Reviews (page 5 of 14)
I really like this album because I like this genre of music. it gives me positive emotions, and I would listen to this album again.
The epitome of cozy music. Sinatra may be one of (if not the) most charming singers to ever grace a record and though this album is not as exciting as later productions, there is not a single song in sight that I would skip. Best Songs are You Make Me Feel So Young and the heavily underappreciated Old Devil Moon. 8/10, play this whenever the silence is too loud.
I love the way this whole album makes me feel.
It all kind of sounds the same but it's fun. He had some pipes.
Viva las Vegas! This feels like the soundtrack for a generation. A lot of fun classics that are easy to listen to. I understand why so many love Frank.
Sinatra might be the greatest male vocalist of all time. Absolute classic, the songs are massive, and his voice transports you into a new world. They don’t make them like this anymore
I think if Frank Sinatra sang anything it would sound magical and fantastic. Him, 5 stars. This is probably another 3.
sinatra is always a joy. felt like Christmas with some of the songs. about halfway through I started listening to another one of his albums, then rounded finished this album out
Pretty swingin'!
l love this album, but cannot listen constantly
Good
All the songs sound the same. But they do sound good.
Feb 2, 2026 - We really need new crooners and big band music again.
We don't say things like "Makin' Whoopee" anymore
💃💃🕺 Swing 5/10
A fantastic album. I've got several Sinatra albums in my collection, but not this one. I'm familiar with almost all of the tracks, and several of them appear on other Sinatra albums I do own. It's an album you could listen to on repeat and not realise you're on the 4th our 5th rotation.
Good
I found it very dissonant. Almost like he was either too slow or too fast for the band supporting him. The lyrics sounded shoehorned to me. The strongest sentiment it stirred in me was humour when I heard Makin' Whoopee...
Like pulling on an old jumper cost and I know all the words
Again maybe due to exposure to these songs in class, but really enjoyed this album. Except maybe "making whoopee"
Iconic voice and nice/pleasant songs to listen to. Got to listen to more Sinatra.
Very different from my usual taste but very refreshing. Songs have very meaningful lyrics and the composition is fantastic. Great album 3.4/5
YUP
Sinatra's answer to this new-fangled "rock 'n' roll" thing! Not my bag, Baby.
очень однотипный альбом , такое ощущение, что слушаешь одну песню. лучшая песня "too marvelous for words". альбом 5/10
Good stuff, a little too love songy for the mood I was in
Perfectly pleasant album. A lot of these seem like popular choices from movies I've watched.
Listening to his inflection is quite illuminating- I picture Frankie acting like he’s a god and to be honest girls across America were brainwashed to thinking he was and so it goes. The one long song is good white noise but Frankie can’t make women who know better swoon . . .
This is a really great album. Frank has a lot of really great albums. Music is magic. Back in the days of paper maps me and a buddy would go find undeveloped hot springs in northern Nevada. I drove, he navigated. Lots of road trippin' listening to Van Morrison, Tom Waits and Frank. If you're ever around Austin, NV and you're so inclined, take an evening to visit Spencer hot springs, crack open a Sam Adams Summer Ale, light up a cigar and listen to Frank's Summer Wind for me. Like I said, music is magic and this album swings.
Sinatra me evoca muchos recuerdos con Cristian asi que es dificil no verlo con buenos ojos (o escucharlo con buenos oidos ;9) Creo que hay otros albumes que puedo disfrutar menos, pero este ha sido muy relajante para empezar el dia.
I really enjoyed it. It's just so pleasant to listen to. Anything Goes is a banger.
solid and exactly what'd you expect
Probably an unpopular opinion, but it was - at best - anodyne...
And they say today's music is racy! Haha! Classic
Absolutely amazing. Smooth vocals, great instrumentals, exceptional storytelling. My only take away is lack of difference in songs. Sort of sounded similar instrumentaly but it was very pleasant to listen to despite this. Doesn't reflect it's age in a bad way at all. My appreciation in heightened as a instrument player my self and lover of older songs. Beautifully curated, a challenge made to seem easy. Reflects a confident, loving aura. 4/5. Would recommend to anyone.
i like it just for background
There’s no denying the greatness of Frank. A voice you could pick out anywhere. Not my particular favorite, but still good.
Lo mejor que hizo Frank fue volver el jazz mas digerible para todos, todo un rey
What a crooner. I’m going to go eat a big pasta dinner now.
I've being incredibly harsh on albums where the songs sound way too much the same. But this is one of the exceptions. This record might not be fantastic but at least is charming. Frank Sinatra's voice is very soothing with sometimes hitting some high notes to add a bit of emotion. However, in general terms, he can get a bit monotone and feeling like he is singing the same exact melody every time. In addition, the fact that most of the songs are about love doesn't help. Fortunately, the band playing behind is very entertaining and gives the music a lot more life and energy thanks to the solos, pauses and little variations on the instruments playing. And that is really all I can say, as there is not much going than Frank Sinatra and the band playing some old fashion vocal jazz tunes.
love sinatra
Old Blue Eyes sure could sing! And the jazzy arrangements by Nelson Riddle complement him perfectly. I added “I’ve Got You Under My Skin” to the playlist.
There’s some great classics in here! It’s a bit samey-same but really well done.
I acknowledhe frank sinatra's voice, and I would listen to it again if I'm searching for a vibe. But I didn't get away with it with no song in specific
They all kinda sounded the same but I like it
Classic
I can recognize the talent; he does have a great singing voice. But, this is not for me.
I would probably never "choose" to listen to Sinatra, but I have always enjoyed the music. 7/10
i wasn't able to go through the lyrics but i enjoyed it dahil sa melody bdhshs
Eh…
not my cuppa
5 stars - Frank has one of the best voices I have ever heard. He ranks in my personal Top 5 for greatest voices I have heard. I could happily listen to him every day.
Classic. All timer
Semmoset lemmenlaivat sieltä. Kyllähän tämmöstä menoa kuuntelee taustalla, mutta ei tätä nyt sen analyyttisemmin voi lähteä arvioimaan. "aikansa kuva" ja kolmoseen
Onhan Frankillä aika kermanen saundi ja syystä aika legis jätkä. Tästähän tuli kiva mieli, läiskätään nelsellä!
Onhan sillä Frankilla hunajainen ääni, vähemmästäkin housut märkänä. Pitää ens kerralla kokeilla laittaa autossa soimaan kun on daami kyydissä. Aika samanlaisiahan nämä kaikki biisit toki on, että ei tätä repeatilla jaksa kuunnella, mutta annetaan nyt kuitenkin nelonen, kun toimii omassa tehtävässään erittäin hyvin.
Ohan tää komeeta laulantaa ja teatraalista menoa. Kauheesti ei jää veisuista kätöseen eli handuun. Perusvarma eikä ärsytä.
No joo. Kyllähän swingiä aina silloin tällöin mielellään kuuntele. Mafiamies Sinatra tietysti alan kovimpia nimiä. Tällä levyllä ei ollut yhtään itselleni entuudestaan tuttua biisiä, eikä kyllä mielestäni olla lähelläkään Sinatran parhaita ralleja. Ihan leppoisaa ja kivaa kuunneltavaa kuitenkin. Vaikka kolme tähteä.
I'll give this 8/10. Great to work to, some classics on here that will be familiar to everyone. I'll be buying this album on vinyl as it's a great album to have on in the background when people are around. Can't give it higher even though I loved it as it wouldn't be in my general rotation of music that I listen to, but I still rate the album very highly.
Same song for the entire album. Its fine
classic. OG. swooner. always great.
5/15, 33%
It’s a classic but it’s not for me
Great vibes from this album and its just something nice to listen to and enjoy. Sinatra's voice is also very warm enhancing that mellow vibe. 6/10, Favorite song: You brought a new kind of love to me
2 and a half.
Enjoyed the swagger of Frankie boy
What the fucking is making whoopy? This guy was friends with gangsters and he can't even say fuck
It's difficult to not be in a good mood with Sinatra playing through the house. Fun fact: he wrote the song Makin' Whoopee about his year as an intern at the whoopee cushion factory
Classic
Hits are good, but it kinda drags at points
Song For Swingin’ Lovers says a lot - dated. Makin’ Whoopee says it all! Frank had some staying’ power, as familiar with this one (which is the best song on the album) and also Pennies From Heaven even though they’re from 70 years ago. (1.9*s) Just doesn’t hold up.
Sinatra may have been the man in the 50s but the sound is just too dated these days. Songs for Swingers is better than the other entries from Frank on the list but I'm still bored. "Anything Goes" was recognizable and a decent track I guess. "Makin' Whoopee" shows just how old and lame this album truly is. Nowadays it would be SZA or Frank Ocean singing "Gettin' Pussy" and would just be new and lame. Hoping we are done with Ol' Blue eyes. 1.19 stars for this record.
This is definitely closer to the Frank Sinatra music that I'm more familiar with and appreciate. I prefer Sinatra with some big band accompaniment belting out a jaunty tune far more than a slowed down romance ballad. I recognized a couple of these from Swingin' Lovers and had about as much fun as I expected which only lasts so long. A couple songs every now and then are a fun reminder of what music used to be. Some of the hits hold up OK but its still something I'd quickly move on from otherwise. Sinatra is a legend and maintains his reputation even if its not close to my heart in any way. 1.99 stars
These days it sounds like an old movie sound track but I imagine in 56 these was top notch stuff with swing, jazz and a great band Watch out Frank, Elvis is coming and its all about to change
Sinatra at his best, timeless.
l'album se fait un peu long à force et un peu trop répétitif
Il est bon le sinatra
Bon y'a pas beaucoup de changement mais c'est super chill détente bonne ambiance. Je mettrai ça quand Alex viendra et on fera comme la cover ^^
Damn Dimebag owes a lot to Eddie.
Despite my general aversion to crooning I kind of enjoyed this. These songs really are quite pleasant to listen to. Not challenging at all and not something I’d listen to often, but I might throw it on again if I was having a bad day.
Love is here to stay 🔥 Making Whoopie 👎🏽
It's a'ight
I’ve listened to this and I love it. Makin’ Whoopee is on this album! Easy 4 stars
This is the music that defined an era, and it still sounds great today. Although some of the references are no longer relevant and some of the language seems strange to the modern listener, it's still excellently crafted music that speaks to universal emotions. Truly Frank Sinatra has stood the test of time thus far, and generations of listeners to come will enjoy his music. Favorite track: "You Make Me Feel So Young" starts the album off on the right foot, "I've Got You Under My Skin" is pretty good as well.
Just absolute PERFECTION
I don’t care if he is the Big Poppa, can he croon?
Old blue eyes is always a good listen.
01) You Make Me Feel So Young - 7,0 02) It Happened in Monterey - 7,0 03) You're Getting to Be a Habit with Me - 6,5 04) You Brought a New Kind of Love to Me - 7,0 05) Too Marvelous for Words - 6,5 06) Old Devil Moon - 7,5 07) Pennies from Heaven - 7,0 08) Love Is Here to Stay - 6,5 09) I've Got You Under My Skin - 10,0 10) I Thought About You - 6,5 11) We'll Be Together Again - 6,5 12) Makin' Whoopee - 7,0 13) Swingin' Down the Lane - 7,0 14) Anything Goes - 7,0 15) How About You? - 7,0 TOTAL: 7,07 (71/100) Current ranking: 443/798
Would’ve gone down smoother with an old fashioned
love, whiskey, sex, cigarettes, kissing
Killer arrangements. Frank great as always.
I'm tempted to rate this higher - it's all very good, Sinatra's singing is buttery smooth, it's thoroughly pleasant to listen to - but it's basically 15 of the same song over and over
each track is only 3 minutes long but unless you are listening specifically to the fantastic horns section you are not gonna be able to tell when one ends and another begins it's fine. it's good even! the band is great, the voice is great. I'd probably even rate it higher individually but as an album it just bleeds together and is less than the sum of its parts
His voice is nice but got kinda bored if the song really didn't go for it
Ok, its a classic! Great for reading a book or cleaning
just a classic background album
There is a smugness to Sinatra that I can't get over. It's incredibly easy listening but it's also cheesy and slimy in a way that I don't like at all.
Very pleasant and easy listening soft swing album. After first few songs it blends into the ether and becomes literal background noise, you only realise it's stopped when you suddenly hear the silence.
A lot of 50s stuff we've had so far is kinda lo-fi and feels dated in a certain unadventurous kinda way, the arrangements here are so gorgeous and colourful and playful though, I really rate Frank's work here too! Have to give it a 4
I get that he has a nice voice. I get that this is groovy and relaxing. I get that for its time this was PEAK. But the world evolved, WE evolved, MUSIC evolved, so I don’t have to pretend I adore this just because it was incredible when it was released. It's not BAD per se, but I wouldn't listen to any song on here again, let alone the whole album. I can’t even imagine living in a time with such limited music options. Like, you’re telling me that on top of having NO Wi-Fi, NO shawarma, NO rights, NO FUCKING ANYTHING, because only straight white men deserved the good stuff, THIS is all I could’ve listened to? No thank you.
Vanilla but just cool enough to not be boring.
It's sinatra. It's fine
A crooning masterclass from Sinatra, with very tasteful arrangements. Clearly really great stuff, but maybe decades of pastiche by others means that it just doesn't grab me as much as it might.
alright, js more frank sinatra stuff
I think this album is not badly produced and the vibe is indeed 'swingy'. For me personally it's a little to monotonous and bland, though.
Gayyyyy. 1.8
This album is pretty perfect. Also I don’t know Frank Sinatra was so old
Loves to mention the moon.
Frank has good songs but they seemed to miss this album. Maybe I'm just not a fan of the standards. The first track is the only thing that saved it from being rated a 1
classic romantic songs
if i was in love or even had a crush this would be very moving. alas, i am too single to love it
Clasico, fantástico!
My first Sinatra record and this was exactly what I expected from him. Sinatra sure can croon and the instrumentation is lush, but I found myself wishing for this to wrap up. All the songs sound similar and there is no variety. This felt dated and of its time. Compared to the rock and roll records coming out around this time, this has no edge to it whatsoever. Not for me.
My parents had this album
It's hard for me to review this album. It's absolutely a vertebrae in the backbone of American pop culture. There's not an American out there who hasn't heard at least a snippet from one of these songs. However, where it fits in the culture or how it influenced other aspects are somewhat opaque to me. I did enjoy this album, I would absolutely listen to it again, but don't know which circumstances would call me back to it. Hard to describe, I guess ⭐⭐⭐.75
Sinatra has a great voice. I can appreciate that this is good music, it's just not the type I generally like. The songs kind of ran together, none of them stood out.
good so far. not all the way done listening. frank sinatra reminds me of christmas. so does etta james…?
13 januari 2026. Benieuwd hoe lang dit gaat duren. Eerste album is al cute. Heb dit echt nog nooit geluisterd, en nu wel :)
Добре, але всі пісні якісь занадто схожі. Проте якщо мати настрій саме на таку музику — це можна слухати, тому 2,5.
I wasn't expecting to like this but I really enjoyed it.
Not my jam, but it wasn't unpleasant either.
really album!! It makes me feel like i'm in a fancy restaurant with good music, very cozy :)
Not my bag baby
френ легенда. но не мое. хорошо на фон
Feel good 90s rom com vibes
!!!
Love me some Sinatra! Some lovely arrangements on here, but after like 5 songs it started to feel a bit same-y to me. Felt more like background music rather than a piece of art/entertainment that I wanted to fully absorb. Banger arrangements by Nelson Riddle tho
THIS IS SO LOVELY
Anything Goes is a classic
A pleasant record. Horn arrangements are incredible. Doesn't stack up to some of my preferred crooner records (Nat King Cole) but it's nice to have on.
It's SInatra, 'nough said.
sinatra is him
Great classic album
very classic very swing
classy oo but not really my type
love it very much
other people’s reviews are so funny this literally letterboxd but for albums. no but they were right i can’t differentiate the songs from each other bye. fun and enjoyable.
90/1001 First listen. About what I expected. Honestly, I liked “I’ve got you under my skin” with Bono better. 4/10
favorite - Too Marvelous For Words 8/10
Impossible not to be drawn into Sinatra’s smooth style!
This album makes you want to be/fall in love and I say that as someone who is a romance cynic. It does get a little repetitive after a while but I would put this on at a swanky dinner party and just vibe out. I get the Frank hype.
It’s clear why Frank is so revered- his voice is soothing and cinematic. I can imagine my grandparents dancing to his music.
when i am i going to listen to this with my swinging lover
Classic Frank, beautiful voice, swaying songs, everything you need for a moonlit supper with your sweetheart
omg why i don't like jazz i guess i should appreciate this anyways it's so old, there were no other ways of making music his voice is truly iconic had to take a pause after the 8th song cause I was falling asleep I am so sorry, mr. sinatra okay, after the break it got better still don't like it though. very one-time, one-vibe listen
i guess i just don’t get it because im not a swingin lover
You will never be a youngin "Every time it rains, it rains" Deep lyrics, love them Trash, but listenable
He was a good singer but he didnt make any good songs. Johnny Cash mogs
awesome!! it makes me feel like I'm in a 90s christmas movie
No. 69 A fresh album, ideal to listen to while you are studying or prepare a delicious meal.
Love Frank. 5 stars
Great stuff. 4 *
6/10
I know that this is supposed to be his best album, but am I crazy in saying i didn't love it? I think there are better crooners out there
This is an absolute classic. Highlight for me is Anything Goes. Fun fact, this was one if the two first albums I bought on vinyl (the second being 52nd Street). This is just a lovely, lovable album.
It's fine. Making whoopie is a mistake of a song.
This is sorta a hard album to approach cause a lot of my parameters for music quality doesn’t apply to music this old. For example, I can’t complain about there being a lack of variety of sounds because there was like 3 genres of music at the time so there wasn’t a lot to pull from. And to be fair, music from the 50s was kinda homogeneous, like a lot of the songs on this album are like wildly well known popular songs recorded by LOTS of people, like making whoopie and those tracks. So I can’t critique the song writing cause Frank didn’t really write songs, this is from when most musicians had writers. It’s actually wild cause really the only thing I can review is his voice and the songs on here that are his songs in the sense that they are most heavily associated with him, like “I’ve got you under my skin” and “you make me feel so young”. Both great songs, genuinely generationally impactful and important to so many people. And I even found a few other tracks I had never heard before that I liked. But for the most part it’s an aged piece of history that is entirely “of it’s time” mostly to a fault. I don’t think I’d ever listen to this album again, it wasn’t god awful or anything, just kinda boring and I’d probably just put on my own Frank playlist so it’s curated with all the songs I like, but yah this album is pretty acceptable and forgettable all at the same time.
instruments were beautiful, his voice was amazing, i love how you can listen to jazz to dance or sleep. but some of the songs did start blending together. overall amazing
I enjoy some of Frank Sinatra. This was a solid album though, despite not knowing most of it previously.
Not my thing at all, he had a fine "crooning "voice and my mother loved him. I was sick of it by the end but it was what it was and a lot better than some of the crap on here.
Mehhh, of the time. I can appreciate that they'd never heard rock music so this was probably peak. Got to try to contextualise, haven't you? I've been washing dishes and shake n vac'ing all day. A delightful homemade pie is in the oven, and the spuds are bubbling away on the stovetop. The house looks and smells wonderful, and I put on my dotty frock and do up my hair just before husband comes home. He comes in, wraps his arms around me and gives me a twirl in the kitchen to some romantic lyrics. The swinging lets me know we're makin whoopie later so we can add to our brood. Oh how wonderful. Then he slaps me about for tea being late to the table. Anyway, it was fine for what it was.
Maybe if I had a martini and a cigarette. Maybe...
NY NJ Swinging singin Mr. Old Blue Eyes. Those horns! Rip Frank Sinatra you would’ve loved Jschlatt and that one guy who was on America’s Got Talent that sounded like a crooner. Merry Christmas to you and your family. Always stay Italian, Frankie baby. Thanks for the love songs that never seem to go out of style or fall out of love.
To jazzy and old timey for me. Fly me to the moon and something stupid by frank sinatra will always be a goodie tho.
jako lep album, opet nisam oduševljena ne bih slušala svaki dan al mnogo opuštajuće
Queria tomar um martini com azeitona.
When elevators die and go to heaven, this is the music that gets played. A great singer, just not my style
Sinatra's voice is as smooth as silk and Nelson Riddle's score is smoother. Absolute classic.
ol’ blue balls… i mean, eyes… blue ball eyes… ol’ blue eyeballs not a fan
What’s “whoopee”?
Why did I listen to this whole album? WHY?!?! WHY COULDN’T IT HAVE BEEN CHET BAKER???!!!???😩 The arrangements and performances of the backing band saved it (barely) for me, but you could smell the smug, douche baggery of Frank oozing out of the speakers and ruining a perfectly good album and there’s nothing you can do to stop it. This era of American pop music was so lame. Why couldn’t he have sung “Pink Pony Club”?
I gotta admit, Sinatra is kinda overrated imo. Like no, it's not bad music, but I wouldn't listen to it as my first choice. He's super influential in the grand scheme, but it's just nothing special, it's all so same-y. So sue me. Top: We'll Be Together Again Not Top: Makin' Whoopee
so beautiful, clear and romantic. Sounds and feels incredible. 8/10
lovely 60s music
frank sinatra really is that guy. he has such a charming voice and quality that it's hard to not feel like you are the main character in a movie when these songs are played.
actually sehr cozy und vibey – es ist gar nicht so mein vibe, also würde es höchstens mal als Hintergrundmusik hören aber ne schlechte Bewertung zu geben tut mir auch echt weh :(((
He has a soothing voice; good lyrics with slightly upbeat tempos. The album is methodically structured and well blended together. It's a beautifully written, romantic album.
sounds like xmas
Classic frank sinatra sound. Not my jam liked a few songs nothing special
Not my vibe, sorry.
1/2/26
I wouldn't have thought it to be my cup of tea, but even for a 70-year-old album, it's still pretty fantastic.
Really starts off with a bang. Overall it's a very enjoyable listen. His voice/lyrics are unique and timeless.
frank sinatra is just *the* genre of lounge music. this is all good stuff but its not christmas music or New York New York or My Way so you cant sing along to it (I've Got You Under My Skin is probably an exception). very pleasant but not all that moving in any particular way, just vibey. Anything Goes is my favorite cuz i like fallout 🤓
Rating: 5/10 Feel like this doesn’t deserve a 2 even though I don’t want to give it a 3 either, it’s a perfectly fine listen that I continually didn’t necessarily want to finish as I got closer to the end. Just good and pleasant enough and doesn’t stir too much in me besides Track 1. Probably underrating it but that’s just my opinion
Pleasant 50s noise. I like sinatra but I don't love sinatra 5.7/10
I'm sure it's influential and all. 5 slow jam pt1 out of 10 mind fuzz
If you don't already know these songs by heart, then this is an absolute must-listen. Sinatra is in top voice as he delivers the definitive versions of the most widely-known American Pop songs. Nelson Riddle's arrangements mesh perfectly with that voice and make the tunes unforgettable.
Wank
Very pleasant, listenable, classy and another one of those albums from well before my era that I'm pleased to have heard, despite it not being "my thing". It absolutely merits its inclusion here, but I'm highly unlikely to ever reach for it again.
As good as recorded music has ever been. Amazing collection of songs, arranged brilliantly. All-stars at every instrument. Frank's mind-blowing technique and the perfection of that style that took over the world. And the recordings are so gorgeous - all of that WWII tube technology brought home and put to good use. Absolutely incredible to think they did it all in three tracks. (It's impossible to explain how mind blowing this is; there is virtually no mixing involved. The dynamics are almost entirely the product of each musician knowing precisely how loudly to play every passage. The trombone player who blew that famous solo on Under My Skin not only had to stand up, but he had to jump on a box and blow his lip out (literally) to play loudly enough to get over the brass' shout chorus.) Everything is recorded live and in single takes. Sure, things got a lot more interesting from and after about 1968. But I don't know that they ever got better.
Not really my cup of tea
Listening was so delightful, the songs are really joyful, lowkey make me wanna dance
My initial thoughts are that the whole album feels very wholesome, the songs are great, simply not something I would listen to on an everyday basis. Sinatra's voice is very soothing to listen to and his music gives me an itch to grab a partner and dance with them. :)
So smooth!
Loved listening to this all the way through. No skips. From you make me feel so young to Pennie’s from heaven
Smooth
If I found someone who despises Sinatra then they'll have to go in the dumpster. Nice of him to make an easy listenable able but every song sounds the same.
Solid Frank - but nothing stands out
🤌🏽
Easy baby!
Classic Frank
I wouldn’t add these songs to my playlist but when I’m just getting ready or driving or smth this would be good to play whenever I’m feeling jazzy. Added to profile!
Classic, good one, even though I’m not a big fan of that music
Classic, dreamy, New York romance vibes from Sinatra. Knew a few off this album.
Fine
god forbid a man love swing Would I listen again: On vinyl Deserves to be on this list: There's probably a better Frank record, right? 4.4
Really good Christmas, cozy, or I'm in love and everything is perfect vibes. I really liked it!
Es lo que esperas de un álbum de Frank Sinatra. Sonido clásico con letras bonitas y una gran presencia de la voz. Objetivamente está bien hecho pero personalmente se hace repetitivo.
Classic Sinatra.
It’s like Fallout!
15 songs fly by. Most feel samey. Nice voice of course but not very interesting for me. Low 3
Jazz is so hard. Listening to this album and trying to follow the chord progression on guitar and I had to tap out 7 tracks in. Too many failures. I think it’s a shame that like Frank Sinatra had every resource available to make this kind of huge cinematic bombastic music when it rips so hard off black artists, but also I don’t think we can throw out the baby with the bathwater; these songs are incredibly well orchestrated, the songwriting is too notch, and Frank’s voice is so full of mystery and life, everything just sounds so classic.
Swing your pants !
Never liked Sinatra. I don't hate Sinatra. This changed neither opinion. It all sounded the same.
you know what. i didn’t mind this. this is fine if you don’t pay attention to the lyrics. it’s also fully winter music for me so october felt wrong for this. but still, i liked it better than the last.
Look, I don't like swing music, so I'm starting at a biased point here... But... Gah, the lyrics are toss, they're sung really slowly which gives you time to guess what crap nonsense they'll say next, and you're often right. There are some nice basslines. I suspect that the tunes are fairly nice, but it's all so slow I'm too busy getting bored of it to care. I just don't get it. I can see it works in a film where you need someone to explain a plotline in songform as it's slow and everyone can understand it and the bloke singing can do so somewhat effortlessly and probably wear a suit and hit on some women or something, but outside of a film I don't get it. It just feels like exposition. Then he started talking about "making whoopie". Christ.
Classic stuff, hard to argue the impact and legacy here.
It’s hard to imagine where this album falls in Frank’s catalog seeing that he recorded 59 studio records. But it sure does seem that he’s firing on all crooning cylinders with this effort. Just brilliant. Optimistic. Timeless. Even more difficult to imagine is the fact that it was recorded 70 years ago. And yet it feels just like yesterday. Drop the needle on this anytime, any place and life just gets better.
I couldn’t tell you what separates this album from his many many others, but I guess that’s kind of the point. Just great, would listen to this all the time
Man, Frank is just so dang solid. Not sure where this fits in his discography but everything he does is just so consistently enjoyable.
It’s catchy swinging jazz, no more no less. 7/10.
What an amazing album, such style, great songs, a perfect album.
Not my style. Found it monotonous.
Perfect Christmas album
Frank Sinatra is absolutely amazing definitely a great starting point in terms of an album of his. I listen to this while riding on a lime bike and it was amazing gave a great calming and almost Christmasy feel but something that is timeless also. Was able to share with my girlfriend too who is also a big fan of Frank Sinatra great listen all throughout
3.1 This was a fun listen, gets you in the romantic root. Every song, structure wise sound the same but if it works it works. Frankie hog at it again. I sent one song from it to pookie. Notable events of the day Work: Had meeting about planner from microsoft support person. Personal: On call with pookem after the meeting and yapped. Then KK called and we yapped about consciousness.
Oh boy, Frank Sinatra is back with another album on my journey, pretty much exactly 3 weeks after I last heard him on here. The last album was so miserably bad I almost ended up giving it a 2. It just sounded very rapey, and it came out more than 10 years after this album, so I kind of thought I was going to be in for more of that here. The album in question was Frank Albert Sinatra And Antonio Carlos Jobim, which absolutely does not roll off the tongue. With an album name like Songs For Swingin' Lovers!, I was really bracing myself for more of the same. Instead, I got a much better album, and substantially less rapey sounding. Noted, the context/subtext behind a few of the songs maybe isn't amazing, but whatever. "Makin' Whoopee" in particular makes me want to jump from the highest bridge I can find. I was substantially less creeped out listening to this one as a whole though. However, I was still bored out of my freaking mind. This music has a rightful place in history. Does it deserve to be on this list? Absolutely!! Songs like "You Make Me Feel So Young" and "I've Got You Under My Skin" are classics, the ladder being my favorite song on the album. Do I want to listen to them? No. No I do not. Do I want to listen to an entire album that consists of 44 minutes of what is essentially the exact same dated song? Also no. But hey, it was better than his later stuff apparently. It would not surprise me even a little bit if this is his absolute peak musically. If anything, this album really makes me want to go back and give the last one I heard a 2. This one is leagues better. I've got one more Frank Sinatra album to go, and it's the oldest album in the entire book. So yeah, I am fully expecting it to sound more or less the same as this, but even more dated and boring. Not the biggest fan of Frank Sinatra's music. I acknowledge it has a huge spot in music history, but don't enjoy actively listening to it all that much. Another pretty low 3 from me, but definitely not a 2. Call it a 3.35/5.
This entire album is gold but I saved "You Make Me Feel So Young," "It Happened In Monterey," and "Love Is Here To Stay."
No. Sorry, Frank, but this is background music for Catholic perverts
Smooth great song writing great delivery great arrangements just a bit mono paced in terms of dynamics.
Perfection
Topp
Frank er en gammel grisegutt. Dette var temmelig ensformig og kjedelig, selv om gamlefar synger fint!
Alors, c'est un très bon album un peu répétitif mais c'est compréhensible en vue de la date de sortie. Toujours très soigné Sinatra, un bon 6/10 pas très marquant.
Frank has done it again. Classy Baddie. It’s very relaxing. Would listen to again:)
Je suis bien incapable de trouver un morceau qui sort du lot, j'ai eu l'impression d'écouter la même chanson pendant une heure. Mais ce n’est pas désagréable à écouter.
Frank Sinatra is an artist that I need to be in the mood for, but when I am he melts my heart. I'm sure it surprises no one that I had a Wee Small Hours phase in high school, or that I sang My Way at karaoke my first night at university. Songs for Swingin' Lovers! is unfortunately an album that does not do nearly as much for me, even when I am in the mood for Sinatra. Swing has never been my thing (hehe), always being drawn to more intimate jazz settings as opposed to big bands. You Make Me Feel So Young is a great track to start the album off, but aside from that very few tracks feel as special to me as others off his records from around the same time. I can't help but compare a lot of the standards to versions I like way better, and in general I think the selection here does not compliment Sinatra's capabilities nearly as well as other albums like Songs for Young Lovers do. I'll admit my bias against swing plays a big part in my relatively negative perception of this album, but I think Sinatra evolves his style much more over the next decade. For this album to be considered more noteworthy than many other far more poignant records doesn't check out for me. Songs for Swingin' Lovers finds a home inside Olive Garden, which coincidentally is like the album in many ways. Bland, noisy, and zero chance of romance even though it feels like there should be.
Franky boy is always great to hear. But albums of his did not work that well for me. Despite all the songs been absolutely well put together and sounding great there is nothing stuck or at least there a no favorites on the album. It kinda lost me. When Spotify already switched to another album of his I didn't even notice.
Good album overall. The lyrics feel kind of sappy but maybe that's just what music was like in this decade.
Classic
‘Ol Blue Eyes was a treat to listen to. Just enjoy the vibe.
There's just something about it with these old-timey standards, they're just so charming. Perhaps it's the Big Band instrumentation or it's something else but It gives a good 50s vibe. you know, when people were lived life slow, and fear of being nuked back to the stone age, and being explicitly racist (more than today at least.) Highlight Song/s: "It Happened In Monterey"
It’s hard to pull monothematic albums off - even for Frank Sinatra. But I think he does it really well. I like his sense of humor and I even learned a new expression - I’m not a native speaker so I had no idea what Makin‘ Whoopee means. Thanks for teaching me. So yeah it’s Frank - he is a legend and I enjoyed this album a lot. This album is a dreamscape making me nostalgic for supposedly simpler times I’ve not seen.
The voice is still the voice but I don't like these arrangements.
Once again, here's Nelson Riddle and his orchestra drowning out some solid (and some great) songs and a perfect voice. And this rendition of Anything Goes, a song that is dear to my heart, is way too slow and syrupy. It would dishonor my father's memory to give this less than a 4 but I didn't like it that much.
Classical Frank, love it
pleasant but a bit boring, i couldn‘t tell the songs apart at all it all pretty much sounded the same
Loved how horny this was xoxo
Favorite: Old Devil Moon Least Favorite: You're Getting To Be A Habit With Me Overall Rating: 7.5/10 A bit repetitive but good vibes overall.
For all the cultural iconography surrounding Sinatra, it’s easy to forget that at his core he was a fucking phenomenal singer. Legendary womanizer, abuser and all around asshole, it doesn’t overshadow a masterful performer at his prime. This is a hell of a record, and even when I didn’t love the song, I was in love with Frank’s performance. Perfect vibes even if Frank wasn’t the easiest dude to deal with.
It sounds like an episode of mad men
Repetitive for sure, good singing and lots of trumpets. Not really my taste. Favourite song I've Got You Under My Skin it has a great instrumental bit.
very romantic and chill, perfect for a december evening
Hard to stay awake to this while listening on my morning commute. Every song sounds the same (as Ben mentioned). Reminds me of the crappy music you hear on New Year’s Eve in time square. Didn’t like. zzzzzzz
Enjoy the nostalgia of this. Feels like a less stressful era and reminds me of some great movies too. It’s almost my first 5 star. Almost. 4.5.
The songs within this album sounds just like Sinatra's other songs: ensemble-filled, with the instruments blending in with his voice. The lineup swings like a pendulum, going from very energetic songs like Too Marvellous for Words being followed by Old Devil Moon. Overall, the album didn't disappoint, although. as I said, this is what you would expect from Sinatra. On-brand or repetitive? What's the difference, it's all about the listener's perspective. It's not within Sinatra's control that Jazz-Swing just sounds like that. Songs I liked the most: Anything Goes, Love is Here to Stay Songs I liked the least: Too Marvellous for Words
Go whoopie yourself
I went in expecting to hate the record. Why? Because I usually don’t care for albums whose sound deliberately evokes a bygone era - one that is often heavily romanticised. And that certainly seems to be the case with Sinatra’s swing and jazz vignettes. Well, I didn’t exactly become a believer, but it was far more entertaining than I had anticipated. Of course, Frank Sinatra was an entertainer - that’s not what I’m questioning. What I mean is that, musically speaking, the record turned out to be quite engaging and compositionally interesting… at least at first. I still struggle, however, with the apparent similarity between the tracks. With each passing tune, they tend to blend and blur into one another. That said, You Are Getting to Be a Habit with Me stood out for its great interplay between flutes and bass. Very nice.
Saucy for the 50’s!
Nice. Reminds me of xmas and my grandma
It's Frank Sinatra man
Aura.
no soy muy fan del jazz pero le dare una oportunidad. no me ha gustado nada, todas las canciones se sentian iguales y no hacia nada que frank sinatra no hubiera hecho en sus anteriores 9 albumes. me ha costado acabarlo, se me ha hecho pesadisimo.
Beautifully crafted, wonderful music, but a little boring at times. As I've gotten older, I've come to appreciate Sinatra's singing more. Years ago, when I played drums, I practiced to his music as his band was unparalleled. But I always found his singing too pop-y, too produced. But what a gorgeous voice. It remains "Christmas" music for me, i.e. it's music I gravitate too when the days are short, when the weather outside is frightful, and I want to bring some cheer into the house. On any given day, I'm still 10x more likely to listen to Duke Ellington or Nina Simone, but I've finally come to appreciate Sinatra.
It's remarkable how long Frank takes to get to any individual note. Just about every phrase is full of sliiiides to get there, and usually singers like Robert Goulet become the butt of jokes for it. Not Frank. It feels perfect. Subtract a star because these don't feel like the best songs. They're canonical, but they're boring — at least today. I don't know his records, but I'm certain that he has songs that communicate a little more feeling under the heavy varnish.
Nice to learn more about Frank Sinatra, I listened to a few albums of his with this listen. Pleasant, but not being a big lyrics guy it does lack a bit of sonic diversity. 3*. Music has come a long way.
Good vocal jazz. Great for date night! Immaculate voice.
easily the best album i’ve listened to so far, absolutely incredible album, i love frank sinatra but this is actually the first album ive fully listened to by him, and there rly is a reason on why he’s considered one of the best to ever do it. i love the sound of this entire era, amazing
How can you not like this.
Yup, that's Frank Sinatra alright.
Some of the orchestration still feels corny to me, but the guy has a great sense of timing and an iconic voice.
"Songs for Swingin' Lovers!" sounds like my childhood in the best way — growing up, we spent one weekend a month in Chicago visiting my Italian Nana, often driving into the city to get a bit of culture that wasn't available in our modest hometown. I have all these sense memories of Frank … but, here's the catch: I don't remember actually listening to Sinatra at any point in my childhood. I think I've created some narrative of his role in my life that is entirely romantic, an amalgamation of Nathan Detroit, Danny Ocean, Joe Piscopo, Phil Hartman, Johnny Fontane, "A Jolly Christmas", and a half dozen mob movies that I love to revisit. Honestly, it feels suitable for the man in question, so much larger than life, to have implanted himself into my life story without having to earn it in its crucibles. This is a fine collection. His charming vocals are unstrained and borderline lazy, but every weird phrasing choice imbues them with so much personality. I can barely tell when one song ends and the next song begins, but for 45 minutes, I am transported to a life I apparently wish I could have had.
It's just not that interesting
First Listen; 4; I did not have high expectations for this album. I thought that I'd think it pleasant enough but boring and similar sounding. Having said that, this was much catchier, more diverse, and catchier than I was expecting. This is actually something I would come back to listen to on it's own.
This album reminded me why I don't listen to 50s music. It's because nothing compares to Sinatra. Everything is on point. The album is somewhat repetitive and I don't think that's an issue.
This is old, but not outdated. I think it definitely stands the test of time. He has a good voice and the music reminds me of old Pixar movies. This album is nostalgic even though I had only heard a couple songs before.
Classic voice singing classic songs.
It was fine. Maybe that whole crooner schtick is just old now. I liked it but I’m in no rush to revisit it
this was good and i thought about swinging with my lover but it is just not the vibe for a walk on a sunny day through the city
The songs were mostly fine, and luckily they’re all short so if you aren’t liking one just wait a minute and it’ll likely be over.
I understand why people gravitate toward Frank Sinatra; this record is mellow and relaxing and Frank has a great, easygoing voice. It really is great, non-offensive background music. It doesn't offer much more than that though, at least not for me. This is fine for a piano bar or for working on something else where I need some background noise without it distracting me. But I can't really see this as something that I'd seek out for any other purpose. It doesn't really illicit any real excitement from me, even if it is enjoyable enough. 3/5
Mr. Sinatra has a good voice, but his timbre is exactly the same across his full range. The singing sounds monotonous, even though it isn't. I don't hate any of the songs, I don't love any either. Favorite song: old devil moon
Swingin’ song by a Swingin’ Cat. Soon there will be shooby shooby doobie doin’ a happening!
I love some frank. Smooth. I love his voice. And been listening to more swingy jazz things.
I somehow have heard every one of these songs, but never listened to the album. It's a bit repetitive and didn't capture my attention. I was listening while working and didn't realize the first song started playing again. It was fun to try to figure out which movie or tv show I'd heard the song in, but I wouldn't listen again.
I mean, he's good, but it's just not really my thing.
really liked :)
3.9
The man has a voice of liquid honey, and the band are playing reeeal nice. It's just a nice warm hug of an album. 3.5 rounded up.
Solid, swingin’, great musicianship, a nice kind of aural wallpaper, but not OH MAN, WHAT IS HAPPENING
Great band backing; smooth vocals (as expected); not really my taste, but great music is still enjoyable; a lot of classics on this album, 'You Make Me Feel So Young' always makes me think of Elf and Christmas. Favorite Song (for this listen): either 'Old Devil Moon' or 'Pennies From Heaven'
Too jazzy
you make me feel so young isch huuuuere geil omg s arrangmeent. er singt guet und het e suuuper stimmfarb aber s arrangement isch mindestens zweimol so wichtig wie er. ui s outro vo it happened in monterrey gad au. you're getting to be a habit with me typische guete swingsong über e abhängigkeit ide beziehig.
gad sehr lust uf frankieee hmm lyrisch überzügts mich sicher nöd unglaublich hahahaha, isch sehr schnell usglutscht jaa es isch cute, es lauft, aber nöd meh iwie CHEESEBURGER HAMBURGER WHOOPER oder wie au immer das video gaht hmm clt liits au ah spotify aber d blöser tönet mengisch SEHR blechig OUH beachboys vergesse uppsi naja uf jede fall hani schwierigkeite, zum das würkli nöd gern haa, aber han villes chli langwilig gfunde. s gfühl isch immerno schön wosmer git aber jo
Romantic and swinging. Delivers as advertised
mmhmm easy listening
He shines here, incredible voice, croony and a little cheeky, instrumentation is fun. This makes you want to dance. It feels like he is putting something of himself out there, a little vulnerable and enthusiastic. If you were very cool in the 50s you would have been going out to this
Hard to rate due to how ubiquitous Sinatra is as a singer, but he did offer to have Woody Allen's legs broken so I can't in good conscience rate this any lower than a 3.
I like me some Big Band, but this didn't really hit. I think it's just a bit too shmultzy? Also pretty much every Sinatra song sounds the same, which isn't a problem when it's one in a playlist, but it's a bit much for a whole album. Neat that it's the first ever UK #1 album though, that's a cool fact