Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line

Penance Soiree

The Icarus Line

2.5
Rating
22884
Votes
1
17%
2
34%
3
33%
4
13%
5
3%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 8)

Wasn’t expecting to like this, but I enjoyed several songs quite a bit. As an album, it felt a little long

Loads of bands borrowed the Jesus Lizard and Birthday Party blueprint, all sporting that big-room, Albini-dry drum sound—but only a few nailed it. While Rye Coalition went full ‘rock out with your cock out,’ Icarus Line turned inward, channeling PIL’s sinister squall. Loved it when it dropped, but it’s feeling time-stamped now. Still solid—just nowhere near a 1001 best album contender.

sounds like Marilyn Manson took over as the lead singer of Jane's Addiction, and they took away almost all of the song structure. I listened to this album 2-3 times to see if I was missing something. Turns out, I was not.

On the one hand, not really sure what this album has done to deserve inclusion. I think The Icarus Line drifted into insignificance without actually making any lasting impact on music. On the other hand, I thought it was pretty great so I'm not too bothered. Very typical of a lot of the early/mid-00s garage punk stuff but there's some mild experimentation that separates it from the obvious comparisons to the likes of Jet and BRMC. The long, dark centrepiece, 'Getting Bright At Night' shows they had some ideas above their station, which I can respect. I think the editor took a punt on what might turn out to be of lasting significance. They may have missed on that front here but for me at least, it’s something I’d never have found and am glad I did. Really enjoyed it.

Punk humps Grunge; both left unsatisfied.

Never heard this before. Really quite impactful and enjoyable. Coming on like something between Jane's Addiction, JaMC, and The Music. Pleasant surprise.

This album wasn't on Spotify so I listened to it on Youtube, though I only found 11 out of 13. I do believe the rating wouldn't have changed had I listened those two songs. Other than that I really liked the bass in the first song and their use of noise throughout the album.

Would enjoy the album more if it were just the first track.

Albums like this are why I do this list. Never heard of this group, but I really enjoyed listening to this album. I liked the distortion and edge, angry and noisy, like if grunge and punk had a really loud kid. Excellent album.

Why was this highly rated? This is just sort of painful to listen to.

Fast loud and outtacontrol

Not for me

Not for me

This felt like 3 different bands put into one I kind of liked it

y'all can listen to the clash and say that's not noise but this is??

The first few songs were okay, but it just got so repetitive. Sounds like knock off Jack White.

Sub optimal strokes

Ovo je dobilo veliki hype kad je izašlo ali ono zapravo je tek solidno

Mix is HORRIBLE. and to read in the bio that there were issues over the mix and THIS is what they chose?! Geez. I get it - grunge, messy, dissonant, but I think of something like ‘Deloused..’ and how important the mix is on that and this is what happens when that’s not there. Horrible and feel like I can’t hear or appreciate the songs properly because of it. And also just a bit repetitive. Messy nothingness. A lucky 2*

OK, there is a lot of noise on this album, but flashes of brilliance too. If it was consistently brilliant I would have given it five stars, but although I was in no hurry for the music to come to an end, there were some tracks that just weren't melodic enough for my liking - so four stars it is.

I'd never heard of these guys before - noice

What a load of shit. I tried it over three pieces. This noise is unbearable. And I say that even though I like to listen to Industrial in between. 1/5

This is not a bad album. It's not a good album, but it's not terrible. It's just completely pointless and forgettable.

Ugh. UGH. The worst thing about the advent of CDs is bands being like, well we gotta make hour long bore fests instead of tight cohesive albums. This sucks. It sounds like 5 other better bands.

Too noisy and unresolved. Could've been good otherwise. 2/5

It's alright. Track 2 is horrible a lot is mid and a couple sold songs. 6/10

Wurde schon etwas nervig nach einiger Zeit, war aber auch nicht in der Stimmung dafür.

This wasn’t good when it came out and it’s not good now. Derivative of other groups that did it better and just noise for noise sake.

1. uuall - 1 2. zpit - 0 3. lazh - 1 4. caviar - 1 5. izland - 1 6. kizz - 0 7. night - 1 8. zleep - 0 9. devil - 1 10. meat - 0 11. virgin - 0 12. zea - 0 13. party - 0

Somewhat serviceable screech-rock.

More hard rock album than alternative, in my opinion. Slight rounding up.

Yet another one where I think they're good at what they do, but I just don't love what they're doing. Wait, didn't I just say that for the last album?

Just solid alternative/garage rock. But sometimes on the edge to annoying.

This did nothing for me. It didn’t engage me. It didn’t excite me the way rock music should. At times it was verging on boring ripping over into downright annoying. Never heard of them and don’t get why this is here.

Fuckin noise. One song wasn’t bad

Very much just noisy. The energy is great, people who like this sort of thing probably love it. It's just not for me.

Never heard of this artist. Band reminds me of Death from Above. Also, Royal Blood. Cool stuff. Pretty rocking. Sounds very garage-rock, raw.

I think it's pretty good. It's definitely reminiscent of the early aughts vibe of Jet, The Vines, Kaiser Chiefs, The Strokes, etc. I'm going to give it a 4, which I feel might be half a star too high, but I've had an AWFUL 2 weeks, and I cannot tell you how thrilled I am to hear something that isn't 80s pop or 70s rock.

shouty, noisy riffs, but no tunes

Hard rock. Strange music.

Most remarkable thing about this is that someone remembered the album in order to put it on the list.

The genre of the album could just be described as “noise.” Like I could barely hear the vocalist over the instruments, and sometimes that’s okay, but I also wasn’t drawn in by the musical part of it either. There were no memorable rifts or catchy hooks or anything.

Decent, but I’m not sure why it’s any different from Queens of the Stone Age or Them Crooked Vultures

Maybe the first album so far that's really about what I'm about, but it's still not quite there. Three and one half out of five

It’s a very muddy sound. Never quite sure what they’re trying to make me listen to.

I’m always glad to hear rock music on this list. However this is shit music. It’s boring, repetitive, derivative, and forgettable. I’m losing faith that the author of 1001 albums actually knows and understands not only good music, but truly influential albums. I’m 100 albums in so far and I am not impressed with the bulk of what crap I’ve had to listen to so far. I thought this would be a fun way to find good, new music. It’s turning out to feel more like a punishment more often than not.

Most of the reviews for this album have been quite negative. The masses are wrong this time. I enjoyed it. Quite solid. Not perfect but this one surprised me in a good way.

This is kinda like the Strokes, with a little Jon Spencer Blues Explosion or Smashing Pumpkins. Not exactly worth listening to before you die. There’s a lot of yelling. Feels like Heavy Metal masquerading as a Christian rock.

This was fine. 3.3

Just uninteresting.

A really fun album. That energy that you only get from noise rock bands. It can drag just a little. But overall a good album. Added it to my collection.

That's not my taste in music - too confusing

No way I could make a full hour of this.

Usually I don't like the "noisy" type grunge, but this was a good balance, and I enjoyed it.

Unexpected hit for me, really enjoyed this more than I realized by the end of it.

I gave this a listen and it didn't do much for me. I just didn't find much that was unique or compelling.

I also don’t really remember this one. Sounded fine.

Had a hard time listening to this bc it’s not on Spotify and the YouTube clips are microwave quality, but man!!! What an amazing sound! This is what indie should strive to be Fave: Up against the wall

I quite liked it, though it did seem quite derivative of various other things (quite Hives-ish). And it went on a little longer than I had patience for.

Pointless noise.

This album just did not do anything for me. It wasn’t the worst thing I’ve ever heard and I like this genre it was just… noise. There was really no melody or story to tell and I was honestly just waiting for it to be over. I wouldn’t want to hear this again but it doesn’t fill me with dread like other 1s so it’s a 2

Man - so good. Going to have to add these guys into my rotation!!

Not good 2/5

Really enjoyed, getting bright at night jumped out, will defo be checking out more from the artist

Kan niet op spotify

ALDI in Chains.

I think Daedalus did it on purpose

Not good, but not the worst thing I've listened to. Occasional moments of not bad.

I can't imagine why I'd want to listen to 54 minutes of this when the White Stripes, the Hives, DFA 1979 and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs all exist

I've never heard of The Icarus Line so this was new to me. While I found this album enjoyable, I don't find anything original or different enough to justify its inclusion on this list. Penance Soiree, while a great album name is no different than any other new, loud, shiny rock from the same time period. 3/5

I mean, I get it…I really like The Stooges, too.

Good noise rock with some awesome guitar work, and solid vocals. I would probably prefer some more melody in places, but enjoyed nonetheless.

I don't get it. It's like a mix of a bunch of post grunge stuff. Like sometimes I hear some white stripes, sometimes I hear some deaftones, some incubus or something but I'd always rather go to the bands I hear influence here rather than listen to this again. It's not bad but it's just boring to me

Not much here for me. Not putting down the music, just hits me as bland background music from the 90s, even though it's not from the 90s.

This shit isn’t raw, just half baked.

Шумный громкий, тяжелый. Был не в подходящем настроении для такой записи.

I liked this more the first time I listened.

Not what I was expecting but I liked it.

New to me. Totally engaged. Aggressively poetic (the best way to be poetic and rock). Yeah the songs blend but so what, the caterwauling vocals belong together with the scalding guitar and lyrics that have the poetry of hip-hop. Getting Bright at Night is an EP unto itself and a microcosm of the Soiree. Worth the price of admission.

Frankly, it could’ve been any band of this era. Nothing particularly distinctive but very much of an ilk. Not so much an evening of penance, more like an afternoon of apathy.

Not horrible, but it didn’t cover any new ground for me and I definitely could’ve lived my life without ever having heard it

Hell yeah. This is a great blend of punk attitude and noisy rock that sounds genuinely off the rails. I bought every minute of it. Great riffs, crunchy recording, this gave me a boost.

They make a big noise, but i failed to detect any sense of songcraft. they're obviously big fans of Captain Beefheart, Pere Ubu, and Sonic Youth, but all those artists—as chaotic and noisy as they can be—know how to write a song. Also, the singer did nothing for me.

Mostly not super interesting.

Great for them, but I can see similiar band every other weekend. This to say I don't really get their inclusion? If they paved a giant way for others, I'll ofcourse take it back but for now... good not great.

An album that thinks it's heavier and rockier than it actually comes across. It feels like it's got all the ingredients to be a great headbanger but something is missing that makes it kind of bland. Again, another album on the list that I can't really fathom why it's on here - there's so many other great albums that could've been picked. Best Tracks: On The Lash; Virgin Velcro; Party The Baby Off

eh. its got its moments but its largely unexciting, and a bit uninspired. its feels like the album is being simultaneously pulled into many different directions and as such it doesnt feel like a concrete thing. not bad though

It's pretty generic mid-2000s alt rock. You can tell this band came around the same time as bands like The Killers or The White Stripes but they're aren't quite as exciting for me as those bands. It's mostly just noise, tbh.

This album is a little all over the place! Some garage rock, some Soundgarden-ish, some post-hardcore, some noise. I like them best doing post hardcore, as in tracks 6 and 7. The opening two tracks are also quite good. But all in all, it’s not an album I’ll be visiting frequently, if at all

Lots of rage, lots of energy, only moderately enjoyable for me.

Terrible. I knew within 5 seconds that this was going to be poor and so it proved to be. I really couldn't stand to listen any longer than about 30 seconds to any of the tracks, they were just too awful. Why exactly is this album on the list? Is it really one of the top 1001 albums ever recorded? Jesus, I hope not.

I enjoyed it but it's nothing crazy. Reminded me of something popular, can't remember what

Absolutely reviled the first song but I think I warmed up to it by the end

01) Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers - 5,5 02) Spit on It - 5,0 03) On the Lash - 5,0 04) Caviar - 5,0 05) Spike Island - 6,0 06) Kiss Like Lizards - 4,0 07) Getting Bright at Night - 3,0 08) Big Sleep - 4,0 09) White Devil - 4,0 10) Meatmaker - 3,0 11) Virgin Velcro - 4,0 12) Seasick - 4,0 13) Party the Baby Off - 5,0 TOTAL: 4,42 (44/100) Current ranking: 471/489 A very tiring kind of music. I was still somehow focused for the first half of the album, but the second half I was buying a washing machine on line and it just made me more nervous. The music, not the washing machine.

When I first heard this I felt quite positive - the sound and energy are great. The problem is there aren't any good songs. I've discussed my inability to connect to songs in a few albums recently, but here I feel pretty confident that the songs just aren't very good at all.

Listening to this on YouTube lessened the experience slightly, but it's not not horrible. Yet, I had to skim this — I still think I got the gist of it.

thought i would enjoy it more than i did based on the whole vibes but yea....

I remember definitely having this on an iPod back in the day, yet re-listening in 2025 it does not bring forth a single memory of a riff, hook, lyric or feeling. It sure sounds good though.

Why is this here?

нормалек.

Fine..? I guess?

Liked it a lot and went digging deeper. But not a classic.

Heavy but hollow.

I am loving this album. It’s noisy but precise. It reminds me of a lot of early 2000s rock such as The Stroke and QOTSA, but it’s consistently better throughout than the albums I’ve heard from those bands. Crazy these guys only have 1,700 monthly listeners o ln Spotify at this point (many of them people from this project no doubt), but considering they don’t exist anymore there’s no reason for any promotion.

Usually, I love me some distorted shit, like distorted bass and guitars. It's fucking amazing in doom and sludge metal. So I would have thought that I would have liked this too. The similarity between this and doom metal is it's repetitiveness. But with doom metal, you can get away with it because the riffs are so fucking good. With this, it gets old fast. That, backed up by the subpar drumming, god awful vocals, and clear rip-off from The White Stripes (of which I am not a massive fan of anyway) makes this album not very good. It gets marks for the overall noise of it, because it's absolute filth and I like that. I also would rather listen to this than Justin Timberlake, or another Elvis Costello album, so it gets a 2.

Wrong album to listen to after a tooth extraction.

Started well, not my fave though

I think there were some cool ideas here, I just got sick of this album very quickly. All the noise and dissonance is very overpowering and just gives you absolutely no room to breathe at all.

Never heard of them before but I loved this album!

2 boring

Bijna lager door dat 2e en 1/2na laatste nummer wat een herrie, rest wel lijp

Ok, we are all in agreement that this is shitty noise. I’ve probably not got a lot to add to that conversation, so I’ll take a different tack, and let’s talk about that Wikipedia entry. What this, written by there biggest fan, who, while learning there second language: English, was also a bit distracted, at the time? Further cementing the idea that only a dickhead would care about this album.

A bit too metal esque for me but I get it

I'm tired.

I do think this was better than I expected. Its not bad, just not memorable. I dont like the mix of clean production with attempts at noise with feeback. Not very memorable but not bad at all.

pretty good

Full disclaimer: I had to look up a user-cobbled together album on Youtube just to listen to this elusive thing. It's good rock, nothing to write home about, but the sheer unavailability of it makes me deduct points. I don't know the story behind it, and I know the band had its issues with the production of this album. But my god, it is 2025!

The music was ok, what could be found, but it is a mystery as to how this album is on the list. The content of the album is unfindable on spotify, the only trace on the web was a playlist on youtube, cobbled together from uploads of various accounts. Those videos had been up for over a decade and only had 10k views. Whoever owns the rights to this couldn't be bothered to enforce copyright or get a deal with Vevo or whatever. The spotify account for what else is available on this artist gets 1.8k listens monthly. To call the interest in this band obscure compared to the rest of this list is an understatement. If anything, this album is an example of how very little art that is produced survives into the future. Only 20 years ago this album made some kind of waves and now it is on the border of extinction. Have a think about that.

Firstly, since this was not available on Spotify I had to listen on YouTube and having to listen to ads in-between every track really interrupted the flow. That aside, this is very early-00s rock, a bit like The Strokes or White Stripes in places but much more noise-y. Some great guitar work but not something I’d revisit. Spike Island was my preferred track. (1.5 stars)

Someone listened to Jane’s Addiction…I didn’t hate it

This was also pretty fun. Like a little weaker almost as good jack white project

I'm all for heavy metal/rock and even some screamo, but that just didn't do it for me. 9/100

Pretty rough and mashing, quite like it

I'm kinda surprised I'd never heard of this band before. It came out around when I was first really paying attention to music and figuring out what I liked, and it's a genre I tend to gravitate towards. All that being said, the music was fine but ultimately unmemorable.

Penance Soiree is an album that should have fell flat on it's face but somehow, it manages to be so amazing. I wasn't having high hopes about this album considering that it was listed as a noise rock album so i was expecting the most annoying thing ever but i did not get that. Instead, what i got was fast and frenetic album with some great melodies and some insane guitar work. The trumpets in some of the tracks did add quite a lot to them as well as they gave the album a pretty bluesy vibe. Granted, Meatmaker does do the annoying thing with it's instruments getting loud at certain intervals and the lyrics can be incredibly juvenile at points but none of these issues were enough to make me score this album any lower than 5 stars. Best Song: White Devil Worst Song: Meatmaker

At first, I didn't remember listening to this, but once I looked at it, I realized that I had, and it wasn't nearly as compelling as I had hoped it would be.

Det är rivigt, det är rått, det är lite coolt. Basen och gitarrerna låter överlag bra, bra "tone". Trummorna ligger kanske lite väl långt bak och saknar lite attack. Sången är lite väl enformig för min smak och nästan alltid samma "effekt". Inte riktigt min smak. Jag har lite svårt att känna av hur pass nyskapande detta var 2004. Känner någonstans 2-3 av 5 just nu.

Inte dålig. Bara att jag inte tycker den hör hemma på den här listan. Har lyssnat på den tidigare men är inget jag tydligt minns och inte säker på att jag kommer komma ihåg den efter detta heller.

I couldn't face listening to this. Tried a couple of tracks and it's just noise for noise's sake.

Nice The Icarus Line t-shirt. Name 3 songs.

Fine early 00s garage rock, but nothing really connected with me.

Not that great

I don’t hate this genre I don’t think but this was ass

4/10 - I didn’t think this album was that bad until Meatmaker. It was just so bad. The rest didn’t make me feel like I needed to turn it off.

Like worse 80s/90s noise rock mixed with worse 90s/00s alt/garage rock. This doesn’t need to be on the list. Its just bad

Didn't live this one. Pretty bland for hard rock, and got very samey. It was one of the few albums that I've had start again (on repeat) and not notice...

Up Against The Wall Motherfucker // On The Lash // Kiss Like Lizards // Getting Bright At Night //

Um, terrible.

Not for me gang. It’s on some heavy metal shit I can’t fuck with it.

Not for me

Drony, biting

bin bim dritte song. finds uuuuhuere langwilige luute rock. 2004 usecho. s buech 2005. seit alles. ich check dases luut und hässig isch und ich appreciate die angst aber bruuuudi. das mues nöd doo sii. bin etz bi party off your baby. nai nai nai. inkreatov, tönt scheisse, höred uf striite, schribed hooks. 1.

puuuuh also ich versuechs emal. de bass isch na cool und slappt aber s isch hslt na nüt speziells oder so also vorweg: es gfalltmer bis jz glaub schomal besser als am luca, so chaotisch findis schono cool ABER das hets scho über 10 jahr vorher geh? wiso isch de scheiss druff? wiso muss ich mier youtube videos geh wo in 240p qualität sind? aber ja spit on it hani rig na en banger gfunde (wett nöd wüsse was sie mit "it" meined) hahah ok s spezielle het chli abgno? jz ischs eifach chli garage rock/grunge?AAAH ja das 9 min lied absolut unnötig also gwüssi teil hani cool gfunde, v.a. de schluss aber ??? white devil chli langsamer aber immernos so vill feedback und so hahahaa ok meatmaker isch de beat bonkers also virgin velcro und sea sick han ich nöd gfunde und es ischmer gad echt z blöd sorry bro party the baby off is h gad es insane cringes video gsi und s lied selber eifach langwilig hahaha alsooo es git safe en stern abzug für das video und dass es echt nüt z sueche het uf de liste...suscht mussi sege dass ich scho au ziitewiis e gueti ziit gha han. ohni youtube werbige etc. dezwüsche wärs natüich chli besser gsi

wasnt in the mood for it, didn’t enjoy it , felt like a dated hard grunge pastiche 1

A lesser version of other snotty rock bands of the era. This list continues to disappoint with its loud selections from 2000. They just can't seem to find the sweet spot between loud and rock.

This generally rocked, but nothing really grabbed me and said, "You must hear more!"

-this rather obscure number from 2004 didn’t exactly blow me away. sort of like Jane’s Addiction, it sounded like they were going for that hard-to-place noise rock sound, but it got kind of boring to me after a while -maybe it’s just a matter of taste. some of the songs hit hard tho -Favorites are Caviar and Spike Island

Need to listen to it more often.

Definitely a few songs on this album that were great, but definitely also a lot of forgettable stuff

Started off pretty cool, and then faded into the background and forgettable. Probably should have been a shorter album.

Not great

Hard to believe this made a buzz when it got released. I guess labels were pushing for anything "pure" rock after the Strokes' craze. This one sounds like a tame version of The Stooges. Pass.

The Stooges for millenials.

What the hell is this album doing on this list?

The album is just kind of a lot of noise. It sounds like any other garage rock / 2000's White Stripes copy. Unfortunately, this album doesn't bring anything new or interesting to the table. It's weird that anyone would put this on a list of quintessential albums. 1.5⭐️

I imagine the NME loved this album, heralding a new dawn of alternative music. it's not that good to be honest, a very average album and undeserving of a place on this list

In bringing this up on Spotify I noticed no one has listened to this album, like ever, 62K listens to the first song, 52K for the third and 20K or less for the rest - and that's since 2004, 20 years. I'm going into this with a big question mark before I've even hit "play". The song titles are great. I can think of 50 albums that sound about this generic and didn't make this list. This sounds like late 90's/early 00's rock that never hit it big because it didn't deserve to. Organized messy rock is all I heard. No hooks, no great guitar work, no compelling vocals, really no groove or soul. Maybe they're fun live? This album lacked damn near everything I look for in a rock album. Try old Jane's Addiction if you want something in this vein that at least has a legitimate reason to keep listening. This was shit. 1 star for trying. No hits, no great songs, no airplay, no influence, no nothin'. I have zero clue how this made anyone's T1001 playlist unless the lead singer created it. For shits and giggles I listened to their 2013 album to see if they got any better or learned how to deliver a rock album, nope, same stuff. 12 min intro instrumental tends to put anyone off if it has no groove & no destination. Who kept giving them money to put this shit on the shelf? I bet their parents won't even go to their gigs.

I've gotta say this is one of the first on the list that was a head scratcher as to how it made it here. Doesn't seem overly popular in terms of stream counts, none of the songs stood out to me and this is generally closer to a genre I enjoy. I heard different influences in or from this throughout, mostly kept thinking of Jack White, but there was another band called Dragpipe that I had found around that era and I looked up their only album and it is around the same stream count. I don't really have much else about this Icarus Line album, the cover art is about the most memorable thing I've got. It wasn't terrible or unlistenable, but I have to think that a band member may be a nephew of the 1001 albums guy. If this is a band you're into I'd recommend looking up Dragpipe. They are nothing amazing either, but I like them better than this. Favorite track "Party the Baby off" 2/5

Not great and I am usually a fun of hard rock and post grunge sounding music

This, to me, seems like the halfway house from Nirvana to the Kieser Chefs. A sort of stepping stone in the evolution of that branch of music. If you like, it's the missing link. It's just a shame someone found it. Not what I would choose to listen to, or hopefully, will ever again. Not completely awful, just not for me.

New band to me, but not sure how I missed them at the time. Noisy and fun, and I liked the vocalist. Stand out track at first listen is ‘Spike Island’ but most of it kept me really interested. Deserves a 2nd listen to see if it’s a grower. It’s probably a high 3, but I’m optimistic I’m going to enjoy this band so will give it a 4 for an impressive first impression.

When this popped up, I’d never heard of The Icarus Line, no idea of genre, there was a clue with the record label, V2, that it would be guitar led, that was all I had to go on, so I just stuck it on and hoped for the best. After probably less than 10 seconds I had a very big smile on my face. This album totally blew me away. It was released in the raising children period of my life, so they got missed. OK, I did discover At The Drive In in this period, but this is on another level. That deep rumbling bass, the mangled guitar. The changes of pace and styles, that very random ode to Suicide with ‘Meatmaker’ I didn’t see that coming. I could hear hints of Jesus and Mary Chain with ‘Getting Bright at Night’ and also ‘Sea Sick’ with a hint of Loop in there too, leaning into some classic grunge, not to mention the obvious Stooges influences, some surprising influences for a band from California. Ironically when I read up about this album, and the band in general, I found out I’d seen Joe Cardamone live back in 2017, supporting Mark Lanegan, but unfortunately, I didn’t do my homework, and didn’t concentrate too hard on what I was listening to at the time, if I had then I would have had this band in my life a lot earlier. Also this was engineered and recorded in London by the legend Alan Moulder, who is responsible for many of my favourite albums of all time, I could see how he must have shaped their sound, and make it appealing especially for my ears. This album is a beauty (the follow up sounded brilliant too), it is one of those reasons why I am doing this challenge. Amongst the shite, there is a gem like this. It’s probably going to be a future top 50 all time great for me. I’m going to buy it today.

Didn't know what to expect from this but I enjoyed it. How have I gone 20 years without hearing it?

I decided after 1 song that this album is not for me.

Never heard of these guys. I actually likes this, not a lot, but liked it. It led me back to Muse, who are superior in every way

Not a huge fan- sounded like a lot of bands from the early 2000s. Would be ok as background but not goi g out of my way to hear them again and will probably never think about them again.

I’d give it 2.5 stars but since I can’t do that, I’m bumping it to 3 because, as someone else said, I never would have heard this otherwise. I was expecting some death core but it wasn’t as brutal as I thought it’d be, and caught more joy out of it than I was expecting. Per my own OCD rules, gotta listen through to all of these albums, and this one kinda caught me by surprise

Not sure why I didn’t know about this band. I enjoyed the record but not sure what puts it in the 1001.

Didn't like the first few songs at all but it improves as it continues. 3 stars or C-.

Eh, I could take or leave this one

I understand what they were trying to go for but really didn’t do it for me, nothing too memorable

Some raw upbeat rock. A good example of an early 2000s band carrying the torch of some late 60s early 70s hard rock. High energy, but gritty

This album is perfectly fine. I don’t understand why it’s so poorly rated. Or why The Icarus Line has so few monthly listeners on Spotify? It reminds me so much of The Black Keys and other similar rock artists of the 2000s.

Groupe inconnu. Punk rock bruitiste, avec de bonnes lignes de basse et quelques morceaux intéressants : "Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers" "Caviar" "Kiss Like Lizards" Mais il ne tient pas la distance (trop de morceaux, les derniers ne sont pas très intéressants). =>2/5

looks good¬ But not available to listen

Started out hating it, but it grew on me, enough to move the needle from a 1 to a 2

It's loud and rough. Not bad, but nothing that really made me want to come back to it either.

Never heard of this band. I see their influences, but nothing on here really connected with me. The singer is trying a little too hard to be Iggy.

Hectic, chaotic, wildness and I quite enjoyed. Immediate thought was 'what connection do they have to the Mars Volta/At the Drive-In.'

Noisy but otherwise unremarkable, mediocre "rock" (?).

It’s nothing spectacular.

Bueno para escuchar de fondo y no prestarle mucha atención. Total del álbum: 63

I get it. The author was trying to make some picks on modern music that would hold up into the future and just had a total miss here. The icarus line really wrote music that turned out to utilize the very worst of rock at the time. 1/5

More fun than I expected

Lyrics: 1/5 Music: 2/5 Production: 1/5 Cohesiveness: 2/5 Overall: 1/5 Stand out songs: The silence at the end of the album Possibly the worst thing I’ve ever had to listen to with the worst song titles on any album I’ve ever heard

This was what it was. 2.

I saw this band live, once. This album was better than that performance. It's fine. That being said, I have no idea why I needed to listen to this album before I died. It's not horrible, but I can't figure out what makes it that important to hear. The other albums on this list that I didn't like, at least those (so far) have had some level of historical significance. Personal enjoyment: 3/5 Relevance to this list: 1/5

Hard Listen...Noisy...Bad Soundgarden..No Thanks

Definitely a violent and dark album at times. Didn't really stand out to me, though I did give it two listens after forgetting my initial impression. Bordering on actively bad, but not completely grating to listen to.

More noise; more shrieking. Why? Even at barely audible, this is unlistenable.

I didn't enjoy this, couldn't finish it and fail to see how this would even remotely be considered essential listening for anyone before they die. There were some glimpses of listenable music here and there so 1.5/5.

Biggest takeaway is how long it felt, really dragging. I didn’t hate it - it was a bit of everything but nothing special. Feels like an album that made an appearance in one list because one compiler was a fan but then was removed the next year.

I didn't take to this straightaway but it definitely grew on me. By the end I was quite looking forward to giving it another go. A bit like The Vines or Black Rebel Motorcycle Club but more sinister

I had never heard of this band despite it being the kind of music I was listening to around the time it came out. Sounds like it would have been played on 93X, the area's hard rock radio station. It's pretty decent, the vocals reminded me at times of White Zombie era Rob Zombie's, sometimes like Alice In Chains and other times The Black Angels. My highlights were White Devil and Seasick. I was also kind of liking Virgin Velcro and Party The Baby Off if you don't think about the song titles or lyrics.

This is the album that some hipster doofus plays when you say that you like white stripes or queens of the stone age and theyre all like "oh yeah they learned everything from these guys that I bet you havent heard of" and so then they put this album on and youre like "yeah ok you know I have an early day tomorrow so I've gotta go" and anyway its not a BAD album but its not as good as lots of the other music that it is supposed to have influenced. 2/5

Not listened not available, other songs so so

some bands have to go through an iteration or two before turning into something great. Uncle Tupelo explodes and turns into Wilco and Son Volt. Alice 'n Chains coughs out a loogie and that thing mutates into Alice in Chains. Slapstick breaks into two pieces and morphs into The Lawrence Arms and Alkaline Trio. the Icarus Line were a band in bad need of a breakup. this is not because i dislike them, but because something is holding them back from actually releasing something great. i feel like everything is half cooked, having trouble finding its own identity. the first track's good, "Spike Island" is good, and i can tolerate a lot of "Getting Bright at Night", but a lot of this bores me. the songs drag on. the album fails to develop an actual image out of the frying negative of guitar noise and yowling that wears its 70's Stoogepunk pedigree on its sleeve. i think this is a just fine album to start your career with on a little who-cares label run by your friends and his CD writer. unfortunately, this is a CD that people paid a lot of money to Richard Branson for, which means that this is your band now. this is it. the Icarus Line broke up after Alvin DeGuzman died of cancer in 2017. even if i'm not the biggest fan of the band, to hell with what i think -- i hope he was at least somewhat satisfied with what he made. i hope that for him, this was a pinnacle, even if i wish it hadn't been. by all accounts, they had much more potential than they let on.

1660 monthly listeners is shocking. This is kinda like the Strokes, with a little Jon Spencer Blues Explosion or Smashing Pumpkins. Not exactly worth listening to before you die. There’s a lot of yelling. Feels like Heavy Metal masquerading as a Christian rock.

2000s US alt-rock. Pretty heavy, edgy and dirty. Noisy and aggressive. Hardly melodic. No rhythm. Didn’t finish.

Blind album and artist. This album blew my mind. I dont think it deserves a 5 but I still love it personally. Saddened to hear this got 0 marketing.

the wikipedia page had a lot of information about how buried this album was by its label and i kind of understand why... oops! sorry, not for me!

yeah, this ain't it, chief. i'm not sure how a band that makes so much noise could end up being so boring but here we are. it's like a garage band from the early aughts saw the stooges/the strokes/queens of the stone age/the white stripes and tried to copy their shtick but add more of a hardcore punk edge. in the end it just feels messy and uninspired. i even listened to this album more than once to try to "get" it but nah, not for me. at least the more straightforward punk songs were pretty good favorites: up against the wall motherfuckers, spit on it, party the baby off

Highlight: On The Lash In a nutshell: homogenised post-hardcore I mean, it’s fine? I like garage rock. Don't mind post-hardcore. Sounds like The Stooges meets Fugazi and The Jesus and Mary Chain. Great riffs and distortion. HOWEVER... it's not groundbreaking. The Used, Mclusky, Shellac and Refused predate The Icarus Line. None of the aforementioned are in the book and performed a hell of a lot better than these wannabes. Overall: 2/10

Another one of them never heard of them before bands. No worries getting to close to the Sun with these guys.

#415. This blends in with everything going on around it, but does manage to be a little bit more annoying than all that. 2/5: derivative Song added to playlist: One the Lash I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

Disc that seams to be taken from the late 70s. Too "crispy" for me. 3/10

begon zeer veelbelovend maar zakte daarna toch wat in

Jane's Addiction meets Soundgarden, not bad, quite listenable actually but not memorable either, 3.2

There were moments when it started to click, but those were outnumbered by the moments when I just wanted the noise to stop. Overall it's too unfocused. Also a pain to listen to since it wasn't on spotify for me.

1001 albums? Add a couple more zeroes between the ones and you might be getting close. Did NOT like this. Next.

Awful twaddle.

Feedback. 1/5

Ei saatavilla

Reminds me of my Iron Maiden era. Cool, but not for my current me.

4/5. I think it was good? But overall I don't think I liked it. Hardcore garage rock that is catchy and well-written but don't think I like this as much as I thought I would. Nevermind, mid writing this review I listened to Getting Bright At Night and that was awesome. As the album went on, I kind of got the vibe it was going for and now I want to re-listen with that in mind. The main issue is that it can be a little jarring with so much noise but it does break it up sometimes with some softer openings or more riffs than just noise. Overall, once I got past the jarring energy, I was with it. Best Song: Big Sleep, Getting Bright At Night, Virgin Velcro

Sounds reminiscent of hard 90s alternative rock, but with the noise turned up to 11. Unfortunately this made the album difficult to listen to, since many of the songs just sounded like a wave of indistinguishable sounds. Add to that the ample feedback for some songs which literally hurt my ears and you have an album I didn’t enjoy. A little pared back and I probably would’ve liked it.

Definitely not my thing

Noisy and passive garage rock. Some cool ideas scattered throughout

This isn't even a must listen to album in this genre, let alone all albums ever.

Very nice Black Flag cover band...

Hard to judge when I can only find 4 songs online

Are we calling just ANYTHING "culturally relevant" now?

Not in the mood to listen to this, had a headache, like all the full bits of QOTSA

The best part was when it ended.

I was prepared to hate this, and I did not enjoy the noisier tracks, but I found most of it to be pretty decent.

2/10…noise rock

Basic shit

I've never heard about these dudes in my life (and judging from the Spotify numbers, never will again), which is wild, since they're right up my alley. Truly fun album to listen.

An actually good album with couple great songs, like "Getting Bright at Night" and "Big Sleep". Interesting style, a bit watered down hardcore with a pleasant sounding vocalist. I like their sound, there are few really good riffs hidden on the tracks. Pretty good atmosphere of the record as well. Ah, why not, 5 stars, it's been a long time since I was so positively surprised.

This ain’t music. Good music is produced by people who have talent, expertise and able to demonstrate this either live or on record. Any music lover should at least appreciate all forms of music even when it is not to their own personal taste. I struggle to find anything on this album which ticks the aforementioned boxes. It what circumstances and surroundings would you actually put this album on and listen to it? To sit and listen left me feeling uncomfortable and stressed. It’s not anything you could have on in the background when doing other tasks as you may as well have the sound of a pneumatic drill coming out of the speakers. The structure and constant time changes make it impossible to sing along with. Maybe this is what the Icarus boys wanted to achieve in the name of art maaan! More worryingly I wondered how the experts compiling this list came up with this choice so I consulted the entry in the book. “The perfect punk statement”. “Huge sonic step forward” lyrics of “Insightful tales of gutter living” are just some of the platitudes. Really? Anyhow why should I care? Never heard of this combo before and whilst I got a bit cross that it was ever thought good enough to go on this list I will never give them another thought and delete the tracks I played so that my streaming algorithm doesn’t get the wrong idea. 1/5 24/10/24

Not bad, nothing stands out.

Goes hard. As someone who doesn't listen to a lot of rock, this was a great listen. Big crashing drums, big guitar lines that went in really unexpected directions, and love Joe Cardamone's voice.

I'm not totally sure what to think of it yet. Only listened to it one time, but it was ... interesting.

Did not enjoy, gave me a headache

Solid garage rock

I enjoyed nothing about this album. Even the songs that were good underneath all the garbage noise were, well, buried in garbage noise. Doesn’t deserve the slot. Good album artwork though.

Really just not good.

Never heard of this band before, for some reason, so no expectations going in. I ended up liking it quite a bit. It's a bit like Jesus and Mary Chain meets Big Black with a little Pavement thrown in. Solid.

I wanted to like this, but it just sounded like a copy cat of garage bands I really like.

grungy noise that i am parking on the not for today pile

Didn’t really like this. Average old English punk feel

The opening gave me so much hope, but I felt like I got Led Zeppelin-slammed. Did not finish.

10/16/24. Never heard of this band before, and this may be the first hardcore punk album I've gotten on this journey. Decent album with a couple standout songs, very solid. Loved the guitars and noise, but thought it ran a bit long.

This album was just bad. I skipped track 2, then tried to power through and by song 9 or 10 I gave up. It’s one of those where I’m just confused on how this got picked as an album you must hear before you die. Is the author so ignorant when it comes to music, he couldn’t find anything else? Just felt like I was listening to noise meant to annoy the hell out of me.

You’re telling me there’s nothing else we could’ve put on this list in place of this shit? I listen to some absolute, hot garbage and even I hated this.

Pretty good.

The compilers sure do like their noise rock. I don't hear much in the way of interest, let alone essential listening.

What can you say about this album, meh

Did these guys just wake up from a coma in 2004? Twenty years too late boys, but nice try.

A noisy support band type of thing. All suicide and debauchery and teenage woes with feedback and dirge. I like that screaming was minimal and you could hear the lyrics, but being less shit is not the same as being good.

Yet another ex-1001 album!™ http://1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie.wikidot.com/album-artists-a-z-ex Wonder if this is what The White Stripes would sound like with more guitar pedals and low production values? Meh, landfill material. 1.5

Not even 1 star.

3 hours of 69 love songs was more enjoyable than this

Not sure how this made the list. Obvious White Stripes and similar copycat just not nearly as good.

That was okay but I’ll never listen to it again

Penance Soiree Never heard of this or The Icarus Line before. Resisted looking them up, and wasn’t quite sure what to expect from the cover or band name. Maybe something Metal or some generic American Alt Rock? Up Against The Wall Motherfucker - kind Alt Rock riffing with a garage punkishness and a bit of RHCP or RATM bass groove. It does sound quite early 2000s-ish and its fine I suppose. Spit on it is less successful and is thankfully pretty brief. On the Lash, has a bit of BRMC to it, but not as good and without the more ominous feel of their songs. Annnnd….I can’t be bothered to go through the rest of it. It’s fine for what it is as some noisy garage rock, but it’s also quite tedious, with very little of interest to differentiate it from anyone else. There were many more better bands with better melodies and better ideas at that time, so why would you choose to listen to this? Listening twice through is enough. Not wretched, just boring. 2 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️ Playlist submission: Up Against The Wall Motherfucker

The cover art is gross. Its not the worst album Ive heard so far, but its not great either. I even read about it and I dont understand why its on this list.

Dit album is niet op Spotify te vinden en de kwaliteit van de nummers op YouTube is een beetje wisselend. Dit soort muziek wordt er niet beter op als het blikkerig klinkt door slechte kwaliteit, dus dat maakt het wat lastig om hier echt lekker naar te gaan zitten luisteren. Het klinkt een beetje als At The Drive-In met een scheut White Stripes. Heel af en toe klinkt de zanger als Bono ('Spike Island'). Ik vind dit best oké muziek, maar ben ook niet super onder de indruk. Gewoon een 3.

ughhh static? no.

Something just felt off about this album. There were no melodies. It wasn't very rhythmic. I can't recall a single chorus.

Every so often I listen to an album and I think to myself “ Why is this on the list, am I missing something” didn’t enjoy the music or the voice much. Very Forgettable I regret to say.

A combination of The Smashing Pumpkins, Marilyn Manson and The White Stripes. Pretty good album.

Please don't hurt me, IMHO more noise but obviously others like it...

I never heard of this band before this, and I was excited to listen to it after skimming the wikipedia page. That excitement went away about 37 seconds into the first song when the vocals come in. The vocals were either monotone with long drawn out notes or half yelling. The majority of the album sounds like one elongated whine which obviously becomes incredibly annoying. I don't like most vocals in this style and consequently I don't care for alternative rock of this era like the Strokes that use a simmilar style. This vocal style lacks the energy and excitement that a hardcore noise rock band needs. Vocals aside, the rest of the album was fine, but wasn't very memorable. Some of the guitar and bass tones were interesting but the majority of it was fuzzed out beyond recognition. The album lack any interesting melodies and rhythms. It wasn't the worst album on here by far, and while I didn't enjoy it, it was worth the listen(except it was nearly an hour long!)

This is like the output of an AI prompt: “write a meet me in the bathroom era album in the style of Alice In Chains”.

repetitive. it was the same edgy track over and over

Hmm, not really for me. Caviar was pretty cool though - some interesting riffage.

ok lol so i really do wonder how records like this get in this list without passing any judgement about the band's music, they're probably legit but they're a "literally who" band; i'm guessing music critics in 2004 chose it as a poster child for something but it's like a salad bowl of 2000s stadium indie/garage rock revival, fucking The Jesus Lizard-style noise rock and a bit of At The Drive-In-style phc it doesn't particularly resonate with me like the two bands i just mentioned, but it's definitely interesting some of it rubs me the right way for sure though

Not as bad as I thought it would be

Didn't have great hopes for this initially -- first couple of songs left me cold with that whole Soup Dragons x Soundgarden vibe. But it grew on me as the album wore on. Once I got into the aesthetic of it, it's a pretty decent rock and roll album. Kinda sludgy in places, but the latter half of the album is definitely the strength. Solid. Unexpected bangers: Spike Island, White Devil, Virgin Velcro

It was very metal, much crunchy noise. Honestly didn't like it very much.

Has the right ingredients for something I would really like but ends up just shy of being really good.

A store-brand version of At The Drive-In, with more garage revival and less post-hardcore. It’s fine — and I tend to be very forgiving of this sound based on my biases — but it’s very sloppy, very cobbled together, and while The Icarus Line would probably argue that that was done so with purposeful intent, the result is closer to a chaotic assault of mediocrity than anything truly experimental. When it is noisy, post-hardcore, and doing what every good band from Refused to The Blood Brothers did in this era, the results feels cheap and the band feels unsure of themselves; when they’re at their tightest, though, they sound like every other dime-a-dozen garage revival band that got overhyped in music rags at the time. If Penance Soirée had a bit more focus, it would be a better record, but I’d still probably felt apathetic about it. It’s heavy for people who thought Franz Ferdinand were hard, and that’s way too tame for me. Yet another instance where I’d have made a radically different decision with the “post-hardcore” inclusions on this list.

Röyhkeän räyhäkkä. YT soittolistasta ei jaksanut rullata toista kierrosta ja ei jäänyt ihan kirkkaana mieleen.

Eipä kovin puhutellut. Aika taviskaurarokkia

Kuuntelin tän biisit valitettavasti epäjärjestyksessä, joten kokonaisuutta on vaikea arvioida. Mutta tää kuulostaa näiltä bändeiltä, jotka kuulostaa aika samalta ja joista mä tykkään: White stripes, Death from above, Royal blood… eli jees! Jäin vain kaipaamaan kunnon bängereitä, tää tyyli kaipaa levylle niitä.

Tämä kirpeistä äänistä tykkäävä bändi kokee, että voi jättää huomioimatta biisinteon perustavimmat edellytykset: toisto, tunnistettavuus, motiivi. VÄÄRIN.

So crap. I should not hav gone back for this

Good sound, It remembers me to the smashing pumpkins

I don’t know why some of these albums are on this list. I didn’t need to listen to this noise.

Not really into the whole post-hardcore scene. Decent enough album, but doesn't feel like anything special compared to other artists from the genre 3/5