Reviews (page 4 of 9)
1.5
3.5
Honestly when it gets jammy, I do kind of like this album, but the more experimental "fun with white noise" bits kind of lose me for the most part. (6.8) ★★★
Not my favourite post-rock, but still very enjoyable. 4 stars
I think parts of this are kind of pretty, but there's definitely some aspects of it that kind of seem a bit aimless. Instrumental stuff is always a bit of a challenge for me. Going 2.5 stars.
3.5
If millions were to have listened to this they should have plausibly all died from boredom. It doesn’t so much sound like one tortoise but more like a trio of them crawling around as slowly as they can on their instruments or on the mixing desk or tape machine and screwing up the playback. Side-long opener Djed is a monumentally dull, messy, aimless, ear-achey waste of time and the other tracks on Side 2 is yet more tedious post-rocky jumble.
This sucks. I get jazz and post rock but this is boring as hell.
Hay que saber meterse en el post rock. Y te tiene que agarrar en el mood indicado. 6/10
Pretty good instrumental music, sounded kind of like a low-key version of Weather Report to me. Little too laid back for my tastes.
Tense dissonance, a thrumming ambience suggesting something's off, expressive and restrained guitars that are at once vaguely punk and darkly jazzy, meditative and absorbing but disquieting.
I have a couple of Tortoise albums in my library, so I kind of knew what to expect here. This is the critically acclaimed second album that for some reason I'd not played before. The long opening track reminds me strongly of the German rock of the mid 1970s - I suppose it has that 'motorik' feel typical of Harmonia, Neu! and maybe Can and the like. Then it sort of expands out.
Mostly just random noises with an occasional interesting melody. 2/5
Len Houmous once owned a tortoise. He sold it to Blue Peter in 1981 to raise money for his kids to go to uni. 2.1 4/6 The Taut and Tame
I remember seeing this cover when digging through albums at the store back in the day. I've never heard it. So far, it is an extremely chill album. Man, that first song messed me up about 14 minutes in. Oh, I'm digging the flow of the 2nd track! Actually, all the remaining tracks, as well. How did I miss this album in the 90's?? I'll now listen to the rest of their catalog. This album bounces around from ambient to math rock to trip hop and is delightful. Worthy of a 4, for sure.
Fav: Along The Banks Of Rivers Least Fav: A Survey Interesting mix of atmospheric, relaxing stuff followed by some lovely jazz. Wish the jazz stuff was the whole album but as my first post-rock album, it’s left me interested in seeing what else it has to offer
Not my cup of tea. Where the hell are these recommendations coming from?
Really enjoyed my first listen of this album
A lot more chill than the title suggests. I'm actually going to add this to my personal collection for some great ambient tunes at work.
I died a little inside when I saw this started with a 20 minute instrumental but Djed builds on itself in interesting ways. I didn't love the glitch section around 14 minutes in but the drums that followed after make up for it. Mostly. What it reminds me of, surprisingly, is Akira Yamaoka. Glass Museum and A Survey and Along the Banks of Rivers have that melancholy guitar you'd hear on something like End of Small Sanctuary or Promise. Back half of the album is stronger / more of what I like but this is a great album to listen to in its entirety added to collection
How did I not know about these guys ? This is exactly my kind of music ! It’s a beautiful, meditative album full of haunting loops and melodies, and it absolutely does not deserve such a low global rating. The album constantly experiments with a wide range of sounds and styles without ever losing its cohesiveness or intensity. There’s clearly a lot of different influences here, from krautrock to jazz, minimalism and early 90s electronica / IDM ; but they all blend together quite well, and the album never feels bloated or overstuffed. Tortoise managed to keep things simple and straighforward, even in their more experimental pieces. That being said – and that’s my only gripe with this album – I feel a bit uncomfortable about a few songs, and mainly the opening track : as great as it is, Djed takes the "influence" aspect dangerously close to plagiarism territory. The first half of the song is a very obvious NEU imitation, right down to the tonality and rythm of their first album, while the second half is closely modelled on Philip Glass' Qatsi period. It sometimes feels like the band is just trying to showcase their imitation skills, and it makes for an album that sounds a bit rehashed or derivative. Fortunately that's not the case for every song ; tracks like Glass Museum or Along the Banks of Rivers feel more organic and natural. A hard choice between a 4 and a 5*. Ultimately I’ll go with a 4* because they copied a bit too much, and invented too little in my humble opinion... but I’m definitely getting the rest of their discography ! 8/10
A very original album, but no less interesting; I was surprised but enjoyed listening to it.
I struggled a bit at first because those long, very long atmospheric stretches feel a bit like prog self-indulgence, or a rehearsal jam that doesn’t end. But then tracks like Glass Museum and The Taut and Tame finally bring some breathing room with clear tones, real grooves, and musical technique that actually shines. That part is genuinely great. So I’m pretty torn. But it’s the kind of record I can come back to and I will, along with their other albums.
No dignity No GPT Happily surprised by this album. Apparently it’s categorized as post rock. So maybe that explains hahaha. However I’m a fan of long tunes, over 15 min. Back then electronic music was emerging as something that would be long lasting. So, in that album I enjoyed the long construction. I also enjoyed how they work on sound itself, and make imperfections part of the whole production (cf. Matthew Herbert in electronic music, about « mistakes » and it eponymous album). Personally I would have enjoyed some more groovy harmonics , or at least more deepening in that matter. There was space for it, even while keeping the « rough » feeling and giving all its space to the drums and the bass. All in all, it made me want to dig more that band, and discover their 2025 just released album. 14/20
Langsam und ruhig - perfekte Hintergrundmusik (auch wenn das die Musiker selbst wohl ungern hören)
Enjoyable
Didn't even notice this was playing
Yeah, not for me. Too crazy for background music, too boring for anything else.
Parts of the first song were headache inducing. Like audio incense. Still stuck it out though.
nearly a 4, a bit too woo woo for me
There are no words? This is elevator music.
Well, someone had fun plinking away on the keyboard and playing with the settings. Doesn't add up to something particularly listenable in the end, unfortunately. Last track is an exception.
Kind of enjoyable, soothing.
I just don't know what this is trying to achieve.
instrumental
Really like this. Super interesting
ugh I just don't enjoy music that doesn't have words
Yet another random noise album. Felt all over the place. Reminded me of Death Cab instrumentals. Unclear why it's here, had some nice moments though, 3*
Whelming
Cool album Definitely would put this on again
I love instrumental albums. I love ambient music. I do like mine with a bit of more drums or faster tempo. Is this why this didn't click? I really, really wanted to like it. Opening 20 minute track is good only in parts, the rest are fine, and the last one is the best on the album so at least it washed away the major disappointment I felt while listening.
This is quite interesting, I don't know why I was expecting yet another indie album. However as interesting as this is, I am not so huge on post-rock despite obvious influence of this band. A lot of ideas here but feels kind of loose. Probably right in the middle for this one.
This was alright. For a normal album of music I would give it about 3.5 stars, but for a 1001 best albums of all time, I'd say maybe 2. It was kinda neat, and I listened twice to make sure I didn't miss anything mind-blowing and it was short enough, but I didn't really enjoy it much. 2 stars.
Big fan of post-rock but not the Tortoise brand of post-rock. Early post-rock like Tortoise or Bark Psychosis tends to be a little too monotonous for my taste, and I heavily prefer the crescendo-driven approach popularized by bands like GY!BE. I remember listening to TNT and not enjoying it very much. However, this album I liked a lot more. It is also very relaxed, but I found the texture and atmosphere more enjoyable. The guitar work is great, and all the extra electronic elements work well. Still not really my type of music, but this albums was good. 7/10
Djed // Glass Museum // 3.5/5
Good background music. Not something that I could just sit and listen to the whole album Of just because
All time low key genius shit
This is your thanksgiving album? Really? If it gets better great, but the first two songs were elevator music
I like the sounds, especially the spaghetti western guitar. Really cool rhythmically, gets you into a vibe. But combine minimalism with a 20-minute piece and it kinda sounds like a Shine on You Crazy Diamond demo tape, a little half baked. I just wish it had more melody. But that’s a genre thing, these guys sound good.
Felt like I was stuck in a lift for way longer than 42 minutes the album lasted
Post-rock is so cool. It's not for everyone, but it's absolutely for me, which is all that matters. Admittedly this isn't my favorite post-rock album, but it's not bad at all. Millions Now Living Will Never Die is a pretty cool album. It's a fully instrumental album, but the textures of the music and the high quality of the compositions make for an engaging album. I think the bass work especially is perfect for the music. The songs are interesting. "Djed" is the mandatory "long-ass-song" of the post-rock album, and it's great. It really does feel like a musical journey of sorts. "Glass Museum" is also super cool. The lack of vocals is something that I'm fine with. It allows the atmospheric nature of the music to really shine. Here's the thing with the post-rock representation on this list. I don't think any of the post-rock albums included on the list are bad. The Sigur Rós album, Spiderland, and this are all excellent, though I do find this to be my least favorite of the three. However, I feel like there are some glaring omissions from the scene that probably should've been included over this album. That's not to say that I want this to be removed. This is among the more influential post-rock albums in general. However, if you give me the choice between this and an album like Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven by Godspeed You! Black Emperor, I'm picking Godspeed over this just about every time. Both bands can coexist, obviously, but I'm just saying that if I had to pick one over the other (which I wouldn't), I wouldn't choose this one. Still, while I can't call this the best post-rock album of all time, it's still a great album that proves that I really am a big fan of the genre, aren't I? High 4/5.
Surprisingly pleasant instrumental group. I let this album run on into the next release on Spotify by accident. I felt this one was fine but I think TNT actually agreed more with me.
Moody and experimental. The tracks do seem to drag on a bit.
The 20 minute song starts off really well, and I could see it slowly turning into a super epic explosive song, but instead it just kinda turns into a wet fart of nothing. Around the 11 minute mark the beat changes to something more interesting, but not as exciting as the opening led me to believe. I want to like this album so much more than I actually do. I can see a lot of elements from albums I love, but it never quite takes their ideas far enough to be interesting. Some of the albums this reminds me of are: Slint - Spiderland, Can - Tago Mago, and Soft Cell - Third. High 3.
first half is banging. id rather be listening to bcnr tho. 3.5
The first track is trash, the rest of the album is pretty good. Unfortunately,, the first track is approx 50% of the album play time
I love NOISES
Some of it was really good, some of it annoying. Split the difference.
fucking annoying pinging sound in a 20 minute song? please end my misery. Genuinely so not enjoyable why did you do this. It is like an ice pick on my skull. This has to be a social experiment. the rest of the album was fine. nothing special at all. 2/5
Nothing amazing, although it works to have in the background when you study.
# Album Name: Millions Now Living Will Never Die # Artist: Tortoise # Rating: 1/5 # Comments: Wow, this is so amateur its unreal. What a joke. # Top Tunes: # Would I listen to it again? No
I dug this pretty well, and I think it's got room to grow on me. "Djed" has a bit of a NEU! thing going on that I appreciate, and I really didn't mind the length at all (that's what she said). "Glass Museum" and "The Taut and Tame" also stood out to me on first listen. It tailed off a bit for me in the final two tracks, but I'm interested to revisit this one and see if I can sink my teeth into it even more. 3.5/5
Pretentious is putting it politely
I seriously didn’t expect to like this album as much as I did. Over the weekend I ended up listening to it a few times. “Glass Museum” with that vibraphone? Totally love it!
This was a perfect listen for some quiet time and I’ve already added to a playlist for the future. Captivating, atmospheric instrumental tracks. Listened to it all through twice. NOTE: I’m still not sure if it was the digital version I listened to or part of the song but at 13:56 on the first track there was what sounded like drops and garbles.
Weirdly interesting instrumental jazz rock.
Man, add some lyrics in here and maybe you'll have something. As it, it's fine.
Worth a few re-listens! I enjoy this more than most of the newer, more spa-friendly post-rock bands. Never heard of them before.
Definitely New to me! Enjoyed this very much!! Ended up listening to a second album and then another similar artist after.
Background, lobby, or elevator music, but not worthy of this list.
I’m confused
meh. I just don't get the artsy post-whatever flavors of music. I bet Thom Yorke really likes these guys. really boring
forgettable background music. why is it on the list?
Chill, instrumental. You know I love those vibes
This is background music at best, but then again I’m not even sure for what. Would seem out of place at a pub, not loud enough for events, too much for an elevator. Just doesn’t really seem to fit at all. As a piece it’s fine, but again I just think having a 20 minute song is heavily self indulgent and I don’t think that the quality warrants a relisten tbh
Fuck off. The pretentious "Tortoise is widely considered one of the most influential music groups of the last 40 years," is such bull shit. This is not impressive or good.
One of those instrumental albums that just fall into the background??? Theres pockets of interest and those moments are sick but overall it’s nothing to write home about.
I understand why the list pickers would have chosen this album, but for the average music listener, ya... nah. Some moments on this album were quite nice, like Glass Museum, but that was more of an exception to the album than the norm. I just felt that a lot of random sounds were placed together that didn't feel coherent, which is kind of the purpose of the album, but does not suit my listening style.
post-rock-y, tud ez jobb is lenni
hat en ezt nem tudtam hova tenni. de voltak jo pillanatai
You had me at post-rock
Strange
Mogwai/boards of Canada
**In-Depth Review: *Millions Now Living Will Never Die* by Tortoise** Released in 1996, *Millions Now Living Will Never Die* is Tortoise’s second studio album and a landmark in the post-rock genre. It’s a meticulously crafted, entirely instrumental record that blends dub, jazz, krautrock, and minimalist electronic music into a cohesive and immersive sonic journey. The album is widely regarded as a foundational text of post-rock, influencing countless bands including Explosions in the Sky, Mogwai, and even Radiohead. --- ### 🎼 **Music & Composition** The album opens with **“Djed”**, a 21-minute suite that is often cited as a post-rock manifesto. It begins with a hypnotic, motorik groove and gradually morphs through dub, ambient, and minimalist phases, using xylophones, analog synths, and glitchy electronics. The track is a masterclass in structure and pacing, shifting moods and textures without ever losing its internal logic. It’s patient, immersive, and rewards close listening. Tracks like **“Glass Museum”** and **“The Taut and Tame”** showcase Tortoise’s ability to balance organic instrumentation with electronic experimentation. The former builds from a contemplative, oceanic calm into a galloping rhythm, while the latter features sharp guitar riffs and jazzy percussion, creating a tension that’s both cerebral and visceral . **“Dear Grandma and Grandpa”** and **“Along the Banks of Rivers”** close the album with ambient introspection and cinematic melancholy, the latter evoking Morricone-esque soundscapes . --- ### 🎛️ **Production & Sound Design** Produced by John McEntire, the album is a benchmark in studio craftsmanship. It employs analog instruments and dub-influenced production techniques—echo, reverb, and space—that give the record a tactile, immersive quality. The mixing is spacious and layered, allowing each instrument to breathe while contributing to a unified atmosphere. The use of mallet percussion, analog synths, and subtle electronic glitches gives the album a timeless, otherworldly feel . --- ### 🧠 **Themes & Interpretation** Though entirely instrumental, the album conveys themes of **transition, memory, and impermanence**. The title itself, *Millions Now Living Will Never Die*, is taken from a Jehovah’s Witnesses pamphlet, suggesting a kind of eternal optimism or existential irony. The music mirrors this ambiguity—serene yet unsettling, mechanical yet emotional. It invites the listener to project their own narrative onto its shifting sonic landscapes . --- ### 🌐 **Influence & Legacy** This album is arguably the first in the genre to feature a 20+ minute post-rock epic, predating similar efforts by Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Sigur Rós. It helped define the post-rock aesthetic: using rock instrumentation for non-rock purposes, emphasizing texture, rhythm, and atmosphere over melody and vocals. Its influence can be heard in everything from Stereolab’s *Dots and Loops* (produced by McEntire) to Radiohead’s *Kid A* . --- ### ✅ **Pros** - **Innovative Structure**: Especially “Djed,” which is a genre-defining epic. - **Rich Production**: Dub effects, analog warmth, and layered textures. - **Genre Fusion**: Seamlessly blends jazz, krautrock, dub, and electronic music. - **Emotional Depth**: Despite being instrumental, it evokes strong moods and imagery. - **Influence**: A cornerstone of post-rock, inspiring a generation of musicians. --- ### ❌ **Cons** - **No Vocals**: May alienate listeners who prefer lyrical content or vocal hooks. - **Demands Patience**: The slow-burning, minimalist approach can feel inaccessible or “background”-like without focused listening. - **Inconsistent Pacing**: Some tracks like “A Survey” are seen as meandering or less essential compared to the album’s highs . --- ### 🎧 **Final Verdict** *Millions Now Living Will Never Die* is not just an album—it’s an experience. It’s a sonic labyrinth that reveals more with each listen, rewarding those who surrender to its pace and atmosphere. While it may not be for everyone, its place in music history is undeniable. Tortoise didn’t just make a record—they helped shape a genre. > **Recommended for fans of**: Talk Talk, Brian Eno, Slint, Stereolab, early electronic minimalism, and atmospheric instrumental music. – A landmark of experimental music and a must-hear for anyone interested in the evolution of post-rock.
Sweeping instrumentals, Avant Garde, mutating melodies, bass-heavy, post-rock, tracks ranging from 20 minutes to 2 minutes in duration. Yes, I am here for this music. Never heard of Tortoise before, but after my first listen-through, I instantly categorised them on my internal music shelf as sitting somewhere between Godspeed You! Black Emperor and Mogwai. That's hallowed ground.
Highlight Song/s: Glass Museum This is quite a texture-rich album, great vibe to it. Such as The Taut and Tame reminds me of something off of Seventeen Seconds (The Cure.) Other than that It is just quite underwhelming for me; just doesn't strike a chord. I can see why someone might like this album.
only beats; no vocals still beats were good
The constant electrical pulse in the last 10+ minutes of djed are annoying af.
3,5
Dreamy pseudo-psychedelia.
i recently had to look after a tortoise for about a week, she was kind of prickly, but very cool, steady and decisive. so basically Tortoise picked their name well
Enjoyed this way more than i thought i would
I'd never heard of Tortoise and was completely unprepared for it. I really like it! It's apparently postrock, which is a genre I don't know a lot about. I genuinely don't have anything bad to say about this. I like the variety, the soundscapes are broad and complex, and I'll definitely explore more of both their work and other postrock works.
It's becoming increasingly clear to me that prog rock and I just don't get along any more. I mean, this effort has some fine moments and conjures up a dreamscape that would surely be a pleasure to experience, but the first track is 21 minutes (about half the album's running time), and I can't be sitting through all that, not at my age. So while one may marvel at the artistry of the guitar work, I'm just going to move on to the next on the list...
Pleasant enough but a bit Muzacky. I like ambient music and this borders on that genre but a pale comparison to Brian Eno. Worryingly, although recorded in 1996 this does sound like it could have been produced by AI. A frightening glimpse of what’s around the corner? 2/5 30/10/25
Solid.jamz
An excellent addition to the post-rock genre. It's a slow burn - make sure you're listening attentively.
Great listening for when in mindless spreadsheet land.
taustamusiikkia ilman vokaaleja. tunnelmallista meininkiä ei siinä mitään.
2.67
Sounds like someone pissing around on a keyboard
This is how you do chilled jazzy ambient tunes. Great stuff.
this album is a bit hard to describe. it's jazz... math... rock? i think? it's so loose in terms of genre and all the tracks, you'd have to find your own meaning if you turned it on yourself. very minimal, very ambient... it's seriously difficult to describe this album, but it's definitely the kind of weird, quiet krautrock that an alternative or indie group would try to make when they're bored. i'm trying to get a good feel for the sound, but more often than not, i lose interest. there's something here, but i'm still trying to figure out what it is.
Not my thing
Alright background music
I actually really kinda liked this. I usually am quite negative toward these super long post rock songs with no vocals that go on forever but this one had enough to me that I enjoyed it. Good background music in a non derogatory way. 8/10
Weird ambient music. OK for while working I guess, but nothing incredibly interesting about it.
Jag skulle vilja ge detta album 2,5/5. Skickliga musiker men kanske inget jag lyssnar på igen. Inslagen av flera minuters skrapiga grusljud som är så typiska för ambient musik är inte riktigt något för mig. Ett album som försvinner i bakgrunden medans man pysslar med annat.
пълнеж
Finally one that I fully enjoyed!
It's fine, you can hear the influence of this on other rock instrumentalists but I just don't think it's a genre that lends itself that well to instrumental songs. 3*
It was good concentration music , I don’t usually like instrumental stuff but it was good
Background music. Not really for me. Got some work done to it though...
Incredible sounds on this album. Manages to be super relaxed while also being esoteric and off kilter at the same time
Pretty good one, good rainy day vibe Will I listen to again: 73%
Wonderful listen! All the twists and turns in Djed, the minimalist electronic sound and is great and then it just jumps at you with some great free jazz and post rock. Great stuff 7/10 Favorite tracks- “Djed” “The Taut and Tame”
I don’t know why
Not good.
Boring as shit. All these '90s post-rock bands are boring as shit with the exception of Mogwai.
Sort of charming. I was quite enjoying Djed until 14 minutes in when it decided to become annoying.
I /love/ post rock, but this was dreadful
Album No. 0033 on my list. Never heared of Tortoise before, but I can definitely see why this is considered an important record. For me, this was an enjoyable listen overall. The whole album is pretty groovy, and even though it does not have any singing parts, it did not bore me at all. On the other hand, its instrumental nature makes this something I'd rather listen to in the background instead of properly listening to this album just for the sake of itself. "Djed", the first track, which makes up around half of the album itself, was my favorite track, despite its length. 3/5 stars!
Cool interesting instrumentals, but not engaging enough for me to listen to the whole song
Good, atmospheric instrumental album with interesting layers, perfect for background music.
Lyric-less album of mostly a bunch of sounds. Is there some musical components? Sure. But there's mostly just a bunch of effects thrown on a loop with some clickity, clack, button pressing bullshit. Maybe watching this 'music' come together in real time, in a live setting, could be cool. But listening to this as an 'album' is just absolute shit. What are we doing here.
Some interesting sounds, and some moments that border on prog rock, but mostly just repetitive, boring riffs.
diudnt like it
This is great backgroundy/ambient stuff. My wife thinks I’m crazy.
Little weird
Superb!
Why is this here?
Instrumental bien mais instrumental
Never heard their stuff before but a like it
Class
Don't know the rest of their stuff very well but I've always liked this one
How haven't I heard this before? I enjoyed it
Never heard this before, great stuff!
Interwsting instrumental
I've always had a soft spot for Tortoise. They're not the kind of band you'd get stuck in your head and there are no obvious singles anywhere in sight. But it's great background music when you need to get some work done. I don't want to sell them short though, because there's actually a lot going on here. Tortoise were pioneers of post-rock, blending electronic music, jazz, and krautrock. The band members are all multi-instrumentalists, with none of them specializing in any in particular. This allows them to switch around instruments at a whim, often mid-song. Their instrumental rock isn't hindered by needs for hooks or confined structures of songs. The band members all have other projects, so Tortoise remains a place of freedom to experiment as they please. Future post-rock bands like Godspeed You! Black Emperor had the road opened to them by the early work of Tortoise and others. The music may be too complex to hum along to exactly, but you can either analyze it or let it wash over you. For what they do, Tortoise are one of the best.
Middle of the road
Gentle and beautiful
Interesting. Need to relisten
Enjoyed this a fair amount, the last 5 tracks especially had this sorta deconstructed vibe to them, focusing on particular sounds and kinda droning them along… light 4
Tortoise was one of those bands i always felt like i was supposed to like but never knew why and guess what... i do like them... so take that!
Sounds
I gave Millions Now Living Will Never Die so many chances, and for the life of me I couldn't really tell you much about it. It's down tempo, but almost the to point of inducing catatonia. I can't deny that it's moody, but I can't imagine throwing this on. Not sure if it's essential either
Yo solía pensar que el post rock era otra cosa, pero ya que a esto le han puesto esta etiqueta me lo voy a creer. Este disco me da más vibras a un ambient rock y a electronic jazz que a otra cosa, pero etiquetas aparte, me parece un álbum muy conseguido. Un sonido sofisticado, muy bien producido y solo apto para paladares eclécticos y open minded. Habilidad infinita para crear atmósferas y estados de ánimo nada convencionales.
This was great, the vibes were awesome and I’m gonna look into Tortoise more, : )
Disjointed noise. Nope
Eh fine but immemorable bg music
I am a bit behind on my 1001 albums to hear before I die challenge so don't mind me if I try and get all caught up here real quick. Recently I was assigned yet another project I had absolutely no idea or expectations with Tortoise's Millions Now Living Will Never Die. This borderline Ambient/Post-Rock project is a really weird blend that I surprisingly got down with a good bit. This project feels like it should have more meat on its' bone, but is in actuality a pretty lean project with not too much to it outside of some very subtle compositions. With no vocals whatsoever, the performers really have to carry their weight with their compositions, and I'd argue they do a decent to good job throughout this project's runtime. Even during Djed I can't lie this album was losing me a bit. I respect the hell out of having an entirely instrumental album with such soft and gentle instrumentals, but sometimes it comes off as more background music than really thoughtful pieces painting pictures of a landscape. I like what Tortoise was going for here, but I want something a bit more focused next time around. Maybe TNT will be just that, but I'll have to wait another day before I get around to it...
First time listening. I almost didn’t make it through the opening track, Djed. It started off ok, but then it turned into a kind of noise that made me want to drive my car into a wall. After that, it is was smooth sailing the rest of the way. Glass Museum, A Survey, and The Taut and Tame were proggy goodness. I also enjoyed the spaghetti western feel of Along The Banks of Rivers. Would probably listen to again, but I’m skipping the first track. 3.5/5
Maybe 2.5? Boring, but mostly not abrasive
En la U tenía un compañero que escribía puros jeroglíficos en las pruebas para que lo citaran a "leer su prueba" y así subir sus notas. Necesito que los chiquillos estos de las tortugas vengan a explicarme ese primer track de casi 21 minutos. Sin él habría amado el disco. La onda de The Taut and Tame está buenísima, pero no puedo superar los 20:57 de algo que sonaba muy a nada, la verdad.
This was an introduction to Tortoise for me, and I’m glad this album is on the list because I really enjoyed it. They remind me a lot of Do Make Say Think, a band I discovered on accident when Amazon sent me the wrong vinyl record one time and I got their You You’re A History In Rust record instead, which I kept after looking it up and discovering that it’s well regarded. I loved that album and this Tortoise album (released a decade before YYAHIR) reminds me a lot of it. This is an all instrumental album that doesn’t serve well as background music because it demands your attention. The music shifts within a song, and different instruments take lead in interesting ways throughout. Without digging into the band for timing reasons, they sound like they have a bass player, guitar player, percussionist, and a fourth member who I can only describe as “weird sound guy” whose job it is to make interesting sounds from things that are not instruments. I don’t know how right I am about this, but I like the approach if it’s true.
Utterly boring
Very trippy slow acid rock
this was really nice. dynamic and yet unobtrusive. i don’t generally seek out this kind of music but i enjoyed this for what it is.
this was very lovely. perfect kind of ambient music — just interesting enough that it doesn’t get tedious, but not distracting.
Demasiado experimental para mí gusto No lo volveré a escuchar nunca mas
Metro y bus, a las 3 de la tarde en septiembre. Relajante y retador. HIPNÓTICO
Essentially ambient shoegaze, with a little jazziness thrown in. Perfect for my current debugging session.
It’s really hard to get it to 1/10
Meh.
Wikipedia says this is a “post-rock” band. I don’t know what that means but I do know that I kind of love it. I don’t know when I would think to seek it out, but this was a good listen. Also Spotify went directly into a Mogwai tune after this album which led me into listening to one of their albums. Very similar and also gorgeous!
Instrumental albums are already dope as hell, but this one bangs. Don’t know how I’ve never listened to these guys before
100% instrumental. Fine for the background. I want a bit more from my music. 1.5 outta 5
Holy shit. I spent the 90s working at a record store. How did I miss this band? This is one of the biggest surprises I've had with this project. Top notch album.
I did not expect to like this when it popped up ... but I did. I think that will grow the more I listen!
Need to listen and rate it.
Enjoyed this, first time of hearing - now part of my ambient collection. Reminded me a bit of Portishead without the vocals.
Quite an interesting listen! This is what this project is for. 3/5
I am partial to ambient music. Nothing completely awful about this album but not groundbreaking either. I enjoyed the two shorter songs. The other songs felt way too long and there wasn’t any discerning beginning, middle, end.
OK so . . . the album is about 50% the first song - the parts that sounded like Kidsmoke (Wilco) I liked a lot, the parts where it sounds like their studio equipment was breaking down and they said, 'Fuck it, keep recording' I liked a lot less. Had they just stuck with the heavy bass line I think I would have really grooved to this album but . . . At one point they appeared to have snuck in the some naval sub pinging sonar for some reason. I feel like this is one of those bands you really have to spend some time with to fully appreciate. Didn't hate, don't love it. Do love Wilco! Closest contemporary in the genre that came to my mind is God is an Astronaut.
Excellent album ! À réécouter ! Et une discographie à explorer ! J’imagine que plein de groupes tirent leurs inspirations de Tortoise. Je pense à GY!BE, Mogwai et autres.
Very long drawn out jamming not my tea but good for them
The first song on this record remind me of a modern day Peanuts. There is this random piano part that triggered that thought. It’s all instrumental. It’s a bit of everything. Noise. Post Rock. Fusion. It reminded me of a band I like called Mogwai. I found out the title of the record is a phrase used by Jehovahs witnesses. Which, I think they use in jest. Kind of funny. Anyways, not really my thing. It’s interesting for sure but the replay ability is not there.
A very cool instrumental album. No single track stood out, but the overall effect was quite impressive.
Very enjoyable. Really helped my brain.
Ambient, nothing crazy
Very good. A clear influence on bands like Mogwai. Pleasantly hypnotic. One to revisit
not really into instrumentals so i found this boring, you know what else i found boring? THE FIRST SONG BEING TWENTY MINUTES LONG!
Electronic... Prefer shorter songs
cloud watching music <3
This was different but I kinda liked it. I feel like this album with great headphones would sound amazing. Interesting instrumentals but a strangely nice listen.
It sounds like this band/album is important because of their influence on other artists, more so than directly. I find the album to be extremely "meh". It reminds me of Philip Glass or other kind of experimental instrumental style things, but far less interesting.
I enjoyed this, but there were times it came close to annoying me. The first half of the first song felt like "what if we just took the first 10 seconds of a normal song and blew it out for 10 minutes." But the later half of the album kept me interested. When it played like a cool soundtrack to a movie I hadn't seen, if worked. When I felt like it was asking me to look at it as some intellectual activity to be "appreciated," it left me cold.
'Glass Museum' is definitely the strongest song, but (besides the movie soundtrack score of the opening song) the rest of it mostly sounded a bit more noodly and experimental. For me, it ultimately was not all that compelling altogether.
Very good, a chill background sounds ape that was innovative for its time
Love instrumental music! This will need more listening!
Minecraft music. Instrumental forgettable pretentious nonsense.
That was awesome.
Really great post-rock album with post-minimalism influences. You can hear NEU! and Steve Reich in there, which is a combination made in heaven
Interesting modern take on krautrock.
This instrumental album feels like a sweet dream, blending krautrock, math rock, post rock and minimalism in the best possible way!
This is exactly what I came to this project for. A seminal band from a genre I enjoy but haven't fully explored. Loved it, one of my favorite discoveries of the project. 5/5
Nee, dit was niet mijn muziek. Wel vette bassrifjes en een kneiter lang eerste nummer van maar liefst 20:57 minuten! Echter, het voelde voor mij meer als een soort lift/wachtrij album, met enkel instrumentale tonen. Ik denk dat dit voor een bepaalde liefhebber een zeer tof album is, maar voor mij kom ik uit op 2 reten
gentle instrumental progressive rock. a reallybold 20 minute long opening track. 2/5
It was just okay background music.
This was a big waste of my time. No connection, no purpose.
Starts with Radioheads worst song Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box Ends with a slow Portishead song without Beth Gibbons tl;dr I don't get it
glass museum 🌀
Not sure why this is on here
Don't get this at all. 2*
I would never seek this out. But for instrumental / electronic music, it is pretty good / not bad. But I’ll probably never listen again.
Different and kind of cool. Not sure why it’s top 1001 albums.
If I had a pound for every time I'd tried to get into post-rock I might be able to afford a pint outside of London. This was the second pound earnt from this record. Sam Jennings first introduced me to it and when he did I listened to it every day for a week or so. This was the first I'd revisited it since. Lots of cool moments but hard to give it a four.
Oh, I love this sort of thing. I can see how, for a lot of people, the meandering tracks can fade in to the background, but they hold my attention and evoke interesting mental images and story threads. Great stuff. 4.5
A bad I have never heard or heard of. Starting out with a 20 minute mood piece is definitely a bold choice, but I'm enjoying it more than I would have expected.
middle part of Djed (around the 12 minutes mark) is a clear pastiche of music for 18 musicians, but it's a great piece of music so it's not a complaint
I enjoyed it much more than I expected.
Almost sounded like video game music. Another where I wish there were decimals, would have this closer to a 4
prefiro o TNT? sim, sem dúvidas mas esse é mto bom tbm, deus abençoe
uai?????? esse eu nao esperava. de fato, o tnt é melhor hein. mas esse num fica atras não!! bem bonitão atmosférico do jeito que post-rock tem que ser. lindo demais!!
I'm sorry, but this is the most not-for-me album ever released. I'm usually opposed to anything with "post" in the genre, and this is the epitome of why
Two may be a bit harsh but I likely won't be listening to this album again. Left me in a state of "?".
I don't get it. Just meanders around without really getting into any kind of story with the instrumental.
My definition of post rock was always influenced by Godspeed! You Black Emperor's euphoric highs. So on my first listen of this, I was wondering why this was characterized as post rock. It was all over the place and though some melodies caught me, they never built to a climax. I'm a person that is infamously into a band that jams on a repeating phrase over and over again and yet it didn't stick the first time. That's when I researched the genre of post rock in general and what I read was that post rock is supposed to be music built on texture and without structure. There's the build up of course, but when I thought of the word "texture", I decided to give it a second listen. It's nothing spectacular, but I can at least give it some respect. This is not an album meant for conventional listening, but rather, light background music that makes some sort of impression. Maybe it's my Stereolab senses tingling. (5/10, 3/5 on this scale)
Excellent extension and progression from their debut. I really enjoy the flow of this album and the wide net of musical styles explored. MNLWND succeeds in taking chances and manages to be very consistent.
Post-rock put me off straight away but I gave it a go anyway. It was fine. The first track is distressingly long but the rest plinky plonk their way along quite quickly. It is blandish background music that occasionally lets out a squeal to make sure you are still there. It’s nothing that I will revisit but it was better than “post rock” would imply.
An 18 minute intro track is a psychologically challenging way to start an album
Mellow, unremarkable for me
I quite liked this, but can’t put my finger on why.
I saw Tortoise live in a warehouse in Dubuque, Iowa, in maybe 2010, which was awesome. They had some synth I’ve never seen before or since that was played like a marimba.
Honestly surprised at the low score for this. I guess I'm the odd man out for liking chill instrumental post rock.
Tortoise puts out music that is both timeless and contemporary.
2.5/5
This album helped me realize that post rock just isn't my thing. I can recognize the technical and experimental virtuosity going on here. I'm just not interested in it.
This is the song that doesn't end. Yes it goes on and on my friends. It might make good cleaning music though
Some interesting sounds and a 21 minute opening track. 1st time for everything.
This album was boring as fuck. Will not play back not even that happy I heard in the first place.
Ambient-noise alternative type stuff. Not my thing at all.
Sparse and sumptuous. I lost track of time, in a decent way.
No interested in an instrumental album
Electronica isn’t my thing unless it’s really good electronica. This ain’t the latter
This album is fine and unique but just all too boring. Nothing particularly offensive but also nothing more than background music. Hardly "one of the most influential music groups of the last 40 years" as their Spotify description reads. 4/10 (2/5)
so sick
Trippy
Boooooring 42 minutes of useless sounds
Nice music for my plane ride
Single listen club🗣️🗣️boring ass passive music. Type shit you’d hear doing your onboarding process for work in a safety video. Knock off wii sports loading music
TNT's a little better, but Tortoise are awesome regardless. Cool this is here.
What?!?!?? Another post-rock album! I'm really surprised, and, as a fan of the genre, I've never actually listened to Tortoise before. This is excellent. They kind of nail all the things that I love about the genre. Slow musical development that makes you feel really familiar with the ideas/motifs/melodies, so that even the slightest of changes is noticeable and impactful. The synth work is honestly pretty incredible. It's deep and varied, but I never feel like it's trying to out-do the guitars or drums. It's obviously given the limelight when it's carrying the melody, but it also tastefully takes the backseat when adding embellishments. I love this, but I'm not going to fault you if you don't. It's pretty different than a lot of other styles of much you'd listen to in the US. I'm also not really sure if it deserves to be in this book. I'd have to see what he said about it in the actual book. Favorite Song(s): Djed, The Taut and Tame, Along the Banks of Rivers
I wish I could find more just instrumental stuff like this. Really good, I hear there next album was even better
Never came across this band before, but, what a find, great musical journey!
5/10 It isn't bad, its just I didn't notice when the music stopped. plus there are some annoying noises in the first track. 8-6-2025
This was ok. I guess the fact that it sounds like pretty much all the other Post Rock music I've heard makes sense as this pretty much defined the genre. In terms of significance, I suppose that makes this album very significant. In terms of listenability, I could listen to it again in the right mood though I think the first track could have cut out much of the last 5ish minutes. 3/5
If there was a soundtrack for a head cold this would be it.
Its pretty, it is interesting at times but overall just music that is there. This isn't the first album we have that has followed a format I find a bit confusing. What is with one really really long song, that has multiple parts that could be broken down into multiple songs that are then followed by multiple shortish songs. I get that there needs to be a certain length to a typical album but if you like long songs do two long songs or focus on short songs. To me I automatically assume the long one is your Opus and the rest is just filler.
Wish I had more time to spend with this. I like it and it's got some pretty interesting things going on with it musically in a proggy-jazzy kind of way. I would come back to this.
The 20-minute intro to an album in a genre I didn't know existed felt like I'd voluntarily stumbled into a rather aimless abyss. I can see why this is categorized as post rock. It kind of sucks all the fun and grit and words out of rock and mostly leaves a gentle, calming experience with rock instrumentals instead. It was fine enough though, nice ambient mood music.
Pretty good, just a long instrumental álbum. Felt like an indie rock album that skipped forever and no one ever sang. Decent but didn't wow me
I don’t care if it’s the best vibe in the world, I’ll never get behind a 20 min song. That said it was a very good vibe.
Kinda boring noises.
I liked this pretty well. It was a challenging listen at first, but also incredibly rewarding once I let the music wash over me. I agree with some reviewer that said it's background music that refuses to stay in the background. For a weekend album, it was much harder to put this on in the background when doing more activities, but I made time for it because I had a theory that if I kept listening to it that it would get better. I have no idea if this is the best of their work or whatever because this is the first time I've listened to them. What unique and complex music!
There are moments during "Djed" where I remind myself that someone wrote and recorded this, because it feels like music that has just always existed. There are other moments where I think, "Why did they choose this here?" only to seconds later be entirely captivated and swept away by that same choice. It's a song/composition/saga that rewards multiple listens, and it's so packed full of good stuff that multiple listens is not a chore, despite its running time. I wish that the other 20 minutes on this record matched it, but they don't, though they're all very listenable. I peeked and saw that this is the only Tortoise album on the list. That's a shame because the next one, TNT, is just as great, and more consistent start to finish.
pretty cool pop album
Background noise; not offensive yet certainly not special
Not bad background music at work, but wouldn’t listen to this otherwise
1-2 experimental
7/29/25. Wasn't expecting an instrumental, but interesting nontheless. Cool, atmospheric sounds in this one, last track had to be my favorite.
Didn't initially grab me, but the songs did start to grow on me. Can't fault the technical playing and instrumentation.
Fucking annoying. 1/5
GY!BE if it was more math rock than drone. 7/10
This has been on my "to listen" list for a while now, and I'm glad this made me get around to it. Tortoise are an instrumental post rock group, featuring members of a variety of bands, covering a lot of ground (most notably to me, David Pajo of Slint is here). In short, this is fantastic, Millions Now Living Will Never Die is a particularly engaging post rock album with sort of indie sensibilities. And they play in a very particular palette, with traditional rock instruments, as well as vibraphones, marimbas, more bass guitars than can be typically expected, and all sort of interesting electronics. A lot is incorporated, and the result is honestly kind of otherworldly, there is some psych, space rock, ambient, glitch, and even a little hip hop influence here and there. In an awfully bold move, the first song here is Djed, a sprawling, 20 minute long epic. It has a really interesting way of progressing, where glitches tear the instrumental swells apart, and abstract synth drones serve as the rhythmic center of new swells. It is a remarkably brisk, engaging 20 minutes with some really intense and beautiful moments. And the rest of this album is no afterthought. Glass Museum is ethereal and gorgeous, The Taut And Tame taps into some really abstract, driving rhythms, and Along The Banks of Rivers taps into something intense, and western-esque: all are incredible tracks. The two shorter tracks here are also pretty great, not the showpieces that everything else is, but still great. On an instrumental album like this, it makes sense that these littler tracks would still be detailed and engaging. For what it is, this is pretty much perfect, I loved it from start to end, and intend to put it in my regular rotation.
That was a nice pull. Mellow and chill, makes for nice ambient music.
An interesting listen. I'd come back to it
Kinda weird alternative.
Okay post rock
Never heard about this band before and it was an OK listen, as it was intrumental and great for background music, but Im not a massive fan of post rock. There are some good instrumental bits but most of it was forgettable. 2.5 but making it to a 3. Meh
Really enjoyed this. Some very nice ambient work, will definitely revisit
There are some really good parts on this album, especially in the 20+ minute opener. It’s textured, creative, and builds nicely, but like the rest of the album, it tends to drift once it gets somewhere interesting. That’s kind of the story throughout: ideas appear, then wander off before they fully land. All in all, this album feels more like a sketchbook of cool sounds than a fully satisfying listen. Honestly, the first track gave me most of what I needed.
Not. Ad
New addition to the Happy Work Focus playlist!
Great album to start the day with. Good vibe.
Love this. TNT was my first intro to Tortoise and is still my fave, but I’d be happy with this as the alternative any day.
Solid
I usually like this kind of music, but this was just bland, uninteresting, and boring.
The beginning of the first song (Djed) made me feel like soldier in a war going on a secret mission with cool, strange soundtrack on the background. Even though the song is 20 minutes long it has great pace and keeps you intrested about what will be next. It slowly turns from just sound effects to multi-instrumental. The second part of song made big affect on me in a nostalgic way, It felt like listening to child playing with everything that gets in his hands. The song does good job keeping you interested but still there are moments where you think it is TOO LONG. The second song(Glass Museum) feels like manipulative girlfriend, in some period of time she makes you feel miserable and does not do anything to stay with you but suddenly she starts to be interesting, entertaining and BEAUTIFUL. The song turns its sound down just to start something even more heavenly in a second. Third song is nothing special and kinda boring for me. The fourth song gives off different feelings in different parts, sometimes negative sometimes positive, more drums would make the song much better. In moments you feel like youre listening to nothing but strange background. I feel like this album is different movie soundtracks stacked together and fifth song is great example of that for me. The last song does not give off same vibe as the whole album, it feels heavier and kinda western. 3.5
Tortoise’s second album, Millions Now Living Will Never Die, stands as a pivotal moment in post-rock’s evolution. Drawing its name from a 1920s prophecy by Jehovah’s Witness leader Joseph Rutherford, the album embraces the spirit of transformation musically and conceptually. The 20-minute opener “Djed” exemplifies this: a shape-shifting, genre-blending journey through krautrock repetition, jazz textures, dub echoes, and ambient electronics. The record’s influence echoes alongside other ‘90s post-rock staples like Hex and Laughing Stock, proving that Tortoise weren’t just experimenting they were helping define an entire movement.
Solid 3.5, good ambience but not particularly memorable.
Really nice. Layered, "transporting," lots of great moments.
Kann man machen
Did I detect... was there... was there Gamelan on that? Best post rock record on here so far. Fantastic album.
I like post-rock, but missed Tortoise until now. Very chill, like the Lofi Girl of post-rock. Great as a daily life soundtrack, probably wouldn’t see live.
For art to be worth seeing, something must happen, or it must be beautiful. An action movie has something happen, but isn't beautiful. Alice Munro's stories are beautiful, but nothing happens. Rzewski's variations on Pueblo Unido are beautiful and have things occur in it. This album fulfills neither requirement. Fortunately, it doesn't sound actively bad and thus it gets a 2.
Jesus Christ we get it you learned how to use garage band, fine, it’s still awful.
Love Tortoise. Been spinning this since it dropped. But “albums you need to hear before you die”? Please. It’s not even their best one. Fantastic background music for doing literally anything. Except dying.
just a bit boring
Not bad. I was working with it on. I'll have to read about what was so great about it. If I had it on in the car or something I think it would be fewer stars
Halfway through the wandering opening track, the Tubular Bell flashbacks were real. But then it carries on meandering and by the end we've been through some stuff together. We're not getting a tattoo to celebrate, but perhaps we're asking Facey Friends? and doing a selfie. It's harmonious enough to put on and leave on; nothing needs skipping, and there's moments of real mood development. Great Math Rock
I...think I enjoyed this? I don't know why I'm so unsure. Parts of it can be a bit irritating, but overall the ambient-ish vibes are appreciated.
Enjoyed this, and am glad to know of its existence. Relaxing, but also interesting. Probably a seven, but I'm rounding down because I can't think when I'd want to listen again.
Really liked this, found it a bit Krautrockesque. Plus Glass Museum took me right back to seeing Robin Guthrie over a decade ago so I’m all for that.
An excellent band's best album. I hadn't listened to this for a while, and it's almost perfect.
This started off okay but then went very prog. At which point it lost me.
This sounds as though it was recorded in 1976, not 1996. I think it's all the better for it. I'm softening in my own older age. I've become a bloody hippy.
At first it was very “background music for an educational film about how microscopes work,” but by the end I was enjoying it as being actually good, not just quirky good.
Not for me, found the album boring
it's alright. it starts off so interesting but floats into the background