Music

Wow Music took me straight back to that era. I didn't know most of this album, but it encapsulates that period of music really well. 3* Highlights: music and don't tell me (because nostalgia)

Classics maar trager dan je denkt

не так бесит как в молодости (т. к. слишком перформатив), но конкретно это альбом слишком наавтотюненный, сильно не зацепил

Not bad, I've heard the hits from this album but never the whole thing. It's pretty good, the non hit songs are more of the same kind of pop music but it isn't tiring and has a catchy beat. Not sure I would go out of my way to listen to this again but it is not bad at all. If I happened upon it I wouldn't be upset.

The glitch-country-of “don’t tell me” is pretty good. And the warm wave of electronica of “what it feels like for a girl” is nice. “Gone” is another good one. Madonna herself doesn’t exactly shine on this album, but I kinda like the production.

The two big singles from this are good songs, but they also belie how fantastically weird the album around them is. The rest of what's here sound like Madonna was listening to a lot of Air, but also sort of presages hyperpop and the wider crossover of French House? Like Homework was already out, and "Around the World" had had a little impact, but this album came out two months before "One More Time". It's not a *great* album, but it is a fascinating one, and a great example of Madonna's ability to anticipate trends, even in the middle portion of her career.

Not really a fan but there is enough here for 3 stars or C as a rating.

bissi trash, bissi gut

i KNOW i can’t be the only one who has seriously been vibing to some music lately… i enjoyed listening to this!! it always feels a little weird to, like, sit down and listen to a dancey pop album like this; nevertheless i did like it. yeah it’s cheesy but it’s cute!!! yay!!!

that was cute and fun. it sounds a bit dated to me though. it had a lot of leftover stylings of her 90s music but with some of the sort of early 2000s techno flourishes on it which made it really sound like a time capsule of that era in a way that i think did not age super well. i think that's typical of pop and it doesn't make it bad music, it just doesn't sound fresh in the way that some of her (even older) music still does. fav tracks: Runaway Lover, Gone, Impressive Instant

Meh

No. 268/1001 Music 3/5 Impressive Instant 2/5 Runaway Lover 3/5 I Deserve It 3/5 Amazing 3/5 Nobody's Perfect 3/5 Don't Tell Me 3/5 What It Feels Like For A Girl 4/5 Paradise 2/5 Gone 4/5 American Pie 4/5 Average: 3,09 I get what she tried to do with this album. Just didn't click for me.

7/10

I'm, conflicted on this one. It would have been genuinely groundbreaking at the time, inspiring ultimately better artists (Goldfrapp), but it also popularised the shit trend of autotune

Rating: 7/10 Very good album overall. The production was definitely the standout, blending pop with electronic and country. Pretty experimental and sounds like this album had a large influence on other 2000s pop artists. Most of this aged pretty well (besides the horrendous autotune) and is mostly pretty catchy as well. Favorite songs: Music, I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Paradise (Not for Me), Gone. Worst song: Nobody's Perfect.

It was just alright, not one of her better albums

A few good songs and a few unlistenable songs. Overall not for me

This album wouldn't exist without Cher's Believe. With that said, there are some truly fun songs on here if you don't take it too seriously. Afterall, "it's the millennium."

Honestly surprised by how much I enjoyed this. The production was minimal yet polished. The combination of acoustic guitar, house style beats, and pop vocals made for a fun listen. 3.5 / 5

Madonna has some legendary songs. None of the songs in this album are among them.

Als damals Music damals auf dem Markt kam, war ich sehr enttäuscht. Es fällt deutlich ab im Vergleich zu "Ray of Light". Heute bin ich immer noch der Meinung, dass es zu den schwächeren Alben gehört, muss aber feststellen, dass es mir jetzt viel besser gefällt. "Music" und "American Pie" ist immer noch grauenhaft, aber ansonsten ist es sehr gut anzuhören. "I deserve" " Can't Tell you" Weltklasse.

Madonna's extraordinary collaboration with Scottish legend, Hamish the DJ. I've not listened to this album for over twenty years. I remember it being a surprising continuation of the redemption of Madonna after her slippage of the mid 90s. Music is actually a corking track - the bass is thumping and pumping and it leads nicely to Impressive Instant, which is a track that had completely exited my memory until it kicked off with an absolutely wicked four-on-the-floor beat that invigorates me in ways I might even be ashamed of it wasn't so damn good. Clearly Madonna had taken notice of Boris wosshischops' mixing for Moloko's Sing It Back because it's almost the same level of good. Runaway Lover suffers a bit for being too "out there" - it can't support the tempo it sets itself and feels five years too late, missing Prodigy and Kosheen doing this what it tries to, but nowhere near as well. The vocals sound disconnected and that's a shame. We then come onto a bit of a "Can you try and make me sound a bit like Dido?" sort of track in I deserve it, and I'm tempted to skip. In fact, at over four minutes it IS a skip, because it does everything it needs to within about 50 seconds. Amazing, put onto this album in the year 2000, has incredible resonance in late 2024 with "Hagmaxxing" being the word du jour. Madonna was doing it back in the day, Gen Z. Nobody's Perfect is an abomination of vocoding and it gets a skip straight into the "Madonna being a bastard hybrid of Green Day and Cheryl Crow" that is Don't Tell Me, and that almost gets a skip too. It doesn't, but only because I quite like that start/stop thing it does. It's also (weirdly) the most "Madonna-voice" track in the whole recording. And I quite like that. She has actually got a good voice, and it's nice to hear it almost unfettered here. The whole rest of this album can do one, though. Do I know what it feels like for a girl? No, surprisingly. As other commentors here have said, that cover version of American Pie is a pickled turd. Rating this album for the first 2 tracks, it'd get a comfortable 5. It doesn't hold its energy well enough to be more than a 3.

Really not that memorable to me

Strange, poppy music

Reasonable range of styles

Fun and enjoyable, pop done right

When one thinks of Madonna albums, one easily thinks of any of her first five; Madonna; Like a Virgin; True Blue; Like a Prayer; and Erotica. those albums are trailblazers and ones that are truly mandatory listens. Music and its one hit that felt like Madonna was reinventing herself… again are okay but not an example of a good portion of her output. 3/5

Listened to this with my husband, on our way up north for a little weekend vacation. I mostly liked it but it did sound pretty dated. I forgot all about the other non-“Music” singles on this.

Better than expected. Some great production flourishes and more interesting subject matters. Sadly it also contains one of the most dogshit cover versions in human history, of American Pie. Impressive as I couldn't think of a way to make that mawkish turd worse myself!

I remember this being the album where Madonna completely lost me. It just felt like she was trying to keep up with where popular music was going, but it didn't feel like there was much if any of her in the music. Actually sitting down to listen to the album didn't really change my opinion about that. It's fine, but I also can't justify this album making this list. Ray of Light I could understand, but this album feels far too pedestrian to be one of the 1001 albums I should listen to before my execution 3/5

It’s true, music does make the people come together. And I guess sometimes it unites the bourgeois and the rebels. But more often it just lets the bourgeois cosplay as rebels. Just because some rich kids go out to the club and dance with the riff raff to the music of one of the wealthiest artists of all time doesn’t mean they’re gonna wake up from their hangover the next day and try to change the world. It’s all performative and temporary.

Hate American pie and the title track, but the rest of it is okay.

Much like her face these days, too much filler

Previously rated: Ray Of Light (3/5) *********************** After the first half, I was leaning towards a 4/5. Really solid dance music with some throwback 80s effects. Then the awful auto-tune in Nobody's Perfect and the annoying sound cutting out on the next track Don't Tell Me, I have to take a point off. I'd still rather listen to any of her first four albums.

Not heard any of this before. It surprised me how different it was to what I'm used to from her. Despite being intriguing the experimental sounds don't pay off on every track. I do like how each track sounds so distinct to the previous one. There were some decent tracks but I think I'd need to listen again to fully get the album. Highlights: Impressive Instant Runaway Lover

Madonna 3/3 (after LaP and RoL) HL: “Amazing”, “What It Feels Like For a Girl”, title track Can’t love it, can’t hate it. Exists in a blind spot I have in late 90’s/early aughts pop. Orbit’s work on the track “Amazing” makes me think I underrated his work on Ray of Light. It does anticipate 2000s dance-pop trends as some critics have suggested, but to me they’re all the ones that make me look back and think “what a tacky era of music” But to illustrate my biases, I put on Robyn’s Body Talk (2010) on for the first time the other day, and I don’t think that aged the best either. Would definitely choose that over Madonna’s eighth album on a list of this caliber, though

Pretty catchy

Nunca he sido el más fan de Madonna. No está mal, pero seguro tiene varios mejores. De esos que no entiendo bien que hacen en la lista.

Mixed reaction to this one. I wasn’t looking forward to it when it popped up. However the first bunch of songs I thought were quite good. Unfortunately by the time I hit Nobody’s Perfect the electronically manipulated voice had worn me down and it lost me from that point forward.

The American Pie cover sucks, but there’s some great songs.

Experimental weird album. The production is crazy. Sounds like they listened to daft punks homework and a bunch of 90s techno. The sings is strange. Madonna is strange. I was interested by this album and could see it being influential but I don’t think it would be accurate to say I liked this album. Bizarre stuff

Forgettable

As much as I dislike electronica, pop and dance music, I have to say this album is very good. Madonna reinventing herself after years of domination and fussioning a ton of different generes to make this experimental album which turned out to be better than ever expected. Dont love any specific song but after listening to it in order without interruptions I can say its a top Madonna album and probably top of that genere. This rates high because of the context of Madonna having to bring something new and different to the table and she brought it. The slow songs kill the vibe mood for me but still those are decent songs.

Not her best, but she reinvents herself each album. The autotune song had to go, though.

7/24/24. Admittedly, this is my first time giving Madonna a true shot. I have to say I liked this one, went in without expectations. Pretty clean and enjoyable pop record, just can't decide if this should be a 3 or a 4. My true rating is a 3.5.

Hope there is more Madonna on the list if this is essential. Some bangers though

Favorites Amazing Nobody’s perfect What it feels be like for a girl

"I deserve it" and "amazing" were the best tracks for me, the rest was a bit bland/boring, wasn't what I was expecting from madonna.

Much less worse than anticipated. Holy shit is that American Pie cover the absolute worst thing I've heard in a long time.

A slightly hunched, crabbit Madonna stares us down from the album cover. There is something uncanny about her visage, which is just as well; for half this album she sounds like a glitching android. The other half, well, it's Madonna - she sings with the same expression as most hostages give in proof-of-life videos. That's not to say that there isn't any interest in 'Music'. In fact, as a studio confection there's plenty to enjoy, Madonna and her producers throwing the entire box of tricks at almost every tune going. Just as well, because beneath the bells and whistles are some rather cookie cutter melodies and uninspired song craft. However, I'm almost missing the point here - 'Music' very much is a collection of gaudy sounds and aural gewgaws - it's tinsel all the way down, boys.

I’ve always discounted this album as auto-tune early-2000s bad dance music. After listening to it properly I still don’t like this Madonna like I do 80s Madonna, but it kind of works together and she hadn’t changed as much as I thought. It’s weird they auto-tune her sometimes when she can clearly sing. Probably needs another listen, sadly I don’t have time. I have discovered it has a French producer so another example of French EDM seeming to be not my thing. Fave Track: I Deserve It Rating: 3

Das Nachfolgealbum von "Ray of Light" ist im Vergleich zu steril, zu perfekt produziert, irgendwie ohne Seele. Allein schon die Coverversion "American pie" kommt gar nicht an das Original heran und ist seelenlos. Dennoch spricht der Mut von Madonna, einen Stilwechsel vorzunehmen, für sie. Countrymusik ist in dieser Form auch für das jüngere Publikum gut erreichbar

6,30

3/5. These are some solid electronic pop songs. I do hear the genre bending, and I think it works for a lot of the faster songs but when it slows down, it's hard to really follow and enjoy for some of them. There is even some influence from Alt Rock, R&B, country that I can hear. It's unique and enjoyable but I don't think it's perfect. It might go up in rating on more listens, which I do want to do, but don't think I super enjoyed it save for some songs. Best Song: Music, What It Feels Like For A Girl, Paradise (Not For Me)

Avaus on helpon tuntuinen mutta pirun tehokas: yksi kuuntelu ei riitä. Jos viehättyisin enemmän aikakauden elektronisesta tarkkuudesta, kuuntelisin loputkin uudelleen. Toimiva LP.

it’s a mess but a decent one

Don’t have to much to day about this one! A fine listen

Coolt men lite långtråkigt

First Madonna album I've listened to. It was fine.

Pop music. Over produced. Some people love it. This is the first time I’ve ever purposefully listened to Madonna. It sounded exactly how I thought it would.

This wasn't bad.

The second album in Madonna's maturity phase. We've got some millennium pop optimism going on but it has actually aged better than some of the other albums from this era. A few solid songs make this a good collection.

There are a few duds on this. It's mostly really good though.

This album made quite a comeback for me... It started out pretty bad but really enjoyed the mid to back end of the record. I still prefer the earlier Madonna album, Like a Prayer, but pleasantly surprised.

This is not a preferred genre in my rotation, but I do recognize the cultural significance of the artist, and have much respect for the way she has been able to reinvent herself and evolve continuously to maintain relevance for 40 years. All that said, this album pales in comparison to everything she did leading up to this release. The two singles merit and I can see where they achieved mainstream success. There rest is average at best IMO. 2.5/5

I thought I was gonna be like a virgin when listening to this one since I really don’t know much of her songs outside of the hits. But then around track six I heard that stupid Cher-inspired autotune vocal modulation effect and I realized I wasn’t being touched for the very first time. I liked the acoustic meets electronic element on some tracks, but outside of the two known singles it all just started to sound the same.

The fact that THIS Madonna album is on the list makes me think we have another 2-3 Madonna albums to go... she has never been my favorite and not sure why it was selected to represent her catalog. I did enjoy Music and Don't Tell Me, but the rest is kinda meh (especially when she leans heavily on Autotune). 2.5/5

First track is gorgeous

Perfectly good.

Not her best album. The 80's techno vibe was really weak. Didn't age well

some decent, some poorer I liked the instrumental parts more than her singing

This sounds like a mix of electropop and general acoustic pop. I don't really know why it's on the list since it isn't one of Madonna's essential albums, as far as I understand. "Paradise (Not For Me)" is a great track, though.

Liked this a lot. Talented lady singing about her boyfriends and break ups a bit like Ray of Light but not quite as good

Ágætt stöff. Alls ekki hennar besta.

Some hits I remember and still enjoy. Pseudo-experimental sound but also feels dated and sonically trendy for 2000. Some beautiful poetry mixed in between some cheesy lyrics.

album wasn’t bad, i’d just say it was decent, the title track was good, and there was an empowering feel in the music, overall the music didn’t blow me away but i respect madonna for her influence

Super poppy, not a huge fan of Madonna but a couple of these tracks aged well imo (better than others) 2.7

Kinda surprised that Music was picked, this really feels like M was chasing the trends instead of forming them. Additionally, William Orbit’s production doesn’t really hold up. But, this is the first Madonna era I really remember- I knew who she was and some of her older songs, but I vividly recall hearing and seeing the videos for the title track and “Don’t Tell Me” often. So there’s definitely nostalgic attachment to it, even if this isn’t her best. C

Wasn't expecting to see Madge pop up again. I suppose this album is evocative of very specific moment in pop culture when she was still relevant and not yet completely cringeworthy. (I say this as someone who went through a HUGE Madonna phase, and did in fact see her on tour in 2004). She did do a bit of a country western aesthetic revival that influenced early aughts fashion. Music and Don't Tell Me were both hits with memorable music videos that got lots of rotation on MuchMusic and/or MTV. It's what I expected though, the hits are hits and they still slap but the rest of this album is boring filler. There isn't anything edgy or exciting here. It's basic pop drivel. I do still love the classic or canon Madonna eras (1983-2005) and respect what she's done as an artist. But everything she's done after Confessions on a Dance Floor has been embarrassing to witness. I don't want to be ageist, BUT, I do wish she'd chosen to age a bit more gracefully like Cher has and act in a way befitting an icon; a way that doesn't diminish her legacy the way all the "edgy" lingerie, grills, and face filler are doing now.

Quite a bit of musical genres in this one. Another end of college days for me. Know the album well.

Good enough to just have playing in the background and ignore.

Wow the opening track took me right back to that time. I like this because it’s basically an electronic album featuring Madonna. Producers deserve title credits!

Following her electro-pop success of Ray of Light, we see similar creativity and excellent electronic production on this record. This one is brighter, faster, and louder. It's also more traditional of a pop album than Ray of Light, which I think serves as a weakness. It's more predictable and it seems like the music is disjoint from Madonna's singing. She also shows less personality and emotion in these songs. The first 3 tracks are a strong start and gives you an idea what this album should have been. Instead, it takes a turn from there with 3 lame tracks: a lifeless ballad, a generic dance tune, and a Cher-level autotune disaster that drags on for 5 minutes of the same line over and over. "Don't Tell Me" is the only song that fits the "cowgirl" design she was going for, with a pleasant blend of electronic, pop, and country that doesn't go too crazy. The following track is some dreamy downtempo, a bit boring and repetitive but also pleasant. "Paradise" is the most creative song and could definitely fit on Ray of Light. And finally, "Gone" is an underwhelming but fitting closer. In comparison to Ray of Light, I do feel it's less consistent and less innovative. The highs don't reach the same, and the lows are just awful. But you do still have top-of-the-notch production skill, and there is quite a bit of surprising innovation throughout.

Seems only tangentially related to Madonna. Could have been anyone singing these tracks. I think I had heard 2 of the songs on here before. It was inoffensive and forgettable but okay for what it is.

3.5

I never really liked her music...

bis auf Music und American Pie solala

Surprisingly unremarkable for Madonna

This was quite fun despite some very odd production in places. The songwriting wasn’t quite as strong as the previous Madonna albums on this list (Like a Prayer and Ray of Light), and I’m surprised this made it on over something like True Blue. It was a good time though, even if a bit inconsistent

nowhere near as good as Like a Prayer. don’t love the more “modern” vibe she went for here. not bad though just not good

very 2000 sounding production, sometimes veers into S-Club but a couple of solid smashes in there

3 --- Excelente calidad de grabación y producción. Salvo por los éxitos, los demás tracks son de relleno

What it feels like for a girl er best, Don't tell me er fínt og American Pie hefur sinn sjarma þrátt fyrir ég fíli originalinn betur. Hitt er ágætur filler.

DO NOT BE FOOLED: THIS IS NOT MADONNA'S COUNTRY ALBUM. IN FACT SHE HAS NEVER DONE A COUNTRY ALBUM. Madonna's entry into the 2000's after Ray of Light was bold and brash (more like belongs in the trash!) When pop stars such as Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, and Jessica Simpson were modeling their careers after her, Madonna was choosing to innovate and experiment with her own music. The result is a mix of house, folk, downtempo, and other diverse sound influencing her approach to electropop. The result is a mixed bag where some songs definitely work better than others. I commend Madonna for being so willing to evolve and attempting to synthesize new elements. It's just that some parts of the album come across as painfully dated, and the American Pie cover should've been dropped.

Blandly fine? Finely bland? The American Pie cover is a shocker.

Some catchy songs but ultimately a pretty unsophisticated venture into electronic pop.

Pretty good

No way near as good as her other album from the era that is on this list. Bit too bland.

2.75

Out of all her albums this one made the list? "I like to singy singy singy like a bird on a wingy wingy wingy"

Not her best. Ok

This album was a pretty good pop album. A few of the songs were superhits from back in the day. All around it seemed to be pretty experimental with it's glitchy sounds and futuristic uses of electronics. It didn't succeed all the time, but was pretty good nonetheless. 3.3/5 -> 3/5.

This is the album Madonna reinvented her image as a cowgirl... and then theres people who still give it low star..

Not the best pick of Madonna albums. Why this is on the list and the earlier work not (f.e. Like a Virgin), beats me.

I generally like Madonna, and have a soft spot for her earlier stuff. This didn't do much for me.

la reprise qui cloture l’album c’est pour m’achever

Alright pop

Madonna blends country and pop well on some of the tracks. Others are standard Madonna pop.

After three opening cuts – which are silly and synthetic, completely disposable club music – there is much to like here. Her voice is/was still in good shape at this point but one woulda like more room for the beats/beds to live and breathe. Perhaps the production was a big deal. The stop-start effect on "Don't Tell Me" is silly. This song also sounds like she's channeling Sublime -- how the mighty have fallen. And poor Joe Henry; his version of this cut -- his own -- is about 1,000 times cooler, though hopefully the royalties from his sister-in-law have cheered him up. The more organic the songs – that is the least plastic and clubby – the better (see "I Deserve It, ' "Gone"). One assumes "Nobody's Perfect" was a relatively early adoption of Autotune (again, who cares?) which doesn't sound any better today and the weird effects (a theremin with sinus congestion?). Best moment of the whole record is the vibe/bed toward the beginning of "What It Feels" but rest of song doesn't remotely do it justice (so maybe h/t to producer on that one). Overall, it's hard to resist the conclusion that this is a trend-chasing exercise by a celebrity desperate to stay relevant. But at least's polished, well-made and often pleasurable.

A more mellow Madonna.

Ik was hiervan aan t genieten. Vond het veel nicer dan ik dacht dat ik het zou vinden, het klonk goed, heel nice geproduceerd etc. Toen kwam american pie

don't think I'll revisit but really not as bad as I expected after really hating "Ray of Light"

It's not her best, and in some ways a bit indulgent. Her French is worse than mine. We didn't need to spend three minutes on Paradise (which should be paradis).

The first few tracks and interesting with a curious electronic vibe, but I like the later tracks that a little bit more mellow and moody. It definitely feels like a mature pop record, though there is nothing catchy enough to warrant repeat listens.

The Queen of Pop shows she’s quite comfortable on the throne, even if her status was starting to slip by the turn of the millennium. The lyrics are a bit clunky, but the beats remain danceable and her confidence shines through. (Side note: Don’t Tell Me was cowritten by Madonna’s brother-in-law Joe Henry, who has a highly underrated music career of his own—including his own take on Don’t Tell Me on his 2001 album Scar, though there it’s called Stop. Extremely recommended!)

Not bad. I can appreciate that she evolved her sound but I guess I like her earlier albums better.

Most of my opinions of Madonna stem from my early exposure to her role in "A League of Their Own" This album, while not my favorite, earns a solid three

Baby making music. But where are the hits, Madge?

somes songs sounded really awkward but others weren't half bad. truly the second half is better than the first. Felt like a fake dance album.

Not for me, but it's clearly well produced and designed to get you moving. 3 The wikipedia article for this album is *sprawling*. This lady has some fans.

эй мистер диджей.. бля, это так старо оказывается... кавер на american pie такой себе, но отчасти понимаю в рамках контекста альбома алкоальбом: маргарита в клубе ночном (3+)

Second half of the album improves a lot. Was not expecting this from Madonna

Had a few good laughs listening to this. It's late-era Madonna, the older pop star trying to keep up with the youngin's. In the era of Britney Spears and whoever else, Madonna puts out this. The production ranges from really cool and interesting to just silly, and that's sort of the album as a whole. I skipped a few songs on here, which is never a good sign, but I also found myself enjoying even more. And "Don't Tell Me" is one I've certainly heard before. I can't really give this more than three stars in good faith because it's goofy and has skips, but I'm not as mad at the inclusion that I worried I would be. Thankfully it's not the only Madonna on the list. Favorite tracks: Music (funny), I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, Paradise (Not For Me), Gone. Album art: The cherry on top, and what had me worried most of all. The album is called "Music," which is dumb enough on its own, but it's a picture of rancher Madonna? This isn't even a country album, I can only remember one song that arguably veers into country-ish instrumentals, why's she doing all this? I hope she was having a laugh here because I certainly am. 3/5

Much better than I expected it to be, but not amazing either. I definitely underestimated Madonna. 7/10 Top 3: 1. Paradise (Not for Me) 2. Gone 3. Impressive Instant

Ordinary Madonna Pop. Nice, but with sone exceptions boring

What is this album doing in this list?! "Madonna" and "Like A Virgin" are 5 star. "True Blue" is 4.5 and "Like a Prayer" is 4 star. "Frozen" is 4 star, just like "Confessions on a Dance Floor". All other Madonna albums are 3 star at most. Out of these remaining albums, Music is one of the best. It is perhaps a bit more consistent than Frozen, but Frozen contains four absolute 5-star singles, and Music contains none: a couple 4 star, a couple 2 star, rest is 3 star. my vote in 2000: 6/10 my vote in 2024: 6/10

Not a bad album, but why pick this one for the 1001 list?

Oof - first play through I was leaning towards a 2, but maybe I was just in a mood that day - the second play through it isn't striking me as being quite as objectionable. It definitely feels like Madonna is trying to play catch up with Björk or something, right? A couple of the tracks feel like sub standard Daft Punk or Air knock offs. Fave tracks - "Gone" maybe? "Don't Tell Me" is the least objectionable of the singles...

not bad

It would be actually good without the auto tunes

meh

The early 2000s auto tune trend was rough

3 songs at 4/5 stars, the rest 1/2... I dunno about the maths on that, but it's another mixed bag Madonna album that's for sure.

decent album, seemed samey for the genre.

J'aime bien Madonna, mais pas mes chansons préférées ! Mes préférées: Music et Paradise (Not for me) j'ai bien aimé sa voix et le rythme pour celles ci

Definitely good! I liked the first song "music" and all the instrumentals on the other songs. Good voice and lyrics 3.7

A quick listen. While Madonna is a talented artist, I don't particularly care for her style of music.

2000, vuosien vuosi.. milleniumin vaihtovuosi ... uudet teknologiat autotunet sun muut löydetty.. käyteätään tässä täydessä vauhdissa.. varmaan luuli että joku futuurinen saundi heh... JA OIKEASSA OLI.. MAHTAVAA ROBO TEKNOLOGIA LAULAU... hulluja pliippejä ja plööppejä, tieto kone polkkaa.. mutta mikäs tuo american pie coveri, ei hitannut tällä kertaa paradise (not for me)

Pop. Folk

Madonna has been making danceable hits for 40 years. “Music” and “Don’t Tell Me” took me straight back to middle school—Probably haven’t heard those songs for 20 years. Loved the club/house tracks on this album but everything else wasn’t too compelling. Three stars.

Mehdonna effort to stay rlevant.

Full of bops but nosedives at the end into a very unnecessary cover of American Pie.

Good

First cut is great. Some other catchy tunes including a nice cover of American Pie.

Not as groundbreaking as other might say just because they remember few songs from MTV.

Wouldn't really listen to this much

Cringe at times, visionary at others. The deep exploration of the early 2000s pop textures makes this read more like hyperpop than pop.

Ah the autotune era. Has this always been Madonna's thing? Interesting to hear more and feel/experience Madonna's branding of herself as an innocent, sexy girl. 'Music' is a great song, the rest of the album wasn't much for me.

Never listened to entire album. Enjoyed it. But it's MADONNA . . . . .

Niet direct mijn meug, maar ik kan het wel nog appreciëren

The first song is not bad, but the rest of the songs are not necessarily better.

# 119 : Kind of ok well rounded album. There's definitely some filler though. A bit lame for a "Super star", but I liked it more then I thought I would. Fun to listen to, but nothing mind blowing. Favourite Track : Amazing Listened : 28/11/2023

Some great moments in there

Good album, Madonna’s foray into pop electronica is an enjoyable listen. 3/5 mainly only because as much as I enjoyed it, I won’t listen to it regularly.

Better-than-respectable, and the experimentation toes a brave line, Don't Tell Me sublimating the genuinely annoying. However, the album's a seriously mixed bag, and the concept never quite comes together but always slightly binds.

Couple of bangers but not enough

Not actually that bad, some funk/soul influences in there.

Inoffensive

It had it's moments. Kinda felt like the start of a bit of "listen to me, I'm still cool. I can hang with the new girls on the scene" kinda vibe. The "futuristic" pop sounds didn't age too well. And why is she wearing a cowboy hat?

Madonna is tight. Crazy looking these days, but such a good artist. Weird, poppy (for its time) and good energy. Reminds me of a country Britney spears album

This album is kind of like the opposite of Transformer for me. I think Madonna is a pretty good singer. Don't get me wrong, I think Lou Reed's singing could grow on me with future listens to other Lou Reed albums as well as the Velvet Underground albums, but I wasn't a big fan of his singing. What I'm trying to say is that while I think the singing was the worst part of Transformer, I think the best part of Madonna's "Music" is her singing. Nothing else really stuck out to me that much. I didn't like the sound on a lot of the songs. I just don't think that the contrast between the techno sound and the almost folk-like sound work well together. Some of the songs dragged on for me. Did "Paradise (Not for Me)" really need to be 6 minutes? Some of the songs were good though. I think the closer, Gone, is the best song in the album. The editing just isn't my thing a lot of the time. Overall, I can see why others might like it a bit and I understand why this album is on here, but this just isn't my thing at all. low 3/5.

It was ok but nothing grabbed my attention

Some hits and misses

Queen of Pop I prefer some of her other albums over this one though

I should have been less surprised that the 5th highest selling artist of all time has decent music. Too poppy for my tastes, but did a lot with it. Interesting.

I'm scared of Madonna

Madonna is catchy as always. Most of it is a bit too cheesy for my taste, but it’s still really good! My favorite of the album is Nobody’s Perfect - it sounds like a modern day down tempo electronic banger! Includes legendary song American Pie as the outro.

Next album please

I was prepared for this to be an utter trainwreck. But it wasn't, some of it was quite, ahem, 'musical.' However the less said about the horror of the American Pie cover, the better.

This proves why Madonna ruled all pop music

Klassiker

la quiero mucho pero no me pinta tanto este género ah 7.5/10

Totally remember the time this electro producer Madonna record dropped, a certain feeling of postmodern genre clashing made everything feel cocainy euphorical before 9/11 hangover awakeing. Also humour wenn from Ali G then to Achmed „l’ll kill you“ the dead terrorist. Rrrreprezent!

American Pie ruined it for me :/

This was good but not great, some good songs but not the absolute consistency of a great pop album.

Hmm. On a re-listen this feels like a bit of a curate's egg, betrayed by three different producers. Three stellar tracks in Music, What It Feels Like and closer Gone. But bits of it feel like out-takes from Ray of Light, bits of it feel like a not quite fully achieved French filter house album, and bits of it are a bit duff. Then of course one of the worst covers of all time. So can't give it more than three stars.

La génération d'avant avait des goûts de chiottes.

Un anniversaire dans une ambiance des plus obscures, l'appartement de Robert est en effet plongé dans le noir depuis plusieurs longs mois. Personne n'est venu nous ouvrir à notre arrivée, nous avons donc decidé de célébrer ces 900 albums dans la sobrieté, non sans lâcher quelques larmes au passage.

no false advertising here: it's definitely music by madonna

This was pretty good. Some familiar tracks, really liked the cover of American Pie.

Not her best, but pretty good. 3 stars.

Not her best but I did love this when it was realised

There is a fitting pop superstar arrogance to just naming a release "Music". Madonna signing about what music does to the "bourgeoisie" is the icing on the cake. Obviously with the sort of team behind something like this, there are catchy pop earworms aplenty. I think this list has leaned too heavily into this artist's later catalog; its all pretty forgettable.

This is my least favorite Madonna album, but I do love Impressive Instant. The rest sounds dated & bland compared to her other work. It's honestly disappointing to see this one & not Confessions on a Dance Floor - that one has an ABBA sample for christ's sake! I will always love/hate Madonna, and she'll always be The Queen of Pop, but this album is a general dud.

Best lekker eens een keer zo’n album te luisteren

2.5

Good but also has some weak moments. What It Feels Like For A Girl is my favourite.

This album incorporates disco, trance, electro-pop, and country/folk elements. Though the use of these elements is not new, the fact that they’re all present in a pop album by a blockbuster artist is really fascinating. The album does sound really dated due to the effects it uses and its production style, but I did really enjoy it as it gave me a new perspective of an artist who is known for her earlier groundbreaking pop work. Madonna is clearly interested in musical growth and even if it doesn’t always land, I appreciate her trying to expand her horizons.

Pretty good, but honestly nothing really brings me back to it.

Better than expected but still felt a little forgettable

I vaguely recall when this album came out, and it was being heralded as a marked turn in Madonna's career. Listening some 22 years later, it doesn't really have much sense of being groundbreaking, indeed some of the content seems quite dated (see 'Feels Like For A Girl'). Still, there are a few decent tracks, including the titular 'Music' which I recall featured none other than Ali G in the accompanying video

This was fine and I liked it but Madonna is the pop dance goddess and this wasn’t her.

This is not in the latest issues of the book anymore. Probably because it's not different enough from Ray of Light. It's not the worst album on the list by far, so that can't be the reason. It's alright. Not a record I would pick myself. Favorite song: What it feels like for a girl

Good follow up to Ray of Light with some harder house and some indie songs. Awful version of American Pie with unnecessary nursery music.

Back in the day my co-judge and I danced to the title track at Club Med, where it was on high rotation. Madonna made a smart move two years earlier, by teaming up with William Orbit for a fresh club sound and here she adds another producer to the mix with good results, though outside of "Music" the up-tempo tracks aren't as strong. Not often you'll find a multi platinum pop album with such adventurous (for its time) production. As far as transformations go, Madonna's not in the same school as David Bowie or Miles Davis but she's up there. In this version I find the Cowboy image is a bit confusing, considering the overall sound.

I didn’t mind this. A couple of good tracks and a reasonable listen. I’m not familiar with all her albums but I quite liked this point in her career. 3*

Some enjoyable moments and crystal clear production certainly keeps Madonna relevant but Music struggles to match up to the title track and is, overall, a little stodgy.

Heb nog nooit goed naar Madonna geluisterd maar ik vond het wel interessant. Er zitten een aantal spacende nummers tussen. Ik vond het niet bijzonder goed maar wel verrassend

definitely of its time

A real mixed bag with high highs and low lows. Has aged suprisingly well for the most part, considering that its 25 years old at the time of these lines. In all the lows (nobody's perfect) drag the thing too much down for 4 stars that the highs (Don't tell me; What it feels like for a girl) would deserve.

61 of 1001 Madonna - Music Favorite Track : Music Rating : 3 / 5 (Rounded Up) It wasn't as bad as I expected. A bit toned down for Madonna. Some songs seemed more suited for a 20 year old, but who am I to judge?

3/.55 A few great songs.

Year 2000 pop, nice to listen to but nothing mind blowing

I often gripe about production. This has 5* production...total credit to that dude. Tbh its a very listenable album. Some of the lyrics are a bit hokey and there are track (nobody's perfect) with a auto tune thing that i skipped. And American Pie was an execrable cover. Almost a 4.

Some brilliant dance production on this. It's not quite ray of light for me, but it's a very good album

Madonna es trobava en un moment dolç, després de la seva recuperació artística i comercial amb 'Ray of Light'. Aquí va continuar amb la seva pròpia reinvenció com a icona rellevant en el nou mil.leni. Ho feia, de nou, juntant-se amb alguns dels grans noms del moment. Una tàctica intel.ligent que encara li serviria durant un bon grapat d'anys. El resultat és un treball interessant, inspirat, basat en les cançons, cada una d'elles tractada com una obra en si mateixa. Temes com 'Nobody's Perfect', 'Amazing' o el propi 'Music' es troben entre el millor de la seva discografia; tot ell un treball molt consistent

I mean yeah it was music

Ah it's fairly shite tbh. Music is a banger, what it feels like... is okay, there is a.l.o.t. of filler, and that American Pie cover is an abomination.

Thought I’d hate this but it wasn’t bad. Obviously the American Pie cover is terrible. But I don’t really like the original that much anyway.

A good pop album. There's definitely some filler though. But I like that a lot of songs have the eccentric feel of experimental electronica (especially the early tracks). The production gets a little adventurous.

Listened a while ago don't remember it

So, Madonna got together with William orbit and a few other late 90s producers and made an album where she's a cowgirl singing over house beats. OK. I mean, there's part of this I like in theory, but I just don't think Madonna can pretend to be the source of electronic underground, especially in a Stetson.

way more musically unique than I thought it owuld be. cool time signature stuff

I’ve always been a little confused how Madonna became the icon that she is today. This album did not clear up any confusion, but I’m looking forward to hearing her earlier work

Banging. Sonically, this comes across as an underground album - urgent, mysterious. Good tunes, too But it runs out of steam during side 1. If it was all as good as the first 3 tracks it would be a four star LP. But, no. 2 stars

I don't think there could be a more rando Madonna album here. Sure, she's immensely influential, but this album isn't really one of her profound ones. Yea, we know the first track, but the rest just kind-of blend into forgetfulness.

ooit was deze dame relevant, maar dat is al zeer veel manen geleden

just not that into her you know Will I listen to again: 0%

Toen dit album uitkwam dacht ik eigenlijk al dat niemand Madonna meer echt serieus nam. Net als dat opgezette lijk van Cher met d'r hit 'Believe'. Blijkbaar hoort dit album toch thuis in een snoblijst. We doen het er maar mee. De openingstrack ken ik en vind ik daarom nog wel aardig, maar daarna begint voor mij eigenlijk het grote uitzitten. Ik vind dit redelijk ruk verder, ik kan er niks mee, heb er geen zin in. Daar staat tegenover dat het wel een prima productie is natuurlijk, Madonna heeft genoeg centen om dat allemaal netjes af te kopen. De nummers op dit album interesseren me gewoon echt helemaal niet. Ik heb hier nog het album 'Fantastic' van Toy-Box liggen, die bevindt zich een beetje in het zelfde straatje met dezelfde geluidseffecten en die zet ik 10 keer liever aan. 'Don't tell me' halverwege het album is ook nog wel aardig, die kennen we uiteraard ook. En aan het einde heb je nog wat herkenbaarheid met die potsierlijke 'American Pie' cover. Twee sterren.

⭐⭐ Inte så speciellt, även med Madonna mått mätt finns det bättre och intressantare album. Låtskrivarmässigt tycker jag detta albumet är beige. Alldeles för få bra spår för att bygga ett helt album känns som en axelryckning att lyssna på det här albumet. Det blir en 2a. Bäst är Music, Don't tell me, Gone

Correct

I didn't like Madonn's music when it came out 45 years ago. Little has changed. It is a a combination of bubblegum and disco, neither of which I care for.

Just generic and boring. 80s Madonna had much more fun music

2.5

Not in my edition of the book! 2000. 2 stars. A non-essential Madonna album that has was not innovative at the time, and which has not dated well. No idea why this is on the list. And the cover of "American Pie" is an abomination.

I don't like pop music. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ❌️ Revisit ❌️ ★★☆☆☆(4/10) Default Total reviewed : 420 Already owned : 93 Purchased : 21 To buy : 5 Nope : 301

I’m not a massive Madonna fan, but I can appreciate that Ray of Light was a good album that basically reinvented her to a younger audience. This sadly, isn’t a very good album and has pretences of having country vibes, simply by wearing clothing in the videos and album cover like it’s a western movie and having a few guitars. It was given more airtime than it deserved on release. I’d argue that Confessions on a Dancefloor has more reasons to be on here that this album.

You're lucky to get this '2' rating Madonna...on the strength of Music and Don't Tell Me. I guess it's hard to be edgy when you are in your 40s.

The opening song "Music" recaptured some of Madona's pop queen status reflecting a sound of the times. However, many songs after felt liked an exploration of experimental sounds missing their mark. Instead of having a pulse on the 2000s, it flatlined.

Good title track. Bored thereafter.

**An ok album

Not a 1 because I’ve heard 1s on here and this ain’t that bad.

I wish they had included her album Something to Remember instead. I do like Madonna, but pretty much exclusively pre-2000.

I apologize and don't want to offend any communities but other than Music, this album is trash Best Song: Music Rating: 4.5/10 Stars: 2

2 out of 5. Her 80's output is more tolerable.

Pop well delivered and produced, never my thing.

Weird that I’m giving Madonna a 2, but i couldn't deal with the auto tune…. or the tunes either.

A genuinely unexceptional album from Madonna. I like that she decided to lean into a country aesthetic while making nothing remotely close to country music.

No fav song

Meh, tho “music” is a banger, the rest of the album is just a big meh

Not great. I think this album began the decline of the Madonna era. Not a huge fan.

It’s fine. Not for me

I found this pretty bland overall. Don’t Tell Me was good though.

2.5

that was so horrible and also she ruined an absolute classic banger of a song

1) Paradise (Not For Me) 2) Runaway Love 3) What It Feels Like for a Girl Least Favourite: Nobody’s Perfect

What a wet fart. I remember when it came out “Music” was everywhere. I have a soft spot for that one. It’s fun and it’s got a beat, plus she’s got that Bourgeoise line… but other than that, this has NOT aged well. Sounds like garbage and the songs are forgettable to a one.

uhhhh idk about this one

There was a song or two when the album came out that gave me a I guess Madonna still has it nostalgia vibe. However I quickly forgot about it and 25 years later listening to it did not rekindle that feeling. Maybe for a die-hard Madonna fan this would be an OK album but no idea how it made the top 1000.

Meh. Not into it. 👎

I knew this album wasn’t great from the various times I read this album page during my over 500 days on this site. But surely it couldn’t be that bad. Boy was I wrong! It truly is that bad. I didn’t realise Madonna could make something so rubbish. The electronic sound with the stereotypical 00s voice that is not pleasant to listen to one bit (especially that terrible autotune voice in that one song). There was one good song, being Runaway Lover, but it’s not good enough to redeem this album. This is the only Madonna album I’ve ever listened to, so I wonder if every one of hers is exactly like this or do I have to blame Robert Dimery again?

No particularly good.

Not good

Proof that once you have the name you can put anything out and people will buy it. A mundane collection of pop songs that if it wasn’t for the name would have dissapeared into the abyss. Far too much auto tune and nothing special to report at all. In fact the main thing to report is the war against crime that is the cover of ‘American pie’ how she got away with that again proves a name means everything. Bang average pop record. Best track- ‘don’t tell me’ Worst track- ‘paradise (not for me) Unless we include ‘American pie’ and then it speaks for itself!! 5/10 average then -1 for the cover! So 4/10

# Album Name: Music # Artist: Madonna # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: Wow, what a stinker. This has aged badly. # Top Tunes: Music # Would I listen to it again? No

Trying to hard to be relevant.

I went back and forth with this one. On occasion this album has Daft Punk-esque dance tunes. On other occasions it has a terrible Don McLean cover. Keeping me guessing I suppose.

This album was all over the place too. Music was fun to dance to in the day, but I felt like it got a huge lift from whatever DJ version was spinning at the time. Everything else was ok. This didn't feel like controversial, edgy Madonna. The lyrics about not selling out were just cringey.

This album is a great reminder of why I don't listen to Madonna. Most of the music is forgettable and the lyrics are vapid.

This was sort of sold to me as Madonna's experimental album, and I *really* don't think it delivers on this promise. Dare I say, Music really hasn't aged well. It's an album that hinges on the incorporation of electronic elements into electronic music, but the electronic elements here are clunky and kind of stiff, and while I did manage to get into this album on a few songs, I don't think it really pulls itself together long enough for me to come away with a particularly positive opinion. That being said, Amazing, What It Feels Like For A Girl, Don't Tell Me and Paradise (Not For Me) are strong songs. The acoustic guitar glitch stuff on Don't Tell Me is the most experimental thing on the album, and it's a unique moment, however it also reminds me that this album is supposed to have sort of a cowboy theme/aesthetic to it that never *really* materializes, and which just takes away from the cohesion of the project. Anyways, Amazing is probably the best pop song here. And What It Feels Like For A Girl is a great song with some really cool lyrics about gender. Paradise also has some cool lyrics which, I *think* are about religion, and it is also a trip hop inspired song with the coolest and most unique texture and tone on the album. Honestly, the second half of this is quite a bit more enjoyable than the first for me, but across the project there are enough songs that are too wrapped up in their aesthetic to let the songwriting really shine through. Although, interestingly enough, I'd say the lyrics across this thing are it's strongest aspect overall, Madonna has some really great, really personal writing. But I still don't think this makes it to a 3. And I know it's a bonus track, but this score is cemented by the American Pie cover, which isn't *terrible*, but it is baffling. It maintains almost none of the songwriting of the original, and isn't sold as Madonna's own thing. It's just a bizarre addition and frankly, kind of a jumpscare. This is not a bad album per se, but it has aged kind of awkwardly, and doesn't have a lot for me. If you *really* like Madonna, maybe give it a try though, there's probably something for you here.

Did not enjoy at all. Some of the worst music I've had so far. It's not offensive but it's not my cup of tea at all.

I found this one hard to listen to and not very enjoyable. The best thing to come from this album was the Above and Beyond remix of What it feels like to be a girl. I didn't find the version of American Pie to be good at all.

I like some Madonna songs, but definitely not these ones. Feels both of the 00's and dated, but it is 2026...

Why do electronic music artists always want to sound like a robot?

There were some nice moments on this album. I particularly liked "Don't tell Me" and "Paradise (Not for Me)" The rest of the album felt kind of awkward and unsure of what it was trying to be or do and I absolutely hated her cover of American Pie.

Me di cuenta q no sé nada de madonna, no sabía que esperar, pero no entiendo porq está este disco. Senti q estaba escuchando temas que quizá les gustarían a un super fan de madonna, a mí no.

Another day another 2000s album on this list from an artist past their prime because the authors didn’t know who was actually making good music in that decade It’s not the worst music I’ve ever heard, Madonna’s clearly a talented vocalist and I appreciate the effort to make something new. Runaway Lover is probably the best song on the album for me, very catchy and fundamentally a solid pop song The rest of this album just isn’t very good unfortunately. The majority of the songs on here kinda suck, Nobody’s Perfect in particular is just a bad song. I think the biggest thing that upsets me about this album is how non-genuine it feels. It really feels like she crammed this album full of industry trends and crowd pleasers (what the hell is American Pie doing on this album man…), and it just really doesn’t feel like Madonna I don’t think every individual moment is bad (like honestly the quality of the music itself is right around a 3), but this albums just kinda a mess for me. High 2 since it doesn’t deeply offend me, but this absolutely shouldn’t be on this list

and the worlds worst cover award goes to madonna!!!!

There are some interesting concepts and risks taken on this album. The second and third tracks feature well crafted electric beats. However, the rest of the album tries to do far too much at once and, more often than not, falls flat on its face. Autotune is frequently overused, and the blend of country and electric is questionable. The cover of "American Pie" is inexcusable. I admire the risks taken here and am sure it influenced others, but at the same time, the album didn't break any new ground and has aged very poorly.

Мені здається, що цей альбом дуже перенасичений філерами. Можливо, вони колись рвали танцювальні майданчики, але зараз вони просто ніякі. Звчиайно тут є хороші пісні і супер хіт - Music. Але загальне враження скоріше ні.

Цей альбом звісно звучить дуже слабко після рей оф лайт і дуже часто виникає враження що постарішали ці пісні поганенько. Може не всі, але більша частина. Хоча і тут є приємні моменти, а загалом "мьюзік" мені звісно дуже віддає нульовими і викликає ностальгію за тими часами.

Ok 2000 pop-electronic album from the icon Madonna. Some interesting production choices here, and they do well to fit the electronic sound well into different types of songs from dance-pop to more serious, slower songs. But ultimately, a forgettable album for me that doesn’t really stand above the pack.

While it was not technically bad, I spent the whole album just wanting to move on to something else.

Some ok beats and "What It Feels Like..." is great but this is mostly overproduced forgettable electropop with bad vocals all the way through. And the worst cover I've ever heard in my life to end it. Ugh.

2.5 Meh.

I really love Madonna but not nearly as much as the writers of this list do, apparently. She always has great hits but the album tracks are just... there. The "American Pie" cover is an abomination, which makes this the lowest rated Madge album so far.

1.7 2x american pie cover was atrocious

Some songs were ok but holy shit this "American Pie" is TERRIBLE.

1.5

Boy, “grown-up” Madonna sure does suck, doesn’t she? This album, made from the mistaken notion that she needed to “compete“ with teenybopper icons Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera, just shows that you don’t have to be an anonymous Brit to make irritating dance/electronica music. Good points: this is slightly less irritating than its genre competitors, and she does limit herself to 44 minutes, for which I am eternally grateful. Bad points: the whispered and treated vocals that crop up intermittently are extremely irritating, and for an artist I know to be intelligent, these have to be some of the dumbest lyrics ever committed to paper. I thought long and hard about giving this three stars, but realized I would be holding my nose with a death grip in order to avoid the stench from doing so. Two stars, baby.

hrrm, maybe later

It really isn't her best. Some good tracks but that cover of American Pie is so bad.

I'm guessing this was experimental and "revolutionary" at the time. Doesn't make it good though.

I think I prefer earlier Madonna.

It’s incredibly dumb to have this album and Ray of Light on the list. Pick one you lazy editor!

Most of it was quite boring, there were a couple songs that were not bad, American pie definitely much better by Don McLean. I expected much more from Madonna.

2000-luvun poppi on niin outoa.

This is awful. The Queen of pop my arse if this what she thinks is acceptable. Generic, autotuned shoite. Some small highlights saves it from a 1

Music

this was fine, some good moments but the american pie cover was criminal

Not good Madonna.

Madona from the 2000’s sounds like she’s trying to conform to the period. Awful. She needed to stay in her lane. She’s still the Queen of Pop, but historians won’t look back kindly with this effort.

I do not miss the glitchy folktronica of the early 2000s. Madonna’s Music is the biggest and arguably best of that genre with plenty of songs that you can tell are decently composed with promising subject matters but the whole production style is so dated and annoying that I still can’t appreciate it beyond a few tracks that rise above the trends they were chasing.

I didn't get through as much of this as I was hoping. It is okayish.

This was a chore to get through.

I don't love Madonna in general, though some of her offerings are in my saved pile of shit to get to later. But Madonna and this electronic nightmare totally missed the target for me. Would not recommend.

I like Madonna, but I would not tell anybody they need to listen to this electronica wallpaper before they die. At least the version on Deezer doesn't have the American Pie cover. I did have to misophonia skip some tracks with whispering, though. NOPE!

Insipid shite

Terrible start. Try hard electronic beats. If this wasn't Madonna this album wouldn't be on the list. Did less in second half of the album to it's benefit

Didn’t love it. I’ve never really been much of a fan but I prefer her earlier pop content if forced to listen. The dance type songs were what I preferred here.