Reviews (page 6 of 8)
Meh. Lots of snarl from the singer, and this is not a good thing.
This should encourage all garage band musicians to believe they too can make a record. This should also convince some that they should not. This band disbanded in 2015 and I am grateful.
1.5
A fine semi hardcore endeavor.
Not for me
Yuck
noisy samey songs
this slapped. vive la mid 2000s
Never heard of these guys! But they're great. Absolutely great. From the jump they just EXPLODE with energy. The production and mixing on the record is stellar. The bass thunders and the drums punch without any of the weird hollow flatness that's started to pervade a lot of modern rock records. The only problem with this album is shared by Royal Blood and Mammoth WVH. Every song is a banger, but EVERY song is a banger, so a whole album of them one after another gets fairly tiring, even though each song individually is genuinely spectacular.
NOt sure why this one is even on the list. Very average noise. First track is decent - up against the wall. The rest of it is like pissing up against the wall.
Sale, cru et bruyant. Écoute favorable, mais difficile alors que j'étais au travail. Je devrai revisiter
Fairly good noisy rock. Seemingly nothing too special but not a bad way to spend an afternoon. 3/5
not for me
The Icarus Line, eine Band aus Los Angeles, die mit ihren rohen und ungeschliffenen Sound, der Elemente von Punk, Rock und Noise miteinander verbindet. Das Album ist durchzogen von einer düsteren und aggressiven Atmosphäre, die perfekt für Momente ist, in denen man etwas Hartes und Authentisches braucht. Besonders hervorzuheben sind die Tracks: “Up Against the Motherfucker”: Ein kraftvoller Song, der mit seinen hämmernden Gitarrenriffs und der wütenden Energie sofort ins Ohr geht. “Spike Island”: Dieser Track besticht durch seine rohe Intensität und die unbändige Energie, die die Band hier entfesselt. “Meatmaker”: Ein Stück, das an die Grenzen von Electro-Body Music stößt und durch seine experimentellen Klänge und die düstere Atmosphäre beeindruckt. Es ist ein Album, das durch seine kompromisslose Härte und Authentizität besticht. The Icarus Line schaffen es, eine intensive emotionale Tiefe zu erzeugen, die den Hörer in ihren Bann zieht. Es ist perfekt für Zeiten, in denen man Musik braucht, die direkt ins Mark trifft und keine Kompromisse eingeht.
Caviar is probably my favorite song so far. Crusty garage mix infused with a grunge spirit and some proggy aspects. Really enjoying Getting Bright At Night -- will absolutely be going through this album again for a relisten. I have never heard of The Icarus Line before, and based on Spotify listens I am in the majority (most tracks sit somewhere in the low 10k). Sure the compositions here don't hold much mainstream radio appeal, but I am surprised their exposure is so low. I found this to be a highly enjoyable record. Definitely rough around the edges, but in that imperfectly perfect sort of way -- like an old stained and torn flannel. Understand that distorted as hell vocals and otherwise mixing might not be for everyone and some songs (such as Spit On It) might come across as audio assault, but I honestly enjoyed it -- very punk.
There were a couple decent songs in the first half even though this isn't my favorite type of music. The end fell off pretty hard with White Devil and Meatmaker.
This may be our lowest Monthly Listeners band at a whopping 1,665 listeners per month. When that album started I thought we were in for a tough listen of just noise rock. It turned out to be pretty cool though with some aspects which I really liked. Still overall kind of a brutal listen at many times, but at least there were some redeeming qualities in a decent amount of some songs. Not my type of music at all but better than expected at a 2.5
Getting some Nirvana vibes from On the Lash. Meatmaker is giving me an aneurysm. I really liked some aspects of this album. Little too wild for me at some parts. Low 3
Nice little album
Should be up my street but just didnt do it for me. Surprised it’s on the list, it isnt a patch on Drive Like Jehu / These Arms Are Snakes / insert literally any other post hardcore band here. There were some interesting moments but nothing that made me think this is anything other than a 2 star standard post hardcore record. Very meh.
I love garage rock and post-hardcore so I thought I was going to love this, but it's a bit too middle of the road in both areas to really grab me. The singer and band in general remind me of Jet, have that sort of try hard swagger in the lyrics and singing style and gratuitous use of wah pedal. In isolation there were some bits I really liked, bass in the first song was class. Dont think it outweighed the stuff I didn't like though, 2.5.
A bit irritating that it isn't on spotify. I think other bands did this kind of music more successfully - not sold. Almost like proto-modern psychadelic/noise rock. Big Sleep was my favourite track. I don't think the vocalist has range.
Heard the name the Icarus line before but don't think I've heard them. I reckon if someone described them to me I would think I would really like them.... However, didn't really grab me. Kinda like the mars Volta a bit but not as interesting. 3 probably fair
A solid heavy rock album
Well, they certainly have a lot of energy. Penance Soiree is an album where it feels like there is a lot happening, but it isn't really going anywhere. The songs also seem to just never stop coming at you. I feel like I never got a moment to breathe between the frantic songs. Some of the instrumentals sounded good, but they were forgotten as soon as the extreme noise crowded everything out in my brain.
I can see why the record label didn’t bother to promote this. I have to assume (I do not care enough to actually read the book to find out) that this on the list because sometimes you need to experience the bad to fully appreciate the good.
Enjoyed this. Will listen to more.
I didn't get this at all
Actually liked the opening track. Hated the rest.
Shit garage rock that goes from "kinda shit" to "really shit" in the span of 53 minutes (why is it so long). Reading the reviews before listening to this made me think it was going to be some cool noise rock, but it's just extremely generic garage rock that sounds like Jack White's evil talentless cousin.
Never heard of this band but they were decent.
I was way more up on this at the start of the album, but over time it started to drag a lot more and began to feel more repetitive and samey. It’s nowhere near as noisy and discordant as people are saying. I thought I was in for an ear-splitting time, but it’s just quite competent grungey / garage rock. It’s ok. There’s enough here that works.
Hm
Not terrible, not great. Like a clone or mixture of music you know already. Kinda forgot I was listening to it. Hard to have a strong opinion. I didn't hate it. But I won't miss it Oh, two stars for trying.
Kind of screamy rock that I'm not into.
Ihana albumi aijaijai vitutti kiiressä pyörällä junaan mutta plääni cois totas lekurille 1v kroonista limaa sieltä heh keuhk 1v...
You take the Rolling Stones during their heroin period and you put them through a distortion pedal. If that sounds like your thing, well, have I got the album for you!
мрачно, неинтересно и вики смешная)
Whyyyy do we get so much noise rock on here? Terrible album.
Not on Spotify
noisy, i didn’t mind the sound of this to be fair, i found there wasnt many stand outs in my opinion and it just felt a bit dragged on, not a bad listen overall though just wouldn’t listen to it again, pretty mediocre
I don't have many words to say about this, honestly. It wasn't as noisy as I was worrying it'd be, and thank goodness for that. Going by the reviews and the samples Spotify provided, I was worried I was in for "noise purely for noise's sake." While I still don't think it adds to much, it's not completely unbearable. And what they're playing behind all the noise... Yep, it's 2000's garage rock revivial. Ultimately, I think I'd rather be listening to The White Stripes, bit as the "we have it at home" variety... It's not gonna "save rock n' roll," but in a pinch, it's fine. And that's my final verdict. "It's fine." A big ol' down-the-middle 3. Which, hey, I was expecting to give this thing a 2, or even a 1, so if I were The Icaris Line I'd be happy with a 3. I also, as well, wouldn't be surprised that I was taken out of later editions of the book.
It's got a bit too much feedback noise for my liking, but it's mostly just some alright 2000's rock with some heavy Stooges / Iggy Pop influence. 3.5 down to 3.
I’m at a 1.5 that I’m going to round down to a 1. That is the first, and hopefully last time I will ever have to write a sentence like that. This album fluctuated for a while in terms of where I was at with it; I thought the first track, “Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers” was fine – not super captivating, but just ultimately fine. I thought the second track, “Spit on It” was obnoxiously mixed and I quickly thought this would be a completely disastrous trainwreck. On the Lash had the worst intro ever, and started to reaffirm my fears, until it ended up actually being pretty good. Caviar was fine, but just sort of a directionless slog. Spike Island was decent – not that good, but it was enjoyable enough that I liked it. Kiss Like Lizards is the highest point of the album – I genuinely think it’s a great track with a lot of fun energy. By that point, I was probably at around a 2.5 that I could bump up to a 3. It was poorly mixed, sure, but it wasn’t so bad that I couldn’t appreciate what the album was going for, it just wasn’t gonna be fully my thing. Getting Bright at Night is one of the longest, loudest, and least substantial tracks I think we’ve gotten on any album so far. It is a never-ending 9-minute mess with a never-ending guitar that never once lets the song breathe on its own merits, and it immediately fucking dragged down the mood. The sad part is that the album gets in one last good gasp of air with Big Sleep, which I thought was pretty enjoyable. After that point, from Track 9 (White Devil) and onward, the album just… ugh. Tracks 9 and 10 are fine, but completely boring – they exist for the sake of padding. Track 11, Virgin Velcro, is decent enough but it’s not doing anything new or special. By now, every song just blended together and felt the same to me, even the better ones. At this point, I had simply grown tired of the album. Seasick is decent enough until the final 2 minutes. The final 2 minutes of Seasick broke me. It’s just noise. It’s genuinely just noise. It’s not even noise with vocals to give the appearance of music. It’s truly just noise, and it’s not even noise that’s good and relaxing in the white noise Brian Eno-esque sort of way – it’s some of the most grating and painfully awful noise ever put to tape to be commercially sold. There’s not a single positive behind it. It grows louder and louder, and then it just… transitions into “Party the Baby Off,” as I’m just supposed to accept that I had my ear to the door of a T-1000 getting tortured in a lab for the last 2 minutes like it didn’t fucking exist. Party the Baby Off has some of the worst lyrics I’ve ever heard in any album closer ever. “But motherfuckers do what they have to, beat your face black and blue” before repeating “take off all your clothes” as the album faded out was genuinely the final straw for me. It genuinely went from an album where 3 of the first 6 tracks were fine to being an utter trainwreck of an album that I simply had no respect for. Don’t get me wrong, I still think that On the Lash, Spike Island, Kiss Like Lizards, and Big Sleep are all good tracks, and I might throw those in my playlists. However, this album just soured on me to such a deeply harsh fucking degree that I simply don’t think I can even give it a 2, as much as I thought about doing so. If this had had even a decent closing track, I could’ve probably been nice and gone up to a 2, just barely, if only to reward the good tracks for actually being good. It’s just not there for me. When I gave Maxinquaye a 1, it was because I simply found the album to be deeply boring – there was no energy and it did absolutely nothing for me. I’m at a 1.5 with this one, and because of the lyrics in that last track, I simply refuse to bump it up to a 2. I do think this album has a better energy and is probably still better than Maxinquaye, but it’s the third time I’m giving an album a 1 (fuck you Kid Rock), and it’s only because it had such an extreme decline that just made me feel disappointed that I even listened to it by the end. This did not need to be on the list.
Boot this album off the list right to hell.
Not much interest in scream rock.
Huh… really random. Like a sleazier White Stripes? Honestly sounded like so many other bands but did not click at all tbh…
Somewhat fun in its noisiness but mostly seemed pretty bland and unremarkable!
Sincerely, I need to find out where the hell the guy who made this list is finding these albums, the music here was completely fine, totally unremarkable - nothing about this album was influential, it didn't even get good reviews when it came out. Really the only thing remarkable about this album is that it's on this 1001 album list... basically sounded like a White Stripes cover band but a bit edgier and honestly not that good !
Listen, I liked this. But I recognize why this didn’t break out in 2004 and has to settle for critical praise. It’s not that different from most of the garage and dance rock we were getting in this era. I’m thinking Louis XIV, We Are Scientists or Black Rebel Motorcycle Club. This album is crying out for 1 or 2 radio singles. If it had at least 1 I would be giving this 5 stars. Alas, 4 is all you’re getting
Yep
Not bad. Some tracks rock hard. 🤘🏼
At the time this came out, there was probably a heavier expectation that The Icarus Line would be among the biggest rock bands of the 2000s. Instead it's another point of evidence that critics had a less than clear reading of what music fans (and the masses) wanted out of the early '00s. This album barely made a splash in the larger scheme of things, and I can think of a handful of albums that could've taken this one's place. Musically, it's nothing interesting either. A lot of groups were going for this sound and most of them did it better than The Icarus Line. All that said, Caviar was a pretty good song.
The whole time this felt like I was listening to a knock off early White Stripes album that took direction from Lou Reed.
Very nice rock album.
I happen to like this and think it does have a place on a list like this.
Slightly tolerable noise rock at points, but the occasional unwanted guitar/instrument shrieks became piercing to my ears. Nothing really ever stands out in noise rock in my opinion.
Whatever. Why is this on the list?
I think we just found the worst album on this list. A reminder of what happens when you don't hug your kids.
unbelievably generic
This week has been all over the place in terms of artists. Bouncing from well known to not so well known. Today’s album is another one of those instances where it makes me wonder what the authors sources were, and how he found some of these. When I clicked on this band’s Spotify profile, and saw that they just barely had about 1,500 monthly listeners, I was legitimately shocked. Being able to see every number in the streams of the most popular songs is always really weird. If we are basing this list on most influential and most popular, how in the world is this here? I’m aware of how horribly cruel that sounds, but it confuses me. Another thing I found amusing is a quote from the Wikipedia article. “It was one of 2004's most critically acclaimed releases…”. Maybe 20 years ago when this released it was worthy of critical acclaim, but if you look at the general consensus now, it’s mostly negative. They aren’t even that many people talking about this anyway. RYM? A total of 471 ratings, with less than 20 actual reviews. AOTY? Only 22 ratings, and a whopping 2 reviews. Who knows, I might be writing the longest review this album has ever received. All I have done so far is shit on this. So let me actually devote some time into talking about the things that I like. You know, even after everything I said, all in all this album isn’t actually half bad. It’s not amazing or anything. But for a small band, I think they manage to sound pretty good, and the production quality is surprisingly high. The vocalist was cool and intense at best, and maybe a little lame at worst. Really my biggest issue is identity. For as heavy and borderline violent that this sounds, it also tries to be experimental and pull together a nine minute long song with build-up like Getting Bright at Night. A lot of this probably comes from the guitarist, who would go on to tour with Nine Inch Nails. You can definitely hear the inspiration too. But if I was in the mood for this kind of music, I would go for other artists from the same time period, like The White Stripes, first. Rating: 6/10
meh
Too hard for me, nope.
Didn't particularly enjoy this but I made it to the end and was glad it was over.
I somehow feel like I should have enjoyed this more than I did but... felt very meh listening to it. I love some of the "dirty" sound of a lot of the instruments a lot tbh BUT something about the exact combo of play style and vocals made me kind of bored actually?
Partly nice
No jaa 2/5
AIka hyvä garagelevy! 4/5
I wasn't biting my nails waiting for this to end, but when it was over I just thought, huh. And felt nothing. Would not listen again.
Here's the deal. I listened to this whole album yesterday. Today I had to go back and play snippets to remember it. Maybe that's on me, but it just kinda sounded like early 2000's rock. I'd go to a show but it just sounds a lot like a lot of other bands.
Feels like they had aspirations of Sonic Youth, The Jesus and the Mary Chain, and My Bloody Valentine without the compelling hooks or song arrangements. Just endless amounts of feedback noise masturbation with little to no differentiation between songs. Lyrics don't matter, as you can't possible discern what is said without reading them, so who cares? Perhaps one of the most pointless albums I have ever heard. Favorite "songs": none Definitely does not belong on this list. Just keeps proving my hunch that the Naughties were the worst decade of popular music ever.
I thought I'd like this more considering their obvious influences, but I found it boring and uninspired.
Penance Soiree is quite annoying because it's really like 80% generic noise without structure or purpose, forgettable in an instant, with a few decent and interesting moments scattered throughout that tease that they were capable of doing something a lot better but not smart enough to realise that. Please save me from this, it's been three weeks since I gave a 4, this is another disappointing 2.
Another non-entity of an album that left me feeling nothing beyond a mild sense of frustration. It's too long (both the album as a whole and most of the individual songs), and it's too slow through most of it. If you're going to be noisy rather than tuneful, you need more energy than the vast majority of this album brings. It's all just so disparate, and the bits that are completely noise can get in the bin. 2/5.
Cross between subways and Jesus lizard - quite good
Absolutely nothing compelling about this album
first listen. Pretty cool but I got tired of it rather fast
Great production. That bass tone! Good songs and a fun mix of styles. Bonus points for the sick album cover.
This band was clearly very into Spacemen 3 and you can hear it on Big Sleep. Still, this is pretty mediocre.
Pretty good
This started off promising but after a couple songs just sounded like the same thing over and over again.
Better than I thought, 3.6
AI-generated 'garage rock'
Didn't enjoy this, even though it seemed like it would be right up my alley. 2/5
Wow. 1,508 monthly listeners on Spotify. I guess 1,508 users get this album a month haha. It says that Icarus Line was inspired by the Stooges. I had a Stooges album yesterday. Opening track was pretty good honestly. High energy and hard hitting. Most of these songs were pretty decent with a few songs that were a bit too much and a little headache inducing. Can definitely hear a lot of influence from The Stooges, Queens of the Stone Age, and The Strokes. Honestly not bad but I don't really understand why it made this list. Getting Bright at Night was a pretty sick song.
This was kind of cool. Pretty aggressive post hardcore punk kind of stuff. When I have to read up on an album from the last 20 years, its usually not a good sign. Apparently this was an important album for the genre? But.. they only get like 1500 monthly listens, so I really don't know. It was cool, but I probably won't revisit it.
Sounds like fooling around in the backyard while my stepdad blasts dated rock albums in the garage, complete with power tools. Noisy and forgettable. The last song was alright, but it's possible i was just glad to be done. I think it'd be a good album to listen to if you needed to stand near a lawnmower for a while.
McLusky vibes at it's best
Songwrighting doesn't appear to have been high on the list of important things when this album was made. Noise, on the other hand .... 1.5/5
fucking garbage
The White Stripes rip-off for sure. But really? This doesn't seem to have had any impact on the culture in the 20 years since it was released. Not to say it was terrible. I love the White Stripes, but if I wanted to listen to that type of music, I'll listen to them.
I can’t decide it this is a mediocre example of music of its era and it aged badly or if it was bad 20 years ago. Given that there’s still music from this era that I listen to, I suspect it was always bad.
GOOD
Yeah kind of alright, bit screamy in places, like the longer song on there
I won't stoop to calling this shoegaze, because it would do the genre injustice. Most of the album is over-distorted rock nonsense with apparently zero thought put into production or a positive listening experience. For the most part, the only discernible feature of the vocals is an American twang, and this is because everything is horribly mixed, making it impossible to appreciate the musicality of any one instrument. I listened to the YouTube playlist, and the comments were wack, as the kids say. Nearly every comment was either unintelligible gibberish, or called this "the last good rock music", "nothing even comes close", and so on. But don't get me wrong – it's not the worst on this list. At least it's coherent music with some vestige of skill. But it's still pretty bad, and these commenters can't see that. Crazy. I mean, if you have to include an anonymous garage rock album, go off, I guess. But this choice seems quota-filling more than anything else. If Penance Soiree really is one of the 1001 most important albums in (Western) musical history, as this list is meant to showcase, then I'll eat my hat. 1/5 Key tracks: Spike Island, The Icarus Line
not my kind of music
So this is my 1001st album. Although there was never really a time that I seriously considered quitting this list it’s still somewhat mind blowing to actually be at the 1001st album. There’s still about 80 albums left so I’ll save all the reminiscing and reflecting and highlighting for the real end but even now I’m starting to get that bittersweet, college graduation feeling about something that’s been a part of my life for years coming to an end. As for the actual album, the more I listened to it, the more I enjoyed it. Thought it was going to be annoying nu metal at first but it turned out to be a really fun mish mash of rock subgenres. Rage against the machine and the whole grunge movement were the biggest influences but I also got early 00s alternative vibes. Big sleep, virgin Velcro, and party the baby off were all standouts but none of the tracks really stood above the rest; was more of a full album experience type thing.
A passable if forgettable noise rock album that just didn’t really stand out from a lot of similar bands (not quite the same style, but the fact that Relationship in Command by At the Drive-In isn’t on this list is pretty ridiculous)
It’s rock. I guess it’s metal. Wouldn’t say it’s very heavy. The lead singer’s voice often drones. If there was a genre called sleepy metal, several of the songs would fit that description. Didn’t hear anything special in this one.
Noisy
Merely fine.
Þó svo að ég sé rokkari í hjartanu þá er þetta ekki rokk sem mér finnst eitthvað spes. Algjört meðalmoð sem mun líklegast aldrei fara aftur á fóninn hjá mér. Ég verð fljótur að gleyma þeim. Sko, ég er meira að segja búinn að gleyma þeim núna strax. Aðeins verra en miðjuplötur.
Once again why? Why is this band and this album on this list? So many more better bands and albums than this dribble. I can’t understand half of their words and when I did wished that I had not.
They sound like a really bad Radiohead mixed with Muse like really bad not listen to them occasionally but listen to them never bad. But I could be wrong because they could be even worse than stated
I mean it was okay. It kinda reminded me of The Vines. The lyrics were kinda meh but instrumentally it sounded pretty alright. I dunno this really didn’t sound that innovative or fresh to me just kinda some more meh garage rock. Don’t think this should’ve been on the list and don’t understand how it got critical acclaim and stuff it’s not that great.
just felt like garage band noise. once again-why is this on the list? how is it notable?
Meh
Not for me. 1/5
From "Spike Island" forward, it's a good album. Maybe the label showed a lack of interest because they listened to only the first four songs.
Not my thing these days. A bit heavy
By genres listed, this should be something I like, but I just don't really think it's all that good. Feels more like southern/blues hard rock than it does noise/garage. Will I listen to again: 5%
46/100 Mildly decent but extremely forgettable
Not particularly notable. Sounds like an amalgamation of artists who came before. Not sure it's deserving of the list, but wasn't terrible either.
Another album in this project where I'm just finding myself wondering.....why??
5/5 - fun album
Never heard of this band but I enjoyed this album.
WAT DOET DIT IN DE LIJST?!? Niet relevant, toen niet, en nu niet. Dit genre staat verder nauwelijks in de lijst, maar ik denk dat er betere voorbeelden te bedenken zijn. Niet onluisterbaar, maar ook niet goed.
Nope
I like noise rock. I'm indifferent to this attempt of noise rock.
I tried to find a way into this and I thought it had merit and some musicality, but it's just not something I can get excited by.
Did not enjoy this one; a wasted slot on this list.
This is noise. Not bad noise but the noise level stays consistent from one song to another through the first half of the album. That to me, doesn’t separate the songs from one another like I personally like to hear. That also means that there really isn’t a stand out song. Later listening and they remind me of Jet. So if you like Jet, these guys may be for you. Choice cut: Caviar
Feel like we haven’t gotten other rock like this through 1001 yet. Reminded me of Jane’s addiction
More like Ick-arus amiright
I can't say that I liked this very much...
Noise/ Garage rock is not a genre I enjoy, especially when done as boring and forgettable as this.
Penance Soiree presents a musically solid offering, showcasing an adeptness in crafting intense and raw rock compositions. The album exudes a gritty energy that is undeniably captivating, drawing you into its chaotic sonic landscape. However, while the music is fine, it fails to leave a lasting impression compared to bands like Black Rebel Motorcycle Club and At the Drive In, who were pioneering similar sonic territories during the same era. The album's production quality is commendable, capturing the band's raw intensity with clarity and precision. Vocalist Joe Cardamone delivers a passionate performance, infusing each track with a sense of urgency and conviction. The guitar work is particularly noteworthy, with dynamic riffs and blistering solos adding depth to the band's sound. Despite its musical prowess, Penance Soiree lacks the innovation and distinctiveness that set apart other contemporaneous acts in the post-punk and garage rock scene. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 0 STAND OUT TRACK - None
This is a real deep cut from the 1001 Albums book, but I guess this random ass band still has people listening to their album more than the myriad of other garage punk bands from 2004. This was pretty cool though, I'm glad I heard it. Yeah it sounds like The Vines or White Stripes at times, but there's also a darker edge to it that's pretty cool (that one track Meatmaker literally sounds like a Suicide song). I'd come back to this. 3.5/5
Du garage rock qui ne se démarque aucunement. J'avais l'impression d'écouter une copie de White Stripes en plus noisy. Tout le long j'avais beaucoup de misère à rester intéressé, souvent j'oubliais qu'il jouait. 4/10
solid album from start to finish. garage rock reminiscent of jack white. highlights: “up against the wall motherfuckers” “caviar” “kiss like lizards”
Never even heard of this. Too bad about their shitty record label. Let’s go! This may not be the album for me. Whoever made this list really likes British bands Spike island the first listenable track Virgin Velcro is intriguing. Best so far
It’s not TERRIBLE but there is no place in my world where I would ever pick this. Musically it’s derivative and repetitive. They write and play but do they know why?
Noisy
Weirdly varied but mostly very noisy
Very mediocre noise
just loud heavy rock album with distortion, reminds me of the white stripes and queens of the stone age, has good songs but nothing special
This started out way better than it ended.
Hubo muchos y mucho mejores discos en 2004: Nick Cave- Abattoir Blues / The Lyre of Orpheus, Arcade Fire- Funeral, Wilco – A Ghost Is Born, Bart Davenport – Game Preserve, Interpol – Antics, Tom Waits – Real gone, Franz Ferdinand – Franz Ferdinand, Modest Mouse – Good news for people who love bad news, Brian Wilson – Smile, Lambchop – Aw c’mon / No you c’mon, The Dears – No cities left, The Divine Comedy – Absent friends, The Delgados – Universal audio, MORRISSEY - You are the quarry, Kasabian-Kasabian, Sonic Youth- Sonic Nurse, THE ORGAN - THE ORGAN, ADAN GREEN - FRIENDS OF MINE, Ye (Kanye West)- The College dropout, Keane- Hopes and feras, TV on the radio- Desperate, Youth, Blood, Green Day - American Idiot, PINBACK-Summer in Abaddon... Este de The Icarus Line tuvo muy buena acogida, aunque para mi gusto inferior a los citados. Incluye una buena ración de Post-hardcore, garaje, punk, noise, rock a secas... caminos transitados por otros como White Stripes , Nine Inch Nails o Mars Volta por citar algunos coetáneos suyos.
Post hardcore crossed with a bit of Queens of the Stone Age. Excellent vocals and band sounds amazing as a whole. Not heard of this band, but it rocks.
"Penance Soiree" is second full-length album by Los Angles post-harcore band The Icarus Line. Garage rock and noise rock are the listed genres. I'd add in stoner rock and just plain hard rock. The band had recorded most of the album the year before but in-fighting with their record label V2 about lack of support delayed things. The album was one of 2004's most critically acclaimed albums. Swirling noises and guitar sounds open "Up Against the Wall Motherfucker." Drums and a loud bass push things at a grinding pace which speeds up. Joe Cardamore's vocals remind me of Layne Staley and The Cults' Ian Astbury. The one thing this song does do is rock. "On the Lash" adds distortion and feedback to the guitars' sounds. This is fast. These guys aren't messing around. The band grinds through some songs ("Geting Bright at Night" and "White Devil") in the middle part of the album. Very much stoner rock with extended jams and distortion. The last two songs bring the heavy but also more of the melody. "Seasick" slows things up and actually adds an acoustic guitar which gives a decent melody. Just so you know it's them, they end the song with two minutes of feedback. The last song "Party the Baby Off" brings the pop-rock. Melodic, layered and catchy guitar hooks. Enough guitar weirdness to keep it interesting. Maybe the best song on the album. There's no doubt this band can just fuckin' rock when they want to. Distorted layered guitars, bass heavy. The music moving like sludge and then speeding up heading into thrash metal terroritory. They reminded me of a lot of bands including Alice in Chains, the Cult, Monster Magnet, Soundgarden and the Smashing Pumpkins. Overall, I found this to be a pretty decent album. So, if you like any of the bands mentioned above, you'll probably like this.
This album wasn't great, but at least it was long. Released in 2004, this album clearly is trying to be part of the early 2000s garage rock revival, trying to be experimental, yet is firmly rooted in 90s alternative rock and post-hardcore. This doesn't necessarily mean that the record shouldn't work, but there's certainly something not right here. I find when albums are trying to fit too many genres in their music, they end up doing nothing well. That's the case here. The garage rock is watered down and doesn't sound organic or spontaneous, the noise elements seem forced, and the alt rock is bland.
Imagine if the Mars Volta were boring, then you'd get this as a result.
I’m a fan of noise rock, but this just didn’t click for me. There were parts that I enjoyed punctuated by atonal noise that went nowhere. Surprised this is on the list when there are many others who have done it better. Liked about half the songs.
Not for me. Might be worth a relisten though
Gotta love a band who have a link to their official MySpace on Wikipedia. I didn’t like a couple of the song titles, and the music isn’t my thing, but it wasn’t too bad. Bit Jane’s Addictiony?
High-school me probably would've loved this the when it came out.
Meh just sounds like a staler version of the early 2000s rock scene Rating: 2.0
More EA Sports game menu core! This and Fever to Tell by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs are MLB 2k5 pilled and Madden 04 celled. In fact, a song on this album was actually in a Tony Hawk game soundtrack. So I’ll expand the genre to PS2 core. Some defining characteristics of PS2 core: distorted guitars…and vocals…and everything else, pop-punk lyrics, couch co-op, media player buried in the settings where you can remove songs from your game, that one dad in your neighborhood that had the PS2 internet card and played strangers in madden online, rogue rap songs that can’t be found on the internet anymore, bad graphics and worse dialogue, chaotic drums. I look back with fond memories but objectively don’t love the music
There were like 2 good songs. The rest of this album was mid & cap. it’s like a 1.5 so i rounded up
I don’t like it but I appreciate it
reasonable sound
Post hardcore that despite a serviceable rhythm section seems to just sound like drivel. Too many grunge and noise rock bands it tries to sound like but doesn't come up with a memorable sound - it just doesn't make up it's mind. Many songs seem to start out fine but guitar and vocals just come off as self absorbed garbage.
I cannot understand the wave of disgust this record causes. It simply is somewhat meeh. Not hard to listen to at all. What is all the fuzz about the noise? There is not too much of it, instead rather traditional songwriting with a tendency to overextend the content, both lyrically and musically. There are moments to be cherished, moments better discarded, and a lot of overblown nothingness inbetween. It feels dated, most of all. I did not know it before and will surely quickly forget. Nothing to have listened to before dying. 2.5, but down rating due to its insignificance.
Really enjoyed this album. Everything was on point and really engaging and fun to listen to. Will most definitely listen again. The vocal performance was really emotional and kept me hooked in. The band were amazing and together it just worked so well. I can't wait to keep listening to this album, it isn't a genre I usually listen to but this might be the start of my journey into it.
Very noisy instruments, which I don't usually like, but listening to it made me feel like rodrick in the live action diary of a wimpy kid movie. So that's positive
This is adjacent to music I quite like - Hot Snakes and Bitch Magnet examples in mind - but remain ambivalent about as a concept. This kind of twisty, angular, declarative rock mostly eschews tunes while staying clear of pure timbre, freeform wanderings, so needs killer riffs and dynamics to work for me. My conception of the form is of records composed almost entirely of the instrumental, interstitial/linking bits of Led Zep records. Maybe some Black Sab intros and outros are in the mix too, or ZZ Top if you’re Shellac. Thé riffs and dynamics on this are just workmanlike, while the record is far too long and the singing starts sounding more yap-yap-yap than manifesto-making as it goes on: the creepiness of the final repeated lines feel like an inevitability. The songs containing Suicide-esque synth pulses pleased my ears, but are more like postures of allegiance than musical decisions.
What is this shit? (Mark - bonus point if you get the reference; two if you explore that path instead of this fetid turd) Did a high school band hear The Stooges 30 years too late? Why should I suffer the consequences?
Certainly they had a lot of ideas but tried to do too much, and that leaves this album lacking Identity and cohesion. Even within some tracks it feels like throwing mud at the wall, and seeing what sticks. Over a 53 minute album that just makes it seem like everything blurs together into a mush. I don't completely hate it but would find it hard to pick a highlight
2.5
Not too bad
Really good
Good Noisy Very good
I didn’t want to Spit On It, but I was getting a little Seasick. We did make it to Spike Island to Party the Baby Off
Interesting find - not the most remarkable of records and gets a bit samey by the end but one I’d like to explore further
Noise rock, indeed. Did not finish.
Honestly? The whole album kind of ran together. Nothing stood out to me at all. Very much all sounded the same. I could see myself liking this maybe back in 2019-2020. Maybe worth revisiting but I doubt I’ll change my opinion
2.5
This felt to me like a garage band, a punk band, and a grunge band had a wild weekend threesome and this baby was the result. It's messed up but totally accepts and embraces who it is, in spite of what its therapist says about it all being dad's and mom's and other dad's fault.
Before Today – 3.5 Wrong – 3.5 Single – 3.5 The Heart Remains a Child – 3.5 Walking Wounded – 3 Flipside – 3.5 Big Deal – 3 Mirrorball – 3.5 Good Cop, Bad Cop – 3 Average - 3.33 She has a nice voice and I liked the Electronic aspects of it but I just found it quite boring
I honestly found myself spacing out for this one. The album lost steam as I picked up on the band’s style. I can see how influential it would have been but it’s ultimately not for me.
It was okay; nothing stellar. Good listen, but got bored near the end.
alright. i liked it more towards the end
Good listen, interesting sound.
It was just noise
Up Fav songs: Up against the wall morherfucker =]
Little too coarse for my liking
Heyrðu, já, þetta er leiðinlegt. Misleiðinlegt svo sem, en alltaf leiðinlegt.
Pretty good! Grimy, grinding rock and roll shifting back and forth in intensity. Probably won't seek out more but I enjoyed it.
Before today, I'd never heard of The Icarus Line. After listening to "Penance Soiree", that makes total sense. I can't recall ever hearing electric guitars sound so unpleasant. These guys may be skilled musicians, but their overindulgence on effects pedals is awful. It sounds like white noise. It's torturous. If you don't believe me, listen to "Spit On It". The one decent song on here is called "Getting Bright at Night". However, they decide to drag this track out for over 9 minutes. Fucking hell, lads, ever hear the phrase, "Don't outstay your welcome"? You can hear their musical influences throughout the album. There's hints of Soundgarden, The Jesus and Mary Chain, NIN, Violent Femmes, and Iggy Pop. So these lads clearly have great taste in music. The problem is, they don't have the creativity to produce that same level of magic. There's nothing catchy or interesting or enjoyable on this album. Give it a miss. 👎👎
Didn't mind this one. Solid punk album.
I had to skip some songs. They were too annoying.
Certainly interesting to review a hardcore album after some of the genres recently. These guys aren't bad. It's a ton of noise but they are decently technical. Not my favourite but for what it is they've done well.
The opening track tells me this could be hard to get through. I got through 3 tracks and couldn't take it anymore. I partially listened to the tracks after that. I'm sorry, I couldn't handle it. I found nothing redeemable.
The band is so loud, yet they make no real noise. The singer is doing so much, yet saying so little. There are so many notes, yet no actual melodies. So much effort for such little payoff. Complete anonymity. Example #36 of “why *must* I hear this before I die?” 2/5
14-year-old me would have loved this. On track 2... This sucks :) I'm all about noise and rock 'n' roll, but this isn't hitting the mark - it's just kinda boring! Haven't they ever heard of dynamic range? The lyrics are so cliche and faux-edgy! I hate his voice! Ahh!
At first, I thought it was a passable early 2000s garage rock album with a noisy punk rock edge, but the vocals aren't great, and the songs aren't very memorable. However, what made me truly dislike this album was the awful production. Every track is cranked up and drenched in distortion so thick that every element of every song fights for dominance in the mix. I gave up halfway through because it was giving me a headache; it was simply unlistenable.
Nothing impressive
Powerful, groovy and best without the overly dramatic Vocalist.
Didn't work for me
Maybe 15 years ago I would have loved this album. It’s not for me now.
Sounded like a Jet rip-off but somehow worse? Just not into it, like at all.
Noisy and boring.
Interesting Album, enjoyed the 2nd half more than the first. Standout songs: Spike Island Big Sleep White Devil
The first half of this album was alright, a solid 6/10. The second half however was in my opinion way better, 8/10. I like harder rock but this was definitely a great listen. Complete album : 7/10
nah. not it. a little generic
Noisy but not in a good way
They were neither very popular nor innovators nor trendsetters, so I don't understand why this album is on the list. Not the worst ever, but 3 songs too long for me. Bands like the Birthday Party, the Jesus Lizard (not on the list) and Girls vs Boys did it better years and years before. Favorite song: spit on it.
I honestly tried to listen to this but couldn’t do it!
Hard to believe I’ve not previously heard of this band. Sounds very pre-grunge (despite debuting 10 years later).
blecch
Very similar to The White Stripes, but with more of a noise rock feel. Wasn’t feeling this one too much, and I usually like early-2000s garage rock revival. It was a bit boring and a little grating.
The distorted guitars and droning vocals are just so overdone. They still had a decent sound, but ruined their own momentum with unnecessary abrasive noise sections
What if the White Stripes filled out their sound a bit more? What if the garage rock revival broke off from conventional garage rock songwriting? What if the world was made of pudding. By far the noisiest 21st century album on this list, embracing full feedback and walls of sound that feels like a trademark of the loudness war (thanks, Rubin!) I feel the garage rock revival style doesn't quite gel well enough with the noise rock that aims to subvert a lot of typical trappings of popular rock. It goes in some interesting directions, such as the big switch-up in Getting Bright at Night and the industrial influence on Meatmaker. That said, Penance Soiree often feels like it drags on for too long with disjointed ideas, making for an overall messy album. Wikipedia claims that this is "one of 2004's most critically acclaimed releases", though the quality of the article leads me to believe that it's legacy has since been forgotten. The truth is that it does some interesting things, but not enough to warrant retrospective praise.
Solid early 2000s rock album. Nothing particularly interesting/catchy and no real stand out tracks on first listen. Worth another listen sometime.
This one was okay, but didn't resonate with me much. Kind of an odd pick for must listen records.
Album 323 of 1001 The Icarus Line - Penance Soiree Rating : 1 / 5 Haven't rated any other rock album this low. Just nothing really there, for me I saw a review on the album that stated, "this is what you'd hear on a network tv show when they need some "edgy" rock music, like in CSI when they go to a seedy club to question someone, or when a main character spins out." That fits.
This was something else, maybe in the right headspace it’d be palatable but I was not feeling it
It was okay - don't get why I needed to listen to this
Feel like I need to stop giving 3* ratings, wish I could give this 3.5. reminding me of royal blood
Not for me 2*
Very much in my wheelhouse but was never that bothered about them at the time. Still its good but nothing special...
A mishmash of different rock and roll tropes including indie, noise and just straight up metal. Quite interesting but altogether amounts to little of meaning or enjoyment.
First listen Saved 6/13: Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers On the Lash Caviar Spike Island Getting Bright At Night Big Sleep
Hell yeah, this is sick! It sucks so bad about the label issues because I never heard of this (presumably due to that) and I love it. I would've 100% been a huge fan of this album when it dropped. Regardless, I'm glad to have found it now at least. Noisy garage rock is my jam.
Lively background music.
A bit too hard rock for me.
Alright for early oughts punk, nothing to really write home about, very middle of the road
Bass riff on the opening track was cool. Pretty middle of the road after that
Decent
This was hard
Really couldn’t get into it. Didn’t even finish.
Garbage
2.5
Not bad.
Who cares about neuroplasticity - I can't listen any more.
They say don’t judge an album by its cover. Based in its cover I thought I’d hate this one, but I didn’t. I ended up liking how the long songs build. Unfortunately there are still enough stinkers here to prevent me from fully recommending it.
Surprisingly small band to make this list. Seemed like some classic rock/metal with maybe some emo influences in tone and lyrics? Overall a fan!
Meh. Not sure why this one is a must listen before oyu die album.
fine, typically rock/punk sound.
Hipster bullshit. Emperor's new clothes. Fuck these guys.
I'm not sure if I loved this or not, I think I'd have to listen to it a few more times to be sure.
No.
It kinda drags on... Cool sound, and I almost like it, but probably won't revisit.
Better than I expected. Reminds me of Filter put in a blender with Zeppelin
Kind of like the White Stripes. But I'll take the white stripes.
Tasty.
Hmm...I like a lot of things about it, but it lacks any pop predictably. So maybe that's good for my brain. But it's hard to listen to for too long. Mostly just sounds like chaos...but in a style that I like?
Forgettable, but 3 stars for good moments and exceeding expectations
nah
Franchement cool, j'ai bien aimé caviar et spike island il me semble !
Unexpectedly enjoyable. It's on the right side of noise for me. A good wall of sound with melody still coming through. Very good album.
Not my thing. To quote my parents, "this is just noise and screeching- not music". Probably useful for psychological torture....
NOISY ROCKING ROCK, SORTA HURTS THE EARS, BUT SORTA LOVE IT Fav songs: On The Lash, Spike Island
Very noisy
Some of this was cool, some was annoying. Ultimately, I’ll probably forget about it. 3/5
Absolutely mid... just Soundgarden wannabes
Never heard of this band before. This whole album went by without grabbing my attention. Just not my cup of tea.
Not available on Spotify
Very grungy and not that enjoyable. But I didn't hate it so much I couldn't finish it
The first song is great but that's about it.
I guess I'm just not punk rock enough for this album. I like my music to be hooky and catchy, and while there are a few songs on here that come close (and they kind of sound like pale imitations of bands like the Rolling Stones, Audioslave, and Smashing Pumpkins), it's a lot of noise and stream of consciousness about being drugged up and depressed. "Spit On It" attempts to take on the capitalistic corruption of art, but it just sounds like bad high school poetry. There's also a vein of misogyny that runs through the album and peaks on the last 3 songs, which are all pretty gross. There are a couple ok moments. "Getting Bright at Night" has an interesting change up in the last 3 minutes of the 9-minute song and "Big Sleep" contains some interesting imagery in yet another song about drugs and depression. Overall, the album is repetitive and, to me at least, feels derivative. There's nothing original about sex, drugs, and rock n roll, and they don't seem to offer anything new. This album is kind of a one-trick pony.
Rock macarra.
Not a single memorable track on the album. Only thing I’ll remember is how awful this album was.
It's fine. I think the energy of chaos would be excellent live, if you're into that sort of thing, but it was a lot less exciting listening to it.
This was a hard one to find. I resorted to a youtube playlist that a fan had created in the end. At the start I was excited to what appeared to be a post hardcore band in the same vein as At The Drive In. Its not though. There's flashes of brilliance in here, but the album meanders around a bit, seemingly trying to find a direction. I wouldn't call it exceptional, but there's enough to get me to go check out what else they have done. On subsequent listens it gets better and I find myself liking it quite a lot.
Well that was a nice surprise, never heard of them before. This is my kind of rock music, the kind that prefers being loud and aggressive and maybe a little sloppy, instead of sounding pristine and perfect. Love the singer's energy, fits it perfectly. Good entry. (Just looked and of course it has a 2.5 rating, you people suck)
this was probably the smallest band on this list, less than 1500 monthly listeners, so an odd choice seemingly. they were fine, just not my favorite genre overall
Sucks
I’m sure if you were there at the time it made sense. I wasn’t there.
A really interesting album - quite aggressive at points, and I liked it!
Not bad, hard rock album.
A tuneless facsimile of some much better bands. Sounds very pretty dated in 2024. Has no place on the 1001 list.
It's fine, but there's better noise rock out there.
Some rock but nothing special
Boring
its okay rock, not my type of metal.
Unrelenting
I generally think that rock singers should get a pass or at least far more latitude on the quality of their singing, but dear god does this guy suck at it. It's like the guy from the Hives was asked to do vocal tracking while wearing ear plugs. Nothing memorable here, just another attempt to jump on the "The Nouns" bandwagon.
Lucky for this album that it came along the day after listening to The Cramps, it made this album immeasurably better. Mind you, a bunch of saucepans being dropped down the stairs would sound better than The Cramps. Anyway, The Icarus Line is not my thing at all, but I listened to the whole album so 2 stars for that.
Not really my thing but I can tell it’s good if it’s your thing
Beaucoup de bruit pour pas grand chose. Si tous les instruments jouaient le même morceau ce serait plus sympa. Certaines difficilement audibles ("Spit on it", l'affreuse "Meatmaker"), certaines juste convenables ("On the lash). Très bof.
No disponible en Spotify
I would have liked this a lot in middle school, it's not so much my type of rock anymore
What the hell is this?
I really do wonder why this is on the list. It's not bad as such, but there's nothing here that I would classify as particularly original or standing out.
This album is in the category of, "we've heard this all before, but done better". Though I like garage noise rock, this doesn't convince me to want to hear anymore from The Icarus Like. There's nothing wrong with it and some of the songs are both intense and interesting, it's just that they don't bring anything new to the table and may have gotten attention (and a record deal) riding some kind of wave of noise music acceptance. I've heard enough!
I should have hated this more
великолепно
если наложить на стандартный гараж/альт рок кучу дисторшна, то насколько это будет классным ноизом?
есть нойз, есть гараж. чуваки не смогли выбрать
Well, I certainly do not hate this as much as the population of reviewers on here do. There are elements of cacophony here, but they definitely do draw away from the album for me like they do for others. 2004 does feel a little late for a band like this though
1.5/5
Nice little punk album
I was unable to listen to Virgin Velcro and Seasick because they're not available in my country on Spotify or Youtube, but I trust the reviews that they're more of the same. I'd hate to leave the project unfinished. Anyway, a lot of distortion. I think there were some good parts, but most didn't mesh well for me. Most was not catchy or interesting.
This album didn’t click with me, didn’t enjoy the singing or the music. A song would get a rhythm that was pleasant to hear and overlay it with so much noise to wrap it up and overlay it. 2/5
I don't get the hate for this. It's a decent rocker, fairly heavy but not overbearingly so, good instrumentation. The bass especially stands out to me. I can definitely see the influence from Iggy Pop/The Stooges. Some of it is kind of dated, sure, but most of the albums from this time are. It kind of falls into a "post grunge we don't know what to do anymore but we all like 70s punk and the White Stripes" category which isn't a bad thing. It does get a little repetitive, that's true. But they certainly deserve more than the whopping 1,440 listeners they have on Spotify...
This felt like a lot of noise. Couldn’t hear or understand the singer. It was weird. Not my jam.
3.5., dobar garaž rock/noise
ei saatavilla
I have heard much worse in this genre, not that it's my thing.
Meh. Pretty noisy. Might've liked this better in high school when I was bitching about my first world problems.
Not totally sure why this album is on here. There are other bands that sound almost identical and made a much larger impact
droning spicy grunge garage band sludge. great background music but there's nothing I could super sink my teeth into here. 3/5
This appears to have a lot of hate, but you know it's a fine noisy late 90s/early 00's rock. Certainly prefer this to nu metal. Very listenable to - but it is too damn long hence only three stars.
4/10. Loud
Some very unmemorable noise rock. 5/10
Bordering on being utter shit. Only thing saving it is that I have heard Napalm Death, All Hope Is Lost, and Reign of Blood before this. All Hope Is Lost was buoyed by the insane drums. Icarus Line can't say the same here. So while not nearly as atrocious as All Hope is Lost I can't rate it higher or lower than that. 2 out of 5.
Beast
While listening, I wasn't sure how I felt about this. It was a lot like yesterday's album by Kings of Leon. They were released the same year and they're both garage rock revival. I didn't hate it but I don't think I liked it very much. Also, like yesterday's album, there were times when I thought it could be something I'd like, but indifference was my overarching emotion.
Slightly less annoying noise metal than the one from a week ago. I did like Getting Bright at Night