Reviews (page 4 of 8)
Madonna two days in a row?? Ray of light yesterday was surprisingly good and got a 3. I'm nearly angling for a 1 with this. What is the aim? The techno pop tracks early in this album are shocking. Only when the sort of country-pop tracks are tried does it sort of hit a note of acceptability. And 'music' as a title. I don't understand? Is it that you were trying to amalgamate loads of different music genres into one, or are you just being super lazy? Or do you actually have that much of a state of self-importance that you feel an album can be titled as such? Ok, it's getting a 1 now.
This had 2 good songs the rest were meh.
Where Madonna briefly stops pretending to be British. The title track is a banger. Ray of Light was heaps better
I don't think this will get repeat listens from me, but this was interesting, had good lyrics and interesting music. I just maybe didn't like this as much as classic era Madonna music.
Light 2
Heard some before; 1.5; Not really sure why this album is on here. Madonna has some other albums that are much better than this, and this one really doesn't hold up well at all with the passage of time. Feels like it's trying to blend elements of trip hop with other production tools from around the turn of the century. And the lyrics just aren't very good at all. And the tracks based around the guitar are just very plain and boring. Favorite Track: Don't Tell Me
Veel gexpirimenteerd met elektronische sounds Soms leuk soms niet Mooie stem
This album came out when I was in high school and I thought Madonna felt out of touch and was very upset with the atrocious cover of "American Pie". Now I'm about the same age she was when she made this and I get what she was trying to do and knowing Madonna has a large gay fan base makes me excited she made some club songs for them, but this album is not for me. I hope this isn't Madonna's only entry on this list. This can't be her best work.
This album feels like it is desperately trying to re-capture former pop-star glory with mixed results. A couple of memorable tracks, one real turd, and some formulaic dance pop electronica. Otherwise known as everything Madonna has done since the 1980s. 2.5⭐️
To go from Ray of Light to this is quite a step down. It’s fine for the most part, but not her strongest effort
-this is the first Madonna album i’ve heard in full, the other being Ray Of Light. was excited because the title track is one of my favorite Madonna songs. and admittedly i now feel that track does most of the heavy lifting on here -definitely not quite on the level of Ray Of Light (neeed to listen to that one again soon!) but still thought it was solid. i liked that she continued with the trip hop influence -Favorites: Music, What It Feels Like For A Girl
Nah 10/1/26
WTF was this shit???
Solid album. Nobody’s Perfect was my highlight. Good 3.8
On est en l'an 2000. Le bug de l'an 2000 n'a finalement pas eu lieu, les avions ne sont pas tombés du ciel et mon grille-pain ne s'est pas rebellé. Par contre, dans le paysage musical, c'est un autre genre de bug qui débarque, un bug volontaire, glitché et savamment orchestré par une certaine Madonna Louise Ciccone. Après avoir atteint le nirvana spirituel et critique avec "Ray of Light" en 1998, la Madone aurait pu se reposer sur ses lauriers mystiques et nous resservir une soupe techno-kabbalistique tiède. Que nenni, elle a troqué le sari pour un chapeau de cow-boy, les mantras pour des vocoders agressifs, et surtout, elle a regardé de l'autre côté de l'Atlantique, vers notre vieille Europe, pour trouver son nouveau son. Et c'est là, pour moi qui ai grandi avec le son froid des années 80, que la fibre patriotique se met à vibrer. Car si "Music" est l'album de Madonna, c'est aussi, dans l'ombre, le triomphe d'un homme : Mirwais Ahmadzaï. Pour nous, enfants du rock, Mirwais n'est pas un inconnu sorti du chapeau. C'est l'âme torturée de Taxi Girl, ce groupe culte qui a bercé mon adolescence avec "Cherchez le garçon". Voir ce héros de la synthpop froide et parisienne se retrouver propulsé architecte sonore de la plus grande star de la planète, c'est un peu comme voir un film d'auteur français remporter le box-office américain. C'est inattendu, c'est chauvin, je l'assume totalement, et bordel, que c'est jouissif. "Music", c'est un virage électro-pop radical, sec, presque brutal par moments. Oubliez les nappes planantes de William Orbit. Ici, le son est "cut-up", haché menu. Le morceau titre, "Music", est une déclaration d'intention imparable : "Hey Mr. DJ, put a record on". Une ligne de basse funk qui tabasse, une voix robotique, et ce groove irrésistible qui donne envie de monter le son à fond. C'est l'hédonisme pur, la fête retrouvée, mais avec cette froideur technologique qui rend le tout ultra-moderne. Le coup de génie, c'est évidemment "Don't Tell Me". Marier la country acoustique et le glitch informatique, il fallait oser. Il y a aussi "What It Feels Like for a Girl", qui commence par ce sample de Charlotte Gainsbourg (encore une touche française !) dans le film "The Cement Garden". Une ballade mid-tempo, plus classique peut-être, mais d'une efficacité mélodique redoutable. Et que dire de "Paradise (Not for Me)" ? Sombre, cinématographique, presque expérimental pour du Madonna. On sent ici toute la patte de Mirwais, cette mélancolie synthétique qui me rappelle les meilleures heures de la new wave, mais passée à la moulinette Pro Tools. Cependant, ma note virevolte, j'hésite. L'album n'est pas exempt de défauts. Il est court, très court (à peine 45 minutes), ce qui est plutôt une qualité à mes yeux — je préfère une claque rapide qu'un ennui prolongé — mais il y a du remplissage. Des titres comme "I Deserve It" ou "Amazing" (qui ressemble étrangement à une chute de studio de "Beautiful Stranger") sentent un peu le réchauffé. Et puis, il y a cette reprise de "American Pie" (souvent incluse en bonus hors US) qui est... disons, discutable. On sent que l'album tire parfois à la ligne pour justifier son statut de LP. C'est là que mon dilemme "3 ou 4 sur 5" prend tout son sens. Si je suis objectif, c'est un album inégal, un collage d'idées brillantes et de moments plus anecdotiques. Un 3/5 solide serait justifié pour la musique seule. Mais... il y a l'audace, il y a cette prise de risque incroyable pour une artiste mainstream de cet acabit. Confier les clés de la maison à un producteur français "underground", imposer ce son sec et sans réverbération au monde entier, c'est fort. Et puis merde, c'est mon côté chauvin qui fait pencher la balance. Ce petit clin d'œil à Taxi Girl, cette fierté de voir la "French Touch" (même si Mirwais est plus "French Cold" que "French Touch" disco-filtrée) dominer les charts mondiaux, ça vaut bien un petit point de bonus. C'est l'album qui a prouvé que la pop de l'an 2000 ne serait pas juste une redite des années 90. Alors, pour l'innovation, pour le courage artistique, et pour Mirwais qui a vengé tous les groupes de rock français ignorés à l'étranger, j'arrondis au supérieur. C'est un disque imparfait, peut-être, mais c'est un disque important qui a marqué la fin de mes années radio et disquaire avec panache. Note : 4/5 (Le point "Cocorico" est inclus)
Nicht auf Apple Music
There was a time that Madonna just had to make a sound and my hormones would go wild. I even didn’t mind her music. This album was her attempt to remain relevant for what I think was the first time and it works. She knows how to keep somewhat in the limelight. Even to this day. She even gets into some Joni Mitchell sounding shit with I Deserve It. This isn’t perfect but I’m not even remotely let down listening to it. It does seem like she gave up the horny lady persona with this album. I’m not sure if it’s the first time she had done that or not. I liked Madonna for getting myself off, I didn’t pay much attention to her career decisions. There are 2 songs where she felt the need to whisper. It’s odd but the music part of Paradise is actually kick ass. Fuck the whispering part. What whispering part?? Choice cut: Paradise
My first Madonna album for this project, and sadly a disappointment for me. I assumed some of her albums would be on the list, but this is one I never listened to before so I had no clue what to expect. My main impression was that the production choices made this, at times, unlistenable for me. I liked (and even loved in the case of I Deserve It and Gone) the songs that were left to be themselves, but the ones that were over-produced with auto-tune or too many blips and bleeps just got annoying. I rarely skip past a song in the project, but I was tempted to during Impressive Instant and Nobody's Perfect. These were just abysmal. They could've been decent, especially the latter. Overall I wish this was an album I could've liked a lot or even loved, but instead it's going to get a 3 due to my very mixed feelings. Somehow others got to listen to her version of American Pie. I didn’t. And that’s ok with me.
Madonna's "music" delivers on it's namesake. Great music? not so much. Awful music? not really. But is it music? Yes
A few good songs, an honestly pretty decent background music while working, but not quiet enough to bump it to 4
Had to put myself in the shoes of a teen in the early 2000s and I could see how this would hit back then, but obviously not my taste now
I would just never listen to any of them again
There’s not a single song I wouldn’t immediately skip if I heard it ever again.
Why is she dressed like a cowboy bruh
Madonna is so much better than this. Why autotune her? She doesn’t need it!
This music is actually pretty interesting, but it has aged just about as well as a lot of graphic design and other art from the year 2000. I was pleasantly surprised overall, but I wouldn't count this as a favorite.
Madonna reinventing herself. It’s not bad but I like her classic stuff better.
Madonna, je connais pour ainsi dire pas du tout et je suis un peu étonné que ça soit un album des années 2000 qui soit proposé, sa plus grande époque, c'est quand même les années 80. Je suppose que je vais la retrouver pendant ce parcours. Bref, cet album, c'était de toute évidence pas fait pour moi, mais je dois admettre que musicalement, c'est plutôt varié et créatif. Ce qui m'a le plus enquiquiné, c'est que des fois, les effets sur la voix qui sont parfois abusés. Du reste, c'était pas mal, mais pas un truc que j'aurais envie d'écouter spontanément.
The list has Like a Prayer, Ray of Light and this one. Which tells us more about the weird bias the critics who put the list together. In the early 2000's there was an obsession critics had with Madonna's later career output. I mean, this is fine, a good album. But no True Blue or Like a Virgin are in there? Anyway, definitively some good songs on here. This guy Ahmadzaï who she hired to write the songs had some cool ideas.
I didn't really like most of this, but it's interesting to hear what passed for experimental in early aughts pop. The lyrics are pretty consistently awful. Music and Don't Tell Me are both undeniable bangers, particularly the latter. Strong 2.
I didn’t mind it but some songs felt very much of the time (Music in particular). Also Madonna has a great voice, the auto tune on a few of the songs felt cheesy and dated. Favorite song was Paradise (not for me)
What in the hell is this sound?? The 2000’s pop sound was all over the place, this sounded like spacey electronic dance music but in the worst way possible. Madonna owes me 49 minutes of my life back. The sad part is that enough people enjoyed this shit for it to make this damn list lmao. Wait Nobody’s Perfect came on and Madonna morphed into T Pain… you can’t make this shit up!
Forgettable. I didn't find the music bad for the most part, but it just didn't do much to engage me. Not a single song I would add to a playlist, or listen to again on purpose. The version of American Pie, a song I don't care for much anyway, is criminal. I seriously question how this album made it onto this list.
Not her best
The sound of a dying swan, the last motion of a headless chicken before it expires, the twitching of butchered meat when salt is applied, the punch-drunk boxer who desperately throws a couple of last haymakers hoping to connect with anything on their way down, a middle aged mum wearing her daughters clothes as a way to hold off peri-menopause, the boss who passes off an underlings work as their own to seem like they still know whats going on, a dad shouting 6-7 at his kids as he hasn't accepted his irrelevance
It’s Madonna, so diva obvs. But I’m not a fan of dance music as a whole
Music Don't Tell Me What It Feels Like for a Girl
Ugh, another Madonna album and William Orbit certainly isn't helping things here. The 2nd half of the album, was actually much better...until Madonna attempted to cover American Pie. Wow, that was amazing. Amazingly bad.
If anything, this album clearly demonstrates how Madonna has some insight into where music and culture are going before they get there.
Madonna's eighth record has her primarily working with producer Mirwais Ahmadzaï and, among their collaborations here, the most interesting are the those that push the furthest into experimental territory (such as "Impressive Instant"). Ahmadzaï's fractured production techniques keep the songs moving (even on tracks that consists of basically one chord). In addition, when Madonna uses less obvious vocal techniques such as hushed vocals or spoken word sections (such as on "Paradise (Not For Me)"), it works remarkably well. The more this album aims towards the conventional however, the less compelling it becomes. The tracks co-produced by William Orbit are especially guilty of this - they are the blandest and least memorable cuts on this record.
Generic ass-pop. Madonna has great stuff, this album isn't it.
She was an hour late when I saw her and had to cut like a prayer. Anyway this album was mid
The album cover is misleading. This is not a country record. Also despite a few standouts, the production's pretty atrocious
I don't like this as much as Ray of Light, but I think it's a good album. I Deserve It and Don't Tell Me are my favourites. Madonna writes some really nice melodies, in fact. I remember thinking at the time that she did a good job in changing things up with Ray of Light, and this continued the development.
Still trying to perfect my line dancing all these years later. I saw her on this tour and I think she was at her best in this era
Yeah man, plenty of artists put out something worth listening to 16 years into their careers. I just don't think Madonna is one of them.
Odd music
Boring and did not age well AT ALL, choosing autotune was not a great decision, the songs without it are okay. 1.75/5
Meh.
A lot of fun songs on here. I've never fully listened to a Madonna album before, so this actually introduced me to a whole new side of her music. I enjoyed it, would listen again!
Not my thing generally but this was surprisingly good. Tracks 2 & 3 has some really interesting house production.
Pretty cool dance music.
Madonna wanted something new again after her best album in her career, Ray of Light. She first started to work again with William Orbit but soon ditched him and worked with Ahmadzaï on this album (two songs were written by Orbit). The end product isn't bad, but it's far from the quality of Ray of Light. The hit singles are all great (Music, Don't Tell Me, What it Feels Like For a Girl). I especially like the remix version of What it Feels like...to which one of the best video clip from that era was made. The early 2000s autotune on some songs are not my cup of tea, though, while some other songs remind me more of the songs from Ray of Light, but with not the same quality (the song Amazing reminds me of Beautiful Stranger). The album is stylish, and groovy but style is more important here than substance.
Music by Madonna is an OK album, but it’s far from her strongest work, which makes its inclusion on the 1001 Albums list a bit surprising. The shift towards a more overtly dance-focused sound is interesting, and there are moments where the production and beats really work. However, despite its slickness, the album never quite feels like it goes anywhere meaningful, lacking the spark and songwriting depth of her best records. There are some genuinely enjoyable pop moments. The title track Music is a great tune and still sounds infectious, while Runaway Lover and What It Feels Like for a Girl are well-crafted, memorable pop songs. Elsewhere, though, the album struggles to maintain momentum. American Pie, in any of its forms, remains a miss for me flat and unnecessary and Paradise (Not for Me) fails to leave much of an impression. Favourite tracks: Music; Runaway Lover; What It Feels Like for a Girl Least favourite tracks: American Pie; Paradise (Not for Me) Album artwork: A classic Madonna album cover
Nothing particularly special, some songs are a bit nostalgic from my childhood, but others have that distict 2000's feel.
This album is fantastic but... of course, it's Madonna. It's great how in this album Madonna explores also new sounds and introduces more experimental aspects to her music, which was something that she started introducing even back to Like a Prayer. In this album there's place for more atmospheric tracks (Paradise (Not for Me), Impressive Instant), other folktronica ones (Gone, Don't Tell Me), as well as others heir of the (great) Ray of Light album, which is no coincidence at all (I Deserve It, Amazing), and club ones (Music, Runaway Lover), without losing any coherence. I absolutely love this album, I'm not going to hide it, and I would say it's one of Madonna's best, so diverse yet really well condensed. Madonna's music is often underrated, being her character/persona and performative skills more valued more and over her music itself. However, she is so fresh to deliver new sounds and adapt them to her music, always with a personal touch. This album is one of her most "pop" records, but still has her interest to dive in new sounds, and they match so well her style. For something she is called the Queen of Pop, she is so great at making very different albums from each other without losing her essence, and this Madonna period is one of her most creative ones. It's electronic, but also very human. It's fun, all the contrary to Ray of Light, it's an escape, a way of thanking music for what it's done to her and how it acts in our world, as a way of expressing ourselves, of freeing ourselves, of uniting ourselves.
An awful, boring album. Was Madonna faking an English accent during this Kabbala, Guy Ritchie phase? Some things are better left in the last millenium.
Just pop music that isn’t all that good. 1/5
Madonna, bringing whatever to the mainstream since forever (or atleast since her second maybe third album). The first couple are bangers for aure but its not because of madonna. And she’s karoke level good at singng at best (listen to i deserve it). Credit to her for finding interesting fringe artists (in music and dance and s&m)and them exploiting the fuck out of them (we could hail her for bringing light to talent but ultimately she’s repackaged it and made a shit load for herself) but now we have the internet, meh, who needs her? I suppose there is a place for good curators but you dont usally idolise the curator. You might thank thwm for their work or admire their taste but you dont salute them for the actual art. She even apologises on nobody’s perfect while perfecting her pitch via autocorrect. FFS.
Well I guess music was not in a good place in the year 2000. What It Feels Like for a Girl narrowly saved this from a 1 just by being a competent pop song.
Finally! After 709 days of partaking in this randomizer, it's about damn time that, at long last, it's decided to give my group 'Music'! I mean, I'unno what we were listening to those past 709 days if none of **that** was music~! And what sweet, sweet ... erm, largely dated music we got. Yeah, let's get to the point: this is some pretty dated dance-pop electronica from Madonna. Put a blindfold on me and ask when this album came out, and I'm sure I'd be able to nail it down to 2000 exactly. To which, I don't wanna act like that's all a bad thing to me. Sometimes I like me a bit of dated music. Y'know, sometimes it's fun to be able to pinpoint exactly when a song or album came out. Heck, sometimes you just want that specific year or decade sound. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, and for good swathes of this album it was dated in a way I really enjoyed. Certainly, I feel like I enjoyed this thing largely more than I did 'Ray Of Light'. It might be blasphemy to diss on 'Ray Of Light', but I gotta be real, I did not dig the "yogacore" ambient trip-hop thing it was doing. I'm a simple gal: I want my pop music poppy, y'know? And where 'Ray Of Light' largely didn't provide that, 'Music' was able to, and I appreciate that. But not every song on this album is good-times music, no. Some of them are ... y'know, lesser than others. And I can name you the exact culprit behind this. So, there's, like, three or four different producer pairings across this album. William Orbit returns from 'Ray Of Light', and he has a pretty great showing on his tracks (minus one, but it's not an official part of the album). There's some other names I don't recognize on "What It Feels Like To Be A Girl", and I think they did a darn good job. These guys, without a doubt, produced the highlights of the album. Then there's the other guy, Mirwais. He did not produce any highlights. In fact, I'd say it's not a coincidence that the best songs on the album don't feature him at all. Here's the thing about Mirwais. I've read somewhere that people consider this to be a bit of an "experimental" album (at least by the standards of Madonna and her variety of pop music), and if it gets that from anything, it's Mirwais's production. He **loves** to slather tracks in robotic vocal filters and stuttery start-stop glitch nonsense ... I can just imagine a Big Important Critic™ at the time hearing this stuff and having his socks knocked off. "Wow! Listen to how far out there this production is! This is amazing!" Meanwhile, I'm just sitting here and understanding more and more why 'American Life' is the disaster it was. Mirwais comes across to me like a guy who has this big bag of tricks that he just **loves** to reach into — by gawd, he can't help but dig into it on every song he produces. "Let's chop the guitar up with abrupt cuts to silence!" "Let's do robot voices!" "Let's turn the autotune up to 11 like you're T-Pain or on Cher's 'Believe'!" I'm sure all of this sounded cool at the time, but in 2025 it's just a little ... much, y'know? Like, my guy, you don't hafta try so hard. You can tone back on the production! I mean, seriously, finding out he co-produced every song on 'American Life' really helps explain why that album sounds as bad as it does. Like, this shit's dated, but less in a "charming of-its-time" kind of way and more in a really goofy way. Like, Madonna's big robot voice at the top of the album asking me if I like to boogie-woogie, as if I'm gawdamm Cool Cat. And to the idea that this album is experimental — I don't really buy it? Mirwais is just throwing all of his favorite glitchy effects at the wall over top some 2000's Britney/Christina-style dance-pop. Like, it would've been just fine on its own, and either way it's hardly experimental. 'Ray Of Light' felt like the bigger experiment. I mean, jeez, I didn't care for its ambient trip-hop shit, but I can at least appreciate the swing it took, and I can give a nod of acknowledgement to how well it worked for others. Mirwais — I'unno. I don't wanna make it sound like his production's unlistenable or anything, but if I were Madonna, I would not have let him co-produce an entire album with me. At the very least, I would've traded him in for someone who wouldn't have let me do **two raps**. (Seriously: we all know 'American Life' isn't a great album, but goodness.) There's also the "American Pie" cover. As I said in my allusion to it above, it's not a part of the main album; it was only included on international releases and the 2016 vinyl ... but, hey, it's here, and I'd always heard it was a trainwreck, so I figured I may as well give it a shot. And I gotta admit, I'm sort of underwhelmed? I guess I'd always assumed it'd be more obviously awful. Most of the feeling I get from it is just ... why? Y'know? Why did you do this? Who asked for this? Who wanted "American Pie" to sound like this? And have so many of its lyrics chopped out? I don't think it's worth the particularly terrible Madonna movie it's attached to. And if you wanna count it as part of this album, well, it's the one non-Mirwais black mark this thing has, so ... points in Mirwais favor, I guess? Y'know, 'Music' is not a bad album, not at all. It can be pretty darn enjoyable in spots. Even the Mirwais tracks had their moments. I just wish he could've shown some restraint and didn't stick out like a big sore thumb as a result. But ultimately, yeah, it's pretty good. Believe me, when it comes to music, I've heard far worse than this. Like 'American Life'! Ha! Ha! Ha! Yeah, I'll stop now.
Doesn't hit as much as Ray Of Light, but it's still decent otherwise. Solid 4 Stars.
I’m at a 3.5 that I’ll bump up to a 4, though I’d MUCH prefer to leave it at a 3.5. This is the first time in a while I’ve been totally frustrated with an album; not because this is explicitly bad or anything, but because this thing is absolutely dripping with potential to meet the same mark as the contemporaries that Madonna was trying to hang with at this time; Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, N*SYNC, etc. It is so close to getting there, and yet it finds ways to feel a little dated & falls short at the parts where it matters most. It’s never in Madonna’s vocals – she sounds really good throughout. It’s a little bit in her songwriting; I think a lot of this album is based in reflections of previous addictions to love, & while it generally works well, I think a few tracks just cover the same topic base a little too much (namely a perceived overlap for Amazing, Paradise & Gone). It’s in the production. It’s *so* close to feeling as catchy as her peers, and while it generally hits something reasonable, it just doesn’t hit the same timeless marks as them. I know tracks like “Oops!... I Did It Again”, “What A Girl Wants” & “Bye Bye Bye” are cheesy as hell, but they’ve aged pretty well into 2025 because they lean into being explicitly catchy. Madonna & her team of producers take themselves more seriously here with more of an adult lean, so that does play a factor, but it’s not the underlying issue here at all. Mirwais Ahmadzaï & his ambitious production style, with a desire to feel unique & innovative for 2000… it just hasn’t aged well. It’s not that he didn’t see the trends that were soon to come in the genre; there’s a lot of tracks here that can tell where the tide is going, with production tricks that would be a lot more refined by 2003 through 2005. It’s just too early for them, and their use here feels deeply dated by comparison, creating a different air around the whole album that just lingers. It’s like early 1980s CGI trying to do the T-1000 effect in T2; it maybe could’ve been done, but it wouldn’t have looked as good. Hell, I’ll even give Mirwais his credit – so many of his tracks are really close to being good, and I admire the ambition he’s trying for. “Music” is a fine opener, it’s just overproduced in a way that feels noticeable by 2025. “Impressive Instant” has a solid base for a track, but if it leaned even more into French house sensibilities ala a Daft Punk track, it could be REALLY good. “I Deserve It” feels like a dollar store version of “Drive” by Incubus, and if they had leaned a little more incorporating some extra electronica, it might’ve shaken off that perception. “Nobody’s Perfect” is drenched in autotune, in a way that feels even more egregious than Cher’s use of it on “Believe” just a few years earlier. Again, it’s just overproduced. “Don’t Tell Me” is good, at least. It’s just a stuttered percussion sample & some string work interrupting a guitar melody, but it’s well done. His simplest production job is his best; almost like he overproduced too much of this thing, you know? “Paradise (Not For Me)” would’ve been good… if it ended about 2 minutes sooner. Letting that track continue for one more useless lap just lessens the impact. It’s the story of the album. However, the tracks where Mirwais isn’t the lead producer DO hit that sort of timeless point, which is where my frustrations with this album REALLY come to light. William Orbit’s production standards from Ray of Light carry over really nicely, and his tracks are great, save for the dreadfully strange cover of American Pie that I’m not counting in this little review. “Runaway Lover” is awesome, with a sort of Eurobeat lean that reminded me a lot of Sonic R and other ‘90s racing games of the era. Same thing with “Amazing”, which has a good punch to its percussion that really makes the track pop. “What It Feels Like For A Girl”, produced by Guy Sigsworth & Mark Stent (who both worked on Bjork’s “Vespertine”) is really catchy, even with a slight overreliance on the chorus. “Gone” (back to Orbit) is a fun closer with a slightly spiritual lean – I do think it doesn’t quite hit the “high” point it’s trying to achieve as a final track, but it’s a good track regardless. So, with just 3 of Mirwais’ tracks hitting a reasonable mark for me, and everyone else really nailing their stuff, I can’t help but wonder if Madonna just made a mistake in letting him produce most of the tracks. It just seems like someone else could’ve handled it better. I’m going to bump this up to a 4, since that’s 7/10 tracks clicking well enough, and there not really being an explicitly bad track, but I’d much prefer to leave it at a 3.5. I don’t blame anyone for giving the rating it has on the site, and it’s certainly not as good as Ray of Light was to my ears. It’s frustrating that it’s dripping with the potential to get there & really hit the mark she was going for, but it ultimately doesn’t meet it. I do admire the swings though. I can only hope “Like A Prayer” will really be that timeless Madonna record whenever we get it.
I remember when this came out and I thought this was the end of her career. I was right
Maybe it’s a generational problem but Madonna will always feel like drunk mom music to me.
Electronic dance pop. Not a bad album, some very good songs and some that are meh. Some tracks remind me of a Sheryl Crow song more than a Madonna song? Notable tracks include Music, I Deserve It, Nobody’s Perfect, Don’t Tell Me, What It Feels Like For A Girl.
Not my bag.
I mean... good-ish. It's an interesting moment in time and decently done. Felt a little like she was trying to capture something - a feeling and a persona in the late 90's club scene.
Ni de puta coña escucho a Madonna.
Wow, that was trash.
Man I really wanted to hate this album. I always liked "Ray of Light" but the fact that the follow up was a cowboy themed 42 year old Madonna trying to compete with the Britney Spears' of the world did not interest me in the slightest. But of course, now that I get it here, I have to try to have an open mind. And I'm alarmed to say that it's a lot better than I'd expected. Madonna was never really that innovative. The vast array of music on this album includes electrohouse, glitch pop, and folktronica, but she didn't invent any of these styles. "What It Feels Like For a Girl" (the album's highest point) sounds like it has the microbeats limited directly from Bjork's "Vespertine". Plenty of other influences are present and borderline ripping off fellow artists. But the thing is, these styles are mostly hiding off in the distance at this time. Madonna not only brought them together but also gave them a pop makeover, selling millions across the globe in the process. I can't completely hate her for that. I'm loathe to go as far as calling Madonna cool. But credit where it's due, she pulled together an groundbreaking album here, despite my initial prejudice.
It’s funny for me to listen to this album as I only knew it from 2 singles that I downloaded from a bit torrent back in the day. Completely forgot how obsessed I was with “Don’t Tell Me,” probably because it was one of the few songs I had downloaded at the time, what a time capsule.
Only made it to track two. I just don't want to listen to this.
Definetly not my style, but it has something that makes you move and dance.
WOW that's a lot of bad autotune! If you scraped off the 2000 crust here there's some good songs. The American Pie cover is nice enough, albeit a week closer. Not sure what theming they were going for with the cover. Doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the album.
(do they start everyone off with this album lmao?) Maybe not surprisingly for me, this is extremely competent pop album and right up my alley (if slightly too polished). Eminently listenable earworms, consistent over a highly collaborative effort (I recognized Guy Sigsworth's fingerprint immediately on "What It Feels Like For A Girl".)
This is pretty groovy. I really only knew the title track (inescapable hit single)... it all hangs together quite nicely.
Really fascinating how much processing and effects they shoved onto this album
I really don't know Madonna, but this was neat. It sounds futuristic to me, 25 years after its release date.
Well this was mostly garbage. Shout out to Impressive Enstant and Runaway Lover for being the only semi-redeeming moments for me. (Who knew I'd respond to what I can only describe as futurist house?) Things dropped off a cliff shortly thereafter though. The obviously experimental folksy/country vibe was pretty terrible. Then a bunch of generic dance pop, some of which sounded like experimental demos in all the wrong ways (stutter guitar on Don't Tell Me, I'm talking about you here). American Pie cover was the breaking point for me, and made me question ending my own life it was so bad. By the time I hit the Raga I didn't know what the fuck I was listening to. This is a complete disaster of mismatched styles in a desperate attempt to compete with Britney and Christina in the charts. It's a singles collection, not an album.
Madonna is talented. This record doesn't reflect that. It's basically an autotune irritation. But, as I was quickly dismissing track after track, I came upon "I Deserve It" which is an acoustic guitar backed track featuring her voice. Nice. Why doesn't she do a whole album like this instead of that crappy electronic poppy bullshit? Couple of other tunes that bear mentioning: "Paradise (Not for Me)" has a dark and brooding vibe with a really cool backbeat groove and the ending tune "Gone" is a quiet, self-reflection that closes out a 3 song album. The rest is noise.
It was fine
Autotune galore. Some songs are okay, but most are quite annoying
this is my favourite madonna album i jus think the vibe and the sound are so perfectly curated. i wish cyber raga was included toooooo!!! my fav songs are amazing, nobodys perfect and that cover of american pie ofcourse
This was the Madonna album that literally no one wanted. Zero hits, super blah pop. Pretty much the poster album for "wait for the artist to write something rather than forcing them to pump out albums." Influence 2. Hits 1. Intangibles 2. Quality 3. Hard pass 2.
Thought this was quite dated and not entirely sure why it's here. The title track isnt great and the American pie cover is awful. They bookend pretty bland dance pop with acoustic guitars in between. Not great overall
Odd, the dancy stuff is a bit basic but ok, the country stuff is awful and smashing them together is a weird choice. What It Feels Like For a Girl is a great track.
Music is one of those albums that tries to reinvent pop but ends up feeling a bit too self-aware for its own good. You can hear Madonna reaching for that mix of futuristic electronica and dance-floor confidence, but a lot of it feels cold and calculated rather than fun. The production, courtesy of Mirwais, is sleek and polished, full of quirky filters and chopped-up beats, but it sometimes overpowers the songs themselves. It feels like a record more interested in style than substance. There are a few bright spots where her personality cuts through the gloss. The title track still has that cheeky swagger that only Madonna can pull off, and “Don’t Tell Me” brings in a country-twang-meets-electro mix that almost works. But elsewhere it drifts into something a bit lifeless, like she’s trying too hard to sound experimental rather than just making good pop. The emotional side that made her earlier work hit so hard is mostly missing here. Overall, Music feels like an ambitious idea that never quite finds its groove. It’s clever, but not especially moving, and the robotic production makes it hard to connect with. It’s not a disaster by any means, but it’s Madonna on autopilot, testing boundaries that other artists would later explore with more heart and better results.
I had no idea Madonna was so concerned about the bourgeoisie and selling out! The downtrodden must have rejoiced upon hearing this. I covered my ears when hearing most of this.
Let’s start with every song is at least one minute too long. Ironically I think Paradise (not for me) was one of the better songs on the album. I like the first hit for about 2 minutes and then I’m done. Overall - I have never really liked much Madonna music after her album “bedtime stories”… with some exceptions (like confessions on the dance floor). In general a solid meh AND please can no one ever cover “American Pie” ever ever again. I actively despise that song and am bitter that I know all the words due to its high radio playtime when this came out.
Boring and uninspired. Simple lyrics and subjects
None of the Madonna bangers I already knew were on here but I thought it was alright
Solid pop record. More good songs than I remember originally.
Labai daug autotune, bet melodijos ir tekstai įdomūs.
Electro pop, techno-pop i ledtog med en fransk producer lavede de et elektronisk poppet album inspireret af den elektroniske bølger i slut 90'erne start 00'erne bla daft punk osv. Et album som fortæller lidt om at leve i en digital verden lige pludselig, så man skulle forestille sig at det var meget aktuelt også den dag i dag. jeg synes ikke personligt det er noget specielt men det er heller ikke dårligt på nogen måde, så det er en perfekt 3'er. jeg lyttede kun til det 1 gange så tilbagevend.
++: Music, Impressive Instant, Runaway Lover, Amazing, What It Feels Like for a Girl +: Nobody's Perfect, Don't Tell Me, Paradise (Not for Me), Gone +-: I Deserve It 7,6/10
The line of certified pop stars reinventing themselves is long. Perhaps it's less notable that it occurs, but for Madonna the results on Music speak for themselves. These ultra-global, mega-machine lady-stars are at their best when they can change with the times and for themselves. It's a shame only a few of them achieve the two necessary conditions: possessing the vision and bravery for the risks while also attaining the contractual freedom to build the infrastructure for exploration and change to actually thread the needle. The likes of Madonna, Beyoncé, and Swift are among the few. I'm sure their careers are being studied right now by the next generation of pop vocalists, and Madonna's Music is certainly on the syllabus.
Madonna was my favorite artist somewhere around sixth grade, after Motley Crue and before Van Halen. I liked this. Not sure about the American Pie cover, but I'll allow it. 4
Ist da Musik drin? Ja doch!
The electronic songs at the beginning were much more interesting to me. Favorite track: Impressive Instant
Not very good.
Made the mistake of starting it on the last track. Hell no. Second star because she must be my lucky star
Although I'm still not much of a Madonna fan, I have to say that this album is *not* what I expected from her, and in a good way. It seems that a lot of the inspiration for the unexpected sound and style is courtesy of Mirwais Ahmadzaï's production skills and talents, as well as Madonna's obvious willingness to stretch herself into more modern pop territory. The highlights for me were all Madonna/Mirwais produced and written tracks, especially the title track (with a fun accompanying video), "Impressive instant" (probably the closest she'll ever get to true electonica, and largely Mirwais' creation), "Don't tell me" (with a tough balancing act in its entertaining-but-too-country-camp video), and the curious Enigma-like "Paradise (not for me)". I'm not sure exactly why she went with the cowboy look on the album cover, but it's funny to see this 2000 album's country kitsch contrasted with Beyonce's much more recent foray into less-kitschy (but no less pop-oriented) country music. I'm torn between three and four stars for this album (especially after having made the mistake of listening and watching her bonus single cover of "American Pie"), but I feel like my ingrained skepticism of Madonna's talent needs to acknowledge how different and fresh-sounding this album is, *especially* for Madonna.
You'd think with all her resources she could have bought herself a far better album. Autotune can't save her voice and apparently no one had the guts to tell her that her lyrics suck too.
Maybe it's the nostalgia talking but I really do enjoy Madonna's experimental era. The title track, Don't Tell Me and What It Feels Like for a Girl are the highlights here.
She was supposed to work with Aphex Twin on one track. Imagine. 3/5
When this album first came out I didn't get into it. I think I was quickly turned off because the lyrics to "Music" are so "koombaya" and cheesy. Now that I'm hearing the full album, I still feel that way, though I appreciate the music production more. I think I'd like this album a lot more with different lyrics and a different vocalist.
A couple of solid singles surrounded by synth and autotune.
After listening to so many straight electronica, the influences here are a lot more obvious than when I heard this 25 years ago. That said, beyond the still-great singles (Music, Don't Tell Me, What it Feels Like for a Girl) it also veers between bad (Nobody's Perfect, Paradise) to dated (all that autotune.)
Madge does dance - she is polished at this point in her career but there just isn't enough soul in it.
great I loved listening to her
A few tracks I liked. Some of the dance stuff wasn’t my vibe. I will always love Don’t Tell Me.
I have, of course, heard the title track. I did not associate it with Madonna, though, but with the entire girl-pop 2000s sound, which is about half of this album. I feel like in retrospect, it pulled off a bullseye for what the era was asking for. What's going on with production here, it's crisp and funky and very electronic, where does the cowgirl even fit in, it's like Beyonce was taking notes for a post-pandemic banger. This feels like it inclines heavy on the vocals though, especially on the second half, a few overproduced bits that feel a little cheesy, the album is maybe a song or two too long. This is not typical sound, I don't think I want any form of physical copy, but I might listen to it when I'm in a 2000s pop production mood. 3/5
Marginal Album, not one of her best.
Music was probably one of the first instances I remember hearing of Madonna still putting out new music. But why does almost every pop star feel like they need to do a country/country adjacent album at least once in their career? Aside from her released singles, this album was pretty forgettable for me. Best: Music Worst: Paradise (Not for Me)
Llama la atención la aparentemente decisión totalmente voluntaria de darle en este disco el máximo protagonismo a la guitarra acústica, viniendo Madonna como venía del universo electrónico de “Ray Of Light”, pero me parece una decisión acertada. No abandona la electrónica, pero hace que el álbum se diferencie claramente de su predecesor. El tono melancólico de algunas composiciones y la atmósfera ambient de la que fue dotado el disco hacen de él uno de los más coherentes de su carrera. Compacto y lo suficientemente experimental como para mantener a Madonna en la cima del pop por aquel entonces.
Not for me. I'm not sure why this album is here, it doesn't sound particularly fresh, or interesting, or new, or influential. In fact, it sounds quite the opposite. It sounds like Madonna chasing the new trends instead of the reverse like earlier in her career. It's catchy, in a way, but it really sounds like an aging superstar clinging to relevance. 2.5 stars
I generally love Madge and get what she’s going for here, but apart from ‘What It Feels Like For A Girl’ and ‘Don’t Tell Me’, this just hasn’t aged well. And did we really need a cover of American Pie to end the album? Don McLean’s original is bad enough, but this version…this is an abomination. There’s just other, better, worthier (granted earlier) Madonna albums that I would include on this list, or any other, ahead of ‘Music’. Perhaps Garry Mulholland summed it up best in his review for The Guardian in September 2000 when he wrote: “It is naff. Screamingly, amusingly, hypnotically naff. Once you have accepted that, it is possible to start listening to Music for what it is: the sound of a bunch of middle-aged trend-watchers second-guessing what today's kids go for. It is the absolute definition of mutton-dressed-as-lamb middle-youth.”
Why?
5/10
Hmm. Ok but nothing great
I don't mind Madonna, and was actually surprised by the second half of the album. Unfortunately the title song was a meme for some of us at company I used to work for (one which will remain unnamed). "Don't tell me to stop Tell the rain not to drop"
Interesting. I'd only really ever heard Madonna's pop hits before, but this album was much more than that. It started out as a dance club album, but got fairly soft and introspective by the end. The music is varied and good, and the lyrics are well written. Her voice is strong and she sings well.
meh.
3 1/2 Stars: It's undeniable what a huge commercial and critical success Ray of Light was at the time. This follow up found our Queen of Pop dabbling in European EDM and it's really kinda strange on one hand, but pretty great on the other. Don't Tell Me and Music are highlights, but it's the dirty electro sound of Impressive Instant that gets me. I love this album as the marker it serves in my own life.
Not very listenable
I’ve always liked this album. Music and Don’t Tell Me are bangers. I don’t even think the American Pie cover is that bad. The vocoder effect is a tad overdone though. Still a good pop album, which is always welcome in my book
I love me some 80s and early-to-mid-90s Madonna. But the stuff after that is just not the same quality. This album is mostly a snore.
It wasn't for me when it came out, and it still isn't for me. It's not outright awful or anything, but it all feels rather surface level. Oh, and the American Pie cover is a war crime.
4/10
This is a fine pop album with some forays into electronica/dance and some interesting production choices. It's very much Y2K era sounding and doesn't do much for me one way or another. Some of it is pretty annoying but made up for on songs like "Music," "Don't Tell Me," and "Gone."
Oof. The second half was tolerable, I didnt mind the mellower tracks as much, but the more ravey electropop sound, really was feeling close to a 1 star. Sounds like late career Cher fronting the Black Eyed Peas, hot garbage. And that American Pie cover hurts
The second best album called Music that I listened to this year. Pretty boring, it had none of the Madonna songs I had heard of. American Pie was the only interesting part.
6/10 - I listened to this the same day I saw that she was nominated for an electronic dance Grammy and was like 🤔. The album was fine but I feel like there should be a more edm focused genre if this is in the electronic dance category
She wanna be carti so bad
After coming off what I consider to be her magnum opus with Ray of Light, Madonna decides to revitalize her sound once again for the year millennium with her very boldly titled project, Music. This project unalike Ray of Light, feels like a staple of its' time and really starts to show the downfall of Madonna's music quality as her futuristic and forward thinking sounds are finally starting to catch back up with her. Don't get me wrong there are some great songs on here like Don't Tell Me, but for the most part I was expecting a lot more from here. This project for the most part has a pretty consistent identity, but when it tries something completely different it really loses itself in a way I really didn't think Madonna would let slide so easily. It also doesn't help the beginning of this album seems very all over the place despite the high quality shown off, but thankfully it does manage to catch itself later down the tracklist. I appreciate what Madonna had in mind with this project but its' own worst enemy happens to be itself and the tracklisting of this project. Would it have killed anyone if this was 2 songs shorter, because if it simply removed Impressive Instant and Amazing this easily would be one of her better releases.
I was quite excited to do this because the other two Madonna albums we have listened to were great, but this was mostly pretty poor, and extremely dated. A big fall off from Ray Of Light.
The sound of this album took me totally off guard as I didn't expect an electropop album from Madonna. But I did like it. I think some of the mixes between the trance sound, the glitch effects and Madonna's voice are done really well. 'Music', 'Runaway Lover' and 'Amazing' are the best tracks to show how well the blend works. Unfortunately, not all the tracks work as well. From the point you reach 'Amazing', the rest of the songs slow things down and abandon all the interesting electronic elements, and feel way more standard or commercial, and don't offer anything appealing in their own, except for 'What It Feels Like for a Girl', which not only has a great message, but also has a great electronic base. The worst tracks, in my opinion, are 'Impressive Instant' and "Nobody's Perfect" because the have way too much autotune. I don't usually have a problem with autotune, but I don't see it working with her, specially when her voice is as amazing as it is. Overall, a decent electropop album.
pretty mid, it would be good to throw on in the background
Amazing. Never really intentionally listened to Madonna. The sound production on this album is peak. Holds up 25 years later. Wide berth of musical styles. Perhaps that’s the concept of the album. Lyrically, not always bangers, but great bits and pieces.
Madonna is annoying to me.
Soft 4. I like Madonna, and I like 2000s music, but this felt really generic for both of those tags.
Just feel like Madge ran out of ideas by the late 90s and early 2000s. I'm a mystic! I'm a cowgirl! I'll do house music with a country theme! I'll sing in French! This hasn't aged well — especially the Don McClean "American Pie" cover which is probably the worst career choice Madonna ever made, outside of getting a gold tooth.
Great dance pop album. What it feels like for a girl is an underrated masterpiece by Madonna.
Review by Me (2.5/5)
This album is so "of its time". This is absolutely what the year 2000 sounded like. Overall this wasn't for me. But I'm not exactly her target market.
This is a solid album from the Queen of Reinvention. However, knowing how the late 90’s/early 2000 played out, everyone was doing an EDM album: Nelly, all the DJs, Sarah McLachlin, even NuMetal kings Korn did an EDM inspired album. As such, I am not a sure this carved new stone, but was more of Madonna keeping up with the times. There is some country influence, like on Don’t Yell Me, and we can’t forget the T-Pain-like autotune everyone was doing on Nobody’s Perfect. There are some good songs here, so no means an insult and I did enjoy listening to it. Her early work was revolutionary; Ray of Light a personal exploration. This album feels like Madonna was just trying to be relevant as an “older” pop star.
Random thoughts: * I thought I owned this on CD but I can't find it. It could be in the boxes in storage and means that when I had to cull down the CDs this is one that didn't make the cut. * It did make me find out that I do own the Immaculate Collection. I dusted that one off to give a listen on my Bose CD player. :) * "Don't Tell Me" is my absolute favorite Madonna track. Seriously love this song, I think it might be in my top 50 or top 100 songs of all time. * I have a hilarious memory (to me and my sister at least) of "Don't Tell Me" where I did a little drunk cowboy dance to this tune while in Blackhawk. I think you had to be there. * "Music" is also a banger! Still fun to play years later. * This was a fun time in music when Madonna went EDM. Actually all of pop went electronica. This was right around the time of Cher's "Believe". * I didn't remember any of the other songs but listening through today, there are some good ones. "What It Feels Like for a Girl" was a stand out on this listen. Maybe being a girl dad or becoming a feminist made me really feel this one. * Dude! American Pie came on and I said "What is this abomination?!?!?" I don't remember this or blocked it out. Apparently, it is only on the international version. And since 1001 is a British endeavor, when you click on the album from 1001 it has "American Pie" tacked on at the end. Good call to leave this off the American version. You don't mess with perfection. * This is probably somewhere around a 3.5 rating but since that is not an option, I'm giving it a 4 for the American version of this album. The international version would be a 3 or 2 for touching Don McLean's masterpiece.
Do I have to? Lol
Of the three Madonna albums I’ve listened to on this list, this was perhaps the weakest. It was different than I expected, and maybe even in a good way - slower songs, kind of interesting (experimental, even?) electronica - but it felt hollow and inauthentic, and failed to come together. Given that it’s not Madonna’s best work, or even especially notable or influential, it’s hard to justify its inclusion on the list. Paradise (Not For Me) 2.5
While I appreciate the musical diversity present on this album, it certainly has its share of highs and lows. Also gets stronger as the album goes; each song is better than the last in my opinion. Something for everyone, but not all for me. Top tracks: Don't Tell Me, Paradise (Not for Me), Gone
The album wasn’t bad, but it was not something I would listen to on purpose. I liked What it feels like for a girl. Everything else sounds very clubby and gay. That’s not bad, but it’s not my vibe
Een soort techno Madonna album? Ok, ik ben volledig klaar hiervoor! Hele futuristische productie en duidelijk volledig op de dansvloer geinspireerd. Mensen zeggen dat Ray of Light het Madonna album is dat EUSEXUA van FKA Twigs heeft geinspireerd, maar een song als Runaway Lover zou ook niet misstaan op dat album! Ah shit, daarna komt helaas wel I Deserve It, ik wil meer technodonna!!! Nee, de tweede helft van dit album kakt harder in dan iemand op een after die dacht niets meer nodig te hebben. Pff, jammer, ik was wel klaar voor technodonna maar de ballads zijn eigenlijk niet zo goed. Vrij matig zelfs. Madonna is voor mij op haar best op up-tempo dansvloerkrakers, maar dat kan er ook aan liggen dat dat de Madonna is die ik het beste ken. American pie de cover, ja ik ben gewoon niet heel erg een fan van covers over het algemeen. Zelfs de kolonisatielijst doet toch vaak een beetje pijn. Ook bij deze cover denk ik toch voornamelijk; waarom luister ik het origineel niet? Album begint dus best wel sterk, kakt hard in en eindigt ook echt een beetje met een stinker met American Pie. Mwah... FAVO: Music, Runaway Lover, Don't tell me
I always liked "Music." "What It's Like for a Girl" is really sweet and beautiful. Ngl, brought a tear to my eye. Melancholic and moving. Not bad, but a lot tracks, especially on first half, kinda mush together. Production is very early-2000s, which isn't bad in-itself but kinda feels generic and pre-set heavy. Very in-the-box. Second half gets a bit more interesting and diverse. "Paradise (Not for Me)" is cool. Last song doesn't sound like a Madonna song. It's okay. I wouldn't mind if someone else put this on. I'm not likely to ever put it on again, but it's not bad. Just not a whole lot of distinction between tracks.
Terrible. Couldn’t take it seriously with the ridiculous lyrics…
Madonna mostra nesse Álbum que o Pop da década de 2000 seria mais uma vez dominado por ela. Excelente disco! CVJ Neko.
I guess she's technically right.
An ok dance album but she has much better albums earlier in her career
Solid album. Didn't love the whisper stuff but some songs are real bops
Not a Madonna fan, the music is mostly meh. Never really got the appeal. yeah she can sing, so what many people can sing. Very generic 2000s music, remember hearing the singles on radio and thinking they weren't that good even as a kid.
16-10-25
This is one of the worst things I have ever listened to. She can’t sing; the lyrics are facile and vapid. Shit in a silk stocking, the manifest inadequacies of the material are to be buried under expensive production but end result sounds little better than europop.
This phase of Madonna is no bueno
Very nice production and instrumentals combined with flat and uninspiring vocals.
True. This is considered music. Not great music but mid music.
I find it best to treat the song American Pie as optional in all circumstances. In this case it was marked as a bonus track, so I feel fully justified.
When I think of Madonna, I think of the 80's, and this release shows how unfair that is to Madonna. Here she is, at the precipice of a new millennia making some great dance music.
Not for me
Madonna is a very good musical artist. I love how she always reinvents herself but never loses her own ... autograph. Yup. It's Madonna, and yeah, it is good actually. But she is a queen for a reason. She made her own table and deserves it. Worth listening to? Well yeah, of course!
Sucked Bad album
more madonna? okay. for whatever reason, she's suddenly a cowgirl. don't judge the album cover, because this is a electronic dance pop album. i'm... not sure what to think of this album. remember when i reviewed "ray of light" and i almost treated it like madonna's swan song at times? this is exactly why i treated it like such. this album is... kinda baffling to me. futuristic country music...? i don't know... sometimes it's an electronic disco party. sometimes it's a forgettable song that would be on a dance dance revolution songlist. sometimes it's a slow jam with autotune. it's a very strange palette of sound, and honestly i don't know if i feel a lot of it. there's a small portion of the album that i would call underrated, but for the most part i just sat there going... "....huh?"
It’s just an average studio album added to the list simply because she’s madonna 3/5
LOVE ITTTTT
thought it was gonna be country, not CUNTRY
On the one hand, I can practically taste the pre-9/11 positivity across this album... this music harkens back to a simpler time in America. Madonna's vocal performance is stellar -- except for a handful of instances where she appears to have used auto-tune, which feels like a baffling decision in retrospect. I assumed that would have been a producer's decision, but upon doing research, I was amazed to see it was the opposite: Madonna wanted to use auto-tune, and the producer agreed to it despite his disagreement. Wow. Okay. Then again, other aspects of the production haven't aged all that well. Decisions to 'over-produce' which feel aggravating to listen to and distract from Madonna's singing. But I'd argue the good choices still outweigh the not so good.. it's a fun listen, and there is stuff beneath the surface to grasp on to if you're listening for it.
A true time capsule. The title track has a grip on my childhood I didn’t know I forgot - my neighbor Loved this album when I was barely a few years old. They had a big statue of a smoking monkey and a broken grand piano. Anyways, why is she dressed up all country on the least country album?
Not a fan.
Not for me 1/5
This was not as bad as I thought it would be. There are a few catchy beats and some interesting melodies to be found on this album. The title track is pretty annoying, but the album starts well overall. The occasional dud track is not a surprise. It’s a bit safe, but it’s a lot better than some of the albums I have been presented with recently. However, Madonna has better albums than this, so it’s hard to be too generous.
Was actually considering a 3 rating until that American Pie cover.
Музыка: 5/10 Разнообразие: 4/10 Тематика и вайб: 6/10 Цепляемость (отдельные песни зашли): 2/10 Реиграбельность (можно ли рандомно врубить на фон): 5/10 Итог: 4.4
Perfect!
first listen super meh
I thought Music was horrible. It lacks the energy and authenticity of Madonna's older work. The electronic direction felt uninspired, especially compared to her earlier hits. It just didn’t capture the magic she used to have. Definitely not a favorite.
I was okay with the first or second song and then it lost me. I was expecting more from this album, and it didn’t do that.
It's hilarious to think this was the number 1 album in the country at one point. Simpler times. Madonna is polarizing, but she's past her prime here. I don't even know what's going on in this album. One of those "throw everything at the wall and see what sticks" type of albums. The skipping guitar track on Don't Tell Me physically hurt my stomach. Madonna has some great songs, but they aren't on this album.
It's ok. She has other albuns I like more
This is terrible early 2000s pop. Awful.
It was okay. There are better Madonna albums.
1 - not good, overproduced electronic pop
If I have learned nothing else from this exercise it is that (a) Elvis Costello made some absolute turds and (b) I actually can get down with Madonna. This album, along with its predecessor are music that I otherwise would never have listened to because I wrote Madonna off as pop bullshit. And yet, both albums are fantastic. Not just in their quality music, but also in terms of experimentation and variety of sounds. The title and artwork do this album no favors, but it is an enjoyable ride all the way through. As far as pop albums go, this is top tier IMO. Title track is instantly recognizable though I never knew its name. Gotta say, this is one of the most turn of the Millennium sounding instrumentals I have ever heard. Ngl I dig it. Impressive Instant is kind of fun, with a backing instrumental loop makes me think of something Marc Rebillet would build upon. The party pauses momentarily as Madonna pulls out an acoustic guitar on I Deserve It. Actually really like this song -- in a different setting sans vocals I would believe someone if they said this was a Gorillaz song. Amazing takes a dip into the turn of the Millennium 60s pop revival sound -- makes me think of Austin Powers for some reason. and Nobody's Perfect is an auto-tuned adventure that reminds me of something that I can't quite put a finger on (I think its a Blur song, but not sure). Absolutely love What It Feels Like for a Girl. Vocals are solid, but the underlying instrumental is dreamy AF. And Paradise (Not for Me) is a wonderful trip-hop influenced piece -- one of my favorites here. In the end, I'm left feeling that this was a really strong album front-to-back. And yet, I don't feel quite pulled to give it a 5. Instead I'm falling in at a very high 4.
Not at all what I expected when I think of Madonna. Very interesting beats and style. Good enough for me!
Not even close to being my normal type of music that I usually choose to listen to, but this album was actually filled with some jams and I highly enjoyed this. Very happy that it wasn't an hour plus long album. Was the perfect length for this genre.
This music album wasn't my favorite music.
Musically, this album is very cool. You can easily hear how it was ahead of the curve on a lot of 2000s musical trends. Lyrically, however, I found this album to be really juvenile and uninteresting. Everything she is saying is fine, but it feels like she has said it all before at this point in her career. Most of the rhymes are low-hanging fruit and a lot of the themes are pretty predictable.
I expected Madonna albums - I did not expect a 2000's album . . . I like a lot of her stuff, Like a Virgin era. She's a lot better singer and musician on this album and I'm sure in 2000 it was important development for her to stay current and relevant (and selling, I believe this album was a commercial success) but it's not my favorite.
Music is a great track Too electronic for me, but I can see why it was chosen for this list 3
I feel like this is a response to Cher's "Believe" album. The timeline somewhat fits, and there's at least one song with the autotune CRANKED like Cher's title track. But there's some good stuff in here, and I kinda get why it was put on the list (and subsequently taken off). "Gone" is probably my favorite track, but I think it would have worked better with actual drums and instrumentation as opposed to the programming. It just sounds less... real. I can see why it was pulled, it feels a little similar to "Ray of Light," although it varies more than that did. I think the song "Music" would have been more effective for me if it just stopped instead of fading out. The other song which I enjoyed was "I Deserve It", I thought that was an interesting, contemplative song. So the songs that were not so upbeat I actually enjoyed more. Who would have thought?
The title track is so fun and I feel like it was such an unexpected hit. But I don't really love the rest of the album and how synth heavy and autotune heavy (or whatever voice effects they were using then). Ray of Light was a cool reinvention of Madonna, this one gets a bit over the top - looking at you Impressive Instant, Nobody's Perfect, and Paradise. I did like some of the softer pieces like I Deserve It, Gone, Don't Tell Me, and What it Feels Like for a Girl (the latter two were successful singles, for good reason). Amazing is a good upbeat tune, that doesn't overdo the synth. I know she was trying to set herself apart in a new genre and stay hip with the young kids, and maybe the fact it doesn't totally resonate with me shows I didn't keep up with the times. Started to creep toward 3.5 but didn't feel like going up to 4.
Despite never previously liking Madonna, I've tried to be open minded. Imagine my surprise when I really enjoyed Like a Prayer and Ray of Light, leading to 4 stars for each. But I knew I was in trouble when my wife (a Madonna fan) told me that Music was the last Madonna album she bought because she didn't like all the autotune. Since autotune is an automatic one star reduction (at best) for me, I knew this one was going to be tough. Overall, I'd say there's enough good on the album to (mostly) override my distaste for autotune and, dare I say it, the autotune in the title track was subtle and even worked as a good effect for a change. After I got through the first half, I figured easy 3, maybe even a shot at a 4. Then I got to Nobody's Perfect. HOLY CRAP WHAT A HORRIBLE SONG. Awful autotune, nauseating key sound. Like I literally will remove a star JUST FOR THIS AWFUL TRACK. Wait, then Don't Tell Me - wtf, they purposely made it sound like the track was glitching?? I had to listen on another service just to make sure there wasn't something wrong with the Apple Music track. Who on earth thought that was a good idea?? The rest of the album was ok - nothing groundbreaking, but catchy enough (although Paradise had more autotune/electronic effects on the vocals than I'd like, which was a shame, because I liked the atmosphere of the song). I don't know if those two awful tracks are enough to bring me down to a 2 on the album. I'll go with the 3 because in general the album was growing on me with each listen, and got better on close listen. Feels wrong to give it a 2 in that case - but those two tracks alone make it no more than a 3. Favorite tracks: Music, Amazing, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Gone.
I have to be a big honest boy and say I did not listen to this album at all, however ‘Music’ and ‘Don’t tell me’ are absolute bangers. Off pure instinct this gets a 3 from me
Look I’ve always had a soft spot for pop music, and that’s something I’ve had to defend / admit to myself quietly so I’m not going to be a genre snob here. However, this just wasn’t a fun listen. Madonna has a catalogue of great tracks, ones which you don’t have to be a pop fan to enjoy/admit how well crafted they are. But lots of these felt like they could have been crafted on audacity by someone of my capabilities, and ‘I deserve it’ epitomised that lyrically and musically throughout. Sunday is a notoriously fantastic day to listen to an album, but this wasn’t one of them. Am sorry.
So I think my review here is a bit biased because I remember buying this album when I was 9 and playing it on my sony walkman thinking I was just so cool. I think what made it a big deal to me was that Madonna was already known, she was a huge star but she wasn't my generation's pop star until this album and then she belonged to us too. 2000 being the year it was, this album was weird and wonderful and futuristic and Madonna had gone from 80s icon to stepping straight into the next millennium with a lot of autotune and for some reason dressed as a cowboy but I was here for it and loved it. This was one of the first albums I bought myself making the decision myself for what I wanted to listen to and feeling like I was growing up. Obviously 'What It Feels Like For A Girl' spoke to me in my little 10 year old world and I felt very adult. So I think that this review is a lot more about how music impacts certain parts of your life and it can be really quite mediocre verging on pretty bad music (apart from Don't Tell Me, that is just a standalone wonderful pop song and I won't hear anything against this) but because of what it was to you at that time, you can listen and still singalong to too many of the words you care to admit and it makes you smile. I guess it's good to remember that music has a role in this way too and I'm glad that this has led me to listen to this album 20 years later.
I can only assume that there’s been an administrative error and that this was meant to be on the 1001 Ways To Die Before You Listen To This Album, as this is possibly the blandest and most pointless album that I have heard from Madonna (and I genuinely love some of her stuff). Bland lyrics, insipid delivery, plus a pointless cover version to round off the whole package. Seriously, what the hell is this on this list for…?
This is such an auto-tuned mess. The few decent songs are more straightforward (Don't Tell Me for example). But What it Feels Like for a Girl tries too hard to be provocative with nothing to show for it. And then there's the blasphemy of the American Pie cover.
Seriously!? I just got "Ray of Light" like two days ago!! Eat sh*t, algorithm. This is the absolute hottest of garbage. 1 star.
I can't believe that this is on the list. The whole thing of experimental music is the risk reward. It's risky, you might make something revolutionary but also there's a chance that people won't like it and you'll look stupid. This is the abominable spawn of eurotrash dance trot and 90s diva pop and it's revolting. Perhaps this failure is so revolting it's impossible to forget. If there is a merciful god, I hope he lets us forget this album so we can live our lives with dignity and grace.
Not sure why this 00s Madonna album is on here.
I'm not sure if it's true but I don't remember pop music sounding like this before the 2010's. In that way it's a bit of a foray in to electronic music from a pop perspective that nobody was doing until a bit later, which is cool. That said, it sounds very much like it was the early version of EDM tinged pop music; the beats that aren't from the singles are pretty forgettable and Madonna might as well have been any other nameless singer with a female voice for some of them. The singles are decent enough; the title track has a unique beat and has more of Madonna's traditional vocal stylings than the other ones. I appreciate that someone took the time to suggest she go in to other genres a bit besides the overarching EDM but none of it screams "crossover hit" to me. "Don't Tell Me" is not going to land on country radio no matter how hard she tried. This is fairly mid. The non singles are pretty bad, the cover of American Pie is somehow more shit than the original. Points for probably pushing the boundaries of pop a little bit forward.
Madonna's 8th album changed the game and definitely deserves to be on this list.
It's rare for a pop album to work for me, and this was no exception. Not objectively bad, but I was glad when it was over. 2.2
This is supposed to be one of the 1001 albums, which one should listen to before one dies? Is that some kind of joke? It's not different to thousand others pop albums out there, except maybe that a very famous person made this album. If I'm missing something I really would like an explanation.
Not great
Typical late 90s/early 00s pop sound with a few new pieces of production technology being shown off. The music is engaging and energetic, and Madonna has a charming voice. She has that showgirl sound, even in the 2000s. Decent record.
Meh
Some classics, some meh
I’m not super familiar with Madonna’s discography, but I know she has plenty of albums better than Music. Most of it is just bland generic pop. The couple songs I did enjoy were funnily enough the ones that were more country inspired. The version of this album on apple music did not include her cover of American Pie, but based on some of the reviews here I had to check it out anyway. It’s a good thing that it’s left off the album, because it alone would drag this down to a one star
Madonna walked so Playboi Carti could run. I’m conflicted on this one. On one hand I don’t like most of these songs, but a remaining few I really do like. So as a whole it’s not great. Favorites were I Deserve It, Don’t Tell Me, and What It Feels Like For A Girl.
Hello fellow kids. Sorry, just no. I'm not sure what cultural relevancy Madonna was aspiring to in 2000 but it was over. She can't even sing. I will say she was working with a talented producer who deserved a better vocalist.
Odotin kunnon tanssimusaa. Jouduin pettymään. Albumi oli jopa alavireinen odotuksiini verrattuna. Useimmat ääniraidoista olivat ärsyttäviä eikä laulukaan säväyttänyt. En kuuntelisi uudestaan. Hämmästyttävää kyllä Madonnan coveri American Pie:sta oli aivan mukiin menevä ja paransi muuten pitkäveteistä albumia.
Ok - but a bit disappointing and not particularly inspiring
Not awful (bar American Pie) but lacks the excitement it tries to bring
Huge singles, but way too many dreary deep cuts and Auto-Tune ballads to make this hold together as an album
Two good songs, rest kind of boring.
# 89 Music ~ Madonna Music is strange. Perhaps this era for Madonna is strange. In a point of her time where you would have considered her a fading star along with her contemporaries in Prince and MJ, her popularity suddenly got a second wind. Now on level playing field with the American teen pop of Spears and Aguilera as well as the continuing RnB explosion, Madonna sought out to make herself stand out by forming a new image for the 2000s: one that attempted to dispel the controversies of the early 90s and portray herself as.... a cowgirl. The music of Music then. Madonna summons the powers of the British electronica scene from trip hop to downtempo to techno and fused it with Americana. These electronica skeletons are decorated with acoustic and electric guitars to give a sort of folky/heartland rock flavour to these otherwise techno party songs. And this is essentially what Music is. Folk party hits. A good deal of these songs are about partying, and unfortunately they sound really hollow. All these electronic tricks from heavy chopping and manipulation to auto-tuning just leaves me cold, as if they are flashing lights that don't deliver. Madonna though sounds great as ever though, and her more introspective and critiquing songs are more convincing than her party songs. Runaway Lover and What It Feels Like for a Girl are great songs that make great use for Madonna's perchance for deep emotion, but outside of this, the rest feels unusually empty. A bit disappointing.
Removed
Was going to be a 2 but I couldn't forgive that awful cover of American Pie
Yes, this was Music by Madonna. Though if you asked someone to sing a song by her I can't imagine any of these would be among them.
I love Madonna, and Ray of Light is well deserved a place on this list, but this, not so much.
Geh mir weg damit. Habe ich irgendwann abgebrochen. War nur nervig.
Dear me. This album contains the worst lyrics you will ever hear. And the production is just something I cant articulate. Like when you get something new and try every feature at once. Over produced? Lazy? Shite? All of the above. Honestly this is dreadful
Hilariously abysmal. So bad. The robot voices, the claims of keeping it real, the horrendous cover of American pie. Laughed a lot, cringed a lot, never again.
I believe this album sort of spearheaded her reinvention as a dance-pop gran, culminating in Confessions on a Dance Floor about 5 years later. The album title is laughable - absolutely no thought whatsoever. "What's on your new album, Madge?" "Music, Guy". Don't Tell Me is a song on the album. The other tracks are not worth reporting on. Tonally, all over the place. Regarding the cover of American Pie: I saw Don McLean some years ago now in Utrecht doing his greatest hits tour. He ended up doing a 10 minute version of his second best song (his best being Vincent). It was pretty spectacular; he's an old man but he sounded young and vibrant, lamenting loss and generational change. Back to Madonna - this album is about 1.5, but I can't for the life of me fathom giving this 2 stars.
Had auto tune just been invented when this was being recorded or something? Extremely liberal use here and it's fairly awful. I recognised a couple of the singles and they're all pretty bad, the cover of American pie is dreadful I don't think 1 is unfair
Similar to the Madonna album from 1997, not really feeling it.
Music makes the people boo together
I don't want to listen to this shit. I remember when the main single was released for this album, it was catchy but it's aged worse than the peanut M&Ms I cleaned out from my kid's car seat last week. It's not that I don't like Madonna...she's got some songs that are certified bangers, they're just not found on this album. I also don't think she has a great voice...distinct, yes, but not great. It's insulting that the presence of a cowboy hat and an acoustic guitar here and there makes people say things like she's experimenting with country music. It's also insulting for people to keep repeating the line about how she was a genius at "reinventing" herself...no, she just paid attention to what was happening in clubs and pop culture and adopted trends early enough to where people thought she was a trendsetter. She was smart for doing that, but she's not an original. Music sucked around the year 2000 when this was released. Nu-metal and rap/rock, boy bands, Eminem, Spice Girls, that goddamn Santana/Rob Thomas song, Britney and Christina were alive while Tupac and Biggie were dead, a lot of artists from the 80s and 90s were trying to figure out where they fit on the landscape and it was just a really weird, shitty time. And that's this album, Madonna trying to figure out where she fit into a weird, shitty time in pop music history so she made a shitty album.
Not bad. Amazing was pretty decent and I quite enjoyed Paradise (Not for Me). The rest varied from okay but not my thing to eh, I don't particularly like this song. 2.5/5 stars.
You know, I didn't really enjoy that.
Une pop électronique chargée et un brin désincarnée. La meilleure chanson est probablement American Pie, soit une reprise de Don McLean, qui transmet une émotion vivante et articulée
Boring, too commercial, uninteresting. Why is this álbum in this list? It made me lose my time. 1 star
Experimental Hahaha Definition Experimental: Doing something that has not been done before. I won't insult your intelligence by explaining the irony of this 2* for the people who did all the computer programs
Terrible album art, terrible album name and very, very mediocre tracks. I guess there is something to say for production quality and some electronic sound choices which are nifty, but it is otherwise botched by the voices, lyrics and superficial composition.
'Music mix the bourgeoisie and the rebel.' The title track, the ostentatious 'Music,' incorporates the same whiny synths that Dr. Dre had been known to employ for his baptism of the g-funk era. Those synths appear on other tracks as well, giving this essentially genreless record a consistent hip-hop bite and confidence. The album cover would have you believe that there is something Western going on here, but besides the few folksy moments of acoustic guitar, make no mistake, this is a record of a city slicker, certified on the wonderfully sophisticated 'What It Feels Like for a Girl': 'But for a boy to look like a girl is degrading / 'Cause you think that being a girl is degrading.' And brava for not 'selling out,' as she closes out w/ on 'Gone.'
Of course, very catchy. Madonna is and has been a master of pop music and, as here, a driving force in the musical zeitgeist. This album marks one of a few moments that drove the mainstream of popular, commercial Western music toward a more heavily electronic sound. Between the beats and the vocal processing, it's hard not to imagine a Daft Punk influence throughout. It's also remarkable that Madonna dominated the charts with this album in her forties: something particularly difficult to do for a woman at that period of time, when female pop vocalists were typically in their early twenties. I've never been a fan of producer-dominated music. I'm interested in the contributions that producers make to albums but on the other hand, I'm left cold by most music that's built from the ground up by a producer tying to figure out what will sell -- and there's a strong current of that, here. That's true as much for pop as it is for Nirvana. To her credit, Madonna scrapped most of an album's worth of material that she'd produced with William Orbit for this record, so her input her is primary. But: as much as she deserves respect for her ability to understand the cultural moment deeply and to push it in a direction (and to drop 9 completed tracks because she doesn't want to repeat herself), the actual music sounds a little clinical. The Western theme has a real foreshadowing of Beyoncé's country turn. The electro-country vibe is still very cool. Madonna's vocals are excellent throughout (and in 2000, let me tell you that you could spot AutoTune from a rural mile away). Honestly, you really should check this out. It's eclectic and weird in the ways that culture from the turn of the millennium could often be. The convergence of disparate genres had begun at this point, but our ability to synthesize them into something organic was still underdeveloped and, though this is a polished version for the era, it still feels a little off-kilter. It's pleasant. The music still feels sterile and more for the benefit of shareholders than listeners but it's at least kinda weird. Standouts: 'Music' was a hit single and it's pretty good. The cover of 'American Pie' is alright; it kind of fucks up the tempo (too straight; thanks, pop music) but the use of a Rhodes piano is pretty great. "What It Feels Like For A Girl' is interesting and also packs a genuine emotional heft -- I'm shocked it hasn't had a resurgence. 'Don't Tell Me' and its chopped up acoustic guitar hook is cool, full stop -- best track on the record and would still be on a lot of good albums. 3.5/5; she's got better albums, but this isn't a bad listen.
4/10 I guess that’s what I get for listening to a pop star’s album that’s just called “music”
""""music""""
I liked the more acoustic songs. I get that Madonna might have wanted to do something different. I wish she would have done something good.
A bit lame, I can't stand the pitch bend fad of the 2000s
79/100. The stuttering synths, warped vocals, and glitch-pop textures give the album a futuristic edge that still sounds good today and those moments shine the brightest. The more traditional pop tracks add a warmer, acoustic balance, though they can’t quite match the freshness of the experimental core.
this woman knows how to make an album
It was madonna. Just a bit nothing but not too bad to turn off.
Ah, 2000. A time when well-established icons (and Victoria Beckham) disguised their ageing voices with that robot autotune sound. When you hear the name Madonna, nobody - absolutely nobody - thinks of this album. Title track might be considered after a while, but this couldn't sound more bland and dated if it tried. A reminder that not everything pre-9/11 was sunshine and rainbows. It's 8 hours since I wrote the above, and I only just got to see other reviews. Considering the number of references to 9/11 in them (not something I ever do) I'm going to say that this album is not just terrorism on the ears, but contains some form of subliminal terrorism within. Madge did it.
Wasn't expecting techno from Madonna tbh, but I think she does it pretty well! Think the album falls off in the second half, but there're a good number of songs I like in this
4 cannot deny the earworms!
This is a music tech exam ahh album I feel like some of the glitchy and techy elements work quite well, like the vocal manipulations in the second song, but some are just trash, like the auto tune on 6, I am not really an auto tune hater, but there's nothing else in the beat so it just sticks out like a sore thumb. But there's obviously a huge budget gone into the production and sound design, even if it is just stealing popular sounds from the time, some bits are really Daft Punk and Euro-techno/house stuff. I feel like parts feel quite bit more arty than some of the poop party pop shit on the radios at the time, some of this (like the title song) is that though. Its quite fun though. ight be just me but it feels like she has nothing to say lyrically, as they are quite stale, which is why the cool effects make them better. Its quite fun though, nothing too offensive (besides maybe the title song). Favourite songs: Impressive instant, runaway lover, Don't tell me, what it feels to be a girl, paradise (not for me), American Pie (although I'm not super familiar with the original). Overall around 6/10
is it just me or is this a totally bizarre choice for a madonna album for this list? i read the wikipedia page and it seemed quite well-acclaimed at the time. is it possible this kind of music has been so refined and polished that this seems pedestrian to me? struggling between a 2 and a 3 but i ultimately didn't mind listening to it that much. i just didn't think anything interesting was happening during it!
eh, this isn't gonna cut it from a legend like madonna. hard to believe anyone, let alone critics, considered this "experimental" at the time. there was a lot changing in music around the turn of the millennium but madonna's safest, blandest album yet was not it. the title track is decent and don't tell me is serviceable. the rest is just 4-minute unremarkable pop song drivel, scooped out of the big slimy vat where it resides and slopped down onto the album to fill time. that said, i thought the american pie cover was at least interesting. it's not amazing by any means, but the different instrumentation and vibe shift is worth a listen or two. seems to be very polarizing in these comments, but i assume those are all from conservative dad rock dudes that hate anyone who tries to put a new spin on the classics, especially a w o m a n !!!! favorites: music, don't tell me, american pie
I honestly didn't go in with high expectations, but I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this album. A solid listen!
I’ve hated the title track of this album my entire life so I imagine my surprise when I really liked the rest of it (minus that terrible American pie cover).
Hard to think there was once a time when Autotune was groundbreaking. Not Madonna's best work, but I've always like "What It Feels Like For A Girl".
I only knew Madonna the way you know her by growing up during the 90s, ie occasionally listening to her songs on radio. I never made an effort to seek out and listen to full albums of hers, however. So I have to say that this came as quite a surprise, because it‘s *nothing * like I expected. „Music“ is strangely experimental, continuously trying out new things. Not all of them work well (the notorious last track for example), but I really enjoyed the many facets of this album and that it wasn’t ashamed to leave the beaten path. Also: Am I going crazy or was there a Daft Punk influence in there? Anyway, not the best album ever but a surprising and enjoyable one nonetheless. I would give 3.5 stars if I could, so let’s round up.
It only took until album 915 for me to get my first Madonna album to review, and it’s her classic album True Blue… er, Music. Neato. I consider myself a causal Madonna fan, but I’m not familiar with anything she put out after Ray of Light. I think her stuff from the eighties and early nineties is fantastic, but I’m not sure what to make of her in this western getup that she’s sporting on the cover of this album. I have no idea what I’m going to hear on this album, but here goes nothing! The booming bass of the title/leadoff track got my full attention, but that was one of the few moments where I was engaged with this album. Musically, I mostly enjoyed the dance sounds on this album, but lyrically and vocally, I just could not have cared less. I’ve heard worse things on this list (yesterday’s effort from Primal Scream comes to mind), but I’ve heard so much better, especially when it comes to pop and dance music from this era. Most of this album just felt robotic and uninspired. If Madonna had anything to say on this album, it certainly didn’t land with me. I did wind up recognizing “Don’t Tell Me,” which was the best song on the album, by a slim margin. I loved the stutter-step of the guitar, and the bass beat was excellent too. “What It Feels Like for a Girl” was pretty good too. I liked the dream-like sound of the electronic elements, and I thought the lyrics were pretty good too (strike what I said earlier, but this is the only instance where this album has anything meaningful to say). While this wasn’t really my speed, I have high hopes for the other Madonna albums on this list, but I still think it’s a crime that this album made the cut, while True Blue didn’t.
Crap. Madonna had her moment in the 1980s. But you can only coast so far on spectacle over substance, without being good at the things that are actually your job - singing, dancing, writing pop songs. Madonna's post-'80s career is a textbook study in diminishing returns.
I have no theory of mind for someone who considers this good music
This album feels extremely dated. All of the sounds here have been so influential in the years after and have since been refined further. Especially the first half is a tough listen if you compare it to anything from the late 2010s. That being said I can appreciate the influence enough to give it its flowers.
This is crap. Theres nothing great about this album at all. If it wasn't by modanna or at least she stood there while someone both over and underproduced this album, it wouldnt even be considered.
THEY MEMORY HOLED "American Pie" lol I was so confused! I listened to this *10* track album on Spotify, then went to the reviews... Why are all these people wanging on about American Pie??? A little digging then brings up an *eleven* track version Woof.
Runaway lover and amazing are good, the rest is just generic pop
I thought I liked most of Madonna's disco, electronic music era stuff... I was wrong. Minus the opening song this pretty much sucks across the board.
старушка весело приуныла
As far as Madonna goes this album is about as good as it gets. However, that's a bit like celebrating the tallest midget as, by and large, the rest of her music bores me to tears. The opening track is solid, there's a couple of other decent tracks, the cover of 'American Pie' is awful. I made it all the way through, so it's 2 stars from me.
Yep !
Pop music isn’t my thing but this was a decent enough listen. I liked some songs, I hated a few, I was indifferent to the rest. Top Track - Don’t Tell Me
Just grating and not that enjoyable.
She’s a legend but she’s not my cup of tea. Nevertheless, this was a good album. Her early stuff was good because it was new. Some of her later stuff is tired and overblown. This album is better! I like it and I will listen again.
So 2000’s but it works.
Really wanted to enjoy this but outside of about two songs it was shite. Utterly dull.
The influence on every single pop song from the 2000s should not be underestimated. To paraphrase another review, it sounds like the quintessential 2000s album because it influenced plenty of albums from the 2000s, despite this being the third decade of her career.
Sometimes maybe good sometimes maybe bad. It starts off a bit poor with the titular track, but it enters into an unapologetic 90s music vision of the 21st century. Its captured by focusing completely on "dance" & "partying." Maybe this improves over multiple listens, but I can barely understand Madonna's voice between the overproduced music. That may come across as a negative, but it actually gives it a very 90s feel.
So, I remember this as one of my first ever albums to listen to, thanks to the fact that my mom had it on tape! I loved it so much as a kid, but I'll be honest, I didn't expect to see it on this list. That's not to say that I didn't have a great time with it again, though. This felt nostalgic, retro-techno, and fun. I really loved a lot of the auto-tune, which is not usually what I like, but I think it felt more honest here since I know Madonna can sing so well without it that there was no question that it's an esthetic choice for the album. Not every song was a hit, but it bought me back to riding around in Mom's old golden 2001 Chevy Malibu listening to Music again and again. Favorite songs: Music Impressive Instant I Deserve It Don't Tell Me
I'm just thinking of all the albums that aren't on this list that could have been over this one........ It does encapsulate that weird time between 90s/00s pop. Didn't mind Don't Tell Me. 1.5/5
The material girl was a product of the 80s, but her star quality had long faded by this album. This album is just generic commercial pop garbage.
I remember when this released and all the talk about Madonna yet again changing styles with the time and how well she does it. The album has some really good songs and some that just pass by without making an impression. All and all its a good album with some stand out moments.
A esto lo llamo música para drag queen básicamente: un electropop vacío sin alma alguna. De hecho, cuando esta mujer se pone a jugar con el autotune no hay quien la aguante. Este disco solo tiene una canción agradable (American Pie) y no es ni siquiera de Madonna. 1/5
5/10. It wasn’t as bad as I expected. Solid pop for that time, but not for me.
Iconicc
kinda meh. its got that 70s 'futuristic' sound at times. a bit depressing
Cool album, I don't know what I was expecting, but it's interesting. 5.4/10
Madonna!
me gustó, nunca le había prestado atención a Madonna y me sorprendió. No sabía que había incursionado asi en el dance y la electrónica
I like this era of Madonna better than the mid 80s. She's more developed.
I can appreciate that in the time period where this came out, there was a lot of teen pop and R&B dominating the charts, and Madonna was going for something relevant but more refined. And I think she mostly succeeded, though it's not the sort of music I'm generally a huge fan of (and the cover of American Pie is a travesty).
I liked the title song but everything else was horrible. Jesus.
Gear: ZMF Bokeh Artwork: 🤠👱♀️🚘 Production: 🥐🤩👍 Music: 🤖🎚️🧼 Rating: 🎼(🎼)/5
A little too techno synth for me. Trying too hard to be club beats instead of good songs. Music and Don't Tell Me are pretty solid.
Actually better than I thought it would be on balance. My younger self would be disappointed that I'm not cooler as a grown-up.
Big ole meh
This album is all over the place. The first song was so bland that I almost gave up, but then the second song hooked me. Then the 3rd and 4th songs were like a totally different sound. She's just totally unpredictable. And then she covers American Pie? with synths and shit? and it ain't wholly terrible, though it's also not better than the original.
Ah, Madonna's autotune phase. While she was a massive force to be reckoned with in the 80s and 90s, by the turn of the century, she was comfortably settled into a niche that, while commercially successful on star power alone, really seemed to leave a lot to be desired.