Reviews (page 3 of 9)
Interesting 20 minute first song. I had heard a shorter version before. Didn’t live listening to the album from start to finish though.
Wow, this was a nice surprise. I especially enjoyed the 20+ minute opening song.
really solid
Good background noise but other than that I did not like it.
Kind of soothing prog rock. Have never heard of them before.
This is a bit good! It’s described as post-rock, but to my ears it includes elements of krautrock, math rock and minimalism, with echoes of Can, Steve Reich, Roy Budd and Terry Riley. The highlight is the opening track Djed which lasts for an epic 20 minutes and features motorik drumming, spacey bits and glitchy breakdowns. The rest of the tracks are shorter but no less interesting with blissed out guitars, vibraphones and marimbas. I absolutely adored this album and will be listening to the rest of their work as soon as I’ve finished listening to this album again
Inoffensive, dull, pedestrian, uneventful and uninspiring. Two stars. 1 "Djed" (2/5) 2 "Glass Museum" (2/5) 3 "A Survey" (2/5) 4 "The Taut and Tame" (2/5) 5 "Dear Grandma and Grandpa" (2/5) 6 "Along the Banks of Rivers" (2/5) Total - 12 Average - 2 313/1001 170/313 albums reviewed were new to me.
Die US-amerikanische Chicagoer Instrumentalband Tortoise nahm ihr zweites Album zwischen Juni und September 1995 in zwei Chicagoer Studios auf: im Idful Music Corporation und im neu eröffneten Soma Electronic Music Studios – beide Male am Mischpult: John McEntire, zugleich Mitglied der Band. Erschienen im Januar 1996 auf Thrill Jockey, markiert das Album einen Wendepunkt, an dem Post-Rock, Krautrock, Dub und Elektronik nicht mehr als Einflüsse nebeneinanderstehen, sondern zu einem kohärenten Klangraum verschmelzen. Der Vorgänger hatte den Rahmen abgesteckt; dieses Album füllt ihn aus. Das Herzstück ist „Djed", eine 21-minütige Komposition, die durch rund 15 Mixstufen ging und am Ende klingt, als hätte sie diese Arbeit nie gekannt – ruhig, zwingend, unaufhörlich. Marimba, Vibraphon, Bass und Elektronik schichten sich übereinander, ohne je zu drängen. Die kürzeren Stücke – „Glass Museum", „A Survey", das eindringliche „Dear Grandma and Grandpa" – funktionieren als Ruhepunkte und Kontrapunkte zugleich und geben dem Album eine Dramaturgie, die über reine Atmosphäre hinausgeht. Dave Pajo, der hier erstmals als Bandmitglied zu hören ist, verleiht dem Ganzen eine dezente gitarristische Textur, die nie vordergründig wird. Millions Now Living Will Never Die ist kein Album, das erklärt, was es tut. Es tut es einfach – und das mit einer Selbstverständlichkeit, die auch nach fast drei Jahrzehnten nicht verblasst ist. Der Maßstab, an dem sich Tortoise bis heute messen lassen muss.
OK.
literally looked to see if the album was almost over and it was still on track 1 background music
It starts with a 21-minute instrumental. And according to the description here, it sold 50,000 copies. The Offspring literally sold more cassettes of Smash out of their trunks. Tortise, what you've just made is one of the most insanely idiotic albums I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent recording were you even close to anything that could be considered required listening. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
Very cool mellow background music. Doesn’t deserve its low rating. 3 stars
Better than i initially expected. Not enough to listen to again though
Interesting without being too repetitive on the samples used. This is cool.
When you click the name of the artist it leads you to the wiki page for the actual animal!!! 🐢
There is a reason why world hits are being hits. This album is why some don’t.
It was weird with a 20 min + song, and yet I was working and it was in the background and I felt a little sad when it was over.
Bold. Big, long opening track. Loads of off-grooves and strange textures. Very different to the usual. TNT is better, but this is very good.
I love Tortoise! I am really surprised to see them on this list, they just don't seem mainstream enough. Have seen them live and they put on a mind blowing show. They are just a very chill psychedlic vibe. They just ride a really fine line of trance and prog that I really love.
I think I got through it?
I really like postrock bands like Aereogramme, Explosions in the Sky, An Autumn and Godspeed! You Black Emperor, so I thought this would be a great album. Well, it’s not. And I think it’s more post-baroque/pop than rock. It has its moments, but that’s all
Loved this!!! Og psychedelic rock and more than once surprised me with its experimental sounds.
Way more marimba than you think
Previously unknown. Not a fan.
definition of background music. Could be good situationally but I like to hear some more things going on
seems like a drone album
If I saw this band busking I probably would give them a full 15 minutes and then talk about it later. Instead I read all about how much I am required to respect this album and I was locked in for the full 40. A kind of peaceful album, certainly unique. I just had to listen a little longer than I would have in the wild. Marks for interestingness.
Without this list, I don’t think I would’ve ever listened to this album in my life. I gave it a couple of spins. I will play it again while cleaning the house. It restored a bit of faith in this whole project.
2/10 Wasn't for me
This was a fine listen of instrumental music. It definitely isn’t an album you must hear before you die though. 2.75 / 5
Пост рок весь похож, но эти ребята вроде бы как одни из пионеров.
Pleasant. Relaxing. Reminds me of when I started messing around with music.
Post rock then. OK. From the write ups it seemed interesting, but in reality? Seems like simpler ambient soundscape created by quite a bit of repetition? Don’t know why but expected more in the experimental avant-garde sound collage vibe, but it’s more prog-rock. Making it an easier listen but well. Opening track 20 minutes, did nothing, went no where, guessing that was the point, and the Casio comment is on point. Next track ultra light jazz motif, another 6 minutes- listen to Guaraldi to see how that one should be done. Then later there’s the rock track, standard prog fair. Then the spy movie soundtrack retrospective scene. Look if this is your thing good for you. So it's supposed atmospheric music made with rock instruments. OK, fine, maybe if it had just been on it would have been fine, but directly listening found it a complete yawn, bored the life out of me. Easy listening, but not in anything like a good way. Wasn’t terrible, background, but what was the point. 2 Star.
Album #75: Millions Now Living Will Never Die - Tortoise Genre (W): Post-rock, jazz fusion Singles: Djed, The Taut and Tame I have not listened to this album before. Thoughts?: This album requires a lot of patience, but you will be rewarded, sometimes, for sitting through it. Despite that, I feel like the album drags on too long to be memorable/enjoyable. Favorite songs: Djed, Glass Museum, The Taut and Tame, Dear Grandma and Grandpa
"Millions Now Living Will Never Die" is the second studio album by American post-rock band Tortoise. Post-rock and jazz fusion are the Wiki-listed genres. The album's title is a reference to a phrase used in the Jehovah's Witness Faith in the 1920's. The bandmembers included Dan Bitney, John Herndon, Douglass McCombs, John Mc Entire and David Pajo. The specific instruments the members played were not listed in the liner notes as most everyone played multiple instruments. The album had very positive reviews being called renowned and groundbreaking in the post-rock genre. The 20-minute epic "Djed" opens with lasers, explosions and marching sounds of horses. A soft dissonant-sounding guitar with birds singing. The song then proceeds to change beats roughly five to six times in what probably is best referred to as suites. Jazzy with a synth/organ. Multiple drums at times. A scratchy-sounding bass. They venture into Krautrock and even prog. Hypnotic ticking and an area where the vibraphone is featured. What a trip! The next song "Glass Museum" begins with a more melodic guitar, drums and a vibraphone. The pace abruptly changes, the volume is increased and they add multiple drums. A wobbly-sounding synth leads into "Dear Grandma and Grandpa." People talking on the telephone. A dreamy and slow guitar melody and drums. Long stretched guitar notes and a humming synth. The album closer "Along the Banks of Rivers" opens chaotically with guitar feedback and drums. A melodic bass riff and a guy screaming into what sounds like a vocoder. The song goes to an extremely fast pace and ends like it started with guitar feedback and just plain noise. Constant beat changes, different lead instruments, two drummers, varying sound levels, random noises and all instrumental. The music is classified as post-rock and also goes into jazz, experimental, prog, Krautrock and avant garde. This album is unpredictable and very original to my ears. I liked this album quite a bit. I saw this band about six years ago and they were fantastic. This album is not for everyone but those willing to be surprised, challenged and looking for something different, look no further.
Didn’t know post rock went back this far. Was fine but I’m never crazy into post rock
Extremely happy to see this one turn up – heard lots of good reports, though never got around to listening before now. First impressions are very positive, and two spins in and I’m really enjoying the mix of electronica, dub and Café Exil-style Eurocentricity. It all feels very ‘70s, cultured and old, but weirdly contemporary. A real find! 9/10
I reccomend giving this a listen as this band is the definition of post-rock... "experimental rock that emphasizes texture, atmosphere, and non-traditional song structures over conventional rock techniques." Instrumentals with lots of electronics. Some songs are more experimental than others.
temitas se fondo bueno apruebo
Odd album but surprisingly enjoyable.
It's not what I used to listen to so that's nice
Yawn
Djed Along the Banks of Rivers
Enjoyable listen.
This was ok. It kind of just all blended together to me, but I didn’t mind having it on.
We played this to death when it came and even went to see them live though my mate left as they sounded too much like the album!! Not heard it a long while so interested to see how it sounds now.
1. jed - 0 2. Glass - 0 3. Survey - 1 4. Tame - 1 5. Dear - 0 6. Rivers - 2
It makes me very happy to see this album, or any Tortoise album, made the list! Such a great super band. The metaphysical soundtrack for a beautiful movie never written. Unique songwriting approaches, significant noise, haunting textures, rhythmic intrigue. I just love what they do. And having seen them perform this and other albums live, I love the way they do it. This is the state of the art for some subcategory of modern jazz.
Wonderful ambient/instrumental record with lots of character and interesting sounds. A pleasant listening experience. I’m looking forward to more Tortoise.
I had never heard of this band or album before. Listening here, it kind of seemed like they were trying to create a feel like you'd find on The Dark Side of the Moon, but without the vocals. TDSOTM is my highest-rated album on this list (so far), so I support the endeavor. I thought the music was good outside of the vibe, too. I played this while I made breakfast, and I never got too distracted to stop listening. Even without vocals and with the long opener, it kept me engaged. My biggest detractor for this one is that I don't really see it having much relisten value. I enjoyed it this time, but I don't know that I'll be drawn back to it again. Still, I have to say I thought it was a pretty good album. Overall: 3.5
Instrumental music that just didn’t seem to go anywhere. This is not for me.
The album and band name couldn't help but remind me of that recent death hoax over the world's oldest tortoise. The album itself was alright, I liked Along the Banks of Rivers most
This is a bold face lie.
10 minute plus cresendo-core could go fuck themself. also wdym that the first song is 20+ minutes while the other are 5 and a half minutes maximum? isnt this just a lazy maggot brain ripoff? but yeah although this is not crescendo-core it need to go fuck itself too. 3/5
Just kind of boring background sounds
1,7/5
Me gusto el concepto del álbum
Ei lähtenyt. Samaa kappaletta koko levy. ⭐️⭐️
Not my piece of cake.
Very atmospheric and engaging music to play in the background. Is that confusing? Yeah, so is the music.
Elevator music. Not too bad as background, but not really much body to concentrate on. Maybe it's called 'post rock' because it's like rock music produced by someone deaf as a post? The best I can say is.. it was there. Anyone who deliberately adds technical glitches to a track to make me think my audio equipment is broken deserves to be slapped around the legs. -1 star. "I must put some Tortoise on", said no-one ever.
Arrancamos semana completa con una desconocida de un género a explorar como es el post-rock. Full ambiental. Ideal para días nublados o mañanas tranquilas. Gustó. Sobre todo, la canción que arranca el álbum. Nos vemos mañana, nuevamente con semana corta.
Djed - “What if Pink Floyd was less stimulating and had, like, xylophones and stuff?” That glitch-out at the 14-minute mark got me. 6.5/10 Glass Museum - Could feasibly be played by a band. Has the potential to be a headbanger, but some weird time stuff prevents it from being so. 7/10 A Survey - A couple of electric guitar people play electric guitar outside in a forest somewhere. 5.5/10 The Taut and Tame - This does, indeed, feel rather taut. Gets somewhat tamer as it goes on. Best drum stuff so far. 7.5/10 Dear Grandma and Grandpa - Old ambient technology sounds. Don’t really think I’d call this music; it’s more of an interesting collection of sounds. 3/10 Along the Banks of Rivers - Almost sounds like background music to a 1940s spy movie when the main character is in a bar talking to his partner about a case he just got. Almost. 6/10 Overall, 5/10. This kind of thing isn’t really my speed. It’s basically Pink Floyd but less stimulating and more vibey(apart from Taut and Tame). It’s good for what it is, but I don’t think I’ll ever find myself listening to this again, besides maybe Taut and Tame.
Took some patience to warm up to.. If post-rock was designed by the world's most chill librarian, this might be it. The intro is basically watching paint dry, but it's pleasant enough background noise. It is peaceful. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - Djed - Glass Museum - Dear Grandma and Grandpa
This was a cool vibe
Sadly forgettable, but inoffensive. Nice to see more ambient work on this list.
Pleasant but not terribly interesting. Some cool rhythmic ideas.
Great album with dream like feel to it. Only thing from making this 5/5 was the first song. It didn't hit me atleast on this first listening, but I will have to see what I say about it after another listening or two. Best track was A Survey.
Banda puramente instrumental, música con sonidos extraños, buen ritmo pero con sonidos raros que sinceramente no lo entiendo. La primera canción dura 20 minutos, puro ruido raro, a los 2 minutos me aburrió. Hay unas canciones de este disco que ayudan a dormir, logran un sonido relajante, pero las demás es como si estuvieras escuchando los efectos de sonido de una película de ciencia ficción.
While this isn't bad, it's the wrong side of weird, experimental and ponderous for me. Interesting to listen to once, but no real replay value.
pretty good albeit a little boring at times, but I got the sense that was intended in order to make the more interesting parts more exciting.
Rating: 6/10 Favorite song(s): not sure I have one in particular Review: I don’t have much to say about this one. It was alright. The soundscape wasn’t completely my cup of tea. It was okay, but nothing exciting. And I enjoy ambient music. Listen again?: Probably not
This was really cool, and that's it. Not to undermine what this record has to offer - I think it has strokes of genius in it's composition and pacing at times, while other times... not as much. When this record really has my attention I really love it. The soundscapes created by Tortoise are unique enough where I can see myself coming back to this to turn my brain off for the night and enjoy it's depth and serenity. When it meanders, it's really not for long. I can easily overlook that. However, at 42 minutes and a whopping 6 tracks - it's not a behemoth like Music Has The Right To Children, which I believe this album is very much like in delivery. I am looking forward to checking out other work from Tortoise to see if there's more under the surface. Highlights: Djed, Glass Museum, Along the Banks of Rivers Lowlight: A Survey
2.5 Really frustrating in that everytime it seemed to be building to something good it just faded out instead. At certain points there also seemed to be one annoying instrument/sound ruining otherwise pleasant music
Das Album wirkt heute erstaunlich blutleer. Die langen Passagen verlieren schnell an Spannung, viele Ideen bleiben skizzenhaft, und der Flow bricht immer wieder weg. Man hört den Anspruch, aber er trägt nicht durch. Unterm Strich mehr Konzept als Wirkung.
Easy five
I like a lot of the groups that came along in the next wave of instrumental rock/post-rock, but I see where this was a big influence. I have to be in the right mood, but I enjoy putting this style on as background music.
just stellar in self-evident ways im struggling to pontificate on. one sorta useful (if insulting simple) way to think ab post rock is the more ambient Static Sense Of Place on one end, and the gradual Actively Going Somewhere on the other. talk talk is more about the stillness, godspeed is more about the Moving. tortoise, at least on this album, land on a pretty interesting spot...its definitely Accumulation Music, which gives it this sense of motion as it evolves, but its so much about the immediate textures that im never really thinking about where the music is heading Towards, exactly. kind of a boring entry lol but man its a great album u all know that i hope. its got jazz, its got synths, its got structural power, those are the three elements of literally all good music ever...........
5/10 Really nice background music at times, but still background music. There was something about 'A Survey' that I enjoyed - the comfort of warm and clean acoustic guitar gently picking over the ambience of crickets in the night. Great track. I didn't connect with the last three tracks at all. Best track: A Survey Will I revisit?: Likely while working or focusing
"Yo La Tengo"-esque I don't have enough patience for this sort of thing
ohhhhh this is a good one when i saw the track listing had the length of the first track, "djed", as "half the damn album", i had no idea what to expect but wow. its amazing. 21 minutes of rich texture, evolving minute to minute. it starts in an almost-danceable drone and moves through a variety of different sounds, never staying in one spot for too long. i was gonna write a whole blow-by-blow description of the entire track but it'd take thousands of words, u really gotta just listen to it. the best i can do in brief is to say it feels equal parts fuck buttons, mike oldfield and boards of canada, with the balance between them shifting movement to movement. but that doesn't do it justice at all and honestly is total bullshit cos really this isn't like anything i've heard before. its incredible. after somethin of that calibre i was worried it'd fall off in the back half but nah, it totally sticks the landing and brings even more diversity to the table. "a survey" feels like its trying to lead me somewhere in a dark forest, "the taut and tame" appeals to me deeply with its fast paced rhythm and bitcrushed cheap casio ass synth, and "dear grandma and grandpa" is honestly bordering on ambient techno. its really fuckin good. i should note that i've based my review on the standard edition but imo with or without the jp edition bonus tracks it's still a solid 5 out of 5. without is for sure a more cohesive experience, u can really feel the break after the main album and the bonus tracks feel almost like an encore....? but it's a really strong encore. especially "gamera". damn.. another album that got the "i love music" reaction from me. i will be giving this one many more listens i think.
Now that was so gorgeous and unexpected. I'm already pretty fond of instrumental albums but this was a real treat. Each song delivers soundscapes that flux and flow; the mind wanders easily without being taken out and interrupted by new sound additions. The balance here is incredible. I had to reel in my initial instinct to give it a 5, as "Djed" is so so strong as the frontloader, and after thinking on the whole (and an immediate second listen) it's a high 4, like 4.7/5, which I'm gonna round into a 5 anyway.
One of the first records in post-rock genre. You can feel punk influence. I like it!
For me Tortoise always represented the labcoat end of post-rock and as such were not necessarily my favourites of that music critic cooked up genre. I prefer the loud/quiet angst of Slint, the beautiful smothering intensity of Labradford or the elegaic end-of-the-world-sadness of GYBE! I'm not sure any of these bands have that much in common other than a commitment in the 90s to not succumb to rock nostalgia which was everywhere at the time and remains rock's dominant mode up to today. Tortoise probably sound most like they were trying to make prog for people with short hair and no interest in wizards. I can just about relate them to Soft Machine or Hatfield and the North. Nothing wrong in that. I like what they are doing but I feel kept at arms length emotionally. Maybe that's because out of all the big post-rock groups they seem closest to trying to meet the then current challenge of techno's impersonality in the way they use rhythm and texture. I listened to this on streaming but I still had a nanosecond of "this CD is skipping" about two thirds of the way into Djed.
snoozefest but not unpleasant
This was pretty cool.
My husband: 'there's better post rock...'
Pierwsza piosenka to 20 minut totalnego chaosu, nic do siebie nie pasuje, chaos zmienia się w hałas a ten w normalną muzykę. Potem jest już nieco lepiej, ale nadal nie na tyle, abym nazwała odsłuchiwanie tej płyty przyjemnym przeżyciem. Kto czegoś takiego słucha z własnej woli? 4/10.
The first track is one of my favorite tunes of the 1990s. Deeeeep bass I could listen to all day. Cavernous.
An interesting album choice for this project. While it has the same structure as some of the prog rock albums in this collection (including the recent ELP dud "Tarkus")--a super long first track/side with somewhat distinct movements, then shorter (and presumably unrelated) tracks to round out the album--I was really reminded more of Kraftwerk's "Autobahn", no doubt due to the instrumental/electronic focus (especially so with "Djed"). I'm not sure exactly why the Wikipedia entry repeatedly mentioned how they were big in the "post-rock" scene (although my confusion is maybe more about that term, I suppose), but I guess I wouldn't have called their music "rock" in any real sense (except maybe "Along the banks of rivers"), and much of this album seems more indebted to Philip Glass or perhaps the avant-garde aspects of industrial/experimental music. Either way, I enjoyed it, but more as background music than something that kept my attention. I'm also mildly intrigued by the album title, given its connection to a seemingly incorrect prediction by the Jehovah Witnesses that the world would end in 1925 (with salvation for many).
A little Twin Peaks-y, esp the last track, but this isn't bad, just a heads up. Atmospheric but not too in your face and sort of low-key progressive. May also be the source of the vague nausea I've felt ever since starting this for the third time.
this made me feel like i was going insane
No classical music at all in this list (and almost no music from before 1955) but tons of ambient noise….. completely inane
This was such a fun listening experience. Most of the time I checked the player and said to myself "its still the same song?!". That's a good and bad thing, but mostly good. I enjoy Post-Rock from time to time. Djed is obviously the standout track, so many movements, it's a full symphony within a song. It's a shame that the shorter songs feel half baked Ideas instead of finished work, mostly sound as if they were demos. The Tout and the Tame was my favorite, reminded me of Stereolab. Curious to listen to TNT and other Tortoise albums, hopefully i'll find something that I like more than the second half of this album
feliz que terei alguns álbuns instrumentais nessa lista, e peguei o meu primeiro. não muito do que eu costumo ouvir quando se trata de instrumental, mas foi bem divertido. ps: ouvi enquanto lavava a cama do meu gato favorita: djed
So glad there were no lyrics because this was a GREAT instrumental album
I didn't mind this. Would make decent focus kind of music.
very enjoyable
I am a latecomer to the greatness of Tortoise and finally saw them live at Big Ears last year. This is not music for every mood for me, but seeing it live is pretty incredible.
Some music is a matter of taste and Tortoise is definitely that. But I love everything about it. Two basses, xylophones, meandering compositions, the drumming, it's all great. It's just art, don't overthink it.
Meh, background music again. And please, no 20 minute songs ever
I know I probably just don’t get it but I really don’t. It’s not bad, musically, just boring.
This was a good surprise. I have never heard of them before. Perfect for my work mix.
I mean, its interesting and it is definitely different than anything being put out commercially at the time. I appreciate the odd time signatures and changes. No one needs to hear this before they die.
Very impressive instrumentation, atmosphere, and songwriting on this album. Shout out David Pajo. 8/10
What the heck is ‘Post Rock’ as a genre? If it’s where you find all the pointless music, then I see how this fits. What a waste of time.
The write up was actually better than the album. Shame, I was intrigued to begin with, then I was waiting for it to end swiftly. A bit of a non entity.
Trash.
ehh prva pjesma od 20min....nisu pink floyd...you are not him
3/5
When i saw the band name and year, I was expecting some US alt-rock but what I got was quite different! I've seen it labelled as post-rock but I found a distinct lack of the rock half of that equation, leaning more into immersive soundscapes and jazz-influenced textures. Not that that's a bad thing and this wasn't unpleasant but it would take multiple listens to unwrap it and it's not going to get that time right now.
Love that it Tjed opens and lays out the plan. The bass and drum solid says it all straight out. Subtle, inventive, intriguing, I'm out of adjectives. Love this.
Quite enjoyable although I couldn’t get completely swept away. Made me yearn for Angelo Badalamenti.
I've always enjoyed this one, though never been swept away by it. Still, there are some nice moments.
Oh man I loved this! Was not familiar with the band or the individual members but reading about them they certainly have put in some work. I've been in a real Sigur Ros/Jonsi mood since returning from Reykjavik and Tortoise easily slips into my current state of mind.
7.5/10
Favorite Track: Glass Museum
A bit of a nightmare to rate. Honestly, it was just kind of there. I trust that this was important, but it's not doing a great deal for me.
What I would describe as ambient rock. Favourite track: Glass Museum
Não curti não, não é meu tipo de som!
Very good breakfast music with the girls, never heard before
wow! really surprising! fully enjoyed. Reminded me of "Friends of Dean Martinez". [ykiwyki)
It might be slightly odd that one track is more than half the album, but it's a sprawling epic so go on then. The flip side can feel patchy by comparison but by no means an afterthought.
Actually very good weird experimental rock stuff. The pureelectronic songs weren't all that great but that's like a total of 10% of this album, the first two songs are rather amazing and the other rock songs are also great
I know this list is meant to expand horizons, but I just am not a 20 minute song type of girlypop. sorry. Is what they do with those 20 minutes, and however many minutes the other songs were, interesting? yes. Will I ever think "hey, i wanna sit down and listen to this album" again? no I was gonna put this as a 3, cause honestly it's fine, but like there more it went on the more my soul died, so 2
Never gonna be my favorite post rock classic but I appreciate it for its idiosyncrasies and lower stakes.
Front to back fantastic and absorbing soundscapes
Really fantastic stuff. Quite staggering. "Djed" feels like a drive through a factory town.
post rock has never super been my thing but this was fairly digestible as they come!
Why...? This is tedious.
Instrumental, but kinda thin in structure and idea. Sounds like music that should have singing over it .
Tough music for a treadmill. A strange addition to the list.
First time listening to this band, maybe the best background music yet, lots of crazy textures and sounds.
OH DAMN I LOVE TORTOISE NOW
To be listened to
Es wabert so vor sich hin. Nicht unangnehm. Fans finden bestimmt auch etwas, dass sie begeistert. Ich bin kein Fan, für mich wurde es mit der Zeit langweilig. 2/5
I’m not sure how I feel about this album. I enjoyed it but I think the album can challenge you because it seems like there isn’t a destination and just a journey. It’s a decent journey. The people play extremely well and know where they’re going it’s just not exciting along the way.
I was going to write a little essay about how I don’t understand post rock well enough to rate it, but I actually really enjoyed this so I’m just going to give it a five.
Das war... Interessant. Sonst kann ich nichts gutes darüber sagen. Mit gefallen 2/6 Songs: 'Glass Museum' war okay, und 'Along the Banks of Rivers' war interessant. Noch Etwas: wenn man einen 21 Minuten Song macht muss er interresant sein, wie z.B.: Waco, Texas von Ethel Cain (15 min), oder America von Prince (21 min), und wenn es noch dazu ein Instrumental ist, dann ist es normalerweise nur gut wenn es Jazz ist. Leider nicht so gut..
Langweilig
A nice listen while working, wouldn't just listen to it though
I like Tortoise a lot, but seems like TNT would be the pick to go on this list. Huh... Still, maybe this one will get some fresh listeners.
Yeah this just wasn't good. It just felt like noise half the time. I couldn't follow what was happening and it just wasn't very interesting. The songs I "liked" had moments, but I don't know if I would call them good. Actual 1.5. Liked Songs: "Glass Museum" and "The Taut and Tame"
03/03/26
its nice ambience i guess but i would never willfully listen again fav song: Along the Banks of Rivers
More 'post-rock' random noise.
another one of thes 20 minutes lead-off songs. I'm not sure how this got a record deal ... sounds like guys futzing with stuff ... I guess if you were incapable of futzing yourself, you might want to listen to someone elses futz?
3/5
I get the impression thar 1001 albums does not choose a band's best albums but has a preference towards early/imfluential albums. So instead of TNT or standards, we get Millions Now Living ...
В песнях нет слов и у меня тоже (но вообще прикольно)
This album led me down the Wikipedia wormhole of post-rock. The music is interesting, but I didn't love it.
Some good stuff in there especially that second (?) song
Very boring but not annoying, other than the first track being 20 minutes long.
I enjoyed this more than I expected.
Very strange instrumental album that I got bored of really fast, there was both too much and not enough going on at the same time.
A pretty good instrumental chill album.
This is a great vibe! I've listened to it before, but it's been a while. This and the next one , TNT, are just great background/focus albums. There are some albums on this list that I've said are good for background music and most of them are Just that. But this holds up under active listening, too. The music is great, intricate and experimental, and always solidly done. It's one of those that I won't really point at a particular song because I just think of the whole thing as one listen. Even the way it's set up promotes that "whole album" listen vibe because the first song meanders and changes and sounds like different songs just as much as the others that are individually named do. Great album. Worth listening to and being on the list. But I can't see giving it a 5 either. I like everything about it, but if it hadn't popped up, I don't know that it has made such an impression on me that I'd have remembered to come back to it. Did it change music and influence dozens of bands? I don't really think so. So, it's great, but not historically noteworthy or groundbreaking. Going with the 4!
Not unpleasant but not particularly inspiring
Q pedo rolas de 20 minutos jajajaj
The hell was that? Goodness sakes, was this tedious collection of sounds supposed to be enjoyable music?
So glad to rediscover this after many years. I listened to Tortoise a bit when I was a University Student, but not with a lot of attention. I's a musical journey with lots of different moments and paths that I enjoyied explore.
8/10
Haven't heard of them. I have a headache today, not a good time to listen to it. But I think even without one I still wouldn't like it, it's just random sounds 2/5
dull
I had listened to “Djed” before after seeing it on Pitchfork’s top 100 songs of the 90’s or some such, but the rest of this was new to me. Chill, non-abrasive, mid-tempo instrumentals are fine with me. They aren’t something I’m particularly into but I have no beef with them. But this album was released on January 30, 1996, and Hanson would put out “MMMBop” on March 24, 1997. If Tortoise had recorded “MMMBop” instead of this then they could have beaten Hanson to the punch and had a hit. The path not taken, you know?
I liked the sounds, very experimental but it made me want to buy a synthesizer!
Cool atmospheric post-rock.
Little disappointed. I thought I’d love this, but I kept waiting for something to happen, then it ended.
I went into this album without any knowledge of the group or the recording and it blew me away. It's not surprising that David Pajo was involved in this because the production and style reminds me a lot of his work in other bands. It's a terrific record that extends rock in a new and interesting way.
Djed didn’t work for me and that song’s half the album. Liked Glass Museum though
When I think something good is gonna happen, nothing does. Then I noticed it's an instrumental album. I mean, there’s nothing surprising or really good about this album, but it’s not garbage either. Maybe someday I’ll listen to Tortoise again.
Didn't hate it, but would never put this on
None of these songs will be added to a playlist, but I found this album immensely satisfying. So chirpy and bouncy, but with this heavy undertone. I can easily focus whilst this is on, and have it guide my thoughts
This album was okay. Definitely had some unique songs and instrumentation. I particularly like the choice of percussion instruments in this album. One negative note about this album is I think some of it is too experimental, in that some of the music was thrown together to see what sticks. Each song felt like there was a slow somewhat boring ethereal parts sandwiched by sections that actually were very good at portraying a story or scenery through sound. Not a bad album, I will have to listen to it again I think to understand it thoroughly.
I think this is my introduction to post-rock? Or at the very least, this is the first time it clicked with me. To draw a dartboard comparison, some aspect of this album reminded me of the Minecraft soundtrack, which is weird to say but I think it rings true. There are defined melodies here, something that is much appreciated when I listen to these experimental leaning albums. Even more so, this album almost feels like jazz, only swapping out a few instruments for ones more often found in rock music. It's a bit repetitive and freeform at times, but for what it is I think it does a really nice job at not overstaying its welcome and presenting appealing musical ideas. Highlight: The Taut and Tame Lowlight: Dear Grandma and Grandpa
Caught my ear as a nice background to work, looking forward to another though, 3.5 rounding down with promise of looking forward to more
Ambient oddness. Not very compelling.
Just because it’s post rock doesn’t mean it’s an “album to listen to before you die”
It was boring/ awful. Couldn't finish it. No point just synths.
Sinceramente muito inspirador!!
Man, that was a hard listen
oh, well. the tracks lead nowhere.
i was gonna say that this album would be dope asl with some vocals, but actually im glad they just let the instruments breathe. insanely good production and atmosphere. this was such a sick listen cool asf
Сложно не воспринимать пост-рок не как фоновую музыку, особенно если вообще нет вокала. Но тут ещё и краут-рок затесался
Мало знаком с пост-роком, как таковым, только очень поверхностно. Соответственно, фанатом не являюсь и мало что по-настоящему оценил. И ожидал, что это будет примерно то же самое, с поправкой на более раннюю эпоху. В целом, так и получилось, но само качество музыки меня приятно удивило. Зачастую альбомы надоедают к концу, здесь же наоборот, сначала было скучновато, и я уже думал, что весь альбом окажется пустым фоновым эмбиентом, но где-то с середины Djed вдруг начались интересные (для 90х) эксперименты со звуком, а следующие более короткие треки и вовсе зацепили приятными мелодиями и нестандартными размерами. В итоге даже не хотелось, чтобы альбом заканчивался. Да, это все еще фоновая музыка, но в то же время и нечто большее. С пост-роком вообще зачастую сложно что-то объяснить и проанализировать - тебя либо цепляет, либо не цепляет. В меня попало, даже интересно послушать что еще есть у этих ребят.
Нот май тайп оф шит. Не знала о них до этого и вряд ли включу еще раз. Нормик, но без вокала утомительно.
Один из самых любимых пост-рок альбомов. Для меня тут нет проходных моментов, а последний трек так вообще в моем списке фаворитов за все время.
Лучшая песня: Glass Museum Худшая: Djed Нормальный пост-рок, ничего сверхъестественного. Те же Bark Psychosis были раньше, но звучат поинтереснее. Не знаю, почему именно этот альбом был выбран среди миллиона подобных пластинок. Ждём Godspeed You! Black Emperor?
Неплохой построк, но я люблю более мрачный и тяжелый. Топ трек - glass museum
звучит интересно, но не зацепило, возможно нужно будет вернуться через время и переслушать
Прослушала на фоне, для такого идеальная музыка. Но закончился альбом, и я даже не поняла, что это какой - то другой трек. Поэтому от меня только 3 балла. Также забыла отрецензировать альбом Snoop Dogg. Что со мной сделал этот челендже, если я вижу альбом 1993 года и радуюсь тому, что это новье. Несмотря на год выхода для меня прозвучал современнее недавнего альбома OutKast, который слушали. Качает Снуп классно
Не моё. Что слушал - что не слушал.
Haven't listened to this one in years. Used to have this in heavy rotation back in the early 2000s. I actually like all of the songs on this record better than "Djed;" having been in many an aimless jam session, I recognize the signs, and "Djed" really should've been edited down a bit more. The transitions are excellent, but there is just too much fat on this for me. The rest of the record is brilliant though. "Glass Museum" and "Along the Banks of the Rivers" are both full of beautiful moments. FOUR STARS
It was ok to have on in the background as I drove home. Nothing too offensive and it washed over just nice
Terrible
Pass
Insanely boring. Disappointing since I normally enjoy ambient/background music, but this had a stronger "I didn't need to hear this before I died" vibe than usual.
15 minutes into the first track, loving the hypnotic sounds that harken to StereoLab but remain their own. Some bits hinted at Primus/Les Claypool. Some were more jazz influenced. Fits into the world of "Knitting Factory Jazz" in my lexicon. Adding to my list of things to go back to, and I'll look for their vinyl. Ends with a call back to Wandering Star from Portishead. This brought me joy.
At the beginning, I thought I’d dread listening to this album throughout the whole runtime, but once it got that groove going in the first song, it changed my mind. The whole album isn’t like that and I would say less than half of it is exciting to listen to, but it definitely has its moments.
I enjoyed this more than I expected to. It was ambient and I found myself thinking that I couldn't picture them at a concert, but it was well built. I really liked it on headphones.
Oh this is cool start. Yeah, this first track is wild. 15 minutes in and I kind of wanted to start again before it ended. Track 2 keeps it up. Especially in that second half. I wish I had heard of this sooner. It would have been perfect for my long walks home in the late 1990s. Good album name, good album art, a river of instrumentation.
Totally fine. Guys are certainly messing around at times and having a good time, but I didn't find anything really groundbreaking here. Not unlistenable at the slightest, just didn't feel cohesive in any bit. Plus a hugely long song at the start really made me concerned that this album was going to be a real multi hour slogfest, but it's not.
Post rock. Would have to listen more to properly rate
Started off extremely annoyed but ended up pleasantly surprised. That’s math rock, baby
Idk why but this kicked my ADHD's ass. Enjoyed overall and will probably listen again when I have to do something I've been procrastinating.
The first song was a hellscape of elevator music lasting eons (okay 16 minutes but still). The rest was kind of more of the same
David Pajo i see you ! really nice loved it
One of the few entirely instrumental rock projects to be included in the book, Millions Now Living Will Never Die is an interesting amalgamation of genres. It's the first of two albums by Tortoise to feature Pajo of Slint fame on bass, uncoincidentally being their two best albums by a long shot. The album starts out slow and smooth with Djed, taking a few minutes to get warmed up before jumping into some lush yet soothing atmospheric Post-Rock. I love the minimalism influence on this record, particularly on Djed, but also on Glass Museum and Along the Banks of Rivers. I think playing around with monotonous and repetitive elements while letting the atmosphere move around them is a great idea when well-executed and I think they did a fair job executing it here. My biggest critique is shared with the other Pajo album TNT; there really isn't much direction or growth throughout the record. Slow builds and crescendos are absolutely my favorite part of Post-Rock as a genre, and though there's some dynamic contrast MNLWND is relatively stagnant, remaining in that mezzo piano softness and rarely leaving. It's relaxing and meditative to be sure, but lacks much intrigue or excitement. Overall though the textures are really nice and the soundscapes they make are lovely. They lose me a little bit near the end of the record, but I feel like this record is designed (or at least best suited) for background listening, and I'm not just saying that because it's instrumental.
certainly not essential. side one is like a teen in the 80's getting a cool new keyboard and doing some noodling at home. side two is nothing that hasn't been done a thousand times in the past. like Focus or Mono with about 1/4th of the talent. "A Survey"... really? this is bollocks. for real. SCORES of amazing beautiful music out there and some pick this for album of the year?? i think the critics are hard up for what real music WAS.
Math-y Metal-y. Pretty good!
To be honest, this album has been really boring and feels likr it drags on for centuries. Who thought a 20 minute song was a good idea? If I heard this in an elevator, it would take me a solid 5 minutes to notice it wasn't elevator music
Interesting arrangements and sonic landscapes. Chilled.
Hmm not sure what I think about this album.🤔 Giving it three for creativity
I'm not really sure what to say except it was weird...
New to me and pleasantly surprising. Worth your time.
Interesting album, wouldn’t say I would seek it out but it was cool to have on to sort of set a mood
Très bonne surprise!!
Instrumental. Just not my kind of instrumental. 2/5.
Exceptional album
Listen I like weird stuff but this was just random sounds and stuff the album
Weird again. Not sure how I felt about it really. Listenable, background music. Nothing too exciting though.
Chill, bit tripy. The first song has a funny break i thought the connection is breaking
Bakgrundsmusik
Det här är behagligt, även om det mer är något som jag skulle dra på i bakgrunden än aktivt lyssna på. Att låta första låten vara halva albumets längd är också helt klart ett val.
Trollar de?
För historielös vad gäller postrock för att sätta högre, men det är ju najs det jag hör!
I had been meaning to explore Tortoise more for a long time now. Really glad this album was served up. I'm a sucker for this style. Post-rock, art rock, somewhat experimental. I'll agree with the one reviewer who said that that track order should have been a bit different. That's first song is a bit overly ambitious to kickoff an album and should have been at the end. It's a bit different from typical post-rock in that if doesn't follow that formula of soft melody that builds to a great crescendo that is then deconstructed. I'm looking forward to my next listen of this one for sure.
got excited to see it's only 6 tracks before i realized the first track is like 20+ minutes. i'm willing to keep an open mind tho Djed - 3/5 Glass Museum - 5/5 A Survey - 2/5 The Taut and Tame - 4/5 Dear Grandma and Grandpa - 2/5 Along the Banks of Rivers - 5/5 Average score: 3.5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ based on the length of the first track, i was ready to give this 1 star and keep it pushing. boy was i wrong i think my enjoyment of this album is a bit mixed, of course, but i think there's quite a bit to appreciate about it too. it's experimental for sure, but not in an off-putting way like some others i've heard; it's actually quite soothing and meditative i definitely never would've seeked this out on my own, but for once, i can say i'm glad the author put me on to this. for that, i'll generously round my scoring up this time
Interesting. I didn't mid it as background music. Nothing that really caught my attention spectacularly or would make me seek them out. 2.
I had no idea what to expect from this album and now that I have listened to it I have no real idea of what to say. It’s a lot of prolonged variations on musical themes and I think it’s worth listening to, but I also had a hard time staying focused on it and often felt my mind wander. Still glad I gave it a spin overall.
A bit boring.
nothing happens there are no songs really just pleasant noise for a long period of time I feel I am being very generous in giving it two but I have heard worse albums on the list.
Sleeper hit.
Not for me
Choppy, instrumental, mildly-jazzy electro stuff. Interesting, sure. Just not that exciting or memorable. And I'm a guy who likes instrumental post-rock.
Many years ago, when I was on college radio, I accidentally played Tortoise when I was supposed to be playing jazz because I grabbed from the wrong shelf. The music was inoffensive but not what I wanted. Same goes for this one. I will say that this record would be much MUCH more enjoyable if they took that opening track ("Djed") and stuck it at the end instead of the beginning. I assume they lose 90% of potential listeners in the first two minutes because of that; the rest of the record is better. So if you're struggling, try skipping that one.
Really moving stuff
Yay! This was on my "to listen" list, and this was a great excuse to hear it! Really cool music, weird but melodic, and I wouldn't bat an eyelid if it came out last week :)
No standouts, but inoffensive
Terrible
I’ve had to listen to this a couple of times to get the hang of it. It’s not exactly catchy. More like Brian Eno ambient mixed with Steve Reich rhythms and David Lynch moodiness. In fact, it could be a soundtrack album. You won’t leave it humming a tune necessarily, but it’s intriguing.
Really enjoyed this, added to the listening roster. Great early post rock.
Not a big fan of music without lyrics, I can see myself studying or reading to this album though.
Here's the Bandcamp link if you want to avoid the warmongering and AI-shitified Spotify https://tortoise.bandcamp.com/album/millions-now-living-will-never-die
UGH WHY
Glorified music for studying.
Rewards patience in a similar way to Philip Glass
I was introduced to this album via a post-rock playlist on Tidal a few weeks before this generated, so it was great to get a chance to dig further into the album. This band is a great discovery for me, surprised I hadn't listened to them before since I am a big fan of a lot of their contemporaries. I love everything about this album really, especially the variety and experimentation. I've since bought this album and TNT, so can't really give it less than 5 stars!
It really is amazing that I have never heard of this band, I can hear there influence or so many artists I am a huge fan of. If you are into varied textures and non standard song structures this one might be for you!
This album caught me on the wrong day. I had a driveway to shovel and was excited for the chance to listen to my album while I did it. This kind of music can be saved by vocals but without any it's boring as shit. It's all one long intro. 1.5
За гурт чув, але ніколи не слухав до цього. Сподобався пост-рок заміс з ф'юженом. Особливо, коли в більш джеззі моменти уходить, то чудовий взагалі. Буду ще слухати далі, є потенціал на 5.
Дуже люблю цей гурт, а Millions Now Living Will Never Die є на вінілі в мене. Такого пост-рока треба більше, не тупориле псевдодраматичне тремоло, а вигадлива, технічна інструментальна музика з прекрасною атмосферою.
Cool! Not something I would have found on my own. I might be going back to this one later.
Digga an sich echt cool höre ich mir sage irgendwann nichmal an im gym kann man sich das nur bei bestem willen nicht geben gerade am leg day
A lot to unpack in a single evening of listening. Loads of ideas and noise, arty, cinema style, picture painting, but not particularly enjoyable at first listen. I imagine this will need multiple goes to get into.
4 plus 1 star to counter haters.
2.5
big video game vibes. the jehovah witness background made me laugh. Not great but I vibed
amazing.
no
Seemed a bit post-rock, which in general I like. Some of it strayed into prog/jazz sounds, which I am less keen on. Overall positive though.
I'd never heard of Tortoise, but this mellow, instrumental album impressed me.
I've been getting into post rock more and more so this is a sweet spot for me. Solid album and I will look into these guys more down the road.
Never heard of this album or even the band. This is also the first time I’ve avoided all reviews before I listened so I could really have my own experience. Regarding the album -- I love this. It set a fabulous chill vibe and mood I'd love to explore again and again. This is getting me at the right time. It brought me into its little world and took me on a fun ride. I'll add it to my collection and will happily revisit more in the future. A fun new discovery and an instant 5 for me.
please abolish 20 minute songs
Didn't even know what genre this was for the first few minutes. Turns out, Earth meets jazz. I love Earth. I love post rock. I don't love jazz. So I don't love this. Along tt Bank of Rivers the best song as it sounded a bit Western. On other tracks it was like they'd just discovered xylophones and glockenspiels and wanted to shoehorn them in to half the songs.
This was pretty nice, but it did get a little too chill for me, like to the point where I get distracted too easily. There was a wasp in our kitchen and I had to open the windows. You know, that sort of thing. I really like post rock, but I like it as it is quite exciting and in your face. This is neither. It's not bad, it's just nice and relatively forgettable.
what do you mean a 20min music ?!
meh. 2.5 stars
Great instrumental rock album Standout song Djed
In a sense, post-rock went where prog never could, i.e., besides the best of Floyd or King Crimson, the progers were too early to the party of strange & experimental notions. Tho 'rock' was still a possibility at the time Tortoise emerged, following the lessons of Talk Talk, the group understood that it could all now be reengineered. In reality, this record has next to nothing to do w/ rock, being more of a conflation of techno, jazz, and European forms, and really only the ideas of those genres. Even when the electric guitar is the most predominant instrument, I think of Sun Ra more than Jimi Hendrix. And yet, tho I respect and enjoy this more than records by ELP or Rush, it ultimately suffers from the same defects: it's boring, it's dead, it's snooty.
All-instrumental band Tortoise may be from Chicago but their music has clear antecedents in German rock bands from the 70's like Neu! and Can, as is most evident on the opening track, the 20-minute epic "Djed". Other influences like Eno, King Crimson and Steve Reich can be heard on this record, but it does maintain its own idiosyncratic identity, which is especially on display in the lyrical guitar melodies and lush textures heard in the tracks on side two. The record does drag in a couple of spots and there are a few less-than-stellar tracks but for the most part this album works well as a cohesive whole.
Never heard of this band before, was surprised to see a 90s indie rock band on this list I’ve never even heard of. This is apparently a really influential post-rock album. First track was 20 minutes long and bored me to death but the rest was perfectly fine and quite nice at times. Felt like a more boring and mellow take on one of those turn of the millennium emo-leaning math rock bands. Like Polvo or Don Caballero or something. It was pleasant to listen to but I didn’t really connect with it that much.
Interesting in places
Interesting concept but I can’t say I found it that enjoyable. I doubt I’ll ever listen to this again.
In places it was good background music but it really lacks any punch and ends up being quite dull.
Rather bittersweet this one. We wait patiently for 473 albums and FINALLY we get some (kind of) post-rock. Shame is, this is very dull, barely getting up above walking pace. Please let there be some ‘Mogwai’ and ‘Godspeed You! Black Emperor’ coming up to save the day and the genre ratings. We desperately need some proper quiet/loud/quiet/loud. Please list, I’m begging!!!
Fine background music. But overall a real yawn.
Swings from sounding like parody of Muzak to sounding like incomplete tracks to someone learning how to use their Casio keyboard.
Day722 -meh, i don’t care for instrumental albums but it does kinda sound like band of horses if you get rid of the stupid keyboard sounds
Progish background music. Pretty at times and melodic, and then deconstructed. Not really what I needed today, but knowing this exists might help in the future. That first song, though... man... everyone says it's long, and that's both a warning and a blessing. It's pretty, but LONG and repetitive. My Rating: 4/5
A good respite from the usual, I greatly prefer this to the electronic music on the list. Musician making music.
3.5 Ambient music with the slappy clappy drum and a myserious pseudo-philosophical title has been done so many times
Definitely not for me
Utterly delicious instrumental post rock, dripping with ideas, melody, intrigue, and subtlety. The opening track fills all of side one and threatens to dominate the album with its delicate balance between scripted perfection and loose jam. Successful and captivating as it remains across its 20+ mins, it can’t dominate when side two packs just as much joy into briefer segments. They went on to make at least 2 better albums than Millions…, but this set very high bar for expectations.
Millions Now Living Will Never Die by Tortoise was completely new to me and unfortunately, not in a good way. I went in open-minded, but the album quickly became a slog. What’s often praised as experimental and forward-thinking landed here as pointless. Rather than drawing me in, the album felt like a test of endurance, with tracks that just did nothing for me at all. There’s no moment that stood out enough to redeem the listen, and by the end I was relieved it was over. Favourite track: None – I struggled to find anything enjoyable. Least favourite track: Every track felt equally tedious. Album artwork: Ironically, the highlight. A genuinely cool and appealing cover
Don’t mind instrumental stuff, though this was a bit weird at times. Better than I anticipated though
Very interesting and experimental rock album. It falls under the Post-Rock genre but, because it was still early in the movement's history, it is not plagued by the Godspeed You! Black Emperor-aping crescendocore structure that has became so prevalent during the 00's. Tortoise's following album, TNT, is also great and quite different from this one. Key tracks: Djed The Taut and the Tame
Really cool instrumentation and production
Come for Djed and stay for...well, come for Djed.
A really fascinating album, I actually really enjoyed it. I want to give it another listen soon, it’s so weird and jazzy. Four for now, but I might switch it to a five.
If someone told me this was the soundtrack to an Italian art house film about watching paint dry (the extended directors cut) I wouldn't be surprised.
Good as a film soundtrack maybe but definitely not my thing
You know it’s very ok when I forgot to do my review after listening and can’t remember what the album even sounded like. I think this was just ambient music with no vocals that was kind of relaxing. 5/10
Loved this. Nice find!
I don’t like 20 min songs
Quite relaxing to listen to overall. Can’t say I’ve ever come across these guys before. Feels a bit like being in a fancy coffee shop with some pleasant ambient background music but there are better choices to listen to if I want something like this. Technically competent but a bit uninspiring. 3.5*
Sucks tortouse balls, sounds like whale sounds with a crappy drummer
This is the least offensive album I’ve had of the last 3 by a landslide. I’m conflicted about rating it. It really feels like nothing more than background music. It’s good background music, but do I need to hear background music before I die?
3.5