Reviews (page 2 of 9)
I’m not about to hung out their back catalogue but I did like this
Groupe inconnu. L’album est totalement instrumental, ce qui est une bonne surprise. Les compositions sont originales (structures non standard, on ne sait pas trop à quoi s’attendre), ce qui est une seconde bonne surprise. Et on a droit à un morceau de 20 mn réussi ! Excellente découverte donc, qui rejoindra ma collection. Et je vais m’intéresser aux autres albums du groupe. =>4/5
This was okay. Instrumental music that covers a lot of ground: indie, post-punk, noise, a bunch of stuff under the sun. I could see myself putting this on as I read or try to write. It wasn't so faceless that I'd completely ignore it, but not mind-blowing enough that it would distract me from a task.
Pretty chill study music
Really liked this one; it has a very krautrock feel with its unpredictable fusions of experimental electronic with these groovier, jammier bits. It starts with the massive opener 'Djed', which feels like an experimental electronic odyssey, constantly stuttering and switching haphazardly between its many movements, with gear that sounds modern but also has the dirty, grainy vintage feel of stuff like '70s Cluster and Tangerine Dream. My favourite part was the second-to-last ambient bit with this simple but gorgeous chord progression. The rest of the record is comprised of a bunch of much smaller, but still very enjoyable forays into the worlds of krautrock, occasionally dabbling in the melancholia of post-rock. 'Glass Museum' especially feels like it could've inspired every GYBE song under the sun with those gorgeous arpeggios and that dreary, twangy lead. 'The Taut and Time' was also great, just super funky kraut feel to this one with these syncopated drums, a very scratchy guitar, and a run-down-sounding organ driving it. 'Along the Banks of Rivers' has this rundown noir feel to it, with these sharp guitars; it reminds me of the guitar tone used on 'Sour Times' by Portishead. Great album, been meaning to check out Tortoise for a while now, so glad it appeared here.
Millions now living will never understand
nothing memorable
It’s background music. It fulfils that role fairly well. Not sure it works well as “an album” in the sense of it being a single, discrete listening experience, though. In other words: It’s highly unlikely I’d ever choose to listen to it again.
It’s inoffensive but ultimately completely pointless and has no right being suggested as something I need to do before I die
Some of it was alright just not enough
5/10
Pretty interesting music, I like the instrumental post rock style.
Needs further listens.
i feel their heavy influence in many bands very dear to me. their meandering soundscapes are difficult to describe. heavy but soft. strong and timid. at times soothing like a summer rain (as Mogwai does), at times cold as frozen winter's night in a film noir (as Cult of Luna does).
Se non sai scrivere un brano di 20 minuti, non farlo.
Yeah, not for me
Great album cover, I really enjoy the wavelike texture in the background. Tortoise is in a nice blue compared to the color of the cover. Djed is really the only listenable song here, for an instrumental album its average. I would rather listen to some videogame soundtracks instead than listen to this again. Instrumental is pretty difficult to mess up, so by default its average. Best Song: Djed. Worst Song: Along the Banks of Rivers.
I like the names of the songs, Glass Museum and Along the Banks of Rivers. Musically, sounds like I’m in the lobby of a hotel, or waiting for the elevator door to open.
Millions Now Living Will Never Die by Tortoise is an alive album that effortlessly adapts to shifting currents and explores intricate yet minimalist soundscapes. Its ability to incorporate jazzy basslines, wandering synths, and authentic guitar riffs all within a single song is fascinating. It creates a lush and beautiful musical ecosystem, carrying the listener into the deep seas, across the lands, and above the clouds. We are taken on a journey through time to admire the enchanting glamour of nature and listen as the sound evolves. This experience is enthralling — a massively under-appreciated, ethereal masterpiece.
Nice
Pretty Good! Need to give it another listen.
This is another band and album I'd never heard of before today. When I saw the 2.8 rating on the site I was pretty discouraged, but I read some of the reviews (which I typically don't do till after I listen) and was a bit less apprehensive. Once Djed started I was totally into it, and then there were multiple instrumental and tempo changes which I was also totally into. Glass Museum started off as a great Cure song and became something completely different. I loved all of it, and smiled throughout. For the second day in a row I had an album that was such a pleasant surprise and the reason I keep going with this project.
Who doesn't love a 20 minute opener? Me, that's who. Glass Museum was quite nice tho. The Taut and Tame had some neat moments also. Overall a pretty decent album but probably not something I'd revisit often.
kinda vvibbeddd
Pleasant enough but no reason to ever play it again
Maybe a 3.5 but I thought this was surprisingly good (surprisingly because I feel like I'm hard to please)
So post-rock is instrumental? And kinda mellow? What does that mean for post-post-rock?
I didn’t expect to love this but I did. It sounded so current that I had to double check the release date.
Not really my usual listening, but I would have it on as background music
Haven’t had an instrumental album in a bit. It was alright, nothing special. 3/5 ⭐️ 258/1089
My brain has not been this quiet in a long time. Just full body relaxation with this album. Spectacular.
Wow. This was just about the chillest album I've listened to in a while. Very relaxing, and I have no criticisms to give by extension. Just truly wonderful.
Lowkey nice
A unique band with a style that is all their own. The word that comes to mind is "deconstructurist," as they strip songs down to components and arrange them in new and often unsettling ways. The openingvtrack, "Djed," is a perfect example of this. Not quite electronic, jazz, or rock, it's not easily defined. As an influential Chicago band, I can hear how Jeff Tweedy and Co. borrowed some of this approach for the Wilco album Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
I only listened to this once, and I feel like I might give it four stars with repeat listens. Really enjoyed hearing the deconstruction, the twists and turns of Djed were an adventure. Other parts felt a little lacking. Glass Museum is the standout here for me, not often I get to say that they have a hell of a vibraphonist
It was fine nothing super exciting.
Very good record. 3,5
I was surprised how much this jam album held my attention. Especially the 20 minute opener it flows by pretty seamlessly and has a curiosity that kept me entertained. Absolutely loved the cowboy western feel of “Along the Banks of Rivers” I was really trying hard to figure out what worked for me on this tape and what didn’t on the jazz album and really couldn’t find anything just vibes I guess. ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
I enjoyed the modern jazz instrumental nature of MILLIONS NOW LIVING WILL NEVER DIE. Too many times, something like this is ruined by a terrible voice. In my opinion the first rack was the worst of the whole album. Djed, is the Egyptian word for endurance and lasting. As a fan of prog rock and jazz, I am accustomed to long tracks, and I respect what they were trying to do here, and perhaps I could have enjoyed it, but "Djed" endures way too long for the minimal changes it makes. It takes until the 12 minute mark for a pivotal change, and by then it has lost most of its momentum, becoming less a dirge, and more a straight up annoyance. The repeats could have been halved and still allowed the track to be a good to great shoe gazer/dream pop/ambient/idm track at half or perhaps even 3/4 of the duration. The album really picks up in quality creatively and with respect to the listener after "Djed" with the exquisite yearning of the "Glass Museum". I can practically see The Glass Menagerie playing out in my head while listening to this track. It was cool hearing vibes rocked out. "A Survey" continues the quality instrumental excursion through a dark and ominous outdoor excursion. "The Taut and Tame" Sounds a bit more like your traditional jazz fusion rock. Not bad, but not groundbreaking either. The double sticking of the drummer with his use of rods rather than sticks is impressive exhibition of performance control and consistency. "Dear Grandma and Grandpa" doesn't really work, but mercifully is short in duration. Ultimately, I have come around to Tortoise's MILLIONS NOW LIVING WILL NEVER DIE being essential enough to be on the list. The production quality is quite high and it is creatively enough of its own thing to merit a spot. I'll take it over many of the terrible country rock and blues rock albums from the early 70s. It is also good enough that I can pinch my nose and djed the hipster cadre that have become attached to this - ahem- vinyl record.
Ambient, instrumental rock music. It was kind of easy to listen to but nothing really grabbed my attention and instead if completely faded into the background. Also I'm not a fan of the way they glued 3 songs together with very simple transitions to make a 20 min behemoth to open the album.
Holy mother of progrock, beginnen met een 20 minuten durend nummer? Ok, ben wel down hier voor! Ik ben er onderhand al achter dat ik Progrock een stuk meer kan waarderen dan ik van tevoren had gedacht, al vind ik het soms wel een beetje geneuzel. De baslijn van het eerste nummer is in elk geval erg lekker en goed op de voorgrond, daar word ik al best wel enthousiast van. Ook vet dat er geen vocals in zitten, althans op minuut 5 heb ik nog niets gehoord. Haha ok Djed is een crazy nummer, het begint lekker atmospherisch, prachtige fijne background muziek en dan na ongeveer 14 minuten begint het te glitchen alsof er iets fout gaat in de muziek. Heel vet gedaan en daarna word het ook iets duisterder lijkt wel? Ok nee, was best wel enthousiast in het begin, maar uiteindelijk is dit wel echt gewoon achtergrond muziek. Heb me prima vermaakt en zelfs nog wat andere nummers in hetzelfde genre doorgeluisterd dankzij Spotify, maar echt blijven hangen? Mwah, dat valt wel mee. Goede werkmuziek, dat wel! FAVO: Djed,
I feel like I need to research this to understand it. Simultaneously a lot going on and also everything blends together.
Huh?
The warm-up band for the soundtrack of the original TRON movie.
very slow but have some good moments
First song definitely has some NEU! (are they on this list? They should be.) vibes, which I appreciate. Doesn't continue like that, unfortunately. Still... A grand old album and way more interesting and diverse than the tenth Elvis Costello album.
Complete shit, will never listen to again, 0/5
A nice ez listening album
Смесь знакомых ритмов и мелодий без общей структуры. Хоть и любимый жанр но не больше 3
I was not a fan.
*Has cool moments with vibes and jazz sounds, but its a little too slow tempo/shoegaze adjacent for me to really enjoy
Some nice shoegazey stuff in here.
given my previous reviews of jazz albums, i suppose i shouldn't like this experimental post-rock type of stuff, but i do. maybe because it uses a different vocabulary musically speaking than jazz? not sure. i added the album to my library, 5/5 will enjoy in the future in a non-lyrical setting
Never heard of this before. Instrumental music. Starts with a 20 min song that is no where near interesting enough to be that long. But the rest of the songs are much the same.
I was waiting and waiting for the songs to kick in and not sound like one long bridge or interlude but that never happened. And what the hell is post-rock? Something made up to give this a space? It’s as if Ross from friends was given a more sophisticated keyboard.
Ik weet niet helemaal wat ik hier mee moet of wat post-rock uberhaupt moet inhouden (klinkt vooral als mensen die zichzelf belangrijker vinden dan ze zijn). Verder klinkt het opzich prima, denk wel vooral als achtergrondmuziek. Hele albums puur instrumentaal vindt ik wel pittig soms hoor, maar vooruit, 3 sterren.
20 minute first song
Omg I loved the tortoise album TNT but had forgotten about it!! This is the kinda thing you wanna listen to with headphones.
Just a bunch of sounds. Needs a front person
More instumentals....kinda slow.
Not horrible to listen to, but a pretty abstract wall of noise whereby nothing stood out to me. Fine as background while I was working, but I can't imagine actually listening to it. The 21-minute opener was as pointless as I expected - 6 minutes of a decent album opener followed by 15 minutes basically wasted.
There was some interesting stuff here. It made great background noise.
I really enjoyed this album, pretty much all the way through. I’d put it on the top of my list of post rock albums I’ve ever heard. It has a lot of moments that go beyond the bounds of the typical shoegaze (which is just a fancier way of saying that there’s some energetic sections in the music). And I appreciate that.
Utter crap
This is just 40 minutes of nothing to me and the first song has no business being 20 minutes long. 4/10
Iconic post rock album. Five stars.
Fell asleep a few times. Just not very interesting.
Very generic easy to go in one ear out the other. Sometimes feels like this list is pay to play. Or maybe I just didn’t pay enough attention. Or maybe I liked it but waited till Monday morning to review after listening on Friday. Either way on to the next.
They know how to build anticipation for something I don’t care about.
Okay, another great ambient album. Djed really took me on a journey, and frankly, this whole exercise is taking me on a journey through which I reimagine my understanding of music.
I thought from the title this might be about animal liberation or something?? but then actually I don't think there were any lyrics so probably not. That first song was long!! Perhaps the longest we've had (20 minutes). Anyway it wasn't thrilling to me and was surprised it was from 1996. certainly expected something different
Tortoise et Mogwai, deux groupes que j'écoutais souvent dans ma période post-rock dernière portion des années 90. Petite préférence pour Mogwai plus destroy.
Super envoûtant comme son, j'ai adoré. Quelque chose dans la facture sonore qui me fait penser à Goldfrapp, et qui est évidemment trippant comme du prog rock. Je sais pas c'est quoi du post-rock, mais ça ça me parle! Je me demande juste si une belle voix dreamy ça rajouterait pas un peu de cachet à tout ça. Mais je suis pas contre la musique instrumentale non plus.
On aime ça le post rock. J'en ai déjà écouté pas mal dans un plus jeune temps mais plus dans le genre "explosif", fort en crescendo et decrescendo comme Explosions in the Sky et Godspeed You! Black Emperor.
No. 427/1001 Djed 2/5 (5x) Glass Museum 3/5 A Survey 2/5 The Taut and Tame 2/5 Dear Grandma and Grandpa 2/5 Along the Banks of Rivers 2/5 Average: 2,1 Soundscapes that weren't abrasive. But it's just not something I would listen to for fun.
Weird ambience but I kinda liked it.
Post rock that just kinda floats, makes you feel like you're in the middle of the ocean. It's surprisingly groovy. It's slow and very pretty, absolutely hypnotic in its textures too. Glass Museum is such a good song. Starts off with some sharp guitar loops, then fades off into this ambient middle point that feels like slowly getting covered in water before exploding into an amazing crescendo in the back half. The opening, Djed, is a 20-minute monster of a song filled with super unique textures and a really mesmerizing progression. I also love the jazz-infused closer. The middle section of the album is slightly weaker but still filled with pretty post rock moments.
This album made me reconsider my understanding of what constitutes a song
Laaaaaangweilig!
Heard Before? Yes. Lots. Notes: - i love this album, but TNT would be a much better choice for this list. more accessible, stronger songs, more variety. - sequencing is just bad. it should open with "Glass Museum". "Djed" should be last and should also be split into several tracks. The sections are distinct so there's no reason to glom it all together as one song. - but my complaints end where the actual music begins. there are so many good ideas here, so many fascinating performances, so many glorious sounds. - the mix is nicely bass-heavy, yet everything still sounds crisp. - more vibraphone! Verdict: Iconic and cerebral, it's jam band music for studio rats. Listen Again? Not for a long time, but it did remind me that I haven't heard their latest (2025) album, so I'll try that now.
Pleasant and ambient but not something I'd go back to again I think. But I enjoyed it for its stay.
if radiohead had a little whimsy
Pleasant and occasionally interesting instrumental music though is not continuously compelling.
Hmmmm, tegu oli selliste taustahelidega. Nagu sellistega, mis on osa mingi seriaali või filmi taustamuusikast ja mängivad taustal kui mingi tegelane kaadrisse tuleb. See muusika pani mind ka mõtlema mustvalgetele fotodele ja sellele, kuidas nende fännid kiidavad mustvalge võimet detaile esile tuua ja mitte tähendust kitši alla matta. See on üks neist albumitest mille puhul tunnen, et mina pole õige seda hindama. Ma tunnen, nagu küsitaks minu arvamust haiku kvaliteedi kohta - mina ei tea. Eelmises reviews esitasin naljaga küsimuse "olen ma kultuurne?", see album ütleb et võibolla ikka mitte. Jah, tunnen ära Ghostface Killah (kuskil on kindlasti sellenimeline tups), aga ma ei suuda leida sellest väidetavalt kultuurselt määravast muusikast post-rocki algeid. hinnang: 2,5. Kuulasin prokrastineerides.
The instrumentals are interesting and there were parts that were actually pretty good to listen too. However, this isn’t really my cup of tea and so I rated it somewhat very in the middle.
I was waiting for something to happen but after 40 minutes im still waiting. If you want to listen to some quality post rock, go check out God is an Astronaut
4.5–never heard of them before this and loved it!
verrassing... soort mix van krautrock,can en zappa light... helaas op het einde iets te veel tangerine dream...
Ihan alkuun voin sanoo ettei oo mitään syytä, että ensimmäinen biisi kestää 20min ja siinä ei varsinaisesti ees tapahdu mitään. Meni työmatka saatana pilalle ton biisin takia... muut biisit oli ihan hyviä, mutta ei tää ny jotenki erikoisesti natsannu
was alright
It's an instrumental album, I would say it's probably not for most people. The first track is 20 minutes long and heavily features a sound that made me think of a squeaking wheel. The rest of the album is pretty chill, maybe focus music.
I really love this - I'm such a lyrics person that something so instrumental will never be a 5 from me, but I am a big fan.
Not my bag.
That’s definitely interesting
Really liked the atmospheric music on this album. A nice discovery. Post rock sounds to me something that would be loud and obnoxious, but fortunately it wasnt
Once again a techno album that was all over the place and just a lot of noise. Not worth a second listen.
Intriguing and relaxing but also recklessly verges into background music.
Tortoise- I had this album in college and hadn’t thought about it in many years. I Really like the their way of doing a Steve Reichesque minimalism thing done with rock band instrumental. Kind of a slow burn but just the right amount unpredictable to keep it interesting throughout. TNT is their better more accessible album I hope that it is on here too.
Started off kinda meh for me- didnt love the first 20 minute song but it got better and actually kinda dug it by the end. Wouldnt listen again and still probably doesnt deserve a spot on the list but i did enjoy it
This project is getting out of control because I liked this a lot, would listen again, and have no idea why.
Can someone tell them that a Post-Rock album doesn’t have to mean it’s incredibly boring. It doesn’t really respect your time, sometimes things actually happen but it’s too few and far between. Is it bad? Not really, there’s a basis of what could make a for some pleasant songs. It doesn’t really form into one though, go make actual short and concise and enjoyable songs rather than this drawn out and frustrating long winded album. There is a lot of more interesting Post Rock out there that does better at experimenting with the Rock format.
Math rock 🪨!
Mid-90s indie rock. Experimental post rock. Instrumental soundscape, guitars.
Not really my vibe. 2 stars for me
6/10 - But in a positive way. It’s different than what I normally listen to but it was unique and imaginative. A few really nice songs, but half of the album was my least favorite song. Respectful 3 stars.
There are some interesting moments on here and the first song reminds me of Music for 18 Musicians (compliment). The rest of the album can border on boring. 6/10
A perfect soundtrack to winter focus.
Me gustó, no se si repetiría, tiene un mood muy especial. Nota: 3.7
For decades there has been a persistent itch within the rock world to create (a) works with rock instrumentation that (b) present modern classical levels of complexity and interest but also (c) capture the spontaneity and sense of creative freedom associated with free jazz. As with most such Hobson's choices in life, you can usually pick any two: (a) and (b) gets you prog, (a) and (c) gets you the Greater Deadhead Jam Band Diaspora, (b) and (c) gets you jazz fusion, more or less. Post-rock, then, is basically an attempt to square that, uh, triangle via simulation; the compositions get a near-classical level of planning and musicianship but with a harder lean into something that, if it isn't improvisational, at least *feels* that way. There's a sense of found-ness to all of it, both in terms of instrumentation and the use of simplicity and negative space. You are listening to something that is very carefully and deliberately crafted to give the impression of having been made quickly and organically, without forethought. It's like if you could hear Pollock. That's a lot of theorizing to basically say that Tortoise does something here that felt new and different at the time and still feels fresh and interesting now. It's fascinating to listen to musicians just creating, seemingly without any care for the fact that they're being observed - and with, in actuality, a great deal of care about the fact that they're being observed. Percussion nerd that I am, I prefer the front half of the album on account of both the more intense polyrhythmic figures and the vibraphones. But I was never bored for more than a few moments. And Explosions in the Sky owe these guys a royalty, or at the very least a beer every time they see them, for setting that band's template on the back half of "Along the Banks of Rivers."
Heh... It wasn't that bad. Forgettable though.
I wonder how some of these albums get made.
I really enjoyed the chilled out atmosphere on this, especially Djed in how it weaved in and out.
охуеть наконец-то нормальный пост рок который я еще не слышал
Djed - transy, so minimal. It was hypnotic and dreamy, the repetitive lines didn't get as boring as I thought they would, lots of catchy ideas. The glitchy section caught me off guard. Feels like an eery waiting room underwater. The drums were standout on this track I think. Glass museum - instantly a breath of fresh air. Finally left the waiting room. The xylophone? Is a really nice touch. Jazzy breaks. Xylophone is generally amazing on this upbeat proggy track. Fast, slow, fast slow. A survey - love an isolated baseline, and chirping crickets? Why not. Da da da da da da da da da. Taut and tame: Groovy as hell, the xylophone keyboard effect is addictive and adds a colourful bounce to the guitar drum relationship. Dear grandma and grandpa: Chill nice, kinda forgettable. Along the banks of the river: Same old same old. Good.
The secret to making me care about instrumental post-rock has always been to make it Neu!
good album, had a cool electronic sound
2.5
A nice album to have on in the background, a pleasant mind-stimulating but not overwhelming thing.
I remember listening to Tortoise back in the early 2000s, long before I knew what post-rock was or had even heard the term. At the time, I just thought they were a cool experimental and avant-garde band messing around with jazz and glitchy electronic music. Fast forward to today, it’s been over 20 years since I last heard this album, and man, I forgot how awesome and impressive this album is, especially considering it came out in 1996. The electronic elements alone were incredibly forward thinking, because back in the mid and late 90s, no one in electronic music was intentionally glitching their sound, yet Tortoise was seamlessly blending it with instrument-driven music. Glitchy electronic music didn’t really take off until the mid-2000s, which makes this even more remarkable. If you’re a post-rock fan, you’ve probably already heard this album, but if not, it’s absolutely an essential.
lækkert nok
Ret fantastisk instrumentalmusik!
Chill
приятно под работу, но в целом ни о чем
Pretty cool. Lots of good moments, and a few tracks are genuinely beautiful. Hypnotic, transporting, and clearly very intelligent. Not all of it lands ("Djed" is kind of a slog by my money) but I was not mad at this. Fave tracks: - Glass Museum - The Taut and Tame - Along the Banks of Rivers Edit: after a relisten, I'm gonna be more generous. This really is pretty damn gorgeous. And while Djed isn't my favorite, it's surprisingly listenable for a 20 minute long track. This is super creative.
Where have you been all my life? Very glad I heard this.
1. 3.5 2. 4 3. 3 4. 3.5 5. 2.5 6. 3
Listening to this album made me discover a deep-appreciation for post rock and the allowance it can give the listener to imagine/paint whatever picture the music take them. I lean towards the camp of people who are actively conscious of the music over lyrics and the meaning/story they tell. Music first, lyrics second. Of course there isn't any lyrics present—or meaning to derive from the non-existent lyrics—in any of the tracks so it's all instrumentals and the feeling they evoke. Tortoise does this excellently. Djed was an Experience and The Taut and Tame is addicting. If there's anything worth praising Tortoise for, it's the curiosity and drive to explore more of the post-rock genre. I'm not completely new to post-rock (psychedelia is one of it's many origins) but listening to this piece makes me want to engage more with the genre. Godspeed You! Black Emperor is a band I've been exploring recently and now I'm as driven as ever to explore them and many other post-rock artists. Not every track was a hit for me but the majority we (more importantly the 20 minute track thankfully). I definitely see myself returning to this album in the future which is rare for most albums. T3: The Taut and Tame, Djed, Glass Museum
it was ok. sounded like a Bjork album without the singing.
This just seems like some bad experimental album from 1968 that everyone (for good reason) forgot about. But no!! It was from 1996!!! Come on people... Music has evolved WELL beyond this. No reason to listen to. No reason to have on this list.
Trash
Never heard of them and I lived deeply in music in 1996. The 21 minute intro song that never went anywhere explains why. What a boring slog this was. Unless you're taking a class on how to make a soundtrack for a boring movie this album has no value top to bottom. There are exactly ZERO reasons this album makes a Top 5005 List, it is pure shit. No hits, no songs or vocals, no great musicianship, no hooks, nothing memorable, just blahhhh. Possibly the least justified album I've heard on here. WTF, there are SO many good albums, why in the world does Tom Fucking Waits, The Beta Band, and Tortoise pop up in one week!?! Baffling and unforgivable!! Half of One Star. I have now banned Tortoise from playing in my Spotify account.
Surreal is a good term for this album. It was artsy, ambient, jazzy, weird, cool, soundtracky to a movie that doesn’t exist outside your head. A 20 minute opener was surprising but as it was broken into different “movements” ( listening, not tracked) it didn’t feel like it. Glass Museum was also a strong contribution. As a bass player, I also appreciated the unitary solo of A Survey (I think it was a Fender Jazz II with a little compression only…simple effects). I don’t know if I will ever come back to this but I definitely feel more experienced listening to it. Hats off Gentlemen!
Random thoughts: * I thought I heard of Tortoise before but maybe I just know the band name. I'm pretty sure I've never listened to this before. * I can see the influences on bands like Radiohead and Explosions in the Sky. * While being only instrumental it was still interesting to listen to. * This seems to be on 1001 more for the influence this band had than maybe the overall enjoyment of the music. * The first track was awesome at even 20 minutes. It kept moving and evolving. * I might pick this up again for background music but is not something I'm probably going to actively listen to.
Instrumental albums don't bother me the way they might some other people. One of my favorite artists is Joe Satriani, and there's little to no singing on most of his records. That said, I wasn't crazy about this. I get why Glass Museum is the most downloaded song on this record. It’s not half bad. Just kind of lays there though. Meanwhile, the rest of the record never really hits any major high points. If you have an instrumental album, there has to be a series of crescendos, and they just didn’t get there for me. Not sure why this is included. Relatively ineffectual. 2 stars
S’il y a bien un genre musical que j’affectionne énormément, c’est le post-rock. Pourquoi ? Parce que le post-rock, c’est un peu comme si le rock’n’roll, fatigué de tourner en rond dans ses propres clichés, se muait soudainement en free jazz. C’est cette trajectoire fascinante où la guitare électrique cesse de jouer les frimeuses sur un ampli poussé à 11 pour devenir un générateur de climat, un outil de sculpture sonore à part entière. Quand on s’aventure dans ce genre musical si particulier, on ne peut absolument pas faire l’impasse sur Tortoise. C'est le groupe fondateur du mouvement, le phare au milieu du brouillard. Et dans leur discographie, Millions Now Living Will Never Die, sorti en 1996 sur le label Thrill Jockey, s'impose d’emblée comme l’un des disque majeur, composé de morceaux longs, complexes et pourtant d’une douceur renversante. Dès la première écoute, on est surpris de découvrir à quel point cet album incarne tous les éléments caractéristiques de ce style novateur. Ici, l’accent est mis de manière obsessionnelle sur les textures, la dynamique et la richesse des timbres plutôt que sur les structures rock conventionnelles telles que les riffs lourds, les solos démonstratifs et les enchaînements d'accords prévisibles. Honnêtement, ras-le-bol des morceaux calibrés pour les radios FM avec leur structure couplet-refrain-couplet-solo-refrain. Tortoise prend cette formule historique, la piétine avec le sourire, puis balaie les morceaux par terre. Sur ce disque, la guitare n’est plus la reine incontestée du royaume ; elle partage équitablement son trône avec des marimbas, des vibraphones, des basses multiples, des synthétiseurs vintage et un jeu de batterie à deux têtes. C’est une musique cérébrale, certes, mais il y a dans Millions Now Living Will Never Die une sensualité organique extraordinaire, une manière de faire glisser les sonorités les unes sur les autres avec une fluidité déconcertante. Les morceaux s’installent dans la pièce, se déploient lentement et modifient l'air que vous respirez. Il faut appréhender ce disque comme un paysage sonore continu, une vaste toile en mouvement. Prenez par exemple le premier morceau de l'album, "Djed". Vingt minutes d'une suite instrumentale magistrale qui résume à elle seule toute l'ambition du projet. On y croise un groove dub nonchalant qui se dissout progressivement dans des vagues électroniques, avant de laisser place à des motifs répétitifs d'une délicatesse inouïe. Le morceau se désagrège, semble bégayer comme un disque rayé, puis renaît sous une forme minimaliste et lumineuse. C'est de la haute voltige de studio, où la console de mixage devient un instrument à part entière. Ce qui rend Tortoise si unique à cette époque, c’est cette capacité hybride à piocher partout sans jamais sonner comme un patchwork indigeste. On retrouve dans leur musique l'héritage du krautrock allemand (cette obsession pour la répétition hypnotique façon Can ou Neu!), la profondeur spectrale du dub jamaïcain, l'élégance formelle du jazz moderne et l'esprit d'aventure de la musique électroacoustique. Tout cela est digéré avec une aisance déconcertante. Les arrangements font preuve d'une retenue exemplaire et les espaces entre les notes comptent tout autant que les notes elles-mêmes. C'est cette gestion du silence et du souffle qui donne aux morceaux cette atmosphère si enveloppante. Les timbres s’entremêlent avec une grâce folle : les sonorités boisées et métalliques des percussions répondent aux grattements discrets des guitares, tandis que les lignes de basse rondes et profondes viennent ancrer le tout dans le sol. On passe d'un climat mélancolique à une séquence rythmique presque dansante sans jamais ressentir la moindre rupture brutale. Trente ans après sa sortie, Millions Now Living Will Never Die n'a pas pris une seule ride. Contrairement à de nombreuses productions des années 90 plombées par des choix de production datés ou des postures de mauvaises foi, cet album conserve une fraîcheur absolue. Il échappe aux outrages du temps simplement parce qu'il n'a jamais essayé de coller à une mode passagère. C'est un disque qui s'écoute les yeux fermés, de préférence au casque, pour saisir toutes les micro-variations qui se cachent dans le mix. C'est une œuvre qui demande un minimum d'abandon, mais qui récompense au-centuple celui ou celle qui accepte de sortir des sentiers battus de la variété rock. Tortoise a prouvé avec cet album qu'il était possible de faire de la musique instrumentale ambitieuse sans tomber dans le piège du rock progressif démonstratif ou du jazz-fusion soporifique. Ils ont ouvert une brèche gigantesque dans laquelle se sont engouffrés des dizaines de groupes par la suite, mais rares sont ceux qui ont réussi à égaler la poésie naturelle de ce disque. En résumé, si vous voulez vivre une expérience d'écoute immersive, intelligente et profondément apaisante, jetez-vous sur cet album sans hésiter une seule seconde. Un grand 5 sur 5 évidemment, car c'est un disque parfait de bout en bout.
Never heard of this band but interested to see what they sound like. More mellow rock. Good stuff though.
Quite good
This album and Mogwai Young Team opened the door to post-rock for me. Hope it does for listeners encountering it in this project.
Holy hell the first song is STILL GOING
Overall, pleasant to listen to. DJED was an interesting track. Parts of it were really cool. Why do artists insist on 20 minute tracks?! Thought my headphones were failing at one point.
Gimme a break 🤦🏻♂️
Oh boy. Boring. Today of all days I got stuck in a traffic jam with no way to turn this off. I guess it made me feel like a tortoise so at least it was thematic.
Starting off way more interesting than I was expecting. Themes develop and then drift off as a new one comes in. Good background music for doing house chores. If I still sat around doing bongs and thinking I was deep this would be on repeat.
WOW, this is a great one!
Not for me this one.
music is love
Genuinely don't know how I feel about this one. Parts were super cool, but a 20 minute song is always a slog no matter what it sounds like. It'll probably end up being a 3 but I definitely considered both 4 and 2 at various points in this journey.
Ayooo that part at 13:55 part of Djed was very unexpected Makes sense that one of the guys from Slint was in this band after Slint
Had this in a backlog and was putting it off because of the not great average rating but I actually really enjoyed it. Great atmosphere and textures without getting so minimal that nothing is happening and it's boring. If I had to complain I would say the first half is stronger Highlights: A Survey, Djed, Glass Museum
Way better than I had expected. Also, the first two minutes of Djed acted as a white noise generator and soothed my crying baby so two thumbs up from me
absolutely
This was all over the place and had some moments I liked quite a bit. Probably suffers a bit from being very adjacent to a lot of my favourite music, without being some of my favourite music.
boring
3/5
3.5/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/tortoise/millions-now-living-will-never-die/ This will get the benefit of the doubt with a rounding up, because I did find it an interesting, if somewhat uneven album. I tend to like post-rock, but this is a bit more experimental than the post-rock albums I usually listen to. It doesn't have the big outbreaks like a Mogwai or Explosions in the Sky, or the beautiful vocals of Sigur Ros, or the more cinematic feel of Swans or GY!BE, so there is slightly less that makes it stand out for me. Still, I like it, and I'll try to give it another go in the future.
Slow core, interesting but with challenges. Maybe give a second listen.
Um bom disco. Apesar de se perder (e se alongar) em leves a experimentações eletrônicas, as partes rítmicas e melódicas são bem bonitas.
nah glass is ok, 2 star
Ehh
Different than I expected. Not bad, but listen through was plenty and I didn’t walk away with much else.
I’d heard of Tortoise but thought they were a sludge metal band. This had some really great moments in it. It’s interesting to hear the early roots of post-rock and how this album has been a clear influence on a bunch of modern bands. There were a few too many moments on this album that felt more like sketches than fully thought out instrumental sections, but overall I thought the sounds they made here were really great, the bass especially.
Pretty cool ambient album. Will be spinning this again.
the 20 minute song is certainly a journey, at one point halfway through it gets ripped apart backwards and forwards and i can't help but think it could've been split into a different track at that point. Then around 18 mins in, it does the same thing, with a new drum beat and synth pattern emerging, but then it hits you with the beginning swirls, so i realize that my opinion is trash lol i think the 2nd track is more post rock than the first, but the first is certainly a journey. the 3rd track is okay, pulsating and simple the 4th track feels more mathy, i like the synths all across this thing all in all, i see the value of an album like this, i think everyone should try a post-rock album at least once, there's a lot of incredible textures on here and i could certainly see how something like this is influential. At the same time, I know a lot of people are gonna be put off, and I'm not sure i think it's a requirement to listen to THIS particular piece of music before you do. I think it should be the case, but i also think that there are other post rock examples that while not as influential are probably better representatives on a list of music you HAAAAAVE to hear before you die. I think a 3/5 is fair. I wish the rating system was out of 10 because I'd aim for a 7 out of ten, closer to a 7 than an 8.
Very unusual but I didn't hate it! In fact I sort of liked it.
I enjoyed this a lot.
I wanna rate this so hard.
jcapte les inspirations que ça a donné mais c'est pas ma came
Encore un album avec un premier son qui dure 20 minutes !? C'était super
Instrumental 👎🏻
Kinda cool. 2.5
I've spend about twenty-five years trying to get Tortoise. It feels like I've spent even longer trying to articulate why I don't care for it. There is plenty of post-rock I like, but not this aggravating mix of repetitive groove, minimalistism pastiche, and imitation Neu. Indeed, it doesn't feel post- anything - the Reich sounds like Reich, the motorik motors along like it's 1974. It goes beyond none of this. The twenty minute opening track is the greatest stumbling block, as its kaleidoscope of styles demonstrates the group's lack of originality in each mode and their inability to meld them together in anything like a coherent composition - essentially McCartney's Standing Stone all over again. After that, the tracks become easier to follow and settle into a gentle groove, but who wants to settle. 2 This was a puzzler. While I really admired their facility for maintaining textural interest I was left thinking that Tortoise’s music really isn’t as good as it sounds. Perhaps I miss the point of ‘Post-Rock’ to say that they could use a singer but honestly much of this material felt like backing for a top line that wasn’t there, rather than the musical event. I’m not saying a top line is an absolute necessity - Debussy was often getting on nicely without one, for example - but there is something about Tortoise’s evocation of the ordinary gestures of rock music that seems to call for more than just textural shift as a structural device. If you mean to reject melody then why create such a comfy nest for it? Someone ought to sing something over this. The album is like a display of impressive sets for a play that never begins. It felt a bit sad to be honest. 2/5
When you look up pictures of the band you're like, yea, that's what that sound looks like. Some really interesting texture here. I couldn't stop checking the time.
Hated the first song. 20 minutes of garbage noise. The rest was better, threatening interesting at times.
I saw many people like this. I didn’t. Completely instrumental and in the most boring way. There were moments it virtually fell into silence and I wondered if my headphones had died. It makes for decent background music - but this is not a compliment. I might be missing something, idk.
I love this album. 20 minute song? It’s great sorry
It was OK
20 minute long song. Quite fun tho
No idea what they were on about. Waited for a singer until I realized this wasn't that type of album. Could have been worse, honestly.
Bit of an odd entry for this list. Can't say I'll be listening again.
It wasn’t bad, but I won’t revisit.
This intrigued me and was certainly pleasant enough to listen to as something in the background. I'm not feeling confident enough to give this 4 stars just yet, but I'll come back to it, give it more of a focused listen, and I see how I feel about it then.
Fine, but boring.
When I first started the album I prepped myself for some insane, unlistenable nonsense noises; but I gave it a go and listened to the second half first; it works, it's not terribly memorable but it flows and has more than a pinch of experimentation without breaking the album
Desk music, krautock
Track #1 "Djed" felt like several ideas bolted together, it didn't need to be 20 minutes. The remainder if the album see-sawed between music and wankery. I did not need to hear this. For 1996 it is not impressive or evolutionary.
Really interesting ambient sounds, makes for a great atmospheric background while working/etc.
very cinematic and catchy.
If progressive rock in a linear journey than this is an open world adventure. The instrumentals slide, bounce, and skate in so many different directions that are consistently interesting. I like the vibes. Favorites were Djed, Glass Museum, and Along The Banks Of Rivers.
Not my cup of tea, but they are legendary
Very cool album. I like that it's entirely instrumental. Lots of sweet sounds in the mix that come together in an eclectic way. It's interesting that the album name comes from a Jehovah's Witness slogan that references the coming of Armageddon and the eternal life that would be granted to the people of that faith when the world ended (that's my understanding of it after a few mins of research, at least). Honestly it's kind of a cool phrase. I like the album art too.
This was such a vibe album, no lyrics but it doesn't need it. The beginning starts with a very whimsical feel with the added percussion from the xylophone (I might be wrong in what instrument they're using) but wow I was just enjoying my morning ride back to the house and this was just beautiful. can't love it enough going to listen to this again!
This one is hard for me to rate. I both loved it and felt like I needed more at the same time. But, it could have been the setting I was listening to it in (driving). Definitely going to give it a relisten 8.5/10
Put your hand up if you also thought the first song at one point was your phone glitching out and losing connection... I have a list of a few adjectives that came to mind after listening to this 3 times today: - Mysterious - Subtle - Sophisticated - Simplistic - Intimate - Underground - Symphonic (pulled out the thesaurus for this one) This felt like uncovering some hidden gem at the beach, very unassuming, at first glance (Album art is dope and definitely adds to its unassumingness, and mysteriousness). You can definitely miss out on subtleties with just a single listen through, I definitely did. Its a hard one to describe, like if i were recommending this to someone, I guess I'd just say alternative, cause I feel like they kinda just did their thing without really trying to fit in to any sort of box. The closest thing I could relate this to would be Boards of Canada. However these guys use a lot more live instrumentation like bass and guitar at points, where as Boards sticks mainly with samples, synths and electronic drums. Will be checking more out by Tortoise, (very fitting name). 9/10
Kakva narkomanija. Kraut Dio u prvoj pjesmi mi je ok zadnja trećina od The Taut and Tame, ostalo me sekira. Too old for this shit. 2/5, 4/10
It didn’t accost me aurally, but it didn’t move me either. A bit like interesting elevator music.
Sleepy
Interesting enough to have a few fly bys but not interesting enough to desire
Holy shit this is amazing
1 1/2 - there is one decent song on this dog turd
Experimental and long. Can feel quite slow at times but kept my interest like good minimalism. Nice varied use of acoustic and electronic instruments. Djed could have been split into several tracks especially since they had distinct parts and endings. Enjoyed The Taut and Tame which stuck out with great musicality. 3/5
More like No Mans Sky than the previous Sigur Ros album
🐢🐢🐢
Interesting and creative but the energy was not for me.
eeeeeaaa mo chevee mui bienb l escucharia en el auto
A nice background/electronic album. I liked this and will probably listen to it again. Another group that has their Spotify bio list them as "one of the most influential groups of the past 40 years". There seem to be a lot of most influential groups out there. In any case I liked this. Probably just a 3 star rating
I like post rock. This was just boring.
I first listened to this looking on a dreary day in my home office, with me occasionally looking out of my window, fogged up with condensation and all I could make out was the motion of trees blowing in the breeze and the occasional drop of rain dancing along my window, and in that moment this hit perfectly. It is very freeform and ambient, especially compared to a lot of other post rock that aims for cinematic swell. I really like this and will have to listen to the rest of their work when I am working and the weather is miserable
1*
Music to listen to when you want to contemplate your life and let it get weird
I respect what you did there, but I do not wish to participate again.
This was great. it was layered and ambitious and interesting. i liked the vibe and will listen again.
Interesting album, neat sound
Their initial album was always on constant repeat for me in the mid-90’s and had TNT. This one might be my least favorite of those albums, improves in the 2nd half. They have better albums than this one. Saw them live at Fillmore West in 2000. Great show. The opening act was two people on laptops, which was kind of funny at the time. Interesting how some things haven’t changed in that front in 26 years.
More ambient than anything else. These folks listened to late stage Talk Talk I think
Achei fraco. O som não é ruim, mas não foi tão divertido ou marcante para estar nessa lista. Com certeza outros álbuns poderiam estar aqui.
i don't hate this album as much as the other people on this site do, lol. i get the simplicity and odd combination of elements can be a turn off but it got some good riffs going Would I listen again: eh Deserves to be on this list: no 3.1
A pleasant surprise from another new to me band and album. No vocals plus a 21 minute opening track is my jam. Along the Banks of Rivers is a great closer and sounds highly influential to Khruangbin. Awesome record. I need to check out TNT also. Viva La Tortuga.
Mielenkiintoinen levy. 3,5/5.
cool chill album
intro was really interesting and felt like 6 different songs, i loved the texture of this especially, might use this album as background noise for chilling...
This band's sound is a synthesis of so many different things, like 70s jazz fusion and minimalism and like Internet 1.0 dial-up sounds (??) and Louisville post-hardcore and Chicago pastiche-y technical whisper-y post-rock(??) but it all becomes this one thing that is so recognizably theirs. I love this album but their real masterpiece is TNT, which I absolutely adore.
Barely on the right side of 3
Strange, kind a Angine de Poitrine of the 90’s.
Just a load of uninteresting noise in the studio. Not for me.
6/10
Unexpected entry in the list. 'Djed' is undoubtedly the highlight here. It is in a weird position because as an album, TNT seems like the obvious choice. However, I really respect the selection. 8/10 [KEEP]
Ah, man, this is absolutely my jam. I would've eaten this kind of post-rock album up as a teen. I've known of Tortoise for years and years and just never gotten around to playing them. Like I say, though, absolutely my jam. This album is brilliant.
Really futuristic and funky album, surprised I liked it as much as I did considering it was instrumental
Very interesting album, never listened to tortoise before. Could get quite lost within the soundscape. At times it did drag on and feel a bit long in the tooth but generally enjoyed it. 3.0/5.0 Best Song: Glass Museum
So fucking good, i love this album so much. Reminds me off a very specific time of my life. It was my introducion to this kind of post rock music that I love so much now. Djed is a superb track.
I like this. It's unlike anything else on this list. It's noisy without losing musicality.
Cómo vas a tener un tema de 20 minutos como primer tema del disco
If this was a film score I'd probably dig it more but as an album it has its moments but nothing that hooked me to come back for more
Podsjeća na new age stvari koje nije da nešto volim ali su mi uvijek ok.
Una mierda, súper psicodelico raro de música de fondo cutrona. No me ha gustado nada
A lot I feel could have been interesting that is just drawn out and left as uninteresting and boring as humanely possible.
First track is really long and boring, so I didn't have high hopes - one track later on that I *quite* enjoyed, but on the whole just far too chilled out for me.
сначала мне показалось, что чисто музыка для выставки потом было ощущение, что это просто какие-то фоновые треки для игры 2 порадовал из-за него и рыб на обложке ставлю 3 звезды
To quote eminent music critic Alan Partridge, ‘that was just noise’. This really did absolutely nothing for me- 20 minute opener ‘Djed’ set the tone for an album that meandered to absolutely nowhere, with no interesting stops on the way. You could probably make something similar with the presets on a keyboard.
A fairly good example of the Post-Rock genre. The 21-minute opener 'Djed' could be seen as the centrepiece of the album, but for me the real highlights were 'Glass Museum' which has a sense of scale and grandeur befitting of the title, and the slightly more frenetic 'The Taut and the Tame' which reminds me of contemporaries Stereolab. Overall I enjoyed it enough for a 4.
I’m really struggling to come up with 100 words for this one, it made so little impression on me, but I’ll give it a go. I’m reserving 1-star ratings on this website for albums that I actively dislike and find a chore to get through, rather than those (like this) that are merely underwhelming, boring, etc., hence the 2-star rating. But make no mistake, I was not a fan of this album. It just felt utterly vapid, lifeless and empty, occasionally annoying and even more rarely vaguely enjoyable. Overall, I suppose it’s serviceable as background music, but that’s about all.
The first time I listened to the album, I think I was working on something, because my take away is that it was subtle and boring. But on replay, it’s clear to me now that this album has a lot going on. Both good and bad. I’ll start with the negative, which is this album is subtle and slow at moments. Like “dear grandma and grandpa”. It wasn’t bad, I just didn’t get anything out of it and I found it to be slow. The positives are that more than half the album is really good. I loved the songs “glass museum”, “the taut and tame”, and “along the banks of rivers”. Those three tracks are my favorite. The only songs I didn’t mention are “a survey” and “djed”. The survey song I didn’t really care for, but Djed is crazy. It’s really the centerpiece of this album despite being at the front. It’s this wild LONG progressive song that incorporates like 100 different ideas and has moments that are mildly psychedelic and progressive. Honestly this song was alienating at first but it just kept getting better and better. I could also see why I checked out the first time I listened to this album, that opening track requires your full attention not just to appreciate everything it has going on but also just to be invested in the song you kinda have to put extra effort into it (or at least you do if you have severe ADHD like I do). Seriously a solid album even if it’s not gunna be one of my favorites.
𝘔𝘪𝘭𝘭𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴 𝘕𝘰𝘸 𝘓𝘪𝘷𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘞𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘕𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘋𝘪𝘦 is one of those albums that makes me wish there were more post-rock records in 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. Bands like Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Mogwai, MONO, or Explosions in the Sky all have albums that would be worth hearing before you die, and Tortoise show another side of what post-rock can be. What I like most about this album is how patient it is. Rather than building toward huge climaxes, Tortoise focus on atmosphere, texture, and subtle changes. At times it feels closer to ambient music than rock, which gives the album a calm, almost hypnotic quality. It’s not the most dramatic post-rock album I’ve heard, but it’s one of the most immersive. The longer it goes on, the more its mood starts to work on me, and by the end I’m completely absorbed in its world.
First listen, just alright.
Something weird happened while this album was downloaded to my iPhone as I normally listen to these albums while taking a walk or driving to and from work. Well, my phone updated to the latest iOS update overnight and all of the music I had downloaded disappeared, I had listened to the first track already and the fact that I couldn’t be bothered to download it again tells you everything you need to know about this album.
The opening track is a masterpiece, just ok after that but probably a 3.5
A snooze fest. 1 star or F.
Enjoyed this. Experimental, instrumental music.
The album was... fine? I mean for 1996 it was probably pretty interesting, but I'm not sure it holds up to anything now. I definitely didn't dislike it, but wasn't "wowed" either.
2 - not for me
It’s alright.
Listening to this, I thought: Steve Reich, Philip Glass, Dirty Three... Normally I'd dig it, but I found it kind of dull. I've heard some of their later stuff and that was more exciting to me. No shade, but I didn't groove with it.
Really enjoyed this. A nice listen late at night
This is wayy underrated over here, it has no business being below a 3.0, so i'm for sure going to rate it a 4. I can hear a lot of what would become math rock in this one. For being essentially a pioneer of post-rock, this is a must listen, and it is a blast. I had the melodies stuck in my head for quite a while. I enjoyed my time with it. Not too long at all in my opinion
Very atmospheric but not a lot happens
instrumental, algunas muy lentas
lot of ambience and tinnitus sounds, low amount of actual vocals
Oh yes, I am the audience for post rock. And no Godspeed on this list, so one must make do. Man, I really like this. Don’t think I heard it before. Still lament the absence of GY!BE. I mean they’re on the supplemental list. Probably one of the earliest additions. I find other post rock lovers are as obsessive music fans as I am, and often much more “discerning.” I mean I am here for ALOT. But yes, this too. Odd synths included. It’s a solid 4. I am sure I will listen again. Boolean: yes, very glad to have heard before I die. But would like to ALSO hear MORE post rock
Here for this background jams. What's another word for atmospheric? Overused word. Anyway, pleasant surprise. 4/5
Interesting. I might like this. Will dig into it some more.
Maso
I have a lot of respect for instrumental albums and long songs. This, however, was rather boring. Not bad, just boring. 2/5.
Completely forgettable, but pleasant background noise occasionally punctuated with strange sound effects
I cannot abide albums that start off with 5 min of ambient sound effects. *How* is that enticing the listener to continue? Who is sitting there going, “wow, I love how the music goes click click clack while a broken air conditioner runs in the background.” ???
3.7 Rather enjoyed that. Never heard this (or of this) before, but it seemed to fuse and blend lots of genres and artists I admire. Good atmosphere. Not really one to extract individual songs, works best as a set.
Good background music, the more experimental tracks I didn't love but it's a good album. Favorite songs: Dear Grandma and Grandpa, Glass Museum
Post rock? That I’ve not heard before? Excellent. And it was.
Pretty great post-rock. This won’t appeal to everyone and that’s fine. It works for me. Djed is one of those modern day standards that still sounds exciting and immersive. Not a bad track here. Hope TNT is also included.
I wouldn't mind if this was background noise
Instrumental album. Did it better than Herbie Hancock. But even so not my taste
Really glad I put this on as an earphones-listen as I think this would have passed me by if it was just on while doing other stuff. Hard to say whether I will come back to this one, but as an instrumental atmospheric album I found this quite impressive.
Maybe it’s the fact that I have an attention span of a gold fish but god damn this first song kept me like a prisoner. I‘m not saying that I don’t like the sound but then again I just kept wanting to stop and move on. The moments of excitement did not carry me through sadly. Maybe I’m just not a music expert but then again that does not matter at all because I just don’t like it that much
Rate: 5/10.
Sims 2 building music. Pitää kuunnella kokonaisena albumina.
Not typically what I would put on, but pretty interesting mood music.
Pretty great, the kinda stuff I like hearing on this project
Ok but pretentious
Fue interesante hipnótico, muy enigmático y entretenido. Creo que es algo que escucharía como fondo o para leer algún libro bastante entretenido.
Didn't think I'd ever heard of Tortoise or heard the music, but tracks two and three were definitely familiar. An interesting trip in post rock and I'm sure I hear echoes of it in things that came later.
This is the kind of discovery I came here for.
Rating: 4.7/5 Short Review: Patient, hypnotic, and quietly futuristic. It builds atmosphere through repetition and texture instead of big emotional gestures. Feels like thought itself slowly unfolding. Favorite Track: “Djed.” A massive slow-burn that somehow keeps reshaping itself without breaking the mood. You drift inside it instead of just listening to it.
It may be important, but it’s ultimately empty. Like haute cuisine that refuses to actually feed you, this “post rock” noodling isn’t unpleasant but it is unfulfilling.
This felt right in a serene Sunday morning.
The first song, Djed, had some weird moments. Otherwise, I was very into this album!
I liked it! Decent variety I guess. Mostly instrumental
This was pretty cool instrumental rock. There were some parts of Djed that were a little abrasive that I didn't love but otherwise this was pretty tight and enjoyable.
This isn't bad for an instrumental album. Some of it sounds like it was meant to be background music for scenes without dialogue in movies. Like the last track sounds like James Bond in the 60s.
So this is what will be played in elevators in 10 years.
chill instrumental.
I do appreciate the experimentation and the way the mix of sounds are built and structured, but I don’t see myself listening to this again.
That first song didn't need to be 20 minutes long when there were distinct breaks in the music and instrumentation throughout. That being said, I really enjoyed the rest of it. Super smooth and a good jam. Favorite Track: Glass Museum, really really liked this one
This is probably good background music but unfortunately it's vocal-less and therefore not the vibe.
pretty interesting
ok i loved this...i felt like i was in a parody cop show, solving silly crimes...
Was really not enjoyable at all. So forgettable I wasn't even always sure the album was playing.
I never thought I'd actually enjoy a post-rock kind of album, but this one was a pleasant surprise. The soundscape it provided felt like running from one fever dream to the next. Maybe if it had hit me on another day I'd be more sour, but I enjoyed the experience. Not something I'd queue up to listen to on a whim, but cool for what it does.
This album really messes with your head, it's this big, instrumental trip that gives me the feeling of ambling through a boring, almost deserted town and then suddenly being on another planet. I got totally lost in "Djed", with its mix of driving beats, weird electronic sounds, and jazzy vibes. It's got this balance of being somewhat easy to listen to but also weirdly interesting and atmospheric. It's got this moody, unpredictable vibe, kinda like Krautrock but with a Western movie soundtrack feel. But then, when I was just really getting into it, the album just ends with this weird sudden stop.
Never thought id appreciate this lofi rock. It has its place during my day. Spaghetti Western guitars over lofi backgrounds are perfect ambient for work.
i like minimalistic stuff but this is unbearable. I like dungeon synth and some of this stuff reminds me of it but this is awful-
Liked it way more than I thought I would. Really interesting combination of math rock and ambient sounds.