Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line

Penance Soiree

The Icarus Line

2.5
Rating
22884
Votes
1
17%
2
34%
3
33%
4
13%
5
3%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 8)

This one is weird. I could see myself liking it given enough listens but its not pleasant enough tor me to want to do that

God, this was boring.

A wall of noise. Literal screaming involved for too long at one point.

Fun and lively post punk album!

Did not like

Nr. 34/1001 Up Against The Wall Motherfucker 3/5 Spit On It 2/5 On The Lash 2/5 Caviar 2/5 Spike Island 2/5 Kiss Like Lizards 1/5 Getting Bright At Night 2/5 Big Sleep 2/5 White Devil 2/5 Meatmaker 1/5 Virgin Velcro 2/5 Sea Sick 2/5 Party The Baby Off 2/5 Average: 1,92 Plain, boring and repetitve

damn this is a load of shit

This is like discount Iceage without the hooks or the interesting guitar riffs. Average noisy indie rock band makes an average noisy indie rock album. Nothing much else to say here. (These songs feel way too long)

What does this album bring to the cultural conversation? I'm struggling to understand why I needed to hear this album before I died.

Just not my vibe. Great for someone that likes this genre.

in two minds about this one... I like the vibe but not sure if I will listen to again. No specific tracks stood out

not good

Not my style

es overstimulated mich aber an sich ist es ein sehr gutes album. sehr laut

Basically every one of these songs starts great and ruins itself over the course of 2-5 minutes

YIKES: this wasn't at all good. Why this album is quite on the list I do not know. Wasn't the pleasant listening journey it should've been. The guitar was loud and jarring and paired with the occasional random outbursts of gain just making it loud and horrible to listen, this wasn't at all good. Also I feel an album from 2014, the era of streaming, with each song under 100k streams on Spotify and under 2000 monthly listeners, this record isn't nearly as influential and important as some of the albums not on this list. Also if an album has this book at the top of the wikipedia page it's a massive red flag.

4.5 stars. This album gets after it. A little muddled and overly distorted at times, but for the most part it's just really good rowdy post-hardcore. Starting with "Spike Island" it takes off, and the standout is "Getting Bright At Night".

Not my type

Essential Tracks: Virgin Velcro (Playlist)

This is what a mix between early naughts retro-rock, Stooges Funhouse-era proto-punk, and nineties post-hardcore should probably sound like. Not that a lot of people really aked for such a mix to exist. Not inherently bad, with quite a few intense moments performance-wise, yet a bit lackluster in terms of hooks and truly memorable moments. Not everyone can have the scenic presence and/or the catchy vocal lines of a Iggy Pop or a Cedric Bixler-Zavala. 2/5 for the purposes of this list of essential albums, translating to a 7/10 grade for more general purposes (5 + 2). Number of albums left to review: 398 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 271 Albums from the list might* include in mine later on: 144 Albums from the list I won't include in mine (many others are more essential to me): 189 (including this one)

Icarus Line kicking out the jams! Feeling some heavy Iggy Pop and MC5 vibes off this record.

I'm not sure why this made the list. Fuzzy, muddy, noisy, these are not inherently bad qualities, but monotonous generally is. The songs really run together, and nothing seems memorable here. "Getting Bright At Night" was a good track for a while, but it's 9 minutes long and about 2/3 of the way through starts sounding like everything else on the album.

If the Hives, Soundgarden, NIN, and Smashing Pumpkins has a love child. Not my fave genre but some cool production elements. Spit on It awesomely jagged; really liked drum and bass on Caviar. Otherwise prob won’t revisit

It's weird, I remember Googling Aaron North (the guitarist from Icarus Line) a while back because I remembered him from his time in Nine Inch Nails, and never knew Icarus Line was as big as it was. I can definitely see it: there's hints of glam with the sleaze turned up to ten, noise, all lead by someone doing their best Iggy Pop impersonation. Reminds me a little bit of the bass-heavy Death From Above (1979). It's easy to get lost in, like after a night out where you're drunk out of your mind and you're trying to piece it all together the next day. I like it, or maybe the idea of it. Favorite tracks: "Up Against the Wall, Motherfuckers", "Getting Bright At Night", "Big Sleep"

Lots of aggressive noise on this album but the band excels at controlled chaos. Unlike a lot of noise rock or hardcore bands, where a certain amount of guitar feedback and sloppiness feels improvised, these guys sound like they’re very deliberate behind the boards. They deploy the screeches and feedback right where they want them. That feeling of being carefully put together is probably a result of the songwriting too. A lot of this music is dense and layered. I hear a Rolling Stones influence on a bunch of songs. Joe Cardamone’s vocals often sound like Mick Jagger. The band even sounds a little like Zeppelin on “Virgin Velcro.” It’s a potent combination: ‘fuck you’ hardcore noise + smart songwriting and musicianship + rockstar showmanship. Excellent album.

Cool sound- I think if I got into them earlier I would have really enjoyed this. I think the singers got an attractive and confident voice, and the band plays in this same un-timid way. Sometimes the singer sounds like Marilyn Manson. The album went by surprisingly quick for me. I liked the change of pace in "Getting Bright At Night" but I feel like it came too late in the album. I wanted it a little earlier. Nice listen. Will try to remember to listen again but if I forget I don't think it will hurt too much. Had some nice tunes on it but I don't know if it has to be on this list.

Icarus Line Genre: Garage rock, Noise rock 2004 Third Listen: 2, 2 (I feel like I've never heard it before) Standouts: None Others: Meatmaker, On the Lash, Spike Island, Big Sleep, White Devil. 3.5

Sonic Youth inspired, but not really my sound.

Talk about a forgettable record. I remember downloading this when I saw it get a little bit of hype in real time and then laughing when I saw it in the first edition of this book. It’s fine for what it is, it’s just super uninteresting. It has some parts that rock and I think the more experimental noisy stuff is when it shines, but otherwise it’s like a hundred other bands of the era.

Een soort van mix van Smashing Pumpkins en Marilyn Manson. Het is beluisterbaar, maar niet echt m'n ding

An album I've never heard of, from a band I've never heard of, released at the nadir of 2000s music... Oh boy, am I looking forward to this. Reading up, the album was beset by arguments from the band - with rolling eyes, one observes that this is always such a good sign. Now what is reassuring is that the record label did nothing to help them. Given the staggering lack of wit, nous or decent taste in the music industry then, this is the smallest glimmer of hope about what looks, on paper at least, like it's going to be a lightly fried turd of an album. Right then. Let's give it a listen. OK, for first impressions, I can see exactly why they were signed to begin with. Despite being a cross between Jane's Addiction and Melt Banana, there's a little bit of talent here. Unfortunately I don't think that little bit of talent ratios well enough to the amount of talent they think they have. This music is the very epitome of "Prima donna", but without the goods to make the bad worth tolerating. Had this been as workmanlike and as dedicated as Melt Banana, it could have been so much more. But it's swimming in testosterone and misplaced swagger, like every other damn thing from the dead years of music. No lads, you're not the next Beatles. Get over yourselves, play some music. Only play for the audience, yeah, not your own egoes.

I only had one listen but will want to explore further. I can't believe I wasn't familiar with this. It's good the prog Rocky tendencies could get on my nerves

Too much grunch

Lo que he podido escuchar me ha gustado, aunque no está en abierto por ningún lado. En Spotify o YouTube Music no está y de Tidal no tengo ya acceso. Veré si puedo oírlo por otro lado.

Not feeling optimistic given the track titles, but who knows? It definitely rocks and rocks hard. It's pretty messy and processed which isn't my favorite sound but I see the appeal. Party The Baby Off was good, but otherwise no standouts for me. 3/5 stars

Man I'm really just not a post-punk marty. It's decent and if I was a teenager who didn't get along with my parents I could see myself raging to this but the whole extremely compressed and distorted vocal thing just doesn't do it for me. Like bro what are you saying?

Really liked this, I assumed with the album cover and song names this would be very heavy metal, but it was actually pretty chill.

Thought this was really quite good! Rock on!

I thought this reminded me of Marilyn Manson. It's alright but I don't think it's anything special. Didn't love the vocals so for that reason I'm a

I hate this horrendous album art work. The music does not do anything for me, but it’s not terrible. I just don’t vibe with this.

Another band I'd never heard of before that I enjoyed. This was a tiny bit too derivative in places, but overall I liked it very much. Definitely on my list to relisten now, as there were a few stand out parts here and there. Nothing too grating and no weak tracks that I noticed on one play through, although there were a few "this is too angst" moments maybe. Will get 4 stars for not being perfection, but good enough for another spin. Bonus points for Spotify playing The Fall "Green Eyed Loco Man" after the album completed, which I took as a good sign, helped me place when this album first came out, and did indeed have some similarities.

sounds like they’re trying too hard to be loud and impressive while not trying hard enough to write an actual song. a couple of clever guitar moments here and there quickly spoiled the arrogant twenty something year old thinger who thinks he’s deep and special. fuck off the lot of you. this record is ass. this isn’t post hardcore it’s just noise. noise usually always sucks. truly a forgettable undancable record made by some shitty local band.

Some were ok and some were pretty bad on first listen

I guess if by post-hardcore you mean heavily distorted guitars and zero energy, sure...

2/13, 15%

Weird one. I've got used to not seeing one of my favourite genres on here as it's not the usual 1001-vibe they go for. So one finally appears and it's a bit lacklustre? I can think of 10 very similar albums that are miles better than this. Good in parts but goes on too long. Some songs just a waste of time. Not terrible though.

It’s a 2004 album, so given how this list works, I’m immediately suspicious of this album’s staying power. A lot of the 2004/2005 picks are very… suspicions. I really thought the first few records were sick! It’s a more intense, dangerous, noisy take on this kind of garage rock thing happening. On my iPhone speakers it sounds terrible, on my proper headphones and my good system it sounds AMAZING! Kind of funny how some of the biggest losers in the transition to computer / iPhone speakers have been the heavier rock groups. That stuff is just hard to get to sound good on small speakers like that, without compromising. This record sounds REALLY good on a proper set of speakers, and I’m glad I didn’t just put it on in the car or something. I think it sounds pretty unique, not very cookie cutter. Not cheesy, not trying to hit a chorus, just really aggressive rock. Just goes 10-20% harder than others, and they really play into the noisiness. I assume they have 0 hits, there’s no real hit here, it’s just an hour of all-out assault. But can’t say I didn’t have fun with it! 3/5

I liked this now

lähimpänä did nt listeniä mitä koskaan ollut, iltamyöhässä eilisen albumi tämä ja pitäisi vielä tehdä asioita...ja seitsemältä nousuun aamulla.. mitä saan palkinnoksi, early 2000 luvun rock album paskaa.. eikä löydy spotifystä.. pitää jostain juutuubista kaivata playlistaa..tänään ei vittu anneta propseja. ykköstä naamaan niin saatanan tylysti. ehkä toimisi salimusiikina, hyvänä päivänä 2, ehkä 3... parempi kuin The White Stripes bändi. Shot a lot of heroin to this entire cd. Good times, bad times,, jooh semmonen yleisö. no ota 2 on the lash

Probably takes the cake for the most obscure artist on this list. Never heard of em and looks like very few other people have as well. Music was too noisy for me. 4/10

Yeah...hmmm...no...not my thing...maybe it was the day, but...didn't enjoy whatsoever. Nearly was a one. Ecch.

My first listen was last night as I crawled into bed. I’m not saying that the album caused a headache, I’m just saying that I didn’t have a headache before I started the album, but I sure did when it was over. I did give it a second chance in the light of a new day. The best compliment that I have for it is that there was no headache today.

726 albums in. We've not heard from Dolly Parton yet. Nor Annie Lennox, Diana Ross, Laurie Anderson. No Joan Jett. No Pat Benatar. No Janelle Monae. But The Icarus Line, we've got them. I was completely underwhelmed by this album. Why is it here? It seemed completely generic and lacking in any kind of spark. How is it notable? How is it important? I don't think it's "good." It's...ok. But what's next?

When I saw this genre was "post-hardcore" I was pretty sure this wouldn't be for me. To my surprise I really love it! Edgy and cool in all the right ways, I didn't realize that I had room for a new post-hardcore band in my life. This is great rock and roll! The 1001 list disabuses me of yet another preconceived notion.

Pareceu-me uma tentativa de ser um white stripes raivoso.

This album took me until about halfway through to really start to get it, and at that point I started it again and listened with fresh ears. I think this one is easy to miss, since it sounds generic at first, like a less poppy version of The Strokes. However, there's a lot more progression in these songs than in Strokes songs (also, these songs are not blatantly ripped off of very famous songs the way most of the Stokes big hits were). 4/5 This album definitely sounds like it was made in the mid 00s, but there's a lot more depth to the music than I initially perceived. Sort of a hidden gem in an incredibly bleak period for rock

Aaron North makes every note chaos in the best way here. As he always does. This album is sloppy and it is barely holding together. And that is the genius of it. Not many hooks or traditional riffs. Just wild punk rock played with the energy of the sun.

The album was not that good. It was loud and it was not screaming but not understandable. Not need to revisit.

Noise. Occasionally a tune breaks through, but not often. Rating: 1.5/5 Playlist track: Spike Island Date listened: 01/09/23

This band has 1329 monthly listeners on Spotify at the time of me writing this. I absolutely did not need to listen to such a minor band's record before I die. Music's passable tho, nothing special.

Noise, just noise And not very good noise at that

It's okay, but no thanks.

I didn't mind the first half and thought it would be a solid three, but the second half kinda dipped in quality in my opinion. It became more unlistenable and less interesting. A low three. I think my favourite song was On The Last, but I honestly had some trouble telling the songs apart.

Imagine these are great live

I really like this genre of music but this is such a completely unremarkable album. It has nothing stand out, nothing original and no songs that would justify it being here. It's in that list of albums that wouldn't have made it on this list if it was not from America. Sometimes things don't become hits because they are just not very interesting.

Who ever likes this should revisit. Your wrong. This is terrible. Does not deserve to be on this list

This wasn't for me. Some songs were ok, some were trash, most were forgettable.

Probably would have liked this at the time; now it's just a bit numbing and not hardcore enough.

24th August 2023 Listened during the day, managed a gym session then home. An impression of Iggy. 2.5 if I could.

When I saw this was post-hardcore, I was expecting to hate it but it was much better than expected.

I've never heard of this album or artist before, but when I looked over the track listing and saw song titles like "Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers" and "Meatmaker," my expectations were pretty low. Overall, I'd say this album was okay. The vocals reminded me of early U2 and Echo & The Bunnymen, which I enjoyed. The instrumentation was very unique, especially when compared to mainstream rock of this era. The middle of the album was my favorite part; "Spike Island" through "Big Sleep" were my favorite songs, but everything else was just okay.

2004. A " best album " I never heard of it. ... Curious. But the ugly portentous cover threatens a forgone conclusion it might not be my taste. (Because it's going to be intentionally jarring and ugly and hard to love?. But let's see. ) Ok. You really have to be in the right mood for this...! Their music is wild and rough and original and varied. And also I sure and hard to get access to via streaming. Important to include a struggling stark and different voice. Even if it's not easy

I swear that I owned a book in the early 70’s with the same title as Track 1 on this. So I googled the phrase & what a good read that was. Could not locate the book I was thinking of but it was a good excuse to drag out The Worst Of Jefferson Airplane LP & listen to We Can Be Together, where they use the phrase. I wasn’t sure if I was up to this album until I got to Spike Island. After that, I enjoyed what I heard. The 9-minute track, Getting Bright At Night was terrific - the beginning of a wonderful trifecta with Big Sleep & White Devil. Both also winners. And the closing track, Party The Baby Off, was a great closer. Pity I was not able to see Virgin Velcro or Sea Sick. I was able to read the lyrics. Can’t believe I’d never heard of this band. Loved the singer’s voice & the music was totally interesting.

Oh really? This sounds like a willfully obscure post-hardcore band much like any other. Alan Moulder mix helps it sound a little better than many. But, I mean, really, this album was barely released, and is not even on spotify at present. How is this a "must hear" album? I mean, they rock. And I'm sure they are heap of sweaty fun live... but this is really a stretch. All attitude and no songs (exception: Kiss Like Lizards). An absolutely inessential record, with nothing to recommend it.

cool rock record with a tinge of punk and post-hardcore, but i like the more bass driven tracks and the rest doesn't really hold my attention

Like less good Strokes or White Stripes.

To sum this up, steal from other bands, add some fuzzy noise and do it poorly.

Kinda boring. What’s special or influential or worthy of being on this list about this record?

Generic noise.

Noisy rock, but fun to listen to. I had not heard this one before, but I will make sure it gets on my rotation.

Some interesting tracks but not enough quality overall for me.

I liked it, a post-hardcore sounding Jack White/White Stripesy mix

A fun noisy racket but not much more. When you think this came out 35 years after The Stooges, you'd think more evolution would have occurred.

It's another early 2000s post-hardcore band taking from the bluesy garage style of the White Stripes, but they really crank up the feedback and distortion to create cool industrial effects. The most popular songs are near the front, and yet I thought they were the most generic and least interesting. "On the Lash" had a pretty sick industrial second half, but other than that, it was forgettable. It picked up for me with "Kiss the Lizards." Great work on the guitar and drums with an outstanding bridge. The transitions from here are seamless and keep hyping up the next track. "Getting Bright at Night" was the song that got me to start paying attention. It's an epic jam track with highs and lows. "Big Sheep" was a bluesy followup with cool industrial effects, just found the middle section a bit boring. "White Devil" was my favorite cause of the strong bluesy sound (this is where White Stripes influence is most prominent), and the psychotic free sax. "Meatmaker" is definitely a modern rendition of the early industrial band Suicide (with that motorik-like beat). It's frightening and shocking. It doesn't fit in and it feels like an experimental miss, but I found it pretty cool. The last 3 tracks is where it dropped in quality. "Seasick" was pretty good, maybe a homage to Jane's Addiction. Didn't need to go on for 6.5 minutes though with how repetitive it was, and that ending dragged on too much. "Party the Baby Off" is a power pop finale, also doesn't fit in, but it's a pleasant finale, especially with the double tracked vocals. Biggest cons: too long, several filler tracks, the good tracks dragged on a bit too long without much variation Almost every track could definitely be improved, but it does a lot of things well, and there are some cool styles here. Not essential, but I found some new impressive things from the genre.

After all the effort I put into finding an almost complete playlist of this album, it turned out to be massively underwhelming. The thing with noise rock is it sounds like all other noise rock. Noisy...and not much else.

Listening to it is - quote - "That's the last thing I want to do" I seriously don't need to hear it before I die. There're tons of bands like this.

I don't think that it really belong on this list. I like some dirty, harsh records but I don't think this neither special nor innovative. If this is peak noise rock that I don't want to hear any more of it.

Enjoyed much more than expected for mid-2000s. This is more like a high 3-low 4 but still. Pretty cool.

Ferme ta gueule

Never heard of them, but I'd listen to this again. Pretty enjoyable.

Though it definitely has noisy, less approachable tracks like Spit on It and Meatmaker, there are high energy, buzzy and loud tracks that carry good energy and are engaging. Liked Spike Island, Getting Bright and Big Sleep. There's enough here that even though it can be a challenging listen, it is a worthwhile listen.

Quite dated and not as good as similar records.

Never heard of this artist before. I think I might have liked the first song, but after that it all went downhill from there. It was loud, abrasive, repetitive, and incoherent. I couldn't get into it at all. I was unable to finish the album because it was tiring to listen to.

They’re trying too hard No thanks

8/10 really good stuff here very enjoyable

men rappelle de rien. rater quelques jours plus tards. semblait écoutable

That bass sound is something else - I think would have been good to see live, lots of energy. But feels a bit contrived.

Kind of close to what I normally listen to, and I think I heard their name before, but first time checking them out. Another really solid record, gotta listen to it more.

Garage rock. Ni fu ni fa.

Garage rock, noise rock

A little bit over top for a Monday evening.

Dad says good voice, songs are rubbish, good after a few beers and a joint.

Never heard of this band. I liked it!

first listen love the energy but starts to sound all the same

I have to be in the mood for this kind of album, but it has its moments. Noisy, swaggering, ramshackle fun with echoes of the Stooges, Suicide, Jesus & Mary Chain. If your main attribute is that you sound like a bunch of other, better artists, it's a bit of a problem. A solid listen, but not something I see myself coming back to. Fave Songs: Caviar, Getting Bright at Night, Party the Baby Off, Spike Island, On the Lash, Seasick

Garage rock, noise rock

Surprised Iv never come across this band or album before. This is right up my street. Straight into my rotation.

Don't like the vocals and pretty much all of the songs are forgettable. I do like noisy rock and hardcore punk but no song on this album stands out that much. It's still fine to listen to but I won't be replaying it. Makes w´me wonder why it's part of the 1001 best albums. Highlights: Up Against The Wall Motherfucker, On The Lash, Caviar

Definitely feels like nice, garage-y stuff. I found it very washed out by the meandering nature of every song. I liked it cause it clearly inspired later bands to make more refined music that's actually enjoyable to listen to.

Today's album was a headache inducer. I've never heard of The Icarus Line before today, and from what I read, they are a post hardcore/aggro punk group. From that description I deduce that this album is going to be loud and angry. That is exactly what it is. It is mostly distortion and noise. At some points, even the vocalist is singing through a distortion filter for some ungodly reason, as if what this music needed was more feedback. It reminds me quite a bit of Nine Inch Nails, which is ironic because one of the guitarists from this band (Aaron North) left and joined NIN. Is a full minute of feedback distortion necessary at the end of Sea Sick? I think not. This is not music, and has influenced nothing. This is just noise with the sole purpose of being loud and annoying. To be on a list like this, you need to either be able to play instruments, have been highly influential, or have a huge, dedicated fan base. These tools have none of this from what I can tell. Spotify says average monthly listeners is only around 1,000 and their most "popular" song only has 50,000 listens (most of which were probably poor bastards trying to do this generator). Overall, this album is complete garbage. I've already forgot most of it, and have recovered most of my hearing. I will never subject myself to this trash ever again and I wonder what the fuck the list creator was smoking when he thought that shit like this was deserving of this list. Favourite songs: Virgin Velcro, Spike Island, Up Against the Wall Motherfucker Least favourite songs: Spit On It, On the Lash, Meatmaker, Sea Sick 2/5

Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Caviar, Big sleep

Much better than I thought it would be, sounds like a classic rock band

Very heavy

Quality alternative rock. A little like the Strokes or White Stripes, but definitely heavier, so it reminds me of 90s rock more than 00s rock. Good energy throughout

This is exactly why I’m doing this list. So happy to discover this kickass record.

Decent 3

First album in over 740 that I haven't been able to find any where. A pretty incredible feat all things considered. The fact that I've had immediate access to almost 750 albums spanning all the way back to the 1950s in my pocket is something we take way for granted. Undertaking a project like this even 15 years ago would have been a very different experience. For all it's short comings, Spotify is the one of the most important advancements in consumerism we've ever experienced

I feel like on paper this album should be a home run for me, but I just found it very boring throughout and certainly overly long. It drones a bit and doesn’t really hook me. Meatmaker was probably the most interesting in my opinion.

Great album, angsty LA rock. Fave track is Big Sleep.

Literally never heard of The Icarus Line outside of this project, which is a bit weird. Yeah, I dig it - very chaotic garagey post-hardcore. Enjoyed it enough for three listens, and would happily go back for more! Fave track - "Getting Bright at Night" is a banger - especially the last third. "Meatmaker" is slavish Suicide worship, and I'm on board for it!

Fy helvete, vilken skit!

3/5 You know that feeling when you get excited about a song and it's progressing nicely and then all of a sudden in the middle it gets experimental and weird and dissonant? That's like 90% of this album. I especially liked Getting Bright at Night, until it broke down the one middle. I just kind of felt like my hopes were lifted then dashed repeatedly so I had a hard time enjoying it fully.

Not my favourite. Seemed like something from around the grunge era however apparently it came after. Not a convert and not intrigued to find any more music by these guys.

Seems derivative and repetitive. I doubt I'd pull this up again. Preemptive 1/5

competent noisy rock.

Kinda trashy, noisy Rock 'n' Roll vibes. Christ, still 3 minutes to go... Excruciatingly boring and about 20 minutes too long. 2 / 5 stars.

Nothing really grabbed me

Solid mid-'00s rock (which is fairly rare, in my experience).

Very loud and raw. I can pick out things to like here; nice riffs, nice rhythms, good stretches; but overall the vibe here is just not for me at all. Some songs/sections of songs (Meatmaker, most of Kiss Like Lizards, the ending of Seasick) are straight up unlistenable. Wouldn't ever put this on again. Best song: Spike Island

I like the noisiness of much of the album. Not such a fan of the vocal style.

I'm not much into this type of music these Days but this was not terrible. I would have been jamming this in the day.

I didn't hate this. But I also didn't love it. Which was surprising since I'm usually here for angry, post-punk shenanigans. It was just so noisy. Such a mess. Shame, really.

Hot garbage

i usually like this kind of music however this was just not very good. awful ending track

não gostei do álbum, mais um de rock e um que não me interessou ou cativou.

Hardcore foward thinkers or the last gasp of 90s rockism? These guys rock. That's about all they do. Would not be out of place in a small town college bar. Not necessarily a criticism.

Not my thing

When this album was selected for me, I never heard of this band before or this album. Any details in regard to their background was scarce and so I went into this with blindfolds on and was just ready to take what was given. That being said, this is actually a pretty good record, albeit on the more raucous side of the equation. The Icarus Line do the best that they can in these balls to the wall, relentless fifty-three minutes, one minute dishing out two minute appetizers like it was nothing and the next minute delivering a nine minute epic as though they knew how to trek Mt. Olympus. All in all, don't turn up your nose when given this album: you may never know what you'll like. Favorites: Up Against the Wall, Motherfuckers, On the Lash, Caviar, Spike Island, Getting Bright at Night, Virgin Velcro, Seasick, Party the Baby Off.

This reminds me of some of the 70s heavy rock that I liked merged with a noisy grunge backdrop. The guitar sound on the title track is so managed by the production team it would be difficult to come close to it live. The speedy stuff is tiring and I don't see these guys adding much to what was on set on the table before them.

I don't know what to say about this. Maybe with another listen I'd give it a higher score

I was a bit embarrassed that I've never heard of this band, but then I see that they have very few listens on Spotify, so I guess it;s not just me. Lots of White Stripes vibes here, minus the enjoyment.

It’s noisy. I don’t really know how to feel; I don’t hate it, but there’s really no reason it should be here. ‘Meatmaker’ randomly reminds me of Suicide, though.

I like noisy, but it's a bit too under-produced here. Real chunky riffs and jams tho.

Apparently I didn't very much care for this one, I stopped listening to it a couple of tracks in because I was distracted by stuff to do on the weekend, and it just never occurred to me to pick it back up.

With a band name and album title that fucking pretentious, I'm gonna say indie rock? The album isn't on Spotify, have found 5-6 songs from it on YouTube though. Ok yep it's p standard 00s indie, and at the noisy end. Jack White is clearly the biggest influence, but the singer very, very obviously idolises Chris Cornell... sadly though, in this case effort doesn't trump talent. He screams a LOT. To describe the overall sound in a word, I'd say "abrasive". I haven't read any other reviews yet but I can't imagine this will get much love. It's not really my thing either but I didn't mind it for the few tracks I heard. 3/5.

Scary album cover. I felt like I was so dialed in to music (maybe just to emo!) back in 2004, when this album came out, but I've never heard of this band as far as I can remember. And I hope to never remember them, either.

Uhh, no thanks

I like this album. It's another that I don't understand the criteria for it's inclusion in the 1001 list, though. I'd rank it 3-4 stars on its own, but in the context of it being a "must listen" record, I'm not sure it meets those aspirations.

Did not enjoy.

It was OK, didn't think much of it

You got good noise (Sonic Youth, Blonde Redhead, Unwound, Jesus Lizard, mclusky, Royal Trux, Swans etc etc) and you got bad noise made by copycat bands that have no sound on their own, like this band. It is just noise with a bit of garage rock, or the other way around.. it does not matter.

Terrible from start to finish. No redeeming qualities whatsoever.

Very ugly music indeed.

I liked the energy and chaotic-ness of the instrumentals in some of the tracks. I would have liked if the singer amped up his angst a bit on those. Needed some at the drive in level delivery. The slower ones didn't do much for me. I wouldn't come back to this project as not enough resonated with me, but I did enjoy a good chunk of the instrumentals - unfortunately the vocalist didn't fit what I needed to match those instrumentals.

Despite what the Wikipedia states, the album is wholly unremarkable.

sounds a bit like a lot of bands i like and it works. heavy, noisy and messy, i bet these were good live.

Probably a big bunch of nonces

I liked this quite a bit. Cool moody stuff with careful songwriting

Niet best, paar nummers maar geluisterd want stond niet op spotify, excusé

Not bad, made it past the desire to skip after 4 seconds. Will listen again

It's not bad in any way; just as a matter of personal preference, it didn't quite click for me. Felt too generic, I think.

2.3 - I hosted a radio show when I was a college freshman and the studio was crammed with records like this - anonymous, generic “loud rock” (our music director’s lame attempt at assigning them a genre). We’d be encouraged to spin a batch of records for a couple of weeks before those were shelved en masse somewhere unknown in order to make room for the next batch of faceless bands.

Ýmislegt í þessu sem hefur hellings potential en ég náði ekki að tengja við fyrstu hlustun. Reyni aftur síðar.

Sounded like Velvet Underground to me in many spots.

Big MCR vibes from this one. I didn't like this album that much, but I could really get into this artist if I wanted to. 3/5. Favorite Track: On The Lash

Enjoyed it, but nothing revolutionary. 3.5

Jesus Christ enough already with the noise I feel deeply personally offended by this album and if I could give it a 0 I would

thus far, one of the least enjoyable albums in this list. i couldn't find much remarkable about this album. it was an exercise in patience when there was mindless screaming or feedback noises. i can't tell if i found it boring when i actively disliked it? but i can say it was unimpressive.

WHY is this album on here? I am sure there are albums more deserving of the slot occupied by this album. I don't normally quote Wikipedia in my reviews, but the article for this album notes it as "one of 2004's most critically acclaimed releases". Says who? I could hear some of the sounds of 2000s rock in here, specifically bands like A Perfect Circle, Chevelle, and such, which I like. But this band and album didn't hit the mark. That is to say, parts of this album were NEARLY tolerable, but this was definitely "noise rock" with an emphasis on "noise".

Ja kunde int lyssna hela albumet för de fanns typ ingenstans!! Så ja missa två sånger!! Men de som ja hörde va banger🥶

I was prepared for some more underwhelming 2000s picks from Bob but this is pretty gnarly. Nice one :)

Bra oväsen! Gillar produktionen

HL: "On the Lash", “Seasick”, "Spit on It" Skipped a couple albums to listen to this 'blind', as it's always a treat to discover a new artist. I think. I don't have anything personal against noisy garage rock; some songs I'll likely revisit in the near future, while others stray into obnoxious, edgy territory. 2.5* January 26, 2023

I didn’t know anything about this band. I haven’t heard their name before. It was an interesting experience listening to this album. It is abrasive, energetic, passionate, with a compelling production and lots of ideas floating around. I think I need to go back a give it another listenings to better understand it. It seems to have more layers for me to discover, but I am no there yet.

Yes, very repetitive, but, a very enjoyable album as well.

The worst parts of The White Stripes (which are rare) combined with the whiney-ness and "not knowing when to stop a song"-isms of Marilyn Manson to create an album that started out already at a two star and just got worse and worse. I had decided one star by the time we got to the nine minute song that was just a combination of the song before and after it for a twenty minute "epic" that just was repetitive and boring. Perhaps this should be a two because none of this was awful, per se, but as my partner taught me: if you find yourself turning the music DOWN as it goes on, it probably isn't your thing.

Not a fan of this one.

Garage noise rock, made to be listened to at a high volume. Burning guitars and ferocious vocals

Litt nice egentlig

This one caught me by surprise. Some very creative, slightly progressive, punk. I'll be revisiting it

Sounds okay, but not on Spotify. So I couldn’t be bothered to listen to all of it.

i wish i’d heard this when it was released because it would’ve really rung my bell

Mediocre noise rock.The most obscure so far.I don’t understand why it’s on the list.

There's the core of a great album here but unfortunately a lot of it gets lost for me with a lot of the songs just being overdone. I think if just a few extra elements had been edited down/out this would have been a 4 or even a 5 for me, but as it stands it's just been buried in too much extra stuff. Best tracks: Spike Island, Getting Bright at Night, White Devil, and Seasick

Albums like these are what I expected this list to be.

Good solid rock album, just not my style.

Oh god this is just tiring

Well, that was noisy. An American Bad Seeds? US noise punk. Scuzzy production. No clear tunes. Music for disaffected youth methinks. Means nothing to me. 2

Just awful.

Not really my thing.

stand-outs: "On the Lash," "Spike Island," "Big Sleep," "Seasick."

I’ve never heard of The Icarus Line, but alt rock often doesn’t go wrong with me. I quite like the album art of this - it gives off White Stripes vibes but more greasy. Songs I already knew: none Favourites: On The Lash Maybe I shouldn’t have set my expectations so high. There were definitely some meaty riffs on this album (as a vegetarian, riffs are the only meat I consume), but unfortunately not much else. I’m can’t say I like the singing - it’s not awful, but it’s also not great. I feel that any rock loses a lot of its charm when too well produced, which might sound a bit silly, but a lot of what I like about bands like Plumtree or Smashing Pumpkins is that they sound like they could have been recorded in a garage. As the album went on, it did start sounding more rough and ready, but the quality of the songs also declined so it didn’t really seem to get better despite this. Maybe that’s just me though.

I liked this to a degree. I do enjoy the raw, garage rock sound/energy it has. None of the tracks blew me away, but none of it was bad either.

This is some good ol loud ass rock done bad

Too much for me

Perfectly dreadful – these clowns clearly love their axes, but why then keep doing the same thing with them over and over again? No surprise they've been banished from the book.

I’ve already forgotten it.

I'm absolutely baffled as to what warranted this to be on the list at any point

Absolute shite

Wickarus

Dig the distortion

Very noisy, but solid tunes in there somewhere too. Clear influence on royal blood and the white stripes, hints of the strokes, queens of the stone age, and plenty of grunge. Not one of the best 1001 albums, but an interesting one I would never otherwise have heard 3 🌟

Goddamn, I was completely blown away by this! At the beginning of my first listen, I had to get a bit into it, but when 'On The Lash' came on, it was like the combination of brutality and catchiness clicked with me. On 'Spike Island' Joe Cardamone's desperate but lazy vocals is easily compared to fellow rock-revivor Julian Casablancas. And what an insanely great sound on the bass and guitar! The brutality seeps through the record - on the vicious 'Kiss Like Lizards' or on 'Getting Bright at Night' where an intense cacophony explodes into energetic riffs. On top of that you have innovative changes in dynamics on the post-punky 'Big Sleep' as well as a jazz-inspired polyrhythmic sequence on 'White Devil'. The record truly keeps you on your toes. Industrial of course also makes a guest appearance on 'Meatmaker' (a 00's fad that I am not a fan of), and psychedelia is given a whirl as well on 'Sea Sick' (this I approve of). But then... For some inexplicable reason, they decided to end the album with 'Party the Baby Off'. What an insufferable, empty-headed tune sounding like it belongs on an Aerosmith album - and not one of the tolerable ones. So much fun. So disappointed. What a rollercoaster.

What the hell just attacked me? I feel completely run over by the sheer amount of feedback, heavy bass and noise. Hidden underneath it all is a palette of punk, hardcore and garage rock that works perfectly on itself; the overlaying elements of aggressive noise just further adds to the experience. Especially the guitars are extremely well mixed almost slapping you in your face every time a solo is about to start. Towards the end I feel like more and more of the songs start blending together and I’m left wishing that this would have been cut to 11 songs. Quite the thrilling ride nonetheless that left me exhausted and my ears pleading for some smooth jazz.

It’s okay, feels a bit generic, mostly don’t care for the singers voice very forgettable.

This was something a bit more up my alley! I quite liked this mix of alternative and garage rock with some noise mixed in, though some of the noisier tracks were a bit difficult to listen to at parts. Favourite: Kiss Like Lizards

Gave me White Stripes vibes. I actually enjoyed quite a bit considering it was so random and unknown. 4.5

I mean, it was alright, like... The use of noise in music is something that can be really good, but I don't think this band did it well. It also seems like they don't know what their style is, so it's really weird.

I had more of an appetite for this kind of thing in my past; it’s appeal - the frenetic racket of the instrumentation and the particular afflicted affect of the vocals - have greatly paled for me. There’s very little post punk/hardcore alternative I still feel inclined to give time to and this ain’t gonna join that list. Given the sneery LA attitude dripping off it I’m resisting the urge to knock off an extra star on general principles, but it was competent and reasonably listenable, just not my thing anymore

I'm sure this album could be much more enjoyable with fewer songs. This kind of noise rock music is not so bad (it's pretty interesting sometimes), but it's annoying after 35 minutes and worsens every minute. This is important enough to be part of the 1001 list. Still, it has many more lost opportunities than actual realization, mainly because of the lack of brevity and self-awareness of its limitations. 2 stars

Ça casse la tête j'ai pas écouté en entier

tout le mode l'avait oublié celui là et à juste titre

Hmm, yeah. Good. Not outstanding, but definitely good. Never heard of these before. Getting Bright at Night is pretty excellent. I love a good 9 minute epic that goes in directions. White Devil, singer doing a massive Black Francis impression which actually isn't bad.

A little surprised I hadn't heard this given that it falls sonically close to my taste. If I had heard it when it came out it probably would have been too intense. There are parts I like, the Stooges influence is clear, but I just don't know if there's much here other than face smashing aggression.

Genuinely surprised I hadn't heard this before. Not sure it deserves to be on this list but it's alright. Kinda like it when they get noisier and more experimental. Wish they'd lean into that more.

Decent garage/post-hardcore rock. It was still just sort of "there" for me except for some interesting musical elements, but generally not my style/interest. Was a bit surprised how low the Spotify plays were, seems like they were quite popular back in the day?

Horrible!

Saw the cover and was hoping for something interesting :(

It grew on me as I listened. Brings me back to high school for sure.

A lot of noise and dirt. There's some good tracks through this record but by no means is it perfect, sadly have to listen on YouTube where the quality is crap. There's a punk Iggy pop vibe going on, on some tracks. A bit different to other "Garage Rock/BluesPunk/Rock going on at the time. 2.5 Stars

This feels like a mix of emo bands and the white stripes. Some of the songs are okay and not that messy. Some other songs are clearly early 2000s emo type and not that enjoyable. It’s a relatively loud album but without much substance. 4.6/10

Another first. Good times. The sort of rock I used to love but don't listen to anymore.

this album was insulting i could not bare to listen to it at any volume higher than the lowest possible one… just no.

abrasive and terrible vocals? check. noisy and distorted music without any logical direction? check. rotten low-fi production? check. unmemorable and poorly-constructed songs? check. overall painful to literally listen to let alone get through? check. 1 star rating? checkmate. 1/10 1 star.

Never heard of this artist, and it didn't leave much of a mark on me, it's just fine noisy garage rock. Probably will never think about it again.

I didn’t mind it, a bit too buzzy in guitar. Far from a scene pioneer, sounds like a melting pot of everything from the late 90s/ early 00s.

This may make me sound old, but it's a bit too noisy for me. Some interesting stuff, but overall not my favorite. 2 stars.

No Bueno

These are the albums that make this whole project worth it for me - had never heard of this band before, but love this absolutely thrashing, nasty, guitar-whirlwind of an LP. The runtime may be a bit long for how many melodic ideas it has to offer, but what it lacks in creativity this album more than makes up for in energy. While it has a solid blues-rock basis, there are a few left-turn zigzags into weird chords or rhythms that keep the listener on their toes and make this an exciting trainwreck-in-motion of a listen.

First half slogged a bit for me, loved the second half. Pretty decent, might listen to some more of their works

Doet me niks, en staat niet op Spotify.

Generic, overly slick, and shiny with substance. Not a bit of it feels sincere.

Reminds me a bit of smashing pumpkins but more forgettable

Hmm. Not sure about this one. Not enough of any one thing to leave an impression. Yeah, it's dark and edgy and distorted, but it's like an easy listening version of metal? Is that what garage/noise rock is? I don't really care for or about this one. In one ear and out the other. Put something from Pharmakon on this list instead, preferably Bestial Burden. Favorite tracks: Getting Bright at Night. Album art: Kinda cool, kinda gross? Not sure what I'm looking at, aside from it being someone's side profile. 1.5/5

So this is one of the lowest rated album...... It's not that bad to be honest and musically is quite accomplished, cohesively engineered and produced. If I felt in a sleazy-glam-rock type of mood I'd put this on. It sounds like a lot of other bands which is ok- they've taken what they wanted. Overall it's not as bad as some make out.

Not for me

I got the Mars Volta vibes, but without the goodness that comes with listening to Frances the Mute.

honestly this wasn't even that bad

Not heard of this band before so could be interesting. Unfortunately it wasn't. Rather messy, not distinct and repetitive.

I am not very familiar and have only dabbled in post-hardcore, but I liked this album and felt they sounded a little like Hot Snakes. His vocals range from the Cult, to STP, to his own thing. Album has a lot of punch.

This isn’t bad at all… heard their name but never knowingly heard their music. Enjoyed it!

Idk just didn’t hit

I don't understand the praise for this album.

Not much for me here. First song was okl...had a bit of a Jane's Addiction feel. After a 2nd song that did nothing for me, 3rd song ok again as a matter of fact the next couple songs were not bad but after that it became increasingly difficult to listen to this album. Vocals too hard and aggressive as was the music. Much of the rest borderline unlistenable. 2.5 🌟

Big Sleep and a few other songs are relatively engaging, but as a soiree this feels musically obligatory. It's not my genre, but not a particularly interesting one anyway.

this is something I could work out to. Rock focused - sounds like the time early 2000s

I remember them from "back in rhe day". I'm pretty sure that this CD sat in a pile on my room for months at a time. Why did it sit for months? Because it's just not that impressive.

Garage rock. Ni fu ni fa.

Really not that great. Couldn't wait for it to end. 1/5

not my jam

TERRIBLE 😵‍💫

Loved it. Super dark and gritty. Never heard of this band before!

I WANTED to like this a lot. It's some really groovy bottled napalm. But it's just a little too edgy for me. Several times I thought a track was going to be a big highlight, but by the time it reached its full crescendo it just wasn't enjoyable any more. I actually suspect this is a problem exacerbated on the first-impression. If I knew where each song was going I think I wouldn't find it as annoying..... but Oh well! on to the next day!

Not bad. Must hear? Nah.

The chances that they pull themselves out of whatever hole they're in without some grippier tunes: low. The chances that they accidentally bury themselves under their own despairing noise muck: worryingly high. In need of a hook and a new outlook.

Noise metal? No, it’s just noise.

Unfortunately this CD only contained a bunch of noise, no songs or anything else that could be called music was detected

I've always wondered how did punk evolved into post-punk. Now, I know. This 2000's garage rock bit topped with layers of noise seems to answer my questions. It's harsh and angsty, like punk, and wooshy, like post-punk. Too much noise and too loud, but I enjoyed it nonetheless.

Not come across these guys before. I enjoyed it. I would definitely listen again.

4.5/5. Right up my mf alley. Bruh it’s got NiN AND Ink + Dagger members. Post hardcore rules

Nothing unusual or interesting about this

people said it shouldn't be on the list

Very cool noise rock. Worth a listen.

Nice to get a different genre in there and it sounded proficient, but not really my thing.

Had never heard of this group but this was a great listen. May relisten to decide whether to add to the usual rotation.

Was zwischen 3 und 4.

I'd never heard of this band before, but was pleasantly surprised - in turns grungy, rock, metal, melodic, noisy... I could really see myself finding more and more to like about this album if I give it a few more listens.

I might need to Re-llisten, but nothing on here connected with me.

Rock garaje alternativa. Interesante

Not good; this is what you'd hear on a network tv show when they need some "edgy" rock music, like in CSI when they go to a seedy club to question someone, or when a main character spins out

Post Rock mood setter . Like !

Never heard of these guys before, sounded interesting enough, although it was difficult to judge on one listening. I'll maybe check out their other albums on Spotify though.

Not on my watch.

Ick. I’d say forgettable but I remembered feeling pleased when the album ended.

This is grim.

Slightly embarrassing rock ... when it went "fuckk youuuuu" at the end of one song in that cringe american rock singing style I think I actually lolled quite a lot. I did not find this engaging, it all just passed me by really with little impact

Fairly dull. Felt like more AI generated rock but this time from the early 2000s. Occasionally I found myself liking a short part of it but then got bored again.

Good music, became repetitive this album

Noisy, boring

Hard rocking metal

Thanks I hate it

Un rock molto rumoroso. Ah è proprio un genere, di quello che non capisci bene le parole e ti fa venire mal di testa. 'Caviar' non è male. Mi sono ricreduto, non è malvagio

So much sound, saying so little. What a mess. Proper California vacuity, really testing the listener’s patience.

Yeah, noise punk-pop post-hardcore something :) Homogeneous album... (4/10) FT: On the Lash