Reviews (page 5 of 8)
I remember that ‘Music’ was everywhere when this came out, which I suppose is pretty typical of Madonna - formulaic enough that her hits are hits. But is that a good thing? Listening 25 years later it’s a bit boring, and seems like pop music is still the same, engineered to give the (sheep) listeners the same things over and over to keep them happy. As usual Madonna’s vocal performance is good, although pretty auto tuned by this point, an aspect of the times that I never really liked much. Hard to rate this for me because although none of the tracks were very bad, none were that great either. 2.5/5
Be warned this album is an infectious disease. It won’t make your life better and it’s probably bad for your overall health but only this album will grow on/in you. Joking aside I really thought this album was trash at first but then the second listen it got funny, and then it got funnier and funnier. Really this album is “so bad it’s good”, the room of music if you will. There probably should’ve been a sign on the studio for keep Madonna away from the dj equipment cause some of the songs on here are so silly and of their time that you don’t even have to look to see if it was made in 2000, you just immediately KNOW it is from 2000. Yah i definitely can’t pretend like I like this album legitimately, but I will still make my friends listen to this album on repeat for the foreseeable future.
Title track is good. Had potential but it never elevates itself above mediocrity. The version of American Pie is very cringe.
Why do so many of the top reviews for this album mention 9/11?? Anyway, “Music” made me dance like I was out clubbing, so therefore it’s a perfect album. I like to boogie woogie as Madonna says, I suppose.
Sorry, I just can't. I've never been a big fan of Madonna, and this is clearly Madonna past her peak. Just no.
That American Pie cover did not need to swap that HARD
Fun but not revelatory for me personally
First half I was not sold, but honestly the back half is really great. What it Feels For a Girl was ahead of its time. Decent overall.
Autotuned to death. Most of her music bores me and I prefer the 80s stuff. I liked I Deserve It and Gone best, and they're among the lowest rated songs on the album...but I think her slow thoughtful stuff is better than the dancy stuff.
Would I (or anyone else) give this faux-confessional Europop knockoff mishegas the time of day of it weren't Madonna? Some of it is pretty nice, I admit, so it gets a 3.
3.5
We all know Madonna for her 80s hits and maybe some of the 90s ones, but I never tried listening to one of her albums or too many songs on purpose so I was interested to see what 2000s Madonna after Ray of Light and before American Life would have done and... I'd be surprised if this album doesn't have a reappraisal in the future because this album is so good, barring a few slow songs that just don't quite work for me (Nobody's Perfect and Paradise) the rest are just greatly produced and well written pop songs that just hit all the right places for me aesthetically, the sort of glitchy, chilled-out and electronic type of stuff that was so common then and elevated by a good singer. This is great, I should go back and check Ray of Light too while I'm at it
utter garbage with possibly the worst cover version of any song ever! saved from a 1 star review purely down to the fact that I managed to make it through the whole album
Madonna suffering from a seriously bad case of the Y2K bug. It sounds like she listened to a bunch of 90s electronic alt rock (Beck, Portishead, Beta Band, Stereolab) and thought, oh I'll have a go at that. The electro pop stuff is pretty solid, if uninspired, high spec dance music as you'd expect from a standard bearer of the genre and some of the chilled out mellow stuff is decent, but what the hell is this acoustic strummy pseudo Sheryl Crow stuff ('I deserve it') and auto-tuned trip hop ('nobody's perfect')?! Awful.
Didn't listen to the whole thing cause meeeehhh
There were a couple times I caught myself thinking "maybe this one will be okay?" But they weren't. Soulless pop trash
I can say I am not a Madonna fan outside of 3-4 songs, but I do love the title track on this one. I have never given this album a listen so this is new to me... The production and vibe on the title track is great, it reminds me a lot of "Everybody" from her first album. Groovy and danceable. "Impressive Instant" was a meandering mess, like a rough draft went wrong, not impressive at all. "Runaway Lover" sounds like a Tel Aviv disco, so generic and far from her comfort zone, no soul. "I Deserve It" should have been a Broken Bells song, they'd have done it better, but I didn't mind it. "Amazing" was anything but, she mailed in the vocal. "Nobody's Perfect" was awful, the music, the vocal, the length. "Don't Tell Me" was country flavored, the beat and weird staccato were distracting - that was a hit (40M listens)?! "What It Feels..." was nauseating. "Paradise" was too long, super boring and overcooked. "Gone" (super vanilla) was thankfully the final tune and my agony could end. There's no reason this disjointed mess of an album should be on the T1001, it doesn't break any ground and most of it sucks. Is it that she moved from shitty pop to shitty dance beat music? 2 stars for trying.
I still recall a lot of the words from the hit singles on this album over twenty years later. It's a pretty decent pop album but of its time and doesn't feel like it was much more than a commercial endeavour.
This album was terrible. I have no clue how it made this list. Washed up, poorly written trash. Hopefully there’s some 80’s Madonna on this list
Not an album I'd run out and buy. Sometimes I wonder about the people who chose the albums for this list.
Trying too hard
This style of dance pop just sounds very fake and tacky to me. It may have been ahead of it's time but I don't think it's aged very well. Not her best work. What It Feels Like for a Girl and Don't Tell Me are pretty good though.
80s and 90s Madonna was an absolute powerhouse. This iteration of her is very far from those heights though. A few good tracks, some that almost became the sound of the early 2000s, but nothing really had the staying power of her earlier work.
The cover of American Pie is the longest 4:33 I've had in 548 albums. Ugh.
I suppose the album title is apt because there isn’t much more to be very descriptive about. I won’t go as far as to say Madonna phoned it in on this one, but her lyricism and vocal performances were pretty vague. The production choices were waaaay better than the vocals/lyrics. A decent opening track with some chunky drums/bassline had me hopeful, and the vocal chopping on “Impressive Instant” kept my hopes high. But it wasn’t until “What It Feels Like For A Girl” that I found anything worth while - I liked the synth pad textures and harmonies, it sounds like an instrumental that could’ve played on Postal Service’s “Give Up”. We know that shes give this sound more life and thump on “Confessions On A Dancefloor” 5 years later, which just adds to this albums meandering quality. It’s a shame, there’s some influences from house, trance, and even downtempo/goa lounge all on this album. But the songs dont really do anything within those genres. Wanted and hoped for more, strong 2/5 Was her cover of “American Pie” a bonus track on this album? If so, go listen to that mess just for fun
bezveze
Pop mommy. The album came in with a bang and went out with a whimper. If the whole album were like the first 2 songs, it would’ve been 5 stars.
This was like her techno album and it wasn't too bad! It was definitely an album from the after her most popular ones but it was still a big deal for Madonna came out with a new album! Lol
Uh no thanks
What a strange album. Feels way past Madonna's prime but looking it up, this was nominatdd for a ton of awards. And I was worried, because the first couple songs were rough 90's/ 00's pop. And there was also some egregious autotune here. But this album actually got progressively better over it's runtime. In fact, the last three songs of What It Feels Like for a Girl, Paradise (Not for Me), and Gone were actually pretty good and I liked them a ton. Not enough to push this album past mid, but a respectable score nonetheless.
A surprisingly crafted pop album. American Pie seems completely unnecessary.
Apart from a few songs, it's just a generic pop album for people who like to dance.
postives: + it was from madonna who is an icon + it had quite a few songs that are good for dancing too and relatable for a teen girl + gave vibes of an early 2000s charlie XCX with the synth and autotune used + good album length negatives: - i only knew 1 song - some songs were too long in length - the song paradise (not for me) and the weird female voice used creeped me out a bit my favouite songs: miss american pie which was the only one i knew but still loved and what it feels like for a girl
Mostly mindless forgettable eh. The good ones seem like Madonna trying to sound like Cheryl Crow. The bad ones have no personality and barely sound like Madonna.
I know a lot of this is bad but there are some nostalgic songs that I didn't even know were madonna (Don't tell me, What it feels like for a girl) and obviously Music is a banger you're all in denial
Enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Nice vocals with a Daft Punk vibe in the music. Better pop than other stuff that was coming out around the same time.
Inte så roligt, miss American Pie var bäst
Solid album.
It was ok. I don’t care for Madonna’s dance club phase. 3 star.
Love this one. Remember it from the day. 4 *
definitely sounds french
Not my cup of tea, I do like a few of her early club songs but this is too shiny and overproduced
Surprisingly good
Really hate rating a Madonna album so low, but I didn’t enjoy it.
*** 1/2 I like Madonna, but this one is not my favourite
I'm angry that I've been forced to listen to this. American Effing Pie FFS.
Fine. I’m not a Madonna expert or anything, and she 100% has one or more albums that deserve to be on this list, but in my opinion this album ain’t one of them. The title track is pretty good, but the other songs didn’t grab me (an internet rando whose contributions to society overall are 1,000,000+ times less than Madonna’s).
There are legitimately great Madonna albums (at least 1 that I know of anyway) and this wasn’t one of them. The terrible dated production is bad enough, if it was slathered over good songs we’d at least have something. But these songs are just bad. I only kind of dug Don’t Tell Me, but the rest was not good
Wow. Bad.
The production on this is all over the place. “What It Feels Like For a Girl” was the only highlight.
Music feels like an album that's not necessarily a miss, but rather an album that's geared toward surface-level listening rather than immersion. It more so feels like an obligation to follow up a hit like Ray of Light, as all the songs on here follow early 2000s tropes of trippy electronic beats and autotuned vocals. It's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation. If Madonna stays faithful to the sound that made her famous, she risks being labeled a one-trick pony, but keeping up with the trends, like here, makes the album soulless and uninteresting. Just listen to the opener and that weird sexual energy combined with a lack of sense of direction, or Nobody's perfect where Madonna uses gimmicky autotune even if she has proven she has the vocal chops to deliver. Breathy vocals and recycled slow beats are tailor-made for the masses. Maybe suburban moms will like it, but not me.
Meh outside of 2 songs
Auto tuned pop confection.
This era of using autotune to make a “creative” point has not aged well. I guess this is a transition record for Madonna - going from the darkly hypersexualized work of the 90s to a more club/dance friendly style. Don’t let the cowboy hat fool you!
Wow, this "Music" is shockingly bad. What the helly happened to Madonna between Ray of Light and this? Pretty sure it's still with William Orbit, but unlike Ray of Light, all the songs here just suck! "Nobody's Perfect" might take the record for worst, most pathetically generic, song ever. The lyrics on that are especially bad, like a 4th graders first poem. I didn't even like a single song off of this, and I am quite trigger happy with likes (got 40k on spotify 😂). Worst inclusion of the list ever, I genuinely can't believe they went with this over Weezer or blink-182 or hell even Madonna's older albums. She was HUGE in the 80s and we only get "Like a Prayer"? Seriously? I'm completely missing some essential music history here. This never should have sniffed the list, this album is awful. Worse than The Streets and SAULT
I have to assume this album is the pioneer of 2000’s pop. At the time of its conception, music production began transitioning to a more digital production process and its on full display here. This album is likely the reason ddr music exists. And without 2000’s ddr (and daft punk), we don’t get Virtual Self + Porter Robinson. The influence here is incredible. The soft, overly processed female vocals, the "cringe-y" lyrics, the simplistic drum patterns... A few tracks I outright despised, but I can’t deny its impact on the modern genres I love. The tail end of the album is quite nice. Favorite Tracks: Nobody’s Perfect What it Feels Like For A Girl
There are songs on here I really liked. The clubbier ones where the production is bolder, but there’s just too many songs that are bland/not really my interest. A lot I liked about the production on this album, though it has those early digital era snare samples I find grating. Wish it leaned farther into the funky/electronic parts of the sound.
This isn’t a bad album, but I wouldn’t call it essential listening. It feels very much of its time and hasn’t aged all that well. The only truly terrible thing here is that cover of American Pie...Yikes. Sometimes you just need someone around you that isn't afraid to say no to you. Save that abortion for a concert surprise cover. Overall a decent release, just nothing I'll ever put on intentionally again.
I really dislike Madonna, and it doesn’t help that this album was made 20 years after her prime
Very interesting production choices but not a bad album
No idea what I expected from this Other than a couple of weird ones, really enjoyed
there are a few bangers on here, everything else is good electro-pop, solid over all
Madonna could always reinvent herself
Oddly enough, “Music” was the first Madonna song I remember hearing. I’m 37 but grew up in a pretty conservative home, so Madonna wasn’t exactly played frequently. I snuck some MTV in in the late 90’s, and the video for this song was frequent. Honestly revisiting this shows it’s a pretty good album that holds up better than I expected. The title track is great, as is Don’t Tell Me. I Deserve It was another pleasant surprise.
Vraiment cool, l'instru un peu expérimentale / glitchée est trop stylée
Listened to this album a lot when it first came out, but don’t feel like it’s aged well. Only managed to listen to half - it annoyed me
Weird
The Good: We get Music!!! The Bad: It is 2000’s Madonna music… The Ugly: That gold grill… Really? Music? This is what the list is turning into? Yesterday I was excited… Today I am distraught… Music will do that to you… And to think that I have 600+ albums to go before the journey ends...
This is a cultural time-capsule best left buried. Very dull pop that at best boasts some interesting production but little else. The decision to include a dreadful cover of what was already one of the 20th century's most over played songs was a bizarre one. At the end I felt like I required a spiritual cleansing, honestly.
Madonna is much more of a singles artist than an album artist and none of the singles from this album were particularly great. Why the fuck is this album on the list? Stick with the compilations.
This is the most ironically named album in history. It is not, in fact, music.
Nope A bunch of songs sound like a night out in a gay club (fabulous night out but Robyn did it better). The other songs sound like she’s ripping off the roster of Lilith Fair artists And American Pie is cringey and not needed
Fine
I am a Madonna stan and it hurts me that this album was selected for this project. Do yourself a favor, skip this and listen to her debut instead (which absolutely SHOULD be on the list!) and then give her the five stars she deserves for single-handedly changing the music scene for female artists.
it’s madonna idk
The album art made me thought it'll be country, pleasantly surprised to listen to electronic music. Good stuff 3
I wanted to hate this just cause I thought the cover was lame. I don't though (at least completely). Even with some tackier sounds of the late 90's early 2000's and some pretty lame lyrics. Music, Runaway Lover and Amazing are pretty good. What it feels like for a girl is cool. Sometimes there is almost a portishead/bjork style production to some of these tracks which I'll give props to Madonna for trying out. Other tracks get annoying though.
La premisa del álbum es intrigante: "música electrónica y funky combinada con folk futurista". Y cumple lo prometido, aunque para entrever algo de folk hay que echarle imaginación. Precisamente, este álbum es la respuesta de Madonna a un momento en que la música comercial estaba evolucionando, intentando mantenerse relevante mezclando sonidos típicos del pop con electrónica más actual. El resultado es como si juntaran en un laboratorio, a lo monstruo de Frankenstein, a Christina Aguilera y Daft Punk. Un álbum comercial e hiperproducido, con sonidos diseñados para vender (salvo por ese autotune aberrante en "Nobody's Perfect", un bodrio total), a la vez que influyente y lleno de temas divertidos y hasta interesantes a ratos. Un álbum merecedor de esta lista, pero que sencillamente no es de mi estilo. Y hasta casi le resto otra estrella por esa versión traumatizante de "American Pie".
Whose idea was it to take the voice of one of the most famous pop stars of all time and put it through the Electrogargle 2000?
cool
Some good songs, some bad songs, a couple of hidden gems you wouldn’t think it’s Madonna, but that’s Her, ever changing ever redefining ever searching. Great album.
ok
I like this album of Madonna Electronica, although some of the arrangements are a bit strange. A couple of times I thought my headphones were playing up. But that merely knocks it down from a hypothetical seven stars to a real five stars.
"Music" +1, late 90s pop music bonaza
3.5
• 3/5 • it’s fine, I suppose. Well crafted, polished production, but kinda boring . . .
3.5/10
fun enough, but a little flat for me personally. funk country and folk are claimed as influences and uh i don't know that Madonna's ever actually heard any of those genres
Evidence that you can all the studio tricks in the world and still produce a steaming pile of turdmusic. I feel sorrow for all the bytes wasted on this. And the cover of American Pie is a lifeless corpse of a song.
7.5/10. This isn't Madonna's best work, but it's still a fun album. :)
Autotuning and a bad version of American Pie detract from this album. Dated and somewhat stale.
Very Ross with a Keyboard vibes.
I’m surprised this was such a critical success at the time as it seems a bit of a mess to me. I don’t necessarily dislike all the production choices (the heavily Daft Punk-indebted Impressive Instant is fun), but the album hops from one style to the next with little cohesion. More importantly, it’s lacking in great songs: Don’t Tell Me is the only one that truly holds up 25 years (wow - I feel old now!) on. 2.5
So
8/10 It’s easy to forget, with the direction that pop music took (so much came to sound like this) but Madonna was ahead of the mainstream curve here, and deep in her phase of working with very credible electronic producers. I was a fan of the Mirwais album earlier that year, was surprised to see him doing the biggest pop album, but it worked. In fact, his production is the best thing here. The other aspects are interesting to good, except for some of the songwriting being not quite up to the beats. But the hard, funky disco techno goes hard. Best: Paradise
This album sucked. It was an irrelevant pop star coopting an underground movement (EDM) to create a soulless and bad pop album
Maybe would like it more if I hadn't lived through its popularity? (34 known/75 new)
Definitely a DIVA in women’s music. Great singer, music, entertainer. However, this album not good.
I don't recall this album. Madonna on the way down on the relevancy scale, but the dance stuff was OK.
Not exactly my jam. But as a man of a certain age, Madonna holds a semi important place in my development that I will always respect her for.
Glad there was variety to the songs, but there wasn’t anything here to write home about.
Well produced pop music and she's a good singer. Not my thing, though.
Completely forgettable, but the title track was pretty good.
No thanks
Meh, not a huge fan. It’s well enough done in that gobs of money are spent to make it polished and shiny. But behind all the gloss is…what? Not much really.
How?
The title track is one of those that I have heard all my life without knowing what it was or who it was by, an it and other tracks sound a lot clubbier than I was expecting. However, I'm not really sure what I was expecting. For all her fame, I don't think I could name more than one or two Madonna songs. Don't Tell Me is some typical but high-quality early 2000s pop. I kind of hate to admit it, but there's a lot of enjoyable tunes on this album and some interesting, unusual and even brave sounds and lyrics.
Pretty standard pop album. Some of the songs were catchy, others sucked. I feel like it liked more than the others on here but it wasn’t anything special.
Favorite Track: Don't Tell Me
eh
Some catchy songs but feels so cynical and that cover of American Pie is a travesty.
It was just okay. I can't really knock it, it was Madonna and definitely one of her stronger showings. Problem, for me, is that Madonna seems to get a great sound stuck in her head and not really know what to do with it, so she just loops it over and over. Being as this is a pretty electronica album, that repetition kind of turns into noise, though not really in a bad way. It's just that the album is the kind of music to play in a store - non offensive to the ears, but also incapable of distracting people from shopping - just background noise (though not quite elevator music).
1. Madonna had her first hit in my first year of high school. My son has left high school. Even if I had had my son when I was in high school (I didn’t), this would have been a very impressive run in a world that is at best ephemeral. 2. Madonna, of course, is anything but ephemeral. 3. In general, and specifically in the context of this project, she is bound, though, to be victim of her success. 4. I’ve generated 931 albums and this is the second Madonna album. I’m working on the presumption that no others will turn up in the 80 or so to come. 5. That means no True Blue. No Like A Prayer. No Erotica To each their own and all that, but this is risible. 6. The other Madonna album (thus far) is Ray Of Light. She’d had an indifferent run (again, subjectively) in the decade before that. Ray Of Light is one of the few times when the phrase ‘a return to form’ has been used correctly. 7. But it also cast a long shadow. 8. You fill in the rest.
This is not one of her best works, but I liked it nonetheless. She tried a new approach and did it quite well.
Really poor overproduced pop album the American pie cover is an abomination
Garbage. Techno country with video game noises and major autotune. No thanks
Favorite Track: Music
A grand reinvention at the time holds up just enough to play in the new age.
Madonna, eh? Boring formulaic pap that is very much of its time and hasn't stood the test of time particularly well.
Absolutely ass. I feel sexually assaulted by the music and I now have ptsd.
The electro stuff is so loud, I could barely hear her. Not that I really wanted to, she had nothing to say but *love*. There was one song that was decent but the rest was ass. Like, it felt like she took the 80’s, pumped it with steroids, then dropped it onto a Y2K computer. Madonna fell off hard.
Absolute terrible album with no worth in this world. Waste of an hour of my life as well. None of the songs were playlist worthy not even close. This album sounds as bad as Madonna looks nowadays. And every song was a shitty club rave beat that sounded terrible. Madonna you can do so much better. Unrelease this now.
Ts is so ass bro. Like imagine if you were groped, thats what happened to my ears on the first half of the album. Then the second half is HOLY MID I feel this shitty music penetrates my ears without my consent and I loathed every second of it Every single track on this feels like it’s all over the place and it’s a shit show all
Honestly, first few songs are kinda aged like dogshit on a hot summers day, but the latter half of album honestly isn't bad at all. Like nothing outstanding, but pretty good music
carti’s was better, which isn’t saying much, but still. “interesting” sound selection. very slow pace, drags waaaayyy too long. not as bad as i thought. 1.5/5
Madonna *Probably* deserves to have an album on the 1001 list. For the life of me, though, I wouldn't agree that this is the correct selection.
I listened to like a prayer 14 times instead
Nobody's Perfect might be the worst song I've ever heard in my life. A loss for women.
The mixing on this was so bad the first few songs physically caused pain.
More assembly line music drivel.
lol, forgot ali g is in the 'music' video. Madonna seems to always surround herself with an amazing production team. This is not to take anything away from her as a musician; more to say it's a smart business mentality. .
I would have imagined Ray Of Light would be the mid-period Madonna this list would have chosen (maybe that's here too?). Hadn't listened to this in its entirety before, and was pleasantly surprised. It may not seem to be super groundbreaking now, but in part that's because it was heavily copied.
I put it on at night, before going to bed. What a mistake.
Am I being Punk'd?....Ashton Kutcher, that you?
Solid
It's not good, it's not bad.
Oh, fuck off. Are you sure the book this site derived its list from wasn’t titled “1001 albums to avoid like the plague if you want to retain even a shred of optimism about human potential or the value of existence over nothingness.”? Ray of Light is the only half decent Madonna album. Throw this and the rest on the metaphorical fire.
This was a struggle. Awful.
Did not enjoy. It was a techno album.
Overall, an album consistent with pop trends of the late 90s, and yet another testament to Madonna's talent for picking the right producers who are guaranteed to make hits, which was on-point since the beginning of her career. Technically speaking, the production is very solid, although a bit muddy from track to track, and the vocals feel supressed from time to time.
Madge peaked with vogue - this is superfluous noise.
this album feels crazy ahead of its time. like no one else was doing it like her in 2000 i had loved what it feels like a girl for a long time but my fav song besides that was gone
The songs with guitar on them were better than the electronica ones. I could see people liking this album a lot, but it didn't really land with me.
Nope. There were two songs I remember liking as a teenager but this album was so bland.
Pretty good stuff - great stuff if you like being in a dance club.
Pretty Good but had higher expectations. She tries something new anyways and that's always appreciable
Generic pop but because Madonna is attached it makes this list. It’s not great
3.5
Maybe there's not a lot here that really stands out or that I could really see myself returning to, but none of it's bad, really, and I don't think I'd mind hearing any of this. Certainly a rather mature, refined album, without being completely sterile
This didn't age very well, especially the title track. There are some good songs though. Don't Tell Me (though I hate the intro) & What It Feels Like for a Girl in particular.
Day465 - to have such a long career i know not every album is top to bottom good so i don’t judge this to harsh
I haven’t explored Madonna’s discography as deeply as I’d like, so this project was a great starting point. I was already familiar with the title track—it plays constantly at my job—and after hearing it almost every day for the past three years, I can’t say it’s my favorite. That said, I really enjoyed the rest of the album. A standout for me was What It Feels Like for a Girl—I think Addison Rae would do a great cover of it.
This isn't the genre I usually listen to or enjoy so I'm not rating it too highly but it was a generally enjoyable experience throughout.
3/5
The 2000s were really a time. I'm feeling both nostalgic and annoyed from this lol. 2.9.
This was like the worst of the 2000s. Don't Tell Me was the most interesting song on here. Personal enjoyment: 2/5 Relevance to this list: 2/5
This is an odd album of hers to have on this list for me. I find this album extremely annoying as the beat is too electronic and repetitious. But maybe that was the point. Anyway, we’re ray of light is a superb album this one I have to skip through to even come close to making it to the end. But it’s Madonna! So fuck what I say.
No surprises, this is a Madonna album that I don't particularly care for. Something about her voice grates on my nerves.
Hoo boy, this album is so early 2000s it physically hurts. Madonna is clearly starting to drink her own Kool-Aid by this point, and she really thinks she's God's gift to music here - despite the overwrought lyrics, weebly autotune, and general dearth of musical innovation all round. There's no greater sign of a lack of imagination than another bloody cover of American Pie.
I don't understand this album. I guess it wasn't bad in any way, but there felt like there was nothing extraordinary about it. It sounded almost like parody of 2000s electro pop. Some of the lyrics were super cliche, but I still don't think it was bad. Weird list is weird. What It Feels Like for a Girl was surprisingly good too.
I got some gripes. First off, this album isn't bad. But do I think it belongs on here though? No. Confessions on a Dance Floor is better and has similar music. It's a better representation of Madonna during this time period. I'm not sure if COADF is on this list or not, but if it isn't, I will riot. The rating of the album is a 3, but I had to express my displeasure in the list; it can be fucking comical.
Could basically guess the release year off the electro-pop elements, which were mostly cringe. Some of the buzzing and beeping is straight up unpleasant in the ears. What It Feels Like is a pretty good track.
Пластиковый звук не оч
Why is this on here? I’m not saying Madonna shouldn’t have an album on this list but this one? No.
I’ve never been a huge Madonna fan, but even taking that consideration this just hasn’t really aged well. I was in high school when this came out, and even the nostalgia isn’t doing it for me.
Feels like someone saw what was popping on TRL and thought, “Yeah, I’ll have one of everything.” The vocoder stuff is so heavy-handed it’s basically cosplay. There's a cold, mechanical sheen over everything, like a Daft Punk costume party but everyone forgot to bring the soul. It’s trying to be futuristic and sexy but lands closer to awkward and metallic. There's no warmth. No pulse. Just vibes made in a lab with no coffee. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions: - Music - Don't Tell Me
Weird style
Aged about as gracefully as Madonna herself.
I’ve always hated the title track, and the other songs are mostly worse. Only Amazing, with its Foo Fighters-like/lite chorus, and Gone prevent this album from getting the lowest score. Horrible album
I remember hating the single. I'm sure I still hate it. music: hated. (⌐■_■)
When I was in the sixth grade, this album was pretty recent. We had some sort of assignment where we had to write/perform a parody song in French. One kid, who had not learned very much French, did Music. His lyrics were “Musique//fait les personnes//vien ensemble//oui!” which is pretty funny grammatically, and also pretty catchy, and I still think about it sometimes. Singing that line in my head was more satisfying than any moment of the actual Music by Madonna.
I loved the mix of genres on this album. It is one of my favourites from Madonna and showed at the time how she could reinvent her sound and remain on top of charts as the Queen of Pop.
2.75
Nogle enkelte numre der er noget værd på, men jeg synes hele den blip-blop produktion er ældet så dårligt. George Bush æra-core
Håber dælme ikke det her er den eneste Madonna plade på listen! Synes det startede fedt, de første par sange var cool! Men den sidste halvdel af pladen havde en del numre som lød decideret forfærdeligt. Kedelige ballader med stenet elektronisk produktion og elendig brug af autotune.
Few good songs, but the rest is very boring
It sounds very dated with the autotunez and ethereal beats. And I was a pretty big fan of Ray of Light (the album prior)
love madge but some of the choices on this album…including and especially the american pie cover (as the closer!!!!)...phew
This music doesn't really music to me.
Musically it's actually... interesting. Light, almost absent sometimes instrumentals, creative autotune, and a few more experiments. But the majority of the album is somehow... soulless? I've kinda liked it, even though its weirdness puts me a bit away from it. Especially the temporary musical stops that are somehow motion-sickness-inducing. On it's own it'd be a pretty good 2/5. Inoffensive, I've just heard a lot of better albums. But the American Pie cover is terrible.
If electro-pop is your thing, I suppose you could do worse. I would readily admit that Madonna has an album or two worthy of this list. I just wouldn't have thought this latter day effort would be one of them. 2.5/5 (a generous rounded up 3 star rating for the app) Album 12/1001
I am not the target audience for this album. I've never been a fan of Madonna or her brand of pop music. This album also utilizes a lot of early 2000's production, which hasn't aged well in my opinion. It's also stange to me that the visual component of this album is country oriented. Nothing about the music on this album makes me think country or cowgirl
Madonna as an adult. It's a good sound.
Two bangers and not much else.
After the great and mature artistic triumph that was Ray of Light, Madonna was probably disappointed that it wasn't also on par with her previous works commercially. So, Madge went right back into radio-ready songs with Music. But despite it's title track becoming her final Billboard #1, the rest of the songs are actually surprising left-field for a pop album. There's the jagged folktronica sound that Madonna would explore more on her next album, American Life, and there's also some Cher-esque autotuned vocals. The end result is, however, quite fractured and struggled to find its own identity. Even the cover artwork hints at a country-inspired album while it's definitely not one. Key tracks: Music Don't Tell Me What It Feels Like for a Girl
I love her but this wasn't her best album imo
Too overproduced for my liking. 5 year old me loved this though, the lyrics are so tacky.
Madonna’s Music didn’t do a whole lot for me, but I’ll give it credit where it’s due—“Runaway Lover” was a legit highlight. Maybe I’ve got a soft spot for early 2000s EDM vibes after all. The rest of the album felt a bit dated, and not in a fun nostalgic way. More like a reminder of when auto-tune started taking over pop music and everyone thought it sounded futuristic. Not terrible, but not something I’d revisit often.
Interesting electronically album by Madonna
Ray of shite
Light, pleasant songs. After all these hip-hop albums and unpleasant experiments, Madonna's voice and music feel like a balm to the soul. 7.5 out of 10.
Ok, but... hear me out... what if we *don't* need to hear this before we die? This takes the worst parts of early aughts pop music and mashes it together with the worst of British electronic music. I don't have anything against Madonna in general, but this is not a good representation of her best music by any stretch.
An okay inclusion on the list. 3/5
Kind of a weird choice for Madonna. I assume she also has older albums here. This is her 2000 comeback album As for this album. Dunno, it’s fine? Not really my music. I don’t think it’s particularly strong. Not complete crap but not good enough for the list. Two stars (assuming Madonna has other entries).
Mid tier Madonna
ugly
Not what I prefer. A couple of interesting tracks. Felt kind of phoned in?
Not a strong one from old ‘Donna
Um, I was there when this came out so I can say with certainty this is not/was not some kind of amazing groundbreaking album. It’s barely fine. I like Madonna just fine, but this is not it.
Meh... boring, washed-up pop record. Early 2000's wasn't a great time for pop music, just a lot of safe, uninspired music. Definitely didn't need to listen to this.
never been much of a fan, but i have immense respect for her and everything she has done. tons of talent and a trailblazer in her field. i must say most of these songs are catchy as hell… except when she tries the country thing. it just kind of falls flat.
Wasn’t bad but nowhere near her 80’s stuff.
A couple good ones but not my jam.
not an awful album just kinda weird and not rlly my taste.
This should be fun pop music but it just isn't fun
a straight up 2, until don't tell me brings it up to a 3. only for the disgusting version of american pie to bring it crashing back down
I thought this would be better than it was, but it was still fine
Why is music in scare quotes? That doesn't bode well. Wow, hot garbage autotune crap.
Great album, sound is dated to its era but still some really great up beat tracks. Not the biggest Madonna fan but this was a good listen. Would have gone 5 stars if it weren’t for the autotune ballad and snoozy back half
First two songs start so promising with Madonna doing some fun things that sound fresh even today but then the rest of the album slips into more safe choices and less experimentation.
Ok Madonna- you are talented, but that is the only thing carrying this album. I admit though that it was a good palette cleanser in the moment.
This cover of American Pie made me angry
Out and out Pop of the highest level. I found myself dancing along while cooking lunch. Like any artist with a huge catalogue Madonna has had her ups and downs. This is definitely an up.
A very mixed bag. Some really crappy songs and some decent ones.
1. music: electronic beat and effects, simple and fun 2. impressive instant: weird vocal effect, strange 3. runaway lover: better vocals and beat 4. i deserve it: acoustic guitar intro, nice vocals, calm ballad, repetitive 5. amazing: eerie intro with strings, nice vocals, catchy chorus, cool song 6. nobodys perfect: asmr intro, goofy vocal effects, interesting synth solo, acoustic bridge, cool song 7. dont tell me: weird stuttering acoustic intro, nice strings, piercing electronic beat, cool outro 8. what it feels like for a girl: british girl talking intro, chill beat, nice vocals, kinda repetitive, cool 9. paradise (not for me): chill intro with whispering, strong synths, beautiful strings, emotionally psychedelic, cool song 10. gone: nice acoustic intro, nice chorus, cool overall: grew on me throughout the album, great production and vocals, cool effects and synths rating: 8/10
"I'm not very smart." About time you admit it you dumb bitch.
During I Deserve It I was thinking “this isn’t so bad” but yeah, I didn’t like that.
It’s not that this album is blatantly bad, it’s just ver uninspired and remedial. Maybe for the early digital age it was groundbreaking but it doesn’t really hold up now. The “glitch” part in the pre chorus of Nobody’s Perfect made me smirk. The lyrics of the first half of the album remind me of a high school girl that’s learning to write poetry. The final two songs are the stand outs. Maybe I’m expecting too much from a dance music album but I was not very impressed.
Flop
Its fun and catchy but not mind blowing.
Only slightly worse Cher, which is huge praise. I really don't care for Madonna's voice, but all the sounds around it are magnificent.
I’ve never been a big Madonna fan. I did enjoy this album though
Guter Pop.
3.5 - Good
Bland, not really much going on, lots of auto-tune (poor taste imo)
It was decent not something id naturally put on but wouldn’t turn it off if it started to play
This was better than expected. Some bangers, and some kinda bad stuff. Feels like a 3.
Хитовая попса двухтысячных от престарелой шкуры
Wasn't a huge fan of this album (Music and American Pie are terrible), but tracks like Don't Tell Me save it for me. 2.5, rounded up.
🥱
Couldn’t make it through this one. Between the drum machine and annoying synths just not for me.
A Madonna album, interesting. I'll check this out. I do know the first track. This is very EDM-y, so far. Pretty cool so far. 3-stars.
Not as good as the previous albums we covered here, but I am impressed by these later albums. She has a sense of how new music is working, but layers more into the lyrics than, say, Britney. The song 'Gone' is really great and I liked the other slower one earlier in the album. It almost went to 3 for losing points for American Pie (even though a bonus), I just dislike that interminable song. But, calling it a 3.5 and actually going up to:
Nearly an hour full of autotuned crap. This version of american pie is a crime.
Would not listen again; I was genuinely excited for this but it underwhelmed me. The Y2K of it all has aged poorly. What it feels like for a girl is still an excellent song. This is a straight up two.
Some classics, but doesn't stand out to me.
If wet white bread were an album it would be Music Not necessarily bad but certainly not good and no flavor at all.
#498. This was worse than I anticipated. 2/5: cringe Song added to playlist: Music I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link
There were some good ideas in here but mostly it was overly repetitive
It's a decent album, but not my taste typically. 3/5
68% Best: Runaway Lover; Paradise (Not for Me) Must-Hear? Nah
Pretty generic pop album. Auto-tune was obnoxious in "Nobody's Perfect". Standout was "Paradise (Not For Me)" until about the 5 minute mark, twice as long as it should have been.
Not a fan
This isn't for me. There have been way worse albums on this list. But Madonna just is not my speed.
Other than the Hit songs that take me back to my childhood, this album is a dud. Love it, or hate it, it's music. Favorite Track: "Music".
Looked at the track list before it started and recognized none of the songs ... turns out that "Hey Mr. DJ" song is actually the title track. Recognized a lot more of this music than I had thought, but none of it has ever really been what I want to hear. 2.5
the mountains of effort poured into this album to give it a different sound ended up making it the most year 2000 sounding ass album imaginable. it's so obviously an elder stateswoman of pop trying to prove she's still got it and just copy pasting whatever christina and britney were up to. holy shit this is so bland. this is a mayonnaise sandwich on wonder bread. [tapping my ear] we're just hearing reports that it ends with an indefensibly weird rendition of american pie this is soooooooo bad
When this album came out, you couldn't go to any gathering of a bunch of white people without hearing it. Parties, dances, wedding receptions. They were playing "Music" and "Don't Tell Me" for sure and probably some others sprinkled in. Maybe even "Believe" by Cher in there too since it was kind of the kickoff for this pop girlie autotune electronica phase. Might have popped in "Ray of Light" too, why not. The y2k vibes and the economy were strong. The receptions were open bar. We had all kinds of "healthy" granola bars that were covered in chocolate. Life was so good. This album aged ooookay.
01) Music - 10,0 02) Impressive Instant - 8,5 03) Runaway Lover - 8,5 04) I Deserve It - 8,0 05) Amazing - 9,5 06) Nobody's Perfect - 8,5 07) Don't Tell Me - 10,0 08) What It Feels Like for a Girl - 10,0 09) Paradise (Not for Me) - 9,5 10) Gone - 8,5 TOTAL: 9,10 (91/100) Current ranking: 40/449 Finally some good pop after all that country, psychedelic rock, singer-songwriter bullshit I've been enduring for the past few weeks. Madonna really comes in like a ray of light... You either love pop or you don't. If you don't, you'll spit on this album and give it an average rating of 2.67. But if you like pop, this will easily be a 5 stars!
Of all the Madonna albums I thought might appear on this list, I think this would have been one of the last ones I would have picked. It's okaaaay, and it's nice to have a pop pick for a change but there are much better albums out there. Only the singles are the standout tracks. Mid.
Not gonna lie, this album fucks.
A couple of tracks have some interesting window-dressing, but this is wholly forgettable.
I am surprised how many genres Madonna had on this album. I expected the pop/disco, but not the beautiful ballads, the tech/world beat, nor the latin influenced conclusion. Truly a great album, even if it wouldn't make my personal top 50.
Only gets 2 because I made it all the way through.
Just terrible
Like chewing toilet paper.
I didn’t really mind this album and thought Don’t Tell Me was actually pretty good. There were no songs I absolutely hated but Paradise (Not For Me) went on for too long, however. I was about to give it a 3/5 but then the cover of American Pie came.
Vapid and pointless. But wildly successful, apparently. Once again it's people that are the real problem here.
Well, I was about to say I'm not a fan. A lot of songs on this are .. not to my liking. And I actually stopped after number 5 (Amazing), but started again for Nobody's Perfect, which wasn't bad. I made it to Paradise (Not for Me), and loved it. Gone wan't bad either. But I actually added Paradise to my liked list. Giving it 4 stars just for that one song.
I’ve always thought that Don’t Tell Me is Madonna’s most underrated single and that American Pie is her worst. The rest of the album is somewhere in the middle - and largely forgettable.
I'm not a big Madonna fan so I had low expectations before I started listening and was pleasantly surprised. A mix of techno/electronica with a little country-adjacent type music that is not bad. Music and Don't Tell Me both stood out. I did not care for Nobody's Perfect with the maxed-out auto-tune and I'll just pretend I didn't hear the American Pie cover.
Madonna’s country album? Ok then. I only remember the single off of it. Let’s see where else the album goes. Well first off I stand corrected: not a country album at all. I don’t hate the late 90s-early 2000s electronica production at all, it’s actually kinda fun. 3 stars if you ignore the bonus track, which we don’t talk about.
Great sounding album production-wise but otherwise this is not for me. The faux-cowboy stuff was painful. The Bjork-ripoff was even worse. The mighty beats in the first half saves this from a 1-star.
This could really be an album by anyone. Crack songwriters, sparkly producers: where is Madonna in all of this? The title track is a great pop tune, but that has little to do with who is fronting this. Could just as easily see (hear) Britney singing this and no-one would notice. I know they were a 'thing' at the time, but the over-autotuned vocals get wearing after a while too. I guess you had to be there. There is something really soulless and cynical about this whole set. The day the music died indeed.
Sorry. Just not my shit. It sounds like it was recorded underwater.
Nope
as if the title track wasn't already the most y2k artefact imaginable, ali g appears in the video. a quarter century is a long time indeed.
Everyones complaining about the American Pie cover and sure it's a bad cover but at least it's a good song? Couldn't say the same about a lot of others on this one.
American pie?
Country with pop themes - Experimental instrumentals that work pretty decent - Nothing offensive but no standouts either
This one has a lot of hits!
Skip
Jesus, that cover of American pie!
Madonna did the cowgirl thing before Beyoncé.
Rare madonna
Going from Ray of Light to this in two years should be a chargeable offence. It is no wonder that the word music is in quotation marks on the cover. Dull, uninspired, ticking boxes for a record. I hated this for how much I couldn't enjoy it - at least give me a reason to listen to it again even if it's so bad I have to laugh. This had nothing. And yet I will probably give Ray of Light four or five stars when I get it.
The girls that get it, get it
Mixed bag of songs, poor in parts. I always thought Madonna was incredibly derivative, she just does styles of music that is popular at the time and hopes for the best. The bjork style "Paradise" is a particular low light, however the American pie cover is a war crime. 2*
Bearable, but that American Pie cover is weapons-grade suck.
This does not need to be on this list. To me this is nothing more than an artifact from this time period in pop music. Slick production and too much autotune. It has a bit of an electronica and trip-hop vibe to it at times. But man this feels so forgettable and inconsequential. Just feature Madonna's good stuff on this list, no need to add this here.
Pop em estágio avançado de qualidade para explorar as camadas com elementos eletrônicos acessíveis sem ser massante.
I listened to this twice to be sure but I imagine it's controversial to say I thought this was bang average and didn't really like it at all. What it feels like for a girl, truly awful and irritating. I'm sorry. I can't like what I can't like. I didn't enjoy it
I really like this album. I think this was a great part of Madonna's career when she was making new, interesting, different music. She wasn't trying to recapture her old music or just bash out crap like she has done recently. I wished she'd stayed on this line.
Not as bad as I expected but it's still mostly dance pop. Probably two and a half stars.
I enjoyed it, although I prefer Madonna’s 80’s albums
I guess it could’ve been worse. Not sure why this one is here. Pretty generic early 2000s pop.
I liked it. Somewhat unexpectedly. I especially enjoyed the ballads. Obviously Madonna is a mature artist at this point in her career with little to prove except that she can create compelling material that reflects an artist that still has something to say. 1/2 star deduction for American Pie which adds little to the original besides a modern production. 3 stars
Couple hits on here and it’s good to see Madonna still had it later in her career.
Of all the albums in Madonna’s massive catalog, it’s been interesting to see what was chosen for this list. Neither, so far, have been my favorites, or her most influential. But this record does have her best track of all time: What It Feels Like for a Girl. Both the song and the video (directed by her then-husband Guy Ritchie) are the best she has ever produced. And for the artist with probably the most memorable, generation-defining records and videos, that’s really saying something. But this one is hands down the best. That said, the mixed media video for the title track did introduce the world to Sasha Baron Cohen. So there’s that, too. You can’t say shit to me about Madonna. It’s unreasonable, and I don’t care, but she’s gets 5s every time.
Sorry, Madge. Light Years by Kylie Minogue is WAY BETTER. Overall: 1/10
This kind of stinks. Madonna isn't my style and later Madonna doesn't seem to do anything that hasn't been done better before. Also the bonus track of American Pie is brutal.
Any other artist could have put out some decent music like this and just had Madonna as a feature on a track or two. This is kind of useless Makes sense that it has been removed from the list.
Another electronic tome with mediocre vocals and monotonous synths. Oh wait, it's Madonna? 🥱
Good
I’m not opposed to pop music, but this was not very good. Her foray into electronic based pop music falls flat. Most of the songs are boring and forgettable. 2/5 Won’t listen again
Good God is this bad. The robo-assault dance music is wholly unmoving. And as much as I dislike robot music, the tiny spaces without her voice are the best parts.
This might be harsh, but I have a head-cold and this album has gone straight through me. After the first couple of songs I did start to question whether it was me or the music - then that horrid autotune song came on and she started singing American Pie and I've concluded, as ever, Madge is the problem.
3.75
Not bad, maybe the end is a bit bland
2.3 Ok, let's ignore the unnecessary butchered American Pie at the end. I'm going to assume that was a bonus track only for the tape cassette release in Djibouti or something and that no one actually ever heard it. That wasn't as terrible as I expected, but overall still pretty poor. The only redeeming thing about it was the surprisingly ok two songs sequence in the middle with Don't Tell me and the Girl one. Other than that it was pretty mundane pop. I remember when autotune was (thankfully) briefly all the rage but it was always going to sound crap in hindsight. Nobody's Perfect is laughably bad as a result. The rest of I'm just waiting to end.