pretty much exclusively pre-2000.
Just dreadful. A mechanical canary
I did this and Like A Prayer back to back, and it's fair to say that I'm an 80's Madonna Stan. Post 80's is just not for me. Dull and dated beats. "Paradise (Not for Me)" absolutely stinks and the less said about her version of "American Pie" the better
I apologize and don't want to offend any communities but other than Music, this album is trash Best Song: Music Rating: 4.5/10 Stars: 2
How anyone can call this music is beyond me
2 out of 5. Her 80's output is more tolerable.
Un album que se oye muy distinto a su época. Tiene temas muy buenos y entretenidos. El cambio de electro-pop a canciones más lentas es bueno a través del album.
Pop well delivered and produced, never my thing.
7+ / 10
The title of the album is misleading cause this is anything but music. How does anyone listen to this?
Not her best work. Not her worst, but towards the bottom of her list.
A couple more uptempo songs from being a masterpiece.
Sound in time.
Weird that I’m giving Madonna a 2, but i couldn't deal with the auto tune…. or the tunes either.
Meh. Feels forced.
I enjoyed it, it might not have been the best dance pop album out there, but its fun and vibey. Also the american pie cover was fine, people just can't stand a girliepop covering a classic in her style, grow up.
This was a fun dance pop album, very inoffensive though. I think Madonna could've explored around a little more. That being said, the American Pie cover was not that bad and y'all are just a bunch of babies.
I don't really understand what this record is doing on the list. I'm not a fan of Madonna, but I can recognize her influence on 80s pop music ; she clearly deserved to have at least one of her early albums here. But this ?... It's just noisy, commercial dance-pop, a genre that has dozens of more talented and more relevant artists. This artificial cash grab is so entirely devoid of soul or inspiration that I had to struggle to not rage-quit after three songs. ''Paradise'' was the only saving grace, but it was too little, too late. One of the most annoying albums for me so far, plagued by autotune and vocoder abuse. Fuck this junk and the industry that enabled it. 2/10
À part 2 morceaux , je n’ai pas aimé cet album qui m’a ennuyé . Madonna a su mieux faire , peut être est ce le virage electro pop qui a attiré la curiosité de certains … mais non ça ne vaut pas 3 étoiles
Probably the only Madonna album I can vaguely get through without despair. The dance-pop stuff is still pretty awful to my ears, but the three tracks that bring in more varied influences work noticeably better. Still, I won’t be coming back to this one anytime soon.
Never one to back down for a complete stylistic change. It's very much a product of a time, somewhat impressive for someone who already had a 2 decade long career at that point. It's kind of dumb dance music and sort of follows the same style as Ray of Light. Hard not to enjoy it for what it is. American Pie is a goofball cover but it works surprisingly well and notches it up to a positive rating.
At first I wasn't super impressed and thought it was just some poor examples of pop songs, but shifting my mindset I realized it was instead some fairly decent examples of some electronic music of the late 90s. The beats were solid, though unfortunately the songs didn't typically go anywhere and would become fairly repetitive fairly quickly. Overall there were some solid tracks on there. I wouldn't ever choose this over her fantastic 80s material but it was pretty decent.
Basically the same as Imagine by John Lennon. The music is fine (that American Pie cover was certainly a choice), but the massive ego running underneath the entire album squanders its potential.
She knows how to craft fun dance music for sure, but it lacks the spark of previous work. And god, do not listen to the lyrics. Sheesh. I could re-listen to many of these tracks, and she brings a good feminist energy to many of the songs. Which makes sense for the Grande Dame of Dance Music. Turn it off before the least essential cover of any song ever, though. Don McLean is mad enough without this garbage to fuel his rage.
A genuinely unexceptional album from Madonna. I like that she decided to lean into a country aesthetic while making nothing remotely close to country music.
Music 2.7 Impressive Instant 2.5 Runaway Lover 2.5 I Deserve It 2.4 Amazing 3 Nobody's Perfect 2.3 Don't Tell Me 2.8 What It Feels Like for a Girl 2.5 Paradise (Not for Me) 2.4 Gone 2.7 Score: 2.58
Fine--not really the sort of music I enjoy. Just more incredible that Madonna has remained relevant in so many different eras
Exciting first few tracks, but it sort of winds down from that. Still a cool album even if it doesn't hit as much as the start. Space music of sorts
Joa, kann man mal machen. Nen paar skips dabei, sonst auch sehr poppig aber passt schon
espectacular. la amo
No fav song
Meh, tho “music” is a banger, the rest of the album is just a big meh
I wasn't expecting to rate this album this well. Judging it by its cover, it seemed out of place on this list being released well after Madonna's prime. But interestingly, it's among the better electronic I've heard so far. I enjoyed Runaway Lover and Nobody's Perfect particularly.
I can't help but think the only reason this made the list is because it's Madonna. The same album released under a different name, I don't think it makes the grade to be in the 1001 albums list. I mean it's better than Murder Ballads, but... Should be re-titled "Girls Gone Vocoder Wild". Tracks like I Deserve It with her pure voice coming through were substantially better than the pure disco house Veronica Electronica bits. Nobody's Perfect seemed to be her apology for releasing that painfully bad track. The day the music died was the day this was released. I was a 2 up until that last track...
This was not my cup of tea to start, sounded like experiments on madonna gone wrong. But the end kind of saved it cause i liked the last few songs
I was shocked by how much I liked this, which is sort of the beginning of late era Madonna, but still feels fresh 25 years later? Certainly compared to other pop music from the late 90s.
Not great. I think this album began the decline of the Madonna era. Not a huge fan.
It’s fine. Not for me
I found this pretty bland overall. Don’t Tell Me was good though.
I remembered liking this album when I first heard it a couple years ago, and it held up really well on a revisit. I really enjoy the electronic pop sound, but what impressed me most was the pacing. It knows when to pull things back with songs like “I Deserve It” before picking the energy back up with “Amazing.” “Nobody’s Perfect” didn’t do much for me, but the album immediately rebounds with “Don’t Tell Me.” A fun, well-paced pop album that I enjoyed more this time around.
In my opinion, not as strong as TRUE BLUE or LIKE A VIRGIN, both of which I think actually belong on the list. I can hear why Dimery eventually took off the list, but I will admit that the 2000s was such an uninspiring music decade that this was one of the better albums from the early naughties.
it is ok
3.5
2.5
Light 3 maybe 3.5 faster songs were better but I enjoyed some of it
I was really excited for this one because I've never run a full Madonna album. Sorely disappointed, though. Kinda just sounds like a middle aged woman trying to connect with the youths. Bunch of cheeky sounds of the time wrapped up in a body of work. I actually don't hate the exploration and trying new things, but my GOD are the lyrics bad. They lyrics are absolutely terrible. Who were the writers?? The title song does a LOT of heavy lifting. It's an undeniable banger. It almost dragged this up to a 2 but alas, fell short.
that was so horrible and also she ruined an absolute classic banger of a song
1) Paradise (Not For Me) 2) Runaway Love 3) What It Feels Like for a Girl Least Favourite: Nobody’s Perfect
lekker
What a wet fart. I remember when it came out “Music” was everywhere. I have a soft spot for that one. It’s fun and it’s got a beat, plus she’s got that Bourgeoise line… but other than that, this has NOT aged well. Sounds like garbage and the songs are forgettable to a one.
No es un disco tan bueno, solo las canciones conocidas son buenas "Don't tell me" "American Pie" "Music"
Creative combination of electronic and acoustic sounds, it's got a rhythm and pulse and major bops. Queen of pop for a reason.
uhhhh idk about this one
There was a song or two when the album came out that gave me a I guess Madonna still has it nostalgia vibe. However I quickly forgot about it and 25 years later listening to it did not rekindle that feeling. Maybe for a die-hard Madonna fan this would be an OK album but no idea how it made the top 1000.
3.6
Meh. Not into it. 👎
I had low expectations but found this surprisingly tolerable.
out of the 4 Madonna albums i've listened to (this is the first one on the list), this is def the weakest one that i've heard. it's very experimental for being from the 2000's, having it's perks and flaws from being that. which there was other madonna albums on here instead of this tho.
I knew this album wasn’t great from the various times I read this album page during my over 500 days on this site. But surely it couldn’t be that bad. Boy was I wrong! It truly is that bad. I didn’t realise Madonna could make something so rubbish. The electronic sound with the stereotypical 00s voice that is not pleasant to listen to one bit (especially that terrible autotune voice in that one song). There was one good song, being Runaway Lover, but it’s not good enough to redeem this album. This is the only Madonna album I’ve ever listened to, so I wonder if every one of hers is exactly like this or do I have to blame Robert Dimery again?
1.5
I was never into Madonna. I obviously know who she is and all but I never like, followed her stuff. It's been an alright album. I'm thinking giving it 4 stars.
I grew up listening to Madonna, so I already knew and liked Music, Don't Tell Me and What It Feels Like for a Girl, which was my favourite. I also really liked Gone and Paradise (Not for Me) was okay. Nobody's Perfect really wasn't for me — I found the electronic sound and heavily processed vocals annoying. American Pie was okay, but I much prefer the original. Overall, a mixed album with some songs I'd definitely listen to again, but not one I'd play from start to finish.
No particularly good.
Not good
Another surprise for me with Madonna coming up trumps with a whole album of great tunes and not just the singles!
Oh my gosh, I was initially thinking I’d give this a 3 because it completely brought “Music” (the song) back into my orbit, which I totally forgot about. But then “Don’t Tell Me” and “What It Feels Like for a Girl” and I FORGOT HOW GOOD THESE SONGS ARE!! Especially how moving the latter is. This is why I am so grateful to be doing this—because it brings music back into my life I forgot about and that hit so much differently now than when I was younger!
Proof that once you have the name you can put anything out and people will buy it. A mundane collection of pop songs that if it wasn’t for the name would have dissapeared into the abyss. Far too much auto tune and nothing special to report at all. In fact the main thing to report is the war against crime that is the cover of ‘American pie’ how she got away with that again proves a name means everything. Bang average pop record. Best track- ‘don’t tell me’ Worst track- ‘paradise (not for me) Unless we include ‘American pie’ and then it speaks for itself!! 5/10 average then -1 for the cover! So 4/10
Madonna - Music This is dogshit kebab terrible. First off, her voice is characterless, dirgeful whine. Second her lyrics are infant school googoo gaga nonsense. Third, she just leeches off her collaborators. Case in point being that the tracks with Mirwais Ahmadzai and William Orbit would be perfectly ok as instrumentals. Best Track - None. But if I have to then Don't Tell Me Worst - I Deserve It. But we didn't. Absolutely fucking terrible. How the hell is this on this list? 2/10
I enjoyed it more than I expected. Some interesting music going on even if the lyrics didn’t grab me. Track 2 or 3 especially piqued my interest
...
People who think this is generic pop music need their head checked! Maybe it sounds more common now, but let's remember that Madonna was the first to do it! She brought this combo techno, country, folk, rock, funk sound into pop music. Anyone who does it today is thanks to her. This is such an enjoyable album. It's not my favorite of hers, and I think there are others that could be here instead, but it's an awesome album. So many great songs, spans many genres, the lyrics are meaningful and personal to her. And Music will always be a perfect pop song and always a banger!! Top Songs: Music, I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like For a Girl, Paradise, Gone
Never heard boring Madonna until now
Best Track - "Music"
Nothing to see here…
# Album Name: Music # Artist: Madonna # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: Wow, what a stinker. This has aged badly. # Top Tunes: Music # Would I listen to it again? No
Trying to hard to be relevant.
My uterus jumped
I went back and forth with this one. On occasion this album has Daft Punk-esque dance tunes. On other occasions it has a terrible Don McLean cover. Keeping me guessing I suppose.
5/10 We're now at the point where this sounds so terribly dated and uninspiring. I mean, until this project, I wouldn't have considered listening to pop albums like this seriously anyway, but then that is because of where I was as a young person when it came out with an interest in things that excited me, not bland filtered pop.
This album was all over the place too. Music was fun to dance to in the day, but I felt like it got a huge lift from whatever DJ version was spinning at the time. Everything else was ok. This didn't feel like controversial, edgy Madonna. The lyrics about not selling out were just cringey.
Don't Tell Me sounded choppy. Nobody's Perfect lowered this album down to a one. The autotune was painful!
Супер. Ни разу не слышал его от начала до конца. Эксперименты с электроникой делают его просто восхитительным. Хочу его на носителе.
I worked at Warner Music when this album was realised. Madonna was Warner’s highest selling artist. This was a solid album spawning 3 great singles. I preferred the remix of “what it feels like to be a girl”… the video is epic. The music video for Madonna's "What It Feels Like for a Girl" was directed by her then-husband, British filmmaker Guy Ritchie. Premiering in March 2001, the controversial, action-packed video features the pop star as a reckless woman embarking on an intense crime spree. This was peak Madonna.
3.5
Meh. Not a big fan. But it's not terrible.
9/10
This album is a great reminder of why I don't listen to Madonna. Most of the music is forgettable and the lyrics are vapid.
This was sort of sold to me as Madonna's experimental album, and I *really* don't think it delivers on this promise. Dare I say, Music really hasn't aged well. It's an album that hinges on the incorporation of electronic elements into electronic music, but the electronic elements here are clunky and kind of stiff, and while I did manage to get into this album on a few songs, I don't think it really pulls itself together long enough for me to come away with a particularly positive opinion. That being said, Amazing, What It Feels Like For A Girl, Don't Tell Me and Paradise (Not For Me) are strong songs. The acoustic guitar glitch stuff on Don't Tell Me is the most experimental thing on the album, and it's a unique moment, however it also reminds me that this album is supposed to have sort of a cowboy theme/aesthetic to it that never *really* materializes, and which just takes away from the cohesion of the project. Anyways, Amazing is probably the best pop song here. And What It Feels Like For A Girl is a great song with some really cool lyrics about gender. Paradise also has some cool lyrics which, I *think* are about religion, and it is also a trip hop inspired song with the coolest and most unique texture and tone on the album. Honestly, the second half of this is quite a bit more enjoyable than the first for me, but across the project there are enough songs that are too wrapped up in their aesthetic to let the songwriting really shine through. Although, interestingly enough, I'd say the lyrics across this thing are it's strongest aspect overall, Madonna has some really great, really personal writing. But I still don't think this makes it to a 3. And I know it's a bonus track, but this score is cemented by the American Pie cover, which isn't *terrible*, but it is baffling. It maintains almost none of the songwriting of the original, and isn't sold as Madonna's own thing. It's just a bizarre addition and frankly, kind of a jumpscare. This is not a bad album per se, but it has aged kind of awkwardly, and doesn't have a lot for me. If you *really* like Madonna, maybe give it a try though, there's probably something for you here.
Not my favorite Madonna, but enjoyable nonetheless. I do feel like the songs start to sound similar after a while. This album did spawn a lot of great gay DJ remixes though.
Not bad. Some of the songs were somewhat forgettable but there are some tunes on here.
Had some good songs on it, but about half was pretty meh? Might be worth a relisten.
Alot better than expected. A few jams here
I like music itself, but the mix isn't good. The treble is too accentuated.
This is #day706 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… this is my first Madonna record represented on the list. A little bit of a time machine this one is. In the early '00s, the title track used to be a radio jingle on Gala Radio, one of the local FM stations here in my hometown, Lviv. It was the station my brother and I would call to say hello on air and request a song during a program called Gala Lunch. And then our parents would discover the phone bill. Anyway, on Music Madonna is doing what Madonna always does: exploring new sounds and reinventing herself. That said, I don't think this is an essential record of hers. It's good, but, you know... Let it be a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day707.
Did not enjoy at all. Some of the worst music I've had so far. It's not offensive but it's not my cup of tea at all.
Not bad tbh, some bangers in there.
I found this one hard to listen to and not very enjoyable. The best thing to come from this album was the Above and Beyond remix of What it feels like to be a girl. I didn't find the version of American Pie to be good at all.
Madonna stopped being interesting many decades ago! In fact, in my case, *Ray of Light* was one of the last things of hers that I could still take in and digest without too much trouble. But after that, I stopped paying attention to what she does—artists who shout from the rooftops that they’re reinventing themselves when all they’re really doing is trying to keep up with trends and rake in a few more bucks over and over again! Forget it. Real icons are people like Tina Turner, David Bowie, Bruce Springsteen… they don’t go around acting like old people trying to be young; they keep up with the times without ceasing to be themselves, doing what they’ve always done and knowing when to stop and appreciate the journey! Here, with Madonna and this album, there’s little left to appreciate :-(
This was pretty easy-going actually, I'm pretty on-board with it. It's just quite nice overall, inoffensive, an easy listen... yes there's some rubbish autotune in there, but most of the synthy electronic stuff worked pretty well for me actually. 3.5 rounded down.
I was actually surprised by how much I enjoyed this because I did not care for the main singles when this came out. Always loved “What It Feels Like For A Girl,” though, but still prefer the remix to the album version. “I Deserve It,” “Amazing,” and “Nobody’s Perfect” are really great songs, and overall this album is pretty solid. The “American Pie” cover is atrocious, though. The album is like a 3.5 and without that cover I’d round up to a 4, but instead I’m rounding down.
I like some Madonna songs, but definitely not these ones. Feels both of the 00's and dated, but it is 2026...
Why do electronic music artists always want to sound like a robot?
Madonna ripped every single track off Len Houmous’ reject list. 2.5 7/11 Don’t Tell Me
Not the best Madonna record but it's still Madonna so it's still somehow catchy and well produced for the most part
Ok pop album, does what you'd expect
There were some nice moments on this album. I particularly liked "Don't tell Me" and "Paradise (Not for Me)" The rest of the album felt kind of awkward and unsure of what it was trying to be or do and I absolutely hated her cover of American Pie.
Some songs I thought were too weird for Madonna, but others I really enjoyed, especially I Deserve It. Evens out to a 3. Not sure what the country aesthetic is about though
Es bastante malo. Principalmente hablando de la reina del pop.
Another banger?! Favourite track: Don’t Tell Me
idk, not a big madonna fan, didnt do it for me
Me di cuenta q no sé nada de madonna, no sabía que esperar, pero no entiendo porq está este disco. Senti q estaba escuchando temas que quizá les gustarían a un super fan de madonna, a mí no.
Another day another 2000s album on this list from an artist past their prime because the authors didn’t know who was actually making good music in that decade It’s not the worst music I’ve ever heard, Madonna’s clearly a talented vocalist and I appreciate the effort to make something new. Runaway Lover is probably the best song on the album for me, very catchy and fundamentally a solid pop song The rest of this album just isn’t very good unfortunately. The majority of the songs on here kinda suck, Nobody’s Perfect in particular is just a bad song. I think the biggest thing that upsets me about this album is how non-genuine it feels. It really feels like she crammed this album full of industry trends and crowd pleasers (what the hell is American Pie doing on this album man…), and it just really doesn’t feel like Madonna I don’t think every individual moment is bad (like honestly the quality of the music itself is right around a 3), but this albums just kinda a mess for me. High 2 since it doesn’t deeply offend me, but this absolutely shouldn’t be on this list
and the worlds worst cover award goes to madonna!!!!
There are some interesting concepts and risks taken on this album. The second and third tracks feature well crafted electric beats. However, the rest of the album tries to do far too much at once and, more often than not, falls flat on its face. Autotune is frequently overused, and the blend of country and electric is questionable. The cover of "American Pie" is inexcusable. I admire the risks taken here and am sure it influenced others, but at the same time, the album didn't break any new ground and has aged very poorly.
I can make better music with my ballsack hitting a drum set
Sorry Madge, I love you, and Confessions II is the album of 2026 so far, but this album has not aged well at all. It feels like more of a relic than most, and its a struggle at times. American Pie is great though, you can suck it.
This is the third album by Madonna I’ve listened to on this list and probably my favourite. Despite the hit singles leaning into the squelchy French disco style it’s the more stripped back acoustic numbers that draw me in the most. Stripping back the production on songs like Gone there’s a real sense of fragility and emotional honesty. The production is excellent but it’s these quiet moments that really enjoy. An intriguing listen
oof… I'm not a fan. Pop music from this era had very little for me to latch onto. And this is definitely no exception. After 4 songs, I'm ready to call it. But I feel obligated to the project to do my best to finish it. …Oh god!! Not the really tacky, bad autotune! Please make it stop! Hey! Someone figured out how to automate the mute button! "Please don't tell me to stop." I already asked you earlier, Madonna. Is she trying to conjure some Kate Bush in that last track? Okay. That's over. I've heard worse. But it's got nothing for me here.
The album isn't nearly as bad as I imagined it would be. I've never been a fan of Madonna's, but some of the songs on Music - "Don't Tell Me", for example - are amazingly well produced and constructed. You can tell that considerable time and care went into the recording process.
It's Madonna taking something of a creative leap, embracing electronic dance music while retaining most of her pop sensibilities. Not my jam but I give a +1 for creative exploration by the Material Girl.
Мені здається, що цей альбом дуже перенасичений філерами. Можливо, вони колись рвали танцювальні майданчики, але зараз вони просто ніякі. Звчиайно тут є хороші пісні і супер хіт - Music. Але загальне враження скоріше ні.
Цей альбом звісно звучить дуже слабко після рей оф лайт і дуже часто виникає враження що постарішали ці пісні поганенько. Може не всі, але більша частина. Хоча і тут є приємні моменти, а загалом "мьюзік" мені звісно дуже віддає нульовими і викликає ностальгію за тими часами.
Meh
in her country era 🐎
Józek męską pipą let's goooooo Nie znałem tego albumu, bardzo miły, bardzo 2000s Btw fajnie, bo dzisiaj jest w slayu Madonna night a mnie tam nie ma, więc przynajmniej można sobie posłuchać
"Józek męską pipą", pięknie wyprodukowana elektronika, chwilami Reni Jusis, chwilami padaka (szczególnie American Pie)
Ok 2000 pop-electronic album from the icon Madonna. Some interesting production choices here, and they do well to fit the electronic sound well into different types of songs from dance-pop to more serious, slower songs. But ultimately, a forgettable album for me that doesn’t really stand above the pack.
I feel like Madonna adapted to the 90's and early '00's better than most '80's artists. Wasn't expecting the "American Pie" cover.
While it was not technically bad, I spent the whole album just wanting to move on to something else.
Music…really?!?
Absolute trash
Some ok beats and "What It Feels Like..." is great but this is mostly overproduced forgettable electropop with bad vocals all the way through. And the worst cover I've ever heard in my life to end it. Ugh.
3/5
2.5 Meh.
3.5
I kind of liked some of these songs, especially the ones she actually sang. The techno ones were not very good.
Why is this album included on this list? There are so many quintessential Madonna albums. This is not one of them.
I really love Madonna but not nearly as much as the writers of this list do, apparently. She always has great hits but the album tracks are just... there. The "American Pie" cover is an abomination, which makes this the lowest rated Madge album so far.
1.7 2x american pie cover was atrocious
She still had it, I loved "The day the music died"
Some songs were ok but holy shit this "American Pie" is TERRIBLE.
1.5
This is a sad attempt at relevance from an aging pop star. Hardly worth inclusion in this list.
Boy, “grown-up” Madonna sure does suck, doesn’t she? This album, made from the mistaken notion that she needed to “compete“ with teenybopper icons Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera, just shows that you don’t have to be an anonymous Brit to make irritating dance/electronica music. Good points: this is slightly less irritating than its genre competitors, and she does limit herself to 44 minutes, for which I am eternally grateful. Bad points: the whispered and treated vocals that crop up intermittently are extremely irritating, and for an artist I know to be intelligent, these have to be some of the dumbest lyrics ever committed to paper. I thought long and hard about giving this three stars, but realized I would be holding my nose with a death grip in order to avoid the stench from doing so. Two stars, baby.
well i missed a few days but that was bound to happen eventually, and will certainly happen again. we proceed anyway. this is mostly a first listen. ive only heard the title track before. this album doesnt feel like it belongs on this list or any list like it, especially considering she has much better albums before this. but whatever. favorite tracks: Music, Runaway Lover, I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me
Sophisticated pop
hrrm, maybe later
1. muzic - 2 2. inztant - 1 3. lover - 1 4. dezerve - 1 5. amazing - 1 6. perfect - 1 7. tell - 1 8. girl - 0 9. paradize- 0 10. gone - 1 11. pie - 0
What the hell was Madonna thinking on this one. And what the hell are critics thinking including it in this list? Appallingly basic electro effects, no semblance of good songwriting, a woeful cover of a classic. On Nobody’s Perfect her vocals are entirely auto-tuned. Why would someone with a voice as powerful and recognisable as Madonna use auto-tune? To sound like some awful pop wannabe? Truly awful album
Me convenciste Madonna
7/10
A few songs will stay with me for longer
It really isn't her best. Some good tracks but that cover of American Pie is so bad.
Better than Coldplay
I'm guessing this was experimental and "revolutionary" at the time. Doesn't make it good though.
This was a background album to my high school years. I think the name recognition makes it appear on this list. I do remember it was somewhat of a big deal that Madonna had put out new music, like someone had crossed the 90's music threshold into the 2000s era.
"I wonder what's on this strange magical vinyl disc?" The humble album title: Like A Prayer and Ray Of Light are both average albums for me. Nothing particularly great or terrible, just standard pop of its time. Music is pretty much the same. That opener is pretty solid. A great synth melody and texture accompanies a composition that lasts exactly as long as it should. I notice that Madonna's voice sounds sort of... artificial? Definitely a filter going on, though subtle. It's not until the second song, Impressive Instant, where a much more obvious vocal filter is used. Honestly, pretty cool for its time. You don't really encounter "robo-vocals" much – at least not in good music (we're excluding most of the 80s here) – until the 21st century. Reminds me a bit of Radiohead's Kid A, released the same year, which saw Yorke also pushing vocalisation boundaries (as it were). I Deserve It is an interesting one. Musically, pretty simple and non-experimental. Yet something about it sounds like (a modern-day) Joni Mitchell, with the clean recording, meandering melody, and self-reflective lyrics. This is not a song to be overlooked. Amazing has some, well, amazing synth parts, along with a solid piano part and melody. Pretty repetitive, though. And the next track, Nobody's Perfect, limits its potential substantially by using vocal autotune. It's hard to get autotune right, and Madonna certainly doesn't. The reason why there was such hard pushback when artists like Cher, T-Pain, and Kanye used autotune is because, in general, it sounds kind of bad. Fake. Inorganic. Don't Tell Me... a little jarring at the beginning, but once the electronic drum comes in, dang. Super peppy and catchy. The chopped-up acoustic guitar takes a minute or so to get used to. So darn cool, though. The textural contrast between the sharp, almost 8-bit percussion, acoustic guitar, and light breezy string arrangement... This is the strongest track on the album, no doubt. Paradise (Not for Me) is just a discount version of Don't Tell Me: the string are pretty similar but everything else is slightly worse. Still decent though. I like the retro arcade-esque synths (very sci-fi) and how oddly they interact with the xylophone's timbre. TIL: American Pie makes for a great cover song. 3/5 Key tracks: I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, American Pie
Not as good as vintage Madonna
Maybe 3.5 for me…really liked the singles off this album but I prefer 80s Madonna.
I was wondering when I was gonna get a Madonna record on my album journey. It's admittedly hard to ignore the so-called "Queen of Pop". However, the record I'm starting with her here is quite the curveball. Continuing in the techno-pop direction of Ray of Light, with both returning producer William Orbit and newcomer French DJ and producer Mirwais, Madonna sought to change up her sound again in the turn-of-the-millennium mainstream dominated by the likes of Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera. The fruit of their combined labor would result in the album Music. Sure, the title is unimaginative, but this record actually set a precedent for the next two decades of Madonna's work, as she kept one foot on the pop music zeitgeist while continuing to experiment. In the case of Music, the album is very much the year 2000, for better or worse. This album is filled to the brim with stuttering electronic beats, squelching basslines, and the adoption of a cowboy kitsch. It very much evokes the time in which it was released. Obviously, it's going to sound dated 25 years after its release because the musical landscape has changed since then, and I don't expect everyone to be as into its blend of techno, electro-house, pop, and country. But as someone who was four years old at the time of this album's release, I cannot deny how much Madonna and this production sell the vibe for the most part. The propulsive, snappy beats and electronic embellishments behind the anthemic title track, that gurgling synth and pulsing bass that are prominent in the space-age club boom of "Impressive Instant", the fast-paced techno flourishes buoying Madonna's rebuke against an unfaithful man on "Runaway Lover", that stuttering acoustic guitar loop that gets built upon for "Don't Tell Me" as she pleaded for her partner to not control her; there are some genuinely intriguing twists and turns with the electronic and techno elements. Though there are a few moments where the energy is dialed back for more acoustic-driven tunes, including the folk ballad "I Deserve It" in dedication to her then-partner Guy Ritchie, followed by the 1960s-inspired pop rock of "Amazing", and the melancholic closer "Gone" as Madonna strummed away on her guitar while reminiscing on this relationship as it comes to a close. Probably the best track on the album for me was "What It Feels Like for a Girl", starting with quoting a Serge Gainsbourg monologue before giving way to a subtle, bouncy beat and supple bass as Madonna addresses the double standards placed onto women by society. It's a surprisingly poignant song coming out of her, combined with such a vibrant ambient production. Really, the only tracks that didn't work for me were the ones that involved heavy manipulation of Madonna's voice where it wasn't needed. "Nobody's Perfect" saw her voice put through a vocoder, while "Paradise (Not Gone)" made prominent use of the Antares Auto-Tune plug-in set for the non-spoken word portions of the track. For as much as this album is already viewed as a year 2000 record, these two tracks in particular felt indicative of the music industry's response to the use of Auto-Tune in Cher's hit "Believe", and not necessarily for the better. Apparently, from what I read on this album, Madonna actually wanted her voice treated differently in this manner, which Mirwais initially objected to but then ended up using said Auto-Tune for a few of the tracks at her request. Thankfully, it's not on every song on the record, but these two tracks alone feature heavily manipulated vocals where you didn't need them for Madonna of all people, and that's what rubbed me the wrong way. Still, I overall had a good time with Music, the album. Madonna and her accompanying producers made the most out of what the year 2000 had to offer.
It's really touching reading the other reviews of folks who listened and danced to this when they were young. If we were listening to one of her first three albums today, I'd be saying the same thing. I love how long of a thread Madonna has woven through the last 40something years in our lives. This is actually my first time listening to this album. I stopped consuming new Madonna content when Bedtime Stories came out. Not necessarily because it was bad or anything; I was just getting into other music is all. This isn't bad at all, but I don't think I like it as much as her earlier work. I do like the classic Madonna x electronic/DJ feel to the album ⭐⭐⭐.49
Much like we had William Orbit to thank for Ray Of Light, we have Mirwais to thank for most of this really funky electro-tinged effort. I didn't realise I had a favourite Madonna album until today but this LP is loaded, although it does tail off a little in the second half. Had me listening to Mirwais' solo album Production as a little side quest but that reminded my why I listened to the first 20% of that album a lot back in the day, but had completely forgotten the other 80%. His production is a lot more interesting with a talented and engaging performer at the forefront.
I think I prefer earlier Madonna.
Good thing this wasn’t called “Movies”
It’s incredibly dumb to have this album and Ray of Light on the list. Pick one you lazy editor!
im a madonna worshiper SORRYYY. my worst sin is thinking that her american pie cover is actually pretty great. although not my favorite madonna work however and i totally get how this would be jarring following her magnum opus ray of light but damn it this is amazing as well!!! and if this website made any sense all her albums from her self titled to confessions would be on here.
Most of it was quite boring, there were a couple songs that were not bad, American pie definitely much better by Don McLean. I expected much more from Madonna.
2000-luvun poppi on niin outoa.
Way too much autotune for my liking and some lyrics are rather bland for my taste overall, but while this album is many things, it's definitely never boring. My favourites are Don't Tell Me, What it Feels like for a Girl, Gone and, yes, American Pie.
Nothing like some Madonna first thing in the morning to warm up the loins.
I don’t think I’ve ever listened to a full Madonna record, and it’s a shame it had to be this one. I don’t get why it’s on this list.
MUSIC MAKES THE PEOPLE COME TOGETHER YEEEEAAAAH 💃💃💃💃
queria estar nas festas na época q esse lançou
This is awful. The Queen of pop my arse if this what she thinks is acceptable. Generic, autotuned shoite. Some small highlights saves it from a 1
The hit-singles "Music", "Don't Tell Me" and "American Pie" plus a forgettable rest.
Music
Two great songs, maybe a third.
I love a bunch of these tracks, but wish the whole thing held together better. Still, a 3.5 in my book because of how much I love Don't Tell Me and What It Feels Like for A Girl
this was fine, some good moments but the american pie cover was criminal
3.5/5
One of her worst!!! American Pie is just awful!!!!!
Not good Madonna.
realmente, anos 2000 demais (até pro meu gosto)
se fosse mais anos 2000 que isso aqui, explodia melhor que o ray of light e um pouco a frente do tempo né, dá pra perceber uma galera do pop/eletronica que se inspirou nesse aqui. acho que sou mais a madonna anos 80, mas ainda eh bacana
First listened on 9th and 11th April 2025. Favourite song is What It Feels Like For a Girl.
Madona from the 2000’s sounds like she’s trying to conform to the period. Awful. She needed to stay in her lane. She’s still the Queen of Pop, but historians won’t look back kindly with this effort.
3.5 it could've been a 4 if the American Pie cover wasn't shocking.
I do not miss the glitchy folktronica of the early 2000s. Madonna’s Music is the biggest and arguably best of that genre with plenty of songs that you can tell are decently composed with promising subject matters but the whole production style is so dated and annoying that I still can’t appreciate it beyond a few tracks that rise above the trends they were chasing.
Unlistenable
so hey that new boards of canada album is pretty good!
I didn't get through as much of this as I was hoping. It is okayish.
Solid pop
9/10… dance / pop / *2000
This was a chore to get through.
Second Madonna album in as many days, and I'm kicking myself that it's taken this long for me to start listening to her full albums. There's some amazing stuff on here.
Super album
Never been a Madge fan and this is why. The first few were just plain awful. Wether the one that was auto-tuned all the way through was supposed to be ironic or not I really couldn't tell. To be fair the albumdid improve the longer you put up with it, but that is not difficult when it starts off that bad. And I have never liked her version of American pie.
Not a big fan of Madge, but this is one of two albums of hers where I can enjoy it in places. Not a fan of the Cher-like auto tune business, but like a lot of the dance synth production. Highlights ‘I deserve it’, ‘Don’t tell me’, ‘Paradise’ and the exceptional ‘Gone’.
This may surprise many people who know me that I really admire Madonna and her work, plus her ability to stay relevent in the changing fads and styles of pop music, and often staying one step ahead of the competition in a very similar way to Dave Bowie. This album is in my opinion, her second best after Ray of Light. There is a big dance/club sound running through this record, contrary to the cover art, I was expecting some hideous Country themed monstrosity when I first saw the cover, not no. 'Don't Tell Me' is a song I've played to death over the years, unlike her awful and completely unnecessary cover of 'American Pie'. Why Madge? What were you thinking?
Another 3.5 and an album that's worthy of further investigation. Don't care much for the autotune-heavy "modern" production, but it was a new tool around this time so was required to be used to death.
i think the cover art throws you off --- otherwise a pleasant surprise
yeah it was pop music 3.5
*listened before the project* I don’t understand why y’all don’t like it.
I don't love Madonna in general, though some of her offerings are in my saved pile of shit to get to later. But Madonna and this electronic nightmare totally missed the target for me. Would not recommend.
I like Madonna, but I would not tell anybody they need to listen to this electronica wallpaper before they die. At least the version on Deezer doesn't have the American Pie cover. I did have to misophonia skip some tracks with whispering, though. NOPE!
Insipid shite
Fav- runaway lover 3/5
486/1089 - That was bad. Autotune and acoustic instruments shouldn't mix and the production choices were really questionable throughout... I think. I forgot most of it after it ended. Apparently there's a Y2K style American Pie bonus track. I don't really get it. The point of the original song was talking about the plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, The Big Bopper, and Ritchie Valens and the tumultuous cultural changes of the 60s. I guess the internet and Y2K was a big change but the grit and worry isn't there in this version, it's a bit too fun sounding for me. Idk what I'm talking about, take it with a grain of salt. I didn't exist in the 90s but I kinda wish this album didn't exist in the 2000s.
En gran parte este album me dio dolor de cabeza De todo lo q se puede poner de Madonna ponen esto, el autor del libro a veces se pasa queriendose hacer el indie, y gracias a dios que como sociedad dejamos atras el efecto robot de la voz 5,5/10